AI Generated (E): KS Pulse - Math, Minds, and Machines How Small Models Think Deeply

Englisch Version - The German Version also exists, but the content differs minimally:

AI-generated News of the Day. The Pulse is an experiment to see if it is interesting to get the latest news in 5 min. small packages generated by an AI every day.

It is completely AI-generated. Only the content is curated. Carsten and I select suitable news items. After that, the manuscript and the audio file are automatically created.

Accordingly, we cannot always guarantee accuracy.

Can LLMs Generate Novel Research Ideas? A Large-Scale Human Study with 100+ NLP Researchers - https://arxiv.org/pdf/2409.04109

rStar-Math: Small LLMs Can Master Math Reasoning with Self-Evolved Deep Thinking - https://arxiv.org/pdf/2501.04519 

Transcript

Welcome to the Knowledge Science Pulse podcast. I'm your host Sigurd, and joining me is my co-host Carsten.

Today, we’re diving into two exciting AI studies: one on how small AI models can master complex math reasoning and another on whether AI can generate novel research ideas.

Carsten, do you think AI can truly think like a human when solving math problems?

#### That’s a big question. AI is great at calculations, but deep reasoning? Im not so sure.

What does the first paper say?

####The first paper introduces rStar-Math a method that enables small language models to achieve math reasoning capabilities comparable to top-tier AI systems like those from OpenAI

####That’s surprising. Smaller models outperforming giants like GPT-4? How do they do it?

####It’s all about deep thinking. Instead of making a single guess, rStar-Math uses Monte Carlo Tree Search to explore multiple reasoning paths.

It also uses a self-evolution process AI generates math problems, solves them, and improves itself in cycles. Over four rounds, this method drastically improved model accuracy.

####That’s impressive!

How much better did it get?

####The results are staggering. For example, on the MATH benchmark, a 7-billion parameter model went from 58.8% accuracy to 90%, surpassing OpenAI’s top model!

On the USA Math Olympiad, rStar-Math solved 53.3% of problems—ranking among the top 20% of high school competitors.

####So instead of just training on pre-existing math problems, the AI is essentially teaching itself through trial and error?

####Exactly! It generates and verifies solutions using code execution, ensuring its reasoning is solid.

This method reduces errors and improves problem-solving skills without relying on larger AI models for supervision.

####That’s a game-changer for AI math reasoning. Now, you also mentioned AI generating novel research ideas. How does that work?

####The second paper tackles a fascinating question! Can AI come up with ideas that are as innovative as human experts?

####AI writing research papers? That sounds bold! How did they test this?

They conducted a large-scale study with over 100 NLP researchers.

These experts blind-reviewed research ideas generated by AI and compared them to human-written ones.

####And how did the artificial intelligence do?

####Surprisingly well! AI-generated ideas were rated more novel than human ideas, with statistical significance. However, human ideas were seen as slightly more feasible.

####That’s unexpected! So AI is better at thinking outside the box but might struggle with practical execution?

####Thats right. AI tends to generate bold, creative ideas, but some may not be easy to implement.

However, when researchers combined AI-generated ideas with human ranking, they got the best of both worlds—high novelty and feasibility.

####That’s a powerful combination. Could AI as a result become a real research assistant in the future?

####Potentially! The study highlights the limitations, too.

AI lacks diversity in its idea generation and struggles with self-evaluation. But if improved, AI could help researchers brainstorm breakthroughs faster than ever before.

####That’s fascinating, both papers show that AI is pushing the limits, One in structured problem-solving and the other in creativity:

####Absolutly! Whether it’s solving math problems or sparking new research, AI is proving to be more capable than we imagined

####Thanks for the breakdown Sigurd and i can’t wait to see where AI goes next.

####Me too! That’s all for today’s Pulse episode. Thanks for listening, and Join us again next time on the Knowledge Science Pulse podcast.