Your Therapist Needs Therapy 159 - Oh No! My Favorite Celebrity Might Be A Dummy

This week Jeremy looks at how celebrity culture has convinced us that visibility is the same as wisdom, turning artists, athletes, and influencers into stand-ins for philosophers, political analysts, and moral authorities. Jeremy uses the recent example of Roger Waters of Pink Floyd fame rubbing elbows with Tucker Carlson as to why it’s a bad idea that our culture keeps outsourcing its thinking to famous people. We take a critical look at the cultural ideas that create a false sense of equivalency between excellence and expertise, and propose some mental parameters to protect our brain from its own worst impulses.

As always, Jeremy has all his practice info at Wellness with Jer, and you can find him on Instagram and YouTube. You can donate directly to support religious trauma survivors here. We appreciate support from likes, follows, and shares as well! None of my online work would be possible without my media maven Kenny, so check out their work as well at kenlingdesign.com

-----

Podcasts about therapy do not replace actual therapy, and listening to a podcast about therapy does not signify a therapeutic relationship.If you or someone you know is in crisis please call or text the nationwide crisis line at 988, or text HELLO to 741741. The Trevor Project has a crisis line for LGBTQ+ young people that can be reached by texting 678678.

Transcript

Copy Transcript Copied

Hello,

00:00:08.266 --> 00:00:09.946
and welcome to another edition of Your

00:00:10.006 --> 00:00:11.727
Therapist Needs Therapy.

00:00:11.887 --> 00:00:13.227
I'm your host, Jeremy Schumacher,

00:00:13.307 --> 00:00:15.327
licensed marriage and family therapist.

00:00:18.349 --> 00:00:20.189
I might be your friendly neighborhood

00:00:20.449 --> 00:00:21.890
therapist if you're here in Wisconsin,

00:00:22.030 --> 00:00:22.489
where I'm at.

00:00:23.570 --> 00:00:26.690
This week, we have to deal with, ugh,

00:00:27.350 --> 00:00:29.690
celebrities doing dumb things.

00:00:30.512 --> 00:00:31.371
Because, ugh.

00:00:31.472 --> 00:00:31.611
Ugh.

00:00:32.957 --> 00:00:36.960
Celebrities are kind of dumb.

00:00:40.201 --> 00:00:41.921
This episode is a lot harder for me

00:00:41.981 --> 00:00:45.363
than it should be because I don't think

00:00:45.423 --> 00:00:46.984
highly of celebrity culture.

00:00:47.424 --> 00:00:48.844
So I really have to check my own

00:00:48.884 --> 00:00:52.506
biases here to do this episode correctly,

00:00:52.527 --> 00:00:54.468
quote unquote correctly,

00:00:55.448 --> 00:00:58.210
without just soapboxing about how nobody

00:00:58.229 --> 00:01:00.890
should be famous.

00:01:01.030 --> 00:01:01.250
Yeah.

00:01:03.459 --> 00:01:05.280
For those of you tuning in on the

00:01:05.340 --> 00:01:07.102
YouTube, hey, hi, welcome.

00:01:08.042 --> 00:01:11.844
You will notice I generally have a poster

00:01:11.905 --> 00:01:12.686
of the wall.

00:01:13.346 --> 00:01:15.867
It's a body art behind me back here

00:01:16.188 --> 00:01:18.269
of various Pink Floyd albums.

00:01:19.051 --> 00:01:22.033
If you've listened to me talk for any

00:01:22.093 --> 00:01:22.894
length of time,

00:01:23.114 --> 00:01:25.135
it's probably come up that Pink Floyd is

00:01:25.194 --> 00:01:26.456
my favorite band.

00:01:27.456 --> 00:01:30.379
And that's really remained unchanged since

00:01:30.459 --> 00:01:32.301
I was like, sixteen years old.

00:01:33.138 --> 00:01:33.259
Um,

00:01:35.594 --> 00:01:37.876
The rest of my top five fluctuates

00:01:37.896 --> 00:01:40.635
depending on what I'm listening to and

00:01:40.796 --> 00:01:42.736
what I've been into most recently,

00:01:43.417 --> 00:01:46.158
which isn't how top fives are supposed to

00:01:46.177 --> 00:01:46.378
work.

00:01:46.397 --> 00:01:47.778
But I do like to push back a

00:01:47.817 --> 00:01:50.379
little bit on like the idea that our

00:01:50.438 --> 00:01:52.599
favorite things are set by the time we're

00:01:52.659 --> 00:01:53.239
age thirty.

00:01:53.879 --> 00:01:58.240
I know that neuroplasticity dips and we

00:01:58.301 --> 00:02:00.441
all age, time is undefeated.

00:02:01.302 --> 00:02:03.362
So I'm aware of these things,

00:02:03.403 --> 00:02:04.543
but I do try and keep

00:02:05.680 --> 00:02:08.662
an open ear to things um definitely like

00:02:08.722 --> 00:02:10.302
the metal I listen to is a lot

00:02:10.364 --> 00:02:12.085
differently different than what I used to

00:02:12.104 --> 00:02:14.346
listen to so this isn't a case of

00:02:14.407 --> 00:02:16.127
like I locked it in early this is

00:02:16.147 --> 00:02:20.730
a truly genuinely uh the best that Pink

00:02:20.751 --> 00:02:24.234
Floyd has to offer is what I continue

00:02:24.253 --> 00:02:26.616
to go back to musically um

00:02:27.699 --> 00:02:30.961
not only is it like comfort albums at

00:02:31.001 --> 00:02:31.781
this point in my life,

00:02:31.820 --> 00:02:33.762
it's still just really good music.

00:02:34.263 --> 00:02:38.224
The run from dark side to, uh,

00:02:39.425 --> 00:02:43.467
the wall is really untouched.

00:02:45.068 --> 00:02:45.388
And,

00:02:46.269 --> 00:02:49.431
and I even include final cut in that.

00:02:50.411 --> 00:02:51.771
There are things on the division bell I

00:02:51.792 --> 00:02:52.611
think are really good.

00:02:53.612 --> 00:02:53.853
Um,

00:02:55.709 --> 00:02:57.610
yes this week we're talking about roger

00:02:57.689 --> 00:03:02.472
waters roger waters is an right like

00:03:02.951 --> 00:03:04.312
there's a bit of a thing in his

00:03:04.353 --> 00:03:06.593
entire career the reason pink floyd is not

00:03:06.633 --> 00:03:11.415
a band uh as as formed in those

00:03:11.455 --> 00:03:14.516
glory years of high production and high

00:03:14.556 --> 00:03:17.617
value is because roger waters and dave

00:03:17.638 --> 00:03:21.659
gilmore couldn't get along and like

00:03:24.168 --> 00:03:28.550
in the final cut being released,

00:03:28.651 --> 00:03:30.233
they weren't talking.

00:03:30.812 --> 00:03:32.153
They couldn't stand each other.

00:03:32.734 --> 00:03:33.974
Really after the wall,

00:03:34.034 --> 00:03:35.896
things deteriorated quite significantly,

00:03:36.276 --> 00:03:39.419
which is very funny when the wall is

00:03:39.718 --> 00:03:41.379
a song about isolation,

00:03:41.580 --> 00:03:43.262
the wall is an album about isolation,

00:03:44.643 --> 00:03:47.384
which Roger Waters wrote after spitting on

00:03:47.425 --> 00:03:49.686
a fan when they climbed on stage during

00:03:50.347 --> 00:03:51.407
the tour for Animals.

00:03:52.168 --> 00:03:53.209
So like, you know,

00:03:54.775 --> 00:03:57.736
He's not a good person and hasn't been

00:03:58.056 --> 00:03:59.957
for much of his career.

00:04:01.618 --> 00:04:03.258
And I think one of the things that

00:04:03.278 --> 00:04:05.139
sort of gets tossed about is like musical

00:04:05.199 --> 00:04:05.841
genius.

00:04:06.381 --> 00:04:08.981
And I would argue that's even incorrect.

00:04:09.862 --> 00:04:11.723
He's a bassist and not a very good

00:04:11.883 --> 00:04:12.003
one.

00:04:13.585 --> 00:04:14.805
Lyrical genius.

00:04:15.004 --> 00:04:15.586
There we go.

00:04:16.865 --> 00:04:17.586
And...

00:04:20.156 --> 00:04:21.958
In the way that Genius often is,

00:04:22.038 --> 00:04:25.000
I think it was spent within a decade

00:04:26.180 --> 00:04:28.221
because his other stuff never really

00:04:28.242 --> 00:04:33.185
attained the height of that epic

00:04:33.425 --> 00:04:35.526
four-concept album run,

00:04:35.646 --> 00:04:37.228
which again remains,

00:04:37.408 --> 00:04:39.990
and I think firmly will remain, untouched.

00:04:42.391 --> 00:04:45.552
So Kendrick Lamar fans who want to talk

00:04:45.593 --> 00:04:47.694
about the generational run that Kendrick's

00:04:47.733 --> 00:04:48.154
been on,

00:04:49.862 --> 00:04:52.682
are the closest and I would argue those

00:04:52.723 --> 00:04:54.543
albums have not all been concept albums

00:04:55.785 --> 00:05:02.548
and also are not classics in the way

00:05:02.947 --> 00:05:05.548
that the Pink Floyd albums will be

00:05:05.588 --> 00:05:06.048
classics.

00:05:06.930 --> 00:05:08.790
Kendrick Lamar fans come at me.

00:05:13.072 --> 00:05:15.754
So my love of Pink Floyd is long

00:05:15.834 --> 00:05:16.454
lasting.

00:05:19.305 --> 00:05:20.386
I talk about the books in my office

00:05:20.406 --> 00:05:22.067
a lot because books matter to me.

00:05:23.267 --> 00:05:24.747
I think it's a big thief line.

00:05:25.088 --> 00:05:26.608
I see you as you see yourself through

00:05:26.629 --> 00:05:27.610
all the books you read.

00:05:30.110 --> 00:05:32.031
There's a part of me that the books

00:05:32.151 --> 00:05:33.372
I like, the music I like,

00:05:33.392 --> 00:05:37.334
the movies I like are a reflection of

00:05:37.375 --> 00:05:38.735
how I view myself, certainly.

00:05:39.055 --> 00:05:41.716
And the things that are organized in our

00:05:41.757 --> 00:05:44.137
house that I'm in charge of are my

00:05:44.197 --> 00:05:45.978
books and my albums.

00:05:47.194 --> 00:05:48.555
I would say my movies are technically

00:05:48.654 --> 00:05:49.134
organized.

00:05:49.175 --> 00:05:50.134
They are cleanly,

00:05:50.216 --> 00:05:52.456
neatly alphabetized in those old school

00:05:52.476 --> 00:05:54.437
flip books that we have on DVDs,

00:05:54.737 --> 00:05:56.398
which I do update regularly because I'm

00:05:56.437 --> 00:05:58.538
coming back around on physical media.

00:05:58.899 --> 00:06:00.759
Go buy your shit so you own it

00:06:00.819 --> 00:06:03.300
and don't let streamers take away all our

00:06:03.360 --> 00:06:03.701
rights.

00:06:03.802 --> 00:06:05.161
PlayStation, looking at you,

00:06:05.262 --> 00:06:07.543
keep making physical copies of discs.

00:06:07.723 --> 00:06:11.125
What in the world is wrong with us?

00:06:11.185 --> 00:06:11.964
It's capitalism.

00:06:14.843 --> 00:06:17.829
But books and movies and these things do

00:06:17.988 --> 00:06:18.790
tend to matter.

00:06:18.850 --> 00:06:20.954
And so on the coffee table in my

00:06:21.033 --> 00:06:21.353
office,

00:06:21.434 --> 00:06:23.336
one of the books that stays on my

00:06:23.396 --> 00:06:25.139
coffee table, it doesn't get rotated out,

00:06:25.860 --> 00:06:26.122
is...

00:06:28.269 --> 00:06:30.370
a coffee table book about Pink Floyd.

00:06:30.769 --> 00:06:32.071
And it's not that it's my favorite Pink

00:06:32.091 --> 00:06:32.531
Floyd book,

00:06:32.591 --> 00:06:34.372
or it's not that it's necessarily relevant

00:06:34.432 --> 00:06:35.132
which book it is.

00:06:35.391 --> 00:06:36.793
It is just a coffee table book.

00:06:36.812 --> 00:06:38.233
There's lots of information about the

00:06:38.254 --> 00:06:40.535
band, pictures from tours, et cetera,

00:06:40.615 --> 00:06:41.095
et cetera.

00:06:42.014 --> 00:06:44.596
It's a way for clients who come into

00:06:44.636 --> 00:06:48.197
my office who might recognize the band to

00:06:48.237 --> 00:06:51.418
know, ah, if I wanna talk about,

00:06:52.720 --> 00:06:52.959
you know,

00:06:55.519 --> 00:06:58.240
Critiquing the man, burn it all down,

00:06:59.281 --> 00:07:00.141
rock and roll.

00:07:01.182 --> 00:07:01.882
Jeremy gets it.

00:07:03.103 --> 00:07:03.423
Also,

00:07:03.744 --> 00:07:05.444
my other coffee table book that I often

00:07:05.483 --> 00:07:08.225
bring up is Marshall McLuhan's The Medium

00:07:08.245 --> 00:07:09.005
is the Massage,

00:07:09.365 --> 00:07:11.007
which I'll probably reference in this

00:07:11.047 --> 00:07:11.786
conversation.

00:07:12.708 --> 00:07:17.790
And an artistic rendering of Rime of the

00:07:17.810 --> 00:07:18.310
Ancient Mariner.

00:07:20.595 --> 00:07:24.137
which is a giant tattoo inspiration for me

00:07:24.177 --> 00:07:26.360
that I have an albatross on my back.

00:07:26.880 --> 00:07:29.663
Also a Pink Floyd reference because I love

00:07:29.704 --> 00:07:32.086
Pink Floyd and all of my body art

00:07:32.125 --> 00:07:33.726
has to reference like four different

00:07:33.747 --> 00:07:36.170
things because I can't help myself.

00:07:40.553 --> 00:07:42.456
Overhead the albatross hangs motionless

00:07:42.475 --> 00:07:44.437
upon the breeze from Echoes by Pink Floyd.

00:07:45.353 --> 00:07:48.134
The reason we have to talk about Roger

00:07:48.175 --> 00:07:51.958
Waters, who is again, a known asshole.

00:07:53.978 --> 00:07:56.882
He's a difficult person to maintain an

00:07:56.942 --> 00:07:58.483
interpersonal relationship with.

00:07:58.923 --> 00:08:03.807
That's his celebrity profile, right?

00:08:03.867 --> 00:08:04.807
Like this is a known,

00:08:04.968 --> 00:08:09.190
he's a known quantity forever for this

00:08:09.250 --> 00:08:09.610
reason.

00:08:10.252 --> 00:08:12.853
It's just that to go see him live

00:08:12.874 --> 00:08:14.615
in concert is still incredible.

00:08:15.913 --> 00:08:19.016
he's a dick these these things have never

00:08:19.036 --> 00:08:23.137
been incompatible so i'm not concerned

00:08:23.177 --> 00:08:28.500
that he's a dick roger waters recently uh

00:08:28.540 --> 00:08:32.542
sat down with tucker carlson who you might

00:08:32.562 --> 00:08:36.303
know as being the the child of ice

00:08:36.344 --> 00:08:38.725
cream barons um

00:08:40.437 --> 00:08:41.979
Tucker Carlson's an epobaby.

00:08:42.178 --> 00:08:44.340
He was on CNN briefly before pivoting to

00:08:44.399 --> 00:08:47.861
full right-wing propaganda on Fox.

00:08:51.163 --> 00:08:53.304
His show was the number one viewed show

00:08:53.385 --> 00:08:54.985
in all of cable television for a long

00:08:55.025 --> 00:08:55.307
time,

00:08:56.626 --> 00:08:58.148
in which he wore stupid little bow ties

00:08:58.168 --> 00:08:59.849
and looked like he was constipated while

00:08:59.908 --> 00:09:02.130
asking basic-ass questions that he never

00:09:02.270 --> 00:09:05.613
answered because that way it seemed like

00:09:05.673 --> 00:09:07.734
he was inquisitive and smart instead of

00:09:07.754 --> 00:09:09.554
just a big dumb idiot doing propaganda.

00:09:11.397 --> 00:09:15.299
Tucker Carlson has left Fox News.

00:09:15.399 --> 00:09:16.760
He was fired.

00:09:17.662 --> 00:09:19.143
He was a lot of the reason they

00:09:19.163 --> 00:09:21.304
got sued for eight hundred some million

00:09:21.345 --> 00:09:23.446
dollars in a defamation suit against

00:09:23.846 --> 00:09:25.106
Dominion voting machines.

00:09:26.187 --> 00:09:28.769
And he's been pretty unapologetic in that.

00:09:28.870 --> 00:09:32.033
He's a grifter conspiracy theorist who may

00:09:32.052 --> 00:09:33.673
or may not run for president in the

00:09:33.714 --> 00:09:34.053
future.

00:09:36.135 --> 00:09:39.759
In a long line of Republican right wing

00:09:41.000 --> 00:09:43.302
people who are bad at policy but

00:09:43.381 --> 00:09:46.423
understand television he would follow the

00:09:46.464 --> 00:09:50.265
likes of Ronald Reagan and Donald Trump as

00:09:50.826 --> 00:09:56.029
genuinely idiotic people who understand TV

00:09:56.830 --> 00:09:58.571
and therefore are electable because they

00:09:58.591 --> 00:10:00.371
understand how to go on TV a lot

00:10:00.412 --> 00:10:03.474
of people think Tucker's smart and I think

00:10:05.393 --> 00:10:07.695
from sort of the left side of things

00:10:08.135 --> 00:10:11.337
um without going like actual leftist from

00:10:11.357 --> 00:10:15.682
a liberal perspective uh of the sort of

00:10:15.802 --> 00:10:18.124
political strategists tucker might be one

00:10:18.183 --> 00:10:21.667
of the smarter ones um but again you're

00:10:21.687 --> 00:10:23.729
dealing with like asshats like russ vaught

00:10:23.869 --> 00:10:26.471
and just again like sort of

00:10:27.947 --> 00:10:29.191
scrape in the bottom of the barrel,

00:10:29.230 --> 00:10:31.056
basement dwelling intellectuals.

00:10:31.456 --> 00:10:32.620
These are not smart people.

00:10:32.660 --> 00:10:35.629
Conservatism is not a smart stance to

00:10:35.668 --> 00:10:35.909
take.

00:10:36.894 --> 00:10:38.394
So, yeah,

00:10:39.475 --> 00:10:41.158
I'm not sold on Tucker being particularly

00:10:41.177 --> 00:10:41.437
smart.

00:10:41.597 --> 00:10:43.679
I think Tucker is good at media.

00:10:44.260 --> 00:10:46.383
He's media savvy after spending a great

00:10:46.423 --> 00:10:48.043
deal of time in television,

00:10:48.504 --> 00:10:50.245
making that stupid face and wearing those

00:10:50.265 --> 00:10:51.707
shitty little bow ties didn't end his

00:10:51.727 --> 00:10:52.107
career.

00:10:52.148 --> 00:10:54.250
So obviously he's like got some skill in

00:10:54.289 --> 00:10:58.133
it because worse people have been sunk for

00:10:58.173 --> 00:10:58.474
less.

00:10:59.539 --> 00:11:02.042
So yeah, I can say he's that.

00:11:02.542 --> 00:11:05.323
His grift, much like Candace Owens,

00:11:05.464 --> 00:11:08.306
I think, who's also a good grifter,

00:11:09.986 --> 00:11:11.368
has pivoted off of MAGA.

00:11:11.427 --> 00:11:12.048
I think, again,

00:11:12.087 --> 00:11:16.191
like rats fleeing a sinking ship has moved

00:11:16.211 --> 00:11:16.971
away from MAGA.

00:11:17.432 --> 00:11:19.932
But Tucker has leaned into his, I think,

00:11:20.013 --> 00:11:21.433
more natural, basest,

00:11:21.474 --> 00:11:25.197
fascist tendencies in that his criticisms

00:11:25.236 --> 00:11:26.898
of Trump are rarely...

00:11:29.056 --> 00:11:31.198
progressive criticisms is simply that

00:11:31.219 --> 00:11:32.961
Trump isn't fascist enough.

00:11:34.023 --> 00:11:36.446
And so Tucker has had people like Nick

00:11:36.485 --> 00:11:37.586
Fuentes on his show,

00:11:37.628 --> 00:11:39.549
who's an avowed neo-Nazi.

00:11:41.513 --> 00:11:42.975
And Tucker continues to platform a lot of

00:11:43.014 --> 00:11:43.335
things.

00:11:43.775 --> 00:11:44.797
Now, I think Tucker is...

00:11:45.874 --> 00:11:46.475
Racist,

00:11:48.375 --> 00:11:50.918
as shown by a number of quotes we

00:11:50.938 --> 00:11:53.841
could pull from Tucker and his refusal to

00:11:53.880 --> 00:11:54.782
take any of them back.

00:11:55.582 --> 00:11:57.024
The reason I think Tucker and

00:11:57.063 --> 00:11:58.846
unfortunately Roger Waters are crossing

00:11:58.885 --> 00:12:02.869
paths here is because Roger Waters has

00:12:02.928 --> 00:12:04.610
long been accused of being an anti-Semite

00:12:04.650 --> 00:12:07.192
because Roger Waters has long spoken about

00:12:07.212 --> 00:12:07.693
racism.

00:12:08.374 --> 00:12:10.235
Israel's occupation of Palestine,

00:12:10.274 --> 00:12:14.375
and he's been opposed to that long before

00:12:14.495 --> 00:12:15.216
October seventh,

00:12:15.275 --> 00:12:16.495
long before this iteration.

00:12:16.535 --> 00:12:17.976
Throughout his career,

00:12:18.017 --> 00:12:19.657
this has been a thing that he's been

00:12:19.856 --> 00:12:19.998
on,

00:12:21.378 --> 00:12:22.778
sometimes when he's been one of the few

00:12:22.817 --> 00:12:23.899
celebrities speaking on it.

00:12:23.999 --> 00:12:24.438
And again,

00:12:26.239 --> 00:12:28.220
we'll get into the larger picture of what

00:12:28.259 --> 00:12:31.500
I'm talking about in that we should not

00:12:31.600 --> 00:12:33.261
celebrate celebrities,

00:12:34.302 --> 00:12:36.663
and we certainly shouldn't have them as

00:12:36.722 --> 00:12:37.923
our personal thought leaders.

00:12:39.328 --> 00:12:40.889
But yeah, I mean,

00:12:40.928 --> 00:12:43.830
credit where some intellectual honesty is

00:12:43.870 --> 00:12:44.350
due.

00:12:44.389 --> 00:12:45.931
Roger Waters has been very consistent

00:12:45.951 --> 00:12:47.211
about this throughout his career.

00:12:47.671 --> 00:12:48.691
And I'm one of the people who,

00:12:48.791 --> 00:12:49.892
as a fan of Pink Floyd,

00:12:49.951 --> 00:12:51.672
sees this criticism pop up somewhat

00:12:51.711 --> 00:12:54.072
regularly and just don't think he's ever

00:12:54.133 --> 00:12:56.052
been anti-Semitic in it.

00:12:57.293 --> 00:12:58.514
I think he has...

00:12:59.928 --> 00:13:01.250
taken a nuanced stance,

00:13:01.289 --> 00:13:04.672
which is to say that Jewish people and

00:13:04.692 --> 00:13:07.113
the state of Israel are different things.

00:13:07.212 --> 00:13:10.615
Not all Jewish people support a Zionist

00:13:10.715 --> 00:13:15.717
agenda and he's not opposed to people

00:13:15.738 --> 00:13:16.499
being Jewish.

00:13:17.359 --> 00:13:19.320
He's opposed to the state of Israel being

00:13:19.921 --> 00:13:22.802
an authoritarian state that is predicated

00:13:22.942 --> 00:13:26.884
on taking land from other people.

00:13:27.125 --> 00:13:29.125
And he's been very consistent in that.

00:13:31.229 --> 00:13:35.711
tucker being an anti-semite i think has

00:13:35.770 --> 00:13:37.192
paired with a lot of people who want

00:13:37.211 --> 00:13:40.153
to talk about israel doing bad things not

00:13:40.192 --> 00:13:41.854
because tucker is critical of the state of

00:13:41.933 --> 00:13:44.695
israel being fascistic authoritarian and

00:13:45.174 --> 00:13:47.495
committing genocide uh but because tucker

00:13:47.535 --> 00:13:49.576
wants to hate the jews which is the

00:13:49.596 --> 00:13:51.258
stance he's had through his entire career

00:13:51.618 --> 00:13:53.158
he's had a number of scandals for saying

00:13:53.177 --> 00:13:55.379
a bunch of really shitty things and again

00:13:55.418 --> 00:13:56.639
continues to exist so

00:13:57.129 --> 00:13:59.312
If people wanna talk about cancel culture,

00:13:59.331 --> 00:14:02.794
we could certainly pull Tucker as a proof

00:14:02.914 --> 00:14:05.236
of concept that cancel culture is not a

00:14:05.297 --> 00:14:05.517
thing.

00:14:06.898 --> 00:14:10.740
And my big issue with Roger Waters going

00:14:10.780 --> 00:14:15.144
on the show is simply that Waters should

00:14:15.205 --> 00:14:16.846
know better at this point in his career

00:14:16.927 --> 00:14:18.548
as somebody who's been outspoken and

00:14:18.567 --> 00:14:20.769
politically active in this arena.

00:14:22.171 --> 00:14:23.932
You gotta know who...

00:14:25.533 --> 00:14:27.934
working with who you're collaborating with

00:14:28.455 --> 00:14:29.735
and i've seen a lot of pink floyd

00:14:29.755 --> 00:14:33.158
fans defend roger waters to say tucker has

00:14:33.177 --> 00:14:35.440
a huge following roger going on uh

00:14:35.580 --> 00:14:37.701
tucker's show isn't a bad thing if it

00:14:37.741 --> 00:14:41.063
reaches some of those people and i

00:14:41.104 --> 00:14:43.024
disagree with that stance i do not think

00:14:43.065 --> 00:14:45.287
tucker has a big following anymore he's

00:14:45.346 --> 00:14:47.347
not on cable news he doesn't have a

00:14:47.408 --> 00:14:50.350
syndicated show like that um and i think

00:14:50.409 --> 00:14:53.873
tucker's audience is not a good one

00:14:57.412 --> 00:15:00.053
if people are still tuning into Tucker

00:15:00.073 --> 00:15:00.453
Carlson,

00:15:00.514 --> 00:15:02.316
it's not to learn new things and be

00:15:02.416 --> 00:15:02.956
interested.

00:15:03.076 --> 00:15:03.596
Because again,

00:15:06.019 --> 00:15:08.640
this popped up on my various feeds in

00:15:08.681 --> 00:15:10.442
different places and seeing it on

00:15:10.522 --> 00:15:11.081
Instagram,

00:15:11.342 --> 00:15:15.885
clicking on the comment sections.

00:15:15.926 --> 00:15:17.908
These are people who listen to Pink Floyd

00:15:18.168 --> 00:15:20.269
and like Another Brick in the Wall,

00:15:20.349 --> 00:15:23.131
but have no application to the greater

00:15:23.172 --> 00:15:24.413
understanding of what Pink Floyd's

00:15:24.572 --> 00:15:25.994
actually criticizing here.

00:15:27.089 --> 00:15:30.211
And these are the Pink Floyd fans that

00:15:30.312 --> 00:15:33.936
you don't like to run into because they're

00:15:33.956 --> 00:15:35.618
Republicans or they voted for Trump.

00:15:35.638 --> 00:15:36.499
And you're like,

00:15:36.719 --> 00:15:38.922
you can't listen to Pink Floyd talk about

00:15:39.162 --> 00:15:41.504
Maggie Thatcher and then vote for Trump.

00:15:41.904 --> 00:15:43.466
That simply doesn't work.

00:15:43.505 --> 00:15:45.028
You missed the point.

00:15:46.229 --> 00:15:48.230
And so Tucker's current audience is

00:15:48.309 --> 00:15:49.630
lacking any sort of critical thinking

00:15:49.650 --> 00:15:52.192
skills and any sort of interest in nuance

00:15:53.033 --> 00:15:55.494
where I don't think it's valid to say

00:15:55.614 --> 00:15:57.375
if you win some of these people over,

00:15:57.414 --> 00:15:59.135
that's a good get.

00:15:59.155 --> 00:15:59.495
You're not.

00:15:59.615 --> 00:16:00.797
You're not winning these people over.

00:16:01.076 --> 00:16:04.197
They're so far gone that you might as

00:16:04.217 --> 00:16:07.139
well be on InfoWars dealing with Alex

00:16:07.159 --> 00:16:07.460
Jones,

00:16:08.419 --> 00:16:10.000
which doesn't exist anymore in the sense

00:16:10.041 --> 00:16:10.981
that it was bought.

00:16:11.903 --> 00:16:13.683
And it isn't run by Alex Jones anymore,

00:16:13.724 --> 00:16:14.884
and now it's a Drew parody,

00:16:15.686 --> 00:16:16.446
which is kind of funny.

00:16:20.850 --> 00:16:22.010
So I don't buy it.

00:16:22.211 --> 00:16:24.352
I think Roger Waters needed to have better

00:16:24.393 --> 00:16:26.673
due diligence to know that he was walking

00:16:26.714 --> 00:16:28.296
into an interview with an avowed

00:16:28.395 --> 00:16:31.217
anti-Semite who wants to talk about Israel

00:16:31.238 --> 00:16:36.142
does a bunch of bad things because he's

00:16:36.402 --> 00:16:37.022
anti-Semitic.

00:16:37.062 --> 00:16:40.264
He hates Jewish people and is fascist,

00:16:40.284 --> 00:16:40.424
right?

00:16:42.058 --> 00:16:44.860
which is not being pro-Palestine and

00:16:45.019 --> 00:16:51.061
anti-genocide, actually.

00:16:51.081 --> 00:16:54.341
So deeply critical of Roger even agreeing

00:16:54.361 --> 00:16:55.302
to be on the show.

00:16:56.503 --> 00:16:58.884
And then,

00:16:58.903 --> 00:17:00.244
where we're gonna get to the meat of

00:17:00.283 --> 00:17:02.565
this week's episode,

00:17:04.285 --> 00:17:08.665
they talked about nine-eleven a bunch.

00:17:08.865 --> 00:17:10.527
And Roger Waters,

00:17:11.758 --> 00:17:12.598
An aged man,

00:17:13.578 --> 00:17:16.201
I forget how old he is, late-seventies,

00:17:21.526 --> 00:17:24.887
is a bassist from a rock band.

00:17:25.828 --> 00:17:30.573
That's his claim to fame.

00:17:30.653 --> 00:17:30.853
Again,

00:17:30.913 --> 00:17:33.515
I would argue he's best known as a

00:17:33.835 --> 00:17:34.395
lyricist.

00:17:36.020 --> 00:17:37.141
He wrote the lyrics.

00:17:37.181 --> 00:17:38.902
David Gilmour predominantly wrote the

00:17:38.942 --> 00:17:39.362
music.

00:17:39.541 --> 00:17:41.521
And those two worked really well until

00:17:41.561 --> 00:17:42.382
they couldn't anymore.

00:17:42.461 --> 00:17:43.622
Thus ended the band.

00:17:44.082 --> 00:17:45.383
If you want to tell me that Radio

00:17:45.423 --> 00:17:49.702
Chaos or Amused to Death are good albums,

00:17:49.864 --> 00:17:51.943
I can tell you which songs on those

00:17:52.023 --> 00:17:53.403
albums I think are good.

00:17:53.544 --> 00:17:55.345
I don't think they're good albums.

00:17:55.924 --> 00:17:57.865
I think Roger Waters had more good art

00:17:58.005 --> 00:18:00.986
available in his brain post Pink Floyd.

00:18:02.546 --> 00:18:03.486
But to a limited degree.

00:18:04.512 --> 00:18:05.834
I think Amused to Death was a good

00:18:05.874 --> 00:18:07.193
song in the same way that I think

00:18:07.233 --> 00:18:08.595
There's No Way Out of Here by Dave

00:18:08.615 --> 00:18:09.855
Gilmour was a good song.

00:18:11.075 --> 00:18:12.715
I think On an Island had a couple

00:18:12.736 --> 00:18:14.237
of good songs.

00:18:14.336 --> 00:18:16.096
Both Dave Gilmour and Roger Waters are

00:18:16.116 --> 00:18:18.198
good enough to keep making good art while

00:18:18.258 --> 00:18:20.679
never reaching the pinnacle of what they

00:18:20.719 --> 00:18:26.540
created together in the band Pink Floyd.

00:18:26.560 --> 00:18:30.942
Being a famed lyricist or more literally a

00:18:31.082 --> 00:18:32.383
famous bass player,

00:18:33.567 --> 00:18:36.809
doesn't give you any expertise in

00:18:37.170 --> 00:18:40.813
mechanical engineering.

00:18:40.873 --> 00:18:42.814
Right?

00:18:42.894 --> 00:18:43.174
And like,

00:18:44.198 --> 00:18:46.900
that sounds so obvious that that there

00:18:46.920 --> 00:18:48.422
shouldn't really be any pushback to that

00:18:48.461 --> 00:18:50.503
concept but this is the thing we conflate

00:18:50.763 --> 00:18:53.405
all of the time in our modern society

00:18:53.826 --> 00:18:56.689
because in our culture of celebrity uh we

00:18:56.970 --> 00:19:01.534
we fall into this trap that repetition uh

00:19:01.814 --> 00:19:07.199
creates some sort of positive mindset uh i

00:19:07.239 --> 00:19:09.160
talked about it a couple weeks ago talking

00:19:09.180 --> 00:19:10.342
about like pro wrestling

00:19:13.051 --> 00:19:14.613
and promoting somebody that that name

00:19:14.653 --> 00:19:15.492
recognition matters.

00:19:15.532 --> 00:19:17.433
We know this in modern politics now that

00:19:17.473 --> 00:19:19.736
like name recognition has value.

00:19:20.056 --> 00:19:21.676
If you see or hear from someone,

00:19:21.717 --> 00:19:24.538
a bunch that some voters who are not

00:19:24.577 --> 00:19:26.500
well educated and not well informed will

00:19:26.539 --> 00:19:28.480
go into the voting booth and see a

00:19:28.520 --> 00:19:29.901
name they recognize and vote for that.

00:19:30.521 --> 00:19:31.761
And that's just how some people operate,

00:19:31.842 --> 00:19:32.042
right?

00:19:32.103 --> 00:19:36.265
Like it's the flaw of democracy is that

00:19:36.845 --> 00:19:37.986
idiots get to vote too.

00:19:40.478 --> 00:19:40.718
See,

00:19:40.878 --> 00:19:42.400
I said I was gonna have to watch

00:19:42.440 --> 00:19:46.204
my own biases on this episode.

00:19:48.547 --> 00:19:51.711
Which is not a bad thing other than

00:19:53.345 --> 00:19:54.464
there's so much misinformation and

00:19:54.484 --> 00:19:55.326
propaganda allowed.

00:19:55.526 --> 00:19:56.105
Because again,

00:19:56.465 --> 00:19:57.726
part of what makes democracy work is

00:19:57.746 --> 00:19:59.586
having well-informed voters.

00:19:59.707 --> 00:20:02.106
And so even idiots can be well-informed.

00:20:02.787 --> 00:20:04.968
And that's not actually how America does

00:20:04.988 --> 00:20:05.508
democracy.

00:20:05.788 --> 00:20:08.729
So we have a lot of idiots voting

00:20:08.769 --> 00:20:11.250
who are purposefully misinformed,

00:20:11.769 --> 00:20:12.509
which is a problem.

00:20:14.664 --> 00:20:16.788
And then just general corruption has

00:20:16.887 --> 00:20:18.088
really reached a fever pitch.

00:20:18.670 --> 00:20:20.892
Because bribery is not a thing anymore,

00:20:20.932 --> 00:20:21.913
according to the Supreme Court.

00:20:22.253 --> 00:20:24.576
Separate topic, staying on topic.

00:20:24.957 --> 00:20:26.298
Roger Waters, the bassist,

00:20:26.919 --> 00:20:29.602
does not understand engineering.

00:20:30.423 --> 00:20:31.964
Because Roger Waters, the bassist,

00:20:32.345 --> 00:20:34.307
did not study engineering.

00:20:35.994 --> 00:20:37.135
Roger Waters, the bassist,

00:20:38.316 --> 00:20:42.478
while building a wall in a concert tour

00:20:42.798 --> 00:20:44.699
and then blowing it up did happen.

00:20:45.160 --> 00:20:48.080
That was not actually ever a real building

00:20:48.221 --> 00:20:51.162
he built or blew up while performing his

00:20:51.201 --> 00:20:51.762
little songs.

00:20:51.782 --> 00:20:52.843
And again,

00:20:52.863 --> 00:20:55.124
I'm being like purposefully over the top

00:20:55.163 --> 00:20:57.705
because his little songs are the wall,

00:20:57.726 --> 00:20:58.865
which I want to step in and defend

00:20:58.885 --> 00:20:59.967
and be like, no, that's awesome.

00:21:00.027 --> 00:21:02.087
And also the wall live was very cool.

00:21:02.268 --> 00:21:04.489
And seeing Roger Waters live is still very

00:21:04.528 --> 00:21:04.749
cool.

00:21:05.878 --> 00:21:09.240
And like not somebody who built buildings,

00:21:09.621 --> 00:21:11.623
let alone giant skyscrapers,

00:21:12.123 --> 00:21:14.785
let alone do we have anybody who builds

00:21:14.845 --> 00:21:16.605
tall buildings and then test those tall

00:21:16.645 --> 00:21:18.386
buildings against planes being flown into

00:21:18.406 --> 00:21:18.547
them?

00:21:18.586 --> 00:21:22.509
Because that simply isn't a thing we do.

00:21:22.529 --> 00:21:25.111
We don't build a hundred and ten story

00:21:25.151 --> 00:21:27.712
tall skyscrapers and then test them by

00:21:27.972 --> 00:21:32.096
seeing how much explosion they can handle.

00:21:32.135 --> 00:21:33.656
That's not a thing.

00:21:35.441 --> 00:21:37.241
So Roger Waters went on to the Tucker

00:21:37.261 --> 00:21:37.942
Carlson show,

00:21:39.383 --> 00:21:41.183
racist anti-Semitic Tucker Carlson,

00:21:41.384 --> 00:21:42.925
and Roger Waters sat down to talk about

00:21:43.006 --> 00:21:47.307
nine, eleven conspiracy theories,

00:21:47.347 --> 00:21:47.909
which is weird.

00:21:48.249 --> 00:21:49.910
I think there are certainly valid

00:21:49.950 --> 00:21:51.671
criticisms that exist of the United States

00:21:51.711 --> 00:21:53.731
government before September eleventh,

00:21:53.892 --> 00:21:57.493
two thousand one that could have served to

00:21:58.075 --> 00:22:00.415
prevent those terrorist attacks,

00:22:00.955 --> 00:22:03.817
to take the online chatter of those

00:22:03.958 --> 00:22:04.818
terrorist attacks

00:22:05.748 --> 00:22:06.429
more seriously.

00:22:07.750 --> 00:22:09.314
I do not think it was an inside

00:22:09.354 --> 00:22:09.714
job.

00:22:09.855 --> 00:22:11.617
I do not think the towers were

00:22:12.859 --> 00:22:16.326
demolitioned as a precursor to go to war

00:22:16.465 --> 00:22:17.548
in the Middle East for oil.

00:22:19.291 --> 00:22:20.772
I do think the United States government

00:22:20.833 --> 00:22:22.615
did not take terrorist threats very

00:22:22.654 --> 00:22:26.257
seriously and then use those as a pretense

00:22:26.277 --> 00:22:26.837
to go to war.

00:22:27.018 --> 00:22:30.059
And I do think that we ratcheted up

00:22:30.119 --> 00:22:32.142
the police state that we live in following

00:22:32.182 --> 00:22:34.063
nine eleven in the name of safety.

00:22:34.584 --> 00:22:34.804
Again,

00:22:34.864 --> 00:22:36.505
I think there are valid criticisms we had.

00:22:37.066 --> 00:22:38.346
I don't think that.

00:22:41.608 --> 00:22:45.632
Nepo baby ice cream baron bow tie wearing

00:22:45.692 --> 00:22:48.974
Tucker Carlson and bass playing.

00:22:50.410 --> 00:22:53.231
not college-educated Roger Waters know

00:22:53.271 --> 00:22:55.413
what the fuck they're talking about when

00:22:55.453 --> 00:23:01.159
it comes to how hot metal beams can

00:23:01.199 --> 00:23:03.980
get before they will melt.

00:23:04.301 --> 00:23:06.143
I just simply don't think they're smart

00:23:06.202 --> 00:23:07.644
enough to have that conversation.

00:23:08.345 --> 00:23:09.905
I say that as somebody who pretty much

00:23:09.986 --> 00:23:12.147
crushed all of the schooling I went to,

00:23:12.749 --> 00:23:14.369
except for organic chemistry.

00:23:15.310 --> 00:23:16.592
And I passed OCHEM I.

00:23:17.170 --> 00:23:19.074
And I took a W in OCHEM too,

00:23:19.114 --> 00:23:20.257
so it wouldn't have to be on my

00:23:20.297 --> 00:23:21.779
transcript because I probably wouldn't

00:23:21.799 --> 00:23:22.381
have passed it.

00:23:23.163 --> 00:23:24.045
And that's not true.

00:23:24.105 --> 00:23:25.366
I would have probably gotten like a C.

00:23:26.854 --> 00:23:27.753
But if you were raised the way I

00:23:27.794 --> 00:23:29.595
was raised, then Cs are not passing.

00:23:29.714 --> 00:23:30.474
And they are, right?

00:23:30.515 --> 00:23:31.776
Cs get degrees.

00:23:31.836 --> 00:23:32.895
I'm a big proponent of this.

00:23:34.537 --> 00:23:36.117
O-Chem, too, is really hard.

00:23:36.337 --> 00:23:38.519
And there's a level of smartness.

00:23:39.818 --> 00:23:42.400
There's a level of knowledge and intellect

00:23:42.440 --> 00:23:45.661
that people who finish those classes and

00:23:45.701 --> 00:23:47.801
go on to study some of the sciences

00:23:48.281 --> 00:23:51.163
more intensely at that level have that I

00:23:51.203 --> 00:23:51.824
did not have.

00:23:52.557 --> 00:23:54.179
My brain is very good at processing

00:23:54.199 --> 00:23:55.400
information very quickly.

00:23:55.740 --> 00:23:57.481
And my brain is very good at connecting

00:23:57.541 --> 00:23:59.242
a lot of pieces that don't seem connected

00:23:59.343 --> 00:23:59.943
at first.

00:24:02.506 --> 00:24:03.907
So something like psychology works really

00:24:03.928 --> 00:24:04.548
well for my brain.

00:24:04.667 --> 00:24:05.469
Pattern recognition,

00:24:06.069 --> 00:24:09.113
a crazy breadth of knowledge without

00:24:09.133 --> 00:24:10.554
needing to get super deep into it.

00:24:10.955 --> 00:24:14.779
I have a cousin who did his PhD

00:24:15.361 --> 00:24:16.261
at University of Minnesota,

00:24:16.281 --> 00:24:17.542
which is where I was doing my undergrad.

00:24:17.742 --> 00:24:19.404
And we overlapped for like a year or

00:24:19.444 --> 00:24:19.744
something.

00:24:19.806 --> 00:24:21.007
I saw him at the Dairy Queen off

00:24:21.047 --> 00:24:21.948
of campus one time.

00:24:24.567 --> 00:24:27.770
he very smart right like the things he

00:24:27.810 --> 00:24:29.952
was working on with his phd i could

00:24:29.992 --> 00:24:32.575
not comprehend as like somebody who was a

00:24:32.634 --> 00:24:34.436
couple years behind him in school and

00:24:34.537 --> 00:24:36.057
wasn't specialized in what he was

00:24:36.077 --> 00:24:39.080
specializing in the idea of things like

00:24:39.161 --> 00:24:42.763
quantum physics are a thing that we read

00:24:42.805 --> 00:24:45.126
about because the marvel universe is

00:24:45.166 --> 00:24:48.209
introducing them and ninety-nine percent

00:24:48.229 --> 00:24:50.290
of the population can't actually fathom

00:24:50.330 --> 00:24:50.991
those things

00:24:52.401 --> 00:24:54.163
right and again you're like wow ninety

00:24:54.202 --> 00:24:55.943
nine percent jared that sounds pretty high

00:24:56.003 --> 00:24:58.527
right like less than half of people have

00:24:58.586 --> 00:25:04.112
college degrees like the the intellectual

00:25:04.172 --> 00:25:09.076
dishonesty that has become so present in

00:25:09.376 --> 00:25:11.898
in the united states to suggest that like

00:25:11.979 --> 00:25:15.261
again experts are not actually experts is

00:25:15.442 --> 00:25:17.064
is a long drawn-out process to get to

00:25:17.104 --> 00:25:18.025
the idea where like

00:25:19.181 --> 00:25:21.722
Mark Wayne Mullen, Mark Wayne Mullen,

00:25:21.863 --> 00:25:23.604
there's almost no way to pronounce his

00:25:23.663 --> 00:25:27.626
name that doesn't veer into like Oklahoma

00:25:29.508 --> 00:25:33.190
hillbilly accent where you know like this

00:25:33.210 --> 00:25:34.070
is not a smart person.

00:25:34.090 --> 00:25:37.292
And there's probably a Mark Wayne out

00:25:37.333 --> 00:25:39.374
there who has risen above his family

00:25:39.413 --> 00:25:42.195
status and did go on to school and

00:25:42.236 --> 00:25:44.017
excel and does something really smart.

00:25:44.657 --> 00:25:47.819
But it's not this guy who's currently

00:25:48.904 --> 00:25:49.285
I don't know,

00:25:49.345 --> 00:25:50.705
director of Homeland Security or

00:25:50.726 --> 00:25:51.086
something.

00:25:51.426 --> 00:25:52.487
I don't even remember what he's in charge

00:25:52.507 --> 00:25:52.586
of.

00:25:52.748 --> 00:25:58.191
He's a fucking moron.

00:25:58.211 --> 00:26:02.653
Because fascism thrives under loyalist

00:26:02.693 --> 00:26:06.155
conditions and hates intelligence,

00:26:06.537 --> 00:26:07.938
hates actual intelligence, right?

00:26:07.978 --> 00:26:10.098
These are small men who are afraid of

00:26:10.378 --> 00:26:11.460
being made to feel stupid.

00:26:11.960 --> 00:26:13.780
And the fact that other people are smarter

00:26:13.800 --> 00:26:16.083
than them makes them feel small, right?

00:26:17.304 --> 00:26:18.464
I can talk about my cousin being super

00:26:18.484 --> 00:26:18.724
smart.

00:26:18.805 --> 00:26:19.865
I can talk about all these people being

00:26:19.884 --> 00:26:21.826
super smart because I don't mind

00:26:22.686 --> 00:26:24.847
acknowledging that other people are a lot

00:26:24.887 --> 00:26:28.109
smarter than me.

00:26:28.150 --> 00:26:29.631
Because like, I'm an idiot.

00:26:30.530 --> 00:26:32.172
I'm really smart in a lot of different

00:26:32.211 --> 00:26:34.353
ways that people are not.

00:26:34.814 --> 00:26:37.994
And also there's so many more ways that

00:26:38.036 --> 00:26:38.695
I'm not smart.

00:26:40.394 --> 00:26:42.075
And it's not like book smart or street

00:26:42.095 --> 00:26:42.355
smart.

00:26:42.494 --> 00:26:45.316
I have actual years and years and years

00:26:45.355 --> 00:26:48.957
worth of study and practice on things that

00:26:48.997 --> 00:26:51.938
have made me quite good at them.

00:26:52.317 --> 00:26:53.438
I can't play the bass.

00:26:53.998 --> 00:26:55.239
So the fact that Roger Waters,

00:26:55.318 --> 00:26:57.058
while he might not be a particularly good

00:26:57.098 --> 00:26:57.519
bassist,

00:26:57.598 --> 00:26:59.759
can play the bass is a form of

00:26:59.819 --> 00:27:01.641
knowledge that he has that I do not.

00:27:04.098 --> 00:27:04.920
I don't know what it's like to grow

00:27:04.940 --> 00:27:05.319
up rich.

00:27:05.579 --> 00:27:07.221
That's a form of knowledge Tucker Carlson

00:27:07.260 --> 00:27:07.520
has.

00:27:07.902 --> 00:27:08.741
I've never been rich.

00:27:08.882 --> 00:27:10.584
Also a form of knowledge Tucker Carlson

00:27:10.604 --> 00:27:11.423
has that I do not.

00:27:16.508 --> 00:27:18.648
But these are not necessarily forms of

00:27:18.749 --> 00:27:20.490
intelligence that I find particularly

00:27:20.509 --> 00:27:20.911
meaningful.

00:27:21.270 --> 00:27:22.352
Playing the bass more so.

00:27:22.971 --> 00:27:25.134
But I want you for just a second.

00:27:26.209 --> 00:27:28.330
your listener just a second to join me

00:27:28.351 --> 00:27:30.913
in a thought experiment and think of a

00:27:30.992 --> 00:27:34.055
person in your life who you know that

00:27:34.095 --> 00:27:41.121
plays the bass guitar right and like just

00:27:41.240 --> 00:27:43.303
holding that person in your mind for a

00:27:43.323 --> 00:27:46.345
sec maybe there's a couple bassists you

00:27:46.365 --> 00:27:48.467
know maybe you've dated a bass player at

00:27:48.507 --> 00:27:50.769
some point in your life and and wonder

00:27:51.169 --> 00:27:55.112
is that somebody who i respect all of

00:27:55.132 --> 00:27:55.732
their opinions

00:27:57.659 --> 00:27:58.038
Because again,

00:27:58.259 --> 00:27:59.380
the bass players that I know are

00:27:59.420 --> 00:28:01.342
predominantly from my time in college and

00:28:02.041 --> 00:28:04.604
a number of them have gone on to

00:28:04.624 --> 00:28:06.664
be college graduates and not play

00:28:06.724 --> 00:28:08.886
professional music and not be particularly

00:28:08.926 --> 00:28:09.988
smart in what they're doing.

00:28:11.107 --> 00:28:12.368
One of them went on to law school

00:28:12.469 --> 00:28:13.869
and as far as I know,

00:28:13.970 --> 00:28:17.272
is a lawyer and I think an intelligent

00:28:17.292 --> 00:28:17.532
person.

00:28:18.355 --> 00:28:20.757
They hiked the Appalachian Trail by

00:28:20.797 --> 00:28:22.498
themselves, which seems like a cool thing.

00:28:22.738 --> 00:28:23.357
I don't know if that has to do

00:28:23.377 --> 00:28:24.038
with intelligence,

00:28:24.077 --> 00:28:26.118
but like some degree of survival, right?

00:28:26.358 --> 00:28:26.739
That's cool.

00:28:27.459 --> 00:28:29.380
I assume there's a number of functional

00:28:29.440 --> 00:28:31.121
knowledge bases that you have to draw from

00:28:31.141 --> 00:28:31.780
to be able to do that.

00:28:32.060 --> 00:28:33.321
And that's cool.

00:28:38.123 --> 00:28:42.845
So when I think confronted with like,

00:28:42.865 --> 00:28:44.185
I wanna say actual smart people,

00:28:45.546 --> 00:28:47.086
When actual smart people get around to

00:28:47.126 --> 00:28:48.407
other smart people, it's enriching,

00:28:48.468 --> 00:28:49.388
it's enlivening,

00:28:49.489 --> 00:28:51.691
it's in zero ways threatening because we

00:28:51.730 --> 00:28:53.372
cannot be experts in all things.

00:28:53.412 --> 00:28:55.773
And this is just a known presupposition.

00:28:56.795 --> 00:28:59.037
I don't like to start with arguments where

00:28:59.057 --> 00:29:00.018
I'm presupposing something.

00:29:00.057 --> 00:29:01.939
The idea that we can't know all things

00:29:02.359 --> 00:29:02.920
is up there.

00:29:03.820 --> 00:29:05.541
The human brain can't even problem solve

00:29:05.582 --> 00:29:06.522
multiple things at a time,

00:29:06.942 --> 00:29:07.723
one thing at a time.

00:29:07.963 --> 00:29:09.726
Our brain has an order of operations.

00:29:10.778 --> 00:29:14.220
The idea that we could not only know

00:29:14.779 --> 00:29:15.440
all things,

00:29:15.480 --> 00:29:17.819
but also excel to a level of expertise

00:29:17.839 --> 00:29:20.881
in all things is just simply preposterous,

00:29:21.580 --> 00:29:23.041
which gets us to, oh no,

00:29:23.082 --> 00:29:24.701
my favorite celebrity might be a dummy.

00:29:25.301 --> 00:29:27.801
The things that most celebrities excel in

00:29:28.603 --> 00:29:30.682
are not being smart.

00:29:30.702 --> 00:29:35.523
I was gonna say are not being

00:29:35.564 --> 00:29:36.584
well-informed, but again,

00:29:36.624 --> 00:29:37.944
I think to be a high-level athlete,

00:29:37.964 --> 00:29:39.125
you have to be really well-informed on a

00:29:39.204 --> 00:29:39.865
number of things.

00:29:40.714 --> 00:29:41.875
Just do a bunch of film studies.

00:29:41.894 --> 00:29:42.976
You have to know your playbook.

00:29:43.796 --> 00:29:45.056
Sometimes when we watch baseball,

00:29:45.576 --> 00:29:46.777
you'll see a pitcher pull out a little

00:29:46.817 --> 00:29:47.836
card from their back thing,

00:29:47.856 --> 00:29:49.097
which has the scouting report on the

00:29:49.117 --> 00:29:50.097
hitters they're going to face.

00:29:52.659 --> 00:29:52.919
You know,

00:29:52.979 --> 00:29:54.999
like there's a high degree of intelligence

00:29:55.019 --> 00:29:56.039
there, right?

00:29:56.059 --> 00:29:57.420
Some of these people are naturally gifted

00:29:57.460 --> 00:29:59.020
and some of these people are naturally

00:29:59.040 --> 00:30:00.980
gifted and do a shit ton of work

00:30:01.080 --> 00:30:03.082
to take their natural talents and excel

00:30:03.182 --> 00:30:03.662
even more.

00:30:05.643 --> 00:30:07.784
I think Kobe Bryant as somebody who was

00:30:07.804 --> 00:30:10.404
like a workaholic with crazy work ethic

00:30:10.884 --> 00:30:11.944
could, you know,

00:30:12.005 --> 00:30:13.545
take something like Phil Jackson's

00:30:13.566 --> 00:30:15.945
philosophy of the triangle offense and run

00:30:15.986 --> 00:30:18.567
it to a degree and a point where

00:30:19.386 --> 00:30:20.508
my brain can't fathom that.

00:30:20.788 --> 00:30:22.708
And I'm somebody who played division one

00:30:22.768 --> 00:30:24.808
college sports, right?

00:30:25.169 --> 00:30:25.368
When you,

00:30:25.548 --> 00:30:28.369
when you see people who are actually an

00:30:28.450 --> 00:30:29.631
interactive people who are actually at the

00:30:29.691 --> 00:30:31.891
pinnacle of their field,

00:30:32.030 --> 00:30:34.172
it is insanely impressive, right?

00:30:36.913 --> 00:30:38.875
And Kobe Bryant was also a sex pest.

00:30:39.154 --> 00:30:40.476
So, you know,

00:30:40.516 --> 00:30:41.395
what are we supposed to do with all

00:30:41.435 --> 00:30:41.715
that?

00:30:43.096 --> 00:30:43.596
Which is like,

00:30:43.737 --> 00:30:46.637
gets back to the idea of like,

00:30:46.657 --> 00:30:48.159
we shouldn't worship celebrities and

00:30:48.239 --> 00:30:51.940
celebrities are not thought leaders,

00:30:51.980 --> 00:30:52.980
right?

00:30:53.000 --> 00:30:56.561
Your local sports athlete knows their

00:30:56.602 --> 00:30:57.903
local sport really well.

00:30:58.603 --> 00:31:02.825
And that's the only expertise that we can

00:31:04.445 --> 00:31:05.385
ascribe to that person.

00:31:06.854 --> 00:31:08.935
this person made it to the highest

00:31:09.036 --> 00:31:11.297
professional level of their sport,

00:31:11.778 --> 00:31:13.159
they probably know that sport really,

00:31:13.199 --> 00:31:16.361
really well in a way that only other

00:31:16.401 --> 00:31:18.383
people who do that sport at that level

00:31:18.442 --> 00:31:19.242
could comprehend.

00:31:20.203 --> 00:31:21.585
That's an exclusive class.

00:31:23.165 --> 00:31:23.665
Absolutely.

00:31:23.686 --> 00:31:24.406
I agree with that.

00:31:25.228 --> 00:31:27.469
And that's not a particularly useful base

00:31:27.489 --> 00:31:29.611
of knowledge unless you're doing that

00:31:29.631 --> 00:31:31.352
sport.

00:31:31.372 --> 00:31:33.513
There's not a lot of career changes that

00:31:33.554 --> 00:31:35.035
professional athletes get to make that

00:31:35.134 --> 00:31:36.435
don't involve their sport.

00:31:37.260 --> 00:31:39.142
They're either media analysts or they're

00:31:39.182 --> 00:31:39.622
coaches.

00:31:40.823 --> 00:31:43.023
Or they just retire and live off of

00:31:43.064 --> 00:31:44.324
all the money they made while they were

00:31:44.344 --> 00:31:45.704
doing their sport at a really high level.

00:31:45.724 --> 00:31:49.086
Right?

00:31:49.146 --> 00:31:49.567
That's it.

00:31:49.747 --> 00:31:51.067
If you're a professional musician,

00:31:51.288 --> 00:31:53.167
I don't expect you to have a ton

00:31:53.208 --> 00:31:56.049
of knowledge on geopolitics.

00:31:57.830 --> 00:31:59.351
You can pluck your strings or you can

00:31:59.411 --> 00:32:01.612
sing really good notes and that takes a

00:32:01.672 --> 00:32:02.992
special form of knowledge to be able to

00:32:03.032 --> 00:32:04.374
do that at the highest level

00:32:05.398 --> 00:32:08.761
of professionalism certainly the other

00:32:08.981 --> 00:32:11.522
influence of me wanting to do this episode

00:32:11.923 --> 00:32:15.185
because my celebrities have been striking

00:32:15.246 --> 00:32:19.548
out lately is uh darren malikian of uh

00:32:19.669 --> 00:32:22.530
pink not pink floyd system of down fame

00:32:22.770 --> 00:32:24.952
also top five band for me um

00:32:26.279 --> 00:32:28.541
The drummer's been like outright mega

00:32:28.582 --> 00:32:29.682
since twenty sixteen.

00:32:29.923 --> 00:32:31.744
So, you know, that one's tough.

00:32:32.144 --> 00:32:32.484
But again,

00:32:32.786 --> 00:32:34.586
I think when we generally summarize,

00:32:34.626 --> 00:32:35.708
who do we think of as drummers?

00:32:35.807 --> 00:32:36.709
Like not smart people.

00:32:37.589 --> 00:32:37.910
And again,

00:32:38.810 --> 00:32:41.532
that's so insulting because to keep a beat

00:32:41.653 --> 00:32:44.395
or to do multi poly rhythms on beat.

00:32:45.616 --> 00:32:48.298
In front of a stadium of people and

00:32:48.338 --> 00:32:50.121
do that with great degree of consistency,

00:32:50.240 --> 00:32:53.442
I think is really impressive.

00:32:53.624 --> 00:32:53.844
And.

00:32:55.443 --> 00:32:57.365
every drummer i know dropped out of high

00:32:57.424 --> 00:33:00.207
school let alone didn't complete college

00:33:00.768 --> 00:33:01.948
and that's not to take away from their

00:33:01.988 --> 00:33:04.049
drumming skills or their artistry or their

00:33:04.109 --> 00:33:06.692
creative mind or their inherent worth as a

00:33:06.711 --> 00:33:08.673
human being who deserves love and safety

00:33:09.173 --> 00:33:11.095
that's just to suggest that as we get

00:33:11.115 --> 00:33:13.836
into more complex topics i don't think

00:33:13.896 --> 00:33:17.298
they'll have good takes i think they'll

00:33:17.318 --> 00:33:19.901
start tapping away at their fingers as i

00:33:19.941 --> 00:33:21.561
try to explain something like systems

00:33:21.602 --> 00:33:21.882
theory

00:33:28.413 --> 00:33:29.512
I'm just in my own head,

00:33:29.553 --> 00:33:31.094
like contradicting myself, be like,

00:33:31.134 --> 00:33:32.314
but I could explain it to them in

00:33:32.354 --> 00:33:33.315
a way that holds their attention.

00:33:33.335 --> 00:33:34.674
Because that's one of the knowledge bases

00:33:34.694 --> 00:33:35.234
that I have,

00:33:35.275 --> 00:33:36.695
taking really complex things and

00:33:36.736 --> 00:33:38.336
simplifying them to people who are not

00:33:38.976 --> 00:33:40.696
needing to know it at the level that

00:33:40.797 --> 00:33:43.877
I know it.

00:33:44.038 --> 00:33:45.298
Which is a form of knowledge, right?

00:33:45.318 --> 00:33:47.118
Which is cool.

00:33:47.239 --> 00:33:48.539
It's cool that we have different forms of

00:33:48.579 --> 00:33:48.980
knowledge.

00:33:49.279 --> 00:33:52.480
And we have to hold some awareness around

00:33:52.520 --> 00:33:55.521
the fact that to know...

00:33:56.431 --> 00:33:58.392
to a very, very, very high degree,

00:33:59.172 --> 00:34:02.833
a quote unquote expert level degree is

00:34:03.053 --> 00:34:03.833
incredibly limiting.

00:34:04.673 --> 00:34:07.555
There are people who design cars to be

00:34:07.595 --> 00:34:09.815
fuel efficient and those people have to be

00:34:09.855 --> 00:34:10.695
insanely smart.

00:34:11.275 --> 00:34:13.777
The mechanic at your local Jiffy Lube

00:34:13.976 --> 00:34:14.936
isn't that smart.

00:34:16.050 --> 00:34:18.170
And the mechanic at your local Jiffy Lube

00:34:18.492 --> 00:34:20.233
knows so many different things about so

00:34:20.253 --> 00:34:21.634
many different cars that they can

00:34:21.994 --> 00:34:24.516
consistently day in and day out work on

00:34:24.536 --> 00:34:26.717
a plethora of cars, makes, models,

00:34:26.956 --> 00:34:30.860
ears in a way that is highly functional.

00:34:30.900 --> 00:34:31.920
That's super helpful to people.

00:34:32.521 --> 00:34:33.862
Again, that's great.

00:34:33.942 --> 00:34:35.342
And we should pay that person a living

00:34:35.402 --> 00:34:37.143
wage for sure.

00:34:37.244 --> 00:34:39.105
And then some.

00:34:39.125 --> 00:34:39.826
I'm not a car guy.

00:34:39.846 --> 00:34:41.726
I don't understand a lot of the car

00:34:41.766 --> 00:34:42.086
stuff.

00:34:42.166 --> 00:34:43.748
I don't know what all the things do.

00:34:46.186 --> 00:34:47.949
regrets in life is that I didn't take

00:34:48.028 --> 00:34:51.550
small motors and engines in high school

00:34:51.592 --> 00:34:52.492
because that was a class we had.

00:34:52.512 --> 00:34:54.054
And I didn't take it because it didn't

00:34:54.094 --> 00:34:56.054
fit as my father,

00:34:56.155 --> 00:34:59.777
who is also a guidance counselor,

00:35:01.259 --> 00:35:04.922
directed me towards staying on my academic

00:35:04.981 --> 00:35:07.083
path, which is fine, right?

00:35:07.123 --> 00:35:08.364
I graduated college in three years,

00:35:08.545 --> 00:35:09.206
saved a lot of money.

00:35:10.157 --> 00:35:11.378
And I don't know how engines work.

00:35:11.597 --> 00:35:13.960
I can't do regular maintenance on my own

00:35:14.760 --> 00:35:15.541
little lawnmower.

00:35:16.041 --> 00:35:18.943
I know enough about cars to change my

00:35:19.123 --> 00:35:20.706
oil and I could change my brakes if

00:35:20.766 --> 00:35:21.266
I need to,

00:35:21.385 --> 00:35:22.686
but I prefer to pay someone else to

00:35:22.706 --> 00:35:23.108
do that.

00:35:24.389 --> 00:35:25.230
I'm not a car guy.

00:35:25.929 --> 00:35:27.570
There's a certain level of knowledge

00:35:27.751 --> 00:35:28.092
there.

00:35:28.231 --> 00:35:28.492
Again,

00:35:28.572 --> 00:35:31.695
pattern recognition and knowledge base

00:35:32.375 --> 00:35:33.916
around that is necessary to do that

00:35:34.137 --> 00:35:34.677
professionally.

00:35:34.757 --> 00:35:36.378
Again, I think that is respectable.

00:35:37.159 --> 00:35:38.521
And also...

00:35:41.097 --> 00:35:43.358
a small unit of knowledge.

00:35:43.858 --> 00:35:45.458
And I don't mean small in like a

00:35:45.818 --> 00:35:47.298
judgmental or comparative way,

00:35:47.378 --> 00:35:51.000
like in the pantheon of all knowledge

00:35:51.139 --> 00:35:51.460
ever,

00:35:51.539 --> 00:35:53.739
that's a very small amount of knowledge

00:35:53.860 --> 00:35:54.239
you have.

00:35:55.081 --> 00:35:57.760
I understand how to change the oil in

00:35:57.820 --> 00:36:00.762
cars that were made from two thousand to

00:36:00.782 --> 00:36:03.661
two thousand twenty six in the history of

00:36:03.762 --> 00:36:04.621
all knowledge.

00:36:04.641 --> 00:36:05.661
It's very small.

00:36:06.043 --> 00:36:07.422
So is modern psychology.

00:36:07.463 --> 00:36:08.722
So it's psychotherapy, right?

00:36:11.295 --> 00:36:15.177
So my point that I've rambled to make

00:36:15.518 --> 00:36:18.740
is that we as humans can only occupy

00:36:18.840 --> 00:36:19.842
very small,

00:36:19.981 --> 00:36:22.324
limited amounts of knowledge at any given

00:36:22.384 --> 00:36:22.623
time.

00:36:23.945 --> 00:36:26.347
To be an expert in a field...

00:36:27.179 --> 00:36:28.681
It takes a lot to be an expert

00:36:28.721 --> 00:36:29.360
in multiple field.

00:36:29.380 --> 00:36:30.021
It takes a lot,

00:36:30.061 --> 00:36:31.384
which is why there are very few people

00:36:31.443 --> 00:36:33.925
who are like doctors and lawyers and

00:36:34.025 --> 00:36:34.626
astronauts.

00:36:35.188 --> 00:36:36.188
And when we find those people,

00:36:37.090 --> 00:36:38.771
we let them run the space mission because

00:36:38.791 --> 00:36:41.293
like, gosh, they're really fucking smart.

00:36:43.315 --> 00:36:45.778
And most people aren't that smart.

00:36:46.672 --> 00:36:47.793
people don't even have a knowledge base

00:36:47.833 --> 00:36:50.414
that like cracks top ten percent of their

00:36:50.454 --> 00:36:53.675
chosen field again your local mechanic at

00:36:53.715 --> 00:36:56.516
jiffy lube is great at being a mechanic

00:36:56.735 --> 00:36:59.335
and also isn't designing cars because they

00:36:59.577 --> 00:37:01.896
aren't at that level in their field of

00:37:01.976 --> 00:37:06.597
car knowledge dudes who who collect cars

00:37:06.677 --> 00:37:11.460
or ladies or whomever people i just drove

00:37:11.480 --> 00:37:11.960
past a

00:37:12.641 --> 00:37:14.422
like hot rod show the other day.

00:37:15.204 --> 00:37:16.063
I don't know how to describe it.

00:37:16.083 --> 00:37:16.985
I'm not a car person.

00:37:17.485 --> 00:37:19.925
It was not classic cars.

00:37:20.106 --> 00:37:22.347
It was cars they did shit to,

00:37:22.367 --> 00:37:23.809
to make them look cool and have big

00:37:24.188 --> 00:37:25.130
engines on the outside,

00:37:25.230 --> 00:37:26.831
which I would describe as a hot rod

00:37:27.130 --> 00:37:27.650
car show.

00:37:31.012 --> 00:37:32.934
They probably know a lot about those cars.

00:37:33.235 --> 00:37:34.655
And that's not somebody who I would

00:37:34.695 --> 00:37:36.936
necessarily assume I want to change the

00:37:37.056 --> 00:37:37.817
oil on my

00:37:42.315 --> 00:37:43.836
They might know a lot about cars.

00:37:43.856 --> 00:37:45.440
They might know a lot about specific

00:37:45.559 --> 00:37:50.188
engines and specific... What chrome does,

00:37:50.668 --> 00:37:50.909
right?

00:37:51.168 --> 00:37:51.670
Or whatever.

00:37:52.070 --> 00:37:52.411
I don't know.

00:37:52.570 --> 00:37:54.233
Maybe they only understand what...

00:37:55.289 --> 00:37:57.331
flame decals to put on cars look good.

00:37:57.411 --> 00:37:57.871
Because again,

00:37:57.891 --> 00:37:59.251
that's a type of knowledge too.

00:37:59.291 --> 00:38:01.251
It's not one that I think is particularly

00:38:01.271 --> 00:38:01.652
important,

00:38:01.731 --> 00:38:03.592
but if you're doing hot rod shows,

00:38:03.612 --> 00:38:05.032
you might, and that's fine.

00:38:05.052 --> 00:38:07.012
I don't think interior decorating feels

00:38:07.072 --> 00:38:07.813
all that important.

00:38:08.454 --> 00:38:09.074
And again,

00:38:09.233 --> 00:38:11.534
those people have useful careers and make

00:38:11.554 --> 00:38:11.954
a lot of money.

00:38:12.255 --> 00:38:12.755
It's great.

00:38:12.775 --> 00:38:14.356
It's great that different people have

00:38:14.396 --> 00:38:15.275
different types of knowledge.

00:38:19.137 --> 00:38:21.617
Conservatist propagandists and bass

00:38:21.657 --> 00:38:22.117
players

00:38:23.458 --> 00:38:25.139
Don't have a base of knowledge to know

00:38:26.920 --> 00:38:27.780
mechanical engineering.

00:38:28.740 --> 00:38:30.362
Don't have a base of knowledge to know

00:38:33.603 --> 00:38:35.985
what government did or didn't do in two

00:38:36.025 --> 00:38:37.746
thousand one twenty five years ago.

00:38:38.286 --> 00:38:38.425
Now,

00:38:38.525 --> 00:38:40.626
Tucker Carlson does have a knowledge base

00:38:40.666 --> 00:38:40.887
to know.

00:38:41.273 --> 00:38:43.894
This is great propaganda that definitely

00:38:44.135 --> 00:38:46.614
fits into his whole shtick,

00:38:46.655 --> 00:38:49.135
which has been devoid of any sort of

00:38:49.275 --> 00:38:52.237
evidence and veers conspiratorial all of

00:38:52.277 --> 00:38:52.677
the time.

00:38:53.416 --> 00:38:56.097
So having a big name celebrity come on

00:38:56.358 --> 00:39:01.619
and talk about a conspiracy theory, again,

00:39:01.639 --> 00:39:02.139
I don't know,

00:39:02.280 --> 00:39:04.820
is conspiracy theories a knowledge base?

00:39:04.860 --> 00:39:05.940
I think by the way that I've sort

00:39:05.960 --> 00:39:06.521
of defined

00:39:07.597 --> 00:39:10.278
knowledge base as usable knowledge,

00:39:10.318 --> 00:39:11.059
then yes, again,

00:39:11.119 --> 00:39:12.519
like the ability to manipulate people,

00:39:12.599 --> 00:39:14.481
to be a grifter is a certain knowledge

00:39:14.501 --> 00:39:14.722
base.

00:39:14.742 --> 00:39:14.942
Again,

00:39:15.021 --> 00:39:17.143
it's not one that I think highly of,

00:39:17.164 --> 00:39:18.164
and it is one that I think we

00:39:18.204 --> 00:39:23.327
should be critical of, right?

00:39:23.608 --> 00:39:27.130
You could be helping people donate their

00:39:27.210 --> 00:39:28.010
organs, right?

00:39:28.771 --> 00:39:30.853
You wanna be like somebody who can shift

00:39:31.253 --> 00:39:32.574
public perception on things,

00:39:32.614 --> 00:39:34.695
let's get the boomers signing up for organ

00:39:34.735 --> 00:39:35.155
donation,

00:39:35.195 --> 00:39:36.797
because whatever PR scare campaign

00:39:37.250 --> 00:39:38.670
ran in the sixties has kept a lot

00:39:38.710 --> 00:39:40.592
of them from being organ donors, right?

00:39:40.652 --> 00:39:42.152
He could be using his powers for good.

00:39:42.331 --> 00:39:42.853
He's not.

00:39:42.972 --> 00:39:44.353
He's using it for personal enrichment.

00:39:46.094 --> 00:39:47.414
So I don't know.

00:39:47.594 --> 00:39:48.474
I don't think that's good.

00:39:48.815 --> 00:39:50.456
And I think Roger Waters, again,

00:39:50.536 --> 00:39:54.018
is not somebody who even being a fan

00:39:54.038 --> 00:39:55.137
of his work for most of his career

00:39:55.157 --> 00:39:56.298
was ever somebody who was like, ooh,

00:39:56.478 --> 00:39:58.800
I would... Roger Waters' opinion,

00:39:58.920 --> 00:39:59.860
let me hear it.

00:40:00.260 --> 00:40:00.740
By and large,

00:40:00.760 --> 00:40:02.701
it has been preferred to ignore his

00:40:02.760 --> 00:40:05.463
opinions because they've mostly been...

00:40:06.467 --> 00:40:06.887
Petty,

00:40:07.849 --> 00:40:09.429
snarky things he said about his former

00:40:09.449 --> 00:40:12.313
bandmates or former wives.

00:40:13.233 --> 00:40:13.653
Because again,

00:40:13.693 --> 00:40:15.255
he's somebody who being in an

00:40:15.275 --> 00:40:16.876
interpersonal relationship with seems

00:40:16.936 --> 00:40:18.217
hard.

00:40:18.317 --> 00:40:19.717
And he toured with Lucius and I like

00:40:19.777 --> 00:40:20.179
Lucius.

00:40:20.259 --> 00:40:20.679
So again,

00:40:20.719 --> 00:40:22.280
like maybe he's got some redeeming

00:40:22.300 --> 00:40:22.701
qualities.

00:40:22.880 --> 00:40:25.143
People, turns out, are not monolithic.

00:40:26.463 --> 00:40:27.764
I do feel confident in saying not an

00:40:27.824 --> 00:40:28.425
expert on that.

00:40:28.925 --> 00:40:30.067
Not an expert on nine-eleven.

00:40:31.487 --> 00:40:34.570
And as he increases in age,

00:40:34.730 --> 00:40:35.650
as we all will,

00:40:37.639 --> 00:40:39.059
This will come to me someday too.

00:40:39.878 --> 00:40:41.619
I expect his brain capacity to deteriorate

00:40:41.800 --> 00:40:45.400
as his brain literally deteriorates and

00:40:45.601 --> 00:40:47.181
he'll become more prone and more likely to

00:40:47.201 --> 00:40:48.400
fall for conspiracy theories.

00:40:48.860 --> 00:40:50.942
So whatever sharpness and on top of it

00:40:50.961 --> 00:40:52.481
he used to have, gosh,

00:40:52.782 --> 00:40:54.623
I'll just be ageist here and say I

00:40:54.663 --> 00:40:57.842
would doubt it as his numerical age

00:40:57.882 --> 00:41:00.503
continues to climb.

00:41:00.523 --> 00:41:01.623
Death comes to us all.

00:41:01.643 --> 00:41:02.923
All of our brains are going to

00:41:02.943 --> 00:41:03.324
deteriorate.

00:41:03.443 --> 00:41:04.925
All of our mental capacities and

00:41:04.965 --> 00:41:06.065
functionings will deteriorate.

00:41:06.873 --> 00:41:09.536
Mine's deteriorating right now because I

00:41:09.556 --> 00:41:10.876
had to watch Tucker Carlson clips.

00:41:10.896 --> 00:41:13.199
No, literally, though,

00:41:13.219 --> 00:41:13.918
it is deteriorating.

00:41:13.998 --> 00:41:16.561
Our brains are done growing past a certain

00:41:16.581 --> 00:41:18.842
point, twenty six ish for most of us.

00:41:19.402 --> 00:41:21.704
And and then we start a slow decline.

00:41:22.485 --> 00:41:23.485
So literally.

00:41:24.586 --> 00:41:25.668
Millennials tuning in.

00:41:25.708 --> 00:41:26.289
Hey, hi.

00:41:26.748 --> 00:41:28.389
Do your back and hip stretches, please.

00:41:29.010 --> 00:41:31.672
Also work on your brain plasticity because

00:41:31.693 --> 00:41:33.454
your brain is deteriorating right now.

00:41:34.235 --> 00:41:34.494
Slowly.

00:41:34.514 --> 00:41:34.635
Slowly.

00:41:36.567 --> 00:41:38.487
but still.

00:41:38.527 --> 00:41:39.208
So, yeah, I mean,

00:41:39.527 --> 00:41:41.887
I don't know whether it's a local

00:41:41.927 --> 00:41:43.748
celebrity saying God helped them win the

00:41:43.789 --> 00:41:44.608
game, uh,

00:41:44.889 --> 00:41:48.130
our little sports ball doing sports ball

00:41:48.170 --> 00:41:48.590
things,

00:41:48.670 --> 00:41:51.190
or it's basis talking about politics or

00:41:51.231 --> 00:41:55.791
it's, I don't know, Kim Kardashian,

00:41:56.092 --> 00:41:58.311
a celebrity whose only claim to fame is

00:41:58.472 --> 00:42:00.012
I think being a celebrity.

00:42:01.193 --> 00:42:01.313
Um,

00:42:04.590 --> 00:42:07.992
Whatever she does, I don't know.

00:42:08.012 --> 00:42:10.954
Divorces Kanye and sells makeup or lip

00:42:10.974 --> 00:42:13.016
filler or... I don't know.

00:42:13.215 --> 00:42:13.817
I don't know what she does.

00:42:14.916 --> 00:42:15.157
Again,

00:42:15.177 --> 00:42:17.418
this is a hard episode for me because

00:42:17.478 --> 00:42:22.362
I don't actually follow celebrities.

00:42:22.402 --> 00:42:23.402
But yeah,

00:42:23.422 --> 00:42:24.643
they might be good at a thing.

00:42:24.824 --> 00:42:25.864
Let them be good at the thing.

00:42:27.724 --> 00:42:29.505
I liked Aaron Rodgers talking about

00:42:29.565 --> 00:42:32.648
football.

00:42:32.688 --> 00:42:32.949
Not...

00:42:34.079 --> 00:42:34.820
COVID vaccines.

00:42:35.360 --> 00:42:37.081
I like Michael Jordan playing basketball

00:42:37.101 --> 00:42:38.922
and Michael Jordan owning a team went

00:42:39.043 --> 00:42:39.824
horribly wrong.

00:42:40.384 --> 00:42:40.603
Again,

00:42:40.945 --> 00:42:42.485
even I think within the same fields,

00:42:43.146 --> 00:42:48.351
that area of expertise is limited, right?

00:42:48.550 --> 00:42:50.773
It's not that we can know all things

00:42:50.833 --> 00:42:51.592
in a given field.

00:42:51.893 --> 00:42:53.394
It's usually like we have a particular

00:42:53.414 --> 00:42:55.215
skillset and if our knowledge base packs

00:42:55.235 --> 00:42:56.016
that skillset up,

00:42:56.396 --> 00:42:59.278
we can get really good at a thing.

00:42:59.360 --> 00:43:01.440
Exceptionally small numbers that people

00:43:01.460 --> 00:43:03.182
can get good at a number of things.

00:43:04.161 --> 00:43:05.581
Most of us are gonna have functional

00:43:05.621 --> 00:43:08.202
knowledge on a lot of things.

00:43:08.242 --> 00:43:09.043
We can cook,

00:43:09.563 --> 00:43:11.143
not good enough to open our own

00:43:11.204 --> 00:43:14.545
restaurant, right?

00:43:14.606 --> 00:43:17.686
So I think a lot of us would

00:43:17.706 --> 00:43:21.088
be happier people not following our

00:43:21.489 --> 00:43:23.050
celebrity's every take.

00:43:23.849 --> 00:43:25.971
I don't think we need to ask celebrities

00:43:25.990 --> 00:43:27.552
a lot of the questions they get asked.

00:43:28.032 --> 00:43:30.713
This isn't bury your head in the sand,

00:43:31.706 --> 00:43:33.487
And don't hold people accountable because,

00:43:33.527 --> 00:43:33.748
again,

00:43:33.807 --> 00:43:35.248
I think we should hold people accountable

00:43:35.288 --> 00:43:36.628
for having shitty opinions.

00:43:37.068 --> 00:43:40.228
I'm all for bringing back public shaming.

00:43:42.250 --> 00:43:43.050
But, yeah, I mean,

00:43:43.130 --> 00:43:44.490
this is a structural issue,

00:43:44.550 --> 00:43:45.590
not an individual one.

00:43:45.811 --> 00:43:47.831
To be critical of an individual celebrity

00:43:47.891 --> 00:43:49.192
does not get at the point that, like,

00:43:49.692 --> 00:43:51.693
we don't need to be having conversations

00:43:51.793 --> 00:43:54.713
about geopolitics with people who are not

00:43:55.253 --> 00:43:56.273
well informed on that.

00:43:59.510 --> 00:44:02.132
don't think like we don't even have that

00:44:02.172 --> 00:44:03.612
i don't think modern journalism really

00:44:03.652 --> 00:44:08.115
gets good at asking good questions i don't

00:44:08.135 --> 00:44:11.277
know if you've tried to follow any

00:44:11.318 --> 00:44:13.018
journalists lately even independent

00:44:13.059 --> 00:44:16.880
journalists again are like woeful on

00:44:17.280 --> 00:44:19.561
minding their own cognitive biases again

00:44:19.581 --> 00:44:21.222
that's the thing that i say regularly we

00:44:21.282 --> 00:44:23.204
all fail at even myself included who talks

00:44:23.224 --> 00:44:24.204
about it somewhat regularly

00:44:25.304 --> 00:44:26.206
I'm not saying you can avoid it.

00:44:26.226 --> 00:44:26.786
I'm just saying, like,

00:44:27.126 --> 00:44:28.347
there are people who are actively working

00:44:28.387 --> 00:44:29.387
against it and there are people who are

00:44:29.427 --> 00:44:31.028
not.

00:44:31.088 --> 00:44:32.230
So, again,

00:44:32.829 --> 00:44:36.672
to find someone who is an expert and

00:44:36.793 --> 00:44:39.014
has lived experience, has education,

00:44:40.295 --> 00:44:41.577
and has the skill set to do their

00:44:41.597 --> 00:44:42.637
thing really well, like, great,

00:44:42.677 --> 00:44:44.099
pay attention to that person in that

00:44:44.139 --> 00:44:46.380
thing.

00:44:46.440 --> 00:44:47.161
That's it.

00:44:48.824 --> 00:44:50.465
But the mechanism and why I said earlier,

00:44:50.505 --> 00:44:52.306
like I'd probably bring Marshall McLuhan

00:44:52.346 --> 00:44:54.527
up because again, like we are seeing,

00:44:54.626 --> 00:44:56.387
we see all of these things.

00:44:56.467 --> 00:44:59.608
Authenticity has been repackaged into not

00:44:59.648 --> 00:45:01.389
just as it filmed reality TV,

00:45:01.429 --> 00:45:02.411
but now we get to see them on

00:45:02.731 --> 00:45:03.550
Instagram live.

00:45:03.570 --> 00:45:04.632
We get to them at TikTok.

00:45:04.652 --> 00:45:06.952
We get to see them have their takes

00:45:06.992 --> 00:45:09.134
and their opinions on every topic ever.

00:45:09.213 --> 00:45:09.514
And like,

00:45:09.574 --> 00:45:11.454
that is a waste of our time.

00:45:12.876 --> 00:45:15.117
Go read a book by an actual historian.

00:45:15.197 --> 00:45:17.378
Don't listen to what Roger Waters has to

00:45:17.418 --> 00:45:17.617
say.

00:45:19.686 --> 00:45:21.998
go read a book by an actual historian

00:45:22.018 --> 00:45:24.007
while listening to Pink Floyd,

00:45:24.186 --> 00:45:24.911
if that's your jam.

00:45:28.903 --> 00:45:32.346
We don't need uninformed opinions on these

00:45:32.365 --> 00:45:32.985
things.

00:45:33.266 --> 00:45:38.889
It only serves to fill our own biases

00:45:39.610 --> 00:45:40.771
in that we say, oh,

00:45:40.891 --> 00:45:42.672
I like this person in this movie or

00:45:42.751 --> 00:45:44.532
in this show or in this song or

00:45:44.612 --> 00:45:45.233
on this team,

00:45:45.293 --> 00:45:46.514
and they said a thing that I agree

00:45:46.534 --> 00:45:47.894
with, so I like them more.

00:45:48.434 --> 00:45:49.815
That's just confirmation bias.

00:45:50.715 --> 00:45:52.197
And then we're disappointed and we're

00:45:52.217 --> 00:45:54.577
bummed out when somebody who's not us says

00:45:54.597 --> 00:45:55.778
something that we don't agree with.

00:45:58.271 --> 00:45:59.592
It's not coalition building.

00:46:00.092 --> 00:46:01.673
It veers towards purity testing,

00:46:01.713 --> 00:46:02.715
but also like, yeah,

00:46:02.755 --> 00:46:04.356
these people are not well-informed on

00:46:04.376 --> 00:46:06.639
these things.

00:46:06.679 --> 00:46:09.121
Find people who like are well-informed and

00:46:09.382 --> 00:46:11.463
learn and grow and have them in community,

00:46:11.503 --> 00:46:12.865
but it's okay to have them in part

00:46:12.885 --> 00:46:14.306
of your community and not other parts.

00:46:14.987 --> 00:46:16.769
I have sports friends and I have board

00:46:16.789 --> 00:46:19.773
game friends and one of those overlaps and

00:46:19.893 --> 00:46:20.873
generally they do not.

00:46:22.000 --> 00:46:23.840
I have therapy friends who are neither

00:46:23.900 --> 00:46:26.322
sport friends nor board game friends.

00:46:26.443 --> 00:46:29.304
I have nature friends who are hippies and

00:46:29.346 --> 00:46:32.208
like to be out in the woods and

00:46:32.228 --> 00:46:34.730
throw disc golfs into baskets.

00:46:36.990 --> 00:46:40.293
It's okay to have community that don't all

00:46:40.514 --> 00:46:41.333
do the same thing.

00:46:41.954 --> 00:46:43.056
Don't hang out with Nazis.

00:46:44.110 --> 00:46:44.389
Again,

00:46:44.469 --> 00:46:45.971
it's great to have standards in your

00:46:46.010 --> 00:46:48.012
coalition building and your community

00:46:48.032 --> 00:46:49.972
building, but like, yeah,

00:46:50.132 --> 00:46:51.554
celebrities aren't that they're not part

00:46:51.574 --> 00:46:52.153
of your community.

00:46:52.833 --> 00:46:54.735
You are exposed to them because your

00:46:54.795 --> 00:46:56.735
attention has been commoditized.

00:46:57.637 --> 00:46:59.737
And so the clicks and the views and

00:46:59.777 --> 00:47:03.820
the watches become part of a commodity

00:47:04.320 --> 00:47:06.581
that is different than community.

00:47:09.221 --> 00:47:11.521
So not only should we not put celebrities

00:47:11.561 --> 00:47:12.161
on pedestals,

00:47:12.222 --> 00:47:14.123
we do not want celebrities to be thought

00:47:14.163 --> 00:47:14.523
leaders.

00:47:15.123 --> 00:47:22.367
Literally anything.

00:47:22.807 --> 00:47:25.789
What a dumb timeline to be alive for.

00:47:27.090 --> 00:47:27.690
And also,

00:47:29.231 --> 00:47:31.251
what a great time to have lived through.

00:47:32.472 --> 00:47:34.632
Pepsi Blue and Dunkaroos, am I right?

00:47:36.094 --> 00:47:37.775
It's just a Glass Animals lyric, but...

00:47:38.971 --> 00:47:40.690
Dunkaroos were fine, not great,

00:47:40.771 --> 00:47:42.132
and I really didn't like Pepsi Blue,

00:47:42.251 --> 00:47:43.572
but I know people who did.

00:47:46.432 --> 00:47:47.693
Stop worshiping celebrities.

00:47:49.693 --> 00:47:51.755
Read books written by people who are

00:47:51.795 --> 00:47:53.494
actually really knowledgeable in the thing

00:47:53.514 --> 00:47:54.255
that they're writing about.

00:47:55.896 --> 00:47:57.436
Listen to podcasts if you must.

00:47:57.476 --> 00:47:59.056
That's a whole commoditized thing, too.

00:47:59.117 --> 00:48:00.237
I'm not even going to get into that

00:48:00.257 --> 00:48:02.358
because that's the medium that I'm

00:48:02.418 --> 00:48:03.398
operating on right now.

00:48:06.820 --> 00:48:08.623
don't make any money on it so you

00:48:08.663 --> 00:48:11.304
know there's your material analysis in a

00:48:11.344 --> 00:48:17.550
nutshell um let's see what's coming up i

00:48:17.570 --> 00:48:19.690
have one more solo episode and then we'll

00:48:19.710 --> 00:48:22.393
have some guests which are cool um

00:48:23.456 --> 00:48:25.257
an episode about cults coming up and an

00:48:25.297 --> 00:48:27.059
episode about community building coming up

00:48:27.199 --> 00:48:30.903
with a surprise special guest.

00:48:30.923 --> 00:48:31.525
That'll be cool.

00:48:31.565 --> 00:48:33.407
Lots of therapists lined up over the next

00:48:33.447 --> 00:48:34.728
couple of months to be guests.

00:48:34.748 --> 00:48:36.170
So we'll do a bit of this and

00:48:36.190 --> 00:48:36.751
a bit of that.

00:48:38.217 --> 00:48:40.637
be fun over on uh youtube unless you're

00:48:40.838 --> 00:48:44.159
already on youtube on my non-podcast uh

00:48:44.179 --> 00:48:45.960
i'm doing a little bit of an episodic

00:48:46.461 --> 00:48:49.422
series on divorce dad rock and how that

00:48:49.483 --> 00:48:51.985
created space for what is now uh the

00:48:52.005 --> 00:48:55.166
current manosphere to exist and uh is one

00:48:55.186 --> 00:48:56.887
of the more connected things i've probably

00:48:56.927 --> 00:48:58.947
ever recorded over on my youtube channel

00:48:59.648 --> 00:48:59.789
um

00:49:00.418 --> 00:49:01.117
which is a lot of fun.

00:49:01.197 --> 00:49:01.938
I just saw the Odyssey.

00:49:01.958 --> 00:49:03.679
So I'll have a review of that as

00:49:03.739 --> 00:49:04.039
well.

00:49:04.559 --> 00:49:06.619
Uh, yeah,

00:49:06.659 --> 00:49:09.141
that's what's going on in my world.

00:49:10.382 --> 00:49:10.541
Uh,

00:49:10.581 --> 00:49:13.182
the religious trauma survivor retreat is

00:49:13.282 --> 00:49:13.922
coming up.

00:49:13.983 --> 00:49:15.884
You can still donate to that if you

00:49:15.903 --> 00:49:17.364
would like to, uh,

00:49:17.505 --> 00:49:19.105
link in the show notes or on my

00:49:19.144 --> 00:49:19.606
website.

00:49:20.326 --> 00:49:20.385
Uh,

00:49:22.280 --> 00:49:22.800
which is cool.

00:49:23.161 --> 00:49:24.663
I've gotten a lot of donations,

00:49:24.682 --> 00:49:26.083
a lot of funding for that,

00:49:26.143 --> 00:49:27.724
but I will leave funding open for it.

00:49:28.746 --> 00:49:30.146
A couple of people are able to attend

00:49:30.186 --> 00:49:30.987
on full scholarship.

00:49:31.027 --> 00:49:32.429
Everybody has partial scholarship.

00:49:32.588 --> 00:49:34.010
And so if you'd like to donate,

00:49:34.590 --> 00:49:36.112
support survivors directly,

00:49:36.492 --> 00:49:37.313
head over to the website.

00:49:38.554 --> 00:49:42.016
In the meantime, take care of yourself.

00:49:42.257 --> 00:49:43.077
Take care of somebody else.

00:49:43.097 --> 00:49:45.000
We'll be back next week with another new

00:49:45.059 --> 00:49:46.201
episode.

00:49:46.221 --> 00:49:46.460
Peace.