
But Consider This
Two spooky girls talking about all things conspiracy theory, murder mystery, or just plain weird.
Episodes
51 episodes
Evelyn Hernandez: The First Laci Peterson
Hey spooky bitches!!Today we're talking about the absolutely heartbreaking case of Evelyn Hernandez and her two missing sons. What do you think happened?TRIGGER WARNING: Mentions of abuse and deaths of childrenSEND YOUR TIP...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 3
•
42:27

The Wife Swap Murders
Hey spooky bitches!Today we're talking the Stockdale family, who were featured on Wife Swap, and their murders! Was the show a catalyst for the entire event? Let us know what you think!
•
Season 3
•
Episode 2
•
51:04

We're Back!!
Hello spooky bitches!!After an (accidental) hiatus, we are back!! Thank you so much for sticking with us, missing us, and supporting us!!Caiti's Band: https://www.instagram.com/wake_up_paul
•
Season 3
•
Episode 1
•
39:15

Spook Rock: Local Lethal
Hey spooky bitches!!Today Gabby is sharing a local lethal from her hometown! It's not just a boulder, it's a rock!
•
59:34

Mini Local Lethal + Nonsense
Hey spooky bitches!!Today Lex has a quickie local story followed by a lot of chit chat and nonsense. Let us know if you'd like more episodes where we just chat!!
•
Season 2
•
Episode 3
•
39:27

The Atrocious Murder of Shad Thyrion
Hey spooky bitches!!TRIGGER WARNING: ABUSE OF A CORPSE, MUTILATION, NECROPHILIAToday we're talking about to absolutely atrocious murder of Shad Thyrion at the hands of Taylor Schabusiness. Let us know your thoughts!
•
Season 2
•
Episode 2
•
48:34

Gypsy Rose Blanchard
Hey spooky bitches!! We're back!!Thank you so much for being patient with us while we took an unexpectedly long hiatus; we appreciate you all!Today we're talking about the controversial case of Gypsy Rose Blanchard; let us know ...
•
Season 2
•
Episode 1
•
1:17:31

Five Nights At Freddy's
MAJOR SPOILERS FOR THE FNAF MOVIEHello spooky bitches! Today we're talking about the Five Nights At Freddy's movies and games! Did you like the movie? Did you play the games? Let us know all your thoughts!Skip to 36:28 to bypass...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 44
•
1:19:12

The Saw Franchise
SPOILERS FOR SAW XMAJOR SPOILERSHey spooky bitches! Today we're taking a deep dive into the world of Saw! THERE WILL BE SPOILERS FOR SAW X. You have been warned!! Let us know what your favorite traps have been!
•
Season 1
•
Episode 43
•
1:20:56

Sherri Papini: The Vanishing Act
Hey spooky bitches!!Today we're discussing the disappearance of Sherri Papini that later turned out to be a hoax! Let us know what you think!
•
Season 1
•
Episode 42
•
49:45

The Devastating Murder of Sophie Lancaster
Hey spooky bitches!Today we're talking about the absolutely heartbreaking murder of goth teen Sophie Lancaster. Would you consider this a hate crime? Let us know all your thoughts!
•
1:31:44

The Kidnapping Hoax of Carlee Russell
Hey spooky bitches!Today we're talking about the very recent and very confusing case of Carlee Russell's fake kidnapping! Let us know all your theories about why she did this and where she was!1
•
Season 1
•
Episode 40
•
27:20

Disney Conspiracies & Chit Chat
Hey spooky bitches!!Today we're breaking up our usual gruesome and upsetting content with something more lighthearted, Disney! Let us know any of your Disney conspiracies! Do you believe in any of the ones we talked about?
•
Season 1
•
Episode 39
•
57:30

The Curious Death of Jeannette DePalma
Hey spooky bitches!!UPDATE: There will be a prayer vigil for Jeannette on Monday, August 7th 2023 at 7pm - 8pm on the steps of Springfield Town Hall (100 Mountain Ave, Springfield NJ 07081)Today we're talking about the confusing...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 38
•
28:08

Stockholm Syndrome: The Norrmalmstorg Robbery
Hey spooky bitches!Today we're talking about the origins of Stockholm syndrome, the Norrmalmstorg robbery! Let us know what you think about this absolutely wild case! Do you think Belle has Stockholm syndrome?Stockhold syndrome ...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 37
•
40:46

Natalia Grace ft Bianca
Hey spooky bitches!!Today our friend Bianca joins the pod for a much heated discussion about the tragic and confusing story of Natalia Grace! Let us know your thoughts on this curious case!GoFund Me created by Natalia's NEW fami...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 36
•
1:30:39

Dorothea Puente: The Death House Landlady
Hey spooky bitches! Today we're talking about the absolutely insane story of Dorothea Puente! Let us know all your thoughts on this case!TRIGGER WARNING: Mentions of suicide, sexual assault, and abuse of the elderly and vulnerable.<...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 35
•
52:36

The Ken & Barbie Killers
Hey spooky bitches!Today we're talking about Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka aka the Ken and Barbie killers! Do you think Karla enjoyed being involved? Let us know all your thoughts!TRIGGER WARNINGS: Sexual assault and murders o...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 34
•
1:31:17

The Burger Chef Murders
Hey spooky bitches!Today we're talking about the tragic murders of four young employees of an old restaurant chain called Burger Chef! Who do you think did it? Let us know your thoughts!Crime Stoppers of Central Indiana: http://...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 33
•
34:25

Ian Watkins: Singer Turned Predator
Hey spooky bitches!!Today we're talking about the absolutely disgusting crimes of former Lostprophets singer Ian Watkins. This case is heavy so we understand if you want to skip this episode!TRIGGER WARNINGS: Sexual abuse and as...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 32
•
1:11:08

Local Lethal: Richard Aderson
Hey spooky bitches!Today Lex is bringing you a local lethal! Who do you think is the culprit? Do you have road rage? Let us know all your thoughts!New York State Crime Stoppers: 866-313-TIPS (8477)New York State Police 845-6...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 31
•
44:32

Nannie Doss: The Lonely Hearts Killer
Hey spooky bitches!Today we're talking the absolutely insane life and crimes of Nannie Doss. Do you think there were more victims? Let us know your thoughts!Thank you so much for your patience with us as we get our lives and our...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 30
•
1:01:22

Is William Shakespeare A Fraud?
Hey spooky bitches!Today we're talking about the conspiracy theory that William Shakespeare didn't write any of his famous works. Do you think Shakespeare is the true creator of his content? Who do you think it was? Let us know!
•
57:38

Local Lethal: Albert Fentress
Hey spooky bitches!Today Gabby is sharing her local lethal with the gruesome and tragic case of Albert Fentress.TRIGGER WARNINGS: SEXUAL ASSAULT, MUTILATION, AND CANNIBALISM OF A TEENAGER.Let us know what you think about...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 28
•
24:13

Diane Schuler: The Tragic Taconic State Parkway Crash
Hey spooky bitches!Today we're talking about the absolutely tragic and slightly controversial case of Diane Schuler and the horrific crash on the Taconic State Parkway. Let us know you thoughts and theories about this case, we'd love to...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 27
•
1:07:53
