Hallmark Mysteries & More
Hallmark Mysteries and More is the ultimate destination for Sleuthers and fans of Hallmark's beloved mystery genre. Hosts Andrea and Eric bring their extensive knowledge and passion to every episode, offering insightful reviews and analysis of both current releases and classic favorites.
As the only podcast dedicated exclusively to this cherished corner of Hallmark programming, we dig deep into the themes, characters, and storytelling that make these mysteries so special.
Beyond our comprehensive reviews, we regularly welcome interviews with Hallmark's biggest stars, directors, writers, and production team members, giving Sleuthers unprecedented behind-the-scenes access. Our conversational style balances fun, engaging banter with informative content that both casual viewers and dedicated Hallmark mystery enthusiasts will appreciate.
Whether you're a longtime Sleuther or just discovering the charm of Hallmark mysteries, join Andrea and Eric for entertaining discussions that celebrate and explore this unique genre. Subscribe now for your weekly dose of mystery, community, and all things Hallmark!
Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
**This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel. **
Episodes
174 episodes
Emma Fielding: Past Malice – Castles, Curses & Killer Twists
This week, Andrea and Eric return to Hartley Castle for their review of Emma Fielding Mysteries: Past Malice, and this time—it’s personal (and possibly cursed). From improved character chemistry to surprise villain reveals, they break do...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 41
•
33:50
April Telek on Kindness, Chaos & Killer Roles (Literally!)
She’s been a red herring, an accomplice, a therapist, and even a murderess—but no matter the role, April Telek brings heart, humor, and unforgettable energy. In this episode, Andrea and Eric sit down with the beloved Hallmark star for a ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 40
•
1:07:24
.png)
Digging Into “Site Unseen” – Emma Fielding Mystery Review
In this week’s episode, Andrea and Eric take a deep dive into Emma Fielding Mysteries: Site Unseen, the archaeology-themed Hallmark mystery that kicked off Courtney Thorne-Smith’s return to television in a leading role.They dig in...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 39
•
41:50
.jpg)
Marilu Henner - Hollywood Icon (Replay)
To celebrate Hallmark Mystery airing Aurora Teagarden: A Lesson in Murder, we decided to replay this fantastic conversation with Marilu Henner. She shares so many amazing stories about her illustrious career as well as great BTS stories about p...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 38
•
52:26
.png)
Aurora Teagarden – Reap What You Sew Review (and Maybe Snooze?)
In this episode, Andrea and Eric dive into Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reap What You Sew—but does this cozy caper stitch together a satisfying story or unravel before the final scene? Spoiler alert: one of your hosts may have literally...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 37
•
38:46
Kaitlyn Leeb Talks The Spencer Sisters, Heartland & Life On and Off Screen
his week, Andrea and Eric are joined by the incredibly talented Kaitlyn Leeb, known to Hallmark fans as Lindsay from The Spencer Sisters and Bianca in Crossword Mysteries. Kaitlyn opens up about her ac...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 35
•
44:44
.png)
British Mysteries, Good Witch Magic & A Holiday Football Fumble?
This week, Andrea and Eric dive into the latest Hallmark news and bring plenty of laughs along the way! From the network’s big announcement about adding British mystery imports (hello, Rosemary & Thyme and Shakespeare &a...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 36
•
45:31
Kylee Evans on Good Witch, Mistletoe Murders & Finding Strength Through Storytelling
This week, we welcome the delightful Kylee Evans, beloved for her roles as Stephanie on Good Witch and Brooke on Mistletoe Murders. In this heartwarming and hilarious interview, Kylee opens up about her journey from sma...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 33
•
54:58
.png)
Should You Watch A Fixer Upper Mystery – A Deadly Deed. We Watched It to Let You Know if You Shoul
In this episode, Andrea and Eric take on the final installment of Hallmark Mystery Channel’s Fixer Upper Mystery trilogy: A Deadly Deed. Is it a satisfying finale or a crumbling renovation? The co-hosts dig into everything from ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 32
•
31:34
Inside the Mystery: Tess Atkins on Hallmark’s Hannah Swensen Series
In this episode, we take a deep dive into the world of Hallmark mysteries with actor Tess Atkins, best known for her role as Michelle in the Hannah Swensen series. Tess shares her journey into acting, from childhood inspirations...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 31
•
58:06
.png)
Crowns, Castles, and Chemistry: A Hallmark Royal Recap
Grab a cup of tea and settle in—this week, we’re diving into Hallmark’s latest royal rom-com lineup! From a Bostonian princess forced into an arranged marriage to a Philadelphia mechanic discovering his inner Duke, we’re ranking, reviewing, and...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 30
•
29:03
Murder, Mayhem, and Mystery Island: Breaking Down Hallmark’s Latest Whodunit.
Calling all Hallmark mystery fans! This week, we’re diving deep into Mystery Island: Winner Takes All, where a game of make-believe murder turns into the real deal. Was the latest installment a thrilling Agatha Christie-inspired closed...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 29
•
30:40
Peter Benson Talks Acting, Directing & Hallmark Mysteries
This week, Andrea and Eric sit down with the one and only Peter Benson, a Hallmark favorite known for his work in both front of and behind the camera. From his extensive acting career—including Aurora Teagarden, Mystery 101, and The C...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 28
•
51:42
.png)
Discussing A Fixer Upper Mystery: Concrete Evidence and Eric's Hallmark Conspiracy Theory
Is Hallmark about to shake up its network? Andrea and Eric dive into Conspiracy Corner to discuss the potential consolidation of Hallmark’s channels and what it could mean for mystery lovers. They also break down the second installment...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 27
•
29:39
Season Finale Deep Dive – The Way Home & The Spencer Sisters
It’s time for a dramatic season finale discussion! In this episode, Andrea and Eric take their final dip into the pond—at least for now—as they break down the emotional and twist-filled ending of The Way Home Season 3. From time-travel...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 26
•
41:00
Unraveling Hallmark Mysteries with Legendary Hallmark Writer: John Christian Plummer” 🎬🔍
n this special episode, we sit down with Hallmark mystery mastermind John Christian Plummer, the writer behind Mystery 101, Curious Caterer, and Mystery Island! He takes us behind the scenes of his creative pro...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 25
•
53:27
.png)
🎙 A Review of A Fixer Upper Mysteries: Framed for Murder 🏡🔍✨
This week, we’re diving into the Fixer Upper Mysteries: Framed for Murder—and let’s just say, the writing may need a little renovation. Starring Jewel and Colin Ferguson, this 2017 Hallmark mystery had us debating its...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 24
•
27:42
🎙 Hallmark Mysteries & More: Breaking Down The Way Home & The Spencer Sisters 🔍✨
In this episode, we dive deep into The Way Home—or at least as deep as we can without getting lost in time travel paradoxes. With only one episode left this season, we still have more questions than answers! What is Jacob doing with hi...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 23
•
38:22
Behind the Seams: A Conversation with Hallmark Costume Designer Kelsey Baran 🎬✨
Ever wondered how your favorite Hallmark characters get their signature looks? In this exclusive interview, we go behind the scenes with Kelsey Baran, the brilliant costume designer behind Hannah Swensen Mysteries and countless ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 22
•
41:27
.png)
Hallmark’s “Loveuary” Movies – Hits, Misses & Everything in Between!
🎬 Hallmark fans, it’s time for LOVEUARY! Hallmark Channel packed February with a lineup of romantic movies, but did they all deliver? In this episode, we break down every Loveuary movie – the swoon-worthy moments, the unexpected...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 21
•
36:44
Hallmark Mysteries: The Way Home & The Spencer Sisters – Episode 8 Recap & Discussion
📺 Calling all Hallmark Mystery fans! In this episode, we break down two of Hallmark’s most talked-about shows: The Way Home (Episode 8 – Smoke on the Water) and The Spencer Sisters! Get ready for an in-depth di...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 20
•
40:14
Lea Thompson Talks Hallmark, Mysteries, & Sisterly Bonds in The Spencer Sisters and The Chicken Sisters
📺 Hollywood legend Lea Thompson joins us for an incredible conversation about her long and dynamic career, from Back to the Future to her latest Hallmark hits, The Spencer Sisters and The Chicken Sisters!
•
Season 3
•
Episode 19
•
58:38
%20(1).png)
Reviewing Garage Sale Mysteries: The Novel Murders
What do you get when you mix Agatha Christie with Sherlock Holmes, toss in a dash of Jennifer Shannon, and top it off with a Hallmark mystery?Well, Garage Sale Mysteries: The Novel Murders, of course. The mystery series has been Andrea's...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 18
•
29:43
.png)
Diving Into The Pond as We Discuss Episodes 7 of The Way Home and The Spencer Sisters
We are onto episode 7 of The Way Home and The Spencer Sisters. The two series continue to go in opposite directions. The Way Home seems to be getting more convoluted, but not in an interesting way. We are struggling to connect with any of the c...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 17
•
37:59
Dylan Neal - Uncensored: The Making of the Gourmet Detective Series
In our final and most revealing conversation with Dylan Neal—actor, writer, and producer—we take a deliciously deep dive into The Gourmet Detective series, one of Hallmark Mystery’s most beloved franchises. Dylan doesn’t hold back as h...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 16
•
1:25:01
%20(1).png)