Dr. Joe Pierre - Why We Believe What Isn’t True

Thoughts on Record: Podcast of the Ottawa Institute of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy

Thoughts on Record: Podcast of the Ottawa Institute of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy
Dr. Joe Pierre - Why We Believe What Isn’t True
Apr 21, 2025 Season 6 Episode 6

Comments or feedback? Send us a text!

In this episode, I’m joined by Dr. Joe Pierre, psychiatrist and author of False, to explore why people believe things that aren’t true—and why challenging those beliefs is rarely as simple as presenting the facts. Drawing from research in psychiatry, cognitive science, and social psychology, Dr. Pierre unpacks the emotional, identity-based, and relational roots of misinformation and conspiratorial thinking.  Whether you’re a clinician, educator, or simply someone trying to make sense of our “post-truth” era, this conversation offers an evidence-based look at the psychology behind false beliefs. In this conversation we discuss: 

  • Why smart people believe irrational things  
  • The emotional and identity functions of conspiracy theories  
  • How misinformation spreads—and why it's so sticky  
  • The limits of fact-checking and logic-based persuasion  
  • The "prognosis" for someone who believes in conspiracy theories  
  • The role of mental illness in extreme beliefs (and where the line is)  
  • Online echo chambers, tribalism, and distrust in institutions  
  • The psychological appeal of certainty in uncertain times  
  • Strategies for promoting critical thinking and intellectual humility  

Bio: Joe Pierre, MD, is a clinical professor in the Department of Psychiatry and Biobehavioral Sciences at the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA. With a background in both molecular biology and psychology from MIT and medical training at UCLA, Dr. Pierre’s career has focused on severe mental illness, particularly psychotic disorders. In addition to his clinical work, he’s a prolific writer and commentator on the psychology of belief, delusion, and misinformation. His Psych Unseen column for Psychology Today explores the intersection of psychiatry, media, and culture. False is his definitive exploration of why we believe things that aren’t true, and what that means for our mental health and collective future.

drjoepierre.com

psychologytoday.com/us/blog/psych-unseen

@psychunseen

@psychunseen.bsky.social

Episode Artwork Dr. Joe Pierre - Why We Believe What Isn’t True 56:38 Episode Artwork Dr. Scott Waltman & Kasey Pierce: Stoicism for the Modern Mind 1:01:13 Episode Artwork Dr. Betsy Chung - Building Emotional Security Within Relationships 51:44 Episode Artwork Donna Jackson Nakazawa: Healing Adverse Childhood Experiences 56:13 Episode Artwork Dr. Yona Bouskila - Do We Have Freewill? 58:16 Episode Artwork Dr. Sharon Martin - Better Boundaries 57:28 Episode Artwork Dr. René Mõttus - Personality Predicts Life Satisfaction 57:57 Episode Artwork Amanda Petrik-Gardner, LCPC - Excessive Reassurance Seeking 54:14 Episode Artwork Dr. Nina Josefowtiz - Behavioural Activation for Depression 1:21:46 Episode Artwork Dr. Lindsay Gibson: Disentangling from Emotionally Immature People 57:28 Episode Artwork Dr. Russell Ramsay - Assessing and Treating Adult ADHD 1:29:12 Episode Artwork Dr. Alec Pollard: When a Loved One Won’t Seek Mental Health Treatment 1:07:14 Episode Artwork Emma Lauer, LCSW: DBT Skills for Highly Sensitive People 51:53 Episode Artwork Dr. Stephanie Catella - Building Emotional Intelligence 53:08 Episode Artwork Dr. Holly Swartz - Social Rhythm Therapy for Bipolar Disorder 53:45 Episode Artwork Dr. Leslie Becker-Phelps: Insecure in Love 54:41 Episode Artwork Drs. Matt Browne & Chris Kavanagh - Decoding the Gurus 1:19:14 Episode Artwork Dr. Kiran Vadaga - Mindfulness of Feelings from a Buddhist Psychology Perspective 1:14:35 Episode Artwork Dr. Mark Solms - Understanding Consciousness to Optimize Therapeutic Outcomes 1:30:13 Episode Artwork Dr. Georgia Ede - Change your Diet, Change your Mind 1:07:07 Episode Artwork Anna Motz - If Love Could Kill: The Myths & Truths of Women Who Commit Violence 1:10:21 Episode Artwork Dr. James Hollis - Living a Life of Meaning 1:02:05 Episode Artwork Dr. Kevin Gary - Coping With Existential Boredom 59:14 Episode Artwork Dr. Randy Nesse - Depression & the Art of Giving Up 1:04:02 Episode Artwork Dr. Marie-Hélène Pelletier - Helping Clinicians to Develop Resilience 1:00:19