The Replay Disaster. And What's Next. | The Avid Ep. 7

It took the NFL 25 years to get replay review right — and they're still not there. Challenge success rates sat at 40% last season. This week on The Avid: a quick rant on the replay disaster. 

Plus — an honest conversation about what's next. Seven episodes of fan frustrations. Now we're taking this next week to build something bigger. When we come back, the show hits different. 

Stay Avid.

Transcript

0:00

What's going on, avid fam? My name is Arik, and we're here at the Avid Done being polite about sports. That's right. So far for the last seven weeks, we've had one topic raw, unfiltered, and just the truth. This week we're gonna go with the replay disaster and an honest conversation about what's next for this show. Let's go. So here's a number I got for you. 40%. That's the challenge success rate in the NFL last season. Coaches threw the red flag knowing and call was wrong. Having seen the replay on the sideline tablet, and they were still only right 40% of the time. 60% of the time the system looked at itself and said, nah, we were right the first time. Replay review was supposed to fix officiating. That was the promise. Put the cameras everywhere, let the guys in New York watch correct the mistakes. It took the NFL 25 years to get it working. The first version, 1986 to 91, was so bad they scrapped it entirely. Only 13% of reviewed calls were reversed. The league abandoned it for eight years. They brought it back in 99. Better cameras, better tech, but the same problem happened. The reviews took forever and still got calls wrong. Games stretched to three and a half hours, coaches burned timeouts on challenges they lost. Fans sat in silence for four minutes watching a rep stare at a tablet. This past season, 2025, the NFL finally expanded replay to cover penalties. Pass interference, roughing the passer, intentional grounding, new camera angles, the works. And you know what? It actually got better. Challenge success rates jumped to 60%. Reviews got shorter, the league started to fix the calls in real time without having to stop the game. So I'll give you the credit where the credit is due. That's right, the system is actually improving. So what are we talking about today? It took 25 years, three complete overhauls and billions of dollars in broadcast technology to get a system that's right 60% of the time when the coach challenges. 60%. If you were taking a pass fail test, you got a D minus. And the parts they won't review, holding, offensive passing interference on contestant catches. The judgment calls that actually decide games, they're still untouchable. Still the ref's eye, the ref's gut, the ref's moment, no camera, no review, and no accountability. The replay system didn't fix officiating, it fixed the easy calls, the ones the cameras can clearly see. The hard calls, those are the ones that actually swing championships, aren't they? Those are still human, still flawed, and still protected. So here's the part that connects this to everything that we've been talking about on this show for the last seven weeks. The leagues don't want perfect officiating. We said in episode three, bad calls create controversy. Controversy creates engagement. The replay system exists to give you the feeling of accountability without the reality of it. But I'm not going to spend ten minutes on this. Because honestly, the replay system is the least broken thing that we've covered on this show. It's actually getting better. Slowly, painfully, but better. And that brings me to something that I'm going to talk about right now. Seven episodes, ticket prices, jerseys, refs, broadcasts, tanking, the stadium experience, and now replay. Seven weeks of everything that's broken about being a sports fan. Seven weeks of the things that make you furious when you love a game that doesn't love you back. And I meant every word, and I'm proud of every episode, but here's what I've realized: the fan frustration lane, the prices, the officiating, the stadium experience, it's important. It's real, but it's also a known conversation. You already knew that ticket prices are too expensive. You already know refs are bad. I just said it louder. So this chapter's over. Next week, a brand new chapter emerges. Can't wait to speak to you then. And if you've been here since episode 1, since $412 for two upper deck seats, thank you, man. So subscribe now so you don't miss a thing when we come back. Until then, stay avid.