Theology and Conflict Avoidance

We explore how church leaders sometimes misuse theology as a defense mechanism, particularly focusing on Romans 8:28 and how it can shut down necessary conversations instead of starting them.

• When we use scripture to end conversations rather than begin them, we're often avoiding uncomfortable feedback
• "Spiritual bypassing" occurs when we use spiritual language to avoid emotional pain, discomfort, or responsibility
• Quoting scripture instead of apologizing or addressing frustration shortcuts growth
• Real spiritual maturity confronts with grace, corrects with humility, and confesses with courage
• The most spiritually mature leaders listen, repent when needed, and change when necessary
• Pause before quoting scripture and ask if you're saying it to help or to escape
• Own your part before sharing scripture—don't spiritualize over your responsibility
• Be clear about decisions rather than hiding behind vague spiritual phrases
• Stay present and listen longer than you talk during difficult conversations

Get our free resource "True North," an epistle written for modern-day church leaders at chemistrystafffing.com/truenorth or reach out at podcast@chemistrystafffing.com.

Have questions or comments?  Send to podcast@chemistrystaffing.com

Be sure to subscribe to The Healthy Church Staff Podcast wherever you regularly listen to podcasts.

- - - - -

Is Your Church Hiring?
If your church is searching for a new staff member, reach out to Todd for a conversation on how he might be able to help.

Are You Looking for a New Ministry Role?
If you are open to a new church role in the next few months, add your free resume and profile at ChemistryStaffing.com.

Transcript

Romans 8:28: Love or Avoidance?

Speaker 1 0:08

Most church leaders absolutely love Romans 8.28 . You know all things work together for good , but what happens when we use it to end conversations instead of starting them ? Well , today we're going to be really honest . We're going to pull back the layers and explore how theology is sometimes misused as a defense mechanism . Yeah , it does . It is sometimes right , avoiding the very feedback and hard conversations that our teams really desperately need . If you've ever been in a meeting where conflict got spiritualized into silence or you've just been told to just trust God when you're really all you needed was some clarity , you're not alone . We're going to talk about it today . Hi there , my name is Todd Rhodes and I am one of the co-founders over at chemistrystaffingcom , and I'm your host right here on the Healthy Church Staff Podcast .

The Problem with Spiritual Bypassing

Speaker 1 1:00

Well , have you ever ever had someone quote a Bible verse in a staff meeting to just kind of shut down a conversation ? I mean , we used Romans 8.28 . It's great theology . It's a great example , though , but if you're dropping it in a performance review to dodge hard feedback , we got a problem . Okay , so let's talk about this .

Speaker 1 1:20

The temptation that we have yes , even church staff people and church leaders the temptation that we have to over spiritualize conflict because , let's be honest , conflict is uncomfortable and in the church world I often say , if you've been a church leader longer than five minutes , you've probably experienced some kind of conflict . We've developed this kind of conflict . We've developed this kind of weird reflex . As church leaders , many of us instead of addressing issues directly , we sometimes kind of wrap them up in scripture and prayer and hope that they just kind of float away and go bye-bye . You know , let's just pray about it . You know God works all things together for good . You know , maybe this is just , maybe this is just a season of pruning , but when we do that , what we're really saying is I don't really want to deal with this . That's not spiritual maturity , it's avoidance dressed in holiness . So what do we do ? What do we do when , for example , let's continue down with that Romans road , right With Romans 8.28, . God works all things together for good , that's true , but it's not a substitute for feedback .

Speaker 1 2:30

So when you use that verse after delivering hard news or instead of taking responsibility , it feels like spiritual gaslighting a little bit . It tells your team you know , don't feel bad , don't process , don't push back , just trust God's got this . That's not empowering , it's just kind of

What Real Spiritual Maturity Looks Like

Speaker 1 2:47

silencing . You need to have a little bit more conversation . So psychologists call this spiritual bypassing . Okay , it's when we use spiritual language to avoid emotional pain or discomfort or responsibility . We see this all the time when we talk with potential staff members for positions , when they tend to sometimes over-spiritualize and it's because they're trying to avoid either emotional pain or discomfort or responsibility and they just kind of put a spiritual verse or a spiritual jargon to it Not always , but sometimes , and we have pretty good sniffers so we sniff that out pretty quickly .

Speaker 1 3:28

But , yeah , the spiritual bypassing is a real thing and in churches this happens all the time . I mean , sometimes we quote scripture instead of apologizing . Yeah , sometimes we pray for someone instead of addressing their frustration . Yeah , sometimes we pray for someone instead of addressing their frustration . Sometimes we talk about God's plan instead of owning our own mistakes and , honestly , it feels safe . It feels safe , but it shortcuts growth . Okay , so let's take a look and I'll get you out on your way today with this last section on why real section , on what real spiritual maturity looks like . Okay , first of all , it doesn't dodge , it confronts , but it confronts with grace . It corrects , but it corrects with humility , and it confesses , and it confesses with courage .

Speaker 1 4:20

The most spiritually mature leaders that I know aren't the ones that are quoting verses in hard conversations . They're the ones who actually sit back , be quiet , listen , repent when they need to and change when it's necessary . And this doesn't mean perfection . Your team doesn't need perfect theology in a meeting , okay . They need real honesty and relational integrity . So how do you have those hard conversations without hiding behind God or scripture , because it's easy to spew those out . Man , we've been taught since a child . You know to internalize scripture . We just need to make sure that we're using it wisely .

Speaker 1 5:02

Here's how to avoid weaponizing

How to Stop Weaponizing Theology

Speaker 1 5:05

your theology . First of all , just pause . Pause before you quote scripture , ask yourself am I saying this to help or am I saying this to escape ? Before you share scripture , own your part . Don't spiritualize over your responsibility .

Speaker 1 5:23

And then be clear . Don't hide unclear decisions behind vague phrases like we're sensing a shift or God's just closing a door here . You have to stay present . You have to listen longer than you talk . And don't forget the prayer aspect of it either , not as a way out , but use it to reinforce connection , not to avoid discomfort .

Speaker 1 5:45

All right , so look , scripture's powerful , and I'm not saying that the Bible is not important . Don't hear me say that , because I'm not saying that . But sometimes and you know this , you know this to be true we use Scripture as a smokescreen . And when we use theology or Scripture to avoid hard conversations , we create confusion , we create resentment because we're shutting down communication and we create spiritual dissonance

Leadership: Honest Over Spiritual Appearance

Speaker 1 6:10

in our team . And God doesn't want your leadership to look spiritual . He wants you to be holy and humble and honest . But that doesn't mean that you have to look spiritual all the time . You need to stop and have the conversations . You know .

Speaker 1 6:23

If this kind of hit home , I'd love to hear your comments . Maybe you've got a story you'd like to tell me . I'd love to hear your stories . Maybe you want to push back and say , todd , I don't agree with you . That's fine . I'd love to hear from you too . You can reach me anytime . Podcast at chemistrystaffingcom Also had a great free resource that we offered last week on the podcast . It's called True North . It's an epistle written for a modern day , epistle written for church leaders . You can get that at chemistrystaffingcom . Slash true north absolutely free and again , reach out to me at podcast at chemistrystaffing and I will be here again tomorrow , right here on the Healthy Church Staff Podcast . Thanks so much for joining me and I'll talk to you again tomorrow .