{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"startTime":4.866,"endTime":9.099,"body":"Hey folks, welcome to the 313th, I think"},{"startTime":9.099,"endTime":11.199,"body":"DarkHorse Podcast"},{"startTime":11.199,"endTime":13.099,"body":"live stream with me, Dr."},{"startTime":13.099,"endTime":14.599,"body":"Bret Weinstein, you, Dr."},{"startTime":14.833,"endTime":15.233,"body":"Heather Heying."},{"startTime":16.066,"endTime":17.633,"body":"Um, before you show anything about"},{"startTime":17.633,"endTime":19.399,"body":"content, yeah, three 13,"},{"startTime":20.333,"endTime":21.533,"body":"three 13 it's gotta be prime."},{"startTime":21.533,"endTime":22.766,"body":"It's, it's so prime."},{"startTime":23.533,"endTime":25.366,"body":"It is the second of the twin"},{"startTime":25.366,"endTime":26.933,"body":"primes, three 11, three 13."},{"startTime":26.933,"endTime":28.633,"body":"We talked about three 11 two episodes"},{"startTime":28.633,"endTime":29.5,"body":"ago, as you'd expect."},{"startTime":30.333,"endTime":32.299,"body":"Uh, again, this is from one of our, our"},{"startTime":32.299,"endTime":34.733,"body":"Locals, uh, members who pointed out to me"},{"startTime":34.733,"endTime":36.933,"body":"that three 13 is a three"},{"startTime":36.933,"endTime":38.1,"body":"11 was a permutable prime."},{"startTime":38.333,"endTime":40.133,"body":"Remember that move any of the digits"},{"startTime":40.133,"endTime":42.266,"body":"around in any order you want."},{"startTime":42.266,"endTime":44.266,"body":"And all resulting numbers, one 31, one"},{"startTime":44.266,"endTime":47.233,"body":"13, et cetera, our prime three 13 is not."},{"startTime":47.866,"endTime":50.333,"body":"Permeable, but it's palindromic."},{"startTime":51.2,"endTime":51.399,"body":"True."},{"startTime":51.733,"endTime":54.433,"body":"Not just in decimal, but also in binary."},{"startTime":54.733,"endTime":55.466,"body":"All right, folks."},{"startTime":55.533,"endTime":58.033,"body":"So the lesson for you is welcome the"},{"startTime":58.033,"endTime":59.433,"body":"prime time and this prime"},{"startTime":59.533,"endTime":61.166,"body":"episode of the DarkHorse podcast."},{"startTime":61.466,"endTime":62.766,"body":"One zero zero one,"},{"startTime":62.766,"endTime":63.766,"body":"one, one zero zero one."},{"startTime":64.9,"endTime":66.633,"body":"That's three 13 in binary."},{"startTime":67.0,"endTime":67.5,"body":"Of course."},{"startTime":67.5,"endTime":68.566,"body":"It is a palindrome."},{"startTime":68.566,"endTime":69.066,"body":"I had to look."},{"startTime":69.366,"endTime":69.633,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":69.633,"endTime":71.633,"body":"Um, but I mean, I just think also."},{"startTime":72.299,"endTime":72.533,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":72.533,"endTime":72.966,"body":"That's amazing."},{"startTime":73.299,"endTime":73.733,"body":"So that's see, you"},{"startTime":73.733,"endTime":74.433,"body":"weren't even listening."},{"startTime":74.433,"endTime":76.233,"body":"No, I was like moving straight ahead."},{"startTime":76.333,"endTime":77.599,"body":"No, it's not like that."},{"startTime":77.833,"endTime":79.9,"body":"Like that in both decimal and it"},{"startTime":79.9,"endTime":83.066,"body":"takes time to catch up the cycles, the"},{"startTime":83.066,"endTime":85.566,"body":"bandwidth being divided across things."},{"startTime":86.433,"endTime":90.533,"body":"In any case, um, we are in this episode"},{"startTime":90.533,"endTime":94.833,"body":"going to of course talk about, uh, the"},{"startTime":95.533,"endTime":98.299,"body":"developing story around the"},{"startTime":98.299,"endTime":100.333,"body":"massive dump of Epstein files."},{"startTime":101.099,"endTime":102.366,"body":"And it's not going to be a discussion"},{"startTime":102.366,"endTime":104.233,"body":"that you have heard elsewhere."},{"startTime":104.9,"endTime":107.099,"body":"Among other things, I'm going to describe"},{"startTime":107.099,"endTime":109.966,"body":"why quite apart from any evidence that"},{"startTime":109.966,"endTime":113.333,"body":"has emerged here or previously, I believe"},{"startTime":113.333,"endTime":117.233,"body":"we can surmise it is likely that Epstein"},{"startTime":117.766,"endTime":121.799,"body":"survived his apparent suicide and may"},{"startTime":121.799,"endTime":124.633,"body":"well still be alive somewhere."},{"startTime":125.2,"endTime":126.866,"body":"So that's not based on the evidence."},{"startTime":126.866,"endTime":129.966,"body":"I'm certainly aware of the evidence and"},{"startTime":129.966,"endTime":132.066,"body":"its thinness in spots and"},{"startTime":133.233,"endTime":134.633,"body":"suggestiveness in other places."},{"startTime":134.633,"endTime":135.4,"body":"But anyway, if you're"},{"startTime":135.4,"endTime":137.233,"body":"here for that, stay tuned."},{"startTime":137.666,"endTime":138.333,"body":"It is coming."},{"startTime":138.8,"endTime":139.199,"body":"Cause that's not where"},{"startTime":139.199,"endTime":139.699,"body":"we're going to start."},{"startTime":139.833,"endTime":142.133,"body":"We're going to start with Orwell because"},{"startTime":142.133,"endTime":144.266,"body":"that is the moment that we're living in."},{"startTime":144.466,"endTime":144.666,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":144.766,"endTime":147.133,"body":"Again, we've tried to, we've, we've read"},{"startTime":147.133,"endTime":149.566,"body":"from Orwell before and it's, it's back."},{"startTime":150.133,"endTime":151.9,"body":"We're going to talk a bit"},{"startTime":151.9,"endTime":153.5,"body":"about the Nobel Peace Prize."},{"startTime":153.966,"endTime":154.3,"body":"Wow."},{"startTime":154.666,"endTime":155.199,"body":"About Wikipedia,"},{"startTime":156.233,"endTime":158.666,"body":"about the horrifying latest,"},{"startTime":158.666,"endTime":161.166,"body":"uh, school shooting in Canada."},{"startTime":162.166,"endTime":164.599,"body":"Uh, and, uh, and maybe then"},{"startTime":164.599,"endTime":166.033,"body":"a little more Orwell because"},{"startTime":166.033,"endTime":171.133,"body":"we will also talk about the article that"},{"startTime":171.133,"endTime":173.866,"body":"has been circulating about AI and the"},{"startTime":173.866,"endTime":177.9,"body":"spooked nature of many insiders who have"},{"startTime":177.9,"endTime":179.766,"body":"been in close contact with AI and are"},{"startTime":179.766,"endTime":181.366,"body":"watching the rate of progress and"},{"startTime":181.366,"endTime":185.699,"body":"arriving, uh, at a shocking conclusion"},{"startTime":185.699,"endTime":189.066,"body":"about its likely impact on normal"},{"startTime":189.066,"endTime":192.266,"body":"civilization and the entire economy."},{"startTime":193.4,"endTime":193.433,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":194.066,"endTime":196.133,"body":"When, as it's likely, we don't get to all"},{"startTime":196.133,"endTime":197.866,"body":"of those things, uh, we will"},{"startTime":197.866,"endTime":199.166,"body":"actually be back in three days."},{"startTime":199.166,"endTime":200.3,"body":"So we'll be back on February"},{"startTime":200.3,"endTime":202.666,"body":"14th, uh, for a live stream."},{"startTime":202.933,"endTime":204.966,"body":"Uh, when you will probably see, uh, some"},{"startTime":204.966,"endTime":206.566,"body":"of that being discussed because I don't"},{"startTime":206.566,"endTime":207.099,"body":"think we're going to get"},{"startTime":207.099,"endTime":209.533,"body":"all of that, uh, today."},{"startTime":209.633,"endTime":210.366,"body":"If we could turn back"},{"startTime":210.366,"endTime":212.766,"body":"time, no, I have not."},{"startTime":212.766,"endTime":213.433,"body":"I don't even know that"},{"startTime":213.433,"endTime":215.166,"body":"song or I don't like it, but"},{"startTime":215.166,"endTime":216.566,"body":"would you like to cover it?"},{"startTime":216.9,"endTime":217.833,"body":"Would you like to do a cover?"},{"startTime":218.066,"endTime":219.3,"body":"I actually, it's a song."},{"startTime":219.3,"endTime":220.566,"body":"I think I don't even know"},{"startTime":220.566,"endTime":221.866,"body":"well enough to get past that."},{"startTime":221.933,"endTime":224.566,"body":"If I could turn back time then if, and I"},{"startTime":224.566,"endTime":225.133,"body":"don't remember what"},{"startTime":225.133,"endTime":226.366,"body":"the second contingent,"},{"startTime":226.699,"endTime":228.533,"body":"you can belt out that, that line."},{"startTime":228.766,"endTime":229.433,"body":"Yes, I could."},{"startTime":229.833,"endTime":232.333,"body":"I'll share who may have been covering it."},{"startTime":232.9,"endTime":233.466,"body":"Is it share?"},{"startTime":233.699,"endTime":234.3,"body":"I think so."},{"startTime":234.5,"endTime":234.933,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":235.733,"endTime":236.133,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":236.833,"endTime":239.833,"body":"I have now very elegantly backtracked out"},{"startTime":239.833,"endTime":241.533,"body":"of that line of discussion."},{"startTime":241.766,"endTime":241.966,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":242.366,"endTime":243.266,"body":"Um, okay."},{"startTime":243.266,"endTime":244.233,"body":"Uh, check out locals."},{"startTime":244.233,"endTime":245.633,"body":"We've got a watch party going on there."},{"startTime":245.666,"endTime":248.266,"body":"Uh, we have a live stream again in a few"},{"startTime":248.266,"endTime":250.566,"body":"days and then a Q and a on Sunday."},{"startTime":250.866,"endTime":252.699,"body":"Uh, so lots of opportunity"},{"startTime":252.699,"endTime":255.366,"body":"to, um, watch and interact."},{"startTime":255.366,"endTime":256.633,"body":"In fact, on Sunday coming up."},{"startTime":257.066,"endTime":260.033,"body":"Uh, but first off, uh, right now top of"},{"startTime":260.033,"endTime":261.966,"body":"the hour, we have three as usual."},{"startTime":262.466,"endTime":263.366,"body":"Amazing sponsors."},{"startTime":263.833,"endTime":264.8,"body":"And we'll start with that now."},{"startTime":265.899,"endTime":267.8,"body":"Our first sponsor today is sorry."},{"startTime":268.666,"endTime":270.933,"body":"SaunaSpace, which makes amazing saunas"},{"startTime":270.933,"endTime":272.266,"body":"and therapeutic lights."},{"startTime":272.466,"endTime":274.633,"body":"So several years ago, I started looking"},{"startTime":274.633,"endTime":276.466,"body":"into saunas, both traditional and"},{"startTime":276.466,"endTime":277.466,"body":"infrared and found a"},{"startTime":277.466,"endTime":278.566,"body":"morass of information."},{"startTime":279.066,"endTime":280.833,"body":"Then red light therapy became popular and"},{"startTime":280.833,"endTime":282.166,"body":"the glut of products and claims became,"},{"startTime":282.166,"endTime":283.733,"body":"it became even more confusing."},{"startTime":284.199,"endTime":285.066,"body":"Is the product effective?"},{"startTime":285.066,"endTime":286.266,"body":"How long does it take to heat up?"},{"startTime":286.266,"endTime":287.066,"body":"What frequencies does"},{"startTime":287.066,"endTime":288.066,"body":"it actually produce?"},{"startTime":288.066,"endTime":288.833,"body":"Does it emit harmful"},{"startTime":288.833,"endTime":289.766,"body":"electromagnetic radiation?"},{"startTime":290.533,"endTime":292.133,"body":"The only product I've found that clearly"},{"startTime":292.133,"endTime":293.566,"body":"lived up to its scientific and health"},{"startTime":293.566,"endTime":295.166,"body":"claims was SaunaSpace."},{"startTime":295.933,"endTime":297.433,"body":"So in a space combines visible red light"},{"startTime":297.433,"endTime":299.266,"body":"and near infrared to provide deep radiant"},{"startTime":299.266,"endTime":300.8,"body":"heat for whole body results at home."},{"startTime":301.166,"endTime":302.066,"body":"There's no harsh led"},{"startTime":302.066,"endTime":303.833,"body":"panel nor a giant wooden box."},{"startTime":304.366,"endTime":305.966,"body":"SaunaSpaces, firelight spectrum is"},{"startTime":305.966,"endTime":307.866,"body":"proprietary sunlight spectrum that was"},{"startTime":307.899,"endTime":308.966,"body":"developed over a decade of"},{"startTime":308.966,"endTime":309.766,"body":"research and development."},{"startTime":310.466,"endTime":311.966,"body":"The incandescent bulbs are flicker free,"},{"startTime":312.333,"endTime":314.1,"body":"glare free, and long lasting, staying"},{"startTime":314.1,"endTime":315.699,"body":"consistent for over five years."},{"startTime":316.566,"endTime":318.233,"body":"SaunaSpace has two flagship products,"},{"startTime":318.233,"endTime":319.966,"body":"the glow and the firelight sauna."},{"startTime":320.433,"endTime":321.066,"body":"I've been using the"},{"startTime":321.066,"endTime":322.366,"body":"first, the glow for years."},{"startTime":322.366,"endTime":323.933,"body":"It's a single large light that could be"},{"startTime":323.933,"endTime":325.466,"body":"used at the side of the desk or bedside."},{"startTime":326.0,"endTime":327.733,"body":"The glow can alleviate screen fatigue and"},{"startTime":327.733,"endTime":329.133,"body":"the ill effects of blue light and helps"},{"startTime":329.133,"endTime":329.899,"body":"the skin mood,"},{"startTime":329.899,"endTime":331.066,"body":"energy, and sleep concerns."},{"startTime":331.633,"endTime":333.233,"body":"The glow also works as spot relief for"},{"startTime":333.233,"endTime":335.0,"body":"sore backs, tight shoulders, or cramps."},{"startTime":336.5,"endTime":339.199,"body":"Firelight sauna, which I started using a"},{"startTime":339.199,"endTime":340.533,"body":"month and a half or so ago at this point,"},{"startTime":340.833,"endTime":342.666,"body":"is a full body sauna that promotes sweat"},{"startTime":342.666,"endTime":345.633,"body":"and provides red light and near infrared"},{"startTime":345.633,"endTime":347.633,"body":"therapy, all in a single experience."},{"startTime":348.133,"endTime":349.699,"body":"It is beautiful and powerful."},{"startTime":349.699,"endTime":350.733,"body":"You get medical spa level"},{"startTime":350.733,"endTime":351.899,"body":"results right in your home."},{"startTime":352.766,"endTime":354.133,"body":"Firelight sauna gives you deep detox,"},{"startTime":354.333,"endTime":355.766,"body":"pain relief, and better sleep."},{"startTime":355.966,"endTime":357.166,"body":"Your skin gets rejuvenated."},{"startTime":357.166,"endTime":358.433,"body":"You get an energy boost, enhanced"},{"startTime":358.433,"endTime":360.533,"body":"cognition, stress relief, and an immune"},{"startTime":360.533,"endTime":361.333,"body":"boost, and it helps"},{"startTime":361.333,"endTime":362.366,"body":"with healing and recovery."},{"startTime":363.1,"endTime":364.933,"body":"Firelight sauna offers fast sessions with"},{"startTime":364.933,"endTime":366.033,"body":"no preheat necessary."},{"startTime":366.399,"endTime":367.766,"body":"You flip the switch, get in, start"},{"startTime":367.766,"endTime":368.633,"body":"sweating in minutes."},{"startTime":369.466,"endTime":371.399,"body":"Sessions last 15 to 25 minutes, half the"},{"startTime":371.399,"endTime":372.199,"body":"time of other saunas."},{"startTime":372.666,"endTime":373.933,"body":"The firelight sauna is a beautifully"},{"startTime":373.933,"endTime":375.8,"body":"beautiful canvas sauna that is"},{"startTime":375.8,"endTime":378.1,"body":"lightweight and plug and play fits into a"},{"startTime":378.1,"endTime":378.966,"body":"spare room or corner."},{"startTime":379.266,"endTime":380.8,"body":"You can start small with the glow, which"},{"startTime":380.8,"endTime":382.266,"body":"is a single full spectrum, red and"},{"startTime":382.266,"endTime":383.733,"body":"infrared light, or go all"},{"startTime":383.733,"endTime":384.933,"body":"in with the firelight sauna."},{"startTime":385.633,"endTime":387.066,"body":"All SaunaSpace products are built with"},{"startTime":387.066,"endTime":388.833,"body":"integrity and handmade in Missouri with"},{"startTime":388.833,"endTime":391.233,"body":"organic cotton, bamboo, sustainable,"},{"startTime":391.233,"endTime":393.133,"body":"unfinished basswood, and medical grade"},{"startTime":393.166,"endTime":394.899,"body":"stainless steel, no toxic"},{"startTime":394.899,"endTime":396.6,"body":"loser plastics, and no off-gassing."},{"startTime":397.066,"endTime":398.466,"body":"The grounding mat and optional silver"},{"startTime":398.466,"endTime":400.433,"body":"lining upgrade blocks environmental EMFs"},{"startTime":400.433,"endTime":402.766,"body":"like wifi to enhance healing, and you get"},{"startTime":402.766,"endTime":404.5,"body":"a hundred day home trial"},{"startTime":404.5,"endTime":405.733,"body":"and outstanding customer care."},{"startTime":406.833,"endTime":408.133,"body":"Take your wellness to the"},{"startTime":408.133,"endTime":409.6,"body":"next level with SaunaSpace."},{"startTime":410.133,"endTime":411.466,"body":"DarkHorse listeners can get an exclusive"},{"startTime":411.466,"endTime":413.333,"body":"10% offsite wide when you shop at"},{"startTime":413.333,"endTime":414.966,"body":"sauna.space.darkhorse."},{"startTime":415.533,"endTime":419.066,"body":"That's SAUNA.space.darkhorse."},{"startTime":419.933,"endTime":420.266,"body":"Discount will be"},{"startTime":420.266,"endTime":421.533,"body":"automatically applied at checkout."},{"startTime":422.633,"endTime":423.933,"body":"Now, I think that ad read"},{"startTime":423.933,"endTime":426.466,"body":"needs something somewhere in there."},{"startTime":426.466,"endTime":429.233,"body":"It needs to say that the tent has a"},{"startTime":429.233,"endTime":431.266,"body":"decidedly Bedouin aesthetic."},{"startTime":432.566,"endTime":434.533,"body":"Probably just because that phrase has"},{"startTime":434.533,"endTime":435.566,"body":"never been used anywhere, but"},{"startTime":436.133,"endTime":437.133,"body":"we've said it before."},{"startTime":438.166,"endTime":439.466,"body":"Well, it is decidedly Bedouin."},{"startTime":440.133,"endTime":440.399,"body":"It is."},{"startTime":440.899,"endTime":441.266,"body":"It's great."},{"startTime":441.666,"endTime":442.833,"body":"Also fun for cats."},{"startTime":443.433,"endTime":445.733,"body":"I can, I can speak from experience that"},{"startTime":445.733,"endTime":447.466,"body":"you turn this thing on and"},{"startTime":447.466,"endTime":448.833,"body":"the cats, the cats will flock."},{"startTime":449.266,"endTime":449.533,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":449.533,"endTime":450.166,"body":"It warms them right up."},{"startTime":450.566,"endTime":450.766,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":450.933,"endTime":452.266,"body":"And if you don't like cats and you don't"},{"startTime":452.266,"endTime":453.899,"body":"have any of your own, just close the door"},{"startTime":453.899,"endTime":454.633,"body":"of your house and"},{"startTime":454.633,"endTime":455.333,"body":"then they won't come in."},{"startTime":455.5,"endTime":456.666,"body":"So don't be concerned that you'll get"},{"startTime":456.666,"endTime":457.566,"body":"cats that you don't want."},{"startTime":458.033,"endTime":458.8,"body":"It's not going to happen."},{"startTime":460.133,"endTime":460.566,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":460.566,"endTime":462.433,"body":"I mean, you've covered the territory."},{"startTime":463.133,"endTime":463.366,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":463.966,"endTime":465.566,"body":"Our second sponsor this week is Xlear."},{"startTime":466.033,"endTime":467.133,"body":"Xlear is a nasal spray that"},{"startTime":467.133,"endTime":468.366,"body":"supports respiratory health."},{"startTime":468.366,"endTime":469.733,"body":"It's widely available online and in"},{"startTime":469.733,"endTime":471.266,"body":"stores and both it and the company that"},{"startTime":471.266,"endTime":471.966,"body":"makes it are fantastic."},{"startTime":472.166,"endTime":472.633,"body":"It's Xlear."},{"startTime":472.899,"endTime":475.966,"body":"That's X L E A R pronounced \"clear.\""},{"startTime":477.166,"endTime":478.133,"body":"Throughout history, improvements in"},{"startTime":478.133,"endTime":479.633,"body":"sanitation and hygiene have had huge"},{"startTime":479.666,"endTime":481.399,"body":"impacts on human longevity and quality of"},{"startTime":481.399,"endTime":482.366,"body":"life more so than"},{"startTime":482.366,"endTime":483.533,"body":"traditional medical advances."},{"startTime":484.166,"endTime":485.433,"body":"For instance, when doctors started to"},{"startTime":485.433,"endTime":486.733,"body":"wash their hands between handling"},{"startTime":486.733,"endTime":488.3,"body":"cadavers and helping women give birth,"},{"startTime":488.733,"endTime":489.833,"body":"seems obvious to us now."},{"startTime":490.233,"endTime":491.833,"body":"The rate of maternal deaths went way down"},{"startTime":491.833,"endTime":493.233,"body":"and it wasn't obvious then."},{"startTime":493.866,"endTime":495.1,"body":"Breathing polluted air and drink, you"},{"startTime":495.1,"endTime":496.933,"body":"take water have hugely negative effects"},{"startTime":496.933,"endTime":498.633,"body":"on human health, clean up the air and"},{"startTime":498.633,"endTime":499.933,"body":"water and people get healthier."},{"startTime":500.766,"endTime":502.633,"body":"Nasal hygiene often gets overlooked, but"},{"startTime":502.633,"endTime":504.033,"body":"consider that the majority of bacteria"},{"startTime":504.033,"endTime":505.699,"body":"and viruses that make us sick enter"},{"startTime":505.699,"endTime":506.666,"body":"through our mouth and nose."},{"startTime":507.166,"endTime":508.633,"body":"That has become a cultural norm to wash"},{"startTime":508.633,"endTime":510.133,"body":"our hands in order to help stop the"},{"startTime":510.133,"endTime":511.666,"body":"spread of disease from person to person."},{"startTime":512.266,"endTime":512.866,"body":"But it's rare that we"},{"startTime":512.866,"endTime":513.799,"body":"get sick through our hands."},{"startTime":514.233,"endTime":514.799,"body":"Rather we get sick"},{"startTime":514.799,"endTime":515.766,"body":"through our mouth and nose."},{"startTime":516.233,"endTime":517.333,"body":"Does it make sense that we should be"},{"startTime":517.333,"endTime":518.5,"body":"using something that we know blocks"},{"startTime":518.5,"endTime":520.533,"body":"bacterial and viral adhesion in the nose?"},{"startTime":521.866,"endTime":522.466,"body":"Enter Clear."},{"startTime":523.333,"endTime":524.6,"body":"Xlear is a nasal spray that contains"},{"startTime":524.6,"endTime":526.566,"body":"Xylitol, a five carbon sugar alcohol."},{"startTime":527.133,"endTime":528.833,"body":"Our bodies naturally contain five carbon"},{"startTime":528.833,"endTime":530.433,"body":"sugars, mostly in the form of ribose and"},{"startTime":530.466,"endTime":532.033,"body":"deoxyribose, which are the backbone"},{"startTime":532.033,"endTime":533.966,"body":"sugars in RNA and DNA respectively."},{"startTime":534.566,"endTime":536.2,"body":"Almost our dietary sugars have six"},{"startTime":536.2,"endTime":537.233,"body":"carbons, sugars like"},{"startTime":537.233,"endTime":538.233,"body":"glucose and fructose."},{"startTime":539.2,"endTime":540.866,"body":"Xylitol is known to produce how sticky"},{"startTime":540.866,"endTime":542.7,"body":"bacteria and viruses are to our tissues."},{"startTime":543.299,"endTime":544.966,"body":"In the presence of Xylitol, bacteria and"},{"startTime":544.966,"endTime":547.166,"body":"viruses, including strep, SARS-CoV-2 and"},{"startTime":547.266,"endTime":549.833,"body":"RSV don't adhere to our airways as well,"},{"startTime":550.1,"endTime":551.633,"body":"which helps our body's natural defense"},{"startTime":551.733,"endTime":553.399,"body":"mechanisms easily flush them away."},{"startTime":554.266,"endTime":556.266,"body":"Xlear is a simple nasal spray that you"},{"startTime":556.266,"endTime":557.1,"body":"use morning and evening."},{"startTime":557.1,"endTime":558.366,"body":"It takes just three seconds."},{"startTime":558.366,"endTime":560.2,"body":"It's fast and easy and healthy."},{"startTime":561.033,"endTime":562.433,"body":"If any of this sounds familiar, perhaps"},{"startTime":562.433,"endTime":563.733,"body":"you listen to Bret's conversation with"},{"startTime":563.733,"endTime":565.733,"body":"Nathan Jones, founder of Xlear, on the"},{"startTime":565.733,"endTime":567.2,"body":"Inside Rail in November, 2024."},{"startTime":567.966,"endTime":569.266,"body":"Or to Bret's conversation with Nate's"},{"startTime":569.266,"endTime":571.799,"body":"father, Lon Jones, osteopath and inventor"},{"startTime":571.799,"endTime":573.833,"body":"of Xlear on how Xylitol intermixed with"},{"startTime":573.833,"endTime":576.0,"body":"respiratory viruses in May of 2025."},{"startTime":576.7,"endTime":578.266,"body":"We recommend those conversations and we"},{"startTime":578.266,"endTime":580.333,"body":"highly recommend Xlear as a daily habit"},{"startTime":580.333,"endTime":581.066,"body":"and prophylactic"},{"startTime":581.066,"endTime":582.266,"body":"against respiratory illnesses."},{"startTime":582.966,"endTime":585.833,"body":"That's Xlear with an X, X-L-E-A-R."},{"startTime":586.266,"endTime":587.899,"body":"Get Xlear online or at your pharmacy,"},{"startTime":588.1,"endTime":589.233,"body":"grocery store, or natural products"},{"startTime":589.233,"endTime":591.0,"body":"retailer and start taking six seconds"},{"startTime":591.0,"endTime":592.466,"body":"each day to improve your nasal hygiene"},{"startTime":592.466,"endTime":594.066,"body":"and support your respiratory health."},{"startTime":595.066,"endTime":595.266,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":595.366,"endTime":597.066,"body":"Still feel Xlear should be spelled with a"},{"startTime":597.066,"endTime":599.899,"body":"C, but I'm also a guy who feels that"},{"startTime":599.899,"endTime":601.566,"body":"xylophone should be spelled with a Z."},{"startTime":602.333,"endTime":603.2,"body":"And how about the xylitol?"},{"startTime":605.6,"endTime":606.166,"body":"You know, chemistry"},{"startTime":606.166,"endTime":607.166,"body":"was never my strong suit."},{"startTime":608.466,"endTime":610.566,"body":"Um, our final sponsor"},{"startTime":610.566,"endTime":612.666,"body":"today is Ma- It was spelling."},{"startTime":613.966,"endTime":618.866,"body":"What I spelled, I literally spelled"},{"startTime":618.866,"endTime":622.5,"body":"inquire today with an E."},{"startTime":622.766,"endTime":623.933,"body":"I think that's just the British spelling."},{"startTime":624.166,"endTime":624.533,"body":"Is it?"},{"startTime":624.533,"endTime":624.966,"body":"I think so."},{"startTime":626.066,"endTime":628.533,"body":"Oh, I feel, I feel quite a bit better."},{"startTime":630.0,"endTime":630.2,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":630.633,"endTime":631.733,"body":"Um, our final sponsor"},{"startTime":631.733,"endTime":633.2,"body":"today, Heather, is Masa Chips."},{"startTime":633.233,"endTime":635.533,"body":"Masa makes ridiculously delicious chips"},{"startTime":635.533,"endTime":637.233,"body":"with simple, real whole ingredients."},{"startTime":638.233,"endTime":640.366,"body":"bulleted list, organic nixtamalized corn,"},{"startTime":640.6,"endTime":642.2,"body":"sea salt, and a hundred"},{"startTime":642.2,"endTime":643.933,"body":"percent grass-fed beef tallow."},{"startTime":643.933,"endTime":644.133,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":644.366,"endTime":644.733,"body":"That's them."},{"startTime":644.966,"endTime":646.966,"body":"This is, that's actually a real bag."},{"startTime":647.233,"endTime":647.633,"body":"Not a prop."},{"startTime":647.933,"endTime":648.1,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":648.1,"endTime":649.666,"body":"Not a bag that we've eaten already."},{"startTime":649.933,"endTime":650.266,"body":"Nope."},{"startTime":650.733,"endTime":651.966,"body":"But we have plenty of those."},{"startTime":651.966,"endTime":654.466,"body":"Masa chips, like the ones in this bag are"},{"startTime":654.466,"endTime":655.533,"body":"made the way that all of"},{"startTime":655.533,"endTime":656.866,"body":"our food used to be made."},{"startTime":656.866,"endTime":658.533,"body":"They're fried in a hundred percent beef"},{"startTime":658.533,"endTime":660.066,"body":"tallow, no seed oils ever."},{"startTime":660.833,"endTime":662.0,"body":"You can taste the difference and your"},{"startTime":662.0,"endTime":662.966,"body":"body can feel the difference."},{"startTime":663.366,"endTime":665.133,"body":"America's health is declining fast."},{"startTime":665.566,"endTime":667.233,"body":"Chronic illnesses, obesity, autoimmune"},{"startTime":667.233,"endTime":668.366,"body":"diseases have exploded."},{"startTime":668.766,"endTime":669.233,"body":"What changed?"},{"startTime":669.933,"endTime":671.433,"body":"One thing that changed is that all chips"},{"startTime":671.433,"endTime":673.266,"body":"and fries used to be cooked in tallow."},{"startTime":673.266,"endTime":675.133,"body":"But in the 1990s, corporations switched"},{"startTime":675.133,"endTime":677.033,"body":"to cheaper seed oils, which include"},{"startTime":677.033,"endTime":678.6,"body":"soybean, canola, safflower,"},{"startTime":679.733,"endTime":680.166,"body":"and corn."},{"startTime":680.6,"endTime":682.2,"body":"Seed oils are often labeled vegetable"},{"startTime":682.2,"endTime":684.1,"body":"oils as if that makes them healthy."},{"startTime":684.1,"endTime":685.666,"body":"Well, in fact, seed oils are linked to"},{"startTime":685.666,"endTime":687.366,"body":"metabolic health issues and inflammation."},{"startTime":688.266,"endTime":690.466,"body":"And today, seed oils make up 20% of the"},{"startTime":690.466,"endTime":692.233,"body":"average American's daily calories."},{"startTime":692.633,"endTime":694.533,"body":"Big food companies also use artificial"},{"startTime":694.533,"endTime":696.633,"body":"dyes, stabilizers, and other toxins."},{"startTime":697.333,"endTime":699.366,"body":"Masa chips, though, absolutely no seed"},{"startTime":699.366,"endTime":701.7,"body":"oils, artificial dyes, or additives ever."},{"startTime":702.466,"endTime":704.566,"body":"Beef tallow is nutrient rich, nourishing,"},{"startTime":704.833,"endTime":706.266,"body":"and makes food taste incredible."},{"startTime":706.833,"endTime":708.033,"body":"Masa chips are crunchy and delicious."},{"startTime":708.266,"endTime":709.266,"body":"And after you eat them, you feel"},{"startTime":709.266,"endTime":711.466,"body":"satisfied, satiated and energetic."},{"startTime":712.633,"endTime":714.466,"body":"Masa also supports American farms and"},{"startTime":714.466,"endTime":715.633,"body":"regenerative agriculture."},{"startTime":716.933,"endTime":719.066,"body":"Choosing real food heals us and our"},{"startTime":719.066,"endTime":720.133,"body":"environment, which in turn"},{"startTime":720.133,"endTime":721.266,"body":"makes us even more healthy."},{"startTime":721.466,"endTime":723.266,"body":"These chips don't only avoid all the bad"},{"startTime":723.266,"endTime":724.799,"body":"stuff, they taste incredible, too."},{"startTime":725.266,"endTime":727.899,"body":"There's a reason Sprouts farmers market."},{"startTime":728.133,"endTime":729.133,"body":"Sprouts farmers market."},{"startTime":729.633,"endTime":730.2,"body":"That's a business."},{"startTime":730.766,"endTime":731.866,"body":"Pick them up nationwide."},{"startTime":732.433,"endTime":733.366,"body":"This is the real deal."},{"startTime":734.166,"endTime":736.433,"body":"Try Masa chips with salsa or nachos or"},{"startTime":736.433,"endTime":737.666,"body":"just eat them straight out of the bag."},{"startTime":738.533,"endTime":740.966,"body":"Our favorites are the white chips made"},{"startTime":740.966,"endTime":743.233,"body":"from their heirloom organic white corn,"},{"startTime":743.233,"endTime":743.866,"body":"which gives a"},{"startTime":743.866,"endTime":745.566,"body":"particularly light and flaky texture."},{"startTime":746.266,"endTime":747.933,"body":"We also love the Masa blue chips, which"},{"startTime":747.933,"endTime":748.833,"body":"have a deeper, nuttier"},{"startTime":748.833,"endTime":750.066,"body":"flavor and a serious crunch."},{"startTime":750.533,"endTime":753.533,"body":"They've also got hatch chili for men,"},{"startTime":754.433,"endTime":755.7,"body":"gender nonconforming women"},{"startTime":755.7,"endTime":757.399,"body":"and the people who love them."},{"startTime":757.766,"endTime":758.633,"body":"They have Cabanero."},{"startTime":759.766,"endTime":760.299,"body":"Cabanero."},{"startTime":760.566,"endTime":761.233,"body":"Cabanero."},{"startTime":761.466,"endTime":762.333,"body":"What the hell are you on about?"},{"startTime":762.533,"endTime":763.0,"body":"Oh, they're spicy."},{"startTime":764.1,"endTime":765.566,"body":"Cabanero is the really spicy one."},{"startTime":765.833,"endTime":767.299,"body":"Yeah, Cabanero is really spicy."},{"startTime":767.966,"endTime":770.233,"body":"Lime, original and wait for it."},{"startTime":770.366,"endTime":771.066,"body":"Churro with cinnamon."},{"startTime":771.5,"endTime":772.133,"body":"They're all amazing."},{"startTime":772.533,"endTime":774.066,"body":"Ready to give Masa a try?"},{"startTime":774.133,"endTime":777.233,"body":"Go to Masachips.com slash DarkHorse and"},{"startTime":777.233,"endTime":780.433,"body":"use the code DarkHorse for 25% off your"},{"startTime":780.433,"endTime":783.533,"body":"first order or simply click or simply"},{"startTime":783.533,"endTime":786.1,"body":"click the link in the video description"},{"startTime":786.1,"endTime":790.533,"body":"or scan the QR claim QR code to claim"},{"startTime":790.533,"endTime":791.666,"body":"this delicious offer."},{"startTime":792.066,"endTime":795.299,"body":"That's Masachips.com slash DarkHorse and"},{"startTime":795.299,"endTime":797.1,"body":"code DarkHorse for 21st"},{"startTime":797.1,"endTime":799.6,"body":"25% off your first order."},{"startTime":799.933,"endTime":801.666,"body":"You know, the buffer must be full because"},{"startTime":801.666,"endTime":805.433,"body":"a lot of stuff keeps, you know, yeah."},{"startTime":807.666,"endTime":808.066,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":808.866,"endTime":811.666,"body":"You wanted to set us in motion in the"},{"startTime":811.666,"endTime":813.433,"body":"correct direction in light of me."},{"startTime":814.466,"endTime":817.466,"body":"In a, in a, in a, this"},{"startTime":817.466,"endTime":822.166,"body":"society moment, relevant direction."},{"startTime":822.433,"endTime":822.966,"body":"I don't know that it's"},{"startTime":822.966,"endTime":823.766,"body":"the correct direction."},{"startTime":824.233,"endTime":825.566,"body":"I don't, I don't want to be"},{"startTime":825.566,"endTime":826.833,"body":"living in an Aurelian landscape."},{"startTime":827.1,"endTime":827.266,"body":"Nope."},{"startTime":827.766,"endTime":832.0,"body":"Um, much less a Huxley in one."},{"startTime":832.7,"endTime":835.433,"body":"Uh, but, uh, this moment is"},{"startTime":835.433,"endTime":836.966,"body":"reminding me a lot of 1984."},{"startTime":837.333,"endTime":837.533,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":838.233,"endTime":839.799,"body":"And we have, we've, it's not the first"},{"startTime":839.799,"endTime":841.799,"body":"time that we have talked to Orwell."},{"startTime":841.799,"endTime":843.933,"body":"In fact, I went and looked, um, I"},{"startTime":843.933,"endTime":846.266,"body":"actually read experts, experts excerpts"},{"startTime":846.266,"endTime":849.433,"body":"from the, he for in live streams, 22, 43,"},{"startTime":850.033,"endTime":852.6,"body":"84 appropriately referenced room one on"},{"startTime":852.6,"endTime":853.666,"body":"one and episode one on one."},{"startTime":854.066,"endTime":856.6,"body":"And we read from Orwell's the road to"},{"startTime":856.6,"endTime":858.533,"body":"Wigan pier, uh, which was published"},{"startTime":858.533,"endTime":859.799,"body":"before 1994 in"},{"startTime":859.799,"endTime":861.233,"body":"episodes one 17 and one 18."},{"startTime":861.466,"endTime":863.466,"body":"So, you know, we've, we've traveled some"},{"startTime":863.466,"endTime":866.733,"body":"of this road before, but the world"},{"startTime":866.733,"endTime":867.566,"body":"doesn't seem to be"},{"startTime":867.566,"endTime":869.433,"body":"getting any less Orwellian."},{"startTime":869.733,"endTime":870.666,"body":"So here we are."},{"startTime":871.033,"endTime":871.2,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":871.2,"endTime":871.866,"body":"I mean, that is one of"},{"startTime":871.866,"endTime":873.533,"body":"the themes of the book."},{"startTime":873.866,"endTime":874.166,"body":"Indeed."},{"startTime":874.166,"endTime":874.366,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":874.533,"endTime":874.833,"body":"Indeed."},{"startTime":874.833,"endTime":876.899,"body":"So I wanted to start, this is this, uh,"},{"startTime":876.899,"endTime":878.933,"body":"this, this, I believe this is a copy that"},{"startTime":878.933,"endTime":881.066,"body":"belonged to my mom and"},{"startTime":881.066,"endTime":882.033,"body":"she got a fancier one."},{"startTime":882.233,"endTime":883.833,"body":"I may be wrong about that,"},{"startTime":883.833,"endTime":888.466,"body":"but, um, this is a 1977, uh,"},{"startTime":889.666,"endTime":891.033,"body":"printing, uh,"},{"startTime":891.366,"endTime":892.633,"body":"originally published in 1949."},{"startTime":893.399,"endTime":894.833,"body":"And I just want to read a couple of"},{"startTime":894.833,"endTime":896.733,"body":"paragraphs from, you know, you don't need"},{"startTime":896.733,"endTime":899.266,"body":"to know exactly what's going on here, uh,"},{"startTime":899.266,"endTime":903.066,"body":"to understand the significance of these"},{"startTime":903.066,"endTime":903.966,"body":"couple of paragraphs."},{"startTime":904.966,"endTime":905.866,"body":"One from early in the book,"},{"startTime":905.866,"endTime":906.766,"body":"one from the middle of the book."},{"startTime":908.733,"endTime":911.933,"body":"So this is, um, gosh, what's his name?"},{"startTime":912.233,"endTime":914.733,"body":"Sime talking to Winston informing Winston"},{"startTime":914.733,"endTime":916.899,"body":"of the glory that is to come."},{"startTime":917.7,"endTime":919.033,"body":"Don't you see that the whole aim of"},{"startTime":919.033,"endTime":920.533,"body":"newspeak is to narrow the range of"},{"startTime":920.533,"endTime":922.366,"body":"thought in the end, we shall make thought"},{"startTime":922.366,"endTime":924.066,"body":"crime literally impossible because there"},{"startTime":924.066,"endTime":926.033,"body":"will be no words in which to express it."},{"startTime":926.266,"endTime":927.7,"body":"Every concept that can ever be needed"},{"startTime":927.7,"endTime":929.7,"body":"will be expressed by exactly one word"},{"startTime":929.7,"endTime":931.7,"body":"with its meaning rigidly defined and all"},{"startTime":931.7,"endTime":932.566,"body":"its subsidiary meanings rubbed out and forgotten."},{"startTime":932.6,"endTime":935.866,"body":"Already in the 11th edition, we're not"},{"startTime":935.866,"endTime":937.799,"body":"far from that point, but the process will"},{"startTime":937.799,"endTime":938.899,"body":"still be continuing long"},{"startTime":938.899,"endTime":940.0,"body":"after you and I are dead."},{"startTime":940.566,"endTime":942.633,"body":"Every year, fewer and fewer words and the"},{"startTime":942.633,"endTime":943.466,"body":"range of consciousness"},{"startTime":943.466,"endTime":944.966,"body":"always a little smaller."},{"startTime":945.566,"endTime":947.366,"body":"Even now, of course, there's no reason or"},{"startTime":947.366,"endTime":948.766,"body":"excuse for committing thought crime."},{"startTime":949.233,"endTime":950.633,"body":"It's merely a question of self-discipline"},{"startTime":950.633,"endTime":953.033,"body":"reality control, but in the end, there"},{"startTime":953.033,"endTime":954.233,"body":"won't be any need even for that."},{"startTime":954.6,"endTime":956.066,"body":"The revolution will be complete when the"},{"startTime":956.066,"endTime":957.1,"body":"language is perfect."},{"startTime":957.866,"endTime":958.766,"body":"Newspeak is Ingsoc"},{"startTime":958.766,"endTime":960.066,"body":"and Ingsoc is newspeak."},{"startTime":960.533,"endTime":960.866,"body":"He added with a sort of mystical satisfaction."},{"startTime":960.933,"endTime":964.2,"body":"Has it ever occurred to you, Winston,"},{"startTime":964.233,"endTime":965.833,"body":"that by the year 2050, at the very"},{"startTime":965.833,"endTime":967.233,"body":"latest, not a single"},{"startTime":967.233,"endTime":968.433,"body":"human being will be alive?"},{"startTime":968.433,"endTime":969.766,"body":"You could understand such a conversation"},{"startTime":969.766,"endTime":972.033,"body":"as we are having now."},{"startTime":973.466,"endTime":973.666,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":974.933,"endTime":978.666,"body":"So, um, that's one, uh, paragraph."},{"startTime":978.933,"endTime":979.5,"body":"Are you okay?"},{"startTime":979.733,"endTime":980.866,"body":"Yes, I'm just fine."},{"startTime":980.933,"endTime":981.2,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":982.466,"endTime":983.933,"body":"You're responding to Orwell, perhaps."},{"startTime":984.899,"endTime":985.666,"body":"Um, the echoes are unmistakable."},{"startTime":985.7,"endTime":991.0,"body":"The echoes in our current environment."},{"startTime":991.433,"endTime":991.633,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":991.966,"endTime":992.166,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":992.466,"endTime":992.666,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":993.233,"endTime":993.433,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":993.733,"endTime":994.133,"body":"And, um,"},{"startTime":995.6,"endTime":998.166,"body":"and then this, this next paragraph, only"},{"startTime":998.166,"endTime":1000.866,"body":"a paragraph, uh, happens in the middle of"},{"startTime":1000.866,"endTime":1004.766,"body":"hate week, uh, which is a, uh, a moment"},{"startTime":1004.766,"endTime":1005.833,"body":"that everyone has"},{"startTime":1005.833,"endTime":1007.033,"body":"been forced to celebrate."},{"startTime":1008.466,"endTime":1010.633,"body":"On the sixth day of hate week, after the"},{"startTime":1010.633,"endTime":1012.466,"body":"processions, the speeches, the shouting,"},{"startTime":1012.466,"endTime":1013.866,"body":"the singing, the banners, the posters, the films, the waxworks, the rolling of"},{"startTime":1013.866,"endTime":1017.633,"body":"the drums and squealing of trumpets, the"},{"startTime":1017.633,"endTime":1019.666,"body":"tramp of marching feet, the grinding of"},{"startTime":1019.666,"endTime":1021.266,"body":"the caterpillars of tanks, the roar of"},{"startTime":1021.266,"endTime":1022.566,"body":"massed planes, the booming of"},{"startTime":1022.566,"endTime":1024.333,"body":"guns after six days of this."},{"startTime":1024.833,"endTime":1026.766,"body":"When the great orgasm was quivering to"},{"startTime":1026.766,"endTime":1028.533,"body":"its climax and the general hatred of"},{"startTime":1028.533,"endTime":1031.166,"body":"Eurasia had boiled up, boiled up into"},{"startTime":1031.166,"endTime":1032.7,"body":"such delirium that if the crowd could"},{"startTime":1032.7,"endTime":1034.133,"body":"have got their hands on the 2,000"},{"startTime":1034.133,"endTime":1035.666,"body":"Eurasian war criminals who were to be"},{"startTime":1035.666,"endTime":1036.866,"body":"publicly hanged on the last day of the"},{"startTime":1036.866,"endTime":1038.066,"body":"proceedings, they would unquestionably"},{"startTime":1038.066,"endTime":1038.7,"body":"have torn them to pieces."},{"startTime":1039.133,"endTime":1041.166,"body":"At just this moment, it had been"},{"startTime":1041.166,"endTime":1044.066,"body":"announced that Oceania was not after all."},{"startTime":1044.066,"endTime":1045.733,"body":"It was, excuse me."},{"startTime":1046.2,"endTime":1047.766,"body":"It had been announced that Oceania was"},{"startTime":1047.766,"endTime":1049.566,"body":"not after all at war with Eurasia."},{"startTime":1050.4,"endTime":1051.933,"body":"Oceania was at war with East Asia."},{"startTime":1052.533,"endTime":1054.433,"body":"Eurasia was an ally."},{"startTime":1058.9,"endTime":1060.833,"body":"So again, that happens in the middle of a"},{"startTime":1060.833,"endTime":1062.133,"body":"book that, you know, you presumably are"},{"startTime":1062.133,"endTime":1063.0,"body":"not in the middle of reading."},{"startTime":1063.0,"endTime":1063.7,"body":"If you haven't read it,"},{"startTime":1063.7,"endTime":1065.066,"body":"you should, obviously."},{"startTime":1065.433,"endTime":1072.333,"body":"In which we are reminded of the capacity"},{"startTime":1072.333,"endTime":1075.433,"body":"for humans to forget what is real, to"},{"startTime":1075.433,"endTime":1077.966,"body":"speak things that are not true, and in"},{"startTime":1077.966,"endTime":1080.0,"body":"speaking them over and over and over"},{"startTime":1080.0,"endTime":1082.666,"body":"again sufficiently, they really do begin"},{"startTime":1082.666,"endTime":1086.166,"body":"to believe that war is peace, that black"},{"startTime":1086.166,"endTime":1089.066,"body":"is white, etc., that 2 plus 2 equals 5."},{"startTime":1089.166,"endTime":1090.566,"body":"All things that are"},{"startTime":1090.566,"endTime":1092.366,"body":"pronounced as truths from 1984."},{"startTime":1093.233,"endTime":1098.066,"body":"So in that vein, we have this week, The"},{"startTime":1098.066,"endTime":1101.2,"body":"Nation magazine, one of the, maybe the"},{"startTime":1101.2,"endTime":1102.166,"body":"country's oldest"},{"startTime":1102.166,"endTime":1104.7,"body":"consistently running news weekly."},{"startTime":1105.733,"endTime":1107.366,"body":"I think it's the oldest American"},{"startTime":1107.366,"endTime":1109.333,"body":"periodical, the oldest consistently"},{"startTime":1109.333,"endTime":1110.9,"body":"published American periodical."},{"startTime":1111.133,"endTime":1113.633,"body":"I'm not sure if it, at least weekly, I"},{"startTime":1113.633,"endTime":1115.366,"body":"believe is the usual claim."},{"startTime":1115.366,"endTime":1116.366,"body":"I don't know if it's the"},{"startTime":1116.366,"endTime":1117.566,"body":"oldest running periodical."},{"startTime":1117.599,"endTime":1119.566,"body":"But we have,"},{"startTime":1120.766,"endTime":1124.9,"body":"so, and if you could show that image from"},{"startTime":1124.9,"endTime":1127.966,"body":"The Nation, this is"},{"startTime":1127.966,"endTime":1132.033,"body":"Minneapolis being excited about,"},{"startTime":1133.366,"endTime":1138.099,"body":"it's not coming from my computer."},{"startTime":1138.5,"endTime":1138.7,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":1139.066,"endTime":1139.533,"body":"There we go."},{"startTime":1140.533,"endTime":1141.566,"body":"So this is the city of"},{"startTime":1141.566,"endTime":1142.533,"body":"Minneapolis tweeting."},{"startTime":1143.333,"endTime":1146.733,"body":"Actually, can you scroll down so we can"},{"startTime":1146.733,"endTime":1148.033,"body":"see that this is coming?"},{"startTime":1148.933,"endTime":1149.933,"body":"We'll read the tweet next."},{"startTime":1150.2,"endTime":1151.433,"body":"So you just show us the"},{"startTime":1151.433,"endTime":1152.966,"body":"whole, yeah, here we go."},{"startTime":1152.966,"endTime":1155.099,"body":"The editors of The Nation magazine said,"},{"startTime":1155.633,"endTime":1157.7,"body":"\"Through countless acts of courage and"},{"startTime":1157.7,"endTime":1159.433,"body":"solidarity, the people of Minneapolis"},{"startTime":1159.433,"endTime":1161.466,"body":"have challenged the culture of fear,"},{"startTime":1161.466,"endTime":1162.566,"body":"hate, and brutality that"},{"startTime":1162.566,"endTime":1163.733,"body":"is crypto United States."},{"startTime":1164.299,"endTime":1166.133,"body":"Their nonviolent resistance has captured"},{"startTime":1166.133,"endTime":1167.2,"body":"the imagination of the"},{"startTime":1167.2,"endTime":1168.266,"body":"nation and the world.\""},{"startTime":1168.933,"endTime":1170.833,"body":"And so now you can scroll back up."},{"startTime":1170.833,"endTime":1173.833,"body":"The Nation has thus nominated the city of"},{"startTime":1173.833,"endTime":1174.733,"body":"Minneapolis for the"},{"startTime":1174.733,"endTime":1177.966,"body":"Nobel, the Nobel Peace Prize."},{"startTime":1177.966,"endTime":1179.4,"body":"I can't, like you said this to me today,"},{"startTime":1179.633,"endTime":1181.4,"body":"and I laughed at you."},{"startTime":1182.066,"endTime":1183.633,"body":"It must be coming from the Babylon Bee,"},{"startTime":1183.633,"endTime":1184.666,"body":"but no, no, it is not."},{"startTime":1184.866,"endTime":1186.299,"body":"So the city of Minneapolis, of course, is"},{"startTime":1186.299,"endTime":1188.599,"body":"very proud to have been nominated."},{"startTime":1189.5,"endTime":1191.266,"body":"I don't even know how a city can be"},{"startTime":1191.266,"endTime":1192.599,"body":"nominated for such a thing, but that's"},{"startTime":1192.599,"endTime":1194.066,"body":"really the shallow end"},{"startTime":1194.066,"endTime":1194.766,"body":"of the pool on this one."},{"startTime":1195.5,"endTime":1197.433,"body":"The city of Minneapolis, whoever is"},{"startTime":1197.433,"endTime":1200.0,"body":"manning their, sorry, theming their"},{"startTime":1200.0,"endTime":1203.366,"body":"social media account, writes of this, of"},{"startTime":1203.366,"endTime":1206.333,"body":"this high honor, \"The bravery, resilience"},{"startTime":1206.333,"endTime":1207.733,"body":"and sacrifice our city"},{"startTime":1209.833,"endTime":1211.2,"body":"to protect and support vulnerable"},{"startTime":1211.2,"endTime":1213.066,"body":"communities show Minneapolis's values."},{"startTime":1213.5,"endTime":1215.033,"body":"We're honored the city was nominated for"},{"startTime":1215.033,"endTime":1216.366,"body":"the Nobel Peace Prize, and it's because"},{"startTime":1216.366,"endTime":1219.0,"body":"of your courageous solidarity to promote"},{"startTime":1219.0,"endTime":1221.166,"body":"democracy, human rights and peace.\""},{"startTime":1221.166,"endTime":1224.0,"body":"Other than there being words missing and"},{"startTime":1224.0,"endTime":1225.233,"body":"it being grammatically weird, I don't"},{"startTime":1225.233,"endTime":1226.7,"body":"even know if they're thinking the nation,"},{"startTime":1227.799,"endTime":1229.933,"body":"the periodical the"},{"startTime":1229.933,"endTime":1231.099,"body":"nation, or if they're thinking"},{"startTime":1232.133,"endTime":1233.9,"body":"the citizens of Minneapolis, presumably"},{"startTime":1233.9,"endTime":1235.799,"body":"not the ones who think what's going on"},{"startTime":1235.799,"endTime":1238.033,"body":"there is absurd and grotesque, only the"},{"startTime":1238.033,"endTime":1240.7,"body":"ones who are actually, you know, using"},{"startTime":1240.7,"endTime":1242.599,"body":"violence to achieve nonviolence, etc.,"},{"startTime":1243.333,"endTime":1245.133,"body":"employing warlike tactics to achieve"},{"startTime":1245.133,"endTime":1247.433,"body":"peace, very, very newspeak, very"},{"startTime":1247.433,"endTime":1249.333,"body":"Orwellian in all of its,"},{"startTime":1250.233,"endTime":1251.633,"body":"all of its instantiations."},{"startTime":1252.066,"endTime":1256.166,"body":"Yes, and I must tell you, as you know"},{"startTime":1256.166,"endTime":1257.299,"body":"very well, we used to be"},{"startTime":1257.299,"endTime":1258.566,"body":"subscribers of the nation."},{"startTime":1259.033,"endTime":1263.0,"body":"It was a special publication."},{"startTime":1263.366,"endTime":1264.233,"body":"It was published at the"},{"startTime":1264.233,"endTime":1265.2,"body":"time we were subscribers."},{"startTime":1265.466,"endTime":1267.766,"body":"I believe it was still published in black"},{"startTime":1267.766,"endTime":1269.066,"body":"and white on newsprint."},{"startTime":1269.666,"endTime":1276.533,"body":"It was a significant source of news, and"},{"startTime":1276.533,"endTime":1277.966,"body":"of course, it had a"},{"startTime":1277.966,"endTime":1279.866,"body":"liberal bent, which it made."},{"startTime":1279.866,"endTime":1281.566,"body":"It had a clear ideological bias."},{"startTime":1281.833,"endTime":1282.766,"body":"It never pretended not to."},{"startTime":1282.766,"endTime":1284.7,"body":"It never pretended not to, which in fact"},{"startTime":1284.7,"endTime":1286.133,"body":"is a good thing because all of these"},{"startTime":1286.133,"endTime":1287.933,"body":"sources have some sort of bias and to"},{"startTime":1287.933,"endTime":1289.566,"body":"pretend otherwise is destructive."},{"startTime":1289.566,"endTime":1290.866,"body":"It was a far left bias."},{"startTime":1290.866,"endTime":1291.533,"body":"It always was."},{"startTime":1291.733,"endTime":1295.099,"body":"Far left bias, but in this case, you have"},{"startTime":1295.099,"endTime":1298.966,"body":"a news periodical weighing in on a"},{"startTime":1298.966,"endTime":1301.733,"body":"contentious issue having effectively"},{"startTime":1301.733,"endTime":1304.766,"body":"declared the conclusion, right?"},{"startTime":1305.066,"endTime":1307.866,"body":"So they are weighing in not only on the"},{"startTime":1307.866,"endTime":1311.133,"body":"behavior of the citizens of Minneapolis"},{"startTime":1311.133,"endTime":1314.866,"body":"who are obstructing the federal exercise"},{"startTime":1314.866,"endTime":1317.866,"body":"of power, which I understand they may"},{"startTime":1317.866,"endTime":1319.733,"body":"support, but to declare that the"},{"startTime":1319.733,"endTime":1323.533,"body":"obviously peace-loving side is to also"},{"startTime":1323.533,"endTime":1328.633,"body":"take a position on the national consensus"},{"startTime":1328.633,"endTime":1330.866,"body":"surrounding illegal immigration."},{"startTime":1332.266,"endTime":1334.066,"body":"So that is an absurdity."},{"startTime":1335.4,"endTime":1338.333,"body":"So peace is apparently anti-borders."},{"startTime":1338.733,"endTime":1338.933,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":1339.066,"endTime":1340.266,"body":"It's an it's an open"},{"startTime":1340.266,"endTime":1342.433,"body":"borders are the route to peace."},{"startTime":1342.433,"endTime":1346.366,"body":"You know, never mind that that it's an"},{"startTime":1346.366,"endTime":1349.766,"body":"obvious route for people who dislike us"},{"startTime":1349.766,"endTime":1353.966,"body":"to come in and dislike our nation or any"},{"startTime":1353.966,"endTime":1354.666,"body":"nation with open"},{"startTime":1354.666,"endTime":1355.799,"body":"borders and to disrupt it."},{"startTime":1356.066,"endTime":1359.833,"body":"So the idea that this is, you know, a a"},{"startTime":1359.833,"endTime":1363.533,"body":"battle, a blow being struck in the battle"},{"startTime":1363.533,"endTime":1365.466,"body":"for peace is absurd."},{"startTime":1365.466,"endTime":1367.566,"body":"It's not an analytical conclusion."},{"startTime":1368.033,"endTime":1370.766,"body":"It's an emotional response to those"},{"startTime":1370.766,"endTime":1372.166,"body":"people are on my team."},{"startTime":1372.833,"endTime":1375.666,"body":"And frankly, you know, the nation has"},{"startTime":1375.666,"endTime":1377.933,"body":"been broken for a very long"},{"startTime":1377.933,"endTime":1379.166,"body":"time as a news periodical."},{"startTime":1379.166,"endTime":1382.766,"body":"But for them to not having to have failed"},{"startTime":1382.766,"endTime":1386.766,"body":"to wake up to their own brokenness as all"},{"startTime":1386.766,"endTime":1390.333,"body":"of the nonsense around wokeness came to"},{"startTime":1390.333,"endTime":1391.933,"body":"light, you would think that they would"},{"startTime":1391.933,"endTime":1394.033,"body":"shudder and realize what they've"},{"startTime":1394.033,"endTime":1397.966,"body":"participated in and go back to being the"},{"startTime":1397.966,"endTime":1399.099,"body":"hard headed liberal"},{"startTime":1399.099,"endTime":1400.599,"body":"publication that they once were."},{"startTime":1401.5,"endTime":1402.633,"body":"No sign of it."},{"startTime":1402.866,"endTime":1404.4,"body":"Yeah, no sign of it."},{"startTime":1405.133,"endTime":1407.333,"body":"So that's exhibit one"},{"startTime":1407.333,"endTime":1409.133,"body":"in the Aurelian landscape"},{"startTime":1410.133,"endTime":1412.599,"body":"that we continue to live in."},{"startTime":1412.599,"endTime":1414.466,"body":"Exhibit two comes from Reuters,"},{"startTime":1416.0,"endTime":1418.799,"body":"who was reporting, reporting which which"},{"startTime":1418.799,"endTime":1420.766,"body":"was Reuters is not a who just as"},{"startTime":1420.766,"endTime":1424.966,"body":"Minneapolis is not a who reporting on the"},{"startTime":1424.966,"endTime":1429.566,"body":"mentally unstable young man who was on"},{"startTime":1429.566,"endTime":1431.966,"body":"both SSRIs and cross sex hormones who"},{"startTime":1431.966,"endTime":1434.366,"body":"opened fire at a Canadian secondary"},{"startTime":1434.366,"endTime":1436.099,"body":"school after killing his own mother and"},{"startTime":1436.099,"endTime":1440.599,"body":"brother and killing nine so far, plus"},{"startTime":1440.599,"endTime":1441.733,"body":"himself probably more."},{"startTime":1442.633,"endTime":1445.766,"body":"So Reuters reported 10 dead after shooter"},{"startTime":1445.766,"endTime":1447.799,"body":"opens fire Canadian high school and rare"},{"startTime":1447.799,"endTime":1451.233,"body":"massacre summary mass shooting took place"},{"startTime":1451.233,"endTime":1451.966,"body":"at school in another"},{"startTime":1451.966,"endTime":1453.133,"body":"location in British Columbia."},{"startTime":1454.033,"endTime":1455.433,"body":"Public alert described the shooter as a"},{"startTime":1455.433,"endTime":1457.266,"body":"female and addressed with brown hair"},{"startTime":1457.266,"endTime":1459.066,"body":"incident among the most deadly mass"},{"startTime":1459.066,"endTime":1459.966,"body":"casualty events in"},{"startTime":1459.966,"endTime":1461.033,"body":"recent Canadian history."},{"startTime":1461.033,"endTime":1462.433,"body":"Now, to be fair to Reuters, they are"},{"startTime":1462.433,"endTime":1464.666,"body":"reporting on what the police,"},{"startTime":1464.966,"endTime":1466.333,"body":"the first police report said."},{"startTime":1466.333,"endTime":1467.433,"body":"So they are they are actually"},{"startTime":1467.433,"endTime":1468.966,"body":"just saying what what was said."},{"startTime":1469.766,"endTime":1470.799,"body":"And then just the first couple of"},{"startTime":1470.799,"endTime":1473.466,"body":"paragraphs in the writer's piece from"},{"startTime":1473.466,"endTime":1475.133,"body":"yesterday, 10 people, including the"},{"startTime":1475.133,"endTime":1476.433,"body":"shooter, are dead after an assailant"},{"startTime":1476.533,"endTime":1478.033,"body":"opened fire at a high school in Western"},{"startTime":1478.033,"endTime":1480.333,"body":"Canada on Tuesday in one of the country's"},{"startTime":1480.333,"endTime":1481.366,"body":"deadliest mass casualty"},{"startTime":1481.366,"endTime":1482.4,"body":"events in recent history."},{"startTime":1483.366,"endTime":1484.766,"body":"The attack brought to Canada the type of"},{"startTime":1484.766,"endTime":1485.966,"body":"mass shooting more common in the"},{"startTime":1485.966,"endTime":1487.566,"body":"neighboring United States and was carried"},{"startTime":1487.566,"endTime":1488.233,"body":"out by a shooter"},{"startTime":1488.233,"endTime":1490.033,"body":"described as female, police said."},{"startTime":1491.833,"endTime":1494.866,"body":"And, you know, even if you haven't heard"},{"startTime":1494.866,"endTime":1496.566,"body":"about this horrifying"},{"startTime":1496.566,"endTime":1498.799,"body":"incident yet, you know what's coming."},{"startTime":1500.7,"endTime":1505.566,"body":"This was not a woman who engaged in a"},{"startTime":1505.566,"endTime":1506.799,"body":"mass shooting at a school."},{"startTime":1507.366,"endTime":1510.366,"body":"This is a confused young man who had"},{"startTime":1510.366,"endTime":1513.733,"body":"mental health issues quite apart from"},{"startTime":1513.733,"endTime":1516.266,"body":"whether or not he was being he believed"},{"startTime":1516.266,"endTime":1519.099,"body":"himself to be female or was encouraged to"},{"startTime":1519.099,"endTime":1521.566,"body":"believe himself to be female, both of"},{"startTime":1521.566,"endTime":1523.0,"body":"which for both of"},{"startTime":1523.0,"endTime":1523.9,"body":"which there is evidence."},{"startTime":1525.5,"endTime":1529.233,"body":"And we are receiving information that"},{"startTime":1529.233,"endTime":1531.299,"body":"reverses reality, that makes it"},{"startTime":1531.299,"endTime":1533.933,"body":"impossible to know what is true."},{"startTime":1534.366,"endTime":1538.666,"body":"And just just as just as when we were"},{"startTime":1538.666,"endTime":1541.966,"body":"assured that the new covid shots that"},{"startTime":1541.966,"endTime":1543.433,"body":"were about to be introduced to the public"},{"startTime":1543.433,"endTime":1546.666,"body":"were safe and effective, and we knew that"},{"startTime":1546.666,"endTime":1548.033,"body":"they could not know they were safe."},{"startTime":1548.033,"endTime":1550.333,"body":"And therefore we had to ask what else are"},{"startTime":1550.333,"endTime":1552.566,"body":"they lying to us about at the point that"},{"startTime":1552.566,"endTime":1555.266,"body":"news organizations, police, whoever it"},{"startTime":1555.266,"endTime":1557.666,"body":"is, start lying to you about something"},{"startTime":1557.666,"endTime":1558.433,"body":"that you can see with"},{"startTime":1558.433,"endTime":1559.9,"body":"your own eyes is not true."},{"startTime":1560.233,"endTime":1561.366,"body":"You have to ask what else"},{"startTime":1561.366,"endTime":1562.4,"body":"are they lying to me about?"},{"startTime":1562.866,"endTime":1564.2,"body":"What else is it?"},{"startTime":1564.2,"endTime":1566.066,"body":"And so there are several"},{"startTime":1566.633,"endTime":1568.433,"body":"photographs out there now."},{"startTime":1568.433,"endTime":1570.966,"body":"If you could show Jennifer Say's tweet"},{"startTime":1570.966,"endTime":1573.233,"body":"and she writes an excellent screed here"},{"startTime":1573.233,"endTime":1576.133,"body":"that we're not going to read through, but"},{"startTime":1576.133,"endTime":1577.966,"body":"at the bottom of it, she has some images"},{"startTime":1579.866,"endTime":1582.599,"body":"and let's just show we don't need to see"},{"startTime":1582.599,"endTime":1584.233,"body":"the one in the range, but this is the"},{"startTime":1584.233,"endTime":1585.466,"body":"young man in question at one"},{"startTime":1585.466,"endTime":1587.733,"body":"of his more attractive moments."},{"startTime":1588.033,"endTime":1589.166,"body":"There are plenty of pictures out there"},{"startTime":1589.166,"endTime":1591.099,"body":"that reveal him to be"},{"startTime":1592.533,"endTime":1595.533,"body":"quite drugged up, both drugs that he's"},{"startTime":1595.533,"endTime":1597.7,"body":"been given by healthcare professionals,"},{"startTime":1597.7,"endTime":1599.566,"body":"SSRIs, and we don't know if he was on"},{"startTime":1599.566,"endTime":1603.2,"body":"cross sex hormones probably, but also"},{"startTime":1603.2,"endTime":1605.133,"body":"several street drugs of his own choosing."},{"startTime":1605.799,"endTime":1609.933,"body":"And then next image that Jennifer Say,"},{"startTime":1612.0,"endTime":1613.266,"body":"probably not going to be able to read"},{"startTime":1613.266,"endTime":1615.366,"body":"this, but this is too small."},{"startTime":1615.766,"endTime":1619.0,"body":"He says this is back in 2023, so a little"},{"startTime":1619.0,"endTime":1622.233,"body":"over two years ago, October of 2023, I"},{"startTime":1622.233,"endTime":1623.966,"body":"went crazy and burnt my house down my"},{"startTime":1623.966,"endTime":1625.599,"body":"second time trying shrooms, but still"},{"startTime":1625.599,"endTime":1626.966,"body":"have a desire to try alternatives."},{"startTime":1628.333,"endTime":1630.866,"body":"And then he talks about, you know, I'm"},{"startTime":1630.866,"endTime":1631.633,"body":"going to keep this brief."},{"startTime":1632.233,"endTime":1634.5,"body":"He's been released from the psych ward."},{"startTime":1634.5,"endTime":1635.866,"body":"He's been diagnosed with, I don't even"},{"startTime":1635.866,"endTime":1638.033,"body":"know what most of these, or half of these"},{"startTime":1638.033,"endTime":1640.333,"body":"diagnoses that he says he's been"},{"startTime":1640.333,"endTime":1643.599,"body":"diagnosed with RADHD, MDD, I think that"},{"startTime":1643.599,"endTime":1644.866,"body":"says this is like an eye test."},{"startTime":1644.866,"endTime":1645.466,"body":"I don't know if those are"},{"startTime":1645.466,"endTime":1649.366,"body":"OCDs, ASD or OCD and OCD."},{"startTime":1649.366,"endTime":1650.0,"body":"So he's been diagnosed"},{"startTime":1650.0,"endTime":1650.766,"body":"with all these things."},{"startTime":1650.766,"endTime":1652.733,"body":"He's in some, you know,"},{"startTime":1653.033,"endTime":1654.866,"body":"diagnosis, happy healthcare system."},{"startTime":1654.866,"endTime":1657.366,"body":"He's been given drugs that are known to"},{"startTime":1657.366,"endTime":1658.066,"body":"make mental"},{"startTime":1658.066,"endTime":1659.866,"body":"instability worse in many cases."},{"startTime":1660.933,"endTime":1664.733,"body":"And now he's putting himself on"},{"startTime":1664.733,"endTime":1668.633,"body":"hallucinogens and let's see now thinking"},{"startTime":1668.633,"endTime":1670.666,"body":"the third paragraph down, maybe fourth,"},{"startTime":1670.666,"endTime":1672.333,"body":"now thinking about extreme harm reduction"},{"startTime":1672.333,"endTime":1676.133,"body":"measures, considering restraint and low"},{"startTime":1676.133,"endTime":1679.033,"body":"doses of DMT, et cetera, et cetera."},{"startTime":1679.033,"endTime":1680.933,"body":"I can't read most of that."},{"startTime":1682.233,"endTime":1684.766,"body":"But this young man had been"},{"startTime":1684.766,"endTime":1686.733,"body":"troubled from a long time ago."},{"startTime":1687.133,"endTime":1690.033,"body":"This is an actively moving"},{"startTime":1690.033,"endTime":1692.333,"body":"story and it's his uncle."},{"startTime":1693.133,"endTime":1695.966,"body":"Who has identified him as the person who"},{"startTime":1695.966,"endTime":1696.933,"body":"was doing the shooting."},{"startTime":1696.933,"endTime":1699.166,"body":"He apparently killed his mother and one"},{"startTime":1699.166,"endTime":1702.466,"body":"of his siblings as well at the family"},{"startTime":1702.466,"endTime":1704.033,"body":"home before going to the school and"},{"startTime":1704.033,"endTime":1706.2,"body":"killing several people, his peers."},{"startTime":1707.666,"endTime":1711.866,"body":"And there is a lot already out about for"},{"startTime":1711.866,"endTime":1715.299,"body":"how long this boy had been troubled."},{"startTime":1716.333,"endTime":1719.033,"body":"There was some evidence that his mother"},{"startTime":1719.033,"endTime":1721.133,"body":"was a trans rights enthusiast."},{"startTime":1722.266,"endTime":1725.333,"body":"We have no idea if she was encouraging"},{"startTime":1725.333,"endTime":1726.633,"body":"him in these delusions."},{"startTime":1726.866,"endTime":1729.066,"body":"She at least early on was concerned about"},{"startTime":1729.066,"endTime":1732.266,"body":"his aggression and apparent violence when"},{"startTime":1732.266,"endTime":1733.599,"body":"he was still quite a young boy."},{"startTime":1734.333,"endTime":1737.066,"body":"All of this is horrible,"},{"startTime":1738.333,"endTime":1739.2,"body":"modern, grotesque,"},{"startTime":1740.233,"endTime":1744.633,"body":"and very much not the behavior of deeply"},{"startTime":1744.633,"endTime":1745.733,"body":"troubled young women."},{"startTime":1746.333,"endTime":1748.833,"body":"Deeply troubled young women do all sorts"},{"startTime":1748.833,"endTime":1751.133,"body":"of harm, but this does not tend to be the"},{"startTime":1751.133,"endTime":1752.566,"body":"kind of thing they do."},{"startTime":1752.966,"endTime":1757.233,"body":"And we are becoming an utterly deranged"},{"startTime":1757.233,"endTime":1760.133,"body":"society when we cannot keep peace from"},{"startTime":1760.133,"endTime":1763.299,"body":"violence with regard to"},{"startTime":1763.299,"endTime":1764.2,"body":"the Nobel Peace Prize."},{"startTime":1764.733,"endTime":1766.633,"body":"And we cannot keep male from female when"},{"startTime":1766.633,"endTime":1769.733,"body":"trying to understand what factors lead to"},{"startTime":1769.733,"endTime":1772.533,"body":"and might have predicted indeed predicted"},{"startTime":1772.533,"endTime":1779.133,"body":"such a fiendish display of murderous rage"},{"startTime":1779.133,"endTime":1781.533,"body":"in no, not a female."},{"startTime":1782.033,"endTime":1783.833,"body":"I don't care if he was wearing a dress."},{"startTime":1784.133,"endTime":1786.266,"body":"That doesn't make you a female."},{"startTime":1786.266,"endTime":1787.299,"body":"It doesn't make you a woman."},{"startTime":1787.533,"endTime":1788.133,"body":"And like, when are we going to grow up?"},{"startTime":1788.133,"endTime":1790.066,"body":"When are we going to grow up?"},{"startTime":1790.433,"endTime":1791.366,"body":"What is happening?"},{"startTime":1792.366,"endTime":1794.799,"body":"So I want to add a couple of things here."},{"startTime":1795.099,"endTime":1798.266,"body":"I'm particularly troubled by the police"},{"startTime":1798.266,"endTime":1801.366,"body":"and then Reuters and many others and many"},{"startTime":1801.366,"endTime":1802.866,"body":"others discussing this as"},{"startTime":1802.866,"endTime":1804.233,"body":"if this had been a woman."},{"startTime":1805.366,"endTime":1808.266,"body":"And yes, I wholeheartedly agree that at"},{"startTime":1808.266,"endTime":1810.033,"body":"one level, the answer is,"},{"startTime":1810.033,"endTime":1810.966,"body":"look, you're just lying."},{"startTime":1811.733,"endTime":1814.066,"body":"And the point is this evidence is that"},{"startTime":1814.066,"endTime":1817.133,"body":"you are willing to lie and therefore it"},{"startTime":1817.133,"endTime":1818.933,"body":"raises exactly the question you suggest"},{"startTime":1818.933,"endTime":1820.633,"body":"about what else are they lying about."},{"startTime":1820.633,"endTime":1821.633,"body":"But I think there's a"},{"startTime":1821.633,"endTime":1823.099,"body":"deeper issue here as well."},{"startTime":1823.466,"endTime":1825.666,"body":"And I want to go back to something that I"},{"startTime":1825.666,"endTime":1827.833,"body":"think we've discussed before called"},{"startTime":1827.833,"endTime":1828.733,"body":"predator inspection."},{"startTime":1830.033,"endTime":1833.2,"body":"There is a phenomenon in nature where"},{"startTime":1833.2,"endTime":1836.633,"body":"when an animal has been captured by"},{"startTime":1836.633,"endTime":1839.566,"body":"another animal when a predation event is"},{"startTime":1839.566,"endTime":1841.4,"body":"occurring, it often"},{"startTime":1841.4,"endTime":1844.433,"body":"attracts other creatures to see."},{"startTime":1845.4,"endTime":1847.866,"body":"And the interpretation of this is that if"},{"startTime":1847.866,"endTime":1849.7,"body":"there is something preying on creatures"},{"startTime":1849.7,"endTime":1853.266,"body":"in your environment, that it makes sense"},{"startTime":1853.733,"endTime":1855.766,"body":"to go find out what it is."},{"startTime":1855.766,"endTime":1856.633,"body":"So, you know, in what"},{"startTime":1856.633,"endTime":1858.533,"body":"way to be more on alert."},{"startTime":1859.266,"endTime":1861.133,"body":"So predator inspection is a real thing"},{"startTime":1861.133,"endTime":1863.0,"body":"because information is a real thing."},{"startTime":1864.066,"endTime":1866.966,"body":"There's a lot that goes into"},{"startTime":1866.966,"endTime":1868.9,"body":"shootings and mass shootings."},{"startTime":1869.7,"endTime":1871.233,"body":"They are not simple events."},{"startTime":1872.433,"endTime":1874.9,"body":"We have a right to process"},{"startTime":1874.9,"endTime":1876.633,"body":"information about patterns."},{"startTime":1877.033,"endTime":1880.966,"body":"There is a very clear pattern about trans"},{"startTime":1880.966,"endTime":1883.633,"body":"women, that is to say men who are"},{"startTime":1883.633,"endTime":1885.133,"body":"presenting as women."},{"startTime":1885.666,"endTime":1887.9,"body":"I'm going to ask that we start using the"},{"startTime":1887.9,"endTime":1889.566,"body":"language trans identified men."},{"startTime":1892.5,"endTime":1894.166,"body":"I that's that's that's the word that I"},{"startTime":1894.166,"endTime":1895.133,"body":"use because there's"},{"startTime":1895.133,"endTime":1896.5,"body":"nothing woman about that guy."},{"startTime":1896.833,"endTime":1897.033,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":1897.566,"endTime":1899.833,"body":"About any any any man who decides to don"},{"startTime":1899.833,"endTime":1902.533,"body":"a dress, whether or not he's, you know,"},{"startTime":1902.533,"endTime":1904.466,"body":"gotten surgery or hormones or whatever."},{"startTime":1905.466,"endTime":1909.066,"body":"The only reason that I am not ready to"},{"startTime":1909.066,"endTime":1911.433,"body":"sign up for that is that I think the"},{"startTime":1911.433,"endTime":1914.666,"body":"problem is it does not tell you the thing"},{"startTime":1914.666,"endTime":1916.599,"body":"that you're trying to clarify with"},{"startTime":1916.599,"endTime":1919.433,"body":"certainty that only if you're in on this"},{"startTime":1919.433,"endTime":1920.333,"body":"discussion, do you"},{"startTime":1920.333,"endTime":1922.166,"body":"understand that that person is a man."},{"startTime":1923.4,"endTime":1925.133,"body":"So I actually I think I"},{"startTime":1925.133,"endTime":1926.233,"body":"think the inverse is true."},{"startTime":1926.233,"endTime":1927.299,"body":"I think that most people when you say"},{"startTime":1927.299,"endTime":1928.233,"body":"trans women, they're like, I"},{"startTime":1928.233,"endTime":1929.566,"body":"don't know what that means."},{"startTime":1929.766,"endTime":1930.7,"body":"I don't I don't know if you mean that's a"},{"startTime":1930.7,"endTime":1931.733,"body":"woman who thinks she's"},{"startTime":1931.733,"endTime":1932.933,"body":"she's a man or that's a man."},{"startTime":1933.2,"endTime":1935.866,"body":"And separate separate question."},{"startTime":1936.133,"endTime":1938.366,"body":"Well, I would say what I would like to"},{"startTime":1938.366,"endTime":1941.333,"body":"see in the meantime, while we are still"},{"startTime":1941.333,"endTime":1944.133,"body":"in this Orwellian landscape, is something"},{"startTime":1944.133,"endTime":1949.0,"body":"like shooting by a trans woman"},{"startTime":1949.0,"endTime":1952.466,"body":"parentheses born male that leaves no."},{"startTime":1952.733,"endTime":1953.166,"body":"I don't like that."},{"startTime":1953.433,"endTime":1953.933,"body":"Well, but here's the"},{"startTime":1953.933,"endTime":1955.266,"body":"reason that here's the reason."},{"startTime":1955.266,"endTime":1956.733,"body":"One male, still male, always male."},{"startTime":1957.0,"endTime":1957.566,"body":"Doesn't change."},{"startTime":1957.966,"endTime":1958.266,"body":"OK."},{"startTime":1959.2,"endTime":1960.633,"body":"So I like I'm as you know."},{"startTime":1961.166,"endTime":1961.2,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1961.266,"endTime":1962.599,"body":"I am sorry."},{"startTime":1963.066,"endTime":1963.599,"body":"Fucking done."},{"startTime":1963.933,"endTime":1964.133,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":1964.433,"endTime":1965.433,"body":"I am done with you."},{"startTime":1965.433,"endTime":1966.799,"body":"I'm with you at the level of done."},{"startTime":1967.666,"endTime":1969.933,"body":"I want to solve the problem, which is we"},{"startTime":1969.933,"endTime":1971.2,"body":"have lost the ability to speak."},{"startTime":1971.466,"endTime":1974.9,"body":"So to your point about Orwell, we have to"},{"startTime":1974.9,"endTime":1977.933,"body":"be able to say that's another one."},{"startTime":1978.533,"endTime":1981.333,"body":"And to the extent that we have decided"},{"startTime":1982.066,"endTime":1984.533,"body":"collectively and maybe we will undecide,"},{"startTime":1984.533,"endTime":1986.733,"body":"but to the extent that we have decided"},{"startTime":1986.733,"endTime":1989.766,"body":"collectively to say that a trans woman is"},{"startTime":1989.766,"endTime":1991.933,"body":"born male, presenting as female."},{"startTime":1993.066,"endTime":1995.566,"body":"We have a right to notice the pattern"},{"startTime":1995.966,"endTime":1997.566,"body":"that is these people keep"},{"startTime":1997.566,"endTime":1999.366,"body":"engaging in mass shootings."},{"startTime":1999.833,"endTime":2003.166,"body":"These people are generally on SSR eyes,"},{"startTime":2003.166,"endTime":2005.166,"body":"which are also connected to both"},{"startTime":2005.166,"endTime":2007.033,"body":"self-harm and murder."},{"startTime":2008.033,"endTime":2009.833,"body":"And it is it is this point"},{"startTime":2009.833,"endTime":2010.799,"body":"about predator inspection."},{"startTime":2011.366,"endTime":2013.966,"body":"We have a right to have the presentation"},{"startTime":2013.966,"endTime":2015.766,"body":"of evidence allow us"},{"startTime":2015.766,"endTime":2017.533,"body":"to recognize a pattern."},{"startTime":2017.533,"endTime":2019.333,"body":"And what is going on here, both on the"},{"startTime":2019.333,"endTime":2021.599,"body":"part of the police and the part of the"},{"startTime":2021.599,"endTime":2025.866,"body":"press, is that they are directly covering"},{"startTime":2025.866,"endTime":2028.666,"body":"for pharma at the very least."},{"startTime":2029.033,"endTime":2032.2,"body":"The idea that pharma has been pushing a"},{"startTime":2032.2,"endTime":2035.599,"body":"medicalized idea of transition, that it"},{"startTime":2035.599,"endTime":2037.233,"body":"is connected to violence in"},{"startTime":2037.233,"endTime":2038.7,"body":"a way that is unmistakable."},{"startTime":2039.2,"endTime":2043.4,"body":"And the police and the press presumably"},{"startTime":2043.4,"endTime":2045.966,"body":"motivated out of some wrongheaded desire"},{"startTime":2045.966,"endTime":2050.133,"body":"not to be insensitive to murderers is"},{"startTime":2050.133,"endTime":2054.766,"body":"covering and obscuring the pattern that"},{"startTime":2054.766,"endTime":2056.833,"body":"we of course should be talking about,"},{"startTime":2057.033,"endTime":2058.8,"body":"along with any other pattern that is"},{"startTime":2058.8,"endTime":2060.133,"body":"connected to these events."},{"startTime":2060.533,"endTime":2064.8,"body":"This is a larger, a more global version"},{"startTime":2064.8,"endTime":2068.233,"body":"of what many women, including myself,"},{"startTime":2068.233,"endTime":2070.466,"body":"have been talking about with regard to"},{"startTime":2070.466,"endTime":2074.333,"body":"the harms enacted by the trans activism"},{"startTime":2074.333,"endTime":2077.566,"body":"on women, which is that we are told, you"},{"startTime":2077.566,"endTime":2079.033,"body":"know, do not believe your lying eyes,"},{"startTime":2079.533,"endTime":2081.466,"body":"believe my delusion, believe my fantasy,"},{"startTime":2081.466,"endTime":2083.233,"body":"it would be disrespectful not to."},{"startTime":2084.133,"endTime":2086.466,"body":"And furthermore, if you, you know, you"},{"startTime":2086.466,"endTime":2089.5,"body":"have if you get that tingling on the top"},{"startTime":2089.5,"endTime":2090.866,"body":"of your head, the back of your head and"},{"startTime":2090.866,"endTime":2092.066,"body":"back of your neck, you"},{"startTime":2092.066,"endTime":2093.4,"body":"sense, am I being followed?"},{"startTime":2094.366,"endTime":2095.766,"body":"And like, look at that guy."},{"startTime":2096.433,"endTime":2099.733,"body":"These these are things that women have"},{"startTime":2099.733,"endTime":2102.766,"body":"been honing for, I'm gonna go with"},{"startTime":2102.766,"endTime":2105.366,"body":"millions of years, have always been"},{"startTime":2105.366,"endTime":2108.633,"body":"encouraged to become aware of to become"},{"startTime":2108.633,"endTime":2111.566,"body":"hyper aware of and to listen to our"},{"startTime":2111.566,"endTime":2113.566,"body":"instincts, even if it might mean that"},{"startTime":2113.566,"endTime":2115.199,"body":"that looks offensive to someone."},{"startTime":2115.466,"endTime":2117.366,"body":"I'm sorry, it's not worth getting"},{"startTime":2117.366,"endTime":2119.3,"body":"murdered over not looking offensive."},{"startTime":2119.666,"endTime":2123.233,"body":"So the idea for a while now, like, oh,"},{"startTime":2123.333,"endTime":2125.199,"body":"actually, I'm not supposed to point out"},{"startTime":2125.199,"endTime":2126.033,"body":"that that's a dude"},{"startTime":2126.033,"endTime":2127.633,"body":"wearing a dress and lipstick."},{"startTime":2128.266,"endTime":2130.666,"body":"No, I am going to point that out."},{"startTime":2130.666,"endTime":2132.666,"body":"And I'm going to be hyper aware of it."},{"startTime":2132.666,"endTime":2134.633,"body":"Because frankly, you're using your"},{"startTime":2134.633,"endTime":2137.966,"body":"cosplay, your fantasy to get into spaces"},{"startTime":2137.966,"endTime":2139.433,"body":"where you don't belong."},{"startTime":2140.199,"endTime":2142.966,"body":"And obviously, you know, murderous rage"},{"startTime":2143.566,"endTime":2145.9,"body":"is an extreme version of"},{"startTime":2145.9,"endTime":2147.733,"body":"going places you should never go."},{"startTime":2148.166,"endTime":2150.433,"body":"But part of what is happening when we're"},{"startTime":2150.466,"endTime":2153.0,"body":"told, oh, it's it's a it's a trans"},{"startTime":2153.0,"endTime":2154.233,"body":"woman's like, no, it's not."},{"startTime":2154.533,"endTime":2156.4,"body":"That is a man who has been mentally"},{"startTime":2156.4,"endTime":2158.699,"body":"unstable since he was a boy, who has been"},{"startTime":2158.699,"endTime":2159.9,"body":"on drugs that"},{"startTime":2159.9,"endTime":2161.533,"body":"probably no one should be on."},{"startTime":2162.233,"endTime":2163.666,"body":"And, you know, I'll"},{"startTime":2163.666,"endTime":2164.766,"body":"get pushback from that."},{"startTime":2164.766,"endTime":2166.833,"body":"But there is, you know, ample evidence"},{"startTime":2166.833,"endTime":2168.666,"body":"that SSRIs are terrible for almost"},{"startTime":2168.666,"endTime":2169.699,"body":"everyone they're on."},{"startTime":2170.133,"endTime":2172.0,"body":"I don't I have not seen any evidence that"},{"startTime":2172.0,"endTime":2173.233,"body":"he was on cross sex hormones."},{"startTime":2174.066,"endTime":2175.566,"body":"But, you know, these"},{"startTime":2175.566,"endTime":2178.033,"body":"these are deranging as well."},{"startTime":2178.266,"endTime":2179.4,"body":"They're more likely to be deranging."},{"startTime":2180.066,"endTime":2182.633,"body":"If you're a woman on testosterone on"},{"startTime":2182.633,"endTime":2185.066,"body":"inexperienced with the levels of"},{"startTime":2185.066,"endTime":2186.366,"body":"exogenous testosterone you're now"},{"startTime":2186.366,"endTime":2188.533,"body":"getting, but especially as a young person"},{"startTime":2188.533,"endTime":2190.5,"body":"who is still going through active puberty"},{"startTime":2190.5,"endTime":2193.366,"body":"as an 18 year old man typically will be"},{"startTime":2193.366,"endTime":2197.3,"body":"receiving exogenous cross sex hormones is"},{"startTime":2197.3,"endTime":2199.733,"body":"is not going to help with what"},{"startTime":2199.733,"endTime":2201.666,"body":"is clearly mental instability."},{"startTime":2202.599,"endTime":2205.333,"body":"And as you say, like we are we are"},{"startTime":2205.5,"endTime":2208.733,"body":"entitled to and we actually are obligated"},{"startTime":2208.733,"endTime":2210.133,"body":"to do pattern"},{"startTime":2210.133,"endTime":2211.733,"body":"recognition for our own selves."},{"startTime":2211.733,"endTime":2214.9,"body":"And on behalf of those whom we care about"},{"startTime":2214.9,"endTime":2218.333,"body":"and when we get when we get garbage like"},{"startTime":2218.333,"endTime":2221.166,"body":"this saying, well, you know, it would"},{"startTime":2221.166,"endTime":2223.766,"body":"seem to be that the logic"},{"startTime":2223.766,"endTime":2226.266,"body":"was the person was an address."},{"startTime":2226.566,"endTime":2227.9,"body":"Therefore, the person was"},{"startTime":2227.9,"endTime":2229.533,"body":"a woman, which is absurd."},{"startTime":2229.533,"endTime":2230.966,"body":"And then there's a press conference in"},{"startTime":2230.966,"endTime":2231.566,"body":"which they're"},{"startTime":2231.566,"endTime":2232.966,"body":"referring to the gun person."},{"startTime":2234.033,"endTime":2236.833,"body":"Yeah, the gun person, like, you know,"},{"startTime":2237.033,"endTime":2240.166,"body":"maybe, maybe there should be, excuse me,"},{"startTime":2240.166,"endTime":2241.5,"body":"a gender neutral term for gunmen."},{"startTime":2242.9,"endTime":2243.266,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":2243.666,"endTime":2244.633,"body":"You can't create it."},{"startTime":2244.633,"endTime":2246.466,"body":"That's part of part of Orville's point is"},{"startTime":2246.466,"endTime":2248.066,"body":"that we don't you know, we can't just"},{"startTime":2248.066,"endTime":2249.733,"body":"decree that there's now a new word for"},{"startTime":2249.733,"endTime":2251.033,"body":"something and in for"},{"startTime":2251.033,"endTime":2251.933,"body":"law and make it happen."},{"startTime":2253.4,"endTime":2256.0,"body":"But gun person is actually that's got a"},{"startTime":2256.0,"endTime":2257.466,"body":"backfire on them because now anytime"},{"startTime":2257.466,"endTime":2259.266,"body":"anyone uses the term gun person, it's"},{"startTime":2259.266,"endTime":2261.4,"body":"like, oh, it's a dude in lipstick."},{"startTime":2261.4,"endTime":2261.833,"body":"Great."},{"startTime":2262.766,"endTime":2263.8,"body":"Like that's that's what we got."},{"startTime":2264.099,"endTime":2264.3,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":2265.033,"endTime":2267.5,"body":"Well, OK, I do want to make one more"},{"startTime":2267.5,"endTime":2268.566,"body":"point, which is that"},{"startTime":2268.566,"endTime":2270.966,"body":"there is a legitimate issue."},{"startTime":2271.466,"endTime":2273.766,"body":"Like, let's say that I don't know when"},{"startTime":2274.866,"endTime":2276.866,"body":"the report came out by the police."},{"startTime":2276.866,"endTime":2278.166,"body":"I don't know if this all went down so"},{"startTime":2278.166,"endTime":2279.666,"body":"fast that the report was actually"},{"startTime":2279.666,"endTime":2281.133,"body":"effectively after it was over."},{"startTime":2281.133,"endTime":2282.633,"body":"I wasn't following real time."},{"startTime":2283.266,"endTime":2285.133,"body":"But let's say that you've got a real time"},{"startTime":2285.133,"endTime":2289.166,"body":"active shooter situation and you are"},{"startTime":2289.166,"endTime":2289.933,"body":"trying to put out"},{"startTime":2289.933,"endTime":2291.633,"body":"information that is a warning."},{"startTime":2292.266,"endTime":2293.266,"body":"Now you have an issue, which"},{"startTime":2293.266,"endTime":2294.733,"body":"is what am I on the lookout for?"},{"startTime":2294.966,"endTime":2297.733,"body":"You are looking for a man who may well be"},{"startTime":2297.733,"endTime":2299.033,"body":"presenting as a woman, either"},{"startTime":2299.033,"endTime":2300.866,"body":"compellingly or not compellingly."},{"startTime":2301.166,"endTime":2302.666,"body":"So if it really was"},{"startTime":2302.666,"endTime":2303.733,"body":"like fog of war stuff."},{"startTime":2303.733,"endTime":2304.033,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":2304.466,"endTime":2306.133,"body":"And all they knew was wearing a dress."},{"startTime":2306.633,"endTime":2307.566,"body":"You could say person and"},{"startTime":2307.566,"endTime":2308.733,"body":"person wearing a"},{"startTime":2308.733,"endTime":2311.566,"body":"dress, email and address is is which is"},{"startTime":2311.566,"endTime":2314.533,"body":"what was written is simply wrong."},{"startTime":2315.0,"endTime":2316.466,"body":"Simply and anyone who got"},{"startTime":2316.466,"endTime":2317.866,"body":"anywhere close would have known."},{"startTime":2317.866,"endTime":2318.066,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":2318.466,"endTime":2321.066,"body":"So all I'm saying is, hey, this is"},{"startTime":2321.066,"endTime":2322.866,"body":"journalistic and police"},{"startTime":2322.866,"endTime":2325.866,"body":"malpractice to be giving us"},{"startTime":2328.366,"endTime":2331.933,"body":"contentious, misleading representations"},{"startTime":2331.933,"endTime":2333.633,"body":"in place of actual information."},{"startTime":2333.633,"endTime":2334.633,"body":"What you actually have to do"},{"startTime":2334.633,"endTime":2336.133,"body":"is give us the information."},{"startTime":2336.866,"endTime":2337.633,"body":"We can sort out later"},{"startTime":2337.633,"endTime":2338.599,"body":"what to think about it."},{"startTime":2338.9,"endTime":2338.933,"body":"But"},{"startTime":2340.533,"endTime":2342.233,"body":"but we need to come to an agreement."},{"startTime":2342.833,"endTime":2343.066,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":2343.066,"endTime":2346.566,"body":"The as I've discussed other times, the"},{"startTime":2346.566,"endTime":2348.633,"body":"idea that the New York Times reports"},{"startTime":2348.633,"endTime":2351.933,"body":"Chelsea Manning giving documents to"},{"startTime":2351.933,"endTime":2355.166,"body":"Julian Assange just is not true."},{"startTime":2355.166,"endTime":2355.9,"body":"It's a fiction."},{"startTime":2356.466,"endTime":2357.233,"body":"You can't do that."},{"startTime":2357.233,"endTime":2360.266,"body":"You can say Bradley Manning, who now goes"},{"startTime":2360.266,"endTime":2363.266,"body":"by Chelsea Manning, but you can't make"},{"startTime":2363.266,"endTime":2365.099,"body":"shit up and they're making shit up."},{"startTime":2365.099,"endTime":2366.933,"body":"And it's going to get people killed"},{"startTime":2366.933,"endTime":2370.133,"body":"because there are lots of patterns here."},{"startTime":2370.133,"endTime":2372.266,"body":"If one of them is that something about"},{"startTime":2372.266,"endTime":2375.566,"body":"trans ideology, about the medications,"},{"startTime":2376.3,"endTime":2379.533,"body":"about the counseling, whatever it is that"},{"startTime":2379.533,"endTime":2383.266,"body":"is causing trans people to engage in mass"},{"startTime":2383.266,"endTime":2386.033,"body":"killings is something that we have a"},{"startTime":2386.033,"endTime":2387.233,"body":"right to grapple with."},{"startTime":2387.433,"endTime":2390.533,"body":"And you are covering for the killers."},{"startTime":2391.5,"endTime":2393.933,"body":"It's not a reasonable thing to do."},{"startTime":2393.933,"endTime":2395.599,"body":"No reasonable person would conclude this"},{"startTime":2395.599,"endTime":2398.266,"body":"except in an Orwellian age"},{"startTime":2398.266,"endTime":2400.166,"body":"where reason isn't a thing."},{"startTime":2400.666,"endTime":2400.866,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":2401.666,"endTime":2404.133,"body":"OK, but at least we have the"},{"startTime":2407.733,"endTime":2411.9,"body":"the the the public has been creating a"},{"startTime":2411.9,"endTime":2414.866,"body":"world encyclopedia for 25 years now."},{"startTime":2415.433,"endTime":2417.3,"body":"And it's it's extraordinary, is it not?"},{"startTime":2419.766,"endTime":2421.5,"body":"So can you see my screen?"},{"startTime":2422.366,"endTime":2424.266,"body":"Nature, the International Journal of"},{"startTime":2424.266,"endTime":2428.233,"body":"Science, Nature on January 29th of 2026"},{"startTime":2428.233,"endTime":2432.666,"body":"wrote an opinion piece titled Wikipedia"},{"startTime":2432.666,"endTime":2434.266,"body":"is needed now more than ever."},{"startTime":2434.266,"endTime":2436.433,"body":"Twenty five years on the online"},{"startTime":2436.433,"endTime":2438.3,"body":"encyclopedia is an antidote to an"},{"startTime":2438.3,"endTime":2439.266,"body":"increasingly poison"},{"startTime":2439.266,"endTime":2440.433,"body":"information ecosystem."},{"startTime":2441.266,"endTime":2443.266,"body":"Researchers should help to nourish it."},{"startTime":2444.599,"endTime":2445.333,"body":"So upside down."},{"startTime":2445.533,"endTime":2449.033,"body":"There was a time, there was a time, that"},{"startTime":2449.033,"endTime":2452.166,"body":"time has passed when Wikipedia was"},{"startTime":2452.166,"endTime":2456.266,"body":"actually extraordinarily useful as a"},{"startTime":2456.266,"endTime":2461.166,"body":"human sourced human actively engaged with"},{"startTime":2461.166,"endTime":2465.133,"body":"fact checked repository of information."},{"startTime":2466.566,"endTime":2467.099,"body":"We have"},{"startTime":2469.566,"endTime":2471.599,"body":"we got slandered in Wikipedia early in"},{"startTime":2471.599,"endTime":2472.599,"body":"talking about Covid."},{"startTime":2473.066,"endTime":2474.866,"body":"And I think they've actually backtracked"},{"startTime":2474.866,"endTime":2476.233,"body":"a little bit, but it's still insane."},{"startTime":2476.533,"endTime":2476.733,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":2477.233,"endTime":2479.866,"body":"And and many people have experienced far"},{"startTime":2479.866,"endTime":2481.866,"body":"more absurd, absurd"},{"startTime":2481.866,"endTime":2483.466,"body":"treatment in Wikipedia."},{"startTime":2485.266,"endTime":2486.766,"body":"And here is Nature, the International"},{"startTime":2486.766,"endTime":2489.0,"body":"Journal of Science, Nature, which is it's"},{"startTime":2489.0,"endTime":2490.033,"body":"I did not know before"},{"startTime":2490.033,"endTime":2493.466,"body":"that was its tagline writing."},{"startTime":2493.733,"endTime":2494.933,"body":"And I'm just going to read a couple"},{"startTime":2494.933,"endTime":2497.199,"body":"little bits from this short bad piece."},{"startTime":2497.466,"endTime":2498.4,"body":"Wikipedia is 25."},{"startTime":2498.633,"endTime":2499.666,"body":"They write the world's largest"},{"startTime":2499.666,"endTime":2501.566,"body":"encyclopedia celebrated its birthday on"},{"startTime":2501.566,"endTime":2502.566,"body":"the 15th of January."},{"startTime":2503.233,"endTime":2504.866,"body":"This is a remarkable milestone, not just"},{"startTime":2504.866,"endTime":2506.599,"body":"because of the website's longevity and"},{"startTime":2506.599,"endTime":2508.766,"body":"enduring relevance, but also because it"},{"startTime":2508.766,"endTime":2510.733,"body":"has retained its founding values."},{"startTime":2511.366,"endTime":2512.433,"body":"These are worth reiterating."},{"startTime":2512.666,"endTime":2514.266,"body":"Wikipedia is free to use, is extremely"},{"startTime":2514.3,"endTime":2517.5,"body":"participatory and aims for a high degree"},{"startTime":2517.5,"endTime":2519.166,"body":"of transparency in its content."},{"startTime":2521.8,"endTime":2526.199,"body":"Let me go a little bit"},{"startTime":2526.199,"endTime":2527.366,"body":"later in the article here."},{"startTime":2528.233,"endTime":2530.633,"body":"They say to accommodate such a"},{"startTime":2530.633,"endTime":2532.433,"body":"collaborative effort, Wikipedia has had"},{"startTime":2532.433,"endTime":2533.8,"body":"to develop and adapt its working"},{"startTime":2533.8,"endTime":2535.0,"body":"practices, which are"},{"startTime":2535.0,"endTime":2536.333,"body":"summarized in five pillars."},{"startTime":2537.033,"endTime":2537.666,"body":"Most famous is"},{"startTime":2537.666,"endTime":2539.966,"body":"Wikipedia's neutral point of view."},{"startTime":2541.066,"endTime":2542.433,"body":"This principle requires"},{"startTime":2542.433,"endTime":2544.366,"body":"editors to be accurate and fair."},{"startTime":2544.933,"endTime":2546.266,"body":"The entry on climate change, for"},{"startTime":2546.266,"endTime":2547.733,"body":"instance, states clearly that the modern"},{"startTime":2547.733,"endTime":2549.566,"body":"increase in global temperatures is caused"},{"startTime":2549.566,"endTime":2550.699,"body":"by human activities."},{"startTime":2551.166,"endTime":2553.0,"body":"But it also discusses the misinformation"},{"startTime":2553.0,"endTime":2554.766,"body":"that informs climate denial."},{"startTime":2556.733,"endTime":2559.833,"body":"I'm just"},{"startTime":2559.833,"endTime":2562.933,"body":"not only did somebody write that, but it"},{"startTime":2562.933,"endTime":2565.666,"body":"got through the editorial process without"},{"startTime":2565.666,"endTime":2568.766,"body":"anyone understanding the Orwellian"},{"startTime":2568.766,"endTime":2570.0,"body":"upside-downness of it."},{"startTime":2570.333,"endTime":2573.433,"body":"Yeah, the neutral point of view that"},{"startTime":2573.433,"endTime":2576.766,"body":"includes clearly this position that"},{"startTime":2576.766,"endTime":2578.166,"body":"you're not allowed to"},{"startTime":2578.233,"endTime":2579.933,"body":"disagree with for why?"},{"startTime":2579.933,"endTime":2581.433,"body":"For political reasons, not for scientific"},{"startTime":2581.433,"endTime":2584.533,"body":"reasons, but it's neutral and balanced"},{"startTime":2584.533,"endTime":2586.666,"body":"and fair, presumably as well, because it"},{"startTime":2586.666,"endTime":2588.733,"body":"provides the other position, which, oh,"},{"startTime":2588.733,"endTime":2589.5,"body":"by the way, is misinformation."},{"startTime":2589.933,"endTime":2590.633,"body":"We all know that."},{"startTime":2590.633,"endTime":2591.4,"body":"Can't we know that?"},{"startTime":2591.4,"endTime":2591.666,"body":"We don't."},{"startTime":2591.666,"endTime":2592.699,"body":"We know that because we're reading it"},{"startTime":2592.699,"endTime":2593.866,"body":"right here in Nature, the"},{"startTime":2593.866,"endTime":2595.433,"body":"International Journal of Science."},{"startTime":2596.266,"endTime":2598.233,"body":"And that demonstrates that the neutral"},{"startTime":2598.233,"endTime":2600.666,"body":"point of view to which Wikipedia aspires"},{"startTime":2600.666,"endTime":2602.033,"body":"is in fact being met."},{"startTime":2603.333,"endTime":2603.5,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":2603.5,"endTime":2606.033,"body":"Which, of course, you know, the sad"},{"startTime":2606.033,"endTime":2609.433,"body":"reality is that Wikipedia was for a time"},{"startTime":2609.433,"endTime":2612.199,"body":"the greatest encyclopedia ever assembled."},{"startTime":2612.566,"endTime":2614.199,"body":"It is still the most complete."},{"startTime":2614.466,"endTime":2617.699,"body":"But the problem is there are entries in"},{"startTime":2617.699,"endTime":2618.9,"body":"there that have no"},{"startTime":2618.9,"endTime":2620.366,"body":"reason to be misleading."},{"startTime":2620.8,"endTime":2622.599,"body":"I'm sure if you look up quasars, you'll"},{"startTime":2622.599,"endTime":2624.766,"body":"get a pretty decent rundown of what we"},{"startTime":2624.766,"endTime":2626.599,"body":"know about quasars because there's"},{"startTime":2626.599,"endTime":2627.533,"body":"nothing riding on it"},{"startTime":2627.533,"endTime":2629.266,"body":"politically or economically."},{"startTime":2629.9,"endTime":2631.366,"body":"But every place where there is stuff"},{"startTime":2631.366,"endTime":2634.433,"body":"riding on it, this is a captured, gamed"},{"startTime":2634.433,"endTime":2636.599,"body":"and hijacked institution."},{"startTime":2637.566,"endTime":2640.133,"body":"And it simply mislead."},{"startTime":2640.466,"endTime":2642.366,"body":"So in some sense, the true stuff, which"},{"startTime":2642.366,"endTime":2644.933,"body":"might even be the majority of it, is the"},{"startTime":2644.933,"endTime":2648.233,"body":"loss leader that covers for the fact that"},{"startTime":2648.233,"endTime":2651.766,"body":"it is basically distributing propaganda"},{"startTime":2651.766,"endTime":2657.066,"body":"everywhere where people are battling over"},{"startTime":2657.066,"endTime":2659.466,"body":"things with important ramifications for"},{"startTime":2659.466,"endTime":2663.033,"body":"profitability or guilt or whatever it is."},{"startTime":2663.333,"endTime":2667.733,"body":"So, you know, it's one of the saddest"},{"startTime":2667.733,"endTime":2670.599,"body":"stories in the entire Internet age"},{"startTime":2670.599,"endTime":2673.266,"body":"because how you had this thing that"},{"startTime":2673.266,"endTime":2675.166,"body":"humanity could benefit from."},{"startTime":2675.166,"endTime":2676.766,"body":"I mean, you remember, encyclopedias used"},{"startTime":2676.766,"endTime":2678.766,"body":"to be these expensive things."},{"startTime":2680.066,"endTime":2681.8,"body":"I'm sure you had a line of them in some"},{"startTime":2681.8,"endTime":2683.533,"body":"bookshelf at your house growing up."},{"startTime":2683.533,"endTime":2684.266,"body":"We certainly did."},{"startTime":2684.266,"endTime":2685.533,"body":"We had an encyclopedia and"},{"startTime":2685.533,"endTime":2687.066,"body":"we were lucky to have it."},{"startTime":2687.833,"endTime":2689.866,"body":"But the idea that suddenly this was going"},{"startTime":2689.866,"endTime":2691.666,"body":"to be available to everybody, something"},{"startTime":2691.666,"endTime":2693.066,"body":"vastly more complete than the"},{"startTime":2693.066,"endTime":2695.333,"body":"encyclopedias you and I remember was"},{"startTime":2695.333,"endTime":2697.066,"body":"going to be available to anybody who"},{"startTime":2697.066,"endTime":2698.533,"body":"could get themselves to the Internet."},{"startTime":2698.866,"endTime":2700.866,"body":"And then anybody who could get there with"},{"startTime":2700.866,"endTime":2702.8,"body":"their phone having the world's greatest"},{"startTime":2702.8,"endTime":2704.133,"body":"encyclopedia in your pocket."},{"startTime":2704.133,"endTime":2705.4,"body":"This was a gift to humanity."},{"startTime":2705.4,"endTime":2707.199,"body":"And it's a major"},{"startTime":2707.199,"endTime":2708.566,"body":"tragedy that it vanished."},{"startTime":2709.033,"endTime":2710.8,"body":"And like so many of the things in our"},{"startTime":2710.8,"endTime":2712.566,"body":"landscape, because it"},{"startTime":2712.566,"endTime":2716.199,"body":"exists, it can't be replaced."},{"startTime":2717.066,"endTime":2717.266,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":2717.866,"endTime":2721.099,"body":"But we can't allow the institutions to"},{"startTime":2721.099,"endTime":2723.133,"body":"fail, but they have failed"},{"startTime":2723.133,"endTime":2723.866,"body":"there for me to replace them."},{"startTime":2723.9,"endTime":2725.466,"body":"But no, you're misunderstanding."},{"startTime":2726.133,"endTime":2726.733,"body":"They exist."},{"startTime":2726.733,"endTime":2728.533,"body":"Therefore, they must be good."},{"startTime":2729.066,"endTime":2731.066,"body":"Like this is the sort of crazy circular"},{"startTime":2731.066,"endTime":2732.233,"body":"argument you get from people"},{"startTime":2732.233,"endTime":2733.699,"body":"when you say it's already gone."},{"startTime":2734.233,"endTime":2735.933,"body":"I know it's standing there in front of"},{"startTime":2735.933,"endTime":2737.099,"body":"you, but it's a skin suit."},{"startTime":2737.933,"endTime":2738.133,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":2738.366,"endTime":2740.366,"body":"And so, you know, whether we're talking"},{"startTime":2740.366,"endTime":2743.333,"body":"about Wikipedia or the FBI, you might"},{"startTime":2743.333,"endTime":2745.366,"body":"need something that does this job."},{"startTime":2745.366,"endTime":2746.566,"body":"But the fact that there's already"},{"startTime":2746.566,"endTime":2748.733,"body":"something that gets all of the traffic"},{"startTime":2748.733,"endTime":2750.433,"body":"and all of the attention and all of the"},{"startTime":2750.533,"endTime":2752.633,"body":"legitimacy and has the budget means"},{"startTime":2752.633,"endTime":2753.933,"body":"there's no room to build it."},{"startTime":2754.5,"endTime":2756.966,"body":"Now, kudos to Elon Musk"},{"startTime":2756.966,"endTime":2759.0,"body":"for building Graka Pedia."},{"startTime":2759.333,"endTime":2761.866,"body":"Early signs are it's just simply hands"},{"startTime":2761.866,"endTime":2763.966,"body":"down better for the fraction of the"},{"startTime":2763.966,"endTime":2765.666,"body":"material that it already covers,"},{"startTime":2765.666,"endTime":2767.933,"body":"including coverage of you and me."},{"startTime":2769.366,"endTime":2772.599,"body":"But it's a hard slog because of the"},{"startTime":2772.599,"endTime":2775.4,"body":"network effects of, you know, the first"},{"startTime":2775.4,"endTime":2776.566,"body":"case in which something"},{"startTime":2776.566,"endTime":2777.733,"body":"like this was accomplished."},{"startTime":2778.533,"endTime":2780.5,"body":"It's such a loss."},{"startTime":2780.966,"endTime":2781.966,"body":"Yeah, it really is."},{"startTime":2783.233,"endTime":2785.3,"body":"I just want to do one little bit from"},{"startTime":2785.3,"endTime":2787.566,"body":"Orwell before we transition into the rest"},{"startTime":2787.566,"endTime":2789.166,"body":"of the rest of what we're"},{"startTime":2789.166,"endTime":2790.0,"body":"going to talk about today."},{"startTime":2790.0,"endTime":2790.199,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":2790.833,"endTime":2791.033,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":2791.199,"endTime":2792.233,"body":"You use the word transition."},{"startTime":2792.633,"endTime":2793.733,"body":"Suddenly I was jarred,"},{"startTime":2793.966,"endTime":2795.033,"body":"but it's a real word."},{"startTime":2795.266,"endTime":2795.699,"body":"Segway."},{"startTime":2795.699,"endTime":2796.166,"body":"Segway."},{"startTime":2796.733,"endTime":2796.933,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":2797.166,"endTime":2797.433,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":2800.233,"endTime":2801.033,"body":"So three years before"},{"startTime":2801.033,"endTime":2802.833,"body":"1984 was published in 1949,"},{"startTime":2803.866,"endTime":2805.533,"body":"Orwell published an essay called"},{"startTime":2805.533,"endTime":2806.133,"body":"\"Politics and the"},{"startTime":2806.133,"endTime":2808.233,"body":"English Language\" in 1946."},{"startTime":2808.966,"endTime":2812.733,"body":"And this is a cute little book that"},{"startTime":2812.733,"endTime":2814.5,"body":"includes several of his essays, including"},{"startTime":2814.5,"endTime":2816.0,"body":"\"Politics and the English Language.\""},{"startTime":2816.266,"endTime":2823.033,"body":"So I want to read just a page from this."},{"startTime":2825.8,"endTime":2827.933,"body":"Orwell writes, \"I, Orwell, am going to"},{"startTime":2827.933,"endTime":2830.033,"body":"translate a passage of good English into"},{"startTime":2830.033,"endTime":2831.733,"body":"modern English of the worst sort.\""},{"startTime":2831.966,"endTime":2835.4,"body":"So this is him talking about how in 1946,"},{"startTime":2836.4,"endTime":2841.166,"body":"the language that he loves was becoming a"},{"startTime":2841.166,"endTime":2846.9,"body":"gunky mess by its most literate users and"},{"startTime":2846.9,"endTime":2848.066,"body":"that this is, you know, no"},{"startTime":2848.066,"endTime":2849.333,"body":"fault but all of our own."},{"startTime":2849.533,"endTime":2849.733,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":2849.966,"endTime":2853.133,"body":"So he says, \"I'm going to translate a"},{"startTime":2853.133,"endTime":2854.533,"body":"passage of good English into modern"},{"startTime":2854.533,"endTime":2855.633,"body":"English of the worst sort.\""},{"startTime":2856.133,"endTime":2857.166,"body":"Here is a well-known"},{"startTime":2857.166,"endTime":2858.633,"body":"verse from Ecclesiastes."},{"startTime":2860.099,"endTime":2861.966,"body":"\"I returned and saw under the sun that"},{"startTime":2861.966,"endTime":2863.766,"body":"the race is not to the swift nor the"},{"startTime":2863.766,"endTime":2865.933,"body":"battle to the strong, neither yet bred to"},{"startTime":2865.933,"endTime":2867.733,"body":"the wise nor yet riches to men of"},{"startTime":2867.733,"endTime":2869.666,"body":"understanding nor yet favor to men of"},{"startTime":2869.666,"endTime":2871.4,"body":"skill, but time and"},{"startTime":2871.4,"endTime":2873.099,"body":"chance happeneth to them all.\""},{"startTime":2875.233,"endTime":2876.633,"body":"Here is Orwell's modern"},{"startTime":2876.633,"endTime":2879.0,"body":"English rendering of Ecclesiastes."},{"startTime":2880.266,"endTime":2882.133,"body":"\"Objective consideration of contemporary"},{"startTime":2882.133,"endTime":2884.366,"body":"phenomena compels the conclusion that"},{"startTime":2884.366,"endTime":2885.666,"body":"success or failure in competitive"},{"startTime":2885.666,"endTime":2887.733,"body":"activities exhibits no tendency to be"},{"startTime":2887.733,"endTime":2889.699,"body":"commensurate with innate capacity, but"},{"startTime":2889.699,"endTime":2891.333,"body":"that a considerable element of the"},{"startTime":2891.333,"endTime":2892.166,"body":"unpredictable must"},{"startTime":2892.166,"endTime":2895.166,"body":"invariably be taken into account.\""},{"startTime":2895.166,"endTime":2897.433,"body":"That's beautiful."},{"startTime":2897.733,"endTime":2898.566,"body":"It's beautiful, right?"},{"startTime":2898.933,"endTime":2901.033,"body":"Let me just read a little bit of his"},{"startTime":2901.033,"endTime":2902.333,"body":"analysis of what he's done here."},{"startTime":2902.599,"endTime":2903.666,"body":"This, Orwell writes, is a"},{"startTime":2903.666,"endTime":2905.699,"body":"parody but not a very gross one."},{"startTime":2906.833,"endTime":2908.3,"body":"\"The beginning and ending of the sentence"},{"startTime":2908.3,"endTime":2909.533,"body":"follow the original meaning fairly"},{"startTime":2909.599,"endTime":2911.333,"body":"closely, but in the middle the concrete"},{"startTime":2911.333,"endTime":2913.633,"body":"illustrations, race, battle, and bread"},{"startTime":2913.633,"endTime":2916.033,"body":"dissolve into the vague phrase, success"},{"startTime":2916.033,"endTime":2917.666,"body":"or failure in competitive activities."},{"startTime":2918.333,"endTime":2920.099,"body":"This had to be so because no modern"},{"startTime":2920.099,"endTime":2922.333,"body":"writer of the kind I am discussing, no"},{"startTime":2922.333,"endTime":2924.066,"body":"one capable of using phrases like"},{"startTime":2924.066,"endTime":2925.833,"body":"objective consideration of contemporary"},{"startTime":2925.833,"endTime":2927.866,"body":"phenomena, would ever tabulate his"},{"startTime":2927.866,"endTime":2928.433,"body":"thoughts in that"},{"startTime":2928.433,"endTime":2929.766,"body":"precise and detailed way."},{"startTime":2930.233,"endTime":2932.166,"body":"The whole tendency of modern prose is"},{"startTime":2932.166,"endTime":2933.533,"body":"away from concreteness."},{"startTime":2934.266,"endTime":2935.3,"body":"Now analyze these two"},{"startTime":2935.3,"endTime":2936.699,"body":"sentences a little more closely."},{"startTime":2936.699,"endTime":2939.099,"body":"The first, Ecclesiastes, contains 49"},{"startTime":2939.099,"endTime":2941.599,"body":"words but only 60 syllables, and all its"},{"startTime":2941.599,"endTime":2942.766,"body":"words are those of everyday life."},{"startTime":2943.366,"endTime":2945.533,"body":"The second, Orwell's send up in modern"},{"startTime":2945.533,"endTime":2948.333,"body":"English, contains 38 words, fewer words,"},{"startTime":2948.333,"endTime":2951.033,"body":"of 90 syllables. 18 of its words are from"},{"startTime":2951.033,"endTime":2952.266,"body":"Latin roots and one from Greek."},{"startTime":2952.733,"endTime":2954.433,"body":"The first sentence contains six vivid"},{"startTime":2954.433,"endTime":2956.633,"body":"images and only one phrase, time and"},{"startTime":2956.633,"endTime":2958.266,"body":"chance, could be called vague."},{"startTime":2958.833,"endTime":2960.666,"body":"The second contains not a single fresh"},{"startTime":2960.666,"endTime":2962.466,"body":"arresting phrase and in spite of its 90"},{"startTime":2962.466,"endTime":2963.766,"body":"syllables it gives only a shortened"},{"startTime":2963.766,"endTime":2964.533,"body":"version of the meaning"},{"startTime":2964.533,"endTime":2965.433,"body":"contained in the first."},{"startTime":2966.3,"endTime":2968.033,"body":"Yet without a doubt is the second kind of"},{"startTime":2968.033,"endTime":2968.8,"body":"sentence that is gaining"},{"startTime":2968.8,"endTime":2970.066,"body":"ground in modern English."},{"startTime":2970.666,"endTime":2971.266,"body":"I do not want to"},{"startTime":2971.266,"endTime":2972.5,"body":"exaggerate, Orwell writes."},{"startTime":2972.866,"endTime":2974.266,"body":"This kind of writing is not yet universal"},{"startTime":2974.266,"endTime":2976.0,"body":"and outcrops of simplicity will occur"},{"startTime":2976.0,"endTime":2977.533,"body":"here and there in the worst written page."},{"startTime":2977.733,"endTime":2979.666,"body":"Still, if you or I were told to write a"},{"startTime":2979.666,"endTime":2981.266,"body":"few lines on the uncertainty of human"},{"startTime":2981.266,"endTime":2983.333,"body":"fortunes, we should probably come much"},{"startTime":2983.333,"endTime":2985.533,"body":"nearer to my imaginary sentence than to"},{"startTime":2985.533,"endTime":2986.833,"body":"the one from Ecclesiastes."},{"startTime":2988.133,"endTime":2990.766,"body":"Obviously most of what we're talking"},{"startTime":2990.766,"endTime":2993.166,"body":"about here isn't about the written word,"},{"startTime":2993.466,"endTime":2995.9,"body":"although the Reuters bit is written word"},{"startTime":2995.9,"endTime":2996.333,"body":"and what's in"},{"startTime":2996.333,"endTime":2997.666,"body":"Wikipedia is the written word."},{"startTime":2998.533,"endTime":3000.966,"body":"But we're seeing now the same thing"},{"startTime":3000.966,"endTime":3006.433,"body":"happening to poetry and vivid imagery and"},{"startTime":3006.433,"endTime":3008.733,"body":"actual observed truth"},{"startTime":3009.733,"endTime":3011.533,"body":"in description, in speech"},{"startTime":3011.533,"endTime":3012.966,"body":"as well, not just in writing."},{"startTime":3013.966,"endTime":3016.466,"body":"We're not going to get to hear from"},{"startTime":3016.466,"endTime":3018.5,"body":"Ecclesiastes anymore because we have to"},{"startTime":3018.5,"endTime":3019.066,"body":"be talking about"},{"startTime":3019.066,"endTime":3021.133,"body":"contemporary phenomenon and such."},{"startTime":3021.633,"endTime":3024.233,"body":"Well, I'm reminded of the"},{"startTime":3024.233,"endTime":3027.766,"body":"preferences of the Academy."},{"startTime":3029.733,"endTime":3031.133,"body":"There's something about"},{"startTime":3032.333,"endTime":3035.599,"body":"leaning into precise"},{"startTime":3035.599,"endTime":3039.099,"body":"language that obscures meaning."},{"startTime":3039.866,"endTime":3042.033,"body":"And I remember when I was writing my"},{"startTime":3042.033,"endTime":3046.533,"body":"dissertation that I was looking at many"},{"startTime":3046.533,"endTime":3049.733,"body":"of the things that my dissertation were"},{"startTime":3049.733,"endTime":3052.366,"body":"based on were actually not fully modern."},{"startTime":3053.633,"endTime":3055.266,"body":"And people used to write differently."},{"startTime":3055.866,"endTime":3056.633,"body":"The greats in our"},{"startTime":3056.633,"endTime":3057.866,"body":"field wrote differently."},{"startTime":3058.099,"endTime":3060.466,"body":"If you look at Darwin, for example, he"},{"startTime":3060.466,"endTime":3061.966,"body":"presents a compelling"},{"startTime":3061.966,"endTime":3064.666,"body":"argument accessible to anybody."},{"startTime":3064.666,"endTime":3068.199,"body":"It's not full of high-minded jargon that"},{"startTime":3068.199,"endTime":3070.099,"body":"makes it impossible for the layperson to"},{"startTime":3070.099,"endTime":3071.466,"body":"know what Darwin is claiming."},{"startTime":3072.366,"endTime":3077.199,"body":"It's written in plain English and as an"},{"startTime":3077.199,"endTime":3079.866,"body":"argument, deliberately so, in which he"},{"startTime":3079.866,"endTime":3082.166,"body":"again and again says, \"Here are the"},{"startTime":3082.166,"endTime":3083.333,"body":"things that if they are"},{"startTime":3083.333,"endTime":3085.166,"body":"true, my argument is false.\""},{"startTime":3085.166,"endTime":3087.133,"body":"So it's not like he's presenting a case"},{"startTime":3087.133,"endTime":3089.866,"body":"and obscuring the case against it."},{"startTime":3089.866,"endTime":3090.866,"body":"He makes both cases,"},{"startTime":3090.866,"endTime":3092.566,"body":"but in English, right?"},{"startTime":3092.9,"endTime":3094.966,"body":"You'll find the same thing in Fisher."},{"startTime":3095.633,"endTime":3099.3,"body":"It's simply a feature of compelling good"},{"startTime":3099.3,"endTime":3101.533,"body":"work in science and elsewhere."},{"startTime":3101.8,"endTime":3104.766,"body":"But it is taken the reason that when I"},{"startTime":3104.766,"endTime":3107.066,"body":"got to writing my dissertation, it felt"},{"startTime":3107.066,"endTime":3108.633,"body":"like this is no longer allowed."},{"startTime":3108.833,"endTime":3110.099,"body":"This is not how we speak anymore."},{"startTime":3110.099,"endTime":3111.033,"body":"And it's like, why?"},{"startTime":3111.033,"endTime":3113.266,"body":"Are we still making big gains the way the"},{"startTime":3113.266,"endTime":3114.866,"body":"people who did write like this were?"},{"startTime":3114.866,"endTime":3115.8,"body":"No, we aren't."},{"startTime":3116.133,"endTime":3118.166,"body":"Jeez, maybe this is one of the reasons is"},{"startTime":3118.166,"endTime":3120.033,"body":"that we're not allowed to present an"},{"startTime":3120.033,"endTime":3121.966,"body":"argument and have it out in English."},{"startTime":3122.433,"endTime":3123.666,"body":"What we're supposed to do is present"},{"startTime":3123.666,"endTime":3125.8,"body":"something so full of jargon that it"},{"startTime":3125.8,"endTime":3127.199,"body":"excludes everybody who"},{"startTime":3127.199,"endTime":3128.766,"body":"isn't already on board."},{"startTime":3129.099,"endTime":3129.866,"body":"I mean, it's a cloaking"},{"startTime":3129.866,"endTime":3131.066,"body":"mechanism is what it is."},{"startTime":3131.533,"endTime":3135.933,"body":"Yeah, I mean, I think I can make an"},{"startTime":3135.933,"endTime":3141.533,"body":"argument for precision, some jargon, but"},{"startTime":3141.533,"endTime":3144.633,"body":"not nearly as much as is being used, and"},{"startTime":3144.633,"endTime":3148.4,"body":"a sort of a tighter, grayer writing form"},{"startTime":3148.4,"endTime":3151.199,"body":"within scientific literature, as opposed"},{"startTime":3151.199,"endTime":3152.333,"body":"to within all of"},{"startTime":3152.333,"endTime":3153.633,"body":"English as Orwell is writing."},{"startTime":3153.966,"endTime":3155.8,"body":"I mean, I remember when I was writing my"},{"startTime":3155.8,"endTime":3157.033,"body":"dissertation, I was simultaneously"},{"startTime":3157.033,"endTime":3160.166,"body":"writing my first book, which was about"},{"startTime":3160.166,"endTime":3162.433,"body":"life and research in Madagascar, but it"},{"startTime":3162.433,"endTime":3163.666,"body":"was not a scientific term."},{"startTime":3163.666,"endTime":3164.599,"body":"It was a literary"},{"startTime":3164.599,"endTime":3166.433,"body":"nonfiction for the general public."},{"startTime":3167.766,"endTime":3170.733,"body":"And people, our peers in grad school"},{"startTime":3170.733,"endTime":3172.066,"body":"would say, oh, you're writing now,"},{"startTime":3172.066,"endTime":3174.133,"body":"meaning because that's what the phase at"},{"startTime":3174.133,"endTime":3175.766,"body":"which you are all done with your"},{"startTime":3175.766,"endTime":3178.866,"body":"hypothesizing and experimental design and"},{"startTime":3178.866,"endTime":3180.666,"body":"data collection and data analysis."},{"startTime":3180.666,"endTime":3182.266,"body":"And now, like now the stage is you're"},{"startTime":3182.266,"endTime":3183.566,"body":"writing, that's all you have to do, and"},{"startTime":3183.566,"endTime":3184.733,"body":"then defend your dissertation, and then"},{"startTime":3184.733,"endTime":3185.699,"body":"you're done, you're writing."},{"startTime":3186.266,"endTime":3187.8,"body":"And I'd say, well, yeah, actually, I am."},{"startTime":3187.8,"endTime":3188.466,"body":"I'm writing a book."},{"startTime":3189.099,"endTime":3189.666,"body":"Oh, but you're talking"},{"startTime":3189.666,"endTime":3190.366,"body":"about the dissertation."},{"startTime":3190.599,"endTime":3191.933,"body":"That doesn't feel like writing, because"},{"startTime":3191.933,"endTime":3195.533,"body":"it's so circumscribed, in part, so that"},{"startTime":3195.533,"endTime":3197.233,"body":"it could be replicated, right?"},{"startTime":3197.233,"endTime":3199.433,"body":"So that there is no ambiguity about what"},{"startTime":3199.433,"endTime":3201.0,"body":"was done and what was seen and what I"},{"startTime":3201.0,"endTime":3202.966,"body":"think I know, or what whoever the author"},{"startTime":3202.966,"endTime":3204.133,"body":"is thinks they know."},{"startTime":3205.566,"endTime":3208.166,"body":"But within the introduction and the"},{"startTime":3208.166,"endTime":3210.266,"body":"discussion of any given paper, any given"},{"startTime":3210.266,"endTime":3211.966,"body":"chapter of a dissertation, for instance,"},{"startTime":3211.966,"endTime":3213.266,"body":"each of which, you know, should hold"},{"startTime":3213.266,"endTime":3216.433,"body":"their own as their own research paper, as"},{"startTime":3216.433,"endTime":3217.366,"body":"was the case for both"},{"startTime":3217.366,"endTime":3218.366,"body":"your and my dissertations,"},{"startTime":3219.466,"endTime":3222.733,"body":"there should be the ability to make big"},{"startTime":3222.733,"endTime":3224.166,"body":"claims, to speak clearly,"},{"startTime":3224.166,"endTime":3225.733,"body":"to not hide behind jargon."},{"startTime":3226.233,"endTime":3228.766,"body":"And you are absolutely correct that these"},{"startTime":3228.766,"endTime":3230.866,"body":"sorts of things are generally frowned"},{"startTime":3230.866,"endTime":3231.766,"body":"upon in the Academy."},{"startTime":3232.199,"endTime":3233.866,"body":"Yeah, it's looked upon as unprofessional"},{"startTime":3233.866,"endTime":3235.599,"body":"when it is exactly the inverse."},{"startTime":3236.599,"endTime":3238.633,"body":"And I would argue that the distinction,"},{"startTime":3238.633,"endTime":3241.166,"body":"which we've made before, is very clear."},{"startTime":3241.833,"endTime":3244.066,"body":"You have terms of art, which are things"},{"startTime":3244.066,"endTime":3246.933,"body":"where it is necessary to speak with"},{"startTime":3246.933,"endTime":3248.599,"body":"special terminology that not everyone"},{"startTime":3248.599,"endTime":3250.433,"body":"would know in order to say what you're"},{"startTime":3250.433,"endTime":3252.866,"body":"saying, because your discipline has, you"},{"startTime":3252.866,"endTime":3254.866,"body":"know, a term for, you"},{"startTime":3254.866,"endTime":3256.599,"body":"know, a paraphyletic clade."},{"startTime":3257.066,"endTime":3260.433,"body":"There's no common parlance way of saying"},{"startTime":3260.433,"endTime":3261.233,"body":"that with precision."},{"startTime":3261.666,"endTime":3263.533,"body":"And so you're forced to use it."},{"startTime":3263.533,"endTime":3265.599,"body":"But the bias in favor of using"},{"startTime":3265.599,"endTime":3267.0,"body":"exclusionary language where it isn't"},{"startTime":3267.0,"endTime":3269.8,"body":"necessary is so clear in modern academic"},{"startTime":3269.8,"endTime":3272.666,"body":"work that it tells you what's going on."},{"startTime":3272.666,"endTime":3274.866,"body":"It's part of a club in which the idea is"},{"startTime":3274.866,"endTime":3276.933,"body":"we know and we will deliver you a"},{"startTime":3276.933,"endTime":3278.333,"body":"conclusion and you will not be able to"},{"startTime":3278.333,"endTime":3279.633,"body":"evaluate why we think this."},{"startTime":3279.866,"endTime":3283.9,"body":"Well, in my, you know, my defense of"},{"startTime":3283.9,"endTime":3286.933,"body":"highly precise and hard to get through"},{"startTime":3286.933,"endTime":3289.866,"body":"language in some parts of the Academy is"},{"startTime":3289.866,"endTime":3293.833,"body":"limited to science where there needs to"},{"startTime":3293.833,"endTime":3295.133,"body":"be the capacity, at least"},{"startTime":3295.133,"endTime":3296.3,"body":"in theory, for replication."},{"startTime":3297.233,"endTime":3300.699,"body":"And so there's no similar defense for"},{"startTime":3300.699,"endTime":3304.266,"body":"history or philosophy, except perhaps"},{"startTime":3304.266,"endTime":3305.766,"body":"with regard to exactly"},{"startTime":3305.766,"endTime":3306.933,"body":"what sources did you use?"},{"startTime":3307.133,"endTime":3309.466,"body":"Like, you know, be clear about where you"},{"startTime":3309.466,"endTime":3311.199,"body":"got this so that someone else can go and"},{"startTime":3311.199,"endTime":3312.066,"body":"look at your sources."},{"startTime":3312.066,"endTime":3316.0,"body":"But there's no similar impetus to"},{"startTime":3316.0,"endTime":3319.366,"body":"replicability in non-scientific fields."},{"startTime":3319.766,"endTime":3321.366,"body":"I totally agree with that."},{"startTime":3322.0,"endTime":3323.933,"body":"And I would just point out that even"},{"startTime":3323.933,"endTime":3327.233,"body":"inside of the Academy, you will often"},{"startTime":3327.233,"endTime":3330.033,"body":"hear people jokingly refer to"},{"startTime":3330.033,"endTime":3331.766,"body":"the jargon in their own work."},{"startTime":3332.733,"endTime":3334.666,"body":"And what it speaks to is"},{"startTime":3334.666,"endTime":3336.566,"body":"the loss of this distinction."},{"startTime":3337.233,"endTime":3337.433,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":3337.466,"endTime":3338.433,"body":"Jargon is unnecessary."},{"startTime":3339.433,"endTime":3340.633,"body":"Terms of art are necessary."},{"startTime":3341.333,"endTime":3341.866,"body":"They're necessary"},{"startTime":3341.866,"endTime":3343.3,"body":"evils, but they're necessary."},{"startTime":3343.733,"endTime":3346.566,"body":"So the point is, if you understand this"},{"startTime":3346.566,"endTime":3348.133,"body":"distinction, you wouldn't refer to your"},{"startTime":3348.133,"endTime":3349.766,"body":"own work as full of jargon because you're"},{"startTime":3349.766,"endTime":3350.8,"body":"not really supposed to"},{"startTime":3350.8,"endTime":3352.133,"body":"put that stuff in there."},{"startTime":3352.666,"endTime":3354.0,"body":"What you're supposed to do is use as"},{"startTime":3354.0,"endTime":3357.133,"body":"little of this as you can in order to"},{"startTime":3357.133,"endTime":3358.766,"body":"make your work fully replicable."},{"startTime":3359.033,"endTime":3361.533,"body":"And I would point to the parallel where"},{"startTime":3361.533,"endTime":3365.666,"body":"people conflate the meaning of rationale"},{"startTime":3365.666,"endTime":3367.466,"body":"and rationalization."},{"startTime":3368.166,"endTime":3369.466,"body":"A rationale is the"},{"startTime":3369.466,"endTime":3370.533,"body":"reason you did something."},{"startTime":3370.866,"endTime":3373.133,"body":"A rationalization is the reason you claim"},{"startTime":3373.133,"endTime":3374.3,"body":"you did something when the"},{"startTime":3374.3,"endTime":3375.8,"body":"rationale was something else."},{"startTime":3376.066,"endTime":3377.866,"body":"You rationalized that which was not"},{"startTime":3377.866,"endTime":3379.533,"body":"rational by the logic"},{"startTime":3379.533,"endTime":3380.4,"body":"that you're presenting."},{"startTime":3381.0,"endTime":3382.833,"body":"And so a rationalization"},{"startTime":3384.133,"endTime":3385.633,"body":"generally is invoked when"},{"startTime":3385.633,"endTime":3387.8,"body":"the conclusion was foregone."},{"startTime":3388.166,"endTime":3390.033,"body":"When you started with a conclusion and"},{"startTime":3390.033,"endTime":3391.533,"body":"then you needed an explanation for why"},{"startTime":3391.533,"endTime":3392.4,"body":"you did the thing,"},{"startTime":3392.4,"endTime":3393.866,"body":"that's your rationalization."},{"startTime":3394.333,"endTime":3394.533,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":3394.699,"endTime":3396.366,"body":"So if you do something for a selfish"},{"startTime":3396.366,"endTime":3397.933,"body":"reason, but you don't wish to pay the"},{"startTime":3397.933,"endTime":3400.099,"body":"cost of your selfishness, you may portray"},{"startTime":3400.099,"endTime":3401.0,"body":"it as something you"},{"startTime":3401.0,"endTime":3402.166,"body":"did for the greater good."},{"startTime":3402.666,"endTime":3403.133,"body":"And the point is"},{"startTime":3403.133,"endTime":3404.133,"body":"that's not why you did it."},{"startTime":3404.5,"endTime":3404.699,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":3404.766,"endTime":3406.833,"body":"You applied something after the fact."},{"startTime":3406.833,"endTime":3408.9,"body":"So anyway, these distinctions between the"},{"startTime":3408.9,"endTime":3413.133,"body":"honorable version and the malformed"},{"startTime":3413.133,"endTime":3415.066,"body":"version is really"},{"startTime":3415.066,"endTime":3416.333,"body":"important to maintain them."},{"startTime":3416.333,"endTime":3418.866,"body":"And I think it fits perfectly here."},{"startTime":3418.866,"endTime":3420.733,"body":"Ecclesiastes makes the point."},{"startTime":3421.966,"endTime":3423.3,"body":"Orwell's ridiculous"},{"startTime":3423.3,"endTime":3425.666,"body":"paragraph fails to make the point."},{"startTime":3425.666,"endTime":3426.833,"body":"You would read right past it"},{"startTime":3426.833,"endTime":3427.599,"body":"because it doesn't sound..."},{"startTime":3427.866,"endTime":3428.699,"body":"It's not memorable."},{"startTime":3429.033,"endTime":3429.8,"body":"It doesn't stick."},{"startTime":3429.933,"endTime":3430.833,"body":"It's not human."},{"startTime":3431.866,"endTime":3433.133,"body":"It's not resonant."},{"startTime":3433.699,"endTime":3436.766,"body":"And yet if you take all the words apart"},{"startTime":3436.766,"endTime":3439.0,"body":"and consider them very carefully in a"},{"startTime":3439.0,"endTime":3440.933,"body":"sort of a thoughtful academic manner, you"},{"startTime":3440.933,"endTime":3443.333,"body":"can conclude that I guess the same"},{"startTime":3443.333,"endTime":3446.433,"body":"message is there without any of the joy"},{"startTime":3446.433,"endTime":3447.599,"body":"or poetry or humanity."},{"startTime":3448.099,"endTime":3448.133,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":3448.133,"endTime":3450.099,"body":"The message could be extracted from"},{"startTime":3450.099,"endTime":3452.066,"body":"Orwell's version of the paragraph, but it"},{"startTime":3452.066,"endTime":3453.966,"body":"doesn't convey itself."},{"startTime":3454.433,"endTime":3456.033,"body":"The user has to do some work to figure"},{"startTime":3456.033,"endTime":3457.033,"body":"out what the hell"},{"startTime":3457.033,"endTime":3458.166,"body":"does that actually mean?"},{"startTime":3459.133,"endTime":3459.333,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":3460.366,"endTime":3460.966,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":3461.199,"endTime":3461.466,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":3461.866,"endTime":3463.599,"body":"I started and ended with Orwell."},{"startTime":3464.066,"endTime":3465.5,"body":"I'm good for the moment."},{"startTime":3465.766,"endTime":3467.133,"body":"From Orwell to Epstein."},{"startTime":3467.766,"endTime":3468.0,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":3468.0,"endTime":3470.433,"body":"So I have two purposes today."},{"startTime":3471.033,"endTime":3473.233,"body":"Obviously there is no shortage of ink and"},{"startTime":3473.233,"endTime":3477.566,"body":"pixels spilled over Epstein, over the"},{"startTime":3477.566,"endTime":3479.733,"body":"content of the recent releases."},{"startTime":3479.933,"endTime":3482.5,"body":"And I don't want to rehash that."},{"startTime":3482.5,"endTime":3483.8,"body":"I don't think there's any point in it."},{"startTime":3484.466,"endTime":3487.566,"body":"But what I do want to do is talk about"},{"startTime":3487.566,"endTime":3491.333,"body":"two things that I think are not widely"},{"startTime":3491.333,"endTime":3494.033,"body":"discussed or maybe not discussed at all."},{"startTime":3494.8,"endTime":3498.166,"body":"The first of them is the question of what"},{"startTime":3498.166,"endTime":3500.933,"body":"is the meaning of what we just saw?"},{"startTime":3501.5,"endTime":3504.966,"body":"So the narrative is that Thomas Massey"},{"startTime":3504.966,"endTime":3508.466,"body":"forced the release of a massive tranche"},{"startTime":3508.466,"endTime":3512.599,"body":"of documents from the Epstein files."},{"startTime":3512.9,"endTime":3515.833,"body":"And people are now going through that"},{"startTime":3515.833,"endTime":3519.333,"body":"material and finding all sorts of"},{"startTime":3519.333,"endTime":3522.3,"body":"patterns and suggestions of"},{"startTime":3522.3,"endTime":3523.866,"body":"bad behavior and all of that."},{"startTime":3523.966,"endTime":3526.099,"body":"Everybody who is paying attention to this"},{"startTime":3526.099,"endTime":3527.3,"body":"story is familiar with"},{"startTime":3527.3,"endTime":3529.266,"body":"some of what has emerged here."},{"startTime":3529.666,"endTime":3529.966,"body":"I'm trying to pay"},{"startTime":3529.966,"endTime":3533.433,"body":"attention to almost the inverse."},{"startTime":3534.566,"endTime":3536.5,"body":"We didn't get all the documents."},{"startTime":3537.866,"endTime":3540.533,"body":"I don't think we got the file."},{"startTime":3541.766,"endTime":3542.866,"body":"And I will come back to"},{"startTime":3542.866,"endTime":3544.233,"body":"that distinction in a second."},{"startTime":3544.233,"endTime":3546.5,"body":"We got a lot of stuff that appears to be"},{"startTime":3546.5,"endTime":3550.566,"body":"real and appears to be significant in"},{"startTime":3550.566,"endTime":3551.766,"body":"terms of telling us what"},{"startTime":3551.766,"endTime":3554.633,"body":"the Epstein phenomenon was."},{"startTime":3555.833,"endTime":3557.166,"body":"I don't know that it tells us what it"},{"startTime":3557.166,"endTime":3558.599,"body":"wasn't, but it tells us a lot about what it was in a certain way."},{"startTime":3558.633,"endTime":3559.966,"body":"What it was in a certain"},{"startTime":3559.966,"endTime":3561.3,"body":"amount about how it worked."},{"startTime":3561.3,"endTime":3564.933,"body":"Not a ton, but anyway, three million plus"},{"startTime":3564.933,"endTime":3568.0,"body":"documents is allowing us to know a lot of"},{"startTime":3568.0,"endTime":3570.033,"body":"what we didn't know before"},{"startTime":3570.033,"endTime":3571.866,"body":"or couldn't be certain of."},{"startTime":3573.466,"endTime":3575.166,"body":"But there's something conspicuous about"},{"startTime":3575.166,"endTime":3577.133,"body":"the pattern in what we have."},{"startTime":3578.033,"endTime":3579.433,"body":"And I wanted to"},{"startTime":3580.966,"endTime":3582.599,"body":"lay out a model on the table."},{"startTime":3582.933,"endTime":3585.433,"body":"Last time you and I spoke about this, we"},{"startTime":3585.433,"endTime":3588.933,"body":"talked about my response to Mike Benz"},{"startTime":3588.933,"endTime":3591.966,"body":"saying he didn't think blackmail was"},{"startTime":3591.966,"endTime":3594.933,"body":"certain here, that the pattern didn't add"},{"startTime":3594.933,"endTime":3597.3,"body":"up because the first time that Epstein"},{"startTime":3597.3,"endTime":3600.533,"body":"went to use the blackmail, the ability to"},{"startTime":3600.533,"endTime":3602.566,"body":"collect more blackmail would evaporate."},{"startTime":3602.566,"endTime":3605.033,"body":"And so how exactly does it work?"},{"startTime":3605.033,"endTime":3609.066,"body":"And I said last time that I thought that"},{"startTime":3609.066,"endTime":3612.033,"body":"effectively Epstein was bringing people"},{"startTime":3612.033,"endTime":3617.333,"body":"in, inducing everybody to go beyond their"},{"startTime":3617.333,"endTime":3621.199,"body":"own limits in some way, and then to live"},{"startTime":3621.199,"endTime":3624.4,"body":"in fear that what they did said or"},{"startTime":3624.4,"endTime":3626.3,"body":"whatever might emerge."},{"startTime":3626.9,"endTime":3629.433,"body":"So some people probably"},{"startTime":3629.433,"endTime":3631.366,"body":"betrayed their marital vows."},{"startTime":3631.933,"endTime":3633.233,"body":"They didn't do anything illegal."},{"startTime":3633.533,"endTime":3636.466,"body":"They didn't have sex with a minor, but"},{"startTime":3636.466,"endTime":3639.166,"body":"they did something that causes them to"},{"startTime":3639.166,"endTime":3640.433,"body":"now reign in their own behavior."},{"startTime":3640.833,"endTime":3643.666,"body":"So that if the network of Epstein"},{"startTime":3643.666,"endTime":3646.333,"body":"connected phenomena starts broadcasting"},{"startTime":3646.333,"endTime":3648.533,"body":"that it strongly favors this policy or"},{"startTime":3648.533,"endTime":3651.266,"body":"strongly disfavors that policy, you know"},{"startTime":3651.266,"endTime":3653.766,"body":"what side you're supposed to come out on."},{"startTime":3653.766,"endTime":3655.333,"body":"And for most people coming out on the"},{"startTime":3655.333,"endTime":3656.966,"body":"side of some policy is a minor thing"},{"startTime":3656.966,"endTime":3658.366,"body":"because there are millions of other"},{"startTime":3658.366,"endTime":3659.333,"body":"people on the same side."},{"startTime":3659.633,"endTime":3661.933,"body":"So who's to say why you did it?"},{"startTime":3662.533,"endTime":3662.733,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":3663.099,"endTime":3665.433,"body":"But the pattern that we have, I would"},{"startTime":3665.433,"endTime":3666.4,"body":"argue is conspicuous."},{"startTime":3667.433,"endTime":3670.333,"body":"What we have is a lot of highly"},{"startTime":3670.533,"endTime":3674.3,"body":"suggestive stuff that I think is, as far"},{"startTime":3674.3,"endTime":3676.666,"body":"as I've seen, not actionable."},{"startTime":3677.233,"endTime":3682.0,"body":"It is indicative, but it is not in and of"},{"startTime":3682.0,"endTime":3684.466,"body":"itself proof of any of the wrongdoing"},{"startTime":3684.466,"endTime":3686.766,"body":"that seems more likely given all of the"},{"startTime":3686.8,"endTime":3688.266,"body":"some total of what we've seen."},{"startTime":3688.566,"endTime":3691.3,"body":"So I have an example or two here."},{"startTime":3692.766,"endTime":3696.033,"body":"Let's show Rod Drear's tweet here."},{"startTime":3697.333,"endTime":3699.199,"body":"Rod Drear says, \"From the Epstein files,"},{"startTime":3699.199,"endTime":3700.233,"body":"I think we might owe the"},{"startTime":3700.233,"endTime":3701.866,"body":"QAnon loons an apology.\""},{"startTime":3702.166,"endTime":3703.0,"body":"By the way, he took a lot"},{"startTime":3703.0,"endTime":3704.099,"body":"of crap for saying loons."},{"startTime":3705.266,"endTime":3707.833,"body":"\"I would like to see a Justice Department"},{"startTime":3707.833,"endTime":3709.633,"body":"investigation of all of"},{"startTime":3709.633,"endTime":3712.333,"body":"this, but who can trust them?\""},{"startTime":3712.633,"endTime":3714.233,"body":"Here's a link to the email below, and"},{"startTime":3714.233,"endTime":3717.066,"body":"then it shows one of the emails from"},{"startTime":3717.066,"endTime":3719.733,"body":"Sarah Kay to Rich Burnett."},{"startTime":3720.333,"endTime":3722.866,"body":"And it says, it's having a little trouble"},{"startTime":3722.866,"endTime":3724.699,"body":"reading, it says, \"Hi Rich, Jeffrey is"},{"startTime":3724.699,"endTime":3727.533,"body":"asking if you can FedEx the painting he"},{"startTime":3727.533,"endTime":3729.866,"body":"had made of the massacre of"},{"startTime":3729.866,"endTime":3731.333,"body":"the Innocents to the ranch.\""},{"startTime":3731.333,"endTime":3732.766,"body":"That's presumably the Zorro Ranch."},{"startTime":3733.433,"endTime":3736.333,"body":"\"It's the large nine by nine foot canvas"},{"startTime":3736.333,"endTime":3739.9,"body":"that we had rolled out for him to see on"},{"startTime":3739.9,"endTime":3742.099,"body":"the entryway where"},{"startTime":3742.099,"endTime":3744.666,"body":"they are killing babies."},{"startTime":3745.833,"endTime":3748.833,"body":"He wants to use it on the ranch and is"},{"startTime":3748.833,"endTime":3750.166,"body":"hoping you could FedEx"},{"startTime":3750.166,"endTime":3751.833,"body":"it to arrive by Wednesday."},{"startTime":3752.233,"endTime":3752.966,"body":"Thanks, Sarah.\""},{"startTime":3754.166,"endTime":3755.666,"body":"Now, there's an obvious"},{"startTime":3755.666,"endTime":3757.599,"body":"linguistic ambiguity in there."},{"startTime":3758.633,"endTime":3762.9,"body":"The benign interpretation is that it was"},{"startTime":3762.9,"endTime":3765.633,"body":"laid out and the painting"},{"startTime":3765.633,"endTime":3767.266,"body":"depicts the killing of babies."},{"startTime":3767.833,"endTime":3769.366,"body":"Which massacre of the Innocents does."},{"startTime":3770.066,"endTime":3772.933,"body":"Yeah, the pernicious interpretation is"},{"startTime":3772.933,"endTime":3775.066,"body":"that this is referencing a location where"},{"startTime":3775.066,"endTime":3777.966,"body":"babies were killed on Epstein's ranch."},{"startTime":3779.333,"endTime":3779.533,"body":"Now,"},{"startTime":3781.233,"endTime":3781.5,"body":"this..."},{"startTime":3781.933,"endTime":3783.666,"body":"That seems like, this is"},{"startTime":3783.666,"endTime":3784.633,"body":"the first time I've seen this?"},{"startTime":3784.633,"endTime":3784.866,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":3784.866,"endTime":3785.599,"body":"It seems like an insane"},{"startTime":3785.666,"endTime":3786.699,"body":"interpretation of this."},{"startTime":3786.966,"endTime":3789.566,"body":"Why would anyone specify an entryway"},{"startTime":3789.566,"endTime":3791.233,"body":"where they kill babies as opposed to an"},{"startTime":3791.233,"endTime":3792.533,"body":"entryway where they don't?"},{"startTime":3793.566,"endTime":3795.666,"body":"That seems like an absurd..."},{"startTime":3795.666,"endTime":3796.566,"body":"I agree with you."},{"startTime":3796.733,"endTime":3798.566,"body":"A massive stretch."},{"startTime":3798.866,"endTime":3799.666,"body":"On the other hand,"},{"startTime":3799.966,"endTime":3801.466,"body":"there's a pattern here."},{"startTime":3802.533,"endTime":3805.666,"body":"You've got a guy who appears to have been"},{"startTime":3805.666,"endTime":3813.533,"body":"involved in trafficking young women and a"},{"startTime":3813.533,"endTime":3816.566,"body":"painting, the massacre of the Innocents."},{"startTime":3817.333,"endTime":3821.033,"body":"And this is an echo of what was seen with"},{"startTime":3821.033,"endTime":3824.266,"body":"the emails that were pried loose from the"},{"startTime":3824.266,"endTime":3828.066,"body":"DNC in which there is all sorts of"},{"startTime":3828.066,"endTime":3830.733,"body":"suggestive discussion amongst John"},{"startTime":3830.733,"endTime":3833.333,"body":"Podesta and his circle of all sorts of"},{"startTime":3833.333,"endTime":3835.733,"body":"things, including pizza, which shows up"},{"startTime":3835.733,"endTime":3837.133,"body":"across the Epstein files."},{"startTime":3837.366,"endTime":3839.699,"body":"So the point is, what the hell is this?"},{"startTime":3840.066,"endTime":3842.699,"body":"Bad taste in art or"},{"startTime":3842.699,"endTime":3844.866,"body":"taste that specifically..."},{"startTime":3845.333,"endTime":3845.9,"body":"Immoral taste."},{"startTime":3846.3,"endTime":3849.666,"body":"Immoral taste in art where the immorality"},{"startTime":3849.666,"endTime":3852.033,"body":"is even that you're engaged in some"},{"startTime":3852.033,"endTime":3854.199,"body":"behavior and you're memorializing it in"},{"startTime":3854.199,"endTime":3856.199,"body":"art for the purpose of making a point"},{"startTime":3856.199,"endTime":3857.8,"body":"about how powerful you are or whatever."},{"startTime":3858.333,"endTime":3860.833,"body":"But the point is, that ain't actionable."},{"startTime":3861.466,"endTime":3864.0,"body":"That's a question about art and poor"},{"startTime":3864.0,"endTime":3865.133,"body":"grammar on the part of"},{"startTime":3865.133,"endTime":3866.9,"body":"somebody who isn't Epstein."},{"startTime":3867.966,"endTime":3871.733,"body":"So it is suggestive of a culture in which"},{"startTime":3871.733,"endTime":3873.966,"body":"the massacring of Innocents might be some"},{"startTime":3873.966,"endTime":3877.666,"body":"kind of weird allusion to their own"},{"startTime":3877.666,"endTime":3879.099,"body":"behavior, but there's nothing"},{"startTime":3879.099,"endTime":3881.266,"body":"you can do about that, right?"},{"startTime":3881.699,"endTime":3883.9,"body":"It doesn't mean anything actionable."},{"startTime":3884.633,"endTime":3885.966,"body":"Okay, so let's look at the"},{"startTime":3885.966,"endTime":3889.8,"body":"tweet about the sulfuric acid."},{"startTime":3892.166,"endTime":3898.4,"body":"So this tweet shows an invoice here."},{"startTime":3898.4,"endTime":3899.366,"body":"We'll show you the tweet first."},{"startTime":3899.366,"endTime":3901.733,"body":"It says, this is from an account called"},{"startTime":3901.733,"endTime":3904.766,"body":"50 Shades of Way, like the liquid that"},{"startTime":3904.766,"endTime":3906.666,"body":"comes off of these manufacture."},{"startTime":3907.866,"endTime":3909.766,"body":"\"On the same exact day that the FBI"},{"startTime":3909.766,"endTime":3911.533,"body":"opened a child sex trafficking case"},{"startTime":3911.533,"endTime":3914.133,"body":"against Epstein in 2018, he ordered half"},{"startTime":3914.133,"endTime":3916.433,"body":"a dozen 55 gallon containers full of"},{"startTime":3916.433,"endTime":3918.766,"body":"sulfuric acid to his private island."},{"startTime":3919.3,"endTime":3921.066,"body":"It could be a coincidence, but what are"},{"startTime":3921.066,"endTime":3922.266,"body":"the odds on the same"},{"startTime":3922.266,"endTime":3923.833,"body":"day was he tipped off?\""},{"startTime":3924.199,"endTime":3925.833,"body":"And then it shows some"},{"startTime":3925.833,"endTime":3927.433,"body":"screenshots that are redacted."},{"startTime":3928.233,"endTime":3931.099,"body":"I can't read them from here, but I've"},{"startTime":3931.099,"endTime":3933.733,"body":"looked at them and what they say is that"},{"startTime":3933.733,"endTime":3936.466,"body":"they made an order for 55 gallon drums,"},{"startTime":3936.8,"endTime":3939.233,"body":"six of them full of sulfuric acid."},{"startTime":3939.933,"endTime":3944.166,"body":"Okay, now, on the one hand, sulfuric acid"},{"startTime":3944.166,"endTime":3945.633,"body":"can be used to dissolve a body."},{"startTime":3946.433,"endTime":3948.066,"body":"On the other hand, it's"},{"startTime":3948.066,"endTime":3949.599,"body":"not the best acid for that."},{"startTime":3950.333,"endTime":3952.033,"body":"And on the third hand, no, it's not."},{"startTime":3952.066,"endTime":3954.166,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":3954.166,"endTime":3955.033,"body":"It's slower, darling."},{"startTime":3955.233,"endTime":3955.833,"body":"You should know that."},{"startTime":3956.133,"endTime":3956.333,"body":"Then?"},{"startTime":3957.3,"endTime":3957.766,"body":"Stronger."},{"startTime":3957.766,"endTime":3958.966,"body":"Hydrochloric acid."},{"startTime":3958.966,"endTime":3960.333,"body":"I can't remember what the better"},{"startTime":3960.333,"endTime":3961.866,"body":"alternatives are, but people who are into"},{"startTime":3961.866,"endTime":3963.033,"body":"dissolving bodies have a"},{"startTime":3963.033,"endTime":3964.233,"body":"list of acids that work better."},{"startTime":3965.5,"endTime":3967.366,"body":"Yeah, yeah, I hadn't either."},{"startTime":3967.366,"endTime":3968.966,"body":"And I'm kind of sorry I did."},{"startTime":3969.266,"endTime":3970.833,"body":"But here's what I would say."},{"startTime":3971.766,"endTime":3975.333,"body":"I find it conspicuous that, especially"},{"startTime":3975.333,"endTime":3977.566,"body":"given the coincidence in timing, that"},{"startTime":3977.566,"endTime":3979.9,"body":"there's an order for six 55 gallon"},{"startTime":3979.9,"endTime":3981.8,"body":"barrels of sulfuric acid."},{"startTime":3982.366,"endTime":3983.599,"body":"Is there an innocent explanation?"},{"startTime":3985.366,"endTime":3986.033,"body":"Yes and no."},{"startTime":3987.133,"endTime":3989.033,"body":"I mean, there's an invoice."},{"startTime":3989.466,"endTime":3990.433,"body":"It's legal to purchase"},{"startTime":3990.699,"endTime":3991.866,"body":"vats of sulfuric acid."},{"startTime":3992.333,"endTime":3995.566,"body":"And there were presumably reasons that"},{"startTime":3995.566,"endTime":3998.099,"body":"normal people would use sulfuric acid."},{"startTime":3998.099,"endTime":3999.233,"body":"Not normal people, but"},{"startTime":3999.233,"endTime":4002.599,"body":"people who own small islands."},{"startTime":4004.233,"endTime":4004.566,"body":"Specifically."},{"startTime":4005.199,"endTime":4005.4,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4005.566,"endTime":4006.866,"body":"Other people who own small islands."},{"startTime":4007.133,"endTime":4007.333,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4007.433,"endTime":4008.533,"body":"If you own that island."},{"startTime":4008.766,"endTime":4008.9,"body":"For what?"},{"startTime":4008.9,"endTime":4009.333,"body":"For why?"},{"startTime":4010.5,"endTime":4013.033,"body":"Well, let me tell you what I've learned."},{"startTime":4013.333,"endTime":4015.766,"body":"And anyone who's welcome to correct me, I"},{"startTime":4015.766,"endTime":4016.566,"body":"know a little bit about"},{"startTime":4016.566,"endTime":4017.866,"body":"this topic, but not a lot."},{"startTime":4019.866,"endTime":4020.133,"body":"Little St."},{"startTime":4020.433,"endTime":4021.599,"body":"James does not appear to"},{"startTime":4021.599,"endTime":4024.066,"body":"have a source of water."},{"startTime":4025.066,"endTime":4026.733,"body":"Now there are a couple of possibilities."},{"startTime":4026.733,"endTime":4026.8,"body":"Little St."},{"startTime":4026.8,"endTime":4027.566,"body":"James is Epstein's Island."},{"startTime":4027.599,"endTime":4028.599,"body":"That's Epstein's Island."},{"startTime":4029.333,"endTime":4031.4,"body":"You could have a well, but the well is"},{"startTime":4031.4,"endTime":4033.866,"body":"not likely to produce enough fresh water."},{"startTime":4034.266,"endTime":4035.599,"body":"And it's also likely to"},{"startTime":4035.599,"endTime":4037.166,"body":"have lots of salt infiltration."},{"startTime":4038.066,"endTime":4040.333,"body":"So how were they getting their water?"},{"startTime":4040.966,"endTime":4043.533,"body":"There are two possible ways."},{"startTime":4043.933,"endTime":4046.266,"body":"One is water catchment, which also is"},{"startTime":4046.266,"endTime":4049.566,"body":"finicky because it requires rainfall."},{"startTime":4049.566,"endTime":4051.433,"body":"And yes, you can collect a lot of water,"},{"startTime":4051.433,"endTime":4055.599,"body":"but it would appear from the documents"},{"startTime":4055.9,"endTime":4057.566,"body":"about the sale of the island."},{"startTime":4057.933,"endTime":4059.3,"body":"For example, the real estate"},{"startTime":4059.3,"endTime":4060.266,"body":"advertisement for the"},{"startTime":4060.266,"endTime":4062.333,"body":"island before Epstein owned it."},{"startTime":4062.333,"endTime":4064.266,"body":"That the way it was done is the obvious"},{"startTime":4064.266,"endTime":4066.699,"body":"way, which is desalination of seawater."},{"startTime":4067.633,"endTime":4068.166,"body":"Reverse osmosis."},{"startTime":4068.166,"endTime":4069.033,"body":"Reverse osmosis."},{"startTime":4069.366,"endTime":4069.566,"body":"Exactly."},{"startTime":4069.833,"endTime":4072.233,"body":"Now reverse osmosis is a very energy"},{"startTime":4072.233,"endTime":4074.199,"body":"intensive, expensive process."},{"startTime":4074.833,"endTime":4077.866,"body":"And it's a finicky process that involves"},{"startTime":4077.866,"endTime":4081.733,"body":"sorting out all of the stuff using"},{"startTime":4081.966,"endTime":4085.833,"body":"membranes that are semi-permeable, using"},{"startTime":4085.833,"endTime":4088.3,"body":"pressure to drive seawater through these"},{"startTime":4088.3,"endTime":4090.033,"body":"membranes such that the salt is held on"},{"startTime":4090.033,"endTime":4090.966,"body":"one side, creating a"},{"startTime":4090.966,"endTime":4092.199,"body":"brine, yada, yada, yada."},{"startTime":4092.733,"endTime":4094.933,"body":"There is a problem with this process,"},{"startTime":4094.933,"endTime":4097.699,"body":"which is that if the pH balance isn't"},{"startTime":4097.699,"endTime":4100.3,"body":"quite right, you get the buildup of"},{"startTime":4100.3,"endTime":4103.366,"body":"mineral materials that degrade, I think"},{"startTime":4103.366,"endTime":4104.199,"body":"the membranes, but"},{"startTime":4104.199,"endTime":4106.3,"body":"certainly build up on the machinery."},{"startTime":4106.566,"endTime":4107.1,"body":"And so you want to"},{"startTime":4107.1,"endTime":4108.033,"body":"prevent that from happening."},{"startTime":4108.033,"endTime":4108.966,"body":"And does it tend to go basic?"},{"startTime":4109.233,"endTime":4111.466,"body":"Is that the direction that it tends to fail?"},{"startTime":4111.766,"endTime":4112.699,"body":"I think so."},{"startTime":4112.699,"endTime":4113.8,"body":"And sulfuric acid is a"},{"startTime":4113.8,"endTime":4114.866,"body":"relatively weak acid?"},{"startTime":4115.666,"endTime":4118.633,"body":"No, but nonetheless, you can titrate."},{"startTime":4118.899,"endTime":4119.1,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4119.466,"endTime":4122.166,"body":"But when I pursued this, I pursued this"},{"startTime":4122.166,"endTime":4125.433,"body":"with the fancy version of chat GPT."},{"startTime":4126.1,"endTime":4128.166,"body":"It does not seem to hallucinate, but I"},{"startTime":4128.166,"endTime":4130.466,"body":"can't vouch for it because I don't even"},{"startTime":4130.466,"endTime":4132.333,"body":"know how to exactly check this, but I"},{"startTime":4132.333,"endTime":4136.466,"body":"asked it to estimate per thousand gallons"},{"startTime":4136.466,"endTime":4141.3,"body":"of potable water produced from Caribbean"},{"startTime":4141.3,"endTime":4143.766,"body":"seawater desalinated"},{"startTime":4143.766,"endTime":4145.166,"body":"by a standard process."},{"startTime":4145.166,"endTime":4147.399,"body":"What would the right amount of sulfuric"},{"startTime":4147.399,"endTime":4151.466,"body":"acid that I would need in order to reduce"},{"startTime":4151.466,"endTime":4154.333,"body":"the basic nature of the output so that we"},{"startTime":4154.333,"endTime":4155.333,"body":"didn't build up scale"},{"startTime":4155.333,"endTime":4157.333,"body":"per thousand gallons, which is not a ton."},{"startTime":4157.566,"endTime":4157.766,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4157.933,"endTime":4158.133,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":4158.666,"endTime":4159.533,"body":"How much do you think it said?"},{"startTime":4160.933,"endTime":4162.066,"body":"I'm going to I'm going to"},{"startTime":4162.066,"endTime":4163.3,"body":"be orders of magnitude off."},{"startTime":4164.6,"endTime":4165.033,"body":"Probably."},{"startTime":4165.633,"endTime":4166.833,"body":"I mean, I was going to guess something"},{"startTime":4166.833,"endTime":4169.233,"body":"very small, like a tablespoon."},{"startTime":4169.8,"endTime":4170.433,"body":"It's too much."},{"startTime":4170.733,"endTime":4172.033,"body":"It says you don't need any."},{"startTime":4172.6,"endTime":4175.433,"body":"It says given basic assumptions about"},{"startTime":4175.433,"endTime":4177.433,"body":"Caribbean seawater, you would need none."},{"startTime":4178.166,"endTime":4179.533,"body":"So, but so,"},{"startTime":4179.8,"endTime":4184.333,"body":"but because pH is not inherently an issue."},{"startTime":4185.0,"endTime":4187.6,"body":"So why you started this story saying that"},{"startTime":4187.6,"endTime":4189.633,"body":"there is a a use, right?"},{"startTime":4189.866,"endTime":4191.766,"body":"And it's associated with the reverse"},{"startTime":4191.766,"endTime":4193.233,"body":"osmosis when your source"},{"startTime":4193.233,"endTime":4195.133,"body":"of water has a pH issue."},{"startTime":4195.866,"endTime":4197.233,"body":"This Caribbean water is not"},{"startTime":4197.233,"endTime":4198.8,"body":"understood to have a pH issue."},{"startTime":4199.0,"endTime":4199.199,"body":"Correct."},{"startTime":4199.466,"endTime":4201.233,"body":"Now, could there be an"},{"startTime":4201.233,"endTime":4203.733,"body":"issue with for some reason?"},{"startTime":4204.233,"endTime":4204.733,"body":"Could there be some"},{"startTime":4204.733,"endTime":4205.466,"body":"other use for sulfuric acid?"},{"startTime":4205.833,"endTime":4208.399,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":4209.066,"endTime":4209.933,"body":"Yes, there could be."},{"startTime":4210.233,"endTime":4212.066,"body":"There could be, but so what do we have?"},{"startTime":4212.666,"endTime":4214.3,"body":"We have nothing like we"},{"startTime":4214.3,"endTime":4215.633,"body":"have nothing actionable."},{"startTime":4215.633,"endTime":4217.966,"body":"We have a conspicuous pattern both in the"},{"startTime":4217.966,"endTime":4219.266,"body":"timing and the"},{"startTime":4219.266,"endTime":4220.933,"body":"quantity of sulfuric acids."},{"startTime":4221.133,"endTime":4223.133,"body":"Six freaking 55"},{"startTime":4223.133,"endTime":4224.333,"body":"gallon drums of this stuff."},{"startTime":4224.766,"endTime":4226.233,"body":"That's a lot of sulfuric"},{"startTime":4226.233,"endTime":4228.466,"body":"acid and 55 gallon drums."},{"startTime":4229.3,"endTime":4233.466,"body":"It obviously suggests a question, but so"},{"startTime":4233.466,"endTime":4235.199,"body":"this, this goes to the next point."},{"startTime":4236.533,"endTime":4237.3,"body":"We have something."},{"startTime":4238.233,"endTime":4239.733,"body":"It may be evidence of a crime."},{"startTime":4240.866,"endTime":4243.133,"body":"It is not actionable, but let"},{"startTime":4243.133,"endTime":4244.366,"body":"me tell you what we don't have."},{"startTime":4244.899,"endTime":4249.433,"body":"We don't have the evidence that the FBI"},{"startTime":4249.433,"endTime":4252.866,"body":"looked into the question of what the 55"},{"startTime":4252.866,"endTime":4254.966,"body":"gallon drums of sulfuric acid were for."},{"startTime":4255.533,"endTime":4257.733,"body":"So the point is, I think that there's a"},{"startTime":4257.733,"endTime":4259.166,"body":"little game being played here where the"},{"startTime":4259.166,"endTime":4261.066,"body":"point is the files, well, we certainly"},{"startTime":4261.066,"endTime":4261.966,"body":"have a lot of files,"},{"startTime":4263.1,"endTime":4265.233,"body":"but we don't have the files that tell us"},{"startTime":4265.233,"endTime":4268.6,"body":"if these leads were chased down, if they"},{"startTime":4268.6,"endTime":4270.0,"body":"weren't chased down, why not?"},{"startTime":4270.266,"endTime":4270.933,"body":"If they were chased"},{"startTime":4270.933,"endTime":4272.266,"body":"down, what was concluded?"},{"startTime":4272.866,"endTime":4275.966,"body":"And so we are now, the public is trying"},{"startTime":4275.966,"endTime":4279.766,"body":"to do a job it can't do with a woefully"},{"startTime":4279.766,"endTime":4283.533,"body":"incomplete data set and no evidence about"},{"startTime":4283.533,"endTime":4286.433,"body":"what was discovered about the"},{"startTime":4286.433,"endTime":4287.833,"body":"things that seem suggestive."},{"startTime":4288.866,"endTime":4291.966,"body":"Did the FBI look into all of the weird"},{"startTime":4291.966,"endTime":4294.533,"body":"mentions of pizza and grape soda and beef"},{"startTime":4294.533,"endTime":4296.266,"body":"jerky and frozen tuna?"},{"startTime":4297.233,"endTime":4297.933,"body":"Frozen tuna tuna?"},{"startTime":4298.366,"endTime":4299.966,"body":"Yeah, frozen tuna, which could be a"},{"startTime":4299.966,"endTime":4301.066,"body":"reference to frozen tuna."},{"startTime":4301.466,"endTime":4302.733,"body":"I mean, it's an island."},{"startTime":4303.366,"endTime":4304.899,"body":"Wouldn't be shocking if there were frozen"},{"startTime":4304.899,"endTime":4307.666,"body":"tuna involved, but in light of all of"},{"startTime":4307.666,"endTime":4310.966,"body":"the, all of the weird language, I mean,"},{"startTime":4311.466,"endTime":4315.066,"body":"why is the beef jerky being kept on ice?"},{"startTime":4316.733,"endTime":4317.433,"body":"Beef jerky does not"},{"startTime":4317.433,"endTime":4318.433,"body":"need to be kept on ice."},{"startTime":4318.433,"endTime":4319.633,"body":"It's one of the reasons that you want"},{"startTime":4319.733,"endTime":4322.366,"body":"beef jerky is that it doesn't require you"},{"startTime":4322.366,"endTime":4323.466,"body":"to control the temperature"},{"startTime":4323.466,"endTime":4325.333,"body":"in order for it to be durable."},{"startTime":4325.566,"endTime":4327.333,"body":"So why does he have all of these people"},{"startTime":4327.333,"endTime":4328.933,"body":"corresponding with them waxing"},{"startTime":4328.933,"endTime":4331.3,"body":"philosophic and updating on how quickly"},{"startTime":4331.3,"endTime":4332.633,"body":"they're going through the beef jerky they"},{"startTime":4332.633,"endTime":4334.066,"body":"have and when they might need some more"},{"startTime":4334.066,"endTime":4335.633,"body":"and why it's being kept on"},{"startTime":4335.633,"endTime":4337.533,"body":"ice and where it's crazy."},{"startTime":4337.966,"endTime":4340.433,"body":"Did the FBI investigate the beef jerky?"},{"startTime":4340.433,"endTime":4341.899,"body":"I'd like to know what they concluded."},{"startTime":4342.333,"endTime":4343.933,"body":"Maybe that's a perfectly innocent"},{"startTime":4343.933,"endTime":4346.066,"body":"explanation, but we don't have it."},{"startTime":4346.8,"endTime":4348.066,"body":"So, okay."},{"startTime":4349.3,"endTime":4350.333,"body":"Now let's talk about"},{"startTime":4350.333,"endTime":4352.033,"body":"why we don't have it."},{"startTime":4353.199,"endTime":4354.966,"body":"I think there are a couple things to"},{"startTime":4354.966,"endTime":4356.833,"body":"understand and basically what I'm going"},{"startTime":4356.833,"endTime":4359.466,"body":"to argue is that both with respect to"},{"startTime":4359.466,"endTime":4361.766,"body":"whether or not Jeffrey Epstein remains"},{"startTime":4361.766,"endTime":4365.033,"body":"alive and with respect to the games that"},{"startTime":4365.033,"endTime":4367.266,"body":"are played over the Epstein files,"},{"startTime":4368.433,"endTime":4369.266,"body":"it's the game theory"},{"startTime":4369.266,"endTime":4370.333,"body":"that tells you what's going."},{"startTime":4371.633,"endTime":4372.933,"body":"So I would argue a"},{"startTime":4372.933,"endTime":4373.733,"body":"couple things are true."},{"startTime":4374.233,"endTime":4375.966,"body":"One,"},{"startTime":4377.133,"endTime":4379.133,"body":"and I pointed this out months ago,"},{"startTime":4380.233,"endTime":4383.633,"body":"you have a guy who appears to have"},{"startTime":4383.633,"endTime":4386.366,"body":"collected a huge amount of compromise."},{"startTime":4387.166,"endTime":4387.933,"body":"What is compromise?"},{"startTime":4388.899,"endTime":4389.666,"body":"It is power."},{"startTime":4390.566,"endTime":4392.566,"body":"It is the power to shape events."},{"startTime":4392.833,"endTime":4393.866,"body":"It is the power to"},{"startTime":4393.866,"endTime":4395.366,"body":"bring people onto your team."},{"startTime":4395.566,"endTime":4397.633,"body":"It is the power to isolate people who"},{"startTime":4397.633,"endTime":4399.5,"body":"need to be gotten out of the way for"},{"startTime":4399.5,"endTime":4401.533,"body":"something that you want them."},{"startTime":4401.833,"endTime":4402.433,"body":"It is power."},{"startTime":4403.1,"endTime":4404.933,"body":"So one of the problems that you're going"},{"startTime":4404.933,"endTime":4407.366,"body":"to run into is the same problem."},{"startTime":4407.666,"endTime":4411.699,"body":"You know, if the police discover a huge"},{"startTime":4411.699,"endTime":4414.466,"body":"stash of money involved in criminal"},{"startTime":4414.466,"endTime":4417.199,"body":"activity, there's an obvious question"},{"startTime":4417.199,"endTime":4419.266,"body":"about what it is that forces them to turn"},{"startTime":4419.266,"endTime":4421.133,"body":"that money in versus"},{"startTime":4421.133,"endTime":4422.866,"body":"disappear that money."},{"startTime":4423.733,"endTime":4425.933,"body":"So what I think is one thing is true."},{"startTime":4426.166,"endTime":4430.366,"body":"We are living downstream of some amazing"},{"startTime":4430.366,"endTime":4433.233,"body":"elite game that looks"},{"startTime":4433.233,"endTime":4435.166,"body":"like Game of Thrones, right?"},{"startTime":4435.466,"endTime":4437.533,"body":"The elites are playing some game with the"},{"startTime":4437.533,"endTime":4439.133,"body":"rest of us where they have information we"},{"startTime":4439.133,"endTime":4440.366,"body":"don't have access to."},{"startTime":4440.366,"endTime":4441.133,"body":"It allows them to make"},{"startTime":4441.566,"endTime":4442.933,"body":"huge amounts of profits."},{"startTime":4442.933,"endTime":4445.666,"body":"It allows them to function like"},{"startTime":4445.666,"endTime":4449.199,"body":"superhumans to the extent that Epstein"},{"startTime":4449.199,"endTime":4450.866,"body":"had accumulated this stuff."},{"startTime":4451.133,"endTime":4455.399,"body":"It is highly valuable to other people to"},{"startTime":4455.399,"endTime":4457.5,"body":"have it and they will therefore be"},{"startTime":4457.5,"endTime":4459.166,"body":"reluctant to cough it up."},{"startTime":4460.266,"endTime":4462.3,"body":"So one of the things that I think we see"},{"startTime":4462.3,"endTime":4465.833,"body":"in the massive release of partial"},{"startTime":4465.833,"endTime":4468.6,"body":"evidence that we saw is that those"},{"startTime":4468.6,"endTime":4471.166,"body":"redactions where the perpetrators'"},{"startTime":4471.733,"endTime":4476.233,"body":"identities are hidden functions as a shot"},{"startTime":4476.233,"endTime":4478.866,"body":"across the bow to the extent that"},{"startTime":4478.866,"endTime":4481.566,"body":"somebody is now in control of Epstein's"},{"startTime":4481.566,"endTime":4482.733,"body":"library of Compromat."},{"startTime":4483.833,"endTime":4487.466,"body":"Well, somebody else can advertise to"},{"startTime":4487.466,"endTime":4489.133,"body":"those who are in that library of"},{"startTime":4489.133,"endTime":4491.933,"body":"Compromat, \"Hey, we now own you.\""},{"startTime":4492.466,"endTime":4492.666,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":4493.0,"endTime":4495.933,"body":"So we'd be foolish not to wonder if"},{"startTime":4495.933,"endTime":4497.233,"body":"that's what the pattern is."},{"startTime":4497.233,"endTime":4499.5,"body":"Why did the documents we did get to see"},{"startTime":4499.5,"endTime":4502.066,"body":"get through and the documents we haven't"},{"startTime":4502.066,"endTime":4503.466,"body":"yet seen not get through?"},{"startTime":4503.466,"endTime":4505.433,"body":"And you can see this, the number of"},{"startTime":4505.433,"endTime":4507.633,"body":"documents that start in the middle or"},{"startTime":4507.633,"endTime":4509.833,"body":"correspondence where you have one piece"},{"startTime":4509.833,"endTime":4510.633,"body":"that's responding to"},{"startTime":4510.633,"endTime":4511.6,"body":"something we don't have."},{"startTime":4512.533,"endTime":4514.333,"body":"It's obvious that this is selective."},{"startTime":4514.733,"endTime":4515.666,"body":"In what way was it selective?"},{"startTime":4515.966,"endTime":4518.466,"body":"What picture does what's not there paint?"},{"startTime":4519.466,"endTime":4521.533,"body":"And one of the things that it does is"},{"startTime":4521.533,"endTime":4527.399,"body":"seems to create the opportunity for that"},{"startTime":4527.399,"endTime":4528.833,"body":"power to be seamlessly"},{"startTime":4528.833,"endTime":4530.233,"body":"transferred to somebody else."},{"startTime":4530.466,"endTime":4532.8,"body":"Yeah, it seems to put, it names a lot of"},{"startTime":4532.8,"endTime":4534.933,"body":"people who may now be considered to be on"},{"startTime":4534.933,"endTime":4537.033,"body":"notice, but presumably there are many,"},{"startTime":4537.033,"endTime":4537.833,"body":"many people who are"},{"startTime":4537.833,"endTime":4539.533,"body":"not yet named as well."},{"startTime":4539.966,"endTime":4540.166,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4540.6,"endTime":4541.766,"body":"Lots of people who know they're in there."},{"startTime":4542.033,"endTime":4542.233,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":4542.399,"endTime":4543.266,"body":"Who know they're in there."},{"startTime":4543.733,"endTime":4546.466,"body":"Who presumably, many of them are dumb"},{"startTime":4546.466,"endTime":4549.166,"body":"shits who went to the site and searched"},{"startTime":4549.166,"endTime":4550.833,"body":"for their own names to see"},{"startTime":4550.833,"endTime":4552.333,"body":"whether or not they're in there."},{"startTime":4552.566,"endTime":4554.3,"body":"So somebody who was paying attention and"},{"startTime":4554.3,"endTime":4556.333,"body":"decided to log that information might be"},{"startTime":4556.333,"endTime":4558.433,"body":"able to get a map of the things they"},{"startTime":4558.433,"endTime":4559.633,"body":"maybe haven't spotted yet"},{"startTime":4559.633,"endTime":4560.633,"body":"and who might be nervous."},{"startTime":4561.766,"endTime":4563.433,"body":"So anyway, the point"},{"startTime":4563.433,"endTime":4564.666,"body":"is it's game of thrones."},{"startTime":4564.666,"endTime":4565.566,"body":"It's still going on"},{"startTime":4565.566,"endTime":4567.166,"body":"whether Epstein survived or not."},{"startTime":4568.766,"endTime":4568.966,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":4569.1,"endTime":4570.433,"body":"Now I want to get to the reason that I"},{"startTime":4570.433,"endTime":4572.133,"body":"think Epstein probably did survive."},{"startTime":4573.699,"endTime":4574.133,"body":"Before you do,"},{"startTime":4575.3,"endTime":4575.933,"body":"does it matter?"},{"startTime":4576.666,"endTime":4577.666,"body":"Yes and no."},{"startTime":4578.399,"endTime":4579.566,"body":"I mean, for one thing, it seems to me"},{"startTime":4579.566,"endTime":4582.3,"body":"that he was, he was a puppeteer, but he"},{"startTime":4582.3,"endTime":4584.633,"body":"wasn't, it seems a brilliant puppeteer."},{"startTime":4585.033,"endTime":4586.033,"body":"Well, let's put it this way."},{"startTime":4586.633,"endTime":4590.566,"body":"If he survived, that describes a"},{"startTime":4590.566,"endTime":4594.133,"body":"landscape of people who participated in"},{"startTime":4597.3,"endTime":4600.766,"body":"dodging justice for him, in hoodwinking"},{"startTime":4600.766,"endTime":4602.633,"body":"the public, in"},{"startTime":4602.633,"endTime":4604.666,"body":"breaking the justice system."},{"startTime":4605.266,"endTime":4606.033,"body":"So the point is that's"},{"startTime":4606.033,"endTime":4607.366,"body":"a vast crime of its own."},{"startTime":4608.033,"endTime":4608.233,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":4608.266,"endTime":4608.766,"body":"We had a right."},{"startTime":4608.766,"endTime":4610.433,"body":"That's a different question from does it"},{"startTime":4610.466,"endTime":4611.666,"body":"matter if he still lives?"},{"startTime":4613.066,"endTime":4614.366,"body":"Well, if he lives, then"},{"startTime":4614.366,"endTime":4617.866,"body":"that implies more crimes yet."},{"startTime":4618.1,"endTime":4619.966,"body":"It implies more crimes yet,"},{"startTime":4622.533,"endTime":4625.899,"body":"but it also, I think, is suggestive of"},{"startTime":4625.899,"endTime":4629.3,"body":"where we should be looking for this power"},{"startTime":4629.3,"endTime":4631.5,"body":"to be continued, to be wielded."},{"startTime":4631.933,"endTime":4633.399,"body":"So to the extent that the thing is still"},{"startTime":4633.399,"endTime":4636.033,"body":"alive, Epstein having survived is"},{"startTime":4636.033,"endTime":4637.966,"body":"meaningful because, wow, is it an"},{"startTime":4637.966,"endTime":4639.666,"body":"important feature of the Game of Thrones"},{"startTime":4639.666,"endTime":4641.366,"body":"that's being conducted."},{"startTime":4642.5,"endTime":4644.6,"body":"So I think that the game theory, quite"},{"startTime":4644.6,"endTime":4645.833,"body":"apart from the evidence, and there is"},{"startTime":4645.833,"endTime":4647.033,"body":"evidence that's weird."},{"startTime":4647.699,"endTime":4651.066,"body":"There's evidence that there was a decoy"},{"startTime":4651.066,"endTime":4655.899,"body":"vehicle when Epstein supposedly killed"},{"startTime":4655.899,"endTime":4660.866,"body":"himself, you know, designed to mislead"},{"startTime":4660.866,"endTime":4663.366,"body":"the press as to what vehicle to follow."},{"startTime":4665.966,"endTime":4669.833,"body":"Could you put up the evidence of the hard"},{"startTime":4669.833,"endTime":4672.033,"body":"drive having been wiped?"},{"startTime":4674.266,"endTime":4677.899,"body":"So, okay, I tweeted nothing to see here,"},{"startTime":4677.899,"endTime":4680.233,"body":"literally, in response to an account"},{"startTime":4680.233,"endTime":4683.466,"body":"called Brian Allen, who says, \"Newly"},{"startTime":4683.466,"endTime":4685.366,"body":"released documents show an FBI agent"},{"startTime":4685.366,"endTime":4688.233,"body":"removed the hard drive from the jail, the"},{"startTime":4688.233,"endTime":4690.833,"body":"jail's camera wiping all the footage from"},{"startTime":4690.833,"endTime":4692.8,"body":"the night Jeffrey Epstein died.\""},{"startTime":4694.3,"endTime":4695.566,"body":"And then if you look at the documents,"},{"startTime":4695.566,"endTime":4696.566,"body":"which are unfortunately"},{"startTime":4698.366,"endTime":4699.399,"body":"a little blurry, I"},{"startTime":4699.399,"endTime":4701.433,"body":"think I have a copy here."},{"startTime":4701.899,"endTime":4703.466,"body":"That's the second one, Jen."},{"startTime":4706.0,"endTime":4712.8,"body":"So this one, uh, is a document, appears"},{"startTime":4712.8,"endTime":4716.666,"body":"to be the interview of a witness who has"},{"startTime":4716.666,"endTime":4719.033,"body":"been redacted on 3-12-2020."},{"startTime":4719.399,"endTime":4720.566,"body":"It's page two of two."},{"startTime":4720.833,"endTime":4722.333,"body":"Page one of two is also included here."},{"startTime":4723.366,"endTime":4725.433,"body":"It says, \"Told to start working on the"},{"startTime":4725.433,"endTime":4728.333,"body":"system, then redacted, started removing"},{"startTime":4728.333,"endTime":4729.666,"body":"the bad drives in"},{"startTime":4729.666,"endTime":4731.0,"body":"order to rebuild the DVR."},{"startTime":4731.033,"endTime":4735.366,"body":"Redacted advised that an FBI agent was"},{"startTime":4735.366,"endTime":4737.399,"body":"the one who pulled out the DVR."},{"startTime":4737.966,"endTime":4740.433,"body":"Redacted also advised that he knew that"},{"startTime":4740.433,"endTime":4743.233,"body":"by replacing both hard drives, the system"},{"startTime":4743.233,"endTime":4746.533,"body":"would be wiped and that he had advised"},{"startTime":4746.633,"endTime":4749.333,"body":"personnel at MCC of that.\""},{"startTime":4749.633,"endTime":4750.833,"body":"MCC is the correctional"},{"startTime":4750.833,"endTime":4752.133,"body":"facility where Epstein was?"},{"startTime":4752.133,"endTime":4752.333,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4752.933,"endTime":4753.6,"body":"So there is"},{"startTime":4754.933,"endTime":4757.899,"body":"evidence, the story that we are given is"},{"startTime":4757.899,"endTime":4759.666,"body":"that there was massive failure in the"},{"startTime":4759.666,"endTime":4762.833,"body":"technology at the prison site."},{"startTime":4762.833,"endTime":4763.466,"body":"It's bad luck."},{"startTime":4764.233,"endTime":4764.933,"body":"Well, I think there is"},{"startTime":4764.933,"endTime":4766.666,"body":"massive failure of the technology."},{"startTime":4766.666,"endTime":4768.633,"body":"It's not well maintained, which of course"},{"startTime":4768.633,"endTime":4771.399,"body":"leaves open the option to make, to hide"},{"startTime":4771.399,"endTime":4773.366,"body":"something with technological failures."},{"startTime":4773.366,"endTime":4774.8,"body":"But the claim here, which I"},{"startTime":4774.8,"endTime":4776.166,"body":"find frankly extraordinary,"},{"startTime":4776.166,"endTime":4777.3,"body":"the claim in what you just read,"},{"startTime":4777.566,"endTime":4780.566,"body":"yeah, is that the drive, that there were"},{"startTime":4780.566,"endTime":4782.066,"body":"failures of multiple drives."},{"startTime":4782.066,"endTime":4783.966,"body":"It was only one drive, I think, that was"},{"startTime":4783.966,"endTime":4785.533,"body":"likely to have the footage."},{"startTime":4785.8,"endTime":4786.533,"body":"It had failed."},{"startTime":4786.933,"endTime":4788.833,"body":"And in order to replace it, to get the"},{"startTime":4788.833,"endTime":4790.633,"body":"system back up and running after his"},{"startTime":4790.633,"endTime":4792.699,"body":"death, they knew that it would wipe the"},{"startTime":4792.699,"endTime":4793.633,"body":"data off this drive."},{"startTime":4794.166,"endTime":4798.833,"body":"Now, that contravenes my understanding of"},{"startTime":4798.833,"endTime":4801.466,"body":"how most drives work, whether this was a"},{"startTime":4801.466,"endTime":4804.699,"body":"physical disk drive or an SSD, there's no"},{"startTime":4804.699,"endTime":4806.233,"body":"reason that memory should be volatile."},{"startTime":4806.466,"endTime":4808.033,"body":"And of course, the FBI should have"},{"startTime":4808.033,"endTime":4809.899,"body":"captured whatever drive was removed."},{"startTime":4810.133,"endTime":4813.333,"body":"And there's of course, an industry that"},{"startTime":4813.399,"endTime":4815.266,"body":"specializes on recovering data, even"},{"startTime":4815.266,"endTime":4818.166,"body":"deleted data from hard drives and things."},{"startTime":4818.366,"endTime":4820.166,"body":"So I don't understand what the claim even"},{"startTime":4820.166,"endTime":4821.466,"body":"is, why it would have been deleted, but"},{"startTime":4821.466,"endTime":4824.5,"body":"let's say that that claim is valid."},{"startTime":4827.0,"endTime":4827.199,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":4828.266,"endTime":4829.933,"body":"Why on earth in light of"},{"startTime":4829.933,"endTime":4831.666,"body":"the crime that was committed,"},{"startTime":4834.433,"endTime":4836.333,"body":"would you not have moved heaven and earth"},{"startTime":4836.333,"endTime":4838.866,"body":"to preserve whatever evidence was there?"},{"startTime":4838.866,"endTime":4840.966,"body":"Because the question about whether he"},{"startTime":4840.966,"endTime":4844.033,"body":"killed himself is painfully obvious,"},{"startTime":4844.366,"endTime":4845.566,"body":"especially in light of the failure, you"},{"startTime":4845.566,"endTime":4848.699,"body":"know, the guards were asleep, the camera"},{"startTime":4848.699,"endTime":4850.266,"body":"system wasn't working in the right place,"},{"startTime":4850.733,"endTime":4852.666,"body":"some dude had been moved"},{"startTime":4852.666,"endTime":4854.766,"body":"into his cell, some murderer."},{"startTime":4855.333,"endTime":4856.933,"body":"So there's all kinds of reasons that"},{"startTime":4856.933,"endTime":4858.266,"body":"there you would want to be able to nail"},{"startTime":4858.266,"endTime":4859.966,"body":"down exactly what happened if that's what"},{"startTime":4859.966,"endTime":4860.833,"body":"you were trying to do."},{"startTime":4860.833,"endTime":4862.533,"body":"And it is very convenient that"},{"startTime":4864.233,"endTime":4866.033,"body":"the hard drive apparently got wiped in an"},{"startTime":4866.033,"endTime":4866.933,"body":"attempt to repair the"},{"startTime":4866.933,"endTime":4869.733,"body":"system, if that happened."},{"startTime":4870.566,"endTime":4870.766,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":4870.933,"endTime":4873.6,"body":"But I don't think any of the evidence we"},{"startTime":4873.6,"endTime":4876.566,"body":"have so far is more than suggestive."},{"startTime":4877.199,"endTime":4878.633,"body":"And some of it, I think"},{"startTime":4878.633,"endTime":4879.766,"body":"turns out to be garbage."},{"startTime":4879.766,"endTime":4882.566,"body":"So there was a brief flurry of excitement"},{"startTime":4882.566,"endTime":4884.933,"body":"over the fact that Epstein appears to"},{"startTime":4884.933,"endTime":4887.133,"body":"have had a Fortnite account of video game"},{"startTime":4887.133,"endTime":4888.666,"body":"that continued to be"},{"startTime":4888.666,"endTime":4890.233,"body":"active after his death."},{"startTime":4890.966,"endTime":4894.033,"body":"Fortnite put out a press release in which"},{"startTime":4894.033,"endTime":4896.733,"body":"they said that some other account had"},{"startTime":4896.733,"endTime":4898.466,"body":"changed their name to look like Jeffrey"},{"startTime":4898.466,"endTime":4900.933,"body":"Epstein's account, the prank or whatever."},{"startTime":4901.899,"endTime":4902.233,"body":"Hilarious."},{"startTime":4903.533,"endTime":4905.733,"body":"But the point is, okay, so that could be"},{"startTime":4905.733,"endTime":4909.366,"body":"just some lone person doing something"},{"startTime":4909.366,"endTime":4911.233,"body":"stupid, or it could be what's called"},{"startTime":4911.233,"endTime":4913.233,"body":"flooding the zone where you're trying to"},{"startTime":4913.233,"endTime":4915.466,"body":"figure out what happened and lots of"},{"startTime":4915.466,"endTime":4917.133,"body":"garbage-y conspiracy theories are"},{"startTime":4917.133,"endTime":4919.666,"body":"introduced into the milieu so that you"},{"startTime":4919.666,"endTime":4921.833,"body":"can't sort reality from garbage."},{"startTime":4923.3,"endTime":4923.766,"body":"But all right."},{"startTime":4924.866,"endTime":4925.766,"body":"Here's my point."},{"startTime":4926.533,"endTime":4929.133,"body":"Put the evidence of something fishy"},{"startTime":4929.133,"endTime":4931.433,"body":"around Epstein's death aside."},{"startTime":4932.333,"endTime":4934.5,"body":"And let's do this from pure game theory."},{"startTime":4936.6,"endTime":4938.766,"body":"Epstein, whether it was the purpose of"},{"startTime":4938.766,"endTime":4941.066,"body":"what he was doing, one of the purposes or"},{"startTime":4941.066,"endTime":4945.166,"body":"not the purpose at all, had a lot of"},{"startTime":4945.166,"endTime":4948.266,"body":"compromise on some of the most important,"},{"startTime":4948.633,"endTime":4949.833,"body":"powerful people on earth."},{"startTime":4950.566,"endTime":4952.366,"body":"You know, members of the Royal Family,"},{"startTime":4953.5,"endTime":4954.533,"body":"people at the top of"},{"startTime":4954.533,"endTime":4957.199,"body":"science, universities,"},{"startTime":4958.333,"endTime":4958.566,"body":"government."},{"startTime":4959.566,"endTime":4960.466,"body":"He had a lot of"},{"startTime":4960.466,"endTime":4963.133,"body":"compromise on powerful people."},{"startTime":4965.133,"endTime":4967.133,"body":"That means two things."},{"startTime":4967.866,"endTime":4970.133,"body":"One, it means that he would have"},{"startTime":4970.133,"endTime":4971.866,"body":"perceived a certain amount of danger"},{"startTime":4971.866,"endTime":4973.833,"body":"because to the extent that people had"},{"startTime":4973.833,"endTime":4975.733,"body":"done things in his presence that then"},{"startTime":4975.733,"endTime":4978.866,"body":"jeopardized them later, the temptation to"},{"startTime":4978.866,"endTime":4981.033,"body":"eliminate him so that that stuff did not"},{"startTime":4981.033,"endTime":4982.199,"body":"come to light must have been"},{"startTime":4982.199,"endTime":4983.366,"body":"on a lot of people's minds."},{"startTime":4983.8,"endTime":4984.0,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":4984.766,"endTime":4991.933,"body":"And two, he had the purest, most refined"},{"startTime":4991.933,"endTime":4993.833,"body":"material with which to"},{"startTime":4993.833,"endTime":4995.466,"body":"fashion a dead man switch."},{"startTime":4995.533,"endTime":4998.966,"body":"The term ring a bell."},{"startTime":4999.533,"endTime":5000.733,"body":"I think you talked about this last time."},{"startTime":5001.266,"endTime":5005.466,"body":"So the point is he would have understood."},{"startTime":5005.733,"endTime":5006.933,"body":"I mean, I know what it means, but you"},{"startTime":5006.933,"endTime":5008.6,"body":"may, if you, if you thought I didn't,"},{"startTime":5008.6,"endTime":5009.366,"body":"it's possible that some"},{"startTime":5009.366,"endTime":5010.733,"body":"people in our audience still."},{"startTime":5010.733,"endTime":5014.333,"body":"A dead man switch is something that is"},{"startTime":5014.333,"endTime":5018.833,"body":"designed to be revealed if you suffer an"},{"startTime":5018.833,"endTime":5022.566,"body":"untimely death in order that those who"},{"startTime":5022.566,"endTime":5025.466,"body":"might want to kill you will not do it."},{"startTime":5026.433,"endTime":5029.533,"body":"And my feeling is Jeffrey Epstein may not"},{"startTime":5029.533,"endTime":5031.633,"body":"have been the swiftest, swiftest tool in"},{"startTime":5031.633,"endTime":5033.699,"body":"the shed, but he was certainly smart"},{"startTime":5033.699,"endTime":5034.933,"body":"enough to understand."},{"startTime":5034.933,"endTime":5035.233,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":5035.233,"endTime":5035.833,"body":"The swiftest."},{"startTime":5035.833,"endTime":5036.866,"body":"He wasn't the"},{"startTime":5036.866,"endTime":5038.366,"body":"sharpest bulb in the drawer."},{"startTime":5040.066,"endTime":5041.466,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":5042.466,"endTime":5043.966,"body":"But he was certainly smart enough to"},{"startTime":5043.966,"endTime":5047.033,"body":"understand a that he was in jeopardy and"},{"startTime":5047.033,"endTime":5050.966,"body":"be that he could change the set of"},{"startTime":5050.966,"endTime":5054.033,"body":"incentives around eliminating him such"},{"startTime":5054.033,"endTime":5056.933,"body":"that were he defined himself in prison,"},{"startTime":5056.933,"endTime":5058.966,"body":"he couldn't just simply be."},{"startTime":5058.966,"endTime":5066.333,"body":"So I think if let's just go through the"},{"startTime":5066.333,"endTime":5068.766,"body":"set of possibilities, it is possible."},{"startTime":5068.866,"endTime":5070.566,"body":"Jeffrey Epstein killed himself."},{"startTime":5070.866,"endTime":5071.6,"body":"Why would he have done that?"},{"startTime":5072.066,"endTime":5074.1,"body":"He would have killed himself because he"},{"startTime":5074.1,"endTime":5078.533,"body":"didn't want to face the consequences for"},{"startTime":5078.533,"endTime":5080.166,"body":"what would be revealed in a trial."},{"startTime":5081.666,"endTime":5081.866,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":5082.899,"endTime":5085.733,"body":"On the other hand, he had a lot of power."},{"startTime":5086.333,"endTime":5088.266,"body":"He had a lot of powerful people who had"},{"startTime":5088.266,"endTime":5091.199,"body":"an interest in him, not saying what he"},{"startTime":5091.199,"endTime":5093.533,"body":"knew on the stand or making a plea deal,"},{"startTime":5093.533,"endTime":5095.399,"body":"throwing bigger fish under the bus."},{"startTime":5096.3,"endTime":5099.433,"body":"So would he have killed himself in order"},{"startTime":5099.433,"endTime":5102.266,"body":"to avoid a trial in which he actually had"},{"startTime":5102.266,"endTime":5105.633,"body":"cards that may well have allowed him to"},{"startTime":5105.633,"endTime":5106.566,"body":"get a sweetheart deal the"},{"startTime":5106.566,"endTime":5108.0,"body":"way he did in his first trial?"},{"startTime":5108.733,"endTime":5109.666,"body":"Doesn't sound likely."},{"startTime":5109.933,"endTime":5113.1,"body":"This is somebody who might have done that"},{"startTime":5113.1,"endTime":5114.466,"body":"only if he thought he"},{"startTime":5114.466,"endTime":5116.366,"body":"didn't have any other options."},{"startTime":5116.666,"endTime":5118.966,"body":"And we were a long way from finding out"},{"startTime":5118.966,"endTime":5120.166,"body":"that he didn't have any other options."},{"startTime":5121.666,"endTime":5124.3,"body":"So that raises the question of whether or"},{"startTime":5124.3,"endTime":5125.699,"body":"not he was suicided."},{"startTime":5127.366,"endTime":5128.966,"body":"Would he have been suicided?"},{"startTime":5129.766,"endTime":5131.366,"body":"Well, he would have been..."},{"startTime":5131.366,"endTime":5132.966,"body":"That's an Orwellian word right there."},{"startTime":5132.966,"endTime":5137.3,"body":"It is an Orwellian word, but he would"},{"startTime":5137.3,"endTime":5139.233,"body":"have been suicided by people who thought"},{"startTime":5139.233,"endTime":5141.666,"body":"they stood to gain by his never making it"},{"startTime":5141.666,"endTime":5143.333,"body":"to the stand, which he would have"},{"startTime":5143.333,"endTime":5144.933,"body":"anticipated, having"},{"startTime":5144.933,"endTime":5146.833,"body":"already been convicted once."},{"startTime":5147.966,"endTime":5151.866,"body":"So I think that that suggests that in"},{"startTime":5151.866,"endTime":5154.566,"body":"light of his being incarcerated, there"},{"startTime":5154.566,"endTime":5157.333,"body":"would be a lot of very powerful people,"},{"startTime":5157.333,"endTime":5158.0,"body":"people with"},{"startTime":5158.0,"endTime":5160.266,"body":"superpowers at their disposal."},{"startTime":5160.833,"endTime":5162.666,"body":"If this involved intelligence agencies,"},{"startTime":5163.966,"endTime":5165.966,"body":"those are the kinds of people who have"},{"startTime":5165.966,"endTime":5170.933,"body":"the ability to fake evidence, to create"},{"startTime":5170.933,"endTime":5176.266,"body":"events, to disappear people and put them"},{"startTime":5176.266,"endTime":5177.333,"body":"in witness protection or"},{"startTime":5177.333,"endTime":5178.433,"body":"whatever it is that they do."},{"startTime":5178.933,"endTime":5181.866,"body":"So the game theory alone suggests that"},{"startTime":5181.866,"endTime":5183.033,"body":"this should be a primary"},{"startTime":5183.033,"endTime":5185.466,"body":"concern for the public."},{"startTime":5185.733,"endTime":5187.866,"body":"And if he is still alive, obviously he's"},{"startTime":5187.866,"endTime":5188.766,"body":"still a witness to whatever"},{"startTime":5188.766,"endTime":5190.233,"body":"it was he was participating in."},{"startTime":5190.233,"endTime":5191.866,"body":"And he knows who else was participating."},{"startTime":5192.333,"endTime":5192.866,"body":"And I should point"},{"startTime":5192.866,"endTime":5195.366,"body":"out, I am so not suicidal."},{"startTime":5196.866,"endTime":5197.733,"body":"I'm really not suicidal"},{"startTime":5197.733,"endTime":5198.666,"body":"and I'm in very good health."},{"startTime":5199.333,"endTime":5200.033,"body":"Yes, you are."},{"startTime":5200.366,"endTime":5200.566,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":5201.533,"endTime":5201.966,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":5205.0,"endTime":5207.0,"body":"You're looking at me like I should have a"},{"startTime":5207.0,"endTime":5210.133,"body":"follow on and I just, I honestly, I mean,"},{"startTime":5210.133,"endTime":5211.833,"body":"I was right there with you."},{"startTime":5212.466,"endTime":5215.066,"body":"Also, the frogs have begun to call and I"},{"startTime":5215.066,"endTime":5217.0,"body":"was thinking about the beauty of a spring"},{"startTime":5217.0,"endTime":5219.233,"body":"that is coming with the frogs calling and"},{"startTime":5219.233,"endTime":5221.966,"body":"how much more I prefer to think about"},{"startTime":5221.966,"endTime":5223.133,"body":"frogs than Jeffrey Epstein."},{"startTime":5223.399,"endTime":5224.533,"body":"Yes, absolutely."},{"startTime":5225.1,"endTime":5225.466,"body":"Absolutely."},{"startTime":5225.899,"endTime":5226.199,"body":"I agree."},{"startTime":5226.566,"endTime":5227.766,"body":"The frogs are beginning to call."},{"startTime":5227.766,"endTime":5229.133,"body":"I heard that last week and thought, you"},{"startTime":5229.133,"endTime":5230.266,"body":"know, there's always that one day."},{"startTime":5230.266,"endTime":5232.133,"body":"It's always strangely in the winter here"},{"startTime":5232.633,"endTime":5233.933,"body":"when the frogs begin to call."},{"startTime":5233.933,"endTime":5235.166,"body":"Oh, that's frogs for you."},{"startTime":5235.533,"endTime":5236.366,"body":"That's temperate frogs."},{"startTime":5237.766,"endTime":5238.533,"body":"It was a little later in"},{"startTime":5238.533,"endTime":5239.833,"body":"Michigan, a lot later in fact."},{"startTime":5240.833,"endTime":5242.633,"body":"Well, Michigan, you may remember, had"},{"startTime":5242.633,"endTime":5244.033,"body":"rather harsher winters."},{"startTime":5244.366,"endTime":5245.566,"body":"Oh, yeah. I mean, just, you know, a little bit"},{"startTime":5245.566,"endTime":5247.699,"body":"south and west of Michigan, the frogs,"},{"startTime":5247.933,"endTime":5250.333,"body":"some species of frogs actually bury"},{"startTime":5250.333,"endTime":5252.266,"body":"themselves underground and become frozen"},{"startTime":5252.266,"endTime":5254.066,"body":"little frogsicles such that you could dig"},{"startTime":5254.066,"endTime":5255.5,"body":"them up and drop them and they'd shatter"},{"startTime":5255.5,"endTime":5256.3,"body":"if you didn't give"},{"startTime":5256.3,"endTime":5257.833,"body":"them the time to thaw out."},{"startTime":5257.833,"endTime":5260.466,"body":"So Michigan and the Pacific Northwest do"},{"startTime":5260.466,"endTime":5261.366,"body":"not exactly have the"},{"startTime":5261.366,"endTime":5262.1,"body":"same kind of winters."},{"startTime":5262.6,"endTime":5262.866,"body":"Totally agree."},{"startTime":5263.266,"endTime":5263.466,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":5263.566,"endTime":5263.866,"body":"Totally agree."},{"startTime":5264.266,"endTime":5264.966,"body":"See, I'm much more"},{"startTime":5264.966,"endTime":5267.933,"body":"energized than Jeffrey Epstein."},{"startTime":5268.966,"endTime":5269.166,"body":"Agreed."},{"startTime":5269.633,"endTime":5270.066,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":5271.633,"endTime":5271.833,"body":"Well,"},{"startTime":5273.333,"endTime":5274.899,"body":"shall we save the..."},{"startTime":5276.533,"endTime":5281.933,"body":"You know, as much more awful what may be"},{"startTime":5281.933,"endTime":5284.266,"body":"coming in AI will be three days from now."},{"startTime":5284.266,"endTime":5285.266,"body":"And that is, in fact, one"},{"startTime":5285.266,"endTime":5287.033,"body":"of the messages in the piece."},{"startTime":5288.333,"endTime":5290.466,"body":"I don't think 72 hours with regard to our"},{"startTime":5290.466,"endTime":5291.266,"body":"discussion of it is"},{"startTime":5291.266,"endTime":5292.3,"body":"going to change that much."},{"startTime":5292.766,"endTime":5293.733,"body":"And we are going to"},{"startTime":5293.733,"endTime":5294.566,"body":"be back in three days."},{"startTime":5294.933,"endTime":5297.066,"body":"So I think we should"},{"startTime":5297.066,"endTime":5297.766,"body":"save that discussion."},{"startTime":5298.166,"endTime":5298.5,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":5298.5,"endTime":5298.933,"body":"We'll save it."},{"startTime":5299.233,"endTime":5299.466,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":5301.633,"endTime":5302.266,"body":"Is there anything else"},{"startTime":5302.266,"endTime":5303.333,"body":"that you wanted to talk about?"},{"startTime":5304.766,"endTime":5305.233,"body":"Frogs, perhaps?"},{"startTime":5305.433,"endTime":5306.766,"body":"Ah, yes."},{"startTime":5307.266,"endTime":5307.733,"body":"Good Lord."},{"startTime":5307.733,"endTime":5309.333,"body":"There is something I want to talk about."},{"startTime":5309.633,"endTime":5311.266,"body":"Full stop from all of that stuff."},{"startTime":5311.266,"endTime":5311.966,"body":"Actually, pick the"},{"startTime":5311.966,"endTime":5313.199,"body":"discussion up from frogs."},{"startTime":5314.233,"endTime":5314.433,"body":"Frogs."},{"startTime":5314.466,"endTime":5316.133,"body":"Which have nothing to do with what I want"},{"startTime":5316.133,"endTime":5318.0,"body":"to present, but is at"},{"startTime":5318.0,"endTime":5319.066,"body":"least a lovely topic."},{"startTime":5319.333,"endTime":5321.733,"body":"I wanted to point out that"},{"startTime":5321.733,"endTime":5324.333,"body":"Ralston has their applications."},{"startTime":5324.566,"endTime":5325.666,"body":"You talked about this last time, too."},{"startTime":5327.433,"endTime":5327.933,"body":"Maybe you didn't."},{"startTime":5328.166,"endTime":5329.133,"body":"I don't think I did."},{"startTime":5329.133,"endTime":5329.966,"body":"I intended to."},{"startTime":5330.266,"endTime":5330.866,"body":"I intended to."},{"startTime":5330.866,"endTime":5331.433,"body":"And I forgot."},{"startTime":5331.433,"endTime":5331.666,"body":"You tweeted it."},{"startTime":5331.899,"endTime":5332.5,"body":"I tweeted it."},{"startTime":5332.733,"endTime":5332.933,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":5333.533,"endTime":5333.733,"body":"Wow."},{"startTime":5334.066,"endTime":5334.333,"body":"You tweeted it."},{"startTime":5337.233,"endTime":5338.533,"body":"I'm not going to put"},{"startTime":5338.533,"endTime":5339.833,"body":"that in the past tense."},{"startTime":5339.833,"endTime":5340.833,"body":"It's just something I don't do."},{"startTime":5341.966,"endTime":5343.666,"body":"Um, all right."},{"startTime":5345.1,"endTime":5345.933,"body":"Ralston College."},{"startTime":5345.933,"endTime":5346.466,"body":"That's the one."},{"startTime":5346.8,"endTime":5350.466,"body":"Is an amazing educational institution and"},{"startTime":5350.466,"endTime":5351.966,"body":"educational experiment."},{"startTime":5352.5,"endTime":5355.166,"body":"You and I spent a lovely, was it a week?"},{"startTime":5356.433,"endTime":5357.333,"body":"Something close to that."},{"startTime":5357.333,"endTime":5357.766,"body":"Close to that."},{"startTime":5358.233,"endTime":5360.666,"body":"At their Savannah campus, interacting"},{"startTime":5360.666,"endTime":5363.633,"body":"with their class, which was on the verge"},{"startTime":5363.633,"endTime":5365.6,"body":"of graduation in their master's program."},{"startTime":5366.566,"endTime":5367.833,"body":"We gave four Sophia"},{"startTime":5367.833,"endTime":5370.133,"body":"lectures, which are available online."},{"startTime":5371.3,"endTime":5373.166,"body":"Anyway, I know that I speak for both of"},{"startTime":5373.166,"endTime":5375.533,"body":"us in that we were completely blown away"},{"startTime":5375.533,"endTime":5377.966,"body":"by how effective Ralston had been at"},{"startTime":5377.966,"endTime":5380.766,"body":"creating an educational environment."},{"startTime":5382.233,"endTime":5386.366,"body":"That was like the full, the full human"},{"startTime":5386.366,"endTime":5387.966,"body":"experience from their"},{"startTime":5387.966,"endTime":5391.066,"body":"initiating their program in Greece."},{"startTime":5391.1,"endTime":5392.066,"body":"Um,"},{"startTime":5393.733,"endTime":5396.566,"body":"learning a language, uh, and then coming"},{"startTime":5396.566,"endTime":5398.733,"body":"back to Savannah and studying"},{"startTime":5400.633,"endTime":5402.066,"body":"classics and much else."},{"startTime":5402.233,"endTime":5406.833,"body":"Anyway, a beautiful experience and one"},{"startTime":5406.833,"endTime":5412.066,"body":"that is clearly hyper enabling for"},{"startTime":5414.766,"endTime":5416.899,"body":"the soul for lack of a better term."},{"startTime":5417.733,"endTime":5419.233,"body":"Anyway, their applications are open."},{"startTime":5419.266,"endTime":5422.533,"body":"I don't know if you all have the"},{"startTime":5422.533,"endTime":5424.933,"body":"bandwidth to take this master's program"},{"startTime":5424.933,"endTime":5427.133,"body":"or if you know somebody who"},{"startTime":5427.133,"endTime":5429.033,"body":"does have that bandwidth, but"},{"startTime":5429.033,"endTime":5432.466,"body":"it's one full intensive full residency"},{"startTime":5432.466,"endTime":5435.666,"body":"year, which begins in Greece"},{"startTime":5435.666,"endTime":5437.733,"body":"and ends in Savannah, Georgia."},{"startTime":5438.066,"endTime":5438.266,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":5438.5,"endTime":5441.766,"body":"And I will tell you that, uh, if I were"},{"startTime":5441.766,"endTime":5444.833,"body":"of an appropriate age and stage in my"},{"startTime":5444.833,"endTime":5446.699,"body":"life, I would want to have done this"},{"startTime":5446.699,"endTime":5448.733,"body":"program, having now seen what it's like."},{"startTime":5449.733,"endTime":5452.466,"body":"So anyway, great stuff."},{"startTime":5453.166,"endTime":5455.699,"body":"And I hope this catches someone's"},{"startTime":5455.699,"endTime":5457.366,"body":"attention who, uh, applies"},{"startTime":5457.366,"endTime":5459.533,"body":"and ends up taking the course."},{"startTime":5459.533,"endTime":5460.766,"body":"And we'd love to hear how it goes."},{"startTime":5461.833,"endTime":5462.033,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":5463.233,"endTime":5465.133,"body":"Actually one more thing before, before we"},{"startTime":5465.133,"endTime":5466.066,"body":"sign off today, we'll be"},{"startTime":5466.066,"endTime":5467.433,"body":"back on Valentine's day,"},{"startTime":5468.533,"endTime":5472.933,"body":"is, uh, two weeks ago, I initiated the"},{"startTime":5472.933,"endTime":5473.766,"body":"COVID era stories"},{"startTime":5473.766,"endTime":5475.533,"body":"project at natural selections."},{"startTime":5476.033,"endTime":5478.533,"body":"And, um, you can show my screen."},{"startTime":5478.533,"endTime":5481.633,"body":"I'm not going to read from this week's"},{"startTime":5481.633,"endTime":5484.899,"body":"contribution, but, um, uh, at natural"},{"startTime":5484.899,"endTime":5487.899,"body":"selections, uh, I am now for, for the"},{"startTime":5487.899,"endTime":5490.0,"body":"foreseeable future, uh, every Tuesday,"},{"startTime":5490.0,"endTime":5493.033,"body":"uh, publishing one or this week, it was"},{"startTime":5493.033,"endTime":5495.766,"body":"two shorter pieces, uh, from people who"},{"startTime":5495.766,"endTime":5497.399,"body":"have written in, uh, the, and the"},{"startTime":5497.399,"endTime":5499.133,"body":"directions for what to submit and how to"},{"startTime":5499.133,"endTime":5500.566,"body":"submit it are here in the COVID, the"},{"startTime":5500.566,"endTime":5501.866,"body":"original COVID era stories post."},{"startTime":5502.633,"endTime":5505.633,"body":"But we now have as of yesterday, three"},{"startTime":5505.633,"endTime":5509.066,"body":"stories in two separate posts of, of"},{"startTime":5509.066,"endTime":5511.5,"body":"people's experiences during COVID that"},{"startTime":5511.5,"endTime":5513.233,"body":"are already highly variable."},{"startTime":5514.0,"endTime":5518.633,"body":"And, uh, this is in part an attempt where"},{"startTime":5518.633,"endTime":5521.766,"body":"none of us to forget for, for us all to"},{"startTime":5521.766,"endTime":5525.166,"body":"remember pieces of the, of the things"},{"startTime":5525.166,"endTime":5528.033,"body":"that we lived through that, um, that are"},{"startTime":5528.033,"endTime":5529.199,"body":"becoming foggier and"},{"startTime":5529.199,"endTime":5531.066,"body":"vaguer with every passing week."},{"startTime":5531.1,"endTime":5533.966,"body":"So I'm encouraging people to write, uh,"},{"startTime":5533.966,"endTime":5535.133,"body":"even if they don't want to submit."},{"startTime":5536.266,"endTime":5539.033,"body":"And, um, we had a huge outpouring of"},{"startTime":5539.033,"endTime":5540.266,"body":"contributions right after"},{"startTime":5540.266,"endTime":5542.0,"body":"I, um, first posted this."},{"startTime":5542.199,"endTime":5543.133,"body":"So, uh, there's a, you"},{"startTime":5543.133,"endTime":5543.866,"body":"know, there's a big backlog."},{"startTime":5543.866,"endTime":5544.633,"body":"There's a lot of work"},{"startTime":5544.633,"endTime":5545.733,"body":"happening behind the scenes."},{"startTime":5546.533,"endTime":5548.066,"body":"But know that if you did want to submit"},{"startTime":5548.066,"endTime":5549.433,"body":"something, it would get read"},{"startTime":5549.433,"endTime":5551.3,"body":"and it might get published."},{"startTime":5552.1,"endTime":5555.066,"body":"And, um, people are, um, are saying that"},{"startTime":5555.066,"endTime":5557.133,"body":"it is helpful not just to write, but to"},{"startTime":5557.133,"endTime":5559.133,"body":"read what other people are saying about"},{"startTime":5559.133,"endTime":5562.533,"body":"what it is that, uh, that individuals and"},{"startTime":5562.533,"endTime":5565.066,"body":"that society went through, uh, as, as we"},{"startTime":5565.066,"endTime":5565.833,"body":"lived through COVID."},{"startTime":5566.833,"endTime":5568.466,"body":"I'm so thrilled that you're doing this."},{"startTime":5568.466,"endTime":5571.5,"body":"I really think in light of the dynamics"},{"startTime":5571.5,"endTime":5574.633,"body":"that you and I lived where sorting out"},{"startTime":5574.633,"endTime":5576.466,"body":"what the hell was going on in real time"},{"startTime":5576.466,"endTime":5578.833,"body":"was an incredibly fraught activity and"},{"startTime":5578.833,"endTime":5581.266,"body":"the pressure to move on and get past this"},{"startTime":5581.266,"endTime":5584.833,"body":"has been incredibly intense that this has"},{"startTime":5584.833,"endTime":5587.633,"body":"not only world changing potential, but"},{"startTime":5587.633,"endTime":5588.833,"body":"world bettering potential."},{"startTime":5589.166,"endTime":5591.533,"body":"If we can figure out at an individual"},{"startTime":5591.666,"endTime":5593.133,"body":"level, at a personal level, what"},{"startTime":5593.133,"endTime":5596.066,"body":"unfolded, how it caused people to behave"},{"startTime":5596.066,"endTime":5599.233,"body":"in the ways that they did and you know,"},{"startTime":5599.433,"endTime":5602.0,"body":"what it means, what are the ways in which"},{"startTime":5602.0,"endTime":5604.266,"body":"we've all been traumatized by the show of"},{"startTime":5604.266,"endTime":5607.699,"body":"force that coerced us into taking"},{"startTime":5607.699,"endTime":5610.166,"body":"medications that we didn't want to take"},{"startTime":5610.166,"endTime":5612.5,"body":"or saying things we didn't want to say"},{"startTime":5612.5,"endTime":5614.933,"body":"the fact that people were forced into all"},{"startTime":5614.933,"endTime":5617.433,"body":"this stuff, the mechanism by which that"},{"startTime":5617.433,"endTime":5618.266,"body":"happened has to be"},{"startTime":5618.266,"endTime":5620.466,"body":"recorded or it will happen again."},{"startTime":5621.133,"endTime":5621.333,"body":"Indeed."},{"startTime":5621.866,"endTime":5622.5,"body":"Precisely right."},{"startTime":5623.533,"endTime":5623.833,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":5624.1,"endTime":5625.766,"body":"Uh, well, we appreciate that"},{"startTime":5625.766,"endTime":5627.033,"body":"you've been here with us today."},{"startTime":5627.533,"endTime":5629.833,"body":"Uh, consider joining us on Locals."},{"startTime":5630.033,"endTime":5632.733,"body":"We will be doing a Q and a on Sunday"},{"startTime":5632.733,"endTime":5635.166,"body":"from, uh, for two hours starting at 11 am"},{"startTime":5635.166,"endTime":5637.233,"body":"Pacific, uh, on Locals only."},{"startTime":5637.533,"endTime":5639.933,"body":"And before then on Saturday at our usual"},{"startTime":5639.933,"endTime":5642.6,"body":"time of 11 30 am Pacific, we'll be doing"},{"startTime":5642.6,"endTime":5645.633,"body":"another live stream, uh, before, um,"},{"startTime":5646.033,"endTime":5647.966,"body":"going off air for a little bit, uh, for"},{"startTime":5647.966,"endTime":5649.266,"body":"the second half of the month, but those"},{"startTime":5649.266,"endTime":5651.133,"body":"are going to be two great inside rail"},{"startTime":5651.133,"endTime":5653.566,"body":"episodes, uh, while we are away."},{"startTime":5653.566,"endTime":5656.8,"body":"Uh, but, uh, come back in three days, uh,"},{"startTime":5656.8,"endTime":5659.5,"body":"for a somewhat rare Saturday live stream."},{"startTime":5660.066,"endTime":5662.899,"body":"And until you see us again, be good to"},{"startTime":5662.899,"endTime":5664.166,"body":"the ones you love, eat"},{"startTime":5664.166,"endTime":5665.833,"body":"good food, and get outside."},{"startTime":5666.133,"endTime":5666.699,"body":"Be well, everyone."}]}