Rethinking the Good Life: Comfort, Suffering, and the Presence of God with Shelbi Shutt

Going Deeper

Going Deeper
Rethinking the Good Life: Comfort, Suffering, and the Presence of God with Shelbi Shutt
Dec 17, 2025 Season 3 Episode 7
Justine Cheri Ordway

In this episode of the Going Deeper podcast, I sit down with speaker Shelbi Shutt to talk about faith, suffering, and what real comfort looks like in a world obsessed with ease and leisure. Shelbi lives with muscular dystrophy, and her story has profoundly shaped the way she understands the good life, discipleship, and the presence of God. Her honesty pushes us to examine what we run to for comfort and whether those places actually bring life.

We talk about how suffering exposes the beliefs we carry beneath the surface. She shares how her diagnosis forced her to confront the “Jesus plus” gospel she didn’t realize she held, and how choosing to participate in the sufferings of Christ has formed her spiritual maturity. She reminds us that true comfort is found in the presence of God.

In a world filled with noise, discipling our attention becomes a real part of following Jesus. We explore how prayer reorients us, how lament and celebration can coexist, and how resurrection life isn’t just a future hope but a present reality that shapes our perspective today.

Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@JustineCheri

Subscribe to The Digest: https://justinecheri.kit.com/ab6b561afa

Connect with Shelbi: https://solo.to/shelbishutt

Shelbi's Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/shelbishutt/

Timestamps:

00:00 — Introduction
 04:19 — Shelbi’s Journey and Diagnosis
 07:17 — Faith and Suffering
 10:20 — The Good Life and the Jesus Plus Gospel
 16:27 — The Role of Suffering in Spiritual Growth
 19:16 — The Illusion of Worldly Comfort
 25:14 — Prayer and True Comfort
 28:20 — Paradise and the Hope of Restoration
 31:34 — Living in the Resurrection Life
 40:19 — Discipling Our Attention in a Distracted World
 42:16 — Longing for the Presence of the Lord
 44:55 — Lament and Celebration: Coexisting Realities
 48:31 — Finding Comfort in Daily Struggles
 52:43 — Current Projects and Future Aspirations

Episode Artwork Rethinking the Good Life: Comfort, Suffering, and the Presence of God with Shelbi Shutt 53:56 Episode Artwork Longing for Home in a Rootless and Restless World with my Editor Eddie Larow 1:04:40 Episode Artwork A Devotional Reading of Philippians and How I'm Leaning Into Advent 50:22 Episode Artwork On Compassionate Wardrobes, Self-Righteousness, and What the Self-Esteem Movement Gets Wrong with Sharon Hodde Miller 1:00:22 Episode Artwork The Wellness Gospel, Radical Faith, and What to Do When You Don't "Feel" God 1:01:01 Episode Artwork Influencer Culture, ChatGPT Boundaries, and Why Reading Your Bible Is So Hard—And What to Do About It 1:02:38 Episode Artwork A Theology of Happiness with Griffin Gooch 53:28 Episode Artwork Is Christian Charity Dead? Forrest Frank, Taylor Swift, and What the Bible Says About the World 56:39 Episode Artwork A Pastor's Thoughts for the Christian in the Wake of Charlie Kirk's Assassination 38:25 Episode Artwork How Should Christians Think About Modern Beauty Treatments? 45:52 Episode Artwork If a Demon Tempted a Woman with Tilly Dillehay 44:31 Episode Artwork An Honest Conversation About Prayer 49:14 Episode Artwork How Is The Joy of the Lord Our Strength? 20:48 Episode Artwork Screen Addictions, Dumb Phones, and Choosing the Better Portion with Lauren Bowerman 1:07:39 Episode Artwork The Cognitive Dissonance of Spiritual Amnesia 49:09 Episode Artwork Hope & Help For Your Anxiety 49:47 Episode Artwork Canceling our Critical Spirits 46:39 Episode Artwork How to Actually Go Deeper With God This Year 34:50 Episode Artwork Encouragement For Those In a Spiritually Dry Season 17:06 Episode Artwork Did Jesus Have Goals and Dreams? 35:02 Episode Artwork Body Image, Burnout, and the Bible with Whitney Lowe 56:56 Episode Artwork People Pleasing, Calvinism, and Praying More | Q&A 45:25 Episode Artwork How to Pursue Holiness in a Culture of Lukewarm Christianity 29:41 Episode Artwork No More Excuses: How to Start Loving, Reading, and Studying your Bible 43:47 Episode Artwork Gracepower > Willpower 36:21