The Cloud of Unknowing: Losing Your Grip on God to Fall Deeper into Love

In this episode, The Unintentional Heretic explores The Cloud of Unknowing and its invitation into a faith that moves beyond analysis, certainty, and the need to master God with the mind. This anonymous medieval text reminds us that God is not finally known through control or explanation, but through love, surrender, silence, and the deep humility of unknowing.

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Welcome back to the unintentional heretic. One of the greatest surprises of my own spiritual journey has been discovering that many of the questions I thought were modern aren't modern at all. Questions about certainty, about doubt, about whether we can really know God. For years I assumed Christianity was primarily about finding the right answers. If I could just figure out the correct doctrine, build a consistent theology, and resolve every tension, I'd finally have solid faith. Then I stumbled across a little anonymous book written nearly 700 years ago. It's called The Cloud of Unknowing, and no one knows who wrote it. We only know that it was written in Middle English by an anonymous spiritual director, probably sometime around thirteen seventy, for a young man longing to know God more deeply. The author never tells us his name in a way that feels fitting. The point of the book isn't the teacher, it's the journey. The title comes from a simple but profound conviction. There's always a cloud between our minds and God. Not because God is hiding, because God is infinitely greater than anything our minds can grasp. The author writes, By love he may be gotten and held, but by thought never. Sit with that for a moment. Not thought is bad, not don't study theology, simply this. Thinking can take us a long way. Love takes us further. This wasn't an isolated idea, it runs throughout Christian history. In the fourth century, Gregory of Nazianzus wrote, It is impossible to express God, and even more impossible to conceive him. Notice what he doesn't say. He doesn't say we can't know God. He says we can't comprehend God. And those are two very different things. I can know my wife, I can spend a lifetime loving her, but I will never completely comprehend her. Love is always larger than explanation. How much more is that true of God? The anonymous author invites us into what he calls a cloud of forgetting. And that sounds strange. He's not asking us to forget God. He's asking us to lay aside everything that distracts us from God, our worries, our ambitions, our endless mental chatter, even for a little while, our ideas about God, because our ideas are never God. They're only signposts. The Christian tradition is always distinguished between the map and the territory. A map's incredibly valuable, but eventually you have to walk the trail. This may be one reason Jesus spoke in parables. People wanted definitions, Jesus gave stories. People asked for certainty, Jesus invited relationship. Even when Moses asked for God's name, the answer was wonderfully elusive. I am who I am. Not a definition, an invitation. One of the great losses in much of modern Christianity is that we've come to believe clarity is the highest spiritual virtue. If everything doesn't fit neatly together, we become anxious. But scripture itself refuses to cooperate with that impulse. Job never gets an explanation. Ecclesiastes asks more questions than it answers. The Psalms argue with God. Jesus cries from the cross, My God, my God, why have you forsaken me? The Bible doesn't eliminate mystery. It teaches us how to live faithfully within it. The author of the cloud gives one of the simplest instructions in all of Christian spirituality. Choose a single word, maybe love, maybe Jesus, maybe peace. When your mind wanders and it will, gently return to the word, not as magic, not as mantra, but as an anchor. Centuries before mindfulness became popular, Christians were practicing what the desert fathers and mothers called Hesekia, holy stillness, intentionally opening the heart. And this is one reason I think we've misunderstood prayer. Many of us treat prayer as talking. The mystics often treated prayer as listening, or even deeper than listening, being. The nineteenth century philosopher Soren Kierkegaard once wrote, A man prayed, and at first he thought prayer was talking, but he became more and more quiet until in the end he realized prayer is listening. I wonder if even listening isn't the final step. Maybe prayer is consenting, simply consenting to the presence of God that's always been here. And this also changes how we think about faith. Faith isn't certainty, faith is trust. Those aren't the same thing. When I fly on an airplane, I don't understand aerodynamics, I trust. The biblical word pistis is much closer to trust, loyalty, and faithfulness than intellectual certainty. And that's a very different way of imagining the Christian life. One of my favorite theologians, Paul Tillich, wrote, The first duty of love is to listen. And I think that's true of prayer too. Maybe the first duty of prayer is simply to become present, not to fix, not to perform, not to convince God of anything, just to become awake. Thomas Aquinas spent his life writing what is arguably the greatest work of systematic theology ever produced, the Summa Theologica. Then near the end of his life, after a profound experience in prayer, he stopped writing altogether. When his secretary urged him to continue, Aquinas replied, I can write no more. All that I have written seems like straw. Think about that. One of Christianity's greatest intellectuals concluded that encounter surpassed explanation. Not because theology is unimportant, but because theology ultimately points beyond itself. And maybe that's what the cloud of unknowing has been trying to tell us all along. God is not a puzzle to solve. God is a mystery to enter. Mystery doesn't mean ignorance, it means inexhaustibility. The more deeply you know someone, the more you realize there's always more to discover. Love never reaches the bottom, and neither does God. I'll leave you with one final line from the cloud of unknowing that stayed with Christians for centuries. For he can be well loved, but not thought. By love he may be caught and held, but by thought, never. Maybe that's why Jesus never said think about me. He said follow me. Because in the end, Christianity isn't primarily a set of ideas to master, it's a life to be lived. And maybe the cloud we've been trying so hard to remove is the very place where God has been waiting for us all along. Thanks for listening to the unintentional heretic. Until next time, keep asking questions.