The Days Grimm Podcast
The Days Grimm, "arguably Indiana's most comical, thrilling, and controversial podcast", This three-pronged mandate acts as a primary filter for their guest selection. The "comical" aspect is reflected in its official genre of "COMEDY INTERVIEWS" and its history of hosting local stand-up comedians. The "thrilling" component is evident in interviews with individuals who have extraordinary life stories, such as people who survived shootings, rare medical conditions, and combat. Finally, the "controversial" element is demonstrated by Brian & Thomas’ willingness to engage in difficult or unfiltered conversations, touching on topics like homelessness, artificial intelligence, and religious hypotheticals.
A crucial element of the show's tone is its tagline, "Brought to you by Sadness & ADHD (non-medicated)". This self-aware and raw positioning signals a modern comedic sensibility that embraces vulnerability and finds humor in personal struggle. The podcast's brand is not built on polished narratives but on the authentic, often messy, intersection of hardship and humor. The most compelling guests are those who have navigated a "Grimm" reality and emerged with a story to tell, and ideally, a sense of humor about it. This dynamic is the core of the show's appeal and the primary filter for identifying a story worth telling.
The Days Grimm Podcast
CC017 The First Magician, Military Recruiter Fails & Dark Comedy | Andy Imlay
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Comedian Andy Imlay returns to The Days Grimm Podcast for a record-breaking fourth appearance, making him the only guest to appear four separate times with four different backdrops. From testing the boundaries of dark comedy to hilarious small-town Boonville drama, this Comedy Cache episode is packed with unfiltered laughs and wild stories.
In this episode, Brian, Cory, and Tom sit down with Andy to explore the mechanics of writing comedy and where the line is drawn with dark humor, referencing heavy-hitting acts like Anthony Jeselnik, Jimmy Carr, and Jim Jeffries. Andy shares a brand new stand-up premise exploring whether historical and religious figures were actually the world's first magicians. He also recounts the unforgettable, laugh-out-loud story of scoring in the 98th percentile on the ASVAB test, only to severely shock the National Guard military recruiter who walked into the office to find Andy on crutches. Whether you are an aspiring comic or just love wild stories about everyday absurdities, this conversation delivers.
Comedy is all about timing, as the crew discusses how tragedy plus timing equals comedy. This episode provides a behind-the-scenes look into a comedian's mind, showing how everyday observations—from weird community Facebook pages to viral videos of Amish communities—can be transformed into engaging stage material.
If you enjoyed this episode with Andy Imlay, be sure to subscribe to The Days Grimm Podcast for more comedy cache episodes, wild stories, and interviews! Hit the like button, share this video with a friend, and let us know your favorite moment in the comments below.
TIMELINE :
00:00 - Intro & Andy Imlay's 4th podcast appearance
03:06 - Andy's feature on the Weird Careers podcast
07:16 - Dark humor boundaries, Anthony Jeselnik, and Jimmy Carr
17:49 - Andy's new stand-up premise: Who was the first magician? 2
6:24 - The hilarious military recruiter ASVAB story
29:22 - Taking a live online IQ test
34:00 - Audience bucket premise
36:41 - Reacting to Amish men moving a barn by hand
41:25 - Discussing Helen Keller and Steve Martin movies
46:20 - Small town Boonville drama & community Facebook pages
54:35 - Details on Andy's upcoming VFW comedy show
[The Days Grimm Podcast Links]
- YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/TheDaysGrimm
- Our link tree: linktr.ee/Thedaysgrimm
- GoFundMe account for The Days Grimm: https://gofund.me/02527e7c
[The Days Grimm is brought to you by]
Sadness & ADHD (non-medicated)