{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"startTime":3603.633,"endTime":3606.336,"body":"(Upbeat Music)"},{"startTime":3608.171,"endTime":3610.239,"body":"Hey folks, welcome to The DarkHorse"},{"startTime":3610.239,"endTime":3612.175,"body":"Dodcast, live stream"},{"startTime":3612.241,"endTime":3615.044,"body":"number 334, I being Dr."},{"startTime":3615.044,"endTime":3617.18,"body":"Bret Weinstein, you being Dr."},{"startTime":3617.28,"endTime":3618.047,"body":"Heather Heying."},{"startTime":3618.615,"endTime":3619.849,"body":"And we are, we're gonna"},{"startTime":3619.849,"endTime":3622.285,"body":"do a little podcasting."},{"startTime":3622.585,"endTime":3623.92,"body":"And I talk about data centers."},{"startTime":3623.92,"endTime":3624.454,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":3624.52,"endTime":3626.122,"body":"And surveillance cameras"},{"startTime":3626.756,"endTime":3628.958,"body":"and the Cartesian crisis."},{"startTime":3629.359,"endTime":3630.326,"body":"Yes, the Cartesian"},{"startTime":3630.326,"endTime":3631.427,"body":"crisis, which marches on."},{"startTime":3631.728,"endTime":3635.064,"body":"It marches right on at a time when so"},{"startTime":3635.064,"endTime":3636.766,"body":"many of our systems, our health, our"},{"startTime":3636.766,"endTime":3638.201,"body":"privacy, everything seems"},{"startTime":3639.502,"endTime":3641.371,"body":"to be at greater risk than ever before,"},{"startTime":3641.371,"endTime":3642.372,"body":"it is becoming ever more"},{"startTime":3642.372,"endTime":3643.406,"body":"difficult to know what's true."},{"startTime":3644.04,"endTime":3646.075,"body":"Yes, the knowing what's true part, which"},{"startTime":3646.075,"endTime":3648.344,"body":"would be the sort of basis for rational"},{"startTime":3648.344,"endTime":3649.245,"body":"action going forward."},{"startTime":3649.245,"endTime":3650.78,"body":"So yes, it is getting harder and harder"},{"startTime":3650.78,"endTime":3653.483,"body":"to act in your own defense with the"},{"startTime":3653.483,"endTime":3655.952,"body":"cruddier, more compromised information."},{"startTime":3655.952,"endTime":3657.62,"body":"So we're gonna talk about that and many"},{"startTime":3657.62,"endTime":3659.989,"body":"of its tendrils and outgrowths."},{"startTime":3660.023,"endTime":3660.857,"body":"Indeed, indeed."},{"startTime":3661.457,"endTime":3663.192,"body":"We won't have a Q and A after the live"},{"startTime":3663.192,"endTime":3663.86,"body":"stream today, but we do"},{"startTime":3663.86,"endTime":3665.561,"body":"have one on Sunday at 11 a.m."},{"startTime":3665.561,"endTime":3667.864,"body":"Pacific for two hours for our supporters"},{"startTime":3667.864,"endTime":3669.332,"body":"on Locals join us there."},{"startTime":3669.365,"endTime":3670.867,"body":"The question answering"},{"startTime":3671.501,"endTime":3673.236,"body":"asking period is open now."},{"startTime":3674.037,"endTime":3677.874,"body":"And just a reminder that YouTube"},{"startTime":3677.874,"endTime":3679.976,"body":"demonetized us several years ago and they"},{"startTime":3679.976,"endTime":3682.245,"body":"quietly remonitized us without actually"},{"startTime":3682.645,"endTime":3686.916,"body":"supplying any of, much of any explanation"},{"startTime":3686.949,"endTime":3689.085,"body":"or really much of our revenue back."},{"startTime":3689.152,"endTime":3690.653,"body":"We know part of the explanation, which is"},{"startTime":3690.653,"endTime":3691.554,"body":"that they're scoundrels."},{"startTime":3692.455,"endTime":3694.223,"body":"They're scoundrels, they're scoundrels."},{"startTime":3694.223,"endTime":3696.259,"body":"And they did tell us the three offending"},{"startTime":3696.359,"endTime":3698.561,"body":"videos that caused us to demonetize us in"},{"startTime":3698.561,"endTime":3700.163,"body":"the first place, all having to do with"},{"startTime":3700.463,"endTime":3701.798,"body":"COVID, miss, diss, and"},{"startTime":3701.798,"endTime":3702.765,"body":"malinformation, I'm afraid."},{"startTime":3703.199,"endTime":3704.067,"body":"Right here, right here."},{"startTime":3704.067,"endTime":3705.301,"body":"Miss and diss from their perspective,"},{"startTime":3705.468,"endTime":3707.136,"body":"malinformation from our perspective,"},{"startTime":3707.136,"endTime":3708.771,"body":"meaning true things that make you"},{"startTime":3708.771,"endTime":3709.839,"body":"distrust your government."},{"startTime":3710.006,"endTime":3711.374,"body":"Yes, yes, yes."},{"startTime":3711.374,"endTime":3712.542,"body":"We were not actually engaged"},{"startTime":3712.542,"endTime":3714.444,"body":"in missed or diss information."},{"startTime":3714.444,"endTime":3717.28,"body":"These terms being kind of formally"},{"startTime":3717.28,"endTime":3719.015,"body":"defined during the COVID era"},{"startTime":3719.348,"endTime":3721.284,"body":"by the Biden administration."},{"startTime":3721.284,"endTime":3723.319,"body":"By the Department of Homeland Security,"},{"startTime":3723.352,"endTime":3725.154,"body":"which labeled missed, diss, and"},{"startTime":3725.188,"endTime":3726.856,"body":"malinformation forms of terrorism,"},{"startTime":3726.856,"endTime":3729.425,"body":"meaning that once they accuse you of"},{"startTime":3729.425,"endTime":3731.694,"body":"these things, you are unpersoned and"},{"startTime":3731.694,"endTime":3733.262,"body":"de-citizened and all sorts"},{"startTime":3733.262,"endTime":3734.163,"body":"of things can happen to you."},{"startTime":3734.23,"endTime":3735.765,"body":"Yeah, you could be unpersoned and"},{"startTime":3735.765,"endTime":3736.833,"body":"de-citizened and such."},{"startTime":3737.066,"endTime":3738.401,"body":"It's not automatic."},{"startTime":3738.434,"endTime":3739.102,"body":"We're not there yet."},{"startTime":3740.336,"endTime":3743.606,"body":"Your rights become mere privileges and"},{"startTime":3743.606,"endTime":3745.341,"body":"you may not know that it has happened."},{"startTime":3746.209,"endTime":3748.478,"body":"So consider, especially if you're"},{"startTime":3748.478,"endTime":3750.713,"body":"watching us on YouTube, subscribing,"},{"startTime":3750.913,"endTime":3754.183,"body":"liking, sharing, we're trying to get over"},{"startTime":3754.183,"endTime":3757.753,"body":"whatever, I don't know, whatever shadow"},{"startTime":3757.753,"endTime":3758.521,"body":"banning and censoring"},{"startTime":3758.521,"endTime":3759.422,"body":"they still have in place."},{"startTime":3759.522,"endTime":3760.723,"body":"Right, Ballyhooing I"},{"startTime":3760.723,"endTime":3762.592,"body":"think is also in order."},{"startTime":3762.592,"endTime":3763.493,"body":"I would have to look it"},{"startTime":3763.493,"endTime":3764.393,"body":"up to be sure of what--"},{"startTime":3764.393,"endTime":3765.628,"body":"Who do you want to Ballyhoo?"},{"startTime":3765.828,"endTime":3766.496,"body":"What do you think it means?"},{"startTime":3767.096,"endTime":3768.498,"body":"Doesn't it mean celebrate?"},{"startTime":3768.865,"endTime":3770.566,"body":"I don't think it can be used that way."},{"startTime":3770.566,"endTime":3771.834,"body":"I don't know my grammar well enough."},{"startTime":3771.834,"endTime":3774.003,"body":"I feel like you've used it as like a, I'm"},{"startTime":3774.003,"endTime":3775.238,"body":"gonna get this way wrong, but like an"},{"startTime":3775.238,"endTime":3776.072,"body":"intransitive verb or"},{"startTime":3776.072,"endTime":3777.039,"body":"something and it's not that--"},{"startTime":3777.54,"endTime":3779.442,"body":"Oh, well, I don't think I've--"},{"startTime":3779.442,"endTime":3780.977,"body":"I don't think a person can Ballyhoo."},{"startTime":3781.144,"endTime":3781.744,"body":"You can't?"},{"startTime":3782.612,"endTime":3783.813,"body":"I think it's, isn't it a noun?"},{"startTime":3785.081,"endTime":3785.581,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":3786.215,"endTime":3787.083,"body":"I think-- You're the one"},{"startTime":3787.083,"endTime":3787.683,"body":"who wrote the word noun."},{"startTime":3788.151,"endTime":3789.452,"body":"I definitely think you can Ballyhoo, but"},{"startTime":3789.452,"endTime":3791.32,"body":"we are gonna find out because there are people out there who know."},{"startTime":3791.32,"endTime":3792.321,"body":"You say that sort of thing"},{"startTime":3792.321,"endTime":3793.589,"body":"and then you never follow up."},{"startTime":3794.056,"endTime":3794.924,"body":"I'm following up."},{"startTime":3795.458,"endTime":3797.927,"body":"Next week's episode is going to be"},{"startTime":3799.061,"endTime":3801.731,"body":"predicated on Ballyhooing and all of its"},{"startTime":3801.731,"endTime":3802.865,"body":"various consequences."},{"startTime":3802.899,"endTime":3804.367,"body":"How many people do you need to remind you"},{"startTime":3804.367,"endTime":3805.268,"body":"in order to make that happen?"},{"startTime":3805.668,"endTime":3807.17,"body":"I think two is sufficient."},{"startTime":3807.503,"endTime":3808.404,"body":"And who are those people?"},{"startTime":3809.105,"endTime":3810.373,"body":"Probably you and Jan."},{"startTime":3810.506,"endTime":3812.742,"body":"I see, I'm just not taking this on."},{"startTime":3813.042,"endTime":3815.244,"body":"All right, I withdraw any reference to"},{"startTime":3815.244,"endTime":3817.413,"body":"Ballyhooing, though I am curious."},{"startTime":3817.413,"endTime":3818.848,"body":"I'm pretty sure you can Ballyhoo."},{"startTime":3818.848,"endTime":3819.715,"body":"I think that's the only"},{"startTime":3819.715,"endTime":3821.584,"body":"thing that does happen actually."},{"startTime":3822.418,"endTime":3823.219,"body":"In the universe."},{"startTime":3823.586,"endTime":3824.921,"body":"No, no, there are other things happening"},{"startTime":3824.954,"endTime":3826.689,"body":"in the universe at all kinds of scales."},{"startTime":3826.989,"endTime":3829.625,"body":"What I'm saying is that with respect to"},{"startTime":3829.625,"endTime":3831.761,"body":"Ballyhoo, whatever it means, I think it"},{"startTime":3831.761,"endTime":3833.563,"body":"is an action that one takes."},{"startTime":3833.563,"endTime":3835.531,"body":"Maybe a group of people can take it"},{"startTime":3835.531,"endTime":3836.732,"body":"collectively, but it is"},{"startTime":3836.732,"endTime":3838.034,"body":"something that has to be done."},{"startTime":3838.301,"endTime":3839.802,"body":"And I think it means celebrate."},{"startTime":3840.102,"endTime":3841.604,"body":"And if not, wow."},{"startTime":3841.704,"endTime":3843.206,"body":"Oh, there's definitely, there's like a"},{"startTime":3843.239,"endTime":3846.042,"body":"joyous, somewhat chaotic connotation to"},{"startTime":3846.042,"endTime":3847.944,"body":"it, whatever part of speech it is."},{"startTime":3847.977,"endTime":3849.345,"body":"And I was just suggesting that they do"},{"startTime":3849.345,"endTime":3851.414,"body":"that for us because I mean, they're here,"},{"startTime":3851.48,"endTime":3852.849,"body":"they like us, most of them."},{"startTime":3852.949,"endTime":3854.183,"body":"I'm sure there are some haters."},{"startTime":3854.417,"endTime":3856.152,"body":"I know it because there always are."},{"startTime":3856.219,"endTime":3857.92,"body":"But those who aren't"},{"startTime":3857.92,"endTime":3859.522,"body":"haters, go ahead and Ballyhoo."},{"startTime":3859.522,"endTime":3860.89,"body":"(Laughing)"},{"startTime":3862.024,"endTime":3864.694,"body":"I mean, maybe you should petition the"},{"startTime":3864.727,"endTime":3866.863,"body":"various platforms to add it as an option,"},{"startTime":3866.896,"endTime":3868.898,"body":"like share, like, subscribe, Ballyhoo."},{"startTime":3869.765,"endTime":3871.934,"body":"Well, I'm led to believe you cannot"},{"startTime":3872.001,"endTime":3873.769,"body":"petition the Lord with prayer."},{"startTime":3874.37,"endTime":3875.404,"body":"I'm not talking about the Lord, I'm"},{"startTime":3875.404,"endTime":3876.205,"body":"talking about YouTube."},{"startTime":3876.239,"endTime":3877.64,"body":"Okay, oh, all right."},{"startTime":3877.707,"endTime":3877.94,"body":"It's different."},{"startTime":3877.94,"endTime":3878.14,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":3879.508,"endTime":3880.009,"body":"Quite."},{"startTime":3880.476,"endTime":3883.012,"body":"Well, no, no, they're both, you know,"},{"startTime":3883.446,"endTime":3884.914,"body":"it's a minor deity of sorts."},{"startTime":3885.114,"endTime":3885.615,"body":"YouTube?"},{"startTime":3885.648,"endTime":3886.148,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":3886.716,"endTime":3888.017,"body":"It has tremendous"},{"startTime":3888.017,"endTime":3889.285,"body":"power, you will grant that."},{"startTime":3889.852,"endTime":3891.554,"body":"Power and deification are"},{"startTime":3891.554,"endTime":3892.521,"body":"not the same thing either."},{"startTime":3893.656,"endTime":3894.557,"body":"All right, this has now"},{"startTime":3894.557,"endTime":3896.125,"body":"become deeply philosophical."},{"startTime":3896.125,"endTime":3897.994,"body":"We have not paid the rent and may not be"},{"startTime":3897.994,"endTime":3899.729,"body":"able to pay the rent, this level of"},{"startTime":3899.729,"endTime":3901.697,"body":"philosophy being deployed up top."},{"startTime":3901.731,"endTime":3903.032,"body":"This is true, this is true."},{"startTime":3903.065,"endTime":3903.9,"body":"And pedantry."},{"startTime":3904.5,"endTime":3905.835,"body":"For sure, for sure that."},{"startTime":3906.502,"endTime":3909.472,"body":"Okay, we are indeed going to pay the rent"},{"startTime":3909.472,"endTime":3911.607,"body":"now with as always is the case, three"},{"startTime":3911.607,"endTime":3912.708,"body":"sponsors right up at the top."},{"startTime":3913.142,"endTime":3915.811,"body":"No other ad reads during our episodes."},{"startTime":3915.811,"endTime":3917.213,"body":"I've already given you one, right?"},{"startTime":3917.246,"endTime":3918.114,"body":"Yes, no, I got one."},{"startTime":3918.214,"endTime":3919.048,"body":"I'm only in possession of"},{"startTime":3919.048,"endTime":3919.882,"body":"two pieces of paper here."},{"startTime":3920.316,"endTime":3920.95,"body":"All right, our first"},{"startTime":3920.95,"endTime":3922.718,"body":"sponsor this week is new to us."},{"startTime":3922.718,"endTime":3924.687,"body":"As of last week, it's American Financing."},{"startTime":3925.421,"endTime":3927.056,"body":"High prices are here to stay, gas and"},{"startTime":3927.056,"endTime":3928.624,"body":"groceries, insurance and utilities."},{"startTime":3928.658,"endTime":3930.526,"body":"Everything costs more than it used to."},{"startTime":3931.427,"endTime":3932.795,"body":"If you're a homeowner who has credit card"},{"startTime":3932.795,"endTime":3934.03,"body":"debt, you may have asked yourself if you"},{"startTime":3934.03,"endTime":3935.164,"body":"should refinance your home"},{"startTime":3935.164,"endTime":3936.065,"body":"to pay off the other debt."},{"startTime":3936.599,"endTime":3938.167,"body":"It's a hard moment to make that decision"},{"startTime":3938.167,"endTime":3939.268,"body":"because your current mortgage rate is"},{"startTime":3939.268,"endTime":3941.771,"body":"probably low compared to today's rates."},{"startTime":3942.104,"endTime":3943.806,"body":"But that low rate, it's not saving you"},{"startTime":3943.806,"endTime":3945.574,"body":"anything if you're also paying credit"},{"startTime":3945.574,"endTime":3947.443,"body":"card interest at 25% or more."},{"startTime":3947.943,"endTime":3949.312,"body":"If you're only making minimum payments on"},{"startTime":3949.312,"endTime":3950.112,"body":"your credit cards, that"},{"startTime":3950.112,"endTime":3951.514,"body":"debt will follow you for years."},{"startTime":3951.781,"endTime":3953.616,"body":"American Financing is saving customers an"},{"startTime":3953.616,"endTime":3955.451,"body":"average of $800 a month by using their"},{"startTime":3955.484,"endTime":3956.585,"body":"equity to finally break"},{"startTime":3956.585,"endTime":3957.72,"body":"free from credit card debt."},{"startTime":3958.688,"endTime":3960.256,"body":"There are no upfront fees and there's no"},{"startTime":3960.256,"endTime":3961.324,"body":"pressure, no hard sell"},{"startTime":3961.324,"endTime":3962.325,"body":"with American Financing."},{"startTime":3962.325,"endTime":3964.26,"body":"It costs you nothing to find out what you"},{"startTime":3964.26,"endTime":3965.227,"body":"could save every month."},{"startTime":3965.494,"endTime":3966.829,"body":"And if you start today, you may be able"},{"startTime":3966.829,"endTime":3968.364,"body":"to delay two mortgage payments."},{"startTime":3968.764,"endTime":3970.766,"body":"Owned by a family in Colorado, American"},{"startTime":3970.766,"endTime":3972.335,"body":"financing is known for its salary-based"},{"startTime":3972.335,"endTime":3973.669,"body":"mortgage consultants, custom loan"},{"startTime":3973.669,"endTime":3974.77,"body":"programs and faster than"},{"startTime":3974.77,"endTime":3976.038,"body":"industry average closings."},{"startTime":3976.505,"endTime":3978.04,"body":"We interacted with them a few months ago"},{"startTime":3978.04,"endTime":3979.208,"body":"and they were great to work with."},{"startTime":3979.575,"endTime":3983.98,"body":"Call American Financing. 866-886-5350,"},{"startTime":3983.98,"endTime":3984.68,"body":"that is hard to read."},{"startTime":3985.314,"endTime":3989.218,"body":"That's 866-886-5350 or"},{"startTime":3989.218,"endTime":3991.754,"body":"americanfinancing.net slash dark horse."},{"startTime":3992.154,"endTime":3992.722,"body":"You know, it's funny."},{"startTime":3992.922,"endTime":3993.956,"body":"I found it hard to read,"},{"startTime":3993.956,"endTime":3995.157,"body":"you found it hard to read."},{"startTime":3995.524,"endTime":3997.96,"body":"It comes in the ears just fine."},{"startTime":3997.96,"endTime":3998.728,"body":"Oh yeah, yeah."},{"startTime":3999.895,"endTime":4001.464,"body":"Yeah, even- I'm just gonna say it, I'm"},{"startTime":4001.464,"endTime":4003.232,"body":"so, you can't like, I can show you this"},{"startTime":4003.232,"endTime":4004.633,"body":"because I just read exactly what's on"},{"startTime":4004.633,"endTime":4005.334,"body":"this piece of paper."},{"startTime":4005.334,"endTime":4007.003,"body":"But what you won't be able to see from"},{"startTime":4007.003,"endTime":4009.372,"body":"that quick glimpse is that"},{"startTime":4010.406,"endTime":4012.041,"body":"the call to action, which is the only"},{"startTime":4012.041,"endTime":4013.442,"body":"part of the ad read that we are required"},{"startTime":4013.442,"endTime":4016.645,"body":"to read verbatim at the end, spells out"},{"startTime":4016.679,"endTime":4018.681,"body":"the numbers in word form."},{"startTime":4019.315,"endTime":4021.684,"body":"And it is amazing how difficult it is for"},{"startTime":4021.684,"endTime":4024.887,"body":"the brain to process speaking a series of"},{"startTime":4025.454,"endTime":4027.49,"body":"numbers spelled out in word form."},{"startTime":4027.656,"endTime":4028.724,"body":"I don't even know how to say it."},{"startTime":4028.791,"endTime":4029.058,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":4029.091,"endTime":4030.559,"body":"Is this an example of Ballyhoo?"},{"startTime":4031.56,"endTime":4033.262,"body":"I don't think this is Hala Ballyhoo."},{"startTime":4033.429,"endTime":4034.33,"body":"Oh, yeah, maybe."},{"startTime":4034.764,"endTime":4036.298,"body":"So let me just say it"},{"startTime":4036.298,"endTime":4038.768,"body":"again to give them their due."},{"startTime":4039.135,"endTime":4043.272,"body":"American Financing call 866-886-5350."},{"startTime":4043.272,"endTime":4043.806,"body":"That's the number."},{"startTime":4043.873,"endTime":4044.54,"body":"Yeah, yeah."},{"startTime":4044.54,"endTime":4047.376,"body":"It implies a neurological separation"},{"startTime":4047.51,"endTime":4049.845,"body":"between the numbers as numbers and the"},{"startTime":4049.845,"endTime":4052.782,"body":"numbers as words that does not seamlessly"},{"startTime":4052.782,"endTime":4053.649,"body":"flip back and forth."},{"startTime":4053.682,"endTime":4055.618,"body":"Yeah, and it's, you know, it's related to"},{"startTime":4055.684,"endTime":4058.12,"body":"this thing where it's hard to read the"},{"startTime":4058.154,"endTime":4059.555,"body":"color blue and it's"},{"startTime":4059.555,"endTime":4060.923,"body":"written in the color red."},{"startTime":4061.09,"endTime":4061.49,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":4061.49,"endTime":4063.959,"body":"Right, but this isn't that because it's"},{"startTime":4063.959,"endTime":4065.895,"body":"not like the numbers aren't"},{"startTime":4065.895,"endTime":4067.329,"body":"exactly what they say they are."},{"startTime":4067.797,"endTime":4070.766,"body":"It's just they're coming in in a medium."},{"startTime":4071.3,"endTime":4072.768,"body":"Medium's not the right word, but like"},{"startTime":4072.868,"endTime":4073.803,"body":"they're coming in in word"},{"startTime":4073.803,"endTime":4074.804,"body":"form when they're numbers."},{"startTime":4074.837,"endTime":4075.137,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4077.173,"endTime":4078.541,"body":"That's, okay, yeah."},{"startTime":4079.241,"endTime":4081.343,"body":"It may continue to get weirdly"},{"startTime":4081.343,"endTime":4083.412,"body":"philosophical this episode, I feel."},{"startTime":4083.479,"endTime":4084.58,"body":"And neurobiological"},{"startTime":4086.682,"endTime":4087.416,"body":"and philosophical."},{"startTime":4087.416,"endTime":4088.117,"body":"I'm with you."},{"startTime":4088.117,"endTime":4089.285,"body":"(Laughing)"},{"startTime":4090.419,"endTime":4092.154,"body":"Our second sponsor this week is Caraway,"},{"startTime":4092.154,"endTime":4093.789,"body":"which makes high quality, non-toxic"},{"startTime":4093.823,"endTime":4095.024,"body":"cookware and bakeware."},{"startTime":4095.424,"endTime":4096.725,"body":"Whether you're looking to make easy"},{"startTime":4096.725,"endTime":4098.627,"body":"summer meals as things heat up outside or"},{"startTime":4098.627,"endTime":4100.029,"body":"are planning some big, shareable dishes"},{"startTime":4100.029,"endTime":4101.964,"body":"to take to picnics and potlucks, Caraway"},{"startTime":4101.997,"endTime":4103.199,"body":"has the right solution for you."},{"startTime":4103.332,"endTime":4104.733,"body":"And having beautiful, simple, functional"},{"startTime":4104.733,"endTime":4106.168,"body":"cookware, bakeware and other kitchen"},{"startTime":4106.168,"endTime":4108.204,"body":"essentials in your kitchen helps maintain"},{"startTime":4108.204,"endTime":4109.538,"body":"visual calm, which is"},{"startTime":4109.538,"endTime":4110.673,"body":"awesome no matter the season."},{"startTime":4111.207,"endTime":4112.708,"body":"Caraway has everything from mixing bowl"},{"startTime":4112.708,"endTime":4114.477,"body":"sets to cutting boards, muffin tins to"},{"startTime":4114.477,"endTime":4115.945,"body":"big pots on which to braise a piece of"},{"startTime":4115.945,"endTime":4118.347,"body":"meat or make a long-stimmered stew."},{"startTime":4119.381,"endTime":4120.583,"body":"You stammered over--"},{"startTime":4120.683,"endTime":4122.585,"body":"I did not stammer, I"},{"startTime":4122.585,"endTime":4123.519,"body":"simply said stammered."},{"startTime":4124.019,"endTime":4125.788,"body":"Long-stimmered stew."},{"startTime":4126.322,"endTime":4126.956,"body":"Whether you're spending"},{"startTime":4126.956,"endTime":4128.357,"body":"time at the grill, that was a,"},{"startTime":4129.692,"endTime":4132.328,"body":"that's not a malapropism, it's a reversal"},{"startTime":4132.328,"endTime":4133.996,"body":"of the beginning of the two words."},{"startTime":4134.296,"endTime":4134.897,"body":"A spoonerism?"},{"startTime":4135.664,"endTime":4137.032,"body":"Is it a spoon, yeah, it's a spoonerism."},{"startTime":4137.032,"endTime":4138.3,"body":"That was a spoonerism, not a stammer."},{"startTime":4138.601,"endTime":4138.901,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4138.968,"endTime":4139.168,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4139.435,"endTime":4140.202,"body":"We're gonna just keep"},{"startTime":4140.202,"endTime":4141.036,"body":"on doing this today."},{"startTime":4142.171,"endTime":4143.506,"body":"You know, England has gone"},{"startTime":4143.506,"endTime":4144.807,"body":"through a bit of a cure stammer."},{"startTime":4145.374,"endTime":4146.709,"body":"Oh, starmer, starmer."},{"startTime":4146.742,"endTime":4147.71,"body":"Starmer, that's it."},{"startTime":4147.743,"endTime":4148.043,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":4148.043,"endTime":4148.277,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4149.612,"endTime":4150.312,"body":"I got nothing else."},{"startTime":4150.479,"endTime":4154.116,"body":"Yeah, long-stimmered stew in the big pots"},{"startTime":4154.283,"endTime":4156.218,"body":"that Caraway sells which are awesome."},{"startTime":4156.752,"endTime":4158.154,"body":"That's how we get back to the ad read."},{"startTime":4158.621,"endTime":4159.722,"body":"Whether you're spending time at the"},{"startTime":4159.722,"endTime":4160.99,"body":"grill, the stove or the oven,"},{"startTime":4161.29,"endTime":4162.625,"body":"Caraway has the gear for you."},{"startTime":4162.625,"endTime":4164.193,"body":"Roast chicken and Caraway's cookware, mix"},{"startTime":4164.193,"endTime":4166.095,"body":"a summery cocktail with their bar set or"},{"startTime":4166.095,"endTime":4167.296,"body":"bake a seasonal berry"},{"startTime":4167.296,"endTime":4168.631,"body":"crisp in their bakeware."},{"startTime":4169.431,"endTime":4171.167,"body":"Caraway kitchenware is crafted with FSC"},{"startTime":4171.167,"endTime":4173.002,"body":"certified birch wood, premium stainless"},{"startTime":4173.002,"endTime":4174.503,"body":"steel and now cast iron"},{"startTime":4174.503,"endTime":4175.571,"body":"and naturally slick ceramic."},{"startTime":4175.971,"endTime":4176.739,"body":"They make several lines"},{"startTime":4176.739,"endTime":4177.773,"body":"of cookware and bakeware."},{"startTime":4177.806,"endTime":4179.108,"body":"Our favorites are their stainless steel"},{"startTime":4179.108,"endTime":4181.076,"body":"line and their enamel cast iron which is"},{"startTime":4181.076,"endTime":4182.111,"body":"offered in six stylish"},{"startTime":4182.111,"endTime":4183.045,"body":"and beautiful colors."},{"startTime":4183.312,"endTime":4184.346,"body":"These pots are strong and"},{"startTime":4184.346,"endTime":4185.481,"body":"highly scratch resistant."},{"startTime":4185.481,"endTime":4186.715,"body":"They'll last generations."},{"startTime":4187.149,"endTime":4187.616,"body":"We're cooking with"},{"startTime":4187.616,"endTime":4188.717,"body":"Caraway in this past year."},{"startTime":4188.717,"endTime":4190.185,"body":"Zach, our elder son was too"},{"startTime":4190.185,"endTime":4191.353,"body":"in his first college apartment."},{"startTime":4191.72,"endTime":4192.721,"body":"He says it's amazing,"},{"startTime":4192.721,"endTime":4193.656,"body":"which we know to be true."},{"startTime":4193.689,"endTime":4194.957,"body":"And we know that he will be cooking with"},{"startTime":4194.957,"endTime":4196.192,"body":"it for a long time to come."},{"startTime":4197.059,"endTime":4199.228,"body":"Right now you can save up to $230 on the"},{"startTime":4199.228,"endTime":4201.03,"body":"12 piece cookware set versus buying the"},{"startTime":4201.03,"endTime":4201.964,"body":"products individually."},{"startTime":4202.331,"endTime":4203.732,"body":"Plus if you want to include their fan"},{"startTime":4203.732,"endTime":4204.934,"body":"favorite Minis duo,"},{"startTime":4204.934,"endTime":4205.968,"body":"you can save up to 350."},{"startTime":4206.569,"endTime":4207.303,"body":"That's $350."},{"startTime":4208.203,"endTime":4210.706,"body":"Visit carawayhome.com slash DarkHorse to"},{"startTime":4210.706,"endTime":4212.641,"body":"take an additional 10% off using code"},{"startTime":4212.641,"endTime":4214.31,"body":"DarkHorse on your next purchase."},{"startTime":4214.743,"endTime":4216.278,"body":"This deal is exclusive for our listeners."},{"startTime":4216.278,"endTime":4219.114,"body":"So visit carawayhome.com slash dark horse"},{"startTime":4219.415,"endTime":4221.65,"body":"or use code DarkHorseat checkout."},{"startTime":4223.152,"endTime":4223.586,"body":"Now Heather."},{"startTime":4223.786,"endTime":4224.119,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":4224.153,"endTime":4226.522,"body":"Our final sponsor today, as"},{"startTime":4226.522,"endTime":4227.923,"body":"I think you know, is Dose."},{"startTime":4228.29,"endTime":4230.392,"body":"Modern life is rough on our bodies,"},{"startTime":4230.392,"endTime":4232.161,"body":"processed food, stress, environmental"},{"startTime":4232.161,"endTime":4233.495,"body":"toxins, late nights."},{"startTime":4233.696,"endTime":4234.396,"body":"It adds up."},{"startTime":4234.63,"endTime":4235.631,"body":"Your liver is working"},{"startTime":4235.664,"endTime":4238.434,"body":"overtime to filter all of that out."},{"startTime":4238.467,"endTime":4239.868,"body":"And if you've been feeling sluggish or"},{"startTime":4239.868,"endTime":4241.704,"body":"just feel off, your liver might be trying"},{"startTime":4241.704,"endTime":4242.638,"body":"to tell you something."},{"startTime":4243.205,"endTime":4244.974,"body":"Dose for your liver is a tasty liquid"},{"startTime":4244.974,"endTime":4247.076,"body":"supplement that supports liver health."},{"startTime":4247.209,"endTime":4248.877,"body":"Your liver has hundreds of functions in"},{"startTime":4248.877,"endTime":4250.846,"body":"your body, most famously as a filter."},{"startTime":4251.513,"endTime":4253.415,"body":"It's an organ of detoxification."},{"startTime":4253.782,"endTime":4256.352,"body":"Dose for your liver taken in daily two"},{"startTime":4256.385,"endTime":4258.32,"body":"ounce in a daily two ounce shot was"},{"startTime":4258.32,"endTime":4259.455,"body":"formulated to cleanse your"},{"startTime":4259.455,"endTime":4261.09,"body":"liver of unwanted elements."},{"startTime":4262.191,"endTime":4263.659,"body":"Dose for your liver has four active"},{"startTime":4263.659,"endTime":4265.894,"body":"ingredients, milk thistle, ginger,"},{"startTime":4265.928,"endTime":4268.564,"body":"dandelion and turmeric in a base of"},{"startTime":4268.564,"endTime":4270.165,"body":"delicious organic orange juice."},{"startTime":4270.332,"endTime":4272.034,"body":"Dose is gluten-free, dairy-free,"},{"startTime":4272.067,"endTime":4273.535,"body":"sugar-free and vegan"},{"startTime":4273.569,"endTime":4274.97,"body":"and it tastes fantastic."},{"startTime":4275.304,"endTime":4277.406,"body":"Dose comes in sleek glass bottles."},{"startTime":4277.439,"endTime":4279.041,"body":"It arrives with a stainless steel shot"},{"startTime":4279.041,"endTime":4281.043,"body":"glass with which you take your dose."},{"startTime":4281.677,"endTime":4282.811,"body":"You can drink it straight"},{"startTime":4282.911,"endTime":4283.946,"body":"or add it to other drinks."},{"startTime":4283.946,"endTime":4285.981,"body":"Try it in fruit smoothies for instance."},{"startTime":4286.382,"endTime":4288.484,"body":"Zach, who is drinking a daily dose,"},{"startTime":4288.817,"endTime":4290.919,"body":"thought that dose for your liver would be"},{"startTime":4290.953,"endTime":4292.087,"body":"excellent in coffee."},{"startTime":4292.454,"endTime":4293.656,"body":"He's dead wrong."},{"startTime":4294.223,"endTime":4296.892,"body":"Dose for your liver, in-house clinical"},{"startTime":4296.892,"endTime":4298.661,"body":"studies found significant improvement in"},{"startTime":4298.661,"endTime":4301.53,"body":"standard measures of liver health after"},{"startTime":4301.563,"endTime":4303.899,"body":"study participants drank dose daily for"},{"startTime":4303.932,"endTime":4304.933,"body":"as little as eight weeks."},{"startTime":4305.234,"endTime":4306.835,"body":"The liver produces and regulates"},{"startTime":4306.835,"endTime":4309.038,"body":"cholesterol, stores vitamins and minerals"},{"startTime":4309.271,"endTime":4311.073,"body":"and impacts digestive and metabolic"},{"startTime":4311.073,"endTime":4312.775,"body":"health, among many other things."},{"startTime":4313.442,"endTime":4315.144,"body":"Dose supports liver function, aids"},{"startTime":4315.144,"endTime":4317.179,"body":"digestion, eases bloating and can even"},{"startTime":4317.179,"endTime":4318.314,"body":"boost energy levels."},{"startTime":4319.081,"endTime":4320.349,"body":"Stick with dose and feel the"},{"startTime":4320.349,"endTime":4321.984,"body":"incredible benefits over time."},{"startTime":4322.084,"endTime":4323.552,"body":"You'll find that you have more energy,"},{"startTime":4323.552,"endTime":4325.254,"body":"better digestion, reduced bloating,"},{"startTime":4325.254,"endTime":4326.822,"body":"healthier liver enzyme function,"},{"startTime":4326.822,"endTime":4329.658,"body":"reduction in brain fog and better sleep."},{"startTime":4330.326,"endTime":4331.727,"body":"Ready to give your liver support?"},{"startTime":4331.96,"endTime":4332.528,"body":"No."},{"startTime":4332.695,"endTime":4334.496,"body":"Ready to give your liver"},{"startTime":4334.563,"endTime":4336.665,"body":"the support that it deserves."},{"startTime":4336.665,"endTime":4337.466,"body":"That's what that says."},{"startTime":4337.866,"endTime":4340.402,"body":"Head to dosedaily.co."},{"startTime":4340.669,"endTime":4343.272,"body":"Slash DarkHorseor enter DarkHorseto"},{"startTime":4343.272,"endTime":4345.541,"body":"get 35% off your first subscription."},{"startTime":4346.075,"endTime":4347.743,"body":"Your body does so much for you."},{"startTime":4347.743,"endTime":4349.178,"body":"Let's do something for it."},{"startTime":4349.378,"endTime":4354.85,"body":"That's D-O-S-E-D-A-I-L-Y.C-O slash dark"},{"startTime":4354.85,"endTime":4356.719,"body":"horse for 35% off your"},{"startTime":4356.719,"endTime":4358.253,"body":"first month subscription."},{"startTime":4361.423,"endTime":4361.757,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":4361.757,"endTime":4362.091,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":4362.124,"endTime":4362.591,"body":"It's time."},{"startTime":4363.092,"endTime":4363.625,"body":"It is time."},{"startTime":4363.625,"endTime":4364.259,"body":"It is time."},{"startTime":4364.893,"endTime":4365.394,"body":"It is time."},{"startTime":4366.228,"endTime":4367.796,"body":"We're gonna talk a little bit first today"},{"startTime":4367.796,"endTime":4369.331,"body":"about data centers and"},{"startTime":4369.331,"endTime":4370.999,"body":"then talk about flop cameras."},{"startTime":4371.1,"endTime":4374.269,"body":"Yeah, and maybe put the things in a kind"},{"startTime":4374.269,"endTime":4376.004,"body":"of a context where they both fit."},{"startTime":4376.138,"endTime":4378.44,"body":"Yeah, I mean, I think, did you say oddly?"},{"startTime":4379.074,"endTime":4379.541,"body":"Clearly."},{"startTime":4379.575,"endTime":4380.342,"body":"Clearly, yeah."},{"startTime":4380.376,"endTime":4382.144,"body":"No, I think the connection in this case"},{"startTime":4382.144,"endTime":4383.712,"body":"is not at all subtle."},{"startTime":4383.879,"endTime":4384.146,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4385.614,"endTime":4386.949,"body":"Although they both came up"},{"startTime":4386.949,"endTime":4389.118,"body":"separately for us this week."},{"startTime":4389.952,"endTime":4391.987,"body":"So, yeah, I think all Americans at this"},{"startTime":4391.987,"endTime":4393.222,"body":"point are thinking about data centers."},{"startTime":4393.222,"endTime":4396.258,"body":"We've all heard of some of these sort of"},{"startTime":4396.291,"endTime":4399.762,"body":"areas where there was a lot of brouhaha."},{"startTime":4399.795,"endTime":4401.196,"body":"Let's just continue to use words that"},{"startTime":4401.196,"endTime":4402.498,"body":"maybe we can't entirely define."},{"startTime":4402.531,"endTime":4402.865,"body":"I don't know what"},{"startTime":4402.865,"endTime":4403.599,"body":"part of speech they are."},{"startTime":4403.665,"endTime":4404.066,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":4405.534,"endTime":4408.003,"body":"About whether or not these companies"},{"startTime":4408.003,"endTime":4410.339,"body":"should be allowed to put down these"},{"startTime":4410.672,"endTime":4413.575,"body":"massive lines, almost always above"},{"startTime":4413.575,"endTime":4415.944,"body":"ground, through neighborhoods that have"},{"startTime":4415.944,"endTime":4419.414,"body":"been pastoral, idyllic, beautiful, and"},{"startTime":4419.414,"endTime":4421.016,"body":"certainly will not continue to be any of"},{"startTime":4421.016,"endTime":4422.05,"body":"those things afterwards."},{"startTime":4422.684,"endTime":4425.587,"body":"And so we're gonna get to some of the"},{"startTime":4427.089,"endTime":4430.726,"body":"known health risks of these data lines."},{"startTime":4431.46,"endTime":4433.162,"body":"But first, what prompted me to be"},{"startTime":4433.162,"endTime":4434.129,"body":"thinking about this this week"},{"startTime":4434.129,"endTime":4435.564,"body":"is I ran across this article"},{"startTime":4437.065,"endTime":4438.901,"body":"in the New York Times,"},{"startTime":4440.202,"endTime":4442.404,"body":"published this week, titled China,"},{"startTime":4442.438,"endTime":4444.44,"body":"Russia, and Others Seek to Enflame Debate"},{"startTime":4444.473,"endTime":4445.774,"body":"Over AI Data Centers."},{"startTime":4446.041,"endTime":4448.177,"body":"State, oops, state actors in China,"},{"startTime":4448.177,"endTime":4450.012,"body":"Russia, and Iran have sought to exploit"},{"startTime":4450.012,"endTime":4451.113,"body":"the US public debate over"},{"startTime":4451.113,"endTime":4452.347,"body":"the effects of the technology."},{"startTime":4452.848,"endTime":4454.349,"body":"And I wanna read part of this article and"},{"startTime":4454.349,"endTime":4456.785,"body":"then also read some of the research that"},{"startTime":4457.219,"endTime":4457.953,"body":"the New York Times is"},{"startTime":4457.953,"endTime":4459.388,"body":"basing this article on."},{"startTime":4460.255,"endTime":4463.525,"body":"And in part because my first read on this"},{"startTime":4463.525,"endTime":4466.662,"body":"was, what the hell, why is this what"},{"startTime":4466.662,"endTime":4468.03,"body":"we're talking about as opposed to the"},{"startTime":4468.03,"endTime":4469.698,"body":"actual risks of these data centers?"},{"startTime":4470.365,"endTime":4473.602,"body":"But actually this is a real concern too."},{"startTime":4473.936,"endTime":4476.572,"body":"And so this is part of, when you have"},{"startTime":4476.572,"endTime":4478.54,"body":"something that is truly a risk, that"},{"startTime":4478.574,"endTime":4480.542,"body":"individuals are being affected in ways"},{"startTime":4480.542,"endTime":4482.711,"body":"that most of us aren't directly affected,"},{"startTime":4482.711,"endTime":4484.48,"body":"but we can hear, we can imagine, we can"},{"startTime":4484.513,"endTime":4486.782,"body":"empathize with what they're going through"},{"startTime":4486.782,"endTime":4488.317,"body":"if they're about to have their entire"},{"startTime":4488.717,"endTime":4490.986,"body":"lives changed by something they didn't"},{"startTime":4490.986,"endTime":4492.254,"body":"ask for and do not want."},{"startTime":4493.255,"endTime":4497.593,"body":"Then the idea that the entire story may"},{"startTime":4497.593,"endTime":4500.362,"body":"be being twisted by foreign agents is of"},{"startTime":4500.362,"endTime":4503.365,"body":"course important, but that does risk"},{"startTime":4503.999,"endTime":4505.367,"body":"making it seem like"},{"startTime":4505.367,"endTime":4506.735,"body":"that's the only reason we care."},{"startTime":4507.703,"endTime":4511.94,"body":"Yeah, and I will just point out that in a"},{"startTime":4511.94,"endTime":4515.41,"body":"landscape where powerful actors often"},{"startTime":4515.41,"endTime":4517.88,"body":"want to make a true observation"},{"startTime":4517.88,"endTime":4520.015,"body":"disappear, this is very clever."},{"startTime":4520.148,"endTime":4522.017,"body":"And this was exactly my reaction."},{"startTime":4522.017,"endTime":4523.852,"body":"So I wanted to sort of give that caveat"},{"startTime":4523.886,"endTime":4526.255,"body":"upfront because I had a very negative"},{"startTime":4526.255,"endTime":4529.157,"body":"reaction to this article and to the"},{"startTime":4529.191,"endTime":4531.693,"body":"research it's based on, but they are"},{"startTime":4531.693,"endTime":4533.529,"body":"making a real point which speaks to the"},{"startTime":4533.529,"endTime":4534.963,"body":"Cartesian crisis, which is,"},{"startTime":4536.665,"endTime":4539.601,"body":"why do you care about data centers?"},{"startTime":4539.735,"endTime":4540.769,"body":"Like think about that now"},{"startTime":4540.769,"endTime":4541.937,"body":"before we start talking about it."},{"startTime":4541.97,"endTime":4543.305,"body":"Why do you think you care?"},{"startTime":4543.805,"endTime":4545.073,"body":"And we're gonna get to some of the"},{"startTime":4545.073,"endTime":4547.209,"body":"reasons that in fact you should care."},{"startTime":4547.242,"endTime":4548.677,"body":"And there are real reasons to be"},{"startTime":4548.677,"endTime":4553.048,"body":"concerned for your health about having"},{"startTime":4553.048,"endTime":4554.616,"body":"such things in your backyard."},{"startTime":4554.883,"endTime":4556.885,"body":"But if you just have a sort of vague"},{"startTime":4556.885,"endTime":4558.554,"body":"sense of like they're not good, it's"},{"startTime":4558.554,"endTime":4560.122,"body":"quite possible that you are being"},{"startTime":4560.122,"endTime":4562.457,"body":"squeezed by something that is not acting"},{"startTime":4562.457,"endTime":4563.292,"body":"in your best interests."},{"startTime":4563.792,"endTime":4566.695,"body":"Yes, or we will get back here, I'm sure."},{"startTime":4566.728,"endTime":4570.299,"body":"But a third possibility is that it could"},{"startTime":4570.299,"endTime":4572.134,"body":"be in the interests of"},{"startTime":4573.168,"endTime":4577.005,"body":"our competitors abroad to exploit the"},{"startTime":4577.005,"endTime":4580.208,"body":"rational concerns of the citizenry"},{"startTime":4580.509,"endTime":4583.779,"body":"because the forces that our"},{"startTime":4585.147,"endTime":4588.75,"body":"government is allowing to produce these"},{"startTime":4588.75,"endTime":4591.453,"body":"phenomena is not actually on our team,"},{"startTime":4591.486,"endTime":4592.254,"body":"which I think the"},{"startTime":4592.254,"endTime":4593.822,"body":"evidence is ever clearer."},{"startTime":4593.822,"endTime":4595.39,"body":"In fact, I have a principle that I will"},{"startTime":4595.39,"endTime":4597.392,"body":"deploy later on this topic."},{"startTime":4597.392,"endTime":4599.895,"body":"Yeah, and so it effectively, it points to"},{"startTime":4599.895,"endTime":4603.165,"body":"an enemy that is known and public and"},{"startTime":4603.165,"endTime":4607.269,"body":"pointable to while potentially obscuring"},{"startTime":4607.269,"endTime":4608.437,"body":"further who we should"},{"startTime":4608.437,"endTime":4609.571,"body":"actually be paying attention to."},{"startTime":4609.671,"endTime":4611.94,"body":"Not to say that again, China, Russia,"},{"startTime":4611.974,"endTime":4615.01,"body":"Iran aren't potentially quite big enemies"},{"startTime":4615.01,"endTime":4618.313,"body":"of the United States and its people, but"},{"startTime":4618.313,"endTime":4619.781,"body":"the idea that the private public"},{"startTime":4619.781,"endTime":4622.618,"body":"enterprise that the US government is"},{"startTime":4622.684,"endTime":4625.487,"body":"increasingly engaging in with these"},{"startTime":4625.954,"endTime":4627.422,"body":"private corporations are"},{"startTime":4627.422,"endTime":4630.125,"body":"simply on our team is 100% wrong."},{"startTime":4630.258,"endTime":4630.492,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":4631.293,"endTime":4632.961,"body":"Okay, so New York Times article"},{"startTime":4634.196,"endTime":4636.832,"body":"published July 9th."},{"startTime":4636.965,"endTime":4639.334,"body":"So that's what, six days ago."},{"startTime":4639.968,"endTime":4642.304,"body":"OpenAI, so they've got a picture first,"},{"startTime":4644.406,"endTime":4646.074,"body":"the caption for which is, \"OpenAI"},{"startTime":4646.074,"endTime":4647.609,"body":"released this cartoon as an example of"},{"startTime":4647.609,"endTime":4649.745,"body":"one generated with chat GPT by people in"},{"startTime":4649.745,"endTime":4651.58,"body":"China who the company believed were"},{"startTime":4651.58,"endTime":4653.115,"body":"affiliated with a regional government."},{"startTime":4653.548,"endTime":4654.583,"body":"It is not clear what word in"},{"startTime":4654.583,"endTime":4655.584,"body":"the title was blurred out.\""},{"startTime":4655.584,"endTime":4657.653,"body":"So that's sort of, it seems like a kind"},{"startTime":4657.653,"endTime":4659.588,"body":"of a weak example to me and then they"},{"startTime":4659.588,"endTime":4661.056,"body":"start with three more examples."},{"startTime":4662.791,"endTime":4664.893,"body":"A state owned newspaper in China recently"},{"startTime":4664.893,"endTime":4666.395,"body":"published a satellite image of a data"},{"startTime":4666.395,"endTime":4668.263,"body":"center in Gainesville, Virginia writing"},{"startTime":4668.263,"endTime":4670.832,"body":"in English, the development of artificial"},{"startTime":4670.832,"endTime":4672.601,"body":"intelligence posed a threat to Americans'"},{"startTime":4672.601,"endTime":4674.036,"body":"physical and financial wellbeing."},{"startTime":4675.804,"endTime":4677.205,"body":"The only thing in that example that"},{"startTime":4677.205,"endTime":4679.708,"body":"strikes me as possibly egregious is that"},{"startTime":4679.708,"endTime":4681.276,"body":"there was a Chinese, a state owned"},{"startTime":4681.276,"endTime":4682.778,"body":"newspaper in China writing in English,"},{"startTime":4682.778,"endTime":4684.813,"body":"but presumably that happens a lot."},{"startTime":4685.414,"endTime":4687.549,"body":"Well, I would say let's take the"},{"startTime":4688.917,"endTime":4691.453,"body":"darkest possible interpretation of that."},{"startTime":4692.387,"endTime":4694.823,"body":"It's very weak tea, so to speak."},{"startTime":4695.123,"endTime":4695.457,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":4695.49,"endTime":4695.824,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":4695.957,"endTime":4696.825,"body":"Posed a threat too."},{"startTime":4696.892,"endTime":4700.295,"body":"Right, this is not a massive effort to"},{"startTime":4700.295,"endTime":4702.564,"body":"manipulate the American public."},{"startTime":4702.564,"endTime":4705.3,"body":"At most it's a drop in the bucket in a"},{"startTime":4705.3,"endTime":4709.471,"body":"discussion in which, you know, presumably"},{"startTime":4709.471,"endTime":4711.206,"body":"almost nobody in the English speaking"},{"startTime":4711.206,"endTime":4714.176,"body":"world saw that particular claim, nor does"},{"startTime":4714.176,"endTime":4715.677,"body":"it change anything if they did."},{"startTime":4716.611,"endTime":4718.38,"body":"Well, I mean, to"},{"startTime":4720.615,"endTime":4721.95,"body":"try to steel man their argument."},{"startTime":4722.384,"endTime":4724.219,"body":"The idea is they provide a few examples"},{"startTime":4724.219,"endTime":4727.022,"body":"up top here and the argument is"},{"startTime":4729.291,"endTime":4730.992,"body":"they're all over the place and"},{"startTime":4730.992,"endTime":4733.595,"body":"increasingly we don't know what is coming"},{"startTime":4733.595,"endTime":4735.864,"body":"from where and what appears to be"},{"startTime":4735.897,"endTime":4738.7,"body":"grassroots, homegrown, citizens caring"},{"startTime":4738.7,"endTime":4740.402,"body":"about the livelihood of themselves and"},{"startTime":4740.402,"endTime":4742.204,"body":"others may actually be coming from"},{"startTime":4743.839,"endTime":4746.975,"body":"shops elsewhere who never met an"},{"startTime":4746.975,"endTime":4748.443,"body":"American, much less care about what"},{"startTime":4748.443,"endTime":4750.946,"body":"happens in American soil in a good way."},{"startTime":4751.613,"endTime":4753.048,"body":"Second example in this New York Times"},{"startTime":4753.048,"endTime":4755.117,"body":"article from a few days ago, a comic"},{"startTime":4755.117,"endTime":4756.651,"body":"strip made to look as if it had been"},{"startTime":4756.651,"endTime":4758.353,"body":"published by a Maryland news outlet"},{"startTime":4758.72,"endTime":4761.056,"body":"created with open AI's chat GBT by people"},{"startTime":4761.056,"endTime":4762.557,"body":"in China, the tech company said,"},{"startTime":4762.958,"endTime":4765.093,"body":"circulated on X this year, blaming data"},{"startTime":4765.093,"endTime":4766.895,"body":"centers for soaring electricity bills."},{"startTime":4767.162,"endTime":4769.164,"body":"It showed a tycoon smoking a cigar"},{"startTime":4769.197,"endTime":4770.398,"body":"clutching bags of cash."},{"startTime":4770.766,"endTime":4772.234,"body":"So again, just an example of something"},{"startTime":4772.234,"endTime":4773.268,"body":"that is made to look"},{"startTime":4773.835,"endTime":4775.303,"body":"grassroots and isn't."},{"startTime":4776.605,"endTime":4778.94,"body":"And a video shared on X by a known covert"},{"startTime":4778.94,"endTime":4780.308,"body":"Russian influence operation."},{"startTime":4780.475,"endTime":4781.777,"body":"I find that phrase very strange."},{"startTime":4781.81,"endTime":4782.911,"body":"Known covert"},{"startTime":4784.312,"endTime":4786.348,"body":"Russian influence operation, questioned"},{"startTime":4786.348,"endTime":4788.15,"body":"the viability of a data center that an"},{"startTime":4788.15,"endTime":4789.818,"body":"American company, Firebird, is"},{"startTime":4789.818,"endTime":4791.653,"body":"constructing in Armenia, the small"},{"startTime":4791.653,"endTime":4793.221,"body":"Caucasus nation that has been"},{"startTime":4793.255,"endTime":4794.623,"body":"a focus of Kremlin pressure."},{"startTime":4795.357,"endTime":4796.958,"body":"Quote, \"The country's electrical grid and"},{"startTime":4796.958,"endTime":4798.994,"body":"stability render it useless,\" end quote,"},{"startTime":4799.161,"endTime":4800.729,"body":"the video's narrator says."},{"startTime":4802.597,"endTime":4805.534,"body":"Again, I would say, to your objection to"},{"startTime":4805.534,"endTime":4806.768,"body":"the first one, weak T"},{"startTime":4807.169,"endTime":4807.802,"body":"at best."},{"startTime":4808.236,"endTime":4809.271,"body":"Weak T at best."},{"startTime":4809.704,"endTime":4810.906,"body":"The second one,"},{"startTime":4813.208,"endTime":4815.21,"body":"okay, there's a tremendous amount of"},{"startTime":4815.21,"endTime":4817.078,"body":"money at stake in these data centers."},{"startTime":4817.412,"endTime":4817.746,"body":"Of course."},{"startTime":4818.246,"endTime":4820.949,"body":"The idea that all you gotta do is get"},{"startTime":4820.949,"endTime":4822.384,"body":"somebody to China to put"},{"startTime":4822.384,"endTime":4823.418,"body":"out a little something."},{"startTime":4824.119,"endTime":4824.819,"body":"But that's not, I mean,"},{"startTime":4825.02,"endTime":4827.022,"body":"that I think is straw manning"},{"startTime":4827.489,"endTime":4832.394,"body":"No, my point is, the New York Times has a"},{"startTime":4832.394,"endTime":4833.962,"body":"serious journalistic budget."},{"startTime":4834.396,"endTime":4836.031,"body":"If their point is that the--"},{"startTime":4836.498,"endTime":4838.333,"body":"So does the state of Washington, but in"},{"startTime":4838.333,"endTime":4839.701,"body":"both cases they're squandering them."},{"startTime":4839.968,"endTime":4843.071,"body":"Right, okay, but if their point is, hey,"},{"startTime":4843.071,"endTime":4845.106,"body":"the discussion is not organic because"},{"startTime":4845.106,"endTime":4847.576,"body":"there are antagonists of the United"},{"startTime":4847.576,"endTime":4851.313,"body":"States intervening, they should find, if"},{"startTime":4851.313,"endTime":4853.215,"body":"they found three industrial strength"},{"startTime":4853.215,"endTime":4854.716,"body":"examples, it still doesn't say that the"},{"startTime":4854.716,"endTime":4856.918,"body":"conversation is significantly altered."},{"startTime":4856.985,"endTime":4860.555,"body":"To find three examples, each of which is"},{"startTime":4860.822,"endTime":4863.325,"body":"suspicious in its own right, suggests"},{"startTime":4863.325,"endTime":4864.593,"body":"there's not a lot to find."},{"startTime":4864.626,"endTime":4867.829,"body":"Well, so I felt that too, and I am gonna"},{"startTime":4867.829,"endTime":4869.097,"body":"read a little bit more from this article"},{"startTime":4869.097,"endTime":4872.834,"body":"before going to the outfit, Alatheia, I"},{"startTime":4872.834,"endTime":4874.336,"body":"think is how it's pronounced, that"},{"startTime":4874.369,"endTime":4875.77,"body":"actually wrote the"},{"startTime":4875.77,"endTime":4877.239,"body":"report on which this is based."},{"startTime":4877.272,"endTime":4877.505,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":4877.639,"endTime":4880.008,"body":"And they have some better examples."},{"startTime":4880.609,"endTime":4883.178,"body":"So I'm not sure why the examples were"},{"startTime":4883.178,"endTime":4885.08,"body":"chosen, that were chosen for"},{"startTime":4885.08,"endTime":4885.981,"body":"the New York Times article."},{"startTime":4887.048,"endTime":4888.75,"body":"\"All our examples continues the New York"},{"startTime":4888.75,"endTime":4890.485,"body":"Times \"of a push by foreign adversaries"},{"startTime":4890.485,"endTime":4892.153,"body":"to seize \"on what polls have shown as"},{"startTime":4892.153,"endTime":4893.755,"body":"deep ambivalence \"verging at times on"},{"startTime":4893.755,"endTime":4895.557,"body":"hostility \"about the spread of the data"},{"startTime":4895.557,"endTime":4897.225,"body":"centers \"needed to power AI, the United"},{"startTime":4897.225,"endTime":4898.026,"body":"States and elsewhere.\""},{"startTime":4898.426,"endTime":4899.594,"body":"So that feels to me like"},{"startTime":4899.594,"endTime":4901.596,"body":"they're changing the truth a bit."},{"startTime":4901.863,"endTime":4903.798,"body":"Deep ambivalence verging at times on"},{"startTime":4903.798,"endTime":4906.101,"body":"hostility, I would say we're beyond deep"},{"startTime":4906.101,"endTime":4907.969,"body":"ambivalence for a lot of people, right?"},{"startTime":4908.003,"endTime":4910.538,"body":"The verging on deep hostility or verging"},{"startTime":4910.538,"endTime":4913.808,"body":"on hostility is an understatement."},{"startTime":4913.875,"endTime":4917.312,"body":"And so, you know, again, I could see an"},{"startTime":4917.312,"endTime":4919.08,"body":"argument that the authors of this piece"},{"startTime":4919.114,"endTime":4922.651,"body":"are trying to sort of not go deep on"},{"startTime":4922.651,"endTime":4926.621,"body":"either side, or not state the strongest"},{"startTime":4926.855,"endTime":4928.623,"body":"version of the argument on either side,"},{"startTime":4928.623,"endTime":4929.557,"body":"although that seems like"},{"startTime":4929.557,"endTime":4930.492,"body":"not very good journalism."},{"startTime":4930.926,"endTime":4932.327,"body":"Okay, but one other thing."},{"startTime":4933.161,"endTime":4936.698,"body":"The third example in their list of three"},{"startTime":4937.399,"endTime":4939.567,"body":"was about a data center, where again?"},{"startTime":4940.268,"endTime":4942.304,"body":"Being constructed by an American company"},{"startTime":4942.304,"endTime":4943.972,"body":"called Firebird being"},{"startTime":4943.972,"endTime":4945.106,"body":"constructed in Armenia."},{"startTime":4946.775,"endTime":4947.075,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":4947.275,"endTime":4948.576,"body":"Yeah, no, no."},{"startTime":4948.944,"endTime":4951.98,"body":"The chances that foreign adversaries have"},{"startTime":4952.113,"endTime":4954.683,"body":"decided to highlight a data center being"},{"startTime":4954.683,"endTime":4956.451,"body":"constructed in Armenia to"},{"startTime":4958.153,"endTime":4960.522,"body":"embolden skeptics and"},{"startTime":4960.555,"endTime":4962.29,"body":"hostile forces in the US."},{"startTime":4962.991,"endTime":4964.726,"body":"Ah, but that one was posted by a known"},{"startTime":4964.759,"endTime":4966.761,"body":"covert Russian influence operation."},{"startTime":4967.495,"endTime":4968.43,"body":"Those five words, and I"},{"startTime":4968.43,"endTime":4969.397,"body":"mean, what can you do?"},{"startTime":4969.664,"endTime":4970.899,"body":"Right, oh, it's obviously--"},{"startTime":4970.899,"endTime":4971.933,"body":"Known covert Russian influence."},{"startTime":4972.0,"endTime":4974.369,"body":"Yeah, it's a direct hit on"},{"startTime":4974.836,"endTime":4976.671,"body":"something really hard to see."},{"startTime":4976.671,"endTime":4978.573,"body":"But if you were going to try to get the"},{"startTime":4978.573,"endTime":4981.009,"body":"American public whipped into a lather"},{"startTime":4981.009,"endTime":4982.911,"body":"over these things, an"},{"startTime":4982.911,"endTime":4984.245,"body":"Albanian data center-- Armenian."},{"startTime":4984.379,"endTime":4985.48,"body":"Armenian data center"},{"startTime":4985.48,"endTime":4987.482,"body":"would not be the go-to."},{"startTime":4987.816,"endTime":4989.884,"body":"It's not the one that's gonna get anybody"},{"startTime":4989.884,"endTime":4990.652,"body":"out of bed in the morning."},{"startTime":4990.819,"endTime":4992.654,"body":"Even those of us who love maps might have"},{"startTime":4992.654,"endTime":4994.189,"body":"a hard time putting Armenia"},{"startTime":4994.255,"endTime":4995.29,"body":"exactly in the right place."},{"startTime":4995.357,"endTime":4997.425,"body":"Right, but I mean, are the Russians"},{"startTime":4997.425,"endTime":4999.594,"body":"targeting the Armenian public?"},{"startTime":4999.694,"endTime":5002.263,"body":"Because, I mean, it's just a non sequitur"},{"startTime":5002.297,"endTime":5003.798,"body":"that you would highlight that when there"},{"startTime":5003.798,"endTime":5005.6,"body":"are so many data centers in the US about"},{"startTime":5005.6,"endTime":5006.301,"body":"which there's already a"},{"startTime":5006.301,"endTime":5007.635,"body":"lot of organic controversy."},{"startTime":5007.836,"endTime":5008.036,"body":"Yep."},{"startTime":5009.637,"endTime":5012.107,"body":"China, Russia, again continuing with the"},{"startTime":5012.107,"endTime":5013.808,"body":"New York Times, China, Russia, and to a"},{"startTime":5013.808,"endTime":5016.678,"body":"lesser extent, Iran, have sought to use"},{"startTime":5016.678,"endTime":5017.912,"body":"state media outlets to turn the"},{"startTime":5017.912,"endTime":5019.514,"body":"controversy over data centers in the"},{"startTime":5019.514,"endTime":5021.75,"body":"United States into, quote, a domestic"},{"startTime":5021.75,"endTime":5023.618,"body":"fracture point, according to a new"},{"startTime":5023.618,"endTime":5026.287,"body":"analysis by Althea, a threat intelligence"},{"startTime":5026.287,"endTime":5027.789,"body":"company which identified scores of"},{"startTime":5027.789,"endTime":5028.823,"body":"articles and posts on"},{"startTime":5028.823,"endTime":5029.891,"body":"social media this year."},{"startTime":5029.924,"endTime":5031.226,"body":"So again, I'm gonna get there."},{"startTime":5032.093,"endTime":5033.595,"body":"Scores-- Scores."},{"startTime":5033.595,"endTime":5035.096,"body":"Scores doesn't sound like that many."},{"startTime":5035.096,"endTime":5035.663,"body":"We're halfway through"},{"startTime":5035.663,"endTime":5038.333,"body":"the year, a score is 12?"},{"startTime":5038.366,"endTime":5038.566,"body":"12."},{"startTime":5038.767,"endTime":5038.967,"body":"12."},{"startTime":5039.501,"endTime":5039.868,"body":"Isn't it?"},{"startTime":5039.968,"endTime":5040.602,"body":"Yeah, I think so."},{"startTime":5040.802,"endTime":5041.036,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":5041.036,"endTime":5041.803,"body":"Yeah, four score, yeah."},{"startTime":5042.07,"endTime":5043.872,"body":"A score is 12, scores a dozen."},{"startTime":5044.339,"endTime":5046.174,"body":"So scores of articles and posts on social"},{"startTime":5046.174,"endTime":5046.941,"body":"media this year does"},{"startTime":5046.941,"endTime":5048.076,"body":"not seem like that much."},{"startTime":5048.71,"endTime":5049.244,"body":"It's nothing."},{"startTime":5049.344,"endTime":5049.611,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":5051.246,"endTime":5052.313,"body":"You know, would it be"},{"startTime":5052.313,"endTime":5053.481,"body":"better if none of them happened?"},{"startTime":5053.481,"endTime":5055.283,"body":"Sure, but, okay."},{"startTime":5055.483,"endTime":5056.951,"body":"The foreign efforts appear intended to"},{"startTime":5056.951,"endTime":5058.52,"body":"stoke the debate over data centers that"},{"startTime":5058.52,"endTime":5060.321,"body":"has united political figures across the"},{"startTime":5060.321,"endTime":5061.99,"body":"political spectrum, from Senator Bernie"},{"startTime":5061.99,"endTime":5062.991,"body":"Sanders of Vermont, a"},{"startTime":5062.991,"endTime":5064.225,"body":"progressive to Stephen K."},{"startTime":5064.225,"endTime":5065.26,"body":"Bannon, the erstwhile"},{"startTime":5065.26,"endTime":5066.528,"body":"advisor to President Trump."},{"startTime":5066.895,"endTime":5069.264,"body":"That may be the kernel of why this"},{"startTime":5069.264,"endTime":5070.932,"body":"article exists right here."},{"startTime":5071.099,"endTime":5074.202,"body":"Hold up, why is there agreement across"},{"startTime":5074.202,"endTime":5075.67,"body":"the entire gamut of"},{"startTime":5075.67,"endTime":5077.205,"body":"political thinking in the US?"},{"startTime":5077.205,"endTime":5078.94,"body":"This is gonna be a problem for us who"},{"startTime":5078.94,"endTime":5079.674,"body":"wanna put up data"},{"startTime":5079.674,"endTime":5081.409,"body":"centers into your backyard."},{"startTime":5081.576,"endTime":5083.845,"body":"We better create skepticism about why"},{"startTime":5083.845,"endTime":5085.78,"body":"you're skeptical about data centers."},{"startTime":5085.847,"endTime":5087.782,"body":"Oh crap, the pitchfork people and the"},{"startTime":5087.782,"endTime":5089.751,"body":"torch people are talking to each other"},{"startTime":5089.751,"endTime":5090.919,"body":"about their hostility"},{"startTime":5090.919,"endTime":5091.986,"body":"to the data centers."},{"startTime":5092.02,"endTime":5092.654,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":5092.787,"endTime":5093.154,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":5093.788,"endTime":5095.19,"body":"That's a reason"},{"startTime":5096.324,"endTime":5097.425,"body":"for alarm if you're a"},{"startTime":5097.425,"endTime":5098.993,"body":"certain type of tycoon."},{"startTime":5099.561,"endTime":5100.095,"body":"Exactly."},{"startTime":5101.629,"endTime":5103.164,"body":"We can't allow any effort by foreign"},{"startTime":5103.164,"endTime":5104.966,"body":"adversaries to extort these fears and"},{"startTime":5104.966,"endTime":5106.668,"body":"undermine our technological development."},{"startTime":5106.701,"endTime":5108.47,"body":"Senator Tom Cotton, Republican of"},{"startTime":5108.47,"endTime":5110.071,"body":"Arkansas, wrote to the acting attorney"},{"startTime":5110.071,"endTime":5111.94,"body":"general, Todd Blanche, referring to"},{"startTime":5111.94,"endTime":5113.408,"body":"genuine public concerns."},{"startTime":5114.175,"endTime":5115.543,"body":"The Trump administration, which after"},{"startTime":5115.543,"endTime":5117.078,"body":"taking office dismantled many of the"},{"startTime":5117.078,"endTime":5118.379,"body":"government teams that tracked foreign"},{"startTime":5118.413,"endTime":5120.448,"body":"influence operations, has begun to"},{"startTime":5120.448,"endTime":5121.783,"body":"recognize the political threat of the"},{"startTime":5121.783,"endTime":5123.318,"body":"rising sentiment against AI."},{"startTime":5124.118,"endTime":5126.421,"body":"A Gallup poll in May found that 71% of"},{"startTime":5126.421,"endTime":5128.089,"body":"Americans were somewhat or strongly"},{"startTime":5128.089,"endTime":5128.99,"body":"opposed to having a data"},{"startTime":5128.99,"endTime":5130.024,"body":"center built near them."},{"startTime":5131.326,"endTime":5133.161,"body":"Really, only 71%?"},{"startTime":5133.795,"endTime":5134.996,"body":"The others haven't heard of it yet."},{"startTime":5135.864,"endTime":5137.665,"body":"Almost 20 percentage points higher than"},{"startTime":5137.665,"endTime":5139.267,"body":"those who oppose construction of a nearby"},{"startTime":5139.267,"endTime":5140.468,"body":"nuclear power plant."},{"startTime":5141.169,"endTime":5142.47,"body":"Many have brought concerns about the"},{"startTime":5142.47,"endTime":5144.806,"body":"effects of AI on jobs and the climate,"},{"startTime":5145.206,"endTime":5146.608,"body":"while people who live near data centers"},{"startTime":5146.608,"endTime":5147.775,"body":"complain their eyesores"},{"startTime":5147.775,"endTime":5149.611,"body":"and emit annoying sounds."},{"startTime":5150.512,"endTime":5152.146,"body":"Some cities and counties have enacted"},{"startTime":5152.146,"endTime":5153.114,"body":"temporary or permanent"},{"startTime":5153.114,"endTime":5154.415,"body":"moratoriums on new construction."},{"startTime":5154.916,"endTime":5157.752,"body":"Now, I include that sentence because, as"},{"startTime":5157.752,"endTime":5159.754,"body":"we will see in another piece I'm gonna"},{"startTime":5160.021,"endTime":5163.057,"body":"read to you from, the actual"},{"startTime":5164.459,"endTime":5166.161,"body":"problems with having these near your"},{"startTime":5166.161,"endTime":5168.663,"body":"house are routinely being underplayed,"},{"startTime":5168.696,"endTime":5170.231,"body":"even when people are saying, \"Oh my God,"},{"startTime":5170.231,"endTime":5171.833,"body":"they're loud and they're"},{"startTime":5171.833,"endTime":5174.035,"body":"hot,\" emit annoying sounds."},{"startTime":5174.035,"endTime":5176.204,"body":"But these are not the primary reasons to"},{"startTime":5176.204,"endTime":5179.14,"body":"hate them as much as much as, and we'll"},{"startTime":5179.14,"endTime":5180.942,"body":"see a picture here in an upcoming piece"},{"startTime":5180.942,"endTime":5183.845,"body":"I'm gonna read from, like what it would"},{"startTime":5183.845,"endTime":5185.847,"body":"look like to go from having an idyllic"},{"startTime":5186.481,"endTime":5189.584,"body":"pastoral natural yard to something with"},{"startTime":5189.584,"endTime":5191.185,"body":"one of these gigantic towers"},{"startTime":5191.185,"endTime":5192.687,"body":"buzzing in it all the time."},{"startTime":5192.954,"endTime":5197.091,"body":"But as much as the aesthetic and natural"},{"startTime":5198.526,"endTime":5200.728,"body":"effects of having such a thing in your"},{"startTime":5200.728,"endTime":5203.798,"body":"yard will be huge, those aren't the main"},{"startTime":5203.798,"endTime":5205.867,"body":"problems and the New York Times doesn't"},{"startTime":5205.867,"endTime":5207.569,"body":"mention anything but"},{"startTime":5208.303,"endTime":5210.505,"body":"eyesores and emit annoying sounds."},{"startTime":5210.705,"endTime":5211.539,"body":"Right, which makes it"},{"startTime":5211.539,"endTime":5213.408,"body":"sound like an empty problem."},{"startTime":5213.908,"endTime":5215.743,"body":"But the truth is,"},{"startTime":5217.111,"endTime":5217.545,"body":"come on,"},{"startTime":5218.746,"endTime":5221.816,"body":"annoying sounds, annoying trivializes"},{"startTime":5221.816,"endTime":5223.051,"body":"them in the description."},{"startTime":5223.151,"endTime":5225.119,"body":"The fact is, this is absolutely"},{"startTime":5225.119,"endTime":5227.555,"body":"quantifiable, there's a decibel level"},{"startTime":5227.589,"endTime":5230.058,"body":"there's a neurological cost to be paid"},{"startTime":5230.325,"endTime":5232.794,"body":"for this white noise that you didn't buy"},{"startTime":5232.794,"endTime":5234.662,"body":"your house expecting to exist."},{"startTime":5234.829,"endTime":5238.166,"body":"So it's a quantifiable harm, it's not an"},{"startTime":5238.166,"endTime":5240.702,"body":"annoyance that you're being picky about."},{"startTime":5241.169,"endTime":5242.704,"body":"Even the annoyance that you're being"},{"startTime":5242.737,"endTime":5243.871,"body":"picky about, I think you're fully"},{"startTime":5243.871,"endTime":5245.406,"body":"entitled to be troubled."},{"startTime":5245.707,"endTime":5247.709,"body":"But the point is, no, no, this is a"},{"startTime":5247.709,"endTime":5249.611,"body":"medical issue actually, this is something"},{"startTime":5249.611,"endTime":5252.413,"body":"that is gonna have an impact on your"},{"startTime":5252.413,"endTime":5254.015,"body":"ability to work, it's gonna have an"},{"startTime":5254.015,"endTime":5256.584,"body":"impact on the quality of your life and"},{"startTime":5256.851,"endTime":5260.321,"body":"the degree of that impact is an"},{"startTime":5260.388,"endTime":5262.824,"body":"absolutely objective fact, right?"},{"startTime":5262.824,"endTime":5263.358,"body":"It's not"},{"startTime":5263.358,"endTime":5264.792,"body":"annoying sounds."},{"startTime":5265.526,"endTime":5266.427,"body":"It's certainly much"},{"startTime":5266.427,"endTime":5268.029,"body":"more than annoying sounds."},{"startTime":5268.429,"endTime":5271.699,"body":"I will get a few articles from here to"},{"startTime":5271.733,"endTime":5274.168,"body":"some of the known effects that no one"},{"startTime":5274.168,"endTime":5275.303,"body":"appears to be talking about"},{"startTime":5275.303,"endTime":5277.805,"body":"except for a handful of people."},{"startTime":5278.573,"endTime":5282.41,"body":"But I am pretty confident that we still"},{"startTime":5282.41,"endTime":5283.344,"body":"don't know the extent of"},{"startTime":5283.344,"endTime":5284.512,"body":"what the costs actually are."},{"startTime":5284.545,"endTime":5284.879,"body":"So"},{"startTime":5286.214,"endTime":5287.782,"body":"objective, yes."},{"startTime":5287.949,"endTime":5289.884,"body":"Quantifiable, yes."},{"startTime":5289.884,"endTime":5291.686,"body":"Fully known and quantified, no."},{"startTime":5291.719,"endTime":5294.355,"body":"I was just talking about the decibel"},{"startTime":5294.355,"endTime":5296.724,"body":"level as a perfect objective fact that"},{"startTime":5297.058,"endTime":5298.66,"body":"could be described by the New York Times."},{"startTime":5298.826,"endTime":5300.895,"body":"Instead they've decided to trivialize it."},{"startTime":5303.197,"endTime":5304.265,"body":"Jumped forward a little bit in this New"},{"startTime":5304.265,"endTime":5306.067,"body":"York Times article, lobbyists have also"},{"startTime":5306.067,"endTime":5307.735,"body":"weighed in to insinuate that American"},{"startTime":5307.735,"endTime":5308.636,"body":"opposition has been"},{"startTime":5308.636,"endTime":5310.338,"body":"fomented with support from abroad."},{"startTime":5311.005,"endTime":5312.94,"body":"Power the Future, an energy industry"},{"startTime":5312.94,"endTime":5314.809,"body":"group, argued recently that domestic"},{"startTime":5314.809,"endTime":5316.077,"body":"opposition to data centers was"},{"startTime":5316.077,"endTime":5318.012,"body":"manufactured by environmental groups"},{"startTime":5318.012,"endTime":5320.181,"body":"financed in part by foreign donors like"},{"startTime":5320.381,"endTime":5322.25,"body":"Hans-Jor Gwiss, I don't know how to"},{"startTime":5322.25,"endTime":5323.484,"body":"pronounce his name, the Swiss"},{"startTime":5323.484,"endTime":5325.119,"body":"philanthropist and conservationist whose"},{"startTime":5325.119,"endTime":5326.721,"body":"foundation is well known for supporting"},{"startTime":5326.754,"endTime":5327.722,"body":"environmental issues."},{"startTime":5328.089,"endTime":5329.19,"body":"Oh, diabolical."},{"startTime":5329.19,"endTime":5330.091,"body":"Yeah, that's"},{"startTime":5331.125,"endTime":5331.492,"body":"awful."},{"startTime":5331.793,"endTime":5333.494,"body":"In a statement, the Gwiss Foundation said"},{"startTime":5333.494,"endTime":5334.228,"body":"it did not provide"},{"startTime":5334.228,"endTime":5335.663,"body":"grants to oppose data centers."},{"startTime":5335.663,"endTime":5336.998,"body":"Quote, \"These reports are false,"},{"startTime":5336.998,"endTime":5338.466,"body":"misleading, and an attempt by special"},{"startTime":5338.499,"endTime":5339.934,"body":"interests to manipulate the public into"},{"startTime":5339.934,"endTime":5340.568,"body":"accepting data"},{"startTime":5340.568,"endTime":5341.569,"body":"centers,\" the statement said."},{"startTime":5341.703,"endTime":5343.571,"body":"So it's just like one"},{"startTime":5343.571,"endTime":5344.772,"body":"layer on top of each other."},{"startTime":5345.139,"endTime":5348.342,"body":"Like the opposition that you feel must"},{"startTime":5348.342,"endTime":5351.179,"body":"have been fomented by those green types"},{"startTime":5351.179,"endTime":5353.314,"body":"who like to hug trees and look at otters."},{"startTime":5354.115,"endTime":5356.35,"body":"That's the argument we're seeing now."},{"startTime":5356.584,"endTime":5359.02,"body":"And it's easier to get that argument in"},{"startTime":5359.153,"endTime":5361.155,"body":"once you claim that there are scores,"},{"startTime":5361.189,"endTime":5364.392,"body":"scores of social media posts this year"},{"startTime":5364.392,"endTime":5368.296,"body":"alone from Russia and China that aren't"},{"startTime":5368.296,"endTime":5368.963,"body":"what they appear to be."},{"startTime":5368.963,"endTime":5369.797,"body":"Scores?"},{"startTime":5370.098,"endTime":5372.2,"body":"This year alone, Russia and China, they"},{"startTime":5373.267,"endTime":5375.303,"body":"have not made their point that the"},{"startTime":5375.303,"endTime":5378.172,"body":"problem is as big as they say it is, but"},{"startTime":5378.172,"endTime":5380.708,"body":"it specifically opens the door wide for"},{"startTime":5380.708,"endTime":5383.044,"body":"lobbyists, as the New York Times says, to"},{"startTime":5383.044,"endTime":5385.413,"body":"make the claim that if you have"},{"startTime":5385.413,"endTime":5387.415,"body":"skepticism about these things, you've"},{"startTime":5387.415,"endTime":5388.716,"body":"probably been manipulated."},{"startTime":5389.05,"endTime":5391.586,"body":"Oh, and it will lodge that in the minds"},{"startTime":5391.586,"endTime":5393.955,"body":"of people who would otherwise naturally"},{"startTime":5393.955,"endTime":5395.423,"body":"be upset about this."},{"startTime":5395.523,"endTime":5399.026,"body":"And so what you have is, so far, three"},{"startTime":5400.528,"endTime":5403.698,"body":"suspicious, tepid examples of the"},{"startTime":5403.698,"endTime":5406.033,"body":"manipulation of the American public."},{"startTime":5406.501,"endTime":5409.337,"body":"And then you have a claim that there are"},{"startTime":5409.437,"endTime":5411.506,"body":"a large number of posts when large is"},{"startTime":5411.506,"endTime":5414.175,"body":"measured in dozens, and the number of"},{"startTime":5414.175,"endTime":5415.777,"body":"posts is so mind-bogglingly"},{"startTime":5415.777,"endTime":5418.045,"body":"large that that's not even a"},{"startTime":5420.214,"endTime":5421.416,"body":"relevant number."},{"startTime":5421.549,"endTime":5424.752,"body":"And then, but my point is, the claim that"},{"startTime":5424.752,"endTime":5427.855,"body":"they are stacking on top of those"},{"startTime":5427.855,"endTime":5430.792,"body":"foundational pieces is that"},{"startTime":5432.693,"endTime":5436.33,"body":"the opposition is a"},{"startTime":5436.364,"endTime":5440.768,"body":"consequence of these vague operations,"},{"startTime":5441.936,"endTime":5443.504,"body":"scores of posts."},{"startTime":5444.071,"endTime":5445.106,"body":"Here are three examples."},{"startTime":5445.106,"endTime":5447.408,"body":"My point is, there's no way that"},{"startTime":5447.408,"endTime":5450.578,"body":"opposition in the US could in any way be"},{"startTime":5451.078,"endTime":5455.016,"body":"profoundly impacted by scores of posts,"},{"startTime":5455.283,"endTime":5457.018,"body":"none of which are apparently"},{"startTime":5458.152,"endTime":5459.353,"body":"profound in their impact."},{"startTime":5459.353,"endTime":5460.388,"body":"I mean, it's not even that they've"},{"startTime":5460.555,"endTime":5462.79,"body":"provided a viral post that turns out to"},{"startTime":5462.79,"endTime":5463.858,"body":"track its way back somewhere."},{"startTime":5463.858,"endTime":5464.892,"body":"It's just, yeah, there"},{"startTime":5464.892,"endTime":5465.46,"body":"are a bunch of posts."},{"startTime":5465.76,"endTime":5466.894,"body":"Yeah, just point of"},{"startTime":5466.894,"endTime":5469.063,"body":"order, we both flubbed scores."},{"startTime":5469.463,"endTime":5469.864,"body":"It's 20."},{"startTime":5470.264,"endTime":5470.631,"body":"20."},{"startTime":5470.631,"endTime":5470.865,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":5471.399,"endTime":5473.434,"body":"Four score, yeah, and"},{"startTime":5473.467,"endTime":5474.569,"body":"is it seven years ago?"},{"startTime":5474.836,"endTime":5477.572,"body":"Yeah, okay, yeah, damn."},{"startTime":5477.939,"endTime":5479.073,"body":"Just, you know, so it's"},{"startTime":5480.107,"endTime":5480.675,"body":"more than we were"},{"startTime":5480.675,"endTime":5481.709,"body":"saying, but still not a ton."},{"startTime":5481.776,"endTime":5484.579,"body":"Yeah, well, yeah, it's not really more,"},{"startTime":5484.612,"endTime":5485.346,"body":"given the orders of"},{"startTime":5485.346,"endTime":5487.515,"body":"magnitude involved in how many posts."},{"startTime":5487.515,"endTime":5488.85,"body":"I mean, 20 is more than 12."},{"startTime":5488.85,"endTime":5490.351,"body":"It's not meaningfully more."},{"startTime":5490.384,"endTime":5491.385,"body":"First of all, it's more."},{"startTime":5491.652,"endTime":5493.454,"body":"Well, let's know, I will make the"},{"startTime":5493.454,"endTime":5494.088,"body":"argument that"},{"startTime":5494.088,"endTime":5496.557,"body":"significant digits wise, they are"},{"startTime":5496.557,"endTime":5497.525,"body":"not being-- But we're making arguments"},{"startTime":5497.525,"endTime":5498.426,"body":"about significant digits."},{"startTime":5499.093,"endTime":5501.095,"body":"I know, I'm just saying, in terms of your"},{"startTime":5501.095,"endTime":5503.397,"body":"calibrating what we've said, they're not"},{"startTime":5503.397,"endTime":5505.433,"body":"offering a different order of magnitude"},{"startTime":5505.433,"endTime":5506.1,"body":"of the number of"},{"startTime":5506.1,"endTime":5507.702,"body":"posts based on our error."},{"startTime":5507.902,"endTime":5511.873,"body":"We're still in double digits, and they"},{"startTime":5511.873,"endTime":5513.14,"body":"wanna multiply that by"},{"startTime":5513.14,"endTime":5514.675,"body":"some vague number scores."},{"startTime":5515.009,"endTime":5518.546,"body":"So it's a trivial number, no matter which"},{"startTime":5518.579,"endTime":5519.914,"body":"version you got, the"},{"startTime":5519.914,"endTime":5520.948,"body":"right or the wrong version."},{"startTime":5522.483,"endTime":5523.351,"body":"Of what a score is."},{"startTime":5523.384,"endTime":5527.822,"body":"Right, so to stack on top of scores of"},{"startTime":5527.822,"endTime":5531.359,"body":"posts, three cruddy examples, the idea"},{"startTime":5531.359,"endTime":5534.095,"body":"that the opposition is in some way a"},{"startTime":5534.095,"endTime":5536.664,"body":"consequence of an organized something, if"},{"startTime":5536.664,"endTime":5538.332,"body":"it is a consequence of an organized"},{"startTime":5538.332,"endTime":5541.435,"body":"something being fomented from abroad, New"},{"startTime":5541.435,"endTime":5542.97,"body":"York Times has an obligation to"},{"startTime":5542.97,"endTime":5545.773,"body":"demonstrate that, which in doing such a"},{"startTime":5545.773,"endTime":5548.075,"body":"poor job of providing evidence, it"},{"startTime":5548.075,"endTime":5549.543,"body":"suggests there is no"},{"startTime":5549.543,"endTime":5550.811,"body":"significant contribution."},{"startTime":5551.412,"endTime":5552.313,"body":"If there is, the New York"},{"startTime":5552.313,"endTime":5553.581,"body":"Times didn't apparently find it."},{"startTime":5554.482,"endTime":5557.118,"body":"Well, again, the New York Times wasn't"},{"startTime":5557.118,"endTime":5558.286,"body":"doing the research that"},{"startTime":5558.286,"endTime":5559.787,"body":"it is reporting on here."},{"startTime":5559.921,"endTime":5561.722,"body":"That came out of the Alathea Foundation,"},{"startTime":5561.722,"endTime":5563.524,"body":"which I'll get to in just a minute."},{"startTime":5563.858,"endTime":5565.026,"body":"Just two more paragraphs out"},{"startTime":5565.026,"endTime":5566.193,"body":"of the New York Times article."},{"startTime":5566.928,"endTime":5568.629,"body":"Another pair of reports by the Bitcoin"},{"startTime":5568.629,"endTime":5570.665,"body":"Policy Institute, a cryptocurrency"},{"startTime":5570.665,"endTime":5572.633,"body":"advocacy group in Washington, also"},{"startTime":5572.633,"endTime":5574.235,"body":"detailed what the group's researchers"},{"startTime":5574.235,"endTime":5576.27,"body":"called an extensive multi-year influence"},{"startTime":5576.27,"endTime":5579.473,"body":"campaign by China to sway the AI race."},{"startTime":5580.241,"endTime":5581.909,"body":"\"There is an organic opposition to data"},{"startTime":5581.909,"endTime":5582.777,"body":"centers,\" the author of"},{"startTime":5582.777,"endTime":5584.111,"body":"the report, Sam Lyman said."},{"startTime":5584.378,"endTime":5585.646,"body":"\"What we are calling for is simply"},{"startTime":5585.646,"endTime":5587.248,"body":"transparency though, because we've been"},{"startTime":5587.248,"endTime":5589.083,"body":"able to document an inorganic element"},{"startTime":5589.083,"endTime":5591.218,"body":"that runs parallel to this specific"},{"startTime":5591.218,"endTime":5592.32,"body":"opposition movement.\""},{"startTime":5592.587,"endTime":5593.554,"body":"That seemed clear."},{"startTime":5594.021,"endTime":5595.856,"body":"Like, okay, we know that there's an"},{"startTime":5595.856,"endTime":5597.792,"body":"organic opposition movement, but there is"},{"startTime":5597.792,"endTime":5600.328,"body":"a parallel inorganic movement that is"},{"startTime":5600.328,"endTime":5601.963,"body":"running in his words, parallel."},{"startTime":5602.663,"endTime":5604.632,"body":"And I think that's likely to be true."},{"startTime":5605.333,"endTime":5606.1,"body":"That's likely to be true."},{"startTime":5606.1,"endTime":5608.703,"body":"So let's just go to the"},{"startTime":5610.705,"endTime":5614.141,"body":"report out of this organization called"},{"startTime":5614.141,"endTime":5616.243,"body":"Alathea, which is what the"},{"startTime":5616.243,"endTime":5617.345,"body":"New York Times is reporting on."},{"startTime":5617.345,"endTime":5618.346,"body":"In fact, right at the top of their"},{"startTime":5618.346,"endTime":5620.247,"body":"website, I happen to have pulled up a PDF"},{"startTime":5620.247,"endTime":5621.549,"body":"so I could highlight sections here."},{"startTime":5622.216,"endTime":5624.919,"body":"But this is just off their website just a"},{"startTime":5624.919,"endTime":5627.755,"body":"couple hours ago today, July 15th."},{"startTime":5627.755,"endTime":5628.656,"body":"It says, \"New York Times"},{"startTime":5628.656,"endTime":5630.157,"body":"cites new Alathea research."},{"startTime":5630.491,"endTime":5631.592,"body":"Russia, China, and Iran"},{"startTime":5631.592,"endTime":5632.96,"body":"target US data center debate.\""},{"startTime":5633.027,"endTime":5635.596,"body":"So they are proud of, as you would expect"},{"startTime":5635.596,"endTime":5638.366,"body":"a research outfit to be proud of being so"},{"startTime":5638.366,"endTime":5640.601,"body":"prominently figuring in"},{"startTime":5640.601,"endTime":5641.502,"body":"a New York Times article."},{"startTime":5642.336,"endTime":5644.005,"body":"They write, \"With opposition to data"},{"startTime":5644.005,"endTime":5645.306,"body":"centers cutting across traditional"},{"startTime":5645.306,"endTime":5646.34,"body":"political lines,\" so"},{"startTime":5646.34,"endTime":5647.641,"body":"again, there's that, right?"},{"startTime":5648.175,"endTime":5649.777,"body":"\"And multiple high-profile projects"},{"startTime":5649.81,"endTime":5651.379,"body":"already blocked or delayed, the data"},{"startTime":5651.379,"endTime":5652.847,"body":"center fight has become volatile at the"},{"startTime":5652.847,"endTime":5654.281,"body":"hyper-local level, creating the"},{"startTime":5654.281,"endTime":5655.182,"body":"conditions that foreign"},{"startTime":5655.182,"endTime":5656.484,"body":"actors are built to exploit."},{"startTime":5657.151,"endTime":5659.186,"body":"Locally fragmented, emotionally charged"},{"startTime":5659.186,"endTime":5660.755,"body":"fights like this one are exactly the"},{"startTime":5660.755,"endTime":5662.857,"body":"conditions state actors look for, a"},{"startTime":5662.857,"endTime":5664.592,"body":"chance to turn grievance into a wedge"},{"startTime":5664.592,"endTime":5666.227,"body":"against trust in US infrastructure,"},{"startTime":5666.227,"endTime":5667.328,"body":"companies, and government."},{"startTime":5667.962,"endTime":5669.43,"body":"Data centers are the current target, but"},{"startTime":5669.43,"endTime":5670.998,"body":"they're also a preview of a repeatable"},{"startTime":5670.998,"endTime":5673.634,"body":"playbook, local opposition hijacked and"},{"startTime":5673.667,"endTime":5674.802,"body":"amplified by foreign state"},{"startTime":5674.802,"endTime":5676.47,"body":"actors into a national narrative."},{"startTime":5677.038,"endTime":5678.873,"body":"Any industry that becomes the center in"},{"startTime":5678.873,"endTime":5680.241,"body":"the next hyper-local fight should expect"},{"startTime":5680.241,"endTime":5682.143,"body":"the same tactics, which is why what's"},{"startTime":5682.143,"endTime":5683.544,"body":"happening to data centers right now is"},{"startTime":5683.544,"endTime":5684.211,"body":"worth studying well"},{"startTime":5684.211,"endTime":5685.246,"body":"beyond this one sector."},{"startTime":5685.746,"endTime":5687.948,"body":"The playbook itself isn't new, find a raw"},{"startTime":5687.948,"endTime":5689.884,"body":"nerve, flood it with content that echoes"},{"startTime":5689.884,"endTime":5691.719,"body":"what people are already saying, then let"},{"startTime":5691.719,"endTime":5693.32,"body":"the fracture widen on its own."},{"startTime":5693.688,"endTime":5695.756,"body":"Russia, China, and Iran have all run this"},{"startTime":5695.756,"endTime":5697.591,"body":"pattern before around natural disasters,"},{"startTime":5697.625,"endTime":5698.859,"body":"elections, and protests."},{"startTime":5699.193,"endTime":5700.895,"body":"Data centers are just the newest venue.\""},{"startTime":5703.931,"endTime":5704.665,"body":"Who are these people?"},{"startTime":5705.766,"endTime":5706.667,"body":"I don't really know."},{"startTime":5707.968,"endTime":5710.271,"body":"They're an independent"},{"startTime":5711.772,"endTime":5714.208,"body":"research outfit that says,"},{"startTime":5715.242,"endTime":5718.245,"body":"and I'm in a PDF now, so I'd have to exit"},{"startTime":5718.245,"endTime":5719.98,"body":"this and have you talk while I went and"},{"startTime":5719.98,"endTime":5721.749,"body":"duck, because these aren't"},{"startTime":5721.749,"endTime":5723.384,"body":"hot linked, but this is a PDF."},{"startTime":5725.352,"endTime":5726.987,"body":"Yeah, so I can't answer that question at"},{"startTime":5726.987,"endTime":5729.99,"body":"the moment with my screen on here."},{"startTime":5730.157,"endTime":5733.894,"body":"Well, I will say I am concerned that this"},{"startTime":5733.894,"endTime":5737.064,"body":"is some sort of thing of the sort of"},{"startTime":5737.064,"endTime":5738.499,"body":"organized effort that"},{"startTime":5738.632,"endTime":5741.035,"body":"we've encountered surrounding"},{"startTime":5742.036,"endTime":5745.005,"body":"vaccines with GAVI, trusted news"},{"startTime":5745.005,"endTime":5750.277,"body":"initiative over pandemic issues that"},{"startTime":5750.277,"endTime":5753.414,"body":"we've seen with respect to, you know,"},{"startTime":5753.781,"endTime":5755.85,"body":"Stanford Internet Observatory and"},{"startTime":5755.85,"endTime":5757.084,"body":"supposed misinformation."},{"startTime":5757.384,"endTime":5760.921,"body":"And what I'm getting is, hey, guess what?"},{"startTime":5761.422,"endTime":5764.125,"body":"We are an organization very concerned"},{"startTime":5764.125,"endTime":5764.825,"body":"about foreign"},{"startTime":5764.825,"endTime":5767.328,"body":"influence in American opinion."},{"startTime":5768.229,"endTime":5771.766,"body":"It is certainly true that our adversaries"},{"startTime":5771.766,"endTime":5774.034,"body":"abroad will have noticed that there is a"},{"startTime":5774.068,"endTime":5776.403,"body":"go-to play that they can engage in where"},{"startTime":5776.403,"endTime":5779.673,"body":"they can simply dump gasoline on the"},{"startTime":5779.673,"endTime":5781.709,"body":"concerns that people already have, making"},{"startTime":5781.709,"endTime":5782.309,"body":"them even more"},{"startTime":5782.309,"endTime":5783.778,"body":"concerned, and that would be bad."},{"startTime":5784.211,"endTime":5786.981,"body":"So what we have to do is counteract this,"},{"startTime":5787.047,"endTime":5789.183,"body":"and my point would be that is"},{"startTime":5790.384,"endTime":5797.191,"body":"a 100% generic opposition play any time"},{"startTime":5797.191,"endTime":5800.227,"body":"an industry has something that's"},{"startTime":5800.227,"endTime":5802.863,"body":"unpopular that it wants to ram down the"},{"startTime":5802.863,"endTime":5805.166,"body":"throats of the American public, is to"},{"startTime":5805.166,"endTime":5806.667,"body":"claim that the opposition to it is"},{"startTime":5806.667,"endTime":5808.469,"body":"getting, you know, foreign"},{"startTime":5809.837,"endTime":5812.606,"body":"gasoline dumped on it to inflame people's"},{"startTime":5812.606,"endTime":5814.341,"body":"otherwise mild opinions."},{"startTime":5815.075,"endTime":5817.945,"body":"And the point is, okay, you're claiming"},{"startTime":5817.945,"endTime":5820.114,"body":"that our adversaries abroad will always"},{"startTime":5820.181,"endTime":5821.549,"body":"notice this and exploit it."},{"startTime":5821.882,"endTime":5823.517,"body":"It's not really obvious to me that our"},{"startTime":5823.517,"endTime":5825.819,"body":"adversaries, especially if there's not"},{"startTime":5825.819,"endTime":5828.455,"body":"going to make a major effort, have much"},{"startTime":5828.455,"endTime":5830.824,"body":"opportunity to affect how concerned"},{"startTime":5830.824,"endTime":5832.493,"body":"people are locally"},{"startTime":5832.526,"endTime":5834.061,"body":"about these data centers."},{"startTime":5834.195,"endTime":5835.696,"body":"People are concerned about them because"},{"startTime":5835.696,"endTime":5837.064,"body":"they're concerning, duh."},{"startTime":5837.531,"endTime":5839.733,"body":"So, you know, okay, the fact that some"},{"startTime":5839.733,"endTime":5841.669,"body":"foreign account you've never heard of"},{"startTime":5841.735,"endTime":5843.971,"body":"adds to a chorus of people already"},{"startTime":5843.971,"endTime":5846.473,"body":"rightly upset doesn't necessarily..."},{"startTime":5846.64,"endTime":5848.542,"body":"It's not a leverage point, right?"},{"startTime":5849.743,"endTime":5850.044,"body":"Well,"},{"startTime":5851.779,"endTime":5852.58,"body":"it is..."},{"startTime":5853.547,"endTime":5856.083,"body":"There is a different kind of threat being"},{"startTime":5856.684,"endTime":5858.752,"body":"postulated for which"},{"startTime":5858.752,"endTime":5861.021,"body":"there is some evidence,"},{"startTime":5862.79,"endTime":5863.624,"body":"which is that"},{"startTime":5865.059,"endTime":5867.094,"body":"we are having our story brains hijacked,"},{"startTime":5867.795,"endTime":5872.132,"body":"that we think that we are internalizing"},{"startTime":5873.601,"endTime":5876.303,"body":"local organic grassroots content in which"},{"startTime":5876.303,"endTime":5880.641,"body":"Americans are revealing the insanity in"},{"startTime":5880.641,"endTime":5881.742,"body":"their own backyards."},{"startTime":5882.276,"endTime":5884.111,"body":"And sometimes that is not in"},{"startTime":5884.111,"endTime":5885.579,"body":"fact what we are internalizing."},{"startTime":5885.913,"endTime":5889.683,"body":"And I will say, so I've pulled up now the"},{"startTime":5889.683,"endTime":5891.552,"body":"Alathea website and just, you know, we"},{"startTime":5891.552,"endTime":5892.653,"body":"can click around a little bit."},{"startTime":5893.053,"endTime":5895.055,"body":"You have stopped tomorrow's"},{"startTime":5895.055,"endTime":5896.991,"body":"narrative risks today, right?"},{"startTime":5898.225,"endTime":5901.128,"body":"So protect your people, brand, license to"},{"startTime":5901.128,"endTime":5902.596,"body":"operate and business continuity with the"},{"startTime":5902.63,"endTime":5905.032,"body":"only proactive AI risk management"},{"startTime":5905.032,"endTime":5907.034,"body":"platform that delivers early warnings of"},{"startTime":5907.034,"endTime":5909.036,"body":"narrative threats so you can stop a"},{"startTime":5909.036,"endTime":5910.504,"body":"crisis before it starts."},{"startTime":5911.071,"endTime":5912.039,"body":"Extend your radar,"},{"startTime":5912.106,"endTime":5913.44,"body":"mitigate before it matters."},{"startTime":5913.741,"endTime":5917.912,"body":"Now I can read those sentences with"},{"startTime":5917.945,"endTime":5919.513,"body":"totally opposite and balances."},{"startTime":5919.847,"endTime":5923.284,"body":"I can imagine a world in which that is"},{"startTime":5923.284,"endTime":5924.418,"body":"something that we need"},{"startTime":5924.685,"endTime":5926.186,"body":"because these are real risks."},{"startTime":5926.186,"endTime":5928.522,"body":"And I can imagine something in a world in"},{"startTime":5928.522,"endTime":5930.291,"body":"which that is something that we need and"},{"startTime":5930.291,"endTime":5932.226,"body":"that I would want, but not these people,"},{"startTime":5932.226,"endTime":5934.228,"body":"not any people, no way, no how, because I"},{"startTime":5934.228,"endTime":5934.995,"body":"don't trust anyone to"},{"startTime":5934.995,"endTime":5936.063,"body":"actually do this kind of work."},{"startTime":5936.297,"endTime":5938.265,"body":"Well, but also in advance,"},{"startTime":5940.134,"endTime":5941.001,"body":"I think that these"},{"startTime":5941.001,"endTime":5942.636,"body":"people are offering a service."},{"startTime":5942.67,"endTime":5944.571,"body":"If you're gonna do something shitty to"},{"startTime":5944.571,"endTime":5946.64,"body":"the American public, here's a service"},{"startTime":5946.64,"endTime":5948.075,"body":"that will allow you to create the"},{"startTime":5948.075,"endTime":5950.444,"body":"impression that the opposition to it is"},{"startTime":5950.444,"endTime":5951.712,"body":"being fomented from abroad."},{"startTime":5951.845,"endTime":5953.013,"body":"I think that's what that is."},{"startTime":5953.781,"endTime":5954.315,"body":"Fair enough."},{"startTime":5954.415,"endTime":5955.349,"body":"And I, yeah."},{"startTime":5956.483,"endTime":5959.653,"body":"If we go to about Alathea the company,"},{"startTime":5960.521,"endTime":5962.222,"body":"Alathea empowers organizations to"},{"startTime":5962.222,"endTime":5964.291,"body":"navigate the growing risks of information"},{"startTime":5964.291,"endTime":5966.093,"body":"manipulation, coordinated influence"},{"startTime":5966.093,"endTime":5967.962,"body":"operations and digital deception with"},{"startTime":5967.962,"endTime":5969.229,"body":"clarity and confidence."},{"startTime":5969.897,"endTime":5972.166,"body":"That could be just mumbo jumbo that is"},{"startTime":5972.166,"endTime":5973.934,"body":"meaningless or it could be exactly the"},{"startTime":5973.934,"endTime":5975.936,"body":"wink that you are talking about it being."},{"startTime":5976.637,"endTime":5979.473,"body":"Okay, and I think a wink is a good way to"},{"startTime":5979.473,"endTime":5981.575,"body":"describe it, but I would just point out,"},{"startTime":5982.71,"endTime":5988.449,"body":"you as a member of the public, a bonafide"},{"startTime":5988.449,"endTime":5990.584,"body":"little person are"},{"startTime":5990.617,"endTime":5991.985,"body":"going to be manipulated."},{"startTime":5992.186,"endTime":5993.887,"body":"You're gonna be manipulated from almost"},{"startTime":5993.887,"endTime":5995.689,"body":"the moment you get up, as soon as you"},{"startTime":5995.923,"endTime":5997.658,"body":"look at your phone, till the moment you"},{"startTime":5997.658,"endTime":5998.525,"body":"put it down at night."},{"startTime":5999.593,"endTime":6001.328,"body":"Who should you be"},{"startTime":6001.328,"endTime":6002.696,"body":"expecting to manipulate you?"},{"startTime":6002.83,"endTime":6004.198,"body":"Well, there's probably a"},{"startTime":6004.198,"endTime":6006.533,"body":"bit of foreign stuff in there."},{"startTime":6006.533,"endTime":6010.337,"body":"Why would foreigners be doing that?"},{"startTime":6010.371,"endTime":6012.272,"body":"Well, you could make an argument that"},{"startTime":6012.272,"endTime":6015.442,"body":"we're in an AI race and a foreign power,"},{"startTime":6015.442,"endTime":6017.244,"body":"if it can get the American public more"},{"startTime":6017.244,"endTime":6018.912,"body":"troubled than it already is about data"},{"startTime":6018.912,"endTime":6020.447,"body":"centers could slow us down."},{"startTime":6020.447,"endTime":6022.75,"body":"They could dump some sand into the gears,"},{"startTime":6023.217,"endTime":6025.252,"body":"but it's a pretty heavy lift given how"},{"startTime":6025.285,"endTime":6027.054,"body":"concerning these things are, how fast"},{"startTime":6027.054,"endTime":6028.655,"body":"it's happening and how much organic"},{"startTime":6028.655,"endTime":6030.591,"body":"opposition there's obviously going to be."},{"startTime":6030.591,"endTime":6033.027,"body":"So you would expect a massive operation"},{"startTime":6033.027,"endTime":6035.129,"body":"if somebody decided to increase the"},{"startTime":6035.129,"endTime":6035.996,"body":"amount of resistance."},{"startTime":6036.33,"endTime":6038.365,"body":"A small effort wouldn't make any sense"},{"startTime":6038.365,"endTime":6041.001,"body":"because it just claimed that the"},{"startTime":6041.668,"endTime":6043.17,"body":"opposition is inorganic."},{"startTime":6043.27,"endTime":6044.905,"body":"So it's probably worse for"},{"startTime":6044.905,"endTime":6046.673,"body":"you to do a little operation."},{"startTime":6046.707,"endTime":6048.976,"body":"It would have to be a big one to matter."},{"startTime":6049.41,"endTime":6051.512,"body":"And, but who also should you"},{"startTime":6051.512,"endTime":6053.08,"body":"be expecting to manipulate you?"},{"startTime":6054.815,"endTime":6057.418,"body":"The motherfuckers in these for-profit"},{"startTime":6057.418,"endTime":6059.186,"body":"businesses that have decided they're"},{"startTime":6059.186,"endTime":6061.255,"body":"going to transform our landscape and not"},{"startTime":6061.255,"endTime":6062.356,"body":"going to ask us about it."},{"startTime":6062.589,"endTime":6064.391,"body":"So yeah, you're being manipulated."},{"startTime":6064.425,"endTime":6065.426,"body":"You're being manipulated."},{"startTime":6065.626,"endTime":6067.161,"body":"There might be manipulation on both"},{"startTime":6067.161,"endTime":6069.263,"body":"sides, but where would I expect the bulk"},{"startTime":6069.263,"endTime":6070.597,"body":"of the manipulation to come from?"},{"startTime":6070.964,"endTime":6072.766,"body":"Are the people who stand to make a"},{"startTime":6072.766,"endTime":6075.069,"body":"fucking mint from these things?"},{"startTime":6075.235,"endTime":6076.97,"body":"Those people are out to manipulate you"},{"startTime":6077.237,"endTime":6078.806,"body":"for sure, for obvious reasons."},{"startTime":6078.806,"endTime":6081.442,"body":"The implied evolutionary dynamics,"},{"startTime":6081.475,"endTime":6084.745,"body":"honestly, is the companies based in"},{"startTime":6084.745,"endTime":6087.781,"body":"America are more on your team than are"},{"startTime":6088.849,"endTime":6091.118,"body":"obviously hostile foreign governments."},{"startTime":6091.785,"endTime":6094.421,"body":"And you could say that and go like, well,"},{"startTime":6094.455,"endTime":6096.757,"body":"yeah, if I had to choose one, I guess I"},{"startTime":6096.757,"endTime":6099.326,"body":"assume that an American based corporation"},{"startTime":6099.326,"endTime":6099.893,"body":"is more likely to be"},{"startTime":6099.893,"endTime":6103.263,"body":"in my team than the CCP."},{"startTime":6104.331,"endTime":6108.235,"body":"But that does seem like a false choice."},{"startTime":6108.735,"endTime":6109.736,"body":"The idea that"},{"startTime":6110.904,"endTime":6114.441,"body":"a American based company is on your team"},{"startTime":6114.475,"endTime":6116.91,"body":"any more than it's on the team of people"},{"startTime":6116.91,"endTime":6119.88,"body":"in Armenia, for instance, is laughable."},{"startTime":6120.447,"endTime":6122.015,"body":"Oh, I think it's preposterous."},{"startTime":6122.282,"endTime":6123.984,"body":"But this is consistent with us talking"},{"startTime":6123.984,"endTime":6125.152,"body":"about the decline of the West,"},{"startTime":6125.452,"endTime":6127.588,"body":"us needing to defend the West."},{"startTime":6127.821,"endTime":6129.79,"body":"And we have talked before about what"},{"startTime":6129.79,"endTime":6134.595,"body":"might be happening to so disintegrate and"},{"startTime":6134.595,"endTime":6136.563,"body":"apparently tear apart the"},{"startTime":6136.563,"endTime":6139.199,"body":"values of the West, including"},{"startTime":6141.435,"endTime":6143.437,"body":"the First and Second Amendments and"},{"startTime":6143.437,"endTime":6149.076,"body":"privacy and the family and just all of"},{"startTime":6149.076,"endTime":6150.511,"body":"the things that we've talked about before"},{"startTime":6150.511,"endTime":6152.045,"body":"about what the West stands for that are"},{"startTime":6152.045,"endTime":6154.748,"body":"decaying through these, these non"},{"startTime":6154.848,"endTime":6157.885,"body":"corporate entities like Black Lives"},{"startTime":6157.885,"endTime":6161.755,"body":"Matter and the woke revolution and trans"},{"startTime":6161.755,"endTime":6164.024,"body":"ideology taking over, which we have"},{"startTime":6164.024,"endTime":6167.928,"body":"posited might have been seeded by outside"},{"startTime":6167.928,"endTime":6170.964,"body":"influences, because how could it possibly"},{"startTime":6171.131,"endTime":6173.433,"body":"make any sense for people, for instance,"},{"startTime":6173.5,"endTime":6175.636,"body":"to destroy an entire generation of people"},{"startTime":6175.636,"endTime":6177.471,"body":"by encouraging them to sterilize"},{"startTime":6177.471,"endTime":6179.006,"body":"themselves, for instance."},{"startTime":6179.473,"endTime":6182.409,"body":"So it is not that you are arguing, I"},{"startTime":6182.409,"endTime":6184.144,"body":"think, and certainly not that I am"},{"startTime":6184.144,"endTime":6188.348,"body":"arguing, that foreign state actors"},{"startTime":6188.348,"endTime":6190.117,"body":"couldn't be interested in having an"},{"startTime":6190.117,"endTime":6190.951,"body":"influence in what we"},{"startTime":6190.951,"endTime":6192.085,"body":"think and how we behave."},{"startTime":6193.086,"endTime":6195.489,"body":"I believe that you are arguing simply"},{"startTime":6195.489,"endTime":6200.194,"body":"that the companies involved here have a"},{"startTime":6200.194,"endTime":6202.996,"body":"high interest, a palpable interest, more"},{"startTime":6202.996,"endTime":6205.933,"body":"of an interest in making sure that we are"},{"startTime":6205.933,"endTime":6208.268,"body":"chaotic in our response to our objections"},{"startTime":6208.268,"endTime":6209.937,"body":"to their particular things that they want"},{"startTime":6209.937,"endTime":6211.371,"body":"to do in the American landscape."},{"startTime":6211.705,"endTime":6214.374,"body":"Whereas a foreign power has sort of"},{"startTime":6214.374,"endTime":6215.709,"body":"interest potentially in"},{"startTime":6215.709,"endTime":6216.91,"body":"creating chaos more generally."},{"startTime":6217.511,"endTime":6219.88,"body":"100%, and I think actually this is gonna"},{"startTime":6219.88,"endTime":6222.282,"body":"pop out of the story very obviously,"},{"startTime":6222.449,"endTime":6224.484,"body":"because the real question, and it's gonna"},{"startTime":6224.484,"endTime":6226.887,"body":"be the question again and again, is you"},{"startTime":6226.887,"endTime":6229.623,"body":"have some entity claiming"},{"startTime":6229.823,"endTime":6231.124,"body":"to care about your wellbeing."},{"startTime":6232.559,"endTime":6234.161,"body":"Is it paying a cost in"},{"startTime":6234.161,"endTime":6235.395,"body":"order to protect your wellbeing?"},{"startTime":6235.729,"endTime":6237.998,"body":"Is it demonstrating that it actually"},{"startTime":6237.998,"endTime":6239.967,"body":"cares about your wellbeing anywhere where"},{"startTime":6239.967,"endTime":6240.701,"body":"we could actually"},{"startTime":6240.701,"endTime":6241.902,"body":"assess it for ourselves?"},{"startTime":6242.336,"endTime":6245.606,"body":"No, these things, maybe because it's"},{"startTime":6245.606,"endTime":6248.075,"body":"their fiduciary responsibility to their"},{"startTime":6248.075,"endTime":6250.51,"body":"shareholders, or because they're in a"},{"startTime":6250.51,"endTime":6253.313,"body":"ruthless game in venture capital land,"},{"startTime":6253.313,"endTime":6255.882,"body":"whatever it may be, they have reasons to"},{"startTime":6255.882,"endTime":6258.819,"body":"be absolutely psychopathic with respect"},{"startTime":6258.819,"endTime":6260.187,"body":"to the interests of common people."},{"startTime":6260.42,"endTime":6262.389,"body":"This is born out again and again in their"},{"startTime":6262.389,"endTime":6264.791,"body":"behavior, and then they come online and"},{"startTime":6264.791,"endTime":6266.46,"body":"they do this thing about, oh, people who"},{"startTime":6266.46,"endTime":6268.695,"body":"don't like you are trying to influence"},{"startTime":6269.029,"endTime":6271.565,"body":"your opinion so that you'll oppose this"},{"startTime":6271.565,"endTime":6272.866,"body":"thing that's actually good."},{"startTime":6273.2,"endTime":6275.035,"body":"Bullshit, I don't believe you."},{"startTime":6275.068,"endTime":6277.638,"body":"And the fact that the New York Times can"},{"startTime":6277.704,"endTime":6280.34,"body":"only come up with weak tea in their"},{"startTime":6280.54,"endTime":6282.709,"body":"article claiming that there's a foreign"},{"startTime":6282.709,"endTime":6284.711,"body":"influence operation causing people to be"},{"startTime":6284.711,"endTime":6285.712,"body":"more upset about data"},{"startTime":6285.712,"endTime":6286.613,"body":"centers than they would be."},{"startTime":6287.381,"endTime":6289.583,"body":"Find something, if you found a million"},{"startTime":6289.583,"endTime":6291.652,"body":"posts, I would still not be impressed,"},{"startTime":6291.652,"endTime":6292.753,"body":"but at least I would say there's"},{"startTime":6292.753,"endTime":6294.054,"body":"something to discuss there."},{"startTime":6294.187,"endTime":6295.322,"body":"How hard is it to come"},{"startTime":6295.322,"endTime":6296.923,"body":"up with scores of posts?"},{"startTime":6298.191,"endTime":6301.061,"body":"So we're gonna leave Alatheia here soon,"},{"startTime":6301.628,"endTime":6303.997,"body":"but let me just scroll down in there,"},{"startTime":6304.731,"endTime":6307.167,"body":"this again, their report that is the"},{"startTime":6307.167,"endTime":6309.169,"body":"basis for the New York Times article that"},{"startTime":6309.169,"endTime":6311.004,"body":"I was sharing some from before."},{"startTime":6311.438,"endTime":6312.472,"body":"I'm not gonna go"},{"startTime":6312.472,"endTime":6313.407,"body":"through any of their examples."},{"startTime":6313.407,"endTime":6314.708,"body":"We'll post this of course in the show"},{"startTime":6314.708,"endTime":6316.009,"body":"notes, overt media, covert"},{"startTime":6316.009,"endTime":6317.644,"body":"operations in the slot machine."},{"startTime":6318.545,"endTime":6319.746,"body":"They're making the same kinds of"},{"startTime":6319.746,"endTime":6321.615,"body":"arguments that we saw the New York Times"},{"startTime":6321.615,"endTime":6322.282,"body":"make because they've"},{"startTime":6322.416,"endTime":6324.151,"body":"got their ideas from here."},{"startTime":6324.651,"endTime":6326.753,"body":"And there aren't that many examples."},{"startTime":6326.787,"endTime":6328.522,"body":"There are some categories examples."},{"startTime":6328.789,"endTime":6330.524,"body":"The last of which is in"},{"startTime":6330.524,"endTime":6331.958,"body":"some ways the most interesting."},{"startTime":6333.66,"endTime":6335.529,"body":"Domestic actors borrow"},{"startTime":6335.529,"endTime":6336.797,"body":"the foreign playbook."},{"startTime":6337.764,"endTime":6339.533,"body":"Beyond foreign amplification, some"},{"startTime":6339.533,"endTime":6341.134,"body":"domestic political actors are beginning"},{"startTime":6341.134,"endTime":6343.036,"body":"to adopt foreign originated aesthetics"},{"startTime":6343.036,"endTime":6345.906,"body":"and tactics in their own anti-data center"},{"startTime":6345.906,"endTime":6348.175,"body":"messaging, a development that changes how"},{"startTime":6348.175,"endTime":6350.01,"body":"these signals have to be read since"},{"startTime":6350.01,"endTime":6351.545,"body":"calling out a homegrown candidate looks"},{"startTime":6351.545,"endTime":6352.612,"body":"very different from calling out"},{"startTime":6352.612,"endTime":6353.947,"body":"propaganda from Tehran."},{"startTime":6354.715,"endTime":6356.183,"body":"One recent example, a state level"},{"startTime":6356.183,"endTime":6358.151,"body":"candidate posted an AI generated Lego"},{"startTime":6358.151,"endTime":6360.053,"body":"style video attacking data centers,"},{"startTime":6360.32,"endTime":6362.389,"body":"lifting the Lego propaganda aesthetic"},{"startTime":6362.422,"endTime":6364.157,"body":"Iran deployed during the war."},{"startTime":6365.058,"endTime":6367.194,"body":"Iran's Lego videos achieved success"},{"startTime":6367.194,"endTime":6368.695,"body":"because the video's weaponized American"},{"startTime":6368.695,"endTime":6370.53,"body":"pop culture rap lyrics, trap beats and"},{"startTime":6370.53,"endTime":6372.132,"body":"animation giving foreign messaging an"},{"startTime":6372.132,"endTime":6373.834,"body":"emotionally familiar feel to domestic"},{"startTime":6373.834,"endTime":6375.836,"body":"audiences, creating a cheap and"},{"startTime":6375.836,"endTime":6377.537,"body":"aesthetically pleasing playbook that any"},{"startTime":6377.571,"endTime":6378.839,"body":"actor foreign or domestic with a"},{"startTime":6378.839,"endTime":6381.274,"body":"grievance and a laptop can replicate."},{"startTime":6381.842,"endTime":6382.976,"body":"There's a lot there."},{"startTime":6383.243,"endTime":6383.577,"body":"Wow."},{"startTime":6383.744,"endTime":6384.01,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":6384.311,"endTime":6386.413,"body":"And so I did not prepare this."},{"startTime":6386.413,"endTime":6388.949,"body":"So we're not gonna show the video here,"},{"startTime":6388.949,"endTime":6391.451,"body":"but it's just as compelling as the ones"},{"startTime":6391.451,"endTime":6392.352,"body":"that were coming out of Iran."},{"startTime":6392.919,"endTime":6397.224,"body":"This is coming out of a congressional"},{"startTime":6397.991,"endTime":6400.06,"body":"candidate in Georgia, I think."},{"startTime":6400.861,"endTime":6403.797,"body":"And exactly as they say here, as Alathia"},{"startTime":6403.83,"endTime":6405.565,"body":"says here, they're using American pop"},{"startTime":6405.565,"endTime":6406.933,"body":"culture, rap lyrics, trap beats,"},{"startTime":6406.933,"endTime":6410.604,"body":"animation to kind of get you interested"},{"startTime":6410.637,"endTime":6413.774,"body":"in listening to the claim that the data"},{"startTime":6413.774,"endTime":6416.109,"body":"center that is apparently steamrolling"},{"startTime":6416.109,"endTime":6417.31,"body":"through some part of Georgia"},{"startTime":6417.778,"endTime":6418.979,"body":"is really, really bad for you."},{"startTime":6420.38,"endTime":6422.349,"body":"What is this doing in a"},{"startTime":6422.349,"endTime":6424.851,"body":"report on foreign influence?"},{"startTime":6425.318,"endTime":6428.455,"body":"What this is doing here, the claim is, is"},{"startTime":6428.488,"endTime":6431.425,"body":"see now even domestic people are using"},{"startTime":6431.425,"endTime":6433.693,"body":"some of the aesthetics and tools that"},{"startTime":6433.693,"endTime":6435.896,"body":"foreign operatives have used before."},{"startTime":6436.029,"endTime":6437.464,"body":"Therefore it's become even harder to"},{"startTime":6437.464,"endTime":6440.1,"body":"tell, real from fake, from"},{"startTime":6440.333,"endTime":6442.135,"body":"homegrown, from foreign grown."},{"startTime":6442.402,"endTime":6445.405,"body":"And I believe that implied, the implied"},{"startTime":6445.405,"endTime":6446.706,"body":"message is, therefore"},{"startTime":6446.706,"endTime":6447.541,"body":"don't trust any of it."},{"startTime":6447.774,"endTime":6449.176,"body":"Anything that makes you feel good, you"},{"startTime":6449.176,"endTime":6451.378,"body":"shouldn't trust, which at some level, if"},{"startTime":6451.378,"endTime":6452.245,"body":"it's on a screen is"},{"startTime":6452.245,"endTime":6454.381,"body":"probably good advice at this point."},{"startTime":6454.714,"endTime":6457.784,"body":"But the idea that because one thing was"},{"startTime":6457.784,"endTime":6460.52,"body":"effective, we now see copycats that are"},{"startTime":6460.52,"endTime":6461.588,"body":"effective even though"},{"startTime":6461.588,"endTime":6462.656,"body":"the message is different."},{"startTime":6462.956,"endTime":6466.026,"body":"We shouldn't trust any of it is a sheet"},{"startTime":6466.059,"endTime":6468.528,"body":"of a move logically and doesn't actually"},{"startTime":6468.528,"endTime":6472.165,"body":"belong in a report supposedly about the"},{"startTime":6472.399,"endTime":6475.202,"body":"problems with foreign influence in how"},{"startTime":6475.202,"endTime":6475.969,"body":"people are viewing"},{"startTime":6475.969,"endTime":6477.003,"body":"data centers in America."},{"startTime":6477.637,"endTime":6478.371,"body":"Yeah, it's really an"},{"startTime":6478.371,"endTime":6480.273,"body":"amazing claim actually."},{"startTime":6480.273,"endTime":6483.577,"body":"First of all, obviously the Iranian"},{"startTime":6483.577,"endTime":6484.978,"body":"effort with the Legos"},{"startTime":6484.978,"endTime":6486.746,"body":"borrowed from the Lego movie."},{"startTime":6486.746,"endTime":6488.648,"body":"So stylistically,"},{"startTime":6489.483,"endTime":6491.484,"body":"whatever that effort was in Iran,"},{"startTime":6492.652,"endTime":6494.287,"body":"they didn't invent that aesthetic."},{"startTime":6495.622,"endTime":6497.157,"body":"But the idea that something is"},{"startTime":6497.157,"endTime":6499.526,"body":"aesthetically tainted is"},{"startTime":6499.526,"endTime":6501.328,"body":"preposterous in its own right."},{"startTime":6501.428,"endTime":6505.165,"body":"Obviously the Iranian Lego videos reached"},{"startTime":6505.165,"endTime":6508.068,"body":"a lot of us and were successful in a way."},{"startTime":6508.435,"endTime":6510.237,"body":"So you would expect anybody with any"},{"startTime":6510.237,"endTime":6512.339,"body":"message to notice what works."},{"startTime":6513.039,"endTime":6515.408,"body":"There's no real accusation there."},{"startTime":6515.442,"endTime":6518.578,"body":"No, and it's actually, the accusation"},{"startTime":6518.578,"endTime":6522.249,"body":"feels very much like the woke revolution."},{"startTime":6522.782,"endTime":6524.518,"body":"It's like, we are gonna"},{"startTime":6524.518,"endTime":6526.987,"body":"identify a moment in time"},{"startTime":6528.355,"endTime":6531.124,"body":"about which we are going to take all of"},{"startTime":6531.124,"endTime":6533.894,"body":"our grievances and all of our reports of"},{"startTime":6533.894,"endTime":6536.529,"body":"who originated what and say, these are"},{"startTime":6536.529,"endTime":6537.864,"body":"the people who were the first peoples"},{"startTime":6537.898,"endTime":6538.465,"body":"ignoring all the"},{"startTime":6538.465,"endTime":6540.667,"body":"people that they killed off."},{"startTime":6541.001,"endTime":6543.537,"body":"And this is the moment, these are the"},{"startTime":6543.537,"endTime":6545.105,"body":"only people who have ever been engaged in"},{"startTime":6545.105,"endTime":6547.007,"body":"slavery and the only people who matter"},{"startTime":6547.007,"endTime":6547.908,"body":"with regard to who's"},{"startTime":6547.908,"endTime":6549.075,"body":"racist and who's not."},{"startTime":6549.476,"endTime":6552.612,"body":"And we get to define the very narrow"},{"startTime":6552.646,"endTime":6554.981,"body":"terms of engagement with you and you have"},{"startTime":6554.981,"endTime":6556.249,"body":"to accept what we've decided."},{"startTime":6556.516,"endTime":6557.517,"body":"And it's cheating, you"},{"startTime":6557.517,"endTime":6558.218,"body":"don't get to do that."},{"startTime":6558.585,"endTime":6560.287,"body":"The woke revolutionaries didn't get to do"},{"startTime":6560.287,"endTime":6562.856,"body":"it and neither do you who appear to be"},{"startTime":6562.856,"endTime":6565.525,"body":"speaking to people on the other side of"},{"startTime":6565.825,"endTime":6566.726,"body":"the line in some ways."},{"startTime":6566.726,"endTime":6568.461,"body":"Although maybe this is, given that the"},{"startTime":6568.461,"endTime":6569.596,"body":"New York Times is picking this up, maybe"},{"startTime":6569.596,"endTime":6571.698,"body":"it's speaking to exactly the same sort"},{"startTime":6571.698,"endTime":6575.936,"body":"of, it's creating the same error in its"},{"startTime":6575.936,"endTime":6578.004,"body":"own internal logic and therefore will"},{"startTime":6578.004,"endTime":6579.205,"body":"risk creating exactly the"},{"startTime":6579.205,"endTime":6581.074,"body":"same errors in the same audience."},{"startTime":6581.942,"endTime":6582.676,"body":"Well, I think the"},{"startTime":6582.676,"endTime":6584.811,"body":"audience is partially the same."},{"startTime":6584.844,"endTime":6586.646,"body":"Obviously the New York Times readership"},{"startTime":6586.646,"endTime":6590.15,"body":"is the same, but there's a general, I"},{"startTime":6590.183,"endTime":6592.052,"body":"think what you're looking at is a slick"},{"startTime":6592.352,"endTime":6595.055,"body":"operation that has spotted a problem."},{"startTime":6595.088,"endTime":6596.723,"body":"Hey, there's a lot of unpopular shit that"},{"startTime":6596.723,"endTime":6598.992,"body":"we wanna do and it's gonna meet"},{"startTime":6599.025,"endTime":6601.494,"body":"opposition and oh shit, guess what?"},{"startTime":6601.761,"endTime":6603.396,"body":"The lefties and the righties are talking"},{"startTime":6603.43,"endTime":6605.465,"body":"cause nobody likes this crap, right?"},{"startTime":6605.966,"endTime":6607.5,"body":"Oh, what are you gonna do about that?"},{"startTime":6607.5,"endTime":6608.969,"body":"Well, here's something, A,"},{"startTime":6610.337,"endTime":6612.205,"body":"foreign influence has definitely been"},{"startTime":6612.205,"endTime":6613.34,"body":"amping that stuff up."},{"startTime":6613.506,"endTime":6615.342,"body":"And we got the goods cause"},{"startTime":6615.342,"endTime":6617.243,"body":"we found, is it scores of?"},{"startTime":6617.377,"endTime":6617.844,"body":"Scores."},{"startTime":6618.345,"endTime":6620.113,"body":"Scores, posts, posted from"},{"startTime":6620.113,"endTime":6621.014,"body":"here, there and everywhere."},{"startTime":6622.115,"endTime":6624.718,"body":"I don't even know whether, I mean, I"},{"startTime":6624.718,"endTime":6625.352,"body":"don't think these"},{"startTime":6625.352,"endTime":6626.653,"body":"people have a methodology."},{"startTime":6626.653,"endTime":6629.356,"body":"I think what they have is a PR mode that"},{"startTime":6629.356,"endTime":6632.225,"body":"is going to demonize any grassroots"},{"startTime":6632.225,"endTime":6633.36,"body":"effort to stop these things."},{"startTime":6633.46,"endTime":6634.794,"body":"I find no statement of methodology."},{"startTime":6634.794,"endTime":6636.997,"body":"At the very least it's verificationist."},{"startTime":6637.03,"endTime":6638.064,"body":"Right, but here's the thing."},{"startTime":6638.264,"endTime":6641.001,"body":"Let's suppose that you were a ruthless"},{"startTime":6641.001,"endTime":6643.303,"body":"capitalist wishing to take advantage of"},{"startTime":6643.303,"endTime":6645.271,"body":"the awkward fact that industry after"},{"startTime":6645.271,"endTime":6647.407,"body":"industry is going to be betraying the"},{"startTime":6647.407,"endTime":6650.343,"body":"citizenry and find itself unpopular and"},{"startTime":6650.343,"endTime":6652.012,"body":"need to fight back in some ways."},{"startTime":6652.012,"endTime":6654.18,"body":"You're gonna provide a service which is"},{"startTime":6654.18,"endTime":6658.118,"body":"to make anybody who stands up in"},{"startTime":6658.118,"endTime":6660.82,"body":"opposition to something awful look"},{"startTime":6660.854,"endTime":6662.789,"body":"tainted or naive because there's a"},{"startTime":6662.789,"endTime":6664.257,"body":"foreign influence operation and they're"},{"startTime":6664.257,"endTime":6666.893,"body":"obviously acting on behalf of it."},{"startTime":6666.893,"endTime":6670.163,"body":"So we're gonna provide that little"},{"startTime":6670.764,"endTime":6672.766,"body":"service and we'll do it"},{"startTime":6672.766,"endTime":6674.367,"body":"actually prospectively."},{"startTime":6674.768,"endTime":6677.003,"body":"Those people have no interests."},{"startTime":6677.17,"endTime":6679.339,"body":"Their economic wellbeing"},{"startTime":6679.606,"endTime":6682.942,"body":"depends on them not falsifying."},{"startTime":6683.009,"endTime":6685.645,"body":"Oh, that's not really coming from China."},{"startTime":6685.645,"endTime":6687.514,"body":"That was somebody using a VPN."},{"startTime":6687.714,"endTime":6689.816,"body":"In other words, they might even have an"},{"startTime":6689.816,"endTime":6691.651,"body":"interest in mistaking things that were"},{"startTime":6691.651,"endTime":6693.453,"body":"posted from somewhere else with a VPN"},{"startTime":6693.453,"endTime":6695.221,"body":"that made them look like they were coming"},{"startTime":6695.221,"endTime":6696.289,"body":"from some state that we"},{"startTime":6696.289,"endTime":6697.757,"body":"take to be antagonistic."},{"startTime":6697.957,"endTime":6699.592,"body":"They have no reason to throw that data"},{"startTime":6699.626,"endTime":6701.061,"body":"out because all of it's gonna get"},{"startTime":6701.795,"endTime":6703.897,"body":"swallowed up by the New York Times, which"},{"startTime":6703.897,"endTime":6705.699,"body":"is gonna accept the story that there's a"},{"startTime":6705.699,"endTime":6707.901,"body":"significant foreign component to"},{"startTime":6707.901,"endTime":6710.503,"body":"opposition to data centers, which again,"},{"startTime":6711.871,"endTime":6714.808,"body":"I think there's, first of all, these"},{"startTime":6714.808,"endTime":6716.009,"body":"people I believe are"},{"startTime":6716.009,"endTime":6718.211,"body":"weaponizing the Cartesian crisis."},{"startTime":6718.311,"endTime":6718.611,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":6718.645,"endTime":6718.878,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":6718.912,"endTime":6720.213,"body":"You don't know what to believe."},{"startTime":6720.213,"endTime":6723.116,"body":"And so here is a plausible claim that's"},{"startTime":6723.116,"endTime":6724.584,"body":"gonna be very hard to falsify."},{"startTime":6724.617,"endTime":6726.419,"body":"Oh, you think those people are really"},{"startTime":6726.419,"endTime":6728.755,"body":"opposed to X, whatever X may be?"},{"startTime":6729.089,"endTime":6730.657,"body":"Well, they're not really opposed to X"},{"startTime":6730.657,"endTime":6731.591,"body":"because part of that is"},{"startTime":6731.591,"endTime":6733.159,"body":"coming out of China, right?"},{"startTime":6733.526,"endTime":6734.494,"body":"So they're gonna play"},{"startTime":6734.494,"endTime":6735.595,"body":"that game again and again."},{"startTime":6735.595,"endTime":6737.03,"body":"It's probably a pretty good business"},{"startTime":6737.297,"endTime":6738.865,"body":"because there's a lot of unpopular stuff"},{"startTime":6738.865,"endTime":6741.067,"body":"that needs to be made to look more"},{"startTime":6741.067,"endTime":6743.403,"body":"legitimate than it is."},{"startTime":6744.738,"endTime":6746.573,"body":"But there's no reason for a methodology."},{"startTime":6746.639,"endTime":6748.074,"body":"And just as there was no reason for a"},{"startTime":6748.074,"endTime":6750.443,"body":"methodology when it came to demonizing"},{"startTime":6751.444,"endTime":6753.713,"body":"people who were sorting out what was"},{"startTime":6753.713,"endTime":6756.416,"body":"going on during COVID, the whole claim."},{"startTime":6756.449,"endTime":6757.283,"body":"You're not a horse."},{"startTime":6757.584,"endTime":6758.585,"body":"Don't take ivermectin."},{"startTime":6758.852,"endTime":6759.886,"body":"That didn't take a methodology."},{"startTime":6759.919,"endTime":6760.153,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":6760.687,"endTime":6762.355,"body":"It's just borrowing our love"},{"startTime":6762.355,"endTime":6764.958,"body":"of story and shaming people."},{"startTime":6765.158,"endTime":6767.193,"body":"Yeah, it's a, hey, you're gonna need an"},{"startTime":6767.193,"endTime":6770.964,"body":"expensive PR effort to blunt people's,"},{"startTime":6771.131,"endTime":6773.633,"body":"let's say, concern about mRNA shots."},{"startTime":6773.666,"endTime":6774.534,"body":"Oh God, well, what are"},{"startTime":6774.534,"endTime":6775.702,"body":"we gonna do about that?"},{"startTime":6775.735,"endTime":6777.67,"body":"Okay, we're gonna portray the people who"},{"startTime":6777.67,"endTime":6781.074,"body":"say this as economically motivated."},{"startTime":6781.074,"endTime":6782.909,"body":"We're gonna portray them as--"},{"startTime":6782.942,"endTime":6783.643,"body":"Grandma killers,"},{"startTime":6783.643,"endTime":6784.944,"body":"anti-science, the whole thing."},{"startTime":6784.978,"endTime":6785.512,"body":"The whole thing."},{"startTime":6785.712,"endTime":6787.313,"body":"The point is you need a PR campaign"},{"startTime":6787.313,"endTime":6789.115,"body":"targeted at this problem that you have."},{"startTime":6789.115,"endTime":6791.217,"body":"And we just so happen to have built one"},{"startTime":6791.251,"endTime":6793.486,"body":"in advance, whatever it may be that's"},{"startTime":6793.486,"endTime":6794.254,"body":"coming down the pike."},{"startTime":6794.254,"endTime":6795.655,"body":"We got your plan right here."},{"startTime":6796.256,"endTime":6797.257,"body":"And so anyway,"},{"startTime":6798.591,"endTime":6800.293,"body":"well, the Cartesian crisis is real."},{"startTime":6800.627,"endTime":6802.228,"body":"I think these people are exploiting it."},{"startTime":6802.495,"endTime":6804.497,"body":"And we better get prepared because what"},{"startTime":6804.497,"endTime":6807.0,"body":"they're really telling you is that again"},{"startTime":6807.033,"endTime":6809.369,"body":"and again and again, you're going to see"},{"startTime":6809.369,"endTime":6811.037,"body":"that same article in The New York Times"},{"startTime":6811.037,"endTime":6812.906,"body":"with a different nominal subject matter."},{"startTime":6813.039,"endTime":6813.406,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":6813.706,"endTime":6816.643,"body":"Yeah, and Alathea"},{"startTime":6817.11,"endTime":6818.845,"body":"actually basically says that."},{"startTime":6818.912,"endTime":6820.013,"body":"They're like, this could be anything."},{"startTime":6820.079,"endTime":6821.414,"body":"It just happens to be data centers right"},{"startTime":6821.414,"endTime":6823.249,"body":"now, but this could be anything."},{"startTime":6823.249,"endTime":6825.084,"body":"And in one way that's true."},{"startTime":6825.185,"endTime":6826.619,"body":"And in another way, they've just pulled"},{"startTime":6826.619,"endTime":6827.62,"body":"the curtain back and"},{"startTime":6827.62,"endTime":6828.488,"body":"like, there's the wizard."},{"startTime":6829.789,"endTime":6830.89,"body":"There it is."},{"startTime":6831.591,"endTime":6832.258,"body":"Okay, so"},{"startTime":6833.993,"endTime":6835.161,"body":"yes, and we're gonna be coming back to"},{"startTime":6835.161,"endTime":6836.696,"body":"this repeatedly today."},{"startTime":6836.696,"endTime":6838.631,"body":"The Cartesian crisis is in full swing."},{"startTime":6839.265,"endTime":6840.033,"body":"We don't know what is true."},{"startTime":6840.266,"endTime":6842.669,"body":"Often we don't know why"},{"startTime":6842.735,"endTime":6843.636,"body":"we think what we think."},{"startTime":6844.07,"endTime":6845.972,"body":"And this is, I asked our audience at the"},{"startTime":6845.972,"endTime":6848.107,"body":"beginning of this episode to try to think"},{"startTime":6848.107,"endTime":6849.442,"body":"about before we started talking about"},{"startTime":6849.442,"endTime":6849.943,"body":"this, what do you"},{"startTime":6849.943,"endTime":6850.877,"body":"think about data centers?"},{"startTime":6851.344,"endTime":6852.912,"body":"Like form your opinion before you start"},{"startTime":6852.912,"endTime":6854.747,"body":"hearing more information and see if you"},{"startTime":6854.747,"endTime":6856.416,"body":"can compare that opinion to"},{"startTime":6856.416,"endTime":6858.351,"body":"what you think at the end."},{"startTime":6858.918,"endTime":6861.387,"body":"And we don't know why we think what we"},{"startTime":6861.387,"endTime":6863.823,"body":"think and we don't know who all has an"},{"startTime":6863.823,"endTime":6865.358,"body":"opinion about what we think and what they"},{"startTime":6865.358,"endTime":6869.162,"body":"might be doing to inform our opinions in"},{"startTime":6869.162,"endTime":6870.23,"body":"ways that we don't know."},{"startTime":6871.397,"endTime":6873.833,"body":"But the pushback against data centers is"},{"startTime":6873.833,"endTime":6877.537,"body":"not primarily, if at all, I think"},{"startTime":6877.537,"endTime":6879.038,"body":"somewhat, but the pushback against data"},{"startTime":6879.038,"endTime":6879.806,"body":"centers is not"},{"startTime":6879.806,"endTime":6880.74,"body":"primarily coming from form."},{"startTime":6881.04,"endTime":6882.542,"body":"So it's just not where it's coming from."},{"startTime":6883.243,"endTime":6885.612,"body":"So I wanna read a little bit from a guest"},{"startTime":6885.612,"endTime":6887.58,"body":"post on Erin Brockovich's sub-stack."},{"startTime":6887.847,"endTime":6888.481,"body":"Erin Brockovich,"},{"startTime":6889.983,"endTime":6892.585,"body":"who was a famous whistleblower"},{"startTime":6893.753,"endTime":6896.089,"body":"from, I'll just say that, a famous"},{"startTime":6896.089,"endTime":6897.957,"body":"whistleblower who has a sub-stack and"},{"startTime":6897.957,"endTime":6899.259,"body":"she's got a guest post by a woman named"},{"startTime":6899.259,"endTime":6901.561,"body":"Madison Taggart detailing some of what is"},{"startTime":6901.561,"endTime":6903.596,"body":"going on in Virginia at the site of"},{"startTime":6903.596,"endTime":6905.031,"body":"Taggart's childhood home."},{"startTime":6905.965,"endTime":6909.135,"body":"So this is not that, this,"},{"startTime":6911.037,"endTime":6912.505,"body":"high voltage, high stakes."},{"startTime":6913.006,"endTime":6915.174,"body":"And so I'm just gonna skip through"},{"startTime":6915.174,"endTime":6918.177,"body":"Brockovich's preamble and just read the"},{"startTime":6918.244,"endTime":6919.412,"body":"very beginning of"},{"startTime":6919.412,"endTime":6921.714,"body":"Taggart's piece and then read"},{"startTime":6922.882,"endTime":6925.285,"body":"something of a rejoinder to the piece."},{"startTime":6926.152,"endTime":6927.22,"body":"My backyard has always"},{"startTime":6927.22,"endTime":6928.755,"body":"felt like a timeless space."},{"startTime":6929.455,"endTime":6931.024,"body":"Our house is at the end of a cul-de-sac"},{"startTime":6931.024,"endTime":6932.926,"body":"and, I should have"},{"startTime":6932.926,"endTime":6933.793,"body":"looked up how to pronounce it."},{"startTime":6933.826,"endTime":6935.595,"body":"Is it Loudon, Loudon Valley Estates?"},{"startTime":6935.762,"endTime":6937.096,"body":"Like the center of what's going on in"},{"startTime":6937.096,"endTime":6938.598,"body":"Virginia with regard to the data centers."},{"startTime":6938.631,"endTime":6939.132,"body":"You haven't heard it?"},{"startTime":6939.165,"endTime":6939.565,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":6939.699,"endTime":6939.932,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":6939.999,"endTime":6940.433,"body":"Drop the top."},{"startTime":6941.501,"endTime":6943.002,"body":"Our house is at the end of a cul-de-sac"},{"startTime":6943.002,"endTime":6944.771,"body":"in Loudon Valley Estates, overlooking the"},{"startTime":6944.771,"endTime":6946.439,"body":"forested hills of the Broad Run River"},{"startTime":6946.439,"endTime":6947.373,"body":"Valley, ringing around"},{"startTime":6947.373,"endTime":6948.341,"body":"the back of the community."},{"startTime":6948.775,"endTime":6950.243,"body":"I could walk to my old high school from"},{"startTime":6950.243,"endTime":6951.477,"body":"the property if I was"},{"startTime":6951.477,"endTime":6952.512,"body":"willing to get my shoes wet."},{"startTime":6953.513,"endTime":6955.181,"body":"I know my backyard from the tall rolling"},{"startTime":6955.181,"endTime":6956.883,"body":"hill where a bird feeder currently sits."},{"startTime":6957.183,"endTime":6958.618,"body":"The sheer cliff decked in cedars,"},{"startTime":6958.618,"endTime":6960.42,"body":"sycamore and dogwood and yet more native"},{"startTime":6960.42,"endTime":6962.221,"body":"brush plunging toward the stream were"},{"startTime":6962.221,"endTime":6964.023,"body":"lines of rocks I made with my father when"},{"startTime":6964.023,"endTime":6965.992,"body":"I was younger, make the river verbal."},{"startTime":6967.16,"endTime":6967.927,"body":"In the winter, the hill"},{"startTime":6967.927,"endTime":6968.861,"body":"is perfect for sledding."},{"startTime":6969.462,"endTime":6971.397,"body":"In springtime, rains flood the stream and"},{"startTime":6971.397,"endTime":6973.032,"body":"blue bells arise around the floodplain."},{"startTime":6973.533,"endTime":6975.535,"body":"My grandmother's garden still stands as a"},{"startTime":6975.535,"endTime":6976.402,"body":"living reminder of her"},{"startTime":6976.402,"endTime":6977.971,"body":"puttering out to tend to the chives."},{"startTime":6978.871,"endTime":6980.239,"body":"Further back in the woods is a place"},{"startTime":6980.239,"endTime":6982.008,"body":"named Picnic Park on Google Maps where my"},{"startTime":6982.008,"endTime":6983.643,"body":"dad has put down picnic tables and is"},{"startTime":6983.643,"endTime":6984.444,"body":"home to the high school"},{"startTime":6984.444,"endTime":6986.012,"body":"cross-country's team's trails."},{"startTime":6987.113,"endTime":6988.614,"body":"My parents' home is the place we could"},{"startTime":6988.614,"endTime":6989.482,"body":"run away to when the"},{"startTime":6989.482,"endTime":6990.883,"body":"weight of modern life was heavy."},{"startTime":6991.484,"endTime":6993.353,"body":"But since 2025, the backyard"},{"startTime":6993.353,"endTime":6994.887,"body":"is no longer just green space."},{"startTime":6995.321,"endTime":6996.923,"body":"It's the stage of a legal and industrial"},{"startTime":6996.923,"endTime":6998.758,"body":"war we had been blissfully oblivious to"},{"startTime":6998.758,"endTime":6999.592,"body":"until a phone call"},{"startTime":6999.592,"endTime":7001.027,"body":"changed everything in 2025."},{"startTime":7002.362,"endTime":7004.163,"body":"The call from hell, as my mom calls it,"},{"startTime":7004.163,"endTime":7005.465,"body":"came on a Friday the 13th."},{"startTime":7005.932,"endTime":7007.367,"body":"I was not home for the call, but I was"},{"startTime":7007.367,"endTime":7008.901,"body":"there for the aftermath when my mom gave"},{"startTime":7008.901,"endTime":7011.371,"body":"me the news, seething in anger and dread."},{"startTime":7011.804,"endTime":7014.04,"body":"Dominion Energy, our power company, asked"},{"startTime":7014.04,"endTime":7015.408,"body":"if they could walk our property for an"},{"startTime":7015.408,"endTime":7017.81,"body":"alternative Golden to Mars high voltage"},{"startTime":7017.81,"endTime":7019.345,"body":"power line called Route 3A."},{"startTime":7020.413,"endTime":7021.714,"body":"We had heard of Golden to Mars."},{"startTime":7022.115,"endTime":7023.416,"body":"Our community had already been fighting"},{"startTime":7023.416,"endTime":7024.817,"body":"another route following Loudoun County"},{"startTime":7024.817,"endTime":7026.986,"body":"Parkway directly in front of us, listed"},{"startTime":7026.986,"endTime":7028.454,"body":"as Route 5 in their plans."},{"startTime":7028.788,"endTime":7030.023,"body":"We previously learned they planned to"},{"startTime":7030.023,"endTime":7031.724,"body":"have nine underground options alongside"},{"startTime":7031.724,"endTime":7033.159,"body":"five above-ground options with an open"},{"startTime":7033.159,"endTime":7033.926,"body":"house to weigh them."},{"startTime":7034.694,"endTime":7035.728,"body":"Route 3A was different."},{"startTime":7036.229,"endTime":7037.23,"body":"It arrived with no public"},{"startTime":7037.23,"endTime":7038.698,"body":"meeting and no advance notice."},{"startTime":7038.965,"endTime":7040.266,"body":"Until that call, none of"},{"startTime":7040.266,"endTime":7041.401,"body":"us had known it existed."},{"startTime":7042.568,"endTime":7046.139,"body":"So here's a picture of Vicki Hugh, who's"},{"startTime":7046.172,"endTime":7048.374,"body":"the author's mother, standing next to a"},{"startTime":7048.374,"endTime":7050.043,"body":"banner showing a size comparison of the"},{"startTime":7050.043,"endTime":7052.912,"body":"185-foot power poles next to other"},{"startTime":7052.912,"endTime":7054.981,"body":"objects, taller by a lot"},{"startTime":7054.981,"endTime":7056.048,"body":"than the Statue of Liberty."},{"startTime":7057.016,"endTime":7058.651,"body":"The banner itself is placed where the"},{"startTime":7058.651,"endTime":7061.054,"body":"proposed pole for Route 3A would be with"},{"startTime":7061.054,"endTime":7062.422,"body":"their house right"},{"startTime":7062.422,"endTime":7063.222,"body":"there in the background."},{"startTime":7063.256,"endTime":7065.691,"body":"And so you've got a house, a person,"},{"startTime":7066.826,"endTime":7069.529,"body":"the 151-foot-tall Tower of Liberty, Tower"},{"startTime":7069.529,"endTime":7071.23,"body":"of Liberty, Statue of Liberty, and the"},{"startTime":7071.23,"endTime":7075.835,"body":"185-foot-tall tower, one of many, that"},{"startTime":7075.835,"endTime":7078.371,"body":"would be erected here."},{"startTime":7078.671,"endTime":7082.408,"body":"Now, the article itself is full of all of"},{"startTime":7082.408,"endTime":7084.71,"body":"the drama that we have learned to expect,"},{"startTime":7084.71,"endTime":7085.878,"body":"and it is worth reading."},{"startTime":7085.878,"endTime":7087.346,"body":"I'm not gonna read any more of it now."},{"startTime":7088.214,"endTime":7090.349,"body":"But among other things, as the part I"},{"startTime":7090.349,"endTime":7093.152,"body":"just read suggests, the company Dominion"},{"startTime":7093.152,"endTime":7100.193,"body":"Energy is, or Dominion Energy is"},{"startTime":7100.193,"endTime":7103.863,"body":"proposing 13, 14, 15 different plans,"},{"startTime":7104.23,"endTime":7107.233,"body":"which is not testament to their caring"},{"startTime":7107.233,"endTime":7108.134,"body":"about the community."},{"startTime":7108.134,"endTime":7110.103,"body":"It's testament to a divide"},{"startTime":7110.103,"endTime":7111.804,"body":"and conquer strategy, right?"},{"startTime":7112.038,"endTime":7113.806,"body":"So if you have 15 different plans,"},{"startTime":7114.173,"endTime":7115.741,"body":"however many different plans, well over a"},{"startTime":7115.741,"endTime":7118.744,"body":"dozen different plans, and some of the"},{"startTime":7118.744,"endTime":7120.246,"body":"plans go through your property, and some"},{"startTime":7120.246,"endTime":7121.114,"body":"of them go through your neighbor's"},{"startTime":7121.114,"endTime":7122.181,"body":"property, and some of them go through"},{"startTime":7122.215,"endTime":7123.516,"body":"neither of your property, but go through"},{"startTime":7123.516,"endTime":7125.084,"body":"someone across town, he never met's"},{"startTime":7125.084,"endTime":7126.285,"body":"property, you're gonna"},{"startTime":7126.285,"endTime":7127.353,"body":"divide the community."},{"startTime":7127.553,"endTime":7130.99,"body":"Instead of having the community united in"},{"startTime":7130.99,"endTime":7132.925,"body":"defense of not here, not"},{"startTime":7132.925,"endTime":7134.594,"body":"now, not ever, don't do this."},{"startTime":7134.894,"endTime":7137.83,"body":"But the big point here that I wanna make"},{"startTime":7137.897,"endTime":7141.167,"body":"is with regard to this image, is what"},{"startTime":7141.167,"endTime":7143.769,"body":"they say, tell the SEC, protect homes,"},{"startTime":7143.936,"endTime":7146.939,"body":"not data centers, underground the lines,"},{"startTime":7147.44,"endTime":7148.574,"body":"underground the lines."},{"startTime":7148.574,"endTime":7150.243,"body":"And you will remember from what I just"},{"startTime":7150.243,"endTime":7154.313,"body":"read, that Dominion Energy did have five"},{"startTime":7154.347,"endTime":7158.551,"body":"underground plans, but never, never do we"},{"startTime":7158.551,"endTime":7159.485,"body":"see these things being"},{"startTime":7159.485,"endTime":7160.686,"body":"built underground, why?"},{"startTime":7160.953,"endTime":7162.922,"body":"Because expensive, because it's gonna"},{"startTime":7162.922,"endTime":7164.857,"body":"cost a lot more for the energy companies"},{"startTime":7164.891,"endTime":7166.859,"body":"in the moment to actually do that."},{"startTime":7166.959,"endTime":7169.762,"body":"And so from there, let me go to this"},{"startTime":7169.762,"endTime":7172.665,"body":"piece, which is where I actually began"},{"startTime":7172.665,"endTime":7173.733,"body":"thinking about this week."},{"startTime":7174.467,"endTime":7177.57,"body":"Peter Anthony Cowan, his excellent"},{"startTime":7177.57,"endTime":7179.005,"body":"sub-stack, I highly recommend it, and"},{"startTime":7179.005,"endTime":7180.273,"body":"we'll link to it again in the show now,"},{"startTime":7180.273,"endTime":7181.274,"body":"it's called \"Living Energy\"."},{"startTime":7181.274,"endTime":7183.042,"body":"He does a lot with EMFs, and we're not"},{"startTime":7183.042,"endTime":7184.577,"body":"gonna spend a lot of time talking about"},{"startTime":7185.645,"endTime":7188.781,"body":"some of his deep dive into EMFs today,"},{"startTime":7188.781,"endTime":7189.782,"body":"but we will come back"},{"startTime":7189.782,"endTime":7191.35,"body":"to it in future episodes."},{"startTime":7191.717,"endTime":7193.486,"body":"He writes, \"Erin Brockovich, power lines"},{"startTime":7193.486,"endTime":7194.987,"body":"on the missing magnetic field.\""},{"startTime":7195.154,"endTime":7196.022,"body":"And I'm just gonna read a"},{"startTime":7196.022,"endTime":7197.356,"body":"little bit from his piece here."},{"startTime":7198.457,"endTime":7200.226,"body":"And he begins with an acknowledgement."},{"startTime":7200.593,"endTime":7201.46,"body":"\"Erin Brockovich's"},{"startTime":7201.494,"endTime":7202.895,"body":"record needs no defense."},{"startTime":7202.929,"endTime":7204.497,"body":"She has spent a career making invisible"},{"startTime":7204.497,"endTime":7206.165,"body":"toxins visible and making the people"},{"startTime":7206.165,"endTime":7207.433,"body":"responsible answer for them."},{"startTime":7207.733,"endTime":7209.268,"body":"That's exactly why the emission below"},{"startTime":7209.268,"endTime":7211.237,"body":"feels so consequential and why with data"},{"startTime":7211.237,"endTime":7213.072,"body":"center driven high voltage lines pushing"},{"startTime":7213.072,"endTime":7214.473,"body":"back through neighborhoods at a pace"},{"startTime":7214.473,"endTime":7216.375,"body":"never seen before, this is a fight where"},{"startTime":7216.375,"endTime":7217.843,"body":"her contribution will be very welcome.\""},{"startTime":7218.444,"endTime":7220.713,"body":"So he now is going to be referring to"},{"startTime":7220.78,"endTime":7222.815,"body":"this piece that I was just reading, which"},{"startTime":7222.815,"endTime":7224.15,"body":"is a guest post on Erin"},{"startTime":7224.15,"endTime":7225.851,"body":"Brockovich's sub-stack,"},{"startTime":7227.42,"endTime":7229.722,"body":"about this 500 kilovolt transmission line"},{"startTime":7229.722,"endTime":7231.023,"body":"cutting through a family's backyard in"},{"startTime":7231.023,"endTime":7231.924,"body":"Loudoun County, Virginia."},{"startTime":7232.425,"endTime":7234.193,"body":"The line will stand 185 feet."},{"startTime":7234.493,"endTime":7236.028,"body":"It will run less than 100 feet from some"},{"startTime":7236.028,"endTime":7237.763,"body":"bedroom windows to move power to the data"},{"startTime":7237.763,"endTime":7240.233,"body":"centers of Ashburn, AKA data center"},{"startTime":7240.266,"endTime":7242.535,"body":"alley, home to the largest concentration"},{"startTime":7242.535,"endTime":7243.869,"body":"of data centers in the world."},{"startTime":7244.303,"endTime":7244.971,"body":"The essay is well"},{"startTime":7244.971,"endTime":7246.005,"body":"written and sympathetic."},{"startTime":7246.038,"endTime":7247.807,"body":"It names the voltage, the trees lost, the"},{"startTime":7247.807,"endTime":7249.275,"body":"eminent domain statute, the wildlife"},{"startTime":7249.275,"endTime":7250.509,"body":"corridor, the 11th hour"},{"startTime":7250.509,"endTime":7251.644,"body":"land due to the school board."},{"startTime":7252.612,"endTime":7254.28,"body":"The term magnetic field does not appear"},{"startTime":7254.28,"endTime":7256.716,"body":"in the article and forget about EMF."},{"startTime":7257.149,"endTime":7259.185,"body":"So Cowan's point here is"},{"startTime":7260.653,"endTime":7264.724,"body":"Brockovich came to public notice by"},{"startTime":7264.757,"endTime":7267.093,"body":"actually defending the public against a"},{"startTime":7267.393,"endTime":7269.996,"body":"health risk, not just an aesthetic risk,"},{"startTime":7270.196,"endTime":7272.632,"body":"not just a land grab by private"},{"startTime":7272.632,"endTime":7274.367,"body":"corporations, but a health risk."},{"startTime":7274.734,"endTime":7276.902,"body":"And the health risk seems to specifically"},{"startTime":7276.902,"endTime":7277.536,"body":"the health risk for"},{"startTime":7277.536,"endTime":7281.374,"body":"these lines is being ignored."},{"startTime":7281.841,"endTime":7283.275,"body":"And so he continues."},{"startTime":7284.243,"endTime":7285.811,"body":"Brockovich's reputation comes from her"},{"startTime":7285.811,"endTime":7287.446,"body":"proving that an invisible toxic"},{"startTime":7287.446,"endTime":7289.382,"body":"industrial exposure can move through a"},{"startTime":7289.382,"endTime":7290.716,"body":"community for years while the people"},{"startTime":7290.716,"endTime":7291.951,"body":"responsible look away."},{"startTime":7292.585,"endTime":7294.353,"body":"Hexavalent chromium was the toxin in"},{"startTime":7294.353,"endTime":7296.756,"body":"Hinkley, California where she sued PG\u0026E."},{"startTime":7297.223,"endTime":7299.458,"body":"A 500 kilovolt line is the textbook case"},{"startTime":7299.458,"endTime":7301.227,"body":"of an invisible exposure running in close"},{"startTime":7301.227,"endTime":7303.129,"body":"proximity to children's bedrooms."},{"startTime":7303.496,"endTime":7305.264,"body":"And the piece treats it as a zoning issue"},{"startTime":7305.264,"endTime":7307.133,"body":"and an aesthetic problem, real problems"},{"startTime":7307.133,"endTime":7308.834,"body":"to be sure, but not the one her career"},{"startTime":7308.834,"endTime":7309.835,"body":"was built on exposing."},{"startTime":7310.403,"endTime":7311.971,"body":"Let's just jump down since we've already"},{"startTime":7311.971,"endTime":7313.072,"body":"spent a long time here."},{"startTime":7314.807,"endTime":7315.808,"body":"Great stuff here."},{"startTime":7315.808,"endTime":7318.044,"body":"And I encourage you to read it"},{"startTime":7319.445,"endTime":7320.88,"body":"with regard to what happened"},{"startTime":7322.081,"endTime":7324.483,"body":"in California with regard to what"},{"startTime":7324.85,"endTime":7325.851,"body":"Brockovich was first"},{"startTime":7325.851,"endTime":7327.019,"body":"bringing to our attention."},{"startTime":7327.019,"endTime":7330.122,"body":"And also, not just that, sorry, but the"},{"startTime":7330.122,"endTime":7333.826,"body":"original fight against power lines being"},{"startTime":7333.826,"endTime":7335.828,"body":"near high voltage power lines being near"},{"startTime":7335.828,"endTime":7336.829,"body":"homes, which actually I"},{"startTime":7336.829,"endTime":7338.864,"body":"will go back here and say,"},{"startTime":7340.266,"endTime":7341.967,"body":"in 1976, I'll read this paragraph."},{"startTime":7341.967,"endTime":7343.569,"body":"The New York Public Service Commission"},{"startTime":7343.602,"endTime":7345.938,"body":"opened hearings of whether 765 kilovolt"},{"startTime":7345.938,"endTime":7346.639,"body":"lines could hurt the"},{"startTime":7346.639,"endTime":7347.64,"body":"people living under them."},{"startTime":7348.374,"endTime":7350.042,"body":"The central witnesses were Andrew Marino"},{"startTime":7350.042,"endTime":7351.177,"body":"and his supervisor, Dr."},{"startTime":7351.177,"endTime":7353.079,"body":"Robert Becker, out of the VA hospital in"},{"startTime":7353.079,"endTime":7355.414,"body":"Syracuse, who would expose rats to low"},{"startTime":7355.414,"endTime":7356.415,"body":"frequency fields and"},{"startTime":7356.415,"endTime":7357.45,"body":"found stunted growth."},{"startTime":7358.084,"endTime":7359.752,"body":"The utilities cross examined Marino for"},{"startTime":7359.752,"endTime":7362.688,"body":"10 days by Marino's own account of the"},{"startTime":7362.688,"endTime":7364.123,"body":"hearings from his book, \"The Electric"},{"startTime":7364.123,"endTime":7365.758,"body":"Wilderness,\" the commission's health"},{"startTime":7365.758,"endTime":7367.393,"body":"report then devoted a significant portion"},{"startTime":7367.393,"endTime":7368.594,"body":"of its length of discrediting his"},{"startTime":7368.594,"endTime":7369.962,"body":"experiments and his character."},{"startTime":7370.93,"endTime":7371.664,"body":"And then the commission"},{"startTime":7371.664,"endTime":7373.265,"body":"conceded the point anyway."},{"startTime":7375.701,"endTime":7378.07,"body":"Those fights were ceded, and the frame"},{"startTime":7378.07,"endTime":7379.305,"body":"that regulators would hear narrowed to"},{"startTime":7379.305,"endTime":7380.806,"body":"real estate and public necessity, then"},{"startTime":7380.806,"endTime":7382.441,"body":"the recent data center build out started"},{"startTime":7382.441,"endTime":7384.343,"body":"dragging 500 kilovolt lines back through"},{"startTime":7384.343,"endTime":7386.011,"body":"backyards at a scale the country hasn't"},{"startTime":7386.011,"endTime":7387.88,"body":"seen since Marino was on the stand."},{"startTime":7388.981,"endTime":7390.182,"body":"But, and sorry, I'm"},{"startTime":7390.216,"endTime":7391.384,"body":"jumping back and forth here,"},{"startTime":7392.918,"endTime":7394.587,"body":"that concession is still sitting there,"},{"startTime":7394.754,"endTime":7396.322,"body":"that this is a real health problem,"},{"startTime":7396.455,"endTime":7399.258,"body":"unretracted in a 1978 government document"},{"startTime":7399.258,"endTime":7400.493,"body":"that has largely been forgotten."},{"startTime":7400.86,"endTime":7402.628,"body":"Okay, so is there no hope?"},{"startTime":7403.395,"endTime":7405.898,"body":"There is hope, bury them, he writes."},{"startTime":7406.399,"endTime":7407.199,"body":"The Loudoun families"},{"startTime":7407.199,"endTime":7408.2,"body":"want the line buried."},{"startTime":7408.601,"endTime":7409.335,"body":"So do the New York"},{"startTime":7409.335,"endTime":7411.003,"body":"farmers, so do the Minnesotans."},{"startTime":7411.036,"endTime":7412.805,"body":"It is the oldest demand in this fight,"},{"startTime":7412.805,"endTime":7414.073,"body":"and it is worth understanding what that"},{"startTime":7414.073,"endTime":7415.875,"body":"actually gets us, besides better views."},{"startTime":7415.875,"endTime":7417.543,"body":"So it's not just an aesthetic point."},{"startTime":7418.177,"endTime":7419.745,"body":"Magnetic fields pass through soil,"},{"startTime":7419.779,"endTime":7421.413,"body":"concrete, and the walls of a house."},{"startTime":7421.714,"endTime":7423.315,"body":"It is extremely difficult to shield them"},{"startTime":7423.315,"endTime":7424.784,"body":"the way you shield an electric field."},{"startTime":7425.084,"endTime":7426.018,"body":"It is much easier to"},{"startTime":7426.018,"endTime":7427.486,"body":"cancel them out with geometry."},{"startTime":7428.32,"endTime":7429.989,"body":"A power line's magnetic field comes from"},{"startTime":7429.989,"endTime":7431.023,"body":"the current running through it."},{"startTime":7431.29,"endTime":7432.691,"body":"When you put two conductors carrying the"},{"startTime":7432.691,"endTime":7434.493,"body":"same current in opposite directions close"},{"startTime":7434.493,"endTime":7436.429,"body":"together, their fields fight each other"},{"startTime":7436.429,"endTime":7437.663,"body":"and mostly cancel out."},{"startTime":7437.963,"endTime":7439.665,"body":"The closer they sit, the more complete"},{"startTime":7439.665,"endTime":7440.9,"body":"the cancellation is."},{"startTime":7440.9,"endTime":7442.401,"body":"This is a very good visual for those just"},{"startTime":7442.401,"endTime":7444.336,"body":"listening, in which a single ambient"},{"startTime":7444.336,"endTime":7445.671,"body":"magnetic field is what"},{"startTime":7445.838,"endTime":7446.872,"body":"you expect it to look like."},{"startTime":7447.072,"endTime":7449.875,"body":"If you have one that is effectively the"},{"startTime":7449.909,"endTime":7452.478,"body":"inverse a field canceling systems, you"},{"startTime":7452.645,"endTime":7453.913,"body":"get a resultant magnetic"},{"startTime":7453.913,"endTime":7455.648,"body":"field of effectively zero."},{"startTime":7456.949,"endTime":7457.85,"body":"High voltage lines"},{"startTime":7457.85,"endTime":7458.951,"body":"carry three conductors."},{"startTime":7459.318,"endTime":7461.153,"body":"The three phases of AC power, and the"},{"startTime":7461.153,"endTime":7462.321,"body":"same rule governs them."},{"startTime":7463.022,"endTime":7464.056,"body":"What determines how far"},{"startTime":7464.056,"endTime":7465.524,"body":"apart they sit is the insulation."},{"startTime":7465.591,"endTime":7467.593,"body":"Overhead, that is in unburied lines."},{"startTime":7467.993,"endTime":7469.228,"body":"The only thing holding the conductors"},{"startTime":7469.228,"endTime":7470.763,"body":"apart is air, and air"},{"startTime":7470.763,"endTime":7471.564,"body":"is a poor insulator."},{"startTime":7472.264,"endTime":7474.266,"body":"If you place high voltage lines too close"},{"startTime":7474.266,"endTime":7476.168,"body":"in open air, the current can arc across"},{"startTime":7476.168,"endTime":7478.137,"body":"the gap, releasing intense light, sound,"},{"startTime":7478.137,"endTime":7480.573,"body":"and extreme heat, and as we know, fire."},{"startTime":7481.006,"endTime":7482.908,"body":"And that's what happened in the Paradise"},{"startTime":7482.908,"endTime":7484.476,"body":"Fire in California a few years back."},{"startTime":7484.476,"endTime":7486.312,"body":"That's what happened in the fire that you"},{"startTime":7486.312,"endTime":7489.481,"body":"saw in 1970, whatever, in the hills in"},{"startTime":7489.481,"endTime":7489.982,"body":"the Santa Monica"},{"startTime":7489.982,"endTime":7491.584,"body":"Mountains, Eight. 77, eight."},{"startTime":7492.251,"endTime":7496.422,"body":"Yep, and so many of the wildfires in the"},{"startTime":7496.422,"endTime":7498.224,"body":"West have been attributed to these"},{"startTime":7499.758,"endTime":7502.628,"body":"lines that were not far enough apart, and"},{"startTime":7502.628,"endTime":7504.163,"body":"so swung together and"},{"startTime":7504.196,"endTime":7505.431,"body":"arced and caused fires."},{"startTime":7505.431,"endTime":7506.165,"body":"And so you have"},{"startTime":7507.166,"endTime":7508.501,"body":"same thing with magnetic"},{"startTime":7508.501,"endTime":7509.268,"body":"lines that are overhead."},{"startTime":7509.268,"endTime":7511.17,"body":"They're far apart, and that means they"},{"startTime":7511.17,"endTime":7512.805,"body":"have no chance of canceling one another."},{"startTime":7513.739,"endTime":7515.474,"body":"So overhead, the three phases hang meters"},{"startTime":7515.474,"endTime":7517.476,"body":"apart, cancel poorly, and cast a wide"},{"startTime":7517.476,"endTime":7519.111,"body":"field that diminishes slowly, reaching"},{"startTime":7519.111,"endTime":7520.98,"body":"homes at still elevated levels."},{"startTime":7521.614,"endTime":7523.816,"body":"Burial swaps that air gap for solid"},{"startTime":7523.816,"endTime":7525.551,"body":"insulation wrapped around each cable,"},{"startTime":7525.851,"endTime":7527.486,"body":"letting the three sit inches apart in a"},{"startTime":7527.486,"endTime":7529.455,"body":"tight bundle called a trefoil, where the"},{"startTime":7529.455,"endTime":7531.29,"body":"cancellation is much more effective."},{"startTime":7531.69,"endTime":7533.259,"body":"The field directly over the trench in the"},{"startTime":7533.259,"endTime":7534.927,"body":"middle of the street can run higher than"},{"startTime":7534.927,"endTime":7537.062,"body":"the street under an overhead tower, but"},{"startTime":7537.062,"endTime":7538.597,"body":"by the time it gets to the sidewalk line,"},{"startTime":7538.597,"endTime":7540.432,"body":"it is minimal, and by the house line, it"},{"startTime":7540.432,"endTime":7541.066,"body":"typically will have"},{"startTime":7541.066,"endTime":7542.334,"body":"collapsed into the background."},{"startTime":7542.735,"endTime":7544.47,"body":"For homes similarly situated in relation"},{"startTime":7544.47,"endTime":7546.005,"body":"to the right-of-way, burial"},{"startTime":7546.005,"endTime":7548.574,"body":"means less exposure, not more."},{"startTime":7548.908,"endTime":7551.61,"body":"And here we have a graph showing this,"},{"startTime":7551.61,"endTime":7553.846,"body":"that yes, indeed, if you bury it, the"},{"startTime":7553.846,"endTime":7555.781,"body":"ground right above where it is buried"},{"startTime":7555.781,"endTime":7558.884,"body":"will have higher magnetic field, but"},{"startTime":7558.918,"endTime":7561.287,"body":"almost nowhere else is it nearly as high,"},{"startTime":7561.287,"endTime":7562.755,"body":"and certainly by the time you get to"},{"startTime":7562.755,"endTime":7565.057,"body":"people's homes, it's not as high, and the"},{"startTime":7565.057,"endTime":7568.294,"body":"real health risks of these lines is in"},{"startTime":7568.294,"endTime":7569.862,"body":"the magnetic fields when they do not"},{"startTime":7569.862,"endTime":7572.097,"body":"cancel, which they will not cancel out if"},{"startTime":7572.097,"endTime":7573.465,"body":"you are keeping them above ground."},{"startTime":7574.466,"endTime":7575.1,"body":"Yes,"},{"startTime":7576.468,"endTime":7579.038,"body":"it's the obvious solution, and the fact"},{"startTime":7579.038,"endTime":7580.739,"body":"that it is not obvious to"},{"startTime":7580.739,"endTime":7582.608,"body":"the industries involved--"},{"startTime":7582.908,"endTime":7583.909,"body":"Oh, it may be obvious to them."},{"startTime":7584.009,"endTime":7585.844,"body":"Oh, I'm sure it's obvious."},{"startTime":7585.844,"endTime":7587.346,"body":"The fact that it is not the obviously"},{"startTime":7587.346,"endTime":7590.449,"body":"right thing to do demonstrates the"},{"startTime":7590.482,"endTime":7592.551,"body":"principle that I think echoes through all"},{"startTime":7592.551,"endTime":7595.721,"body":"of these stories, which is the, they"},{"startTime":7595.721,"endTime":7597.189,"body":"don't actually give a"},{"startTime":7597.189,"endTime":7599.258,"body":"shit about us principle."},{"startTime":7599.325,"endTime":7601.527,"body":"And you did it with an acronym, even."},{"startTime":7601.627,"endTime":7606.265,"body":"Yeah, T-D-A-G-S-A-U, if we exclude the"},{"startTime":7606.298,"endTime":7609.034,"body":"little a in between the G and the S."},{"startTime":7609.335,"endTime":7610.569,"body":"But here's-- It's not a pronounceable"},{"startTime":7610.569,"endTime":7611.937,"body":"acronym, but an acronym that's less."},{"startTime":7612.037,"endTime":7612.938,"body":"They're gonna tell you"},{"startTime":7613.339,"endTime":7614.473,"body":"that this is not a problem."},{"startTime":7614.74,"endTime":7615.374,"body":"They're gonna lead you to"},{"startTime":7615.374,"endTime":7616.675,"body":"believe this is not a problem."},{"startTime":7617.476,"endTime":7620.646,"body":"But they're demonstrating in refusing to"},{"startTime":7620.646,"endTime":7622.247,"body":"mitigate all of the problems."},{"startTime":7622.247,"endTime":7624.283,"body":"The aesthetic problem is mitigated too."},{"startTime":7624.283,"endTime":7626.986,"body":"You're actually taking people's homes and"},{"startTime":7626.986,"endTime":7630.189,"body":"degrading them with these giant,"},{"startTime":7630.222,"endTime":7632.691,"body":"crackling tower structures."},{"startTime":7633.025,"endTime":7634.693,"body":"The point is, if these industries"},{"startTime":7634.693,"endTime":7637.062,"body":"actually gave a shit about us, then the"},{"startTime":7637.062,"endTime":7638.364,"body":"point is this would be the obviously"},{"startTime":7638.364,"endTime":7639.264,"body":"right way to do this, and"},{"startTime":7639.264,"endTime":7640.432,"body":"yes, it would be more expensive."},{"startTime":7640.432,"endTime":7642.101,"body":"But the point is, how would you know if"},{"startTime":7642.101,"endTime":7643.335,"body":"they gave a shit about us?"},{"startTime":7643.869,"endTime":7646.505,"body":"They would be willing to spend more to do"},{"startTime":7646.505,"endTime":7648.107,"body":"this properly and not destroy the"},{"startTime":7648.107,"endTime":7649.708,"body":"communities that, oh, by the way, they"},{"startTime":7649.708,"endTime":7651.143,"body":"don't live in, right?"},{"startTime":7651.81,"endTime":7653.045,"body":"They're doing this in your backyard."},{"startTime":7653.112,"endTime":7654.613,"body":"They're not doing it in their backyard."},{"startTime":7655.147,"endTime":7657.416,"body":"So anyway, they're demonstrating that"},{"startTime":7657.416,"endTime":7658.417,"body":"they're psychopathic."},{"startTime":7658.684,"endTime":7660.452,"body":"We shouldn't really expect"},{"startTime":7660.452,"endTime":7661.654,"body":"them to be anything else."},{"startTime":7661.654,"endTime":7663.956,"body":"That's the ecosystem of the market."},{"startTime":7663.956,"endTime":7668.293,"body":"If you do not make it pay to care about"},{"startTime":7668.293,"endTime":7670.562,"body":"people, will result in the evolution of"},{"startTime":7670.562,"endTime":7671.43,"body":"critters that don't."},{"startTime":7671.697,"endTime":7672.831,"body":"And these are critters that don't."},{"startTime":7673.065,"endTime":7674.533,"body":"So the point is we are going to have to"},{"startTime":7674.533,"endTime":7677.67,"body":"force them to do the right thing, or"},{"startTime":7677.67,"endTime":7678.837,"body":"they're not gonna do the right thing."},{"startTime":7678.871,"endTime":7681.073,"body":"And they're gonna claim, of course, that"},{"startTime":7681.073,"endTime":7682.908,"body":"what they've done is harmless to you or"},{"startTime":7682.908,"endTime":7683.909,"body":"that you're being petty."},{"startTime":7683.909,"endTime":7685.778,"body":"But of course, if it were your house, you"},{"startTime":7685.778,"endTime":7687.98,"body":"would know that that was preposterous."},{"startTime":7689.314,"endTime":7689.715,"body":"That's right."},{"startTime":7692.251,"endTime":7692.685,"body":"I think"},{"startTime":7693.919,"endTime":7695.988,"body":"I've said enough today on this."},{"startTime":7697.956,"endTime":7700.426,"body":"There are real reasons to be concerned"},{"startTime":7700.793,"endTime":7702.327,"body":"about these lines running"},{"startTime":7702.327,"endTime":7703.062,"body":"through your neighborhood."},{"startTime":7703.595,"endTime":7705.831,"body":"Real reasons and the biggest reasons are"},{"startTime":7705.831,"endTime":7707.366,"body":"mostly not the ones you're hearing about."},{"startTime":7708.967,"endTime":7711.67,"body":"Bearing the lines doesn't solve all the"},{"startTime":7711.67,"endTime":7714.039,"body":"problems, but it solves so many of them"},{"startTime":7714.406,"endTime":7716.608,"body":"while also solving the problem of, we"},{"startTime":7716.608,"endTime":7720.045,"body":"don't have enough power"},{"startTime":7720.045,"endTime":7720.679,"body":"that we're generating."},{"startTime":7721.113,"endTime":7723.649,"body":"We don't have enough places, we don't"},{"startTime":7723.649,"endTime":7724.483,"body":"have enough data centers."},{"startTime":7724.85,"endTime":7727.586,"body":"That is a real problem given our"},{"startTime":7727.586,"endTime":7729.021,"body":"exploding use of AI."},{"startTime":7730.322,"endTime":7734.793,"body":"So this feels like an obvious step, but"},{"startTime":7734.793,"endTime":7736.628,"body":"for the initial higher cost."},{"startTime":7736.628,"endTime":7738.497,"body":"And as actually Cowan writes about later"},{"startTime":7738.497,"endTime":7741.6,"body":"in that piece, with regard to what PG, I"},{"startTime":7741.6,"endTime":7743.469,"body":"think it was PG and E still, had to do in"},{"startTime":7743.469,"endTime":7744.503,"body":"the wake of the Paradise Fire in"},{"startTime":7744.503,"endTime":7746.905,"body":"California, where they finally are like,"},{"startTime":7746.905,"endTime":7747.973,"body":"\"Okay, I guess we've got to bury these"},{"startTime":7747.973,"endTime":7749.475,"body":"lines \"because we keep on having these"},{"startTime":7749.475,"endTime":7751.443,"body":"fires \"sparked by overhead lines.\""},{"startTime":7751.81,"endTime":7754.446,"body":"And they quoted a price that was sky high"},{"startTime":7754.446,"endTime":7755.481,"body":"at first said, \"Oh, what was us?"},{"startTime":7755.481,"endTime":7756.215,"body":"\"We can't do this, we're"},{"startTime":7756.215,"endTime":7757.382,"body":"just a poor utility company.\""},{"startTime":7757.649,"endTime":7760.586,"body":"And then what they have reported since"},{"startTime":7760.586,"endTime":7762.654,"body":"now doing it is that their prices are"},{"startTime":7762.654,"endTime":7764.156,"body":"actually going lower, the more they do it"},{"startTime":7764.156,"endTime":7765.891,"body":"because economies of scale and actually"},{"startTime":7765.891,"endTime":7766.859,"body":"having to do it, they"},{"startTime":7766.859,"endTime":7768.026,"body":"find ways to make it cheaper."},{"startTime":7768.26,"endTime":7770.462,"body":"Yes, and it also has benefits down the"},{"startTime":7770.462,"endTime":7774.433,"body":"road, which is storms, it's different"},{"startTime":7774.433,"endTime":7777.569,"body":"with high tension wires, but the point is"},{"startTime":7777.803,"endTime":7780.305,"body":"above ground wires are not only ugly and"},{"startTime":7780.405,"endTime":7783.642,"body":"not only expose you to much greater EMF,"},{"startTime":7783.809,"endTime":7785.511,"body":"but they're also vulnerable."},{"startTime":7785.544,"endTime":7787.546,"body":"It's been done because it's cheap on the"},{"startTime":7787.546,"endTime":7789.982,"body":"front end and they're running it through"},{"startTime":7789.982,"endTime":7791.283,"body":"your backyard, not theirs."},{"startTime":7792.151,"endTime":7793.252,"body":"But the benefits,"},{"startTime":7794.386,"endTime":7794.686,"body":"R."},{"startTime":7794.686,"endTime":7798.991,"body":"Crumb, the artist, actually used to make"},{"startTime":7798.991,"endTime":7802.461,"body":"a point when he drew drawings of"},{"startTime":7802.461,"endTime":7805.364,"body":"cityscapes, he would make a point of"},{"startTime":7805.364,"endTime":7809.067,"body":"including the unbearably ugly electrical"},{"startTime":7809.101,"endTime":7811.37,"body":"and telephone wires because he was very"},{"startTime":7811.37,"endTime":7813.806,"body":"focused on the ugliness of things."},{"startTime":7814.439,"endTime":7815.073,"body":"And"},{"startTime":7816.508,"endTime":7819.378,"body":"most of us spend a lot of time trying not"},{"startTime":7819.378,"endTime":7820.512,"body":"to see those things, to"},{"startTime":7820.512,"endTime":7821.947,"body":"think about them because they are"},{"startTime":7823.248,"endTime":7826.018,"body":"degrading of the beauty of everything."},{"startTime":7826.919,"endTime":7828.62,"body":"We got this background edit going and"},{"startTime":7828.62,"endTime":7833.592,"body":"it's taxing and it means that we live, we"},{"startTime":7833.592,"endTime":7835.594,"body":"inherently live in a less rich world"},{"startTime":7835.627,"endTime":7837.196,"body":"because we're trying to edit away big"},{"startTime":7837.196,"endTime":7838.43,"body":"parts of it if we"},{"startTime":7838.43,"endTime":7839.965,"body":"live in such landscapes."},{"startTime":7840.098,"endTime":7840.399,"body":"Yeah,"},{"startTime":7841.867,"endTime":7844.603,"body":"but the obvious right thing is either, if"},{"startTime":7844.603,"endTime":7846.271,"body":"you can't do this in a way that's"},{"startTime":7846.271,"endTime":7848.907,"body":"tolerable, then you damn well better buy"},{"startTime":7848.907,"endTime":7851.71,"body":"the people out who live in the places"},{"startTime":7851.71,"endTime":7853.111,"body":"that you're going to destroy and you"},{"startTime":7853.111,"endTime":7854.346,"body":"better buy them out at"},{"startTime":7854.379,"endTime":7855.514,"body":"an appropriate price."},{"startTime":7855.614,"endTime":7857.883,"body":"You can't cheap out on what you're doing"},{"startTime":7857.916,"endTime":7861.086,"body":"to people because you claim to have this"},{"startTime":7861.119,"endTime":7862.354,"body":"right of eminent domain"},{"startTime":7862.354,"endTime":7864.122,"body":"through their backyard."},{"startTime":7864.356,"endTime":7864.523,"body":"Right, but"},{"startTime":7865.791,"endTime":7866.792,"body":"as you well know, as we've"},{"startTime":7866.792,"endTime":7868.06,"body":"talked about before, of course,"},{"startTime":7869.494,"endTime":7871.43,"body":"people's homes aren't a commodity."},{"startTime":7872.397,"endTime":7874.7,"body":"If they just moved in three years ago and"},{"startTime":7874.7,"endTime":7876.134,"body":"they aren't sure they wanna be there,"},{"startTime":7876.168,"endTime":7877.035,"body":"that's great for them."},{"startTime":7877.436,"endTime":7880.839,"body":"But in the case of Taggart, the guest"},{"startTime":7880.839,"endTime":7883.242,"body":"author on Brockovich's site, she's"},{"startTime":7883.242,"endTime":7884.81,"body":"talking about her grandmother puttering"},{"startTime":7884.843,"endTime":7886.478,"body":"with the chives in the garden, right?"},{"startTime":7886.712,"endTime":7887.246,"body":"I get it."},{"startTime":7887.746,"endTime":7890.048,"body":"But you gotta do something to balance the"},{"startTime":7890.048,"endTime":7892.584,"body":"fact that sometimes it is important to do"},{"startTime":7892.584,"endTime":7893.685,"body":"something that forces"},{"startTime":7893.685,"endTime":7894.853,"body":"somebody to be displaced."},{"startTime":7894.853,"endTime":7897.956,"body":"And the problem is if the idea is, well,"},{"startTime":7897.99,"endTime":7900.626,"body":"we'll buy you out, but you're not gonna"},{"startTime":7900.626,"endTime":7904.129,"body":"buy me out for a level that I can buy"},{"startTime":7904.129,"endTime":7906.798,"body":"something equivalent somewhere else, then"},{"startTime":7906.832,"endTime":7908.3,"body":"you're a criminal, right?"},{"startTime":7908.6,"endTime":7910.602,"body":"I'm not arguing that there's not a"},{"startTime":7911.503,"endTime":7913.872,"body":"tragedy that is forced out of their"},{"startTime":7913.872,"endTime":7916.141,"body":"ancestral home because of eminent domain."},{"startTime":7916.375,"endTime":7919.344,"body":"But the point is 90% of the problem is"},{"startTime":7920.312,"endTime":7923.715,"body":"you're not giving people the ability to"},{"startTime":7923.715,"endTime":7926.018,"body":"make a lateral move to some place that"},{"startTime":7926.018,"endTime":7927.319,"body":"they will like equally well."},{"startTime":7927.519,"endTime":7929.054,"body":"I'm not saying it's perfect, but at the"},{"startTime":7929.054,"endTime":7931.623,"body":"very least, a civilization that gave a"},{"startTime":7931.623,"endTime":7934.393,"body":"shit about people and did recognize that"},{"startTime":7934.393,"endTime":7936.128,"body":"sometimes we have to do something that"},{"startTime":7936.461,"endTime":7937.996,"body":"takes a piece of property that somebody"},{"startTime":7937.996,"endTime":7940.732,"body":"owns, the minimum you've gotta do is buy"},{"startTime":7940.732,"endTime":7941.8,"body":"them out appropriately."},{"startTime":7941.867,"endTime":7944.469,"body":"And of course we don't do that because,"},{"startTime":7944.67,"endTime":7946.071,"body":"you know, see earlier principle."},{"startTime":7946.672,"endTime":7947.205,"body":"Say it again."},{"startTime":7947.806,"endTime":7950.776,"body":"Oh, they don't actually give a shit about"},{"startTime":7950.943,"endTime":7954.913,"body":"us, the TDAGSAU principle."},{"startTime":7955.414,"endTime":7956.248,"body":"Tdags how?"},{"startTime":7956.381,"endTime":7957.482,"body":"Tdags how, yeah."},{"startTime":7957.983,"endTime":7959.051,"body":"Kind of just rolls off the tongue."},{"startTime":7959.785,"endTime":7959.985,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7962.154,"endTime":7962.521,"body":"All right."},{"startTime":7962.888,"endTime":7963.622,"body":"Speaking of."},{"startTime":7963.622,"endTime":7965.39,"body":"Speaking of not giving a shit about us."},{"startTime":7965.39,"endTime":7966.525,"body":"They don't actually give a shit about us."},{"startTime":7966.525,"endTime":7968.093,"body":"They don't actually give a shit about us."},{"startTime":7968.16,"endTime":7970.529,"body":"No, and this becomes clearer every hour."},{"startTime":7971.563,"endTime":7972.297,"body":"All right, so we are gonna"},{"startTime":7972.297,"endTime":7973.865,"body":"switch gears, but not really."},{"startTime":7973.932,"endTime":7975.734,"body":"Because we're not expecting of."},{"startTime":7975.734,"endTime":7978.003,"body":"Yeah, we are talking about a different"},{"startTime":7980.005,"endTime":7981.473,"body":"head on the same Hydra."},{"startTime":7981.773,"endTime":7982.975,"body":"Hydras have multiple heads, right?"},{"startTime":7984.009,"endTime":7984.042,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":7984.042,"endTime":7984.643,"body":"Yeah, okay."},{"startTime":7984.843,"endTime":7985.444,"body":"So we're talking about a"},{"startTime":7985.444,"endTime":7986.511,"body":"different head of the same Hydra."},{"startTime":7986.511,"endTime":7990.382,"body":"We're gonna talk about the Flock camera"},{"startTime":7990.382,"endTime":7992.884,"body":"phenomenon, which people are increasingly"},{"startTime":7992.884,"endTime":7994.086,"body":"aware of, but I would say"},{"startTime":7994.086,"endTime":7995.587,"body":"that one of the key dimensions"},{"startTime":7996.688,"endTime":7998.924,"body":"of the Flock story is that it kind of"},{"startTime":7998.924,"endTime":8000.192,"body":"suddenly erupted in"},{"startTime":8000.225,"endTime":8001.893,"body":"many of our consciousnesses"},{"startTime":8003.562,"endTime":8006.098,"body":"recently because it's sort of quietly"},{"startTime":8006.098,"endTime":8009.634,"body":"been installed around the country without"},{"startTime":8009.634,"endTime":8012.003,"body":"a discussion, which is a"},{"startTime":8012.003,"endTime":8013.171,"body":"big key to the problem."},{"startTime":8013.171,"endTime":8017.142,"body":"So these cameras are, Flock is a company."},{"startTime":8017.142,"endTime":8019.978,"body":"This company is producing cameras."},{"startTime":8019.978,"endTime":8021.847,"body":"I think there is something like 80,000"},{"startTime":8021.913,"endTime":8023.482,"body":"acknowledged cameras"},{"startTime":8023.615,"endTime":8025.617,"body":"in the US at the moment."},{"startTime":8026.151,"endTime":8030.455,"body":"And what they ostensibly do is sit there"},{"startTime":8030.655,"endTime":8033.658,"body":"and passively they're solar powered."},{"startTime":8033.692,"endTime":8035.227,"body":"The technological innovation to the"},{"startTime":8035.227,"endTime":8036.728,"body":"extent that there is one is that they"},{"startTime":8036.728,"endTime":8039.231,"body":"don't have wires that have to conduct"},{"startTime":8039.231,"endTime":8042.701,"body":"data back to some sort of data center."},{"startTime":8042.701,"endTime":8044.336,"body":"They are wireless and"},{"startTime":8044.336,"endTime":8046.238,"body":"therefore broadcast through the cloud."},{"startTime":8046.838,"endTime":8048.573,"body":"And what they are ostensibly there to do"},{"startTime":8048.974,"endTime":8051.643,"body":"is to track license plates."},{"startTime":8051.743,"endTime":8053.445,"body":"And you wanna, can we put up"},{"startTime":8054.513,"endTime":8056.648,"body":"their website just to see exactly what"},{"startTime":8056.648,"endTime":8057.015,"body":"you're talking about?"},{"startTime":8057.015,"endTime":8058.717,"body":"You want Flock's website or De-Flock?"},{"startTime":8058.717,"endTime":8061.42,"body":"Yeah, Flock first just to see in their"},{"startTime":8061.42,"endTime":8063.155,"body":"words what it is that they're"},{"startTime":8064.589,"endTime":8064.923,"body":"doing."},{"startTime":8065.59,"endTime":8066.992,"body":"How effective is Flock?"},{"startTime":8067.926,"endTime":8070.562,"body":"2025 impact census results from 700 law"},{"startTime":8070.562,"endTime":8071.363,"body":"enforcement agencies."},{"startTime":8071.363,"endTime":8075.033,"body":"Their claim is that Flock technology"},{"startTime":8075.033,"endTime":8076.101,"body":"supported more than 1 million"},{"startTime":8076.101,"endTime":8078.003,"body":"investigations, assisted in solving 20%"},{"startTime":8078.37,"endTime":8079.971,"body":"of cleared cases, helped locate more than"},{"startTime":8079.971,"endTime":8082.074,"body":"10,000 missing persons and contributed"},{"startTime":8082.074,"endTime":8083.475,"body":"significantly to stolen vehicle"},{"startTime":8083.475,"endTime":8084.676,"body":"recoveries across the country."},{"startTime":8085.277,"endTime":8087.279,"body":"So that it was worth showing."},{"startTime":8087.879,"endTime":8090.515,"body":"What they say is they're doing-- The face"},{"startTime":8090.515,"endTime":8092.117,"body":"that they're putting forward and the face"},{"startTime":8092.117,"endTime":8093.485,"body":"that they're putting forward is, look,"},{"startTime":8093.485,"endTime":8094.386,"body":"this is not really an"},{"startTime":8094.386,"endTime":8096.087,"body":"invasion of privacy."},{"startTime":8097.055,"endTime":8099.257,"body":"It's just tracking license plates as you"},{"startTime":8099.257,"endTime":8101.827,"body":"drive down the street on a public road."},{"startTime":8101.86,"endTime":8102.994,"body":"So there's nothing"},{"startTime":8102.994,"endTime":8104.096,"body":"really to be worried about."},{"startTime":8104.429,"endTime":8106.298,"body":"And these things do a hell of a lot of"},{"startTime":8106.298,"endTime":8107.065,"body":"good according to that."},{"startTime":8107.833,"endTime":8112.737,"body":"Now, the problem is that the issue, the"},{"startTime":8112.771,"endTime":8114.873,"body":"argument to make in favor of these things"},{"startTime":8114.906,"endTime":8115.774,"body":"is very straightforward."},{"startTime":8115.807,"endTime":8117.109,"body":"In fact, we've just done it for them."},{"startTime":8118.577,"endTime":8121.813,"body":"The argument against them is actually"},{"startTime":8121.98,"endTime":8124.683,"body":"subtle and at least"},{"startTime":8124.683,"endTime":8127.752,"body":"complicated and many dimensional."},{"startTime":8128.086,"endTime":8130.655,"body":"So let us just acknowledge upfront that"},{"startTime":8130.655,"endTime":8133.024,"body":"if you have a network of these cameras"},{"startTime":8133.225,"endTime":8135.927,"body":"deployed across civilization, it will"},{"startTime":8135.927,"endTime":8137.929,"body":"result in the solving of a bunch of"},{"startTime":8137.929,"endTime":8138.663,"body":"crimes that you would"},{"startTime":8138.663,"endTime":8140.065,"body":"not otherwise solve."},{"startTime":8140.499,"endTime":8141.399,"body":"But I would also--"},{"startTime":8142.634,"endTime":8143.301,"body":"The evidence actually"},{"startTime":8143.301,"endTime":8144.369,"body":"doesn't support that conclusion."},{"startTime":8145.937,"endTime":8149.574,"body":"So what I find when I go looking is"},{"startTime":8150.675,"endTime":8151.61,"body":"cars are found,"},{"startTime":8152.811,"endTime":8154.012,"body":"but perpetrators are not."},{"startTime":8154.913,"endTime":8157.082,"body":"So people get their property returned to"},{"startTime":8157.082,"endTime":8160.318,"body":"them with the help of Flock cameras, but"},{"startTime":8160.318,"endTime":8161.853,"body":"crimes are not being solved at a greater"},{"startTime":8161.853,"endTime":8163.688,"body":"rate and the people who stole"},{"startTime":8163.688,"endTime":8164.689,"body":"the cars aren't being found."},{"startTime":8164.789,"endTime":8166.625,"body":"Okay, well, I would point out that this"},{"startTime":8166.625,"endTime":8170.228,"body":"actually points of our current police"},{"startTime":8170.829,"endTime":8173.798,"body":"situation, which is that the people who"},{"startTime":8173.832,"endTime":8176.468,"body":"are organizing it and dictating it don't"},{"startTime":8176.468,"endTime":8177.769,"body":"actually give a shit about us."},{"startTime":8178.37,"endTime":8179.004,"body":"That's the point."},{"startTime":8179.004,"endTime":8179.704,"body":"They've stopped"},{"startTime":8179.704,"endTime":8180.972,"body":"policing in large measure."},{"startTime":8180.972,"endTime":8182.44,"body":"There are entire parts of the country,"},{"startTime":8182.44,"endTime":8184.276,"body":"we've lived in them, where people don't"},{"startTime":8184.276,"endTime":8186.678,"body":"call 911 because nobody fricking shows up"},{"startTime":8186.678,"endTime":8187.646,"body":"and it doesn't matter what"},{"startTime":8187.646,"endTime":8188.613,"body":"it is that you're reporting."},{"startTime":8188.78,"endTime":8190.515,"body":"You can be reporting a literal home"},{"startTime":8190.515,"endTime":8192.05,"body":"invasion where somebody is threatening"},{"startTime":8192.05,"endTime":8193.685,"body":"you in your house and the police don't"},{"startTime":8193.685,"endTime":8195.12,"body":"come for an hour, if at all."},{"startTime":8195.453,"endTime":8198.423,"body":"So the point is they're not solving"},{"startTime":8198.423,"endTime":8199.925,"body":"crimes even with the data"},{"startTime":8199.925,"endTime":8201.426,"body":"about where to find the car."},{"startTime":8201.56,"endTime":8202.16,"body":"Well, that's because"},{"startTime":8202.16,"endTime":8203.395,"body":"nobody's doing any policing."},{"startTime":8203.528,"endTime":8204.863,"body":"Why are they not doing any policing?"},{"startTime":8205.03,"endTime":8205.564,"body":"Because they don't"},{"startTime":8205.564,"endTime":8206.765,"body":"actually give a shit about us."},{"startTime":8206.765,"endTime":8207.866,"body":"That's why, right?"},{"startTime":8207.866,"endTime":8209.234,"body":"This is not their neighborhoods that"},{"startTime":8209.234,"endTime":8209.968,"body":"aren't being policed."},{"startTime":8209.968,"endTime":8210.669,"body":"It's our neighborhoods"},{"startTime":8210.669,"endTime":8211.536,"body":"that aren't being policed."},{"startTime":8211.536,"endTime":8214.573,"body":"So I will grant that in a world that"},{"startTime":8214.573,"endTime":8216.274,"body":"actually functioned, if you deployed"},{"startTime":8216.274,"endTime":8217.776,"body":"these cameras everywhere, you"},{"startTime":8217.776,"endTime":8219.377,"body":"would solve a good many crimes."},{"startTime":8219.411,"endTime":8221.313,"body":"Some of them absolutely horrifying."},{"startTime":8221.646,"endTime":8222.814,"body":"You would solve some crimes."},{"startTime":8223.148,"endTime":8225.283,"body":"But I would also point out that if you"},{"startTime":8225.283,"endTime":8227.586,"body":"were to activate every microphone on"},{"startTime":8227.652,"endTime":8231.356,"body":"every cell phone carried by every person"},{"startTime":8231.389,"endTime":8233.758,"body":"and record everything said by those"},{"startTime":8233.758,"endTime":8234.993,"body":"people, you would also"},{"startTime":8234.993,"endTime":8235.927,"body":"solve a bunch of crimes."},{"startTime":8235.927,"endTime":8237.929,"body":"So the point is the fact that you're"},{"startTime":8237.929,"endTime":8240.599,"body":"going to do some good here, A, doesn't"},{"startTime":8240.599,"endTime":8242.067,"body":"mean anything if you're not doing the"},{"startTime":8242.067,"endTime":8243.602,"body":"good that you could be doing by going"},{"startTime":8243.602,"endTime":8245.136,"body":"back to actual policing"},{"startTime":8245.136,"endTime":8247.038,"body":"and investing in it, right?"},{"startTime":8247.138,"endTime":8249.074,"body":"But it's also not true that everything"},{"startTime":8249.074,"endTime":8251.109,"body":"that does some good should be embraced"},{"startTime":8251.142,"endTime":8252.911,"body":"involves a massive compromise of the"},{"startTime":8252.911,"endTime":8254.512,"body":"liberties that make this a great country."},{"startTime":8254.546,"endTime":8255.046,"body":"You know what?"},{"startTime":8255.78,"endTime":8256.581,"body":"Unfortunately, there's a"},{"startTime":8256.581,"endTime":8258.183,"body":"perfect analogy here to sunscreen."},{"startTime":8260.018,"endTime":8263.021,"body":"Does sunscreen reduce sun exposure?"},{"startTime":8264.589,"endTime":8265.957,"body":"Best case scenario, okay?"},{"startTime":8266.424,"endTime":8269.027,"body":"Using a physical zinc and tallow based"},{"startTime":8269.027,"endTime":8270.729,"body":"sunscreen and you've reduced your sun"},{"startTime":8270.729,"endTime":8273.098,"body":"exposure, not so much that you're now sun"},{"startTime":8273.098,"endTime":8274.666,"body":"deprived, but enough that you don't get"},{"startTime":8274.666,"endTime":8276.034,"body":"the melanoma that you would have gotten"},{"startTime":8276.034,"endTime":8276.668,"body":"that has killed you."},{"startTime":8277.602,"endTime":8280.305,"body":"That is the equivalent of a crime being"},{"startTime":8280.305,"endTime":8283.141,"body":"solved because there was a Flock camera"},{"startTime":8283.141,"endTime":8284.409,"body":"in the right place at the right time."},{"startTime":8285.51,"endTime":8289.648,"body":"But more people end up harmed by lack of"},{"startTime":8289.648,"endTime":8292.117,"body":"sun exposure and by the toxins in their"},{"startTime":8292.117,"endTime":8294.352,"body":"chemical based sunscreens than they do"},{"startTime":8294.352,"endTime":8297.022,"body":"helped by the fact that they had exactly"},{"startTime":8297.022,"endTime":8299.224,"body":"the right confluence of factors that"},{"startTime":8299.224,"endTime":8300.725,"body":"helped them with"},{"startTime":8300.725,"endTime":8302.56,"body":"regard to their melanoma."},{"startTime":8302.727,"endTime":8303.828,"body":"It's exactly the same thing."},{"startTime":8303.828,"endTime":8306.164,"body":"Wow, we've got a problem and we can solve"},{"startTime":8306.164,"endTime":8307.632,"body":"it with perfect surveillance."},{"startTime":8308.099,"endTime":8310.035,"body":"So you're telling us that all we have to"},{"startTime":8310.035,"endTime":8311.936,"body":"do is sacrifice our First Amendment"},{"startTime":8311.936,"endTime":8314.739,"body":"rights and all of our privacy and we can"},{"startTime":8314.739,"endTime":8316.374,"body":"move towards the"},{"startTime":8316.374,"endTime":8318.476,"body":"asymptote of a crime-free state?"},{"startTime":8319.044,"endTime":8319.678,"body":"No, thank you."},{"startTime":8320.245,"endTime":8321.446,"body":"No, thank you."},{"startTime":8321.68,"endTime":8323.615,"body":"Yeah, I mean, you know, of course, Ben"},{"startTime":8323.648,"endTime":8324.816,"body":"Franklin nailed this one."},{"startTime":8324.816,"endTime":8326.351,"body":"I'm sure I won't get the quote exactly"},{"startTime":8326.351,"endTime":8328.386,"body":"right, but he said, you know, those who"},{"startTime":8328.386,"endTime":8330.855,"body":"would surrender liberty"},{"startTime":8330.955,"endTime":8332.457,"body":"for safety deserve neither."},{"startTime":8334.225,"endTime":8334.526,"body":"But"},{"startTime":8335.56,"endTime":8337.595,"body":"this is just one of many objections."},{"startTime":8337.662,"endTime":8339.698,"body":"This is an invasion of privacy."},{"startTime":8339.798,"endTime":8342.3,"body":"It is an invasion of privacy without"},{"startTime":8343.601,"endTime":8344.669,"body":"probable cause."},{"startTime":8344.803,"endTime":8346.538,"body":"I mean, that probable cause is one of the"},{"startTime":8346.571,"endTime":8348.907,"body":"central protectors of our privacy, which"},{"startTime":8348.907,"endTime":8350.875,"body":"is that government doesn't have the right"},{"startTime":8350.875,"endTime":8352.477,"body":"to search you unless it has really good"},{"startTime":8352.477,"endTime":8354.412,"body":"reason, you know, enough to stand up in a"},{"startTime":8354.412,"endTime":8355.78,"body":"court to think that you're doing"},{"startTime":8355.78,"endTime":8357.482,"body":"something that would justify a breach of"},{"startTime":8357.482,"endTime":8359.084,"body":"your privacy rights."},{"startTime":8359.451,"endTime":8362.587,"body":"This is just gonna be done en masse, but"},{"startTime":8362.587,"endTime":8364.656,"body":"there's also something utterly"},{"startTime":8364.656,"endTime":8367.025,"body":"preposterous about the presentation."},{"startTime":8367.692,"endTime":8368.893,"body":"Well, it's just"},{"startTime":8368.893,"endTime":8370.161,"body":"looking at license plates."},{"startTime":8370.729,"endTime":8371.463,"body":"Hey, let me show you something."},{"startTime":8372.764,"endTime":8373.565,"body":"You know what this is?"},{"startTime":8374.265,"endTime":8375.266,"body":"This is a kid camera."},{"startTime":8375.633,"endTime":8377.235,"body":"What it does is it photographs children."},{"startTime":8377.302,"endTime":8377.969,"body":"Oh, that's sweet."},{"startTime":8377.969,"endTime":8378.77,"body":"Yeah, isn't that nice?"},{"startTime":8378.803,"endTime":8379.037,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8379.637,"endTime":8380.705,"body":"So don't worry about it."},{"startTime":8380.739,"endTime":8381.473,"body":"You're not a kid."},{"startTime":8381.506,"endTime":8383.007,"body":"You're not gonna get photographed because"},{"startTime":8383.007,"endTime":8384.509,"body":"this is for photographing children."},{"startTime":8384.843,"endTime":8386.177,"body":"So basically-- Everyone wants more"},{"startTime":8386.177,"endTime":8387.045,"body":"photographs of children."},{"startTime":8387.779,"endTime":8388.713,"body":"Not everybody does, but"},{"startTime":8388.913,"endTime":8390.315,"body":"most people presumably do."},{"startTime":8390.381,"endTime":8390.949,"body":"That's not helpful."},{"startTime":8391.149,"endTime":8392.65,"body":"All right, I take it back."},{"startTime":8393.485,"endTime":8396.721,"body":"But the point being, look, you're talking"},{"startTime":8396.721,"endTime":8397.889,"body":"about license plates."},{"startTime":8398.256,"endTime":8401.226,"body":"You're installing a camera."},{"startTime":8401.326,"endTime":8404.229,"body":"What you say it's for when you install it"},{"startTime":8404.229,"endTime":8406.197,"body":"is hardly the limit of what it can be"},{"startTime":8406.197,"endTime":8407.499,"body":"used for, as many"},{"startTime":8407.499,"endTime":8408.533,"body":"people have demonstrated."},{"startTime":8408.6,"endTime":8410.735,"body":"I mean, for one thing, we know that these"},{"startTime":8410.735,"endTime":8412.804,"body":"things not only look at license plates,"},{"startTime":8412.804,"endTime":8413.671,"body":"but they also look at"},{"startTime":8413.838,"endTime":8415.373,"body":"other features of your car."},{"startTime":8415.373,"endTime":8416.841,"body":"They look at things like whether you have"},{"startTime":8416.841,"endTime":8418.543,"body":"a roof rack, whether you've got a dent,"},{"startTime":8418.877,"endTime":8419.811,"body":"whether you've got a bumper"},{"startTime":8419.811,"endTime":8422.08,"body":"sticker or a stripe or whatever."},{"startTime":8422.313,"endTime":8423.481,"body":"Do you wanna show the deFlock site?"},{"startTime":8423.515,"endTime":8425.116,"body":"Yeah, let's look at the deFlock site."},{"startTime":8426.151,"endTime":8426.618,"body":"You can either show it"},{"startTime":8426.618,"endTime":8428.853,"body":"from my screen or yours."},{"startTime":8429.788,"endTime":8432.724,"body":"So deFlock is the, I guess the major,"},{"startTime":8432.757,"endTime":8434.793,"body":"although there are plenty of outfits that"},{"startTime":8434.793,"endTime":8435.994,"body":"are objecting to Flock."},{"startTime":8436.694,"endTime":8437.962,"body":"An open source project"},{"startTime":8437.962,"endTime":8439.431,"body":"mapping license plate readers."},{"startTime":8439.998,"endTime":8443.134,"body":"So what are ALPRs?"},{"startTime":8443.701,"endTime":8446.07,"body":"Automated license plate readers, are AI"},{"startTime":8446.07,"endTime":8448.573,"body":"powered cameras that capture, analyze the"},{"startTime":8448.64,"endTime":8450.241,"body":"images of all passing vehicles during"},{"startTime":8450.241,"endTime":8450.975,"body":"details like your car's"},{"startTime":8450.975,"endTime":8452.243,"body":"location, date and time."},{"startTime":8452.243,"endTime":8453.878,"body":"They also capture your car's make model"},{"startTime":8453.878,"endTime":8455.647,"body":"color and identifying features such as,"},{"startTime":8455.914,"endTime":8457.782,"body":"exactly as you were just saying, dents,"},{"startTime":8458.349,"endTime":8460.185,"body":"roof racks and bumper stickers, often"},{"startTime":8460.185,"endTime":8460.885,"body":"turning these into"},{"startTime":8460.885,"endTime":8462.353,"body":"searchable data points."},{"startTime":8462.754,"endTime":8464.422,"body":"These cameras collected on millions of"},{"startTime":8464.422,"endTime":8465.69,"body":"vehicles, regardless of whether the"},{"startTime":8465.69,"endTime":8467.425,"body":"driver is suspected of a crime."},{"startTime":8468.626,"endTime":8470.562,"body":"These systems are marketed as"},{"startTime":8470.562,"endTime":8471.996,"body":"indispensable tools to fight crime, but"},{"startTime":8471.996,"endTime":8473.398,"body":"they ignore the powerful tools police"},{"startTime":8473.398,"endTime":8475.2,"body":"already have to track criminals, such as"},{"startTime":8475.2,"endTime":8476.468,"body":"cell phone location data, creating a"},{"startTime":8476.468,"endTime":8479.237,"body":"loophole that doesn't require a warrant."},{"startTime":8479.304,"endTime":8480.505,"body":"Doesn't require a warrant."},{"startTime":8480.805,"endTime":8483.575,"body":"I will also point out that this subtly"},{"startTime":8483.608,"endTime":8487.145,"body":"reflects many of the other novel abuses"},{"startTime":8487.178,"endTime":8489.514,"body":"in our rights landscape these days."},{"startTime":8489.714,"endTime":8492.851,"body":"I'm thinking in particular of Real ID,"},{"startTime":8492.917,"endTime":8496.721,"body":"which I did an episode with Twyla Brace"},{"startTime":8496.754,"endTime":8498.156,"body":"at some point, in which I"},{"startTime":8498.156,"endTime":8499.424,"body":"learned quite a bit about it."},{"startTime":8499.424,"endTime":8501.392,"body":"And the central point that she made in"},{"startTime":8501.392,"endTime":8505.096,"body":"that episode was that this takes a state"},{"startTime":8505.096,"endTime":8506.831,"body":"level kind of data, your"},{"startTime":8506.831,"endTime":8509.133,"body":"driver's license and federalizes it."},{"startTime":8509.133,"endTime":8509.901,"body":"And that that's really the"},{"startTime":8509.901,"endTime":8511.236,"body":"point of what they're doing."},{"startTime":8511.636,"endTime":8513.771,"body":"This does the same thing where it takes"},{"startTime":8513.771,"endTime":8515.406,"body":"local surveillance and"},{"startTime":8515.406,"endTime":8517.675,"body":"runs it through a national,"},{"startTime":8518.81,"endTime":8521.145,"body":"both a company and a, you know, a"},{"startTime":8521.145,"endTime":8523.514,"body":"nationalizing police entity."},{"startTime":8523.848,"endTime":8525.183,"body":"And so there's not, as far as you know,"},{"startTime":8525.183,"endTime":8526.05,"body":"there's no national"},{"startTime":8526.05,"endTime":8527.986,"body":"database yet or is there?"},{"startTime":8528.086,"endTime":8529.754,"body":"I think it's kind of inherent to the way"},{"startTime":8529.754,"endTime":8531.256,"body":"you do it because what these things are"},{"startTime":8531.256,"endTime":8532.924,"body":"doing is they are"},{"startTime":8533.458,"endTime":8536.528,"body":"uploading their data to the cloud."},{"startTime":8536.561,"endTime":8538.429,"body":"This is not divided by state."},{"startTime":8538.463,"endTime":8539.03,"body":"And so--"},{"startTime":8539.23,"endTime":8540.064,"body":"Right, but the cloud isn't,"},{"startTime":8541.933,"endTime":8543.334,"body":"I just don't know the specifics."},{"startTime":8543.401,"endTime":8544.302,"body":"Let's put it this way."},{"startTime":8544.302,"endTime":8546.17,"body":"If you don't have the protections, then"},{"startTime":8546.17,"endTime":8547.138,"body":"there's no reason that this"},{"startTime":8547.138,"endTime":8548.273,"body":"will be done in a state level."},{"startTime":8548.273,"endTime":8549.741,"body":"It's being done through a company that"},{"startTime":8549.741,"endTime":8551.242,"body":"isn't fundamental to one state."},{"startTime":8551.542,"endTime":8554.913,"body":"So what you've got is a national system"},{"startTime":8555.213,"endTime":8556.981,"body":"and you've got lots of ways"},{"startTime":8557.015,"endTime":8558.583,"body":"in which this can be abused."},{"startTime":8558.783,"endTime":8562.453,"body":"First of all, we know from, you know,"},{"startTime":8562.82,"endTime":8564.589,"body":"Edward Snowden, I believe."},{"startTime":8565.423,"endTime":8566.824,"body":"He's certainly the whistleblower, but I"},{"startTime":8566.824,"endTime":8568.893,"body":"think the story I remember correctly is,"},{"startTime":8569.627,"endTime":8570.995,"body":"I think I remember it correctly, that"},{"startTime":8571.062,"endTime":8574.666,"body":"there was a report inside the NSA of"},{"startTime":8575.066,"endTime":8578.77,"body":"agents using their fancy surveillance"},{"startTime":8578.77,"endTime":8581.039,"body":"tools to spy on girlfriends"},{"startTime":8581.039,"endTime":8582.44,"body":"and wives and things like this."},{"startTime":8583.308,"endTime":8586.11,"body":"So here you've got a system in which you"},{"startTime":8586.11,"endTime":8587.712,"body":"can, you know, a private"},{"startTime":8588.746,"endTime":8592.35,"body":"entity can search to find out where"},{"startTime":8592.35,"endTime":8595.053,"body":"somebody's going or has been or the"},{"startTime":8595.053,"endTime":8596.888,"body":"collection of places that they've been."},{"startTime":8597.121,"endTime":8598.756,"body":"So you've got all kinds of"},{"startTime":8598.756,"endTime":8599.991,"body":"potential for abuse there."},{"startTime":8599.991,"endTime":8600.925,"body":"You've got potential"},{"startTime":8600.925,"endTime":8602.293,"body":"for abuse by the state."},{"startTime":8602.627,"endTime":8604.295,"body":"So I'll just point to one thing."},{"startTime":8605.863,"endTime":8608.633,"body":"There is a principle that protects the"},{"startTime":8608.666,"endTime":8611.769,"body":"Fourth Amendment, your right to privacy,"},{"startTime":8612.637,"endTime":8614.238,"body":"called the fruit of the poisonous tree,"},{"startTime":8614.539,"endTime":8617.642,"body":"which says that if the police violate"},{"startTime":8617.642,"endTime":8620.011,"body":"your rights in order to,"},{"startTime":8621.512,"endTime":8623.881,"body":"let's say, solve a crime, they discover"},{"startTime":8623.881,"endTime":8625.984,"body":"something having violated your rights and"},{"startTime":8625.984,"endTime":8628.72,"body":"then they use the something that they"},{"startTime":8628.82,"endTime":8630.521,"body":"have discovered and they come up with a"},{"startTime":8630.521,"endTime":8631.723,"body":"legitimate path to"},{"startTime":8631.723,"endTime":8633.324,"body":"have discovered it, right?"},{"startTime":8633.858,"endTime":8636.094,"body":"Then it is not admissible in court."},{"startTime":8636.26,"endTime":8637.629,"body":"The court protects you because it is"},{"startTime":8637.629,"endTime":8639.364,"body":"fruit of the poisonous tree, the"},{"startTime":8639.397,"endTime":8640.898,"body":"illegitimate search, but there's very"},{"startTime":8640.898,"endTime":8642.1,"body":"little protection against"},{"startTime":8642.1,"endTime":8643.234,"body":"something like that here."},{"startTime":8643.334,"endTime":8645.47,"body":"This can be used to figure out patterns"},{"startTime":8645.47,"endTime":8647.739,"body":"of behavior and then an apparently"},{"startTime":8647.739,"endTime":8650.141,"body":"legitimate path to the discovery can be"},{"startTime":8651.275,"endTime":8653.811,"body":"phoned up and there'd be very little"},{"startTime":8653.811,"endTime":8655.146,"body":"opportunity to detect it."},{"startTime":8657.148,"endTime":8659.183,"body":"But there is also, in light of the fact"},{"startTime":8659.183,"endTime":8660.785,"body":"that the people who are claiming that we"},{"startTime":8660.785,"endTime":8663.655,"body":"need this in order to improve policing"},{"startTime":8663.721,"endTime":8666.891,"body":"are not up in arms about the bad state of"},{"startTime":8666.891,"endTime":8668.659,"body":"policing to begin with, right?"},{"startTime":8668.793,"endTime":8670.161,"body":"So they're not doing this"},{"startTime":8670.194,"endTime":8671.195,"body":"because they give a shit."},{"startTime":8671.596,"endTime":8672.73,"body":"What are they doing it for?"},{"startTime":8672.864,"endTime":8675.366,"body":"And I would argue we're gonna end up here"},{"startTime":8675.366,"endTime":8677.502,"body":"all the time indefinitely."},{"startTime":8678.302,"endTime":8680.938,"body":"There is an architecture being built up."},{"startTime":8681.606,"endTime":8683.808,"body":"It is clearly a control architecture."},{"startTime":8684.042,"endTime":8685.743,"body":"It has different elements to it."},{"startTime":8685.743,"endTime":8689.647,"body":"It has elements that involve a kind of"},{"startTime":8689.647,"endTime":8691.215,"body":"universal surveillance."},{"startTime":8691.716,"endTime":8693.484,"body":"I would argue that the surveillance does"},{"startTime":8693.484,"endTime":8695.853,"body":"not trigger the right kind of fear in us"},{"startTime":8695.853,"endTime":8698.89,"body":"because most of us grew up at a time when"},{"startTime":8698.923,"endTime":8700.792,"body":"in order for surveillance to happen,"},{"startTime":8700.792,"endTime":8702.493,"body":"somebody would have to take notice of you"},{"startTime":8702.493,"endTime":8704.062,"body":"and for most people, that's not an issue."},{"startTime":8704.529,"endTime":8706.297,"body":"Now it is an issue for civilization."},{"startTime":8706.998,"endTime":8708.666,"body":"If they surveil the people who are"},{"startTime":8708.666,"endTime":8711.135,"body":"actually making a difference, they can"},{"startTime":8711.636,"endTime":8714.706,"body":"prevent change by just surveilling people"},{"startTime":8714.706,"endTime":8716.674,"body":"who have become a problem."},{"startTime":8717.008,"endTime":8718.743,"body":"But in this case, there's a new kind of"},{"startTime":8718.743,"endTime":8720.111,"body":"surveillance that's possible."},{"startTime":8720.178,"endTime":8721.279,"body":"I call it retroactive"},{"startTime":8721.279,"endTime":8723.347,"body":"surveillance, which is you bank it all."},{"startTime":8723.514,"endTime":8725.083,"body":"You bank all of the emails, all of the"},{"startTime":8725.083,"endTime":8726.884,"body":"text messages, all of the traffic."},{"startTime":8727.118,"endTime":8729.153,"body":"And then at the point somebody becomes"},{"startTime":8729.153,"endTime":8731.456,"body":"interesting five years down the road, you"},{"startTime":8731.456,"endTime":8732.657,"body":"can figure out what it is"},{"startTime":8732.657,"endTime":8734.225,"body":"that you can catch them for."},{"startTime":8734.392,"endTime":8735.76,"body":"It's data-driven society."},{"startTime":8736.194,"endTime":8736.994,"body":"It's data mining."},{"startTime":8737.061,"endTime":8738.663,"body":"It's creating the conditions that allow"},{"startTime":8738.663,"endTime":8740.832,"body":"for near perfect data mining, which is"},{"startTime":8740.832,"endTime":8744.635,"body":"powerful and not how"},{"startTime":8745.069,"endTime":8747.371,"body":"truth is discovered, right?"},{"startTime":8747.405,"endTime":8749.273,"body":"This is not the same thing as a"},{"startTime":8749.273,"endTime":8752.81,"body":"scientific investigation and it is"},{"startTime":8754.145,"endTime":8755.947,"body":"extraordinarily dangerous at the same"},{"startTime":8755.947,"endTime":8757.281,"body":"time that it feels like it's"},{"startTime":8757.281,"endTime":8758.716,"body":"gonna open up the world to us."},{"startTime":8758.883,"endTime":8760.151,"body":"Well, it's extraordinarily"},{"startTime":8761.219,"endTime":8761.953,"body":"dangerous."},{"startTime":8761.953,"endTime":8762.687,"body":"It's not new."},{"startTime":8762.72,"endTime":8765.49,"body":"This was proposed in fact out loud during"},{"startTime":8765.49,"endTime":8767.925,"body":"the Bush years as total information"},{"startTime":8767.959,"endTime":8770.394,"body":"awareness, which is now-- Bush too."},{"startTime":8770.762,"endTime":8773.698,"body":"I believe it was actually,"},{"startTime":8776.067,"endTime":8777.301,"body":"I believe it actually"},{"startTime":8777.301,"endTime":8779.604,"body":"spanned that entire period."},{"startTime":8780.538,"endTime":8782.373,"body":"It was initially a proposal to start"},{"startTime":8782.373,"endTime":8784.208,"body":"banking everything before that was all"},{"startTime":8784.208,"endTime":8785.476,"body":"that technologically plausible."},{"startTime":8785.476,"endTime":8785.877,"body":"It would have been a"},{"startTime":8785.877,"endTime":8786.811,"body":"major investment now."},{"startTime":8786.811,"endTime":8788.112,"body":"It's become much more tractable."},{"startTime":8788.479,"endTime":8789.58,"body":"But anyway, the point is"},{"startTime":8790.214,"endTime":8791.782,"body":"you bank all of that stuff."},{"startTime":8792.55,"endTime":8793.985,"body":"Well, what does that mean?"},{"startTime":8793.985,"endTime":8795.753,"body":"Does that mean, yes, we've paid a huge"},{"startTime":8795.753,"endTime":8797.255,"body":"price, but we're gonna be"},{"startTime":8797.588,"endTime":8798.756,"body":"prosecuting all the crimes?"},{"startTime":8798.756,"endTime":8799.857,"body":"Oh, I don't think so."},{"startTime":8800.057,"endTime":8800.758,"body":"I think we're gonna be"},{"startTime":8800.758,"endTime":8804.295,"body":"prosecuting people who"},{"startTime":8805.363,"endTime":8807.565,"body":"are a threat to power and that people who"},{"startTime":8807.565,"endTime":8809.433,"body":"are actually acting in service of power"},{"startTime":8809.433,"endTime":8810.034,"body":"are gonna get away"},{"startTime":8810.034,"endTime":8811.169,"body":"with all kinds of things."},{"startTime":8811.169,"endTime":8814.372,"body":"Witness Epstein, for example."},{"startTime":8814.972,"endTime":8815.74,"body":"So there's gonna be a"},{"startTime":8815.74,"endTime":8817.475,"body":"two-tier aspect to this."},{"startTime":8817.642,"endTime":8819.81,"body":"The opportunity to go after you for any"},{"startTime":8819.81,"endTime":8822.046,"body":"little thing is gonna be there, but"},{"startTime":8823.147,"endTime":8824.749,"body":"the important people, they're gonna get"},{"startTime":8824.749,"endTime":8826.25,"body":"away with murder, probably literally."},{"startTime":8827.151,"endTime":8827.585,"body":"So--"},{"startTime":8829.353,"endTime":8831.088,"body":"Can we hear from the Flock"},{"startTime":8831.622,"endTime":8834.125,"body":"CEO responding to D-Flock?"},{"startTime":8834.258,"endTime":8835.026,"body":"Absolutely."},{"startTime":8835.126,"endTime":8837.929,"body":"Yeah, so D-Flock, we only showed you the"},{"startTime":8837.995,"endTime":8838.563,"body":"first part of their"},{"startTime":8838.563,"endTime":8841.766,"body":"site, but they of course are,"},{"startTime":8843.067,"endTime":8844.435,"body":"I actually don't know exactly what"},{"startTime":8844.435,"endTime":8846.337,"body":"they're doing, but there are people"},{"startTime":8846.37,"endTime":8848.673,"body":"acting aligned with D-Flock who are"},{"startTime":8848.673,"endTime":8849.874,"body":"taking out Flock cameras."},{"startTime":8849.974,"endTime":8851.275,"body":"I think Flock-- Let me just say that."},{"startTime":8851.275,"endTime":8854.045,"body":"Flock is just legitimately crowdsourcing"},{"startTime":8854.478,"endTime":8856.347,"body":"information on where these cameras are"},{"startTime":8856.614,"endTime":8859.383,"body":"and where they're pointed and what people"},{"startTime":8859.383,"endTime":8860.918,"body":"do with that information is on them."},{"startTime":8863.221,"endTime":8863.888,"body":"How is, what?"},{"startTime":8864.522,"endTime":8866.424,"body":"I'm agreeing with you that D-Flock is"},{"startTime":8866.424,"endTime":8868.86,"body":"just putting together information on the"},{"startTime":8868.86,"endTime":8870.528,"body":"Flock cameras so that the public has it,"},{"startTime":8870.595,"endTime":8871.996,"body":"and then there are people doing things,"},{"startTime":8872.029,"endTime":8874.198,"body":"clearly breaking the law, going after"},{"startTime":8874.198,"endTime":8876.067,"body":"Flock cameras, using that data."},{"startTime":8877.101,"endTime":8877.335,"body":"Okay."},{"startTime":8878.569,"endTime":8880.972,"body":"You've got organizations like the ACLU"},{"startTime":8880.972,"endTime":8883.04,"body":"and the EFF who take an above-the-board"},{"startTime":8883.04,"endTime":8884.775,"body":"approach to fight for their point of"},{"startTime":8884.775,"endTime":8886.51,"body":"view, and thankfully we live in a"},{"startTime":8886.544,"endTime":8888.479,"body":"beautifully democratic, capitalistic"},{"startTime":8888.479,"endTime":8890.414,"body":"country where we can fight in court."},{"startTime":8890.915,"endTime":8892.717,"body":"And I have a lot of respect for those"},{"startTime":8892.717,"endTime":8894.485,"body":"groups because they have reasonable"},{"startTime":8894.485,"endTime":8896.32,"body":"debates and we follow the law."},{"startTime":8896.854,"endTime":8897.755,"body":"And then unfortunately there's"},{"startTime":8897.755,"endTime":8899.957,"body":"terroristic organizations like D-Flock"},{"startTime":8900.358,"endTime":8902.126,"body":"whose primary motivation is chaos."},{"startTime":8902.393,"endTime":8903.694,"body":"They are closer to Antifa"},{"startTime":8903.694,"endTime":8905.062,"body":"than they are anything else."},{"startTime":8905.429,"endTime":8907.431,"body":"And that I think is unfortunate because"},{"startTime":8907.565,"endTime":8908.266,"body":"we don't want chaos"},{"startTime":8908.266,"endTime":8909.233,"body":"or I don't want chaos."},{"startTime":8909.3,"endTime":8910.568,"body":"I like law and order."},{"startTime":8910.968,"endTime":8911.736,"body":"I like a society that"},{"startTime":8911.736,"endTime":8913.004,"body":"has a bedrock of safety."},{"startTime":8913.404,"endTime":8914.705,"body":"So for those groups I think it's just"},{"startTime":8914.705,"endTime":8916.507,"body":"disappointing that they haven't chosen a"},{"startTime":8916.507,"endTime":8918.676,"body":"more constructive mannerism to try to get"},{"startTime":8918.843,"endTime":8920.811,"body":"what they want, which they have a right"},{"startTime":8920.811,"endTime":8922.446,"body":"to have, but that's why we have a"},{"startTime":8922.446,"endTime":8923.981,"body":"democratically elected process."},{"startTime":8924.949,"endTime":8926.684,"body":"We're not forcing Flock on anyone."},{"startTime":8927.451,"endTime":8929.32,"body":"Elected officials know that as a"},{"startTime":8929.654,"endTime":8931.355,"body":"community, you want to be safe."},{"startTime":8932.323,"endTime":8934.425,"body":"We're not forcing Flock on anyone."},{"startTime":8935.226,"endTime":8935.493,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":8935.593,"endTime":8938.596,"body":"Yeah, they get to negotiate with local"},{"startTime":8938.596,"endTime":8942.333,"body":"municipalities and police departments and"},{"startTime":8942.333,"endTime":8944.035,"body":"the people don't get a choice at all."},{"startTime":8944.101,"endTime":8946.504,"body":"So actually we are having it forced on us"},{"startTime":8946.504,"endTime":8948.973,"body":"and you can speak indirectly and say, we"},{"startTime":8948.973,"endTime":8949.941,"body":"aren't forcing it on you."},{"startTime":8949.941,"endTime":8952.777,"body":"Your police department, your HOA, your"},{"startTime":8952.777,"endTime":8954.111,"body":"whatever is forcing it on you."},{"startTime":8954.312,"endTime":8956.314,"body":"It's still you who's doing it."},{"startTime":8956.314,"endTime":8959.116,"body":"The bigger objection to that is the idea"},{"startTime":8959.317,"endTime":8962.286,"body":"that law and order, that this is about"},{"startTime":8962.286,"endTime":8965.022,"body":"law and order and the only way to"},{"startTime":8965.022,"endTime":8967.124,"body":"accomplish law and order is to be wholly"},{"startTime":8967.124,"endTime":8968.96,"body":"surveilled, is to give up your privacy."},{"startTime":8968.993,"endTime":8971.028,"body":"That like, you can either have your"},{"startTime":8971.028,"endTime":8972.496,"body":"privacy or you can have law and order."},{"startTime":8972.663,"endTime":8973.898,"body":"And if you choose privacy,"},{"startTime":8974.165,"endTime":8975.766,"body":"you're encouraging chaos."},{"startTime":8976.067,"endTime":8977.234,"body":"That's wrong."},{"startTime":8977.702,"endTime":8979.203,"body":"Yes, now I find something"},{"startTime":8979.203,"endTime":8980.671,"body":"else objectionable here."},{"startTime":8980.971,"endTime":8982.873,"body":"And this is a theme that"},{"startTime":8982.873,"endTime":8984.709,"body":"has echoed for decades."},{"startTime":8985.476,"endTime":8988.379,"body":"The portrayal of the admittedly"},{"startTime":8988.379,"endTime":8991.782,"body":"law-breaking vigilantes who are taking"},{"startTime":8991.782,"endTime":8993.451,"body":"down these cameras as"},{"startTime":8993.517,"endTime":8996.687,"body":"terrorist is batshit insane."},{"startTime":8997.221,"endTime":8998.255,"body":"And here's the reason."},{"startTime":9000.791,"endTime":9001.659,"body":"Words have meaning."},{"startTime":9002.827,"endTime":9006.997,"body":"Terrorism is about manipulating people"},{"startTime":9007.064,"endTime":9009.767,"body":"into harming themselves using fear."},{"startTime":9010.735,"endTime":9012.603,"body":"How many people do you know who are"},{"startTime":9012.603,"endTime":9015.072,"body":"terrified that Flock cameras are being"},{"startTime":9015.072,"endTime":9017.208,"body":"attacked by vigilantes?"},{"startTime":9017.742,"endTime":9020.344,"body":"I don't know anybody who's afraid of this"},{"startTime":9020.411,"endTime":9022.913,"body":"at all, except maybe the people who are"},{"startTime":9022.913,"endTime":9024.348,"body":"minding the bottom line at Flock."},{"startTime":9024.515,"endTime":9024.749,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":9025.716,"endTime":9026.55,"body":"It's not frightening."},{"startTime":9027.218,"endTime":9028.986,"body":"You can like it, you can"},{"startTime":9028.986,"endTime":9030.921,"body":"hate it, but it's not scary."},{"startTime":9031.122,"endTime":9033.791,"body":"And so the point is the idea, the reason"},{"startTime":9033.791,"endTime":9036.427,"body":"that this guy who-- CEO."},{"startTime":9037.194,"endTime":9039.23,"body":"Yeah, but he looks like he came from"},{"startTime":9039.23,"endTime":9042.166,"body":"central casting, the same place Mark"},{"startTime":9042.166,"endTime":9044.301,"body":"Zuckerberg came from and Sam Altman, and"},{"startTime":9044.335,"endTime":9045.503,"body":"why do they all look like that?"},{"startTime":9046.103,"endTime":9047.405,"body":"But anyway, this"},{"startTime":9048.706,"endTime":9051.342,"body":"robot here who's deploying language in"},{"startTime":9051.342,"endTime":9054.745,"body":"this clumsy way, what he's trying to do"},{"startTime":9055.212,"endTime":9057.214,"body":"is trigger your"},{"startTime":9057.248,"endTime":9059.216,"body":"amygdala because you spent"},{"startTime":9060.418,"endTime":9063.054,"body":"the last 25 years"},{"startTime":9063.354,"endTime":9066.223,"body":"thinking terrorism was something."},{"startTime":9066.223,"endTime":9067.758,"body":"And the point is, okay, we're now going"},{"startTime":9067.758,"endTime":9069.693,"body":"to borrow that the same way the"},{"startTime":9069.693,"endTime":9071.562,"body":"Department of Homeland Security declared"},{"startTime":9071.562,"endTime":9073.264,"body":"mystic and malinformation terrorism."},{"startTime":9073.831,"endTime":9075.866,"body":"It's a magic term, and this robot is"},{"startTime":9075.866,"endTime":9078.068,"body":"deploying that magic term in order to"},{"startTime":9078.068,"endTime":9080.104,"body":"portray these people who again, like them"},{"startTime":9080.104,"endTime":9082.073,"body":"or hate them, are not frightening."},{"startTime":9082.506,"endTime":9084.208,"body":"They're not threatening people, they're"},{"startTime":9084.208,"endTime":9085.976,"body":"threatening objects, right?"},{"startTime":9085.976,"endTime":9087.645,"body":"He's portraying them as terrorists"},{"startTime":9087.812,"endTime":9090.648,"body":"because it makes him seem sympathetic,"},{"startTime":9091.315,"endTime":9092.149,"body":"which is not something"},{"startTime":9092.149,"endTime":9093.384,"body":"it's easy to do for a robot."},{"startTime":9093.818,"endTime":9097.021,"body":"But-- Well, he also, I mean, this is"},{"startTime":9097.154,"endTime":9099.623,"body":"perhaps only deserving of a footnote of a"},{"startTime":9099.623,"endTime":9101.125,"body":"footnote, he also invokes"},{"startTime":9101.125,"endTime":9103.694,"body":"the ACLU with great pleasure."},{"startTime":9103.994,"endTime":9105.229,"body":"And so it prompted me to"},{"startTime":9105.229,"endTime":9106.897,"body":"just take a look at the ACLU."},{"startTime":9106.964,"endTime":9109.733,"body":"We've talked for years about how far the"},{"startTime":9109.867,"endTime":9112.369,"body":"ACLU has fallen, but just the very"},{"startTime":9112.369,"endTime":9113.471,"body":"beginning of their site."},{"startTime":9113.938,"endTime":9114.905,"body":"Can you see it here?"},{"startTime":9115.139,"endTime":9115.439,"body":"No?"},{"startTime":9115.673,"endTime":9116.373,"body":"Okay, why?"},{"startTime":9116.44,"endTime":9117.174,"body":"Nothing changed."},{"startTime":9118.976,"endTime":9120.845,"body":"Okay, maybe now."},{"startTime":9124.582,"endTime":9125.182,"body":"Can you see it now?"},{"startTime":9125.249,"endTime":9125.516,"body":"Cool."},{"startTime":9127.284,"endTime":9128.352,"body":"ACLU, defend the rights"},{"startTime":9128.352,"endTime":9129.653,"body":"of all people nationwide."},{"startTime":9129.954,"endTime":9131.255,"body":"Okay, sounds good so far."},{"startTime":9131.722,"endTime":9133.457,"body":"With immigrant rights, trans justice,"},{"startTime":9133.457,"endTime":9135.226,"body":"reproductive freedom, and more at risk,"},{"startTime":9135.326,"endTime":9136.76,"body":"we're in courts and communities across"},{"startTime":9136.76,"endTime":9138.095,"body":"the country to protect everyone's rights,"},{"startTime":9138.095,"endTime":9139.864,"body":"and we need you with us, donate now."},{"startTime":9140.164,"endTime":9142.132,"body":"Those are their three top examples of the"},{"startTime":9142.132,"endTime":9143.1,"body":"work that they are doing."},{"startTime":9143.134,"endTime":9145.836,"body":"Immigrant rights, by which they largely"},{"startTime":9145.87,"endTime":9147.004,"body":"do not mean legal"},{"startTime":9147.004,"endTime":9148.405,"body":"immigrants, no, they do not."},{"startTime":9149.406,"endTime":9151.342,"body":"Trans justice, okay, guys."},{"startTime":9151.575,"endTime":9153.744,"body":"And reproductive freedom, by which they"},{"startTime":9153.744,"endTime":9157.081,"body":"mean, of course, because Ro Fell, they"},{"startTime":9157.081,"endTime":9160.284,"body":"are looking to make, the most generous"},{"startTime":9160.284,"endTime":9161.685,"body":"interpretation is they are looking to"},{"startTime":9161.685,"endTime":9164.755,"body":"make abortion available in all 50 states"},{"startTime":9164.755,"endTime":9166.857,"body":"for women who need it, which I am in"},{"startTime":9166.857,"endTime":9169.293,"body":"favor of, but largely that has become"},{"startTime":9169.293,"endTime":9171.395,"body":"such a weaponized and politicized issue"},{"startTime":9171.896,"endTime":9174.298,"body":"beyond what it is inherently by the fact"},{"startTime":9174.298,"endTime":9175.966,"body":"that some people simply feel that it's"},{"startTime":9175.966,"endTime":9177.134,"body":"the wrong decision to make"},{"startTime":9177.134,"endTime":9178.569,"body":"always, and some people don't."},{"startTime":9179.57,"endTime":9181.038,"body":"If those are seriously the top three"},{"startTime":9181.038,"endTime":9183.04,"body":"issues that the ACLU thinks it's"},{"startTime":9183.04,"endTime":9185.276,"body":"defending, then who's"},{"startTime":9185.276,"endTime":9186.677,"body":"donating to them, and why?"},{"startTime":9187.044,"endTime":9190.147,"body":"Yet not only are those conspicuous as a"},{"startTime":9190.181,"endTime":9192.516,"body":"collection of issues, but in some sense,"},{"startTime":9192.516,"endTime":9194.485,"body":"the need for an ACLU, like the need for"},{"startTime":9194.485,"endTime":9196.554,"body":"an FBI, has never been greater, and to"},{"startTime":9196.554,"endTime":9197.888,"body":"have them missing in"},{"startTime":9197.888,"endTime":9200.291,"body":"action is awfully strange."},{"startTime":9200.291,"endTime":9202.026,"body":"It's not like there isn't more important"},{"startTime":9202.026,"endTime":9203.794,"body":"stuff for them to be focused on, and yet"},{"startTime":9204.328,"endTime":9205.629,"body":"they've decided to focus where they"},{"startTime":9205.629,"endTime":9206.764,"body":"focus, which suggests"},{"startTime":9207.031,"endTime":9208.065,"body":"that they've been captured."},{"startTime":9208.265,"endTime":9211.001,"body":"Yeah, you know, maybe for instance, the"},{"startTime":9211.001,"endTime":9213.27,"body":"people who are about to have giant"},{"startTime":9213.27,"endTime":9214.972,"body":"magnetic fields erected outside of their"},{"startTime":9214.972,"endTime":9216.607,"body":"homes are deserving of having several"},{"startTime":9216.607,"endTime":9217.374,"body":"liberties protected."},{"startTime":9217.908,"endTime":9220.411,"body":"I don't know, seems like an issue more"},{"startTime":9220.411,"endTime":9224.215,"body":"important than at least by the taglines"},{"startTime":9224.215,"endTime":9225.849,"body":"here any of these are."},{"startTime":9225.983,"endTime":9226.283,"body":"Yep,"},{"startTime":9227.885,"endTime":9229.019,"body":"so I had a couple more points."},{"startTime":9229.019,"endTime":9230.254,"body":"Have we shown the"},{"startTime":9230.254,"endTime":9232.222,"body":"DFLOC site and their map?"},{"startTime":9232.356,"endTime":9234.024,"body":"People at least ought to be aware of it."},{"startTime":9235.025,"endTime":9238.095,"body":"So DFLOC is an organization that--"},{"startTime":9238.128,"endTime":9239.463,"body":"We showed DFLOC, but I don't know the map"},{"startTime":9239.463,"endTime":9240.13,"body":"you're talking about, is"},{"startTime":9240.13,"endTime":9241.198,"body":"it down on the same page?"},{"startTime":9241.198,"endTime":9241.966,"body":"Yeah, show the map."},{"startTime":9244.868,"endTime":9249.073,"body":"So this map allows you to scan around."},{"startTime":9249.073,"endTime":9250.641,"body":"You can see how many of these things"},{"startTime":9250.641,"endTime":9252.543,"body":"there are, where they're clustered, you"},{"startTime":9252.543,"endTime":9255.045,"body":"can zoom in and you can discover--"},{"startTime":9255.846,"endTime":9256.847,"body":"Montana doesn't have many."},{"startTime":9257.381,"endTime":9258.882,"body":"No, it doesn't."},{"startTime":9258.983,"endTime":9259.75,"body":"Of course it doesn't have many people."},{"startTime":9259.883,"endTime":9260.851,"body":"But anyway, this goes right"},{"startTime":9260.851,"endTime":9262.219,"body":"down to the individual camera."},{"startTime":9262.419,"endTime":9264.521,"body":"I would point out that these are cameras,"},{"startTime":9264.521,"endTime":9267.424,"body":"this is I believe crowdsourced data."},{"startTime":9267.458,"endTime":9268.659,"body":"This is not being supplied"},{"startTime":9268.659,"endTime":9269.76,"body":"by-- Like I saw a camera here."},{"startTime":9269.96,"endTime":9271.395,"body":"Floc, yes, exactly."},{"startTime":9271.929,"endTime":9275.599,"body":"And so there is a substantial"},{"startTime":9277.601,"endTime":9280.404,"body":"effort by people to"},{"startTime":9280.404,"endTime":9281.639,"body":"take these cameras down."},{"startTime":9281.639,"endTime":9284.975,"body":"And you may have seen some very clever"},{"startTime":9284.975,"endTime":9286.71,"body":"videos in which people"},{"startTime":9288.746,"endTime":9292.049,"body":"ironically describe the actions you might"},{"startTime":9292.049,"endTime":9293.817,"body":"take against these cameras as things that"},{"startTime":9293.817,"endTime":9295.419,"body":"you definitely shouldn't do"},{"startTime":9296.987,"endTime":9298.656,"body":"as a way of distributing the information"},{"startTime":9298.656,"endTime":9300.09,"body":"without getting in trouble."},{"startTime":9300.124,"endTime":9301.525,"body":"Anyway, it's all a very humorous thing"},{"startTime":9301.525,"endTime":9302.426,"body":"and I must tell you,"},{"startTime":9303.494,"endTime":9305.262,"body":"whatever you think about such efforts,"},{"startTime":9305.462,"endTime":9307.498,"body":"you gotta be pretty upset that this"},{"startTime":9307.531,"endTime":9310.3,"body":"massive network was deployed raising"},{"startTime":9310.367,"endTime":9312.136,"body":"obvious privacy concerns"},{"startTime":9312.302,"endTime":9314.204,"body":"without us being consulted, right?"},{"startTime":9314.204,"endTime":9317.908,"body":"Just as the data center plan was being"},{"startTime":9317.975,"endTime":9320.744,"body":"erected without any consideration for"},{"startTime":9320.744,"endTime":9322.813,"body":"what the effect was gonna be on people"},{"startTime":9322.813,"endTime":9324.181,"body":"living near these things or what the"},{"startTime":9324.181,"endTime":9328.485,"body":"effect frankly on civilization of the"},{"startTime":9328.485,"endTime":9329.586,"body":"data centers and the thing"},{"startTime":9329.586,"endTime":9330.821,"body":"that they're designed to do."},{"startTime":9331.188,"endTime":9333.19,"body":"But what I want people to"},{"startTime":9334.625,"endTime":9335.959,"body":"keep track of is a couple of things."},{"startTime":9336.16,"endTime":9339.163,"body":"One, when you and I were much younger"},{"startTime":9339.163,"endTime":9341.632,"body":"people, there was an active discussion"},{"startTime":9342.132,"endTime":9344.501,"body":"about the failure or the"},{"startTime":9345.402,"endTime":9348.138,"body":"loss of the cop on the beat."},{"startTime":9348.405,"endTime":9349.907,"body":"And the idea was that actually the"},{"startTime":9349.907,"endTime":9351.575,"body":"relationship between the police and the"},{"startTime":9351.575,"endTime":9353.01,"body":"citizens used to be very different"},{"startTime":9353.41,"endTime":9355.245,"body":"because cops walked a beat and they"},{"startTime":9355.245,"endTime":9356.013,"body":"interacted with the"},{"startTime":9356.013,"endTime":9356.914,"body":"people in the neighborhood."},{"startTime":9356.914,"endTime":9357.347,"body":"So they were an"},{"startTime":9357.347,"endTime":9358.549,"body":"aspect of the neighborhood."},{"startTime":9358.916,"endTime":9361.885,"body":"And then they ended up in patrol cars,"},{"startTime":9361.885,"endTime":9363.654,"body":"which took them to a remove."},{"startTime":9364.088,"endTime":9367.091,"body":"And this is like the ultimate version of"},{"startTime":9367.091,"endTime":9369.693,"body":"that where the cop is really like a"},{"startTime":9369.693,"endTime":9374.431,"body":"little sensor on a pole and will be"},{"startTime":9374.431,"endTime":9376.467,"body":"deployed when the powers that be decide"},{"startTime":9376.467,"endTime":9377.334,"body":"that the thing in"},{"startTime":9377.334,"endTime":9379.77,"body":"question is important enough."},{"startTime":9380.104,"endTime":9381.305,"body":"Same thing happened to medicine."},{"startTime":9381.638,"endTime":9383.44,"body":"Same thing happens across all systems."},{"startTime":9383.741,"endTime":9385.209,"body":"Maybe humanity doesn't scale."},{"startTime":9385.876,"endTime":9387.177,"body":"Right, that's the thing."},{"startTime":9387.211,"endTime":9390.547,"body":"The market for all of its genius has a"},{"startTime":9390.547,"endTime":9392.349,"body":"defect, which is that it is going to"},{"startTime":9392.85,"endTime":9394.051,"body":"promote the most"},{"startTime":9394.084,"endTime":9395.919,"body":"efficient way of doing something."},{"startTime":9395.919,"endTime":9398.322,"body":"And sometimes the efficient way is"},{"startTime":9398.355,"endTime":9400.624,"body":"destructive of the values at the core of"},{"startTime":9400.624,"endTime":9401.759,"body":"the system that you're building."},{"startTime":9401.759,"endTime":9404.228,"body":"So, yes, we all, I wouldn't use the"},{"startTime":9404.228,"endTime":9405.462,"body":"phrase law and order, that"},{"startTime":9405.462,"endTime":9408.432,"body":"one's charged, but we all want"},{"startTime":9409.767,"endTime":9411.335,"body":"equal protection under the law."},{"startTime":9411.368,"endTime":9415.005,"body":"We want the law to be fair and reasonable"},{"startTime":9415.139,"endTime":9417.574,"body":"to result in a very low rate of crime."},{"startTime":9417.775,"endTime":9418.876,"body":"We all want those things, every"},{"startTime":9418.876,"endTime":9420.144,"body":"reasonable person does."},{"startTime":9420.844,"endTime":9422.079,"body":"This is not about that."},{"startTime":9422.079,"endTime":9423.747,"body":"This is about policing on the cheap."},{"startTime":9424.014,"endTime":9426.283,"body":"It's about creating a system with a"},{"startTime":9426.283,"endTime":9428.919,"body":"rational explanation that will be abused"},{"startTime":9428.952,"endTime":9431.355,"body":"by the powerful for their own purposes."},{"startTime":9431.955,"endTime":9436.894,"body":"Consider for a moment the opportunity to"},{"startTime":9436.927,"endTime":9439.73,"body":"create a false pattern of evidence."},{"startTime":9439.797,"endTime":9442.199,"body":"If you want actually to frame somebody"},{"startTime":9442.199,"endTime":9444.268,"body":"with a system like this, you can create"},{"startTime":9444.268,"endTime":9445.102,"body":"the impression that their"},{"startTime":9445.102,"endTime":9446.603,"body":"car went from here to there."},{"startTime":9447.704,"endTime":9449.64,"body":"Obviously that won't be among the first"},{"startTime":9449.64,"endTime":9453.01,"body":"use cases, but the opportunity to do such"},{"startTime":9453.01,"endTime":9455.445,"body":"things with a relatively low resolution"},{"startTime":9455.445,"endTime":9456.447,"body":"camera uploading to the"},{"startTime":9456.447,"endTime":9458.916,"body":"cloud, can these things be spoofed?"},{"startTime":9459.016,"endTime":9460.217,"body":"How good is the security?"},{"startTime":9460.217,"endTime":9463.287,"body":"Can somebody send a feed up as if it"},{"startTime":9463.287,"endTime":9465.656,"body":"comes from a particular Flock camera that"},{"startTime":9465.656,"endTime":9467.224,"body":"leaves the impression that this car"},{"startTime":9467.224,"endTime":9468.826,"body":"passed by here at this moment?"},{"startTime":9469.293,"endTime":9471.061,"body":"The opportunity for"},{"startTime":9471.061,"endTime":9473.096,"body":"abuse is through the roof."},{"startTime":9473.73,"endTime":9475.766,"body":"And then the final thing is, well, what"},{"startTime":9475.766,"endTime":9477.267,"body":"is this all really for?"},{"startTime":9477.434,"endTime":9479.036,"body":"And I think it's kind of obvious."},{"startTime":9479.036,"endTime":9481.638,"body":"If you look at the push towards"},{"startTime":9482.206,"endTime":9485.175,"body":"tokenization of assets, towards central"},{"startTime":9485.175,"endTime":9486.743,"body":"bank digital currencies, that is"},{"startTime":9486.743,"endTime":9488.645,"body":"programmable money that can be turned off"},{"startTime":9488.645,"endTime":9490.714,"body":"if you displease the powers that be."},{"startTime":9490.981,"endTime":9492.583,"body":"If you look at the creation of these"},{"startTime":9492.583,"endTime":9495.185,"body":"massive data centers, is that really"},{"startTime":9495.185,"endTime":9497.955,"body":"about citizen use of AI?"},{"startTime":9498.121,"endTime":9500.791,"body":"Maybe, some of it is, but is it really"},{"startTime":9500.791,"endTime":9503.293,"body":"about creating a storehouse of"},{"startTime":9503.293,"endTime":9505.429,"body":"information that will allow you to be"},{"startTime":9505.429,"endTime":9507.865,"body":"controlled and locked down?"},{"startTime":9508.665,"endTime":9510.467,"body":"That's certainly the impression I have,"},{"startTime":9510.634,"endTime":9511.401,"body":"and we didn't have a"},{"startTime":9511.401,"endTime":9512.87,"body":"discussion about any of this."},{"startTime":9513.136,"endTime":9515.405,"body":"This is happening, and then we have to"},{"startTime":9515.405,"endTime":9518.809,"body":"react to it because it's all on a freight"},{"startTime":9518.809,"endTime":9522.079,"body":"train, headed down the line, and we're"},{"startTime":9522.079,"endTime":9523.247,"body":"always playing defense."},{"startTime":9523.714,"endTime":9525.048,"body":"So it's"},{"startTime":9527.317,"endTime":9528.418,"body":"pretty frightening stuff."},{"startTime":9528.986,"endTime":9531.288,"body":"And at some level, we"},{"startTime":9531.288,"endTime":9532.656,"body":"have a moral right to object."},{"startTime":9532.689,"endTime":9533.523,"body":"We're not being given the"},{"startTime":9533.523,"endTime":9534.958,"body":"opportunity to object, and"},{"startTime":9536.159,"endTime":9538.695,"body":"hence the current discussion about people"},{"startTime":9538.962,"endTime":9539.83,"body":"tearing these things"},{"startTime":9539.83,"endTime":9540.797,"body":"down if they're on volition."},{"startTime":9541.899,"endTime":9543.634,"body":"That was an excellent little soliloquy."},{"startTime":9543.8,"endTime":9546.703,"body":"I'm reminded of what I think is"},{"startTime":9548.472,"endTime":9550.541,"body":"observation, a truism of yours"},{"startTime":9551.575,"endTime":9553.076,"body":"that is one of these things that feels"},{"startTime":9553.11,"endTime":9554.211,"body":"obvious in retrospect."},{"startTime":9554.545,"endTime":9558.048,"body":"And you may have a more concise or"},{"startTime":9558.081,"endTime":9560.15,"body":"elegant way of saying it, but it's"},{"startTime":9560.15,"endTime":9561.184,"body":"something like every good"},{"startTime":9561.184,"endTime":9562.552,"body":"system requires discretion,"},{"startTime":9563.854,"endTime":9567.658,"body":"that any system that entirely removes all"},{"startTime":9567.691,"endTime":9570.761,"body":"human influence from it, and simply"},{"startTime":9570.761,"endTime":9572.896,"body":"allows for the aggregate, the machine,"},{"startTime":9572.963,"endTime":9575.866,"body":"the average, to make the decision that,"},{"startTime":9575.933,"endTime":9577.034,"body":"again, on average,"},{"startTime":9577.034,"endTime":9578.268,"body":"would be the right decision,"},{"startTime":9579.97,"endTime":9583.44,"body":"is going to fail, except in a system that"},{"startTime":9583.44,"endTime":9585.475,"body":"is merely complicated and not complex."},{"startTime":9586.009,"endTime":9589.179,"body":"You need human beings to be able to come"},{"startTime":9589.179,"endTime":9591.014,"body":"in and say, \"Oh, actually, there's"},{"startTime":9591.014,"endTime":9593.417,"body":"mitigating factors that the AI, or the"},{"startTime":9593.417,"endTime":9595.986,"body":"statistics, or the model could not"},{"startTime":9595.986,"endTime":9597.554,"body":"account for, did not want to account for,"},{"startTime":9597.554,"endTime":9599.156,"body":"would not account for, whatever it is,"},{"startTime":9599.156,"endTime":9601.191,"body":"but I, human, am going to have my"},{"startTime":9601.191,"endTime":9604.861,"body":"humanity override your machine thinking.\""},{"startTime":9605.462,"endTime":9607.998,"body":"And increasingly, we need to remind"},{"startTime":9607.998,"endTime":9611.001,"body":"ourselves that the error we're living in"},{"startTime":9611.435,"endTime":9614.838,"body":"is actively interested in, as you say,"},{"startTime":9614.838,"endTime":9617.608,"body":"efficiency over effectiveness, often."},{"startTime":9617.674,"endTime":9620.544,"body":"It claims to do both, and the words are"},{"startTime":9620.544,"endTime":9622.112,"body":"so similar in English that it feels like"},{"startTime":9622.112,"endTime":9622.98,"body":"they're the same things,"},{"startTime":9622.98,"endTime":9624.281,"body":"and they're anything but."},{"startTime":9624.614,"endTime":9626.316,"body":"Efficiency and effectiveness are anything"},{"startTime":9626.316,"endTime":9629.653,"body":"but the same, and we need the"},{"startTime":9630.887,"endTime":9633.657,"body":"error capacity, not just the ability to"},{"startTime":9633.657,"endTime":9636.059,"body":"think outside the averages, but frankly,"},{"startTime":9636.059,"endTime":9638.095,"body":"also the ability to make errors and"},{"startTime":9638.095,"endTime":9640.364,"body":"correct them of the individual human"},{"startTime":9640.364,"endTime":9642.866,"body":"being with discretion in a system,"},{"startTime":9643.266,"endTime":9645.902,"body":"because if we hand it over entirely to"},{"startTime":9645.902,"endTime":9649.439,"body":"the machines, to the Flock cameras, to"},{"startTime":9649.439,"endTime":9652.075,"body":"the data centers, to the AI,"},{"startTime":9652.709,"endTime":9655.045,"body":"we will become assimilated."},{"startTime":9655.312,"endTime":9657.514,"body":"I mean, that's inherently what it is"},{"startTime":9657.514,"endTime":9659.282,"body":"asking of us, to be"},{"startTime":9659.282,"endTime":9660.65,"body":"assimilated, to lose our humanity."},{"startTime":9661.485,"endTime":9662.252,"body":"Yes,"},{"startTime":9662.786,"endTime":9665.288,"body":"well, you need discretion for any of"},{"startTime":9665.288,"endTime":9666.39,"body":"these systems to work."},{"startTime":9666.556,"endTime":9668.625,"body":"That discretion has to be wielded by"},{"startTime":9668.625,"endTime":9670.594,"body":"something that's mission aligned, and"},{"startTime":9670.594,"endTime":9673.163,"body":"what we're getting instead is a whole lot"},{"startTime":9673.163,"endTime":9675.766,"body":"of discretion being wielded by people who"},{"startTime":9675.766,"endTime":9677.0,"body":"are indifferent to us."},{"startTime":9677.134,"endTime":9677.768,"body":"That's really the"},{"startTime":9677.768,"endTime":9679.336,"body":"point, is they have decided."},{"startTime":9679.403,"endTime":9680.203,"body":"They have discretion."},{"startTime":9680.237,"endTime":9682.606,"body":"They have discretion, and they have"},{"startTime":9682.606,"endTime":9683.907,"body":"enough discernment that they're not gonna"},{"startTime":9683.907,"endTime":9684.908,"body":"do this to themselves."},{"startTime":9685.542,"endTime":9686.977,"body":"They're gonna do it to the rest of us,"},{"startTime":9687.244,"endTime":9689.112,"body":"and we don't get to say anything about it"},{"startTime":9689.112,"endTime":9691.415,"body":"because somehow the consent of the"},{"startTime":9691.415,"endTime":9695.085,"body":"governed has failed in the corruption of"},{"startTime":9695.185,"endTime":9698.955,"body":"government and the shift in the way power"},{"startTime":9698.955,"endTime":9701.324,"body":"is wielded, right, so that corporate"},{"startTime":9701.324,"endTime":9704.795,"body":"power exists in a way that is not, you"},{"startTime":9704.795,"endTime":9705.829,"body":"know, we've got international"},{"startTime":9705.829,"endTime":9708.298,"body":"corporations, and we don't have a"},{"startTime":9708.298,"endTime":9710.834,"body":"structure that can properly regulate"},{"startTime":9710.834,"endTime":9712.335,"body":"their behavior or monitor"},{"startTime":9712.335,"endTime":9713.737,"body":"their intent or anything like that."},{"startTime":9714.304,"endTime":9715.906,"body":"So we are sort of suffering"},{"startTime":9715.906,"endTime":9717.974,"body":"the downside of discretion"},{"startTime":9719.076,"endTime":9720.444,"body":"where nothing is wielding it on our"},{"startTime":9720.444,"endTime":9723.346,"body":"behalf and something is wielding it as a"},{"startTime":9723.346,"endTime":9726.416,"body":"result of, you know, I don't know,"},{"startTime":9726.616,"endTime":9728.351,"body":"meetings that they've"},{"startTime":9728.418,"endTime":9730.187,"body":"held where they've decided"},{"startTime":9731.655,"endTime":9734.725,"body":"how it is that we are supposed to, not"},{"startTime":9734.725,"endTime":9736.126,"body":"only how it is that we are supposed to"},{"startTime":9736.126,"endTime":9738.428,"body":"live, but how we are"},{"startTime":9738.428,"endTime":9740.03,"body":"supposed to feel about it."},{"startTime":9741.064,"endTime":9741.431,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":9741.731,"endTime":9742.232,"body":"You know?"},{"startTime":9742.332,"endTime":9744.267,"body":"Yeah, and then we come full circle then"},{"startTime":9744.267,"endTime":9745.902,"body":"to what the story we started with,"},{"startTime":9746.937,"endTime":9749.94,"body":"that we are being hamstrung, we are being"},{"startTime":9749.973,"endTime":9754.111,"body":"corralled and contained and averaged and"},{"startTime":9754.745,"endTime":9756.546,"body":"told that efficiencies are what matter"},{"startTime":9756.98,"endTime":9760.484,"body":"rather than qualities that we may choose"},{"startTime":9760.517,"endTime":9763.353,"body":"to value around truth seeking or beauty"},{"startTime":9763.754,"endTime":9766.423,"body":"or movement or any number of things,"},{"startTime":9766.423,"endTime":9767.657,"body":"connection, humanity,"},{"startTime":9767.657,"endTime":9769.459,"body":"relationship, any of these things."},{"startTime":9769.76,"endTime":9773.563,"body":"We must have their values, and in order"},{"startTime":9773.563,"endTime":9776.433,"body":"to keep us thinking the way they want, we"},{"startTime":9776.466,"endTime":9778.969,"body":"are going to have all of the information"},{"startTime":9778.969,"endTime":9781.238,"body":"coming at us that we do not experience in"},{"startTime":9781.238,"endTime":9783.707,"body":"real time with another human being"},{"startTime":9783.74,"endTime":9786.343,"body":"suspect because we never know what it"},{"startTime":9786.343,"endTime":9787.644,"body":"actually means or where it came from."},{"startTime":9788.278,"endTime":9789.246,"body":"Yeah, yeah."},{"startTime":9789.346,"endTime":9789.713,"body":"It's,"},{"startTime":9792.349,"endTime":9795.085,"body":"we're gonna have to get better at playing"},{"startTime":9795.085,"endTime":9797.621,"body":"this game because it's going to be one"},{"startTime":9797.621,"endTime":9799.89,"body":"front after the next in part because the"},{"startTime":9799.89,"endTime":9802.259,"body":"actual objective is pretty clear."},{"startTime":9802.425,"endTime":9804.528,"body":"It's frightening, it's strange, and it's"},{"startTime":9804.528,"endTime":9806.396,"body":"a little bit hard to believe once you see"},{"startTime":9806.396,"endTime":9808.365,"body":"it, but it's not an accident that we're"},{"startTime":9808.365,"endTime":9812.402,"body":"looking at universal surveillance and a"},{"startTime":9812.402,"endTime":9813.603,"body":"shift in currency that"},{"startTime":9813.637,"endTime":9816.072,"body":"provides near perfect control."},{"startTime":9816.373,"endTime":9817.808,"body":"You know, it's not an accident that"},{"startTime":9817.808,"endTime":9819.609,"body":"that's happening all at once, and it's"},{"startTime":9819.609,"endTime":9821.211,"body":"not an accident that it is happening"},{"startTime":9821.278,"endTime":9823.413,"body":"internationally across the West."},{"startTime":9823.713,"endTime":9826.75,"body":"That's a part of some kind of plan, and"},{"startTime":9827.951,"endTime":9830.554,"body":"it's a completely unacceptable plan, and"},{"startTime":9830.854,"endTime":9834.591,"body":"it is largely being protected by the fact"},{"startTime":9834.591,"endTime":9836.459,"body":"that people find it hard to imagine that"},{"startTime":9836.459,"endTime":9837.494,"body":"anybody would do that to them."},{"startTime":9839.262,"endTime":9840.163,"body":"It is unimaginable,"},{"startTime":9841.198,"endTime":9841.832,"body":"and yet true."},{"startTime":9842.065,"endTime":9842.766,"body":"And yet true."},{"startTime":9842.833,"endTime":9843.4,"body":"And yet true."},{"startTime":9844.467,"endTime":9844.801,"body":"Okay,"},{"startTime":9845.869,"endTime":9847.003,"body":"we're gonna be back."},{"startTime":9847.27,"endTime":9848.772,"body":"Let me actually just give a plug."},{"startTime":9848.872,"endTime":9851.675,"body":"I am continuing to publish \"Cobadara"},{"startTime":9851.741,"endTime":9854.177,"body":"Stories\" on natural selections, and we'll"},{"startTime":9854.177,"endTime":9854.978,"body":"put a link to that in"},{"startTime":9854.978,"endTime":9855.946,"body":"the show notes as well."},{"startTime":9856.846,"endTime":9860.684,"body":"They are extraordinary, and I still have,"},{"startTime":9860.684,"endTime":9862.385,"body":"I closed down the submissions because I"},{"startTime":9862.385,"endTime":9864.654,"body":"got so many in the first month that I"},{"startTime":9864.654,"endTime":9866.189,"body":"still have dozens that I haven't even"},{"startTime":9866.189,"endTime":9869.292,"body":"looked at and responded to yet, and"},{"startTime":9869.593,"endTime":9872.028,"body":"several in the hopper yet."},{"startTime":9872.062,"endTime":9872.629,"body":"They are"},{"startTime":9873.763,"endTime":9875.632,"body":"remarkable with regard to the diversity"},{"startTime":9875.632,"endTime":9877.033,"body":"of experience that people have had and"},{"startTime":9877.033,"endTime":9878.168,"body":"also where they're coming from."},{"startTime":9878.535,"endTime":9880.17,"body":"So certainly a lot out of the United"},{"startTime":9880.17,"endTime":9882.138,"body":"States, but from really all over the"},{"startTime":9882.138,"endTime":9884.241,"body":"world, all the demographics, all the"},{"startTime":9884.241,"endTime":9886.276,"body":"experiences you might imagine, and I"},{"startTime":9886.309,"endTime":9887.744,"body":"encourage you to go look."},{"startTime":9887.744,"endTime":9890.28,"body":"I've heard from people who say,"},{"startTime":9891.881,"endTime":9894.517,"body":"people who have submitted stories and"},{"startTime":9894.517,"endTime":9896.953,"body":"people who have not, who say, \"I didn't"},{"startTime":9896.953,"endTime":9898.688,"body":"know how much I needed this."},{"startTime":9898.755,"endTime":9900.757,"body":"I didn't know, I"},{"startTime":9900.79,"endTime":9902.926,"body":"thought, because I lived this"},{"startTime":9904.394,"endTime":9905.095,"body":"era, and it was so"},{"startTime":9905.095,"endTime":9906.463,"body":"recent, and I was fighting it.\""},{"startTime":9906.463,"endTime":9908.398,"body":"And so I thought watching people forget,"},{"startTime":9908.398,"endTime":9911.701,"body":"go through the memory holding of it all"},{"startTime":9911.701,"endTime":9914.037,"body":"that I still remembered, but each one of"},{"startTime":9914.037,"endTime":9916.206,"body":"these stories for many people has brought"},{"startTime":9916.206,"endTime":9917.841,"body":"something else back, like, \"Oh, right,"},{"startTime":9918.074,"endTime":9920.01,"body":"that did happen,\" or, \"Oh my goodness, I"},{"startTime":9920.01,"endTime":9921.044,"body":"didn't know that was happening.\""},{"startTime":9921.645,"endTime":9924.781,"body":"So, and it's not, overall, I don't find"},{"startTime":9924.781,"endTime":9926.983,"body":"it a depressing exercise."},{"startTime":9927.183,"endTime":9929.352,"body":"I think I encourage you to read them"},{"startTime":9930.353,"endTime":9932.722,"body":"in order to continue to make sense of"},{"startTime":9932.722,"endTime":9935.525,"body":"what happened to us in 2020"},{"startTime":9935.792,"endTime":9937.394,"body":"through now at some level."},{"startTime":9937.394,"endTime":9937.861,"body":"But like"},{"startTime":9938.962,"endTime":9942.465,"body":"the authoritarianism that became so"},{"startTime":9942.465,"endTime":9944.367,"body":"impossible to ignore, even though many"},{"startTime":9944.367,"endTime":9946.936,"body":"people had seen it before, that there are"},{"startTime":9946.936,"endTime":9948.505,"body":"many more people whose eyes are open and"},{"startTime":9948.505,"endTime":9949.606,"body":"won't close again, yeah."},{"startTime":9950.34,"endTime":9952.942,"body":"Yeah, it's cathartic."},{"startTime":9952.942,"endTime":9955.078,"body":"And I think it's galvanizing."},{"startTime":9955.812,"endTime":9957.614,"body":"It's amazing how successful they were at"},{"startTime":9957.614,"endTime":9960.884,"body":"hiding and bringing those stories back at"},{"startTime":9960.884,"endTime":9965.088,"body":"the very personal level of detail is how"},{"startTime":9965.088,"endTime":9966.122,"body":"we're going to remember."},{"startTime":9966.456,"endTime":9967.457,"body":"Yeah, that's right."},{"startTime":9968.625,"endTime":9970.293,"body":"Okay, so we'll have a Q\u0026A"},{"startTime":9970.293,"endTime":9972.829,"body":"on Sunday, 11 a.m. to 1 p.m."},{"startTime":9972.829,"endTime":9973.43,"body":"Pacific."},{"startTime":9973.43,"endTime":9976.399,"body":"You can go on Locals and find a place to"},{"startTime":9976.399,"endTime":9977.467,"body":"ask your questions now."},{"startTime":9977.467,"endTime":9978.735,"body":"We have a lot of fun with those and we"},{"startTime":9978.735,"endTime":9979.636,"body":"interact with the chat."},{"startTime":9980.27,"endTime":9981.871,"body":"And then our next livestream is gonna be"},{"startTime":9981.871,"endTime":9983.473,"body":"next Tuesday, rather than Wednesday."},{"startTime":9985.408,"endTime":9988.411,"body":"We have our sponsors this week."},{"startTime":9988.411,"endTime":9991.047,"body":"We're American Financing, Caraway \u0026 Dose,"},{"startTime":9991.081,"endTime":9993.016,"body":"all awesome, check them out."},{"startTime":9993.717,"endTime":9997.42,"body":"And until you see us next time, be good"},{"startTime":9997.42,"endTime":9998.688,"body":"to the ones you love, eat"},{"startTime":9998.688,"endTime":10000.49,"body":"real food, and get outside."},{"startTime":10000.824,"endTime":10001.491,"body":"Be well, everyone."},{"startTime":10002.726,"endTime":10004.794,"body":"(Upbeat Music)"}]}