The SCOTUSblog Gamble

Thomas C. Goldstein was one of the best-known appellate lawyers in the country. He argued more than 40 cases before the United States Supreme Court and co-founded SCOTUSblog, a widely read source for Supreme Court coverage. 

He was also, according to federal prosecutors, a high-stakes poker player who frequently played in games involving tens of millions of dollars. 

In this episode of Final Notice, Jason Carr, tax attorney, breaks down how Goldstein’s gambling activity, personal debts, law firm finances, and mortgage applications became a federal criminal tax case. Prosecutors said Goldstein concealed millions of dollars in poker wins and losses, diverted legal fees payable to his law firm into his personal bank account to satisfy poker-related debts, directed people to pay his creditors instead of paying him directly, and used law firm assets to satisfy poker debts that were falsely classified as “legal-fee” expenses on the firm’s books. 

The case also included mortgage fraud allegations. In 2021, Goldstein sought financing to purchase a $2.6 million home in Washington, D.C., and submitted mortgage applications that required him to list his liabilities and debts. Prosecutors said he omitted millions in liabilities, including more than $14 million owed on two promissory notes and taxes owed to the IRS, and that his false statements enabled him to obtain a $1.98 million loan. 

Jason explains how personal financial chaos becomes criminal tax exposure when business books are used to disguise personal expenses, when income gets routed around normal reporting channels, and when debts are hidden from lenders. He also explains what Goldstein should have done instead: separate personal and business finances, properly report gambling income, classify owner payments correctly, amend inaccurate returns, address unpaid taxes through civil IRS resolution tools, and involve a tax attorney early when the facts raise possible criminal exposure. 

This episode is for business owners, law firm owners, high-income professionals, tax preparers, CPAs, enrolled agents, bookkeepers, gamblers with significant winnings or losses, and anyone who wants to understand how an IRS balance-due problem can become an IRS-CI and DOJ problem. 

Key Takeaways:

• Gambling income is taxable. Large swings, informal accounting, private games, and personal debts do not eliminate the reporting obligation. 
• Business accounts should not be used as personal clearing accounts. If a business pays a personal expense, the payment needs to be classified correctly. 
• Calling a personal expense a business expense does not make it deductible. Prosecutors said Goldstein used law firm assets to pay poker debts and caused those payments to be falsely classified as legal-fee expenses. 
• Third-party creditor payments can still create tax issues. A taxpayer generally cannot avoid tax consequences just because money is routed to a creditor instead of paid directly to the taxpayer. 
• Mortgage applications create a separate paper trail. Prosecutors said Goldstein omitted millions in liabilities, including more than $14 million owed on two promissory notes and taxes owed to the IRS. 
• When tax problems overlap with false books, false deductions, diverted income, and lender statements, privilege matters. A tax attorney can help evaluate exposure before the taxpayer, preparer, or accountant creates avoidable risk. 
• The goal is to keep a tax problem in the civil IRS lane whenever possible, using amended returns, collection alternatives, penalty relief, audit defense, and clean documentation. 
• For tax professionals, the warning sign is pressure. If a client asks you to classify personal debts as business expenses, route income around the business, or report only part of the picture, stop and document the issue. 

Suggested Timestamps 

00:30: Branded intro, Final Notice: Real Tax Cases. Exposed. 

00:45: Who Thomas C. Goldstein was 

01:30: SCOTUSblog, Supreme Court litigation, and high-stakes poker 

02:30: The tax charges and the government’s theory 

03:45: Hidden poker income and gambling losses 

04:45: Diverted legal fees and creditor payments 

05:45: Personal expenses classified as law firm expenses 

06:45: The mortgage application allegations 

07:45: Why IRS-CI and the FBI both became involved 

08:30: What Goldstein should have done instead 

09:30: Separating personal and business finances 

10:15: Reporting gambling income and documenting losses 

11:00: Amended returns and civil tax resolution options 

11:45: Why attorney-client privilege matters when facts get serious 

12:30: Final lesson, the IRS follows the records 

13:00: Close and call to action 

Resources Mentioned 

• DOJ case source: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/prominent-lawyer-convicted-trial-tax-evasion-and-mortgage-fraud 
• IRS-CI case source: https://www.irs.gov/compliance/criminal-investigation/prominent-lawyer-thomas-goldstein-convicted-of-tax-evasion-and-mortgage-fraud 
• The Law Office of Jason Carr, PLLC: https://carrtaxlaw.com 

Transcript

SPEAKER_01 0:06

You're listening to Final Notice. Real Tax Cases Exposed with Jason Carr. Each week we break down real Department of Justice tax fraud prosecutions and reveal what should have been done to avoid them. And now here's your host, Jason Carr.

SPEAKER_00 0:28

More than 40 Supreme Court arguments, poker games involving tens of millions of dollars, and a SCOTUS blog founder convicted of tax evasion, false returns, failure to pay, and mortgage fraud. Today's case is about Thomas C. Goldstein. If you're a lawyer, you probably know the name. Goldstein co-founded SCOTUS Blog, one of the best known sources for Supreme Court coverage. He was also a prominent appellate attorney who argued more than 40 cases before the United States Supreme Court. That is rare error. He was also, according to the government, a high stakes poker player who frequently played in games involving tens of millions of dollars. That's also a rare error. Different altitude, different oxygen. Goldstein lived in Chevy Chase, Maryland. He was the sole owner of Goldstein and Russell PC, a boutique appellate law firm focused on Supreme Court litigation and other appellate work. But between 2016 and 2023, according to the Department of Justice, he stopped paying taxes on time and engaged in a scheme to evade taxes for 2016. The government said he hid millions of dollars in poker wins and losses, diverted legal fees payable to his law firm into his personal bank account to satisfy poker-related debts, directed people to pay as creditors instead of paying them directly, and used law firm assets to pay poker debts while causing those payments to be classified as legal fee expenses on the firm's books. That last part matters. The IRS sees bad bookkeeping every day. Bad bookkeeping becomes something else when personal expenses get routed through a business, when income gets diverted, and when the paper trail starts telling a story that the bank records do not support. So how did this unravel? DOJ information focuses on what came out through court documents and trial evidence, and the story is not subtle. First, you have the income problem. The government said Goldstein could seal millions in poker wins and losses from the government. Gambling income is taxable. That can surprise casual gamblers, but it should not surprise anyone playing at this level. Second, you have the routing problem. The government said legal fees owed to the law firm were diverted into Goldstein's personal account to satisfy poker debts. That matters because when business income bypasses the business, you lose clean reporting. You also create the appearance that someone is trying to keep money away from the books. Third, you have the creditor payment problem. The DOJ said Goldstein directed people to pay as creditors instead of paying them directly. That's a classic tax problem. You don't avoid income just because someone pays your debt instead of handing you cash. If a third party satisfies your obligation, that could still be income or otherwise tax significant. The IRS follows the benefit, not just the check. Fourth, you have the business expense problem. The government said Goldstein used law firm assets to satisfy poker debts, then cause those payments to be falsely classified as legal fee expenses on the law firm books. That is where the case moves from messy to dangerous. If a business pays a personal expense, the answer is not to slap a business label on it and hope nobody notices. The answer is to classify it correctly. It might be compensation, it might be a distribution, it might be a loan, it might be a receivable. But if it's personal, calling it a legal fee does not make it a legal fee. The government also said Goldstein spent millions on personal expenses, including poker, travel, and luxury goods, while underreporting income and failing to pay all taxes owed. Then the case picked up a second lane, mortgage fraud. In 2021, Goldstein submitted mortgage applications to two lenders while seeking financing to buy a $2.6 million home in Washington, D.C. Those applications required him to list his liabilities and debts. According to DOJ, he omitted millions in liabilities, including more than $14 million owed on two promissory notes and taxes owed to the IRS. The government said those false statements enabled him to obtain a $1.98 million loan. That's how a tax problem becomes a bank problem. And once tax investigators and FBI agents are both looking at the same set of records, you're no longer dealing with a simple IRS balance due case. The jury convicted Goldstein of tax evasion, assisting in the preparation of false tax returns, willful failure to timely pay taxes, and making false statements to mortgage lenders. So what should he have done instead? Let's assume, purely as a practical tax lesson, that someone like this walks into my office early, before the false classifications, before the mortgage applications, before IRSCI and the FBI are involved. The first move is separation. Personal gambling activity and law firm operations cannot share the same bloodstream. Separate bank accounts, separate books, separate ledgers. Every transfer between the firm and the owner needs a label that matches reality. Salary, distribution, loan, reimbursement, capital contribution, or repayment. If you cannot explain the transfer in one sentence, it probably should not happen until your tax advisor and bookkeeper understand it. Second, we clean up the reporting. Gambling income and gambling losses have specific reporting rules. You don't net everything informally in your head and report the number that feels fair. You gather the records, buy-ins, payouts, markers, promissory notes, wire transfers, casino records, foreign activity, and third-party payments. Then you build a tax file that an IRS examiner can follow without needing a detective wall and red string. Third, if prior returns are wrong, we amend them before the government finds the issue. That means Form 1040X for amended individual returns, amended business returns if the entity books were wrong, corrected K1s or W2s if needed, and a clean explanation supported by documents. The goal here is simple. Move the case into civil compliance while you still can. Fourth, if taxes are owed and cash is tight, we deal with collections lawfully. That might mean an installment agreement, a partial pay installment agreement, penalty abatement, or another collection alternative depending on the taxpayer's financials. If the taxpayer can't pay in full, we analyze assets, income, allowable expenses, equity, and collection statute timing. We don't hide the ball. We build a payment strategy. Fifth, if there's real criminal exposure, you need privilege. This is where a tax attorney matters. A CPA is critical for return preparation and accounting, but when the facts include possible false deductions, diverted income, third-party creditor payments, and misleading financial statements, the taxpayer needs legal advice under attorney client privilege. The accountant may still be involved, but the work needs to be structured carefully. And if you're a tax professional listening to this, this is your bright red warning light. When a client asks you to classify personal debt payments as business expenses, stop. When business revenue is redirected to personal accounts, stop. When a client gives you personal information and pressures you to make the return work, stop. Document what you were told. Ask for source records. Escalate the issue. Do not let the client's urgency become your preparer penalty, your subpoena, or your worst day at the office. The lesson here is simple. The IRS does not require your financial life to be boring. You can own a business, you can gamble, you can make money in unusual ways. You can have debt, you can owe taxes, but the records have to tell the truth. In this case, the government's theory was that records did the opposite. Hidden poker income, diverted legal fees, creditor payments instead of direct payments, personal gambling debts classified as law firm expenses, and mortgage applications that left out major liabilities. That is the tax version of going all in with a weak hand. And the government called.com. Links in the show notes. This has been Final Notice, Real Tax Cases Exposed.

SPEAKER_01 7:55

If you enjoyed today's episode, share it with a friend or colleague who needs to hear it. Subscribe so you never miss a case. For show notes and more, visit cartaxlaw.com. This podcast is legal education and commentary, not legal advice, and listening does not create an attorney client relationship. Full disclaimer at Cartaxlaw.com.