Monthly Giving Prediction #5: Retention Is Built Before the Gift

The neat donor funnel sounds good in slides, but it doesn’t match how people actually decide to give. 

We dig into the real path supporters take today—bouncing from reels to Google to LinkedIn to your site—and why the strongest retention work happens long before the first dollar shows up. 

Instead of chasing one perfect subject line or a last-minute match, we focus on what actually converts: consistency, clarity, and leadership that lowers the emotional risk of giving.

You’ll hear how to spot and support the messy, multi-touch donor journey without getting lost in attribution rabbit holes. We unpack the limits of tracking tools and UTMs, then pivot to what you can control every day: narrative consistency across your website, social bios, and emails; visible leaders who show context and follow-through; and storytelling that explains the why, not just the need. 

The goal is simple but powerful—help donors predict you. Predictability builds safety, and safety powers renewal.

LettrLabs is the proud presenter of Missions to Movements. 

LettrLabs helps nonprofits build lasting donor relationships through real, handwritten mail that’s fully automated - turning moments of intent into meaningful connection. From thank-yous to impact updates, they help you cut through with mail donors actually open, remember, and trust.

Join me and the LettrLabs team on March 30th at 1pm Eastern for a FREE webinar that will showcase even more examples and case studies of how direct mail can work for you.

The Monthly Giving Builder: Generate your comprehensive monthly giving plan and build your program step by step - with a guided companion working alongside you from start to finish. 

Let's Connect!

• Send a DM on Instagram or LinkedIn and let us know what you think of the show!
• My book, The Monthly Giving Mastermind, is here! Grab a copy here and learn my framework to build, grow, and sustain subscriptions for good.
• Want to book Dana as a speaker for your event? ...

Transcript

Retention Before The Gift

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Welcome back to Missions to Movements. We are in the monthly giving prediction number five out of six series. Retention is built before the gift. If you have missed one through four, you can go back and listen to any of these new year bonus episodes, part of this series. And today I'm talking about the fact that the traditional funnel is a little dead. And I think we're all proving it in how we just live our lives. And that idea that someone they discover you, then they subscribe, then they donate, then they get nurtured, then they stay forever. That neat linear journey that we always used to track, that I always used to talk about, that's not how we are behaving. And if the retention strategy still assumes that path, then we need to rethink some things. Enter in the modern donor journey and what that looks like. So here's a sample of what today's donor might do instead. They might see a reel from your organization or someone on your team or a content creator or an influencer or a friend. They might then Google your organization. They might click around on a website, but maybe not give. They might then research your leadership and connect with a founder on LinkedIn and read some of those posts for a couple weeks. They might watch how you respond to something that's going on that might be relative to your cause area. They might lurk quietly. They might do a lot of lurking. And then one day they will decide. It wasn't necessarily a perfect attribution. There might not be a true, maybe aha moment that's trackable in the CRM of what exactly led them there. But I was just on a call with a friend of mine, Jordan Gill. She's amazing from Systems Who Saved that saved me. And she showed me this tool. Let me look at my notes called Hydros, H Y R O S Tracking. And it was fascinating. And I wonder how much of this exists in the more um, I don't want to say complicated, but kind of complicated CRMs that are out there. And it showcased somebody clicked on her ad three times before making a purchase. It showed somebody looked on a website, wrote an email, clicked on an ad, like all of the journey actions. I guess some of this, if you're tracking Google UTMs, you're able to see some of this journey. But I think that was so interesting. And that it's messy. We bounce around. Like you might watch an organic reel, then see an ad, then go to the website, then send an email, then we like bounce around. It's so just it's just human. It's just what we do. And I think it's the shift that we need to kind of catch up to. And that retention doesn't start after the gift. It's built so far before it. And this matters, I think, more than ever, because if someone gives today, it's rarely because of one thing that happened. It's not just your subject line, it's not just the matching gift deadline or the perfectly timed appeal. I think it's because of your consistency, like you're showing up. You are creating trust, you're showcasing your values that feel clear. You are storytelling all the time. Donors understand the why, not just the need that you have. And there is visibility. They have seen you enough to believe in what you're doing and that you're still going to be there and you're going to follow through. So by the time that someone donates, they're often just confirming a decision that they've already made emotionally. So that's why I think retention doesn't only live in the donor emails that you send or the thank you pages or the stewardship workflows. It's truly being built everywhere. And why things that don't look like fundraising are actually retention strategies. For example, I tend to believe that leadership visibility matters. People don't just trust organizations, they trust people. So when leaders share context and speak with clarity and show consistently over time, they show up, they lower the emotional risk of giving. And I think that narrative consistency matters. So another way to think about this is if your website says one thing, but then your social media bio maybe says another and your posts are saying something different, and then your emails are talking about something else, some other story, and it feels disconnected. Maybe they feel unsure about what it is that you're trying to express. And uncertainty can really harm long-term commitment. Okay. So I think leadership showing up matters. I think narrative consistency matters. And I think showing up matters. So, and I think this is what many, many, many of you already do already. You're showing up not just during campaigns, not just during crisis, but in the in-between moments where you're really enforcing this is who we are, this is what we stand for. Because reach without connection doesn't renew. So a reframe here instead of asking how do we retain donors after they give, think about and start to look at and figure out if you can find out how are people experiencing us before they ever give? Because donors are forming opinions about you far long before the welcome series or the receipt email or your snail mail gift comes in. By the time retention becomes your job, that outcome may already be decided for how long they're going to stick around. And then we can only do more on the back end of getting them to stick with us for the long haul. And I think another question we're sitting with, and maybe you create like a small focus group and ask some of your monthly donors this, but is what made your most loyal donors trust you before they ever gave a dollar? Was it a story that they read that they couldn't forget? Was it a leader? Was it you that showed up consistently? What is a moment where you named something that they were already feeling? Because I think these moments matter a lot. And it's important for us to start to track and understand. Leading into the next final prediction of this series, we're gonna talk about where monthly giving is headed next. And that's not just more screens, not just better tools, but it's a shift towards shared real life connection, belonging, and what that means for the future of donor relationships. You know what I'm gonna say? If you have not yet, RSVP'd for the monthly giving summit. It is happening February 25th, 26th. It is virtual. There are VIP ticket options available. If you would like recordings, go to monthlygiving summit.com or you can click the link in the show notes. And I hope to see you there and in the next episode for prediction number six.