I Killed Maria Goretti with Michael Lichens

Gotta Be Saints

Gotta Be Saints
I Killed Maria Goretti with Michael Lichens
Jul 01, 2025 Season 12 Episode 219
Brendan Gotta

Send us a text

In this episode of the Gotta Be Saints Podcast, I sit down with Michael Lichens — author, editor, and one of today’s best storytellers on Catholic saints and forgotten holy witnesses.

Michael joins me to discuss I Killed Maria Goretti, a gripping true story about the life, martyrdom, and legacy of Saint Maria Goretti — and the stunning conversion of her murderer, Alessandro Serenelli. Originally written by Pietro Di Donato and newly republished by Sophia Institute Press, this book draws from firsthand interviews with Maria’s family, the friars who knew Alessandro, and Alessandro himself.

But this conversation goes far beyond history — it’s a powerful reflection on mercy, radical forgiveness, and how no soul is beyond the reach of God’s grace. Michael shares the details of Maria’s heroic witness, the unimaginable forgiveness shown by her mother, and how Alessandro’s heart was transformed from hardness to holiness.

This episode offers inspiring insights for anyone wrestling with sin, guilt, or the question: Can I really be forgiven? You’ll come away reminded that God’s mercy can heal even the most broken hearts and that we, too, are called to offer that mercy to others.

Topics Covered:

  • The story behind I Killed Maria Goretti and why it’s so unique
  • Who was Maria Goretti before her martyrdom — her devotion, daily life, and heroic virtue
  • Alessandro Serenelli’s tragic background and what led to the crime
  • The radical forgiveness Maria offered on her deathbed — and what it means for us
  • How Alessandro’s life was changed through Maria’s intercession
  • The importance of sharing stories of mercy in a world obsessed with outrage
  • Why Michael believes Maria Goretti is a perfect saint for our time

📖 Get the Book:
I Killed Maria Goretti by Pietro Di Donato is newly republished by Sophia Institute Press — pick up your copy here.

📲 Try Truthly (Sponsored):
Truthly is the world’s first Catholic action app — your AI sidekick for daily reflections, instant teachings, and confidence in sharing the faith. Get started here and use code gottabesaints for a free trial.

🎙️ Join the Conversation:
Subscribe, share, and leave a review if this episode deepened your trust in God’s mercy and inspired you to become an agent of forgiveness in your own life.

Support the show

Episode Artwork I Killed Maria Goretti with Michael Lichens 18:54 Episode Artwork Unsolicited Advice with George Weigel 30:02 Episode Artwork Cardinal George Pell with Tess Livingstone 33:00 Episode Artwork Pope Leo XIV with Fr. Joseph Fessio, S.J. 35:57 Episode Artwork From Calvinist to Catholic with Dr. Peter Kreeft 32:00 Episode Artwork Piety and Personality: The Temperaments of the Saints 34:46 Episode Artwork The Catholic Roots of Nagasaki with James Nolan 38:47 Episode Artwork The Hour of Testing with Fr. Donald Haggerty 36:53 Episode Artwork The Secret to Holiness - Lessons from Our Lady 32:42 Episode Artwork Christ Is Risen - Now What? 16:38 Episode Artwork The Glacier Priest with Dr. Josh McMullen 36:48 Episode Artwork From the Messianic Movement to the Catholicism with Matthew Wiseman 38:19 Episode Artwork Seeing Christ in Others with Michael Acaldo 46:18 Episode Artwork The Fruit of Pilgrimage with Fr. John Nepil 27:45 Episode Artwork Adventure: The Anxiety Antidote with Adam Trufant 37:13 Episode Artwork Catholic Heroes of Civil and Religious Rights with Roxanne King 26:56 Episode Artwork The Importance of a Good Book with Joseph Pearce 22:05 Episode Artwork Superhabits With Dr. Andrew Abela 28:20 Episode Artwork The Joyful Mysteries of the Rosary 20:02 Episode Artwork Going on Mission with Anna Gagnet 50:23 Episode Artwork The Call to Daily Conversion with Fr. James Kubicki, SJ 29:18 Episode Artwork The Life and Legacy of Fr. Joseph Fessio, SJ 19:01 Episode Artwork Finding Truth with Fr. Gregory Pine, OP 34:47 Episode Artwork Finding Freedom Part Four - Making a Choice 55:24 Episode Artwork Finding Freedom Part Three - Detachment 49:01