ChiTuckyBourbonBrothers

Episode 138 - Colonial E.H. Taylor Single Barrel

ChiTucky Bourbon Brothers Season 7 Episode 12

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 28:32

Send us Fan Mail

A $60-$80 single barrel bourbon should not taste like furniture polish, yet sometimes it does and that’s the risk we all sign up for when “single barrel” is on the label. We pick up that thread and go deep on Colonel E.H. Taylor Single Barrel from Buffalo Trace, starting with a bottle that didn’t taste right and ending with one that absolutely delivers.

The turning point is the detective work: we hold the bottle up to the light, find the tiny laser etching, and decode what it means. Our pour is traced to a bottling date of June 9, 2020, and we talk through what the letter and digits can and can’t tell you without Buffalo Trace’s internal database. From there, we get into the bigger question bourbon fans argue about nonstop: why certain years get more “secondary market chatter,” and why you can’t judge a whole label by one off barrel.

Then we taste. Expect real, specific bourbon tasting notes: a balanced sweet nose, oak that suggests age, a dry start that blooms into apple-like sweetness, citrus leaning grapefruit, a honey lift, and a medium-to-long finish with a peppery kick and a light Kentucky hug. We also compare bottles, talk store picks like Binny’s, and map out a practical “P-O-U-R man’s” route to high-end complexity without chasing unicorn prices. If you like bourbon nerdiness with laughs, a surprise Roomba cameo, and a little E.H. Taylor history, this one’s for you.

Subscribe for more tastings, share this with your bourbon group chat, and leave a review if you want us to keep hunting the best barrels. What’s the best single barrel you’ve ever opened?

People on this episode