Why Every Church Scandal Was Probably Years in the Making

In this introductory episode of the Healthy Church Staff Podcast's new series, host Todd Rhoades discusses leadership failures in churches, which often develop slowly over time rather than appearing suddenly. Based on his new book, "When the Church Falls," Rhoades explores the erosion of personal and spiritual health in church leaders, emphasizing the disconnect between outward success and inner deterioration. He highlights the culture of silence around addressing leaders' struggles and presents introspective questions and preventative measures to maintain alignment between leaders' private character and public persona.• Leadership failures in churches often result from long-term erosion rather than sudden actions.• Outward ministry success can mask the internal collapse of a leader's soul and character.• Church cultures often silence concerns, avoiding early intervention and labeling it as disloyalty.• The new book 'When the Church Falls' serves as a guide to preventing leadership collapses.• Introspective questions and preventative actions are suggested to safeguard leaders.

Have questions or comments?  Send to podcast@chemistrystaffing.com

Be sure to subscribe to The Healthy Church Staff Podcast wherever you regularly listen to podcasts.

- - - - -

Is Your Church Hiring?
If your church is searching for a new staff member, reach out to Todd for a conversation on how he might be able to help.

Are You Looking for a New Ministry Role?
If you are open to a new church role in the next few months, add your free resume and profile at ChemistryStaffing.com.

Transcript

Host Introduction And New Series

Why The Book Exists

The Cost Of Leadership Failure

Erosion Versus Lightning

Momentum Is Not Maturity

Silence, Culture, And Missed Questions

When Does Collapse Begin

Preventative Mindset And Guardrails

Self-Assessment Action Steps

Book, Assessment, And Contact Info

Closing Challenge And Hope

SPEAKER_00 0:08

We never saw this coming. That's what they always say. Here's the thing. They did. They always did. That headline you read last month to pass through got removed. That didn't start when the story dropped. It actually started years before with a slow compromise, most likely that nobody wanted to make. Hi there, my name's Todd Rhodes. I'm one of the co-founders over at Chemistrystaffing.com, and I'm your host right here every weekday for the Healthy Church Staff Podcast. Today we're going to start a new series that's based on a brand new book that I've just written and released today. It's called When the Church Falls, What We Can Learn from Leadership Collapses, and How to Prevent the Next One. And this is really one of the things that's driven my ministry really over the past 25 years. It came out of a very personal story that maybe I'll share sometime along the line during this next two-week series, during these next 10 episodes. But something happened to me uh good earlier earlier on in my career, where I had a really close friend that just had a horrible moral failure. And I was one that had to help clean up the mess. And ever since that time, I have really been introspective. Whenever I see another leader fall or a church failure or a leadership failure, I don't pile on, at least I don't think I do. I hope I don't. But what I do is take a look at that and wonder what happened there. I try to do a little bit of an autopsy on that situation. Because here's the truth: something happened there that devastated an individual. And when you're in ministry, it's not just that you're hurting yourself, it's that you hurt your family, you hurt your church. It has some really huge spiritual implications when leaders fall. And I always wonder what happened, and I always wonder what could have been done so that this didn't happen. And that's what this book is about, and that's what our series is going to be about right here on the Healthy Church Stat Podcast for the next couple of weeks. We're going to start today, and I'm going to start with this truth, okay? This is kind of the basis for our whole time together on this topic. Leadership failure happens more like erosion, not like lightning. We're all drawn to the drama. We're all drawn to the kind of explosive fall that came out of nowhere after 30 years of ministry, but it came out of nowhere. But the reality is the collapse rarely works that way. It's usually slow and quiet. It's usually even almost invisible. A leader maybe pulls back from real relationships and then the feedback stops flowing and they're tired and rest becomes a luxury. And nobody really asks how the pastor's doing anymore. I've seen this pattern over. And it's not like anybody wakes up as a pastor and says, today I'm going to do something really stupid. But over time, little decision by little decision, it happens. And here's the kicker of this whole thing. That erosion, when it's happening behind the scenes, it's hardly even noticeable sometimes. In fact, erosion often looks like success. Now listen, this is the dangerous part, okay? Here's the truth. A ministry can be growing, it can be growing exponentially while a leader's soul inside is shrinking. There can be bigger crowds and bigger budgets and more influence, and at the same time, at the same time, all while the person is at the center of just quietly unraveling personally and spiritually. We often mistake momentum for maturity, but let me tell you, momentum and maturity maturity, they are not the same thing. Barnes says that only one in five pastors rate their mental and emotional health as X. One in five. So the shell looks healthy, but the roots are just slowly and surely drying out. And we don't speak up because our culture won't let us. For crying out loud, it's the church. In healthy environments, people name their concerns early, but too often in the church and church cultures, they protect that leader instead of protecting the people. Staff members are gonna feel are going to fear being labeled as disloyal. Board members, they assume the best without asking all the hard questions. Matter of fact, when things on the chart are up and to the right, they don't ask the hard questions because they want to believe that everything's going great. And in some cultures, in a lot of cultures before the fall, if you look back, if you peel back the layers, any of that questioning that goes on that should naturally happen between maybe the board or the staff and that leader that fell, any questioning all of a sudden over you over the years, see what I said there? All of a sudden over the years, slowly questioning things just becomes looked on as disloyalty. And the result really is a slow drift, a slow drift toward collapse, and and nobody really is willing to stop it. So question is, Todd, when does it really begin? I don't know. I don't know, but I think it begins at a moment that moment when a leader stops paying attention to their soul, when their self-awareness gives way to their self-preservation. And I hear this a lot from pastors, when nobody feels safe enough to ask the hard questions, and it happens when a church mistakes momentum for maturity. Here's the bottom line. If you wait until there's a headline, you've waited too long, obviously. Ask yourself today, who really knows me? If you're a leader, this whole series, this whole book, When the Church Falls, is meant as a wake-up call to everybody that's in leadership. Even if if you're a senior pastor, you're an executive pastor, you're on a church staff. We've all probably, if you've been in ministry very long, worked with very closely or at least know somebody who's gone through some kind of moral failure or some kind of a fall from grace. And so this series is more of a preventative action for you. This book is more of a preventative action for you to put up those safeguards, to put up those guardrails, to identify the signs that you may be at risk or your church may be at risk. So here are some of the action steps as we get started on this first day. Just some introspective questions that I would love for you to ask yourself. First one is who really knows me? Who really knows me? And who has permission to challenge me? Take just five minutes this week and honestly evaluate this. Is your private character still aligned with your public persona? Or have over time have they gotten apart and are different from each other? So, as I mentioned, this is episode one of a special series. It's based on a brand new book that I wrote. It's called When the Church Falls. Now, if you want to go deeper, or if you're a board or a board member or a pastor who wants to assess your church's risk of falling into one of these patterns, you can go to the website when the churchfalls.com. When the churchfalls.com, you can grab a copy of the book there. And there's also I've developed a free assessment tool for pastors and church boards that you can take there. It's absolutely free. And if you help need help navigating any of this kind of thing, man, I'm your guy. Shoot me an email, podcast at chemistry staffing.com. Podcast at chemistry staffing.com. You can also reach out to me at my new website as well, at todd.church. Todd.church. All right, that's episode one of ten episodes in this series. I hope you'll join me again tomorrow. This is this is my heart, okay? I don't want to see, I don't want to see another pastor fall. I'm tired of reading the headlines. I'm tired of hearing the stories. I'm tired of churches having to pick up all the pieces. And this book and this series on this podcast is hopefully going to be something that is going to help you to first of all assess your risk. And second of all, make some corrective action if over time, silently, slowly, you're heading toward a fall. All right, I hope this has been helpful. Hope you'll join me again tomorrow right here on the Healthy Church Day.