#948 האם ׳מאמר הדור׳ של הרב קוק רלוונטי לדורנו? | הרב ספי בר חי VS הרב גיא אלאלוף

בפרק זה של הפודקאסט "על המשמעות" עו"ד תמיר דורטל מארח את הרב גיא אלאלוף והרב ספי בר חי לדיבייט על משמעות "מאמר הדור" של הרב קוק בימינו והשפעתו על הציונות הדתית. הפרק מפגיש שתי תפיסות עולם מנוגדות ונוקבות בתוך העולם האמוני והישיבתי. מצד אחד, הרב ספי בר חי, המייצג את התפיסה הקלאסית מבית מדרשה של ישיבת שבי חברון, מציג את הרעיון לפיו החילוניות בת זמננו נובעת למעשה מצימאון ל"תורה גדולה". לטענתו, אנשים נמנעים משמירת מצוות לא מתוך כפירה או חוסר מוסריות, אלא משום שהם אידיאליסטים המחפשים משמעות עמוקה שהמסגרות הרגילות לעיתים מתקשות לספק. מצד שני, הרב גיא אלאלוף יוצא למתקפה חריפה נגד תפיסה זו. הוא טוען כי הגישה הזו יוצרת "תודעת עבדות" של הציבור הדתי-לאומי כלפי העולם החילוני והאליטות. לשיטתו, הניסיון להתחנף לחילוניות, כביכול, מתעלם מהמציאות בשטח – שבה רוב האנשים שחוזרים היום בתשובה מחפשים דווקא תורה פשוטה, קדושה, וחיבור למסורת, ולא אידיאלים פילוסופיים מורכבים. האם הציבור הדתי-לאומי באמת סובל מתחושת נחיתות מול מובילי מחאת קפלן? האם טעינו בהבנת כוונתו המקורית של הרב קוק כשהחילוניות שינתה את פניה? ומה באמת מחפשים היום צעירים ישראלים כשהם מתקרבים לדת? במהלך דיון סוער וחסר פילטרים זה, המאזינים ייחשפו לניתוח עומק היסטורי, סוציולוגי ופילוסופי של התנועות השונות ביהדות ב-120 השנים האחרונות. החל מתנועת ההשכלה, דרך החינוך הממלכתי-דתי ותופעת הדתל"שים, ועד לרבני הטיק-טוק של ימינו. תשמעו כאן ויכוח עקרוני על הדרך הנכונה להשפיע על החברה הישראלית, ותלמדו כיצד טקסטים שנכתבו לפני למעלה ממאה שנה עדיין מעצבים את הפוליטיקה ואת תפיסת העולם של מגזרים שלמים בישראל. אם אתם סקרנים לגבי עתיד היהדות בישראל, הפרק הזה ישאיר אתכם עם חומר למחשבה. 

00:00:00 הצגת האורחים והנושא מאמר הדור
00:04:18 התביעה לתורה גדולה בדור הגאולה
00:11:11 ביקורת על תפיסת החילוניות כאידיאליסטית
00:18:56 האם הציבור הדתי סובל מתודעת עבדות?
00:23:03 הוויכוח על משמעות המושג חילונים נורמטיביים
00:30:22 האם חילונים באמת מחפשים תורה גדולה?
00:36:00 תפקיד בית המדרש ופנימיות התורה
00:46:36 האם לימוד אמונה מתאים לכולם?
00:52:35 הצלחות וכישלונות בחינוך הממלכתי דתי 
00:58:35 תופעת הדתלשים ומניעי חזרה בתשובה
01:03:35 יחס רבני הציונות הדתית למחאת קפלן
01:09:48 קבלת ביקורת והקשבה לדעות מנוגדות
01:15:15 מאיפה שואבת הציונות הדתית את תפיסתה?
01:25:32 ספרי אמונה ומוסר למתחילים ביהדות (פרימיום)

 #פודקאסט #על_המשמעות

Transcript

SPEAKER_02 0:06

Alan Khavarim, Regal French, Alamot, the Regal Sperr him, Allah Patriot, and the people who are not a good thing.

SPEAKER_00 8:49

And I shame to die, I benched on a fallbeat, but I have Cold Pam Shuaya by show, Iab but so I mean the Shash at timely mud. Kills the Brahmashu Ben Bitlenu Kilo, the Shanim, and the Mm. But Tomuch Matara kilo.

SPEAKER_01 16:42

She Torah, the correct Ben Horin, and the other thing. So to me, show now. But fisailonim should have dole, Mamash is intellect to all Yotemegar Givesonim the Hamishra, Ms. Rochinkimeshra Modimoto, Nim Shallam, as well another Lama, Kiume O Lam Lotaan, Shul Toragdola, or Merch would say, Takhiv Lota Minot Habed Trotzhadam and the Lord, Lolo Marla Nashim, Mahem Khoshvim. And he holds Cavano, a Lolo Maram Shokim. The Varchani, and Hosovia Zello, Torah, and the other thing. The Gambu Bamagolka intellectuals, the Washington Haps in Toragola, the other Hiloni, a Hil uh, stomach smolan, Shanezik as a capilanist, can Hiloniamiti, Amasaltiam and Gamba Muna, he a master, Mamado Lom Deberkimakayamas, as a as as a masotema em Lomhapsim Toragdolim Toractana, Masha Rapsefi, a Tev attiv le Vazato Tobashi Orso, Torash, TikTok, Shall Rabanimactanim, Shall Shem Deberity Tam Alahima Petim Shim, Vanigat Ania should be called Ms. Hilonim Hapsimashol. Kilefakot M omrimashu them omdimachormash omri. Stop Ematim Toractana, Metno Nemo time, Sapinta etaschora.

SPEAKER_00 23:44

Have seen a sherota killassiota, and Mamarado idealistic, no F idealist.

SPEAKER_01 27:58

Then the Borodnat or Mimazotin.

SPEAKER_02 28:55

Can Safim Bahia Fitzbayim or Let him? Okay.

SPEAKER_00 29:48

It's right, political Israel.

SPEAKER_01 31:27

Avalz the Ulolo Ged Belgoshav Cook, a mcoka vod. Stomatanikaberez, Arafkuku, Adam Ormot Gadov, Kesemod Bisibamutova, Lokum Lotomad. Aval, and Utah Etimanyan, Chatham Toragdola. The can you say a theorish, Kalav Cook, Bishnat Beshrim Shannab, Sr. Vadin Latzwah Toragola? Sadhsimbus Model Kot, Varbushniot, Male, Vegadush, Betawiot, Shekhan, Mibli, and the Mm. Maybe Fascism and the Foods.

SPEAKER_02 35:28

Gamim Kulamu Pushima Simganatim? A dano.

SPEAKER_01 35:31

Can the Mizet Halta? Times of Girata Magal shaped howitzer story lonachon. Zotomer Gam Pam, Ayuamonkofri, Shemayon, Normativi Makutin, but Kufatascala, are you a monomankofrim? Why are normatively uditolamitz, the Hakamisha Ubiaud, Gamifthook, Achem Kufata Skala, Tatah Badosh Mendelson Vala, if the hooky lot you do, but weot and shouldn't have a tama missile for Nirzah Bashoa.

SPEAKER_00 38:42

And Shelter Shell Imshot, the Zelamat, the Lamadumaraveo, Engelaver of Drukum, Angelavuk when I okay, shoot. Pownicau, Tachiva, and Hutzimo. Zomaran, Shovim, Shadam Tachilmod, the Lishol Shellot. And you say colour be a showing for Butlummash by Sofia Maverick, Ulove Viterra shoot. Ulove Viterra shoot, medium screened out to Sholi, and shallowit Kahara Voder, and the bet in Dr. Shall I get him. Look, what have you talked about to Chuva? Shah Bar Sims, and you said, and he was a Truc Dola, Tragdola Mod. Kids who had a heavy ramp, at Tibush and Limited with Kevin Ardukman, Madalaglium, Bamar at Tibus Amistra. Zo.

SPEAKER_01 41:38

I love the Rukman, I love it. No.

SPEAKER_02 42:27

Okay, Bonda Financier.

SPEAKER_00 43:37

As an American Shakira, Otto Arave, the Damaker Gamer Shamain Barret. Scooby to Shavashari Famlo Idiot, Lobakiba Zavula Mash McKirchamirka's Marbegamirka's recruit, would you be no session as you a cash and vouchere Mutura? Amarichada Hivre, Havan. As a moral fish is a Tleno, recruit because it's not the Satan. Okay. Larota? She called Dam Shotamikure. Cola Damstamikure. Come short micodem. Cola Shu Shanique. Ms. Dialgadon. Lobali Imursa Algadol.

SPEAKER_01 46:48

Immersive talent as an Eurosella Mar Colem cover saying Love Tmashita, the Romad, and Shall Shell, Vilantavi Chuva. Shall you have Masha Tamarta with her dim shame to Rakhtana? Avatar Martha. Ginita Haredim Kemizar. Haredimizarit, the Lanita, as any Sam Kochovit, Lafted the Storanita Vicua Shinta Politica, Avan Shav Shall Ken Velo? Ken. Lomartita. La Martes Bashu.

SPEAKER_00 47:18

Animit stay in Ishmaimasha Marty.

SPEAKER_01 47:21

Shotorashadani metas as a baya. No Tamata Tolakana, Maharadimba YouTube today, Naty Severze, Shall we wrote it a call at Tamartes of Bashio. And you loch and shit.

SPEAKER_00 47:35

And you loch your shit like the team, and you looks shot to be afraid. Okay.

SPEAKER_01 47:45

I shall not say an Kudashamiroship de Belia. Shut up. Can and so better midrash to Magaman. Colum call and success, and you matiba smell at midrash. Lobashabron, Bauchem, a Valamatibe should have any odd geebashwa Matiba, Sada Sibai Hidash and Romaski Ma, the Kenny Bemeto, Shabon Garua, as an Evelse Lagida Mashurava, and Iraq at Sayen says Shivamo Tazaner, Roshivaswa Dam get dol, the Hashummoch and Bashitua Yomvani Marichoto, but some of the better midrash ashivanula, Zani Tukma Mitsu, the Makvana, A Kavana Shomri Mashukmo, uh Amisrail Zukutorava, Zorbachuva. A shovim, and a Tonim Marasotkim Atafuch, Zotomeratani, B Kovaimah Rimshi Gamsakim Kozomchovam and Medumchobchuva, and Rosh Amisrael Dafka Zukretora, Shavedati to Ragdola, Vamunachim, Shotamatzik, at Takaratam Avram Livni, Autorashi Universarich, or Secretam Kulo, Podibata Aintova, Cominamunachim, at Vimiz Remoshem Hapsim Hapsinda, Radati, Sneed Varimshem Kimat Sotrim, Sha the Bel Rakaz, of Nosakama, that him Hapsim Torashimit Kevin Matsuut, Zakon, the Katshim Hapsim K dusha. Mashabatinto the Titkimat N, Katsunto Titom the Brima Mona Idealim Varakim Kmashadibata, the Valnifla, Otta and Faresh. Shigama Marty Bashush and Bashushati Hapsefi, and Mitochavodashuna debate, a val and gamma matos debatife, Shabetzim, and Lama Lamanus, can he be met Hoshevana Shimkumaravsefi, Vitamidav, M Buvanim, Rabim, Hodakanich and Misraev, Stomathem, Magasha Kesf, Shalav, Mugeshatano, Medinata Yudim, Taf Shin Peivav, The Velhen Dafka Kokevishem Avadim, Lemish Pogabiz. The Thomas Dugam Bush and Shimmara Safish and Debati Sita Milim, Hitler, can Kamaim, Meot, can Briad Moshutier Tanashim show makes a flu and so, because we mim, Dafka Bigel Zanusazakoerbi, Kizanashim sheet, after Pisha Niohma, Mizar, Bablo Gizarze, and you have and any animal silto Dakopem, Lehnyashek Azwitz Okalem Daikwa. Tigam Lum is Tigamuma Dutas, Kuda, Vanimel, Anashimapshuti, Mazuva, Matha Kdusha, Dusha, Vemh Kushab, Katavitum Tsu. Mazakushabam Tio, the Mitsadhad, the Dusha, Smit Katim Two. Ya do Instagram. Tumin Mashima Ma Nat Barnat Ma Kluma Fanab. And Lomchimediali. Lomsi Machim, Zemashibsu, a Hush Tayim. Zemashripsu, but kufata of cook. Iom Lomchimedial in Vahim Pam Hasrubuchovak Moa Rav dovbigon. Sadak mo a rav Ronski, and a shim a khoshtayamim, the kivacha. And shim rao hushtaim at a gedluchamistra u mute because the mechuva. Ayomatawa shim Kazomba Chuva Mamutim, Emotim Kdusha, Emotim Tfiya Mutim Mikve, Emrotim Latusreuman, Insarek Kivravote, Emotin Havayot Haniot, Masta Korello Existentialism, Ken Beta Uga Mizak, Rashtagon Hona Volom Shane Vem Rutim It Cosh, Basa Fatimut Fazer, Cosa Better Mr. T. Mm The Bel Jargon. Met Jargon, Sukha Edish Modernit, Edit Bet Mid Rashit, Cooknickit, Vemasorti, Lodoverota, Khan, I'm Sakimit Commercial Martha Rotkin, Nagesh, Mmapetz, Al Galei, At Nua Azotti Shamiatzgim Mecomot Comoshavon, Vetem, Afekadok, Zavadanu, Zavadanu, Maamarado, Zayanifla, Ifeman Sripala Maamarado, Sancho, Mamarado, Tavaniholim, Aval Aval Zanifla, Zello, Cashur Doreen, Sorrif Doc, the Femalashim, Tavaram, Medialum Varakim Dorimatora, and to Ata of Cook, and I'm not going to be able to do it.

SPEAKER_00 55:59

So, we have to do that.

SPEAKER_01 1:00:23

But as a fair Hilonim, Nevot, a Hilonish and Ukvarokayam, Stomet Unia, Ukvarenus, Kia Hilonim as a vote, the Cyanot Gama, yes progressive metorefit, and halat archim progressivim, la tabim, small kitsoni, the colour of Lima. Imadama, Mashekoreb uh the Sephar, Mashikalobi Ceph as a bethinoch al Shem Shimon Perez, as the Mashakore Shahilonim a Nikra Zaka Shotim Shall Miklukumutam Normali as a normal as a trivial dehem La Mamadim. Asha Mashamadimatimba Huma Mamadim, Balhun Natchuita Mamadim, and that you know mimadim a mamadi mayom, the macom shobo at a home to be car, but the team stuck in Vasufim, the king coming cream, shabanoshim today, has rubbichovak, sat it karvuk, tat pox, but also meet our bevi ma'am has lots of meetar bevachimusha tot, noam the kebadome, but uh gave any bad any bad but there mizhmed. Can ma kill my chmajmonima husband or it's a hironim, the sonteva, any bad by the miser, and you're negative, I've actually at Machuva. The Mamash lot nochuva uh animal yeshavanstorm. Nakiva Hemed Kenzi will be chuba, Kamut Ms. Shall Hulsama, Pashutki Zatana Hikovala Hilani, as a Hilani should say Kadem Tatzade Hakadima, Wallach Ola Hemed Olachimotim. Ola Zoki Motorashidi and Makita Hebra Bemike and Nasui Shakazoti, Sadh, Yot Satash Vidy Magabhamas, Faradit, Eloki Blackimsohemed Bichal, Imi Ahim Shakovim Lemasu, it's ashimshovimas faradim, a few Iomba Boker Low Ravno, Bame Ravim, Ityomer Shasniki, um the the Yavraba Khmed, the Bebnakiva, the other Baloki Blackima Bihlal, Yeshno Chuvayum, Kheshwa Dash, Rovan Shim Kosram Chuva, Hosum Chuva, Khabad, Breswe, We Shas, We Khadim Sparadim, Ostam, Yasham Gaush Kadash, Hosum Chuvamaschovador Shalos, Sham unaffiliated, Momizuim, Mlochim Tzad, Mlo M Lose, Bhakala Mishaka, and Campaign Debatium Rosemos Minuti, Yeshua Marshall Huna Hadmabatino, Shem and M Shumbaya, Lavim Mish, Lam Shalimba Mashu, and Yom, the Britinut, Animalitz, Animal Ritz, Aleva Kulano, the Val the Gadut Nefesh, Gamaravsefire Verazapoli, the Gadut Nefes, the animal ritza, Vanikoshepshe M Lobamishak, Shut Natachov, Aderaba, and Mishaker, Shavitia, Monit Bishop, Shamonomonus Vim, Vitzara, Lokbagima Liberal, Ms. Gambe Shivat Comosha Vichon Vedomotea, Monomon de Tlashim, Vaniomar Sibba, Sibam to time, Rosh Sibas, I'm Travanetrog, Magia, Mul and Che Kapla Natayasin, the Vich, Mavich, Mavic, Mavik and Yerosha Mine, who vachti anika rav, who vachticha and shimala, atemshibi, and a holbiadehem, Sarbanim, Matatawe Holbiadem, Vaz, Uma Gishatem Lord Simotim Shelly. Kamani Hoita Metzhim Vulechelem, the Mukhemka to fame, Shibata Vibes, Atoma, Bamkaz, what a capianista, and yaholbiodecha, and himself, big lauchanias of Tarz. Lamacolic is Zul. Lama could be called his ul. Lama Sovereign Court. Lama I to that can't be court by him ally. I took that campaign on the Shimia Schupo, but he says this bo the Viru ali be called.

SPEAKER_02 1:07:05

Okay, the Rav Droaria. At Madashla, Motash Motash, Latla Kaplanazev, the voila take a bite.

SPEAKER_00 1:08:35

The Nisan Tai, Nisan Havon, Latir, Sikushala in Twash, U Pahot Meser Hus, Temester Hus, Vika, Arav Arafta, Amaral, Tiktova, Ohalita Ladim, Tavash, Tito Halitaim, the U Catalmberat, Vu Yatsama, Nitoch, Bepele, Mamashu Hai Sham Hatha Hakak, The Mshichtov, Shiktobayoman, the Halakimashukata, the Then Beto Yoman, Lavoyam, Shell Banam Shodair, She Yamovs for him. Aval Avalcheri, Davketishma. Any kill me Vakita, and you have Lobashachnaut Haloboshov. Any Mr Ani image Michael Manoto Lishma and Hoshev to Rosmando Taniba. Anybody. Uli core at his Bomashon. Uh Lagosh and Tabid Haika, Alva, Avalani, Ava Kahalim Duti Kahlutti, Besagama Zanahonishit, Zenakon Cibit, the imishumavir bicot at Cibotilumi. And I shall tatsmeno. K and it be another one the meat at Cibotilumi, Lomikuffa. Avalimish Cibukas and Viral because he shall be money to pair. I am shiny Tabidi Kabel, Lotiske, like a Shannon Lavin. Carani Gilut.

SPEAKER_02 1:10:51

Regal French Tan Arab guy. Shaves Temps, Thodon. Bodla sitem subscribe, Vodla Semano, Vodlo Tamatem Baruch, and Volush of Tempertiot Dialogue Dialogue. Dialogue? Lo dialogue the Sna? Ah, it's a Ravsiakha Mod Hashuva's Dialogue as the small okay.

SPEAKER_01 1:11:37

So remember to make the gas in a gastish part with Verimber. Coco Yesh Kazakh. Yes, and he would have a kaboatic, laxy, limo, with Pater, any gaminhani roy, and he wrote how seta and the barmaty bo with the lower, can the merit and give the halama. Can I votishiu? She dear a la tibicor, I gave any Mikolea Mehalim Shotit or a Kashua Rosgom says, Yotamovashim, a Pana Hachio, Sh the Karn Kuda, Agave Amatarashulita, uh Shivutain Lola Mhardi, the Amartisatura, Shalom, Bashivota Berber, Amukavutah, but Tumaniguma Agmara, and Ma show by Shivota that Shivot is there, Lotum Himotomitham, a Martin Bitus and Shimfiguimeno, it cavantizhma context at Govot Matilvativai, are you a limot? Maza Alimote, and gma, and as minute as a combo matchmot, you should make classes mainstream. Sada, the Amori Imataba, and Ahno Achuniz Lokhav Animal Autokino. Can I margish him with Mikoladam? Elamimi Maadonim, Maadonim Vadonim Bekaplan, A Hilonibon ima Hilonoma Mermashu, Havim Lorita Roshiv, the Zathu Shashley. Stomart the Roshim Kabelbi code Mikoladam, Roshadim Kabel Bicorit Mi Elu, Shahem Kovimita Norma, Shahem Kovimita default, Shahemuvanme Lav Sha Medina, Mekimutam Dina. And it was Odmish Pat Katao, Anikatafti, Mamarim, Baiton Olam Katano, Mamarimut. The Balamarim Alalo Etiographia Zionito Israel, e histographia, Madima Zakola, Dain Me Faguer, Ainobagalot, Accoreklum, Vanibati recruit the Tigaro, Avikai, Rafka, Rav Moliver, Vereti Kamaherzav, Zikme, blah blah blah blah blah. Kibati Govot Madimot, Kibati to Govot, Mamon Havim, Toranim, Miss Vivot, Shavekhavon, Lomish, the Dafkan Volksamagita, but Shamori, Ehatama Isla Ricot Tigara Torash, and Shiva Nimekimutom Dina. Atabara Ak tinta Hilonim, Lamalecha, Atta Gidmashari, and you lam, and you must lighting. Can Mazatio the tit, at Tionut, Nasima Kipa, Yoshevi, Sholo, or Semha, Vitia Tit. Lonochon, Atio, at Hivakna Mlo Aya Wikipedia, and Arave Molivar, so uh Merichonet Attionuta the tit. As a bizion, uh Arav Molivar Hovitzion, so by Vidat Katovich, I tell you, a congression shot no at the light up no, the tit, Zayation, Vanashima Masha. No, the latest. Biduk, bidukas because it's the titsum uh Sarakabatoda. Bimukom sh at the team, at your name the team should Iom, it fits a Mozasha Rav, and Mamruli Lo Mapiton, Lamani, I Rafael, Herzeloy Car, Herz, Herz, Bemetter, Adam Gadol, in a fair poet. Lama, Kiotpam, Atfisa, at a title meet Nishalaban Kudas at Fisashama Mizrahi, Achilon, who are reborn, and Achno Avadim, the Madonim, the success, Sedar, Mul a Lama Hiloni, Belpamsiloni Musuamikad, Ken Kmosha Haverai, Korea, and gid me a lot of Hima Korea, Allahim, Ken Shon Kama Alaims and Sharimish Lotaren, Hilona Halonikabetao, Uya Bos, Mishwa Marita Gin Micray Mukramatim, as a manu uh misuchit Sabesella, Kidasuha Nigutanu, Kidatinik, Vanikuda Zotti, in the Kudaben, If so it reminds it modita. Ima Rafsefitoen Shaz, Taut Muchleticheri, Saver, as a par benopshut the Rome. Imu Lomudar Dudit, as Bemet and Hoshev Shazen Kudata Mahlocket Commons Dibauno, She Ahomodes of Fort Visual Gabera Paras. Imagine Vinim Shavkas Benai as Yesha Maldabel. Stomet Ottawa and Yosamaya and Madeba Muvan. So we've anticano givashum mit Nash. Come to the ship.

SPEAKER_00 1:18:19

As an eartibe, what comes to Miguel Hamash Gadaltibe Socia, Lamati Bishivat Sousia, Lamati Borotio, Lamati Bay Aramor, Shavonikosh. Why don't we have Hananiuka? Avalatisatolam Vavanashella Mitsu, Novat, B of Muchlat Mito, Shavalta Katavatik Shore and Kipasuga, the colour of Satalovat and you don't debate. I am the better midrash, Shemish Masp Matsubimeta Tudatibuit, Nikoshe. Well I love the shell.

SPEAKER_01 1:20:51

Come on, that's a setting. A Chubavity Hilo.

SPEAKER_00 1:20:58

And I should go dead slam.

SPEAKER_01 1:21:09

Shabakh one betum a the Betham Halarichi Natamis Finata M. Not Finata M. And as Fenata M Z Aramor, Sudan, the Makarapo Agisha, Shavikko, Zagisha Betham Shall Aramor, but you could be what it couldn't. Sadh, Aval Aramor Shintama Kivunchela, Stomachani Tisha, but Mosata as the Bruce Mosha Arafsefim Dovel. Avahaka Dibu Modishana, the Adela Bagdole Vakrim Shall Arafsefi, and Niki Batita Sirton Arafsefield, Kensha Moi Tirai Bizarre Bakazov Kiranegano, Slanch or Togdola, Kidafkan Sharamorush Basanimachonot, Arab Twitau, Shashabashema, Hutiamin, as Arab Zwitao, Uzesh Besimus Finazu to Kivan, Bashimachonot, Avisrava, Vatis Ravress, and Sukan, the Lomosh Romoto, Listakav, and the other, Arab Zwitao Lotomek, Barav Khanitrog, the Barav Heimgans, and Shekaplan, with Bater, Kakham, the Od Schlara Banini Shiva Cav, and the Swinan, Hasidud, Telmidarov Svuda, Kironi Samisa.

SPEAKER_00 1:24:01

Like the Bleachenoti innovate, Mamashato Lam Viahaslam Ti out.