Science of Reading: The Podcast
Science of Reading: The Podcast will deliver the latest insights from researchers and practitioners in early reading. Via a conversational approach, each episode explores a timely topic related to the science of reading.
Science of Reading: The Podcast
S11 E3: Tier 1: Your MTSS Foundation, with Sarah Brown, Ph.D.
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
While Tier 1 instruction is the foundation of a successful Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS), it is also the element we most often overlook. On this episode of Science of Reading: The Podcast, Sarah Brown, Ph.D., consultant and co-author of Effective Universal Instruction: An Action-Oriented Approach to Improving Tier 1, joins host Susan Lambert, Ed.D., to explore why this is and what it takes to give Tier 1 the attention it deserves. Together, Sarah and Susan also discuss common misconceptions about Tier 1; why a strong Tier 1 directly determines how targeted and intensive your interventions can be; and how to use data to assess whether your Tier 1 is truly working.
Show notes:
- Download our free companion MTSS ebook!
- Learn more about building a sustainable, data-informed MTSS.
- Read Effective Universal Instruction by Sarah Brown, Kim Gibbons, and Brad Niebling.
- Read Routines for Reading Results by Sarah Brown
- Learn more about System Impact Consulting.
- Connect with Sarah Brown on LinkedIn.
- Listen to Season 3 of Amplify’s Beyond My Years podcast.
- Subscribe to Susan’s new Science of Reading Substack.
- Join our Science of Reading community Facebook group.
- Connect with Susan Lambert.
Quotes:
"Our labels don't define our students' skills and abilities. The quality and intensity of our instruction is really what matters." —Sarah Brown
"We are running ourselves ragged trying to provide intervention for too many students." —Sarah Brown
"Tier 1 instruction really deserves the same love and attention as your interventions and other tiers." —Sarah Brown
"MTSS is a framework, not a roadmap, which means it doesn't look the same in every school." —Sarah Brown
Timestamps*:
0:00 Introduction: Tier 1: The MTSS foundation, with Sarah Brown
3:00 Sarah Brown's background and path to MTSS
6:00 Defining Tier 1 instruction
10:00 What an effective Tier 1 looks like
14:00 Why a strong Tier 1 enables targeted intervention
17:00 Using data to assess your Tier 1
21:00 Common misconceptions about Tier 1
22:00 What Tier 1 intervention looks like
27:00 Common themes in Tier 1
38:00 Effective Universal Instruction and closing thoughts
*Timestamps are approximate, rounded to nearest minute
[00:00:00] Sarah Brown: We are running ourselves ragged trying to provide intervention for too many students.
[00:00:10] Susan Lambert: This is Susan Lambert, and welcome to Science of Reading: The Podcast from Amplify. We're on to Episode 3 of this MTSS season. So far, we've explored the philosophy at the heart of a Multi-Tiered System of Supports, and we've gotten an overview of the pillars of an effective MTSS. Now, it's time to put the spotlight on each of those foundational elements.
[00:00:35] First up, core instruction. In this episode, we'll explore why core instruction may indeed be the most important element of MTSS, how it fits and connects with the rest of the system, what strong core instruction looks like, and some common misconceptions. To explore all of that, I'm joined by Dr. Sarah Brown, consultant and president of System Impact Consulting.
[00:01:03] She's the co-author of the books Effective Universal Instruction, MTSS for Reading Improvement, and Routines for Reading Results. She previously served as bureau chief leading special education and MTSS implementation for Iowa. Sarah is the right person for this conversation about MTSS and core instruction.
[00:01:27] And before we dive in, a quick note. We've put together a new e-book to complement the season. Download this free resource on implementing a Multi-Tiered System of Supports for literacy at amplify.com/mtssebook. There's also a link in the show notes. Okay, let's bring Sarah on now.
[00:01:49] Well, Dr. Sarah Brown, thank you so much for joining us on today's episode. Great to have you here.
[00:01:55] Sarah Brown: Thank you for having me. I'm excited to be here.
[00:01:57] Susan Lambert: I would tell our listeners a story of how we met at a conference sitting at a bar, but they might not be as interested in that as we thought it was interesting.
[00:02:06] Sarah Brown: It was. It was a great evening.
[00:02:09] Susan Lambert: We would love if you could tell our listeners just a little bit about your journey into education and maybe why MTSS, which is going to be part of our topic today, why that became of particular interest to you.
[00:02:23] Sarah Brown: Sure. So I've worked at every, just about every level of education, so from the building level as a school psychologist to a district leader and then a state leader. Now I consult full time. I work with schools around the country. I'm helping them to take evidence-based practices and turn them into practical, actionable supports for teachers and students.
[00:02:47] And, you know, school psychs get a whole year of an internship, which is a gift, where we get to practice and study at the same time, so it's cool. And I came from a really different type of school psychology program than a lot of school psychologists have, where it's very instruction focused. And in my program, my advisor told me I was going to be teaching a reading group every day for that whole year.
[00:03:13] Susan Lambert: Wow.
[00:03:14] Sarah Brown: And secret... Yeah, I know, I know. And secretly, I was wondering, you know, "Why am I going to need to know how to teach reading? I'm a school psychologist, not a teacher." And which is now I realize the silliest thing I ever could have thought. Luckily, I didn't say it out loud until apparently now on a podcast, a very popular one.
[00:03:31] But what happened was really life-changing for me. I taught four first-grade boys, and... four or five... at the end of the year, all four to five.... It's been decades.... were on track readers, all of them.
[00:03:45] Susan Lambert: Wow.
[00:03:45] Sarah Brown: And yeah. All year long, though, I had really great training. I had an amazing program, and I progress monitored them all year long using a curriculum-based measure. And then we adapted based on how they were responding. And I learned two things, really.
[00:04:02] One, high-quality instruction really matters, and then also that all kids can learn, that our labels don't define our students' skills and abilities, that the quality and intensity of our instruction is really what matters.
[00:04:18] And so that really set the trajectory of my career at that point in time, and it really got me interested in what we now call MTSS. Before it was, I mean, decades before it was called that. My dissertation became about MTSS. It was all about screening then. And I was really fortunate through my early roles to have fantastic professional experiences and mentors who were using data to support students and teachers, and it really just helped me really build an understanding about and passion for data and system-wide supports.
[00:04:57] Susan Lambert: That's an amazing story because too often we hear people that are going into education or are in the classroom or support staff in the building, "We weren't prepared for this. We didn't know what it meant to teach reading." And you had a strong foundation that led you then on this trajectory.
[00:05:15] Sarah Brown: Well, I mean, sadly, I think it's because I wasn't trained as a teacher. That's the scary part, Susan. That's the scary part, is that it was because I wasn't trained as a teacher, which is really scary. I didn't know that at the time. I really thought that everybody was getting training in these same practices.
[00:05:35] Susan Lambert: Hmm. And I bet in hindsight you are very grateful for that because it sounds like now you're impacting and working with schools all over the country to try to help figure this thing out, which the thing we're going to talk about.
[00:05:49] Well, one of the things we know about the MTSS system is the importance of universal instruction, sometimes called Tier 1 instruction, sometimes called core instruction.
[00:06:00] Can you help us understand what exactly do those terms mean?
[00:06:04] Sarah Brown: Yeah, absolutely. So Tier 1 instruction is really the foundation upon which everything else in your MTSS, your Multi-Tiered System of Supports, is built. So it's not really the flashy part of an MTSS. Nobody, nobody comes to an MTSS thinking about Tier 1.
[00:06:23] Well, if you have, then you should pat yourself on the back right now, but most people don't. But it really is the most essential part to your success of the entire system. We don't see schools, I don't see schools that end up seeing a real growth in overall student outcomes that aren't thinking about their Tier 1.
[00:06:44] You don't focus on just your Tier 2, just your Tier 3, and see dramatic growth in student outcomes. So it includes your core curriculum materials, so those curriculum materials that you're using, your evidence-based instructional strategies that maybe all your teachers in grade level are agreeing to use, so maybe your vocabulary routine that you're using that's common across everybody.
[00:07:09] It also includes your differentiation that you're using in order to help students meet those grade-level learning targets and your daily learning targets, and then the assessment that you use with all students, so your universal screening measures, your curriculum-embedded assessments, so if you have assessments every 5 or 10 lessons in your programs, and then your daily formative assessments that you're using during your instruction that helps you determine what you might reteach or how you might determine your next steps as you teach.
[00:07:43] Susan Lambert: So, you know, I often think about Tier 1 instruction being, or universal instruction being the forgotten element of MTSS. So you alluded to that. Why do you think, why do you think it has been that forgotten element in the past?
[00:07:58] Sarah Brown: You know, I think, I mean, I would ask you this question, too. I think our brains are wired to like new things. And so I think we like the new. I had a principal once in a training we were doing a statewide training, and a principal almost called me over and said, "You know, we've been working on Tier 1 for 15 years, Sarah. I want some new Tier 2 ideas."
[00:08:22] And so I think that we want some new ideas, and we look to Tier 2, and so we're looking for new interventions. We like that idea of looking for that. I think it feels heavy. But I'm interested in your thoughts, too, around that.
[00:08:36] And I also think that students who struggle to learn to read or that are at the forefront of our minds are the ones that we're thinking about every single day. They're the ones that are keeping us up at night. And so they're also the ones that we're thinking about right now, and it feels like we need to help them first.
[00:08:56] They do need attention, but we're never... The truth is, we're not going to be able to give those students the attention they need in order to truly close their learning gaps if we don't have a strong Tier 1.
[00:09:09] Susan Lambert: Yeah, that makes sense. And I don't even know how I would answer that question, why it be this forgotten element. And I wonder, too, if it's just a, "Well, of course, we do instruction, universal instruction for all." But I think even me as a classroom teacher never thought about that being the first step of, I mean, really the prevention mechanism.
[00:09:33] 'Cause I think you're right. Those kids that are struggling, we want to just do something different for them, help them right now, and so we don't think about Tier 1. So maybe that's a good segue to say when Tier 1 instruction is working well, what does it actually look like?
[00:09:47] Sarah Brown: Yeah. I mean, the very first thing is let's look at our outcomes, right? Let's use our data to see what it looks like.
[00:09:53] The first thing is that the vast majority of our students are successful without needing additional intervention. That's what it looks like essentially first. However that looks, MTSS is a framework, not a roadmap, which means that it doesn't look the same in every school. It doesn't have to look one way.
[00:10:13] We're going to see across student groups that we have strong outcomes, and we see similar levels of growth. Regardless of if I'm a student who came to the school with a large number of resources at home, or I came to the school with fewer resources at home, I'm making great growth.
[00:10:32] So I'm going to see that. My Tier I is supporting all of our students who came to our school. And so that's the outcome piece. In addition, our teachers are using data continuously to adjust instruction to meet student needs, to help them meet grade-level standards, and our systems are supporting our educators so that they feel equipped and empowered to meet student needs.
[00:10:57] We need educators to feel like they have what they need on a daily basis to meet student needs. They're the ones who are delivering Tier I. They need to feel like they have what they need to do that well.
[00:11:11] Susan Lambert: Yeah. I love that when I asked that question, the first thing you said was outcomes. You pointed right to student learning, and I think that is a bit of a mindset shift from... Of course, I was in the classroom decades ago, but I don't remember the conversation being about student learning. It was about teaching or the program or instruction.
[00:11:35] And so maybe that is part of why we need to start to see universal instruction or Tier 1 instruction as part of MTSS, because what matters is how well the students are doing. What doesn't matter is, "Oh, I'm teaching it. They're just not learning it." That's a shift in mindset.
[00:11:56] Sarah Brown: Yeah. And we can look at... There are evidence-based practices, like when students aren't there, like when we don't have successful Tier 1, then we can look at and ask some questions around why isn't our Tier 1 as successful as we want it to be, and then we'll look at some evidence-based practices that we might want to put into place, that we might need in our school that can help beef it up, that can help intensify it to meet the needs of the learners in our building this year.
[00:12:23] But I can't just sit here and say, "Here are the three practices that you and your school should put in place this year in order to have a successful Tier 1," because it can look differently. There are multiple right ways.
[00:12:35] Susan Lambert: Yeah. I like that. And you said that, too. It's a framework, not a roadmap. I think that is just distilling it to something very simple that people can remember in their head. It's like what works for the school down the road may not be working for my first-grade classroom.
[00:12:51] Sarah Brown: Yeah.
[00:12:52] Susan Lambert: So you alluded to this a little bit, why this Tier 1 instruction is so important. Can you dig in a little bit? Why is it so important, especially for students who need more intervention?
[00:13:06] Sarah Brown: Yeah. So Tier 1 instruction is really critical because it builds a strong foundation, we've already said that, for all students.
[00:13:13] And when the vast majority of students are successful, fewer students require intervention. That means that for the students who do need the intervention, we can provide intervention that's more targeted and that's more intensive.
[00:13:27] Here's what happens in lots of schools today. We are running ourselves ragged trying to provide intervention for too many students. And so in the schools that I'm in across the country, we are providing intervention to a ton of students, and what happens is we're trying, because we're trying to help so many students, we're doing things like if we have a 30-minute intervention block, we cut it into two 15-minute interventions.
[00:13:58] Or we take that block and we provide some students intervention Monday, Wednesday, and some students intervention Tuesday, Thursday. And we do that because we're trying to serve more students. We want to help all of the students. And it makes sense in the moment.
[00:14:12] But here's what ends up happening. We can't provide the intensity that students need in order to catch up. And what happens is none of our students, or very few of them, not enough of them, are making catch-up growth. And we start to become a little bit used to students needing intervention for all of the years and not ever really catching up.
[00:14:37] And so we start to think about, oh, you know, we have these Tier 2 students who are always Tier 2 students, and in reality, our interventions are intended to close learning gaps. And when we have a reasonable number of students who need to access those interventions because our Tier 1 instruction is effective, they can be intensive enough to do that.
[00:15:03] But what's happening, and the real danger of what happens when we are trying to provide interventions to too many students, the real danger of that is that we start to expect five-lesson-a-week growth with two-lesson-a-week intensity. And what I mean by that is we will set our goals for students to be based on what would be a five-lesson-a-week intensity of intervention.
[00:15:34] And when students are only making two-lesson-a-week intensity, 'cause that's all we're really able to provide because we've cut that intensity down 'cause we're serving more students, then we start to look, and because it's the way for almost all of our students that we're providing intervention to, we start to say things like, "Oh, well maybe the goal was too high," or, "Maybe this is all the student can grow. Maybe they're just always going to be a Tier 2 student. Or maybe it's because their parents aren't practicing enough with them at home."
[00:16:04] And so we start to look at some of those within-student factors as being the reason. Maybe it's because they have a disability. And we start to look at some of those within-student factors as being the reason for their lack of progress, when in reality it might be because our Tier 1 instruction isn't as effective as it needs to be in order for our interventions to be as targeted and intensive as they could be.
[00:16:30] Susan Lambert: So you're making the case for a strong Tier 1 both curriculum and instructional practices. How do you help schools recognize that, and what are some of the next steps? I know I'm throwing you a left curveball here.
[00:16:47] Sarah Brown: Yeah. So the way historically that we've looked at that is schools look at their data, either their outcome data or your screening data when you have universal screening data, and they'll set that 80% cut point. That's historically what schools have used, and they've said, "Are 80% of our students meeting targets? And if not, then let's focus on Tier 1."
[00:17:09] Many schools that I work with have never seen 80% of their students on track. And so when I walk in and I say, "Are 80% of your students on track?" people's eyes will roll. And they will say, "Sarah, that's never been the case here. We're never going to hit 80%." And so it doesn't really sell people.
[00:17:26] Susan Lambert: Yeah.
[00:17:27] Sarah Brown: So if you are in a school where you're like, "Sarah, I'm already on board with Tier 1. I'm listening to this podcast because of that today, but I want to convince other people," I actually look at a different question.
[00:17:38] And so we look at the growth that we see over time for just students who started the year on track. So if you take and just look at your students who start the year on track, and then you look at where they are in the middle of the year or the end of the year and see what percentage of those students grew enough to stay on track.
[00:18:07] Susan Lambert: Interesting.
[00:18:07] Sarah Brown: Then what do you see? Because that's just looking... Those students likely only received Tier 1 supports.
[00:18:15] Susan Lambert: Right.
[00:18:16] Sarah Brown: And that actually changes the conversation. I've done that with schools, and I can tell you, in districts where we've had multiple buildings, when we ask that question, I've had districts with 10 buildings where every single school ended up choosing to set a Tier 1 goal the next year when they looked at that question.
[00:18:37] And they looked at data for Tier 1, and then their intervention tiers, and every single building chose to set a Tier 1 goal when they looked at that question. And so that's a really powerful question to ask because we don't always look at our data that way, but it just, that's a way to just tease out our Tier 1 data.
[00:18:54] And then once we know that we're going to focus on Tier 1, then we can start to dig down a little bit and ask the question about why our Tier 1 might not be as effective as we want it to be.
[00:19:06] Susan Lambert: You know, I often hear people talk about, "Well, why should we..." And I know we're not talking about universal screening, but it's so important here... "Why should we, at midyear and end of year, continue to administer a universal screening assessment to a student who's on track at the beginning of the year?" And here's one reason why we should, right?
[00:19:27] Sarah Brown: Yeah. Yeah. It is it is your well-child checkup. That's the best way to describe it. It's your well-child checkup. We go to the doctor whether we're sick or not to make sure not only that we're on track developmentally, but that we're growing enough to stay on track. And this tells us that about each tier.
[00:19:48] So I do that at Tier 1, but I can do the same for our intervention tiers, too. I can also tease out my students who are just receiving intervention. What percentage of those grew enough to catch up? And/or what percentage of those grew enough, like met growth targets. So you can look at those and really look how effective are our intervention systems, how effective are our Tier 1. Yeah, it's really powerful.
[00:20:13] Susan Lambert: So in your work with schools, what are some of the common misconceptions you see or hear about Tier 1 instruction?
[00:20:22] Sarah Brown: Yes. A couple this year right now. So one is that Tier 1 should look the same for everybody. The outcomes are the same. So the standards, the grade-level standards are the same for everyone. But we need to remember that we might need to differentiate sometimes to help students meet those standards.
[00:20:39] So I might teach everybody the same the first time, but then I might need to, accounting for what my students in my class today need, but then I might decide then that I'm going to have some students who are ready for independent practice, while I'm going to pull a small group over to the side to give some repeated maybe "we dos" and "you dos" with feedback before they're ready for independent practice.
[00:21:02] And so that differentiation may occur. It might not look the same for everybody in order to help them meet those grade-level standards. So that's one common misconception is that it needs to look the same for everyone. The outcomes are the same. How to help students get to those outcomes may look a little bit different.
[00:21:19] The second that is, I think, a really big one that we regularly look at is that Tier 1 can't be intensified. We think about the intensifications as being Tier 2 and Tier 3.
[00:21:31] Susan Lambert: Oh, yeah.
[00:21:31] Sarah Brown: But a Tier 1 can be intensified, and we call that in the, in the research, it's called class-wide intervention. I call it Tier 1 intervention.
[00:21:40] So we think about Tier 1 improvement historically as being like we adopt a new curriculum, or we have to spend an entire year doing standard work, like working on our standards. But we can improve our Tier 1 today by doing Tier 1 intervention. It's very simple. It's just extra practice.
[00:22:00] That's all it is. It's very simple. We do it with a whole class or a whole grade. It's really easy, just extra practice. But it's also very hard because of two reasons. The first is that it has to be high-quality practice. The second is that we have to do it every day, and it's hard to do anything in schools every day.
[00:22:19] But when we can do those two things, the payoff is huge. Very, very quickly we see a lot of growth for all students. It's incredible. So if you want to dig deeper into, and the research is called class-wide intervention, also, like Tier 1 intervention, Matt Burns currently does research on it. It's been researched for decades now.
[00:22:41] There are some programs that do it. You can find really great easy-to-use routines that you can just implement in your classroom for five, ten minutes a day. Just extra practice, but it has to be high-quality practice.
[00:22:53] Susan Lambert: Can you provide an example of what that might look like?
[00:22:57] Sarah Brown: Starting in like third grade, for instance, it would be like partner reading with paragraph shrinking, would be a really great evidence-based example. That would be high quality because everybody is doing everything.
[00:23:12] So think about that. Everybody's getting the practice which makes it high quality. So everybody has to do it, just like our kids can't learn to drive by watching us drive.
[00:23:24] If that was the case, that's how we would do it. That'd be fantastic if they could watch us drive and they would learn to drive, sign me up.
[00:23:31] But it doesn't happen. They have to do the driving. Our students have to do the reading. And so partner reading is great, 'cause nobody can take a break.
[00:23:40] Susan Lambert: Right.
[00:23:40] Sarah Brown: The second kids are in groups, somebody's checking out. So partner reading is a great strategy. I can do it every day. I have to make sure, though, that in that moment students are getting feedback immediately, which is why partner reading is a great strategy because somebody can be the coach, somebody can be the reader.
[00:23:58] Susan Lambert: Right. Yep. Yep.
[00:24:00] Sarah Brown: So that's a great strategy that's evidence-based. And it can be as simple in kindergarten as doing like every day some extra quick practice with the sounds we've been learning. Maybe I put them up on slides, and I just very quickly, I'm going to go through them, and we're going to say the sound, then we're going to write the sound on our whiteboard.
[00:24:19] But I'm not going to have a student, the student of the day, do it and call on one student and do it, 'cause that's going to be really slow, and everybody's not going to get the practice. And I might be at a different part of the room, and I can't give a correction if needed. I want it to be really, really quick, and I need it to be... I need it to get lots of reps in in a very short amount of time.
[00:24:43] Those are just very briefly some of the things to be thinking about.
[00:24:48] Susan Lambert: And I wonder how many good teachers do some of that already and don't realize what they're doing is actually a quality Tier 1 intervention to provide students that extra practice.
[00:24:59] Sarah Brown: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The thing we want to do is, this is in addition to what we're already doing. It is not the learning target of today. It's previous learning targets, 'cause we're trying to accelerate growth. Now, we know our students aren't on track, so we're trying to accelerate growth.
[00:25:17] We're giving it to everybody, not just students who've been identified for intervention, and we're adding it on to our already... our Tier 1. So we can replace independent work time, or we can find an extra 10 minutes of the day where we might, where we might do that, that's been historically independent work time or time of the day.
[00:25:36] Susan Lambert: Yeah. That makes sense. And what you said is instruction for all kids. So that means it's even going to benefit those kids that need more intensive intervention outside of the core, right?
[00:25:47] Sarah Brown: A hundred percent, yeah. It benefits everybody, and frankly, it also benefits students who are already on track because here's what we know.
[00:25:54] This is extra practice. Practice is great for everybody. Think about musical instruments and sports. There aren't students who we say can stop practicing their sport. Even our best athletes are still practicing. Our best musicians are still practicing. They have to practice every day, even when they're strong. What we don't do every day is provide the extra "I do, we do, you do."
[00:26:19] If I already am a strong driver, I don't ... When I go into Hertz and rent cars as I travel for work, if they made me watch a video about how to drive a new Jeep even though I don't have a Jeep at home, like I, that would be awful. I'd go to Avis next door. I don't need to watch a video, but getting extra practice is always okay. Even for our on-track readers, that extra practice every day is fine. It's fine.
[00:26:45] Susan Lambert: Yeah. Doesn't hurt them.
[00:26:45] Sarah Brown: They're still going to grow. No.
[00:26:47] Susan Lambert: Doesn't hurt them at all. Yeah, that's great.
[00:26:49] Any other misconceptions before we move into themes, common themes?
[00:26:53] Sarah Brown: No, I think those, those are two great ones. Yeah, Tier 1 can be intensified, and Tier 1 does... We do differentiate in order to help students meet those grade-level standards.
[00:27:02] Susan Lambert: Yeah. I love that. Okay, what about common themes that you see in your observations across schools and districts?
[00:27:09] Sarah Brown: Yeah. So one right now that I see is that sometimes we're making plans for Tier 1, and then we're just diving in and teaching day to day and hoping for the best, and getting through the lesson, and thinking about, like we have these, we have pacing guides, and we're just trying to get through this day.
[00:27:27] You know, we're not just trying to get through this day, right, but we're teaching to the pacing guide and not necessarily like looking at, okay, here's what my students need and then responding to each student's need each day.
[00:27:38] So one thing that we want to think about is, yes, we want to have that plan. We need the pacing guide 'cause we need to make sure that we're teaching the standards and we're teaching the skills that students need each year.
[00:27:49] And then think about before, during, and after the lesson, what am I going to plan for as I go into this? So before, think about the students in my class this year, what might I need to differentiate and make sure that I'm doing right before as I plan this lesson to make sure they can be successful.
[00:28:07] During the lesson, I'm responding to each response that students are making to shift between my "I dos, we dos, and you dos." And then after the lesson, deciding for tomorrow's lesson, is there anything that I need to be reteaching or hitting more during the practice to make sure that they are really mastering the skills that we're hitting?
[00:28:31] And so really thinking about I have got this plan, but I'm also going to really be adjusting the before, during, and after planning to make sure that those plans are successful for the students in my class today.
[00:28:42] Susan Lambert: And is that related to the whole fidelity conversation? Which I don't even want to bring up that word but, right?
[00:28:49] Sarah Brown: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I think it can be, 100%. Yeah. 100% yes. Because I don't, and I think that's a yes. I'm afraid of that conversation, frankly, Susan. Because I don't, and I'm afraid, frankly, because I think I might fall on the wrong side of it.
[00:29:04] I'm frankly pro-fidelity. I'm not pro-fidelity in the idea of like I think that we should go in and be like checking off that we're all doing all of the things, like every day at all. But I'm pro-fidelity in that I think we need to support teachers to know what resources they have and empower them to feel confident in those things.
[00:29:27] I think many times they're, like from what I hear from teachers that I support, like things are thrown at them, and they are not given any time at all to know what these resources are, to understand what's even there. And then, like they either feel like they're supposed to use them, or they're like told that these are some resources they can use. And then maybe like they're told they're tools that you may use, but then somebody may or may not ask them about fidelity later.
[00:29:55] And so it's like this like back and forth. It's this odd conversation. I think that we need to decide like what are the things that are going to be most helpful for our students, and then let's stick to those. We should be able to decide on some of the things that are evidence-based that we're all going to do, and then keep fidelity to those things.
[00:30:14] But we do need to like decide like what are the outcomes that we're going to achieve, and then be teaching toward those outcomes for our students.
[00:30:22] Susan Lambert: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. I don't like that word either because everybody has a different image in their mind of what that fidelity means. "Do you think it's good? Do you think it's bad? Is it somewhere in between?"
[00:30:31] I do hear that word thrown around a lot in the schools and the districts that I work with, and maybe we all need to have a conversation about what fidelity means. We'll leave that for another time. Yeah.
[00:30:43] Sarah Brown: Agree. Agree. Agree.
[00:30:44] Susan Lambert: Okay. Sorry. Next theme. I interrupted you.
[00:30:47] Sarah Brown: The other theme that I see a lot right now is that it's around instructional habits. For many teachers, their entire career up until now, we've had to create our own lessons, like all of our lessons from scratch. And you can raise your hand if this is the very first year you've ever been given instructional materials in reading, but I'm going to guess it's a chunk, a good chunk of people.
[00:31:09] And so the instructional habit has always been that we've created everything from scratch. And so as you go into planning a lesson, a lot of teachers, their thought in what a lesson planning, like lesson planning is, is creating things. And so even when they have a set of curriculum materials, like lesson planning looks like creating things, and creating new activities.
[00:31:32] So you can think about instructional planning and lesson planning as being a different activity when you do have some curriculum materials. What that might look like is a little bit different. So if you do have curriculum materials, you can think about lesson planning a little bit differently.
[00:31:49] The first thing you can do in lesson planning is look at the lesson parts and try to match them up with your Science of Reading knowledge. So think about, "Oh, this first part is practice in phonemic awareness skills." And so you can like map those out.
[00:32:09] Then second, think about, okay, where are my students now, and what might they need? So think about then the differentiation piece that we've already talked about. Oh, we've already actually hit some of these phonic skills that they're introducing, so I'm going to skip some of the modeling part that they've talked about. I'm going to do less of that, and I'm going to skip right to "we do" and see how students do. And then I'll touch back on "I do" if I need to, if they don't seem to get it, but I really think they're ready for some "we do." And so you can decide those things. And so that's one point.
[00:32:40] Another thing with the lesson planning is just to resist the urge to try to make every part of the lesson fit every big idea of reading, because what happens is that in the schools that I'm in, at least, we don't have enough time in the reading block for that to be the case.
[00:32:58] And so a good example of that are the decodable books, for instance. So decodable books are, the whole goal of them, the whole purpose, is to get kids practice reading. It's like that "miles on the road." The practice driving is the goal. Decodable books, that whole goal is giving them practice with the code. So we don't need to spend time showing them the cover and having them talk about... discussing the characters, predicting what's going to happen.
[00:33:27] We want them to be reading the words and getting everybody access to that print. And so I want people to feel permission to not have to reinvent the wheel, and to recognize I've always had to do that, so I might have the urge to do that. But try to think about my lesson planning time can be to look at even the scary manual, 'cause they're thick. They're thick. And to try to match up and do some of those things instead, and see where that takes you.
[00:33:59] Susan Lambert: Yeah. I, I love that idea of changing how you're thinking about this. Yes, read the lesson before you teach it. Internalize that lesson for what it means for your students, and then act on it and modify it as you think that you need to.
[00:34:12] I wonder what role administrators play in that lesson planning piece, too,because in my day as a teacher, I had to turn in every week my lesson plans, and every administrator wanted something different. And it felt like I couldn't follow a strong program because I've got to make these super creative or something like to impress my principal who never probably looks at them.
[00:34:37] I don't know. But do you find that?
[00:34:40] Sarah Brown: I mean, yes. I want to know what the point of that is too. One, if we're not looking at them, then don't have teachers do them. Two, why are we doing these lesson plans. Let's give teachers, one, let's give teachers time to have the conversations as teams about instruction.
[00:35:00] Instruction is the most important part. Instruction is what results in learning. And so giving teachers time together to look at the lessons and talk about the instruction is going to be really powerful.
[00:35:14] Susan Lambert: Yeah.
[00:35:14] Sarah Brown: They don't have that. In the vast majority of schools that I'm in, they don't have that time.
[00:35:20] And so figuring out if you as an administrator can figure out how to give grade-level teams, even if they're one section, like but you have a curricular set of materials, most of those curriculum materials have some common like lesson parts. Even like a K-2 team could sit together and have a great conversation about what are some of those parts and what are some like some conversations we can have.
[00:35:45] At least mapping the lesson parts to the big ideas of reading, at the beginning of the year can be really powerful and helpful to your teachers. We cannot assume without time to plan that and think about that, that teachers like feel super empowered and equipped. We need time. Isn't it something like 90% of teachers report that they don't have enough time to plan?
[00:36:13] Susan Lambert: Yeah. I believe it. I believe it. What about how you've see, like when you, when you were thinking about like the heart and the soul of Tier 1 instruction and how teachers are delivering that, what kind of changes have you noticed over the years in how they approach it?
[00:36:29] Sarah Brown: Yeah. I think that just the idea of having materials. I think that's a big change. I think that is a big change over time. And recently a big change is that we're just including all students. The idea that now everybody has access and all students deserve access and should have access is a big change in the heart and like what we think about with Tier 1 now, that students with disabilities, that students who are multilingual learners who are still learning English, with differentiation, with accommodations and modifications, that everybody can access Tier 1 and should have access to Tier 1 and can benefit from that in addition to their interventions, that this is important, that this access to rich vocabulary, to this background knowledge that they need, that it's going to help them to understand the world around them and future ideas and future problem-solving and thinking is so important. I think that that is a huge change that I just, I love about our approach to Tier 1 in recent years.
[00:37:37] Susan Lambert: Yeah. And I've noticed that too, and, and teachers are now having conversations about not just using the term differentiation in general, but how can I do the same thing, yet scaffold?
[00:37:48] What scaffolding techniques can I use? What does scaffolding actually mean? How do I not over-scaffold. I hear those kind of conversations.
[00:37:58] Sarah Brown: Yeah. That's amazing. Yes. Yes.
[00:38:00] Susan Lambert: You've written a book all about this. It's called Effective Universal Instruction. It's amazing, by the way. How might this book be helpful for our listeners?
[00:38:12] Sarah Brown: Yeah. So, I co-wrote that book with Kim Gibbons and Brad Niebling. I feel really lucky that that book came out in 2019, and now it's a bestseller with Guilford. I've heard from educators that, which is crazy, that a Tier 1 book has gotten some love. And I've heard that it's helpful.
[00:38:32] I think that it's helpful from what I've heard from people because it provides not like, "Here are the five ideas you should do everywhere," but that it provides some tools and a process to help any school consider the changes that might help them support their local Tier 1.
[00:38:52] So no matter how, like whether you're a big school or a rural school, given the resources that you have and the students in your school today, what are the things that you can think about? What are the most common barriers to a successful Tier 1 that we tend to see? And what are the questions that you can ask, the data that you can look at?
[00:39:10] And then we provide agendas, we provide the questions, and different tools for schools to use to hopefully help teams feel empowered to improve their Tier 1. So that's what we hope schools find through the book.
[00:39:24] Susan Lambert: Yeah. Well, it's a bestseller, so I know many of our listeners probably already have it. But we'll put a link in the show notes for those that don't have it. And at the time you wrote it, which it takes time to write a book. You must have seen a real need for it because there's not that many out there that actually talk about this Tier 1 instruction.
[00:39:42] Sarah Brown: Yeah. We wrote it quite a while ago now. Yeah, it was, came out in 20, late 2018, I think. So yeah, we wrote it a while ago because at the time when we were working with schools, and still today a lot of schools will call and ask for me to work with them around MTSS asking for intervention support because it is the most exciting part of an MTSS.
[00:40:03] And when we go in and start to look at data and do classroom walkthroughs, what we see is a Tier 1 need too. And at the time when we would look at things, the main resources that you find that are really accessible for teachers and principals all talk about the only Tier 1 things that you would see outside of research literature around classified intervention would say, "Buy a new curriculum. Do standards review" that's going to take years.
[00:40:31] And really, that's all you would see. So we wanted to write something that would be accessible but aligned with research that could help schools really look at their data and dig in and do something tomorrow to help their Tier 1.
[00:40:44] Susan Lambert: I want to just reiterate to the listeners that yes, there's tools and resources and checklists and all the things to actually help you accomplish that work. It's not just a book, theoretical book about effective universal instruction.
[00:40:56] Sarah Brown: Thanks.
[00:40:56] Susan Lambert: It's a really nice toolkit.
[00:40:58] Sarah Brown: Well, thank you.
[00:40:59] Susan Lambert: I wonder as we get ready to close out if there's any final messages you would like to leave with our listeners.
[00:41:06] Sarah Brown: Just Tier 1 instruction really deserves the same love and attention as your interventions and other tiers, if we haven't already hit that over the head.
[00:41:15] It truly is the foundation that supports everything else. So a couple ways to do that. Teachers really do need strong support to feel confident in their core curriculum. I'm sure teachers are like, "Yes." And so the training and guidance on how to make the connections between, and just time to think about that instruction.
[00:41:37] Use your curriculum embedded assessments. They are powerful tools. They can help you decide what to reteach to students. So don't think about them as ways to take grades for students. But I encourage you to just take the next one that pops up in your set of materials, and take it to your PLC and just look at it and sort students and identify, "Are there some skills here that maybe most of my students are popping up on as needing some extra practice in that I can just reteach or incorporate extra practice in for the next week?" And see what it's telling you, and just have a conversation in your PLC about that.
[00:42:18] And then finally, just think about collaboration and resources within the school. So PLC time, coaching, instructional coaching, all of those things can be focused on Tier 1. Tier 1 intervention is a massive resource that can be used, and then I would focus anything on that. So instructional coaching, if there's a grade-level team that wants to provide extra practice, I would throw every resource toward that team to help them be able to provide that extra practice because you will see results.
[00:42:51] Susan Lambert: Yeah.
[00:42:52] Sarah Brown: So give Tier 1 some love.
[00:42:54] Susan Lambert: Give Tier 1 some love. I love that. That's a great final word, and I agree with that.
[00:43:00] And I appreciate the work that you're doing across the country. Also, just want to get it out there that you didn't just co-author this book, but there's other books you've co-authored, and we will make sure that we link our listeners in the show notes to those books as well. So maybe you need a break from authoring books. I don't know, Sarah.
[00:43:19] Sarah Brown: I, I don't, You know, those are, it's my weekend and holiday work is writing books. Mostly, I feel like I'm in schools, which is fun. It's the most fun work that I get to do is be in schools. But yeah, I really appreciate... This is a great conversation. I really appreciate you inviting me, Susan.
[00:43:37] Susan Lambert: Well, I am so glad that you joined us. You have the expertise to be able to talk to teachers about this important topic. So thank you again for joining.
[00:43:45] Sarah Brown: Thanks.
[00:43:48] Susan Lambert: That was Dr. Sarah Brown, consultant and president of System Impact Consulting. She's co-author of the books Effective Universal Instruction, MTSS for Reading Improvement, and Routines for Reading Results. We'll have links in the show notes.
[00:44:05] And don't forget to check out our new companion e-book, Implementing a Multi-Tiered System of Supports for Literacy. Download this free resource today at amplify.com/mtssebook. There's also a link in the show notes. If you've got MTSS questions, please drop them in our listener mailbag, amplify.com/sormailbag.
[00:44:31] Next up, we've got a special episode featuring one of our all-time favorite guests. Dr. Mitchell Brookins returns to the podcast to discuss his new book, Scaffolding Complex Texts.
[00:44:44] Mitchell Brookins: I wish that we could go back to having conversations about concepts. You know, the life idea plus the text idea comes together, and we get a deeper idea.
[00:44:53] Susan Lambert: That's next time. Science of Reading: The Podcast is brought to you by Amplify. I'm Susan Lambert. Thank you so much for listening.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.