Horror For The Holidays
Jay And Jeff take on the best and worst the holiday horror world has to offer. Watch as two semi-qualified critics slog through endless shlock to finally answer the question, what is the pie for?
Episodes
128 episodes
2025 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular Episode 2: Hollow Gate
Jeff and Jay take a trip over the state line to get some subs and sudz! Uh Jay, why does that lunatic think you are Vietnamese?
•
Season 2025
•
1:34:00
2025 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular Episode 1: What Happens Next Will Scare You
Jay and Jeff dive into another Chris LaMartina film to kick off the spooktacular! Wait how does this movie have three Jays? Is that BigFoot?
•
Season 2025
•
Episode 1
•
1:34:04
Stocking Stuffers Episode 41: Crypticon Minneapolis
Jay and Jeff are on the road, hear all the details, listen as history is made, enjoy the soothing voice of Matt Dupée! All this and more!!!!!!!!!
•
Episode 41
•
23:11
Horror For The Holidays Episode 71: Deadly Games
Jeff and Jay take on a Christmas classic and answer the question does Bonnie Tyler belong in Christmas horror? Spoiler alert yes! Rest in Peace JR.
•
Season 4
•
Episode 3
•
1:21:40
Stocking Stuffers Episode 40: What's Grinding Jeff's Gears? Lord of The Rings Edition
Jeff let's you know what is grinding his gears with modern dark fantasy vs Lord Of The Rings! Episode one of ten million.
•
Episode 40
•
25:35
Horror For The Holidays Episode 70: Good Tidings
This week Jay and Jeff sit down and watch their favorite shows on their tablets. No mom we aren't ready for bed yet!
•
Season 4
•
Episode 2
•
1:29:23
Stocking Stuffers Episode 39: Crawfish King
Uncle Pig Knuckle gives Jeff and Jay a taste of the swamp.
•
Episode 39
•
23:34
Horror For The Holidays Episode 69: Christmas Craft fair Massacre
On this weeks episode Jeff and Jay learn a very important lesson… Don’t Do Anything!
•
Season 4
•
Episode 1
•
1:00:37
Fat Boy Summer Episode 3: Frogman
Jeff and Jay head into the swamp for the last episode of Fat Boy Summer! Why yes Jay has been know to take a maiden now and then! Cult, what cult?
•
Episode 3
•
1:17:40
Horror For The Holidays Episode 68: P2
The boys celebrate Christmas in July with a controversial movie from the 00's. Jay didn't want you to know but Angela's skin is very soft!
•
Season 3
•
Episode 20
•
1:21:00
Fat Boy Summer Episode 2: The Black Phone
On this week's episode Jeff talks about The Black Phone and Jay talks about the 1985 movie Ladyhawke for some reason.
•
Episode 2
•
1:18:35
Fat Boy Summer Episode 1: Return Of The Living Dead
The Fat Boys hang out by the pool and some zombies show up, it's heavy stuff bro! or maybe not? It turns out the real zombies are the friends we made along the way.
•
Episode 1
•
1:10:57
Stocking Stuffers Episode 38: What's Up With Them Zombies?
People debate whether fast or slow zombies are scarier, but for the fat boys it's all academic because they can't get away from either.
•
Episode 38
•
31:06
Horror For The Holidays Episode 67: A Creature Was Stirring
Thank God it's just one of them stirring this time Jay. How old are these people! What happened to the tunnel? Where's Brad Pitt?
•
Season 3
•
Episode 19
•
1:14:54
Stocking Stuffers Episode 37: Into the BC14 Universe
Jeff takes Jay on a long strange trip, did any of it happen, and more importantly did anyone care?
•
Episode 37
•
27:08
Horror For The Holidays Episode 66: One Hell Of A Christmas
How does this keep happening? It's another movie about Satan! Jay you've got to learn to spell!
•
Season 3
•
Episode 18
•
1:10:40
Stocking Stuffers Episode 36: Clown in a Destination Field Finally
Jeff runs from a Clown in a Cornfield, while Jay traces his Final Destination Bloodlines or something! We watched the movies, we did the thing! Get off our back audience!
•
Episode 36
•
34:39
Horror For The Holidays Episode 65: Krampus vs Bigfoot
Jeff and Jay dive into the Bigfoot Cinematic Universe at the best place, 5 movies in! Listen to Jay die inside as Jeff reaches new levels of comedic nirvana.
•
Season 3
•
Episode 17
•
1:11:36
Stocking Stuffers Episode 35: Jeff and Jay Drop into Sinners
Jeff and Jay talk about Drop for a second then gush about Sinners! Take notes Osgood!
•
Episode 35
•
36:22
Horror For The Holidays Episode 64: Lake Alice
Jeff and Jay take on this film? Is it a film, did anything happen, what's that Jay? They never even said the thing?!?!
•
Season 3
•
Episode 16
•
1:25:19
Stocking Stuffers Episode 34: What up with them Aliens?
Jeff bombards Jay with crazy alien conspiracies, then they talk about Rush for some reason, and wrap it up with a couple quizzes.
•
Episode 34
•
27:30
Horror For The Holidays Episode 63: Christmas Bloody Christmas
Jeff and Jay take on the Christmas Terminator and speculate on whether or not he'll be back.
•
Season 3
•
Episode 15
•
1:17:46
Stocking Stuffers Episode 33: Old Lady in The Unicorn Summer Camp with Finn Wolfhard
Jeff and Jay talk about 3 new movies and say goodbye to the library in their own special way.
•
Episode 33
•
30:53