Polity Matters
A podcast on the foundations of Presbyterian Church government. Hosted by Scott Edburg, Jared Nelson, and Ben Ratliff.
Polity Matters
133. One Big Beautiful Directory
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Ben, Scott, and Jared sit down with members of the committee tasked with revising the PCA’s Directory for Worship: Nate Shurden, Joel St. Clair, and Chad Van Dixhoorn.
Official Website: politymatters.org
Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee
Twitter/X: @PolityMatters
Facebook: Polity Matters Page
Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters. My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined as always by Scott Edberg and Jared Nelson. And uh you have joined us today, not to hear from us, but to hear from some of our uh guests that we have. And uh I'm really not gonna say much more than that. It feels weird to stop talking so soon, but I'm gonna let Jared start talking now and tell you what's happening.
SPEAKER_01Uh well, if people don't know what Ben is referring to, we have a three members of our uh directory committee that was tasked with uh revising uh the directory for worship in the PCA. And we're gonna hear a little bit from them. Uh first, I just wondered if you would, all three of you, uh we have three of you on here, uh, would mind uh introducing yourself and uh just telling us a little bit about where you are, where's your ministry, and how'd you get involved with uh or have some sort of an interest in studying uh worship? And maybe we can start first with uh uh the chairman, uh Nate, introducing yourself.
SPEAKER_05Happy to do so, Jared and Scott and Ben. Thank you for having us here on Polity Matters. It's a joy and a delight to be with you today. Yes, Nate Sherden here. I am the senior minister at Cornerstone Presbyterian Church in Franklin, Tennessee. Had the privilege of planting this congregation nearly 16 years ago now, and am very grateful for the opportunity to have that uh opportunity to serve so long here. Uh previously was uh at first Presbyterian Church in Jackson, Mississippi, and got the joy to serve uh there with Ligan Duncan for a number of years. And um from Mississippi, if that doesn't come through too strong in my accent, even here on the on the podcast, that is that is home for me. Um I am married to my wife Christy, uh almost 25 years coming up on it. We have five uh children, and uh so it's never a dull moment in the Sheridan household.
SPEAKER_00So grateful to be with you guys. My name is Joel St. Clair, and I'm the pastor of Mosaic Silver Spring. Uh, it's a PCA church in the Metro, DC area uh for the last uh 15 years, like Nate. It's a church that I planted and has particularized and sent out to plant and uh have labored here in the Potomac Presbytery now for a number of years. It's a place I love, it's a place our family loves, and it's a place God's called us uh to minister.
SPEAKER_01And then um our third member here, I'll have to make a little confession before we got on. I called them the Indiana Jones of the Presbyterian world.
SPEAKER_03Chad Van Dixorn, married to Emily. We have five kids, a few of whom are in the PCA, uh, as is my wife. I'm a minister in the Orthodox Presbyterian Church and uh delighted to often be at your assemblies uh giving greetings from our church to yours. Uh I currently work at the Reformed Theological Seminary in Charlotte.
SPEAKER_01All right, thank you. Well, I we have a few questions. Some of them will be kind of getting our legs and context for what we're talking about, and then we'll get into some of the work that you've done. Uh, but first, uh a little bit of the history. The PCA goes back to the 1970s and uh and the uh early days. There was work that was done to uh put together a uh form of government, rules for discipline, and then there was a start on the directory, but then uh there was this temporary statement that was put on there, and 50 years later, we still have a temporary statement. And there was a charge that was given to your uh committee to revise that directory um and try to present something uh that would be acceptable. But first, maybe we've had 50 years in the PCA uh without a directory. Uh, we're a little bit out of um practice with it. Uh, who wants to talk tell me what a directory is and how it might be different than what some other churches have, whether it's just you know spirit-led or prayer books or anything like that?
SPEAKER_05Well, I might just venture in there and then Chad and Joel, please uh please chime in. But uh a directory uh traditionally within the Reformed and Presbyterian world would seek to lay out biblical principles and foundations, uh biblical theological for worship, identifying ordinary elements for worship, giving pastoral directions for how worship should be practiced and conducted so that worship is um is governed by the word of God according to the constitution of that denomination. And so it's different, and you mentioned a prayer book earlier, Jared. It's different from a prayer book in that it doesn't give um uh fixed forms or prescribed prayer services, and it's not also uh just quote unquote spirit-led in the sense that there is uh no direction that's given. We believe that the Bibles um and worship should be regulated by the Word of God. And so this so the directory literally does give direction, um, helps to give um uh give wisdom um theologically and biblically and practically so that um our worship will be ordered and and edifying. So that's a quick summary.
SPEAKER_01Maybe Chad could tell us a little bit of how we ended up with a directory rather than a prayer book.
SPEAKER_03Yes, so so uh just to build on what Nate's saying, I mean, since the uh beginning of the Reformation, every Reformed church uh cared about doctrine and piety, government and worship. Every reformed church uh had uh a document covering each of those different uh facets of the Christian life. Um and uh the the the outlier was the Church of England, which uh did have directions for worship, but was you know pretty prescriptive about what that worship ought to look like. I mean the advantage of that was that if you were a new pastor and of course, or or or new to the reform faith, everything was just presented for you. You just kind of walked into a into the uh a Book of Common Prayer and everything was all laid out for you, sort of like going to a posh furniture store uh and uh just saying, I'll take one of those living rooms and you know, one of those bedrooms, and it's already for you. Uh the problems with that it came with the level of prescription and the prohibitions for anyone ministering or worshiping uh in any way deviating from that. So the Westminster Assembly, 100 years on, uh, decides it's better to offer directions for worship, kind of in line with what every other reformed church was doing. Um which is a little bit more Home Depot. Uh I I mean you you you know, all the parts are there, but you got to put them together yourself. Uh IKEA might be a better example, except it's actually pretty rich and wonderful in ways that IKEA is not necessarily rich and wonderful.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, I've I've thought of it sometimes as you have certain prescribed elements, but not forms, although a few forms, baptism, Lord's Supper, you know. Um but I also wonder, we we've been out of practice and having a directory. How is it different too than like a form of government or rules of discipline? Like what's how are we supposed to read it? How was how is it supposed to function within the church? I don't know if one of you want to jump in with that. We hadn't heard from Julie.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a great question. My hope would be that in some ways we could use the directory more frequently than maybe what we see some of the elements. So when you think about the government portions, then you think about things like session meetings or congregational meetings, when you think about discipline, uh it's so important and yet not as frequently used. Where when you think about the elements that are in the directory, that's every week. That's also during the week in family worship. Um, there are things that cover the whole of life that would be important not only for presbyteries or for sessions, um, not only for congregational meetings, which are rare, uh, but I would hope would build a connection in the directory for public worship to every member of a church, both its officers as well as its members, uh, to be able to engage and say, oh, this is reformed worship. This is what this looks like, um, and and that it would be helpful in that way.
SPEAKER_03Uh if if I were to say anything, anything extra, it's that both our directory for church government and a directory for worship or a book of church order and a directory for worship are are governed by an understanding of the sufficiency of scripture. Um and and so there's an important hermeneutical point of continuity between them as uh as the Westminster Confession of Faith points out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I'll I'll ask one question that'll kind of lead into where Ben is going. So um we had um the makings or at least some of the materials of uh an old directory uh for worship. Uh as you went through your revising process, uh what was what was your basis and and what resources did you use uh in order to look at, okay, how have directories functioned in other um denominations that are maybe using them currently or in the past? Uh what were some of your sources for looking at revising our our directory for worship?
SPEAKER_03So uh we we use the 1645 directory. Uh that's just such an important milestone in the history of English speaking Presbyterianism. Um I I read through the different Scottish directories. Um of course the the work done in 17 in the 1780s. Uh that's that's that's really key. So that's kind of the the backdrop to the PCA's directory. And and then you know there are just different iterations uh through history that we've referred to, uh, you know, 1894 and uh 1925, 1933, and then of course the uh the the PCA's own sort of evolving text. So these are major reference points um as are uh you know other other directories. But those I think those are the main ones that that that we were looking at.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, we also spent some time um just encouraging uh each of the members of the committee to read through the OPC directory and the ARP directory as current directories that are happening in sister denominations that are currently in force and in and in use for those to be um didactically a part of the the framework as we're beginning to think through. So there's some current work there, but that historical study that Chad just noted was the basis for much of what we did. Jared, you good?
SPEAKER_04I'm gonna edit this part out. So that's it.
SPEAKER_05Is there anything we're gonna keep? That's the question.
SPEAKER_04Well, that'll be yeah, we'll it'll be like a 15-minute episode at this point.
SPEAKER_05Um record, but 15 minutes.
SPEAKER_04Well, here, let me let me kind of jump off of what Jared was moving toward. Think thinking uh maybe take a few minutes and talk through sort of process and and revit the aim of revisions as well. So you guys said in the sort of in your introduction explanation, uh what did we call it? Background, that one of the stated goals uh was to include more biblical and confessional language, explicitly adding cross-references to scripture and the standards and the BCO. Um and I think you had a line in there that that got at this to some degree, and so I'm curious if y'all can elaborate on it. How how does the revised directory better illustrate that relationship between our worship and our doctrine and our piety and our discipline? So if it's if the intent is for it to fit better into our system, how how is it doing that as it's coming to us?
SPEAKER_05I think one way, one way, Dan, that that it seeks to do that, obviously the where you're pointing between the cross-references of the BCO and the scriptural text going back to the foundations of the Bible, regulating our practice for worship, and then having the citations in the BCO where the directory is making allusions to teaching that is in the Book of Church order, but it's not unpacking it at every point in the directory. And so when it makes an instruction or a guidance in the directory and cites the BCO, it's meaning for it to for the reader to go to that portion of the BCO to read that section of the BCO and help the principal teaching of it to inform that practice as it relates to the directory. And so thinking of it in that handbook style, I think, was part of what we hoped that this directory would do so that sessions and uh churches could use it didactically in the life of their congregation. Um, and so that we hope that this direct directory helps achieve that end and can be used in that purpose in local congregations.
SPEAKER_00I'll just add that if we felt like there was something within the BCO that already made explicit guidance, then we tried not to duplicate. So as we thought about the directory of public worship, we didn't feel like we had to say everything again. Uh, part of the process is taking what existed and then saying, um, how do we revise this in a way that sits well, not only with the current structure of the BCO, but in connection to our standards and uh scripture, of course, uh, thinking of our whole constitution and how it shapes the piety of the church.
SPEAKER_04It's a very, very like un-Presbyan thing to not say it over and over again. I don't understand that. Especially anti-PCA General Assembly, man. Uh that is true. That'll be novel for a lot of people. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. What's the old rule of like, you know, everything has been said, just not everybody's gotten to say it yet?
SPEAKER_04Um, that's right.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. We tried to avoid that a little bit.
SPEAKER_04Um you talked in another spot in the sort of some of this preliminary uh writing that you were seeking to balance between observing God's word and rejoicing in the the liberty that Christ has granted to the church. Um and so obviously what we're talking about, right, is is the on the one side would be overbearing prescription. And and you know, we kind of have talked about this a little bit already. But then on the other end would be just unhelpful abandonment of reformed worship. So so we're not trying to just have, you know, a book of forms, but we're also not just sort of letting loose. Um how do you navigate that balance? And I don't know, maybe maybe I can ask you all to give us some examples perhaps of where you navigated that balance and and how it kind of played out in your in your work.
SPEAKER_03So lots of lots of examples are possible. I don't I don't think we thought we were trying to balance what God word got what God's word teaches and uh sort of celebrate Christian freedoms. We think that God's word teaches us to celebrate the freedoms we have as as well as to uh make sure that we're including um uh the the biblical elements of of worship and and thoughtfully thinking through the the forms and circumstances uh that attach themselves to them. So um but but when we're thinking uh, for example, about how long a prayer should be, how many different kinds of prayer should be in a service, what should be the content of those prayers, how many hymns or or or psalms are are you gonna sing, um, how much scripture are you going to read? These are all uh examples um of of areas where where we want to say each one of these elements is important, uh they all need to be held in a happy balance, and we don't want to prescribe exactly what what's to be done in each each worship service. So those those that's sort of those are easy examples uh to cite, but they're also really important ones. They capture something important about the history of the reformed faith as it recognizes what's inviolable uh and what's variable.
SPEAKER_05And I think just to underscore what what Chad noted there, that is that is what a directory does as opposed to what a fixed form or the lack of direction might be given in another denominational format is is to let the word of God speak clearly and plainly and bind our belief and practice. And then in those areas where there is um where the scripture is either um silent uh on or matters of Adi Afra or circumstances related to worship, we might be able to give um good wisdom and directions, the perhaps or the mays associated with that in order to give guidance, but not to bind consciences uh in those places and recognize that different different contexts, different times may be better expressed in different ways. And sometimes local write local sessions and local context can can read what is needed better in those moments. And so not to traipse too much um over those, um, over what's been rightfully given to that that local context. So uh we hope it we hope we struck at least a road where that is um where where both of those things are balanced.
SPEAKER_03And those kinds of principles are already articulated in the preface to the 1645 directory, they're they're reiterated again in the 1789 directory, uh, and you can hear echoes of it uh in the current PCA directory as well.
SPEAKER_00That's right. There was a self-awareness with our language in the directory. Uh so the use of the word shall uh versus the use of the word should versus the use of the word may. And and I would say that the committee was self-aware as we employed those words and some of the conversations taking place about how do we uh weigh out how to interpret and then apply God's word in the directory of public worship, and the use of those words were reflective of the consensus of the committee on on how the spot should unfold. So I think that's just important. We don't acknowledge that per se in the document itself, that we didn't want to add um uh you know a very lengthy explanation for how we went about the process, but a podcast like Polity Matters gives us the the perfect opportunity, right, to highlight right here is some of how this all unfolded.
SPEAKER_03Yes. And so to to pile on again, because I I I like this, it just jogs another jogs another memory. Um I oh, I thought it jogged memory, but that memory's just gone here. I had I had a great follow-up to Joel's comment that's just evaporated, terrifying this early in the day.
SPEAKER_05That was gonna be a jewel, I know it.
SPEAKER_04You guys had a line in in the the beginning of your report that I loved. The current directory offers some instruction with a frown that a revised directory could communicate better with a smile. Thus the rewritten directory presents biblical indicatives that lie beneath biblical imperatives, thereby highlighting truths about God and his gospel that inform the manner in which we worship. Um can can y'all and I know that we're sort of we're sort of touching on on the same things several times, but I just I I think it's helpful for folks who are listening. And uh we're we're such big fans, I think, of this project that we we want to give as much chance to promo as we can. Can you talk some about what it was like to move from frowns to smiles? Joel, why are you laughing?
SPEAKER_00I don't understand I did not author the moves from frowns to smiles, but I love it. And uh maybe a maybe a great um illustration of this. Uh a lot of you have gone to the pool, maybe you've taken your kids to the pool. There's often a giant sign uh with large red lettering that says, here's the 10 things you may not do at this pool. Do not do these things. And and if you were taking your kids to the pool and all you talked about was the giant sign of the things that you don't do, uh I I think they're so much more involved with what's going to happen at the pool. So those things are important, no doubt, but that's not it, right? And and and uh so when I think about the opportunity to give um a directory of public worship, I I think about not only the important guidelines that need to be in place uh uh for the church, but I think about how worship fits within scripture uh to encourage, uh to enliven, to give spiritual vitality to God's people in the world in which we now live. And so to me, the directory that we wrote was trying to capture some of that bigger picture of not only here's the things don't do these things, but also here's why God has given us worship uh as his people, and here are the elements uh of worship that we can celebrate in regularly as a reformed church. And and that was incredibly encouraging for the committee, I think, to um think, okay, we've put it this way. Is there more to be said um here? And and can something be said that uh are we missing a component of where that's uh where scripture is painting that broader picture uh to enliven God's people, is there a component of that that can be grabbed onto and include it in the directory that isn't in the current uh directory? Uh and that process was uh an encouragement to me, uh meeting in and meeting out.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Yeah. I just absolutely agree with that. I think part of our, or I would say even central to our aim in the revisions that are presented is to lift high the loftiness of the call of worship, of what worship is as the as the head and chief calling of the church, and and that it should uh be um as we reflect on it and speak about it, it should lift the sensibilities of pastors and elders and even congregation members as they engage about a high view of who God is, the supremacy and importance of who he is and the work of worship, and for our prose and guidance and direction related to that in the directory to have that effect so that it didn't have just the um the the the big red sign that uh joel was alluding to earlier where we're reading uh reading it to um uh to as a stop action or to just a just a do injunction but um but to actually catch the spirit of of the gift of worship and the blessing of worship to be in the presence of Almighty God and our mediator the Lord Jesus Christ and being indwelt by his spirit and that something of that um that incredible privilege comes through in the language of of the directory and and and that's been one of the things in terms of feedback even from folks who have um read the directory and engaged that has um has encouraged me so far is they've picked up on that thread of the distinctiveness and the uniqueness of the tone and its expression that it has almost been devotional uh in order to read through and and uh that's very close to what our our hope and our aim was in in pinning it and and that's that that was never intended as a scathing denunciation of the previous directory I mean the the previous directory does speak sometimes about the duty and privilege and the duty and privilege I mean there's an understanding that that worship's a wonderful thing.
SPEAKER_03But but there were times when um when that just a little bit more description of what we're doing, a little bit more biblical language um uh a a a a slightly more exalted tone uh can give a reader more of a sense of that privilege um than than the current directory was communicating as as we thought.
SPEAKER_01I would just give a positive uh I'm not on the committee but I I would give a positive in in some of the language uh one that stuck out to me was uh for 47 uh two uh Christian worship perfects the saints and points the world to Christ through worship on the Lord's day we are formed and prepared for love and service every day above all else our worship aims to God's glory for we were created and redeemed to worship him alone as the only true God. Thus every service of worship is an act of love to our Lord where we find our joy and his pleasure I I think that's a good positive definition of what's going on in fact that not only are we bringing a sacrifice of praise but we're being formed too so I appreciated some of that positive language.
SPEAKER_04Yeah that'll make you want the Lord's Day to come soon. That's good yes indeed Jared I've got another question I'm gonna throw at him but I think it'll transition us uh towards some of your your things coming up next um by the way for listeners Scott is here we're just not letting him talk uh this is totally here I'm just you can't put me in charge of these sorts of things they'll be cutting out whatever I ask and so I'm just enjoying the ride gentlemen uh you're and and maybe also for listeners let me preface this again you know the purpose of our conversation today was not to talk about all the details in the actual uh proposed uh new language people can read and they should go read um and they'll be blessed we we were trying to kind of talk about the bigger picture some of the intentions and and processes so in that vein y'all's recommendation um is either that we adopt it or re recommit it back to the committee which I I appreciate in so many ways um and I I like this word you use some some friends of mine used this that uh with you um let's see uh including multiple meetings for study discovery discussion and principled compromise that's that phrase that I like principled compromise uh maybe maybe that's a helpful phrase uh for me to ask about what should commissioners uh consider when they evaluate y'all's recommendation right so there's no amendments somebody's gonna say right we can we can't fit we can't do anything to this on the floor and we can't just you know how how are y'all gonna encourage folks as as you bring this recommendation and what should folks think about?
SPEAKER_00Yeah I I think among committee members uh I don't think there's a single person that got all of the wording that they wanted or that crafted every chapter in exactly how they would have desired like I don't think a single person. There were uh multiple conversations of the principled compromise that it's referencing uh and and uh you know no one lost all of those conversations but certainly no one won all those conversations and I I think that's for two reasons. I I think one uh was that Nate did a fantastic job leading and uh and so I just want to praise Nate's leadership uh with the tone that he set and his own modeling of not trying to strong uh strong arm the committee not trying to uh throw down his title as convener and then chairman uh but instead uh really modeling for us okay uh let's engage together in love and try to work through this I think it also is a testament to Kevin de Young's choice for the membership of the committee um so if uh the the result here of a unanimous revision uh I I think is largely down to Kevin de Young's choices for who staffed the committee it wasn't driven by large names it wasn't driven by celebrity but it was driven by people who would come and show up and put in the work and so uh okay now that we have that no one no one got what they wanted if somebody's reading this bin and they show up and they say well this doesn't say what I want then they should feel like they're in great company because that's how every single member of the committee feels so so they they would have had that feeling whether they were reading it for the first time in the commissioner's handbook or whether they had been in all of the in-person and video conference meetings and debating with us, they wouldn't have got what they wanted. I can give them my word that that wouldn't have happened. And so when we think through this idea of uh do I get what I want so if you read this and you think well we should have amendments because I want to change this one part I I think first understands that we were crafting not by one individual's particular interpretations of what should be done but we were interpreting by what would be helpful to the whole church and then what would be approved in our estimation by two thirds of the presbyteries. And so at the end of the day if if uh a reader of this wants to see a constitutional directory of public worship then when they consider how badly they want a revision with our first recommendation of amendments they should ask themselves not first about the time that would take to go chapter by chapter. By the way they did chapter by chapter for the BCO originally it took them three years I think to work through chapter by chapter the BCO starting point which is maybe why they gave up on the Directory of Public Worship Jarrett because they were like man this is taking another seven years and we got lots of other things as a denomination to do.
SPEAKER_05I'm not sure right um but I would encourage them to think um hey you're in good company but how confident am I that the amendment or change that I want is going to get 67% not just of the assembly but of the presbyteries and to the extent that you're confident of that then you should ask yourself a second question can this wait a couple years and I'll move it then because that's going to be your option uh if it becomes constitutional and so I I would encourage brothers to consider uh the actions of the 52nd assembly to uh start this committee all of the hours that have been put in which we tried to capture and and then this idea of uh taking this step with a collective and cohesive work before trying to one-shot amend this uh in assembly in a way that will have downstream effects in the subsequent year that's my take that's a good that's a good word uh from joel and I appreciate those those kind comments as well let me just say that the ineptness of the leader and the chairman of this committee was supported by these two brothers and many others very graciously they came alongside picking up pieces all along the way and and uh sometimes what makes a a a chairman is those who help him lead and that is very much the case in in the context of this of this team I would encourage I would say those who are reading the directory and evaluating it to Joel's point we all had compromises that were made there was language that was wrestled with and wrangled over and slept on and and matters that were tabled and come back to and um this committee worked really hard um uh read reread continued to edit wordsmith we peer reviewed with with um with with leaders and and members across the PCA some pre-reading to help us see how they would understand and think through some of the languages being suggested um so as we as we worked through it uh we we recognized that we agreed in the in the broadness of the of the committee that Kevin de young chose and it was their sensibilities were were as broad as the PCA is in terms of its practice on these matters um the Lord brought us together and there was a conviction that this is a good endeavor that the Lord has has given us too and I will say the spirit in our in the room as we gathered was one of camaraderie of joy of fellowship. In fact one of the brothers who I was we we got to the end of this at work at least to the point where we're going to recommend it to the 54th General Assembly in Louisville and said well if this actually goes through and it winds up you know passing the biggest disappointment is going to be that we're not going to be getting back together to be working on this together again. So that really was I feel like I have seven, eight new friends in the work of ministry and the PCA through this endeavor. And I'll just say um when I was first named uh in this process I would get a phone call from a friend who'd say hey uh congratulations for being on this committee and then I'd get another phone call that said hey condolences for being on this committee um because there was um there was great concern that this uh committee would be uh one that could be fracturing with our work would be very difficult and though it was challenging that it was serious there was lots of study and deliberation I believe this committee represents the PCA and the principal compromise of the kind of work we want to be about as brothers um in this denomination and and so as you look at it um I think that's one of the things you want to think keep in mind that um that is you're gonna see little things that each one of us disagree with or wouldn't want to say it a little bit either tighter or looser in one way, shape or form. We we realized that for the greater good of the PCA and for the work of where it is we are as a denomination, we believe that this principled compromise document will be helpful to the health and the peace and the purity of the PCA going forward and not the final word on the subject but an incredibly um foundational starting place for us to continue to build from in the days to come yeah to kind of follow up on that I I feel like you've talked a little bit about your experience uh on the committee so have a little bit of a feel for that uh but um there of course when people look at your product there there's gonna be some objections um some people you're never going to please um but I I wonder if you might have something that you would say to a couple or three um objections that may be out there and and what your case is to them.
SPEAKER_01So first I I think you're gonna have people both on the the looser and stricter ends that have objections what what first would you say to those who uh have kind of maybe a a reaction to a directory that says uh I I think this will narrow us uh this will restrict my liberty um I I'm I I'm not sure about having a directory how would you answer that as an objection that somebody might have uh to uh having a directory at all so um I I think one of the things that the committee uh it came together on and there was a coming together of the minds as we met and talked is that there is such a thing as reformed worship um and uh for a reformed church not to offer uh a ruling elder a member a new minister existing ministers any guidance on what reformed worship can look like if we offer no instruction or inspiration um we we're really sort of underselling what the reformed faith is I mean the reformation is not just the recovery of the gospel it was self-consciously at least amongst especially amongst the reformed a recovery of of worship Christian worship understood according to reform principles and so um yeah we it's actually really important to offer guidance at the same time uh and the other brothers can speak to this we were very mindful of the fact that the history of the reformed faith as is evident in revisions of the directory as is evident in discussions at the Westminster Assembly evidences a diversity from from the beginning about issues regarding leading in worship um uh what's to be emphasized you know how we're to understand different forms in which the word is to be read uh debates over whether a benediction is a proclamation or a prayer and so on and so forth.
SPEAKER_03So there's there's a long history of discussion that we attempted to make ourselves familiar with um and uh so so we're we're reflecting the fact that there is reform worship and there's variants within the reform world we we think a directory a good one reflects both of those things.
SPEAKER_00My sense is that um St. Louis is different from Cleveland Mississippi which is different from Western Pennsylvania and different from Nashville, Tennessee and Charlotte, North Carolina and California and New York and Western and eastern Canada and that uh when I think about what it would look like to take those uh elements of reformed worship and then work those out um I I feel like if I'm pressed to say I know what worship should look like uh to the T in all of those places um or I trust sessions uh who have been uh called by God and elected by congregations to lead together um to further fill out the specific details of the elements of the directory for public worship. I gotta lean toward trusting sessions in all of those places and and doing that knowing it's it's very likely some of these things may be different than the way I may personally prefer it, but still well within the history and tradition of reform worship and then certainly well within the guidelines that we have as worships regulated by scripture. And so if that's the case, um it, you know, I think I would say trust church sessions who, you know, as we're told in BCO 12 are ultimately overseen and responsible for as a court how worship unfolds in a given place, then to trust that and to resist the sense that I know best for uh now the size of the PCA in its varying contexts, uh cultures and places.
SPEAKER_01So yeah it seems uh with the the language of principled compromise, the the principled would be the minimum scriptural requirements this is what you should do. And then the compromise would be preference, taste, cultural uh things that are there. And so um I I do think uh uh we've talked about it before on the show 125e in the BCO already says that you the session should be using uh the directory and uh so it would be good if we had an updated one uh for those sessions to to to be using so dare say a constitutional one yeah I mean one that we all actually do agree on yeah so it's it's principled in that the the kind of the the essential component parts are there but then the principles are also seen in a degree of vision casting you know this must be there but then you can also run a directory in such a way as to make people want more than what the minimum is and and so so we weren't simply saying we weren't we were identifying uh you know these are essential component parts of a worship service but we're also saying and and and look at what it can be um and and we hope that people coming from a variety of traditions or backgrounds will read that and say yeah that that's actually beautiful that would honor God that would edify God's people we want we want more of this well that's that's to the objection of the person who may have some concerns about it being uh too get you know you want something looser afraid it might get you too strict um how would you answer on the other end there might be some people who say you know this this constitutional directory it's too broad gives too much latitude uh maybe they have a few areas where they say well this should be principle and not um not preference or or taste or something like that and there's a few areas in which it seems that there's just silence and certain parts of worship being led um whether that be um there's kind of a uh a direction that it's not appropriate for everybody but telling sessions this is your duty to uh in terms of who's doing prayer and reading of scripture how would you answer somebody that might have some objections about uh this is the uh the revised uh directory is uh too broad or gives too much latitude how would you answer somebody who has those concerns well you know I'm in the curious position of being an OPC minister who as a professor teaches PCA church polity uh which is great fun by the way um and you know one of the striking things about the current situation in the PCA is that the status quo articulates some commitments regarding marriage, the Lord's supper and baptism but right now a PCA minister, I mean I'm gonna just make this I'm gonna exaggerate the case in order to make the point doesn't need to be committed to singing or reading or preaching.
SPEAKER_03I mean of course you have to be they're called teaching elders and so on but you know when you have a directory that's merely that that's in almost entirely in the wisdom bucket with almost nothing in the the shell and should bucket um you have a very very unique situation in the history of the reform faith. So I I I do come at this with the perspective of saying almost anything is a lot more clarity than pious advice which is where the from an outsider where the PCA looks like it is now for most things.
SPEAKER_05Yeah I I would just agree with that as well that was part of the objective even of this committee of recognizing that I think the PCA and Chad you might be able to correct me uh on this historically but I I think one way in which we have one which one way in which we are unique among uh reformed and Presbyterian denominations I think in history is not having a constitutional directory for public worship and and when you step back and simply look at that reality um that that should strike us as odd that that that this this this primary this highest calling this distinguishing mark of of the work of the church is something of which we do not have any particular statement um that is constitutional and giving shape and form to our corporate gatherings and worship that seems unusual and and odd and it indeed is historically and and so I I you know though I deeply uh sympathize there are there are areas and I think I think Joel might have this and Chad may have this and and others on the there are some areas where I'd go man I would probably say that a little tighter so I would feel that with some of our folks who say there's not there's too much latitude here. But as I think as I think through it um you know we're trying to build a fence uh around a um um around so to speak a playground um uh that that hasn't had one uh before and and to recognize that okay the fence is not perfect there's some ways in which I'd like to see it a little tighter but but having a fence is is better than the one that we we don't have um right now and and to say that um everything is um is As it ought to be. And I, you know, we say in the opening comments that this is not a perfect document. We don't anticipate this, you know, for for um for for the future never being touched or tampered with. That is not the PCA way. That's not how this functions. Um, and and so this seems to be where um there may be some tightening, there may be some clarifying, there may be some other things that will be done that the assembly will decide needs to be done in the future. But this is a, we think, a really wonderfully um um principled compromise place to start with regards to establishing that that fence. And um, and I think not having had that for 50 uh years plus in the air in the PCA, um that there are some challenges that we face in establishing that now. Um, you know, my wife and I were talking the other night about um uh about a disciplinary matter with one of our children and just recognizing that, you know, had we spotted that a few years ago, it would have been a little easier than it is now, a few years later, because some habits have been developed, some sensibilities and traditions have developed that maybe aren't as aren't as healthy as we wish that they were, and there's gonna be some challenges establishing that now. And I do sense that that is gonna be part of the case, part of the case here. But recognizing that at least getting to the point where we are we have something in place is maybe a start from which we can build from.
SPEAKER_02I know we don't want to get too far into the weeds of the language of the directory. There's been a a little hoopla, though, on Twitter concerning 50-2 and then 52-3 on reading and praying publicly. Uh the latter part of it saying if the minister or elders are not reading, the session should give careful thought on the suit to the suitability of anyone who is to read a part of worship. And then the same in 52-3 for prayer. Um, some are concerned that I think the PCA is broadening its current practice. And so I would just pose to you three guys uh what was the intent behind uh the language there? If you can dive into that a little. I think it perhaps could help uh uh just because I think giving better clarity on the committee's thinking would help us better understand those provisions.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so um that there's there's five different positions in the PCA uh when it comes to leading, there's the uh only the minister, there's the only the elders, only officers, uh, only men, uh, and only members. Although there's some churches that also have musical accompaniment by uh non-members, uh even professionals who might not be Christians, but just in terms of like leading, cutting out accompanying at the moment here, um, you you've got five groups, and as you kind of move down that list, you have more people who are encouraged to participate in worship. But each of these five positions is actually exclusive of the others. You know, if you're in the middle and you're an officer's only person, you think that the ministers only or the elders only positions are too uh restrictive, and you think that the other two positions are actually too expansive. Um so we have, you have uh in the PCI five different five different sort of positions. I won't laugh anymore. Um and maybe we do in the OPC too. Um but uh uh with with those five different views, um uh if you're gonna have a directory at all, there needs to be some attempt to cast a vision um uh to educate, to inspire. But but then also to um uh to to offer some kind of guidance for each of those positions. And so uh in uh you know 1645, it's ministers and seminary students, basically, or ministers and expectants. 1789. Um again, there's there's a provision for um uh for for those training for the ministry, but it's it's kind of ministers and teachers. And that that's the norm until about 1894 when it's ministers or or some authorized person. And then the authorized person language uh exists for a century or uh about, and then the PCA current directory just says, or any other person, or something like that. Um so we're actually trying to bring us back to something that's a little bit more thoughtful and organized, like the idea that someone should be approved by a session. That that that's that's important. Um uh that the person ought to have gifts. Uh that that person is ordinarily the minister who is gifted and trained. That that that that reading the word is part of the ministry of the word is an assumption of our committee, and it's an assumption that's you know been significantly lost. This is this is one aspect of the ministry of the word. Um at the same time, you know, you could go back to the Westminster Assembly, you've got people there who think that the minister should read if no one else is available, uh that that that officers can read, that elders can read. You've got a bunch of different positions. I think maybe all of these positions are are held at the Westminster Assembly. Um somehow, uh amazingly, between 1644 and 1645, they they do actually land on ministers, which kind of defies all the previous debate. Um, but there's there's variance there. Um and uh that I guess that variance kind of re-emerges and gets incorporated to some extent in the late 19th century into the 20th century. And we're just trying to say, look, let's uh let's recognize these differences, but let's promote a normative vision, let's offer guidance. Um and in a sense, it's it's significantly more robust, it gives much more guidance than the current sort of pious advice directory of the PCA has. Um so that's my opening thought or ramble.
SPEAKER_05That's helpful, Chad. I think that that could not say it clearer or echo it more strongly, but that is the spirit of the committee, even as we deliberated over this matter. And this, as you might imagine, was a subject that we visited and revisited and revisited and and wordsmiffed and wordsmithed on. And um and and Chad very helpfully just captured the spirit of our meetings and engagement together and what we hope that um will be received in the way that it was intended, um, as as being in being consistent uh with what has been handed down really since um I guess it was it was in that you know the the the the 1890s, uh I guess when we start seeing that that shift of of standing in that um tradition and and even being a little more clarifying by laying this at the feet of sessions to take seriously the the the leadership role of reading in the context of worship. So hopefully that comes through clear.
SPEAKER_03Can I say some uh what one more thing? And I I'm not quite sure how to say this well, so I'll say it badly, which is unfortunate. I wish my best was much better, but here we go. I I think that um for those myself included who think that a a ministry of word and prayer is really important for the church, um, and that our ministers ought to be really capable both in private and public prayer and very diligent in their reading of the scriptures, not just their teaching of the scriptures. You you don't get there by legislating that, you you get there by praying about it, by promoting these ideas through thoughtful reading and education. Um and and then you get there by practice. And in churches where people have heard a pastor read the scriptures with such power that you know the the hair goes up on the back of their neck, they're profoundly moved. That's the best sales pitch for a minister to be reading scripture. When when ministers are not reading well, it will not be clear to anyone as to why the minister should be reading. It'll just look like clericalism. If he insists on praying and reading, and he's and he's not bringing any excellence to the table. Um so that that just sounds really grumpy, and sometimes I do, but I I really think that modeling is better than legislating. And and if a whole church begins to see, wow, we have we have people who just give their life to the reading of scripture, to prayer, to leading. They do it so well. We want them to do it. If someone later wants to make some kind of a change, that change is going to be more plausible in a church where people are pre-persuaded. Um otherwise, it's just gonna look heavy-handed. Um I'm bound to repeat myself. I'll stop there.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, and I I thought it was it was interesting in looking at some other uh NAPARC directories. Some are more explicit on this, but then I was trying to find in the ARP section there what they have to say about it. They don't even talk about it at all. And it seems like it it's anybody. So it is interesting just to say it's not anybody in the session needs to really consider this. And I I thought that reading through uh there's a lot of things that say this should be the case. And you can think, well, if you say shall, you're gonna have to name every single exception, but the should is very helpful to be a didactic tool and to say this is this is our general principles. And that's why even with the diversity, all of our worships have something that looks the same, right? I mean, it may be different going from one PCA church to another, but you go to a Baptist or a Pentecostal church and you say, actually, I think reform worship has a lot more in common with those uh in the midst of that diversity, too. So I guess I'm I'm doing a little bit of uh uh editorializing here. I thought you um there there's some good moves that went there, and I think this would be a great didactic tool if people are using this in Sunday schools uh to try to teach um reform worship. When we did a unit on reform worship, we looked at the old directory and we're like, I don't know if that's the best thing, but if we would have had this, we would have used, uh I think we would use this. But um I wonder, uh kind of in thinking about what we talked about, uh, are there anything final words, final thoughts, uh final takes that that you want to have uh that you'd want to leave with somebody that you want them to know uh before General Assembly comes up about the directory, about the process, or uh or anything along those lines?
SPEAKER_03It's so both Nate and Joel have spoke about the the unity of the committee, and they've also mentioned that you know nobody got everything they wanted. I you know, as a non-voting uh member advisor, non-voting advisor to the committee, um watching these brothers uh uh come to the point where everybody could say, we we actually like the whole. We're encouraged. We we can't, we almost could not believe the unity that God brought to this committee. That entailed a lot of prayer. Nate sent out uh things that he asked us to pray about and pray on uh ahead of time, so helpful. Um it in it involved uh happy uh uh Christian fellowship. Um but but we ourselves think that the Lord really um blessed us, at least the bunch of us, diverse as we were, uh, were able to come to a the same position um and and say, yeah, we like this. Now now where where am I going with this? Um anytime someone is thinking about that they're approaching a confessional text or an ecclesiastical text for the first time, the the instinct is to say, Oh, I you know, oh, I like how that said, oh, I wouldn't have said it that way. And then at some point they have to kind of check themselves and say, what I'm really asking is um not would I have said it this way, but does this does this ablely, maybe even adequately, express what God's Word teaches? Um I mean, Westminster Divines, sorry, last last mention, you know, debated phrase by phrase, went tooth and nail over lines, paragraphs, sentences, proof text, and then uh they never subscribed to it. Uh that's this is a historical anachronism, but but there came a point when they said, are we ready to send this to parliament? And that's done by an overwhelming vote by people who you know you know, kind of argued and prayed their way the whole way through. That's what we that's what this committee is now delivering to the assembly. And the assembly's uh posture, I hope, will be. Does this is this is not is this the directory that we dream about, um big beautiful directory, but but is it is is it is the is it something that that is commensurate with the word of God?
SPEAKER_05That's helpful. Chad, one big beautiful directory. I'm gonna use that line again somewhere, I think. Don't know where, don't know when, but it's gonna come out.
SPEAKER_04I usually take titles for episodes from lines that have been said in it. And Chad has given me like five already since we started.
SPEAKER_05So I believe there's you're gonna get five more in the next five minutes, I'm sure. But um no, I what I just again to underscore Chad's um uh you know point there, I I do think the um that that is there there the adequate, the able to communicate what the Bible teaches and what the reformed faith advances, and and can we um can we get behind uh this and in and promote this? Do we see this as having a formatively positive impact upon the life and health and peace and purity of the of the PCA? And we, as a committee to a man, feel that to be the case and and and with zeal and with encouragement um um hand it to the assembly for its consideration. Now, I think we all we all would jokingly uh say that this may be the only good work that this directory does may have been in our hearts in the committee. Uh, you know, that may be that may be the Lord's mission, and and that's where this stops is and uh and you know we we will entrust that to his kind providence through however he guides and directs. But we we do we did sense uh you know, this side of being mystical about the the the process, um, we did sense that the Lord truly met us through through this work. And and to have uh wrestled together, to prayed together, to have had the the level of joy, even when we disagreed over language and and principle and how best to say and communicate something, was I would say unique. And it was peculiar in my experience of working with brothers on projects like this. And and would have to pray that the Spirit of the Living God would take that same spirit and spread it about amongst us in the PCA, even as we consider this upcoming General Assembly, not just this business of the Directory for Public Worship. We've got a few overtures before us, as I understand, and a few other matters uh to consider, that the Lord would really grant us this kind of camaraderie and partnership in the work of the gospel that continues to be principled and compromised as we move forward into the days to come. So super it was a super encouragement, um, and I'm grateful to be at the spot that we're at. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I I'm not saying this directory is an ice cream social uh in as much as it can gather everybody together. Right, I I'm not trying to say that. But but I do think if if you were um if you were anxious or fearful about the results of this committee, whether because you thought it would be way too open, or whether you were anxious and fearful because you thought, uh, man, this is just going to close off and radically change how my church does worship. My hope for you is that when you open up and read not only the introductory remarks, but read through the actual directory to worship, I I hope you're ministered too. Uh, that was the result for all of us on the committee. And my hope is that the the vast majority of the assembly, when we show up uh at 8 a.m. on Wednesday morning, bright and early uh in Louisville, that that we can all vote uh to that end and say, yeah, let's take a step forward and complete what's been 50 years in the making.
SPEAKER_04As the Westminster Divines would say, this podcast is over. Thanks for joining us. A big thanks to our three guests for joining us uh today. We really appreciate it. Uh, you know, here at the end, we should say that things could have been a lot worse. They could have been a lot better. You know, Nate and Joel, you guys could have been put on the Christian Nationalism Committee. Uh Chad, you could and always still could be in the PCA if you wanted to. So uh, you know, worse, better. Very glad that all of y'all were here with us. Um Nate Sherden, Joel St. Clair, Chad Van Dixhorn. Uh listeners, make sure you're subscribed, make sure you're following us on social media. We've got lots of overtures content out there. We're very glad to host um this committee. Uh, unless the guys can think of anything else, uh, I'll simply close out by saying until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
SPEAKER_00Goodbye. Goodbye. Goodbye. See ya.
SPEAKER_04Y'all take care.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Especially the Preaching
Ben Ratliff
The Westminster Standard
Ryan Biese
Larger For Life
Blue Ridge Institute for Theological Education