First Milk In-Tents Talks
Welcome to In-Tents Talks, the podcast from British farmer-owned dairy co-operative First Milk.
Recorded on farms, in fields and at events across the UK, In-Tents Talks brings together the people shaping the future of regenerative dairy farming. From farmers and scientists to customers, partners and industry experts, each episode explores the ideas, evidence and partnerships helping build more resilient farming businesses and food systems.
These are honest conversations about the challenges facing agriculture today - and the practical solutions already being put into action. We'll explore everything from soil health, biodiversity and animal welfare to carbon, water, supply chains and the economics of farming, sharing what's working, what we're learning and where the biggest opportunities lie.
Whether you're a farmer, adviser, customer or simply interested in the future of food, subscribe to hear conversations from the field that go beyond the headlines - and discover how regenerative dairy is helping shape a more resilient future for farming and food.
First Milk In-Tents Talks
From risk to river health - can collaboration help improve our rivers?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
What will it take to improve water quality while building more resilient farming businesses?
Recorded live at Groundswell 2026, Lee Truelove, Director of Regenerative Farming at First Milk, is joined by Ric from the Cleddau Partnership to explore the challenges facing water quality and why farmers and local communities need to work together to address them.
Together, they discuss what water monitoring is telling us about the health of the Cleddau catchment in West Wales, and how First Milk’s approach to nutrient footprinting and water risk mapping is helping build a clearer picture of where action can make a difference.
From building trust between farmers and communities to tackling nutrient losses in ways that work for both the river and the farm business, the conversation explores why collaboration is essential if lasting improvements are to be made.
Ric also shares his vision for what success could look like: healthier rivers, more profitable and resilient farms, greater recognition for farmers making positive changes and, ultimately, an approach that could provide a model for other catchments.
Whether you're a farmer, adviser or simply interested in the future of our rivers and food system, this episode offers a practical look at how farming and communities can work together to improve water quality.
Like this episode? Subscribe to ensure you never miss out. Want to find out more about First Milk and its regenerative agriculture approach? Visit www.firstmilk.co.uk
Hello and welcome to Intense Talks. Wherever you find us, on a farm, in a field, or an event somewhere around the UK, we'll be talking to the people at the heart of regenerative dairy farming. Each episode explores the challenges facing agriculture today and the practical ideas, innovations and partnerships that are helping build a more resilient future for farming and food. This episode was recorded at Grandswell 2026 and was hosted by Lee True love, the Director of Regenerative Farming at First Milk. It focuses on water quality. I hope you enjoy listening.
Speaker 1Hi everyone, if you look at the tent, we've got carbon, nature, and water, and they should have equal status, and they haven't today, both in environmental and in government, and even in what we've done up until this point. So we've launched the first milk water strategy, and I'm going to introduce Ric in a minute, but that First Milk water strategy is about really taking the responsibility very seriously of what dairy farming can impact both positively, but unfortunately sometimes not positively on watercourses. And what we've launched in that is uh both the first time at scale there's been nutrient footprinting done. So nutrient footprinting is essentially measuring the incoming nitrates, phosphates, potash versus what leaves the farm in milk and livestock and crops. So that balance in the middle is a key metric to understand if we're loading the environment upon which we farm or if we're more in equilibrium. The second thing we're doing is we've now water-risked map every one of 90,000 hectares. So we've done nutrient footprinting on 700 farms. So not a pilot, not a trial, all of them. And we've now water-risked mapped that 90,000 hectares. So what that means is every single field is now uh graded for its risk, and the risk is associated with its proximity to the water, it's proximity to every river, stream, beckon, burn, also its slope, and also its historic flood risk. So if you combine those two, you have two pretty unique uh metrics now on our water stewardship. And I think water and dairy farming in the last two decades, possibly three, seems to be dominated by how big a slurry store you can you can build. Well, building a bigger slurry store doesn't take away the problem, it just helps you to manage it slightly better. So we want to take the whole agenda on to the next level. I'm going to introduce you to Ric now. Um, Ric is a key member, I don't know if he calls himself chairman or leader of the uh of the Cleddau Partnership. So Cleddau, the Cleddau is a really important river in West Wales. So it's important for First Milk, both in terms of you know our community, but obviously our farmers uh are all part of that that river um catchment. But I think within the sort of NGO sector, uh river activist section, Ric is pretty unique, I would suggest, because not only is he passionate, and there's lots of people in this sector who are passionate, but I think he gets his points across much better than anybody else because he's articulate and super professional. What I want the theme to come from from this talk is about collaboration. We've all got a common interest in rivers. No farmer wants their river um to deteriorate, and you know, there actually are a lot of common goals with the community groups. So, with that, I'm gonna let Ric do a bit of talking because you're the guest, Ric. Um, and really that I suppose the first question for me is water is rising up the agenda, and I think we both share enthusiasm for that. But why is water quality today such a critical issue? And why do you think collaboration is the way forward?
Speaker 2I think water is critical for different reasons to different people. So we're very focused on nutrients because nutrients are damaging the ecology of the river, and a lot of those nutrients in permitture come from the dairy sector. Other people have focused on pathogens, what's happening with E. coli in the water, is it safe for me to bathe? Others are focused on their uh their sport, their fishing, their boating. Uh is it actually this water looks horrible, it smells. The the water companies want water to be fit to drink, and sometimes it's not. So everybody has a different agenda with water quality. Um, I really, really like to start by applauding what First Milk are doing with nutrient footprinting. I think it's a real game changer in terms of how we see it going forward.
Speaker 1Just building on that, you've got, I think, correct me if I'm wrong, is it 100, 150 citizen scientists, would we call them that? Volunteers, uh, enthusiastic people in the Cleddau partnership. Is that about right?
Speaker 2Yeah, we we do a lot of water quality tracking mapping. We've done also some uh additional work with farms, uh, some First Milk farms, um, so soil compaction measurement, uh measuring water quality directly on farm runoff. So those volunteers come from all walks of life, a lot a lot of really, really technically competent people, but they care about the river. And one of our jobs in this partnership with First Milk is to build the trust between the community and the farmers. And those volunteers are really at the heart of that. We want the farmers to sort of learn from us, and we want to learn from the farmers. And really, if both sides understand, they're not sides, we're working together, but if both parties understand the perspective of the other, we're more likely to succeed.
Speaker 1So, with all of that testing, you know, it is obviously extra scrutiny, which some farmers I'm sure would have some reservations about. But what have we learned so far, you know, with that testing? And because I'm a Hereford boy, River Wye, how does a Cleddau compare to the sort of uh the Hollywood River at the moment in terms of uh what's gone on there?
Speaker 2Well, the the the first comparison is is the the simple physical water quality testing for phosphates and nitrates. And the Cleddau is is significantly higher in both than the Wye. The Cleddau is is actually the worst, uh it has the highest failure rate of any of the what they call special area conservation rivers in Wales, any of the nine. So by all measures, the Cleddau is is pretty much one of the worst in Wales. Uh, and and that's reflected in the biology of the river. Fish stocks are rapidly declining, uh, you know, we're losing a lot of the the beneficial plant life, etc., etc. So we've learnt a lot about how bad it is. We've also learnt a lot about how variable it is. And a lot of people will hear about the why, and it's generally in the context of phosphate. Um, and phosphate is is is pretty bad. Phosphate is very sticky, it sticks in the soil. If you have a surplus of phosphate from farming, a lot of it will just stay in the soil, sometimes for decades. Uh, so you have what we call legacy phosphorus that can be actually tapped into from from farming, depending on the way you farm. We also have very high levels of nitrate uh from mainly coming in from fertilizer. Um, and that tends to go through the soil into the groundwater, and we have now building levels of nitrate in the groundwater, which is often what is abstracted for drinking water and actually on farm use as well. So both nitrogen and phosphorus are important. Phosphorus is much more spatially sensitive, so phosphorus can be high or low depending on what is what is draining into that particular brook, what the weather conditions are, nitrate, nitrogen tends to be more of a constant because it's in the groundwater. So, as a as a group of of the community, we understand a lot more about water quality. The two things that sort of struck me was one, what what what is where where is most of that phosphorus and nitrogen coming from? And we we commissioned a study by Lancaster University which took the whole catchment as a nutrient footprint. And it's very clear that 80% plus of both is coming from farming on the Cleddau. So if we're gonna restore this river to good health, farming, we need to change the way we farm, but that has to be a win-win. So whatever we do has to work out for the farmers as well as for the river.
Speaker 1Thanks, Ric. And I think our members, you know, listening in to this podcast will probably uh want me to sort of inject, and I know you you do deal with this in bat with balance. So, you know, water companies and other farming systems uh, you know, do create some of the issue. I think with the reason why we're working with other cleat, I we're appreciative that we've got a real density of members there. But how do you think you can um perhaps reach those that aren't with First Milk? Because of course, uh our members may say that they they're motivated to do a lot of good work, but what about their neighbours? Good question.
Speaker 2Probably 80% of our farm contact is with First Milk customers because we we you know we've we've got to know each other. We are doing some work with Pembroke uh Pembroke Creamery or some contacts there. And I do uh get invited from time to time to some of the farming discussion groups where there are farmers on on in the groups that are supplying different different uh processors, but we would like to build a similar relationship with with other main processors that are buying milk in Pembrokeshire.
Speaker 1And the the final question, Ric, is I suppose it's more about what do you really want to, what does good look like? What do you really want to see in the River Cleddau? I know you want to see paddle boarding with you on top of it, uh, and and hopefully when you fall in, you're you're happy to fall in. I'll survive. But yeah, what you know, what what meaningfully do you think is realistic to uh to expect we can do over, say, five or ten years?
Speaker 2Let me break it down into three or four. The first one, obviously, is that instead of the Cleddau failing on most of its uh pollution or you know in compliance tests, we're passing on most of them. So the river becomes good. They call it good status. That's it, that's a simple one. Uh the second thing for me would be that the farmers that have made the changes that have brought that about are successful and that those farms are more profitable and more resilient because that's the only way it's going to work. The third one for me would be around the consumer. You know, there's a bit of a dream that in the future the consumer will have more visibility on the produce that they buy. And if I want to buy liquid milk that's from a farmer with good regenerative credentials, whatever that scheme is, I can't do that anymore at the moment in the in the supermarket. And ditto for cheese or whatever, maybe Golden Hooves, a slight exception, but quite small. But my dream would be that the consumer can actually decide to buy this milk rather than that milk, this cheese rather than that cheese, and pay a premium for it, which comes back to the farmer. Um, the other one that I would like to see is that a lot of the schemes in place, the sustainable farming scheme, in Wales, it's co-op, uh, the regular the control of agriculture and pollution regulations, there's a lot of things that that really address the consequences of this problem, not the cause. So the cause in Pembrokeshire is that we are beyond the carrying capacity of the land, and thus there is surplus phosphorus and surplus nitrogen every day of the year going into the soil and into the rivers. So we have to address that cause as well as just dealing as as Lee mentioned, uh, extra extra slurry storage, buffer zones, etc. etc., is all to do with the consequences, not the cause. So I'd really like that that that change to come about. And the last one, and possibly the most important, farmers get criticized a lot. And you know, the result of the system that they work in, there's been a lot of pressure to produce at lower and lower uh cost, and therefore scale has increased, economies have scaled. I'd like to see an increase in respect from the community for what farmers have done to improve our river. That would be that will be one other dream, if you like.
Speaker 1Thanks, Ric. Um, so just to round up then, I think we at First Milk, as I said, we take the responsibility for rivers, and that includes the River Eden in Cumbria, the River Nith in Dumfries, and there's many other sort of major rivers that we're connected with. But hopefully, through the example of working with the Cleddau Partnership, we can we can make similar progress with those other groups, Ric. I know that it's actually now a really big community, and I think you know, for our for our members, we need to realize that you know there are literally thousands of people now that are super concerned, super motivated about river quality. But you know, pasture-based, grazing-based, regenerative farming, we believe has got many, many aspects that are complementary. Um, we've just got to you know deal with some of our issues, but also elevate, I think, what many of our members are already doing. Do you want to add to that?
Speaker 2I've just said I do see the the Pembroke and the Cleddau, and with First Milk's involvement and hopefully some other dairy companies, this can be a real sort of beacon or example for the rest of the country. We have an incredible density of dairy cows, we have a very sensitive river. Uh, we have First Milk present. I think we have 25,000 milk in dairy cows and 15,000 people living on the Cleddau C catchment. So we and each dairy cow excretes about 40 or 50 times more nitrogen and phosphorus than a human being. So you can see where the dynamic is. So Pembrokeshire is a little bit of an extreme case. If we can mend Pembrokeshire, I'm sure we can mend other areas as well.
Speaker 1Thank you, Ric. Um, I think that was really fascinating, and thanks for I know it's the first time to grain as well. Um, but thank you very much. Thank you.
SpeakerA huge thank you to today's guests for sharing their perspective. If you enjoyed this podcast, then subscribe to the channel so you never miss an episode as we continue conversations with people that are helping to shape a resilient future for dairy. Thanks for listening.