{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"startTime":3600.033,"endTime":3603.233,"body":"(Music)"},{"startTime":3604.666,"endTime":3605.866,"body":"Hey folks, welcome to"},{"startTime":3605.866,"endTime":3607.099,"body":"the DarkHorse Podcast."},{"startTime":3607.533,"endTime":3610.4,"body":"Livestream number three."},{"startTime":3611.533,"endTime":3612.5,"body":"I should know."},{"startTime":3612.5,"endTime":3613.433,"body":"Are we whispering today?"},{"startTime":3613.766,"endTime":3614.566,"body":"No, we're not whispering."},{"startTime":3614.933,"endTime":3616.933,"body":"I'm struggling because we had a very good"},{"startTime":3616.933,"endTime":3618.833,"body":"discussion about the last episode number,"},{"startTime":3618.833,"endTime":3620.966,"body":"but it doesn't actually come to mind."},{"startTime":3621.333,"endTime":3621.599,"body":"Three twelve."},{"startTime":3621.833,"endTime":3622.533,"body":"Three twelve."},{"startTime":3622.966,"endTime":3624.466,"body":"Well, then that means I'm Dr."},{"startTime":3624.466,"endTime":3624.833,"body":"Bret Weinstein."},{"startTime":3625.199,"endTime":3625.733,"body":"You are Dr."},{"startTime":3625.733,"endTime":3626.266,"body":"Heather Heying."},{"startTime":3626.566,"endTime":3627.4,"body":"It means no such thing."},{"startTime":3628.366,"endTime":3632.766,"body":"It follows that we would be those people"},{"startTime":3632.766,"endTime":3634.466,"body":"in light of the fact that this is the"},{"startTime":3634.466,"endTime":3635.833,"body":"DarkHorse Podcast livestream."},{"startTime":3635.833,"endTime":3636.533,"body":"There it is."},{"startTime":3636.533,"endTime":3636.966,"body":"There it is."},{"startTime":3637.166,"endTime":3639.033,"body":"And I will say I'm reminded."},{"startTime":3640.033,"endTime":3641.233,"body":"It is the evolutionary lens."},{"startTime":3641.866,"endTime":3644.3,"body":"I'm reminded of a quote that I looked up"},{"startTime":3644.3,"endTime":3646.866,"body":"and was slightly surprised to discover is"},{"startTime":3646.866,"endTime":3649.166,"body":"attributed to Vladimir Lenin, but"},{"startTime":3649.166,"endTime":3650.433,"body":"nonetheless, it applies."},{"startTime":3652.666,"endTime":3653.766,"body":"I see you backing away."},{"startTime":3654.733,"endTime":3656.666,"body":"The quote is to the effect."},{"startTime":3656.733,"endTime":3657.833,"body":"No doubt it was not in English"},{"startTime":3657.833,"endTime":3659.266,"body":"originally, if it's really Lenin."},{"startTime":3659.466,"endTime":3663.133,"body":"But the quote is something like some"},{"startTime":3663.133,"endTime":3665.266,"body":"decades nothing happens and"},{"startTime":3665.266,"endTime":3667.433,"body":"some weeks a decade happens."},{"startTime":3669.266,"endTime":3672.033,"body":"I feel like it has"},{"startTime":3672.033,"endTime":3673.699,"body":"been one of those weeks."},{"startTime":3673.966,"endTime":3677.199,"body":"There is so much stuff that I am"},{"startTime":3677.199,"endTime":3680.199,"body":"overwhelmed trying to understand it."},{"startTime":3681.033,"endTime":3684.166,"body":"And this is complicated because you've"},{"startTime":3684.166,"endTime":3686.3,"body":"been away doing other things."},{"startTime":3686.666,"endTime":3689.599,"body":"I was in Texas visiting my oldest friend,"},{"startTime":3689.599,"endTime":3691.866,"body":"her husband, about an hour outside of"},{"startTime":3691.866,"endTime":3693.433,"body":"Austin and was basically completely"},{"startTime":3693.433,"endTime":3696.233,"body":"offline for several days, which was"},{"startTime":3696.233,"endTime":3697.766,"body":"pleasant to say the least."},{"startTime":3699.733,"endTime":3700.333,"body":"I mean, you were dealing"},{"startTime":3700.333,"endTime":3701.733,"body":"with significant issues."},{"startTime":3702.133,"endTime":3702.699,"body":"Absolutely."},{"startTime":3702.699,"endTime":3703.633,"body":"They weren't online."},{"startTime":3703.633,"endTime":3703.833,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":3704.133,"endTime":3704.8,"body":"The wildlife."},{"startTime":3706.066,"endTime":3707.599,"body":"Yes, it was so cold."},{"startTime":3707.599,"endTime":3709.3,"body":"It was actually so cold in Central Texas"},{"startTime":3709.3,"endTime":3714.233,"body":"that we had to move their flock of 31, I"},{"startTime":3714.233,"endTime":3716.266,"body":"think, chickens from their usual coops"},{"startTime":3716.266,"endTime":3719.199,"body":"into a barn that they could heat."},{"startTime":3719.566,"endTime":3722.033,"body":"And so I got to carry chickens, but I"},{"startTime":3722.033,"endTime":3722.966,"body":"also saw armadillos."},{"startTime":3723.433,"endTime":3723.633,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":3723.766,"endTime":3724.199,"body":"Pretty great."},{"startTime":3724.199,"endTime":3724.966,"body":"Which is pretty great."},{"startTime":3724.966,"endTime":3726.833,"body":"It's been decades since I've seen an"},{"startTime":3726.833,"endTime":3727.966,"body":"armadillo and I would like"},{"startTime":3727.966,"endTime":3728.866,"body":"to have seen an armadillo."},{"startTime":3729.066,"endTime":3730.4,"body":"Yeah, they're not the"},{"startTime":3730.4,"endTime":3731.199,"body":"brightest of mammals."},{"startTime":3731.666,"endTime":3732.633,"body":"That's not their strong suit."},{"startTime":3732.633,"endTime":3734.4,"body":"I must say I was walking."},{"startTime":3734.966,"endTime":3736.466,"body":"I was actually on the phone with our son,"},{"startTime":3736.466,"endTime":3739.133,"body":"our son Zach at one point and walking and"},{"startTime":3739.133,"endTime":3740.666,"body":"sort of came up short."},{"startTime":3740.666,"endTime":3742.066,"body":"So I get that is the back end of an"},{"startTime":3742.066,"endTime":3744.566,"body":"armadillo trying to get into a hole by a"},{"startTime":3744.566,"endTime":3747.3,"body":"stump and the armadillo was panicking,"},{"startTime":3747.333,"endTime":3748.866,"body":"panicking, panicking, and then clearly"},{"startTime":3748.866,"endTime":3750.033,"body":"decided that it had achieved"},{"startTime":3750.033,"endTime":3751.666,"body":"its goal of becoming invisible."},{"startTime":3752.5,"endTime":3753.9,"body":"Two-thirds of the armadillo was still"},{"startTime":3753.9,"endTime":3756.466,"body":"patently visible and it was still even"},{"startTime":3756.466,"endTime":3757.766,"body":"like shaking its butt a little bit."},{"startTime":3757.766,"endTime":3760.033,"body":"Yes, they are, as you say, not the"},{"startTime":3760.033,"endTime":3762.233,"body":"brightest animals and in my experience,"},{"startTime":3762.233,"endTime":3763.866,"body":"their vision isn't so good either."},{"startTime":3764.866,"endTime":3769.533,"body":"Yeah, later by our friend Mike's hives."},{"startTime":3769.533,"endTime":3771.099,"body":"He's a bee guy."},{"startTime":3771.133,"endTime":3773.166,"body":"He's actually he picks the most amazing"},{"startTime":3773.166,"endTime":3775.4,"body":"honey out of Bastrop County in Texas and"},{"startTime":3775.4,"endTime":3778.233,"body":"hit the bees make the most amazing honey"},{"startTime":3778.233,"endTime":3779.066,"body":"and he facilitates"},{"startTime":3779.066,"endTime":3780.066,"body":"their making of the honey."},{"startTime":3781.033,"endTime":3784.566,"body":"But I saw I was walking near them and an"},{"startTime":3784.566,"endTime":3787.466,"body":"armadillo came running towards me as if I"},{"startTime":3787.466,"endTime":3788.766,"body":"wasn't there and it's not that they"},{"startTime":3788.766,"endTime":3789.599,"body":"aren't scared of apes."},{"startTime":3789.833,"endTime":3790.5,"body":"They are right."},{"startTime":3790.766,"endTime":3792.133,"body":"He did not see me."},{"startTime":3792.133,"endTime":3794.033,"body":"He or she metaphorically speaking when"},{"startTime":3794.033,"endTime":3796.666,"body":"God invented the armadillo, he quickly"},{"startTime":3796.666,"endTime":3798.4,"body":"realized it was going to need some ARMRA."},{"startTime":3799.4,"endTime":3801.466,"body":"Yeah, or to protect it from itself."},{"startTime":3801.766,"endTime":3801.933,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":3801.933,"endTime":3802.733,"body":"Or some bad instincts."},{"startTime":3803.033,"endTime":3804.333,"body":"Yes, it was going to have some run-ins"},{"startTime":3804.333,"endTime":3806.633,"body":"and it needed a plan B rather than just"},{"startTime":3806.633,"endTime":3808.366,"body":"escaping based on its"},{"startTime":3808.366,"endTime":3811.333,"body":"insight into the world or speed."},{"startTime":3811.9,"endTime":3812.099,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":3813.033,"endTime":3813.233,"body":"Well,"},{"startTime":3814.333,"endTime":3815.733,"body":"yeah, actually, I know"},{"startTime":3815.733,"endTime":3818.3,"body":"let's pay the rent up top."},{"startTime":3818.733,"endTime":3819.766,"body":"Let's do the"},{"startTime":3819.766,"endTime":3821.9,"body":"top-of-the-hour ads as we always do."},{"startTime":3821.933,"endTime":3827.866,"body":"Three sponsors whom we very much like and"},{"startTime":3827.866,"endTime":3830.366,"body":"that's why you hear us reading the ads"},{"startTime":3830.366,"endTime":3831.866,"body":"right now and then we'll get into some of"},{"startTime":3831.866,"endTime":3832.4,"body":"the heart of the matter."},{"startTime":3832.866,"endTime":3833.066,"body":"Totally."},{"startTime":3833.433,"endTime":3833.633,"body":"Totally."},{"startTime":3835.233,"endTime":3835.666,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":3835.666,"endTime":3837.933,"body":"I'm going to do my best at reading not"},{"startTime":3837.933,"endTime":3839.8,"body":"always a strong suit, but we'll see."},{"startTime":3840.8,"endTime":3842.933,"body":"Our first sponsor Heather is CrowdHealth"},{"startTime":3842.933,"endTime":3844.599,"body":"and CrowdHealth isn't insurance."},{"startTime":3844.933,"endTime":3846.433,"body":"It's better as you will know."},{"startTime":3847.033,"endTime":3848.933,"body":"Health insurance in the United States is"},{"startTime":3848.933,"endTime":3850.933,"body":"a mess to put it mildly from overpriced"},{"startTime":3850.933,"endTime":3852.9,"body":"premiums to confusing fine print endless"},{"startTime":3853.033,"endTime":3854.733,"body":"paperwork claims that don't get paid"},{"startTime":3854.733,"endTime":3855.733,"body":"customer service that"},{"startTime":3855.733,"endTime":3857.0,"body":"is unhelpful and hostile."},{"startTime":3857.599,"endTime":3859.166,"body":"These complicated systems aren't"},{"startTime":3859.166,"endTime":3860.566,"body":"functional and they wear us down."},{"startTime":3861.466,"endTime":3862.366,"body":"We used to contend with"},{"startTime":3862.366,"endTime":3863.699,"body":"this madness, but not anymore."},{"startTime":3864.099,"endTime":3866.366,"body":"There is a better way you can stop"},{"startTime":3866.366,"endTime":3868.033,"body":"playing the rigged insurance game."},{"startTime":3868.033,"endTime":3869.699,"body":"You can have CrowdHealth instead."},{"startTime":3870.3,"endTime":3872.166,"body":"CrowdHealth is a community of people"},{"startTime":3872.166,"endTime":3873.066,"body":"funding each other's"},{"startTime":3873.066,"endTime":3874.366,"body":"medical bills directly."},{"startTime":3874.366,"endTime":3875.466,"body":"No middlemen, no networks,"},{"startTime":3875.666,"endTime":3877.9,"body":"no nonsense with CrowdHealth."},{"startTime":3877.933,"endTime":3880.266,"body":"You get health care for under $100 for"},{"startTime":3880.266,"endTime":3882.966,"body":"your first three months, including access"},{"startTime":3882.966,"endTime":3885.0,"body":"to a team of health bill negotiators,"},{"startTime":3885.233,"endTime":3887.333,"body":"low-cost prescriptions and lab testing"},{"startTime":3887.333,"endTime":3889.466,"body":"protocols and a database of low-cost"},{"startTime":3889.533,"endTime":3891.133,"body":"high-quality doctors"},{"startTime":3891.133,"endTime":3892.3,"body":"vetted by CrowdHealth."},{"startTime":3892.5,"endTime":3894.533,"body":"And if something major happens, you pay"},{"startTime":3894.533,"endTime":3897.933,"body":"the first $500 and then the crowd steps"},{"startTime":3897.933,"endTime":3899.199,"body":"in to help fund the rest."},{"startTime":3900.233,"endTime":3902.699,"body":"It feels like the options we used to have"},{"startTime":3902.699,"endTime":3904.733,"body":"before Obamacare messed everything up."},{"startTime":3905.266,"endTime":3907.166,"body":"After we left our salary jobs as college"},{"startTime":3907.166,"endTime":3908.833,"body":"professors, we spent years buying health"},{"startTime":3908.833,"endTime":3909.933,"body":"insurance in the marketplace."},{"startTime":3910.4,"endTime":3910.966,"body":"It was awful."},{"startTime":3911.566,"endTime":3913.633,"body":"Our family of four had health insurance"},{"startTime":3913.633,"endTime":3915.4,"body":"for emergencies only and we were paying"},{"startTime":3915.4,"endTime":3918.066,"body":"more than $1,500 a month for a policy"},{"startTime":3918.066,"endTime":3921.333,"body":"with a $17,000 annual deductible to a"},{"startTime":3921.333,"endTime":3922.433,"body":"company that was"},{"startTime":3922.433,"endTime":3923.733,"body":"unresponsive and unhelpful."},{"startTime":3923.966,"endTime":3925.599,"body":"Tens of thousands of dollars paid out for"},{"startTime":3925.599,"endTime":3926.666,"body":"no benefit whatsoever."},{"startTime":3927.266,"endTime":3929.233,"body":"Heather went looking for alternatives and"},{"startTime":3929.233,"endTime":3930.033,"body":"she found CrowdHealth."},{"startTime":3931.133,"endTime":3932.366,"body":"We have now had two sets of great"},{"startTime":3932.366,"endTime":3933.5,"body":"experiences with CrowdHealth."},{"startTime":3933.733,"endTime":3935.333,"body":"Our younger son Toby broke his foot in"},{"startTime":3935.333,"endTime":3938.166,"body":"the summer of 2024 and Heather slipped on"},{"startTime":3938.166,"endTime":3939.033,"body":"wet concrete and split"},{"startTime":3939.033,"endTime":3940.466,"body":"her scalp open a year later."},{"startTime":3940.833,"endTime":3942.733,"body":"Both times we went to the ER and got good"},{"startTime":3942.733,"endTime":3943.833,"body":"but expensive treatment"},{"startTime":3943.833,"endTime":3944.633,"body":"from the medical staff."},{"startTime":3945.033,"endTime":3946.133,"body":"In both cases, CrowdHealth"},{"startTime":3946.133,"endTime":3947.966,"body":"paid our bills with no hassle."},{"startTime":3947.966,"endTime":3949.233,"body":"Their app was simple and straightforward"},{"startTime":3949.233,"endTime":3951.366,"body":"to use and real people who worked at"},{"startTime":3951.366,"endTime":3952.4,"body":"CrowdHealth were easy to"},{"startTime":3952.4,"endTime":3953.833,"body":"reach, clear and communicative."},{"startTime":3954.533,"endTime":3956.666,"body":"With CrowdHealth, you pay for little"},{"startTime":3956.666,"endTime":3958.566,"body":"stuff out of pocket, but any event that"},{"startTime":3958.566,"endTime":3964.266,"body":"costs more than $500, a diagnosis that"},{"startTime":3964.266,"endTime":3966.166,"body":"requires ongoing treatment, a pregnancy"},{"startTime":3966.166,"endTime":3968.4,"body":"or an accident, you pay the first $500"},{"startTime":3968.4,"endTime":3969.533,"body":"and they pay the rest."},{"startTime":3970.133,"endTime":3972.133,"body":"Seriously, it's easy, affordable and so"},{"startTime":3972.133,"endTime":3973.233,"body":"much better than health insurance."},{"startTime":3973.666,"endTime":3974.933,"body":"We can still hardly believe it."},{"startTime":3975.599,"endTime":3976.866,"body":"The health insurance system is hoping"},{"startTime":3976.866,"endTime":3978.266,"body":"you'll stay stuck in their same"},{"startTime":3978.266,"endTime":3979.966,"body":"overpriced, over complicated mess."},{"startTime":3980.466,"endTime":3980.933,"body":"Don't do it."},{"startTime":3981.666,"endTime":3983.199,"body":"This year, take your power back."},{"startTime":3983.199,"endTime":3985.733,"body":"Join CrowdHealth to get started for $99 a"},{"startTime":3985.733,"endTime":3987.166,"body":"month for your first three months using"},{"startTime":3987.166,"endTime":3988.466,"body":"the code DarkHorse at"},{"startTime":3988.466,"endTime":3990.166,"body":"joinCrowdHealth.com."},{"startTime":3990.166,"endTime":3990.366,"body":"That's"},{"startTime":3990.366,"endTime":3993.5,"body":"joinCrowdHealth.com, code DarkHorse."},{"startTime":3993.533,"endTime":3995.833,"body":"Remember CrowdHealth is not insurance opt"},{"startTime":3995.833,"endTime":3997.266,"body":"out, take your power back."},{"startTime":3997.266,"endTime":3997.933,"body":"This is how we win."},{"startTime":3998.366,"endTime":4000.166,"body":"Join CrowdHealth.com."},{"startTime":4001.199,"endTime":4003.4,"body":"Didn't quite nail it, but close."},{"startTime":4003.666,"endTime":4004.033,"body":"Wasn't bad."},{"startTime":4004.333,"endTime":4004.533,"body":"No."},{"startTime":4005.133,"endTime":4005.533,"body":"Wasn't bad."},{"startTime":4005.766,"endTime":4006.166,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":4006.166,"endTime":4008.533,"body":"Our second sponsor this week is ARMRA"},{"startTime":4008.533,"endTime":4009.466,"body":"Colostrum, an ancient"},{"startTime":4009.466,"endTime":4010.533,"body":"bioactive whole food."},{"startTime":4011.166,"endTime":4012.433,"body":"Here at DarkHorse, we talk frequently"},{"startTime":4012.433,"endTime":4013.366,"body":"about the fact that we live"},{"startTime":4013.366,"endTime":4014.566,"body":"in an age of hyper novelty."},{"startTime":4015.366,"endTime":4016.966,"body":"Humans are the most adaptable species on"},{"startTime":4016.966,"endTime":4018.766,"body":"the planet and even we can't keep up with"},{"startTime":4018.766,"endTime":4019.533,"body":"the rate of change that we"},{"startTime":4019.533,"endTime":4020.433,"body":"are enacting on ourselves."},{"startTime":4021.033,"endTime":4022.966,"body":"We are bathed in electromagnetic fields,"},{"startTime":4022.966,"endTime":4024.233,"body":"artificial light, seed oils,"},{"startTime":4024.533,"endTime":4026.133,"body":"microplastics, endocrine disruptors in"},{"startTime":4026.133,"endTime":4028.0,"body":"our air, water, food, and textiles."},{"startTime":4028.533,"endTime":4029.966,"body":"And there are a myriad other modern"},{"startTime":4029.966,"endTime":4031.533,"body":"stressors like overcrowding and having"},{"startTime":4031.533,"endTime":4032.733,"body":"too little control over"},{"startTime":4032.733,"endTime":4033.766,"body":"our own choices in life."},{"startTime":4034.433,"endTime":4035.566,"body":"Here's something you can control."},{"startTime":4036.199,"endTime":4037.233,"body":"Strengthen your immune health with a"},{"startTime":4037.233,"endTime":4038.233,"body":"bioactive whole food"},{"startTime":4038.233,"endTime":4039.3,"body":"that is ARMRA Colostrum."},{"startTime":4039.9,"endTime":4041.333,"body":"All of this hyper novelty can disrupt the"},{"startTime":4041.333,"endTime":4042.633,"body":"signals that your body relies on"},{"startTime":4042.633,"endTime":4043.866,"body":"negatively impacting gut,"},{"startTime":4043.866,"endTime":4044.933,"body":"immune, and overall health."},{"startTime":4045.533,"endTime":4046.766,"body":"ARMRA Colostrum works at the cellular"},{"startTime":4046.766,"endTime":4048.5,"body":"level to bolster your health from within."},{"startTime":4049.066,"endTime":4050.766,"body":"Colostrum is nature's first whole food,"},{"startTime":4051.166,"endTime":4052.5,"body":"helping to strengthen gut and immune"},{"startTime":4052.5,"endTime":4054.133,"body":"health and fuel performance."},{"startTime":4054.866,"endTime":4055.466,"body":"ARMRA Colostrum is"},{"startTime":4055.466,"endTime":4056.466,"body":"great add to smoothies."},{"startTime":4056.966,"endTime":4057.866,"body":"I love it with banana and"},{"startTime":4057.866,"endTime":4059.266,"body":"mint and cacao and raw milk."},{"startTime":4059.833,"endTime":4061.233,"body":"Bovine Colostrum can support a healthy"},{"startTime":4061.233,"endTime":4063.233,"body":"metabolism and strengthen gut integrity"},{"startTime":4063.233,"endTime":4065.766,"body":"and ARMRA Colostrum is a bioactive whole"},{"startTime":4065.766,"endTime":4068.099,"body":"food with over 400 functional nutrients"},{"startTime":4068.099,"endTime":4069.333,"body":"including but not limited to"},{"startTime":4069.333,"endTime":4070.166,"body":"immunoglobulins,"},{"startTime":4070.166,"endTime":4072.233,"body":"antioxidants, minerals, and prebiotics."},{"startTime":4073.166,"endTime":4074.599,"body":"ARMRA Colostrum starts with sustainably"},{"startTime":4074.599,"endTime":4076.133,"body":"sourced colostrum from grass-fed cows"},{"startTime":4076.133,"endTime":4077.833,"body":"from their coop of dairy farms in the US"},{"startTime":4077.833,"endTime":4079.566,"body":"and they source only the surplus"},{"startTime":4079.566,"endTime":4081.166,"body":"colostrum after calves are fully fed."},{"startTime":4081.866,"endTime":4083.233,"body":"Unlike most colostrums on the market"},{"startTime":4083.233,"endTime":4084.633,"body":"which use heat pasteurization that"},{"startTime":4084.633,"endTime":4086.433,"body":"depletes nutrient potency, ARMRA"},{"startTime":4086.433,"endTime":4088.433,"body":"Colostrum uses an innovative process that"},{"startTime":4088.433,"endTime":4090.566,"body":"purifies and preserves the integrity of"},{"startTime":4090.566,"endTime":4092.533,"body":"hundreds of bioactive nutrients while"},{"startTime":4092.533,"endTime":4094.166,"body":"removing calcium and fat to guarantee the"},{"startTime":4094.166,"endTime":4096.0,"body":"highest potency and bioavailability."},{"startTime":4096.833,"endTime":4098.333,"body":"The quality control is far above industry"},{"startTime":4098.333,"endTime":4099.366,"body":"standards including being"},{"startTime":4099.433,"endTime":4100.766,"body":"certified to be glyphosate free."},{"startTime":4102.066,"endTime":4103.566,"body":"People who have used ARMRA's Colostrum"},{"startTime":4103.566,"endTime":4105.866,"body":"have reported clearer skin faster and"},{"startTime":4105.866,"endTime":4106.666,"body":"thicker hair growth and"},{"startTime":4106.666,"endTime":4107.733,"body":"better mental concentration."},{"startTime":4108.433,"endTime":4109.633,"body":"In addition people using ARMRA's"},{"startTime":4109.633,"endTime":4110.866,"body":"Colostrum have noticed a decrease in"},{"startTime":4110.866,"endTime":4112.466,"body":"muscle serenity after exercise, better"},{"startTime":4112.466,"endTime":4114.166,"body":"sleep, and fewer sugar cravings."},{"startTime":4114.833,"endTime":4116.366,"body":"ARMRA Colostrum is the real deal."},{"startTime":4116.833,"endTime":4117.766,"body":"We've got a special offer"},{"startTime":4117.766,"endTime":4118.666,"body":"for the DarkHorse audience."},{"startTime":4119.199,"endTime":4120.333,"body":"Receive 30% off your"},{"startTime":4120.333,"endTime":4121.266,"body":"first subscription order."},{"startTime":4121.666,"endTime":4123.833,"body":"Go to ARMRAa.com slash DarkHorse or"},{"startTime":4123.833,"endTime":4125.866,"body":"enter DarkHorse to get 30% off your"},{"startTime":4125.866,"endTime":4127.466,"body":"first subscription order."},{"startTime":4128.166,"endTime":4131.433,"body":"That's ARMRAa.com slash DarkHorse."},{"startTime":4133.466,"endTime":4138.433,"body":"And our final sponsor."},{"startTime":4138.666,"endTime":4139.733,"body":"I'm trying to trick my computer."},{"startTime":4139.733,"endTime":4139.933,"body":"I know."},{"startTime":4140.266,"endTime":4140.566,"body":"I know."},{"startTime":4140.566,"endTime":4141.633,"body":"It's an elegant solution."},{"startTime":4141.933,"endTime":4143.666,"body":"It's there."},{"startTime":4143.866,"endTime":4145.366,"body":"There are no elegant solutions here."},{"startTime":4145.366,"endTime":4145.966,"body":"DarkHorse apparently."},{"startTime":4146.3,"endTime":4147.633,"body":"There are no elegant solutions."},{"startTime":4147.633,"endTime":4148.566,"body":"Only trade-offs."},{"startTime":4149.033,"endTime":4151.133,"body":"As Thomas Sowell says well, well, he"},{"startTime":4151.133,"endTime":4152.066,"body":"doesn't really say exactly."},{"startTime":4152.333,"endTime":4153.899,"body":"No, and I feel like we could come up with"},{"startTime":4153.899,"endTime":4154.933,"body":"elegant solutions, but"},{"startTime":4154.933,"endTime":4155.933,"body":"somehow this is a rat."},{"startTime":4155.933,"endTime":4156.933,"body":"It's probably not even a solution."},{"startTime":4157.233,"endTime":4158.966,"body":"It's probably just clergy without even"},{"startTime":4158.966,"endTime":4161.199,"body":"solving anything which you know, the"},{"startTime":4161.233,"endTime":4161.966,"body":"worst of both worlds."},{"startTime":4162.899,"endTime":4165.033,"body":"Our final sponsor."},{"startTime":4165.666,"endTime":4167.533,"body":"Got an oil in our final sponsor."},{"startTime":4167.766,"endTime":4170.766,"body":"This week is Xlear and that's Xlear a"},{"startTime":4170.766,"endTime":4171.5,"body":"nasal spray that"},{"startTime":4171.5,"endTime":4172.666,"body":"supports respiratory health."},{"startTime":4172.899,"endTime":4174.566,"body":"It's widely available online in stores"},{"startTime":4174.566,"endTime":4175.633,"body":"and both it and the company"},{"startTime":4175.633,"endTime":4176.566,"body":"that makes it are fantastic."},{"startTime":4176.833,"endTime":4180.066,"body":"It's Xlear, but it's it's spelled X L E A"},{"startTime":4180.066,"endTime":4183.1,"body":"R pronounced clear throughout history."},{"startTime":4183.1,"endTime":4184.666,"body":"Improvements in sanitation and hygiene"},{"startTime":4184.666,"endTime":4186.399,"body":"have had huge impacts on human longevity"},{"startTime":4186.399,"endTime":4188.333,"body":"and quality of life more so than"},{"startTime":4188.333,"endTime":4189.399,"body":"traditional medical advances."},{"startTime":4189.633,"endTime":4191.399,"body":"For instance, when doctors started to"},{"startTime":4191.399,"endTime":4192.666,"body":"wash their hands between handling"},{"startTime":4192.733,"endTime":4194.333,"body":"cadavers and helping women give birth,"},{"startTime":4194.333,"endTime":4196.033,"body":"which seems obvious to us today, but was"},{"startTime":4196.033,"endTime":4198.233,"body":"not then the rate of maternal deaths went"},{"startTime":4198.233,"endTime":4200.166,"body":"way down breathing, plitted air and"},{"startTime":4200.166,"endTime":4201.566,"body":"drinking tainted water have hugely"},{"startTime":4201.566,"endTime":4202.866,"body":"negative effects on human health."},{"startTime":4203.166,"endTime":4204.699,"body":"Clean up the air and water and people get"},{"startTime":4204.699,"endTime":4206.899,"body":"healthier nasal hygiene often gets"},{"startTime":4206.899,"endTime":4208.199,"body":"overlooked, but consider that the"},{"startTime":4208.199,"endTime":4209.833,"body":"majority of bacteria and viruses that"},{"startTime":4209.833,"endTime":4210.633,"body":"make us sick enter"},{"startTime":4210.633,"endTime":4211.666,"body":"through our mouth and nose."},{"startTime":4212.233,"endTime":4213.866,"body":"It has become a cultural norm to wash our"},{"startTime":4213.866,"endTime":4215.399,"body":"hands in order to help stop the spread of"},{"startTime":4215.399,"endTime":4217.3,"body":"disease from person to person, but it's"},{"startTime":4217.3,"endTime":4218.766,"body":"rare that we get sick through our hands."},{"startTime":4219.1,"endTime":4219.766,"body":"Rather we get sick"},{"startTime":4219.766,"endTime":4220.566,"body":"through our mouth and nose."},{"startTime":4220.8,"endTime":4221.933,"body":"Thus, it makes sense that we should be"},{"startTime":4221.933,"endTime":4223.266,"body":"using something that we know blocks"},{"startTime":4223.333,"endTime":4225.366,"body":"bacterial and viral adhesion in the nose"},{"startTime":4225.366,"endTime":4227.733,"body":"enter Xlear Xlear again."},{"startTime":4227.733,"endTime":4230.166,"body":"X L E A R is a nasal spray that contains"},{"startTime":4230.166,"endTime":4232.666,"body":"xylitol also spelled with an X a five"},{"startTime":4232.666,"endTime":4233.833,"body":"carbon sugar alcohol."},{"startTime":4234.1,"endTime":4235.966,"body":"Our bodies naturally contain five carbon"},{"startTime":4235.966,"endTime":4237.766,"body":"sugars mostly in the form of ribose and"},{"startTime":4237.766,"endTime":4239.566,"body":"deoxyribose, which are the backbone"},{"startTime":4239.566,"endTime":4241.166,"body":"sugars and RNA and DNA."},{"startTime":4241.566,"endTime":4243.166,"body":"While most of our dietary sugars have six"},{"startTime":4243.166,"endTime":4245.0,"body":"carbons sugars, carbons."},{"startTime":4246.733,"endTime":4248.033,"body":"Carvones are a thing,"},{"startTime":4248.033,"endTime":4249.133,"body":"but never heard of a car."},{"startTime":4249.133,"endTime":4250.166,"body":"Yeah, I don't know."},{"startTime":4250.866,"endTime":4252.266,"body":"Most of our dietary sugars have six"},{"startTime":4252.266,"endTime":4254.666,"body":"carbons sugars like glucose and fructose"},{"startTime":4254.666,"endTime":4257.1,"body":"xylitol is known to reduce how sticky"},{"startTime":4257.1,"endTime":4259.233,"body":"bacteria and viruses are to our tissues."},{"startTime":4259.433,"endTime":4259.633,"body":"However,"},{"startTime":4260.633,"endTime":4262.366,"body":"in the presence of xylitol bacteria and"},{"startTime":4262.366,"endTime":4264.6,"body":"viruses including strep SARS-CoV-2 and"},{"startTime":4264.6,"endTime":4267.199,"body":"RSV don't adhere to our airways as well,"},{"startTime":4267.433,"endTime":4268.899,"body":"which helps our bodies natural defense"},{"startTime":4268.899,"endTime":4270.766,"body":"mechanisms easily flush them away."},{"startTime":4271.733,"endTime":4273.533,"body":"Clear is a simple nasal spray that you"},{"startTime":4273.533,"endTime":4274.399,"body":"use morning and evening."},{"startTime":4274.433,"endTime":4275.566,"body":"It takes just three seconds."},{"startTime":4275.566,"endTime":4277.633,"body":"It's fast and easy and decidedly healthy."},{"startTime":4278.399,"endTime":4279.633,"body":"If any of this sounds familiar, perhaps"},{"startTime":4279.633,"endTime":4280.933,"body":"you listen to Bret's conversation with"},{"startTime":4280.933,"endTime":4282.466,"body":"Nathan Jones founder of clear on the"},{"startTime":4282.466,"endTime":4285.1,"body":"Inside Rail in November of 2024 or"},{"startTime":4285.1,"endTime":4286.699,"body":"Bret's conversation with Nate's father,"},{"startTime":4286.933,"endTime":4289.233,"body":"Lon Jones osteopath and inventor of Xlear"},{"startTime":4289.233,"endTime":4291.266,"body":"on how xylitol interacts with respiratory"},{"startTime":4291.266,"endTime":4292.966,"body":"viruses in May of last year."},{"startTime":4293.433,"endTime":4294.899,"body":"We recommend those conversations and we"},{"startTime":4294.899,"endTime":4296.966,"body":"highly recommend clear as a daily habit"},{"startTime":4296.966,"endTime":4297.733,"body":"and prophylactic"},{"startTime":4297.733,"endTime":4299.066,"body":"against respiratory illnesses."},{"startTime":4299.666,"endTime":4303.466,"body":"That's clear with an X X L E A R get"},{"startTime":4303.466,"endTime":4305.266,"body":"clear online or at your pharmacy grocery"},{"startTime":4305.266,"endTime":4307.066,"body":"store or natural products retailer and"},{"startTime":4307.066,"endTime":4308.633,"body":"start taking six seconds each day to"},{"startTime":4308.633,"endTime":4310.5,"body":"improve your nasal hygiene and support"},{"startTime":4310.5,"endTime":4312.133,"body":"your respiratory health."},{"startTime":4312.6,"endTime":4312.966,"body":"Excellent."},{"startTime":4312.966,"endTime":4315.3,"body":"You know, when I hear Lon Jones sort of"},{"startTime":4315.3,"endTime":4318.466,"body":"sounds like a Wild West gunslinger to me."},{"startTime":4318.833,"endTime":4319.433,"body":"Yeah, totally."},{"startTime":4320.933,"endTime":4322.5,"body":"I know you have lots of"},{"startTime":4322.5,"endTime":4323.399,"body":"places you want to go today."},{"startTime":4323.6,"endTime":4324.833,"body":"I know there's some places that we want"},{"startTime":4324.833,"endTime":4327.266,"body":"to go today, but given your introduction"},{"startTime":4327.266,"endTime":4330.899,"body":"with a possible Vladimir's led into"},{"startTime":4330.899,"endTime":4335.233,"body":"quotation about some decades, nothing"},{"startTime":4335.233,"endTime":4337.633,"body":"happens, nothing happens or a week's"},{"startTime":4337.633,"endTime":4338.733,"body":"worth of something happens."},{"startTime":4338.733,"endTime":4339.1,"body":"No, no."},{"startTime":4339.1,"endTime":4340.666,"body":"So in some decades, nothing happens and"},{"startTime":4340.666,"endTime":4341.966,"body":"in some weeks, a decade happens."},{"startTime":4342.233,"endTime":4342.466,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":4343.633,"endTime":4345.0,"body":"So in light of that, I was thinking that"},{"startTime":4345.0,"endTime":4348.433,"body":"I might finish by reading this famous"},{"startTime":4348.433,"endTime":4350.933,"body":"poem by William Butler Yates, but maybe"},{"startTime":4350.933,"endTime":4352.133,"body":"we should start here."},{"startTime":4352.133,"endTime":4352.666,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":4352.666,"endTime":4354.8,"body":"Just just as a just as a framing."},{"startTime":4354.8,"endTime":4357.666,"body":"So it's the second coming by William"},{"startTime":4357.666,"endTime":4359.5,"body":"Butler Yates published in 1919."},{"startTime":4360.133,"endTime":4362.133,"body":"So he was he did not know that he was"},{"startTime":4362.133,"endTime":4364.066,"body":"between World Wars, but he was just post"},{"startTime":4364.066,"endTime":4367.466,"body":"World War One turning and"},{"startTime":4367.466,"endTime":4368.866,"body":"turning in the widening guire."},{"startTime":4369.533,"endTime":4370.533,"body":"The Falcon cannot hear the"},{"startTime":4370.533,"endTime":4372.566,"body":"Falconer things fall apart."},{"startTime":4373.366,"endTime":4376.066,"body":"The center cannot hold mere anarchy is"},{"startTime":4376.066,"endTime":4377.1,"body":"loosed upon the world."},{"startTime":4377.466,"endTime":4378.933,"body":"The blood-dimmed tide is loose and"},{"startTime":4378.933,"endTime":4380.133,"body":"everywhere the ceremony"},{"startTime":4380.133,"endTime":4381.433,"body":"of innocence is drowned."},{"startTime":4382.433,"endTime":4384.366,"body":"The best lack all conviction while the"},{"startTime":4384.366,"endTime":4386.5,"body":"worst are full of passionate intensity."},{"startTime":4387.8,"endTime":4389.266,"body":"Surely some revelation is at hand."},{"startTime":4389.733,"endTime":4391.166,"body":"Surely the second coming is at hand."},{"startTime":4391.166,"endTime":4393.366,"body":"The second coming hardly are those words"},{"startTime":4393.366,"endTime":4395.266,"body":"out when a vast image out of spiritus"},{"startTime":4395.266,"endTime":4397.866,"body":"Mundi troubles my sight somewhere in"},{"startTime":4397.866,"endTime":4399.733,"body":"sands of the desert to shape with Lion"},{"startTime":4399.733,"endTime":4402.199,"body":"Body and the head of a man a gaze blank"},{"startTime":4402.199,"endTime":4404.666,"body":"and pitiless as the Sun is moving its"},{"startTime":4404.666,"endTime":4407.166,"body":"slow thighs while all about it real"},{"startTime":4407.166,"endTime":4409.233,"body":"shadows of the indignant desert birds."},{"startTime":4410.266,"endTime":4412.566,"body":"The darkness drops again, but now I know"},{"startTime":4412.566,"endTime":4414.666,"body":"that 20 centuries of stony sleep were"},{"startTime":4414.666,"endTime":4416.533,"body":"vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle"},{"startTime":4416.533,"endTime":4419.433,"body":"and what rough beast its hour come round"},{"startTime":4419.433,"endTime":4420.966,"body":"at last slouches"},{"startTime":4420.966,"endTime":4422.833,"body":"towards Bethlehem to be born."},{"startTime":4426.233,"endTime":4428.366,"body":"The center must the center."},{"startTime":4428.733,"endTime":4432.133,"body":"Sorry center cannot hold is the phrase"},{"startTime":4432.133,"endTime":4434.366,"body":"that most everyone in modern times is"},{"startTime":4434.366,"endTime":4435.899,"body":"familiar with whether or not they know"},{"startTime":4435.899,"endTime":4438.566,"body":"that it comes from Yates and it feels"},{"startTime":4438.566,"endTime":4442.733,"body":"there is much ink has been spilled over"},{"startTime":4442.733,"endTime":4446.133,"body":"the interpretation of this poem as as is"},{"startTime":4446.133,"endTime":4448.699,"body":"true of many great poems because unlike"},{"startTime":4448.699,"endTime":4450.133,"body":"pros they are not meant"},{"startTime":4450.133,"endTime":4452.366,"body":"to have unlike most pros."},{"startTime":4452.366,"endTime":4455.233,"body":"They are not meant to have a single"},{"startTime":4455.233,"endTime":4457.366,"body":"interpretation but"},{"startTime":4457.366,"endTime":4460.566,"body":"variously history is cyclic."},{"startTime":4461.533,"endTime":4464.399,"body":"We are exiting one horrible age and"},{"startTime":4464.399,"endTime":4466.466,"body":"entering another but there is no promise"},{"startTime":4466.466,"endTime":4468.766,"body":"that the new one shall have a better"},{"startTime":4468.766,"endTime":4472.066,"body":"moral center a stronger one or that it"},{"startTime":4472.066,"endTime":4474.533,"body":"itself shall shall redeem us."},{"startTime":4475.199,"endTime":4477.666,"body":"Those are some of the interpretations of"},{"startTime":4477.666,"endTime":4480.066,"body":"of what this poem as a whole means."},{"startTime":4480.066,"endTime":4483.166,"body":"It is the origin of the phrase slouching"},{"startTime":4483.166,"endTime":4486.533,"body":"towards Bethlehem in which we are"},{"startTime":4486.533,"endTime":4490.133,"body":"inexorably returning to someplace that"},{"startTime":4490.133,"endTime":4493.666,"body":"perhaps brought light at one point but"},{"startTime":4493.666,"endTime":4496.566,"body":"may not again the center cannot hold that"},{"startTime":4496.566,"endTime":4497.399,"body":"is certainly what it feels"},{"startTime":4497.399,"endTime":4498.533,"body":"like right now in the world."},{"startTime":4499.233,"endTime":4500.666,"body":"Yes, it's a brilliant poem."},{"startTime":4501.133,"endTime":4505.3,"body":"Maybe my favorite and I agree it is not"},{"startTime":4505.3,"endTime":4507.1,"body":"designed to have a single interpretation."},{"startTime":4509.0,"endTime":4512.066,"body":"It's what the kids call a vibe but it"},{"startTime":4512.066,"endTime":4518.566,"body":"obviously resonates across many decades"},{"startTime":4518.566,"endTime":4520.566,"body":"more than a hundred years at this point"},{"startTime":4520.566,"endTime":4525.733,"body":"for a reason and I have to tell you my"},{"startTime":4525.733,"endTime":4528.866,"body":"head has been absolutely spinning in"},{"startTime":4528.866,"endTime":4531.133,"body":"light of everything that is emerging and"},{"startTime":4531.133,"endTime":4533.966,"body":"trying to just make sense even basic"},{"startTime":4533.966,"endTime":4537.133,"body":"sense of it and hadn't thought of this"},{"startTime":4537.133,"endTime":4538.8,"body":"poem the whole time but you're right it"},{"startTime":4539.399,"endTime":4542.733,"body":"puts it in in stark relief where we are"},{"startTime":4542.733,"endTime":4545.133,"body":"and the center cannot hold"},{"startTime":4545.133,"endTime":4546.699,"body":"but at some level it must."},{"startTime":4547.833,"endTime":4548.166,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":4548.166,"endTime":4549.366,"body":"I mean that's that's where we find"},{"startTime":4549.366,"endTime":4550.933,"body":"ourselves over and over and over again."},{"startTime":4551.733,"endTime":4554.133,"body":"It's not working and it must work, you"},{"startTime":4554.133,"endTime":4555.899,"body":"know, and this is the argument of people"},{"startTime":4555.899,"endTime":4558.566,"body":"in many places on the"},{"startTime":4558.566,"endTime":4560.3,"body":"continuum across many domains."},{"startTime":4560.333,"endTime":4562.566,"body":"You know, sure the institutions are"},{"startTime":4562.566,"endTime":4564.866,"body":"failing but we need them and then there's"},{"startTime":4564.866,"endTime":4566.933,"body":"a you know, there's a disagreement over"},{"startTime":4566.933,"endTime":4568.233,"body":"yes, we need institutions"},{"startTime":4568.533,"endTime":4569.633,"body":"but do we need these ones?"},{"startTime":4570.3,"endTime":4570.966,"body":"You know, aren't these"},{"startTime":4570.966,"endTime":4572.5,"body":"institutions too flawed?"},{"startTime":4572.933,"endTime":4574.633,"body":"Don't we need to Phoenix them then?"},{"startTime":4574.866,"endTime":4577.666,"body":"Don't we need to watch them as they"},{"startTime":4577.666,"endTime":4579.533,"body":"destroy themselves fully and from their"},{"startTime":4579.533,"endTime":4581.8,"body":"ashes build new ones?"},{"startTime":4582.199,"endTime":4583.666,"body":"Yeah, build something that functions"},{"startTime":4583.666,"endTime":4585.399,"body":"because we can't we can't live like this."},{"startTime":4585.533,"endTime":4588.466,"body":"Obviously we have total collapse of all"},{"startTime":4588.466,"endTime":4590.433,"body":"the things on which we're depending but"},{"startTime":4590.433,"endTime":4594.333,"body":"the edifice is still stand which is the"},{"startTime":4594.333,"endTime":4596.5,"body":"worst of both worlds because it leaves"},{"startTime":4596.5,"endTime":4599.0,"body":"you without you know, we"},{"startTime":4599.0,"endTime":4600.033,"body":"don't seem to have an FBI."},{"startTime":4601.033,"endTime":4602.3,"body":"We might need something to do"},{"startTime":4602.3,"endTime":4604.1,"body":"investigation on behalf of the public but"},{"startTime":4604.1,"endTime":4605.166,"body":"you can't set one up"},{"startTime":4605.166,"endTime":4607.033,"body":"because there is one."},{"startTime":4607.866,"endTime":4608.333,"body":"So anyway,"},{"startTime":4609.699,"endTime":4610.3,"body":"hard"},{"startTime":4610.3,"endTime":4611.899,"body":"to know and that's actually I think part"},{"startTime":4611.899,"endTime":4612.533,"body":"of what bureaucratic"},{"startTime":4612.533,"endTime":4614.566,"body":"bloat is at a smaller level."},{"startTime":4614.566,"endTime":4616.5,"body":"I don't you know, I know maybe it usually"},{"startTime":4616.5,"endTime":4618.266,"body":"at a less important level in corporate"},{"startTime":4618.266,"endTime":4620.566,"body":"bloat like oh we had we had a thing that"},{"startTime":4620.566,"endTime":4622.233,"body":"did this job and you know, usually we"},{"startTime":4622.233,"endTime":4624.033,"body":"usually people think of this like oh it"},{"startTime":4624.033,"endTime":4625.066,"body":"just like it scaled up."},{"startTime":4625.066,"endTime":4628.066,"body":"We need more things but I've seen we've"},{"startTime":4628.066,"endTime":4629.733,"body":"seen this most directly but I certainly"},{"startTime":4629.733,"endTime":4632.6,"body":"have seen it over and over and over again"},{"startTime":4632.6,"endTime":4635.0,"body":"at the academic level where you have you"},{"startTime":4635.0,"endTime":4636.833,"body":"have something that works but one piece"},{"startTime":4636.833,"endTime":4638.233,"body":"of it starts to fail and so you have the"},{"startTime":4638.233,"endTime":4640.1,"body":"creation of a center or you know, like"},{"startTime":4640.1,"endTime":4641.866,"body":"something else is kind of doing the job"},{"startTime":4641.866,"endTime":4643.633,"body":"and then that is failing and so you have"},{"startTime":4643.633,"endTime":4645.866,"body":"this and you know, you just get colleges"},{"startTime":4645.866,"endTime":4647.866,"body":"upon colleges and systems upon systems"},{"startTime":4647.866,"endTime":4651.233,"body":"and centers and and and it feels"},{"startTime":4651.233,"endTime":4654.766,"body":"incomprehensible if you walk in at the"},{"startTime":4654.766,"endTime":4656.733,"body":"moment that everyone, you know walks in"},{"startTime":4656.733,"endTime":4658.833,"body":"at whatever point they enter it unless"},{"startTime":4658.833,"endTime":4659.366,"body":"they were part of the"},{"startTime":4659.366,"endTime":4660.833,"body":"creation like what is this mess?"},{"startTime":4660.833,"endTime":4661.533,"body":"What is this madness?"},{"startTime":4662.066,"endTime":4665.366,"body":"Why do we have this and you know, even if"},{"startTime":4665.366,"endTime":4667.733,"body":"each decision and you know, much of what"},{"startTime":4667.733,"endTime":4669.533,"body":"we will talk about this week, we're not"},{"startTime":4669.533,"endTime":4671.199,"body":"decisions made in good faith or good"},{"startTime":4671.199,"endTime":4674.133,"body":"conscience, but even if each decision to"},{"startTime":4674.133,"endTime":4678.066,"body":"fix a wrong to right or wrong was made"},{"startTime":4678.066,"endTime":4679.399,"body":"honorably that doesn't mean that the"},{"startTime":4679.399,"endTime":4680.233,"body":"system that you end up with"},{"startTime":4680.233,"endTime":4681.5,"body":"is functional or honorable."},{"startTime":4681.766,"endTime":4684.1,"body":"Yes, and sometimes the systems that we"},{"startTime":4684.1,"endTime":4686.433,"body":"assume were set up honorably weren't."},{"startTime":4686.433,"endTime":4686.633,"body":"Sure."},{"startTime":4687.233,"endTime":4690.199,"body":"Anyway, upcoming podcast will cover one"},{"startTime":4690.199,"endTime":4692.1,"body":"such instance that I've just learned"},{"startTime":4692.233,"endTime":4693.966,"body":"where I assumed something had been set up"},{"startTime":4693.966,"endTime":4700.766,"body":"in good faith that just wasn't but maybe"},{"startTime":4700.766,"endTime":4703.833,"body":"an overarching theme so that we can"},{"startTime":4703.833,"endTime":4705.1,"body":"understand the rest of"},{"startTime":4705.1,"endTime":4706.366,"body":"what we have to cover today."},{"startTime":4706.633,"endTime":4712.133,"body":"Is as longtime DarkHorse viewers know we"},{"startTime":4712.133,"endTime":4713.433,"body":"talk frequently about the distinction"},{"startTime":4713.433,"endTime":4715.833,"body":"between complicated systems and complex"},{"startTime":4715.833,"endTime":4718.533,"body":"systems and all of our institutions are"},{"startTime":4718.533,"endTime":4720.733,"body":"set up to function within a complex"},{"startTime":4720.733,"endTime":4722.433,"body":"system humanity civilization."},{"startTime":4723.133,"endTime":4726.066,"body":"These are complex systems inherently and"},{"startTime":4726.066,"endTime":4728.566,"body":"what I think we are seeing is the fact"},{"startTime":4728.566,"endTime":4730.966,"body":"that you can't set up a static system or"},{"startTime":4730.966,"endTime":4733.166,"body":"even one that you have built the"},{"startTime":4733.166,"endTime":4735.533,"body":"provisions to update that's going to"},{"startTime":4735.533,"endTime":4738.433,"body":"accommodate the kind of parasitism that"},{"startTime":4738.433,"endTime":4740.166,"body":"evolves in a complex system."},{"startTime":4740.433,"endTime":4742.066,"body":"In other words, you need to have"},{"startTime":4742.066,"endTime":4744.666,"body":"something analogous to an immune system"},{"startTime":4744.933,"endTime":4747.833,"body":"in order to prevent your well-intentioned"},{"startTime":4747.833,"endTime":4750.166,"body":"institutions from being overwhelmed by"},{"startTime":4750.166,"endTime":4751.633,"body":"the things that would love to get a hold"},{"startTime":4751.633,"endTime":4752.833,"body":"of them and use them for their own"},{"startTime":4752.833,"endTime":4754.666,"body":"purposes against the public spirit."},{"startTime":4755.333,"endTime":4756.366,"body":"And that's where we are."},{"startTime":4756.6,"endTime":4758.033,"body":"There's a reason that we're watching it"},{"startTime":4758.033,"endTime":4759.166,"body":"across every institution."},{"startTime":4760.533,"endTime":4763.033,"body":"There are certainly conspiracies of"},{"startTime":4763.033,"endTime":4765.033,"body":"plenty involved in the failure of those"},{"startTime":4765.033,"endTime":4766.733,"body":"things but the idea that there would be"},{"startTime":4766.733,"endTime":4768.333,"body":"things trying to gain access and that"},{"startTime":4768.333,"endTime":4770.033,"body":"they would eventually find their way in"},{"startTime":4770.033,"endTime":4772.066,"body":"is pretty well guaranteed if you don't"},{"startTime":4772.066,"endTime":4773.866,"body":"have a complex system fighting it"},{"startTime":4773.866,"endTime":4775.666,"body":"something analogous to an immune system"},{"startTime":4775.666,"endTime":4777.233,"body":"and I don't think we've ever figured out"},{"startTime":4777.233,"endTime":4778.233,"body":"how to build such a thing."},{"startTime":4779.033,"endTime":4781.833,"body":"So we are living in an era of"},{"startTime":4781.833,"endTime":4784.266,"body":"jaw-dropping corruption."},{"startTime":4785.433,"endTime":4787.833,"body":"Maybe just to return to my"},{"startTime":4787.833,"endTime":4790.033,"body":"brief focus on bureaucracy."},{"startTime":4791.766,"endTime":4793.766,"body":"Bureaucracy is made up of entities that"},{"startTime":4793.766,"endTime":4795.933,"body":"are complex systems individual humans but"},{"startTime":4795.933,"endTime":4797.633,"body":"it is inherently a complicated system"},{"startTime":4797.633,"endTime":4800.133,"body":"itself and so the beings who are running"},{"startTime":4800.133,"endTime":4802.466,"body":"it may assume that what they're involved"},{"startTime":4802.466,"endTime":4806.133,"body":"in is complex like they are but it is not"},{"startTime":4806.133,"endTime":4807.233,"body":"and therefore cannot solve"},{"startTime":4807.233,"endTime":4809.433,"body":"the problems of complexity."},{"startTime":4809.766,"endTime":4811.433,"body":"Yeah, there's a reason that we"},{"startTime":4811.433,"endTime":4813.899,"body":"analogize them to Cox, right?"},{"startTime":4813.933,"endTime":4816.366,"body":"It specifically tells you then the people"},{"startTime":4816.366,"endTime":4819.166,"body":"who staff these systems, right?"},{"startTime":4819.166,"endTime":4820.066,"body":"They are cogs when we"},{"startTime":4820.066,"endTime":4822.3,"body":"dismiss, you know, their functioning."},{"startTime":4822.633,"endTime":4824.633,"body":"We talk about them, you know, a cog is a"},{"startTime":4824.633,"endTime":4827.833,"body":"simple entity, you know, maybe not at the"},{"startTime":4827.833,"endTime":4830.733,"body":"material level but it can't keep up with"},{"startTime":4830.733,"endTime":4833.266,"body":"a complex problem like corruption."},{"startTime":4833.566,"endTime":4835.133,"body":"So anyway, it's an arms race and there's"},{"startTime":4835.133,"endTime":4836.966,"body":"a reason that we've lost it across the"},{"startTime":4836.966,"endTime":4839.8,"body":"board and it is it's that the complexity"},{"startTime":4839.8,"endTime":4841.533,"body":"got the better of the complicated and"},{"startTime":4841.533,"endTime":4843.6,"body":"that was predictable enough."},{"startTime":4843.933,"endTime":4845.066,"body":"Of course, our founders didn't"},{"startTime":4845.066,"endTime":4846.866,"body":"know about complexity, right?"},{"startTime":4847.233,"endTime":4847.633,"body":"We had not."},{"startTime":4848.833,"endTime":4849.966,"body":"I'm sure some of them"},{"startTime":4849.966,"endTime":4851.933,"body":"intuited something about complexity."},{"startTime":4852.8,"endTime":4855.033,"body":"They feared things that we would now"},{"startTime":4855.033,"endTime":4857.966,"body":"understand as complex like private"},{"startTime":4858.033,"endTime":4860.766,"body":"interests overwhelming government in the"},{"startTime":4860.766,"endTime":4863.966,"body":"spirit of the public but they didn't have"},{"startTime":4863.966,"endTime":4865.733,"body":"the tools and we still don't have the"},{"startTime":4865.733,"endTime":4867.266,"body":"tools to describe a"},{"startTime":4867.266,"endTime":4868.366,"body":"system that resists this."},{"startTime":4868.866,"endTime":4869.766,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":4870.0,"endTime":4870.5,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":4870.5,"endTime":4872.399,"body":"I think the first thing that we should"},{"startTime":4872.399,"endTime":4874.433,"body":"address is the emergence"},{"startTime":4874.433,"endTime":4877.5,"body":"of Robert Trivers email."},{"startTime":4877.5,"endTime":4879.466,"body":"There are actually several emails in the"},{"startTime":4879.466,"endTime":4882.0,"body":"new Epstein release and we should talk"},{"startTime":4882.0,"endTime":4885.366,"body":"about our relationship to Bob and we"},{"startTime":4885.366,"endTime":4887.166,"body":"should talk about what we see and what we"},{"startTime":4887.166,"endTime":4890.333,"body":"think others see especially in the email"},{"startTime":4890.333,"endTime":4891.866,"body":"that has gotten so much attention."},{"startTime":4892.1,"endTime":4892.699,"body":"Do we start with the"},{"startTime":4892.699,"endTime":4893.966,"body":"email or do we go there?"},{"startTime":4893.966,"endTime":4895.8,"body":"No, I think we should I think we should"},{"startTime":4895.8,"endTime":4897.933,"body":"put Bob in context so people understand"},{"startTime":4897.933,"endTime":4898.833,"body":"where we're coming from."},{"startTime":4899.3,"endTime":4902.733,"body":"So Bob was my undergraduate advisor."},{"startTime":4903.266,"endTime":4904.833,"body":"It was my de facto undergraduate."},{"startTime":4904.833,"endTime":4906.366,"body":"He was your de facto advisor."},{"startTime":4906.366,"endTime":4908.166,"body":"Yes, your actual advisor."},{"startTime":4909.833,"endTime":4910.466,"body":"Doesn't matter."},{"startTime":4910.466,"endTime":4910.866,"body":"It doesn't matter."},{"startTime":4910.866,"endTime":4912.633,"body":"I was I was not able"},{"startTime":4912.633,"endTime":4913.666,"body":"to be a biology major."},{"startTime":4913.666,"endTime":4915.3,"body":"So he was my de facto advisor and I was"},{"startTime":4915.3,"endTime":4918.0,"body":"his research assistant for over a year."},{"startTime":4918.3,"endTime":4918.5,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":4919.266,"endTime":4921.733,"body":"So at the point that"},{"startTime":4921.733,"endTime":4924.399,"body":"you and I landed at UCSC."},{"startTime":4925.5,"endTime":4930.566,"body":"I was evolution crazed and I had showed"},{"startTime":4930.566,"endTime":4933.966,"body":"you why this was such a powerful way of"},{"startTime":4933.966,"endTime":4935.933,"body":"viewing the world and you were becoming"},{"startTime":4935.933,"endTime":4938.033,"body":"evolution crazed as well."},{"startTime":4938.5,"endTime":4939.833,"body":"If you use that word, but okay."},{"startTime":4940.333,"endTime":4942.233,"body":"Well, let's just say, you know, at the"},{"startTime":4942.233,"endTime":4944.033,"body":"point you discover that there's a"},{"startTime":4944.033,"endTime":4946.366,"body":"framework that allows you to think about"},{"startTime":4946.366,"endTime":4947.733,"body":"all sorts of things that you might be"},{"startTime":4947.733,"endTime":4949.233,"body":"thinking about otherwise, but not know"},{"startTime":4949.233,"endTime":4950.8,"body":"how to work with it."},{"startTime":4950.833,"endTime":4954.666,"body":"It's very it's exhilarating to find a"},{"startTime":4954.666,"endTime":4955.766,"body":"framework that makes"},{"startTime":4955.766,"endTime":4957.733,"body":"these questions tractable."},{"startTime":4958.666,"endTime":4961.633,"body":"We landed at UCSC and I remember you"},{"startTime":4961.633,"endTime":4963.733,"body":"saying to me, do you know who's here?"},{"startTime":4965.033,"endTime":4965.833,"body":"And I said, no."},{"startTime":4966.199,"endTime":4967.5,"body":"And you said, Robert Rivers,"},{"startTime":4968.699,"endTime":4969.966,"body":"one of the greatest evolutionary"},{"startTime":4970.133,"endTime":4971.699,"body":"biologists since Darwin."},{"startTime":4973.066,"endTime":4976.533,"body":"And I was shocked and delighted and you"},{"startTime":4976.533,"endTime":4978.1,"body":"and I signed up for his"},{"startTime":4978.1,"endTime":4980.466,"body":"amazing social evolution course."},{"startTime":4981.5,"endTime":4984.066,"body":"Of course, he was a master lecturer and"},{"startTime":4984.066,"endTime":4985.699,"body":"he was a brilliant teacher, brilliant"},{"startTime":4985.699,"endTime":4988.866,"body":"teacher and he, you know, covered all so"},{"startTime":4988.866,"endTime":4990.666,"body":"the most fascinating topics, especially"},{"startTime":4990.666,"endTime":4993.833,"body":"was very focused on human beings and it"},{"startTime":4993.833,"endTime":4996.133,"body":"was just a mind-blowing experience to be"},{"startTime":4996.133,"endTime":4998.333,"body":"in this class and to hear this great"},{"startTime":4998.433,"endTime":5000.766,"body":"thinker expound on all of these topics."},{"startTime":5001.033,"endTime":5003.166,"body":"He was very scientifically rigorous."},{"startTime":5004.033,"endTime":5007.3,"body":"He was very aware of what he didn't know."},{"startTime":5007.333,"endTime":5008.533,"body":"He had all sorts of the best"},{"startTime":5008.533,"endTime":5010.966,"body":"characteristics of a scientific mind."},{"startTime":5011.866,"endTime":5013.699,"body":"And anyway, we became"},{"startTime":5013.699,"endTime":5016.266,"body":"generous with both his his mind, his"},{"startTime":5016.266,"endTime":5017.8,"body":"thoughts and his time."},{"startTime":5018.899,"endTime":5021.833,"body":"Not only that, but as you've discussed"},{"startTime":5021.833,"endTime":5025.566,"body":"publicly, he warned us when we went off"},{"startTime":5025.566,"endTime":5027.733,"body":"to graduate school that we should make"},{"startTime":5027.733,"endTime":5031.566,"body":"sure that our experience maintained"},{"startTime":5031.566,"endTime":5034.633,"body":"contact with undergraduates because he"},{"startTime":5034.633,"endTime":5037.866,"body":"said they will ask you questions that"},{"startTime":5037.866,"endTime":5041.833,"body":"people who are more expert will not and"},{"startTime":5041.833,"endTime":5043.399,"body":"they will they will push you around and"},{"startTime":5043.399,"endTime":5045.966,"body":"they will keep your mind alive and agile"},{"startTime":5046.133,"endTime":5047.733,"body":"in a way that if you went to somewhere"},{"startTime":5047.733,"endTime":5050.566,"body":"like Rockefeller or something where there"},{"startTime":5050.566,"endTime":5051.633,"body":"were no undergraduates."},{"startTime":5051.899,"endTime":5052.933,"body":"The point is everybody's learned what"},{"startTime":5052.933,"endTime":5055.033,"body":"questions we don't ask because we can't"},{"startTime":5055.033,"endTime":5056.1,"body":"figure out how to answer them."},{"startTime":5056.1,"endTime":5058.166,"body":"And so your mind can become stale"},{"startTime":5058.166,"endTime":5060.366,"body":"and this will maybe be less obvious to"},{"startTime":5060.366,"endTime":5061.866,"body":"people, but he also said"},{"startTime":5061.866,"endTime":5063.066,"body":"go to a place with a museum."},{"startTime":5063.8,"endTime":5065.133,"body":"What is the advantage of being a museum?"},{"startTime":5065.333,"endTime":5067.133,"body":"I said to him, but I you know, but Bob, I"},{"startTime":5067.133,"endTime":5067.766,"body":"want to be an animal"},{"startTime":5067.766,"endTime":5069.166,"body":"behaviorist in museum."},{"startTime":5069.166,"endTime":5069.8,"body":"Everything's dead."},{"startTime":5070.0,"endTime":5071.633,"body":"Not so much behavior there, right?"},{"startTime":5072.366,"endTime":5074.199,"body":"He said, sure, fine."},{"startTime":5074.966,"endTime":5076.366,"body":"But a you know, there's there are"},{"startTime":5076.366,"endTime":5078.066,"body":"questions to be asked of the collections"},{"startTime":5078.066,"endTime":5079.699,"body":"of the organisms in the collections that"},{"startTime":5079.699,"endTime":5081.066,"body":"you probably haven't imagined."},{"startTime":5081.066,"endTime":5083.533,"body":"But more important by far is that a"},{"startTime":5083.533,"endTime":5086.633,"body":"museum is a place where people come and"},{"startTime":5086.633,"endTime":5089.566,"body":"this is part of the tragedy of the death"},{"startTime":5089.566,"endTime":5092.466,"body":"of research museums that increasingly"},{"startTime":5092.466,"endTime":5095.033,"body":"when people need to see collections, want"},{"startTime":5095.033,"endTime":5096.966,"body":"to see collections to answer scientific"},{"startTime":5096.966,"endTime":5099.366,"body":"questions that they have, they go to"},{"startTime":5099.366,"endTime":5101.833,"body":"someplace off-site and run into it."},{"startTime":5101.833,"endTime":5104.733,"body":"No one but you know, an active museum as"},{"startTime":5104.733,"endTime":5107.266,"body":"the Museum of Comparative Zoology was at"},{"startTime":5107.266,"endTime":5109.533,"body":"Harvard when he was there as a graduate"},{"startTime":5109.533,"endTime":5112.433,"body":"student and very early in his career and"},{"startTime":5112.433,"endTime":5114.466,"body":"at the University of Michigan Museum of"},{"startTime":5114.466,"endTime":5116.133,"body":"Zoology where we ended up doing our"},{"startTime":5116.133,"endTime":5118.699,"body":"graduate work were world-class, you know,"},{"startTime":5118.733,"endTime":5120.633,"body":"some of the absolute best research"},{"startTime":5120.633,"endTime":5122.5,"body":"museums in the world, Museum of Zoology"},{"startTime":5123.033,"endTime":5124.899,"body":"and people would come through all the"},{"startTime":5124.899,"endTime":5125.766,"body":"time to do research."},{"startTime":5125.766,"endTime":5128.333,"body":"And so you just run into people if you"},{"startTime":5128.333,"endTime":5130.633,"body":"were hanging out in the in the range"},{"startTime":5130.633,"endTime":5131.533,"body":"hanging out in the collections."},{"startTime":5131.733,"endTime":5134.3,"body":"I was a curatorial assistant for a couple"},{"startTime":5134.3,"endTime":5135.699,"body":"of summers and there's just the number of"},{"startTime":5135.699,"endTime":5137.933,"body":"people who would come through from other"},{"startTime":5137.933,"endTime":5139.533,"body":"universities, including for you know,"},{"startTime":5139.533,"endTime":5142.033,"body":"from Europe and they would have some"},{"startTime":5142.033,"endTime":5142.699,"body":"particular question"},{"startTime":5142.699,"endTime":5143.866,"body":"that they were there to do."},{"startTime":5143.866,"endTime":5145.833,"body":"They were measuring, you know, scales on"},{"startTime":5145.833,"endTime":5147.866,"body":"lizards from a particular spot, you know,"},{"startTime":5147.866,"endTime":5149.533,"body":"because I was in the Herp Division where"},{"startTime":5149.533,"endTime":5151.133,"body":"we were where we had collections of"},{"startTime":5151.133,"endTime":5152.533,"body":"reptiles and amphibians."},{"startTime":5153.433,"endTime":5156.899,"body":"But of course, no one of any note is only"},{"startTime":5156.899,"endTime":5158.633,"body":"going to be focused on their particular"},{"startTime":5158.633,"endTime":5159.899,"body":"research question at a time."},{"startTime":5159.899,"endTime":5161.533,"body":"And so, you know, Bob's point which had"},{"startTime":5161.533,"endTime":5164.466,"body":"been invisible to me before was you want"},{"startTime":5164.466,"endTime":5166.233,"body":"to be, you know, you want to be exposed"},{"startTime":5166.233,"endTime":5169.633,"body":"to as many ideas as possible in order to"},{"startTime":5169.633,"endTime":5172.733,"body":"stay as vibrant as possible and to, you"},{"startTime":5172.733,"endTime":5174.233,"body":"know, just to be learning and to be"},{"startTime":5174.233,"endTime":5176.033,"body":"thinking scientifically as"},{"startTime":5176.033,"endTime":5177.6,"body":"broadly as you possibly can."},{"startTime":5178.066,"endTime":5180.266,"body":"You know, the narrower your focus, the"},{"startTime":5180.266,"endTime":5182.533,"body":"narrower the particular place where you"},{"startTime":5182.533,"endTime":5184.066,"body":"are with regard to how many people come"},{"startTime":5184.066,"endTime":5186.233,"body":"through, the fewer interactions you have"},{"startTime":5186.233,"endTime":5187.533,"body":"with people who haven't yet been exposed"},{"startTime":5187.533,"endTime":5188.633,"body":"to the ideas of your field."},{"startTime":5188.633,"endTime":5189.266,"body":"And this is the point"},{"startTime":5189.266,"endTime":5190.866,"body":"about teaching undergraduates."},{"startTime":5191.566,"endTime":5195.133,"body":"The less good a scientist you will be, no"},{"startTime":5195.133,"endTime":5197.133,"body":"matter what your chops are to begin with."},{"startTime":5197.233,"endTime":5197.566,"body":"Absolutely."},{"startTime":5198.0,"endTime":5199.3,"body":"And these both prove"},{"startTime":5199.3,"endTime":5201.166,"body":"to be highly predictive."},{"startTime":5201.833,"endTime":5203.333,"body":"You know, I think the teaching of"},{"startTime":5203.333,"endTime":5205.333,"body":"undergraduates is great and they do ask"},{"startTime":5205.333,"endTime":5206.066,"body":"you questions you"},{"startTime":5206.066,"endTime":5207.066,"body":"won't get anywhere else."},{"startTime":5207.666,"endTime":5210.666,"body":"And our training in a museum that has"},{"startTime":5210.666,"endTime":5214.666,"body":"sadly been crippled since we left as the,"},{"startTime":5214.666,"endTime":5217.433,"body":"you know, bean counters have decided"},{"startTime":5217.433,"endTime":5218.733,"body":"museum work isn't important."},{"startTime":5219.133,"endTime":5220.166,"body":"But while we were there,"},{"startTime":5220.366,"endTime":5221.899,"body":"it was a great experience."},{"startTime":5222.166,"endTime":5223.433,"body":"I wouldn't trade it."},{"startTime":5225.033,"endTime":5227.166,"body":"Okay, so Bob is a friend of"},{"startTime":5227.166,"endTime":5230.5,"body":"ours and several people have"},{"startTime":5231.899,"endTime":5234.733,"body":"on X asked, you know, well, what do you"},{"startTime":5234.733,"endTime":5236.633,"body":"think of the Travers revelation?"},{"startTime":5236.866,"endTime":5237.633,"body":"Why aren't you speaking?"},{"startTime":5238.233,"endTime":5241.066,"body":"And I will say the situation is a"},{"startTime":5241.066,"endTime":5242.633,"body":"delicate one and I'm going to share"},{"startTime":5242.733,"endTime":5245.266,"body":"something with you that will explain to"},{"startTime":5245.266,"endTime":5246.366,"body":"you why I wasn't eager"},{"startTime":5246.366,"endTime":5248.3,"body":"to rush into that frame."},{"startTime":5251.933,"endTime":5255.533,"body":"Bob is in he's on hospice."},{"startTime":5255.933,"endTime":5256.433,"body":"He is dying."},{"startTime":5256.666,"endTime":5258.133,"body":"In fact, he has lived longer"},{"startTime":5258.133,"endTime":5259.899,"body":"than he was expected to live."},{"startTime":5259.933,"endTime":5262.433,"body":"This is not a new issue."},{"startTime":5262.699,"endTime":5266.133,"body":"He is completely not cognizant anymore."},{"startTime":5267.133,"endTime":5269.766,"body":"He could die anytime and at the point he"},{"startTime":5269.766,"endTime":5272.6,"body":"does I would imagine that there's going"},{"startTime":5272.6,"endTime":5274.066,"body":"to be speculating about whether the"},{"startTime":5274.066,"endTime":5275.8,"body":"timing of his death in light of the"},{"startTime":5275.8,"endTime":5279.366,"body":"embarrassing release in the Epstein files"},{"startTime":5279.366,"endTime":5280.533,"body":"is a little too convenient."},{"startTime":5280.866,"endTime":5281.5,"body":"It isn't."},{"startTime":5281.5,"endTime":5282.333,"body":"It's just a coincidence."},{"startTime":5282.566,"endTime":5285.333,"body":"I've known since early"},{"startTime":5285.333,"endTime":5287.133,"body":"December that this was the condition."},{"startTime":5288.266,"endTime":5293.433,"body":"So anyway, Bob is he's going to die and"},{"startTime":5293.433,"endTime":5295.766,"body":"he's never going to know that this"},{"startTime":5295.766,"endTime":5297.333,"body":"discussion was happening."},{"startTime":5300.533,"endTime":5301.166,"body":"That said,"},{"startTime":5303.266,"endTime":5304.933,"body":"you and I had the same reaction."},{"startTime":5304.933,"endTime":5308.266,"body":"You and I separately became aware of the"},{"startTime":5308.266,"endTime":5311.133,"body":"Travers email that was widely circulating"},{"startTime":5311.133,"endTime":5313.199,"body":"at the end of last week,"},{"startTime":5313.533,"endTime":5314.566,"body":"which if we're going to talk about we"},{"startTime":5314.566,"endTime":5315.633,"body":"really do need to share it."},{"startTime":5315.633,"endTime":5316.933,"body":"Okay, we will do that."},{"startTime":5317.433,"endTime":5320.133,"body":"But you and I had the sense watching this"},{"startTime":5320.133,"endTime":5323.033,"body":"that yes, that is not."},{"startTime":5326.133,"endTime":5329.433,"body":"It's not a defensible email, but it does"},{"startTime":5329.433,"endTime":5331.966,"body":"not mean what the people who were"},{"startTime":5331.966,"endTime":5333.966,"body":"interpreting it seem to think as far as"},{"startTime":5333.966,"endTime":5335.133,"body":"we can tell knowing Bob."},{"startTime":5335.8,"endTime":5338.3,"body":"This does not read to us the way it seems"},{"startTime":5338.3,"endTime":5342.1,"body":"to be reading to others and you have I"},{"startTime":5342.1,"endTime":5344.699,"body":"think very astutely pointed out that it"},{"startTime":5344.699,"endTime":5348.533,"body":"is an exercise that we have to go through"},{"startTime":5348.533,"endTime":5351.899,"body":"to say if we didn't know Bob Travers,"},{"startTime":5351.899,"endTime":5354.366,"body":"yes, would we be reading this the way"},{"startTime":5354.366,"endTime":5356.466,"body":"others are and I don't I can't answer the"},{"startTime":5356.466,"endTime":5357.433,"body":"question for myself."},{"startTime":5357.433,"endTime":5358.699,"body":"I don't think so, but"},{"startTime":5358.699,"endTime":5361.333,"body":"I mean, this is at the point that I"},{"startTime":5361.333,"endTime":5363.233,"body":"became aware of the email and it's just"},{"startTime":5363.233,"endTime":5364.066,"body":"been a couple of days."},{"startTime":5364.066,"endTime":5367.133,"body":"I guess that is the question I keep on"},{"startTime":5367.133,"endTime":5368.533,"body":"coming back to because I'm so"},{"startTime":5370.133,"endTime":5372.366,"body":"I'm so surprised by the response that"},{"startTime":5372.366,"endTime":5375.3,"body":"people are having and it's and I and I we"},{"startTime":5375.3,"endTime":5378.699,"body":"can never know how if we had seen this"},{"startTime":5378.699,"endTime":5380.633,"body":"email without knowing who had written it"},{"startTime":5380.633,"endTime":5383.733,"body":"what we would have thought but knowing"},{"startTime":5383.733,"endTime":5386.233,"body":"that it comes, you know, and put aside"},{"startTime":5386.233,"endTime":5389.133,"body":"the fact that he is a friend of ours, but"},{"startTime":5389.133,"endTime":5390.333,"body":"knowing that it comes from one of the"},{"startTime":5390.333,"endTime":5391.133,"body":"greatest evolutionary"},{"startTime":5391.233,"endTime":5393.933,"body":"minds ever to exist it."},{"startTime":5395.533,"endTime":5398.3,"body":"It reads as academic speculation."},{"startTime":5399.133,"endTime":5400.033,"body":"It is not history."},{"startTime":5400.033,"endTime":5401.266,"body":"It is not fantasy."},{"startTime":5401.733,"endTime":5402.766,"body":"It is nothing of the sort."},{"startTime":5403.466,"endTime":5406.266,"body":"It is it is evolutionary"},{"startTime":5406.266,"endTime":5409.766,"body":"thinking about horrible things."},{"startTime":5410.433,"endTime":5411.666,"body":"So I think maybe we should share it"},{"startTime":5411.666,"endTime":5412.366,"body":"rather than because some"},{"startTime":5412.366,"endTime":5413.333,"body":"people want to run into it."},{"startTime":5413.333,"endTime":5415.466,"body":"Let me say one nonsensical conversation."},{"startTime":5415.466,"endTime":5417.333,"body":"I don't know if I said it in explaining"},{"startTime":5417.333,"endTime":5420.933,"body":"how we end up in this conversation now"},{"startTime":5420.933,"endTime":5423.6,"body":"rather than before I needed permission to"},{"startTime":5423.6,"endTime":5424.733,"body":"talk about Bob's condition."},{"startTime":5424.733,"endTime":5425.866,"body":"It was not public."},{"startTime":5426.633,"endTime":5427.399,"body":"I now have that"},{"startTime":5427.399,"endTime":5428.5,"body":"permission from his family."},{"startTime":5429.033,"endTime":5432.133,"body":"So I'm I'm entering that piece of"},{"startTime":5432.133,"endTime":5434.566,"body":"information so that people have it and so"},{"startTime":5434.566,"endTime":5437.666,"body":"that his death does not cause the"},{"startTime":5437.666,"endTime":5438.766,"body":"speculation that otherwise"},{"startTime":5438.766,"endTime":5440.5,"body":"I'm sure it would so okay."},{"startTime":5440.533,"endTime":5441.733,"body":"Let's show the email."},{"startTime":5442.333,"endTime":5443.633,"body":"So it's it's on my"},{"startTime":5443.633,"endTime":5444.933,"body":"screen or you have it I guess."},{"startTime":5446.533,"endTime":5449.066,"body":"So this is Robert Travers writing to"},{"startTime":5449.066,"endTime":5450.766,"body":"Jeffrey Epstein with the"},{"startTime":5450.766,"endTime":5454.166,"body":"subject trans on December 17th 2018."},{"startTime":5456.1,"endTime":5456.933,"body":"Clearly, I think"},{"startTime":5456.933,"endTime":5458.533,"body":"responding to a question."},{"startTime":5458.833,"endTime":5461.166,"body":"The question of which is not in the files"},{"startTime":5461.166,"endTime":5462.966,"body":"as far as either of us is found."},{"startTime":5464.199,"endTime":5465.3,"body":"He writes it is very simple."},{"startTime":5465.6,"endTime":5467.133,"body":"I will compare male to female with female"},{"startTime":5467.133,"endTime":5469.899,"body":"to male with greater molecular with"},{"startTime":5469.899,"endTime":5470.566,"body":"greater molecular"},{"startTime":5470.566,"endTime":5471.833,"body":"control over development."},{"startTime":5471.833,"endTime":5473.433,"body":"We are increasingly capable of producing"},{"startTime":5473.433,"endTime":5475.766,"body":"novel phenotypes more found in men by"},{"startTime":5475.766,"endTime":5477.666,"body":"blocking testosterone receptors or by"},{"startTime":5477.666,"endTime":5479.8,"body":"castration at the same time increasing"},{"startTime":5479.8,"endTime":5480.766,"body":"estrogen production."},{"startTime":5481.166,"endTime":5482.833,"body":"The one blocks male features the second"},{"startTime":5482.833,"endTime":5485.433,"body":"encourages female features more masculine"},{"startTime":5485.433,"endTime":5487.266,"body":"women heavy testosterone dosage"},{"startTime":5487.266,"endTime":5488.433,"body":"incredible external"},{"startTime":5488.533,"endTime":5489.866,"body":"effects heavily bearded men."},{"startTime":5489.866,"endTime":5490.933,"body":"You would never guess they had a female"},{"startTime":5490.933,"endTime":5493.5,"body":"bone on their body first kind male to"},{"startTime":5493.5,"endTime":5494.699,"body":"female is four times more"},{"startTime":5494.699,"endTime":5495.966,"body":"frequent than female to male."},{"startTime":5496.666,"endTime":5498.766,"body":"The first is attractive is a woman with a"},{"startTime":5498.766,"endTime":5499.699,"body":"cock so that if your"},{"startTime":5499.699,"endTime":5501.166,"body":"fantasy is to suck a man's dick."},{"startTime":5501.433,"endTime":5502.033,"body":"Otherwise, you are"},{"startTime":5502.033,"endTime":5502.866,"body":"completely heterosexual."},{"startTime":5503.533,"endTime":5504.8,"body":"It would be much nicer if the rest of the"},{"startTime":5504.8,"endTime":5505.966,"body":"organism is female than you"},{"startTime":5505.966,"endTime":5507.199,"body":"get the best of both worlds."},{"startTime":5508.166,"endTime":5509.533,"body":"So many transsexual women are very"},{"startTime":5509.533,"endTime":5511.166,"body":"attractive and easily make money which in"},{"startTime":5511.166,"endTime":5512.333,"body":"turn they assert promotes their"},{"startTime":5512.333,"endTime":5514.433,"body":"prostitution since they have to pay hefty"},{"startTime":5514.433,"endTime":5515.533,"body":"fees for injections every"},{"startTime":5515.533,"endTime":5516.733,"body":"week, but they are sexually happy."},{"startTime":5517.366,"endTime":5518.566,"body":"Once you have reached manhood even"},{"startTime":5518.566,"endTime":5520.199,"body":"castration does not prevent the cessation"},{"startTime":5520.199,"endTime":5523.399,"body":"of organism of a means orgasm there."},{"startTime":5524.433,"endTime":5525.066,"body":"Contrast the poor"},{"startTime":5525.066,"endTime":5526.266,"body":"female to male versions."},{"startTime":5526.266,"endTime":5527.433,"body":"They are unhappy and lonely."},{"startTime":5527.433,"endTime":5528.566,"body":"They are men with mum pums"},{"startTime":5528.566,"endTime":5529.866,"body":"the worst of both worlds."},{"startTime":5530.533,"endTime":5532.233,"body":"If you like smelly masculine men you want"},{"startTime":5532.233,"endTime":5534.033,"body":"that hard cock that comes with the show."},{"startTime":5534.033,"endTime":5535.433,"body":"You do not want one of nature's more"},{"startTime":5535.433,"endTime":5536.266,"body":"complex and variable"},{"startTime":5536.266,"endTime":5538.033,"body":"structures the pum pum."},{"startTime":5538.433,"endTime":5539.633,"body":"I don't know which one is right."},{"startTime":5540.933,"endTime":5543.266,"body":"I couldn't tell whether that was a typo."},{"startTime":5543.633,"endTime":5546.633,"body":"He's so we will get to Bob's"},{"startTime":5546.633,"endTime":5547.566,"body":"long-standing connection"},{"startTime":5547.566,"endTime":5549.3,"body":"with Jamaica, but he's using."},{"startTime":5549.899,"endTime":5550.166,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":5550.166,"endTime":5551.633,"body":"I don't know which one of those which one"},{"startTime":5551.633,"endTime":5552.566,"body":"of those is the one he"},{"startTime":5552.566,"endTime":5555.333,"body":"means mum pum pum pum whatever."},{"startTime":5555.333,"endTime":5557.0,"body":"It's obviously a word for vagina."},{"startTime":5557.466,"endTime":5557.666,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":5559.833,"endTime":5561.133,"body":"You do not want one of nature's more"},{"startTime":5561.133,"endTime":5563.466,"body":"complex and variable structures that is"},{"startTime":5563.466,"endTime":5565.466,"body":"an acquired taste and not with a man."},{"startTime":5566.066,"endTime":5566.8,"body":"There are hundreds of"},{"startTime":5566.8,"endTime":5568.466,"body":"female trans videos and websites."},{"startTime":5568.466,"endTime":5569.566,"body":"I have never seen a male one."},{"startTime":5570.133,"endTime":5571.566,"body":"By the way, we are now pushing the"},{"startTime":5571.566,"endTime":5572.333,"body":"intervention earlier."},{"startTime":5572.633,"endTime":5573.199,"body":"So you notice your"},{"startTime":5573.199,"endTime":5575.066,"body":"three-year-old son has trans tendencies."},{"startTime":5575.066,"endTime":5576.199,"body":"So now you intervene with hormones."},{"startTime":5576.766,"endTime":5577.933,"body":"I would be frightened to do that."},{"startTime":5578.3,"endTime":5578.966,"body":"But who knows?"},{"startTime":5581.966,"endTime":5583.6,"body":"Before you start your thing on this."},{"startTime":5583.6,"endTime":5587.066,"body":"I just want to say again that there is"},{"startTime":5587.066,"endTime":5590.166,"body":"there is no fantasy here."},{"startTime":5590.366,"endTime":5592.466,"body":"There is no there is no description of"},{"startTime":5592.466,"endTime":5594.866,"body":"what has happened in Bob's world nor what"},{"startTime":5594.866,"endTime":5595.933,"body":"he would hope to happen."},{"startTime":5596.766,"endTime":5600.133,"body":"This is a man who went intact and and"},{"startTime":5600.133,"endTime":5601.266,"body":"again, he is he is now"},{"startTime":5601.266,"endTime":5602.966,"body":"dying was not into girls."},{"startTime":5603.333,"endTime":5605.233,"body":"He was certainly wasn't into boys or men."},{"startTime":5606.033,"endTime":5608.133,"body":"He was sexually attracted to women, you"},{"startTime":5608.133,"endTime":5611.199,"body":"know, perhaps more than more than others."},{"startTime":5611.199,"endTime":5612.966,"body":"He was he was very sexually active."},{"startTime":5612.966,"endTime":5615.166,"body":"He had a active libido healthy libido,"},{"startTime":5615.166,"endTime":5617.966,"body":"but none of this describes"},{"startTime":5619.033,"endTime":5621.666,"body":"desire or hope or or"},{"startTime":5621.666,"endTime":5623.8,"body":"action on his part in any way."},{"startTime":5624.5,"endTime":5626.366,"body":"Yes, and I think you know, if you look at"},{"startTime":5626.366,"endTime":5628.066,"body":"the discussion that's happened about it,"},{"startTime":5628.066,"endTime":5630.233,"body":"there's a lot of focus understandably on"},{"startTime":5630.233,"endTime":5631.866,"body":"the very end of it where he's talking"},{"startTime":5631.866,"endTime":5633.633,"body":"about intervention interventions and"},{"startTime":5633.633,"endTime":5637.033,"body":"children, which of course one thing I"},{"startTime":5637.033,"endTime":5639.866,"body":"would just say upfront is it's hard to"},{"startTime":5639.866,"endTime":5642.833,"body":"remember how long ago 2018"},{"startTime":5642.833,"endTime":5645.933,"body":"was in this discussion, right?"},{"startTime":5645.933,"endTime":5647.566,"body":"It doesn't seem like it could possibly be"},{"startTime":5647.566,"endTime":5650.066,"body":"that long ago, but it is fairly long ago."},{"startTime":5650.766,"endTime":5652.266,"body":"And what he's talking about when he says"},{"startTime":5652.266,"endTime":5655.766,"body":"we I think some people imagine that he"},{"startTime":5655.766,"endTime":5658.866,"body":"was somehow involved in some such effort."},{"startTime":5658.933,"endTime":5660.366,"body":"He's talking with the"},{"startTime":5660.366,"endTime":5662.366,"body":"sort of scientific we right."},{"startTime":5662.666,"endTime":5664.433,"body":"Yes, that those who are involved in these"},{"startTime":5664.433,"endTime":5667.366,"body":"interventions are pushing them earlier"},{"startTime":5667.366,"endTime":5669.133,"body":"and you know, of course, he never"},{"startTime":5669.133,"endTime":5671.266,"body":"intended this email to be read by anybody"},{"startTime":5671.266,"endTime":5674.133,"body":"other than Epstein presumably and so he"},{"startTime":5674.133,"endTime":5677.033,"body":"wasn't using, you know, careful language"},{"startTime":5677.033,"endTime":5679.466,"body":"at all, obviously, and you know, frankly,"},{"startTime":5679.466,"endTime":5680.566,"body":"I find the email"},{"startTime":5680.566,"endTime":5684.233,"body":"grotesque in several places, but"},{"startTime":5687.233,"endTime":5690.366,"body":"he's clearly referring to he talks about"},{"startTime":5690.366,"endTime":5694.966,"body":"websites about trans women and the"},{"startTime":5694.966,"endTime":5698.266,"body":"phenomenon of people who who transition"},{"startTime":5698.266,"endTime":5700.899,"body":"and are actually happier having done so"},{"startTime":5700.899,"endTime":5703.033,"body":"does exist, which is"},{"startTime":5703.033,"endTime":5704.333,"body":"what he's referring to."},{"startTime":5704.666,"endTime":5708.333,"body":"So and this is a man whose contributions"},{"startTime":5708.333,"endTime":5710.933,"body":"to evolutionary biology are legend and"},{"startTime":5710.933,"endTime":5713.1,"body":"shall remain so but you know, quite"},{"startTime":5713.1,"endTime":5715.1,"body":"frankly, but you know quite separate from"},{"startTime":5715.1,"endTime":5716.6,"body":"most of his major contributions."},{"startTime":5717.233,"endTime":5719.566,"body":"He had a long-standing academic"},{"startTime":5719.566,"endTime":5721.5,"body":"scientific interest in"},{"startTime":5721.5,"endTime":5723.733,"body":"sexuality in all organisms."},{"startTime":5724.1,"endTime":5725.233,"body":"Honestly, I remember, you know"},{"startTime":5725.233,"endTime":5727.399,"body":"conversations about the lesbian gulls and"},{"startTime":5727.399,"endTime":5729.133,"body":"you know, the different the different"},{"startTime":5729.133,"endTime":5730.399,"body":"considerations that different"},{"startTime":5730.399,"endTime":5732.966,"body":"environmental conditions under which"},{"startTime":5732.966,"endTime":5737.733,"body":"female female sexual attraction evolves"},{"startTime":5737.733,"endTime":5741.1,"body":"in non-human species and how faculty if"},{"startTime":5741.1,"endTime":5742.966,"body":"it is and how common it is and how much"},{"startTime":5742.966,"endTime":5746.333,"body":"rare the evolution of male male"},{"startTime":5746.333,"endTime":5748.5,"body":"attraction is in non-human species and of"},{"startTime":5748.5,"endTime":5751.033,"body":"course that interest that academic that"},{"startTime":5751.033,"endTime":5752.066,"body":"scientific interest"},{"startTime":5752.066,"endTime":5753.433,"body":"extended to humans as well."},{"startTime":5753.433,"endTime":5755.233,"body":"He had great and long-standing interest"},{"startTime":5755.233,"endTime":5757.6,"body":"in all things human including all things"},{"startTime":5757.6,"endTime":5760.366,"body":"human sexually that is quite different"},{"startTime":5760.366,"endTime":5762.166,"body":"having having a research interest and"},{"startTime":5762.166,"endTime":5765.8,"body":"having a you know, a personal interest in"},{"startTime":5765.833,"endTime":5766.933,"body":"experiencing things"},{"startTime":5766.933,"endTime":5768.8,"body":"are completely different."},{"startTime":5769.266,"endTime":5772.233,"body":"Yes, in fact, so I would say not only do"},{"startTime":5772.233,"endTime":5774.899,"body":"you have an interest in all things sexual"},{"startTime":5774.899,"endTime":5776.233,"body":"as an evolutionary biologist."},{"startTime":5776.633,"endTime":5778.866,"body":"Obviously, it's an important it's one of"},{"startTime":5778.866,"endTime":5781.5,"body":"the most important factors, but he had an"},{"startTime":5781.5,"endTime":5783.866,"body":"interest in anything that was"},{"startTime":5783.866,"endTime":5786.133,"body":"non-standard because obviously there is"},{"startTime":5786.133,"endTime":5788.166,"body":"an evolutionary question of why we aren't"},{"startTime":5788.166,"endTime":5789.433,"body":"just simply all straight."},{"startTime":5790.066,"endTime":5790.266,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":5790.766,"endTime":5793.633,"body":"Yeah, so I remember a discussion from"},{"startTime":5793.633,"endTime":5796.166,"body":"that wonderful social evolution course"},{"startTime":5796.166,"endTime":5799.5,"body":"where we were lucky enough to experience"},{"startTime":5799.5,"endTime":5801.233,"body":"one of the great evolutionary biology"},{"startTime":5801.233,"endTime":5803.133,"body":"courses ever taught on Earth."},{"startTime":5803.133,"endTime":5805.766,"body":"I promise you it was that and I remember"},{"startTime":5805.766,"endTime":5808.866,"body":"him saying that one of the interesting"},{"startTime":5808.866,"endTime":5811.366,"body":"things he had noted apparently he had"},{"startTime":5811.366,"endTime":5813.699,"body":"done anonymous surveys of students."},{"startTime":5813.699,"endTime":5814.766,"body":"I don't think they just covered this"},{"startTime":5814.766,"endTime":5817.466,"body":"topic, but he said, you know, this class"},{"startTime":5817.466,"endTime":5821.433,"body":"is not representative of the larger"},{"startTime":5821.433,"endTime":5824.933,"body":"College the number of gay people in this"},{"startTime":5824.933,"endTime":5826.566,"body":"course is much lower than you would"},{"startTime":5826.566,"endTime":5829.333,"body":"expect based on the population of the"},{"startTime":5829.333,"endTime":5832.533,"body":"College the larger College and he"},{"startTime":5832.533,"endTime":5836.6,"body":"discussed a hypothesis for why that might"},{"startTime":5836.6,"endTime":5842.433,"body":"be and his his point at the time was that"},{"startTime":5842.433,"endTime":5845.866,"body":"he thought that gay people were likely to"},{"startTime":5845.866,"endTime":5848.333,"body":"think about the topic of evolution as"},{"startTime":5848.333,"endTime":5850.5,"body":"hostile to them because it is so focused"},{"startTime":5850.5,"endTime":5852.666,"body":"on reproduction and Bob was very"},{"startTime":5852.666,"endTime":5854.833,"body":"broad-minded and Bob knew better than to"},{"startTime":5854.833,"endTime":5855.966,"body":"think it was only"},{"startTime":5855.966,"endTime":5857.466,"body":"about direct reproduction."},{"startTime":5858.666,"endTime":5861.733,"body":"In fact, he my understanding of how Bob"},{"startTime":5861.733,"endTime":5863.3,"body":"became an evolutionary biologist."},{"startTime":5863.3,"endTime":5865.466,"body":"You tell me if I have any of the details"},{"startTime":5865.466,"endTime":5867.699,"body":"wrong as you know them, but he was a"},{"startTime":5867.699,"endTime":5871.966,"body":"mathematician in training and he spotted"},{"startTime":5871.966,"endTime":5875.1,"body":"basically the math inside of evolutionary"},{"startTime":5875.1,"endTime":5878.6,"body":"biology and he wrote to WD Hamilton,"},{"startTime":5879.066,"endTime":5881.466,"body":"maybe the greatest biologist or"},{"startTime":5881.466,"endTime":5884.066,"body":"evolutionary biologist since Darwin and"},{"startTime":5884.066,"endTime":5886.233,"body":"was encouraged by Hamilton."},{"startTime":5886.866,"endTime":5888.666,"body":"So Hamilton did not go on to be his"},{"startTime":5888.666,"endTime":5891.233,"body":"formal advisor, but they became friends"},{"startTime":5891.233,"endTime":5895.166,"body":"and colleagues and in any case, Hamilton"},{"startTime":5895.166,"endTime":5898.6,"body":"is famous among other things for putting"},{"startTime":5898.6,"endTime":5903.666,"body":"the mathematics to the logic of indirect"},{"startTime":5903.666,"endTime":5905.399,"body":"reproduction through kin."},{"startTime":5905.766,"endTime":5910.466,"body":"So the model called kin selection is a"},{"startTime":5910.466,"endTime":5912.166,"body":"formulation of WD Hamilton."},{"startTime":5913.1,"endTime":5916.5,"body":"And so anyway, Bob was one of the"},{"startTime":5916.5,"endTime":5918.066,"body":"messages that will come through here is"},{"startTime":5918.066,"endTime":5923.466,"body":"that Bob was not you can't peg"},{"startTime":5923.466,"endTime":5925.666,"body":"him as one thing or the other."},{"startTime":5925.666,"endTime":5927.466,"body":"He's an evolutionary biologist, but does"},{"startTime":5927.466,"endTime":5930.066,"body":"not have the biases of many other"},{"startTime":5930.133,"endTime":5931.166,"body":"evolutionary biologists."},{"startTime":5931.166,"endTime":5933.166,"body":"The collection of things that he did and"},{"startTime":5933.166,"endTime":5934.833,"body":"did not believe and suspected about"},{"startTime":5934.933,"endTime":5937.733,"body":"evolution was highly unique to Bob."},{"startTime":5938.633,"endTime":5941.3,"body":"Yeah, he had lived he had lived an"},{"startTime":5941.3,"endTime":5942.533,"body":"interesting life because he was the son"},{"startTime":5942.533,"endTime":5944.433,"body":"of a diplomat, I believe and"},{"startTime":5944.433,"endTime":5945.833,"body":"so had lived a number of places."},{"startTime":5946.433,"endTime":5948.233,"body":"That's not the story I remember, but I"},{"startTime":5948.233,"endTime":5950.133,"body":"can't quite place there is that there was"},{"startTime":5950.133,"endTime":5952.1,"body":"some famous a thologist under whom he"},{"startTime":5952.1,"endTime":5953.533,"body":"worked almost by chance."},{"startTime":5953.966,"endTime":5954.199,"body":"Irv."},{"startTime":5954.866,"endTime":5955.733,"body":"Oh, it was Irv Devore."},{"startTime":5956.133,"endTime":5959.233,"body":"Yeah, and having otherwise been thinking"},{"startTime":5959.233,"endTime":5962.233,"body":"about the law, I think and maybe maybe"},{"startTime":5962.233,"endTime":5965.133,"body":"also math, but I know my memory of the"},{"startTime":5965.133,"endTime":5966.666,"body":"details that hasn't"},{"startTime":5966.666,"endTime":5968.8,"body":"been re-upped in a while."},{"startTime":5968.8,"endTime":5970.266,"body":"So I don't I don't remember all of it,"},{"startTime":5970.266,"endTime":5974.3,"body":"but but yes, he was as the great"},{"startTime":5974.333,"endTime":5977.066,"body":"scientists always are interested in and"},{"startTime":5977.066,"endTime":5981.199,"body":"capable of making inferences in and"},{"startTime":5981.199,"endTime":5984.3,"body":"observations in across many, many domains"},{"startTime":5984.3,"endTime":5987.933,"body":"and the curiosity is almost boundless and"},{"startTime":5987.933,"endTime":5989.966,"body":"curiosity can look"},{"startTime":5989.966,"endTime":5992.533,"body":"dangerous when taken out of context."},{"startTime":5992.766,"endTime":5994.399,"body":"But this I mean, this is this is an issue"},{"startTime":5994.399,"endTime":5995.566,"body":"that is evolution of biologists."},{"startTime":5995.866,"endTime":5998.6,"body":"We we have seen a lot and you know, we're"},{"startTime":5998.6,"endTime":6001.8,"body":"perhaps first introduced to people's fear"},{"startTime":6001.8,"endTime":6004.733,"body":"of evolutionary questions indeed as"},{"startTime":6004.733,"endTime":6006.699,"body":"undergraduates when people in the social"},{"startTime":6006.699,"endTime":6008.433,"body":"sciences would say things like you can't"},{"startTime":6008.433,"endTime":6009.233,"body":"ask those questions."},{"startTime":6009.233,"endTime":6011.233,"body":"You can't ask what the evolutionary"},{"startTime":6011.233,"endTime":6014.8,"body":"foundations of genocide might be or of"},{"startTime":6014.8,"endTime":6018.366,"body":"rape and you know, an evolutionary take"},{"startTime":6018.366,"endTime":6022.233,"body":"is actually the more we know the better"},{"startTime":6022.233,"endTime":6025.166,"body":"able we can then take what we understand"},{"startTime":6025.166,"endTime":6028.0,"body":"about a thing that has no inherent moral"},{"startTime":6028.0,"endTime":6030.166,"body":"valence as it happens and we can apply"},{"startTime":6030.166,"endTime":6032.366,"body":"our understanding as humans with morals"},{"startTime":6032.366,"endTime":6034.733,"body":"and say that is despicable and if we"},{"startTime":6034.733,"endTime":6036.399,"body":"understand it better from an evolutionary"},{"startTime":6036.399,"endTime":6039.366,"body":"perspective, we are better able to reduce"},{"startTime":6039.366,"endTime":6042.466,"body":"its instance its incidence in the wild in"},{"startTime":6042.466,"endTime":6045.133,"body":"humans like it is it is through knowledge"},{"startTime":6045.133,"endTime":6047.766,"body":"that we can actually get these horrifying"},{"startTime":6047.766,"endTime":6050.266,"body":"human behaviors under control and I'm not"},{"startTime":6050.266,"endTime":6051.833,"body":"saying that that is there's any evidence"},{"startTime":6051.833,"endTime":6054.766,"body":"of exactly that in in this email, but in"},{"startTime":6054.766,"endTime":6058.433,"body":"general that is the that is that is an"},{"startTime":6058.433,"endTime":6060.733,"body":"argument that evolutionary biologists"},{"startTime":6060.733,"endTime":6062.333,"body":"find themselves having to make and it is"},{"startTime":6062.333,"endTime":6064.266,"body":"a legitimate argument over and over again"},{"startTime":6064.266,"endTime":6068.866,"body":"as we ask questions about ethnic conflict"},{"startTime":6068.866,"endTime":6071.133,"body":"about rape about about"},{"startTime":6071.133,"endTime":6072.5,"body":"genocide things like this."},{"startTime":6073.133,"endTime":6073.333,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":6074.633,"endTime":6076.333,"body":"So a couple things one."},{"startTime":6077.533,"endTime":6078.666,"body":"There is another email."},{"startTime":6079.066,"endTime":6080.633,"body":"I don't think there's anything especially"},{"startTime":6082.233,"endTime":6083.366,"body":"tantalizing in it."},{"startTime":6083.366,"endTime":6085.133,"body":"There's another email in this Tranche."},{"startTime":6085.133,"endTime":6086.833,"body":"It's not part of the same email chain."},{"startTime":6086.833,"endTime":6088.3,"body":"So it doesn't tell us what question he"},{"startTime":6088.3,"endTime":6090.3,"body":"thinks he's answering in the email that"},{"startTime":6090.3,"endTime":6092.266,"body":"you've just read, but there is another"},{"startTime":6092.266,"endTime":6094.366,"body":"email in which he discuss discusses the"},{"startTime":6094.366,"endTime":6098.666,"body":"lesbian gulls and it appears to be his"},{"startTime":6098.666,"endTime":6102.133,"body":"description of a book that he is writing"},{"startTime":6102.133,"endTime":6104.533,"body":"about other kinds of"},{"startTime":6104.533,"endTime":6106.166,"body":"sexuality other than straight."},{"startTime":6107.066,"endTime":6111.8,"body":"So anyway, that discussion is one that he"},{"startTime":6111.8,"endTime":6112.933,"body":"is participating in."},{"startTime":6112.933,"endTime":6116.199,"body":"I will also say you and I first met Bill"},{"startTime":6116.199,"endTime":6119.899,"body":"Hamilton through Bob at a party that Bob"},{"startTime":6119.899,"endTime":6121.566,"body":"threw in Santa Cruz."},{"startTime":6123.633,"endTime":6124.199,"body":"What a party."},{"startTime":6124.466,"endTime":6127.066,"body":"Yeah, it was well, let's just say nothing"},{"startTime":6127.066,"endTime":6128.733,"body":"wild happened there."},{"startTime":6128.733,"endTime":6130.033,"body":"No, no, no, it was actually it was"},{"startTime":6130.033,"endTime":6132.199,"body":"actually a fairly boring party except for"},{"startTime":6132.199,"endTime":6133.199,"body":"the people who were there"},{"startTime":6133.199,"endTime":6134.666,"body":"except for the fact that W.D."},{"startTime":6134.966,"endTime":6137.233,"body":"Hamilton was and"},{"startTime":6137.233,"endTime":6140.466,"body":"and the Dootons right of Oakland, right?"},{"startTime":6140.733,"endTime":6142.766,"body":"So I see it on your on your page there."},{"startTime":6142.766,"endTime":6143.966,"body":"So you were going to bring it up, but"},{"startTime":6145.633,"endTime":6146.266,"body":"Huey P."},{"startTime":6146.266,"endTime":6149.6,"body":"Newton the radical black activist Black"},{"startTime":6149.6,"endTime":6152.633,"body":"Panther Black Panther had a PhD in"},{"startTime":6152.633,"endTime":6154.899,"body":"biology from the University of California"},{"startTime":6154.899,"endTime":6158.333,"body":"at Santa Cruz because Bob Trivers had"},{"startTime":6158.333,"endTime":6162.5,"body":"encouraged him in his interest in doing"},{"startTime":6162.5,"endTime":6165.6,"body":"so and was his mentor there and after"},{"startTime":6165.6,"endTime":6169.033,"body":"Newton was killed after Huey P."},{"startTime":6169.033,"endTime":6171.166,"body":"Newton was killed which is long before or"},{"startTime":6171.166,"endTime":6173.733,"body":"at least somewhat before maybe not that"},{"startTime":6173.733,"endTime":6176.533,"body":"long before we met Bob Bob remain friends"},{"startTime":6176.533,"endTime":6179.199,"body":"with with Huey Newton's family and so,"},{"startTime":6179.199,"endTime":6181.566,"body":"you know this Bob occasionally through"},{"startTime":6181.566,"endTime":6182.8,"body":"these parties which again, there was"},{"startTime":6182.8,"endTime":6185.366,"body":"nothing remarkable about them except for"},{"startTime":6185.366,"endTime":6186.833,"body":"the fact that they were in a small"},{"startTime":6186.833,"endTime":6190.533,"body":"apartment Bob, you know, Bob had they"},{"startTime":6190.533,"endTime":6193.566,"body":"were a small underlit apartment in which"},{"startTime":6193.566,"endTime":6195.366,"body":"then, you know, he would and this is how"},{"startTime":6195.366,"endTime":6196.366,"body":"I remember him referring to them."},{"startTime":6196.366,"endTime":6197.566,"body":"The Newtons from Oakland were always"},{"startTime":6197.566,"endTime":6199.566,"body":"there a group of three four five people."},{"startTime":6199.566,"endTime":6201.533,"body":"I don't I don't really remember much more"},{"startTime":6201.533,"endTime":6202.333,"body":"than that except for the"},{"startTime":6202.333,"endTime":6203.433,"body":"Newtons from Oakland were there."},{"startTime":6203.966,"endTime":6206.666,"body":"We were always there when we were there a"},{"startTime":6206.666,"endTime":6208.199,"body":"few graduate students and then some"},{"startTime":6208.199,"endTime":6210.166,"body":"evolutionary luminary like W.T."},{"startTime":6210.166,"endTime":6211.8,"body":"Hamilton and then outside you'd be"},{"startTime":6211.8,"endTime":6213.0,"body":"smoking pot and inside."},{"startTime":6213.433,"endTime":6213.833,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":6213.833,"endTime":6215.199,"body":"I just served standing awkwardly around"},{"startTime":6215.199,"endTime":6217.133,"body":"there was Jamaican music, of course, but"},{"startTime":6217.133,"endTime":6220.133,"body":"well, but so this is this is a place"},{"startTime":6220.333,"endTime":6223.466,"body":"where you think you know what Bob is, but"},{"startTime":6223.466,"endTime":6225.266,"body":"it's unlikely right."},{"startTime":6225.466,"endTime":6225.866,"body":"So, okay."},{"startTime":6226.1,"endTime":6228.966,"body":"Yeah, not only was Bob very close with"},{"startTime":6228.966,"endTime":6231.466,"body":"Huey Newton Bob himself was a Black"},{"startTime":6231.466,"endTime":6233.766,"body":"Panther Bob was thrown out"},{"startTime":6233.766,"endTime":6235.5,"body":"of the Black Panthers a story."},{"startTime":6235.533,"endTime":6237.199,"body":"I don't completely understand, but I"},{"startTime":6237.199,"endTime":6238.566,"body":"think he was thrown out for his own"},{"startTime":6238.566,"endTime":6239.966,"body":"protection or something like that."},{"startTime":6240.666,"endTime":6242.666,"body":"So you would think not not for the"},{"startTime":6242.666,"endTime":6243.766,"body":"obvious fact that he"},{"startTime":6243.766,"endTime":6244.566,"body":"wasn't actually black."},{"startTime":6245.933,"endTime":6247.233,"body":"Well, I mean, I guess"},{"startTime":6247.233,"endTime":6248.166,"body":"we're going to go here."},{"startTime":6248.166,"endTime":6250.633,"body":"But the thing is, as you well know, but"},{"startTime":6250.633,"endTime":6253.899,"body":"those in the public will not Bob"},{"startTime":6253.899,"endTime":6257.3,"body":"preferred Black culture."},{"startTime":6258.066,"endTime":6259.3,"body":"He did not pretend to be"},{"startTime":6259.3,"endTime":6261.399,"body":"black, but he sought out."},{"startTime":6261.433,"endTime":6263.266,"body":"I mean, he built a house in Jamaica."},{"startTime":6263.433,"endTime":6266.033,"body":"He was married to a Jamaican woman."},{"startTime":6266.033,"endTime":6271.933,"body":"He felt more at home in that culture."},{"startTime":6271.933,"endTime":6273.733,"body":"He understood it and I went into the"},{"startTime":6273.733,"endTime":6275.033,"body":"field with him into Jamaica."},{"startTime":6275.033,"endTime":6277.133,"body":"So I saw him in his element there."},{"startTime":6277.833,"endTime":6281.766,"body":"I lived in his mother-in-law's house"},{"startTime":6281.766,"endTime":6284.3,"body":"while I was there and they took me in and"},{"startTime":6284.3,"endTime":6285.633,"body":"took care of me like a"},{"startTime":6285.633,"endTime":6286.466,"body":"member of the family."},{"startTime":6286.866,"endTime":6287.6,"body":"So anyway, I got to"},{"startTime":6287.6,"endTime":6289.466,"body":"see Bob in his element."},{"startTime":6290.233,"endTime":6292.399,"body":"But my point about him defying"},{"startTime":6292.399,"endTime":6297.433,"body":"expectations, you would think from the"},{"startTime":6297.633,"endTime":6298.6,"body":"connection to the Black"},{"startTime":6298.6,"endTime":6299.733,"body":"Panthers and Huey Newton,"},{"startTime":6300.833,"endTime":6303.366,"body":"you would think potentially from the"},{"startTime":6303.366,"endTime":6305.433,"body":"reading of that email that is so common"},{"startTime":6305.433,"endTime":6310.6,"body":"that Bob was a radical liberal,"},{"startTime":6311.666,"endTime":6311.866,"body":"right?"},{"startTime":6312.866,"endTime":6314.066,"body":"He was nothing of the kind."},{"startTime":6314.333,"endTime":6318.899,"body":"In fact, he, you know, I was quite a"},{"startTime":6318.899,"endTime":6320.733,"body":"young person at the point that I was in"},{"startTime":6320.733,"endTime":6322.8,"body":"the field with him sort of in 1991,"},{"startTime":6323.966,"endTime":6324.633,"body":"something like that."},{"startTime":6325.666,"endTime":6326.433,"body":"Maybe 1990."},{"startTime":6327.733,"endTime":6330.066,"body":"But anyway, you know, he and I argued"},{"startTime":6330.066,"endTime":6333.5,"body":"over this and he thought I was naive for"},{"startTime":6333.5,"endTime":6335.066,"body":"being as liberal as I was."},{"startTime":6335.633,"endTime":6337.866,"body":"He was not especially political except"},{"startTime":6337.866,"endTime":6343.366,"body":"when it came to the disdain for the way"},{"startTime":6343.366,"endTime":6344.5,"body":"American Blacks had"},{"startTime":6344.5,"endTime":6346.033,"body":"been treated by the system."},{"startTime":6346.866,"endTime":6348.266,"body":"He had deep disdain for"},{"startTime":6348.266,"endTime":6349.133,"body":"the American movement."},{"startTime":6349.133,"endTime":6350.066,"body":"He had deep disdain."},{"startTime":6350.066,"endTime":6351.6,"body":"But even there you think,"},{"startTime":6351.6,"endTime":6354.566,"body":"okay, he's not a radical liberal."},{"startTime":6355.533,"endTime":6356.666,"body":"And it's not even obvious to me that he"},{"startTime":6356.666,"endTime":6357.566,"body":"was a liberal at all."},{"startTime":6358.233,"endTime":6361.366,"body":"But you know, on this one issue, maybe he"},{"startTime":6361.366,"endTime":6362.233,"body":"was a radical liberal."},{"startTime":6362.733,"endTime":6364.666,"body":"No, not even there, right?"},{"startTime":6364.666,"endTime":6367.766,"body":"And I was, he was technically on Twitter."},{"startTime":6368.066,"endTime":6370.433,"body":"I think he, you know, he was too old to"},{"startTime":6370.433,"endTime":6371.966,"body":"ever take it on or something."},{"startTime":6372.033,"endTime":6373.533,"body":"But he had an account and I went to that"},{"startTime":6373.533,"endTime":6376.333,"body":"account yesterday just to see what was"},{"startTime":6376.333,"endTime":6379.199,"body":"there and it did not"},{"startTime":6379.199,"endTime":6380.433,"body":"surprise me terribly."},{"startTime":6380.833,"endTime":6383.033,"body":"But one of the things I found there and I"},{"startTime":6383.033,"endTime":6385.399,"body":"forgot to give it to Jen to show it, but"},{"startTime":6385.399,"endTime":6388.699,"body":"he posted a video of a black man."},{"startTime":6388.699,"endTime":6390.399,"body":"I don't know who it is very well-spoken"},{"startTime":6390.399,"endTime":6392.899,"body":"talking to a, I think it's a white"},{"startTime":6392.899,"endTime":6395.366,"body":"podcaster, somebody I don't recognize."},{"startTime":6396.133,"endTime":6398.933,"body":"But the black man is describing the fact"},{"startTime":6398.933,"endTime":6403.766,"body":"that liberals are abusing the concept of"},{"startTime":6403.766,"endTime":6406.233,"body":"slavery and that they are pretending that"},{"startTime":6406.233,"endTime":6407.133,"body":"this is a uniquely"},{"startTime":6407.433,"endTime":6409.133,"body":"white on black phenomenon."},{"startTime":6409.566,"endTime":6410.733,"body":"And that's not what it is."},{"startTime":6410.733,"endTime":6414.033,"body":"And this person describes sort of global"},{"startTime":6414.033,"endTime":6417.733,"body":"frequency with which slavery has"},{"startTime":6417.733,"endTime":6419.666,"body":"happened, the involvement of blacks in"},{"startTime":6419.666,"endTime":6421.766,"body":"enslaving other blacks and selling them"},{"startTime":6421.766,"endTime":6423.666,"body":"sometimes to blacks, sometimes to whites."},{"startTime":6423.933,"endTime":6427.433,"body":"But anyway, the point is Bob's sympathies"},{"startTime":6427.433,"endTime":6431.866,"body":"with American blacks was not of a kind"},{"startTime":6431.866,"endTime":6433.866,"body":"that you commonly encounter."},{"startTime":6434.166,"endTime":6436.866,"body":"He was not ideological as far as I ever"},{"startTime":6436.866,"endTime":6440.466,"body":"saw in any, in any context."},{"startTime":6441.233,"endTime":6444.166,"body":"He assessed situations as they arrived"},{"startTime":6444.166,"endTime":6445.966,"body":"and came to his own conclusions."},{"startTime":6446.933,"endTime":6448.966,"body":"And that's, you know, the conclusions"},{"startTime":6448.966,"endTime":6450.166,"body":"were not always the same ones that we"},{"startTime":6450.166,"endTime":6451.433,"body":"would, that either of us would come to."},{"startTime":6452.433,"endTime":6454.066,"body":"And I do think there's some evidence that"},{"startTime":6454.066,"endTime":6456.433,"body":"he, you know, wrote some things."},{"startTime":6456.433,"endTime":6458.233,"body":"I can't remember some sort of like woke"},{"startTime":6458.233,"endTime":6459.933,"body":"sound egg and anti-Trump"},{"startTime":6459.933,"endTime":6461.933,"body":"rants at some, at some points."},{"startTime":6463.733,"endTime":6467.433,"body":"But this is not, he can't be slotted in"},{"startTime":6467.433,"endTime":6471.666,"body":"to any political category for sure."},{"startTime":6471.666,"endTime":6473.733,"body":"And I think really to any category other"},{"startTime":6473.733,"endTime":6475.466,"body":"than, you know,"},{"startTime":6475.466,"endTime":6476.733,"body":"brilliant evolutionary biologist."},{"startTime":6477.199,"endTime":6477.399,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":6477.533,"endTime":6479.0,"body":"Now I wanted to add one other thing."},{"startTime":6479.033,"endTime":6482.666,"body":"One of the places that Bob was way ahead"},{"startTime":6482.666,"endTime":6485.766,"body":"of most evolutionary biologists is that"},{"startTime":6485.766,"endTime":6490.633,"body":"he did not suffer from believing the"},{"startTime":6490.633,"endTime":6493.066,"body":"trope that is now widely used to"},{"startTime":6493.066,"endTime":6495.033,"body":"discredit what is now called evolutionary"},{"startTime":6495.033,"endTime":6496.733,"body":"psychology, what would once have been"},{"startTime":6496.733,"endTime":6498.166,"body":"called socio biology,"},{"startTime":6499.3,"endTime":6501.433,"body":"the claim that many of the things that"},{"startTime":6501.433,"endTime":6504.199,"body":"these biologists are talking about are"},{"startTime":6504.199,"endTime":6506.966,"body":"cultural and therefore not evolutionary."},{"startTime":6508.233,"endTime":6509.966,"body":"Bob was way ahead on this front."},{"startTime":6510.233,"endTime":6511.833,"body":"Bob understood that culture was an"},{"startTime":6511.833,"endTime":6513.6,"body":"evolutionary phenomenon, even if we"},{"startTime":6513.6,"endTime":6514.466,"body":"didn't understand the"},{"startTime":6514.466,"endTime":6515.766,"body":"exact interaction of them."},{"startTime":6516.333,"endTime":6518.866,"body":"So he took human behavior very seriously."},{"startTime":6519.866,"endTime":6522.933,"body":"And in any case, just you"},{"startTime":6522.933,"endTime":6523.933,"body":"said it very well there."},{"startTime":6524.566,"endTime":6527.166,"body":"You can't slot him into any known"},{"startTime":6527.166,"endTime":6529.433,"body":"category because he was very much a"},{"startTime":6529.433,"endTime":6531.566,"body":"one-off individual for"},{"startTime":6531.566,"endTime":6532.399,"body":"both better and worse."},{"startTime":6533.133,"endTime":6535.666,"body":"But in terms of his insight into biology,"},{"startTime":6536.066,"endTime":6540.233,"body":"he had deep interest in non usual human"},{"startTime":6540.333,"endTime":6542.666,"body":"sexuality precisely because it inherently"},{"startTime":6542.666,"endTime":6544.899,"body":"raises an evolutionary question."},{"startTime":6545.433,"endTime":6547.733,"body":"That's in the emails."},{"startTime":6548.033,"endTime":6550.266,"body":"The one that you read is confusing"},{"startTime":6550.266,"endTime":6553.866,"body":"because of its grotesqueness, but it's in"},{"startTime":6553.866,"endTime":6555.366,"body":"the other emails where he's discussing,"},{"startTime":6555.366,"endTime":6557.433,"body":"you know, his book project."},{"startTime":6558.133,"endTime":6561.366,"body":"He specifically says that he wants to"},{"startTime":6561.366,"endTime":6563.6,"body":"include lots of animal examples of"},{"startTime":6563.6,"endTime":6565.733,"body":"unusual sexuality, but he's afraid of"},{"startTime":6565.733,"endTime":6567.899,"body":"boring the people who are human focused."},{"startTime":6569.0,"endTime":6573.566,"body":"So, you know, this is the context in"},{"startTime":6573.566,"endTime":6575.033,"body":"which you and I are reading it."},{"startTime":6575.033,"endTime":6577.433,"body":"And I will say I was talking to a good"},{"startTime":6577.433,"endTime":6580.066,"body":"friend of Bob's a couple days ago, and he"},{"startTime":6580.066,"endTime":6583.366,"body":"was telling me stories in which Bob, he"},{"startTime":6583.366,"endTime":6585.199,"body":"basically said that Bob would humor any"},{"startTime":6585.233,"endTime":6587.1,"body":"perspective and take it seriously in"},{"startTime":6587.1,"endTime":6588.199,"body":"order to have the argument."},{"startTime":6588.199,"endTime":6590.133,"body":"And that's how I remember Bob also."},{"startTime":6590.633,"endTime":6593.033,"body":"So I wish we did know what question he"},{"startTime":6593.033,"endTime":6594.566,"body":"was responding to in that email."},{"startTime":6594.566,"endTime":6598.366,"body":"It doesn't fully vindicate it, but it it"},{"startTime":6598.366,"endTime":6599.766,"body":"would go a long way to saying what"},{"startTime":6599.766,"endTime":6601.066,"body":"exactly he was getting at."},{"startTime":6601.333,"endTime":6604.766,"body":"But let's see what what else do I know?"},{"startTime":6604.766,"endTime":6608.1,"body":"Well, you would I think when we were"},{"startTime":6608.1,"endTime":6609.566,"body":"talking before like what you"},{"startTime":6609.566,"endTime":6610.733,"body":"know, what do you want to say?"},{"startTime":6610.733,"endTime":6613.033,"body":"I will say that I have I have known for a"},{"startTime":6613.033,"endTime":6613.8,"body":"while that Bob was"},{"startTime":6613.8,"endTime":6615.033,"body":"nearing the end of his life."},{"startTime":6615.033,"endTime":6617.233,"body":"And so have been thinking about writing"},{"startTime":6617.233,"endTime":6618.333,"body":"an obituary for a while."},{"startTime":6618.333,"endTime":6619.366,"body":"And so I have written some things."},{"startTime":6619.366,"endTime":6620.866,"body":"I'm not going to share them here, but I"},{"startTime":6620.866,"endTime":6622.366,"body":"think both you and I"},{"startTime":6622.366,"endTime":6624.8,"body":"have have much more to say."},{"startTime":6624.8,"endTime":6628.933,"body":"But I think you were planning to mention"},{"startTime":6628.933,"endTime":6632.466,"body":"that he was he is still but he's at the"},{"startTime":6632.466,"endTime":6633.533,"body":"end of his life now."},{"startTime":6634.466,"endTime":6637.466,"body":"Extraordinarily complicated had had"},{"startTime":6637.466,"endTime":6639.566,"body":"mental instability and"},{"startTime":6639.566,"endTime":6640.933,"body":"always had money tribbles."},{"startTime":6641.866,"endTime":6644.133,"body":"And so, you know, anyone who knew him, I"},{"startTime":6644.133,"endTime":6648.333,"body":"remember an animal behavior conference in"},{"startTime":6648.333,"endTime":6651.466,"body":"Atlanta in, gosh, would have been like"},{"startTime":6651.466,"endTime":6654.233,"body":"the late 90s years since we had been in"},{"startTime":6654.233,"endTime":6655.399,"body":"near daily contact"},{"startTime":6655.399,"endTime":6656.3,"body":"with him at Santa Cruz."},{"startTime":6658.733,"endTime":6661.699,"body":"But I think after I think after maybe"},{"startTime":6661.699,"endTime":6664.833,"body":"before we had actually invited him to be"},{"startTime":6664.833,"endTime":6666.433,"body":"the man who would marry us, he was the"},{"startTime":6666.433,"endTime":6667.5,"body":"officiant at our wedding."},{"startTime":6667.833,"endTime":6669.566,"body":"So this this is a man who we obviously"},{"startTime":6669.566,"endTime":6673.3,"body":"felt felt strongly positively about that"},{"startTime":6673.3,"endTime":6675.633,"body":"that he would oversee oversee that."},{"startTime":6676.433,"endTime":6678.766,"body":"But he was given the plenary at the"},{"startTime":6678.766,"endTime":6680.933,"body":"animal behavior conference in"},{"startTime":6680.933,"endTime":6684.066,"body":"in Atlanta in whatever year."},{"startTime":6684.066,"endTime":6684.966,"body":"I don't remember what year this would"},{"startTime":6684.966,"endTime":6686.066,"body":"have been, but late 90s."},{"startTime":6686.699,"endTime":6689.166,"body":"And he was not totally"},{"startTime":6689.166,"endTime":6690.566,"body":"having a stable moment."},{"startTime":6690.566,"endTime":6692.933,"body":"His talk was was great as I remember it,"},{"startTime":6692.933,"endTime":6694.8,"body":"but he was dressed entirely in gold lame."},{"startTime":6695.833,"endTime":6697.666,"body":"That does sound like Bob."},{"startTime":6698.433,"endTime":6700.733,"body":"And and I had seen I had seen him the day"},{"startTime":6700.733,"endTime":6702.6,"body":"before I'd been wandering and he sort of"},{"startTime":6702.6,"endTime":6704.1,"body":"saw me across campus like Heather High"},{"startTime":6704.1,"endTime":6707.1,"body":"and you know, went over and we spent a"},{"startTime":6707.1,"endTime":6710.166,"body":"couple of hours talking both him hashing"},{"startTime":6710.166,"endTime":6710.833,"body":"out what he was going to"},{"startTime":6710.833,"endTime":6712.166,"body":"say in his in his talk."},{"startTime":6712.566,"endTime":6715.533,"body":"But also it was clear that he was having"},{"startTime":6715.533,"endTime":6717.766,"body":"a manic moment and that as soon as he"},{"startTime":6717.766,"endTime":6719.533,"body":"gave his talk, he was going to fly to"},{"startTime":6719.533,"endTime":6720.466,"body":"Jamaica because that's"},{"startTime":6720.466,"endTime":6721.199,"body":"where he felt most at home."},{"startTime":6721.233,"endTime":6725.333,"body":"And I was shocked then that his"},{"startTime":6725.333,"endTime":6727.366,"body":"brilliance was not sufficient."},{"startTime":6727.366,"endTime":6728.833,"body":"And there was there was nothing untoward"},{"startTime":6728.833,"endTime":6730.033,"body":"about anything he was doing."},{"startTime":6730.033,"endTime":6732.133,"body":"It was like he just literally showed up"},{"startTime":6732.133,"endTime":6733.966,"body":"showed up in entirely gold lame suits,"},{"startTime":6733.966,"endTime":6736.566,"body":"which was not common."},{"startTime":6737.033,"endTime":6737.966,"body":"Like I've never seen it before."},{"startTime":6737.966,"endTime":6741.399,"body":"Was on the audience included some"},{"startTime":6741.399,"endTime":6742.733,"body":"graduate students who were very"},{"startTime":6742.733,"endTime":6747.366,"body":"disrespectful of him and who were clearly"},{"startTime":6747.366,"endTime":6750.066,"body":"laughing at the fashion choice as opposed"},{"startTime":6750.066,"endTime":6753.033,"body":"to at the at the man whose brilliance was"},{"startTime":6753.033,"endTime":6755.433,"body":"still on display on clear display."},{"startTime":6756.133,"endTime":6759.066,"body":"And I thought then this is a man whose"},{"startTime":6759.066,"endTime":6763.733,"body":"struggles in parts of his life may cause"},{"startTime":6763.733,"endTime":6765.966,"body":"him not to be recognized for the"},{"startTime":6765.966,"endTime":6767.566,"body":"extraordinary contributions that he's"},{"startTime":6767.566,"endTime":6769.6,"body":"made to the human understanding of not"},{"startTime":6769.6,"endTime":6770.566,"body":"just the human condition,"},{"startTime":6770.866,"endTime":6772.6,"body":"but all of life on Earth."},{"startTime":6773.766,"endTime":6775.066,"body":"Several things to add one."},{"startTime":6776.766,"endTime":6779.966,"body":"The gold lame definitely is indicative of"},{"startTime":6779.966,"endTime":6781.866,"body":"exactly what you're saying, but it is"},{"startTime":6781.866,"endTime":6785.8,"body":"also connected into the sort of Jamaica"},{"startTime":6785.8,"endTime":6788.833,"body":"thread of his life because it is the kind"},{"startTime":6788.833,"endTime":6790.933,"body":"of choice that would be much more."},{"startTime":6790.933,"endTime":6792.866,"body":"I mean, it's still a little extreme, but"},{"startTime":6792.866,"endTime":6795.833,"body":"it would be much more natural in the more"},{"startTime":6795.833,"endTime":6798.266,"body":"demonstrative culture of Jamaica."},{"startTime":6798.533,"endTime":6800.366,"body":"I mean, that's one of the things to make"},{"startTime":6800.366,"endTime":6802.233,"body":"it was very eye-opening to me and"},{"startTime":6802.233,"endTime":6806.199,"body":"watching the way the exuberant way in"},{"startTime":6806.199,"endTime":6807.8,"body":"which people lived and did"},{"startTime":6807.8,"endTime":6812.199,"body":"everything was very eye-opening."},{"startTime":6812.533,"endTime":6813.866,"body":"So anyway, if you dressed"},{"startTime":6813.866,"endTime":6815.5,"body":"up, you dressed up, right?"},{"startTime":6816.866,"endTime":6818.5,"body":"So anyway, you could imagine even know"},{"startTime":6818.5,"endTime":6819.466,"body":"where you source a gold."},{"startTime":6819.466,"endTime":6820.066,"body":"I may suit on."},{"startTime":6822.533,"endTime":6825.366,"body":"Yeah, this is just before, you"},{"startTime":6825.366,"endTime":6827.399,"body":"know, you can just Google it."},{"startTime":6827.433,"endTime":6829.1,"body":"Yeah, he couldn't have just Googled it."},{"startTime":6829.1,"endTime":6831.566,"body":"I mean, frankly, the town where his"},{"startTime":6831.566,"endTime":6835.3,"body":"family lives, Southfield, when I was"},{"startTime":6835.3,"endTime":6838.133,"body":"there in 1990 or 1991, there was"},{"startTime":6838.133,"endTime":6840.466,"body":"literally not even a phone, right?"},{"startTime":6840.466,"endTime":6843.533,"body":"It was that, you know, I rode my bike to"},{"startTime":6843.533,"endTime":6845.433,"body":"the junction to call you because the"},{"startTime":6845.433,"endTime":6846.899,"body":"junction, you know, the junction of the"},{"startTime":6846.899,"endTime":6848.133,"body":"roads was also the junction of the"},{"startTime":6848.133,"endTime":6849.533,"body":"telephone lines and there was a payphone"},{"startTime":6849.533,"endTime":6851.466,"body":"there, which didn't always work, even"},{"startTime":6851.466,"endTime":6852.733,"body":"though it was like, I don't"},{"startTime":6852.733,"endTime":6853.566,"body":"know, it was eight or ten miles."},{"startTime":6853.866,"endTime":6856.033,"body":"It was a long ride to discover that the"},{"startTime":6856.033,"endTime":6856.866,"body":"payphone wasn't working."},{"startTime":6857.933,"endTime":6860.966,"body":"But but you're worth it."},{"startTime":6861.433,"endTime":6861.833,"body":"Thank you."},{"startTime":6862.966,"endTime":6864.8,"body":"So I did want to say something about the"},{"startTime":6864.8,"endTime":6866.233,"body":"choice of Bob as the"},{"startTime":6866.233,"endTime":6867.166,"body":"officiant at our wedding."},{"startTime":6867.433,"endTime":6869.0,"body":"Okay, because you and I were very"},{"startTime":6869.0,"endTime":6869.966,"body":"deliberate about that"},{"startTime":6869.966,"endTime":6872.133,"body":"and it went off great."},{"startTime":6872.133,"endTime":6872.966,"body":"He did a great job."},{"startTime":6872.966,"endTime":6875.733,"body":"But the reason that we chose Bob was that"},{"startTime":6875.733,"endTime":6877.566,"body":"we were evolutionary biologists."},{"startTime":6878.733,"endTime":6881.433,"body":"A religious officiant didn't exactly seem"},{"startTime":6881.433,"endTime":6884.266,"body":"like the right thing to do, but Bob"},{"startTime":6884.266,"endTime":6886.666,"body":"again, not being the person that you"},{"startTime":6886.666,"endTime":6888.533,"body":"would expect when you hear, oh, you know,"},{"startTime":6888.733,"endTime":6890.266,"body":"Harvard trained evolutionary biologist,"},{"startTime":6891.366,"endTime":6892.533,"body":"Bob was a religious guy."},{"startTime":6893.533,"endTime":6894.833,"body":"And so he understood"},{"startTime":6894.833,"endTime":6896.699,"body":"the intersection between."},{"startTime":6896.699,"endTime":6897.533,"body":"He understood himself to"},{"startTime":6897.533,"endTime":6898.433,"body":"be a Christian, I believe."},{"startTime":6899.033,"endTime":6900.399,"body":"I don't, you know, I was"},{"startTime":6900.399,"endTime":6901.666,"body":"struggling with that yesterday."},{"startTime":6902.033,"endTime":6903.866,"body":"I feel almost certain that that's what he"},{"startTime":6903.866,"endTime":6906.033,"body":"would say he was, but I don't remember"},{"startTime":6906.033,"endTime":6907.1,"body":"him ever saying it and I"},{"startTime":6907.1,"endTime":6907.966,"body":"don't know it for sure."},{"startTime":6908.233,"endTime":6910.366,"body":"Certainly he had spirituality and he and"},{"startTime":6910.366,"endTime":6913.066,"body":"he talked about Jesus with"},{"startTime":6913.066,"endTime":6914.666,"body":"a familiarity and a respect."},{"startTime":6915.633,"endTime":6915.8,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":6915.833,"endTime":6917.766,"body":"So anyway, he seemed like the right guy"},{"startTime":6917.766,"endTime":6919.733,"body":"for the job, assuming that he was going"},{"startTime":6919.733,"endTime":6922.633,"body":"to show up in his more functional phase."},{"startTime":6924.233,"endTime":6925.833,"body":"But anyway, and he did a great job."},{"startTime":6925.833,"endTime":6927.966,"body":"He he he threaded the needle with respect"},{"startTime":6927.966,"endTime":6931.133,"body":"to treating the you know, the spiritual"},{"startTime":6931.133,"endTime":6934.333,"body":"responsibility of the officiant properly"},{"startTime":6934.333,"endTime":6937.666,"body":"and also not pretending that we were"},{"startTime":6937.666,"endTime":6939.633,"body":"believers in the standard sense,"},{"startTime":6939.933,"endTime":6945.233,"body":"including he insisted on a on a meeting."},{"startTime":6945.666,"endTime":6947.133,"body":"Frank, that doesn't sound important"},{"startTime":6947.133,"endTime":6948.633,"body":"enough, but on a meeting with us in"},{"startTime":6948.633,"endTime":6952.5,"body":"advance of the ceremony to discuss to"},{"startTime":6952.5,"endTime":6954.233,"body":"discuss us, to discuss our relationship"},{"startTime":6954.233,"endTime":6957.566,"body":"and specifically, as I remember, to ask"},{"startTime":6957.566,"endTime":6959.033,"body":"us if we intended to have children"},{"startTime":6959.033,"endTime":6962.333,"body":"because he was he was there."},{"startTime":6962.333,"endTime":6963.266,"body":"He was going to be our officiant"},{"startTime":6963.266,"endTime":6967.966,"body":"regardless, but he felt that people who"},{"startTime":6967.966,"endTime":6968.733,"body":"were choosing to be"},{"startTime":6968.733,"endTime":6969.833,"body":"married should have children."},{"startTime":6970.766,"endTime":6973.966,"body":"And he wanted to know if he wanted to."},{"startTime":6974.266,"endTime":6976.033,"body":"He thought he knew already, but he wanted"},{"startTime":6976.033,"endTime":6978.633,"body":"to make sure that this were true before"},{"startTime":6978.633,"endTime":6981.433,"body":"he before he performed a marriage"},{"startTime":6981.433,"endTime":6983.766,"body":"ceremony that might, if he had been"},{"startTime":6983.766,"endTime":6984.733,"body":"wrong, been meant"},{"startTime":6984.733,"endTime":6985.699,"body":"something else entirely."},{"startTime":6986.433,"endTime":6986.633,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":6987.266,"endTime":6989.033,"body":"Had we said that we were not planning to"},{"startTime":6989.033,"endTime":6991.033,"body":"have them, I am certain we would have"},{"startTime":6991.033,"endTime":6992.966,"body":"gotten a talking to and that it would"},{"startTime":6992.966,"endTime":6997.266,"body":"have included what the right word is like"},{"startTime":6997.266,"endTime":6999.6,"body":"a highly sophisticated zinger, the kind"},{"startTime":6999.6,"endTime":7000.5,"body":"of thing that lands."},{"startTime":7000.766,"endTime":7002.699,"body":"And you never forget that it was said,"},{"startTime":7002.699,"endTime":7005.6,"body":"you know, that kind of thing, you know,"},{"startTime":7005.6,"endTime":7007.5,"body":"like there was a wedding"},{"startTime":7007.5,"endTime":7010.566,"body":"in Jamaica when I was there."},{"startTime":7011.366,"endTime":7013.033,"body":"I think I was invited to go to it, though"},{"startTime":7013.033,"endTime":7014.933,"body":"I didn't know the people was crazy."},{"startTime":7016.033,"endTime":7018.733,"body":"Hurried goat was the wedding."},{"startTime":7018.733,"endTime":7020.366,"body":"The wedding food is delicious."},{"startTime":7021.633,"endTime":7026.199,"body":"But anyway, it started to rain at the"},{"startTime":7026.199,"endTime":7027.066,"body":"beginning of the day."},{"startTime":7027.066,"endTime":7028.366,"body":"And it was clear that this outdoor"},{"startTime":7028.366,"endTime":7031.533,"body":"ceremony was going to be, you know, soggy"},{"startTime":7031.533,"endTime":7032.8,"body":"at best and maybe drenched."},{"startTime":7032.8,"endTime":7034.033,"body":"And I said, Bob, you know,"},{"startTime":7035.833,"endTime":7036.733,"body":"what do we think about"},{"startTime":7036.733,"endTime":7037.566,"body":"the fact that it's raining?"},{"startTime":7037.8,"endTime":7039.6,"body":"And he said, it's a blessing, Bret."},{"startTime":7040.933,"endTime":7042.733,"body":"You know, like you can't figure this out."},{"startTime":7043.199,"endTime":7045.833,"body":"Like, of course it rains on ceremonies."},{"startTime":7046.066,"endTime":7047.533,"body":"You have to treat it as a blessing."},{"startTime":7047.533,"endTime":7047.733,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7047.966,"endTime":7049.866,"body":"And of course they would."},{"startTime":7050.533,"endTime":7052.933,"body":"And as I remember, there was an errant"},{"startTime":7052.933,"endTime":7056.133,"body":"single giant lightning strike and"},{"startTime":7056.133,"endTime":7059.833,"body":"thunderclap at the moment of Bob"},{"startTime":7059.833,"endTime":7061.133,"body":"finishing his officiant"},{"startTime":7061.133,"endTime":7062.866,"body":"duties and us getting married."},{"startTime":7063.1,"endTime":7064.766,"body":"He slam dunked the assignment and the"},{"startTime":7064.766,"endTime":7066.199,"body":"universe was clapping."},{"startTime":7066.533,"endTime":7067.433,"body":"Yeah, exactly."},{"startTime":7067.866,"endTime":7070.166,"body":"And not in Jamaica in the Eastern Sierra."},{"startTime":7072.933,"endTime":7078.766,"body":"So I do want to say I think that his"},{"startTime":7078.766,"endTime":7082.533,"body":"relationship to his mental health issues"},{"startTime":7082.533,"endTime":7086.166,"body":"is not the relationship of Nash depicted"},{"startTime":7086.166,"endTime":7087.033,"body":"in a beautiful mind."},{"startTime":7087.333,"endTime":7088.433,"body":"People will have seen it."},{"startTime":7089.0,"endTime":7091.666,"body":"You know, Nash, at least as the story"},{"startTime":7091.666,"endTime":7092.833,"body":"go, Nash, the mathematician."},{"startTime":7093.133,"endTime":7098.033,"body":"Yes, effectively mastered his I think it"},{"startTime":7098.033,"endTime":7101.466,"body":"was schizophrenia by sort of learning to"},{"startTime":7101.466,"endTime":7103.233,"body":"recognize what that he"},{"startTime":7103.233,"endTime":7104.6,"body":"was seeing wasn't real."},{"startTime":7104.6,"endTime":7106.766,"body":"And he sort of had control over it."},{"startTime":7107.133,"endTime":7108.333,"body":"Bob didn't."},{"startTime":7108.333,"endTime":7110.633,"body":"And probably, you know, I don't I don't"},{"startTime":7110.633,"endTime":7113.166,"body":"I'm not 100 percent certain what it was."},{"startTime":7113.166,"endTime":7116.1,"body":"But the fact is Bob was well known in"},{"startTime":7116.1,"endTime":7120.133,"body":"academic circles to have issues."},{"startTime":7120.933,"endTime":7121.8,"body":"It is erratic."},{"startTime":7123.0,"endTime":7125.633,"body":"It interface terribly with his ability to"},{"startTime":7125.633,"endTime":7126.8,"body":"hold down a position."},{"startTime":7127.366,"endTime":7130.933,"body":"The community correctly viewed it as"},{"startTime":7130.933,"endTime":7132.766,"body":"their obligation to take"},{"startTime":7132.766,"endTime":7134.233,"body":"care of him in some way."},{"startTime":7134.466,"endTime":7136.066,"body":"But Bob never made it easy."},{"startTime":7136.066,"endTime":7137.966,"body":"He was his own worst enemy."},{"startTime":7138.199,"endTime":7140.0,"body":"And I feel certain that Bob would agree"},{"startTime":7140.0,"endTime":7141.733,"body":"to that statement with a laugh."},{"startTime":7142.233,"endTime":7143.8,"body":"Of course, he's his own worst enemy."},{"startTime":7144.1,"endTime":7144.3,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7145.333,"endTime":7149.266,"body":"But I do think this highly unusual"},{"startTime":7149.266,"endTime":7151.199,"body":"individual has to be understood."},{"startTime":7151.199,"endTime":7154.033,"body":"You can't make almost any leap about what"},{"startTime":7154.033,"endTime":7156.3,"body":"you think he must have been thinking or"},{"startTime":7156.3,"endTime":7159.1,"body":"you know, what he would and wouldn't do."},{"startTime":7159.1,"endTime":7160.766,"body":"It's it's just not a reasonable"},{"startTime":7160.766,"endTime":7161.633,"body":"conclusion with"},{"startTime":7161.633,"endTime":7163.133,"body":"somebody as unusual as this."},{"startTime":7163.133,"endTime":7165.199,"body":"But just to I don't want to have to keep"},{"startTime":7165.199,"endTime":7166.733,"body":"coming back to it, but just to repeat,"},{"startTime":7166.733,"endTime":7167.833,"body":"you know, his own worst enemy."},{"startTime":7168.033,"endTime":7168.266,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":7169.266,"endTime":7172.666,"body":"But a man with no interest, no interest"},{"startTime":7172.666,"endTime":7175.199,"body":"sexually in anything but adult women."},{"startTime":7175.333,"endTime":7175.5,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":7176.466,"endTime":7179.233,"body":"And, you know, there's there's stuff on"},{"startTime":7179.233,"endTime":7181.766,"body":"record about him talking about girls"},{"startTime":7181.766,"endTime":7183.966,"body":"becoming women physically"},{"startTime":7183.966,"endTime":7185.5,"body":"earlier than they used to."},{"startTime":7185.866,"endTime":7186.733,"body":"And this is a comment"},{"startTime":7186.733,"endTime":7187.933,"body":"that many people have made."},{"startTime":7189.199,"endTime":7192.433,"body":"There is there is a difference between"},{"startTime":7192.433,"endTime":7193.766,"body":"being interested in girls and being"},{"startTime":7193.766,"endTime":7194.466,"body":"interested in women."},{"startTime":7194.933,"endTime":7196.466,"body":"And that doesn't mean that being"},{"startTime":7196.466,"endTime":7198.966,"body":"interested in 16 year olds who have the"},{"startTime":7198.966,"endTime":7200.266,"body":"bodies of women and the"},{"startTime":7200.266,"endTime":7203.399,"body":"mind still of children is OK."},{"startTime":7203.866,"endTime":7205.8,"body":"But it's very different from what most"},{"startTime":7205.8,"endTime":7207.566,"body":"people think of when they imagine"},{"startTime":7207.566,"endTime":7211.166,"body":"pedophilia, for instance, that has that"},{"startTime":7211.166,"endTime":7212.333,"body":"is zero relationship"},{"startTime":7212.333,"endTime":7213.833,"body":"to the man that we know."},{"startTime":7215.166,"endTime":7216.766,"body":"And I will also say I've now forgotten"},{"startTime":7216.766,"endTime":7218.233,"body":"what the term is, but I think there is"},{"startTime":7218.233,"endTime":7219.566,"body":"even a technical term that"},{"startTime":7219.566,"endTime":7221.666,"body":"distinguishes those states."},{"startTime":7222.033,"endTime":7225.333,"body":"And I don't know what it is, but it's a"},{"startTime":7225.333,"endTime":7226.666,"body":"distinction that nobody likes to hear"},{"startTime":7226.666,"endTime":7228.5,"body":"made because, frankly, I think it's"},{"startTime":7228.5,"endTime":7230.333,"body":"disgusting for older men to target"},{"startTime":7230.333,"endTime":7231.633,"body":"younger women, legal or not."},{"startTime":7232.6,"endTime":7235.833,"body":"But but nonetheless, Bob"},{"startTime":7235.833,"endTime":7238.433,"body":"has to be taken as he was."},{"startTime":7238.433,"endTime":7239.833,"body":"And he was very much an evolutionary"},{"startTime":7239.833,"endTime":7242.366,"body":"biologist, clearly answering a question"},{"startTime":7242.366,"endTime":7246.199,"body":"and doing so without the expectation that"},{"startTime":7246.199,"endTime":7246.866,"body":"it was going to be"},{"startTime":7246.866,"endTime":7248.466,"body":"read by people, obviously."},{"startTime":7248.866,"endTime":7250.5,"body":"And it's not surprising that people"},{"startTime":7250.5,"endTime":7253.166,"body":"reading it with the sense that Epstein is"},{"startTime":7253.166,"endTime":7255.033,"body":"this terrifying,"},{"startTime":7255.766,"endTime":7257.433,"body":"obviously evil human being."},{"startTime":7258.0,"endTime":7258.199,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7258.333,"endTime":7258.866,"body":"This is 2018."},{"startTime":7259.199,"endTime":7259.6,"body":"It was known."},{"startTime":7260.133,"endTime":7260.433,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7260.433,"endTime":7261.899,"body":"Like, yes, it was."},{"startTime":7261.899,"endTime":7265.433,"body":"And Bob, his his terrible mistake"},{"startTime":7265.433,"endTime":7268.0,"body":"defending Epstein post conviction."},{"startTime":7268.133,"endTime":7268.466,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7268.466,"endTime":7269.933,"body":"But only 2014 or something."},{"startTime":7269.933,"endTime":7270.266,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7270.466,"endTime":7273.133,"body":"He regretted very quickly."},{"startTime":7274.233,"endTime":7276.866,"body":"Knew it was a mistake, but OK."},{"startTime":7279.0,"endTime":7280.066,"body":"I have a note I can't read."},{"startTime":7281.133,"endTime":7282.6,"body":"It's nothing new there."},{"startTime":7283.833,"endTime":7284.6,"body":"Is there anything else"},{"startTime":7284.6,"endTime":7287.066,"body":"that needs to be said here?"},{"startTime":7290.266,"endTime":7292.866,"body":"You know, not not not that I"},{"startTime":7292.866,"endTime":7293.733,"body":"can think of at the moment."},{"startTime":7294.399,"endTime":7296.466,"body":"I think there's so"},{"startTime":7296.466,"endTime":7298.3,"body":"much to be said about him."},{"startTime":7298.3,"endTime":7299.433,"body":"And I, you know, I have"},{"startTime":7299.433,"endTime":7301.466,"body":"been I didn't see this coming."},{"startTime":7301.733,"endTime":7302.8,"body":"I didn't see this email coming."},{"startTime":7304.133,"endTime":7306.266,"body":"But but we both knew because the world"},{"startTime":7306.266,"endTime":7310.766,"body":"knew that he had had friendship with"},{"startTime":7310.766,"endTime":7313.433,"body":"Epstein and that and that he had received"},{"startTime":7313.433,"endTime":7316.033,"body":"some money for some research that was"},{"startTime":7316.033,"endTime":7316.866,"body":"completely unrelated to"},{"startTime":7316.866,"endTime":7318.066,"body":"anything about sexuality."},{"startTime":7318.066,"endTime":7322.199,"body":"It was like a function and running and it"},{"startTime":7322.199,"endTime":7323.866,"body":"was fluctuating asymmetries, which is a"},{"startTime":7323.866,"endTime":7325.766,"body":"common subject of his"},{"startTime":7325.766,"endTime":7326.533,"body":"research in Jamaica."},{"startTime":7330.766,"endTime":7333.3,"body":"I think, you know, I and"},{"startTime":7333.3,"endTime":7334.766,"body":"perhaps you will probably."},{"startTime":7336.666,"endTime":7338.333,"body":"Put something out that will, you know,"},{"startTime":7338.566,"endTime":7342.0,"body":"will act as a kind of obituary when he"},{"startTime":7342.0,"endTime":7343.366,"body":"does die, which will be soon."},{"startTime":7344.433,"endTime":7345.633,"body":"And I am."},{"startTime":7347.133,"endTime":7349.566,"body":"I am glad that he isn't"},{"startTime":7349.566,"endTime":7350.966,"body":"aware that this is happening now."},{"startTime":7351.333,"endTime":7351.533,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7352.166,"endTime":7355.5,"body":"And I would."},{"startTime":7355.566,"endTime":7357.733,"body":"And I guess this isn't"},{"startTime":7357.733,"endTime":7359.333,"body":"about Bob, but one thing that."},{"startTime":7360.933,"endTime":7364.266,"body":"That seeing people's responses has."},{"startTime":7365.8,"endTime":7369.433,"body":"Made me wonder, people are so sure of"},{"startTime":7369.433,"endTime":7372.8,"body":"things that I am sure are"},{"startTime":7372.8,"endTime":7374.766,"body":"not true about what this means."},{"startTime":7376.166,"endTime":7378.066,"body":"How often are we all doing this?"},{"startTime":7378.666,"endTime":7382.366,"body":"How often can we read words that absent"},{"startTime":7382.366,"endTime":7385.866,"body":"context seem to mean something that they"},{"startTime":7385.866,"endTime":7387.399,"body":"absolutely do not mean?"},{"startTime":7388.433,"endTime":7391.333,"body":"You know, could could we be wrong about"},{"startTime":7391.333,"endTime":7392.833,"body":"Bob not as a human being?"},{"startTime":7393.466,"endTime":7394.433,"body":"You know, could you know, are there"},{"startTime":7394.433,"endTime":7395.3,"body":"things we don't know?"},{"startTime":7395.3,"endTime":7395.766,"body":"Of course."},{"startTime":7396.633,"endTime":7399.366,"body":"And am I asking for people to accept"},{"startTime":7399.366,"endTime":7401.133,"body":"justifications of bad behavior?"},{"startTime":7401.166,"endTime":7402.266,"body":"No, no."},{"startTime":7403.1,"endTime":7406.266,"body":"But the certainty with which"},{"startTime":7406.266,"endTime":7407.833,"body":"many people with whom I am."},{"startTime":7408.1,"endTime":7409.3,"body":"You know, otherwise aligned"},{"startTime":7409.3,"endTime":7413.366,"body":"on the anti trans bandwagon."},{"startTime":7414.733,"endTime":7417.466,"body":"Have have taken to this and said, this"},{"startTime":7417.466,"endTime":7418.399,"body":"is, you know, this is the"},{"startTime":7418.399,"endTime":7419.899,"body":"most vile evil I've ever seen."},{"startTime":7419.899,"endTime":7420.633,"body":"This is so despicable."},{"startTime":7421.533,"endTime":7422.833,"body":"I cannot see it that way."},{"startTime":7422.833,"endTime":7424.066,"body":"And again, I don't know if I could"},{"startTime":7424.066,"endTime":7426.166,"body":"possibly possibly have seen it that way."},{"startTime":7426.166,"endTime":7426.966,"body":"If I didn't know from the"},{"startTime":7426.966,"endTime":7428.066,"body":"beginning who was writing it."},{"startTime":7428.866,"endTime":7431.933,"body":"But it it makes me want to ask everyone."},{"startTime":7433.466,"endTime":7437.433,"body":"To have some humility and be suspicious"},{"startTime":7437.433,"endTime":7439.199,"body":"of your own certainty always."},{"startTime":7440.133,"endTime":7441.633,"body":"I think that's an excellent point."},{"startTime":7441.633,"endTime":7443.566,"body":"And I would just point out that the stage"},{"startTime":7443.566,"endTime":7445.266,"body":"is set for this kind of leaping to"},{"startTime":7445.266,"endTime":7449.6,"body":"conclusions by the vacuum of."},{"startTime":7451.866,"endTime":7454.3,"body":"Proper prosecution, right?"},{"startTime":7454.3,"endTime":7456.333,"body":"The fact that these emails had to be"},{"startTime":7456.333,"endTime":7458.266,"body":"pried loose, right,"},{"startTime":7458.533,"endTime":7459.433,"body":"that they were denied."},{"startTime":7459.966,"endTime":7461.766,"body":"And they were redacted weirdly."},{"startTime":7461.766,"endTime":7464.1,"body":"And it's the whole thing is odd."},{"startTime":7464.466,"endTime":7466.233,"body":"But but we're not denying in any way that"},{"startTime":7466.233,"endTime":7469.333,"body":"that like that email, it's obviously I"},{"startTime":7469.333,"endTime":7471.8,"body":"mean, honestly, it it sounds like Bob."},{"startTime":7471.8,"endTime":7472.0,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7472.466,"endTime":7474.433,"body":"As much as I wish he hadn't written it"},{"startTime":7474.433,"endTime":7475.766,"body":"and there's stuff in there that I am"},{"startTime":7475.766,"endTime":7478.433,"body":"surprised that he said, there's nothing"},{"startTime":7478.433,"endTime":7480.666,"body":"in there that that sounds like it was"},{"startTime":7480.666,"endTime":7481.6,"body":"created by something"},{"startTime":7481.6,"endTime":7482.866,"body":"trying to get Bob in trouble."},{"startTime":7483.133,"endTime":7483.466,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7483.466,"endTime":7486.466,"body":"It sounds like a sort of clinical,"},{"startTime":7486.899,"endTime":7488.966,"body":"scientific discussion of a thing that"},{"startTime":7488.966,"endTime":7491.166,"body":"people are doing to other people,"},{"startTime":7493.266,"endTime":7496.0,"body":"aside from like fully aside from the"},{"startTime":7496.0,"endTime":7497.633,"body":"moral valence, which."},{"startTime":7499.8,"endTime":7501.766,"body":"I believe that Bob would agree, but I do"},{"startTime":7501.766,"endTime":7504.166,"body":"not know is horrifying, right?"},{"startTime":7504.166,"endTime":7507.666,"body":"The moral valence of transing of transing"},{"startTime":7507.666,"endTime":7508.866,"body":"children is horrifying."},{"startTime":7509.1,"endTime":7510.766,"body":"Yes, I have no no doubt that he would"},{"startTime":7510.766,"endTime":7512.633,"body":"agree to that in a proper discussion."},{"startTime":7513.933,"endTime":7517.3,"body":"And I would say, I assume I speak for you"},{"startTime":7517.3,"endTime":7520.033,"body":"here, but I wouldn't be defending him if"},{"startTime":7520.033,"endTime":7522.3,"body":"I thought he had been"},{"startTime":7522.3,"endTime":7525.666,"body":"involved in abusing kids."},{"startTime":7526.233,"endTime":7529.199,"body":"There's no this is such a bright line."},{"startTime":7529.666,"endTime":7529.866,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":7530.066,"endTime":7532.233,"body":"You know, no one deserves that defense."},{"startTime":7533.733,"endTime":7535.766,"body":"So anyway, truly don't think that that's"},{"startTime":7535.766,"endTime":7536.533,"body":"what's going on here"},{"startTime":7536.533,"endTime":7537.933,"body":"because it's not who Bob was."},{"startTime":7538.3,"endTime":7540.166,"body":"Bob does care about children,"},{"startTime":7540.166,"endTime":7542.033,"body":"has his own children now grown."},{"startTime":7542.033,"endTime":7545.533,"body":"But but anyway, OK, so shall we move on"},{"startTime":7545.533,"endTime":7548.733,"body":"to other phenomena in this neighborhood?"},{"startTime":7550.133,"endTime":7550.266,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7550.266,"endTime":7552.033,"body":"And so one one of the the only other"},{"startTime":7552.033,"endTime":7553.466,"body":"thing that I definitely want to talk"},{"startTime":7553.466,"endTime":7556.266,"body":"about is that actually the gender madness"},{"startTime":7556.266,"endTime":7557.6,"body":"seems to be falling apart."},{"startTime":7557.6,"endTime":7557.966,"body":"I don't know if we"},{"startTime":7557.966,"endTime":7559.199,"body":"want to go there next or"},{"startTime":7559.199,"endTime":7561.733,"body":"I would like to save that till last."},{"startTime":7561.733,"endTime":7562.933,"body":"I think it's really important."},{"startTime":7563.166,"endTime":7564.733,"body":"I was hoping we would talk about it."},{"startTime":7564.733,"endTime":7567.366,"body":"I'm glad you you delved into it."},{"startTime":7567.366,"endTime":7567.566,"body":"OK."},{"startTime":7567.833,"endTime":7568.733,"body":"But anyway, I think I think"},{"startTime":7568.733,"endTime":7570.666,"body":"it's a good bookend for this."},{"startTime":7571.066,"endTime":7572.633,"body":"So I wanted to talk a little bit more"},{"startTime":7572.633,"endTime":7576.699,"body":"about the week that just was including"},{"startTime":7576.699,"endTime":7580.6,"body":"this massive release of files, three"},{"startTime":7580.6,"endTime":7582.199,"body":"million some documents"},{"startTime":7582.199,"endTime":7584.833,"body":"in this latest tranche."},{"startTime":7585.433,"endTime":7588.633,"body":"And I will give you my it's a great word,"},{"startTime":7588.633,"endTime":7589.566,"body":"by the way, Tranche."},{"startTime":7590.066,"endTime":7590.266,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":7590.333,"endTime":7591.266,"body":"Do we all know it"},{"startTime":7591.266,"endTime":7592.666,"body":"because of the big short?"},{"startTime":7593.233,"endTime":7595.466,"body":"I certainly have no I've never run into"},{"startTime":7595.466,"endTime":7596.366,"body":"it in another context."},{"startTime":7596.366,"endTime":7597.899,"body":"I'm sure finding I know finance guys do."},{"startTime":7598.033,"endTime":7600.366,"body":"Yeah, people now use it, but I have the"},{"startTime":7600.366,"endTime":7602.833,"body":"sense that it came from there."},{"startTime":7602.833,"endTime":7605.899,"body":"But I know finance people used it before."},{"startTime":7606.833,"endTime":7610.766,"body":"But anyway, so here is the thing that I"},{"startTime":7610.766,"endTime":7614.699,"body":"am trying to track as I'm watching this"},{"startTime":7614.699,"endTime":7618.833,"body":"flood of discoveries in this massive"},{"startTime":7618.833,"endTime":7620.533,"body":"tranche of mostly"},{"startTime":7620.533,"endTime":7621.966,"body":"emails, but not entirely."},{"startTime":7621.966,"endTime":7622.899,"body":"There are audio files."},{"startTime":7622.899,"endTime":7623.466,"body":"There's some video."},{"startTime":7626.433,"endTime":7631.466,"body":"There is so much that is worth remarking"},{"startTime":7631.466,"endTime":7635.6,"body":"on in these files that I think it is"},{"startTime":7635.6,"endTime":7638.1,"body":"guaranteed that we will"},{"startTime":7638.1,"endTime":7639.366,"body":"make the following error."},{"startTime":7639.366,"endTime":7640.533,"body":"And I think we are making the"},{"startTime":7640.533,"endTime":7641.833,"body":"following error collectively."},{"startTime":7643.666,"endTime":7645.933,"body":"What's in the files is impossible to look"},{"startTime":7645.933,"endTime":7649.633,"body":"away from, except in a few strange cases"},{"startTime":7649.633,"endTime":7652.666,"body":"where people seem to be prone to do that."},{"startTime":7653.133,"endTime":7656.866,"body":"But there's so much present there that it"},{"startTime":7656.866,"endTime":7660.333,"body":"looks whatever isn't there."},{"startTime":7660.8,"endTime":7663.366,"body":"In other words, we do not understand the"},{"startTime":7663.366,"endTime":7664.733,"body":"relationship between"},{"startTime":7664.733,"endTime":7668.033,"body":"what these files were."},{"startTime":7668.733,"endTime":7671.6,"body":"We don't know what fraction of the actual"},{"startTime":7671.6,"endTime":7674.066,"body":"sum total of the files it represents."},{"startTime":7674.366,"endTime":7676.366,"body":"Well, this is my question to you when you"},{"startTime":7676.366,"endTime":7678.866,"body":"when having missed the release because I"},{"startTime":7678.866,"endTime":7680.0,"body":"was blissfully in Texas"},{"startTime":7680.0,"endTime":7680.933,"body":"moving chickens around."},{"startTime":7681.366,"endTime":7683.066,"body":"Moving chickens and dodging armadillos."},{"startTime":7684.833,"endTime":7688.466,"body":"My question is, is there any way to know"},{"startTime":7688.466,"endTime":7689.466,"body":"what fraction this is?"},{"startTime":7689.466,"endTime":7690.3,"body":"Like, what what is the"},{"startTime":7690.3,"endTime":7691.366,"body":"complete solution set?"},{"startTime":7692.1,"endTime":7694.633,"body":"We don't know that that we don't know"},{"startTime":7694.633,"endTime":7695.8,"body":"what fraction this is."},{"startTime":7695.8,"endTime":7699.766,"body":"We don't know how the choosing happened."},{"startTime":7700.1,"endTime":7701.166,"body":"We don't know if things were."},{"startTime":7701.533,"endTime":7703.166,"body":"I mean, obviously, you know, from just"},{"startTime":7703.166,"endTime":7704.666,"body":"the one email that we've talked about"},{"startTime":7704.666,"endTime":7706.566,"body":"here, there was something that follows"},{"startTime":7706.566,"endTime":7708.533,"body":"from that isn't here."},{"startTime":7708.533,"endTime":7708.866,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7709.133,"endTime":7709.266,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":7709.366,"endTime":7711.866,"body":"So so this is this is this very part"},{"startTime":7711.866,"endTime":7715.1,"body":"stout selective tranche, as you say."},{"startTime":7715.333,"endTime":7716.666,"body":"It is a selective tranche."},{"startTime":7716.666,"endTime":7719.833,"body":"And the image in my mind is like."},{"startTime":7722.0,"endTime":7722.699,"body":"A bunch of."},{"startTime":7724.033,"endTime":7726.166,"body":"I don't know if they're bullet holes, but"},{"startTime":7726.166,"endTime":7727.266,"body":"something has put a"},{"startTime":7727.266,"endTime":7730.033,"body":"bunch of holes onto a screen."},{"startTime":7730.866,"endTime":7733.266,"body":"And what you can see is the outline that"},{"startTime":7733.266,"endTime":7734.033,"body":"there was a person"},{"startTime":7734.033,"endTime":7735.833,"body":"standing in front of it, right?"},{"startTime":7735.866,"endTime":7737.233,"body":"The places where there are no."},{"startTime":7737.233,"endTime":7738.033,"body":"So the point is we can"},{"startTime":7738.033,"endTime":7739.266,"body":"see the part we can see."},{"startTime":7739.566,"endTime":7741.233,"body":"What we can't see is the part that we"},{"startTime":7741.233,"endTime":7742.566,"body":"can't see, obviously."},{"startTime":7743.233,"endTime":7747.666,"body":"But the implication, you know, why why"},{"startTime":7747.666,"endTime":7749.233,"body":"did we go through all of this nonsense"},{"startTime":7749.233,"endTime":7752.833,"body":"where we were being told that there was"},{"startTime":7752.833,"endTime":7757.433,"body":"nothing important in the files that we"},{"startTime":7757.433,"endTime":7758.833,"body":"were imagining this?"},{"startTime":7758.833,"endTime":7760.933,"body":"Like, what even was that?"},{"startTime":7760.933,"endTime":7763.033,"body":"And can we fire cash Patel already?"},{"startTime":7763.066,"endTime":7765.466,"body":"Like, I don't understand."},{"startTime":7766.866,"endTime":7770.033,"body":"Obviously, he's not on"},{"startTime":7770.033,"endTime":7771.733,"body":"our side for some reason."},{"startTime":7771.733,"endTime":7772.666,"body":"Is he compromised?"},{"startTime":7772.666,"endTime":7773.233,"body":"Is he afraid?"},{"startTime":7773.466,"endTime":7775.0,"body":"I don't know, but he can't do the job."},{"startTime":7775.466,"endTime":7776.733,"body":"So anyway."},{"startTime":7778.233,"endTime":7780.166,"body":"Keep in mind that as you focus on the"},{"startTime":7780.166,"endTime":7782.466,"body":"things that we're focusing on, all of"},{"startTime":7782.466,"endTime":7783.933,"body":"which is understandable, that we would be"},{"startTime":7783.933,"endTime":7786.133,"body":"focused on it, that you need to remember"},{"startTime":7786.133,"endTime":7790.166,"body":"that this is very likely a game in which"},{"startTime":7790.166,"endTime":7792.8,"body":"you're being fed certain things in order"},{"startTime":7792.8,"endTime":7793.966,"body":"that you not notice the"},{"startTime":7793.966,"endTime":7795.033,"body":"things you don't have."},{"startTime":7795.6,"endTime":7797.733,"body":"And I would say one of the"},{"startTime":7797.733,"endTime":7799.333,"body":"patterns, you know, so I'm"},{"startTime":7800.966,"endTime":7803.533,"body":"wrestling with what is here and what"},{"startTime":7803.533,"endTime":7805.566,"body":"story it tells about what isn't here."},{"startTime":7806.533,"endTime":7809.033,"body":"And one of the things that I think is"},{"startTime":7809.033,"endTime":7811.466,"body":"becoming clear and we can talk about, you"},{"startTime":7811.466,"endTime":7814.3,"body":"know, Mike Benz was on Joe Rogan talking"},{"startTime":7814.3,"endTime":7817.033,"body":"about this, and he talked about his own"},{"startTime":7817.033,"endTime":7822.733,"body":"process for remembering things."},{"startTime":7822.733,"endTime":7826.233,"body":"He has like an encyclopedic access to a"},{"startTime":7826.233,"endTime":7828.566,"body":"bunch of factual data that the rest of us"},{"startTime":7828.566,"endTime":7829.399,"body":"struggle to keep track of."},{"startTime":7829.399,"endTime":7830.933,"body":"And he talks about how he does it."},{"startTime":7831.433,"endTime":7833.1,"body":"Never mind the particulars."},{"startTime":7833.633,"endTime":7836.066,"body":"He basically describes having a structure"},{"startTime":7836.066,"endTime":7838.8,"body":"in mind and fitting things to it."},{"startTime":7839.233,"endTime":7841.866,"body":"So I felt a resonance with what he"},{"startTime":7841.866,"endTime":7843.866,"body":"described because I also think I carry"},{"startTime":7843.866,"endTime":7846.233,"body":"around a model of what I think is going"},{"startTime":7846.233,"endTime":7848.133,"body":"on in the universe, whether it's biology"},{"startTime":7848.133,"endTime":7849.866,"body":"stuff or whether it's, you"},{"startTime":7849.866,"endTime":7851.166,"body":"know, human political stuff."},{"startTime":7851.166,"endTime":7852.3,"body":"But I have a loose sense"},{"startTime":7852.3,"endTime":7853.666,"body":"of what I think is going on."},{"startTime":7854.066,"endTime":7854.833,"body":"And every time I see"},{"startTime":7854.833,"endTime":7857.266,"body":"something that fits, I add it."},{"startTime":7857.266,"endTime":7858.466,"body":"And every time I see something that"},{"startTime":7858.466,"endTime":7860.0,"body":"doesn't fit, it's even more important"},{"startTime":7860.0,"endTime":7860.899,"body":"because then the point is,"},{"startTime":7860.899,"endTime":7862.833,"body":"huh, is that thing not right?"},{"startTime":7862.833,"endTime":7864.366,"body":"Or is my model not right?"},{"startTime":7864.366,"endTime":7865.566,"body":"Am I missing something here?"},{"startTime":7865.566,"endTime":7866.766,"body":"And it tells you kind of"},{"startTime":7866.766,"endTime":7867.899,"body":"where to spend your time."},{"startTime":7868.3,"endTime":7871.666,"body":"So one of the things, the patterns that I"},{"startTime":7871.666,"endTime":7873.733,"body":"think is emerging as people are sorting"},{"startTime":7873.733,"endTime":7875.333,"body":"through this stuff and posting, posting,"},{"startTime":7875.333,"endTime":7876.533,"body":"posting, you know, have you seen this?"},{"startTime":7876.533,"endTime":7877.033,"body":"Have you seen that?"},{"startTime":7878.366,"endTime":7884.899,"body":"Is there is an awful lot of stench of all"},{"startTime":7884.899,"endTime":7886.633,"body":"of the things that we have"},{"startTime":7886.633,"endTime":7892.133,"body":"feared without proof of much."},{"startTime":7894.033,"endTime":7895.666,"body":"And that pattern, I"},{"startTime":7895.666,"endTime":7898.699,"body":"suspect, is not an accident."},{"startTime":7898.966,"endTime":7901.433,"body":"I think it is the result of two things."},{"startTime":7902.266,"endTime":7902.466,"body":"One,"},{"startTime":7904.0,"endTime":7906.766,"body":"the people that Epstein was interacting"},{"startTime":7906.766,"endTime":7911.866,"body":"with were mostly sophisticated in the"},{"startTime":7911.866,"endTime":7915.899,"body":"sense that they are aware, they think in"},{"startTime":7915.899,"endTime":7917.466,"body":"terms of legal discovery."},{"startTime":7918.666,"endTime":7920.533,"body":"And so while they can't help themselves"},{"startTime":7920.533,"endTime":7923.033,"body":"sometimes, they generally avoid putting"},{"startTime":7923.033,"endTime":7926.966,"body":"things in print that could come back to"},{"startTime":7926.966,"endTime":7928.433,"body":"haunt them later in a lawsuit."},{"startTime":7929.733,"endTime":7931.533,"body":"So that's one of the reasons, that's the"},{"startTime":7931.533,"endTime":7932.666,"body":"more organic reason."},{"startTime":7932.666,"endTime":7935.033,"body":"But the other reason, I suspect, is that"},{"startTime":7935.033,"endTime":7937.8,"body":"aside from a few people who are seemingly"},{"startTime":7937.8,"endTime":7939.566,"body":"deliberately being thrown under the bus,"},{"startTime":7940.333,"endTime":7942.699,"body":"what we are, I think, being given is"},{"startTime":7942.699,"endTime":7944.266,"body":"supposed to satisfy a"},{"startTime":7944.266,"endTime":7945.133,"body":"\"see, we were right\""},{"startTime":7946.266,"endTime":7949.566,"body":"without allowing anything to change."},{"startTime":7950.166,"endTime":7950.366,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":7950.366,"endTime":7951.066,"body":"That's the thing."},{"startTime":7951.066,"endTime":7952.166,"body":"Goliath is the force that"},{"startTime":7952.166,"endTime":7953.533,"body":"opposes all meaningful change."},{"startTime":7953.933,"endTime":7955.8,"body":"And you can imagine that Goliath has been"},{"startTime":7955.8,"endTime":7958.733,"body":"forced to cough up more than he would"},{"startTime":7958.733,"endTime":7960.333,"body":"like to about whatever the Epstein"},{"startTime":7960.333,"endTime":7963.699,"body":"operation was, but that he would like to"},{"startTime":7963.699,"endTime":7964.733,"body":"change as little as possible."},{"startTime":7964.766,"endTime":7966.833,"body":"So we are in a"},{"startTime":7966.833,"endTime":7968.666,"body":"negotiation that we didn't ask for."},{"startTime":7968.666,"endTime":7969.566,"body":"We in the public feel like"},{"startTime":7969.566,"endTime":7970.666,"body":"this is not a negotiation."},{"startTime":7970.866,"endTime":7972.533,"body":"We are entitled to know what this was."},{"startTime":7972.533,"endTime":7973.866,"body":"We are entitled to know all of it."},{"startTime":7974.399,"endTime":7976.633,"body":"Victims are entitled to be heard, to be"},{"startTime":7976.633,"endTime":7977.633,"body":"compensated, to be"},{"startTime":7977.633,"endTime":7979.066,"body":"validated and not gaslit."},{"startTime":7980.233,"endTime":7983.633,"body":"And this tranche, as much as there is"},{"startTime":7983.633,"endTime":7986.166,"body":"important stuff in it, isn't doing the"},{"startTime":7986.166,"endTime":7988.866,"body":"job because, you know, the smoking guns"},{"startTime":7988.866,"endTime":7990.433,"body":"are mostly not there."},{"startTime":7990.966,"endTime":7991.133,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":7992.866,"endTime":7997.233,"body":"But again, it's designed the fraction"},{"startTime":7997.233,"endTime":7999.933,"body":"that we are seeing is designed to give us"},{"startTime":7999.933,"endTime":8002.199,"body":"enough that we will feel that we've, you"},{"startTime":8002.199,"endTime":8004.366,"body":"know, Massey finally forced the stuff"},{"startTime":8004.366,"endTime":8005.566,"body":"into the open, which he did."},{"startTime":8006.433,"endTime":8009.233,"body":"But he forced them to cough up a fraction"},{"startTime":8009.233,"endTime":8010.366,"body":"that they were in charge of."},{"startTime":8010.866,"endTime":8011.833,"body":"And that's that's the"},{"startTime":8011.833,"endTime":8013.333,"body":"overarching message that I'm getting."},{"startTime":8013.866,"endTime":8016.133,"body":"So I wanted to just point out a few"},{"startTime":8016.133,"endTime":8018.333,"body":"things that show up here that I think are"},{"startTime":8018.333,"endTime":8019.633,"body":"potentially meaningful."},{"startTime":8020.866,"endTime":8027.566,"body":"One of them is the phenomenon of."},{"startTime":8029.633,"endTime":8034.166,"body":"Well positioned people talking in coded"},{"startTime":8034.166,"endTime":8038.633,"body":"language that is known to be connected to"},{"startTime":8038.633,"endTime":8042.199,"body":"pedophilia is conspicuous."},{"startTime":8043.0,"endTime":8046.666,"body":"So the number of places in which pizza is"},{"startTime":8046.666,"endTime":8049.8,"body":"discussed here is large."},{"startTime":8050.566,"endTime":8053.366,"body":"It has exactly the same feel as the"},{"startTime":8053.366,"endTime":8055.966,"body":"Podesta emails where."},{"startTime":8057.6,"endTime":8060.466,"body":"It certainly seems to point to the worst"},{"startTime":8060.466,"endTime":8062.833,"body":"possible stuff going on"},{"startTime":8064.366,"endTime":8066.266,"body":"in and around Epstein on his island that"},{"startTime":8066.266,"endTime":8067.233,"body":"may be at his ranch."},{"startTime":8067.533,"endTime":8069.066,"body":"I hadn't even heard of his ranch until"},{"startTime":8069.066,"endTime":8070.566,"body":"now, but apparently he"},{"startTime":8070.566,"endTime":8072.533,"body":"had a very large ranch."},{"startTime":8075.333,"endTime":8077.133,"body":"Anyway, but maybe we should look at some"},{"startTime":8077.133,"endTime":8078.866,"body":"of these pizza emails."},{"startTime":8080.233,"endTime":8083.766,"body":"So here's one from Roy Hodges."},{"startTime":8084.1,"endTime":8085.233,"body":"I don't know who that is."},{"startTime":8085.233,"endTime":8087.133,"body":"He says, I wanted to let you know that"},{"startTime":8087.133,"endTime":8088.466,"body":"the crew really appreciate"},{"startTime":8088.466,"endTime":8090.166,"body":"appreciated the pizza today."},{"startTime":8090.866,"endTime":8092.566,"body":"Thank you for letting us do that."},{"startTime":8093.866,"endTime":8097.266,"body":"OK, so that could be innocent, but kind"},{"startTime":8097.266,"endTime":8099.533,"body":"of unusual to talk about pizza."},{"startTime":8100.233,"endTime":8102.133,"body":"And here's one redacted"},{"startTime":8102.133,"endTime":8104.066,"body":"who it's from is redacted."},{"startTime":8104.066,"endTime":8105.133,"body":"It says this is better"},{"startTime":8105.133,"endTime":8106.866,"body":"than a Chinese cookie."},{"startTime":8107.399,"endTime":8108.266,"body":"See attached."},{"startTime":8108.6,"endTime":8111.533,"body":"Let's go for pizza and grape soda again."},{"startTime":8112.066,"endTime":8113.733,"body":"No one else can understand."},{"startTime":8114.933,"endTime":8115.833,"body":"Go now."},{"startTime":8118.366,"endTime":8119.366,"body":"So grape soda is"},{"startTime":8119.366,"endTime":8121.266,"body":"apparently also a code word."},{"startTime":8121.266,"endTime":8123.766,"body":"Now, of course, you know, is there any"},{"startTime":8123.766,"endTime":8125.366,"body":"chance at all that this is actually a"},{"startTime":8125.366,"endTime":8126.899,"body":"discussion of pizza and grape soda?"},{"startTime":8126.899,"endTime":8128.233,"body":"I suppose you have to leave that"},{"startTime":8128.233,"endTime":8129.866,"body":"possibility open, but in light."},{"startTime":8130.533,"endTime":8131.233,"body":"Sure."},{"startTime":8131.866,"endTime":8134.066,"body":"Yeah, it's not plausible."},{"startTime":8134.466,"endTime":8134.666,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8135.466,"endTime":8138.066,"body":"And mind you, this is after those of us"},{"startTime":8138.066,"endTime":8139.333,"body":"who have understood, you"},{"startTime":8139.333,"endTime":8140.533,"body":"know, I've been saying forever."},{"startTime":8140.733,"endTime":8141.899,"body":"Look, the problem with the pizza gate"},{"startTime":8141.899,"endTime":8143.5,"body":"story is that there are two pizza gate"},{"startTime":8143.5,"endTime":8145.3,"body":"stories and one of them is ridiculous and"},{"startTime":8145.3,"endTime":8146.266,"body":"the other one isn't."},{"startTime":8146.266,"endTime":8148.533,"body":"But when you attempt to talk about the"},{"startTime":8148.533,"endTime":8149.966,"body":"fact that actually there is something"},{"startTime":8149.966,"endTime":8153.366,"body":"troubling in the Podesta emails and all"},{"startTime":8153.366,"endTime":8154.933,"body":"of the rest of it, the point is, oh, you"},{"startTime":8154.933,"endTime":8157.0,"body":"know, you believe some ridiculous story."},{"startTime":8157.0,"endTime":8158.133,"body":"I guess you're you know,"},{"startTime":8158.133,"endTime":8159.0,"body":"you're a mental lightweight."},{"startTime":8159.433,"endTime":8159.633,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8160.633,"endTime":8161.866,"body":"OK, you want to show the next one?"},{"startTime":8164.866,"endTime":8167.199,"body":"OK, this one is from"},{"startTime":8167.199,"endTime":8169.333,"body":"redacted to Jeffrey Epstein."},{"startTime":8169.8,"endTime":8172.3,"body":"It says you mean radiating soft glow?"},{"startTime":8173.066,"endTime":8174.833,"body":"By the way, there's this weird equal sign"},{"startTime":8174.833,"endTime":8176.266,"body":"that shows up in a lot of these."},{"startTime":8176.266,"endTime":8178.166,"body":"I don't under it's like a font issue."},{"startTime":8179.0,"endTime":8180.566,"body":"It may just be the way it's been like"},{"startTime":8180.566,"endTime":8182.466,"body":"optically optical character scanned."},{"startTime":8182.933,"endTime":8184.133,"body":"Whatever, whatever it is."},{"startTime":8184.433,"endTime":8186.866,"body":"So you mean radiating a soft glow with"},{"startTime":8186.866,"endTime":8189.8,"body":"the look of bliss and excitement?"},{"startTime":8189.833,"endTime":8191.5,"body":"Yeah, that's the pizza."},{"startTime":8193.133,"endTime":8193.399,"body":"What?"},{"startTime":8194.233,"endTime":8194.633,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8194.633,"endTime":8196.6,"body":"This does sound like somebody"},{"startTime":8196.6,"endTime":8199.333,"body":"responding to an email from Jeffrey"},{"startTime":8199.333,"endTime":8199.866,"body":"Epstein with the"},{"startTime":8199.866,"endTime":8200.933,"body":"subject, the pizza monster."},{"startTime":8201.366,"endTime":8202.299,"body":"Oh, the pizza monster."},{"startTime":8202.5,"endTime":8202.833,"body":"Of course."},{"startTime":8204.566,"endTime":8204.933,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":8205.366,"endTime":8206.399,"body":"Do we have another one of these?"},{"startTime":8207.533,"endTime":8207.899,"body":"That's it."},{"startTime":8207.899,"endTime":8208.1,"body":"No."},{"startTime":8208.333,"endTime":8208.533,"body":"OK."},{"startTime":8208.933,"endTime":8212.733,"body":"So anyway, the point is if you have been"},{"startTime":8212.733,"endTime":8216.266,"body":"thinking and saying, hey, there is"},{"startTime":8216.266,"endTime":8217.966,"body":"pedophilia going on here."},{"startTime":8218.066,"endTime":8220.133,"body":"This is not just, you know,"},{"startTime":8221.133,"endTime":8222.666,"body":"inappropriately young women."},{"startTime":8223.0,"endTime":8225.733,"body":"This this is about the abuse of children."},{"startTime":8226.666,"endTime":8228.5,"body":"Then the answer is, well, you feel"},{"startTime":8228.5,"endTime":8230.133,"body":"vindicated looking at this stuff."},{"startTime":8230.399,"endTime":8231.133,"body":"On the other hand."},{"startTime":8232.633,"endTime":8236.2,"body":"It's yet more totally creepy discussion"},{"startTime":8236.2,"endTime":8238.866,"body":"of pizza and grape soda."},{"startTime":8239.566,"endTime":8241.433,"body":"And so it runs through"},{"startTime":8241.433,"endTime":8242.399,"body":"your fingers like water."},{"startTime":8242.5,"endTime":8245.133,"body":"So again, it's like perfectly designed to"},{"startTime":8245.133,"endTime":8248.0,"body":"satisfy the people who have been saying,"},{"startTime":8248.0,"endTime":8249.266,"body":"look, you have to look here."},{"startTime":8249.266,"endTime":8250.299,"body":"And other people have been telling them"},{"startTime":8250.299,"endTime":8251.233,"body":"you're imagining it."},{"startTime":8251.766,"endTime":8252.366,"body":"And then it's like, no,"},{"startTime":8252.366,"endTime":8253.333,"body":"I wasn't imagining it."},{"startTime":8253.333,"endTime":8254.433,"body":"See, it shows up right here again."},{"startTime":8255.266,"endTime":8256.166,"body":"It's like, OK, yeah, but"},{"startTime":8256.166,"endTime":8257.433,"body":"what we need is prosecutions."},{"startTime":8258.166,"endTime":8258.566,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8258.566,"endTime":8261.399,"body":"We need people who do these things to be"},{"startTime":8261.399,"endTime":8262.733,"body":"locked away forever."},{"startTime":8262.733,"endTime":8263.633,"body":"This is tantalizing."},{"startTime":8263.633,"endTime":8264.266,"body":"It's not evidence."},{"startTime":8264.5,"endTime":8265.866,"body":"Yeah, it's it's actually I mean,"},{"startTime":8266.066,"endTime":8267.166,"body":"ironically, it's titillating."},{"startTime":8267.6,"endTime":8267.833,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8268.066,"endTime":8268.966,"body":"It's yeah."},{"startTime":8269.033,"endTime":8270.833,"body":"It would be evidence if it"},{"startTime":8270.833,"endTime":8273.766,"body":"were connected to something else."},{"startTime":8274.066,"endTime":8275.466,"body":"But on its own, it's not"},{"startTime":8275.466,"endTime":8278.533,"body":"sufficient to to cross any burden."},{"startTime":8280.433,"endTime":8282.266,"body":"OK, so other things that"},{"startTime":8282.266,"endTime":8287.033,"body":"show up in the files are."},{"startTime":8289.899,"endTime":8290.933,"body":"OK, here's one."},{"startTime":8291.466,"endTime":8293.266,"body":"You want to put up the email from the"},{"startTime":8293.266,"endTime":8294.433,"body":"redacted person where they"},{"startTime":8294.433,"endTime":8296.633,"body":"talk about the torture video."},{"startTime":8298.966,"endTime":8301.933,"body":"OK, so this is from a redacted person to"},{"startTime":8301.933,"endTime":8305.799,"body":"Jeffrey Epstein on February 4th, 2004."},{"startTime":8306.333,"endTime":8308.533,"body":"I mean, February 24th."},{"startTime":8308.833,"endTime":8309.133,"body":"Sorry."},{"startTime":8310.466,"endTime":8311.1,"body":"It is February."},{"startTime":8311.566,"endTime":8314.733,"body":"This email is from April 24th of 2009."},{"startTime":8315.133,"endTime":8316.133,"body":"It says, Where are you?"},{"startTime":8316.133,"endTime":8316.7,"body":"Are you OK?"},{"startTime":8317.133,"endTime":8318.933,"body":"I loved the torture video."},{"startTime":8319.166,"endTime":8319.933,"body":"It's from Jeffrey"},{"startTime":8319.933,"endTime":8321.333,"body":"Epstein to a redacted person."},{"startTime":8321.7,"endTime":8326.933,"body":"Now, of course, that validates the sense"},{"startTime":8326.933,"endTime":8329.266,"body":"that many of us have that this probably"},{"startTime":8329.266,"endTime":8332.533,"body":"even goes beyond the sexual abuse of"},{"startTime":8332.533,"endTime":8334.266,"body":"children and on to"},{"startTime":8334.266,"endTime":8336.433,"body":"torture and maybe murder."},{"startTime":8338.5,"endTime":8340.866,"body":"But again, have you ever used the word"},{"startTime":8340.866,"endTime":8342.933,"body":"torture metaphorically?"},{"startTime":8342.933,"endTime":8345.166,"body":"Of course, everybody uses that word"},{"startTime":8345.166,"endTime":8346.366,"body":"metaphorically sometimes."},{"startTime":8346.666,"endTime":8347.7,"body":"So is this incriminating?"},{"startTime":8347.966,"endTime":8348.633,"body":"Not on its own."},{"startTime":8348.633,"endTime":8349.066,"body":"It's not."},{"startTime":8350.433,"endTime":8352.566,"body":"But you know, and that's 2009, was it?"},{"startTime":8352.566,"endTime":8352.766,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8353.233,"endTime":8354.833,"body":"Now in twenty twenty six, so much of"},{"startTime":8354.833,"endTime":8358.466,"body":"porn, apparently, is, you know, actually,"},{"startTime":8359.366,"endTime":8362.2,"body":"actually involves at least mild forms of"},{"startTime":8362.2,"endTime":8363.966,"body":"torture, pain, pain"},{"startTime":8363.966,"endTime":8367.433,"body":"induction, BDSM, that, you know."},{"startTime":8368.866,"endTime":8370.2,"body":"The dude was disgustingly ahead of his"},{"startTime":8370.2,"endTime":8372.233,"body":"time is one of the one"},{"startTime":8372.233,"endTime":8373.066,"body":"of the interpretations."},{"startTime":8373.066,"endTime":8373.366,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8374.766,"endTime":8376.633,"body":"OK, so all right."},{"startTime":8376.633,"endTime":8379.966,"body":"You want to put up the Bitcoin one?"},{"startTime":8379.966,"endTime":8382.366,"body":"So Bitcoin shows up in a bunch of these"},{"startTime":8382.366,"endTime":8386.333,"body":"emails in a way that I think matches the"},{"startTime":8386.333,"endTime":8387.666,"body":"same kind of pattern."},{"startTime":8388.866,"endTime":8394.566,"body":"So this is from April 25th, 2015 from"},{"startTime":8394.566,"endTime":8397.066,"body":"Jeffrey Epstein to Jochi Ito."},{"startTime":8399.2,"endTime":8404.066,"body":"And I'm having trouble understanding who"},{"startTime":8404.066,"endTime":8406.633,"body":"wrote what, but it says the way that"},{"startTime":8406.633,"endTime":8408.766,"body":"Bitcoin is organized currently is that"},{"startTime":8408.766,"endTime":8411.033,"body":"there are five core developers and around"},{"startTime":8411.033,"endTime":8413.033,"body":"100 contributors to the core code."},{"startTime":8413.033,"endTime":8414.766,"body":"The five core developers are like Linus"},{"startTime":8414.766,"endTime":8417.266,"body":"Torvalds or the Linus Torvalds of Linux."},{"startTime":8417.633,"endTime":8418.633,"body":"They decide what changes"},{"startTime":8418.633,"endTime":8420.366,"body":"are made to the core code."},{"startTime":8420.366,"endTime":8423.366,"body":"One of the five is the lead developer of"},{"startTime":8423.366,"endTime":8425.333,"body":"Vladimir and his chief scientist, Gavin,"},{"startTime":8425.799,"endTime":8427.566,"body":"Gavin, Vladimir and Corey, an important"},{"startTime":8427.566,"endTime":8428.433,"body":"contributing developer."},{"startTime":8428.666,"endTime":8430.366,"body":"We're being paid out of a nonprofit"},{"startTime":8430.366,"endTime":8431.766,"body":"organization called"},{"startTime":8431.766,"endTime":8432.799,"body":"the Bitcoin Foundation."},{"startTime":8432.799,"endTime":8434.766,"body":"A few weeks ago, it blew up when one of"},{"startTime":8434.766,"endTime":8435.5,"body":"the board members"},{"startTime":8435.5,"endTime":8438.066,"body":"declared the foundation bankrupt."},{"startTime":8439.066,"endTime":8440.966,"body":"Many organizations scrambled to step into"},{"startTime":8440.966,"endTime":8443.333,"body":"the vacuum, created the foundation and"},{"startTime":8443.333,"endTime":8444.633,"body":"take control, in"},{"startTime":8444.633,"endTime":8445.866,"body":"quotes of the developers."},{"startTime":8445.866,"endTime":8448.233,"body":"We moved quickly and the three developers"},{"startTime":8448.233,"endTime":8450.6,"body":"decided to join the Media Lab."},{"startTime":8450.6,"endTime":8452.299,"body":"That's the MIT Media Lab, presumably."},{"startTime":8453.5,"endTime":8455.433,"body":"This is a big win for us."},{"startTime":8456.6,"endTime":8459.433,"body":"OK, so there's certainly plenty of"},{"startTime":8459.433,"endTime":8462.766,"body":"discussion around the capture of Bitcoin."},{"startTime":8463.1,"endTime":8465.733,"body":"Here we have discussions, and this is far"},{"startTime":8465.733,"endTime":8469.299,"body":"from the only bit of it, you know, in"},{"startTime":8469.299,"endTime":8471.466,"body":"this new tranche of the Epstein files."},{"startTime":8472.0,"endTime":8472.733,"body":"On the other hand,"},{"startTime":8472.733,"endTime":8474.299,"body":"what does it actually say?"},{"startTime":8474.7,"endTime":8476.833,"body":"Well, enough to give the people who think"},{"startTime":8476.833,"endTime":8479.233,"body":"that there is something nefarious going"},{"startTime":8479.233,"endTime":8482.166,"body":"on, something to chew on, but"},{"startTime":8482.166,"endTime":8483.533,"body":"not enough to make the case."},{"startTime":8483.566,"endTime":8485.2,"body":"And I do think Bitcoin is down a bit"},{"startTime":8485.2,"endTime":8486.733,"body":"today, maybe because of this."},{"startTime":8487.033,"endTime":8490.333,"body":"But nonetheless, it has more of this."},{"startTime":8491.0,"endTime":8493.466,"body":"It gives you something to keep you busy,"},{"startTime":8493.466,"endTime":8494.666,"body":"but it doesn't go"},{"startTime":8494.666,"endTime":8496.399,"body":"where it would need to go."},{"startTime":8497.366,"endTime":8497.566,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8497.866,"endTime":8498.166,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":8498.166,"endTime":8501.833,"body":"And I will also say that one of the"},{"startTime":8501.833,"endTime":8503.966,"body":"things that I noticed"},{"startTime":8503.966,"endTime":8508.333,"body":"in these emails is the."},{"startTime":8511.066,"endTime":8513.166,"body":"I just don't even know how to describe it"},{"startTime":8513.166,"endTime":8515.2,"body":"other than a kind of"},{"startTime":8515.2,"endTime":8518.566,"body":"stench of Jewish supremacy."},{"startTime":8519.566,"endTime":8522.033,"body":"And it's disgusting."},{"startTime":8524.233,"endTime":8525.733,"body":"But nonetheless, it's sort"},{"startTime":8525.733,"endTime":8527.299,"body":"of here in black and white."},{"startTime":8528.433,"endTime":8531.1,"body":"So here you want to put up the the email"},{"startTime":8531.1,"endTime":8533.466,"body":"to, I guess, Roger Schenck."},{"startTime":8534.366,"endTime":8536.133,"body":"It's February 23rd of."},{"startTime":8537.5,"endTime":8540.433,"body":"2009 starts by."},{"startTime":8542.2,"endTime":8542.633,"body":"Sorry."},{"startTime":8545.0,"endTime":8546.833,"body":"Yeah, it doesn't really matter, but they"},{"startTime":8546.833,"endTime":8547.633,"body":"keep on being on Friday."},{"startTime":8547.833,"endTime":8549.0,"body":"It turns out they do."},{"startTime":8549.0,"endTime":8549.666,"body":"I've tried swapping"},{"startTime":8549.666,"endTime":8550.766,"body":"months and it does not work."},{"startTime":8552.866,"endTime":8555.066,"body":"This is the way the Jew."},{"startTime":8556.133,"endTime":8557.033,"body":"It's not well written."},{"startTime":8557.566,"endTime":8559.533,"body":"This is the way that you have seen."},{"startTime":8559.566,"endTime":8561.133,"body":"Yes, this is from Jeffrey Epstein."},{"startTime":8561.166,"endTime":8563.833,"body":"This is the way the Jew make money and"},{"startTime":8563.833,"endTime":8566.0,"body":"made a fortune in the past 10 years"},{"startTime":8566.0,"endTime":8568.066,"body":"selling short and shipping future."},{"startTime":8569.033,"endTime":8572.033,"body":"Selling short the shipping futures,"},{"startTime":8572.033,"endTime":8573.733,"body":"selling short the shipping futures."},{"startTime":8574.133,"endTime":8576.566,"body":"Let the goyim deal with the real world."},{"startTime":8578.466,"endTime":8580.266,"body":"OK, so"},{"startTime":8580.266,"endTime":8581.233,"body":"I've seen some discussion."},{"startTime":8583.233,"endTime":8584.433,"body":"The goyim is an epithet."},{"startTime":8584.866,"endTime":8585.066,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8587.033,"endTime":8587.933,"body":"I didn't know that."},{"startTime":8588.566,"endTime":8589.266,"body":"Oh, yeah."},{"startTime":8590.666,"endTime":8593.0,"body":"That's interesting because I have."},{"startTime":8594.766,"endTime":8596.866,"body":"I have been referred to as"},{"startTime":8596.866,"endTime":8599.166,"body":"over the goyim by various people."},{"startTime":8599.666,"endTime":8600.833,"body":"I never took it as an epithet."},{"startTime":8601.566,"endTime":8602.166,"body":"It's an epithet."},{"startTime":8602.366,"endTime":8604.533,"body":"It can be said by you."},{"startTime":8605.133,"endTime":8607.266,"body":"Yeah, it can be said ironically."},{"startTime":8607.833,"endTime":8608.766,"body":"So it's one of these words"},{"startTime":8608.766,"endTime":8610.799,"body":"that context matters a lot."},{"startTime":8610.833,"endTime":8613.166,"body":"But it's definitely an epithet."},{"startTime":8614.133,"endTime":8615.133,"body":"Gentile is different."},{"startTime":8615.866,"endTime":8616.966,"body":"And shiksa is different."},{"startTime":8617.333,"endTime":8618.566,"body":"Shiksa is an epithet."},{"startTime":8619.866,"endTime":8620.166,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8620.533,"endTime":8621.033,"body":"So anyway."},{"startTime":8624.399,"endTime":8626.266,"body":"So then this last email"},{"startTime":8626.266,"endTime":8628.1,"body":"shows the same pattern."},{"startTime":8628.566,"endTime":8630.233,"body":"This is from Jeffrey"},{"startTime":8630.233,"endTime":8632.2,"body":"Epstein's email account."},{"startTime":8633.633,"endTime":8636.166,"body":"J.E.E. vacation at Gmail"},{"startTime":8636.166,"endTime":8639.433,"body":"to Peggy Siegel subject."},{"startTime":8640.799,"endTime":8642.233,"body":"Reyat slut."},{"startTime":8644.066,"endTime":8646.466,"body":"He says no goyim in abundance."},{"startTime":8647.366,"endTime":8647.766,"body":"J.P."},{"startTime":8647.966,"endTime":8650.633,"body":"Morgan execs brilliant wasps."},{"startTime":8652.033,"endTime":8654.533,"body":"OK, and then the question he's responding"},{"startTime":8654.533,"endTime":8656.233,"body":"to is, is it going to"},{"startTime":8656.233,"endTime":8657.733,"body":"be 100 percent Jew night?"},{"startTime":8658.5,"endTime":8661.233,"body":"Even Pearlman and Yum Yum has some goyim."},{"startTime":8661.633,"endTime":8664.066,"body":"I'm getting my quote media elite list"},{"startTime":8664.733,"endTime":8666.466,"body":"exact out for Saturday"},{"startTime":8666.466,"endTime":8668.366,"body":"and will email some names."},{"startTime":8668.766,"endTime":8670.033,"body":"What about Charlie Rose?"},{"startTime":8670.333,"endTime":8670.733,"body":"Love him."},{"startTime":8671.266,"endTime":8672.399,"body":"What about Jane Fonda?"},{"startTime":8672.666,"endTime":8673.533,"body":"My new best friend."},{"startTime":8673.933,"endTime":8676.966,"body":"Nothing like an ex Jew hater with a"},{"startTime":8676.966,"endTime":8678.5,"body":"Jewish boyfriend to mix it up."},{"startTime":8678.5,"endTime":8680.0,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":8680.233,"endTime":8682.1,"body":"So this goes on."},{"startTime":8682.333,"endTime":8683.1,"body":"But nonetheless."},{"startTime":8687.933,"endTime":8689.266,"body":"You are listening in."},{"startTime":8690.133,"endTime":8691.7,"body":"To private conversations that were not"},{"startTime":8691.7,"endTime":8693.7,"body":"intended to be viewed by anybody else."},{"startTime":8693.899,"endTime":8697.7,"body":"Nonetheless, it's damning that this is."},{"startTime":8699.333,"endTime":8703.733,"body":"The way they are talking and frankly, I"},{"startTime":8703.733,"endTime":8706.633,"body":"think it's actually central to what's"},{"startTime":8706.633,"endTime":8709.366,"body":"going on, because to the extent that what"},{"startTime":8709.366,"endTime":8712.833,"body":"we clearly have is a."},{"startTime":8714.466,"endTime":8718.566,"body":"Hyper entitled network of people who feel"},{"startTime":8718.566,"endTime":8721.2,"body":"they have the right to abuse others."},{"startTime":8721.533,"endTime":8725.866,"body":"Obviously, this is connected to the sense"},{"startTime":8725.866,"endTime":8728.233,"body":"that you and they are not the same."},{"startTime":8728.566,"endTime":8728.766,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8729.2,"endTime":8731.866,"body":"So the idea that you have supremacists,"},{"startTime":8731.866,"endTime":8732.566,"body":"those are different."},{"startTime":8732.733,"endTime":8734.399,"body":"The rules are different because those"},{"startTime":8734.399,"endTime":8736.2,"body":"other people aren't really people and."},{"startTime":8739.333,"endTime":8741.899,"body":"Obviously, the West is based on the"},{"startTime":8741.899,"endTime":8744.133,"body":"exactly inverse interpretation that"},{"startTime":8744.133,"endTime":8746.7,"body":"everybody and frankly, Christianity is to"},{"startTime":8746.7,"endTime":8750.066,"body":"the fundamental dignity of people."},{"startTime":8751.333,"endTime":8753.866,"body":"Is central and to the extent that anybody"},{"startTime":8756.233,"endTime":8758.966,"body":"is exempting themselves from"},{"startTime":8760.733,"endTime":8764.2,"body":"this agreement, it's not surprising to"},{"startTime":8764.2,"endTime":8765.666,"body":"find them taking advantage of"},{"startTime":8765.666,"endTime":8767.5,"body":"anyone and everyone else, so."},{"startTime":8770.233,"endTime":8772.066,"body":"What will we be able to prove from this?"},{"startTime":8773.366,"endTime":8773.966,"body":"Not much."},{"startTime":8774.2,"endTime":8775.133,"body":"What does it confirm"},{"startTime":8775.133,"endTime":8776.266,"body":"about what we suspected?"},{"startTime":8777.866,"endTime":8778.299,"body":"A lot,"},{"startTime":8779.299,"endTime":8781.366,"body":"but not, you know, maybe the point is"},{"startTime":8781.366,"endTime":8784.799,"body":"this gives you preponderance of the"},{"startTime":8784.799,"endTime":8785.633,"body":"evidence without"},{"startTime":8785.633,"endTime":8787.399,"body":"crossing reasonable doubt."},{"startTime":8787.399,"endTime":8787.966,"body":"Maybe that's"},{"startTime":8787.966,"endTime":8788.6,"body":"the right thing."},{"startTime":8788.6,"endTime":8789.266,"body":"I think that's right."},{"startTime":8789.266,"endTime":8790.233,"body":"I think that's it."},{"startTime":8790.466,"endTime":8791.966,"body":"I think that's exactly right."},{"startTime":8792.533,"endTime":8792.733,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8792.866,"endTime":8793.633,"body":"Now, OK."},{"startTime":8793.633,"endTime":8794.333,"body":"On several fronts."},{"startTime":8795.133,"endTime":8795.433,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8795.433,"endTime":8796.933,"body":"On on on a number of fronts."},{"startTime":8796.933,"endTime":8799.066,"body":"But I mean, that's an interesting gap."},{"startTime":8799.066,"endTime":8800.666,"body":"That gap should have a name, the one"},{"startTime":8800.666,"endTime":8802.566,"body":"between preponderance of the evidence and"},{"startTime":8802.566,"endTime":8803.433,"body":"reasonable doubt,"},{"startTime":8803.433,"endTime":8805.233,"body":"because a lot of probably does."},{"startTime":8805.233,"endTime":8805.766,"body":"His space."},{"startTime":8805.766,"endTime":8806.766,"body":"Yeah, it probably does."},{"startTime":8807.299,"endTime":8808.666,"body":"Good if it doesn't."},{"startTime":8809.066,"endTime":8811.866,"body":"So one last thing before we leave the"},{"startTime":8811.866,"endTime":8815.633,"body":"Epstein files is I wanted to talk about"},{"startTime":8815.633,"endTime":8820.266,"body":"what I think Mike Benz posed a very good"},{"startTime":8820.266,"endTime":8823.266,"body":"challenge in his Joe Rogan conversation,"},{"startTime":8824.266,"endTime":8825.1,"body":"which came out in the"},{"startTime":8825.1,"endTime":8825.866,"body":"last couple of days."},{"startTime":8827.1,"endTime":8828.233,"body":"Do you want to show his"},{"startTime":8828.233,"endTime":8830.333,"body":"discussion of the blackmail question?"},{"startTime":8831.366,"endTime":8833.566,"body":"I've never been convinced that the"},{"startTime":8833.566,"endTime":8838.766,"body":"central role of the Epstein young girl,"},{"startTime":8841.033,"endTime":8842.866,"body":"in my view, sidebar of the Epstein."},{"startTime":8843.566,"endTime":8847.266,"body":"Money laundering story is"},{"startTime":8848.333,"endTime":8849.666,"body":"is that it was for blackmail."},{"startTime":8850.666,"endTime":8853.5,"body":"I and part of this is because the moment"},{"startTime":8853.5,"endTime":8858.066,"body":"Jeffrey Epstein formally officially"},{"startTime":8858.066,"endTime":8860.866,"body":"threatened somebody with blackmail and"},{"startTime":8860.866,"endTime":8863.533,"body":"that person tells his wife and that wife"},{"startTime":8863.533,"endTime":8866.033,"body":"tells her friends and that gets out to"},{"startTime":8866.033,"endTime":8868.133,"body":"somebody else that knows Jeffrey Epstein."},{"startTime":8870.533,"endTime":8873.1,"body":"Jeffrey Epstein's access goes away."},{"startTime":8873.533,"endTime":8875.766,"body":"Overnight, that's the sort of thing that"},{"startTime":8875.766,"endTime":8879.633,"body":"even a rumor of that spreading and nobody"},{"startTime":8879.633,"endTime":8880.366,"body":"else is going to want"},{"startTime":8880.366,"endTime":8881.566,"body":"to do business with them."},{"startTime":8881.566,"endTime":8883.466,"body":"So you think people just assume it's"},{"startTime":8883.466,"endTime":8886.5,"body":"blackmail because that is how you would"},{"startTime":8886.5,"endTime":8887.333,"body":"blackmail someone,"},{"startTime":8887.7,"endTime":8889.333,"body":"especially underage girls?"},{"startTime":8889.566,"endTime":8892.766,"body":"I think it is very possible that there"},{"startTime":8892.766,"endTime":8895.333,"body":"could have been indirect blackmail,"},{"startTime":8895.766,"endTime":8900.466,"body":"meaning Epstein passes it on to an"},{"startTime":8900.466,"endTime":8903.433,"body":"intelligence service to, you know, to a"},{"startTime":8903.433,"endTime":8905.5,"body":"corporate espionage client or something,"},{"startTime":8906.5,"endTime":8910.166,"body":"and they use that for their own purposes."},{"startTime":8910.666,"endTime":8911.333,"body":"But even then,"},{"startTime":8913.266,"endTime":8916.233,"body":"I mean, imagine, for example, if, you"},{"startTime":8916.233,"endTime":8920.333,"body":"know, like on the Bill Gates thing, like"},{"startTime":8921.466,"endTime":8923.766,"body":"there was an bill Gates gets an email."},{"startTime":8924.566,"endTime":8926.399,"body":"I have a video of you sleeping with this"},{"startTime":8926.399,"endTime":8928.933,"body":"person and, you know, or"},{"startTime":8928.933,"endTime":8930.366,"body":"somebody much lower level."},{"startTime":8931.133,"endTime":8932.833,"body":"The moment they send that to the press,"},{"startTime":8933.566,"endTime":8936.0,"body":"if, you know, in order to they figure"},{"startTime":8936.0,"endTime":8937.066,"body":"they have nothing to lose, I mean,"},{"startTime":8937.366,"endTime":8939.866,"body":"there's not been anybody in the seven"},{"startTime":8939.866,"endTime":8941.533,"body":"years that's transpired who said, I've"},{"startTime":8941.533,"endTime":8942.333,"body":"been I was personally"},{"startTime":8942.333,"endTime":8943.266,"body":"blackmailed by Jeffrey."},{"startTime":8943.6,"endTime":8945.866,"body":"I think because the moment you do that,"},{"startTime":8946.366,"endTime":8947.733,"body":"nobody comes to your parties anymore."},{"startTime":8948.1,"endTime":8949.799,"body":"No, but you lose all the access, you lose"},{"startTime":8949.799,"endTime":8951.7,"body":"all the deal flow, you lose all the"},{"startTime":8951.7,"endTime":8952.5,"body":"goodwill that you've"},{"startTime":8952.5,"endTime":8954.166,"body":"generated because this rumor,"},{"startTime":8955.2,"endTime":8956.0,"body":"people are very risk"},{"startTime":8956.0,"endTime":8957.466,"body":"averse, especially at that level."},{"startTime":8957.966,"endTime":8958.033,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8958.033,"endTime":8960.766,"body":"But just to have it over their head and"},{"startTime":8960.766,"endTime":8962.333,"body":"never use it, though."},{"startTime":8962.833,"endTime":8962.966,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":8962.966,"endTime":8965.2,"body":"Well, I think I think that what you could"},{"startTime":8965.2,"endTime":8968.7,"body":"have is because he does"},{"startTime":8968.7,"endTime":8969.899,"body":"his own nefarious stuff."},{"startTime":8970.566,"endTime":8972.966,"body":"He could compile it so that if they ever"},{"startTime":8972.966,"endTime":8974.966,"body":"go out, if they ever threaten him with"},{"startTime":8974.966,"endTime":8976.399,"body":"something, he's now"},{"startTime":8976.399,"endTime":8977.666,"body":"got something on them."},{"startTime":8979.533,"endTime":8980.433,"body":"I honestly can't tell"},{"startTime":8980.433,"endTime":8981.799,"body":"which position Benz is taking."},{"startTime":8982.133,"endTime":8983.466,"body":"He seems to be taking both positions."},{"startTime":8983.866,"endTime":8985.899,"body":"What he is saying is that the explanation"},{"startTime":8985.899,"endTime":8989.466,"body":"that many of us have explored, that this"},{"startTime":8989.466,"endTime":8992.166,"body":"was a blackmail operation designed to"},{"startTime":8992.166,"endTime":8994.433,"body":"capture compromise for the point for the"},{"startTime":8994.433,"endTime":8996.733,"body":"purpose of steering anything and"},{"startTime":8996.733,"endTime":8997.766,"body":"everything in the world."},{"startTime":8997.766,"endTime":8997.966,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":8998.266,"endTime":9002.833,"body":"That that does not add up because if you"},{"startTime":9002.833,"endTime":9006.466,"body":"attempted to execute once on the"},{"startTime":9006.466,"endTime":9008.466,"body":"blackmail, the rest of what you had"},{"startTime":9008.466,"endTime":9011.333,"body":"banked would or your ability to bank"},{"startTime":9011.333,"endTime":9013.466,"body":"more, at least would evaporate."},{"startTime":9014.033,"endTime":9015.799,"body":"So that seems like a generic."},{"startTime":9016.033,"endTime":9019.433,"body":"So he does seem to also argue that it is"},{"startTime":9019.433,"endTime":9021.566,"body":"or maybe it's just what Joe is saying to"},{"startTime":9021.566,"endTime":9023.866,"body":"him is maybe Joe is"},{"startTime":9023.866,"endTime":9024.933,"body":"responding the way I was like."},{"startTime":9024.933,"endTime":9025.933,"body":"I can't tell what you're saying, man."},{"startTime":9025.933,"endTime":9026.966,"body":"You're saying this, you're saying that."},{"startTime":9028.766,"endTime":9029.899,"body":"But it seems like that's an argument"},{"startTime":9029.899,"endTime":9032.399,"body":"against blackmail always, isn't it?"},{"startTime":9032.399,"endTime":9033.733,"body":"Well, in any sort of operation,"},{"startTime":9033.733,"endTime":9035.466,"body":"an operation, an operation."},{"startTime":9036.166,"endTime":9037.2,"body":"So there are two."},{"startTime":9037.633,"endTime":9039.566,"body":"So again, this is where I"},{"startTime":9039.566,"endTime":9042.1,"body":"think it is important to."},{"startTime":9043.133,"endTime":9045.733,"body":"See pieces of evidence, figure out if"},{"startTime":9045.733,"endTime":9047.166,"body":"they fit the model you're playing with to"},{"startTime":9047.166,"endTime":9048.799,"body":"the extent that they don't see if the"},{"startTime":9048.799,"endTime":9050.366,"body":"model needs adjusting, if the evidence"},{"startTime":9050.366,"endTime":9050.933,"body":"isn't what it"},{"startTime":9050.933,"endTime":9052.666,"body":"appears, that sort of thing."},{"startTime":9052.866,"endTime":9057.066,"body":"And so I get two possibilities from."},{"startTime":9059.066,"endTime":9060.866,"body":"What I think is actually a very good"},{"startTime":9060.866,"endTime":9062.966,"body":"question that Ben's is pointing to."},{"startTime":9063.533,"endTime":9065.2,"body":"So the question is, how"},{"startTime":9065.2,"endTime":9067.299,"body":"could you build a compromise?"},{"startTime":9067.666,"endTime":9068.7,"body":"A."},{"startTime":9070.133,"endTime":9071.566,"body":"Collection."},{"startTime":9073.166,"endTime":9075.666,"body":"Project that didn't."},{"startTime":9076.333,"endTime":9078.466,"body":"Blow itself up on first use."},{"startTime":9080.166,"endTime":9082.166,"body":"One thing he says, and then he doubts it"},{"startTime":9082.166,"endTime":9083.833,"body":"because it doesn't really add up much"},{"startTime":9083.866,"endTime":9086.333,"body":"better is that Epstein could forward"},{"startTime":9086.333,"endTime":9088.533,"body":"whatever he's got to somebody else, but"},{"startTime":9088.533,"endTime":9089.966,"body":"it's still it's got the same."},{"startTime":9089.966,"endTime":9090.966,"body":"It's got the same problem."},{"startTime":9091.266,"endTime":9094.533,"body":"So here's what I want to propose as a"},{"startTime":9094.533,"endTime":9096.866,"body":"model that I think satisfies"},{"startTime":9098.0,"endTime":9098.7,"body":"Ben's."},{"startTime":9098.966,"endTime":9100.966,"body":"I don't know how you"},{"startTime":9100.966,"endTime":9104.533,"body":"play realize Ben's Ben's."},{"startTime":9105.2,"endTime":9108.433,"body":"Challenge to that model, but also."},{"startTime":9109.866,"endTime":9111.733,"body":"It's all of the evidence that this looks"},{"startTime":9111.733,"endTime":9113.933,"body":"like an operation to accumulate"},{"startTime":9113.933,"endTime":9116.766,"body":"compromise, right, including the fact"},{"startTime":9116.766,"endTime":9118.833,"body":"that in in the files."},{"startTime":9120.466,"endTime":9123.133,"body":"Are things in which we actually get to"},{"startTime":9123.133,"endTime":9124.5,"body":"hear Epstein and frankly."},{"startTime":9125.799,"endTime":9127.333,"body":"It's kind of a mental lightweight."},{"startTime":9128.233,"endTime":9129.033,"body":"He's not deep."},{"startTime":9129.366,"endTime":9130.5,"body":"He's not deep."},{"startTime":9130.899,"endTime":9132.366,"body":"Somebody described him as."},{"startTime":9132.766,"endTime":9134.633,"body":"All these amazing scientists hanging"},{"startTime":9134.633,"endTime":9136.033,"body":"around him because of"},{"startTime":9136.033,"endTime":9137.299,"body":"that, because of his insights."},{"startTime":9137.933,"endTime":9138.166,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9138.5,"endTime":9140.799,"body":"And yeah, they're humoring him."},{"startTime":9141.1,"endTime":9142.733,"body":"The good ones are humoring him."},{"startTime":9144.766,"endTime":9146.066,"body":"Maybe there are some fakers among the"},{"startTime":9146.066,"endTime":9147.466,"body":"scientists who don't understand that he's"},{"startTime":9147.466,"endTime":9148.6,"body":"not deep, but whatever."},{"startTime":9149.633,"endTime":9151.633,"body":"OK, so here's the model I want to propose"},{"startTime":9151.633,"endTime":9156.233,"body":"that what Jeffrey Epstein was doing was a"},{"startTime":9156.233,"endTime":9159.5,"body":"control architecture designed to ensnare"},{"startTime":9159.5,"endTime":9160.866,"body":"people across"},{"startTime":9160.866,"endTime":9165.033,"body":"discipline and zones of business."},{"startTime":9166.533,"endTime":9167.7,"body":"And the way it worked"},{"startTime":9167.7,"endTime":9169.366,"body":"was he dragged people in."},{"startTime":9170.533,"endTime":9172.366,"body":"He figured out what people."},{"startTime":9173.933,"endTime":9176.133,"body":"What limits that they would push that"},{"startTime":9176.133,"endTime":9177.533,"body":"would compromise them."},{"startTime":9177.533,"endTime":9179.966,"body":"In other words, he created an environment"},{"startTime":9179.966,"endTime":9183.533,"body":"in which people seem to feel no concern"},{"startTime":9183.533,"endTime":9186.633,"body":"about doing awful things."},{"startTime":9187.633,"endTime":9189.633,"body":"And he dragged people in as far as they"},{"startTime":9189.633,"endTime":9192.066,"body":"would go so that where they were was way"},{"startTime":9192.066,"endTime":9194.1,"body":"beyond their own normal standard."},{"startTime":9194.5,"endTime":9194.7,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9194.7,"endTime":9196.966,"body":"That they did things that they then."},{"startTime":9198.966,"endTime":9199.466,"body":"Couldn't defend."},{"startTime":9201.399,"endTime":9204.933,"body":"And that the control mechanism comes from"},{"startTime":9204.933,"endTime":9207.399,"body":"the thing, like imagine that you were an"},{"startTime":9207.399,"endTime":9209.5,"body":"affiliate of this and."},{"startTime":9209.6,"endTime":9213.466,"body":"You and I never would find ourselves in"},{"startTime":9213.466,"endTime":9215.166,"body":"that position, but somebody who would"},{"startTime":9215.166,"endTime":9216.899,"body":"allow themselves to let their guard down"},{"startTime":9216.899,"endTime":9218.766,"body":"and say things that they shouldn't say"},{"startTime":9218.766,"endTime":9222.033,"body":"like Bob or do things they shouldn't do"},{"startTime":9222.033,"endTime":9223.033,"body":"like all of these people"},{"startTime":9223.033,"endTime":9224.366,"body":"who went to the island,"},{"startTime":9225.766,"endTime":9227.266,"body":"they then live in fear."},{"startTime":9228.266,"endTime":9229.733,"body":"Oh, was he recording that stuff?"},{"startTime":9229.733,"endTime":9232.2,"body":"So the point is they self censor and they"},{"startTime":9232.2,"endTime":9236.0,"body":"become very sensitive to the message"},{"startTime":9236.0,"endTime":9238.633,"body":"about what it is that whatever it is that"},{"startTime":9238.633,"endTime":9239.133,"body":"was running Epstein,"},{"startTime":9239.166,"endTime":9241.533,"body":"believes about the world."},{"startTime":9241.533,"endTime":9243.333,"body":"Here are the positions that we hold."},{"startTime":9243.833,"endTime":9245.899,"body":"And so the point is they become eager to"},{"startTime":9245.899,"endTime":9249.633,"body":"please the thing that has got them with"},{"startTime":9249.633,"endTime":9251.333,"body":"their guard down, having done things that"},{"startTime":9251.333,"endTime":9254.1,"body":"aren't defensible and then telling them,"},{"startTime":9254.366,"endTime":9256.366,"body":"Oh, here's our position on this, that or"},{"startTime":9256.366,"endTime":9258.299,"body":"the other, able to steer people without"},{"startTime":9258.299,"endTime":9259.766,"body":"actually blackmailing."},{"startTime":9259.766,"endTime":9260.233,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9260.233,"endTime":9261.899,"body":"Because people will fear."},{"startTime":9262.833,"endTime":9263.233,"body":"Further."},{"startTime":9263.533,"endTime":9264.333,"body":"Another piece of this model would be."},{"startTime":9264.366,"endTime":9273.233,"body":"That it is willing to ratchet up that it"},{"startTime":9273.233,"endTime":9277.133,"body":"is willing to embarrass people by to the"},{"startTime":9277.133,"endTime":9279.266,"body":"extent somebody is not responding to the"},{"startTime":9279.266,"endTime":9281.2,"body":"message about what it is that Epstein and"},{"startTime":9281.2,"endTime":9283.766,"body":"his friends want to happen in the world,"},{"startTime":9284.266,"endTime":9286.166,"body":"that something slightly embarrassing"},{"startTime":9286.166,"endTime":9287.366,"body":"emerges on you first."},{"startTime":9287.933,"endTime":9289.166,"body":"So shot across the bow."},{"startTime":9289.666,"endTime":9292.366,"body":"So anyway, I guess I don't know how good this model is, but the idea is it would"},{"startTime":9292.399,"endTime":9297.1,"body":"explain the fact that we don't have, I"},{"startTime":9297.1,"endTime":9299.533,"body":"think any credible examples in which this"},{"startTime":9299.533,"endTime":9301.266,"body":"thing is actually blackmailing people."},{"startTime":9301.766,"endTime":9303.066,"body":"Yet it seems to be a blackmail"},{"startTime":9303.066,"endTime":9305.0,"body":"accumulation enterprise."},{"startTime":9306.866,"endTime":9308.566,"body":"I at least haven't heard another"},{"startTime":9308.566,"endTime":9309.7,"body":"alternative hypothesis"},{"startTime":9309.7,"endTime":9311.233,"body":"that is more explanatory,"},{"startTime":9312.466,"endTime":9315.233,"body":"you know, he Epstein wasn't doing this in"},{"startTime":9315.233,"endTime":9318.466,"body":"order to, you know, pleasure a bunch of"},{"startTime":9318.466,"endTime":9319.766,"body":"the world's rich people out of the"},{"startTime":9319.766,"endTime":9320.766,"body":"goodness of his heart."},{"startTime":9321.233,"endTime":9321.433,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9321.433,"endTime":9322.799,"body":"That's not what was going on. No,"},{"startTime":9323.399,"endTime":9325.899,"body":"it wasn't what was going on is the fact"},{"startTime":9325.899,"endTime":9329.433,"body":"that he was a shockingly rich guy is"},{"startTime":9329.433,"endTime":9331.866,"body":"mysterious, as Eric points out regularly."},{"startTime":9331.866,"endTime":9333.233,"body":"And it does not add up"},{"startTime":9333.233,"endTime":9334.433,"body":"that he made a fortune."},{"startTime":9334.666,"endTime":9335.633,"body":"It seems like somebody"},{"startTime":9335.633,"endTime":9336.733,"body":"handed him a fortune."},{"startTime":9337.399,"endTime":9338.733,"body":"So it looks like an operation."},{"startTime":9339.399,"endTime":9341.633,"body":"It looks like an operation to collect a"},{"startTime":9341.633,"endTime":9342.799,"body":"compliment on people."},{"startTime":9343.266,"endTime":9344.533,"body":"It looks like it has."},{"startTime":9347.5,"endTime":9349.433,"body":"Like it's a fractal, right?"},{"startTime":9349.866,"endTime":9350.466,"body":"You have, you have every single person."},{"startTime":9350.733,"endTime":9353.299,"body":"You have everything from, you know,"},{"startTime":9354.166,"endTime":9357.133,"body":"embarrassing shit said in emails through"},{"startTime":9357.133,"endTime":9360.133,"body":"what looks like it is likely to involve"},{"startTime":9360.133,"endTime":9363.333,"body":"sexual abuse of actual"},{"startTime":9363.333,"endTime":9366.266,"body":"children, torture, maybe murder."},{"startTime":9367.399,"endTime":9368.333,"body":"So it looks like it"},{"startTime":9368.333,"endTime":9369.866,"body":"has every level of depth."},{"startTime":9370.799,"endTime":9373.0,"body":"And that's actually, if you were trying,"},{"startTime":9373.466,"endTime":9375.366,"body":"if your real point was money and power in"},{"startTime":9375.399,"endTime":9377.833,"body":"the world, and the idea was all of that"},{"startTime":9377.833,"endTime":9381.866,"body":"stuff was a means to an end, to gain"},{"startTime":9381.866,"endTime":9385.033,"body":"power, to gain leverage, and you couldn't"},{"startTime":9385.033,"endTime":9386.566,"body":"blackmail because you'd blow the whole"},{"startTime":9386.566,"endTime":9388.666,"body":"thing up, then it would look something"},{"startTime":9388.666,"endTime":9390.466,"body":"like this, where the"},{"startTime":9390.466,"endTime":9392.233,"body":"idea is it's really people."},{"startTime":9393.7,"endTime":9396.466,"body":"You're aligning their incentive to be of"},{"startTime":9396.466,"endTime":9398.6,"body":"like mind with you about whatever it is"},{"startTime":9398.6,"endTime":9400.2,"body":"you're trying to accomplish in the world."},{"startTime":9400.2,"endTime":9402.066,"body":"If the answer is, oh, now's"},{"startTime":9402.066,"endTime":9403.299,"body":"the moment to pump Bitcoin."},{"startTime":9403.833,"endTime":9404.1,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9404.133,"endTime":9407.233,"body":"If the person that has the goods on you"},{"startTime":9407.233,"endTime":9409.966,"body":"is suddenly wild about Bitcoin, how hard"},{"startTime":9409.966,"endTime":9411.866,"body":"is it for you to leap on the, Hey, I'm"},{"startTime":9411.866,"endTime":9413.366,"body":"another wild about Bitcoin person."},{"startTime":9413.866,"endTime":9414.1,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9414.833,"endTime":9416.766,"body":"So anyway, that's kind of"},{"startTime":9416.766,"endTime":9417.766,"body":"what I'm getting from this."},{"startTime":9417.766,"endTime":9420.1,"body":"I don't see a lot of proof."},{"startTime":9420.399,"endTime":9421.566,"body":"I see a lot of"},{"startTime":9421.566,"endTime":9424.5,"body":"confirmation of stuff, right?"},{"startTime":9424.766,"endTime":9426.866,"body":"Of, you know, not a trivial kind of"},{"startTime":9426.866,"endTime":9430.7,"body":"important kind, but, but mostly what I"},{"startTime":9430.7,"endTime":9433.433,"body":"get is that we still haven't nailed the"},{"startTime":9433.433,"endTime":9435.366,"body":"structure, its purpose."},{"startTime":9435.733,"endTime":9437.933,"body":"And most importantly, we still don't know"},{"startTime":9437.933,"endTime":9438.866,"body":"what role it has been"},{"startTime":9438.866,"endTime":9439.933,"body":"playing in our history."},{"startTime":9440.166,"endTime":9442.933,"body":"And I think, you know, I forgot in all of"},{"startTime":9442.933,"endTime":9445.333,"body":"the preparing for this morning, I forgot"},{"startTime":9445.333,"endTime":9447.333,"body":"to dig up my own tweet where I said"},{"startTime":9447.333,"endTime":9449.833,"body":"effectively, uh, I think Trump is"},{"startTime":9449.833,"endTime":9451.366,"body":"negotiating with us over Epstein."},{"startTime":9451.833,"endTime":9452.966,"body":"This is not negotiable."},{"startTime":9452.966,"endTime":9455.066,"body":"There are no higher priorities because I"},{"startTime":9455.066,"endTime":9456.066,"body":"really think that that's true."},{"startTime":9456.233,"endTime":9458.466,"body":"Whatever this thing was is playing some"},{"startTime":9458.466,"endTime":9460.799,"body":"role in our ability to govern ourselves"},{"startTime":9460.799,"endTime":9463.7,"body":"at a global scale that we don't know."},{"startTime":9464.266,"endTime":9464.433,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9464.433,"endTime":9465.899,"body":"I mean, Ukraine shows up here."},{"startTime":9466.466,"endTime":9468.933,"body":"I've been saying forever, somehow that's"},{"startTime":9468.933,"endTime":9469.866,"body":"more than just a war."},{"startTime":9470.1,"endTime":9472.466,"body":"That's a, that's a place to empty the"},{"startTime":9472.466,"endTime":9475.633,"body":"American treasury into, you know, into a"},{"startTime":9475.633,"endTime":9476.733,"body":"black hole in the universe."},{"startTime":9477.066,"endTime":9478.466,"body":"It's a potential source"},{"startTime":9478.466,"endTime":9480.6,"body":"for humans to traffic."},{"startTime":9480.6,"endTime":9482.266,"body":"It's a potential source for organs."},{"startTime":9482.533,"endTime":9483.333,"body":"We don't know what it is."},{"startTime":9483.366,"endTime":9485.066,"body":"We only know that it's sacred and we're"},{"startTime":9485.066,"endTime":9486.933,"body":"not allowed to challenge it or we become,"},{"startTime":9486.933,"endTime":9490.299,"body":"you know, uh, you know, Putin's friends."},{"startTime":9491.233,"endTime":9491.533,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9491.833,"endTime":9495.766,"body":"So anyway, we need to know yesterday what"},{"startTime":9495.766,"endTime":9498.066,"body":"role this is playing in our lives because"},{"startTime":9498.066,"endTime":9500.666,"body":"it's big and this confirms that it's big,"},{"startTime":9500.666,"endTime":9502.399,"body":"but it doesn't tell us how it's big and"},{"startTime":9502.399,"endTime":9503.399,"body":"it doesn't tell us how big."},{"startTime":9504.833,"endTime":9505.1,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":9505.899,"endTime":9506.133,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":9506.666,"endTime":9507.133,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":9507.133,"endTime":9507.933,"body":"Can we do one other thing"},{"startTime":9507.933,"endTime":9509.833,"body":"before we get to, uh, yeah."},{"startTime":9510.233,"endTime":9511.033,"body":"The one other thing is I"},{"startTime":9511.033,"endTime":9511.899,"body":"wanted to point to something."},{"startTime":9512.033,"endTime":9513.866,"body":"I think it may actually be from just"},{"startTime":9513.866,"endTime":9515.733,"body":"before last week, but nonetheless, it's"},{"startTime":9515.733,"endTime":9519.366,"body":"so in keeping with what the hell are we"},{"startTime":9519.366,"endTime":9521.799,"body":"living through that I wanted to show it."},{"startTime":9521.799,"endTime":9526.766,"body":"So this is a video of the new CEO of Tik"},{"startTime":9526.766,"endTime":9529.666,"body":"TOK describing his"},{"startTime":9529.666,"endTime":9532.166,"body":"upgraded procedure for, uh,"},{"startTime":9535.066,"endTime":9535.799,"body":"keeping people safe"},{"startTime":9535.799,"endTime":9536.766,"body":"from hate or something."},{"startTime":9537.833,"endTime":9540.866,"body":"We made a change to designate the use of"},{"startTime":9540.866,"endTime":9543.633,"body":"the term Zionist as a proxy for a"},{"startTime":9543.633,"endTime":9545.333,"body":"protected attribute as hate speech."},{"startTime":9546.1,"endTime":9548.033,"body":"So if somebody were to use Zionist, of"},{"startTime":9548.033,"endTime":9549.733,"body":"course you can, you can use it in the, in"},{"startTime":9549.733,"endTime":9551.966,"body":"the sense of your proud Zionist, but if"},{"startTime":9551.966,"endTime":9554.5,"body":"you're using it in the context of, um,"},{"startTime":9554.833,"endTime":9557.166,"body":"degrading somebody, calling somebody a"},{"startTime":9557.166,"endTime":9560.333,"body":"Zionist as a, as a dirty name, then that"},{"startTime":9560.333,"endTime":9562.399,"body":"gets designated as hate"},{"startTime":9562.399,"endTime":9564.5,"body":"speech, um, to be moderated against."},{"startTime":9564.966,"endTime":9567.833,"body":"Over the course of 2024, we tripled the"},{"startTime":9567.833,"endTime":9569.399,"body":"amount of accounts that we were banning"},{"startTime":9569.566,"endTime":9570.933,"body":"for hateful activity."},{"startTime":9571.299,"endTime":9573.533,"body":"We also have, I think over two dozen"},{"startTime":9573.533,"endTime":9575.366,"body":"Jewish organizations that are constantly"},{"startTime":9575.366,"endTime":9578.033,"body":"feeding us intelligence and information"},{"startTime":9578.033,"endTime":9579.866,"body":"when they spot violative trends."},{"startTime":9580.066,"endTime":9581.133,"body":"There is no finish line."},{"startTime":9581.766,"endTime":9584.433,"body":"There's no finish line to moderating hate"},{"startTime":9584.433,"endTime":9586.866,"body":"speech, identifying hateful trends,"},{"startTime":9587.666,"endTime":9589.133,"body":"trying to keep the platform safe."},{"startTime":9589.766,"endTime":9592.666,"body":"Um, there's no such thing as an end game."},{"startTime":9595.466,"endTime":9595.833,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":9595.833,"endTime":9598.033,"body":"So I find that chilling."},{"startTime":9599.433,"endTime":9601.7,"body":"Um, for one thing, there's an echo in"},{"startTime":9601.7,"endTime":9606.2,"body":"there of the worst of woke, right?"},{"startTime":9606.633,"endTime":9607.833,"body":"Where he says, you know,"},{"startTime":9608.1,"endTime":9609.566,"body":"there's no finish line, right?"},{"startTime":9609.566,"endTime":9610.666,"body":"The fight against racism"},{"startTime":9610.666,"endTime":9611.899,"body":"will never be over, right?"},{"startTime":9611.899,"endTime":9612.933,"body":"That's what they used to say."},{"startTime":9612.933,"endTime":9614.866,"body":"And the answer is you're creating an"},{"startTime":9614.866,"endTime":9616.566,"body":"environment in which you have license,"},{"startTime":9616.566,"endTime":9621.433,"body":"uh, to take liberties and, um, you've,"},{"startTime":9621.433,"endTime":9622.6,"body":"you've, you've written a set of rules to"},{"startTime":9622.6,"endTime":9625.0,"body":"the game in which we don't even, you"},{"startTime":9625.0,"endTime":9626.833,"body":"know, we don't even get to ask you, we'll"},{"startTime":9626.833,"endTime":9628.233,"body":"have you accomplish the goal yet because"},{"startTime":9628.233,"endTime":9629.533,"body":"you've already told us, well, that's not"},{"startTime":9629.533,"endTime":9630.399,"body":"ever going to happen."},{"startTime":9630.666,"endTime":9631.633,"body":"I'm always going to have"},{"startTime":9631.633,"endTime":9632.666,"body":"the right to use the game."},{"startTime":9633.133,"endTime":9633.966,"body":"This will never be over."},{"startTime":9634.7,"endTime":9636.433,"body":"Our rules may change at any moment."},{"startTime":9636.733,"endTime":9637.866,"body":"That's, that's at our whim."},{"startTime":9638.033,"endTime":9638.2,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9638.6,"endTime":9639.666,"body":"And, uh, and as long as we"},{"startTime":9639.666,"endTime":9640.933,"body":"call it hate speech, we win."},{"startTime":9640.933,"endTime":9641.166,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9641.866,"endTime":9644.233,"body":"I can, I can, uh, use the word Zionist,"},{"startTime":9644.233,"endTime":9647.133,"body":"but you can't, and I will tell you, um, I"},{"startTime":9647.166,"endTime":9648.7,"body":"don't mean that between you and me, but I"},{"startTime":9648.7,"endTime":9649.133,"body":"mean, that's what"},{"startTime":9649.133,"endTime":9650.066,"body":"he's effectively saying."},{"startTime":9650.466,"endTime":9652.5,"body":"And I will say, uh, in using,"},{"startTime":9652.5,"endTime":9653.066,"body":"well, no, I could, I"},{"startTime":9653.066,"endTime":9654.0,"body":"could use it about myself."},{"startTime":9654.2,"endTime":9655.866,"body":"If I, if I felt that I was"},{"startTime":9655.866,"endTime":9657.233,"body":"as I could say that I am,"},{"startTime":9657.533,"endTime":9659.133,"body":"you can use it in a positive context and"},{"startTime":9659.133,"endTime":9659.866,"body":"you can't use it in a"},{"startTime":9659.866,"endTime":9662.1,"body":"negative one, which is insane."},{"startTime":9662.533,"endTime":9665.633,"body":"For one thing, you have a bunch of people"},{"startTime":9665.633,"endTime":9668.133,"body":"who are proudly using"},{"startTime":9668.133,"endTime":9669.299,"body":"that term for themselves."},{"startTime":9669.299,"endTime":9671.366,"body":"Now I will just say for my part, I have"},{"startTime":9671.366,"endTime":9673.733,"body":"been very cautious about that term"},{"startTime":9673.733,"endTime":9678.633,"body":"because of the, uh, linguistic"},{"startTime":9678.633,"endTime":9680.533,"body":"flexibility that it"},{"startTime":9680.533,"endTime":9682.166,"body":"seems to accompany it."},{"startTime":9682.233,"endTime":9682.533,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9682.866,"endTime":9684.033,"body":"It can mean, I think it"},{"startTime":9684.033,"endTime":9685.666,"body":"can mean three things."},{"startTime":9686.666,"endTime":9689.933,"body":"Um, it does get used by people who hate"},{"startTime":9689.933,"endTime":9691.833,"body":"Jews for whatever reason, and it gets"},{"startTime":9691.833,"endTime":9693.166,"body":"used as a synonym, right?"},{"startTime":9694.033,"endTime":9694.633,"body":"A synonym."},{"startTime":9694.966,"endTime":9695.366,"body":"For Jew."},{"startTime":9696.466,"endTime":9701.366,"body":"Um, it is used in a technical way for the"},{"startTime":9701.366,"endTime":9703.566,"body":"movement that initially pushed for the"},{"startTime":9703.633,"endTime":9707.466,"body":"creation of Israel and, uh, defends it in"},{"startTime":9707.466,"endTime":9709.666,"body":"its effectively current form."},{"startTime":9710.133,"endTime":9713.399,"body":"And it seems to be used for a radical"},{"startTime":9713.399,"endTime":9716.633,"body":"plan that goes by the name of greater"},{"startTime":9716.633,"endTime":9720.266,"body":"Israel, uh, in which Israel is bigger"},{"startTime":9720.266,"endTime":9721.933,"body":"than its current borders."},{"startTime":9722.333,"endTime":9722.533,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9722.799,"endTime":9726.833,"body":"So I don't like the term because there's"},{"startTime":9726.833,"endTime":9727.933,"body":"always, it doesn't have"},{"startTime":9727.933,"endTime":9728.733,"body":"an agreed upon definition."},{"startTime":9728.733,"endTime":9729.733,"body":"It doesn't have an agreed upon"},{"startTime":9729.733,"endTime":9732.433,"body":"definition, but to the extent that people"},{"startTime":9732.433,"endTime":9735.066,"body":"who hold one of these positions are"},{"startTime":9735.066,"endTime":9738.799,"body":"describing themselves with that term, I"},{"startTime":9738.799,"endTime":9739.866,"body":"have to be liberated"},{"startTime":9739.866,"endTime":9741.299,"body":"to use that term too."},{"startTime":9741.733,"endTime":9742.766,"body":"And I'll make my caveat."},{"startTime":9742.766,"endTime":9744.2,"body":"But the point is if you're defining your"},{"startTime":9744.2,"endTime":9746.266,"body":"team that way, then I get to say things"},{"startTime":9746.266,"endTime":9747.733,"body":"about your team using the same term."},{"startTime":9748.166,"endTime":9750.033,"body":"It can't be a magic term."},{"startTime":9751.399,"endTime":9755.233,"body":"So there, there can't be magic terms."},{"startTime":9755.933,"endTime":9757.166,"body":"Yeah, there can't be magic terms."},{"startTime":9757.399,"endTime":9757.6,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9758.033,"endTime":9759.233,"body":"Um, and you know, it"},{"startTime":9759.233,"endTime":9761.133,"body":"does, you know, let's, um,"},{"startTime":9761.833,"endTime":9763.833,"body":"I mean, I, when you told me about this"},{"startTime":9763.833,"endTime":9765.933,"body":"and I'm, you know, I'm not going to say"},{"startTime":9765.933,"endTime":9767.333,"body":"it on air because I don't feel like it,"},{"startTime":9767.633,"endTime":9769.433,"body":"but I said to you, this is the N word."},{"startTime":9770.366,"endTime":9770.566,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":9770.766,"endTime":9770.966,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9771.333,"endTime":9773.066,"body":"Um, and you know, I feel for"},{"startTime":9773.066,"endTime":9775.833,"body":"the same way about, um, cunt."},{"startTime":9777.033,"endTime":9778.066,"body":"I don't like it when I hear that word"},{"startTime":9778.066,"endTime":9779.033,"body":"coming out of men's mouths."},{"startTime":9779.033,"endTime":9780.133,"body":"I don't like it when I hear it coming out"},{"startTime":9780.133,"endTime":9781.466,"body":"of women's mouths, but,"},{"startTime":9781.466,"endTime":9784.066,"body":"uh, it's not protected."},{"startTime":9784.166,"endTime":9785.433,"body":"It's not, what did you say?"},{"startTime":9785.433,"endTime":9786.399,"body":"Special it's, there's no,"},{"startTime":9786.399,"endTime":9787.466,"body":"it's not magic."},{"startTime":9787.466,"endTime":9788.1,"body":"It's not magic."},{"startTime":9788.1,"endTime":9790.0,"body":"There are no magic words anywhere."},{"startTime":9790.133,"endTime":9792.566,"body":"Everyone can use any word they want and"},{"startTime":9792.566,"endTime":9794.166,"body":"let, you know, let us reveal ourselves."},{"startTime":9794.833,"endTime":9796.5,"body":"Let us reveal who we are."},{"startTime":9796.5,"endTime":9796.666,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":9796.666,"endTime":9797.633,"body":"I agree with that."},{"startTime":9797.633,"endTime":9799.733,"body":"And let me just say, look, I don't want"},{"startTime":9799.733,"endTime":9800.433,"body":"to be called a kike."},{"startTime":9800.766,"endTime":9802.033,"body":"I don't want to hear other people called"},{"startTime":9802.033,"endTime":9804.899,"body":"a kike, but I do want people to have the"},{"startTime":9804.899,"endTime":9807.266,"body":"right to use the word because the world"},{"startTime":9807.266,"endTime":9808.466,"body":"in which words get"},{"startTime":9808.466,"endTime":9810.866,"body":"forbidden is not a good world."},{"startTime":9811.233,"endTime":9813.033,"body":"Our founders well understood that."},{"startTime":9813.6,"endTime":9818.466,"body":"And so anyway, I mean the, the tenuous"},{"startTime":9818.466,"endTime":9821.6,"body":"agreement that long existed over the word"},{"startTime":9821.6,"endTime":9825.866,"body":"nigger and the permutation nigga,"},{"startTime":9827.166,"endTime":9833.866,"body":"that tenuous agreement was informal."},{"startTime":9834.833,"endTime":9835.033,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9835.899,"endTime":9838.799,"body":"And at an informal level, you could say,"},{"startTime":9839.266,"endTime":9839.933,"body":"understood culturally."},{"startTime":9840.266,"endTime":9840.466,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":9840.666,"endTime":9842.366,"body":"You could understand that."},{"startTime":9842.966,"endTime":9844.166,"body":"No, I'm not saying it was understandable."},{"startTime":9844.466,"endTime":9845.2,"body":"No, I'm saying it was"},{"startTime":9845.2,"endTime":9846.366,"body":"understood culturally."},{"startTime":9846.566,"endTime":9849.866,"body":"We, we all knew the rules in which of the"},{"startTime":9849.866,"endTime":9851.666,"body":"game in which we were playing and also"},{"startTime":9851.799,"endTime":9854.7,"body":"that we could opt out, but that people"},{"startTime":9854.7,"endTime":9855.299,"body":"would know that we were"},{"startTime":9855.299,"endTime":9856.1,"body":"opting out of that game."},{"startTime":9856.1,"endTime":9857.866,"body":"Well, and the point is there's opting out"},{"startTime":9857.866,"endTime":9859.366,"body":"and there's other things that might"},{"startTime":9859.399,"endTime":9860.266,"body":"superficially seem"},{"startTime":9860.266,"endTime":9861.566,"body":"like it, but aren't right."},{"startTime":9861.866,"endTime":9866.866,"body":"So the point is it was agreed for decades"},{"startTime":9866.866,"endTime":9868.966,"body":"that you were not allowed to use that"},{"startTime":9869.033,"endTime":9871.2,"body":"word in earnest and that black people"},{"startTime":9871.2,"endTime":9872.233,"body":"were you allowed to use it"},{"startTime":9872.233,"endTime":9874.066,"body":"for what they wanted informally."},{"startTime":9874.066,"endTime":9875.366,"body":"It wasn't a rule."},{"startTime":9875.666,"endTime":9877.766,"body":"You weren't going to be ruined if you"},{"startTime":9877.766,"endTime":9882.899,"body":"violated the rule, but it was understood."},{"startTime":9883.533,"endTime":9888.2,"body":"However, the ability to discuss the word"},{"startTime":9888.2,"endTime":9891.799,"body":"existed, the ability to include it in a"},{"startTime":9891.799,"endTime":9895.233,"body":"script in which it was necessary for"},{"startTime":9895.233,"endTime":9897.866,"body":"historical authenticity was allowed."},{"startTime":9897.866,"endTime":9899.433,"body":"The ability, you know, to"},{"startTime":9899.433,"endTime":9901.233,"body":"read Huck Finn was there."},{"startTime":9901.233,"endTime":9903.333,"body":"The ability to sing along with Bob Dylan"},{"startTime":9903.333,"endTime":9905.833,"body":"in Hurricane was there."},{"startTime":9906.133,"endTime":9908.266,"body":"The point is it had a natural boundary,"},{"startTime":9908.266,"endTime":9909.933,"body":"which is you're not allowed to use the"},{"startTime":9909.933,"endTime":9912.033,"body":"word in earnest, but to the extent that"},{"startTime":9912.033,"endTime":9914.2,"body":"it is a word that has to be discussed or"},{"startTime":9914.2,"endTime":9915.366,"body":"described or whatever."},{"startTime":9916.5,"endTime":9919.633,"body":"The, you know, in good faith, you can use"},{"startTime":9919.633,"endTime":9920.933,"body":"it as needed, but don't go out of your"},{"startTime":9920.933,"endTime":9921.666,"body":"way to use it and"},{"startTime":9921.666,"endTime":9922.466,"body":"don't use it in earnest."},{"startTime":9922.833,"endTime":9923.066,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":9923.299,"endTime":9923.466,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9923.733,"endTime":9925.7,"body":"But the point is that ship has sailed a"},{"startTime":9925.7,"endTime":9928.466,"body":"long time ago and the prosecution"},{"startTime":9928.466,"endTime":9931.333,"body":"effectively of people for using it in"},{"startTime":9931.333,"endTime":9933.333,"body":"ways that were at one time clearly"},{"startTime":9933.333,"endTime":9937.966,"body":"tolerated, has broken the dam."},{"startTime":9938.233,"endTime":9941.033,"body":"And now we have Zionism of all terms,"},{"startTime":9941.033,"endTime":9944.466,"body":"like an actual historical fact, right?"},{"startTime":9944.466,"endTime":9947.266,"body":"A movement that we can't discuss unless"},{"startTime":9947.266,"endTime":9948.166,"body":"we're on board with it."},{"startTime":9948.166,"endTime":9948.433,"body":"Like what?"},{"startTime":9949.033,"endTime":9951.1,"body":"You don't get to write a rule like that."},{"startTime":9951.133,"endTime":9953.166,"body":"It just it's intolerable because it"},{"startTime":9953.166,"endTime":9954.633,"body":"breaks logic, right?"},{"startTime":9954.633,"endTime":9955.466,"body":"It makes it impossible."},{"startTime":9955.933,"endTime":9957.366,"body":"We can't, you know, it's like having"},{"startTime":9957.366,"endTime":9958.399,"body":"that's no barrier."},{"startTime":9961.0,"endTime":9963.466,"body":"It is to me, but you know, it's like you"},{"startTime":9963.466,"endTime":9966.666,"body":"cannot forbid me from talking about"},{"startTime":9966.666,"endTime":9969.533,"body":"Bradley Manning and his turning over of"},{"startTime":9969.533,"endTime":9973.466,"body":"documents to WikiLeaks just because"},{"startTime":9973.466,"endTime":9975.366,"body":"Bradley now wishes to be"},{"startTime":9975.366,"endTime":9976.333,"body":"referred to as Chelsea."},{"startTime":9976.366,"endTime":9979.5,"body":"And I can adhere to calling Bradley"},{"startTime":9979.5,"endTime":9981.633,"body":"Chelsea now, but I can't go back into"},{"startTime":9981.633,"endTime":9982.633,"body":"history and pretend he was"},{"startTime":9982.633,"endTime":9983.733,"body":"Chelsea then because he was."},{"startTime":9984.566,"endTime":9984.766,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":9985.066,"endTime":9985.266,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9985.866,"endTime":9988.466,"body":"So anyway, I don't know what the hell is"},{"startTime":9988.466,"endTime":9990.833,"body":"going on with TikTok, but it is insane"},{"startTime":9990.833,"endTime":9993.933,"body":"that that presser, whatever his name is,"},{"startTime":9994.266,"endTime":9997.766,"body":"feels like he's speaking coherently."},{"startTime":9997.766,"endTime":9998.266,"body":"That's the CEO."},{"startTime":9998.566,"endTime":9998.766,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":9999.233,"endTime":9999.733,"body":"CEO of TikTok."},{"startTime":9999.733,"endTime":10001.333,"body":"It feels like he's speaking coherently"},{"startTime":10001.333,"endTime":10003.733,"body":"there where he's obviously advertising"},{"startTime":10003.733,"endTime":10005.1,"body":"dystopia that he is now."},{"startTime":10005.933,"endTime":10009.733,"body":"Inacting pioneering like, come on, you"},{"startTime":10009.733,"endTime":10010.733,"body":"don't get to do that."},{"startTime":10010.966,"endTime":10011.566,"body":"We we have."},{"startTime":10011.566,"endTime":10013.066,"body":"I don't think anyone is pioneering"},{"startTime":10013.066,"endTime":10014.133,"body":"dystopia at this point."},{"startTime":10014.7,"endTime":10015.299,"body":"I mean, lots of"},{"startTime":10015.299,"endTime":10017.466,"body":"little new pioneering like"},{"startTime":10017.466,"endTime":10019.266,"body":"innovations, little ones,"},{"startTime":10019.266,"endTime":10021.266,"body":"little, little ones, all parallel, all"},{"startTime":10021.266,"endTime":10022.366,"body":"happening at the same time."},{"startTime":10022.6,"endTime":10024.133,"body":"Yeah, all happening at the same time."},{"startTime":10024.133,"endTime":10025.933,"body":"Well, dystopian innovations across the"},{"startTime":10025.933,"endTime":10026.866,"body":"board, across the land."},{"startTime":10027.066,"endTime":10029.966,"body":"The more AI enabled that the dystopian"},{"startTime":10029.966,"endTime":10031.933,"body":"pioneers become, the more we will"},{"startTime":10031.933,"endTime":10032.833,"body":"discover what the true"},{"startTime":10032.833,"endTime":10033.966,"body":"limits of dystopia are."},{"startTime":10034.899,"endTime":10035.299,"body":"Fantastic."},{"startTime":10036.233,"endTime":10036.766,"body":"Should we go back to"},{"startTime":10036.766,"endTime":10037.799,"body":"William Butler Yates then?"},{"startTime":10039.633,"endTime":10040.399,"body":"Always a good plan."},{"startTime":10041.766,"endTime":10041.966,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":10042.5,"endTime":10042.866,"body":"So, okay."},{"startTime":10043.133,"endTime":10045.666,"body":"So here's, here's a silver lining."},{"startTime":10046.066,"endTime":10046.266,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":10046.333,"endTime":10049.266,"body":"I guess I think, I think, so actually I"},{"startTime":10049.266,"endTime":10052.133,"body":"was, I, we didn't get to last week, but"},{"startTime":10052.166,"endTime":10055.433,"body":"before, you know, over a week ago, there"},{"startTime":10055.433,"endTime":10063.399,"body":"was, this announcement, local to us, not"},{"startTime":10063.399,"endTime":10065.866,"body":"super, super local, but local-ish,"},{"startTime":10066.333,"endTime":10067.766,"body":"although don't do my screen yet because"},{"startTime":10067.766,"endTime":10069.033,"body":"my computer is freaking out."},{"startTime":10069.366,"endTime":10069.6,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":10069.6,"endTime":10070.866,"body":"Now, now you can, if you"},{"startTime":10070.866,"endTime":10071.733,"body":"feel like it, if you can."},{"startTime":10072.799,"endTime":10074.866,"body":"This is in, I don't even"},{"startTime":10074.866,"endTime":10076.433,"body":"know, where was this published?"},{"startTime":10077.733,"endTime":10078.833,"body":"Seattle Times health reporter."},{"startTime":10078.833,"endTime":10080.399,"body":"I think this is in the Seattle Times,"},{"startTime":10081.066,"endTime":10082.133,"body":"Marybridge Children's"},{"startTime":10082.133,"endTime":10083.5,"body":"Hospital to Close Gender Clinic."},{"startTime":10083.899,"endTime":10084.666,"body":"So this is published on"},{"startTime":10084.666,"endTime":10086.166,"body":"January 27th of this year."},{"startTime":10087.1,"endTime":10089.633,"body":"This is here in the Puget Sound, west of"},{"startTime":10089.633,"endTime":10091.333,"body":"the Cascades, on the very, very blue part"},{"startTime":10091.333,"endTime":10092.233,"body":"of Washington state."},{"startTime":10093.433,"endTime":10096.233,"body":"And just a couple of paragraphs here."},{"startTime":10096.233,"endTime":10097.733,"body":"Marybridge Children's Hospital in Tacoma"},{"startTime":10097.733,"endTime":10099.533,"body":"plans to shut down its gender clinic this"},{"startTime":10099.533,"endTime":10102.0,"body":"week under mounting federal pressure to"},{"startTime":10102.0,"endTime":10103.299,"body":"ban all gender affirming"},{"startTime":10103.299,"endTime":10104.566,"body":"health care for trans youth."},{"startTime":10105.466,"endTime":10106.733,"body":"Hospital leaders announced the decision"},{"startTime":10106.733,"endTime":10108.533,"body":"in a Monday memo to employees writing"},{"startTime":10108.533,"endTime":10110.266,"body":"that, quote, recent developments at the"},{"startTime":10110.266,"endTime":10111.833,"body":"federal level threatened to halt Medicaid"},{"startTime":10111.833,"endTime":10114.399,"body":"and Medicare programs, payments to the"},{"startTime":10114.399,"endTime":10116.266,"body":"entire multi-care health system, which"},{"startTime":10116.266,"endTime":10118.166,"body":"owns Marybridge, if it continues to offer"},{"startTime":10118.166,"endTime":10118.733,"body":"gender affirming"},{"startTime":10118.733,"endTime":10119.733,"body":"health services to minors."},{"startTime":10120.966,"endTime":10122.933,"body":"This was an incredibly painful decision"},{"startTime":10122.933,"endTime":10123.833,"body":"and one that I wish we"},{"startTime":10123.833,"endTime":10124.866,"body":"did not have to make."},{"startTime":10125.366,"endTime":10127.666,"body":"Multicare CEO Bill Robertson wrote in the"},{"startTime":10127.666,"endTime":10129.233,"body":"memo, which the hospital shared with the"},{"startTime":10129.233,"endTime":10131.633,"body":"Seattle Times, we recognize how important"},{"startTime":10131.633,"endTime":10133.166,"body":"this care is to our gender health clinic"},{"startTime":10133.166,"endTime":10135.133,"body":"patients and have a sense of the impact"},{"startTime":10135.133,"endTime":10135.966,"body":"this will have on these"},{"startTime":10135.966,"endTime":10137.066,"body":"patients and their families."},{"startTime":10137.433,"endTime":10137.733,"body":"End quote."},{"startTime":10138.666,"endTime":10140.066,"body":"But without federal Medicaid and Medicare"},{"startTime":10140.066,"endTime":10142.233,"body":"payments, Robertson continued, quote, our"},{"startTime":10142.233,"endTime":10143.899,"body":"organization would cease to exist."},{"startTime":10144.266,"endTime":10144.733,"body":"End quote."},{"startTime":10145.2,"endTime":10146.733,"body":"According to the hospital, more than 60%"},{"startTime":10147.0,"endTime":10148.266,"body":"of all Marybridge patients were on"},{"startTime":10148.266,"endTime":10149.366,"body":"Medicaid, known as"},{"startTime":10149.366,"endTime":10150.466,"body":"Apple Health in Washington."},{"startTime":10151.633,"endTime":10153.133,"body":"Marybridge cut its gender clinic waitlist"},{"startTime":10153.133,"endTime":10154.966,"body":"of about 150 families in September,"},{"startTime":10155.433,"endTime":10156.899,"body":"confirming them that the clinic would"},{"startTime":10156.899,"endTime":10158.333,"body":"continue to serve those who were already"},{"startTime":10158.333,"endTime":10159.866,"body":"receiving gender affirming medication"},{"startTime":10159.866,"endTime":10161.533,"body":"like hormone therapy and puberty"},{"startTime":10161.533,"endTime":10162.566,"body":"blockers, but would not"},{"startTime":10162.566,"endTime":10163.799,"body":"start any new medical treatment."},{"startTime":10164.6,"endTime":10166.166,"body":"This week's news means cutting off care"},{"startTime":10166.166,"endTime":10167.533,"body":"to the clinic's remaining patients,"},{"startTime":10167.533,"endTime":10170.2,"body":"roughly 320 young people, including 180"},{"startTime":10170.2,"endTime":10173.133,"body":"under 18, who will now have to get their"},{"startTime":10173.133,"endTime":10175.133,"body":"prescriptions renewed or find gender"},{"startTime":10175.133,"endTime":10176.866,"body":"affirming mental health care elsewhere."},{"startTime":10177.566,"endTime":10178.366,"body":"And it goes on."},{"startTime":10179.2,"endTime":10179.466,"body":"But,"},{"startTime":10180.566,"endTime":10183.133,"body":"you know, the language here is insane."},{"startTime":10184.0,"endTime":10186.233,"body":"Gender affirming health care, gender"},{"startTime":10186.233,"endTime":10187.266,"body":"affirming medication."},{"startTime":10188.466,"endTime":10188.666,"body":"No."},{"startTime":10190.133,"endTime":10191.399,"body":"At best, fantasy"},{"startTime":10191.399,"endTime":10194.266,"body":"affirming medication at best."},{"startTime":10194.799,"endTime":10195.0,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":10196.166,"endTime":10198.133,"body":"Mental instability affirming medication,"},{"startTime":10198.866,"endTime":10201.7,"body":"celebration of mental illness medication."},{"startTime":10202.366,"endTime":10202.566,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":10202.833,"endTime":10204.399,"body":"That's what they're not going to be doing"},{"startTime":10204.399,"endTime":10207.033,"body":"for these many children"},{"startTime":10207.033,"endTime":10208.5,"body":"and other young people."},{"startTime":10208.766,"endTime":10211.866,"body":"Anymore, but only at this point, end of"},{"startTime":10211.866,"endTime":10214.466,"body":"January, under duress from, from the"},{"startTime":10214.466,"endTime":10215.6,"body":"Trump administration, from the federal"},{"startTime":10215.6,"endTime":10217.2,"body":"government who said, we're going to cut"},{"startTime":10217.2,"endTime":10218.966,"body":"off Medicare and Medicaid payments unless"},{"startTime":10218.966,"endTime":10220.166,"body":"you cease and desist."},{"startTime":10220.433,"endTime":10221.466,"body":"You got to stop."},{"startTime":10221.866,"endTime":10222.966,"body":"So if I can, oh, actually,"},{"startTime":10225.133,"endTime":10227.766,"body":"yeah, maybe we can just go right here to"},{"startTime":10227.766,"endTime":10229.733,"body":"then this week, just,"},{"startTime":10231.933,"endTime":10234.533,"body":"just yesterday, I believe February 3rd,"},{"startTime":10234.533,"endTime":10237.7,"body":"we have here the American Society of"},{"startTime":10237.7,"endTime":10239.433,"body":"Plastic Surgeons makes"},{"startTime":10239.433,"endTime":10240.766,"body":"a position statement."},{"startTime":10240.766,"endTime":10244.5,"body":"It's the ASPS, the very first major"},{"startTime":10244.5,"endTime":10246.433,"body":"medical organization, and it may just be"},{"startTime":10246.433,"endTime":10248.666,"body":"the very first medical organization, full"},{"startTime":10248.666,"endTime":10251.866,"body":"stop, to put out a position statement on"},{"startTime":10251.866,"endTime":10252.533,"body":"gender surgery for"},{"startTime":10252.533,"endTime":10253.433,"body":"children and adolescents."},{"startTime":10254.466,"endTime":10257.1,"body":"The summary of which is the clinical"},{"startTime":10257.1,"endTime":10258.6,"body":"management of children and adolescents"},{"startTime":10258.666,"endTime":10260.433,"body":"presented with gender dysphoria or gender"},{"startTime":10260.433,"endTime":10262.833,"body":"incongruence has undergone rapid change."},{"startTime":10263.066,"endTime":10265.533,"body":"And ASPS, again, the American Society of"},{"startTime":10265.533,"endTime":10267.166,"body":"Plastic Surgeons, wishes to offer"},{"startTime":10267.166,"endTime":10268.933,"body":"guidance to members providing gender"},{"startTime":10268.933,"endTime":10270.433,"body":"surgery services for this population."},{"startTime":10271.166,"endTime":10272.866,"body":"This position statement discusses the"},{"startTime":10272.866,"endTime":10274.233,"body":"views of the American Society of Plastic"},{"startTime":10274.233,"endTime":10277.0,"body":"Surgeons on breast, chest, genital, and"},{"startTime":10277.0,"endTime":10278.466,"body":"facial gender surgery for individuals"},{"startTime":10278.466,"endTime":10279.433,"body":"under the age of 19."},{"startTime":10279.933,"endTime":10281.966,"body":"Funny, the summary doesn't say what their"},{"startTime":10281.966,"endTime":10282.766,"body":"position statement is."},{"startTime":10282.766,"endTime":10283.399,"body":"They're still hiding."},{"startTime":10283.833,"endTime":10285.533,"body":"They're still hiding here, but you have"},{"startTime":10285.533,"endTime":10286.666,"body":"to scroll, you have to scroll, you have"},{"startTime":10286.666,"endTime":10290.333,"body":"to scroll, you know, caveat after caveat,"},{"startTime":10290.333,"endTime":10291.933,"body":"after caveat, hiding behind what they've"},{"startTime":10291.933,"endTime":10293.333,"body":"already said, explaining why they didn't"},{"startTime":10293.333,"endTime":10294.2,"body":"come to this sooner."},{"startTime":10294.799,"endTime":10296.533,"body":"Finally, the ASPS position."},{"startTime":10297.666,"endTime":10299.7,"body":"ASPS recommends that surgeons delay"},{"startTime":10299.7,"endTime":10301.799,"body":"gender-related breast, chest, genital,"},{"startTime":10302.066,"endTime":10303.466,"body":"and facial surgery until a"},{"startTime":10303.466,"endTime":10305.433,"body":"patient is at least 19 years old."},{"startTime":10306.733,"endTime":10308.766,"body":"It's too little too late, but it's"},{"startTime":10308.766,"endTime":10310.533,"body":"utterly necessary and it's about time."},{"startTime":10311.333,"endTime":10311.6,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":10311.6,"endTime":10313.333,"body":"It's like the changes to"},{"startTime":10313.333,"endTime":10314.533,"body":"the child vaccine schedule."},{"startTime":10314.933,"endTime":10316.566,"body":"Oh my God, we got a lot further to go."},{"startTime":10317.366,"endTime":10318.366,"body":"But good."},{"startTime":10319.066,"endTime":10320.433,"body":"This they're making no statement."},{"startTime":10320.433,"endTime":10323.1,"body":"They're the Association for the Society"},{"startTime":10323.1,"endTime":10324.666,"body":"of Plastic Surgeons, so maybe they"},{"startTime":10324.666,"endTime":10326.166,"body":"wouldn't have any say about the"},{"startTime":10326.166,"endTime":10328.266,"body":"endocrinological interventions."},{"startTime":10329.399,"endTime":10331.299,"body":"But with regard to surgery, which is"},{"startTime":10331.299,"endTime":10333.633,"body":"after all their bailiwick, they're saying"},{"startTime":10333.633,"endTime":10337.133,"body":"until you hit 19, excuse me, until you"},{"startTime":10337.133,"endTime":10338.633,"body":"hit 19, you shouldn't have facial"},{"startTime":10338.633,"endTime":10341.933,"body":"feminization or I guess masculinization,"},{"startTime":10341.933,"endTime":10343.0,"body":"but I've never heard of that happening."},{"startTime":10343.333,"endTime":10343.899,"body":"Maybe that happens."},{"startTime":10344.966,"endTime":10346.333,"body":"Although that would be an adding rather"},{"startTime":10346.333,"endTime":10347.299,"body":"than subtracting, so"},{"startTime":10347.299,"endTime":10348.533,"body":"that's not as easy to do."},{"startTime":10349.533,"endTime":10352.066,"body":"Genital or top surgery,"},{"startTime":10352.066,"endTime":10353.133,"body":"what is called top surgery."},{"startTime":10354.133,"endTime":10357.866,"body":"So again, too little too late and they"},{"startTime":10357.866,"endTime":10359.299,"body":"hedge and they hedge and they hedge and"},{"startTime":10359.299,"endTime":10362.299,"body":"they explain themselves away about which"},{"startTime":10362.299,"endTime":10363.433,"body":"I have very little patience,"},{"startTime":10364.866,"endTime":10366.533,"body":"but they ultimately get there."},{"startTime":10366.933,"endTime":10369.633,"body":"And then in the wake of this, if you can"},{"startTime":10369.633,"endTime":10372.933,"body":"show the national review"},{"startTime":10372.933,"endTime":10374.566,"body":"in the wake of this ASPS"},{"startTime":10375.666,"endTime":10378.799,"body":"statement, position statement, asked the"},{"startTime":10378.799,"endTime":10383.7,"body":"AMA what they thought and the AMA, the"},{"startTime":10383.7,"endTime":10385.466,"body":"American Medical Association, said in the"},{"startTime":10385.466,"endTime":10387.033,"body":"statement in national review that"},{"startTime":10387.033,"endTime":10388.433,"body":"because, quote, \"the evidence for"},{"startTime":10388.433,"endTime":10390.466,"body":"gender-referring surgical intervention in"},{"startTime":10390.466,"endTime":10392.366,"body":"minors is insufficient for us to make a"},{"startTime":10392.366,"endTime":10394.833,"body":"definitive statement,\" the AMA agrees"},{"startTime":10394.833,"endTime":10397.933,"body":"with ASPS that surgical interventions in"},{"startTime":10397.933,"endTime":10398.466,"body":"minors should be"},{"startTime":10398.466,"endTime":10400.233,"body":"generally deferred to adulthood."},{"startTime":10401.0,"endTime":10402.833,"body":"The AMA supports, quote, \"evidence-based"},{"startTime":10402.833,"endTime":10404.966,"body":"treatment,\" and, quote, \"including other"},{"startTime":10404.966,"endTime":10406.5,"body":"types of gender-affirming care for"},{"startTime":10406.5,"endTime":10408.033,"body":"minors,\" the organization added."},{"startTime":10408.666,"endTime":10410.766,"body":"And that screenshot is part of a tweet"},{"startTime":10410.766,"endTime":10414.933,"body":"that I believe it was Lior Sapir had in"},{"startTime":10414.933,"endTime":10416.666,"body":"which he says, \"The American Medical"},{"startTime":10416.666,"endTime":10417.866,"body":"Association agrees with"},{"startTime":10417.866,"endTime":10419.133,"body":"the ASPS about surgeries."},{"startTime":10420.066,"endTime":10421.766,"body":"If the AMA was wrong about surgeries,"},{"startTime":10421.766,"endTime":10422.466,"body":"could it also have been"},{"startTime":10422.466,"endTime":10423.233,"body":"wrong about hormones?\""},{"startTime":10424.866,"endTime":10425.433,"body":"Good question."},{"startTime":10425.799,"endTime":10426.633,"body":"Of course they are."},{"startTime":10426.666,"endTime":10430.933,"body":"And as Lior Sapir knows very well, he's"},{"startTime":10430.933,"endTime":10435.633,"body":"on the side of reality and moral"},{"startTime":10435.633,"endTime":10438.033,"body":"rightness in this fight"},{"startTime":10438.033,"endTime":10439.033,"body":"has been from the beginning."},{"startTime":10441.133,"endTime":10442.533,"body":"So it's happening."},{"startTime":10443.433,"endTime":10444.399,"body":"It has felt like it was"},{"startTime":10444.399,"endTime":10445.866,"body":"happening for a long time."},{"startTime":10445.866,"endTime":10447.7,"body":"And I have been suspicious that there"},{"startTime":10447.7,"endTime":10450.166,"body":"would be clawing back and"},{"startTime":10450.166,"endTime":10452.066,"body":"it's not over by any means."},{"startTime":10452.466,"endTime":10453.666,"body":"I guess, I mean, the other big piece of"},{"startTime":10453.666,"endTime":10455.866,"body":"news, which I actually didn't have a"},{"startTime":10455.866,"endTime":10458.666,"body":"screenshot of or a direct reference to,"},{"startTime":10458.933,"endTime":10462.7,"body":"is that the first lawsuit providing"},{"startTime":10462.7,"endTime":10467.833,"body":"basically, I can't think of any legal"},{"startTime":10467.833,"endTime":10470.1,"body":"terms at the moment, restitution, that's"},{"startTime":10470.1,"endTime":10473.966,"body":"not the right word, to someone who got"},{"startTime":10473.966,"endTime":10476.766,"body":"transitioned because their parents were"},{"startTime":10476.766,"endTime":10479.066,"body":"told that if they didn't, they would"},{"startTime":10479.066,"endTime":10480.933,"body":"commit suicide, has received,"},{"startTime":10480.933,"endTime":10482.6,"body":"I think, $2 million in damages."},{"startTime":10483.066,"endTime":10483.266,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":10483.766,"endTime":10488.0,"body":"So all of this is happening a couple of"},{"startTime":10488.0,"endTime":10489.566,"body":"years after we have the"},{"startTime":10489.566,"endTime":10490.966,"body":"Cass report out of England,"},{"startTime":10492.333,"endTime":10496.766,"body":"after so many people have been working so"},{"startTime":10496.766,"endTime":10498.966,"body":"hard at revealing the truth for so long,"},{"startTime":10499.6,"endTime":10501.666,"body":"but frankly, the ASPS, the American"},{"startTime":10501.666,"endTime":10503.0,"body":"Society of Plastic Surgeons,"},{"startTime":10504.133,"endTime":10505.833,"body":"actually coming out with a position"},{"startTime":10505.833,"endTime":10507.5,"body":"statement, weak as it"},{"startTime":10507.5,"endTime":10510.233,"body":"is, is hugely important."},{"startTime":10510.233,"endTime":10512.633,"body":"And among other things, the ACLU, among"},{"startTime":10512.633,"endTime":10515.366,"body":"other once important and now deeply"},{"startTime":10515.366,"endTime":10517.399,"body":"corrupt organizations, cannot continue to"},{"startTime":10517.399,"endTime":10519.133,"body":"claim that all of the medical"},{"startTime":10519.133,"endTime":10521.666,"body":"organizations support gender-affirming"},{"startTime":10521.666,"endTime":10525.266,"body":"care, which, by the way, many of us have"},{"startTime":10525.266,"endTime":10526.433,"body":"been objecting to that term,"},{"startTime":10526.433,"endTime":10527.833,"body":"gender-affirming care forever."},{"startTime":10528.366,"endTime":10529.1,"body":"This was, again,"},{"startTime":10530.566,"endTime":10531.0,"body":"mental instability,"},{"startTime":10531.0,"endTime":10532.299,"body":"affirming care at best."},{"startTime":10532.5,"endTime":10532.7,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":10533.0,"endTime":10535.166,"body":"And I will point out, as we've talked"},{"startTime":10535.166,"endTime":10539.299,"body":"about before, it is actually not just"},{"startTime":10539.299,"endTime":10541.7,"body":"offensive and absurd, but it is"},{"startTime":10541.7,"endTime":10544.833,"body":"linguistically insane."},{"startTime":10546.133,"endTime":10548.133,"body":"It's as gender-denying"},{"startTime":10548.133,"endTime":10549.366,"body":"as it is gender-affirming."},{"startTime":10549.766,"endTime":10550.166,"body":"Of course."},{"startTime":10550.333,"endTime":10550.566,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":10550.566,"endTime":10551.566,"body":"You're affirming one gender"},{"startTime":10551.566,"endTime":10555.633,"body":"and denying biology while--"},{"startTime":10555.899,"endTime":10558.066,"body":"Denying who you are, abandoning your own"},{"startTime":10558.066,"endTime":10559.7,"body":"identity in the name"},{"startTime":10559.7,"endTime":10562.1,"body":"of creating identity."},{"startTime":10562.333,"endTime":10562.533,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":10563.1,"endTime":10564.066,"body":"So anyway, it was"},{"startTime":10564.066,"endTime":10565.666,"body":"obscene, and I agree with you."},{"startTime":10565.7,"endTime":10568.933,"body":"Like, I cannot stand the fact that we're"},{"startTime":10568.933,"endTime":10570.666,"body":"going to be mealy-mouthed"},{"startTime":10570.666,"endTime":10572.766,"body":"about reversing our position now."},{"startTime":10572.766,"endTime":10574.266,"body":"Well, here's why we only got to it now."},{"startTime":10574.266,"endTime":10575.233,"body":"In 2024, the evidence"},{"startTime":10575.233,"endTime":10576.466,"body":"wasn't all in, so we never--"},{"startTime":10576.733,"endTime":10577.633,"body":"We're all really busy."},{"startTime":10577.833,"endTime":10579.433,"body":"We have lots of stuff on our desk, so"},{"startTime":10579.433,"endTime":10581.2,"body":"we've been maiming children, you know,"},{"startTime":10581.533,"endTime":10582.566,"body":"because this just hadn't"},{"startTime":10582.566,"endTime":10583.633,"body":"gotten to the top of the pile."},{"startTime":10583.633,"endTime":10584.066,"body":"It's just what we were"},{"startTime":10584.066,"endTime":10585.299,"body":"doing and what could you do?"},{"startTime":10586.333,"endTime":10587.833,"body":"But I want to point"},{"startTime":10587.833,"endTime":10588.5,"body":"out a couple of things."},{"startTime":10588.766,"endTime":10589.133,"body":"One,"},{"startTime":10590.833,"endTime":10591.766,"body":"once again,"},{"startTime":10592.933,"endTime":10597.266,"body":"the institutions are brought to reality"},{"startTime":10597.266,"endTime":10599.033,"body":"kicking and screaming."},{"startTime":10599.733,"endTime":10602.733,"body":"They can no longer sustain their stupid"},{"startTime":10602.733,"endTime":10606.533,"body":"fiction, and so the public and its"},{"startTime":10606.533,"endTime":10608.633,"body":"understanding is dragging the"},{"startTime":10608.633,"endTime":10610.399,"body":"institutions so that they will finally"},{"startTime":10610.399,"endTime":10613.366,"body":"acknowledge this is the exact inverse of"},{"startTime":10613.366,"endTime":10614.299,"body":"what experts and"},{"startTime":10614.299,"endTime":10615.666,"body":"authorities are supposed to be."},{"startTime":10615.833,"endTime":10617.966,"body":"It's not supposed to be that we wake up"},{"startTime":10617.966,"endTime":10618.866,"body":"and force the New York"},{"startTime":10618.866,"endTime":10619.899,"body":"Times to report shit."},{"startTime":10620.266,"endTime":10621.666,"body":"It's supposed to be that they actually"},{"startTime":10621.666,"endTime":10622.733,"body":"have a bunch of people who are trying to"},{"startTime":10622.733,"endTime":10624.299,"body":"figure out what's going on and send them"},{"startTime":10624.299,"endTime":10625.166,"body":"into the field and look."},{"startTime":10625.466,"endTime":10627.366,"body":"We're not supposed to be dragging the,"},{"startTime":10627.366,"endTime":10630.066,"body":"you know, medical societies to the"},{"startTime":10630.066,"endTime":10631.6,"body":"recognition of biology."},{"startTime":10632.0,"endTime":10634.333,"body":"They're supposed to take that on board as"},{"startTime":10634.333,"endTime":10635.133,"body":"part of their mission."},{"startTime":10635.433,"endTime":10637.766,"body":"So the fact that this is trailing is one"},{"startTime":10637.766,"endTime":10638.966,"body":"thing worth noticing."},{"startTime":10639.2,"endTime":10641.733,"body":"Once again, the public has woken up to"},{"startTime":10641.733,"endTime":10643.866,"body":"the obvious well ahead of the"},{"startTime":10643.866,"endTime":10645.633,"body":"institutions, and the institutions are"},{"startTime":10645.633,"endTime":10647.733,"body":"only coming around once they can no"},{"startTime":10647.733,"endTime":10649.1,"body":"longer sustain their lives."},{"startTime":10650.266,"endTime":10653.733,"body":"Second thing is, okay, this is the second"},{"startTime":10653.733,"endTime":10655.566,"body":"time that we were seeing"},{"startTime":10655.566,"endTime":10657.533,"body":"this inside of a couple months."},{"startTime":10658.666,"endTime":10658.866,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":10659.266,"endTime":10659.466,"body":"Climate."},{"startTime":10660.333,"endTime":10662.266,"body":"We started turning around on climate"},{"startTime":10662.266,"endTime":10664.366,"body":"because, you know what, the race is on."},{"startTime":10664.833,"endTime":10667.533,"body":"We're going to need energy for AI now,"},{"startTime":10667.833,"endTime":10669.333,"body":"you know, so let's figure out every kind"},{"startTime":10669.333,"endTime":10670.566,"body":"of energy we could have."},{"startTime":10670.566,"endTime":10671.899,"body":"You know, oil is good."},{"startTime":10671.899,"endTime":10673.166,"body":"There's a lot of energy in there."},{"startTime":10673.166,"endTime":10674.7,"body":"And hey, nuclear, that's pretty fancy."},{"startTime":10675.233,"endTime":10677.299,"body":"So the point is, well, we can't very well"},{"startTime":10677.299,"endTime":10680.133,"body":"go sustaining our mythology that allowed"},{"startTime":10680.133,"endTime":10682.866,"body":"us to intimidate you and control you and"},{"startTime":10682.866,"endTime":10684.933,"body":"get you to fight each other because"},{"startTime":10684.933,"endTime":10687.066,"body":"actually we now have a new agenda that is"},{"startTime":10687.066,"endTime":10688.533,"body":"incompatible with the story we've been"},{"startTime":10688.533,"endTime":10690.033,"body":"giving you for decades."},{"startTime":10690.833,"endTime":10691.1,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":10691.5,"endTime":10692.933,"body":"So there's that too."},{"startTime":10693.366,"endTime":10697.233,"body":"And then the third thing is, okay, here"},{"startTime":10697.233,"endTime":10698.866,"body":"we're seeing zero as a special number."},{"startTime":10699.6,"endTime":10699.799,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":10700.399,"endTime":10701.2,"body":"The fact that the"},{"startTime":10701.2,"endTime":10702.333,"body":"dominoes will start to fall."},{"startTime":10702.333,"endTime":10703.766,"body":"The dominoes are starting to fall because"},{"startTime":10703.766,"endTime":10705.533,"body":"the last thing you want to do is be the"},{"startTime":10705.533,"endTime":10707.233,"body":"last person on board with the new"},{"startTime":10707.233,"endTime":10708.666,"body":"reality, which is, oh,"},{"startTime":10708.933,"endTime":10709.799,"body":"we were maiming children."},{"startTime":10710.933,"endTime":10712.633,"body":"We stopped."},{"startTime":10713.066,"endTime":10713.833,"body":"Hey, we were early."},{"startTime":10714.2,"endTime":10714.399,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":10714.666,"endTime":10715.1,"body":"That's the thing."},{"startTime":10715.1,"endTime":10715.633,"body":"We were early."},{"startTime":10715.866,"endTime":10716.466,"body":"You know, we were ahead"},{"startTime":10716.466,"endTime":10718.1,"body":"of the, you know, American."},{"startTime":10718.1,"endTime":10719.366,"body":"I mean, we did do it for years."},{"startTime":10719.633,"endTime":10719.966,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":10720.2,"endTime":10721.7,"body":"And we did know exactly what we were"},{"startTime":10721.7,"endTime":10724.433,"body":"doing because how could you not?"},{"startTime":10725.566,"endTime":10726.133,"body":"But we stopped."},{"startTime":10726.966,"endTime":10728.233,"body":"Can't you congratulate us for stopping?"},{"startTime":10728.533,"endTime":10728.733,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":10728.966,"endTime":10731.433,"body":"Which also reminds me of COVID."},{"startTime":10732.299,"endTime":10732.5,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":10732.833,"endTime":10734.399,"body":"They were literally"},{"startTime":10734.399,"endTime":10735.5,"body":"middle ground scramble."},{"startTime":10735.899,"endTime":10737.2,"body":"This is a middle ground scramble."},{"startTime":10737.399,"endTime":10738.899,"body":"And they're trying to formulate the"},{"startTime":10738.899,"endTime":10741.533,"body":"position in which will now we understand"},{"startTime":10741.533,"endTime":10743.633,"body":"that the data isn't quite as persuasive"},{"startTime":10743.633,"endTime":10745.866,"body":"as we once thought it was about the blah,"},{"startTime":10745.866,"endTime":10746.666,"body":"blah, blah, blah, blah."},{"startTime":10746.933,"endTime":10748.733,"body":"And the answer is no, you motherfuckers,"},{"startTime":10748.733,"endTime":10751.399,"body":"you were maiming children for money and"},{"startTime":10751.399,"endTime":10753.466,"body":"you had a cover story and it was false."},{"startTime":10753.466,"endTime":10754.866,"body":"And we've been telling you that and"},{"startTime":10754.866,"endTime":10756.066,"body":"you've been ignoring it and you're still"},{"startTime":10756.066,"endTime":10757.166,"body":"not owning up to what you did."},{"startTime":10757.7,"endTime":10759.7,"body":"And frankly, your cover story, was lots"},{"startTime":10759.7,"endTime":10761.633,"body":"of cover stories and some of them, maybe"},{"startTime":10761.633,"endTime":10763.266,"body":"all of them were completely despicable."},{"startTime":10766.166,"endTime":10768.266,"body":"Threatening parents with the idea that"},{"startTime":10768.266,"endTime":10769.166,"body":"their child would commit"},{"startTime":10769.166,"endTime":10771.133,"body":"suicide unless you maimed them?"},{"startTime":10772.933,"endTime":10774.7,"body":"I don't know what's more"},{"startTime":10774.7,"endTime":10776.6,"body":"disgusting to do to a parent."},{"startTime":10777.566,"endTime":10780.066,"body":"Oh, I have a choice between, you know,"},{"startTime":10780.066,"endTime":10781.633,"body":"this is what people would say."},{"startTime":10781.633,"endTime":10783.066,"body":"I could either have, you know,"},{"startTime":10783.066,"endTime":10785.033,"body":"a dead son or a live daughter."},{"startTime":10785.033,"endTime":10785.299,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":10785.566,"endTime":10786.633,"body":"Or, you know, usually"},{"startTime":10786.633,"endTime":10787.433,"body":"the other way around."},{"startTime":10788.299,"endTime":10789.766,"body":"But, you know, bullshit,"},{"startTime":10789.766,"endTime":10790.666,"body":"it was always bullshit."},{"startTime":10791.266,"endTime":10793.799,"body":"And the fact that people would, young"},{"startTime":10793.799,"endTime":10795.633,"body":"people who were confused about their own"},{"startTime":10795.633,"endTime":10796.799,"body":"identity, who are going through the"},{"startTime":10796.799,"endTime":10798.666,"body":"throes of adolescence as everyone does,"},{"startTime":10799.233,"endTime":10801.733,"body":"in a world where they had been told that"},{"startTime":10801.733,"endTime":10803.166,"body":"they could and probably they should, they"},{"startTime":10803.166,"endTime":10804.433,"body":"would certainly get a lot more social"},{"startTime":10804.433,"endTime":10806.766,"body":"cachet if they did so, decide that they"},{"startTime":10806.766,"endTime":10807.666,"body":"were the opposite sex."},{"startTime":10808.266,"endTime":10810.0,"body":"They knew that the magic words to say to"},{"startTime":10810.0,"endTime":10811.166,"body":"their parents in order to get their"},{"startTime":10811.166,"endTime":10813.066,"body":"gender affirming care, which is to say"},{"startTime":10813.066,"endTime":10814.866,"body":"their mental instability affirming care."},{"startTime":10814.866,"endTime":10817.333,"body":"It's actually what it was, was, \"Mom,"},{"startTime":10817.333,"endTime":10818.299,"body":"Dad, I'm going to kill myself if you"},{"startTime":10818.299,"endTime":10819.033,"body":"don't let me do this.\""},{"startTime":10819.766,"endTime":10824.633,"body":"So this was a disgusting tactic that was"},{"startTime":10824.633,"endTime":10827.633,"body":"created by who knows whom, and then"},{"startTime":10827.633,"endTime":10829.666,"body":"spread like wildfire across a population"},{"startTime":10829.666,"endTime":10833.0,"body":"that was then duly maimed by plastic"},{"startTime":10833.0,"endTime":10835.033,"body":"surgeons, the professional organization"},{"startTime":10835.033,"endTime":10836.966,"body":"of which is finally saying, \"Yeah,"},{"startTime":10836.966,"endTime":10838.0,"body":"actually maybe wait at"},{"startTime":10838.0,"endTime":10838.866,"body":"least until you're 19.\""},{"startTime":10839.633,"endTime":10842.966,"body":"Because then at least they get to sign"},{"startTime":10842.966,"endTime":10843.833,"body":"their own paperwork,"},{"startTime":10844.833,"endTime":10845.1,"body":"right?"},{"startTime":10845.333,"endTime":10846.766,"body":"Like there's obviously nothing magical"},{"startTime":10846.766,"endTime":10848.833,"body":"that happens on your 19th birthday."},{"startTime":10849.299,"endTime":10851.866,"body":"No, that's probably actually it, is the"},{"startTime":10851.866,"endTime":10854.433,"body":"idea is if you're a kid and somebody"},{"startTime":10854.433,"endTime":10858.933,"body":"coerces your parent into consenting to"},{"startTime":10858.933,"endTime":10861.866,"body":"maiming you, one can imagine the lawsuit"},{"startTime":10861.866,"endTime":10863.433,"body":"in which you say, \"Hey, I had a right not"},{"startTime":10863.433,"endTime":10865.166,"body":"to be maimed and you lied to my parent.\""},{"startTime":10865.466,"endTime":10868.733,"body":"Whereas if you sign a bunch of stuff that"},{"startTime":10868.733,"endTime":10870.333,"body":"says they're in the fine print, if you"},{"startTime":10870.333,"endTime":10873.233,"body":"know just how to squint at it, well then"},{"startTime":10873.233,"endTime":10873.933,"body":"the answer is, \"Well,"},{"startTime":10874.333,"endTime":10875.366,"body":"we did tell you that.\""},{"startTime":10875.366,"endTime":10875.566,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":10876.066,"endTime":10878.533,"body":"Even if you got your first cross-sex"},{"startTime":10878.533,"endTime":10880.733,"body":"hormone prescription after a half an hour"},{"startTime":10880.733,"endTime":10882.233,"body":"conversation with a person you'd never"},{"startTime":10882.233,"endTime":10884.166,"body":"met before, which we know happens over"},{"startTime":10884.166,"endTime":10885.066,"body":"and over and over again."},{"startTime":10885.833,"endTime":10888.366,"body":"And in some cases, we're then directed to"},{"startTime":10888.366,"endTime":10891.566,"body":"the pipeline for surgery, for cross-sex"},{"startTime":10891.566,"endTime":10893.166,"body":"surgery, which isn't a thing, but"},{"startTime":10893.666,"endTime":10895.0,"body":"gender-destroying"},{"startTime":10895.0,"endTime":10898.033,"body":"surgery right away as well."},{"startTime":10898.833,"endTime":10900.766,"body":"Well, if you're legally an adult, then"},{"startTime":10900.766,"endTime":10903.233,"body":"it's a kind of liability protection,"},{"startTime":10904.333,"endTime":10904.533,"body":"actually."},{"startTime":10904.899,"endTime":10906.033,"body":"Yeah, I think it is."},{"startTime":10907.333,"endTime":10909.733,"body":"Yeah, there's a lot"},{"startTime":10911.766,"endTime":10914.133,"body":"to say here, but the fact is they knew"},{"startTime":10914.133,"endTime":10916.799,"body":"they're not telling us a true story and"},{"startTime":10916.799,"endTime":10920.5,"body":"it is a ghastly crime against humanity."},{"startTime":10921.033,"endTime":10923.566,"body":"And I wanted to add one thing, which is I"},{"startTime":10923.566,"endTime":10926.133,"body":"just want people to take a moment to put"},{"startTime":10926.133,"endTime":10929.866,"body":"themselves in the shoes of a normal"},{"startTime":10929.866,"endTime":10932.533,"body":"parent who loves their child, finds that"},{"startTime":10932.533,"endTime":10934.899,"body":"their child is troubled, which is very"},{"startTime":10934.899,"endTime":10936.466,"body":"easy to be in a world that makes as"},{"startTime":10936.466,"endTime":10937.366,"body":"little sense as this."},{"startTime":10938.033,"endTime":10939.966,"body":"And your child is convinced that they"},{"startTime":10939.966,"endTime":10941.933,"body":"might be trans and the doctor is telling"},{"startTime":10941.933,"endTime":10943.7,"body":"you, \"Well, wouldn't you rather have a"},{"startTime":10943.7,"endTime":10945.066,"body":"live daughter than a dead son?\""},{"startTime":10946.933,"endTime":10948.299,"body":"Think about what that does to you."},{"startTime":10948.299,"endTime":10950.033,"body":"If you're afraid, if you've got a"},{"startTime":10950.033,"endTime":10951.399,"body":"troubled child, you have to"},{"startTime":10951.399,"endTime":10953.433,"body":"be afraid of suicide, right?"},{"startTime":10953.433,"endTime":10954.433,"body":"It happens a lot."},{"startTime":10955.466,"endTime":10955.566,"body":"So"},{"startTime":10956.566,"endTime":10958.2,"body":"you're thinking, \"Oh, a doctor has just"},{"startTime":10958.2,"endTime":10959.933,"body":"told me that suicide is"},{"startTime":10959.933,"endTime":10963.166,"body":"likely if I don't consent to this."},{"startTime":10964.233,"endTime":10965.533,"body":"I will literally not be"},{"startTime":10965.533,"endTime":10967.1,"body":"able to live with myself."},{"startTime":10967.1,"endTime":10969.366,"body":"If I say no, even if I think that's the"},{"startTime":10969.366,"endTime":10970.233,"body":"right thing to do for my"},{"startTime":10970.233,"endTime":10971.433,"body":"child, that's my instinct."},{"startTime":10971.733,"endTime":10972.466,"body":"I'm not an expert."},{"startTime":10973.433,"endTime":10976.266,"body":"And what if I say no, and then the worst"},{"startTime":10976.266,"endTime":10977.433,"body":"happens, which it might.\""},{"startTime":10978.233,"endTime":10979.133,"body":"How will I live with myself?"},{"startTime":10979.133,"endTime":10980.1,"body":"How will I live with myself?"},{"startTime":10980.466,"endTime":10984.133,"body":"So the answer is you default into"},{"startTime":10984.133,"endTime":10986.033,"body":"whatever intervention you say, at least"},{"startTime":10986.033,"endTime":10987.6,"body":"I've done what I can."},{"startTime":10988.2,"endTime":10989.633,"body":"And the point is actually what you did is"},{"startTime":10989.633,"endTime":10991.2,"body":"consent to have a doctor name your child."},{"startTime":10992.0,"endTime":10994.2,"body":"And it is your job not to do that, but it"},{"startTime":10994.2,"endTime":10996.833,"body":"is also understandable how experts who"},{"startTime":10996.833,"endTime":10998.7,"body":"represent themselves as knowing something"},{"startTime":10998.7,"endTime":11000.833,"body":"about your child's mind and what might"},{"startTime":11000.833,"endTime":11004.933,"body":"help it can trick people into doing this."},{"startTime":11005.333,"endTime":11005.533,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":11005.566,"endTime":11005.933,"body":"I mean, they're"},{"startTime":11005.933,"endTime":11007.466,"body":"destroying people and families."},{"startTime":11007.7,"endTime":11010.033,"body":"And anyway, I think it makes sense to"},{"startTime":11010.033,"endTime":11012.166,"body":"spend a minute in those parent's shoes"},{"startTime":11012.166,"endTime":11013.066,"body":"because it is not a"},{"startTime":11013.066,"endTime":11013.966,"body":"comfortable place to be."},{"startTime":11014.333,"endTime":11015.966,"body":"No, no, not at all."},{"startTime":11017.333,"endTime":11017.566,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":11019.133,"endTime":11019.466,"body":"Full stop."},{"startTime":11019.866,"endTime":11020.266,"body":"I have one."},{"startTime":11020.766,"endTime":11021.466,"body":"Do you have more?"},{"startTime":11022.066,"endTime":11023.299,"body":"There's one last little thing I want to"},{"startTime":11023.299,"endTime":11024.233,"body":"say before we sign off."},{"startTime":11024.433,"endTime":11024.7,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":11024.7,"endTime":11025.733,"body":"Let's do your thing."},{"startTime":11025.933,"endTime":11027.1,"body":"And then I have a little correction."},{"startTime":11028.1,"endTime":11028.533,"body":"Are you sure you don't"},{"startTime":11028.533,"endTime":11029.833,"body":"want to do that first?"},{"startTime":11030.066,"endTime":11031.066,"body":"So what we just talked about?"},{"startTime":11031.666,"endTime":11031.866,"body":"No."},{"startTime":11032.7,"endTime":11032.899,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":11033.366,"endTime":11033.566,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":11035.266,"endTime":11038.033,"body":"So last week I introduced a new project"},{"startTime":11038.033,"endTime":11039.166,"body":"on natural selections, my"},{"startTime":11039.166,"endTime":11040.433,"body":"Substack COVID era stories."},{"startTime":11040.433,"endTime":11041.899,"body":"You can show my screen here if you like."},{"startTime":11042.866,"endTime":11044.566,"body":"And just read the"},{"startTime":11044.566,"endTime":11047.233,"body":"invitation to contribute stories."},{"startTime":11047.566,"endTime":11048.866,"body":"The responses, but remarkable."},{"startTime":11049.566,"endTime":11050.0,"body":"Thank you."},{"startTime":11050.666,"endTime":11053.133,"body":"We have received many, many, many so far."},{"startTime":11053.666,"endTime":11055.899,"body":"And yesterday I published the first one,"},{"startTime":11055.899,"endTime":11059.0,"body":"The Symptoms I Carry by Heidi Brandes."},{"startTime":11059.0,"endTime":11059.966,"body":"It's extraordinary."},{"startTime":11060.533,"endTime":11061.633,"body":"I recommend it."},{"startTime":11061.633,"endTime":11063.166,"body":"We'll put a link to the"},{"startTime":11063.166,"endTime":11066.466,"body":"page in the show notes."},{"startTime":11067.133,"endTime":11072.666,"body":"And I continue to encourage stories both"},{"startTime":11072.666,"endTime":11075.333,"body":"because you might want to see them"},{"startTime":11075.333,"endTime":11076.866,"body":"published and we aren't going to publish"},{"startTime":11076.866,"endTime":11079.066,"body":"everything that we receive, but we will"},{"startTime":11079.133,"endTime":11080.166,"body":"publish many of them."},{"startTime":11080.166,"endTime":11081.733,"body":"I will publish many of them, but also"},{"startTime":11081.733,"endTime":11084.066,"body":"because the act of writing about things"},{"startTime":11084.066,"endTime":11085.966,"body":"that you experienced is often"},{"startTime":11085.966,"endTime":11086.799,"body":"legitimately"},{"startTime":11086.799,"endTime":11088.533,"body":"therapeutic in its own right."},{"startTime":11090.166,"endTime":11090.366,"body":"Excellent."},{"startTime":11090.733,"endTime":11091.0,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":11091.0,"endTime":11091.733,"body":"I haven't read it yet."},{"startTime":11091.966,"endTime":11093.066,"body":"I'm excited about this project."},{"startTime":11093.266,"endTime":11093.666,"body":"It's fantastic."},{"startTime":11094.266,"endTime":11095.766,"body":"I will say that this first"},{"startTime":11095.766,"endTime":11100.733,"body":"story that we ran doesn't involve"},{"startTime":11103.666,"endTime":11105.666,"body":"death or injury from COVID or the"},{"startTime":11105.666,"endTime":11109.566,"body":"vaccine, but it describes deep"},{"startTime":11109.566,"endTime":11111.666,"body":"destruction of relationship, which is"},{"startTime":11111.666,"endTime":11113.2,"body":"something that so many of us experienced."},{"startTime":11115.133,"endTime":11115.366,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":11116.166,"endTime":11117.866,"body":"My little correction."},{"startTime":11118.733,"endTime":11121.966,"body":"In our recent discussion of the credit"},{"startTime":11121.966,"endTime":11123.633,"body":"shooting in Minneapolis,"},{"startTime":11124.7,"endTime":11127.933,"body":"we talked about the issue of the"},{"startTime":11127.933,"endTime":11129.133,"body":"accidental discharges"},{"startTime":11129.133,"endTime":11132.666,"body":"of the P320 install."},{"startTime":11133.1,"endTime":11134.733,"body":"And I got something wrong, which many"},{"startTime":11134.733,"endTime":11137.233,"body":"people pointed out, which is I said it"},{"startTime":11137.233,"endTime":11138.066,"body":"has a light trigger."},{"startTime":11138.566,"endTime":11139.866,"body":"That's not correct."},{"startTime":11140.366,"endTime":11142.133,"body":"What appears to be the case is the"},{"startTime":11142.133,"endTime":11144.466,"body":"failure to be drop safe was the result of"},{"startTime":11144.466,"endTime":11146.133,"body":"the fact, not that the trigger spring was"},{"startTime":11146.133,"endTime":11147.966,"body":"light, but that the trigger itself was"},{"startTime":11147.966,"endTime":11149.833,"body":"too heavy and carried momentum."},{"startTime":11149.833,"endTime":11153.233,"body":"That is not relevant to the accidental"},{"startTime":11153.233,"endTime":11155.133,"body":"discharge that may have happened before"},{"startTime":11155.133,"endTime":11157.899,"body":"the shooting of Predy."},{"startTime":11158.333,"endTime":11160.533,"body":"However, there is still plenty of"},{"startTime":11160.533,"endTime":11162.033,"body":"evidence, which you can find yourself"},{"startTime":11162.033,"endTime":11164.799,"body":"online, of accidental discharges that are"},{"startTime":11164.799,"endTime":11165.966,"body":"not based on a drop."},{"startTime":11166.433,"endTime":11171.466,"body":"There's one video I saw yesterday of six"},{"startTime":11171.466,"endTime":11174.766,"body":"police officers attempting to arrest a"},{"startTime":11174.766,"endTime":11176.566,"body":"young man who is resisting."},{"startTime":11176.933,"endTime":11181.366,"body":"They are trying to get him handcuffed."},{"startTime":11182.033,"endTime":11183.7,"body":"One of their guns goes off in its"},{"startTime":11183.7,"endTime":11184.766,"body":"holster, not having been"},{"startTime":11184.766,"endTime":11186.333,"body":"removed, nobody touching it."},{"startTime":11187.233,"endTime":11188.899,"body":"So anyway, the problem of accidental"},{"startTime":11188.899,"endTime":11191.066,"body":"discharge is still potentially relevant"},{"startTime":11191.066,"endTime":11192.133,"body":"to the predatory shooting."},{"startTime":11192.133,"endTime":11193.333,"body":"It is not the light trigger"},{"startTime":11193.333,"endTime":11194.633,"body":"that would have caused it."},{"startTime":11195.533,"endTime":11196.633,"body":"Enough people pointed it out"},{"startTime":11196.633,"endTime":11197.833,"body":"that I just wanted to make sure"},{"startTime":11199.266,"endTime":11201.6,"body":"that if you were misled by my"},{"startTime":11201.6,"endTime":11204.633,"body":"presentation, now you know what I know."},{"startTime":11205.366,"endTime":11205.566,"body":"Awesome."},{"startTime":11205.966,"endTime":11207.366,"body":"What I now know is what I mean."},{"startTime":11207.633,"endTime":11208.433,"body":"What you now know."},{"startTime":11208.433,"endTime":11208.633,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":11210.533,"endTime":11210.933,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":11211.233,"endTime":11213.766,"body":"We will be back here same time next week."},{"startTime":11214.566,"endTime":11218.433,"body":"Check out our sponsors, which were Crowd"},{"startTime":11218.433,"endTime":11221.733,"body":"Health, Time Law, no, no, no."},{"startTime":11221.933,"endTime":11222.566,"body":"What were they?"},{"startTime":11222.566,"endTime":11223.299,"body":"We had some confusion."},{"startTime":11223.666,"endTime":11225.633,"body":"Xlear, ARMRA, and CrowdHealth."},{"startTime":11226.033,"endTime":11226.233,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":11227.433,"endTime":11230.133,"body":"And we appreciate you, our audience,"},{"startTime":11230.133,"endTime":11231.366,"body":"very, very much appreciate you"},{"startTime":11231.366,"endTime":11233.733,"body":"subscribing, liking, sharing things that"},{"startTime":11233.733,"endTime":11236.033,"body":"you find here, full episodes, clips that"},{"startTime":11236.033,"endTime":11236.933,"body":"our amazing producer Jen"},{"startTime":11236.933,"endTime":11238.666,"body":"is putting out all the time."},{"startTime":11239.266,"endTime":11242.7,"body":"And until you see us next time, be good"},{"startTime":11242.7,"endTime":11244.133,"body":"to the ones you love, eat"},{"startTime":11244.133,"endTime":11245.799,"body":"good food, and get outside."},{"startTime":11246.133,"endTime":11246.733,"body":"Be well, everyone."}]}