Builder vs. Steady State: The Hiring Mistake Costing You Top Talent Artwork

Opt In

Do I have to be friends with my co workers to get ahead? Should I take the promotion even if I hate the job? Is my salary big enough or am I getting screwed? Do I have to choose between having a family and having a career? I've been laid off now what do I do? I'm Melissa Franks, and I've spent the last 25 years building my corporate career and a family to along the way, there have been bumps and bruises and some epic going down in flames of glory moments. My journey up the corporate ladder found me forging new ground without a safety net. Through my real life stories, experiences, and special guests on the show, I take the mystery out of how to succeed in the corporate world. I'm going to spill all the tea about how decisions are really made, how to tell who the hidden influencers are, and how to realize your full potential while enjoying the process at the same time. Each week, we will dive into a topic where I will share the good, the bad, and the ugly of my experiences and what we can all learn from them. You will walk away each week with a clear set of next steps to take action and improve your circumstances. We are going to speak frankly and freely about when it's time to opt in or to opt out. Opt In is a place where you can come to get practical, actionable advice to propel your career and your life in the direction you want. Work with me: www.melissafranks.com/offers

All Episodes

Opt In

Builder vs. Steady State: The Hiring Mistake Costing You Top Talent

July 15, 2026 • Melissa Franks

0:00 | 26:53

Have you hired the same role more than once and watched it still not work out, even with genuinely talented people? If your answer is yes, that's not a talent problem.

In this episode of the Opt In Podcast, Melissa Franks tackles one of the most common hiring mistakes small business owners make: assuming an A player is an A player everywhere. Not a question of skill, but of fit. There are only two operating modes at work, builder and steady state, and hiring the wrong one into a role sets even the most talented person up to fail.

If your job description hasn't changed since the last time this role turned over, someone is paying for that gap. Spoiler: it's your business.

Melissa breaks down why founders keep hiring skilled people into the wrong seat (it's not bad luck, it's an undefined role), walks through the two-column audit you can run on any role this week, and gives you the exact framework for figuring out whether the seat needs a builder or a steady state person, before you ever post the job again.

In This Episode:

Why "I want the best person" is the wrong starting point for a job description
The real difference between a builder and a steady state person, and why it has nothing to do with seniority or department
The two-column exercise to diagnose exactly why past hires in this role didn't work
Why a job description without defined performance metrics guarantees your new hire defaults to what worked at their last job
How to figure out which one you are as a founder, and why that determines who you hire next
Why your best people quietly leave, and it's rarely about the money
Your homework: one role, one audit, one honest answer.

Connect with Melissa:

Book a free consultation with Melissa → https://www.melissafranks.com

Learn more about On Call COO fractional services → https://www.melissafranks.com

Watch the Episodes on Youtube

Instagram: instagram.com/melissa_franks

LinkedIn: Melissa Franks