The Secret Is OUT

Shift At The Center | Sally Gary: Faith, Sexuality, And The Change at CenterPeace

Stan Stadig Season 1 Episode 5

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 33:48

Send us Fan Mail

Shift At The Center | Sally Gary

Faith, Sexuality, and the Change at CenterPeace


Sally Gary spent years helping LGBTQ Christians find a place in the church. But what happened when the founder of CenterPeace changed her own beliefs about same-sex marriage?

In this episode of The Secret Is OUT, host Stan Stadig tells Sally’s story—from her Church of Christ upbringing and years at Abilene Christian University to coming out, building a ministry, and finding love with Karen Keen.

For fourteen years, CenterPeace made room for honest conversations about faith and sexuality while maintaining a traditional Christian view of marriage. Sally believed that view herself. She lived it, wrote about it, and became someone conservative churches trusted.

Then years of listening, studying Scripture, and facing her own loneliness brought her somewhere she hadn’t expected. In October 2020, she told her own conference that she had become affirming of same-sex marriage. Then she introduced the woman she planned to marry.

Throughout the shift, Sally still loved the people and places that had shaped her. Changing her mind meant risking those relationships. It also meant imagining a life she had spent decades believing was unavailable to her.

Along the way, I share some of my own experience with trying to explain—and change—my sexuality. Sally’s story raises questions many of us know personally: Can I be gay and Christian? What happens when my understanding of Scripture changes? Will the people who love me still make room for me?

In this episode

  • Sally Gary’s upbringing in the Churches of Christ and connection to Abilene Christian University.
  • Coming out privately, then speaking publicly at ACU.
  • Why Sally founded CenterPeace for LGBTQ Christians and their families.
  • Celibacy, loneliness, and reconsidering beliefs about same-sex marriage.
  • Her relationship with biblical scholar Karen Keen.
  • The 2020 announcement that changed CenterPeace.
  • Finding belonging while staying connected to Christian faith.

Written and narrated by Stan Stadig. This is a narrated account of Sally Gary’s story, drawing on her public statements, writing, and published interviews.

Content note: Discussion of suicidal thoughts, family abuse, religious rejection, attempts to change sexual orientation, and long-term isolation.


For further info on Sally Gary, CenterPeace, and the 2026 Conference:

Visit centerpeace.net to learn about the upcoming 20th Anniversary Conference as well as the ministry, LGBTQ Christian community, retreats, and support for families.

The 2026 CenterPeace Conference takes place October 15–17 in Dallas, at First United Methodist Church of Dallas. Visit the conference information and registration page for speakers, workshops, and the schedule.

Explore more:

Support and community

If this episode brings up thoughts of suicide or you need immediate emotional support, call or text 988 in the United States or Canada.

For support around faith and sexuality, CenterPeace offers community for LGBTQ people, their families, and church leaders.

Music credits

With thanks to the musicians whose work helps tell this story:

Additional audio credits: “Esperanza” by bmangelo; microphone feedback and tapping by freqman; road and busy-room ambience by breviceps; small-group conversation ambience by neilraouf; car-door and engine audio by nematoki; and Zoom connection audio by rachelribeiro71.

References and further reading