Practice to Profit: Simple Business Growth Strategies for Sustainable Success

Stop Grading Your Email Metrics

Subscriber Episode Jenny Melrose: Business Strategist Episode 280

This episode is only available to subscribers.

Unhinged with Jenny Melrose

Less noise. More clarity. 3 premium episodes each week to help you grow smarter!

Your email open rate is not a judgment of your skill, and it’s definitely not a pass or fail grade. I’m breaking down how to read email marketing metrics as signals so you can make smarter decisions, faster. Instead of chasing industry benchmarks that may not match your niche, we focus on trend-based analysis: your last 30 days, your last 90 days, and the same period last year. That simple shift turns your dashboard into a roadmap for growth.

We dig into list growth the right way by tracking new subscribers per month, growth rate, unsubscribe rate, and the true sources of your subscribers. If you don’t know which lead magnet is converting, where it’s being found, or whether those subscribers match your offer, list growth can quietly become expensive noise. From there, we tackle open rate as a directional metric and talk about how Apple Mail Privacy Protection changes what “opens” even means. You’ll also learn how to compare similar emails and refresh subject lines so they don’t become predictable.

Then we get to the action metrics: click-through rate and sales conversion. We look at what makes people click, how to strengthen your call to action, why one clear link can outperform a cluttered email, and how to spot whether you have an open problem or a conversion problem. Finally, we reframe unsubscribes as healthy list cleanup, show you what unsubscribe spikes can teach you, and walk through quick diagnoses like high opens with low clicks or high clicks with low sales. If this helps you see your email data with fresh eyes, subscribe, share it with a friend, and leave a review. What metric do you want to improve first?

People on this episode