Ինչու են պաշտոնյաները հրաժարվում տեղեկատվություն տրամադրելուց. 8-րդ հարկ

«8-րդ հարկ» փոդքասթի հերթական թողարկումը պետական պաշտոնյաների կողմից տեղեկատվության տրամադրումը մերժելու մասին է։ #Հետք ի լրագրող, փաստաբան Գրիշա Բալասանյանը և լրագրող Տիրայր Մուրադյանը զրուցել են տեղեկատվության մատչելիության, գրավոր հարցումների և դրանց վերաբերյալ դատական գործերի ընթացքի մասին։ 

Տեղեկատվություն ստանալու նպատակով դատական գործերը, սովորաբար, տարիներ են տևում, որից հետո ստացվող տեղեկատվությունը կորցնում է արդիականությունը։ Պաշտոնյաները, հաճախ կամայական մերժումներով, խոչընդոտում են լրագրողների՝ տեղեկատվություն ստանալու իրավունքի իրացմանը։ Այդ վարքագիծը բարդացնում է լրագրողների աշխատանքը, որի հետևանքով տուժում է նաև հանրությունը։

Transcript

Copy Transcript Copied

SPEAKER_02 1:50

It takes an hartsum nerium net so process nerum, you have former hartsumer in Vatan Patashanum, Arrasunalinum Naiv, Datakan Kalkovet, Hartsumery Patashanere, et Angestunal, as Gorzum Mezokuma, Krishan of Nav, Pastabanary, Palatiantham, Licenza Volvas, Pastaban. Bit Michev Bungalate S Hartzumery Setto in the Kamermotasumitimers Haman Voltefsa Kapas Heta Snerechen, Dransdatal Nedchen, Matkinvor Katuchan Hartzum neder Meng Octago, Vorpus Gorzik, Volv Hassanalia, uh Ned Chevormy, Katuchan Hartzumarkelu, Espressat Idavunk. It's some other champ, Mestavat, Messi.

SPEAKER_00 4:39

Do arans terikatvitsus tanalu, fakumum Chaskaroa press. Tunaversan two now Sanunda Voros deb Kerum Bets Katumatsunovotvuma Yer Pemenet. Tunaversanunda uh Uter Kat Vitsunegites in Chovakarevor Martha Gone Hanre Vera has go to Naporchumirats, Ida Ganastal, Driani Hak Mikichavali Horkain Kartswan Bed Khandra Dharnank or Tef, uh the Gatutzana Zutmyain, Kartal, Ev Hangis, Nastelichi Dudranoviratsumstanal Vidaunky Dran Hajor To Halida Mknus. Do answer Versna Khan uhrankatsivats Hans Numer Siren, Bitz Barabach Dabar and Herzov Neri Matchelgan, Pantroh, Gutnoch, Taratsov, Martikovkesh, Mes Vos Dep Kirum, Oknuman. I think Arten Vosh Usumasi Rats Tavjal Nesh Pohansuman Mes Asman, yes, Iskanem Karwa Selmanatz Hansum Duke Shau Nakik ordev Shadvanerin, Hasanel Chunam, Kam Gutzel Chimetatselte words Kauru versna, but it's Bare Bach Tabash Namankakats Nerelunk. Mates has gurts and ale hashtag. Yes, Pet Kanaevsatz and Masovins Chita, Vedias Pet Kagan, Yev Sparrem in Pahanch Munk, that they got Spahanj Munk Pahanch Munkka Bavaris. But it's subjective naiv for Dirk and Nerkasum new teamage. But the Bart has to make it Ishans opportunity over Ishansangalhinha, uh Zenatuchi Vosh Hana Vere has Kochuna Ujlini. In Chuver of a Dev has no in Hana Karavar Mantiru to Basmati problem Nevka, Basmativ Charasha Hunet, Bazmativ, Corruption Risk, Yevetehanarot Line Henauchun Handruchana, Atum Leratwam Josari, Leratvam Justini Versha Hundred Chanhamar Shatum, uh at Gehtot Apranka Doska Gajeres. Hence Dranove Pymanavat, sounds ner and parts, Karto Mam, Vichaka Gritsuale Lupacharov Thaikatuna Merj.

SPEAKER_02 15:34

Yesum for Shot Batzane, is Kazban Madre Lou Hartzum, Yev Avelin, Nunisk Mes Two Lane Talis me Hodvat Sasharad Nachar Neri, Ashkata Seniak Neshima.

SPEAKER_00 16:31

But if Arten Voroshumer Kayatznail Yev Skset Inkiren Parkivatre Lava Shatanki Hamar, Sksetz Hare Resource Nerokta Gorza Lievalum Banakanabar, Arten Haskatsav Ishhanat Kana Vadbanchi Ev Karalia, Dran Snap Anznakan, Okutzanal, Ne Inchaunumen, Yevda Anelan, Hajor Tishanutzuna, Bolo Ishano Tuner, Dabanorosh, Ailharzat, Inchkanovada, Balan Savorvats. Hima Vonsorf Madishanary, Artening Army Gitzha Hatuman, Dirahamar, Dranova Pyman Awards, at the Khanutzuna, Informatia Chital, Kam Hana Varina, Samana Pakel.

SPEAKER_02 18:02

They Gachtni Hans Narakanov, Gachtney Griffover canats. So, we have to use the same thing.

SPEAKER_00 25:08

Yet a hymn can't hera parakwas Tavalner, waki sakal hete uchneskarwa sanal. Dramat Tavumete informatyan Hassanel, but said information worakial chuchaskarov but sartakish, and hearts of the cars. Ayo, Antamena Heart Gravarmanka, Antana Pese Valen Dav, Pastat Chenusum Naside Lou Velu Chainana, Anthaumena Mek Jamva and Taskum Karil Patasan Comet Kapek, and the other.

SPEAKER_02 38:02

I think for datakan karkov taek stanalu merg ports edites, name for menk physica instituti vedaberial medata varsum for Kanitari Davids. Hinktari. Hinktari devetshin uzum, physical institute it's usuming, hoca barsuntivo shumere, uh institute merjumer, uh talk asumer for Hinkhari Hazard.

SPEAKER_00 39:02

But Sherjakam Michawari Nakarmas in the Shet, uh Meg Tanir Araj, but physical institute of hacking. Uh, Shirjakam Michawadi datakang kunnets, part well, and yevda, the ranit seto in Svarka Gitzapets. Uh Kartumam Salov Mijotzer, but it's mischievous datakampashmanitsunashata Archinaweta, had kapesler agreed hammer. Zaruchis Kazun Nashinka were at informatyan Hanatsuka Yevhetbabar, Pet Kashat Arakara Parakel, it's havok mere datakan gorze and kan Yerkar and Tevum were at information, Arten Pet Kchilino for Mes Tarlison had Vachari Himamvera Hetah, Fizika Instituting Yatan Radarang, Hink Tarin, Babakan, Yerkar Jamanaker, uh it informatyan stana luhamash. Yev arteng asits, uh mezu akiped k chivit, kamerasat mateling jura, patvopet kai jeris durz gaink, um each verchaunaketzink, hocutak andovnari, uhirkaitzwits bytes uhta saurpes barriakan hachtanakespezgirant sankarach ortevet informat, chokta gorzit chairant, nor Voroshum Nedenka.

SPEAKER_02 40:38

Florence, Havelvas Netchkar, uh at Voroshum de Rimage Arranz Nap Pesch. Hink Dali, Yev Mezanitz Jamanakinats, Yevni Arter, uh Data Kant Hamakarkin Tara Bernett Inc. Uh Physica Institute Pasta Banitzaks, Shkitemirava Banitzaks, Inktalinka, Me Physica Institute Hokka Bartuna Horti Nahagay, Kamahatarov.

SPEAKER_00 41:18

I think the eth's man, herinak dues, kartsmat Horkan Banner Davelov Gites, te uhzenthucts nail, but steh uh data patmutsuna rachatsov, data ranin tramadretinformatya were pochanticanoleragro nerin, wakis spitak, athos formati tterin. Uh phak informatian, epergachni pauna koch the katus. I think nunis data ranin hana volutin chain talis, ginahatel da petka pakvi, tech pakvi. I think athos formati uh spitak tohtver sneliv nail selber informatsa absurd uhsen wash uh chigitamalit there are not here, copy tassets, but it's fasten uh uh yet vera darnak and data can hamakarkin uh depcurn pet kagnal uh datacan uh pashpan chanch anaparo or pc gone uh dust direcam button. Darcial mech idravunk, swat naharvat, so teambuchakan informatiach statsang. Bit's warpes island rank, uh, Karlja D mail mipin Dranits Elemasun, Mates who said, Bites Havenaselchika were of Gona Masamp, Shad Arak, uh Arak, Nakatiunam data nihameats, anarabra informatia standard, but uh paratwikol. Savakayum, Voj Batkan, Marminer, Atkaner Zhortavarakan, Urichem Bernal, Yev and Mifat Himawalila, Venkashatum Yeval Nirakamda Tavat Chemkau Rasel Vol Mishtate Pes Shadeum Ayotapansiken Ashatum, Batsayel Gnahatman Harzahat Hinchkanova Aranchumirenzanakasha Haring, Yevinchkanova, Veraberum Irense Merza Vor Neri Riskerin Ortev Grete Bolor Volort Nerum, Karelia Gatnel Korruption Risker, Haknavatz Pashpanvoh Irenste Sanki Pashpanvoh Informatia Volet Pesel Hasanelichidarnum. Inch Pesnachort is Khanutunary Debkum Yev, Kartoumai Sishanutkum, Hajor Tishanut Gimanang Te Inchiaw.

SPEAKER_02 45:31

Nav mewaki Arzanakrum Kusane were snare, Hamkang Karusnede Miatak, Miyaziv Chen, Taikatun Telamadrilu Hartzum. Mengharkas Menk Hosumink Metzama Sam, Taikutsu Neshastana Ludin at Bartutunin, Paskan to Karusnese, for Takitzel Hartzumenkan, Te Catusun, Pachas, Stanumeng, Yevash Hatumenko. Mercedesmer financere Hartzunis, normal Stanuma taekatun Stanuma taekatun, economica inachunis, ushatumov, bytes stanoma takut. Yes imports is never normal to catusu standard. And Hamena Hamakov Nera Kano Voroshum Ned.

SPEAKER_00 49:04

Veraknichantatarana Yevas Ampopochtor's Saradas Datani Voroshuma, Hima Dimelenk Vujrabic Dataran, Huisunenalo, Vord Vijrabic Datanis Hatarak Voroshumovaki Kaveratnifikasin or Datakan Act, Vorovatev Vojorenko, Vojashatanka in Praxicayum, Chica Neman Ban Vod Leragroka, Hartzmanekitz, Petkawaki, Hambagri, Lyazura Gira, Voj Gites, yes Lyazorum Mesis Leragro, Vordkatna Yevaparaki.

SPEAKER_02 50:06

Data Vorner Portsaru data Vorneri.

SPEAKER_00 50:09

Tarinerov, Ashatoh Data Vorneren, Skisnak Ner Chen, uhsen Voroshdeb Kerumskasnak Nera Aveli Portsaruenkhan Starshaur Portsaru Nere Vorovatev Tarinerov Ashata's Data Vorner Galia Sel Artenskel and Svarach Hashkata Levekme PC absurda in Voroshum Nerenkayasum. Asiktavujenk Voj, Vicharabek datani Nhadepa in Voroshum Nenkartoum, Wora Irent Sparta Khanutunerimchematunvoch, Evropakan datarani Voroshum Nenovajn Kartum, eenchhtari Nerov Kira sasno inut. Bollor data analysis dishgohem in chem deshgo ver of the ports notis for data kan hamakarka was tahuzunchiva.