{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"startTime":3600.033,"endTime":3603.5,"body":"(Music)"},{"startTime":3604.933,"endTime":3606.833,"body":"Hey folks, welcome to the DarkHorse"},{"startTime":3606.833,"endTime":3608.933,"body":"podcast live stream."},{"startTime":3608.933,"endTime":3611.133,"body":"It is number 309."},{"startTime":3612.199,"endTime":3612.866,"body":"I am Dr."},{"startTime":3612.866,"endTime":3613.266,"body":"Bret Weinstein."},{"startTime":3613.833,"endTime":3614.366,"body":"You are Dr."},{"startTime":3614.366,"endTime":3614.866,"body":"Heather Heying."},{"startTime":3616.0,"endTime":3616.933,"body":"Here with a special"},{"startTime":3616.933,"endTime":3618.466,"body":"mid-January Saturday edition."},{"startTime":3618.666,"endTime":3619.766,"body":"A Saturday edition."},{"startTime":3619.766,"endTime":3621.233,"body":"It's kind of a throwback to when we used"},{"startTime":3621.233,"endTime":3622.8,"body":"to do live streams on Saturday."},{"startTime":3623.733,"endTime":3625.433,"body":"And a throw forward because it won't be"},{"startTime":3625.433,"endTime":3626.366,"body":"our last Saturday live stream."},{"startTime":3626.433,"endTime":3627.366,"body":"(Whistles)"},{"startTime":3627.699,"endTime":3627.966,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":3628.666,"endTime":3630.633,"body":"In the future is where we will do the"},{"startTime":3630.633,"endTime":3631.766,"body":"next Saturday live stream."},{"startTime":3632.433,"endTime":3632.833,"body":"This one."},{"startTime":3633.133,"endTime":3634.733,"body":"That being the nature of next."},{"startTime":3634.966,"endTime":3635.933,"body":"The nature of next."},{"startTime":3635.933,"endTime":3636.266,"body":"The nature."},{"startTime":3636.566,"endTime":3638.066,"body":"Oh, that's a good title for something."},{"startTime":3638.433,"endTime":3638.766,"body":"The nature of next."},{"startTime":3638.766,"endTime":3640.666,"body":"No idea what it would be, but something."},{"startTime":3642.033,"endTime":3643.133,"body":"309 isn't even tough."},{"startTime":3643.666,"endTime":3643.933,"body":"No."},{"startTime":3644.166,"endTime":3645.533,"body":"No, it's pretty obvious."},{"startTime":3645.9,"endTime":3646.466,"body":"But we're coming up on a"},{"startTime":3646.466,"endTime":3647.8,"body":"couple of interesting primes."},{"startTime":3647.8,"endTime":3650.866,"body":"One of our supporters at Locals pointed"},{"startTime":3650.866,"endTime":3654.166,"body":"out to us some"},{"startTime":3654.166,"endTime":3655.4,"body":"interesting primes coming up."},{"startTime":3655.4,"endTime":3656.133,"body":"So we'll get there."},{"startTime":3656.166,"endTime":3657.366,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":3657.599,"endTime":3659.266,"body":"Remind me, there's some interesting stuff"},{"startTime":3659.266,"endTime":3660.566,"body":"that's come up about primes."},{"startTime":3660.766,"endTime":3662.9,"body":"And I'm sort of eager to talk about it in"},{"startTime":3662.9,"endTime":3664.066,"body":"light of the fact that you and I have"},{"startTime":3664.066,"endTime":3665.833,"body":"been focused there for some time."},{"startTime":3666.733,"endTime":3668.533,"body":"But anyway, yeah, 309, not prime."},{"startTime":3668.533,"endTime":3669.066,"body":"Not prime."},{"startTime":3669.066,"endTime":3670.666,"body":"Speaking of Locals though, join us at the"},{"startTime":3670.666,"endTime":3671.199,"body":"watch party that's"},{"startTime":3671.199,"endTime":3672.266,"body":"happening on Locals right now."},{"startTime":3672.866,"endTime":3674.599,"body":"And tomorrow, 11 a.m."},{"startTime":3674.933,"endTime":3677.566,"body":"Pacific for two hours, we'll have our"},{"startTime":3677.566,"endTime":3679.699,"body":"monthly Sunday Q\u0026A for"},{"startTime":3679.699,"endTime":3680.5,"body":"local supporters only."},{"startTime":3680.733,"endTime":3682.9,"body":"The question asking period is open now."},{"startTime":3682.9,"endTime":3684.033,"body":"Closes after this live stream."},{"startTime":3684.533,"endTime":3685.0,"body":"Join us there."},{"startTime":3686.866,"endTime":3688.733,"body":"Anything else to say at the top of the"},{"startTime":3688.733,"endTime":3689.4,"body":"hour today, we're going"},{"startTime":3689.4,"endTime":3690.666,"body":"to talk about science."},{"startTime":3691.033,"endTime":3691.233,"body":"Science."},{"startTime":3692.099,"endTime":3692.533,"body":"Scientificism."},{"startTime":3692.9,"endTime":3694.566,"body":"And experts and expertise"},{"startTime":3694.566,"endTime":3696.666,"body":"and the failure of both."},{"startTime":3697.3,"endTime":3699.733,"body":"And what I think is soon going to be the"},{"startTime":3699.733,"endTime":3701.199,"body":"next big hit on Broadway."},{"startTime":3703.599,"endTime":3704.466,"body":"I shut up to think."},{"startTime":3705.3,"endTime":3706.466,"body":"Yes, that one I made a"},{"startTime":3706.466,"endTime":3707.466,"body":"point of not telling you about."},{"startTime":3707.466,"endTime":3709.266,"body":"So I'm going to make you guess."},{"startTime":3709.866,"endTime":3710.3,"body":"Oh, God."},{"startTime":3710.933,"endTime":3711.333,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":3711.333,"endTime":3711.699,"body":"Not yet."},{"startTime":3711.699,"endTime":3712.066,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":3712.066,"endTime":3713.199,"body":"No, I'm not getting it."},{"startTime":3713.199,"endTime":3714.4,"body":"It's going to take me a little while to"},{"startTime":3714.4,"endTime":3715.833,"body":"get into a cynical enough"},{"startTime":3715.833,"endTime":3717.866,"body":"mode to be even in the ballpark."},{"startTime":3717.866,"endTime":3719.133,"body":"We're going to talk about the state of"},{"startTime":3719.133,"endTime":3719.933,"body":"science right here in"},{"startTime":3719.933,"endTime":3721.566,"body":"Washington state for a bit first."},{"startTime":3721.933,"endTime":3723.8,"body":"So if that's not going to increase your"},{"startTime":3723.8,"endTime":3725.533,"body":"cynicism, I don't know what is."},{"startTime":3725.9,"endTime":3727.833,"body":"The Washington state of science."},{"startTime":3728.133,"endTime":3728.599,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":3729.333,"endTime":3729.533,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":3729.933,"endTime":3731.133,"body":"Well, in this case, the state of"},{"startTime":3731.133,"endTime":3733.066,"body":"Washington state of science, not the"},{"startTime":3733.066,"endTime":3735.199,"body":"nation's capital, Washington state of"},{"startTime":3735.199,"endTime":3738.033,"body":"science, but but but related because here"},{"startTime":3738.033,"endTime":3742.033,"body":"we have our our executive, Governor Bob"},{"startTime":3742.033,"endTime":3744.833,"body":"Ferguson, arguing with the orders coming"},{"startTime":3744.833,"endTime":3746.533,"body":"down from the nation's executive with"},{"startTime":3746.533,"endTime":3749.599,"body":"regard to some changes to, for instance,"},{"startTime":3749.599,"endTime":3751.033,"body":"the the childhood vaccine schedule."},{"startTime":3752.233,"endTime":3752.433,"body":"Amazing."},{"startTime":3752.8,"endTime":3755.833,"body":"OK, well, Bob Ferguson is up."},{"startTime":3756.333,"endTime":3758.933,"body":"And my guess is when it comes to"},{"startTime":3758.933,"endTime":3760.066,"body":"disappointing, he"},{"startTime":3760.066,"endTime":3761.166,"body":"doesn't fail to disappoint."},{"startTime":3761.566,"endTime":3762.266,"body":"Yeah, it's unfortunate."},{"startTime":3762.666,"endTime":3763.333,"body":"But there we are."},{"startTime":3764.533,"endTime":3764.8,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":3764.8,"endTime":3767.333,"body":"Let's let's pay the rent first and start"},{"startTime":3767.333,"endTime":3770.9,"body":"the episode with three as usual, three"},{"startTime":3770.9,"endTime":3772.233,"body":"ads right at the top for"},{"startTime":3773.199,"endTime":3775.333,"body":"sponsors who make products."},{"startTime":3775.333,"endTime":3777.033,"body":"In this case, all three are products that"},{"startTime":3777.033,"endTime":3780.733,"body":"we truly stand by and for."},{"startTime":3780.733,"endTime":3781.433,"body":"These are excellent"},{"startTime":3781.433,"endTime":3782.433,"body":"products, all of them."},{"startTime":3782.433,"endTime":3784.633,"body":"The first is Sauna Space, which makes"},{"startTime":3784.633,"endTime":3786.833,"body":"amazing saunas and therapeutic lights."},{"startTime":3787.866,"endTime":3789.366,"body":"Several years ago, I started looking into"},{"startTime":3789.366,"endTime":3791.933,"body":"saunas, both traditional infrared, having"},{"startTime":3791.933,"endTime":3795.666,"body":"found that they were delightful in many"},{"startTime":3795.666,"endTime":3797.633,"body":"places that you could you could access"},{"startTime":3797.666,"endTime":3799.566,"body":"them and thought that maybe we could"},{"startTime":3799.566,"endTime":3801.166,"body":"bring one into our own home."},{"startTime":3801.866,"endTime":3803.666,"body":"I found a morass of information."},{"startTime":3803.933,"endTime":3804.633,"body":"You will remember this."},{"startTime":3804.633,"endTime":3807.366,"body":"We both went looking and then red light"},{"startTime":3807.366,"endTime":3809.066,"body":"therapy became popular and the glut of"},{"startTime":3809.066,"endTime":3809.766,"body":"products and claims"},{"startTime":3809.766,"endTime":3811.133,"body":"became even more confusing."},{"startTime":3811.766,"endTime":3812.766,"body":"Is the product effective?"},{"startTime":3813.0,"endTime":3814.366,"body":"How long does it take to heat up?"},{"startTime":3814.366,"endTime":3815.133,"body":"What frequencies does"},{"startTime":3815.133,"endTime":3815.933,"body":"it actually produce?"},{"startTime":3815.933,"endTime":3816.5,"body":"Does it emit harmful"},{"startTime":3816.566,"endTime":3817.733,"body":"electromagnetic radiation?"},{"startTime":3818.133,"endTime":3819.933,"body":"The only product that I found that"},{"startTime":3819.933,"endTime":3821.433,"body":"clearly lived up to its scientific and"},{"startTime":3821.433,"endTime":3822.833,"body":"health claims was Sauna Space."},{"startTime":3823.233,"endTime":3824.166,"body":"This is long before they"},{"startTime":3824.166,"endTime":3825.0,"body":"were a sponsor of ours."},{"startTime":3825.599,"endTime":3827.266,"body":"Sauna Space combines visible red light"},{"startTime":3827.266,"endTime":3829.3,"body":"and near infrared to provide deep radiant"},{"startTime":3829.3,"endTime":3830.966,"body":"heat for whole body results at home."},{"startTime":3831.433,"endTime":3832.599,"body":"This is no harsh LED"},{"startTime":3832.599,"endTime":3834.133,"body":"panel nor a giant wooden box."},{"startTime":3834.733,"endTime":3836.566,"body":"Sauna Space's fire light spectrum is a"},{"startTime":3836.566,"endTime":3838.866,"body":"proprietary sun-like spectrum that was"},{"startTime":3838.866,"endTime":3840.099,"body":"developed over a decade of"},{"startTime":3840.099,"endTime":3840.866,"body":"research and development."},{"startTime":3841.366,"endTime":3843.233,"body":"The incandescent bulbs are flicker free,"},{"startTime":3843.633,"endTime":3845.599,"body":"glare free, and long lasting, staying"},{"startTime":3845.599,"endTime":3847.133,"body":"consistent for over five years."},{"startTime":3847.866,"endTime":3849.633,"body":"Sauna Space has two flagship products,"},{"startTime":3849.9,"endTime":3851.5,"body":"the glow and the fire light sauna."},{"startTime":3852.066,"endTime":3852.733,"body":"I've been using the"},{"startTime":3852.733,"endTime":3853.866,"body":"first, the glow, for years."},{"startTime":3854.366,"endTime":3855.866,"body":"It's a single large light that can be"},{"startTime":3855.866,"endTime":3857.433,"body":"used at the side of the desk or bedside."},{"startTime":3857.766,"endTime":3859.766,"body":"The glow can alleviate screen fatigue and"},{"startTime":3859.766,"endTime":3861.166,"body":"the ill effects of blue light and helps"},{"startTime":3861.166,"endTime":3862.066,"body":"with skin, mood,"},{"startTime":3862.066,"endTime":3863.033,"body":"energy, and sleep concerns."},{"startTime":3863.566,"endTime":3865.199,"body":"The glow also works as spot relief for"},{"startTime":3865.199,"endTime":3866.766,"body":"sore backs, tight shoulders, or cramps."},{"startTime":3867.166,"endTime":3868.633,"body":"And if you've got cats, they'll love it."},{"startTime":3869.133,"endTime":3870.233,"body":"The fire, I can attest to this."},{"startTime":3870.966,"endTime":3874.199,"body":"The fire light sauna, which we just got a"},{"startTime":3874.199,"endTime":3876.533,"body":"few weeks ago and Bret and Toby built,"},{"startTime":3877.833,"endTime":3879.866,"body":"is a full body sauna that promotes sweat"},{"startTime":3879.866,"endTime":3881.933,"body":"and provides provides red light and near"},{"startTime":3881.933,"endTime":3882.9,"body":"infrared therapy all"},{"startTime":3882.9,"endTime":3883.833,"body":"in a single experience."},{"startTime":3883.833,"endTime":3885.366,"body":"It is beautiful and powerful."},{"startTime":3885.366,"endTime":3886.533,"body":"You get medical spa level"},{"startTime":3886.533,"endTime":3887.733,"body":"results right in your home."},{"startTime":3888.633,"endTime":3889.933,"body":"The fire light sauna gives you deep"},{"startTime":3889.933,"endTime":3891.666,"body":"detox, pain relief, pain"},{"startTime":3891.666,"endTime":3893.266,"body":"relief, and better sleep."},{"startTime":3893.766,"endTime":3894.833,"body":"Your skin gets rejuvenated."},{"startTime":3894.833,"endTime":3896.066,"body":"You get an energy boost, enhanced"},{"startTime":3896.066,"endTime":3896.866,"body":"cognition, stress"},{"startTime":3896.866,"endTime":3898.099,"body":"relief, and an immune boost."},{"startTime":3898.466,"endTime":3899.699,"body":"It helps with healing and recovery."},{"startTime":3900.466,"endTime":3902.366,"body":"The fire light sauna offers fast sessions"},{"startTime":3902.366,"endTime":3903.833,"body":"with no preheat necessary."},{"startTime":3903.833,"endTime":3904.566,"body":"You flip the switch and"},{"startTime":3904.566,"endTime":3905.599,"body":"start sweating in minutes."},{"startTime":3906.366,"endTime":3908.433,"body":"Sessions last 15 to 25 minutes, half the"},{"startTime":3908.433,"endTime":3909.266,"body":"time of other saunas."},{"startTime":3909.666,"endTime":3911.099,"body":"And the fire light sauna is a beautiful"},{"startTime":3911.099,"endTime":3912.833,"body":"canvas sauna that is lightweight and plug"},{"startTime":3912.833,"endTime":3913.766,"body":"and play and fits into"},{"startTime":3913.766,"endTime":3914.766,"body":"a spare room or corner."},{"startTime":3915.366,"endTime":3916.933,"body":"You can start small with the glow, which"},{"startTime":3916.933,"endTime":3918.833,"body":"is a single full spectrum red and"},{"startTime":3918.833,"endTime":3920.3,"body":"infrared light or go all in"},{"startTime":3920.3,"endTime":3921.366,"body":"with the fire light sauna."},{"startTime":3921.866,"endTime":3923.633,"body":"All sauna space products are built with"},{"startTime":3923.633,"endTime":3925.466,"body":"integrity and handmade in Missouri with"},{"startTime":3925.466,"endTime":3927.766,"body":"organic or with organic cotton, bamboo,"},{"startTime":3928.233,"endTime":3929.733,"body":"sustainable unfinished basswood, and"},{"startTime":3929.733,"endTime":3930.933,"body":"medical grade stainless steel."},{"startTime":3931.3,"endTime":3933.433,"body":"No toxic loser plastics, no off-gassing,"},{"startTime":3934.0,"endTime":3935.599,"body":"and the grounding mat and optional silver"},{"startTime":3935.599,"endTime":3937.866,"body":"lining upgrade blocks environmental EMFs"},{"startTime":3937.866,"endTime":3939.4,"body":"like wifi to enhance healing."},{"startTime":3939.866,"endTime":3941.533,"body":"And you get a hundred day home trial and"},{"startTime":3941.533,"endTime":3943.099,"body":"outstanding customer service."},{"startTime":3943.599,"endTime":3944.466,"body":"Take your wellness to the"},{"startTime":3944.466,"endTime":3945.633,"body":"next level with sauna space."},{"startTime":3946.133,"endTime":3947.466,"body":"DarkHorse listeners can get an exclusive"},{"startTime":3947.533,"endTime":3949.533,"body":"10% off site wide when you shop at"},{"startTime":3949.533,"endTime":3951.4,"body":"sauna.space.darkhorse."},{"startTime":3951.9,"endTime":3954.833,"body":"That's S-A-U-N-A.space.darkhorse."},{"startTime":3955.3,"endTime":3955.933,"body":"Discount will be"},{"startTime":3955.933,"endTime":3957.5,"body":"automatically applied at checkout."},{"startTime":3957.5,"endTime":3961.766,"body":"I will just say the quality of the"},{"startTime":3961.766,"endTime":3963.8,"body":"materials and the degree to which they"},{"startTime":3963.8,"endTime":3965.033,"body":"are well thought out"},{"startTime":3965.033,"endTime":3966.199,"body":"is really impressive."},{"startTime":3966.199,"endTime":3967.433,"body":"Yeah, it looks good."},{"startTime":3967.433,"endTime":3972.266,"body":"It is well built and things like no glues"},{"startTime":3972.266,"endTime":3975.666,"body":"in the interface between the metal rods."},{"startTime":3975.666,"endTime":3978.866,"body":"I mean, the metal joining pieces and the"},{"startTime":3978.866,"endTime":3981.766,"body":"wooden rods that support the thing,"},{"startTime":3981.766,"endTime":3983.066,"body":"there's, you know, having no glue in"},{"startTime":3983.066,"endTime":3984.3,"body":"there makes sense because"},{"startTime":3984.3,"endTime":3985.766,"body":"what would off gas if there was."},{"startTime":3986.033,"endTime":3986.766,"body":"So anyway, really,"},{"startTime":3986.766,"endTime":3988.366,"body":"really nicely made products."},{"startTime":3988.366,"endTime":3989.733,"body":"The term you used last time, I"},{"startTime":3989.733,"endTime":3990.933,"body":"think was the fit and finish."},{"startTime":3990.933,"endTime":3991.533,"body":"Fit and finish."},{"startTime":3991.833,"endTime":3992.3,"body":"Extraordinary."},{"startTime":3992.3,"endTime":3992.833,"body":"It really is."},{"startTime":3993.066,"endTime":3993.266,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":3993.5,"endTime":3993.766,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":3993.766,"endTime":3994.666,"body":"Our second sponsor"},{"startTime":3997.133,"endTime":3998.933,"body":"is not eaten by dung beetles anywhere,"},{"startTime":3999.233,"endTime":4000.599,"body":"but I'm trying to, there we go."},{"startTime":4001.533,"endTime":4004.133,"body":"Our second sponsor today is Masa chips."},{"startTime":4004.733,"endTime":4006.033,"body":"These are so good."},{"startTime":4006.3,"endTime":4007.733,"body":"Masa makes ridiculously delicious chips"},{"startTime":4007.766,"endTime":4008.933,"body":"with only three simple,"},{"startTime":4008.933,"endTime":4010.099,"body":"real whole ingredients."},{"startTime":4011.133,"endTime":4013.233,"body":"Organic, nixtamalized corn, sea salt, and"},{"startTime":4013.233,"endTime":4015.066,"body":"100% grass fed beef tallow."},{"startTime":4015.666,"endTime":4017.133,"body":"Masa chips are made the way that all of"},{"startTime":4017.133,"endTime":4018.166,"body":"our food used to be made."},{"startTime":4018.166,"endTime":4019.199,"body":"They're fried in 100% beef"},{"startTime":4019.199,"endTime":4020.633,"body":"tallow, no seed oils ever."},{"startTime":4020.633,"endTime":4021.666,"body":"You can taste the difference and your"},{"startTime":4021.666,"endTime":4022.966,"body":"body can feel the difference."},{"startTime":4023.833,"endTime":4025.233,"body":"America's health is declining fast."},{"startTime":4025.566,"endTime":4027.0,"body":"Chronic illnesses, obesity, autoimmune"},{"startTime":4027.0,"endTime":4028.099,"body":"diseases have exploded."},{"startTime":4028.466,"endTime":4029.0,"body":"What changed?"},{"startTime":4029.466,"endTime":4031.066,"body":"Lots of things change, but one thing that"},{"startTime":4031.066,"endTime":4032.733,"body":"changed is that all chips and fries used"},{"startTime":4032.733,"endTime":4033.666,"body":"to be cooked in tallow."},{"startTime":4034.466,"endTime":4036.466,"body":"But in the 1990s, corporations switched"},{"startTime":4036.466,"endTime":4037.966,"body":"to cheaper seed oils, which includes"},{"startTime":4037.966,"endTime":4039.933,"body":"soybean, canola, sunflower, and corn."},{"startTime":4040.666,"endTime":4042.066,"body":"Seed oils are often labeled vegetable"},{"startTime":4042.066,"endTime":4043.933,"body":"oils as if that makes them healthy."},{"startTime":4043.933,"endTime":4045.599,"body":"Well, in fact, seed oils are linked to"},{"startTime":4045.599,"endTime":4047.0,"body":"metabolic health issues and inflammation."},{"startTime":4047.3,"endTime":4049.5,"body":"And today, seed oils make up 20% of the"},{"startTime":4049.5,"endTime":4051.699,"body":"average American's daily calories, not"},{"startTime":4051.699,"endTime":4053.633,"body":"20% of the average American's daily fat"},{"startTime":4053.633,"endTime":4056.599,"body":"calories, their entire calories, 20%."},{"startTime":4057.166,"endTime":4059.033,"body":"Big food companies also use artificial"},{"startTime":4059.033,"endTime":4060.766,"body":"dyes, stabilizers, and other toxins."},{"startTime":4061.466,"endTime":4063.3,"body":"Masa chips though, none of it."},{"startTime":4063.733,"endTime":4064.633,"body":"Absolutely no seed oils,"},{"startTime":4064.866,"endTime":4066.466,"body":"artificial dyes, or additives ever."},{"startTime":4067.266,"endTime":4069.333,"body":"Beef tallow is nutrient rich, nourishing,"},{"startTime":4069.333,"endTime":4070.533,"body":"and makes food taste incredible."},{"startTime":4071.166,"endTime":4072.5,"body":"Masa chips are crunchy and delicious and"},{"startTime":4072.5,"endTime":4074.033,"body":"after you eat them, you feel satisfied,"},{"startTime":4074.366,"endTime":4075.833,"body":"satiated, and energetic."},{"startTime":4077.266,"endTime":4079.4,"body":"Masa also supports American farms and"},{"startTime":4079.4,"endTime":4080.4,"body":"regenerative agriculture."},{"startTime":4080.866,"endTime":4082.333,"body":"Choosing real food heals us in our"},{"startTime":4082.333,"endTime":4083.266,"body":"environment, which in turn"},{"startTime":4083.266,"endTime":4084.5,"body":"makes us even more healthy."},{"startTime":4085.333,"endTime":4087.099,"body":"Try masa chips with salsa or goat cheese"},{"startTime":4087.133,"endTime":4088.4,"body":"or a spicy pepper jam."},{"startTime":4088.9,"endTime":4090.333,"body":"Smother them in beans and cheese or just"},{"startTime":4090.333,"endTime":4091.566,"body":"eat them straight out of the bag."},{"startTime":4091.566,"endTime":4092.3,"body":"They're all delicious."},{"startTime":4092.9,"endTime":4094.433,"body":"At the moment, my favorites are their"},{"startTime":4094.433,"endTime":4096.133,"body":"white chips made from heirloom organic"},{"startTime":4096.133,"endTime":4097.666,"body":"white corn, which gives a particularly"},{"startTime":4097.666,"endTime":4099.0,"body":"light and flaky texture."},{"startTime":4099.566,"endTime":4101.199,"body":"I also love their blue chips, which have"},{"startTime":4101.199,"endTime":4101.966,"body":"a deeper nuttier"},{"startTime":4101.966,"endTime":4103.133,"body":"flavor and a serious crunch."},{"startTime":4103.633,"endTime":4105.633,"body":"They've also got hatch chili, kobanero,"},{"startTime":4106.166,"endTime":4108.6,"body":"these guys, lime original, and wait for a"},{"startTime":4108.6,"endTime":4109.5,"body":"churro with cinnamon."},{"startTime":4110.399,"endTime":4111.866,"body":"Ready to give Masa a try?"},{"startTime":4111.866,"endTime":4114.066,"body":"Go to masachips.com slash DarkHorse and"},{"startTime":4114.066,"endTime":4115.533,"body":"use code darkhorse for 25%"},{"startTime":4117.699,"endTime":4118.533,"body":"off your first order."},{"startTime":4118.866,"endTime":4121.833,"body":"That's masachips.com slash DarkHorse and"},{"startTime":4121.833,"endTime":4123.6,"body":"code darkhorse for 25%"},{"startTime":4123.899,"endTime":4124.699,"body":"off your first order."},{"startTime":4125.133,"endTime":4126.433,"body":"And if you don't feel like ordering"},{"startTime":4126.433,"endTime":4128.0,"body":"online starting in October, Masa will be"},{"startTime":4128.0,"endTime":4128.833,"body":"available nationwide"},{"startTime":4128.833,"endTime":4129.766,"body":"at Sprout supermarkets."},{"startTime":4130.1,"endTime":4131.033,"body":"Stop by and pick up a"},{"startTime":4131.033,"endTime":4132.066,"body":"bag before they're gone."},{"startTime":4132.766,"endTime":4134.833,"body":"I've been in kind of a lime phase."},{"startTime":4134.833,"endTime":4135.633,"body":"You've been in a lime phase?"},{"startTime":4135.8,"endTime":4137.533,"body":"I was in a lime phase for a little bit."},{"startTime":4137.533,"endTime":4141.633,"body":"And when, so I was away, um, uh, with my"},{"startTime":4141.633,"endTime":4142.566,"body":"mom, uh, in"},{"startTime":4142.566,"endTime":4144.399,"body":"California for this last week."},{"startTime":4144.399,"endTime":4145.366,"body":"That's why we're doing"},{"startTime":4145.366,"endTime":4146.333,"body":"on Saturday, Wednesday."},{"startTime":4147.133,"endTime":4148.433,"body":"And when I got back, one of the first"},{"startTime":4148.433,"endTime":4149.366,"body":"things I did was opened"},{"startTime":4149.366,"endTime":4151.766,"body":"up a bag of lime masachips."},{"startTime":4151.766,"endTime":4152.566,"body":"There it is."},{"startTime":4152.566,"endTime":4153.433,"body":"They're really good."},{"startTime":4154.933,"endTime":4157.699,"body":"Yeah. Now our final sponsor, Heather is clear"},{"startTime":4157.699,"endTime":4159.266,"body":"clear is a nasal spray that"},{"startTime":4159.266,"endTime":4160.533,"body":"supports respiratory health."},{"startTime":4160.533,"endTime":4162.1,"body":"And it's a product that we have been"},{"startTime":4162.1,"endTime":4163.533,"body":"using for quite a while."},{"startTime":4163.8,"endTime":4165.399,"body":"It's made by a company with"},{"startTime":4165.399,"endTime":4166.5,"body":"which we are well familiar."},{"startTime":4166.966,"endTime":4169.366,"body":"It's clear that X L E"},{"startTime":4169.366,"endTime":4171.433,"body":"A R pronounced clear."},{"startTime":4171.666,"endTime":4175.566,"body":"Now I will say we back all of the"},{"startTime":4175.566,"endTime":4178.466,"body":"companies that, uh, sponsor our podcast."},{"startTime":4178.466,"endTime":4179.633,"body":"I do not necessarily"},{"startTime":4179.633,"endTime":4180.933,"body":"stand by this spelling."},{"startTime":4181.566,"endTime":4182.833,"body":"I find it, I find it confusing."},{"startTime":4183.366,"endTime":4185.466,"body":"Um, throughout history improvements,"},{"startTime":4185.466,"endTime":4187.566,"body":"excellent product, questionable spelling."},{"startTime":4187.8,"endTime":4189.066,"body":"The product is so good."},{"startTime":4189.3,"endTime":4190.233,"body":"You look past the"},{"startTime":4190.233,"endTime":4191.466,"body":"spelling, that's the way it works."},{"startTime":4191.766,"endTime":4194.066,"body":"But obviously the reason for it is, and"},{"startTime":4194.066,"endTime":4195.899,"body":"you'll get here in the ad read here is"},{"startTime":4195.899,"endTime":4197.766,"body":"that the active ingredient is xylitol,"},{"startTime":4198.033,"endTime":4198.833,"body":"which doesn't sound like it"},{"startTime":4198.833,"endTime":4199.966,"body":"starts with an X, but it does."},{"startTime":4200.566,"endTime":4202.133,"body":"And so clear also starts with an X and"},{"startTime":4202.133,"endTime":4203.1,"body":"doesn't sound like it does."},{"startTime":4203.1,"endTime":4203.366,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":4203.566,"endTime":4206.1,"body":"But in the interest of full consistency,"},{"startTime":4206.1,"endTime":4207.8,"body":"I also don't support"},{"startTime":4207.8,"endTime":4209.033,"body":"the spelling of xylitol."},{"startTime":4209.6,"endTime":4211.666,"body":"So would you like it to start with a C?"},{"startTime":4212.833,"endTime":4213.033,"body":"Uh,"},{"startTime":4215.366,"endTime":4215.566,"body":"wow."},{"startTime":4216.233,"endTime":4217.199,"body":"That is cool."},{"startTime":4217.866,"endTime":4219.866,"body":"You're causing a dyslexia flare up."},{"startTime":4220.166,"endTime":4221.333,"body":"Hopefully I'll be able to read this ad"},{"startTime":4221.333,"endTime":4222.666,"body":"without it interfering too much."},{"startTime":4223.366,"endTime":4225.033,"body":"Throughout history, improvements in"},{"startTime":4225.033,"endTime":4226.899,"body":"sanitation and hygiene have had huge"},{"startTime":4226.899,"endTime":4228.966,"body":"impacts on human longevity and quality of"},{"startTime":4228.966,"endTime":4230.566,"body":"life more so than"},{"startTime":4230.566,"endTime":4231.766,"body":"traditional medical advances."},{"startTime":4232.233,"endTime":4233.699,"body":"For instance, when doctors started to"},{"startTime":4233.699,"endTime":4235.366,"body":"wash their hands between handling"},{"startTime":4235.366,"endTime":4236.966,"body":"cadavers and helping women give birth,"},{"startTime":4237.333,"endTime":4237.933,"body":"the rate of maternal"},{"startTime":4237.933,"endTime":4239.066,"body":"deaths went way down."},{"startTime":4239.5,"endTime":4240.866,"body":"Breathing polluted air and drinking"},{"startTime":4240.866,"endTime":4242.866,"body":"tainted water have hugely negative"},{"startTime":4242.866,"endTime":4244.933,"body":"effects on human health, clean up the air"},{"startTime":4244.933,"endTime":4246.3,"body":"and water and people get healthier."},{"startTime":4247.033,"endTime":4249.333,"body":"Nasal hygiene often gets overlooked, but"},{"startTime":4249.333,"endTime":4251.166,"body":"consider that the majority of bacteria"},{"startTime":4251.166,"endTime":4253.033,"body":"and viruses that make us sick enter"},{"startTime":4253.033,"endTime":4254.233,"body":"through the mouth or nose."},{"startTime":4254.433,"endTime":4256.833,"body":"It has become a cultural norm to wash"},{"startTime":4256.833,"endTime":4258.3,"body":"your hands in order to help stop the"},{"startTime":4258.3,"endTime":4259.933,"body":"spread of disease from person to person."},{"startTime":4259.933,"endTime":4261.333,"body":"But it's rare that you"},{"startTime":4261.333,"endTime":4262.466,"body":"get sick through our hands."},{"startTime":4263.166,"endTime":4264.0,"body":"Rather we get sick"},{"startTime":4264.0,"endTime":4265.066,"body":"through our mouth and nose."},{"startTime":4265.866,"endTime":4267.699,"body":"Thus it makes sense that we should be"},{"startTime":4267.699,"endTime":4269.433,"body":"using something that we know blocks"},{"startTime":4269.433,"endTime":4271.933,"body":"bacterial and viral adhesion in the nose."},{"startTime":4272.333,"endTime":4273.266,"body":"Enter clear."},{"startTime":4275.5,"endTime":4277.0,"body":"See, I'm teaching myself."},{"startTime":4277.933,"endTime":4279.433,"body":"Clear is a nasal spray that contains"},{"startTime":4279.433,"endTime":4282.666,"body":"xylitol, a five carbon sugar alcohol."},{"startTime":4283.3,"endTime":4285.233,"body":"Our bodies naturally contain five carbon"},{"startTime":4285.233,"endTime":4287.1,"body":"sugars, mostly in the form of ribose and"},{"startTime":4287.1,"endTime":4289.633,"body":"deoxyribose, which are the backbone of"},{"startTime":4289.633,"endTime":4291.233,"body":"sugars like RNA and DNA."},{"startTime":4291.566,"endTime":4293.833,"body":"Respectively, while most of our dietary"},{"startTime":4293.833,"endTime":4294.933,"body":"sugars have six"},{"startTime":4294.933,"endTime":4296.566,"body":"carbons, sugars like glucose,"},{"startTime":4297.766,"endTime":4299.433,"body":"the emphasis is all wrong."},{"startTime":4299.433,"endTime":4301.666,"body":"While most of our dietary sugars have six"},{"startTime":4301.666,"endTime":4303.833,"body":"carbons like glucose and fructose,"},{"startTime":4304.866,"endTime":4306.933,"body":"xylitol is known to reduce how sticky"},{"startTime":4306.933,"endTime":4308.966,"body":"bacteria and viruses are to our tissues."},{"startTime":4309.266,"endTime":4311.233,"body":"In the presence of xylitol, bacteria and"},{"startTime":4311.233,"endTime":4313.633,"body":"viruses, including strep, SARS-CoV-2 and"},{"startTime":4313.633,"endTime":4316.433,"body":"RSV, don't adhere to our airways as well,"},{"startTime":4316.433,"endTime":4318.0,"body":"which helps our body's natural defense"},{"startTime":4318.0,"endTime":4321.3,"body":"mechanisms easily flush them away."},{"startTime":4322.0,"endTime":4323.833,"body":"Clear is a simple nasal spray that you"},{"startTime":4323.833,"endTime":4325.233,"body":"use morning and evening."},{"startTime":4325.433,"endTime":4326.766,"body":"It takes just three seconds."},{"startTime":4327.0,"endTime":4328.133,"body":"It's fast, it's easy"},{"startTime":4328.133,"endTime":4329.199,"body":"and decidedly healthy."},{"startTime":4329.699,"endTime":4331.433,"body":"If any of this sounds familiar, perhaps"},{"startTime":4331.433,"endTime":4333.633,"body":"you listen to my conversation with Nathan"},{"startTime":4333.633,"endTime":4336.866,"body":"Jones, founder of Clear on the Inside"},{"startTime":4336.866,"endTime":4340.133,"body":"Rail in November of 2024, or my"},{"startTime":4340.133,"endTime":4341.833,"body":"conversation with Nate's father, Lon"},{"startTime":4341.833,"endTime":4344.566,"body":"Jones, osteopath and inventor of Clear on"},{"startTime":4344.566,"endTime":4345.966,"body":"how xylitol interacts"},{"startTime":4345.966,"endTime":4347.266,"body":"with respiratory viruses."},{"startTime":4348.366,"endTime":4350.433,"body":"That episode was in May of 2025."},{"startTime":4350.966,"endTime":4353.066,"body":"We recommend those conversations and we"},{"startTime":4353.066,"endTime":4355.1,"body":"highly recommend Clear as a daily habit"},{"startTime":4355.1,"endTime":4355.966,"body":"and prophylactic"},{"startTime":4356.0,"endTime":4357.466,"body":"against respiratory illnesses."},{"startTime":4357.766,"endTime":4361.966,"body":"That's Clear with an X X L E A R."},{"startTime":4361.966,"endTime":4365.3,"body":"Get Clear online or at your pharmacy"},{"startTime":4365.3,"endTime":4367.399,"body":"grocery store or natural products"},{"startTime":4367.399,"endTime":4370.033,"body":"retailer and start taking six seconds"},{"startTime":4370.033,"endTime":4371.833,"body":"each day to improve your nasal hygiene"},{"startTime":4371.833,"endTime":4373.966,"body":"and support your respiratory health."},{"startTime":4374.366,"endTime":4375.866,"body":"I will also say these people have been"},{"startTime":4375.866,"endTime":4377.8,"body":"fantastically supportive of"},{"startTime":4377.8,"endTime":4379.266,"body":"the health freedom movement."},{"startTime":4379.266,"endTime":4381.066,"body":"And I was shocked once I became aware of"},{"startTime":4381.066,"endTime":4382.366,"body":"this product and how"},{"startTime":4382.366,"endTime":4383.666,"body":"readily available it is."},{"startTime":4384.033,"endTime":4386.133,"body":"Yeah, actually, while I was in California"},{"startTime":4386.133,"endTime":4389.333,"body":"with my mom this last week, I went into a"},{"startTime":4389.333,"endTime":4395.033,"body":"CVS to get her and it was not only"},{"startTime":4395.033,"endTime":4397.333,"body":"readily available, but the"},{"startTime":4397.333,"endTime":4398.699,"body":"imitations are already out."},{"startTime":4399.533,"endTime":4403.666,"body":"So, you know, buy Clear X L E A R and"},{"startTime":4403.666,"endTime":4406.866,"body":"recognize that it is effective enough and"},{"startTime":4406.866,"endTime":4409.133,"body":"already popular enough that the"},{"startTime":4409.133,"endTime":4410.866,"body":"mainstream drug stores"},{"startTime":4410.866,"endTime":4412.833,"body":"are putting out imposters."},{"startTime":4413.166,"endTime":4414.466,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":4414.466,"endTime":4415.333,"body":"Well, hopefully the"},{"startTime":4415.333,"endTime":4416.933,"body":"imposters are spelled even worse."},{"startTime":4419.333,"endTime":4420.866,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":4421.333,"endTime":4421.666,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":4421.766,"endTime":4424.533,"body":"I think it's time for us to talk about"},{"startTime":4424.533,"endTime":4427.0,"body":"science and its competitors."},{"startTime":4427.466,"endTime":4427.666,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":4427.699,"endTime":4430.433,"body":"Science, scientism, all the science."},{"startTime":4431.433,"endTime":4431.633,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":4432.133,"endTime":4432.8,"body":"Why don't we start"},{"startTime":4432.8,"endTime":4437.066,"body":"with, so in response to"},{"startTime":4438.066,"endTime":4439.899,"body":"recent changes to the childhood vaccine"},{"startTime":4439.899,"endTime":4445.466,"body":"schedule put out by HHS as then"},{"startTime":4445.466,"endTime":4448.733,"body":"publicized by the CDC and is ultimately,"},{"startTime":4448.733,"endTime":4450.3,"body":"of course, coming from the executive"},{"startTime":4450.3,"endTime":4453.5,"body":"branch of the United States, several"},{"startTime":4453.5,"endTime":4455.6,"body":"governors, including our very own right"},{"startTime":4455.6,"endTime":4456.866,"body":"here in the state of Washington, Bob"},{"startTime":4456.866,"endTime":4459.0,"body":"Ferguson, freaked out."},{"startTime":4460.0,"endTime":4461.733,"body":"And let us show this video."},{"startTime":4462.533,"endTime":4465.466,"body":"This is actually a video in a tweet that"},{"startTime":4465.466,"endTime":4466.733,"body":"Governor Ferguson of the state of"},{"startTime":4466.733,"endTime":4469.433,"body":"Washington himself put out explaining"},{"startTime":4469.433,"endTime":4471.533,"body":"what he was going to do in response."},{"startTime":4473.633,"endTime":4475.466,"body":"The Centers for Disease Control has seen"},{"startTime":4475.466,"endTime":4477.733,"body":"an exodus of scientific experts and"},{"startTime":4477.733,"endTime":4480.266,"body":"alarming shifts in policy that place"},{"startTime":4480.266,"endTime":4482.266,"body":"Washingtonians health at risk."},{"startTime":4483.066,"endTime":4484.933,"body":"I immediately took action and teamed up"},{"startTime":4484.933,"endTime":4486.766,"body":"with other governors to form the West"},{"startTime":4486.766,"endTime":4488.066,"body":"Coast Health Alliance."},{"startTime":4488.899,"endTime":4491.5,"body":"The Alliance ensures Washingtonians will"},{"startTime":4491.5,"endTime":4493.233,"body":"continue to receive responsible"},{"startTime":4493.233,"endTime":4495.366,"body":"recommendations from health experts who"},{"startTime":4495.366,"endTime":4497.8,"body":"rely on, you guessed it, science."},{"startTime":4498.666,"endTime":4499.8,"body":"But we are not stopping there."},{"startTime":4500.333,"endTime":4501.866,"body":"I'm proud to partner with insurance"},{"startTime":4501.866,"endTime":4503.866,"body":"Commissioner Kuderer and a bipartisan"},{"startTime":4503.866,"endTime":4505.866,"body":"group of legislators, Senator Cleveland,"},{"startTime":4506.466,"endTime":4508.166,"body":"Representative Bernosky and Senator"},{"startTime":4508.166,"endTime":4510.633,"body":"Harris to shift vaccine recommendations"},{"startTime":4510.633,"endTime":4512.966,"body":"away from science denying federal"},{"startTime":4512.966,"endTime":4515.233,"body":"committees and place it with our own"},{"startTime":4515.233,"endTime":4517.066,"body":"Washington State Department of Health,"},{"startTime":4517.466,"endTime":4518.933,"body":"which will be guided by,"},{"startTime":4518.933,"endTime":4520.899,"body":"you guessed it again, science."},{"startTime":4523.066,"endTime":4528.233,"body":"Unfortunately, our governor doesn't seem"},{"startTime":4528.233,"endTime":4529.6,"body":"to know what the word means."},{"startTime":4531.166,"endTime":4532.966,"body":"Let me just begin."},{"startTime":4533.3,"endTime":4535.766,"body":"There's a lot to say here, including how"},{"startTime":4535.766,"endTime":4537.033,"body":"he behaved during COVID."},{"startTime":4537.033,"endTime":4538.366,"body":"He's only been the governor of the state"},{"startTime":4538.366,"endTime":4540.766,"body":"of Washington since January 2025."},{"startTime":4541.399,"endTime":4542.633,"body":"But he was the attorney general of the"},{"startTime":4542.633,"endTime":4544.266,"body":"state of Washington since 2012, and"},{"startTime":4544.266,"endTime":4545.033,"body":"therefore the attorney"},{"startTime":4545.033,"endTime":4546.466,"body":"general during all of COVID."},{"startTime":4547.0,"endTime":4548.766,"body":"And he has quite a direct record."},{"startTime":4549.233,"endTime":4550.266,"body":"But before we get there,"},{"startTime":4550.266,"endTime":4551.866,"body":"let's see what he's responding to."},{"startTime":4552.433,"endTime":4554.366,"body":"So here, if you can see my screen, go"},{"startTime":4554.366,"endTime":4555.366,"body":"ahead and show it here."},{"startTime":4555.366,"endTime":4559.166,"body":"Here's what the official document put out"},{"startTime":4559.166,"endTime":4563.033,"body":"by the federal government on January 2nd,"},{"startTime":4563.033,"endTime":4565.533,"body":"2026, the assessment of the US childhood"},{"startTime":4565.533,"endTime":4567.233,"body":"and adolescent immunization schedule"},{"startTime":4567.233,"endTime":4568.5,"body":"compared to other countries."},{"startTime":4568.833,"endTime":4570.833,"body":"This was as part of the announcement that"},{"startTime":4570.833,"endTime":4572.0,"body":"the CDC's childhood"},{"startTime":4572.0,"endTime":4574.5,"body":"vaccination schedule would be changed."},{"startTime":4575.166,"endTime":4576.899,"body":"And I'm just going to end it by Tracy"},{"startTime":4576.899,"endTime":4579.133,"body":"Beth Hogg and Martin Koldorf, both names"},{"startTime":4579.133,"endTime":4581.3,"body":"that people familiar with DarkHorse will"},{"startTime":4581.3,"endTime":4582.6,"body":"also be familiar with."},{"startTime":4583.033,"endTime":4584.566,"body":"And I'm just going to read the first four"},{"startTime":4584.566,"endTime":4586.233,"body":"paragraphs of the executive summary."},{"startTime":4587.0,"endTime":4589.833,"body":"On December 5th, 2025, President Trump"},{"startTime":4589.833,"endTime":4591.199,"body":"issued a presidential memorandum"},{"startTime":4591.199,"endTime":4592.733,"body":"directing the Secretary of the US"},{"startTime":4592.733,"endTime":4594.133,"body":"Department of Health and Human Services,"},{"startTime":4594.399,"endTime":4596.699,"body":"HHS, that's Kennedy, of course, and the"},{"startTime":4596.699,"endTime":4597.899,"body":"acting director of the Centers for"},{"startTime":4597.899,"endTime":4599.5,"body":"Disease Control and Prevention, the CDC,"},{"startTime":4600.0,"endTime":4601.899,"body":"to review best practices from peer"},{"startTime":4601.899,"endTime":4603.733,"body":"developed nations regarding childhood"},{"startTime":4603.733,"endTime":4605.333,"body":"vaccination recommendations and the"},{"startTime":4605.333,"endTime":4606.166,"body":"scientific evidence"},{"startTime":4606.166,"endTime":4607.433,"body":"underlying those practices."},{"startTime":4608.199,"endTime":4609.8,"body":"The president instructed them to update"},{"startTime":4609.8,"endTime":4612.266,"body":"the US core childhood vaccine schedule if"},{"startTime":4612.266,"endTime":4613.033,"body":"they determine that"},{"startTime":4613.033,"endTime":4614.766,"body":"superior practices exist abroad."},{"startTime":4616.0,"endTime":4617.333,"body":"This assessment is a scientific,"},{"startTime":4617.633,"endTime":4619.533,"body":"evidence-based, data-driven response to"},{"startTime":4619.533,"endTime":4620.466,"body":"the president's directive."},{"startTime":4620.899,"endTime":4622.333,"body":"It argues that a change in the US"},{"startTime":4622.333,"endTime":4624.233,"body":"childhood vaccine schedule is necessary."},{"startTime":4624.733,"endTime":4626.333,"body":"It compares the US with peer nations,"},{"startTime":4626.866,"endTime":4628.466,"body":"examines vaccine update and trust,"},{"startTime":4628.899,"endTime":4630.399,"body":"addresses clinical and epidemiological"},{"startTime":4630.399,"endTime":4632.066,"body":"considerations and knowledge gaps,"},{"startTime":4632.533,"endTime":4634.533,"body":"analyzes vaccine mandates, and outlines"},{"startTime":4634.533,"endTime":4635.899,"body":"recommendations and next steps for"},{"startTime":4635.933,"endTime":4637.133,"body":"immediate and long-term action."},{"startTime":4638.133,"endTime":4640.166,"body":"The US is a global outlier among peer"},{"startTime":4640.166,"endTime":4641.733,"body":"nations in the number of target diseases"},{"startTime":4641.733,"endTime":4643.233,"body":"included in its childhood vaccination"},{"startTime":4643.233,"endTime":4645.066,"body":"schedule and in the total number of"},{"startTime":4645.066,"endTime":4646.233,"body":"recommended vaccine doses."},{"startTime":4647.566,"endTime":4649.066,"body":"The acting CDC director should"},{"startTime":4649.066,"endTime":4650.433,"body":"immediately consider, and this has now"},{"startTime":4650.433,"endTime":4653.266,"body":"happened, this is what happens in this"},{"startTime":4653.266,"endTime":4655.466,"body":"next paragraph here is what Governor"},{"startTime":4655.466,"endTime":4657.633,"body":"Ferguson in Washington is responding to,"},{"startTime":4658.233,"endTime":4659.566,"body":"the acting CDC director should"},{"startTime":4659.566,"endTime":4660.866,"body":"immediately consider updating the"},{"startTime":4660.899,"endTime":4662.766,"body":"childhood immunization schedule to keep"},{"startTime":4662.766,"endTime":4665.633,"body":"vaccines for 10 diseases, measles, mumps,"},{"startTime":4665.633,"endTime":4667.533,"body":"rubella, polio, pertussis, tetanus,"},{"startTime":4667.533,"endTime":4669.966,"body":"diphtheria, hemophilus, influenza type B,"},{"startTime":4670.233,"endTime":4672.199,"body":"Hib, pneumococcal disease, and human"},{"startTime":4672.199,"endTime":4676.966,"body":"papillomavirus, HPV, for which peer"},{"startTime":4676.966,"endTime":4678.666,"body":"developed nations share international"},{"startTime":4678.666,"endTime":4680.933,"body":"consensus, as well as varicella,"},{"startTime":4681.366,"endTime":4684.033,"body":"chickenpox, the consensus vaccines in the"},{"startTime":4684.033,"endTime":4684.933,"body":"category of vaccines"},{"startTime":4684.933,"endTime":4686.1,"body":"recommended for all children."},{"startTime":4687.3,"endTime":4689.533,"body":"These consensus vaccines will represent"},{"startTime":4689.533,"endTime":4691.199,"body":"the core childhood vaccine schedule."},{"startTime":4692.1,"endTime":4695.133,"body":"This report does not substantively"},{"startTime":4695.133,"endTime":4696.6,"body":"address the consensus vaccines."},{"startTime":4697.366,"endTime":4699.433,"body":"All other vaccines currently on the US"},{"startTime":4699.433,"endTime":4701.533,"body":"schedule, the non-consensus vaccines,"},{"startTime":4701.866,"endTime":4703.366,"body":"should be recommended for high-risk"},{"startTime":4703.366,"endTime":4705.166,"body":"groups and populations and or through"},{"startTime":4705.166,"endTime":4706.833,"body":"shared clinical decision making by taking"},{"startTime":4706.833,"endTime":4707.666,"body":"individual patient"},{"startTime":4707.666,"endTime":4709.0,"body":"characteristics into account."},{"startTime":4709.833,"endTime":4711.833,"body":"Figure one, no vaccine should be moved to"},{"startTime":4711.833,"endTime":4712.966,"body":"the not recommended category."},{"startTime":4713.866,"endTime":4715.166,"body":"So this is tiny."},{"startTime":4715.166,"endTime":4715.733,"body":"Let me see if I can"},{"startTime":4715.733,"endTime":4717.666,"body":"make it bigger for us."},{"startTime":4719.066,"endTime":4720.3,"body":"Oops, well, that didn't work here."},{"startTime":4720.633,"endTime":4721.666,"body":"Why don't you give me my screen back here"},{"startTime":4721.666,"endTime":4722.433,"body":"while I figure out how to"},{"startTime":4722.433,"endTime":4723.699,"body":"make my computer comply."},{"startTime":4726.666,"endTime":4729.033,"body":"So while I'm doing that, Bret, if you"},{"startTime":4729.033,"endTime":4731.399,"body":"have anything to add, go for it."},{"startTime":4731.399,"endTime":4733.633,"body":"I will just say note that."},{"startTime":4734.266,"endTime":4738.066,"body":"Note how many vaccines, how many diseases"},{"startTime":4738.066,"endTime":4740.266,"body":"are still being vaccinated against on the"},{"startTime":4740.266,"endTime":4741.3,"body":"recommended childhood"},{"startTime":4741.3,"endTime":4743.166,"body":"vaccine schedule by the CDC?"},{"startTime":4744.399,"endTime":4746.399,"body":"And I'm about to pull up the list."},{"startTime":4746.899,"endTime":4749.666,"body":"They have, again, not even"},{"startTime":4749.666,"endTime":4751.533,"body":"taken away from availability."},{"startTime":4752.133,"endTime":4755.399,"body":"They've just moved to, you are allowed to"},{"startTime":4755.399,"endTime":4756.166,"body":"decide for yourself."},{"startTime":4756.166,"endTime":4757.933,"body":"And of course, we are always allowed to"},{"startTime":4757.933,"endTime":4758.733,"body":"decide for ourselves."},{"startTime":4758.733,"endTime":4760.866,"body":"That is part of what the health freedom"},{"startTime":4760.866,"endTime":4762.433,"body":"movement is fighting for."},{"startTime":4763.166,"endTime":4767.733,"body":"But let me find the list of things that"},{"startTime":4767.733,"endTime":4769.199,"body":"are not included here, which for some"},{"startTime":4769.199,"endTime":4770.1,"body":"reason isn't showing up."},{"startTime":4770.366,"endTime":4770.566,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":4770.933,"endTime":4775.133,"body":"Let me just say first, I got it."},{"startTime":4776.899,"endTime":4778.366,"body":"Tracy Beth Hogue and Martin"},{"startTime":4778.366,"endTime":4783.566,"body":"Koldorf are in no way extreme."},{"startTime":4784.266,"endTime":4784.466,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4784.566,"endTime":4787.833,"body":"These people are institutional in"},{"startTime":4787.833,"endTime":4791.399,"body":"orientation and cautious in a direction"},{"startTime":4791.399,"endTime":4796.266,"body":"that frankly, I think is a bit troubling"},{"startTime":4796.266,"endTime":4798.566,"body":"in the sense that the presumption that"},{"startTime":4798.566,"endTime":4802.699,"body":"there is value in these vaccines and in"},{"startTime":4802.699,"endTime":4804.366,"body":"light of the way in which they're tested,"},{"startTime":4804.833,"endTime":4809.233,"body":"that the consensus of Western nations"},{"startTime":4809.233,"endTime":4810.833,"body":"should somehow be guiding us,"},{"startTime":4810.833,"endTime":4813.566,"body":"I think is actually incorrect."},{"startTime":4813.933,"endTime":4815.833,"body":"But nonetheless, the point is our"},{"startTime":4815.933,"endTime":4819.266,"body":"governor is responding to people who are"},{"startTime":4819.266,"endTime":4821.466,"body":"cautious in his direction and he is"},{"startTime":4821.466,"endTime":4825.233,"body":"treating them as if they are zealots or"},{"startTime":4825.233,"endTime":4826.6,"body":"cranks and nothing could"},{"startTime":4826.6,"endTime":4827.899,"body":"be further from the truth."},{"startTime":4829.366,"endTime":4834.733,"body":"So first of all, I don't get the sense"},{"startTime":4834.733,"endTime":4838.266,"body":"from our governor that he has a deep"},{"startTime":4838.266,"endTime":4840.466,"body":"feeling about anything."},{"startTime":4841.0,"endTime":4842.266,"body":"Well, this is a, this is a posture."},{"startTime":4842.8,"endTime":4843.966,"body":"This is absolutely true."},{"startTime":4844.233,"endTime":4847.766,"body":"And the idea that by comparing what we're"},{"startTime":4847.766,"endTime":4851.866,"body":"doing to our peer nations with whom when"},{"startTime":4851.866,"endTime":4853.766,"body":"you compare our children's health, we"},{"startTime":4853.766,"endTime":4857.233,"body":"clearly come out badly and trying to come"},{"startTime":4857.233,"endTime":4858.966,"body":"into greater alignment with nations that"},{"startTime":4858.966,"endTime":4861.466,"body":"are peers with regard to also basically"},{"startTime":4861.466,"endTime":4863.966,"body":"being weird, also being Western educated,"},{"startTime":4863.966,"endTime":4866.233,"body":"industrialized, rich, and democratic, all"},{"startTime":4866.233,"endTime":4869.333,"body":"with issues associated with those words,"},{"startTime":4870.633,"endTime":4871.666,"body":"that that is somehow"},{"startTime":4871.666,"endTime":4872.666,"body":"going against science."},{"startTime":4873.033,"endTime":4875.5,"body":"So he's saying that Denmark is an"},{"startTime":4875.5,"endTime":4877.866,"body":"anti-scientific country, that most of"},{"startTime":4877.866,"endTime":4879.466,"body":"Western Europe are"},{"startTime":4879.466,"endTime":4881.399,"body":"actively going against science."},{"startTime":4881.8,"endTime":4884.266,"body":"And how is it then that those countries"},{"startTime":4884.266,"endTime":4886.933,"body":"who are apparently ignorant of Bob"},{"startTime":4886.933,"endTime":4889.466,"body":"Ferguson's special science have children"},{"startTime":4889.466,"endTime":4890.466,"body":"who are healthier than ours?"},{"startTime":4891.333,"endTime":4892.5,"body":"So here we have,"},{"startTime":4893.633,"endTime":4897.266,"body":"following these recommendations, as we"},{"startTime":4897.266,"endTime":4899.566,"body":"just read from Hogan Koldorf, the"},{"startTime":4899.566,"endTime":4900.899,"body":"Childhood Immunization Scheduled by"},{"startTime":4900.899,"endTime":4903.766,"body":"Recommendation Group, including the ones"},{"startTime":4903.766,"endTime":4906.733,"body":"that I just read, which immunizations"},{"startTime":4906.733,"endTime":4908.666,"body":"still recommended for all children,"},{"startTime":4909.666,"endTime":4911.166,"body":"which is, as you say, quite"},{"startTime":4911.166,"endTime":4912.433,"body":"conservative, quite a lot."},{"startTime":4913.033,"endTime":4915.966,"body":"There are many people who would say, this"},{"startTime":4915.966,"endTime":4918.533,"body":"list is already is far"},{"startTime":4918.533,"endTime":4919.866,"body":"too long, far too long."},{"startTime":4919.866,"endTime":4922.8,"body":"But okay, these, all of these, you know,"},{"startTime":4922.8,"endTime":4927.466,"body":"DTAP or, and Tdap, Diphtheria, Tetanus,"},{"startTime":4927.466,"endTime":4930.566,"body":"and Aeschyla or Pertussis, and Musals,"},{"startTime":4930.566,"endTime":4932.366,"body":"Mumps, and Rubella, and Varicella, and"},{"startTime":4932.366,"endTime":4934.466,"body":"several others are still on the"},{"startTime":4934.466,"endTime":4936.8,"body":"recommended schedule for children."},{"startTime":4938.366,"endTime":4939.533,"body":"Recommended now only for certain"},{"startTime":4939.533,"endTime":4942.266,"body":"high-risk groups of populations include"},{"startTime":4942.266,"endTime":4946.033,"body":"RSV, and Hep B, and Dengue, and"},{"startTime":4946.033,"endTime":4947.533,"body":"meningococcal, and Hep A."},{"startTime":4948.833,"endTime":4950.933,"body":"And immunizations based on shared"},{"startTime":4950.966,"endTime":4952.1,"body":"clinical decision making."},{"startTime":4952.1,"endTime":4954.166,"body":"That is not inherently recommended for"},{"startTime":4954.166,"endTime":4958.066,"body":"anyone, but any parent who, frankly, has"},{"startTime":4958.066,"endTime":4960.1,"body":"come to a bad decision and decided that"},{"startTime":4960.1,"endTime":4962.266,"body":"their child needs such a thing, can"},{"startTime":4962.266,"endTime":4963.466,"body":"continue to get"},{"startTime":4963.466,"endTime":4966.566,"body":"rotavirus, COVID-19, influenza,"},{"startTime":4967.899,"endTime":4972.266,"body":"and still, I'm not sure why this, why Hep"},{"startTime":4972.266,"endTime":4973.833,"body":"A, Hep B, M, and Jococoa,"},{"startTime":4973.833,"endTime":4974.833,"body":"and Sherman come on both lists."},{"startTime":4974.833,"endTime":4976.3,"body":"So I'm going to put that aside."},{"startTime":4976.3,"endTime":4978.233,"body":"I'm not sure what the details are there,"},{"startTime":4978.233,"endTime":4979.733,"body":"but they've got basically"},{"startTime":4979.733,"endTime":4982.733,"body":"flu and COVID vaccines on the,"},{"startTime":4983.833,"endTime":4985.3,"body":"you and your doctor and your God can make"},{"startTime":4985.3,"endTime":4986.633,"body":"this decision for yourself, for your"},{"startTime":4986.633,"endTime":4988.833,"body":"child, but the CDC is no longer offering"},{"startTime":4988.833,"endTime":4990.333,"body":"a recommendation one way or the other."},{"startTime":4991.666,"endTime":4996.366,"body":"And the idea that this, this warrants a"},{"startTime":4996.366,"endTime":4998.266,"body":"statement from a governor who clearly"},{"startTime":4998.266,"endTime":5000.8,"body":"doesn't know what science is, that he's"},{"startTime":5000.8,"endTime":5002.866,"body":"going to stand by science and make sure"},{"startTime":5002.866,"endTime":5004.833,"body":"that all Washingtonians are healthy due"},{"startTime":5004.833,"endTime":5007.233,"body":"to a, you know, healthy dose of scientism"},{"startTime":5007.233,"endTime":5009.266,"body":"is frankly alarming."},{"startTime":5009.766,"endTime":5011.699,"body":"Like he's the one we should be alarmed"},{"startTime":5011.766,"endTime":5013.166,"body":"by, not anything coming"},{"startTime":5013.166,"endTime":5017.166,"body":"out of HHS in this month."},{"startTime":5017.666,"endTime":5021.0,"body":"So what he is doing is"},{"startTime":5021.0,"endTime":5021.933,"body":"he is- Governor Ferguson."},{"startTime":5022.166,"endTime":5024.266,"body":"Governor Ferguson is he is picking up on"},{"startTime":5024.266,"endTime":5028.066,"body":"a decades long propaganda campaign that"},{"startTime":5028.066,"endTime":5030.833,"body":"misled a lot of people, including you and"},{"startTime":5030.833,"endTime":5033.366,"body":"me, into imagining that these things had"},{"startTime":5033.366,"endTime":5035.133,"body":"a net health benefit that was not"},{"startTime":5035.133,"endTime":5037.466,"body":"demonstrated and imagining that they had"},{"startTime":5037.466,"endTime":5040.266,"body":"been safety tested such that the"},{"startTime":5040.266,"endTime":5042.333,"body":"likelihood of them doing harm was"},{"startTime":5042.333,"endTime":5044.166,"body":"vanishingly small, which it isn't."},{"startTime":5045.066,"endTime":5047.5,"body":"So that propaganda campaign was a big"},{"startTime":5047.5,"endTime":5051.333,"body":"investment by pharma and the idea that"},{"startTime":5051.333,"endTime":5054.633,"body":"with the Trump administration moving"},{"startTime":5054.633,"endTime":5058.566,"body":"against the vaccine recklessness that has"},{"startTime":5058.566,"endTime":5061.033,"body":"overtaken our medical establishment, that"},{"startTime":5061.033,"endTime":5063.333,"body":"the right thing to do is to do the"},{"startTime":5063.333,"endTime":5066.833,"body":"opposite of whatever Trump is doing is,"},{"startTime":5067.633,"endTime":5068.633,"body":"as you point out, the"},{"startTime":5068.633,"endTime":5070.233,"body":"exact inverse of science."},{"startTime":5070.966,"endTime":5072.766,"body":"And I will also just say, I think I"},{"startTime":5072.766,"endTime":5076.3,"body":"hinted at it before, but there is a"},{"startTime":5076.3,"endTime":5079.5,"body":"growing consensus amongst the policy"},{"startTime":5079.5,"endTime":5081.366,"body":"oriented people in the health freedom"},{"startTime":5081.366,"endTime":5083.233,"body":"movement that we don't want to take your"},{"startTime":5083.233,"endTime":5085.433,"body":"vaccines, you should be free to choose."},{"startTime":5085.966,"endTime":5087.5,"body":"I don't agree with this."},{"startTime":5088.133,"endTime":5093.466,"body":"We have things like a CDC in order to"},{"startTime":5093.466,"endTime":5094.933,"body":"protect us from bad"},{"startTime":5094.933,"endTime":5096.766,"body":"decisions in a medical realm."},{"startTime":5097.566,"endTime":5099.866,"body":"Either we should allow a free for all and"},{"startTime":5099.866,"endTime":5102.433,"body":"we should warn patients, hey, you can"},{"startTime":5102.433,"endTime":5104.6,"body":"have anything you want, but a lot of it,"},{"startTime":5104.6,"endTime":5105.933,"body":"probably almost all of it"},{"startTime":5105.933,"endTime":5107.266,"body":"isn't any good for you at all."},{"startTime":5107.533,"endTime":5107.733,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":5107.933,"endTime":5109.333,"body":"That's not my position."},{"startTime":5109.566,"endTime":5111.166,"body":"And it's not that we don't have policies"},{"startTime":5111.166,"endTime":5112.333,"body":"that prevent people from"},{"startTime":5112.333,"endTime":5113.699,"body":"taking some of what they want."},{"startTime":5113.699,"endTime":5114.366,"body":"Well, that's my point."},{"startTime":5114.666,"endTime":5114.966,"body":"Drug laws exist."},{"startTime":5115.366,"endTime":5117.133,"body":"Well, pharmacies exist and you have to"},{"startTime":5117.133,"endTime":5118.833,"body":"have a script from a doc to"},{"startTime":5118.833,"endTime":5120.633,"body":"get the stuff in the pharmacy."},{"startTime":5120.899,"endTime":5123.266,"body":"So the point is we've decided to regulate"},{"startTime":5123.266,"endTime":5126.566,"body":"things at the point you find out that"},{"startTime":5126.566,"endTime":5129.666,"body":"Bobby Kennedy and Toby Rogers are right,"},{"startTime":5129.666,"endTime":5132.966,"body":"that these things were never tested with"},{"startTime":5132.966,"endTime":5134.933,"body":"the process that would be necessary to"},{"startTime":5134.933,"endTime":5135.966,"body":"demonstrate their safety."},{"startTime":5136.433,"endTime":5137.8,"body":"The answer is there's only one rational"},{"startTime":5137.8,"endTime":5140.933,"body":"thing to do, which is full pause."},{"startTime":5141.233,"endTime":5143.133,"body":"Why is choice bad?"},{"startTime":5143.966,"endTime":5147.766,"body":"Because some people are gullible."},{"startTime":5148.333,"endTime":5150.233,"body":"And if you have a gullible parent, you"},{"startTime":5150.233,"endTime":5152.666,"body":"don't deserve to have a vaccine injury"},{"startTime":5152.666,"endTime":5154.766,"body":"because your doctor was persuasive or"},{"startTime":5154.766,"endTime":5157.166,"body":"your parent didn't know what questions to"},{"startTime":5157.166,"endTime":5159.3,"body":"ask or they were nervous about being a"},{"startTime":5159.3,"endTime":5160.966,"body":"first time parent or whatever it is."},{"startTime":5160.966,"endTime":5162.333,"body":"But I think that's what he's doing here."},{"startTime":5162.333,"endTime":5163.633,"body":"I think that's what Governor Ferguson is"},{"startTime":5163.633,"endTime":5169.066,"body":"doing here is creating alarm and fear in"},{"startTime":5169.066,"endTime":5171.833,"body":"response to a very,"},{"startTime":5171.833,"endTime":5174.866,"body":"very conservative slow."},{"startTime":5175.133,"endTime":5176.966,"body":"Okay, we're going to take a few things"},{"startTime":5176.966,"endTime":5179.199,"body":"off the childhood vaccine schedule, given"},{"startTime":5179.199,"endTime":5181.333,"body":"that we've noticed that no one else is"},{"startTime":5181.333,"endTime":5183.533,"body":"doing the crazy stuff we're doing and our"},{"startTime":5183.533,"endTime":5185.466,"body":"childhood vaccine schedule exploded over"},{"startTime":5185.466,"endTime":5187.733,"body":"the last 10 and 20 and 30 and 40 years."},{"startTime":5188.733,"endTime":5191.733,"body":"So if he responds with this kind of"},{"startTime":5192.0,"endTime":5194.6,"body":"hysterical, anti-scientific,"},{"startTime":5195.266,"endTime":5198.366,"body":"pro-scientistic rhetoric to a very"},{"startTime":5198.366,"endTime":5199.8,"body":"conservative set of recommendations,"},{"startTime":5201.433,"endTime":5203.966,"body":"what he is trying to do is get parents"},{"startTime":5203.966,"endTime":5206.533,"body":"basically up in arms, presumably not"},{"startTime":5206.566,"endTime":5210.233,"body":"actually, but parents up in arms to decry"},{"startTime":5210.233,"endTime":5212.433,"body":"the craziness that is happening and to"},{"startTime":5212.433,"endTime":5216.433,"body":"get them to even more unquestioningly"},{"startTime":5216.433,"endTime":5219.3,"body":"simply vaccinate their children with any"},{"startTime":5219.3,"endTime":5221.633,"body":"drug that a doctor or a pharmaceutical"},{"startTime":5221.633,"endTime":5223.133,"body":"company presents them with."},{"startTime":5223.633,"endTime":5228.1,"body":"Well, if I can briefly detour into a"},{"startTime":5228.1,"endTime":5230.166,"body":"thought about the political landscape"},{"startTime":5230.166,"endTime":5232.133,"body":"that sets this in motion."},{"startTime":5233.466,"endTime":5235.266,"body":"I've become, I mean, you and I are"},{"startTime":5235.266,"endTime":5240.6,"body":"lifelong liberals traumatized by the"},{"startTime":5240.6,"endTime":5244.0,"body":"state of nominal liberals, the state of"},{"startTime":5244.0,"endTime":5245.033,"body":"the Democratic Party."},{"startTime":5245.933,"endTime":5247.566,"body":"And the state period."},{"startTime":5248.166,"endTime":5248.399,"body":"Indeed."},{"startTime":5248.399,"endTime":5250.466,"body":"And I should just say people need to"},{"startTime":5250.466,"endTime":5251.866,"body":"understand that the state of Washington"},{"startTime":5251.866,"endTime":5252.966,"body":"is really two states."},{"startTime":5253.733,"endTime":5255.333,"body":"I meant the nation state,"},{"startTime":5255.333,"endTime":5256.733,"body":"like the whole, the state."},{"startTime":5257.166,"endTime":5258.766,"body":"Traumatized by states."},{"startTime":5259.0,"endTime":5260.3,"body":"State power turns out to"},{"startTime":5260.3,"endTime":5261.733,"body":"be tremendously dangerous."},{"startTime":5261.733,"endTime":5263.266,"body":"It's not that there's not governance that"},{"startTime":5263.266,"endTime":5265.1,"body":"needs to be done, but inevitably it seems"},{"startTime":5265.1,"endTime":5266.633,"body":"to fall into the hands of people who"},{"startTime":5266.633,"endTime":5268.266,"body":"don't do that governance and do something"},{"startTime":5268.266,"endTime":5269.166,"body":"else with that power."},{"startTime":5270.0,"endTime":5272.333,"body":"But state of Washington is two states."},{"startTime":5272.766,"endTime":5273.399,"body":"You could say the same"},{"startTime":5273.399,"endTime":5274.633,"body":"thing about the state of Oregon."},{"startTime":5275.766,"endTime":5278.399,"body":"There's the Western part of the state,"},{"startTime":5278.399,"endTime":5280.033,"body":"the wet part of the state in which"},{"startTime":5280.033,"endTime":5281.866,"body":"Seattle and Tacoma exist."},{"startTime":5282.366,"endTime":5282.933,"body":"And then there's the"},{"startTime":5282.933,"endTime":5283.899,"body":"Eastern part of the state."},{"startTime":5284.0,"endTime":5288.533,"body":"And they're politically not alike."},{"startTime":5289.1,"endTime":5291.066,"body":"And so what is happening in the state."},{"startTime":5291.066,"endTime":5292.699,"body":"Eastern Washington's politics is much"},{"startTime":5292.699,"endTime":5293.6,"body":"more like that of Idaho."},{"startTime":5294.1,"endTime":5294.3,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":5294.933,"endTime":5297.266,"body":"And what happens is the demographics of"},{"startTime":5297.266,"endTime":5300.633,"body":"the state mean that Seattle effectively"},{"startTime":5300.633,"endTime":5304.533,"body":"dictates not only the city policy, but"},{"startTime":5304.533,"endTime":5306.533,"body":"the state policy because it is large"},{"startTime":5306.533,"endTime":5310.399,"body":"enough to sway state level elections."},{"startTime":5311.266,"endTime":5315.133,"body":"So in effect, what you have is a kind of"},{"startTime":5315.133,"endTime":5318.733,"body":"Democratic party tyranny being inflicted"},{"startTime":5318.733,"endTime":5321.133,"body":"on those of us in the state who know"},{"startTime":5321.133,"endTime":5325.733,"body":"better because Seattle is, you know, a"},{"startTime":5325.733,"endTime":5326.833,"body":"large population center."},{"startTime":5326.833,"endTime":5329.199,"body":"And I can't, I can't complain about that"},{"startTime":5329.199,"endTime":5330.566,"body":"at the level of democracy."},{"startTime":5330.566,"endTime":5332.066,"body":"That's how democracy works."},{"startTime":5332.933,"endTime":5337.166,"body":"But we are divided and the idea that"},{"startTime":5337.166,"endTime":5339.266,"body":"they're going to treat this federal move"},{"startTime":5339.266,"endTime":5342.633,"body":"as tyranny and they're going to impose"},{"startTime":5342.633,"endTime":5345.399,"body":"some sort of state level tyranny in order"},{"startTime":5345.399,"endTime":5346.899,"body":"to compensate for the fact that the"},{"startTime":5346.899,"endTime":5349.066,"body":"federal tyranny is actually being relaxed"},{"startTime":5349.066,"endTime":5351.666,"body":"by this administration is"},{"startTime":5351.666,"endTime":5352.933,"body":"everything's turned on its head."},{"startTime":5353.399,"endTime":5354.3,"body":"And the point I wanted to"},{"startTime":5354.3,"endTime":5355.566,"body":"make about liberalism is this."},{"startTime":5356.3,"endTime":5361.433,"body":"As we have become alarmed about the"},{"startTime":5361.433,"endTime":5366.533,"body":"propaganda and the political direction of"},{"startTime":5366.533,"endTime":5368.266,"body":"the blue team, which has in effect"},{"startTime":5368.266,"endTime":5370.933,"body":"embraced the inverse of all of the values"},{"startTime":5370.933,"endTime":5372.766,"body":"that you and I grew up with."},{"startTime":5373.133,"endTime":5374.366,"body":"One of the things that has become"},{"startTime":5374.366,"endTime":5379.266,"body":"apparent is that blue team voters, people"},{"startTime":5379.266,"endTime":5381.166,"body":"who really resonate with the Democratic"},{"startTime":5381.166,"endTime":5387.133,"body":"party seem to have a diminished ability"},{"startTime":5387.133,"endTime":5389.533,"body":"to recognize that some belief that they"},{"startTime":5389.533,"endTime":5391.566,"body":"held turned out not to be right."},{"startTime":5391.8,"endTime":5393.733,"body":"In other words, they have a kind of"},{"startTime":5393.733,"endTime":5396.966,"body":"unfalsifiable mindset where they come to"},{"startTime":5396.966,"endTime":5399.066,"body":"believe that something is this."},{"startTime":5399.433,"endTime":5401.266,"body":"And then that's special to blue team."},{"startTime":5401.666,"endTime":5403.699,"body":"I think it's, I don't, I guess I don't"},{"startTime":5403.699,"endTime":5405.266,"body":"know that we have evidence that it's"},{"startTime":5405.266,"endTime":5406.233,"body":"special to blue team."},{"startTime":5406.233,"endTime":5407.733,"body":"I see ample evidence of what you're"},{"startTime":5407.733,"endTime":5411.233,"body":"talking about on the blue team, but I"},{"startTime":5411.233,"endTime":5414.699,"body":"don't know that we have seen recently"},{"startTime":5416.8,"endTime":5418.133,"body":"major errors."},{"startTime":5418.866,"endTime":5421.166,"body":"I mean, there's been plenty of chaos,"},{"startTime":5421.166,"endTime":5424.133,"body":"obviously, at the federal level in the"},{"startTime":5424.133,"endTime":5426.6,"body":"last year and in the last"},{"startTime":5426.6,"endTime":5428.566,"body":"nine years and like all the time."},{"startTime":5428.833,"endTime":5435.033,"body":"But it feels to me that there are lots of"},{"startTime":5435.033,"endTime":5436.866,"body":"my team, no matter what"},{"startTime":5436.866,"endTime":5438.733,"body":"they do, players on both sides."},{"startTime":5438.733,"endTime":5440.933,"body":"Oh, there are lots of partisans who"},{"startTime":5440.933,"endTime":5442.966,"body":"aren't doing an analysis."},{"startTime":5442.966,"endTime":5444.399,"body":"They may be presenting something as an"},{"startTime":5444.399,"endTime":5445.633,"body":"analysis that isn't one."},{"startTime":5446.633,"endTime":5450.466,"body":"And frankly, the idea of both sides is"},{"startTime":5450.466,"endTime":5452.566,"body":"complicating here because I think there"},{"startTime":5452.566,"endTime":5454.633,"body":"really is a blue team and"},{"startTime":5454.633,"endTime":5456.066,"body":"there isn't really a red team."},{"startTime":5456.066,"endTime":5457.266,"body":"The red team is at the moment a battle"},{"startTime":5457.466,"endTime":5458.333,"body":"between several"},{"startTime":5458.333,"endTime":5459.966,"body":"different factions, right?"},{"startTime":5459.966,"endTime":5461.866,"body":"It's a battle between the"},{"startTime":5461.866,"endTime":5466.733,"body":"old GOP, MAGA, MAHA, right?"},{"startTime":5466.733,"endTime":5469.433,"body":"There's tension there, but I do find much"},{"startTime":5469.433,"endTime":5472.533,"body":"more self-reflection on that side about"},{"startTime":5472.533,"endTime":5474.166,"body":"what we got wrong,"},{"startTime":5474.166,"endTime":5475.333,"body":"what we didn't get wrong."},{"startTime":5476.233,"endTime":5477.733,"body":"Well, and it's also, I mean, this is an"},{"startTime":5477.733,"endTime":5479.6,"body":"old point that has been made by many"},{"startTime":5479.6,"endTime":5485.133,"body":"people, but because the media and higher"},{"startTime":5485.133,"endTime":5488.166,"body":"ed, like the media and education, have"},{"startTime":5488.166,"endTime":5490.199,"body":"been effectively owned and"},{"startTime":5490.199,"endTime":5492.6,"body":"run by Team Blue for so long."},{"startTime":5493.233,"endTime":5496.066,"body":"Team Red, people on Team Red are simply"},{"startTime":5496.066,"endTime":5497.933,"body":"more familiar with hearing opposing"},{"startTime":5497.933,"endTime":5500.199,"body":"arguments and become more comfortable"},{"startTime":5500.199,"endTime":5501.933,"body":"knowing that there are people who think"},{"startTime":5501.933,"endTime":5504.066,"body":"differently in the world from them and"},{"startTime":5504.066,"endTime":5504.933,"body":"that not the entire"},{"startTime":5504.933,"endTime":5506.333,"body":"world doesn't look like them."},{"startTime":5506.333,"endTime":5509.333,"body":"Whereas if you are on the blue team and"},{"startTime":5509.333,"endTime":5511.5,"body":"you live in a blue city, in a blue state,"},{"startTime":5511.833,"endTime":5513.766,"body":"and you watch corporate media and you"},{"startTime":5513.766,"endTime":5515.533,"body":"read corporate media and you go to public"},{"startTime":5515.533,"endTime":5518.766,"body":"schools, there's a very good chance that"},{"startTime":5518.766,"endTime":5520.6,"body":"you just never run into anyone who"},{"startTime":5520.6,"endTime":5522.233,"body":"doesn't think like you do, or at least"},{"startTime":5522.233,"endTime":5523.233,"body":"who doesn't say it aloud."},{"startTime":5523.699,"endTime":5525.966,"body":"And so you come to find it easy to"},{"startTime":5525.966,"endTime":5527.866,"body":"demonize those people, to imagine that"},{"startTime":5527.866,"endTime":5529.266,"body":"they are the boogeyman in the corner,"},{"startTime":5530.333,"endTime":5534.166,"body":"which is, it's a bizarre and frankly"},{"startTime":5535.6,"endTime":5538.066,"body":"really sad irony that it's exactly those"},{"startTime":5538.066,"endTime":5540.133,"body":"people who then claim things like in this"},{"startTime":5540.133,"endTime":5541.066,"body":"house, everything's about"},{"startTime":5541.066,"endTime":5542.666,"body":"inclusiveness and diversity."},{"startTime":5542.666,"endTime":5543.633,"body":"It's like, you know, you're the people"},{"startTime":5543.633,"endTime":5545.699,"body":"who actually only know the world that you"},{"startTime":5545.699,"endTime":5547.266,"body":"have created instead of actually"},{"startTime":5547.266,"endTime":5549.766,"body":"recognizing the, you know, the beautiful"},{"startTime":5549.766,"endTime":5551.766,"body":"diversity of experiences and thoughts"},{"startTime":5551.766,"endTime":5553.433,"body":"that humans have across the planet."},{"startTime":5553.699,"endTime":5555.5,"body":"No, I think this is quite right, that"},{"startTime":5555.5,"endTime":5560.066,"body":"effectively the blue team is better able"},{"startTime":5560.066,"endTime":5563.0,"body":"to create an impenetrable echo chamber"},{"startTime":5563.0,"endTime":5566.033,"body":"where people inside the echo chamber will"},{"startTime":5566.033,"endTime":5567.366,"body":"actually do the bidding of the echo"},{"startTime":5567.366,"endTime":5569.3,"body":"chamber and they will fend off anything"},{"startTime":5569.3,"endTime":5571.466,"body":"that might, you know, this is why we get"},{"startTime":5571.466,"endTime":5573.466,"body":"the attacks that we get, right?"},{"startTime":5573.866,"endTime":5575.833,"body":"You know, the one I'm constantly"},{"startTime":5575.833,"endTime":5578.333,"body":"complaining about is, you know, if you"},{"startTime":5578.333,"endTime":5582.933,"body":"can't see that Bret and Heather are, you"},{"startTime":5582.933,"endTime":5584.133,"body":"know, scientific"},{"startTime":5584.133,"endTime":5586.866,"body":"know-nothings and hacks, I can't help you."},{"startTime":5587.399,"endTime":5590.133,"body":"That kind of accusation isn't going to"},{"startTime":5590.133,"endTime":5590.933,"body":"work for anybody who"},{"startTime":5590.933,"endTime":5592.233,"body":"spent time listening to us."},{"startTime":5592.233,"endTime":5594.333,"body":"It's obviously just not accurate, but if"},{"startTime":5594.333,"endTime":5595.966,"body":"you're trying to decide whether to listen"},{"startTime":5595.966,"endTime":5598.233,"body":"to us, it's enough to make you think as"},{"startTime":5598.233,"endTime":5600.666,"body":"you begin to hear something that we say"},{"startTime":5600.666,"endTime":5602.066,"body":"that sounds reasonable to you, the point"},{"startTime":5602.066,"endTime":5602.966,"body":"is, oh, am I being tricked?"},{"startTime":5603.533,"endTime":5605.666,"body":"So you second guess"},{"startTime":5605.666,"endTime":5607.8,"body":"yourself and you won't listen."},{"startTime":5607.8,"endTime":5609.833,"body":"And so that thing where you've got like,"},{"startTime":5610.166,"endTime":5612.633,"body":"you know, well, I pay attention to many"},{"startTime":5612.633,"endTime":5613.566,"body":"different news sources."},{"startTime":5613.8,"endTime":5614.766,"body":"Well, they're not really"},{"startTime":5614.766,"endTime":5616.033,"body":"many different news sources."},{"startTime":5616.033,"endTime":5617.633,"body":"You're paying attention to one news"},{"startTime":5617.633,"endTime":5619.733,"body":"source that has many different mastheads."},{"startTime":5620.633,"endTime":5622.333,"body":"And so you get the sense that you're"},{"startTime":5622.333,"endTime":5623.733,"body":"broad-minded and you're consulting"},{"startTime":5623.733,"endTime":5624.666,"body":"different perspectives."},{"startTime":5625.233,"endTime":5626.933,"body":"And anytime something shows up, the"},{"startTime":5626.933,"endTime":5629.066,"body":"challenge is that, you know, there'll be"},{"startTime":5629.066,"endTime":5631.666,"body":"a ready-made op-ed that will tell you why"},{"startTime":5631.666,"endTime":5633.333,"body":"it's preposterous or, you"},{"startTime":5633.333,"endTime":5634.833,"body":"know, why that person is insane."},{"startTime":5635.533,"endTime":5637.233,"body":"So anyway, it becomes whatever the"},{"startTime":5637.233,"endTime":5638.899,"body":"mechanism is that does it."},{"startTime":5638.899,"endTime":5642.566,"body":"At the moment, the blue team voters"},{"startTime":5642.566,"endTime":5645.766,"body":"cannot discover that"},{"startTime":5645.766,"endTime":5646.666,"body":"they have been wrong."},{"startTime":5648.266,"endTime":5652.266,"body":"They have an unfalsifiable mindset that"},{"startTime":5652.266,"endTime":5654.066,"body":"causes them to do exactly what Governor"},{"startTime":5654.066,"endTime":5657.233,"body":"Ferguson is doing here, which is if"},{"startTime":5657.233,"endTime":5659.066,"body":"they're doing it, then"},{"startTime":5659.066,"endTime":5660.333,"body":"we must do the inverse."},{"startTime":5660.833,"endTime":5661.266,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":5661.266,"endTime":5661.466,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":5661.699,"endTime":5662.899,"body":"If they want to close the border, then we"},{"startTime":5662.899,"endTime":5663.766,"body":"should open it completely."},{"startTime":5664.333,"endTime":5664.533,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":5664.633,"endTime":5665.566,"body":"That kind of mindset."},{"startTime":5665.933,"endTime":5666.833,"body":"And yeah, instead of"},{"startTime":5666.833,"endTime":5669.399,"body":"analytics, it's contrarianism."},{"startTime":5670.733,"endTime":5673.133,"body":"And the thing that was so maddening"},{"startTime":5673.133,"endTime":5676.533,"body":"during COVID that is now maddening in the"},{"startTime":5676.533,"endTime":5678.966,"body":"same way on the larger question of"},{"startTime":5678.966,"endTime":5682.033,"body":"vaccines is nothing should"},{"startTime":5682.033,"endTime":5683.533,"body":"be less partisan than this."},{"startTime":5683.966,"endTime":5686.366,"body":"Every single American should be able to"},{"startTime":5686.366,"endTime":5689.366,"body":"agree we want the vaccine schedule that"},{"startTime":5689.366,"endTime":5692.866,"body":"increases the quality and length of life"},{"startTime":5692.866,"endTime":5695.166,"body":"for the maximum number of people."},{"startTime":5695.566,"endTime":5697.033,"body":"We may differ over what we"},{"startTime":5697.033,"endTime":5698.433,"body":"expect that to look like."},{"startTime":5698.433,"endTime":5699.533,"body":"Some of us might expect it to"},{"startTime":5699.533,"endTime":5701.166,"body":"have very few vaccines on it."},{"startTime":5701.166,"endTime":5702.533,"body":"Some of us might expect it to have even"},{"startTime":5702.533,"endTime":5705.8,"body":"more than the schedule from a year ago,"},{"startTime":5705.8,"endTime":5708.8,"body":"but we shouldn't disagree over whether"},{"startTime":5708.8,"endTime":5710.233,"body":"that would be a good thing."},{"startTime":5710.533,"endTime":5712.533,"body":"And at some level, we effectively do."},{"startTime":5713.033,"endTime":5715.233,"body":"Somebody has already decided the more"},{"startTime":5715.233,"endTime":5716.066,"body":"vaccines, the better."},{"startTime":5717.0,"endTime":5717.366,"body":"And we're going to"},{"startTime":5717.366,"endTime":5718.199,"body":"push in that direction."},{"startTime":5718.633,"endTime":5719.966,"body":"And anybody who's pushing in the other"},{"startTime":5719.966,"endTime":5722.033,"body":"direction is obviously doing so because"},{"startTime":5722.033,"endTime":5724.766,"body":"they are callous about the health of"},{"startTime":5724.8,"endTime":5727.566,"body":"people or because they're stupid or"},{"startTime":5727.566,"endTime":5728.366,"body":"something like that."},{"startTime":5728.366,"endTime":5732.266,"body":"And it's like we need a moment at which"},{"startTime":5734.0,"endTime":5736.066,"body":"we are able to shake people with an"},{"startTime":5736.066,"endTime":5738.266,"body":"unfalsifiable mindset by the lapels and"},{"startTime":5738.266,"endTime":5741.466,"body":"say, you know, wake up, you actually need"},{"startTime":5741.466,"endTime":5743.933,"body":"to participate in an analytical process."},{"startTime":5743.933,"endTime":5744.366,"body":"That's right."},{"startTime":5744.933,"endTime":5746.466,"body":"And it will lead you somewhere very"},{"startTime":5746.466,"endTime":5747.366,"body":"different than you are."},{"startTime":5748.166,"endTime":5750.733,"body":"Yes, that is exactly right."},{"startTime":5753.199,"endTime":5757.733,"body":"So you may not remember, in fact, we"},{"startTime":5757.733,"endTime":5758.699,"body":"weren't in Washington"},{"startTime":5758.699,"endTime":5760.066,"body":"during most of COVID."},{"startTime":5760.3,"endTime":5761.033,"body":"We were in Oregon."},{"startTime":5762.066,"endTime":5763.833,"body":"And so Bob Ferguson was not our attorney"},{"startTime":5763.833,"endTime":5765.566,"body":"general for four years"},{"startTime":5765.566,"endTime":5768.166,"body":"between 2018 and 2022."},{"startTime":5769.433,"endTime":5772.033,"body":"And it turns out that one of the things"},{"startTime":5772.033,"endTime":5773.866,"body":"that he did during COVID as attorney"},{"startTime":5773.866,"endTime":5776.766,"body":"general, which he had been since 2012 and"},{"startTime":5776.766,"endTime":5779.533,"body":"only became not the attorney general, but"},{"startTime":5779.533,"endTime":5781.266,"body":"instead the governor of the state of"},{"startTime":5781.266,"endTime":5783.866,"body":"Washington in 2025, was imposing and"},{"startTime":5783.866,"endTime":5784.966,"body":"forcing COVID vaccine"},{"startTime":5784.966,"endTime":5786.166,"body":"mandates on his employees."},{"startTime":5787.666,"endTime":5789.566,"body":"And so here you can actually, you can"},{"startTime":5789.566,"endTime":5790.8,"body":"show my screen here."},{"startTime":5790.8,"endTime":5793.433,"body":"This is from an organization called the"},{"startTime":5793.433,"endTime":5794.566,"body":"Silent Majority Foundation."},{"startTime":5795.433,"endTime":5798.1,"body":"And they do a lot of work in support of"},{"startTime":5798.1,"endTime":5799.733,"body":"the Second Amendment, in support of free"},{"startTime":5799.733,"endTime":5801.033,"body":"speech, in support of medical"},{"startTime":5801.033,"endTime":5802.533,"body":"freedom, among other things."},{"startTime":5803.033,"endTime":5804.166,"body":"Here's the medical freedom page,"},{"startTime":5804.166,"endTime":5805.833,"body":"including some of the cases that they"},{"startTime":5805.833,"endTime":5807.166,"body":"have brought, one of which"},{"startTime":5807.166,"endTime":5808.766,"body":"is Hanson versus Ferguson."},{"startTime":5809.966,"endTime":5811.066,"body":"And I'm just going to read their blurb"},{"startTime":5811.066,"endTime":5813.233,"body":"about this still open, I believe,"},{"startTime":5814.466,"endTime":5817.566,"body":"case on December 3rd, 2024, Silent"},{"startTime":5817.566,"endTime":5819.233,"body":"Majority Foundation filed a lawsuit on"},{"startTime":5819.233,"endTime":5821.466,"body":"behalf of 10 former employees of the"},{"startTime":5821.466,"endTime":5822.966,"body":"Washington State Office of the Attorney"},{"startTime":5822.966,"endTime":5826.3,"body":"General, challenging the Attorney General"},{"startTime":5826.3,"endTime":5828.666,"body":"Office's adoption and implementation of"},{"startTime":5828.666,"endTime":5830.366,"body":"policy 1.58, which was"},{"startTime":5830.366,"endTime":5831.699,"body":"titled simply vaccination."},{"startTime":5832.733,"endTime":5834.333,"body":"Our plaintiffs were required by AGO"},{"startTime":5834.333,"endTime":5836.533,"body":"policy 1.58 to be fully vaccinated"},{"startTime":5836.533,"endTime":5838.866,"body":"against COVID-19 as a condition of their"},{"startTime":5838.866,"endTime":5840.966,"body":"employment, while the policy provided the"},{"startTime":5840.966,"endTime":5842.366,"body":"option to request accommodations or"},{"startTime":5842.366,"endTime":5843.666,"body":"modifications for employees with"},{"startTime":5843.666,"endTime":5844.766,"body":"disabilities, health"},{"startTime":5844.766,"endTime":5846.066,"body":"conditions or religious beliefs."},{"startTime":5846.566,"endTime":5847.899,"body":"None received accommodation."},{"startTime":5848.766,"endTime":5850.366,"body":"Attorney General Bob Ferguson took an"},{"startTime":5850.366,"endTime":5851.566,"body":"oath to support the United States"},{"startTime":5851.566,"endTime":5853.433,"body":"Constitution and the Washington State"},{"startTime":5853.433,"endTime":5854.666,"body":"Constitution, both of"},{"startTime":5854.666,"endTime":5855.399,"body":"which he has violated."},{"startTime":5856.433,"endTime":5858.466,"body":"And the Silent Majority Foundation stands"},{"startTime":5858.466,"endTime":5859.833,"body":"with our courageous plaintiffs who are"},{"startTime":5859.833,"endTime":5861.166,"body":"taking a stand against Bob Ferguson."},{"startTime":5862.166,"endTime":5864.533,"body":"Now, I looked through a certain amount of"},{"startTime":5864.533,"endTime":5866.466,"body":"these documents, and if I"},{"startTime":5866.466,"endTime":5868.766,"body":"can see my screen again here,"},{"startTime":5870.666,"endTime":5874.933,"body":"including the declarations from several"},{"startTime":5874.933,"endTime":5875.399,"body":"of the plaintiffs,"},{"startTime":5875.766,"endTime":5876.833,"body":"several of the 10 plaintiffs."},{"startTime":5878.133,"endTime":5880.366,"body":"I didn't read all of any of them, nor did"},{"startTime":5880.366,"endTime":5881.366,"body":"I read all of them, but I"},{"startTime":5881.366,"endTime":5883.233,"body":"read some of many of them."},{"startTime":5883.733,"endTime":5884.899,"body":"And you have, for instance,"},{"startTime":5886.066,"endTime":5890.1,"body":"Stacy B and Natalia C, who were entirely"},{"startTime":5890.1,"endTime":5892.333,"body":"teleworkers, never went into an office at"},{"startTime":5892.333,"endTime":5895.8,"body":"all, but were denied vaccine and at least"},{"startTime":5895.8,"endTime":5897.266,"body":"one of their cases, I think both, they"},{"startTime":5897.266,"endTime":5900.933,"body":"were longstanding Christians with obvious"},{"startTime":5900.933,"endTime":5902.466,"body":"reason to make a stand"},{"startTime":5902.466,"endTime":5903.533,"body":"for religious exemptions."},{"startTime":5904.399,"endTime":5905.5,"body":"They didn't get their exemptions."},{"startTime":5905.933,"endTime":5908.166,"body":"They literally never saw face"},{"startTime":5908.166,"endTime":5909.866,"body":"to face any of their coworkers."},{"startTime":5910.566,"endTime":5911.3,"body":"They refused to get"},{"startTime":5911.3,"endTime":5912.366,"body":"vaccinated and they were fired."},{"startTime":5913.966,"endTime":5916.266,"body":"This was under Attorney General Bob"},{"startTime":5916.266,"endTime":5918.199,"body":"Ferguson, now the governor of the state"},{"startTime":5918.199,"endTime":5920.633,"body":"of Washington, the very man who claims"},{"startTime":5920.633,"endTime":5922.666,"body":"that we shall bring science back to the"},{"startTime":5922.666,"endTime":5924.899,"body":"state of Washingtonians so"},{"startTime":5924.899,"endTime":5926.733,"body":"that they can be healthy again."},{"startTime":5927.399,"endTime":5930.666,"body":"Firing people who work entirely remotely"},{"startTime":5930.666,"endTime":5932.833,"body":"for not getting a shot that is not only"},{"startTime":5932.833,"endTime":5935.3,"body":"not effective, but actually dangerous is"},{"startTime":5935.3,"endTime":5938.033,"body":"not exactly a scientific approach, is it?"},{"startTime":5938.733,"endTime":5943.233,"body":"Even if those COVID vaccinations were"},{"startTime":5943.266,"endTime":5946.666,"body":"actually effective against a disease that"},{"startTime":5946.666,"endTime":5951.466,"body":"was actually more dangerous than it turns"},{"startTime":5951.466,"endTime":5953.199,"body":"out to have been, even if both of those"},{"startTime":5953.199,"endTime":5954.666,"body":"things had been true, which they are not."},{"startTime":5956.633,"endTime":5959.066,"body":"Forcing people who work entirely remotely"},{"startTime":5959.066,"endTime":5962.133,"body":"and have never yet and are never expected"},{"startTime":5962.133,"endTime":5965.166,"body":"to come into an office to get a vaccine"},{"startTime":5965.166,"endTime":5967.666,"body":"that they have a legitimate reason to"},{"startTime":5967.666,"endTime":5968.533,"body":"request an exemption"},{"startTime":5968.533,"endTime":5970.933,"body":"from is utterly insane."},{"startTime":5971.6,"endTime":5973.133,"body":"This man doesn't stand for science."},{"startTime":5973.533,"endTime":5975.333,"body":"He stands for authoritarianism."},{"startTime":5975.633,"endTime":5976.733,"body":"He stands for bullying."},{"startTime":5977.166,"endTime":5980.333,"body":"He stands for trust in experts for"},{"startTime":5980.333,"endTime":5983.566,"body":"deferring your own thought and analytics"},{"startTime":5983.566,"endTime":5986.833,"body":"and agency and autonomy over to other"},{"startTime":5986.833,"endTime":5988.166,"body":"people so that what?"},{"startTime":5988.166,"endTime":5989.1,"body":"So that he can get on with"},{"startTime":5989.1,"endTime":5990.266,"body":"whatever else he's doing."},{"startTime":5990.633,"endTime":5992.166,"body":"It has nothing to do with science."},{"startTime":5992.633,"endTime":5994.633,"body":"I see no evidence that anything he has"},{"startTime":5994.633,"endTime":5996.6,"body":"done has to do with science."},{"startTime":5996.6,"endTime":5999.6,"body":"And in general, I wouldn't go after an"},{"startTime":5999.6,"endTime":6003.066,"body":"attorney for not understanding science,"},{"startTime":6003.199,"endTime":6004.633,"body":"but he did this to himself."},{"startTime":6004.966,"endTime":6008.1,"body":"He's standing up and claiming that he's"},{"startTime":6008.1,"endTime":6010.033,"body":"going to be bringing science back to the"},{"startTime":6010.033,"endTime":6011.233,"body":"state of Washington and"},{"startTime":6011.233,"endTime":6012.433,"body":"he's completely full of crap."},{"startTime":6012.966,"endTime":6013.233,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":6015.066,"endTime":6018.6,"body":"Not only is his perspective completely"},{"startTime":6018.6,"endTime":6021.733,"body":"unscientific, but that particular piece"},{"startTime":6021.733,"endTime":6024.3,"body":"of tyranny is obviously a violation of"},{"startTime":6024.3,"endTime":6026.066,"body":"Nuremberg, even in the most narrow"},{"startTime":6026.066,"endTime":6028.166,"body":"interpretation, because what Nuremberg"},{"startTime":6028.166,"endTime":6030.366,"body":"says is that when you have an"},{"startTime":6030.366,"endTime":6033.8,"body":"experimental remedy, you have an absolute"},{"startTime":6033.8,"endTime":6036.566,"body":"right, A, to be fully informed, which we"},{"startTime":6036.566,"endTime":6039.033,"body":"were not, and B, to decide"},{"startTime":6039.033,"endTime":6040.633,"body":"whether or not to consent to it."},{"startTime":6040.633,"endTime":6041.566,"body":"The government cannot"},{"startTime":6041.566,"endTime":6042.566,"body":"force you to do this."},{"startTime":6043.233,"endTime":6045.166,"body":"And we hanged seven"},{"startTime":6045.166,"endTime":6046.633,"body":"doctors over these violations."},{"startTime":6047.033,"endTime":6050.366,"body":"So, you know, this is obviously a tyrant"},{"startTime":6050.366,"endTime":6052.3,"body":"who is pretending to be."},{"startTime":6052.3,"endTime":6053.6,"body":"Doesn't look like a tyrant, though."},{"startTime":6053.6,"endTime":6055.066,"body":"How could he possibly be a tyrant when he"},{"startTime":6055.066,"endTime":6056.199,"body":"looks so soft and doe?"},{"startTime":6057.066,"endTime":6057.566,"body":"He does."},{"startTime":6058.433,"endTime":6061.199,"body":"And of course, he's not his own tyrant."},{"startTime":6061.6,"endTime":6062.833,"body":"He is, of course, a"},{"startTime":6062.833,"endTime":6065.666,"body":"political animal like the guy."},{"startTime":6065.966,"endTime":6066.166,"body":"Like his predecessor."},{"startTime":6066.466,"endTime":6066.766,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":6067.533,"endTime":6071.1,"body":"An empty shirt spewing the propaganda as"},{"startTime":6071.1,"endTime":6074.533,"body":"if he feels this way passionately, where"},{"startTime":6074.533,"endTime":6075.766,"body":"the point is, no, his"},{"startTime":6075.766,"endTime":6077.066,"body":"team has decided to do this."},{"startTime":6077.533,"endTime":6077.766,"body":"Why?"},{"startTime":6078.066,"endTime":6080.199,"body":"Presumably we could chase it down to"},{"startTime":6080.199,"endTime":6082.866,"body":"large donations from people who stand to"},{"startTime":6082.866,"endTime":6085.133,"body":"lose hundreds of billions of dollars if"},{"startTime":6085.133,"endTime":6087.933,"body":"we decide to back off this insane"},{"startTime":6087.933,"endTime":6090.266,"body":"commitment to vaccinations that were"},{"startTime":6090.266,"endTime":6091.466,"body":"never tested for safety."},{"startTime":6091.833,"endTime":6093.533,"body":"Well, and it's properly tested."},{"startTime":6093.533,"endTime":6095.466,"body":"It's far easier to have a political"},{"startTime":6095.466,"endTime":6096.566,"body":"platform based on"},{"startTime":6096.566,"endTime":6098.133,"body":"contrarianism than on analysis."},{"startTime":6098.933,"endTime":6100.533,"body":"You know, if your entire position is"},{"startTime":6100.533,"endTime":6102.766,"body":"going to be, we reject what the other"},{"startTime":6102.766,"endTime":6105.266,"body":"side says, then you're going to impose"},{"startTime":6105.266,"endTime":6107.899,"body":"vaccine mandates in 2021 and you're going"},{"startTime":6107.899,"endTime":6110.699,"body":"to reject a reduction in the recommended"},{"startTime":6110.699,"endTime":6112.233,"body":"childhood vaccines that"},{"startTime":6112.233,"endTime":6114.266,"body":"the CDC is making in 2026."},{"startTime":6114.733,"endTime":6116.633,"body":"That's what you're going to do if you're"},{"startTime":6116.633,"endTime":6120.333,"body":"not responding with careful conscious"},{"startTime":6120.333,"endTime":6122.266,"body":"thought, but instead with, oh, they said"},{"startTime":6122.266,"endTime":6123.3,"body":"that, then we say this."},{"startTime":6124.0,"endTime":6127.233,"body":"It's the opposite of like human"},{"startTime":6127.233,"endTime":6129.133,"body":"conscious, thoughtful analysis."},{"startTime":6129.899,"endTime":6130.633,"body":"It's robotic."},{"startTime":6131.066,"endTime":6131.733,"body":"It's automatic."},{"startTime":6132.833,"endTime":6133.833,"body":"And it's dangerous."},{"startTime":6135.133,"endTime":6138.333,"body":"And, you know, we've seen it before."},{"startTime":6139.033,"endTime":6142.533,"body":"We've seen the cynicism in this before."},{"startTime":6142.533,"endTime":6144.366,"body":"I'm trying to remember Eric Topol"},{"startTime":6145.033,"endTime":6149.433,"body":"participated in delaying the vaccine"},{"startTime":6149.433,"endTime":6153.533,"body":"campaign so that it would not be deployed"},{"startTime":6153.533,"endTime":6158.033,"body":"under Trump and then advocated for, you"},{"startTime":6158.033,"endTime":6160.966,"body":"know, inflicting it on people because of"},{"startTime":6160.966,"endTime":6163.466,"body":"a false claim that it was somehow"},{"startTime":6163.533,"endTime":6165.833,"body":"essential to ending the pandemic."},{"startTime":6166.533,"endTime":6169.833,"body":"It's just, it's simply reactionary."},{"startTime":6170.133,"endTime":6171.466,"body":"And the fact is, you know, at the moment"},{"startTime":6171.466,"endTime":6174.866,"body":"we are having trouble convincing"},{"startTime":6174.866,"endTime":6178.466,"body":"President Trump of the extent of the"},{"startTime":6178.466,"endTime":6180.266,"body":"danger of the mRNA shots."},{"startTime":6181.433,"endTime":6181.633,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":6182.3,"endTime":6186.333,"body":"So when he changes his position, will"},{"startTime":6186.333,"endTime":6187.733,"body":"they then flip theirs?"},{"startTime":6187.733,"endTime":6190.133,"body":"Because the one thing they know is that"},{"startTime":6190.133,"endTime":6192.166,"body":"if Trump believes that they don't, like,"},{"startTime":6192.566,"endTime":6194.666,"body":"this has to be a process."},{"startTime":6195.133,"endTime":6197.766,"body":"No, but you just said we like the Maha"},{"startTime":6197.766,"endTime":6198.333,"body":"movement is having"},{"startTime":6198.333,"endTime":6199.466,"body":"trouble convincing him."},{"startTime":6199.733,"endTime":6199.933,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":6200.033,"endTime":6202.133,"body":"So at the moment, the blue team and Trump"},{"startTime":6202.133,"endTime":6202.866,"body":"are on the same side."},{"startTime":6203.566,"endTime":6205.699,"body":"So I think you won't like that."},{"startTime":6205.699,"endTime":6207.833,"body":"That flip, that's a rare"},{"startTime":6207.833,"endTime":6210.133,"body":"case of alignment in part."},{"startTime":6210.466,"endTime":6214.066,"body":"I mean, you know, the timing of COVID and"},{"startTime":6214.066,"endTime":6216.933,"body":"the release of the mRNA vaccines was as"},{"startTime":6216.933,"endTime":6220.066,"body":"we remember, and most people here will"},{"startTime":6220.066,"endTime":6222.433,"body":"remember, very strange indeed that you"},{"startTime":6222.433,"endTime":6228.3,"body":"had in October, November of 2020,"},{"startTime":6229.8,"endTime":6232.766,"body":"Kamala Harris, who was then running as"},{"startTime":6232.766,"endTime":6237.866,"body":"VP, arguing that if these vaccines got"},{"startTime":6237.866,"endTime":6240.333,"body":"accepted under Trump, that she would"},{"startTime":6240.333,"endTime":6241.233,"body":"certainly not take them."},{"startTime":6241.733,"endTime":6243.333,"body":"And then as soon as the Biden Harris"},{"startTime":6243.333,"endTime":6246.199,"body":"ticket took the White House,"},{"startTime":6247.366,"endTime":6249.1,"body":"then suddenly their Democrat"},{"startTime":6249.1,"endTime":6251.766,"body":"shots, which makes no sense."},{"startTime":6252.166,"endTime":6254.366,"body":"Like the shots are not political, you"},{"startTime":6254.366,"endTime":6255.466,"body":"know, the thing is the thing."},{"startTime":6256.3,"endTime":6259.333,"body":"But they did flip their position then,"},{"startTime":6259.333,"endTime":6261.733,"body":"based on who could"},{"startTime":6261.733,"endTime":6263.466,"body":"claim ownership of them."},{"startTime":6264.433,"endTime":6265.933,"body":"But they haven't, they somehow they"},{"startTime":6265.933,"endTime":6267.133,"body":"haven't managed to flip it back."},{"startTime":6267.866,"endTime":6268.833,"body":"And, you know, of course it's been"},{"startTime":6268.833,"endTime":6272.566,"body":"predicted for a long time that once we,"},{"startTime":6272.833,"endTime":6275.399,"body":"whatever, like collectively Maha, mRNA"},{"startTime":6275.399,"endTime":6278.266,"body":"skeptical, we managed to convince enough"},{"startTime":6278.266,"endTime":6281.866,"body":"people of the truth that that technology"},{"startTime":6281.866,"endTime":6284.266,"body":"is both not safe and not effective."},{"startTime":6285.066,"endTime":6287.433,"body":"At some point, you may find team blue"},{"startTime":6287.433,"endTime":6289.933,"body":"erasing history, revisioning history and"},{"startTime":6289.933,"endTime":6290.5,"body":"being like, yeah, but"},{"startTime":6290.5,"endTime":6291.566,"body":"that was a Trump thing."},{"startTime":6292.166,"endTime":6292.366,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":6292.566,"endTime":6294.466,"body":"But I, you know, the longer the longer"},{"startTime":6294.466,"endTime":6297.266,"body":"the time is that elapses between now and"},{"startTime":6297.266,"endTime":6298.366,"body":"then, I think the less likely they'll be"},{"startTime":6298.366,"endTime":6299.166,"body":"able to pull that off."},{"startTime":6299.666,"endTime":6301.0,"body":"Like who knows how this will be written."},{"startTime":6301.966,"endTime":6302.966,"body":"You know, we're still, it still feels"},{"startTime":6302.966,"endTime":6304.699,"body":"like a very active fight to those of us"},{"startTime":6304.699,"endTime":6307.166,"body":"who are trying to, you know, reduce the"},{"startTime":6307.166,"endTime":6308.666,"body":"childhood vaccine schedule for the safety"},{"startTime":6308.666,"endTime":6311.733,"body":"of American children and make sure that"},{"startTime":6311.733,"endTime":6313.233,"body":"new vaccines aren't"},{"startTime":6313.233,"endTime":6314.866,"body":"using the mRNA platform."},{"startTime":6315.666,"endTime":6318.666,"body":"But for many people who went along during"},{"startTime":6318.666,"endTime":6321.133,"body":"COVID, they already think this is, they"},{"startTime":6321.133,"endTime":6324.166,"body":"want it to be remote history that they"},{"startTime":6324.166,"endTime":6326.0,"body":"never have to think about again because"},{"startTime":6326.0,"endTime":6326.8,"body":"they don't want to look at"},{"startTime":6326.8,"endTime":6327.533,"body":"themselves in the mirror."},{"startTime":6327.966,"endTime":6329.666,"body":"And there, there is no reckoning."},{"startTime":6330.166,"endTime":6331.633,"body":"It felt like there had to be a reckoning"},{"startTime":6331.633,"endTime":6333.5,"body":"and there surely would be a reckoning and"},{"startTime":6333.5,"endTime":6334.266,"body":"there seems to be no"},{"startTime":6334.266,"endTime":6335.266,"body":"reckoning by and large."},{"startTime":6335.566,"endTime":6337.666,"body":"And you have freaking Governor Ferguson"},{"startTime":6337.666,"endTime":6339.3,"body":"standing up and pretending to be pro"},{"startTime":6339.3,"endTime":6342.533,"body":"science when he's, when he's a, a"},{"startTime":6342.533,"endTime":6345.399,"body":"scientist, no scientific guy."},{"startTime":6345.766,"endTime":6346.833,"body":"Yeah, not in the slightest."},{"startTime":6347.766,"endTime":6352.899,"body":"It feels to me like there's a trick that"},{"startTime":6352.899,"endTime":6354.3,"body":"has been played and I think it actually"},{"startTime":6354.3,"endTime":6355.3,"body":"goes back to your"},{"startTime":6355.3,"endTime":6358.666,"body":"point about the difference."},{"startTime":6359.133,"endTime":6362.466,"body":"If you've been a conservative, then"},{"startTime":6362.466,"endTime":6365.366,"body":"you've been forced to confront all sorts"},{"startTime":6365.366,"endTime":6367.8,"body":"of liberal arguments,"},{"startTime":6368.033,"endTime":6369.066,"body":"good, bad, and otherwise."},{"startTime":6369.5,"endTime":6369.699,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":6369.8,"endTime":6371.533,"body":"And so the point is you're sort of forced"},{"startTime":6371.533,"endTime":6375.0,"body":"to have a broader mindset because you"},{"startTime":6375.0,"endTime":6375.766,"body":"just don't have an"},{"startTime":6375.766,"endTime":6377.566,"body":"industrial strength mechanism for..."},{"startTime":6378.333,"endTime":6379.399,"body":"You're going to have to contend with your"},{"startTime":6379.399,"endTime":6380.399,"body":"own blind spots sometimes."},{"startTime":6381.0,"endTime":6381.166,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":6381.533,"endTime":6382.166,"body":"You're at least going to"},{"startTime":6382.166,"endTime":6383.433,"body":"have them pointed out to you."},{"startTime":6384.399,"endTime":6394.766,"body":"Well, I just wonder if the trick is not a"},{"startTime":6394.766,"endTime":6397.699,"body":"version of repulsion."},{"startTime":6399.3,"endTime":6404.666,"body":"If you're a blue team true believer and"},{"startTime":6404.666,"endTime":6407.833,"body":"it begins to dawn on you that something"},{"startTime":6407.833,"endTime":6408.8,"body":"that you're being told"},{"startTime":6408.8,"endTime":6410.466,"body":"doesn't actually add up,"},{"startTime":6411.533,"endTime":6415.266,"body":"then you immediately fast forward to what"},{"startTime":6415.266,"endTime":6418.0,"body":"happens if you confess your doubts and"},{"startTime":6418.0,"endTime":6420.366,"body":"you think, \"Oh, all of these people who"},{"startTime":6420.366,"endTime":6422.633,"body":"like me will instantly stop because"},{"startTime":6422.633,"endTime":6423.5,"body":"that's what they do.\""},{"startTime":6423.733,"endTime":6424.733,"body":"And then the question is,"},{"startTime":6424.733,"endTime":6427.333,"body":"\"Well, will anybody like me?\""},{"startTime":6427.333,"endTime":6427.566,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":6427.933,"endTime":6428.133,"body":"Who?"},{"startTime":6428.733,"endTime":6429.766,"body":"Those awful people."},{"startTime":6430.333,"endTime":6431.633,"body":"You don't want to be liked by them."},{"startTime":6431.933,"endTime":6433.466,"body":"That's what that basket"},{"startTime":6433.466,"endTime":6434.433,"body":"of deplorables..."},{"startTime":6434.433,"endTime":6435.666,"body":"They don't have nice cocktail parties."},{"startTime":6435.933,"endTime":6436.266,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":6436.5,"endTime":6438.166,"body":"They have evil cocktail parties."},{"startTime":6438.166,"endTime":6439.233,"body":"They have cocktail parties you'd be"},{"startTime":6439.233,"endTime":6440.266,"body":"embarrassed to go to."},{"startTime":6440.266,"endTime":6441.066,"body":"They cook outside."},{"startTime":6442.366,"endTime":6443.366,"body":"They do sometimes."},{"startTime":6443.866,"endTime":6446.566,"body":"But that idea that you've got a cartoon"},{"startTime":6446.566,"endTime":6448.6,"body":"of who's on the other side."},{"startTime":6448.6,"endTime":6448.8,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":6449.066,"endTime":6451.533,"body":"And so you can't even fathom, even if I"},{"startTime":6451.533,"endTime":6453.033,"body":"did believe that, what next?"},{"startTime":6453.366,"endTime":6455.733,"body":"But I mean, this reminds me very much of"},{"startTime":6455.733,"endTime":6458.033,"body":"what we went through in 2017 with"},{"startTime":6458.033,"endTime":6460.233,"body":"Evergreen, where you're called a racist"},{"startTime":6460.233,"endTime":6461.466,"body":"and then I'm called a racist."},{"startTime":6462.033,"endTime":6462.866,"body":"And there's a whole bunch of people"},{"startTime":6462.866,"endTime":6463.766,"body":"who've never met us before."},{"startTime":6463.766,"endTime":6464.233,"body":"It's like, \"Oh God,"},{"startTime":6464.233,"endTime":6465.1,"body":"they got called racist."},{"startTime":6465.1,"endTime":6465.666,"body":"They must be racist.\""},{"startTime":6466.8,"endTime":6469.066,"body":"And you and I doesn't take long to look"},{"startTime":6469.066,"endTime":6471.533,"body":"inside like, \"Yep, still not."},{"startTime":6471.933,"endTime":6472.233,"body":"Definitely not."},{"startTime":6472.766,"endTime":6473.133,"body":"Huh."},{"startTime":6473.133,"endTime":6473.466,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":6473.466,"endTime":6474.3,"body":"I know it's not true."},{"startTime":6474.966,"endTime":6475.199,"body":"Huh."},{"startTime":6475.666,"endTime":6476.233,"body":"Well, this is"},{"startTime":6476.233,"endTime":6477.166,"body":"interesting what I'm seeing.\""},{"startTime":6477.933,"endTime":6479.033,"body":"I got called this thing"},{"startTime":6479.033,"endTime":6480.3,"body":"that was patently not true."},{"startTime":6480.3,"endTime":6481.033,"body":"And in some cases, there"},{"startTime":6481.033,"endTime":6482.133,"body":"were people actively lying."},{"startTime":6482.133,"endTime":6483.433,"body":"And in some cases, there are just people"},{"startTime":6483.433,"endTime":6484.733,"body":"shaping it up and following"},{"startTime":6484.733,"endTime":6486.1,"body":"along and they're all wrong."},{"startTime":6487.0,"endTime":6488.833,"body":"And it didn't destroy me."},{"startTime":6489.566,"endTime":6489.933,"body":"Still standing."},{"startTime":6490.266,"endTime":6492.366,"body":"What a lot of interesting people are on"},{"startTime":6492.366,"endTime":6493.6,"body":"this side of the looking glass."},{"startTime":6493.6,"endTime":6494.766,"body":"And so that's what we started saying."},{"startTime":6494.766,"endTime":6496.766,"body":"Through the looking glass you go, when"},{"startTime":6496.766,"endTime":6499.233,"body":"you actually hold your own and say,"},{"startTime":6499.233,"endTime":6501.0,"body":"\"Well, I am still the same person I was."},{"startTime":6501.566,"endTime":6502.466,"body":"And some of what I"},{"startTime":6502.466,"endTime":6503.699,"body":"think I know may change."},{"startTime":6503.699,"endTime":6504.566,"body":"I hope that continues to"},{"startTime":6504.566,"endTime":6505.733,"body":"be true throughout my life."},{"startTime":6505.733,"endTime":6507.733,"body":"But at this moment, this thing where I"},{"startTime":6507.733,"endTime":6508.233,"body":"went through the looking"},{"startTime":6508.233,"endTime":6509.866,"body":"glass, nothing changed about me.\""},{"startTime":6510.333,"endTime":6512.899,"body":"It was my understanding of how the rest"},{"startTime":6512.899,"endTime":6514.733,"body":"of you are making decisions and who you"},{"startTime":6514.733,"endTime":6515.8,"body":"decide your friends are."},{"startTime":6516.133,"endTime":6517.966,"body":"And if that's how you decide who your"},{"startTime":6517.966,"endTime":6520.5,"body":"friends are, and you're going to pick"},{"startTime":6520.5,"endTime":6523.033,"body":"based on who's in power right now, I"},{"startTime":6523.033,"endTime":6524.266,"body":"don't want you as my friends."},{"startTime":6525.133,"endTime":6528.833,"body":"If you're only choosing teams based on"},{"startTime":6528.833,"endTime":6529.966,"body":"power, you are"},{"startTime":6529.966,"endTime":6532.1,"body":"dangerous and shallow, both."},{"startTime":6533.166,"endTime":6536.766,"body":"And unfortunately, that's a lot of who we"},{"startTime":6536.766,"endTime":6537.866,"body":"are all contending with,"},{"startTime":6537.866,"endTime":6538.933,"body":"the dangerous and the shallow."},{"startTime":6539.966,"endTime":6543.533,"body":"But I guess to those who are still in the"},{"startTime":6543.533,"endTime":6546.533,"body":"shadows, who are questioning the dominant"},{"startTime":6546.533,"endTime":6548.133,"body":"paradigm, who are looking at Ferguson,"},{"startTime":6549.033,"endTime":6550.633,"body":"talking about science as if he knows"},{"startTime":6550.633,"endTime":6552.233,"body":"anything, going, \"God, I don't think that"},{"startTime":6552.233,"endTime":6553.1,"body":"guy knows anything.\""},{"startTime":6553.1,"endTime":6555.466,"body":"And gosh, it does seem like getting our"},{"startTime":6555.466,"endTime":6557.066,"body":"childhood vaccine schedule more aligned"},{"startTime":6557.066,"endTime":6558.633,"body":"with, say, that of Western Europe might"},{"startTime":6558.633,"endTime":6559.533,"body":"make sense because their"},{"startTime":6559.533,"endTime":6560.566,"body":"kids appear to be healthier."},{"startTime":6561.033,"endTime":6561.866,"body":"What is he on about?"},{"startTime":6563.166,"endTime":6565.633,"body":"I guess I and I think we are here to tell"},{"startTime":6565.633,"endTime":6567.766,"body":"you that when you do stand up, yeah, you"},{"startTime":6567.766,"endTime":6569.766,"body":"take a lot of crap, for sure."},{"startTime":6570.166,"endTime":6571.366,"body":"But when you go through that looking"},{"startTime":6571.366,"endTime":6575.266,"body":"glass, there is a relief and a release of"},{"startTime":6575.266,"endTime":6577.266,"body":"tension around all the"},{"startTime":6577.266,"endTime":6578.699,"body":"things that you were not saying."},{"startTime":6578.933,"endTime":6580.966,"body":"And you start to find the people who are"},{"startTime":6580.966,"endTime":6583.866,"body":"actually honest brokers about their own"},{"startTime":6583.866,"endTime":6586.633,"body":"values and commitments to the world, as"},{"startTime":6586.633,"endTime":6589.5,"body":"opposed to people who are simply making"},{"startTime":6589.5,"endTime":6591.566,"body":"sure that everyone sounds the same."},{"startTime":6591.933,"endTime":6595.366,"body":"Because that appearance of"},{"startTime":6595.366,"endTime":6597.333,"body":"homogeneity is just that."},{"startTime":6597.333,"endTime":6598.066,"body":"It is an appearance."},{"startTime":6598.333,"endTime":6600.433,"body":"And there's plenty of people who believe"},{"startTime":6600.433,"endTime":6603.199,"body":"the way Ferguson is telling us we all"},{"startTime":6603.199,"endTime":6605.3,"body":"need to believe, but there are many more"},{"startTime":6605.3,"endTime":6607.066,"body":"than it appears who don't."},{"startTime":6607.966,"endTime":6609.633,"body":"And going through the looking glass and"},{"startTime":6609.633,"endTime":6611.199,"body":"realizing that it doesn't kill you, it"},{"startTime":6611.199,"endTime":6612.733,"body":"actually frees you and makes you"},{"startTime":6612.733,"endTime":6615.033,"body":"stronger, and a more joyous and"},{"startTime":6615.033,"endTime":6617.733,"body":"purposeful person is incredibly"},{"startTime":6617.733,"endTime":6619.666,"body":"fantastic, and I recommend it."},{"startTime":6621.266,"endTime":6621.866,"body":"Two things."},{"startTime":6622.899,"endTime":6624.399,"body":"First, I want to just"},{"startTime":6624.399,"endTime":6625.766,"body":"correct that story a little bit."},{"startTime":6625.766,"endTime":6630.433,"body":"The way you've told it, we didn't know"},{"startTime":6630.433,"endTime":6631.8,"body":"who the others were."},{"startTime":6631.8,"endTime":6633.3,"body":"And the fact is, you and I have been good"},{"startTime":6633.3,"endTime":6635.933,"body":"about making common cause with religious"},{"startTime":6635.933,"endTime":6636.899,"body":"people and conservative"},{"startTime":6636.899,"endTime":6638.066,"body":"people."},{"startTime":6638.066,"endTime":6641.833,"body":"You represented that when we got called"},{"startTime":6641.833,"endTime":6643.833,"body":"racist, we discovered that the other"},{"startTime":6643.833,"endTime":6644.733,"body":"people weren't crazy."},{"startTime":6645.333,"endTime":6646.733,"body":"No, I certainly didn't"},{"startTime":6646.733,"endTime":6647.933,"body":"mean to say that at all."},{"startTime":6647.933,"endTime":6651.566,"body":"It was that people became, these are the"},{"startTime":6651.566,"endTime":6653.466,"body":"people who became friends and community,"},{"startTime":6654.233,"endTime":6656.933,"body":"whereas we had not been in"},{"startTime":6656.933,"endTime":6658.333,"body":"the midst of them before."},{"startTime":6658.933,"endTime":6662.166,"body":"Well, it certainly kicked into high gear"},{"startTime":6662.166,"endTime":6666.066,"body":"at that point, but lots of people weren't"},{"startTime":6666.066,"endTime":6668.833,"body":"willing to interact with conservatives or"},{"startTime":6668.833,"endTime":6670.0,"body":"religious folks or whatever."},{"startTime":6670.0,"endTime":6671.0,"body":"And that wasn't us."},{"startTime":6671.0,"endTime":6671.433,"body":"Of course not."},{"startTime":6671.666,"endTime":6674.566,"body":"So anyway, I just wanted to fix that."},{"startTime":6674.566,"endTime":6678.133,"body":"And now my other point had to do with..."},{"startTime":6678.433,"endTime":6679.766,"body":"Looks like propaganda, maybe."},{"startTime":6680.0,"endTime":6681.633,"body":"No, it didn't."},{"startTime":6681.633,"endTime":6682.3,"body":"That was an earlier point."},{"startTime":6683.199,"endTime":6685.166,"body":"I'm trying to remember, it had to do with"},{"startTime":6685.166,"endTime":6688.6,"body":"Ferguson and his particular brand of"},{"startTime":6688.6,"endTime":6689.3,"body":"scientism, but I've"},{"startTime":6689.3,"endTime":6690.033,"body":"lost it for the moment."},{"startTime":6690.966,"endTime":6694.266,"body":"Well, he does like to sound important and"},{"startTime":6694.266,"endTime":6695.266,"body":"science sounds important."},{"startTime":6695.733,"endTime":6697.6,"body":"And so it's not that surprising that he"},{"startTime":6697.6,"endTime":6701.066,"body":"would use science as a weapon with which"},{"startTime":6701.066,"endTime":6702.333,"body":"to sound important, but"},{"startTime":6702.333,"endTime":6708.066,"body":"it's a real shame and it's bad."},{"startTime":6708.066,"endTime":6710.5,"body":"It's very bad for actual science."},{"startTime":6711.1,"endTime":6712.933,"body":"And for what those of us who are trying"},{"startTime":6712.933,"endTime":6714.533,"body":"to make sense of the world scientifically"},{"startTime":6714.533,"endTime":6717.266,"body":"are trying to do, because there are a lot"},{"startTime":6717.266,"endTime":6720.166,"body":"of otherwise smart people who are seeing"},{"startTime":6720.166,"endTime":6722.466,"body":"this kind of garbage, mostly people on"},{"startTime":6722.466,"endTime":6723.833,"body":"the right and who are"},{"startTime":6723.833,"endTime":6725.466,"body":"concluding, \"Okay, that's it."},{"startTime":6725.466,"endTime":6726.266,"body":"No science for me."},{"startTime":6726.266,"endTime":6726.666,"body":"Thank you.\""},{"startTime":6727.466,"endTime":6728.966,"body":"And in that way, who wins?"},{"startTime":6729.533,"endTime":6730.333,"body":"No one wins."},{"startTime":6730.566,"endTime":6732.633,"body":"We all lose when people turn away from"},{"startTime":6732.633,"endTime":6734.133,"body":"science because it's being wielded by"},{"startTime":6734.133,"endTime":6735.366,"body":"people who don't know what it is."},{"startTime":6735.633,"endTime":6738.266,"body":"So I remember what my point was, which is"},{"startTime":6738.266,"endTime":6740.633,"body":"that somebody should pose to him"},{"startTime":6740.633,"endTime":6744.0,"body":"immediately after he goes on this tirade,"},{"startTime":6744.366,"endTime":6746.366,"body":"ostensibly defending science, when in"},{"startTime":6746.366,"endTime":6748.366,"body":"fact he is defending scientism."},{"startTime":6750.133,"endTime":6752.033,"body":"This science you speak of, does it"},{"startTime":6752.033,"endTime":6753.266,"body":"recommend the COVID"},{"startTime":6753.266,"endTime":6754.766,"body":"shots for healthy people?"},{"startTime":6756.466,"endTime":6757.366,"body":"Now he's going to"},{"startTime":6757.366,"endTime":6758.033,"body":"say- Well, he obviously does."},{"startTime":6758.266,"endTime":6760.133,"body":"I mean, that's why I bring up his history"},{"startTime":6760.133,"endTime":6761.633,"body":"as attorney general."},{"startTime":6761.633,"endTime":6761.933,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":6761.933,"endTime":6762.633,"body":"But he could have changed"},{"startTime":6762.633,"endTime":6763.933,"body":"his mind, but he hasn't."},{"startTime":6764.633,"endTime":6764.866,"body":"Why?"},{"startTime":6764.866,"endTime":6765.833,"body":"Because the official recommendations"},{"startTime":6766.166,"endTime":6768.866,"body":"still are in favor of these shots and"},{"startTime":6768.866,"endTime":6771.166,"body":"have not made eye contact with the"},{"startTime":6771.166,"endTime":6772.533,"body":"absolute horror show"},{"startTime":6772.633,"endTime":6773.899,"body":"that they actually are."},{"startTime":6773.899,"endTime":6775.833,"body":"And the fact that since they don't block"},{"startTime":6775.833,"endTime":6777.133,"body":"transmission, there was never any"},{"startTime":6777.133,"endTime":6778.866,"body":"justification for forcing"},{"startTime":6778.866,"endTime":6780.0,"body":"these things on anybody."},{"startTime":6780.8,"endTime":6782.666,"body":"And certainly there was never any"},{"startTime":6782.666,"endTime":6784.466,"body":"argument for healthy people."},{"startTime":6784.766,"endTime":6786.733,"body":"And in light of what they actually do to"},{"startTime":6786.733,"endTime":6787.966,"body":"your physiology, there's a strong"},{"startTime":6787.966,"endTime":6789.366,"body":"argument against them for everybody."},{"startTime":6789.633,"endTime":6795.133,"body":"But point is, in 2026, you"},{"startTime":6795.133,"endTime":6796.233,"body":"are a champion of science."},{"startTime":6796.833,"endTime":6799.966,"body":"You are trying to put those vaccines on a"},{"startTime":6799.966,"endTime":6802.399,"body":"Washington schedule that are being taken"},{"startTime":6802.399,"endTime":6804.833,"body":"off the schedule by the CDC because of"},{"startTime":6804.833,"endTime":6805.899,"body":"your commitment to science."},{"startTime":6806.533,"endTime":6806.933,"body":"Hey, Bob,"},{"startTime":6808.3,"endTime":6809.766,"body":"tell me about the COVID shots."},{"startTime":6810.033,"endTime":6812.266,"body":"You want those for people as well?"},{"startTime":6812.466,"endTime":6813.366,"body":"Or are you willing to"},{"startTime":6813.366,"endTime":6814.8,"body":"admit that that was a mistake?"},{"startTime":6814.8,"endTime":6815.466,"body":"And the answer is you"},{"startTime":6815.466,"endTime":6816.666,"body":"will admit no such mistake."},{"startTime":6817.266,"endTime":6820.166,"body":"And failing to admit that almost anybody,"},{"startTime":6820.166,"endTime":6821.899,"body":"since nobody's taking these COVID shots,"},{"startTime":6821.899,"endTime":6822.8,"body":"since everybody's figured out how"},{"startTime":6822.8,"endTime":6825.666,"body":"dangerous they are, most people are not"},{"startTime":6825.666,"endTime":6827.3,"body":"admitting to themselves that that's why"},{"startTime":6827.3,"endTime":6828.633,"body":"they're not taking the shots."},{"startTime":6829.233,"endTime":6831.166,"body":"But the shots have extremely low"},{"startTime":6831.166,"endTime":6832.666,"body":"penetrance at the moment, even though"},{"startTime":6832.666,"endTime":6833.766,"body":"COVID is still circulating."},{"startTime":6834.333,"endTime":6837.6,"body":"So in light of that, your average person"},{"startTime":6837.6,"endTime":6841.033,"body":"walking around not getting COVID shots is"},{"startTime":6841.033,"endTime":6842.566,"body":"aware there's a problem with them."},{"startTime":6843.066,"endTime":6844.433,"body":"Will Bob Ferguson admit it?"},{"startTime":6844.433,"endTime":6845.066,"body":"He will not."},{"startTime":6845.5,"endTime":6847.166,"body":"What does that tell you about his"},{"startTime":6847.166,"endTime":6849.0,"body":"proclamations about science?"},{"startTime":6849.0,"endTime":6850.633,"body":"It tells you that they're garbage."},{"startTime":6850.633,"endTime":6851.333,"body":"They're just something."},{"startTime":6851.8,"endTime":6853.8,"body":"They're a posture, a political posture."},{"startTime":6853.8,"endTime":6855.733,"body":"They tell you nothing about what he would"},{"startTime":6855.733,"endTime":6858.066,"body":"do, you know, for his own children."},{"startTime":6858.066,"endTime":6861.033,"body":"If they were being offered these shots,"},{"startTime":6861.566,"endTime":6862.666,"body":"they don't tell you a thing."},{"startTime":6863.199,"endTime":6863.966,"body":"So anyway,"},{"startTime":6866.066,"endTime":6871.266,"body":"one of the small, bright points about"},{"startTime":6871.266,"endTime":6873.833,"body":"politics in the state of Washington is"},{"startTime":6873.833,"endTime":6875.733,"body":"that our stuffed"},{"startTime":6875.733,"endTime":6879.166,"body":"shirts are not compelling,"},{"startTime":6880.399,"endTime":6880.6,"body":"right?"},{"startTime":6881.066,"endTime":6882.733,"body":"You can look right through."},{"startTime":6882.733,"endTime":6883.399,"body":"They're not charismatic."},{"startTime":6883.666,"endTime":6885.233,"body":"They're paper thin, right?"},{"startTime":6885.966,"endTime":6888.699,"body":"And so in light of that, we are, you"},{"startTime":6888.699,"endTime":6890.633,"body":"know, on the one hand, that says bad"},{"startTime":6890.633,"endTime":6892.5,"body":"things about the population of the state"},{"startTime":6892.5,"endTime":6894.233,"body":"that we will elect these empty shirts."},{"startTime":6894.833,"endTime":6898.466,"body":"On the other hand, it is nice that"},{"startTime":6898.466,"endTime":6900.933,"body":"they're not like super"},{"startTime":6900.933,"endTime":6902.533,"body":"geniuses and rhetorical."},{"startTime":6903.433,"endTime":6906.899,"body":"Or even just Kevin Newsom, who I've never"},{"startTime":6906.899,"endTime":6909.5,"body":"been compelled by, did strike a figure."},{"startTime":6909.766,"endTime":6910.0,"body":"Oh, yeah."},{"startTime":6910.166,"endTime":6913.033,"body":"Like he was charismatic in"},{"startTime":6913.033,"endTime":6914.366,"body":"a sort of a way for a while."},{"startTime":6914.366,"endTime":6915.633,"body":"I mean, I think even most Californians"},{"startTime":6915.633,"endTime":6916.399,"body":"now are like, what the"},{"startTime":6916.399,"endTime":6917.3,"body":"hell is up with this guy?"},{"startTime":6918.033,"endTime":6922.8,"body":"But he's harder to immediately dismiss"},{"startTime":6923.366,"endTime":6924.433,"body":"because he has"},{"startTime":6924.433,"endTime":6926.199,"body":"rhetorical skills and charisma."},{"startTime":6926.766,"endTime":6926.966,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":6927.066,"endTime":6930.199,"body":"He is skilled and he is smart and he is"},{"startTime":6930.199,"endTime":6933.333,"body":"therefore much more dangerous than these"},{"startTime":6933.333,"endTime":6935.966,"body":"herbivorous know-nothings that we elect"},{"startTime":6935.966,"endTime":6938.066,"body":"up here in the damper"},{"startTime":6938.066,"endTime":6939.166,"body":"parts of the West Coast."},{"startTime":6941.533,"endTime":6943.233,"body":"I mean, seriously, the degree to which"},{"startTime":6943.233,"endTime":6945.633,"body":"Ferguson doesn't look."},{"startTime":6945.633,"endTime":6946.6,"body":"So you think maybe if we just take him"},{"startTime":6946.6,"endTime":6947.466,"body":"out to a state house,"},{"startTime":6947.466,"endTime":6948.066,"body":"things will improve?"},{"startTime":6948.866,"endTime":6949.433,"body":"They might."},{"startTime":6949.433,"endTime":6950.399,"body":"He might have a deficiency."},{"startTime":6950.766,"endTime":6953.699,"body":"It's not beyond the realm of possibility."},{"startTime":6954.166,"endTime":6957.233,"body":"But just the degree to which my reaction"},{"startTime":6957.233,"endTime":6958.6,"body":"seeing this guy, and I haven't spent a"},{"startTime":6958.6,"endTime":6961.533,"body":"lot of time hearing him or looking at"},{"startTime":6961.533,"endTime":6965.333,"body":"him, but it's like, okay, I knew Inslee."},{"startTime":6965.333,"endTime":6966.466,"body":"I even met Inslee once."},{"startTime":6966.766,"endTime":6966.966,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":6967.333,"endTime":6969.8,"body":"And my thought was, that is"},{"startTime":6969.8,"endTime":6971.333,"body":"nothing but a stuffed shirt."},{"startTime":6971.533,"endTime":6974.366,"body":"There's not like a human being in there."},{"startTime":6974.366,"endTime":6976.866,"body":"This is a person, there's a scriptwriter."},{"startTime":6976.866,"endTime":6979.1,"body":"He might as well be a robot."},{"startTime":6979.8,"endTime":6980.0,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":6980.933,"endTime":6982.566,"body":"We found another one."},{"startTime":6982.833,"endTime":6983.066,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":6983.066,"endTime":6985.066,"body":"Like, that's not that easy to do to find"},{"startTime":6985.066,"endTime":6986.566,"body":"somebody who has no convictions"},{"startTime":6986.566,"endTime":6990.066,"body":"whatsoever and can read the script"},{"startTime":6990.066,"endTime":6992.433,"body":"without stumbling, but mean nothing."},{"startTime":6992.433,"endTime":6992.933,"body":"Probably doesn't even"},{"startTime":6992.933,"endTime":6993.733,"body":"know what he just read."},{"startTime":6994.133,"endTime":6995.699,"body":"He just knows that that's his job to"},{"startTime":6995.699,"endTime":6997.733,"body":"deliver it as if he thinks it's true."},{"startTime":6998.633,"endTime":6999.733,"body":"And it's interesting"},{"startTime":6999.766,"endTime":7000.633,"body":"that we found another."},{"startTime":7001.533,"endTime":7001.933,"body":"It is."},{"startTime":7004.399,"endTime":7004.6,"body":"Meanwhile,"},{"startTime":7005.733,"endTime":7008.166,"body":"also in the state of Washington, also"},{"startTime":7008.166,"endTime":7009.333,"body":"among elected officials,"},{"startTime":7010.366,"endTime":7015.233,"body":"we have the majority leader in the state"},{"startTime":7015.233,"endTime":7017.766,"body":"Senate, a guy named Jamie Peterson,"},{"startTime":7019.066,"endTime":7022.233,"body":"who was responding to, well, let's, you"},{"startTime":7022.233,"endTime":7023.533,"body":"have this video to pull up."},{"startTime":7023.766,"endTime":7025.466,"body":"Let's check this guy out."},{"startTime":7025.466,"endTime":7027.199,"body":"This is out of Seattle"},{"startTime":7027.199,"endTime":7032.166,"body":"being asked about men and women."},{"startTime":7032.733,"endTime":7033.633,"body":"Men and women."},{"startTime":7033.633,"endTime":7033.833,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":7034.033,"endTime":7034.399,"body":"Men and women."},{"startTime":7034.399,"endTime":7035.766,"body":"As if those were two different things."},{"startTime":7036.233,"endTime":7037.899,"body":"Well, yes, precisely."},{"startTime":7039.166,"endTime":7040.0,"body":"Senator Peterson, you said at the"},{"startTime":7040.0,"endTime":7041.666,"body":"beginning that one of the key priorities"},{"startTime":7041.666,"endTime":7043.933,"body":"for Senate Democrats would be to make"},{"startTime":7043.933,"endTime":7045.633,"body":"sure science is respected."},{"startTime":7046.566,"endTime":7048.466,"body":"Can you acknowledge that there are"},{"startTime":7048.466,"endTime":7051.766,"body":"biological differences between men and"},{"startTime":7051.766,"endTime":7054.833,"body":"women that would give boys a physical"},{"startTime":7054.833,"endTime":7057.166,"body":"advantage over girls in athletics?"},{"startTime":7060.266,"endTime":7060.633,"body":"No,"},{"startTime":7062.366,"endTime":7063.066,"body":"I don't think I could"},{"startTime":7063.066,"endTime":7064.166,"body":"say that definitively."},{"startTime":7064.533,"endTime":7067.266,"body":"First of all, I'm not that I don't have"},{"startTime":7067.266,"endTime":7068.733,"body":"the scientific expertise to"},{"startTime":7068.733,"endTime":7070.066,"body":"be able to weigh in on that."},{"startTime":7070.066,"endTime":7072.633,"body":"Based on what I know,"},{"startTime":7074.066,"endTime":7077.399,"body":"a lot of many of the kids who participate"},{"startTime":7077.399,"endTime":7080.8,"body":"in athletics, who are transgender, are"},{"startTime":7080.8,"endTime":7083.366,"body":"taking puberty blockers, are taking"},{"startTime":7083.366,"endTime":7086.566,"body":"hormones that probably change the"},{"startTime":7086.566,"endTime":7090.199,"body":"scientific balance about competitiveness."},{"startTime":7090.733,"endTime":7094.366,"body":"So I don't have the tools or the training"},{"startTime":7094.366,"endTime":7096.366,"body":"to be able to weigh in and offer a"},{"startTime":7096.366,"endTime":7098.066,"body":"scientific conclusion about that."},{"startTime":7098.466,"endTime":7101.733,"body":"But I think that there is some reason to"},{"startTime":7101.733,"endTime":7103.3,"body":"be skeptical of that claim."},{"startTime":7103.933,"endTime":7104.266,"body":"Thank you."},{"startTime":7104.466,"endTime":7105.199,"body":"Would you be willing to"},{"startTime":7105.199,"endTime":7106.233,"body":"make that a requirement?"},{"startTime":7106.566,"endTime":7107.533,"body":"We need to move on."},{"startTime":7107.533,"endTime":7108.6,"body":"Sorry, we need to move on."},{"startTime":7108.966,"endTime":7109.166,"body":"Bill?"},{"startTime":7111.0,"endTime":7112.366,"body":"I'm just going to repeat what he said"},{"startTime":7112.366,"endTime":7114.166,"body":"because I transcribed it."},{"startTime":7114.766,"endTime":7117.5,"body":"This is Jimmy Peterson, state senator out"},{"startTime":7117.5,"endTime":7119.933,"body":"of Seattle, majority leader, Democrat,"},{"startTime":7120.433,"endTime":7121.066,"body":"state of Washington."},{"startTime":7122.399,"endTime":7123.666,"body":"Quote, \"Many of the kids who participate"},{"startTime":7123.666,"endTime":7125.633,"body":"in athletics who are transgender are"},{"startTime":7125.633,"endTime":7127.066,"body":"taking puberty blockers, are taking"},{"startTime":7127.066,"endTime":7128.633,"body":"hormones that probably change the"},{"startTime":7128.633,"endTime":7130.366,"body":"scientific balance about competitiveness."},{"startTime":7130.666,"endTime":7132.766,"body":"So I don't have the tools or the training"},{"startTime":7132.766,"endTime":7134.533,"body":"to be able to weigh in and offer a"},{"startTime":7134.533,"endTime":7136.466,"body":"scientific conclusion about that.\""},{"startTime":7137.566,"endTime":7139.866,"body":"That's an amazing evasion."},{"startTime":7142.366,"endTime":7149.266,"body":"At some level, I just wanted to present"},{"startTime":7149.266,"endTime":7151.233,"body":"that and it is what it is."},{"startTime":7154.733,"endTime":7157.333,"body":"What era are we living in?"},{"startTime":7158.466,"endTime":7163.066,"body":"You could argue that what Ferguson is"},{"startTime":7163.066,"endTime":7165.433,"body":"responding to in the previous story that"},{"startTime":7165.433,"endTime":7169.366,"body":"we were talking about is vaguely nuanced."},{"startTime":7170.733,"endTime":7175.033,"body":"How did we get to a childhood vaccine"},{"startTime":7175.033,"endTime":7178.066,"body":"schedule that was so full if not because"},{"startTime":7178.066,"endTime":7179.699,"body":"there was evidence to support it?"},{"startTime":7179.699,"endTime":7181.366,"body":"We know this isn't true, but how did we"},{"startTime":7181.366,"endTime":7182.433,"body":"get there if there"},{"startTime":7182.433,"endTime":7183.633,"body":"wasn't evidence to support it?"},{"startTime":7184.266,"endTime":7187.433,"body":"So diminishing it could be seen as a move"},{"startTime":7187.433,"endTime":7188.666,"body":"in the wrong direction."},{"startTime":7189.333,"endTime":7190.866,"body":"None of that is true, but there's at"},{"startTime":7190.866,"endTime":7192.933,"body":"least a few little logical steps that you"},{"startTime":7192.933,"endTime":7194.033,"body":"need to keep in your head"},{"startTime":7194.033,"endTime":7196.133,"body":"at a time to understand why."},{"startTime":7197.399,"endTime":7199.766,"body":"Putting our childhood vaccine schedule in"},{"startTime":7199.766,"endTime":7202.266,"body":"greater alignment with that of healthier,"},{"startTime":7202.399,"endTime":7205.166,"body":"weird nations of Western Europe is a good"},{"startTime":7205.166,"endTime":7206.566,"body":"move for the health of our children."},{"startTime":7209.0,"endTime":7212.899,"body":"I never would have predicted when we met"},{"startTime":7212.899,"endTime":7216.766,"body":"in 1985 or when we were in grad school in"},{"startTime":7216.766,"endTime":7218.666,"body":"1995 or when we were teaching at"},{"startTime":7218.666,"endTime":7221.266,"body":"Evergreen in 2005 or 2015"},{"startTime":7221.266,"endTime":7224.966,"body":"that we could have arrived here."},{"startTime":7226.133,"endTime":7229.033,"body":"That the same people who were talking"},{"startTime":7229.033,"endTime":7232.733,"body":"about needing to rely more on science"},{"startTime":7232.733,"endTime":7237.233,"body":"then defer to the expertise of"},{"startTime":7239.199,"endTime":7243.733,"body":"off-camera experts to decide whether or"},{"startTime":7243.733,"endTime":7245.433,"body":"not males and females"},{"startTime":7245.433,"endTime":7247.566,"body":"are in fact different."},{"startTime":7248.433,"endTime":7250.533,"body":"And possibly, again,"},{"startTime":7252.133,"endTime":7253.6,"body":"many of the kids who participate in"},{"startTime":7253.6,"endTime":7255.399,"body":"athletics who are transgender, he says,"},{"startTime":7255.399,"endTime":7256.766,"body":"are taking purity blockers or taking"},{"startTime":7256.766,"endTime":7258.566,"body":"hormones that probably change the"},{"startTime":7258.566,"endTime":7260.933,"body":"scientific balance about competitiveness."},{"startTime":7262.333,"endTime":7266.566,"body":"It doesn't change the underlying truth."},{"startTime":7267.933,"endTime":7269.933,"body":"If you take testosterone as a"},{"startTime":7269.933,"endTime":7271.199,"body":"woman, you can get stronger."},{"startTime":7272.3,"endTime":7274.266,"body":"If you take estrogens"},{"startTime":7274.266,"endTime":7276.733,"body":"and progesterone as a man,"},{"startTime":7277.766,"endTime":7279.899,"body":"you will likely get somewhat weaker."},{"startTime":7280.666,"endTime":7283.533,"body":"But the developmental and"},{"startTime":7283.533,"endTime":7285.966,"body":"endocrinological environment in which you"},{"startTime":7285.966,"endTime":7289.366,"body":"come of age at puberty and through"},{"startTime":7289.366,"endTime":7292.033,"body":"puberty defines what your skeleton looks"},{"startTime":7292.033,"endTime":7295.866,"body":"like, how your muscles are arranged, what"},{"startTime":7295.866,"endTime":7298.0,"body":"kinds of muscles you have, and you cannot"},{"startTime":7298.0,"endTime":7301.833,"body":"undo that with insane, dangerous,"},{"startTime":7302.166,"endTime":7303.766,"body":"disruptive, puberty"},{"startTime":7303.766,"endTime":7305.266,"body":"blockers and cross-sex hormones."},{"startTime":7307.033,"endTime":7308.933,"body":"You can mess with yourself for sure."},{"startTime":7309.5,"endTime":7311.366,"body":"You can make yourself less of what you"},{"startTime":7311.366,"endTime":7312.733,"body":"could have been, be"},{"startTime":7312.733,"endTime":7314.333,"body":"that a man or a woman."},{"startTime":7314.333,"endTime":7316.533,"body":"You can make yourself less of a man and"},{"startTime":7316.533,"endTime":7318.033,"body":"you can make yourself less of a woman,"},{"startTime":7318.033,"endTime":7319.866,"body":"but that doesn't mean that you have"},{"startTime":7319.866,"endTime":7321.366,"body":"equalized and made"},{"startTime":7321.366,"endTime":7323.133,"body":"yourself the other thing."},{"startTime":7323.133,"endTime":7324.166,"body":"It's not possible."},{"startTime":7324.166,"endTime":7325.1,"body":"We can't do that."},{"startTime":7325.1,"endTime":7325.833,"body":"We are mammals."},{"startTime":7325.833,"endTime":7327.333,"body":"There is no sex change in mammals."},{"startTime":7327.366,"endTime":7328.133,"body":"End of story."},{"startTime":7328.466,"endTime":7328.933,"body":"Cannot happen."},{"startTime":7329.366,"endTime":7329.566,"body":"No."},{"startTime":7330.699,"endTime":7334.233,"body":"So you said that the"},{"startTime":7335.266,"endTime":7336.033,"body":"the governor and the"},{"startTime":7336.033,"endTime":7337.699,"body":"vaccine story is more nuanced."},{"startTime":7338.366,"endTime":7338.866,"body":"Well,"},{"startTime":7339.966,"endTime":7341.8,"body":"I don't think it's nuanced, but I do"},{"startTime":7341.8,"endTime":7342.6,"body":"think it's something."},{"startTime":7342.966,"endTime":7344.0,"body":"It takes a little bit of..."},{"startTime":7344.266,"endTime":7347.333,"body":"It takes a lot, actually, for one reason,"},{"startTime":7347.833,"endTime":7350.033,"body":"which is, and I've been struggling for a"},{"startTime":7350.033,"endTime":7353.866,"body":"way to say this, such that it lands and"},{"startTime":7353.866,"endTime":7355.733,"body":"carries the proper connotations."},{"startTime":7356.066,"endTime":7360.366,"body":"But the thing that caused you and me not"},{"startTime":7360.366,"endTime":7363.333,"body":"to understand the hazard that our"},{"startTime":7363.333,"endTime":7365.033,"body":"children were exposed to as we went to"},{"startTime":7365.033,"endTime":7366.666,"body":"the wellness visits and got the vaccines"},{"startTime":7366.666,"endTime":7371.166,"body":"for them was that what turns out to be"},{"startTime":7371.166,"endTime":7376.433,"body":"true is impossible in the world that we"},{"startTime":7376.433,"endTime":7377.466,"body":"thought we lived in."},{"startTime":7378.066,"endTime":7380.633,"body":"If the systems that we understood these"},{"startTime":7380.633,"endTime":7382.8,"body":"vaccines to have been created in and"},{"startTime":7382.8,"endTime":7385.666,"body":"accepted by were at all functional, they"},{"startTime":7385.666,"endTime":7386.933,"body":"wouldn't be on the schedule."},{"startTime":7387.566,"endTime":7390.066,"body":"It would be impossible to put them on the"},{"startTime":7390.066,"endTime":7392.333,"body":"schedule without testing them against an"},{"startTime":7392.333,"endTime":7395.1,"body":"inert placebo, without at least some"},{"startTime":7395.1,"endTime":7398.466,"body":"valid scientific attempt to figure out"},{"startTime":7398.466,"endTime":7401.233,"body":"what their net impact on health was."},{"startTime":7401.566,"endTime":7404.333,"body":"Some attempt to figure out what the"},{"startTime":7404.333,"endTime":7406.699,"body":"combinatorics, if one of them is good and"},{"startTime":7406.699,"endTime":7407.933,"body":"another one is good, what"},{"startTime":7407.933,"endTime":7409.433,"body":"happens when you give them both?"},{"startTime":7409.433,"endTime":7410.066,"body":"What happens when you give"},{"startTime":7410.066,"endTime":7411.133,"body":"them both on the same day?"},{"startTime":7412.433,"endTime":7417.1,"body":"So I feel dumb because the evidence was"},{"startTime":7417.1,"endTime":7419.633,"body":"apparently available if we had gone"},{"startTime":7419.633,"endTime":7421.266,"body":"digging, but the problem is you can't"},{"startTime":7421.266,"endTime":7422.466,"body":"approach life that way."},{"startTime":7423.133,"endTime":7425.233,"body":"What are the chances that this car is"},{"startTime":7425.233,"endTime":7426.933,"body":"past any safety test at all?"},{"startTime":7427.366,"endTime":7429.1,"body":"Well, I would say if you're buying a car"},{"startTime":7429.1,"endTime":7431.166,"body":"in an American car dealership, the"},{"startTime":7431.166,"endTime":7434.899,"body":"chances are 100% that it has been through"},{"startTime":7434.899,"endTime":7436.833,"body":"a battery of safety tests."},{"startTime":7438.033,"endTime":7439.366,"body":"If I found out that wasn't"},{"startTime":7439.366,"endTime":7441.566,"body":"true, that'd be one thing."},{"startTime":7441.566,"endTime":7444.666,"body":"But the point is, did I go and check that"},{"startTime":7444.666,"endTime":7445.866,"body":"the tests were done?"},{"startTime":7445.866,"endTime":7446.933,"body":"Did I visit the facility to"},{"startTime":7446.933,"endTime":7448.033,"body":"make sure it actually exists?"},{"startTime":7448.3,"endTime":7449.633,"body":"You can't live that way."},{"startTime":7449.633,"endTime":7451.3,"body":"So if you buy a vacuum, you look for the"},{"startTime":7451.3,"endTime":7453.199,"body":"little thing that says UL, Underwriters"},{"startTime":7453.199,"endTime":7456.566,"body":"Laboratory, something effective and"},{"startTime":7456.566,"endTime":7458.266,"body":"knowledgeable has vetted this product."},{"startTime":7458.266,"endTime":7458.866,"body":"It's not going to"},{"startTime":7458.866,"endTime":7460.266,"body":"catch fire in your hands."},{"startTime":7460.266,"endTime":7461.733,"body":"And if it does, you have a lawsuit."},{"startTime":7462.066,"endTime":7462.266,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7462.699,"endTime":7465.366,"body":"And you know, the equivalent of the UL"},{"startTime":7465.833,"endTime":7470.533,"body":"listing for a vaccine is, you know, the"},{"startTime":7470.533,"endTime":7472.5,"body":"friendly and knowledgeable pediatrician"},{"startTime":7472.5,"endTime":7473.933,"body":"who you've talked a certain amount of"},{"startTime":7473.933,"endTime":7476.266,"body":"biology with and tells you, yes, this is"},{"startTime":7476.266,"endTime":7477.733,"body":"time for this vaccine."},{"startTime":7478.1,"endTime":7479.3,"body":"It has these benefits."},{"startTime":7479.8,"endTime":7481.133,"body":"The harms are extremely"},{"startTime":7481.133,"endTime":7482.466,"body":"rare and blah, blah, blah."},{"startTime":7483.133,"endTime":7484.566,"body":"Point is, okay."},{"startTime":7484.566,"endTime":7487.199,"body":"So pharma hired our pediatricians out"},{"startTime":7487.199,"endTime":7488.733,"body":"from under us to pretend that"},{"startTime":7488.733,"endTime":7489.966,"body":"tests were done that warrant."},{"startTime":7491.166,"endTime":7492.866,"body":"And so the point is,"},{"startTime":7492.866,"endTime":7494.6,"body":"okay, they snuck one bias."},{"startTime":7494.833,"endTime":7500.8,"body":"And so the truth is impossible in the"},{"startTime":7500.8,"endTime":7502.066,"body":"world you think you live in."},{"startTime":7502.3,"endTime":7503.266,"body":"You don't live in that world."},{"startTime":7503.266,"endTime":7504.3,"body":"That's how it is possible."},{"startTime":7504.3,"endTime":7505.899,"body":"But the truth is impossible in the world"},{"startTime":7505.899,"endTime":7506.766,"body":"you think you live in."},{"startTime":7506.766,"endTime":7509.966,"body":"And so that's the reason that this"},{"startTime":7509.966,"endTime":7512.933,"body":"governor too many will sound like he's"},{"startTime":7512.933,"endTime":7515.066,"body":"actually courageously defending science"},{"startTime":7515.066,"endTime":7516.766,"body":"is because they think they live in a"},{"startTime":7516.766,"endTime":7517.866,"body":"world they don't live in."},{"startTime":7517.866,"endTime":7519.466,"body":"And in that world, the Trump"},{"startTime":7519.466,"endTime":7521.033,"body":"administration has gone insane."},{"startTime":7521.466,"endTime":7524.266,"body":"They've appointed a kook who is a"},{"startTime":7524.266,"endTime":7526.166,"body":"well-known anti-vaxxer who doesn't"},{"startTime":7526.166,"endTime":7527.766,"body":"understand how it is that"},{"startTime":7527.766,"endTime":7528.933,"body":"people are kept healthy."},{"startTime":7529.866,"endTime":7532.133,"body":"And in that world, you know, it's great"},{"startTime":7532.133,"endTime":7534.466,"body":"that the states are trying to stem the"},{"startTime":7534.466,"endTime":7535.533,"body":"tide of this madness."},{"startTime":7536.833,"endTime":7538.5,"body":"Whereas, and I think this is sort of"},{"startTime":7538.5,"endTime":7540.566,"body":"where you were going, whereas when"},{"startTime":7540.566,"endTime":7543.8,"body":"Washington State Senate Majority Leader"},{"startTime":7543.8,"endTime":7547.466,"body":"Jamie Peterson has this mushy mouth"},{"startTime":7547.466,"endTime":7550.266,"body":"response to whether or not boys should be"},{"startTime":7550.266,"endTime":7553.399,"body":"allowed to compete against girls in girls"},{"startTime":7553.399,"endTime":7557.266,"body":"sports, it's much easier to just see on"},{"startTime":7557.266,"endTime":7560.066,"body":"the face of the comet that he's being"},{"startTime":7560.066,"endTime":7562.933,"body":"cowardly and not trusting what is in"},{"startTime":7562.933,"endTime":7564.566,"body":"front of his and everyone's eyes."},{"startTime":7564.566,"endTime":7566.033,"body":"Yeah, that's exactly what he is doing."},{"startTime":7566.266,"endTime":7569.566,"body":"He is trying to deliver a response that"},{"startTime":7569.566,"endTime":7572.266,"body":"explains why he doesn't accept the"},{"startTime":7572.266,"endTime":7574.166,"body":"obvious, will not"},{"startTime":7574.166,"endTime":7575.433,"body":"catch anybody's attention."},{"startTime":7575.733,"endTime":7576.399,"body":"There's not enough"},{"startTime":7576.399,"endTime":7578.533,"body":"content in it to evaluate it."},{"startTime":7578.833,"endTime":7580.566,"body":"So the whole point is I would like to"},{"startTime":7580.566,"endTime":7582.399,"body":"give you, I would like to kick up enough"},{"startTime":7582.399,"endTime":7584.466,"body":"dust that this question goes away."},{"startTime":7584.733,"endTime":7586.6,"body":"I would like not to pay the price of"},{"startTime":7586.6,"endTime":7588.733,"body":"angering the trans activists."},{"startTime":7589.233,"endTime":7591.933,"body":"I would like not to say anything concrete"},{"startTime":7591.933,"endTime":7594.199,"body":"enough that, you know, it will make the"},{"startTime":7594.199,"endTime":7596.5,"body":"news as they explore why I didn't know"},{"startTime":7596.5,"endTime":7597.266,"body":"what I was talking about."},{"startTime":7597.266,"endTime":7600.5,"body":"So his real point, I think I see in that"},{"startTime":7600.5,"endTime":7602.833,"body":"person, that his real point is to take"},{"startTime":7602.833,"endTime":7607.399,"body":"factors which have some impact and to"},{"startTime":7607.399,"endTime":7609.866,"body":"throw them together while proclaiming"},{"startTime":7609.866,"endTime":7611.933,"body":"that he has not enough expertise to know"},{"startTime":7611.933,"endTime":7614.566,"body":"anything about men and women and that"},{"startTime":7614.566,"endTime":7615.899,"body":"it's supposed to go away."},{"startTime":7616.199,"endTime":7617.433,"body":"And what you just did is"},{"startTime":7617.433,"endTime":7618.266,"body":"not supposed to happen."},{"startTime":7618.566,"endTime":7618.833,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7619.166,"endTime":7621.233,"body":"And that's, and I apologize, I don't know"},{"startTime":7621.233,"endTime":7622.166,"body":"how to pronounce your last name, but"},{"startTime":7622.166,"endTime":7624.266,"body":"that's Brandi Kruse who's asking the"},{"startTime":7624.266,"endTime":7626.966,"body":"question and whose clip that is and kudos"},{"startTime":7626.966,"endTime":7629.0,"body":"to her for effectively"},{"startTime":7629.0,"endTime":7630.133,"body":"not letting it go away."},{"startTime":7630.133,"endTime":7630.333,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":7630.633,"endTime":7630.899,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7630.899,"endTime":7632.966,"body":"For being there and asking the question"},{"startTime":7632.966,"endTime":7636.566,"body":"and then taking it and posting it and"},{"startTime":7636.566,"endTime":7640.899,"body":"here we are because we should not be"},{"startTime":7640.899,"endTime":7642.433,"body":"letting people hide"},{"startTime":7642.433,"endTime":7644.6,"body":"behind their cowardice."},{"startTime":7645.333,"endTime":7645.533,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":7645.699,"endTime":7647.266,"body":"This is an elected official"},{"startTime":7647.266,"endTime":7650.1,"body":"responding in a public forum."},{"startTime":7650.899,"endTime":7652.533,"body":"You know, he's allowed to have a private"},{"startTime":7652.533,"endTime":7655.199,"body":"life and have whatever insane beliefs he"},{"startTime":7655.199,"endTime":7658.633,"body":"may have, but this is an elected official"},{"startTime":7658.633,"endTime":7660.5,"body":"responding to a public question in a"},{"startTime":7660.5,"endTime":7662.1,"body":"public forum and his"},{"startTime":7662.1,"endTime":7664.666,"body":"response is beyond inept."},{"startTime":7665.133,"endTime":7666.5,"body":"I mean, that's being very, very kind."},{"startTime":7667.6,"endTime":7667.933,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":7667.933,"endTime":7670.533,"body":"And if we were wise as an electorate, we"},{"startTime":7670.533,"endTime":7672.866,"body":"would take any instance of such a thing"},{"startTime":7672.866,"endTime":7674.266,"body":"and we would say, okay,"},{"startTime":7674.266,"endTime":7675.566,"body":"that person can't be in office."},{"startTime":7676.233,"endTime":7676.333,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7676.333,"endTime":7677.933,"body":"If you can't answer this question, if"},{"startTime":7677.933,"endTime":7679.466,"body":"you're not willing to pay the price of"},{"startTime":7679.466,"endTime":7680.933,"body":"answering a simple question with a"},{"startTime":7680.933,"endTime":7683.566,"body":"straightforward answer, then obviously"},{"startTime":7683.566,"endTime":7685.1,"body":"you can't do our bidding."},{"startTime":7685.1,"endTime":7686.933,"body":"We don't know who's bidding you will do."},{"startTime":7686.933,"endTime":7687.166,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7687.533,"endTime":7690.3,"body":"But you know, so Brandi Kruse, good on you"},{"startTime":7690.3,"endTime":7692.399,"body":"for forcing this into the open."},{"startTime":7693.0,"endTime":7695.533,"body":"And the point is for the same reason that"},{"startTime":7695.533,"endTime":7697.233,"body":"you should read the books they wish to"},{"startTime":7697.233,"endTime":7700.399,"body":"burn, we should highlight every time"},{"startTime":7700.399,"endTime":7703.433,"body":"somebody puts out a puff of squid ink and"},{"startTime":7703.433,"endTime":7706.966,"body":"disappears, make sure the camera sees"},{"startTime":7706.966,"endTime":7709.033,"body":"where they emerged later and highlight"},{"startTime":7709.033,"endTime":7712.433,"body":"their cowardice because obviously we"},{"startTime":7712.433,"endTime":7713.466,"body":"can't be governed this way."},{"startTime":7714.366,"endTime":7714.866,"body":"It's true."},{"startTime":7716.533,"endTime":7719.366,"body":"So that segues somewhat less naturally"},{"startTime":7719.6,"endTime":7722.166,"body":"into the last thing I want to talk about,"},{"startTime":7722.166,"endTime":7724.366,"body":"unless you wanted to speak more"},{"startTime":7724.366,"endTime":7726.966,"body":"explicitly about science and scientism"},{"startTime":7726.966,"endTime":7729.033,"body":"first, before we go to Broadway."},{"startTime":7731.033,"endTime":7734.566,"body":"Can I just ask, am I going to be expected"},{"startTime":7734.566,"endTime":7735.566,"body":"to break into song"},{"startTime":7735.566,"endTime":7736.6,"body":"when we get to Broadway?"},{"startTime":7736.899,"endTime":7737.5,"body":"No, good."},{"startTime":7737.8,"endTime":7737.833,"body":"No."},{"startTime":7737.833,"endTime":7739.466,"body":"I mean, you're good at it, but I'm not"},{"startTime":7739.466,"endTime":7741.366,"body":"going to ask that from you on air."},{"startTime":7741.366,"endTime":7741.833,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7741.833,"endTime":7742.966,"body":"It's, it's tough."},{"startTime":7743.333,"endTime":7744.933,"body":"Especially, I think this is a musical"},{"startTime":7744.933,"endTime":7746.1,"body":"that I didn't even know existed."},{"startTime":7746.1,"endTime":7746.866,"body":"So I don't think you're"},{"startTime":7746.866,"endTime":7747.466,"body":"going to know the songs."},{"startTime":7747.966,"endTime":7748.233,"body":"No."},{"startTime":7748.433,"endTime":7749.033,"body":"And it's hard to make"},{"startTime":7749.033,"endTime":7750.166,"body":"those things up on the spot."},{"startTime":7751.266,"endTime":7752.433,"body":"Though people in musicals"},{"startTime":7752.433,"endTime":7753.433,"body":"appear to be doing exactly."},{"startTime":7753.433,"endTime":7754.333,"body":"They appear to be doing exactly."},{"startTime":7754.733,"endTime":7754.766,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7754.833,"endTime":7757.866,"body":"So remember Dylan Mulvaney."},{"startTime":7758.133,"endTime":7759.166,"body":"Oh, do I?"},{"startTime":7759.566,"endTime":7759.766,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7759.833,"endTime":7761.399,"body":"So I did not actually prompt"},{"startTime":7762.066,"endTime":7763.766,"body":"this with a picture of him."},{"startTime":7763.966,"endTime":7766.633,"body":"But listen, let me just say he's, he's"},{"startTime":7766.633,"endTime":7769.633,"body":"the, the talented twink who,"},{"startTime":7770.733,"endTime":7771.666,"body":"and there are people who are"},{"startTime":7771.666,"endTime":7773.133,"body":"like, he has no talent at all."},{"startTime":7773.133,"endTime":7774.5,"body":"And he has no singing voice."},{"startTime":7774.5,"endTime":7775.166,"body":"He's actually a"},{"startTime":7775.166,"endTime":7776.466,"body":"really, really talented guy,"},{"startTime":7777.699,"endTime":7781.199,"body":"a slight bodied young gay man, a twink"},{"startTime":7781.199,"endTime":7783.833,"body":"who mocks women for a living and has been"},{"startTime":7783.833,"endTime":7785.233,"body":"very, very successful at it."},{"startTime":7785.6,"endTime":7788.199,"body":"Before he began his whatever it is, Days"},{"startTime":7788.199,"endTime":7790.3,"body":"of Girlhood thing on TikTok, which"},{"startTime":7790.3,"endTime":7792.566,"body":"skyrocketed him to fame and got him an"},{"startTime":7792.566,"endTime":7794.233,"body":"invite to the Biden White House and you"},{"startTime":7794.233,"endTime":7794.766,"body":"know, all of the"},{"startTime":7794.766,"endTime":7796.233,"body":"things and, and what was it?"},{"startTime":7796.233,"endTime":7796.766,"body":"Budweiser?"},{"startTime":7797.166,"endTime":7797.433,"body":"Oh man."},{"startTime":7797.866,"endTime":7799.033,"body":"So they tanked single"},{"startTime":7799.033,"endTime":7801.833,"body":"handedly tanked Budweiser."},{"startTime":7802.066,"endTime":7802.633,"body":"Oh, I think he was in"},{"startTime":7802.633,"endTime":7803.633,"body":"a bubble bath drinking."},{"startTime":7803.966,"endTime":7806.566,"body":"So, so I'm, he's a he and"},{"startTime":7806.566,"endTime":7807.766,"body":"he's presenting as a she."},{"startTime":7808.3,"endTime":7810.133,"body":"And so everything you see about him will"},{"startTime":7810.133,"endTime":7812.766,"body":"always use the she her pronouns, but no,"},{"startTime":7813.066,"endTime":7814.733,"body":"everyone knows because he"},{"startTime":7814.733,"endTime":7816.899,"body":"was trying to be a performer."},{"startTime":7817.133,"endTime":7819.033,"body":"He's a talented twink, like I said."},{"startTime":7819.699,"endTime":7821.666,"body":"And before he decided, I know how I'm"},{"startTime":7821.666,"endTime":7822.5,"body":"going to do this, I'm"},{"startTime":7822.5,"endTime":7823.866,"body":"going to pretend to be a girl."},{"startTime":7825.0,"endTime":7827.366,"body":"He, there's a lot of video out there of"},{"startTime":7827.366,"endTime":7829.333,"body":"him trying, you know, trying his hand at"},{"startTime":7829.333,"endTime":7830.1,"body":"like, he's got one"},{"startTime":7830.1,"endTime":7831.533,"body":"being like a safari guide."},{"startTime":7831.766,"endTime":7833.633,"body":"And like, there's, I looked into him a"},{"startTime":7833.633,"endTime":7834.833,"body":"lot when he started emerging."},{"startTime":7835.066,"endTime":7836.633,"body":"And he's a one man village people."},{"startTime":7837.199,"endTime":7838.666,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7838.666,"endTime":7839.566,"body":"And so like, and you know,"},{"startTime":7839.566,"endTime":7841.633,"body":"he has, he has real skills."},{"startTime":7843.133,"endTime":7845.066,"body":"He's going to be playing a"},{"startTime":7845.066,"endTime":7846.266,"body":"big new role on Broadway."},{"startTime":7847.166,"endTime":7847.366,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7847.666,"endTime":7849.533,"body":"And I want you to guess who."},{"startTime":7849.833,"endTime":7852.033,"body":"And so I'm telling, I'll just tell you,"},{"startTime":7852.033,"endTime":7854.133,"body":"this is in a musical"},{"startTime":7854.133,"endTime":7854.933,"body":"that I didn't know existed."},{"startTime":7854.933,"endTime":7855.766,"body":"It's an historical"},{"startTime":7855.766,"endTime":7857.966,"body":"figure, an historical figure."},{"startTime":7857.966,"endTime":7860.333,"body":"And you know, you don't have to spend"},{"startTime":7860.333,"endTime":7863.0,"body":"really any time at this at all, but I"},{"startTime":7863.0,"endTime":7863.933,"body":"thought it might be a mute."},{"startTime":7864.066,"endTime":7864.333,"body":"Not yet."},{"startTime":7866.533,"endTime":7870.033,"body":"So I sent our amazing producer, Jen, is"},{"startTime":7870.033,"endTime":7871.366,"body":"looking at me because I sent her some"},{"startTime":7871.366,"endTime":7874.466,"body":"pictures, not of him, but of the"},{"startTime":7874.466,"endTime":7876.633,"body":"historical figures, some paintings from"},{"startTime":7876.633,"endTime":7878.233,"body":"back in the day for her to show once I"},{"startTime":7878.233,"endTime":7881.933,"body":"start describing the historicalness of"},{"startTime":7881.933,"endTime":7883.933,"body":"this person, because I needed a reminder"},{"startTime":7883.933,"endTime":7886.066,"body":"and I will give our audience a reminder."},{"startTime":7886.699,"endTime":7889.033,"body":"But so she has just come to understand"},{"startTime":7889.033,"endTime":7890.733,"body":"who Dylan Mulvaney will"},{"startTime":7890.733,"endTime":7891.8,"body":"be playing on Broadway."},{"startTime":7892.466,"endTime":7893.433,"body":"Is it Joan of Arc?"},{"startTime":7893.833,"endTime":7894.366,"body":"Joan of Arc."},{"startTime":7895.0,"endTime":7896.233,"body":"No, no."},{"startTime":7897.566,"endTime":7898.733,"body":"Is it that offensive?"},{"startTime":7899.466,"endTime":7901.166,"body":"It's all, it's in some ways,"},{"startTime":7901.433,"endTime":7903.333,"body":"in some ways it's, it's worse."},{"startTime":7904.433,"endTime":7906.766,"body":"Only because like Joan of Arc, Joan of"},{"startTime":7906.766,"endTime":7909.666,"body":"Arc, we know in part because she was"},{"startTime":7909.666,"endTime":7911.266,"body":"really a girl, I think, right?"},{"startTime":7911.266,"endTime":7913.933,"body":"Like a young woman, a young, a girl."},{"startTime":7913.933,"endTime":7917.766,"body":"And it was super, even more unusual that"},{"startTime":7917.766,"endTime":7919.433,"body":"she was a girl being so courageous,"},{"startTime":7920.6,"endTime":7923.366,"body":"but that unusual, like the fact of her"},{"startTime":7923.366,"endTime":7926.333,"body":"being a girl or a woman, other than it"},{"startTime":7926.333,"endTime":7928.133,"body":"being unusual for her to have taken on"},{"startTime":7928.133,"endTime":7931.166,"body":"such a public role, wasn't part of,"},{"startTime":7931.166,"endTime":7934.533,"body":"wasn't part of her fame necessarily."},{"startTime":7934.766,"endTime":7936.566,"body":"Like it didn't, it didn't inherently"},{"startTime":7936.866,"endTime":7943.733,"body":"impact what she did in the world."},{"startTime":7946.6,"endTime":7948.933,"body":"Oh my God."},{"startTime":7949.933,"endTime":7951.333,"body":"Yeah, I do not know."},{"startTime":7951.633,"endTime":7953.033,"body":"Yeah, no, it's, I mean, it's, it's"},{"startTime":7953.033,"endTime":7954.633,"body":"getting, Joan of Arc was a good guess."},{"startTime":7954.633,"endTime":7955.333,"body":"It was a good guess."},{"startTime":7955.333,"endTime":7958.433,"body":"So on, there's a, there's a five, there's"},{"startTime":7958.433,"endTime":7961.666,"body":"a musical called Six on Broadway."},{"startTime":7961.666,"endTime":7963.033,"body":"It's won a ton of awards."},{"startTime":7964.566,"endTime":7967.1,"body":"And it's been on Broadway since 2021."},{"startTime":7968.333,"endTime":7968.933,"body":"And currently,"},{"startTime":7970.033,"endTime":7972.566,"body":"Gina Gianna Yannelli, apologies if I'm"},{"startTime":7972.566,"endTime":7974.233,"body":"mispronouncing her name, is going to step"},{"startTime":7974.233,"endTime":7975.733,"body":"down from this role on February 15th."},{"startTime":7975.733,"endTime":7978.033,"body":"And on February 16th, Dylan Mulvaney will"},{"startTime":7978.033,"endTime":7980.066,"body":"be taking on the role currently being"},{"startTime":7980.066,"endTime":7985.133,"body":"played by Gianna Yannelli as Anne Boleyn."},{"startTime":7986.333,"endTime":7987.466,"body":"Anne Boleyn, Anne Boleyn."},{"startTime":7987.466,"endTime":7987.899,"body":"So you can go ahead and"},{"startTime":7987.933,"endTime":7989.533,"body":"show the first, the first shot."},{"startTime":7989.533,"endTime":7991.366,"body":"Now this is a painting of Anne Boleyn."},{"startTime":7991.366,"endTime":7992.833,"body":"These are, we have a couple of paintings"},{"startTime":7992.833,"endTime":7994.833,"body":"here, all of them in the public domain."},{"startTime":7995.166,"endTime":7996.3,"body":"So Anne Boleyn was"},{"startTime":7996.3,"endTime":7998.1,"body":"born in the early 1500s."},{"startTime":7998.8,"endTime":8001.366,"body":"She died in 1536 when her head was cut"},{"startTime":8001.366,"endTime":8003.066,"body":"off at the order of her"},{"startTime":8003.066,"endTime":8004.533,"body":"then husband, Henry VIII."},{"startTime":8005.666,"endTime":8007.399,"body":"Born, the name of the musical is Six,"},{"startTime":8007.699,"endTime":8008.966,"body":"which is a reference to"},{"startTime":8008.966,"endTime":8010.699,"body":"Henry VIII's Six Wives."},{"startTime":8012.266,"endTime":8013.899,"body":"She was, Anne Boleyn was born to a high"},{"startTime":8013.899,"endTime":8016.533,"body":"class family in 1522."},{"startTime":8017.566,"endTime":8021.1,"body":"She joined the court of Henry V, Henry"},{"startTime":8021.1,"endTime":8023.166,"body":"VIII's wife, Catherine of Aragon."},{"startTime":8023.166,"endTime":8023.766,"body":"That was his first"},{"startTime":8023.766,"endTime":8025.566,"body":"wife as a maid of honor."},{"startTime":8027.433,"endTime":8031.0,"body":"Here we have a painting of the court of"},{"startTime":8031.0,"endTime":8033.266,"body":"Henry VIII in which Catherine"},{"startTime":8033.266,"endTime":8034.866,"body":"of Aragon is still the queen."},{"startTime":8035.666,"endTime":8039.166,"body":"But he's there, Henry VIII in the left,"},{"startTime":8039.166,"endTime":8041.233,"body":"left middle, sort of being"},{"startTime":8041.233,"endTime":8042.666,"body":"lecherous with Anne Boleyn."},{"startTime":8042.666,"endTime":8044.566,"body":"She resisted his advances though."},{"startTime":8044.566,"endTime":8045.666,"body":"She resisted his advances"},{"startTime":8045.666,"endTime":8047.366,"body":"unlike other women in his court."},{"startTime":8048.433,"endTime":8051.533,"body":"And so because he had become insistent"},{"startTime":8051.533,"endTime":8054.733,"body":"that he really needed to marry her, he"},{"startTime":8054.733,"endTime":8056.733,"body":"sought a divorce from"},{"startTime":8056.733,"endTime":8057.633,"body":"Catherine of Aragon."},{"startTime":8058.133,"endTime":8060.0,"body":"And the church, the Catholic"},{"startTime":8060.0,"endTime":8061.833,"body":"church, said no, divorce, no."},{"startTime":8062.066,"endTime":8063.533,"body":"And you have a child with her."},{"startTime":8063.733,"endTime":8065.3,"body":"And so we can't annul and like, no."},{"startTime":8066.666,"endTime":8068.066,"body":"And so the Catholic church would not"},{"startTime":8068.066,"endTime":8069.199,"body":"allow the annulment."},{"startTime":8069.833,"endTime":8072.233,"body":"And this was the beginning of the schism"},{"startTime":8072.233,"endTime":8074.366,"body":"between the Catholic church and what"},{"startTime":8074.366,"endTime":8076.366,"body":"would later become the Church of England."},{"startTime":8076.6,"endTime":8077.533,"body":"Oh, I did not know that."},{"startTime":8077.533,"endTime":8077.866,"body":"Exactly."},{"startTime":8078.066,"endTime":8080.733,"body":"So Anne Boleyn was actually in some ways"},{"startTime":8080.733,"endTime":8083.166,"body":"the key figure, the first figure in what"},{"startTime":8083.166,"endTime":8084.8,"body":"would become the English Reformation and"},{"startTime":8084.8,"endTime":8086.133,"body":"the beginning of the Church of England,"},{"startTime":8086.133,"endTime":8087.266,"body":"although the Church of England wasn't"},{"startTime":8088.0,"endTime":8090.433,"body":"officially formed, I think, until the"},{"startTime":8090.433,"endTime":8092.5,"body":"reign of Queen Elizabeth I, who actually"},{"startTime":8092.5,"endTime":8094.666,"body":"is Anne Boleyn and Henry VIII's only"},{"startTime":8094.666,"endTime":8098.966,"body":"child, Queen Elizabeth I, and obviously"},{"startTime":8098.966,"endTime":8100.399,"body":"very important historical figure."},{"startTime":8101.233,"endTime":8105.166,"body":"So Henry VIII goes around the church,"},{"startTime":8105.5,"endTime":8108.066,"body":"basically says no to the Pope."},{"startTime":8108.333,"endTime":8110.066,"body":"He creates the Archbishop of Canterbury"},{"startTime":8110.066,"endTime":8113.766,"body":"and the Archbishop of Canterbury says,"},{"startTime":8113.966,"endTime":8116.6,"body":"okay, you get to have this divorce."},{"startTime":8117.199,"endTime":8119.833,"body":"And then they get married."},{"startTime":8120.266,"endTime":8121.766,"body":"And so show this, this is them and"},{"startTime":8121.766,"endTime":8122.733,"body":"they're in the good times."},{"startTime":8122.733,"endTime":8123.866,"body":"They're hunting together."},{"startTime":8123.866,"endTime":8125.233,"body":"This is Henry VIII and"},{"startTime":8125.233,"endTime":8127.399,"body":"Anne Boleyn hunting together."},{"startTime":8127.866,"endTime":8132.1,"body":"Back when he still thought that she might"},{"startTime":8132.1,"endTime":8132.866,"body":"produce for him the"},{"startTime":8132.866,"endTime":8133.899,"body":"male heir that he wanted."},{"startTime":8134.733,"endTime":8138.633,"body":"But she had baby Elizabeth, whom he"},{"startTime":8138.633,"endTime":8142.333,"body":"apparently was affectionate towards, but"},{"startTime":8142.333,"endTime":8143.366,"body":"then she had three miscarriages."},{"startTime":8144.333,"endTime":8146.466,"body":"And he was beginning to"},{"startTime":8146.466,"endTime":8147.866,"body":"get rather upset with her."},{"startTime":8148.8,"endTime":8152.066,"body":"And so trumped up, we believe, a number"},{"startTime":8152.066,"endTime":8154.233,"body":"of charges of high treason, which"},{"startTime":8154.233,"endTime":8156.5,"body":"included adultery, that she was having"},{"startTime":8156.5,"endTime":8158.166,"body":"incest with her brother, George, and that"},{"startTime":8158.166,"endTime":8158.833,"body":"she was plotting to"},{"startTime":8158.833,"endTime":8159.833,"body":"kill her husband, the King."},{"startTime":8162.633,"endTime":8165.466,"body":"And, you know, later historians found all"},{"startTime":8165.466,"endTime":8167.066,"body":"of these charges completely unconvincing,"},{"startTime":8167.366,"endTime":8170.166,"body":"but a jury that included not only her"},{"startTime":8170.166,"endTime":8172.266,"body":"former betrothed before she joined the"},{"startTime":8172.266,"endTime":8174.133,"body":"court and married the King and also her"},{"startTime":8174.133,"endTime":8175.833,"body":"uncle found her guilty"},{"startTime":8175.833,"endTime":8177.399,"body":"unanimously and she was beheaded."},{"startTime":8178.533,"endTime":8180.166,"body":"And so here she is in the tower before"},{"startTime":8180.166,"endTime":8183.699,"body":"the beheading, feeling rather sorry for"},{"startTime":8183.699,"endTime":8184.899,"body":"herself, as you can imagine."},{"startTime":8185.566,"endTime":8189.933,"body":"So Dylan Mulvaney, a talented twink in"},{"startTime":8189.933,"endTime":8193.666,"body":"2026 is going to be playing Anne Boleyn,"},{"startTime":8194.366,"endTime":8197.633,"body":"one of the most important and influential"},{"startTime":8197.633,"endTime":8200.933,"body":"women from English history whose"},{"startTime":8200.933,"endTime":8205.166,"body":"femaleness was utterly and completely"},{"startTime":8205.166,"endTime":8208.299,"body":"endogenous to her role in history."},{"startTime":8208.533,"endTime":8210.933,"body":"She couldn't have been any of the things"},{"startTime":8210.933,"endTime":8212.7,"body":"that she was if she'd just been a dude."},{"startTime":8214.033,"endTime":8214.366,"body":"There's no,"},{"startTime":8215.566,"endTime":8217.233,"body":"there's, I am now,"},{"startTime":8217.799,"endTime":8219.466,"body":"what that words, I think"},{"startTime":8219.466,"endTime":8220.366,"body":"I'm out."},{"startTime":8220.666,"endTime":8221.133,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":8221.133,"endTime":8223.866,"body":"So imagine for a second that you and I"},{"startTime":8223.866,"endTime":8226.7,"body":"lived some different life than we've led"},{"startTime":8226.966,"endTime":8229.266,"body":"and found ourselves at this production."},{"startTime":8229.5,"endTime":8229.7,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8230.066,"endTime":8231.466,"body":"It looks like an interesting musical."},{"startTime":8231.733,"endTime":8233.333,"body":"I mean, you know, you and I could find"},{"startTime":8233.333,"endTime":8234.666,"body":"ourselves there because it would be"},{"startTime":8234.666,"endTime":8237.799,"body":"interesting to see what such an"},{"startTime":8237.799,"endTime":8239.633,"body":"abomination would be like."},{"startTime":8239.633,"endTime":8239.866,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8240.166,"endTime":8242.466,"body":"But imagine you were there in earnest."},{"startTime":8242.899,"endTime":8243.1,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8246.1,"endTime":8253.333,"body":"Struggling to see Dylan Mulvaney as a"},{"startTime":8253.333,"endTime":8255.2,"body":"compelling woman in this role."},{"startTime":8255.2,"endTime":8255.666,"body":"And, you know, he's"},{"startTime":8255.666,"endTime":8256.799,"body":"more compelling than some."},{"startTime":8257.266,"endTime":8257.6,"body":"Oh, yeah."},{"startTime":8257.966,"endTime":8259.133,"body":"No, in fact, I mean, you can, while"},{"startTime":8259.133,"endTime":8259.799,"body":"Bret's talking, you can"},{"startTime":8259.799,"endTime":8260.833,"body":"show my screen if you want."},{"startTime":8260.833,"endTime":8262.666,"body":"This is one of the"},{"startTime":8262.666,"endTime":8263.866,"body":"press releases about this."},{"startTime":8263.866,"endTime":8264.366,"body":"And this is Dylan"},{"startTime":8264.366,"endTime":8265.433,"body":"Mulvaney on the right here."},{"startTime":8265.766,"endTime":8267.966,"body":"But nonetheless, I would argue that any"},{"startTime":8268.0,"endTime":8270.733,"body":"reasonable person who is aware that"},{"startTime":8270.733,"endTime":8273.1,"body":"that's Dylan Mulvaney is going to be"},{"startTime":8273.1,"endTime":8275.866,"body":"struggling to maintain the suspension of"},{"startTime":8275.866,"endTime":8278.666,"body":"disbelief that is required in order to"},{"startTime":8278.666,"endTime":8281.033,"body":"enjoy and absorb the particular show."},{"startTime":8281.766,"endTime":8282.066,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":8282.399,"endTime":8283.799,"body":"And so it is."},{"startTime":8284.266,"endTime":8287.899,"body":"It is a gamble, I would argue, on behalf"},{"startTime":8287.899,"endTime":8289.266,"body":"of whatever company is putting this"},{"startTime":8289.266,"endTime":8292.033,"body":"production on that is presumably"},{"startTime":8292.033,"endTime":8294.799,"body":"motivated to make money that you will"},{"startTime":8294.799,"endTime":8296.399,"body":"bring in a lot of people who want to see"},{"startTime":8296.399,"endTime":8299.7,"body":"the spectacle and presumably want to"},{"startTime":8299.7,"endTime":8303.633,"body":"virtue signal to their friend group."},{"startTime":8303.633,"endTime":8306.133,"body":"Well, I saw the Dylan Mulvaney production"},{"startTime":8306.133,"endTime":8308.433,"body":"of what was it called?"},{"startTime":8308.433,"endTime":8308.566,"body":"Six."},{"startTime":8308.566,"endTime":8309.066,"body":"Oh, six."},{"startTime":8309.933,"endTime":8311.0,"body":"And it was marvelous."},{"startTime":8311.366,"endTime":8311.566,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8311.799,"endTime":8313.266,"body":"Oh, he really, oh, I'm sorry."},{"startTime":8313.466,"endTime":8314.6,"body":"She really does a great job."},{"startTime":8314.6,"endTime":8314.766,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8314.766,"endTime":8316.166,"body":"She really does a compelling job."},{"startTime":8316.166,"endTime":8316.799,"body":"You wouldn't even"},{"startTime":8316.799,"endTime":8317.966,"body":"realize that blah, blah, blah."},{"startTime":8318.233,"endTime":8319.799,"body":"So the point is that might"},{"startTime":8319.833,"endTime":8321.366,"body":"actually be a winning strategy."},{"startTime":8321.366,"endTime":8322.533,"body":"Unlike Budweiser, which"},{"startTime":8322.533,"endTime":8324.833,"body":"tanked its brand over this person."},{"startTime":8325.5,"endTime":8327.933,"body":"This might actually work because, A,"},{"startTime":8327.933,"endTime":8329.766,"body":"you've got a lot of sanctimonious"},{"startTime":8329.766,"endTime":8331.333,"body":"liberals who do love to"},{"startTime":8331.333,"endTime":8332.633,"body":"posture in front of their friends."},{"startTime":8333.133,"endTime":8334.133,"body":"And it's not a show."},{"startTime":8334.466,"endTime":8336.566,"body":"He's not the lead."},{"startTime":8336.566,"endTime":8337.566,"body":"There are six leads."},{"startTime":8337.566,"endTime":8338.299,"body":"There were six wives."},{"startTime":8338.933,"endTime":8340.866,"body":"And apparently the conceit of the show is"},{"startTime":8340.866,"endTime":8344.233,"body":"somehow it goes back and forth and now"},{"startTime":8344.233,"endTime":8346.6,"body":"the six wives are regaining their agency"},{"startTime":8346.6,"endTime":8348.5,"body":"and showing that they were more than just"},{"startTime":8348.5,"endTime":8350.7,"body":"wives of Henry the 8th or something."},{"startTime":8350.7,"endTime":8351.1,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":8351.1,"endTime":8352.633,"body":"Obviously, I haven't seen it."},{"startTime":8353.766,"endTime":8356.2,"body":"And it looks like, as far as I can tell,"},{"startTime":8356.733,"endTime":8358.933,"body":"all the other people playing the former"},{"startTime":8358.933,"endTime":8360.266,"body":"wives of Henry the"},{"startTime":8360.266,"endTime":8361.066,"body":"8th are actually women."},{"startTime":8362.1,"endTime":8362.566,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":8362.566,"endTime":8362.766,"body":"For now."},{"startTime":8364.466,"endTime":8367.033,"body":"But here's a,"},{"startTime":8369.5,"endTime":8370.799,"body":"let me just read a"},{"startTime":8370.799,"endTime":8372.066,"body":"couple of paragraphs here."},{"startTime":8373.166,"endTime":8376.1,"body":"From Tudor queens to pop icons, the six"},{"startTime":8376.1,"endTime":8377.533,"body":"wives of Henry the 8th take the"},{"startTime":8377.533,"endTime":8379.566,"body":"microphone to remix 500 years of"},{"startTime":8379.566,"endTime":8381.733,"body":"historical heartbreak into a euphoric"},{"startTime":8381.733,"endTime":8384.533,"body":"celebration of 21st century girl power."},{"startTime":8387.033,"endTime":8388.566,"body":"This new original musical is the global"},{"startTime":8388.566,"endTime":8389.366,"body":"sensation that everyone"},{"startTime":8389.433,"endTime":8390.533,"body":"is losing their head over."},{"startTime":8390.966,"endTime":8391.166,"body":"Cute."},{"startTime":8392.066,"endTime":8393.733,"body":"Six is the winner of 23 awards, including"},{"startTime":8393.733,"endTime":8395.833,"body":"the 2022 Tony award for best original"},{"startTime":8395.833,"endTime":8397.033,"body":"score and the outer critic"},{"startTime":8397.033,"endTime":8398.233,"body":"circle award for best musical."},{"startTime":8398.666,"endTime":8399.433,"body":"The New York Times"},{"startTime":8399.433,"endTime":8401.166,"body":"says six totally rules."},{"startTime":8401.166,"endTime":8401.966,"body":"It was a critic's pick."},{"startTime":8402.299,"endTime":8404.133,"body":"And the Washington Post held six as"},{"startTime":8404.133,"endTime":8405.899,"body":"exactly the kind of energizing,"},{"startTime":8405.899,"endTime":8406.766,"body":"inspirational"},{"startTime":8406.766,"endTime":8409.533,"body":"illumination this town aches for."},{"startTime":8410.166,"endTime":8413.966,"body":"So that's all kudos for some time in the"},{"startTime":8413.966,"endTime":8415.766,"body":"past five years, this show, when it"},{"startTime":8415.766,"endTime":8416.866,"body":"didn't have a dude playing"},{"startTime":8416.866,"endTime":8419.433,"body":"one of Henry the 8th's wives."},{"startTime":8420.399,"endTime":8423.766,"body":"I am curious what the critics will say at"},{"startTime":8423.766,"endTime":8427.566,"body":"these insane, captured ideological papers"},{"startTime":8427.566,"endTime":8430.066,"body":"and other media at the point that you"},{"startTime":8430.066,"endTime":8431.733,"body":"actually have a talented"},{"startTime":8431.733,"endTime":8433.366,"body":"twink playing anvil in."},{"startTime":8434.833,"endTime":8435.033,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8435.066,"endTime":8436.666,"body":"And actually, there's the"},{"startTime":8436.666,"endTime":8437.933,"body":"question of what they will say."},{"startTime":8438.633,"endTime":8440.366,"body":"And I think an equally interesting"},{"startTime":8440.366,"endTime":8442.166,"body":"question is what they will"},{"startTime":8442.166,"endTime":8444.766,"body":"imagine they are allowed to say."},{"startTime":8444.766,"endTime":8445.566,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8445.966,"endTime":8448.866,"body":"Because that's been the game all along is"},{"startTime":8448.866,"endTime":8450.5,"body":"you're not allowed to notice, you're not"},{"startTime":8450.5,"endTime":8452.299,"body":"allowed to comment, you're not allowed to"},{"startTime":8452.299,"endTime":8456.1,"body":"have a natural reaction to transness."},{"startTime":8456.666,"endTime":8457.133,"body":"That's weird."},{"startTime":8457.333,"endTime":8457.933,"body":"That's funny."},{"startTime":8458.266,"endTime":8459.533,"body":"That's curious."},{"startTime":8460.0,"endTime":8461.299,"body":"That's hard to fathom."},{"startTime":8462.1,"endTime":8462.933,"body":"None of those things,"},{"startTime":8463.233,"endTime":8464.933,"body":"you know, it has to be."},{"startTime":8464.933,"endTime":8466.299,"body":"That's transactional and"},{"startTime":8466.299,"endTime":8467.433,"body":"in service of his career."},{"startTime":8468.166,"endTime":8468.433,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8468.666,"endTime":8469.166,"body":"Exactly."},{"startTime":8469.633,"endTime":8469.833,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8470.033,"endTime":8472.066,"body":"I wonder if he's a bad guy, right?"},{"startTime":8472.666,"endTime":8473.666,"body":"You're allowed to wonder that."},{"startTime":8473.666,"endTime":8474.566,"body":"Well, not once he's"},{"startTime":8474.566,"endTime":8475.399,"body":"transitioned, you're not."},{"startTime":8475.833,"endTime":8476.033,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8476.566,"endTime":8478.266,"body":"So anyway, it'll be interesting."},{"startTime":8478.666,"endTime":8480.933,"body":"I actually would, I would want to go out"},{"startTime":8480.933,"endTime":8483.433,"body":"of our way and read the reviews of this"},{"startTime":8483.433,"endTime":8486.899,"body":"thing and try to figure out whether, you"},{"startTime":8486.899,"endTime":8488.5,"body":"know, what reaction they actually had,"},{"startTime":8488.966,"endTime":8490.933,"body":"how well it got translated into review."},{"startTime":8491.433,"endTime":8493.266,"body":"Because in general, I would imagine that"},{"startTime":8493.266,"endTime":8495.733,"body":"reviewers, you probably go into that gig,"},{"startTime":8496.333,"endTime":8498.733,"body":"because you kind of like having a"},{"startTime":8498.733,"endTime":8501.333,"body":"reaction and it being something you can"},{"startTime":8501.333,"endTime":8502.6,"body":"articulate well enough."},{"startTime":8502.633,"endTime":8504.966,"body":"And that people think highly of your"},{"startTime":8504.966,"endTime":8506.433,"body":"reviews because you said it was good."},{"startTime":8506.433,"endTime":8508.1,"body":"They went and they thought it was good."},{"startTime":8508.1,"endTime":8508.766,"body":"That's right."},{"startTime":8509.166,"endTime":8510.166,"body":"And so what was"},{"startTime":8510.166,"endTime":8512.5,"body":"a certain class of performers whom you"},{"startTime":8512.5,"endTime":8513.7,"body":"are no longer allowed"},{"startTime":8513.7,"endTime":8515.533,"body":"to accurately review."},{"startTime":8516.066,"endTime":8516.766,"body":"Maybe there is."},{"startTime":8516.766,"endTime":8517.366,"body":"Maybe there is."},{"startTime":8517.766,"endTime":8519.0,"body":"And maybe you're not good at lying"},{"startTime":8519.0,"endTime":8521.133,"body":"because maybe reviewing in general"},{"startTime":8521.133,"endTime":8524.166,"body":"involves dishing on what you saw and that"},{"startTime":8524.166,"endTime":8525.833,"body":"any critique you have, you"},{"startTime":8525.833,"endTime":8528.266,"body":"deliver and feel cool doing so."},{"startTime":8528.6,"endTime":8530.7,"body":"In this case, maybe you're forced into a"},{"startTime":8530.7,"endTime":8534.366,"body":"skill that you aren't so practiced in."},{"startTime":8534.933,"endTime":8535.133,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8536.033,"endTime":8536.366,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":8537.833,"endTime":8538.633,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":8538.633,"endTime":8539.566,"body":"That's all I have about that."},{"startTime":8539.866,"endTime":8540.133,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8540.133,"endTime":8541.166,"body":"Well, I hope they don't take my"},{"startTime":8541.166,"endTime":8542.766,"body":"suggestion of Joan of Arc because."},{"startTime":8543.533,"endTime":8545.1,"body":"Well, it depends on how well he'll do"},{"startTime":8545.1,"endTime":8546.666,"body":"playing Anne Boleyn."},{"startTime":8547.233,"endTime":8549.066,"body":"Well, not how well he'll do, but how well"},{"startTime":8549.066,"endTime":8550.299,"body":"he'll be said to have done."},{"startTime":8550.299,"endTime":8550.633,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8551.1,"endTime":8553.366,"body":"And if it succeeds, who knows what roles"},{"startTime":8553.366,"endTime":8555.533,"body":"we might find him in next."},{"startTime":8556.299,"endTime":8557.266,"body":"Lassie, for example."},{"startTime":8558.466,"endTime":8559.166,"body":"As the dog?"},{"startTime":8559.866,"endTime":8560.299,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8560.333,"endTime":8562.066,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":8562.066,"endTime":8562.633,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":8563.333,"endTime":8564.833,"body":"I mean, I don't know."},{"startTime":8565.166,"endTime":8567.133,"body":"He's gotten this far."},{"startTime":8567.133,"endTime":8567.333,"body":"He's attractive."},{"startTime":8567.766,"endTime":8568.133,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8568.133,"endTime":8568.733,"body":"But so was Lassie."},{"startTime":8569.666,"endTime":8570.066,"body":"Absolutely."},{"startTime":8570.533,"endTime":8570.966,"body":"And, you know,"},{"startTime":8572.266,"endTime":8575.333,"body":"being a girl is one level of jump and"},{"startTime":8575.333,"endTime":8576.299,"body":"being an entirely"},{"startTime":8576.299,"endTime":8577.5,"body":"different species is another."},{"startTime":8578.0,"endTime":8580.233,"body":"It might be within his skill set."},{"startTime":8580.233,"endTime":8580.933,"body":"Yeah. He's aspirational."},{"startTime":8581.366,"endTime":8581.833,"body":"Why not try?"},{"startTime":8582.066,"endTime":8582.266,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8582.533,"endTime":8582.799,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":8583.133,"endTime":8583.333,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8585.033,"endTime":8585.266,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":8585.533,"endTime":8586.066,"body":"Before we stopped,"},{"startTime":8588.466,"endTime":8589.733,"body":"and we'll be back on Wednesday and we'll"},{"startTime":8589.733,"endTime":8591.466,"body":"also be back tomorrow"},{"startTime":8591.466,"endTime":8593.066,"body":"with our Q and A on locals."},{"startTime":8593.933,"endTime":8595.399,"body":"Did you want to say something about"},{"startTime":8596.566,"endTime":8598.333,"body":"the passing of Scott Adams this week?"},{"startTime":8599.633,"endTime":8602.733,"body":"Yeah, I guess I do."},{"startTime":8602.733,"endTime":8604.566,"body":"And I will say I have"},{"startTime":8605.666,"endTime":8607.933,"body":"complex feelings here."},{"startTime":8608.266,"endTime":8610.166,"body":"Scott and I were in a bit of contact at"},{"startTime":8610.166,"endTime":8611.033,"body":"the end of his life."},{"startTime":8611.933,"endTime":8614.666,"body":"He said some very nice things about me,"},{"startTime":8614.666,"endTime":8615.233,"body":"in particular,"},{"startTime":8615.233,"endTime":8616.266,"body":"something he had said publicly."},{"startTime":8616.566,"endTime":8618.433,"body":"He reiterated and he thought I was very"},{"startTime":8618.433,"endTime":8619.533,"body":"good at explaining things."},{"startTime":8621.033,"endTime":8623.433,"body":"But anyway, we had a nice interaction."},{"startTime":8623.966,"endTime":8625.733,"body":"He knew already that he was"},{"startTime":8625.733,"endTime":8629.399,"body":"facing death very shortly."},{"startTime":8629.799,"endTime":8631.333,"body":"Said he was on a hospice already."},{"startTime":8633.366,"endTime":8634.266,"body":"And I didn't ..."},{"startTime":8635.366,"endTime":8638.366,"body":"It was sort of too late for us to have a"},{"startTime":8638.366,"endTime":8639.366,"body":"conversation that I"},{"startTime":8639.366,"endTime":8640.5,"body":"would like to have had."},{"startTime":8640.966,"endTime":8641.366,"body":"Publicly."},{"startTime":8641.366,"endTime":8641.566,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8641.899,"endTime":8645.766,"body":"Well, publicly or not, I would have just"},{"startTime":8645.766,"endTime":8649.133,"body":"simply at a human level, I wanted to"},{"startTime":8649.133,"endTime":8655.1,"body":"understand the meaning of his arc with"},{"startTime":8655.1,"endTime":8656.766,"body":"respect to COVID and"},{"startTime":8656.766,"endTime":8658.366,"body":"specifically the COVID shots."},{"startTime":8660.366,"endTime":8662.399,"body":"Because we were on different sides."},{"startTime":8663.233,"endTime":8664.933,"body":"Scott was a pro vaccine."},{"startTime":8665.266,"endTime":8668.533,"body":"He was not wildly pro vaccine, but he was"},{"startTime":8668.533,"endTime":8671.866,"body":"by his own accounting trying to read the"},{"startTime":8671.866,"endTime":8674.033,"body":"tea leaves and figure out whether or not"},{"startTime":8674.033,"endTime":8674.933,"body":"it made more sense to"},{"startTime":8674.933,"endTime":8676.033,"body":"get it or not get it."},{"startTime":8676.033,"endTime":8676.6,"body":"And ultimately"},{"startTime":8676.6,"endTime":8680.1,"body":"pro vaccine enough that given who he was"},{"startTime":8680.1,"endTime":8681.366,"body":"in the world, he got it"},{"startTime":8681.366,"endTime":8682.533,"body":"even though he didn't have to."},{"startTime":8683.033,"endTime":8683.233,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8684.566,"endTime":8688.633,"body":"And then he changed"},{"startTime":8688.633,"endTime":8690.566,"body":"his tune to his credit."},{"startTime":8690.833,"endTime":8692.733,"body":"He acknowledged and he went out of his"},{"startTime":8692.733,"endTime":8694.333,"body":"way to acknowledge that he"},{"startTime":8694.333,"endTime":8696.566,"body":"had gotten it totally wrong."},{"startTime":8696.566,"endTime":8698.6,"body":"Maybe we should just watch the clip."},{"startTime":8698.6,"endTime":8699.233,"body":"I have it."},{"startTime":8700.566,"endTime":8702.666,"body":"You want to put up"},{"startTime":8702.666,"endTime":8703.899,"body":"the clip of Scott Adams?"},{"startTime":8704.799,"endTime":8706.066,"body":"Completely."},{"startTime":8706.566,"endTime":8710.966,"body":"Having said as clearly as possible that"},{"startTime":8710.966,"endTime":8712.066,"body":"the anti-vax people"},{"startTime":8712.066,"endTime":8713.133,"body":"seem to be the winners."},{"startTime":8715.166,"endTime":8716.2,"body":"I want you to hear that clearly."},{"startTime":8716.833,"endTime":8718.033,"body":"The anti-vax people"},{"startTime":8718.033,"endTime":8719.033,"body":"appear to be the winners."},{"startTime":8719.433,"endTime":8723.066,"body":"The anti-vaxxers clearly"},{"startTime":8723.066,"endTime":8725.133,"body":"are the winners at this point."},{"startTime":8725.133,"endTime":8725.7,"body":"And I think it will"},{"startTime":8725.7,"endTime":8726.466,"body":"probably stay that way."},{"startTime":8727.566,"endTime":8728.666,"body":"And I don't want to put"},{"startTime":8728.666,"endTime":8730.366,"body":"any shade on that whatsoever."},{"startTime":8731.833,"endTime":8733.066,"body":"They came out the best."},{"startTime":8733.533,"endTime":8734.899,"body":"They have the winning position."},{"startTime":8735.966,"endTime":8738.366,"body":"The unvaccinated have a current advantage"},{"startTime":8738.366,"endTime":8741.266,"body":"because they feel better."},{"startTime":8742.266,"endTime":8744.733,"body":"The thing they're not worrying about is"},{"startTime":8744.733,"endTime":8746.933,"body":"what I have to worry about, which is I"},{"startTime":8746.933,"endTime":8749.399,"body":"wonder if that vaccination five years"},{"startTime":8749.399,"endTime":8752.233,"body":"from now because really the anti-vaxxers,"},{"startTime":8752.233,"endTime":8754.866,"body":"I think we're really just distrustful of"},{"startTime":8754.866,"endTime":8756.533,"body":"big companies and big government."},{"startTime":8757.399,"endTime":8758.466,"body":"That's never wrong."},{"startTime":8759.233,"endTime":8761.566,"body":"It's never wrong to distrust government."},{"startTime":8762.266,"endTime":8763.366,"body":"It's never wrong to"},{"startTime":8763.366,"endTime":8764.766,"body":"distrust big companies."},{"startTime":8765.766,"endTime":8765.966,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8766.466,"endTime":8768.366,"body":"So if you just took the position, let's"},{"startTime":8768.366,"endTime":8769.066,"body":"just distrust"},{"startTime":8769.066,"endTime":8770.366,"body":"everything the government did."},{"startTime":8770.866,"endTime":8771.333,"body":"Well, you won."},{"startTime":8772.633,"endTime":8773.166,"body":"You won."},{"startTime":8774.033,"endTime":8775.933,"body":"You won completely."},{"startTime":8776.966,"endTime":8778.633,"body":"I did not end up in the right place."},{"startTime":8780.533,"endTime":8781.033,"body":"Agree?"},{"startTime":8781.933,"endTime":8783.299,"body":"You would all agree with that, right?"},{"startTime":8783.833,"endTime":8785.766,"body":"I did not end up in the right place."},{"startTime":8786.733,"endTime":8788.666,"body":"The right place would be natural"},{"startTime":8788.666,"endTime":8790.466,"body":"immunity, no vaccination."},{"startTime":8792.133,"endTime":8793.5,"body":"You should take victory"},{"startTime":8793.5,"endTime":8795.433,"body":"and I should take defeat."},{"startTime":8796.333,"endTime":8797.5,"body":"We can agree on that, right?"},{"startTime":8798.366,"endTime":8801.666,"body":"That my position is now the weakest and"},{"startTime":8801.666,"endTime":8803.466,"body":"your position has gone from the weakest"},{"startTime":8803.466,"endTime":8805.566,"body":"to the strongest and that"},{"startTime":8805.566,"endTime":8807.166,"body":"we can just say, that's true."},{"startTime":8808.233,"endTime":8809.799,"body":"The people who didn't give acts are"},{"startTime":8809.799,"endTime":8811.333,"body":"absolutely in the winning position."},{"startTime":8814.366,"endTime":8814.833,"body":"You win."},{"startTime":8815.966,"endTime":8816.633,"body":"You win."},{"startTime":8817.466,"endTime":8818.333,"body":"You are the winners."},{"startTime":8819.366,"endTime":8820.366,"body":"You are the winners."},{"startTime":8821.333,"endTime":8821.466,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":8821.466,"endTime":8824.333,"body":"Let me say that part with no ambiguity."},{"startTime":8825.166,"endTime":8825.666,"body":"You won."},{"startTime":8826.566,"endTime":8826.866,"body":"You won."},{"startTime":8829.6,"endTime":8831.366,"body":"All of my fancy"},{"startTime":8831.366,"endTime":8833.733,"body":"analytics got me to a bad place."},{"startTime":8833.766,"endTime":8836.533,"body":"All of your heuristics"},{"startTime":8836.533,"endTime":8838.433,"body":"don't trust these guys."},{"startTime":8838.433,"endTime":8839.133,"body":"It's obvious."},{"startTime":8839.133,"endTime":8840.6,"body":"Totally worked."},{"startTime":8843.766,"endTime":8844.166,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":8844.166,"endTime":8845.366,"body":"Now a couple of things about that."},{"startTime":8845.366,"endTime":8846.233,"body":"One, it's obviously"},{"startTime":8846.233,"endTime":8847.833,"body":"not a continuous clip."},{"startTime":8849.566,"endTime":8855.266,"body":"So when that happened, when Scott said"},{"startTime":8855.266,"endTime":8859.166,"body":"that on his show, it rubbed a lot of us"},{"startTime":8859.166,"endTime":8862.866,"body":"who had been against and skeptical of and"},{"startTime":8862.866,"endTime":8865.2,"body":"concerned about the COVID vaccines the"},{"startTime":8865.2,"endTime":8866.333,"body":"wrong way because..."},{"startTime":8866.333,"endTime":8869.766,"body":"Well, I mean, it allows him that he did"},{"startTime":8869.766,"endTime":8873.233,"body":"analysis and grants the win to people"},{"startTime":8873.233,"endTime":8875.133,"body":"whom he claims did no analysis at all."},{"startTime":8875.366,"endTime":8875.733,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8875.733,"endTime":8877.333,"body":"Which is exactly not what happened."},{"startTime":8877.666,"endTime":8878.5,"body":"Now, I'm not saying..."},{"startTime":8878.833,"endTime":8879.666,"body":"There were contrarians"},{"startTime":8879.666,"endTime":8880.799,"body":"and they were faithful."},{"startTime":8881.866,"endTime":8883.666,"body":"And so there were people on both sides"},{"startTime":8883.666,"endTime":8885.166,"body":"who just did the thing because that's"},{"startTime":8885.166,"endTime":8886.766,"body":"what the team did or just did the thing"},{"startTime":8886.766,"endTime":8888.066,"body":"because I will always do the"},{"startTime":8888.1,"endTime":8889.766,"body":"opposite of whatever X does."},{"startTime":8890.233,"endTime":8891.299,"body":"But there are also people"},{"startTime":8891.299,"endTime":8892.766,"body":"doing analysis on both sides."},{"startTime":8893.1,"endTime":8893.299,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":8893.766,"endTime":8896.399,"body":"Now, I do appreciate that he went..."},{"startTime":8896.666,"endTime":8899.266,"body":"I mean, he went too far out of his way,"},{"startTime":8899.266,"endTime":8905.433,"body":"in my opinion, here to accept defeat and"},{"startTime":8905.433,"endTime":8907.166,"body":"to award victory to"},{"startTime":8907.166,"endTime":8908.533,"body":"those who disagreed with him."},{"startTime":8908.866,"endTime":8910.166,"body":"That's not really the point."},{"startTime":8910.166,"endTime":8910.833,"body":"The point is..."},{"startTime":8911.133,"endTime":8915.166,"body":"And Scott was very careful about the"},{"startTime":8915.166,"endTime":8917.366,"body":"lesson of this, that, and the other."},{"startTime":8917.366,"endTime":8919.2,"body":"If you read what he's written, if you"},{"startTime":8919.2,"endTime":8921.233,"body":"listen to the way he spoke, his"},{"startTime":8921.233,"endTime":8924.433,"body":"particular brand of genius involved"},{"startTime":8924.866,"endTime":8928.899,"body":"analyzing things dispassionately and"},{"startTime":8928.899,"endTime":8933.066,"body":"proceeding from them with a sophisticated"},{"startTime":8933.066,"endTime":8934.333,"body":"waiting and all of that."},{"startTime":8934.833,"endTime":8936.966,"body":"Anyway, he did things that,"},{"startTime":8938.066,"endTime":8942.166,"body":"in my opinion, actually likely changed"},{"startTime":8942.166,"endTime":8945.266,"body":"history, his embrace of Trump back before"},{"startTime":8945.266,"endTime":8948.866,"body":"many people in the public eye were doing"},{"startTime":8948.866,"endTime":8950.899,"body":"that was, I think, pivotal."},{"startTime":8951.466,"endTime":8957.133,"body":"But in any case, it's striking that he"},{"startTime":8957.133,"endTime":8959.866,"body":"says that those of us who resisted these"},{"startTime":8959.866,"endTime":8963.366,"body":"shots don't have to worry about what he"},{"startTime":8963.366,"endTime":8964.566,"body":"now has to worry about."},{"startTime":8964.566,"endTime":8965.133,"body":"And that, of course,"},{"startTime":8965.399,"endTime":8966.866,"body":"rings in many of our ears."},{"startTime":8966.866,"endTime":8967.566,"body":"It's less than five"},{"startTime":8967.633,"endTime":8969.133,"body":"years since that clip."},{"startTime":8969.7,"endTime":8969.899,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":8970.166,"endTime":8970.966,"body":"And he's gone."},{"startTime":8971.966,"endTime":8974.233,"body":"And not only has he gone, but he's gone"},{"startTime":8974.233,"endTime":8979.033,"body":"of something that has skyrocketed in the"},{"startTime":8979.033,"endTime":8981.533,"body":"aftermath of the vaccine campaign, which"},{"startTime":8981.533,"endTime":8984.066,"body":"is these rapidly developing cancers."},{"startTime":8984.533,"endTime":8985.166,"body":"Aggressive cancers."},{"startTime":8985.833,"endTime":8986.133,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8986.5,"endTime":8988.333,"body":"So anyway, I think this is tragic."},{"startTime":8988.633,"endTime":8991.7,"body":"And I think the reason that I'm going"},{"startTime":8991.7,"endTime":8995.633,"body":"down this road is in light of who Scott"},{"startTime":8995.633,"endTime":9000.533,"body":"was, I believe he would want us to do"},{"startTime":9001.666,"endTime":9002.433,"body":"the analysis."},{"startTime":9002.866,"endTime":9004.166,"body":"And the analysis is not definitive."},{"startTime":9004.466,"endTime":9007.2,"body":"It's quite possible that he had some"},{"startTime":9007.2,"endTime":9010.333,"body":"cancer that was unrelated to the shots."},{"startTime":9010.333,"endTime":9013.133,"body":"But it is also quite plausible that his,"},{"startTime":9013.433,"endTime":9015.366,"body":"what he describes as the analytics and"},{"startTime":9015.366,"endTime":9018.933,"body":"the rejection of the reflexive resistance"},{"startTime":9018.933,"endTime":9020.733,"body":"to the shots that he saw in"},{"startTime":9020.733,"endTime":9023.299,"body":"his opponents cost him his life."},{"startTime":9025.533,"endTime":9028.166,"body":"He was somebody who said very clearly"},{"startTime":9028.166,"endTime":9031.033,"body":"that he had almost no regrets in life."},{"startTime":9031.766,"endTime":9033.766,"body":"If we had gotten to the conversation, I"},{"startTime":9033.766,"endTime":9034.733,"body":"would have asked him if"},{"startTime":9034.733,"endTime":9036.533,"body":"this one was different."},{"startTime":9036.933,"endTime":9040.666,"body":"But anyway, I think what I would hope is"},{"startTime":9040.666,"endTime":9042.866,"body":"that A, we could see the kind"},{"startTime":9042.866,"endTime":9044.566,"body":"of guy that Scott was there."},{"startTime":9044.566,"endTime":9048.566,"body":"He was trying in his own way to"},{"startTime":9048.566,"endTime":9050.966,"body":"acknowledge his opponents."},{"startTime":9051.266,"endTime":9054.233,"body":"He was saying good game to those of us"},{"startTime":9054.233,"endTime":9056.266,"body":"who had vehemently disagreed with him at"},{"startTime":9056.266,"endTime":9059.233,"body":"the time, but his particular"},{"startTime":9059.233,"endTime":9062.066,"body":"understanding of what had happened is"},{"startTime":9062.066,"endTime":9065.399,"body":"incorrect and unfair to those of us who"},{"startTime":9065.399,"endTime":9068.233,"body":"were actually doing our own analysis and"},{"startTime":9068.233,"endTime":9069.899,"body":"came out on the other side and tried to"},{"startTime":9069.899,"endTime":9072.233,"body":"convince Scott of that analysis."},{"startTime":9073.033,"endTime":9074.6,"body":"And yes, we did turn out to be right."},{"startTime":9075.7,"endTime":9078.366,"body":"As you say, the"},{"startTime":9078.366,"endTime":9081.233,"body":"reflexive people do exist, right?"},{"startTime":9081.233,"endTime":9083.233,"body":"There were lots of contrarians and I've"},{"startTime":9083.233,"endTime":9086.633,"body":"said multiple times, there are lots of"},{"startTime":9086.633,"endTime":9088.766,"body":"people whose track record is essentially"},{"startTime":9088.766,"endTime":9091.233,"body":"perfect with respect to COVID, but it"},{"startTime":9091.233,"endTime":9093.1,"body":"doesn't imply anything about what they"},{"startTime":9093.1,"endTime":9095.266,"body":"know beyond simple distrust."},{"startTime":9095.933,"endTime":9097.566,"body":"And so because the system"},{"startTime":9097.566,"endTime":9100.2,"body":"was so reliably wrong on every"},{"startTime":9100.2,"endTime":9101.533,"body":"count, it was the inverse."},{"startTime":9102.166,"endTime":9103.5,"body":"They told you the inverse of what you"},{"startTime":9103.5,"endTime":9104.666,"body":"should do if you did the opposite."},{"startTime":9105.1,"endTime":9108.166,"body":"So Adams is right that if you only were"},{"startTime":9108.166,"endTime":9109.866,"body":"using heuristics, you landed on this"},{"startTime":9109.866,"endTime":9112.866,"body":"point, but that does not mean that all of"},{"startTime":9112.866,"endTime":9116.066,"body":"us, I don't even know most of us, but it"},{"startTime":9116.066,"endTime":9117.333,"body":"certainly doesn't mean that all of us"},{"startTime":9117.333,"endTime":9118.533,"body":"were only using heuristics."},{"startTime":9118.766,"endTime":9119.6,"body":"There are obviously"},{"startTime":9119.6,"endTime":9120.733,"body":"many of us who were not"},{"startTime":9120.733,"endTime":9121.333,"body":"correct."},{"startTime":9122.0,"endTime":9125.1,"body":"And what we do next time, this is now a"},{"startTime":9125.133,"endTime":9127.166,"body":"challenging problem because once you've"},{"startTime":9127.166,"endTime":9131.066,"body":"seen the institutional structure tell you"},{"startTime":9131.066,"endTime":9132.5,"body":"the exact inverse of what you're supposed"},{"startTime":9132.5,"endTime":9135.133,"body":"to do, it is now harder to think"},{"startTime":9135.133,"endTime":9137.633,"body":"independently about each thing, right?"},{"startTime":9139.266,"endTime":9139.299,"body":"But"},{"startTime":9142.233,"endTime":9145.066,"body":"that's a haunting clip to me now because"},{"startTime":9145.066,"endTime":9149.733,"body":"I do personally, I do suspect that the"},{"startTime":9149.733,"endTime":9151.6,"body":"shots probably cost him his life, that"},{"startTime":9151.6,"endTime":9154.133,"body":"decision, that particular analysis for a"},{"startTime":9154.133,"endTime":9155.399,"body":"guy who was very analytical, that"},{"startTime":9155.399,"endTime":9158.166,"body":"particular analysis may have been fatal."},{"startTime":9158.7,"endTime":9159.733,"body":"And I do think that"},{"startTime":9159.733,"endTime":9162.899,"body":"there's a general thread."},{"startTime":9164.466,"endTime":9169.333,"body":"COVID briefly woke people up because in"},{"startTime":9169.333,"endTime":9171.533,"body":"general, you have a political"},{"startTime":9171.533,"endTime":9173.533,"body":"perspective, you vote based on it."},{"startTime":9173.966,"endTime":9175.799,"body":"It's very hard to tell what"},{"startTime":9175.799,"endTime":9177.7,"body":"in your life is different."},{"startTime":9179.2,"endTime":9182.266,"body":"If we parachuted you into your life two"},{"startTime":9182.266,"endTime":9184.566,"body":"years after an election without your"},{"startTime":9184.566,"endTime":9186.166,"body":"knowledge of who had won and we said,"},{"startTime":9186.166,"endTime":9187.966,"body":"okay, now look at your life, tell me who"},{"startTime":9187.966,"endTime":9189.1,"body":"won, you wouldn't know."},{"startTime":9190.633,"endTime":9192.533,"body":"But in the case of the COVID shots, your"},{"startTime":9192.533,"endTime":9195.6,"body":"political belief, those damn anti-vaxxers"},{"startTime":9195.6,"endTime":9196.866,"body":"are killing grandma."},{"startTime":9198.933,"endTime":9202.366,"body":"Well, if you had that belief,"},{"startTime":9204.1,"endTime":9204.899,"body":"it had a material"},{"startTime":9204.899,"endTime":9206.399,"body":"impact on your physiology."},{"startTime":9206.933,"endTime":9208.133,"body":"It's not certain that it"},{"startTime":9208.133,"endTime":9209.733,"body":"did, but in many cases it did."},{"startTime":9209.933,"endTime":9211.433,"body":"So lots of people either experienced"},{"startTime":9211.433,"endTime":9213.633,"body":"something or saw something in people,"},{"startTime":9213.633,"endTime":9214.766,"body":"other people who had taken them."},{"startTime":9215.466,"endTime":9217.166,"body":"And it was that moment at which you"},{"startTime":9217.166,"endTime":9218.866,"body":"realize, oh, wait a second, those"},{"startTime":9218.866,"endTime":9221.033,"body":"impassioned beliefs that I'm getting from"},{"startTime":9221.033,"endTime":9223.933,"body":"my newspaper actually put"},{"startTime":9223.933,"endTime":9226.166,"body":"my life in jeopardy, right?"},{"startTime":9226.166,"endTime":9226.966,"body":"So that's an"},{"startTime":9226.966,"endTime":9228.399,"body":"important thing to recognize."},{"startTime":9228.733,"endTime":9229.633,"body":"And unfortunately,"},{"startTime":9231.2,"endTime":9234.533,"body":"the outpouring of love for Scott before"},{"startTime":9234.533,"endTime":9237.233,"body":"his death and after was, I think..."},{"startTime":9237.633,"endTime":9238.633,"body":"Except for the New York Times."},{"startTime":9239.833,"endTime":9241.533,"body":"Right, which slandered him."},{"startTime":9241.866,"endTime":9244.399,"body":"But that outpouring was about something."},{"startTime":9244.966,"endTime":9248.433,"body":"People saw that Scott cared about them in"},{"startTime":9248.433,"endTime":9250.366,"body":"a strange way, but he cared about people."},{"startTime":9250.899,"endTime":9253.899,"body":"He talked about basically essentially"},{"startTime":9253.899,"endTime":9255.566,"body":"giving himself over to"},{"startTime":9255.566,"endTime":9257.766,"body":"people, trying to be useful."},{"startTime":9257.766,"endTime":9259.266,"body":"He talked about this in his final note."},{"startTime":9260.366,"endTime":9264.033,"body":"And I think it is important that we at"},{"startTime":9264.033,"endTime":9265.166,"body":"least have in our"},{"startTime":9265.166,"endTime":9267.5,"body":"minds the question open."},{"startTime":9268.433,"endTime":9272.633,"body":"Did we watch somebody do the analysis on"},{"startTime":9272.633,"endTime":9276.666,"body":"a literal whiteboard in front of us, come"},{"startTime":9276.666,"endTime":9279.133,"body":"to a conclusion, and then pay the"},{"startTime":9279.133,"endTime":9280.5,"body":"ultimate price over it?"},{"startTime":9280.5,"endTime":9282.299,"body":"I'm not saying that did happen, but I'm"},{"startTime":9282.299,"endTime":9284.966,"body":"saying it's probable enough that that"},{"startTime":9284.966,"endTime":9288.966,"body":"example ought to remain in our minds next"},{"startTime":9288.966,"endTime":9292.866,"body":"time we find ourselves arguing over some"},{"startTime":9292.866,"endTime":9294.633,"body":"medical technology that shouldn't be"},{"startTime":9294.633,"endTime":9296.233,"body":"political, but obviously is."},{"startTime":9297.1,"endTime":9298.133,"body":"Very good."},{"startTime":9299.133,"endTime":9299.366,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":9300.433,"endTime":9301.066,"body":"It's a big loss."},{"startTime":9301.566,"endTime":9302.766,"body":"Yeah, it really is a big loss."},{"startTime":9303.633,"endTime":9306.633,"body":"And I was heartened to see"},{"startTime":9306.633,"endTime":9309.899,"body":"the reaction that people had."},{"startTime":9310.399,"endTime":9312.433,"body":"Scott paid a big price for"},{"startTime":9314.566,"endTime":9315.733,"body":"saying things out loud."},{"startTime":9316.566,"endTime":9318.066,"body":"We didn't always agree with him."},{"startTime":9318.066,"endTime":9320.966,"body":"I took him to task over what he had said"},{"startTime":9322.566,"endTime":9325.333,"body":"in a previous episode, but it was nice to"},{"startTime":9325.333,"endTime":9327.166,"body":"see how many people he had been"},{"startTime":9327.166,"endTime":9329.533,"body":"meaningful to, and he'll be"},{"startTime":9329.533,"endTime":9331.066,"body":"missed and he won't be forgotten."},{"startTime":9332.133,"endTime":9332.533,"body":"Yes, he will."},{"startTime":9333.066,"endTime":9333.866,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":9333.866,"endTime":9335.333,"body":"Well, I think that that"},{"startTime":9335.333,"endTime":9337.1,"body":"brings us to the end for today."},{"startTime":9337.7,"endTime":9340.466,"body":"We will be doing a Q and A"},{"startTime":9340.466,"endTime":9341.966,"body":"on Locals tomorrow at 11 a.m."},{"startTime":9341.966,"endTime":9343.2,"body":"Pacific for a couple hours."},{"startTime":9343.2,"endTime":9344.266,"body":"Join us on Locals."},{"startTime":9344.266,"endTime":9346.166,"body":"You can join us on Locals right now and"},{"startTime":9346.166,"endTime":9347.066,"body":"ask a question that"},{"startTime":9347.066,"endTime":9348.799,"body":"we'll try to get to tomorrow."},{"startTime":9349.366,"endTime":9352.566,"body":"We'll be back next Wednesday with our"},{"startTime":9352.566,"endTime":9355.566,"body":"next evolutionary lens."},{"startTime":9355.633,"endTime":9357.2,"body":"Check out our sponsors this week."},{"startTime":9357.2,"endTime":9358.066,"body":"They were Sauna Space,"},{"startTime":9358.7,"endTime":9360.1,"body":"Masa Chips, and Clear."},{"startTime":9360.1,"endTime":9362.466,"body":"That's Clear with an XLEAR."},{"startTime":9362.833,"endTime":9364.266,"body":"Awesome products all."},{"startTime":9365.799,"endTime":9368.066,"body":"And a recognition again that we're"},{"startTime":9368.066,"endTime":9369.666,"body":"supported by you and we appreciate you."},{"startTime":9369.866,"endTime":9372.233,"body":"We thank you for being here and for"},{"startTime":9372.233,"endTime":9374.066,"body":"appreciating what we're doing and for"},{"startTime":9374.066,"endTime":9376.333,"body":"sharing when you feel like it"},{"startTime":9376.333,"endTime":9377.866,"body":"what we're doing with others."},{"startTime":9378.833,"endTime":9381.166,"body":"And until you see us next time, be good"},{"startTime":9381.166,"endTime":9382.633,"body":"to the ones you love, eat"},{"startTime":9382.633,"endTime":9384.433,"body":"good food, and get outside."},{"startTime":9384.833,"endTime":9385.399,"body":"Be well, everyone."}]}