التصالح مع الإخوان... هل هو ممكن؟

حلقة جديدة من بودكاست 180 درجة

هل يمكن أن تُطوى صفحة الصراع؟ وما الفرق بين المصالحة السياسية، والمصالحة المجتمعية، والمحاسبة القانونية؟ وهل تمثل المصالحة مخرجًا للأزمات أم أنها قد تعيد إنتاجها؟

في هذه الحلقة، نناقش هذا الملف الشائك من زوايا متعددة، بعيدًا عن الشعارات والانفعالات، لنطرح الأسئلة التي يتجنبها كثيرون، ونبحث عن إجابات تستند إلى قراءة سياسية وتاريخية وواقعية.

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Asre malaikum Murahmadullah Breakatu Alambikum Ma Budkast Mi Otamani Dharga Ma Hukum Aimukrig Muhammad Ashare. In harda Halitnah Hanibda Biswell Hell Musri Mektaget Saleh Malikwen Wallahlas into Aya in Modu Shaik Waka Ditnah see Me Otamanin Draga Biniftah Malafit Ishaika Min Akram Ashar Sinin Iswel Naiman Birgaitodna Hel Mus Yimfat Saleh Malikwen Igabit Suel Tinkusimguzin Pina Shaifa in Hum Guz Inl Mukama Mehme Hasa Wulestani Shafa in Aimusal Hamahum Maneha Hrob Kidid Type Helb Saraha Iswel Aslan Halap Melim Shaizin Nigel Untozruna Badr Faser Halakida Ma Bodkast Me Otabanin Darga Alem Bekum Gedid Ma Bodkast Me Otabanin Darga. Issuel Haii illezim Nisalu Tipkan Limaslahet Rotar Almumkin Yasal Selem Haii Selem Mup Temay Haii Walla Garha Mak Minkida Ablimin Kellemfil Modwada Lezim Nirga Warashwaya Unchufre Litil Ichwen Masugun Urehilit Snait Il Maslumeya Terihle Lochinil Ottrofitel Sharp Taula Ichwen Rechlit Ichwen Enafira in Muslumi El Muta Gedida Yani Fyasab Nasr Kenit Subholula Fyasr Kenit Hudnitum Il Mashruta Fyasrum Bara Ken Asril Etua Emma Fyasl Sisi Peken As Asom Warubama Yakun Elnte Busarahama Piah the Sisi Gera Hel Ikwen Itsa Ulfikra Inil Ichwen Zema un Sabakan Defa Karub Fikr Il Asir El Muhar Linar Helit Hum with Hum Kulusugun Whetabar Hum Lusugun Noa Butula Winhoa Fide Ldin Ud Watan Ud Le Uno Ged Ilain Bifakarub Slub El Asir Muharra Kul Maharatia Yithurufi Hasig Yet Law Minha Shenin Timu Minzom Ur Husub Taib Hel Kul Asir Muharra Desim Bisign Bemashua and Tomi Taib Walamunknit Howudel Alam Dari Yumraga Utari Hai Pai Helen Ichwen Misa Mogdin Haya in Iwan Hardar Shomanefswen Ilna Rafum Tonzim Fuakal Ambr I Tassar Idag Kyad Barra Masr Futurkea London Goa Masr Uruf Nishab Sugum Ulmanefy Yesuel Helen T Sobeh Matzim Mola Mahavra Min Senator Baucham Sin L Had N Hard I Lakwend Bid Daw Lef Mos Daiman Murtobet Mahda Is Sign Ulla Signal Mul Fik L A Sir Muhara Sign Mish Mugarat Gudran Wa Aswar Lekin Lumasana Nefsi Behawil Insan Mwata N Aidi Ina Moshru Amun Pakan Shuf Ton Turaf Level Hindi Tad Zen Habita Batshenbucan Bitla Wa Dokum De How Al Fikr Oh Insane Mun Kfi Ala Zetu Wafat Had U Tay Ple Nah Gab Tariz Mora Hel Mutari Ashen Go Basuel Il Farado Yeah Izin Morah El Muhtari Mana Abdul Nos Al Hadisisi Sanait Psychology Il Asir El Muhar Hand I Abdul Noser Bad Halligamat Sanat Rahm Sin Elef It Seganu Ut Adam Seyid Utpuhiru Sunit Hawitin Adresal Khar Haradmin Hadir Shefid Dawla Hadu Il Islam Adu Lebashro Islam Al Al When Twiled Il Mazdu Mea Il Rasak Nezetil In Tukambu Fikrit El Ged Pa Hut Wazukirf Tabum Kilmet At Pahu Isad Amal Musal Haguz Eye Udahan Um Sanat Sabin Latamanin Al Mar Haladi Fatah Sugun Ragar Khuenl Mukama Tedrigian Uda Ken Ludaruva CSI Yalam Had Gamia Feg Min Asra Ken Ufilms Asbah C S Un Kobet Ulbefata Hal Bahal Mulek Itiar Sed Tem Minjama Mutasiral Bhitobot Sugun Adeshab In Tcom Demoi What Wazah Moslumia Mugad Mint Ramok Rabin Ichwen Push Mut Tamin Besheclum Beshir Fi Itiari Sed Kodram Hum Sisul Fikrit Tilk Mutor. Nigi Lahdu Mubarak Wukan Chi Marhalit Osiasit El Itu Min Wahad Wut Amin Elfin Wahdosh. Mwarak Ihtar Lefene Waletem Keen. Ichwanit Haraku, Finokabatu Gemayet, Lakenum T Seganu Pishat Limit Fees It Al An. Motakal Hine Makan Shi Must N of Kar Gid'Az Tir Lakin U Ade Blist N F C De Ked War Rumuz Geman. In Natiga, Bardu Wellit Nazan Takabe Itraget Netigal Lebto Il Ken Yudu Mubarak Wagaz Dowla Lamika We In Mubarak Damon Kambiatum Emil In Hate Salahza Muhima We Sal Hel S. I Sisi Ba Man Al Fane Wutal Toshar Il Mazlume Al Kobra. Bad Teleteen Yun Yu Ufad Draba Umuhakavet Gema Utasnefwen Katonzin Hebi Liga Ligir Hish Bisitinette Lakin Fizeman Telma Wood F Social Media Ufi Ifab York Il Hossa Fach Telefil Wap Tul Ad Lafi I Sugumba It Must Nadid Wakawi Vizer In Nazalent Command Shab Nef Sul Wat Halet In Sab Kemel Handel A Harin Wunes Mishai's At Mercy Wizad Yani Bisaraha Moslum Yad Ged Lekin Bushek Lew Saw Anaf Fizzil Wood Washing Media Pai Tal Mahabat Ms Lessir Mohar Oul Hag Tegrubal At Kalia The Grubal At Kalia But Truk Asar Kawaia Limugarat Hataru It Tazib Al Mwane Petiklik Boot Wale Sa Gadab Munafasanu Fadib Semniha Marhalet Asadma Shor Bzum Bitadakham El Excess In La Mkuludi Windana Hina Moslum Bin Hina Bitwid Nezidakaliawut Sana Wet Da Bin Tukam Ramzi Auf Ali Ufadi Hina Bib De Misu Kul Total Il Hawia Il Gemaya Dehil Sugun Bitikwa Nahnu Duddl Ahabia Hammak Il Staktob Lil Asir Bad Miveta Horror Ided Integit Tonzim Il Haya Military Lobasina Hale In Gemait Lichwen Kulema Usirat A Hobisat Byup A Signoa Gamabad Bia Hammak Ertobotu Bitonzim Akter M Lugudu Ibil Heric Tayib Ihiel Mekev Ming Gematili Hwen. Wanamab Ulin Mekhov Ngamatili Hwen Bab Ash Azdi Broz and Kelleman Halah Itim Alamustawal Mukamay and the Shap Ihiel Mekev When Ona Blikida In Shap Ichwen Dawl Alamsto Shabi El Mhov And Shap Tuzel Bil Eterov Bel Ato Budu Shab Omru Maiin Samor Halit Alfinut Moshar Tosher Il Mesma Etrof Sor Yeh in Tabruba Fashit Undil Mumarasot Fiha Ken Khap We Gibada Talyan Shatobedini Il Kahnut Aulus Dine Al Motal Mustri Hassin I Din Y Kudin Usias Alam Uhina Lesin Yub Afi E Len Woda No Mish Aus Yo Aladin Anashef Indul Medini Bedal Ciesa Tirkiz Alam Shaut Hadame Talimir Hairiya Chef Baseda May Kun Shifi I Stig Lel Tilkan Amel Lissiasa The Hal Mwaton Y His Num Hud Mukama Bish L Sait O R Ali Yani The Tafaro Lamal Hab La Hitim Mist Demo Lisiessa And Hap Ama Machil Mwaton El Basit Lemida Mahush Hid Nam D Is Mah Stig L C Sitani Al Mustawa CS Il Machel and Dowla. Ohan Desimalfaker Tobat Mabin A Tonzim E Dowli We Mabin Gem Yet O Ansha De Khan Fomos CSI Fos Shafina Tabot Di Hwen Bil Heric Tehid Mbesh Whi Hai Wa Ay Musalha Tastelzim Hina Elen Hai An and Fasol Anatolzim E Dowl. Nig Notania Hel Ichwen and Da Kudra Ala Kobul Dowl Watania Elen Il Tizem Bekam Il Medanit Dowler Baida and Fikritil Alam The El Sab Nigini Kellim Ala Il Mach Il Amnium. Nahov E Mne Tid A Wil Hair Befikre Tell Yanil Sliha Walaisila. Ementat Agema Betemlik Eda Wet De Hil Dowla Legamel Malumet Yani. Massalan, Had of Gematrich When Pshtagfi Mosla Hed Mesa. Mutala Alakul Mustanosa. Hell Intime Ulit Dowla Ul Watan Ul Elu Well Intimat Toblaul I Tona But Mun Luma Mill Defet Head De Hal I Dal Ibede Bekhov Amni Udes Le Hel Balumet Wal Hak Kashala Bad Oko Hena Postambul Wandinefs Mekov Yan Vicretin Hwen Fiton Zum Hum Intime Wale Um Luba Yil Hiv Krotwe We Howf Nigalha Gam Fusale De Hil Mukama Yani Masalan Ft Grub Amal Mah Dizira Likweni Ho Yani Munzer Min Allah Leg Zuluk Trob Min Hotel Elo Kalim Tuma Udir Borom Massela Khweni Anakfart Rubin Dinet Umato Kola Tazim Fukul Dul M Garol Y Shin Harbalik Ut Leswe Tes Wer Munken Tut Lat Stimalfis Yani Zn Dima Kelf Mashhua Uhi Di Aslehetum En Eslehitum Ilem Temkinum Godon F American Lesimkul Aslehad Halu Anna Type Udakulu Lesim Ebleme Sal T Sal Hegem Murage Mwalena Did Lomf Lomf Hat Uli Hwemer Susmf How Lak La Mercilonfurf Sutir Lomf Bib De Blomf Lovzi Kirmin Nessel Howala Murz Dum Launf Love Z Mah Lonfan Shortam S Casa Banglad Bessenamunkin Atihimek Autalic Isha O Ashtimak Ose Asumet Mod Malde Y Uli Gematic Well Let Mercil Hom for Kedek Ragin Mishfeh Raghalian Nigani Lotum Eliya Shefafia M Shefia Mal Watan Yani Shefafia Malwatan Bukulum Kaunet Pasodemwil Ela Kathol Kerige Cole That Hat Tatarabiza Fikrit Muy L Hamal Siri Unwithat Fukala Binna Shamu Pahadin Binam Al Hamal Siri Fikre Zir Mukbula Temem Taib Halino Wakaim Unikalim Bishlu Wake Taib Kulilena Ultu Dal Hat Is Mahbi Anabol Lenil Machel Mohammaka Wusaba Taib Temkin Lichwen Hattam Muqtamel Medani Budor Blacharin Temkini Lichwen Hattalom Fournaesh Half Mach Basal Eh Del Baz Habal Awel Ichw Hatamil Mahwe Ibezen Fikrit Lichwen Katonzim Anafiro Y Half Ala Zeman Wal Mufrud Ne Tulakwana Hor Lit Hata Alamstawal Hamalan Anabud Auditum Lai Zirga Namalam B Shek Leferdi Yumasil Nafsu Yalan Was Al Lake N Hair Gab Fikrit In Nana Wala Tonzimbi S Nidni Wala Ilitonzim Walanaf Koba Mehani A Hawilha Le Massem Captu Monsin In Aham Haga Masla Tat Tonzim Fam Alumatin Nekaba A God N Kobat Dor Efil Halat Il Shtagal Fust Shabel Ichwen O Dil Ichwen Yulakindil Modu Mureb In Ninth Shtagal O Hatat Sahib Tod Al A Kama Shabel Ihwela Tef Oalik He Beh Diluk Febitelli Bardu Dag Mokbul Toy Yanil Musalha Asbah Kid Mustahila Toy E Hil Hal Ena Mahal Al Musalhal Insenia Wuda Mubab Bashia Mini How Fakar Zame Ness But Fak Yani Al Musalhal Insania Walhia Mumkina Walela Al Musalhal El Insania Mumkina Kaulan Wahita Lenigi Musal Hamkdanaya Shmugarrat Karor C S Al Musal Hadi Mana Innesil F Showera Ul He'll Be Wood Uf Gemati Draishu Maabat Gambaba Minhir Hof Wukaraya Munhir Mab Ach Ninta Lenekuntemi Ligamati Wen Hat Izini Awla Wintam Wazov Fnomti Ahasesa Hatin Illi Mahumati Dawla Tua Dilet N Zimid Dawli Anam Belsh Ay Motul Masri Ywa Fil Fakhda Allahu Alama Akulu Shait Imta Sal Musalha Insenia In Megamiel Atrav Tatrif Bul Khap Eterf Mutabed Mul Khapak Imma Dawla Taterif Aydan In Fita Yahu Zet Ful Hassal Y Daw Yet Machon C Feschal Win La Homf Uma Basab La Homfris Dem Sile Bad Tele Tin Sit Dummar Ayiseka Anabulfema Wood Lazat Ma Heza Wale Sala Homf El Gesedi Hol M Sut Alomf Lovzi La Homfut Drimk Tama Lomfut Dum Kaunetu Belly La Homfudud Dadal Minu Kede Dud D Shabel Ichwen Minut Pium Analomekanid Dawal Hafakarze Musalha Walla Tosfi Finez Zema Bit Un Musalha Ashendel Meshem L Balet Uphines Betrud Sol Madur Hinabel Khlef Less Halil Musal Hamane Tesema Ullamane Tenezul Andes Ladef Share Akter Had Rafed Bishek Laudet Lichwen Uli Ullag Wana Bishlessari Molan Raf Daudit Lichwen Katonzin Belbu Utal In Tagamhatit Len Amla Mushkila Ugudhum Mawa BM and Hamlet Hamzam Amzele Sabot Ked. Fkulbekan, Law Intaf Madrasa Umudaris, Ubait Mudarisin I Tif Ali Moshekil Mal Mudir, Utrukribak, Munkiniani Y Zuk, Fabitelli, Ugudhum Kakutla, Asbachatal Mukama Kaku. Bishashani C Semon. A Frod Wukama Ukulena Don Kalemda, Tadimahov Hai Tai Mulhum Kagamea Here Dowla Di Fakimbula Tay Talon Shufla Mah Musalha U Kharagum Sig. Wehil Hal Abel Man Musalham and Nessel F Sig Tail Kellum Humbo Fakaruzid Hatra Kun Fin Hum Mos Luma Ness Min Hum Udal Yani Anafer Hale Pi Hum Be Fakaruse I'll B El Mur Lakadit Was Ritubly Well Ilbi Adi Aziz Handom Fikran Thom Shekilit Pari It Gemain Talmy Aita War Rasa Hatam Shwissig La Riga Okama Anabolaka Al Mui El Mulaka Lifia Tanaw Fikri Uud Refokat Ton Zim Ozla Ma Bab Ash Ma Fkarha Bit Hazen Afkardib Zo Widow Blacks Zakira Gemaya Lil Elem Il Hadis Lumi Anita Ziban Mwane Anikalem De Kullu Dahua Kudulin Toko Zal Motakalda Biem Alhamit Tawid Nafsi Il Ben Adam Il Esirda Behul U Bar Alamud De Hilu Bisco Alas Hekl Eko Nene Meshasib Haki Bil Hamalit Aad Siot Ruya Al Motakal Bekn Enafsu In O Bahia Laharbu Mukaddesa Fedabi Dun Sho Ur Ah Mak Bel Butula U Rabbaf Sir Shufut A Garab Musal Haf. Genub Afrika Legnatal Hai Al Musalha Ita Amarita Hey Hokume Il In Saful Musalha Igazer Amarit Musa Musar Halotome Bad Ash Re So De Lakin Hel Day Im Fa Fus Walla Tobia Sra Much Tarif Indi Hwen Mush Mugar Torof S Lakin Andum Mushu Ibel Hadud Hot Hok Teda Lenidi Hai Hel Muskita Ihi Lakabat Abel Medicare Lymphis Ner Lakabal Ula Fen Sakha Tani Bellet Al Hakabatania Melefidam In Nesil Metufroba Walana Hatari Nesil Metusina In N Sil Met Show E Mina Hammel In Masulia Tell It Not A Hel Herc Il Imp Tid Dowdy Mush and De Khatar Al Am One Absaraha Shaf and Hua Khatar Hata Shab Masri Bima Inia Shirt In Les Def Ay Rab Head O Dino Tamo is Kerashab El Masrit Basit Il Sur Echwen And Hov Hai Nog Echwen Zufufu When Howd It El Estamor Hat Uli Me Half Moshua Mish Moshua Who Misheku Ochor Musl And Three Rowford Doula Want Three Mumara Set Bad Ichwen Febres Is Kira Shabay Tai Nobus Listener You Head Mutoka Is N Hat Mutoka In Azom Kek Munazom Land Fat Baby Shray Wana Uget Mazardi Then How Shabby Tai Miguel Snere Ted Il Musal Half Ferdi Mumkin Yesalf Ferdi and Mag Mua Motwaratouche Fidem The Wear When I Shaf Scenario De Mulet Snere Tell It With I Sl Has O Pia The C C O Bad C C C O Lazy Mesal Il Musal Hal Muk Mayal Botia Habrisaman Innes Gow Zimmed Gows Rata Dima Pshi Tivet C Sin Binisian Itadrigi Why Ton Zim Say It Hamel Kutu Dehidian Wharigian When I Babin Lift Isn't Fer Halim Seri Hat Ter Imma Hant Musal Halfia Oh Nant Al Musal Halbuk Tame El Bati Ah Brisaman Toy Naud Hiran Noted Psychology Il A Sir M Horror Una Ham Schmugrod Ragbashir Lin Tum Al Haya Nitek the Grub T Sabma Hawi Ye Me Rwe Zulm Mustamir Hata Lemogut Fil Herid Manas Lichwen Hinaudutu Hu Akana Asiro Horror Will Sign Hina Echrug Illa Manzu Fahua Horror Was Eufakir Fikrit Asir Muharrar U Hurug Mid Sap Lainu Bizal El Matakal Awai Beledu A Sir Tagruba Hata Bad Auditu O Hurugu Wuda Achtar Minis Signasu. Patakalus Munterit Tefkir Asir Moharar Dahteg Gohtibar Whtag Ira Halakat Mi Away. Musal Hamal Hwen Shmugar Su L C S E Dima Ara Kitawe Hal Musri Daw Lamedia Hadisa Wal Dawulit Mushru Adini Yeda Gihad Dawir Maluma W Ash Betharak Ton Zim Vir Maluma Hal Halif Tasaf Hag Dida Walanifli Kita Bud Mik Fizibera Bilaraga. Femi Otomanin Daraga Fetah Nar Mod Femi Otomanin Bishbed Dowar Al Haki Min Zawia Tokli Debun Hell Musul Modutalifa Udaiman Mukhtani Infish Mustabel Minhir Has Mil Modi Wadab Talluk Baman Hal A Talok Bil Modi. Falezim Nasim Ru Lil Mustabel That Is Work Talluc Zemini Bitil Kalmar Hal Wahiren Sukran Gaziran Wan Al Kalkum Harahir