{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":22.05,"endTime":23.790000000000003,"body":"Colleges and"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":22.05,"endTime":23.790000000000003,"body":"universities have long"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":23.790000000000003,"endTime":26.090000000000003,"body":"served as the tap that"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":23.790000000000003,"endTime":26.090000000000003,"body":"filled the talent pool."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":26.720000000000002,"endTime":29.849,"body":"Over time, the insulation"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":26.720000000000002,"endTime":29.849,"body":"of universities has become"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":29.85,"endTime":32.150000000000006,"body":"an issue as the digital"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":29.85,"endTime":32.150000000000006,"body":"economy has flourished."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":32.659,"endTime":35.97,"body":"Today, being cut off from the"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":32.659,"endTime":35.97,"body":"real world has led to colleges"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":35.97,"endTime":38.68,"body":"struggling to develop graduates"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":35.97,"endTime":38.68,"body":"who can meet the demands"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":38.68,"endTime":41.319,"body":"and needs of organizations"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":38.68,"endTime":41.319,"body":"they strive to work for."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":42.24,"endTime":45.329,"body":"Over the last 40 years,"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":42.24,"endTime":45.329,"body":"very little has changed"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":45.33,"endTime":47.939,"body":"in terms of the programs"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":45.33,"endTime":47.939,"body":"offered by universities."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":48.675,"endTime":51.035,"body":"The lack of speed to adapt"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":48.675,"endTime":51.035,"body":"the curriculum to suit a"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":51.035,"endTime":54.574,"body":"fast-paced, quickly evolving"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":51.035,"endTime":54.574,"body":"market in nearly every"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":54.574,"endTime":58.035,"body":"industry has yielded a crop of"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":54.574,"endTime":58.035,"body":"college graduates which only"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":58.035,"endTime":61.665000000000006,"body":"14% of hiring managers feel"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":58.035,"endTime":61.665000000000006,"body":"are prepared for employment."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":62.754000000000005,"endTime":65.34400000000001,"body":"Layer on the student debt"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":62.754000000000005,"endTime":65.34400000000001,"body":"crisis of the last couple"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":65.345,"endTime":68.224,"body":"of decades and you have an"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":65.345,"endTime":68.224,"body":"environment where faith in"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":68.224,"endTime":70.044,"body":"higher education is eroding."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":70.605,"endTime":72.874,"body":"College enrollments are"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":70.605,"endTime":72.874,"body":"plummeting as young people"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":72.874,"endTime":75.124,"body":"and workers seeking skill"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":72.874,"endTime":75.124,"body":"development and career"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":75.124,"endTime":77.475,"body":"changes explore other"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":75.124,"endTime":77.475,"body":"avenues for learning."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":78.304,"endTime":82.854,"body":"From 2018 to 2022, college"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":78.304,"endTime":82.854,"body":"enrollment dropped 8%, the"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":82.855,"endTime":84.295,"body":"steepest decline on record."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":85.214,"endTime":87.574,"body":"So what can be done to"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":85.214,"endTime":87.574,"body":"address these skills gaps?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":88.205,"endTime":90.675,"body":"What can be done to ensure"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":88.205,"endTime":90.675,"body":"that Korn Ferry's estimate"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":90.705,"endTime":95.16499999999999,"body":"of 85 million jobs going"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":90.705,"endTime":95.16499999999999,"body":"unfilled by 2030 at a cost of"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":95.244,"endTime":99.42399999999999,"body":"8.5 trillion to the economy"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":95.244,"endTime":99.42399999999999,"body":"doesn't become a prophecy?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":100.595,"endTime":104.295,"body":"The answer may just lie in a"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":100.595,"endTime":104.295,"body":"new approach to an old idea."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":106.365,"endTime":108.725,"body":"Welcome to the People"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":106.365,"endTime":108.725,"body":"Managing People podcast."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":109.105,"endTime":111.815,"body":"We're on a mission to build"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":109.105,"endTime":111.815,"body":"a better world of work and to"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":111.815,"endTime":115.14399999999999,"body":"help you build happy, healthy,"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":111.815,"endTime":115.14399999999999,"body":"and productive workplaces."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":115.974,"endTime":118.495,"body":"I'm David Rice, Senior"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":115.974,"endTime":118.495,"body":"Editor of People Managing"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":118.495,"endTime":119.92399999999999,"body":"People and your host."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":120.514,"endTime":123.92399999999999,"body":"My guest today is Ryan"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":120.514,"endTime":123.92399999999999,"body":"Craig—Managing Director at"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":123.92399999999999,"endTime":127.5,"body":"Achieve Partners—a venture"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":123.92399999999999,"endTime":127.5,"body":"capital firm dedicated to"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":127.5,"endTime":129.81,"body":"investing in the future"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":127.5,"endTime":129.81,"body":"of learning and earning."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":130.419,"endTime":133.57,"body":"Ryan joined me ahead of the"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":130.419,"endTime":133.57,"body":"release of his new book titled"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":133.62,"endTime":136.8,"body":"Apprentice Nation - How the"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":133.62,"endTime":136.8,"body":"\"Earn and Learn\" Alternative"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":136.8,"endTime":140.1,"body":"to Higher Education Will Create"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":136.8,"endTime":140.1,"body":"a Stronger and Fairer America."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":141.03900000000002,"endTime":143.369,"body":"We're going to talk about the"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":141.03900000000002,"endTime":143.369,"body":"challenges facing apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":143.369,"endTime":146.409,"body":"programs, how other countries"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":143.369,"endTime":146.409,"body":"use apprenticeships for"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":146.57,"endTime":149.94,"body":"workforce development, and"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":146.57,"endTime":149.94,"body":"who the task of building these"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":149.96,"endTime":151.5,"body":"programs actually falls to."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":152.35,"endTime":153.72,"body":"So let's just jump right in."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":158.679,"endTime":160.17,"body":"So Ryan, thank you"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":158.679,"endTime":160.17,"body":"for joining us."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":160.2,"endTime":162.34,"body":"I know we've got a lot"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":160.2,"endTime":162.34,"body":"to talk about, so I want"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":162.34,"endTime":163.43,"body":"to get right into it."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":163.46,"endTime":166.3,"body":"And my first question for"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":163.46,"endTime":166.3,"body":"you is - apprenticeships,"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":166.32,"endTime":168.62,"body":"you know, they've evolved"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":166.32,"endTime":168.62,"body":"significantly over the years"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":168.669,"endTime":171.27,"body":"and they're no longer limited"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":168.669,"endTime":171.27,"body":"to just traditional trades."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":171.719,"endTime":174.559,"body":"We see apprenticeships popping"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":171.719,"endTime":174.559,"body":"up in tech and other sectors."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":175.089,"endTime":178.73,"body":"Can you provide us an overview"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":175.089,"endTime":178.73,"body":"of apprenticeship programs?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":179.22,"endTime":182.17,"body":"You know, how they have the"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":179.22,"endTime":182.17,"body":"potential to transform workforce"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":182.21,"endTime":185.82,"body":"planning, essentially, and how"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":182.21,"endTime":185.82,"body":"organizations develop or seek"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":185.85999999999999,"endTime":187.10999999999999,"body":"the skills that are needed?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":187.26,"endTime":187.71,"body":"Sure."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":187.85999999999999,"endTime":192.09,"body":"Well, we're facing a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":187.85999999999999,"endTime":192.09,"body":"combination of a skills"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":192.09,"endTime":196.02,"body":"gap where employers aren't"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":192.09,"endTime":196.02,"body":"finding the talent they need."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":196.555,"endTime":199.085,"body":"And that's coupled really"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":196.555,"endTime":199.085,"body":"with an experience gap where"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":199.73499999999999,"endTime":204.635,"body":"employers are larding job"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":199.73499999999999,"endTime":204.635,"body":"descriptions with requirements"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":204.655,"endTime":209.325,"body":"that really would mean that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":204.655,"endTime":209.325,"body":"someone trying to get an entry"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":209.325,"endTime":212.755,"body":"level position in a field needs"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":209.325,"endTime":212.755,"body":"to have worked for a year,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":212.795,"endTime":213.974,"body":"two years, or three years."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":213.98499999999999,"endTime":217.065,"body":"I mean, it's some shocking"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":213.98499999999999,"endTime":217.065,"body":"statistics if you actually"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":217.065,"endTime":219.885,"body":"look at these job descriptions"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":217.065,"endTime":219.885,"body":"for jobs that used to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":219.895,"endTime":221.095,"body":"be truly entry level."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":221.385,"endTime":226.224,"body":"On average, they're asking for a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":221.385,"endTime":226.224,"body":"year's worth of work experience."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":226.375,"endTime":228.374,"body":"And, cyber security"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":226.375,"endTime":228.374,"body":"is a perfect example."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":228.375,"endTime":232.785,"body":"A tier one analyst to break"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":228.375,"endTime":232.785,"body":"into cyber security, those jobs"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":232.795,"endTime":235.215,"body":"ask for certifications that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":232.795,"endTime":235.215,"body":"you really need to have worked"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":235.215,"endTime":237.225,"body":"for three years to attain."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":237.635,"endTime":241.024,"body":"So, it's employers aren't"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":237.635,"endTime":241.024,"body":"finding the talent that they"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":241.07399999999998,"endTime":244.224,"body":"want, and young people are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":241.07399999999998,"endTime":244.224,"body":"increasingly having a hard"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":244.224,"endTime":245.814,"body":"time launching careers."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":245.814,"endTime":249.924,"body":"40% of new college"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":245.814,"endTime":249.924,"body":"graduates are underemployed."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":250.314,"endTime":253.914,"body":"Americans of all stripes"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":250.314,"endTime":253.914,"body":"feel stymied in terms"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":253.914,"endTime":257.074,"body":"of, how do I access this"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":253.914,"endTime":257.074,"body":"dynamic digital economy?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":257.719,"endTime":258.089,"body":"Right?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":258.16900000000004,"endTime":261.17900000000003,"body":"Five years ago, my last book"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":258.16900000000004,"endTime":261.17900000000003,"body":"was about the rise of what"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":261.17900000000003,"endTime":263.279,"body":"I call faster and cheaper"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":261.17900000000003,"endTime":263.279,"body":"alternatives to college"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":263.499,"endTime":265.059,"body":"bootcamps and so forth."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":265.379,"endTime":268.17900000000003,"body":"But those programs have not"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":265.379,"endTime":268.17900000000003,"body":"had a, you know, not been"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":268.17900000000003,"endTime":269.209,"body":"successful for everyone."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":269.42900000000003,"endTime":272.209,"body":"And the reason for that is that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":269.42900000000003,"endTime":272.209,"body":"it may be equipping you with"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":272.209,"endTime":274.67900000000003,"body":"the skills you need, but you're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":272.209,"endTime":274.67900000000003,"body":"not getting the experience."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":274.759,"endTime":278.519,"body":"And even though there is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":274.759,"endTime":278.519,"body":"a shortage of Salesforce"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":278.599,"endTime":281.939,"body":"administrators, not many"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":278.599,"endTime":281.939,"body":"employers are excited about"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":282.049,"endTime":284.709,"body":"hiring someone who's just, you"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":282.049,"endTime":284.709,"body":"know, just out of a bootcamp"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":284.719,"endTime":288.204,"body":"program who's a newly minted"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":284.719,"endTime":288.204,"body":"Salesforce administrator."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":288.524,"endTime":293.434,"body":"So that's the dynamic that we're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":288.524,"endTime":293.434,"body":"seeing and the impact of it is,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":293.504,"endTime":297.454,"body":"I think it's really wide and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":293.504,"endTime":297.454,"body":"deep across the country and is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":297.484,"endTime":301.024,"body":"leading to some of the economic,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":297.484,"endTime":301.024,"body":"social, and even political"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":301.024,"endTime":302.324,"body":"instability that we're seeing."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":302.874,"endTime":307.124,"body":"People feel like there's no"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":302.874,"endTime":307.124,"body":"pathway to economic opportunity"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":307.124,"endTime":308.624,"body":"and socioeconomic mobility."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":309.404,"endTime":313.844,"body":"So apprenticeship is a great"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":309.404,"endTime":313.844,"body":"tool we could harness to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":313.844,"endTime":315.979,"body":"address all of the above."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":316.189,"endTime":318.689,"body":"And the reason for that is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":316.189,"endTime":318.689,"body":"that it's not just a training"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":318.689,"endTime":321.939,"body":"program, like boot camp,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":318.689,"endTime":321.939,"body":"let alone college degree."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":322.289,"endTime":325.169,"body":"It's not a program that requires"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":322.289,"endTime":325.169,"body":"you to pay tuition or take on"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":325.169,"endTime":326.549,"body":"debt or take any financial risk."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":326.809,"endTime":329.309,"body":"Apprenticeships are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":326.809,"endTime":329.309,"body":"by definition a job."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":329.799,"endTime":333.129,"body":"And it's a job that pays a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":329.799,"endTime":333.129,"body":"living wage with built-in"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":333.229,"endTime":335.799,"body":"training, both formal"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":333.229,"endTime":335.799,"body":"classroom training, as well"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":335.799,"endTime":339.629,"body":"as on the job training, with"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":335.799,"endTime":339.629,"body":"built-in wage increases as"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":339.629,"endTime":342.86899999999997,"body":"you become more productive"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":339.629,"endTime":342.86899999999997,"body":"and a built-in career path."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":343.629,"endTime":347.769,"body":"And so how great would it be"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":343.629,"endTime":347.769,"body":"if we had a country with as"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":347.769,"endTime":350.729,"body":"many large scale apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":347.769,"endTime":350.729,"body":"programs across every sector of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":350.739,"endTime":354.279,"body":"the economy as we have colleges"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":350.739,"endTime":354.279,"body":"and universities, with as many"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":354.279,"endTime":358.609,"body":"apprentice jobs as we have seats"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":354.279,"endTime":358.609,"body":"in freshman college classes."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":358.959,"endTime":360.879,"body":"And so that's really"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":358.959,"endTime":360.879,"body":"what the book is about."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":361.099,"endTime":364.349,"body":"And question is how we go"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":361.099,"endTime":364.349,"body":"from, well, first of all,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":364.349,"endTime":368.209,"body":"where we are on apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":364.349,"endTime":368.209,"body":"as a country and how we"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":368.209,"endTime":369.209,"body":"go from here to there."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":369.664,"endTime":372.034,"body":"It's interesting,"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":369.664,"endTime":372.034,"body":"like companies have these huge,"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":372.054,"endTime":374.944,"body":"learning development budgets and"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":372.054,"endTime":374.944,"body":"they're willing to spend tons"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":374.944,"endTime":377.004,"body":"on technology to support that."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":377.284,"endTime":380.024,"body":"As you've noted, few companies"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":377.284,"endTime":380.024,"body":"create apprenticeship programs"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":380.024,"endTime":382.634,"body":"themselves, and if they do,"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":380.024,"endTime":382.634,"body":"they very rarely scale it."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":383.054,"endTime":385.914,"body":"And it seems like, you"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":383.054,"endTime":385.914,"body":"brought up in the book"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":385.914,"endTime":388.904,"body":"that an intermediary is"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":385.914,"endTime":388.904,"body":"really kind of required."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":389.044,"endTime":392.374,"body":"You're suggesting that it sets"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":389.044,"endTime":392.374,"body":"up and runs the apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":392.384,"endTime":394.394,"body":"program for companies."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":394.734,"endTime":395.954,"body":"Can you talk a little"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":394.734,"endTime":395.954,"body":"bit about that?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":395.954,"endTime":398.124,"body":"And cause I think people"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":395.954,"endTime":398.124,"body":"will hear that and they're"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":398.124,"endTime":401.214,"body":"kind of curious, like who is"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":398.124,"endTime":401.214,"body":"the ideally intermediary if"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":401.214,"endTime":402.754,"body":"it's not higher education?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":403.24399999999997,"endTime":403.604,"body":"Right."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":403.884,"endTime":404.704,"body":"Yeah, who's doing that."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":405.014,"endTime":407.714,"body":"So first of all, let's look at"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":405.014,"endTime":407.714,"body":"where apprenticeships actually"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":407.714,"endTime":409.324,"body":"thrive around the world."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":409.974,"endTime":413.734,"body":"In the U.S., we do have a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":409.974,"endTime":413.734,"body":"vibrant apprenticeship sector"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":413.734,"endTime":414.824,"body":"in the construction trades."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":415.254,"endTime":418.574,"body":"And in the construction trades,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":415.254,"endTime":418.574,"body":"it's not construction firms"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":418.684,"endTime":420.49399999999997,"body":"that are setting up and writing"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":418.684,"endTime":420.49399999999997,"body":"their apprenticeship programs."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":420.49399999999997,"endTime":422.034,"body":"It's unions who are doing it."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":422.36899999999997,"endTime":423.909,"body":"Unions act as the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":422.36899999999997,"endTime":423.909,"body":"intermediaries."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":423.909,"endTime":426.779,"body":"They set up and run these"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":423.909,"endTime":426.779,"body":"apprenticeship programs for"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":426.939,"endTime":428.609,"body":"employers, for contractors."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":428.889,"endTime":432.11899999999997,"body":"In Germany, where,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":428.889,"endTime":432.11899999999997,"body":"apprenticeship is a way of life"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":432.11899999999997,"endTime":434.879,"body":"and as many people get their"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":432.11899999999997,"endTime":434.879,"body":"start through apprenticeship is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":434.879,"endTime":436.909,"body":"through college and university."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":437.139,"endTime":441.649,"body":"Again, companies like Siemens"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":437.139,"endTime":441.649,"body":"and BASF and Bertelsmann"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":441.819,"endTime":444.299,"body":"generally aren't the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":441.819,"endTime":444.299,"body":"ones that run their own"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":444.299,"endTime":445.609,"body":"apprenticeship programs."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":445.609,"endTime":449.949,"body":"Apprenticeship programs are run,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":445.609,"endTime":449.949,"body":"set up and run by large chambers"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":449.949,"endTime":454.249,"body":"of commerce and powerful"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":449.949,"endTime":454.249,"body":"unions, whose role in doing so"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":454.249,"endTime":455.559,"body":"was actually written into law."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":455.899,"endTime":458.269,"body":"They're required to do this,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":455.899,"endTime":458.269,"body":"which is why I kind of laugh"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":458.269,"endTime":461.109,"body":"every time you see some sort"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":458.269,"endTime":461.109,"body":"of delegation from the U.S."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":461.129,"endTime":464.279,"body":"State government going over to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":461.129,"endTime":464.279,"body":"Germany to drink the Riesling"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":464.279,"endTime":467.089,"body":"and eat the schnitzel and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":464.279,"endTime":467.089,"body":"look at their apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":467.109,"endTime":469.999,"body":"programs, because it's not"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":467.109,"endTime":469.999,"body":"replicable in a couple of ways."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":470.009,"endTime":472.919,"body":"One is that we don't have"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":470.009,"endTime":472.919,"body":"these massive, so if you're in"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":472.929,"endTime":475.699,"body":"Munich and you have your own"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":472.929,"endTime":475.699,"body":"little consulting business,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":476.049,"endTime":478.159,"body":"you're required by law to join"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":476.049,"endTime":478.159,"body":"the Chamber of Commerce there."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":478.159,"endTime":481.179,"body":"So the Munich Chamber of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":478.159,"endTime":481.179,"body":"Commerce has 400,000 members."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":481.679,"endTime":482.489,"body":"They're large and powerful."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":482.499,"endTime":483.429,"body":"We don't have"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":482.499,"endTime":483.429,"body":"anything like that."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":483.429,"endTime":486.709,"body":"Our Chambers of Commerce"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":483.429,"endTime":486.709,"body":"are a pale imitation of what"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":486.709,"endTime":488.129,"body":"they have over in Germany."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":488.589,"endTime":489.429,"body":"So that's not going to work."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":489.449,"endTime":492.439,"body":"And as a result, it's never"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":489.449,"endTime":492.439,"body":"going to be law that Chambers"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":492.439,"endTime":493.779,"body":"of Commerce in the U.S."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":493.779,"endTime":495.61899999999997,"body":"have to run"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":493.779,"endTime":495.61899999999997,"body":"apprenticeship programs."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":495.629,"endTime":497.809,"body":"So it's not replicable."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":497.81,"endTime":500.659,"body":"But what's replicable"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":497.81,"endTime":500.659,"body":"is the UK and Australia."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":501.064,"endTime":504.544,"body":"So Germany is about 15"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":501.064,"endTime":504.544,"body":"times better than the U.S."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":504.564,"endTime":506.414,"body":"on apprenticeship in"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":504.564,"endTime":506.414,"body":"terms of apprentices as a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":506.414,"endTime":507.454,"body":"percentage of the workforce."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":507.464,"endTime":508.854,"body":"They're 15 times the U.S."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":509.224,"endTime":510.104,"body":"That's not surprising."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":510.124,"endTime":511.504,"body":"What's surprising"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":510.124,"endTime":511.504,"body":"is that the U.K."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":511.654,"endTime":515.3340000000001,"body":"and Australia, which 30 years"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":511.654,"endTime":515.3340000000001,"body":"ago looked a lot like the U.S."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":515.719,"endTime":519.3190000000001,"body":"in terms of having a relatively"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":515.719,"endTime":519.3190000000001,"body":"small apprenticeship sector,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":519.7090000000001,"endTime":521.169,"body":"mostly in construction."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":521.5590000000001,"endTime":526.169,"body":"Today, those countries are 8x"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":521.5590000000001,"endTime":526.169,"body":"where we are on apprentices as"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":526.169,"endTime":527.3290000000001,"body":"a percentage of the workforce."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":527.609,"endTime":530.169,"body":"And it's very common for"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":527.609,"endTime":530.169,"body":"people to launch careers"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":530.179,"endTime":532.8090000000001,"body":"in financial services,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":530.179,"endTime":532.8090000000001,"body":"tech, healthcare, logistics"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":533.049,"endTime":533.919,"body":"through apprenticeships."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":533.9590000000001,"endTime":535.519,"body":"They have apprenticeships"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":533.9590000000001,"endTime":535.519,"body":"all across the economy."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":535.599,"endTime":536.4590000000001,"body":"Now, how did they do that?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":536.499,"endTime":539.099,"body":"They don't have large Chambers"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":536.499,"endTime":539.099,"body":"of Commerce or powerful"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":539.099,"endTime":540.349,"body":"unions the way Germany does."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":540.9190000000001,"endTime":543.6690000000001,"body":"The way they did that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":540.9190000000001,"endTime":543.6690000000001,"body":"is by recognizing that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":544.019,"endTime":546.0490000000001,"body":"employers don't create"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":544.019,"endTime":546.0490000000001,"body":"apprenticeships on their own."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":546.349,"endTime":548.599,"body":"It's intermediaries who do the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":546.349,"endTime":548.599,"body":"heavy lifting of setting up"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":548.599,"endTime":552.6590000000001,"body":"and running these programs,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":548.599,"endTime":552.6590000000001,"body":"and they needed to incentivize"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":552.719,"endTime":556.589,"body":"the establishment of a robust"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":552.719,"endTime":556.589,"body":"ecosystem of intermediaries to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":556.589,"endTime":558.859,"body":"do the heavy lifting of setting"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":556.589,"endTime":558.859,"body":"up and running these programs,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":558.859,"endTime":559.739,"body":"and so that's what they did."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":560.339,"endTime":562.8190000000001,"body":"They essentially funded"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":560.339,"endTime":562.8190000000001,"body":"apprenticeship programs,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":562.8190000000001,"endTime":566.379,"body":"both the training component"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":562.8190000000001,"endTime":566.379,"body":"as well as providing pay"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":566.379,"endTime":568.6890000000001,"body":"per apprentice type funding."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":568.6890000000001,"endTime":571.5590000000001,"body":"So intermediaries got paid"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":568.6890000000001,"endTime":571.5590000000001,"body":"for the training, they knew"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":571.5590000000001,"endTime":573.2990000000001,"body":"that they would be paid,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":571.5590000000001,"endTime":573.2990000000001,"body":"every apprentice they trained."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":573.2990000000001,"endTime":575.489,"body":"And they'd also get paid"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":573.2990000000001,"endTime":575.489,"body":"every time an apprentice was"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":575.489,"endTime":577.509,"body":"hired by an employer client."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":577.889,"endTime":581.1790000000001,"body":"And today, as I said, you"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":577.889,"endTime":581.1790000000001,"body":"have these ecosystems of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":581.1790000000001,"endTime":584.9190000000001,"body":"intermediaries in the U.K.,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":581.1790000000001,"endTime":584.9190000000001,"body":"1200 intermediaries that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":584.989,"endTime":586.5490000000001,"body":"are in the business of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":584.989,"endTime":586.5490000000001,"body":"setting up and writing these"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":586.5590000000001,"endTime":589.729,"body":"programs that knock on the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":586.5590000000001,"endTime":589.729,"body":"doors of every large and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":589.729,"endTime":591.1590000000001,"body":"mid-sized employer in the U.K."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":591.1590000000001,"endTime":593.109,"body":"offering to set up and run"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":591.1590000000001,"endTime":593.109,"body":"an apprenticeship program."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":593.5390000000001,"endTime":595.619,"body":"So you'd have to knock on"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":593.5390000000001,"endTime":595.619,"body":"a lot of doors in the U.S."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":595.619,"endTime":598.8090000000001,"body":"to find any company that's"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":595.619,"endTime":598.8090000000001,"body":"been approached similarly."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":598.8090000000001,"endTime":601.0490000000001,"body":"It doesn't, it's not"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":598.8090000000001,"endTime":601.0490000000001,"body":"a thing here yet."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":601.0490000000001,"endTime":603.9490000000001,"body":"And it's not a thing because"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":601.0490000000001,"endTime":603.9490000000001,"body":"we haven't done what the U.K."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":603.969,"endTime":605.109,"body":"did, which is fund it."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":605.269,"endTime":608.5490000000001,"body":"If you actually look at the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":605.269,"endTime":608.5490000000001,"body":"disparity in funding, public"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":608.5490000000001,"endTime":612.639,"body":"funding for apprenticeship,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":608.5490000000001,"endTime":612.639,"body":"we spend over $500 billion"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":612.999,"endTime":615.599,"body":"a year of federal and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":612.999,"endTime":615.599,"body":"state money on accredited"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":615.599,"endTime":618.379,"body":"colleges and universities,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":615.599,"endTime":618.379,"body":"on college classrooms."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":618.9140000000001,"endTime":621.884,"body":"We spend less than 400"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":618.9140000000001,"endTime":621.884,"body":"million on apprenticeships."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":621.884,"endTime":623.9240000000001,"body":"So the ratio is over"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":621.884,"endTime":623.9240000000001,"body":"a thousand to one."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":624.714,"endTime":628.5440000000001,"body":"And if you compare a college"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":624.714,"endTime":628.5440000000001,"body":"student to an apprentice"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":628.5440000000001,"endTime":630.7040000000001,"body":"and say, how much support is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":628.5440000000001,"endTime":630.7040000000001,"body":"that individual receiving?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":631.0640000000001,"endTime":633.5540000000001,"body":"For every dollar the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":631.0640000000001,"endTime":633.5540000000001,"body":"apprentice is receiving,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":634.004,"endTime":635.354,"body":"the college student gets 50."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":635.964,"endTime":637.864,"body":"So I don't know if the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":635.964,"endTime":637.864,"body":"right ratio is 2 to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":637.864,"endTime":639.3340000000001,"body":"1, 5 to 1, 10 to 1."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":639.8240000000001,"endTime":641.964,"body":"It's not 50 to 1 or a 1000 to 1."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":641.984,"endTime":645.394,"body":"So we are way out of balance"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":641.984,"endTime":645.394,"body":"with every other country, and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":645.394,"endTime":648.9340000000001,"body":"that's a huge problem given the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":645.394,"endTime":648.9340000000001,"body":"skills and experience gaps that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":648.9340000000001,"endTime":652.359,"body":"I mentioned, as well as the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":648.9340000000001,"endTime":652.359,"body":"fact that the digital skills"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":652.399,"endTime":655.229,"body":"that employers are having a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":652.399,"endTime":655.229,"body":"hard time finding are actually"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":655.239,"endTime":657.489,"body":"harder to learn in a classroom"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":655.239,"endTime":657.489,"body":"than they are on the job."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":657.9390000000001,"endTime":660.889,"body":"So you know, how great"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":657.9390000000001,"endTime":660.889,"body":"would it be if we had"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":660.889,"endTime":664.0390000000001,"body":"apprenticeship programs"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":660.889,"endTime":664.0390000000001,"body":"for all of these tech jobs?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":664.0390000000001,"endTime":666.9540000000001,"body":"And most good jobs"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":664.0390000000001,"endTime":666.9540000000001,"body":"are our tech jobs."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":667.504,"endTime":669.6840000000001,"body":"So that's what we've done wrong."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":669.7040000000001,"endTime":671.6640000000001,"body":"There's other things too"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":669.7040000000001,"endTime":671.6640000000001,"body":"that I talk about in the book"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":671.6640000000001,"endTime":673.724,"body":"that we haven't done that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":671.6640000000001,"endTime":673.724,"body":"other countries have done."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":673.724,"endTime":674.8240000000001,"body":"But that's the main one."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":674.9540000000001,"endTime":678.0440000000001,"body":"If we could fix that, we'd"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":674.9540000000001,"endTime":678.0440000000001,"body":"have thousands and thousands of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":678.0440000000001,"endTime":681.504,"body":"intermediaries, nonprofits, and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":678.0440000000001,"endTime":681.504,"body":"I profile a bunch of them in the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":681.504,"endTime":684.504,"body":"book that are made these nascent"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":681.504,"endTime":684.504,"body":"intermediaries in the U.S."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":684.504,"endTime":687.1540000000001,"body":"that are doing it without"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":684.504,"endTime":687.1540000000001,"body":"funding effectively."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":687.464,"endTime":690.5840000000001,"body":"But you could imagine if"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":687.464,"endTime":690.5840000000001,"body":"we created incentives that,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":690.714,"endTime":695.019,"body":"big staffing companies,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":690.714,"endTime":695.019,"body":"manpower, would get into"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":695.019,"endTime":697.389,"body":"the business of setting up"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":695.019,"endTime":697.389,"body":"and running apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":697.389,"endTime":698.749,"body":"programs for their clients."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":699.0490000000001,"endTime":702.0290000000001,"body":"And big and mid-sized company"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":699.0490000000001,"endTime":702.0290000000001,"body":"would become very common for"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":702.0390000000001,"endTime":705.119,"body":"companies to have apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":702.0390000000001,"endTime":705.119,"body":"programs and apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":705.129,"endTime":708.3290000000001,"body":"pathways because we'd be"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":705.129,"endTime":708.3290000000001,"body":"effectively subsidizing it."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":708.5590000000001,"endTime":712.239,"body":"But, we know that the return on"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":708.5590000000001,"endTime":712.239,"body":"investment from these programs,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":712.4390000000001,"endTime":715.099,"body":"obviously for the individual,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":712.4390000000001,"endTime":715.099,"body":"it's almost infinite because"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":715.099,"endTime":717.089,"body":"instead of paying, they're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":715.099,"endTime":717.089,"body":"not paying any tuition or"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":717.089,"endTime":718.0490000000001,"body":"taking any financial risk."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":718.0690000000001,"endTime":719.8240000000001,"body":"They're just getting a job"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":718.0690000000001,"endTime":719.8240000000001,"body":"that wouldn't have been"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":719.8240000000001,"endTime":721.464,"body":"otherwise been able to get."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":721.724,"endTime":724.5340000000001,"body":"But for the employer, as"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":721.724,"endTime":724.5340000000001,"body":"well as for government that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":724.604,"endTime":727.094,"body":"funds it, it's an exceptional"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":724.604,"endTime":727.094,"body":"return, a much higher"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":727.094,"endTime":729.964,"body":"return than an investment in"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":727.094,"endTime":729.964,"body":"another college classroom."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":730.994,"endTime":732.364,"body":"One of the"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":730.994,"endTime":732.364,"body":"things that's unique"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":732.524,"endTime":734.754,"body":"about apprenticeships is"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":732.524,"endTime":734.754,"body":"the combination of that"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":734.764,"endTime":737.004,"body":"on the job training with"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":734.764,"endTime":737.004,"body":"theoretical learning."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":737.004,"endTime":739.3140000000001,"body":"And I'm curious, like if"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":737.004,"endTime":739.3140000000001,"body":"you were assessing a, an"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":739.3140000000001,"endTime":741.7940000000001,"body":"apprenticeship program where"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":739.3140000000001,"endTime":741.7940000000001,"body":"you were designing, what"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":741.7940000000001,"endTime":745.4190000000001,"body":"advice kind of like in terms"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":741.7940000000001,"endTime":745.4190000000001,"body":"of striking the right balance"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":745.4190000000001,"endTime":748.1890000000001,"body":"to ensure participants gain"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":745.4190000000001,"endTime":748.1890000000001,"body":"both practical skills and"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":748.1890000000001,"endTime":751.339,"body":"that theoretical knowledge"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":748.1890000000001,"endTime":751.339,"body":"that plugs into other areas of"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":751.339,"endTime":753.6790000000001,"body":"the job that they're going to"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":751.339,"endTime":753.6790000000001,"body":"take, what advice do you have"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":753.7090000000001,"endTime":754.859,"body":"kind of for assessing that?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":754.999,"endTime":757.769,"body":"Because if you were looking"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":754.999,"endTime":757.769,"body":"at an intermediary, what would"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":757.769,"endTime":759.359,"body":"you look for in the program?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":759.6690000000001,"endTime":760.489,"body":"Well,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":759.6690000000001,"endTime":760.489,"body":"let's be clear."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":760.5290000000001,"endTime":763.969,"body":"On the job training is typically"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":760.5290000000001,"endTime":763.969,"body":"very informal, and it's probably"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":763.969,"endTime":766.3290000000001,"body":"not too different than, what"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":763.969,"endTime":766.3290000000001,"body":"you would learn in most jobs."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":767.7090000000001,"endTime":769.899,"body":"When you're working in a job,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":767.7090000000001,"endTime":769.899,"body":"you're learning to do the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":769.899,"endTime":772.349,"body":"job as you go, and you're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":769.899,"endTime":772.349,"body":"learning other things as well."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":772.379,"endTime":774.849,"body":"And on the job training is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":772.379,"endTime":774.849,"body":"not much more than that."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":774.999,"endTime":777.999,"body":"It's the formal component"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":774.999,"endTime":777.999,"body":"that's different and that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":777.999,"endTime":780.889,"body":"formal component needs to have"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":777.999,"endTime":780.889,"body":"a number of different elements."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":781.0290000000001,"endTime":784.239,"body":"So you need the technical or"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":781.0290000000001,"endTime":784.239,"body":"digital skills that you need"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":784.3190000000001,"endTime":785.4590000000001,"body":"that employers can't find."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":785.759,"endTime":786.999,"body":"That's a lot of what we see."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":787.349,"endTime":790.769,"body":"But you also need to understand"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":787.349,"endTime":790.769,"body":"the industry that you're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":790.769,"endTime":793.5440000000001,"body":"working in and your job role."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":793.8240000000001,"endTime":796.214,"body":"So, for example, if you're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":793.8240000000001,"endTime":796.214,"body":"going to be a sales force"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":796.214,"endTime":799.4040000000001,"body":"administrator working for a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":796.214,"endTime":799.4040000000001,"body":"hospital, you don't understand"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":799.4140000000001,"endTime":802.624,"body":"the healthcare system and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":799.4140000000001,"endTime":802.624,"body":"how hospitals actually work."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":802.624,"endTime":804.0440000000001,"body":"You're not going to be"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":802.624,"endTime":804.0440000000001,"body":"effective at your job."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":804.8140000000001,"endTime":808.0740000000001,"body":"So, one of the apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":804.8140000000001,"endTime":808.0740000000001,"body":"programs that my group, Achieve"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":808.144,"endTime":811.4140000000001,"body":"Partners, helps run is a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":808.144,"endTime":811.4140000000001,"body":"healthcare IT apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":811.4140000000001,"endTime":815.0840000000001,"body":"program where we spend the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":811.4140000000001,"endTime":815.0840000000001,"body":"first month and a half basically"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":815.0840000000001,"endTime":817.764,"body":"just training people on to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":815.0840000000001,"endTime":817.764,"body":"understand the healthcare"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":817.764,"endTime":819.4140000000001,"body":"system and how healthcare works."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":819.6640000000001,"endTime":823.9440000000001,"body":"And then finally, there's a soft"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":819.6640000000001,"endTime":823.9440000000001,"body":"skills component as well to it."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":824.1940000000001,"endTime":826.354,"body":"You need to know for most"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":824.1940000000001,"endTime":826.354,"body":"of these individuals, it's"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":826.354,"endTime":828.854,"body":"their first, what I would"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":826.354,"endTime":828.854,"body":"call good job, first job"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":828.854,"endTime":830.384,"body":"in a professional setting."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":830.384,"endTime":833.7040000000001,"body":"First job is not kind of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":830.384,"endTime":833.7040000000001,"body":"a frontline worker job and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":833.705,"endTime":836.7840000000001,"body":"they need to understand how"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":833.705,"endTime":836.7840000000001,"body":"to interact, whether it's"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":836.7840000000001,"endTime":840.214,"body":"an in-person or remote work"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":836.7840000000001,"endTime":840.214,"body":"in a professional manner."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":840.884,"endTime":842.3040000000001,"body":"So I'd say those are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":840.884,"endTime":842.3040000000001,"body":"the three elements."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":843.1840000000001,"endTime":845.1840000000001,"body":"Anytime we talk"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":843.1840000000001,"endTime":845.1840000000001,"body":"about, talent development"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":845.1940000000001,"endTime":847.594,"body":"or recruiting or anything"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":845.1940000000001,"endTime":847.594,"body":"like that, we talk a little"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":847.594,"endTime":849.624,"body":"bit about diversity, equity"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":847.594,"endTime":849.624,"body":"and inclusion these days are"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":849.634,"endTime":851.5340000000001,"body":"central to the discussion"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":849.634,"endTime":851.5340000000001,"body":"in the corporate world."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":851.7840000000001,"endTime":855.5640000000001,"body":"How can companies kind of"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":851.7840000000001,"endTime":855.5640000000001,"body":"ensure that the apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":855.5640000000001,"endTime":858.0840000000001,"body":"programs, let's say that"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":855.5640000000001,"endTime":858.0840000000001,"body":"they partner with, reflect"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":858.9540000000001,"endTime":860.854,"body":"the inclusivity and offer"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":858.9540000000001,"endTime":860.854,"body":"the opportunities to"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":860.854,"endTime":862.994,"body":"underrepresented groups"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":860.854,"endTime":862.994,"body":"that they're intending to?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":863.224,"endTime":865.524,"body":"Well, I mean, first"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":863.224,"endTime":865.524,"body":"of all, again, apprenticeships"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":865.5340000000001,"endTime":868.374,"body":"are the only pathway that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":865.5340000000001,"endTime":868.374,"body":"offer true level playing field."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":868.384,"endTime":871.0840000000001,"body":"So they're as accessible to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":868.384,"endTime":871.0840000000001,"body":"the most underprivileged,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":871.114,"endTime":874.3240000000001,"body":"underrepresented individual"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":871.114,"endTime":874.3240000000001,"body":"as they are to someone"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":874.3240000000001,"endTime":876.8140000000001,"body":"who was born on third base"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":874.3240000000001,"endTime":876.8140000000001,"body":"thinks they hit a triple."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":877.104,"endTime":881.714,"body":"So that what we find is that our"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":877.104,"endTime":881.714,"body":"apprenticeship infrastructure"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":881.714,"endTime":886.619,"body":"today is so, so limited that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":881.714,"endTime":886.619,"body":"every time one of our companies"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":886.869,"endTime":890.009,"body":"launches an apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":886.869,"endTime":890.009,"body":"program, we have two or"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":890.009,"endTime":893.139,"body":"three hundred applicants for"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":890.009,"endTime":893.139,"body":"every seat in the cohort."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":893.379,"endTime":893.969,"body":"And why not?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":894.139,"endTime":897.969,"body":"Because these apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":894.139,"endTime":897.969,"body":"pathways are essentially,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":898.0790000000001,"endTime":900.589,"body":"if you're successful, you're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":898.0790000000001,"endTime":900.589,"body":"going to be making six figures"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":900.589,"endTime":903.619,"body":"in three or four years in a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":900.589,"endTime":903.619,"body":"sector that you knew nothing"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":903.619,"endTime":906.5590000000001,"body":"about and with hard digital"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":903.619,"endTime":906.5590000000001,"body":"platform skills that you didn't"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":906.5590000000001,"endTime":907.9290000000001,"body":"have coming into the job."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":908.4090000000001,"endTime":911.3290000000001,"body":"So whether it's a Salesforce"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":908.4090000000001,"endTime":911.3290000000001,"body":"or cybersecurity or healthcare"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":911.3290000000001,"endTime":916.5590000000001,"body":"IT or a workday apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":911.3290000000001,"endTime":916.5590000000001,"body":"program, we have 200, 300"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":916.5590000000001,"endTime":917.509,"body":"applicants for every seat."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":917.509,"endTime":921.599,"body":"And so we screen not on"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":917.509,"endTime":921.599,"body":"specific skills, we screen on"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":921.609,"endTime":924.3190000000001,"body":"aptitude, we screen on interest"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":921.609,"endTime":924.3190000000001,"body":"and we screen on diversity."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":924.7090000000001,"endTime":926.979,"body":"Because if we can help,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":924.7090000000001,"endTime":926.979,"body":"if our intermediaries"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":927.1690000000001,"endTime":930.599,"body":"can help their clients"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":927.1690000000001,"endTime":930.599,"body":"also diversify their tech"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":930.619,"endTime":932.2090000000001,"body":"workforces, it's another win."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":932.6590000000001,"endTime":935.349,"body":"So our cohorts tend to be"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":932.6590000000001,"endTime":935.349,"body":"majority underrepresented"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":935.359,"endTime":938.399,"body":"minority in fields"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":935.359,"endTime":938.399,"body":"where the percentage of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":938.4290000000001,"endTime":942.609,"body":"underrepresented minorities"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":938.4290000000001,"endTime":942.609,"body":"are 5%, 10% typically."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":943.2090000000001,"endTime":947.489,"body":"So, yeah, we think it's a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":943.2090000000001,"endTime":947.489,"body":"hugely useful tool for DEI"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":947.739,"endTime":951.1740000000001,"body":"to help diversify workforces,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":947.739,"endTime":951.1740000000001,"body":"especially in fields where"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":951.214,"endTime":952.394,"body":"that's a major problem."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":953.514,"endTime":954.9540000000001,"body":"We're in this"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":953.514,"endTime":954.9540000000001,"body":"time where everybody's talking"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":954.9540000000001,"endTime":956.004,"body":"about automation, right?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":956.004,"endTime":958.344,"body":"You know, AI and other"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":956.004,"endTime":958.344,"body":"technological advancements."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":958.6640000000001,"endTime":960.024,"body":"I'm curious, how do"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":958.6640000000001,"endTime":960.024,"body":"you see apprenticeships"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":960.024,"endTime":963.0840000000001,"body":"adapting to stay relevant"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":960.024,"endTime":963.0840000000001,"body":"in that future job market?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":963.094,"endTime":965.4440000000001,"body":"And it's almost kind of"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":963.094,"endTime":965.4440000000001,"body":"inevitable because if AI"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":965.4440000000001,"endTime":967.354,"body":"is going to be replacing"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":965.4440000000001,"endTime":967.354,"body":"jobs, don't we all kind"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":967.354,"endTime":969.4140000000001,"body":"of have to almost take an"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":967.354,"endTime":969.4140000000001,"body":"apprenticeship approach?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":969.8340000000001,"endTime":971.1940000000001,"body":"Yeah, look,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":969.8340000000001,"endTime":971.1940000000001,"body":"I think you're right."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":971.234,"endTime":974.734,"body":"And I think the reason you're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":971.234,"endTime":974.734,"body":"right is that what a generative"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":974.734,"endTime":978.504,"body":"AI is already doing, it may be"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":974.734,"endTime":978.504,"body":"shrinking the skills gap, right?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":978.514,"endTime":981.734,"body":"Like you may not need to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":978.514,"endTime":981.734,"body":"master Salesforce in the same"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":981.734,"endTime":983.764,"body":"way in a couple of years,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":981.734,"endTime":983.764,"body":"because there will be a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":983.764,"endTime":984.774,"body":"sort of a natural language."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":984.774,"endTime":987.484,"body":"You'll be able to just, tell"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":984.774,"endTime":987.484,"body":"the system what you want to do."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":987.8140000000001,"endTime":988.8340000000001,"body":"So there's that element."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":989.4040000000001,"endTime":992.764,"body":"But the other element is that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":989.4040000000001,"endTime":992.764,"body":"it's going to dramatically"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":992.764,"endTime":995.729,"body":"widen the experience gap"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":992.764,"endTime":995.729,"body":"that we were talking about."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":996.219,"endTime":999.5390000000001,"body":"So think about your first"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":996.219,"endTime":999.5390000000001,"body":"good job out of college."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":999.729,"endTime":1002.609,"body":"I know for me, probably"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":999.729,"endTime":1002.609,"body":"half of the time, half of my"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1002.619,"endTime":1006.609,"body":"hours were spent doing kind"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1002.619,"endTime":1006.609,"body":"of menial work that today"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1006.719,"endTime":1009.6990000000001,"body":"AI is like putting together"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1006.719,"endTime":1009.6990000000001,"body":"presentations for clients."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1009.964,"endTime":1010.2840000000001,"body":"Right?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1010.394,"endTime":1013.754,"body":"AI is going to do most,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1010.394,"endTime":1013.754,"body":"if not all of that work."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1013.874,"endTime":1016.644,"body":"And so the employers are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1013.874,"endTime":1016.644,"body":"going to expect that entry"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1016.644,"endTime":1020.6640000000001,"body":"level workers from day one are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1016.644,"endTime":1020.6640000000001,"body":"going to be doing higher value"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1020.9240000000001,"endTime":1025.134,"body":"tasks, the kind of tasks that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1020.9240000000001,"endTime":1025.134,"body":"we might do, with a year or"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1025.134,"endTime":1027.285,"body":"two years worth of experience."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1027.859,"endTime":1029.839,"body":"And so they're going"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1027.859,"endTime":1029.839,"body":"to be looking for that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1029.839,"endTime":1031.449,"body":"experience out of the gate."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1031.449,"endTime":1033.91,"body":"So that's why, I talked"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1031.449,"endTime":1033.91,"body":"about the entry level"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1033.91,"endTime":1034.96,"body":"cybersecurity job."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1035.279,"endTime":1038.079,"body":"The reason that entry level"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1035.279,"endTime":1038.079,"body":"cybersecurity job is really"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1038.079,"endTime":1041.31,"body":"not entry level anymore"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1038.079,"endTime":1041.31,"body":"is that those tier one"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1041.68,"endTime":1043.91,"body":"cybersecurity analyst jobs"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1041.68,"endTime":1043.91,"body":"have been largely automated."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1043.98,"endTime":1044.829,"body":"They're using AI."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1044.83,"endTime":1047.019,"body":"And so there really is no such"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1044.83,"endTime":1047.019,"body":"thing as tier one anymore."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1047.019,"endTime":1049.539,"body":"You're coming in and you're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1047.019,"endTime":1049.539,"body":"expected to do tier two"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1049.539,"endTime":1052.6090000000002,"body":"tasks, and you can't do two"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1049.539,"endTime":1052.6090000000002,"body":"tier tasks if you've never"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1052.65,"endTime":1054.05,"body":"worked in cybersecurity."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1054.43,"endTime":1058.45,"body":"So think about all good"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1054.43,"endTime":1058.45,"body":"entry-level jobs that college"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1058.45,"endTime":1061.63,"body":"graduates are either getting"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1058.45,"endTime":1061.63,"body":"or wanna get today moving"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1061.63,"endTime":1065.19,"body":"from tier one to tier two"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1061.63,"endTime":1065.19,"body":"jobs and tier two jobs are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1065.1950000000002,"endTime":1066.03,"body":"gonna require experience."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1066.03,"endTime":1066.99,"body":"So how are you gonna get that?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1066.99,"endTime":1068.13,"body":"There are three ways to do it."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1068.31,"endTime":1069.24,"body":"One is apprenticeship."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1069.54,"endTime":1071.7,"body":"Apprenticeship is kind"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1069.54,"endTime":1071.7,"body":"of the best way to do it."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1072.06,"endTime":1075.24,"body":"But you can also believe that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1072.06,"endTime":1075.24,"body":"schools, high schools and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1075.24,"endTime":1079.47,"body":"colleges and universities"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1075.24,"endTime":1079.47,"body":"do more to integrate"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1079.47,"endTime":1083.26,"body":"real work projects into"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1079.47,"endTime":1083.26,"body":"courses and classrooms."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1083.88,"endTime":1086.16,"body":"So, that is a possibility,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1083.88,"endTime":1086.16,"body":"what's called work"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1086.16,"endTime":1087.04,"body":"integrated learning."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1087.44,"endTime":1090.6200000000001,"body":"Requires a good deal of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1087.44,"endTime":1090.6200000000001,"body":"coordination, motivation on the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1090.6200000000001,"endTime":1093.569,"body":"part of schools and colleges and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1090.6200000000001,"endTime":1093.569,"body":"universities who typically have"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1093.5700000000002,"endTime":1094.99,"body":"not been motivated to do that."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1095.46,"endTime":1096.3,"body":"But that is one option."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1096.3,"endTime":1100.18,"body":"The second one is, or the third"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1096.3,"endTime":1100.18,"body":"option besides apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1100.18,"endTime":1102.0900000000001,"body":"and work integrated"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1100.18,"endTime":1102.0900000000001,"body":"learning is internships."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1102.21,"endTime":1104.0800000000002,"body":"So internships differ from"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1102.21,"endTime":1104.0800000000002,"body":"apprenticeships in that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1104.0800000000002,"endTime":1105.15,"body":"they're not full time jobs."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1105.3400000000001,"endTime":1108.1390000000001,"body":"They're jobs that you take while"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1105.3400000000001,"endTime":1108.1390000000001,"body":"you're enrolled in a formal"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1108.1390000000001,"endTime":1111.179,"body":"educational program and for a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1108.1390000000001,"endTime":1111.179,"body":"limited duration, typically."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1111.3990000000001,"endTime":1113.1490000000001,"body":"Hopefully they're paid,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1111.3990000000001,"endTime":1113.1490000000001,"body":"because if they're not paid,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1113.6090000000002,"endTime":1115.1190000000001,"body":"then they're inequitable."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1115.169,"endTime":1118.699,"body":"But, internships tend"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1115.169,"endTime":1118.699,"body":"to be informal, kind"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1118.699,"endTime":1120.179,"body":"of relationship based."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1120.654,"endTime":1122.834,"body":"Catch as catch can, and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1120.654,"endTime":1122.834,"body":"there are too many schools"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1122.904,"endTime":1125.4840000000002,"body":"out there that have done a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1122.904,"endTime":1125.4840000000002,"body":"good job systematizing and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1125.4840000000002,"endTime":1127.034,"body":"formalizing internships."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1127.304,"endTime":1130.674,"body":"So for my money, the best bet"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1127.304,"endTime":1130.674,"body":"is a modern apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1130.874,"endTime":1133.5040000000001,"body":"system like, most other"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1130.874,"endTime":1133.5040000000001,"body":"developed countries have and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1133.5040000000001,"endTime":1134.354,"body":"that we haven't built yet."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1134.894,"endTime":1137.2740000000001,"body":"You had talked"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1134.894,"endTime":1137.2740000000001,"body":"about you had 300 applicants"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1137.414,"endTime":1139.0240000000001,"body":"for one opening, right?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1139.114,"endTime":1141.634,"body":"How do you go through the"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1139.114,"endTime":1141.634,"body":"talent matching process"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1141.634,"endTime":1144.5240000000001,"body":"and identifying who that"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1141.634,"endTime":1144.5240000000001,"body":"sort of ideal person is?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1144.5240000000001,"endTime":1146.404,"body":"And is it sometimes"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1144.5240000000001,"endTime":1146.404,"body":"somebody you don't expect?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1146.434,"endTime":1147.644,"body":"Maybe they just"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1146.434,"endTime":1147.644,"body":"have the right..."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1147.824,"endTime":1148.4740000000002,"body":"Oh, totally."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1148.7240000000002,"endTime":1149.084,"body":"Yeah."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1149.114,"endTime":1151.7540000000001,"body":"So today our companies are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1149.114,"endTime":1151.7540000000001,"body":"doing it in a couple of ways."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1151.784,"endTime":1153.124,"body":"First of all no degree."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1153.294,"endTime":1154.7740000000001,"body":"We're never asking for a degree."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1154.784,"endTime":1156.154,"body":"So that's the easy, that's easy."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1156.454,"endTime":1159.364,"body":"The second is we do a lot"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1156.454,"endTime":1159.364,"body":"of assessments where we're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1159.364,"endTime":1163.154,"body":"assessing for what we think"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1159.364,"endTime":1163.154,"body":"is aptitude and we look at"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1163.404,"endTime":1165.354,"body":"who's good, what are the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1163.404,"endTime":1165.354,"body":"characteristics of someone"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1165.354,"endTime":1167.7640000000001,"body":"who's actually good at"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1165.354,"endTime":1167.7640000000001,"body":"doing that entry level job."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1168.174,"endTime":1170.394,"body":"And we kind of work backwards"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1168.174,"endTime":1170.394,"body":"into an assessment so"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1170.394,"endTime":1174.304,"body":"we can assess for those"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1170.394,"endTime":1174.304,"body":"capabilities up front."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1174.7340000000002,"endTime":1177.114,"body":"Where we're going to and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1174.7340000000002,"endTime":1177.114,"body":"where some of our companies"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1177.114,"endTime":1180.194,"body":"have already moved to is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1177.114,"endTime":1180.194,"body":"essentially a pre-course."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1180.214,"endTime":1182.424,"body":"So the best way to learn"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1180.214,"endTime":1182.424,"body":"if someone's going to be"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1182.424,"endTime":1184.4740000000002,"body":"good at something is to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1182.424,"endTime":1184.4740000000002,"body":"give them a trial, right?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1184.4740000000002,"endTime":1188.044,"body":"We know that to be trials,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1184.4740000000002,"endTime":1188.044,"body":"job trials are four times"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1188.044,"endTime":1191.194,"body":"more effective than the next"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1188.044,"endTime":1191.194,"body":"best predictor of whether"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1191.194,"endTime":1192.2540000000001,"body":"someone can do a job."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1192.5240000000001,"endTime":1195.464,"body":"So we're going to be giving"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1192.5240000000001,"endTime":1195.464,"body":"candidates or, those interested"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1195.464,"endTime":1198.2340000000002,"body":"in these apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1195.464,"endTime":1198.2340000000002,"body":"programs kind of trials through,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1198.2440000000001,"endTime":1202.2540000000001,"body":"short online courses where"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1198.2440000000001,"endTime":1202.2540000000001,"body":"they'll be doing coursework"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1202.304,"endTime":1205.2640000000001,"body":"that will demonstrate their,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1202.304,"endTime":1205.2640000000001,"body":"not just capability, but"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1205.2640000000001,"endTime":1207.644,"body":"also interest level in the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1205.2640000000001,"endTime":1207.644,"body":"apprenticeship program."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1208.194,"endTime":1211.124,"body":"And those who complete that,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1208.194,"endTime":1211.124,"body":"sort of pre apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1211.164,"endTime":1214.059,"body":"course will be at a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1211.164,"endTime":1214.059,"body":"minimum guaranteed in an"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1214.059,"endTime":1217.3490000000002,"body":"in-person interview with the"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1214.059,"endTime":1217.3490000000002,"body":"recruiter for the cohort."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1217.479,"endTime":1220.539,"body":"So that's one way to guarantee"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1217.479,"endTime":1220.539,"body":"that you don't just send your"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1220.539,"endTime":1222.909,"body":"resume off and you never hear"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1220.539,"endTime":1222.909,"body":"about the position again, which"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1222.909,"endTime":1226.929,"body":"is the typical sort of job"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1222.909,"endTime":1226.929,"body":"applicant experience nowadays."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1227.529,"endTime":1229.229,"body":"Now, there have"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1227.529,"endTime":1229.229,"body":"been some companies that"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1229.229,"endTime":1232.3490000000002,"body":"have attempted to start their"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1229.229,"endTime":1232.3490000000002,"body":"own apprenticeship program."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1232.8790000000001,"endTime":1235.789,"body":"I'm curious, what has been your"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1232.8790000000001,"endTime":1235.789,"body":"impression of say, like, I think"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1235.979,"endTime":1237.3590000000002,"body":"Google has one for example."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1237.3590000000002,"endTime":1238.909,"body":"So what has been your"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1237.3590000000002,"endTime":1238.909,"body":"impression of the efforts"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1238.909,"endTime":1240.949,"body":"that have been made by"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1238.909,"endTime":1240.949,"body":"companies rather than you?"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1242.299,"endTime":1244.289,"body":"What are some of the lessons"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1242.299,"endTime":1244.289,"body":"that they've learned, maybe?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1244.589,"endTime":1246.439,"body":"So I was at"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1244.589,"endTime":1246.439,"body":"a meeting a couple of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1246.439,"endTime":1248.929,"body":"weeks ago where about"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1246.439,"endTime":1248.929,"body":"the future of the U.S."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1248.949,"endTime":1252.909,"body":"workforce and a bunch of Fortune"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1248.949,"endTime":1252.909,"body":"500 companies were in attendance"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1253.039,"endTime":1256.019,"body":"and they started bragging about"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1253.039,"endTime":1256.019,"body":"their apprenticeship programs."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1256.3690000000001,"endTime":1259.309,"body":"And one of them was a big"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1256.3690000000001,"endTime":1259.309,"body":"systems integrator that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1259.309,"endTime":1262.679,"body":"said, well, we've hired"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1259.309,"endTime":1262.679,"body":"2000 over the last 10 years."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1262.689,"endTime":1266.689,"body":"And then another one, a gigantic"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1262.689,"endTime":1266.689,"body":"food service company, we just"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1266.689,"endTime":1269.6190000000001,"body":"hired a new cohort of three"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1266.689,"endTime":1269.6190000000001,"body":"cybersecurity apprentices."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1269.989,"endTime":1273.189,"body":"And given the scale of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1269.989,"endTime":1273.189,"body":"these companies, 2000 over"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1273.189,"endTime":1275.8890000000001,"body":"a decade, it's kind of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1273.189,"endTime":1275.8890000000001,"body":"laughable and three is a joke."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1276.3890000000001,"endTime":1280.229,"body":"So it's just, the scale"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1276.3890000000001,"endTime":1280.229,"body":"that these programs that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1280.229,"endTime":1281.229,"body":"companies run of their own."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1281.279,"endTime":1282.8990000000001,"body":"And again, why, you know,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1281.279,"endTime":1282.8990000000001,"body":"why should we expect"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1282.909,"endTime":1284.449,"body":"companies to run their own"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1282.909,"endTime":1284.449,"body":"apprenticeship programs?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1284.449,"endTime":1285.989,"body":"We don't ask them to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1284.449,"endTime":1285.989,"body":"run their own schools"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1286.3590000000002,"endTime":1287.289,"body":"to train their talent."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1287.579,"endTime":1290.089,"body":"So most companies have"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1287.579,"endTime":1290.089,"body":"gone the other direction."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1290.259,"endTime":1293.3790000000001,"body":"Most companies used to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1290.259,"endTime":1293.3790000000001,"body":"do much more on training"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1293.3990000000001,"endTime":1294.489,"body":"entry level talent."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1294.8590000000002,"endTime":1297.919,"body":"And today there's much more"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1294.8590000000002,"endTime":1297.919,"body":"of it as an expectation that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1298.019,"endTime":1301.729,"body":"we want folks who were kind"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1298.019,"endTime":1301.729,"body":"of perfectly suited for this"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1301.729,"endTime":1303.579,"body":"role and will come and will"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1301.729,"endTime":1303.579,"body":"be productive on day one."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1303.579,"endTime":1304.6490000000001,"body":"Now there are exceptions, right?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1304.699,"endTime":1307.799,"body":"You know, the, at the top end,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1304.699,"endTime":1307.799,"body":"the Goldman Sachs and McKinsey's"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1307.809,"endTime":1310.8690000000001,"body":"of the world, they hire really"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1307.809,"endTime":1310.8690000000001,"body":"smart people and they invest in"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1310.8690000000001,"endTime":1313.519,"body":"training them and they've have"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1310.8690000000001,"endTime":1313.519,"body":"business models that work too."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1313.8690000000001,"endTime":1316.6190000000001,"body":"For the vast majority of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1313.8690000000001,"endTime":1316.6190000000001,"body":"companies, it's not that they"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1316.6190000000001,"endTime":1319.319,"body":"really want someone who's going"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1316.6190000000001,"endTime":1319.319,"body":"to be productive on day one."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1319.549,"endTime":1322.339,"body":"And so, the idea that somehow"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1319.549,"endTime":1322.339,"body":"we should just wait around and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1322.339,"endTime":1325.159,"body":"hope that, employers themselves"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1322.339,"endTime":1325.159,"body":"are going to, figure out how"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1325.159,"endTime":1328.409,"body":"to run these programs I think,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1325.159,"endTime":1328.409,"body":"you know, the fact that we are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1328.409,"endTime":1331.759,"body":"last among developed countries"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1328.409,"endTime":1331.759,"body":"on apprenticeship is kind of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1331.759,"endTime":1332.8990000000001,"body":"proof that that doesn't work."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1333.229,"endTime":1334.8790000000001,"body":"And then for our"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1333.229,"endTime":1334.8790000000001,"body":"listeners out there who are,"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1334.8890000000001,"endTime":1337.339,"body":"working with companies that are"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1334.8890000000001,"endTime":1337.339,"body":"starting to explore the idea"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1337.3890000000001,"endTime":1340.659,"body":"of introducing apprenticeships"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1337.3890000000001,"endTime":1340.659,"body":"into their orgs, what would"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1340.669,"endTime":1343.839,"body":"be sort of your top three"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1340.669,"endTime":1343.839,"body":"pieces of advice to ensure"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1343.839,"endTime":1346.249,"body":"that those programs have some"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1343.839,"endTime":1346.249,"body":"effectiveness from the start?"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1346.449,"endTime":1347.6490000000001,"body":"I would"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1346.449,"endTime":1347.6490000000001,"body":"say look for a partner."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1347.864,"endTime":1350.914,"body":"So, we're seeing the emergence"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1347.864,"endTime":1350.914,"body":"of a whole host of partners"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1351.144,"endTime":1353.454,"body":"that, you know, like Multiverse,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1351.144,"endTime":1353.454,"body":"for example, which has come"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1353.454,"endTime":1356.714,"body":"over from the UK and is a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1353.454,"endTime":1356.714,"body":"broad based apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1356.714,"endTime":1359.2240000000002,"body":"service provider that is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1356.714,"endTime":1359.2240000000002,"body":"working with, big companies"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1359.2240000000002,"endTime":1362.344,"body":"like Verizon, Google to launch"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1359.2240000000002,"endTime":1362.344,"body":"and run their apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1362.354,"endTime":1363.904,"body":"programs for them."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1363.914,"endTime":1366.7240000000002,"body":"Or companies like SkillStore,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1363.914,"endTime":1366.7240000000002,"body":"which are doing it for tech"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1366.7240000000002,"endTime":1369.964,"body":"apprenticeship programs or"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1366.7240000000002,"endTime":1369.964,"body":"nonprofits like Apprenti."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1370.269,"endTime":1373.159,"body":"And you're up to do such"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1370.269,"endTime":1373.159,"body":"perform the same function."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1373.439,"endTime":1377.319,"body":"So I, I think if you look at"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1373.439,"endTime":1377.319,"body":"all the things that you need"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1377.319,"endTime":1380.589,"body":"to do to run an apprenticeship"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1377.319,"endTime":1380.589,"body":"program, I talk about in"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1380.6390000000001,"endTime":1382.829,"body":"the book, there are about 10"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1380.6390000000001,"endTime":1382.829,"body":"things that you need to do"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1382.829,"endTime":1383.8790000000001,"body":"that you're not doing today."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1384.179,"endTime":1388.579,"body":"And the hardest is you're going"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1384.179,"endTime":1388.579,"body":"to be hiring and paying someone"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1388.679,"endTime":1392.239,"body":"or a bunch of people who are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1388.679,"endTime":1392.239,"body":"not productive in their jobs"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1392.669,"endTime":1393.789,"body":"for an extended period of time."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1393.799,"endTime":1396.3690000000001,"body":"And that's kind of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1393.799,"endTime":1396.3690000000001,"body":"anathema to most employers."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1396.8790000000001,"endTime":1399.199,"body":"So why not look for a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1396.8790000000001,"endTime":1399.199,"body":"partner who's willing to"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1399.219,"endTime":1400.729,"body":"take on that risk, cause"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1399.219,"endTime":1400.729,"body":"they're in the business"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1400.729,"endTime":1402.159,"body":"of doing it effectively."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1402.3790000000001,"endTime":1404.8890000000001,"body":"And whether they're for profit"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1402.3790000000001,"endTime":1404.8890000000001,"body":"or nonprofit, their business"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1404.8890000000001,"endTime":1407.719,"body":"model is setting up, running"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1404.8890000000001,"endTime":1407.719,"body":"this program and then passing"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1407.719,"endTime":1410.679,"body":"the talent onto you, reducing"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1407.719,"endTime":1410.679,"body":"the risk, reducing the cost."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1410.779,"endTime":1413.8490000000002,"body":"I mean, I would say, think about"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1410.779,"endTime":1413.8490000000002,"body":"all the things your company"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1413.949,"endTime":1417.259,"body":"partners on or outsources"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1413.949,"endTime":1417.259,"body":"to specialized partners."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1417.564,"endTime":1418.894,"body":"Apprenticeship should"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1417.564,"endTime":1418.894,"body":"be one of those."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1418.964,"endTime":1420.554,"body":"Apprenticeship should"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1418.964,"endTime":1420.554,"body":"be one of those things."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1420.7540000000001,"endTime":1424.204,"body":"And so I think that the, kind"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1420.7540000000001,"endTime":1424.204,"body":"of to do it ourselves, there"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1424.204,"endTime":1426.194,"body":"are lots of companies who have"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1424.204,"endTime":1426.194,"body":"the idea to do it and they"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1426.194,"endTime":1428.0240000000001,"body":"look at what's involved and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1426.194,"endTime":1428.0240000000001,"body":"then they kind of give up."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1428.564,"endTime":1431.594,"body":"Or they look at what's involved"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1428.564,"endTime":1431.594,"body":"and they hire three, and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1431.644,"endTime":1432.584,"body":"that's kind of the end of it."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1432.594,"endTime":1436.384,"body":"So the way to scale again is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1432.594,"endTime":1436.384,"body":"to tap this emerging network"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1436.384,"endTime":1439.4940000000001,"body":"of intermediaries that we're"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1436.384,"endTime":1439.4940000000001,"body":"seeing and that network is"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1439.4940000000001,"endTime":1442.0040000000001,"body":"going to grow much larger"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1439.4940000000001,"endTime":1442.0040000000001,"body":"as we begin to figure out"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1442.0040000000001,"endTime":1443.534,"body":"the public policy on this."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1443.884,"endTime":1444.534,"body":"Yeah,"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1443.884,"endTime":1444.534,"body":"it's interesting."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1444.674,"endTime":1446.684,"body":"I think you just touched on"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1444.674,"endTime":1446.684,"body":"something really important"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1446.684,"endTime":1449.2340000000002,"body":"in that, it's one thing"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1446.684,"endTime":1449.2340000000002,"body":"that you, we have these"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1449.2340000000002,"endTime":1451.194,"body":"expectations of folks when they"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1449.2340000000002,"endTime":1451.194,"body":"come out of school and then"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1451.194,"endTime":1452.164,"body":"they don't have the skills."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1452.164,"endTime":1454.7740000000001,"body":"And I think for them, they"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1452.164,"endTime":1454.7740000000001,"body":"think they're going to go into"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1454.7740000000001,"endTime":1456.634,"body":"a job and really grow and learn."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1456.634,"endTime":1458.9840000000002,"body":"And it's actually kind of"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1456.634,"endTime":1458.9840000000002,"body":"a painful experience in"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1458.9840000000002,"endTime":1460.334,"body":"the beginning for them."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1460.334,"endTime":1462.604,"body":"So, and that there's a cost"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1460.334,"endTime":1462.604,"body":"to the business and sort"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1462.604,"endTime":1465.594,"body":"of a cost to morale through"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1462.604,"endTime":1465.594,"body":"the experience that happens."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1465.604,"endTime":1467.854,"body":"So I think it's a really"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1465.604,"endTime":1467.854,"body":"important thing that we've,"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1467.894,"endTime":1469.184,"body":"we do start to explore this."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1469.4740000000002,"endTime":1470.104,"body":"That's interesting."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1470.104,"endTime":1470.464,"body":"Yeah."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1470.5040000000001,"endTime":1472.564,"body":"You know, I mean, you could"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1470.5040000000001,"endTime":1472.564,"body":"say that, yes, lots of people"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1472.574,"endTime":1475.5040000000001,"body":"have kind of demoralizing,"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1472.574,"endTime":1475.5040000000001,"body":"almost hazing experiences"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1475.5040000000001,"endTime":1476.7740000000001,"body":"in their first jobs."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1477.094,"endTime":1479.2540000000001,"body":"Apprenticeship programs are"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1477.094,"endTime":1479.2540000000001,"body":"not that because the people"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1479.2540000000001,"endTime":1483.144,"body":"who are involved with that take"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1479.2540000000001,"endTime":1483.144,"body":"more of a, education training"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1483.214,"endTime":1485.5040000000001,"body":"aspect to it where, and there's"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1483.214,"endTime":1485.5040000000001,"body":"a mentor formal mentoring"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1485.5040000000001,"endTime":1487.005,"body":"component built into it."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1487.0140000000001,"endTime":1489.0240000000001,"body":"And the expectation is that"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1487.0140000000001,"endTime":1489.0240000000001,"body":"you're, that you don't know"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1489.0240000000001,"endTime":1490.904,"body":"what you're doing on day one."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1491.134,"endTime":1492.914,"body":"And that, for most of these"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1491.134,"endTime":1492.914,"body":"programs, you're kind of"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1492.914,"endTime":1495.954,"body":"spending three months in a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1492.914,"endTime":1495.954,"body":"classroom before you're being"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1495.964,"endTime":1499.4740000000002,"body":"asked to do any, substantial and"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1495.964,"endTime":1499.4740000000002,"body":"it's that kind of commitment."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1499.4740000000002,"endTime":1501.934,"body":"But again, hard for a"},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1499.4740000000002,"endTime":1501.934,"body":"company to do themselves."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1502.7440000000001,"endTime":1503.374,"body":"Absolutely."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1503.7640000000001,"endTime":1506.344,"body":"Oh Ryan, thank you for giving us"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1503.7640000000001,"endTime":1506.344,"body":"a little bit of your time today."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1506.344,"endTime":1506.874,"body":"I appreciate it."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1506.884,"endTime":1509.534,"body":"That's I think this is a really"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1506.884,"endTime":1509.534,"body":"important topic and I hope to"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1509.534,"endTime":1511.714,"body":"see more employers exploring it."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1511.9840000000002,"endTime":1512.304,"body":"It's great."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1512.304,"endTime":1512.864,"body":"Well, thanks David."},{"speaker":"Ryan Craig","startTime":1512.904,"endTime":1513.544,"body":"Good being with you."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1514.824,"endTime":1516.064,"body":"If you're"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1514.824,"endTime":1516.064,"body":"interested in hearing more"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1516.064,"endTime":1519.034,"body":"from Ryan, be sure to follow"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1516.064,"endTime":1519.034,"body":"him on LinkedIn and you can"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1519.034,"endTime":1521.7340000000002,"body":"pick up a copy of Apprentice"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1519.034,"endTime":1521.7340000000002,"body":"Nation on Amazon or download"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1521.7540000000001,"endTime":1522.9940000000001,"body":"the audio version on auto."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1522.9940000000001,"endTime":1525.344,"body":"I want to thank you"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1522.9940000000001,"endTime":1525.344,"body":"for tuning in today."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1525.604,"endTime":1528.154,"body":"And if you'd like to keep up"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1525.604,"endTime":1528.154,"body":"to date on all things HR and"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1528.164,"endTime":1532.844,"body":"leadership, head on over to"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1528.164,"endTime":1532.844,"body":"peoplemanagingpeople.com/subscribe"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1532.844,"endTime":1534.219,"body":"and join our"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1532.844,"endTime":1534.219,"body":"newsletter community."},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1534.919,"endTime":1537.749,"body":"Until next time, I hope"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1534.919,"endTime":1537.749,"body":"you find some fresh air and"},{"speaker":"David Rice","startTime":1537.749,"endTime":1538.8490000000002,"body":"laugh at something silly."}]}