Killer Heart To Hearts
Hosted by real-life couple William Cannon and Elise Buedel, Killer Heart to Hearts isn’t just another true crime podcast. It’s immersive, sharply written, and emotionally honest. With a tone that’s darkly witty, culturally aware, and often chilling, each episode dissects stories of murder, disappearance, and betrayal — always with a human heartbeat beneath the horror.
Whether it’s the psychology of an incel, the mystery of a locked hotel room, or a murder staged to look like a suicide, we dive into the shadows — and bring our listeners with us.
Episodes
89 episodes
AFTER DARK: Gone Antiquing
Bellefonte, Pennsylvania. April 2005.Ray Gricar has spent years building cases, following evidence, and knowing exactly where to look when something doesn’t add up.Then one day, he vanishes.And the deeper people look, the s...
•
26:38
71. The Alaskan Avenger
Anchorage, Alaska. Summer 2016.Over five days, three men are attacked in their homes by the same stranger — a man with a black leather jacket, a claw hammer, and a terrifying sense of purpose.What looks, at first, like a violent s...
•
1:02:13
AFTER DARK: The Way
Salado, Texas. July 1997.Lela and Raymond Howard leave home for a local music festival just 15 miles away.They never arrive.Days pass. Then weeks. And the farther the search stretches, the harder it becomes to explain how t...
•
20:20
70. Firebug
An heiress from Duluth.A trail of fires stretching from Minnesota to the Mexican border.And a quiet little mining town in Arizona… that never saw her coming.Marjorie Congdon Caldwell Hagen carried wealth, suspicion, and mis...
•
1:17:27
AFTER DARK: Playing Hooky
Port Clinton, Ohio. December 2019.A 14-year-old boy leaves home on a Friday morning and walks to school like he always did. Except this day, Harley Dilly never makes it there.For weeks, the town searches. Streets, water, woods — e...
•
16:02
69. Broken Arrow
Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. 2015.A family inside a quiet suburban home —a mother.a father.and their seven kids.And then, in the middle of the night…something breaks.A 911 call. And a crime scene...
•
53:15
AFTER DARK: The Foreigner
A young American YouTuber builds a life in a remote town in the southern Philippines.Then armed men—posing as police—drag him from his home and force him onto a boat headed out to sea.No proof of life. No body. Tons of questions.<...
•
19:11
68. Love Is A Battlefield
They thought it was just a drive.One friend in the backseat.One boyfriend riding shotgun.And a teenage girl behind the wheel.But what happened next wasn’t an accident.It was a decision.And once the car ...
•
Episode 69
•
42:28
AFTER DARK: Sleeping Beauty
High above the clouds, where the air is thin and rescue is nearly impossible…a climber makes history.But on the way down, something goes terribly wrong. And the world’s tallest mountain becomes her final resting place.<...
•
13:01
67. King
April 1968. Memphis, Tennessee.Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. comes to stand with striking sanitation workers — exhausted, under surveillance, and living with constant threats.Then, outside Room 306 at the Lorraine Motel, a single gun...
•
Episode 67
•
51:46
After Dark: Vanishing Point
In August 2016, a family of five left their redcurrant farm in Silvan, Victoria — driving north with a wad of cash, while their phones and bank cards stayed behind.Over the next few days, they fractured across New South Wales and Victori...
•
17:06
66. 3'S Bar
A crowded St. Patrick’s night in downtown Longmont, CO. After last call, Rita Gutierrez-Garcia steps into the alley west of 3’S Bar. At 3:07 a.m., her phone dials 911…and then goes silent. And Rita never makes it home. W...
•
Episode 66
•
46:51
AFTER DARK: Lost In Paradise
She went to Jamaica to write about beaches.Instead, she became a story the island couldn’t explain.In May 2000, travel writer Claudia Kirschhoch vanished from a luxury resort in Negril.Her clothes were still in the room.
•
16:42
65. Naughty List
In December 1992, six people were murdered in Dayton, Ohio — over Christmas weekend. The killers? A group of teenagers who called themselves the Downtown Posse.No motive. No mercy. Just violence… for the hell of it.Sour...
•
Episode 65
•
44:44
AFTER DARK: Hallelujah
People like to say Jeff Buckley’s death was poetic. That it meant something. That it was fate, legacy, or some tragic echo of his father.It wasn’t.Jeff drowned after wading into a dangerous river at dusk. The myth came later — bec...
•
15:42
64. Amicable
They called it an amicable divorce.No battles over money. No fights over custody. Jennifer even shared how grateful she was for the peace between them.Two weeks later, police were called to a quiet house in Brandon, Mississippi.
•
Episode 64
•
32:12
AFTER DARK: Wolf Island Road
Wolf Island Road.A forgotten path at the edge of a Massachusetts town…where history, violence, and legend all collide.From stories of colonial executions and restless spirits…to tales of phantom headlights and voices caught...
•
13:39
63. Cold Turkey
Thanksgiving.The kind of holiday where the food’s good, the smiles are polite, and nobody mentions the family tension simmering just below the surface.Paul Merhige sat at the table like everyone else.Chatted. Posed for phot...
•
Episode 63
•
33:25
AFTER DARK: Nowhere Fast
Five men leave a basketball game in Northern California.They never make it home.Months later, their car is found on a snowy mountain road — in perfect working condition. Inside, maps, Folded clothes. Uneaten snacks.Four bod...
•
15:55
62. Thicker Than Blood
She was twelve years old.He was twenty-three.And together…they wiped out an entire family.This is the story of Jasmine Richardson and Jeremy Steinke. A twisted teenage romance.A triple murder in a quiet Canadian subu...
•
Episode 62
•
35:52
AFTER DARK: The Somerton Man
1948.A man is found dead on an Australian beach.No name. No ID.Just a scrap of Persian poetry in his pocket… and a code no one can crack.This is the mystery of the Somerton Man.A ghost in a suit.A messa...
•
14:28
61. The Ghost Bride
High in the Colombian Andes, there's a hotel that's been abandoned for decades.Tourists say it's haunted.Locals say it's cursed.And if you stand at the edge of the cliff and listen closely...You might just hear her.<...
•
Episode 61
•
32:01
AFTER DARK: 20 Years A Slave
For decades, a locked door hid a secret.A boy, vanishing from the outside world…but never leaving the house.This is the story of Kimberly Sullivan — and the stepson she allegedly kept in captivity for more than twenty years.
•
14:22
