Sisters in Stars Hollow: A Gilmore Girls Rewatch Podcast
Welcome to Sisters in Stars Hollow, a cozy Gilmore Girls rewatch podcast hosted by sisters Julia and Alex.
Julia has been a Gilmore Girls fan for over a decade, while Alex is experiencing Stars Hollow for the very first time! Together, they revisit the series episode by episode, sharing first-time reactions, predictions, hot takes, and plenty of laughs along the way.
Julia and Alex break down the funny, the wholesome, the chaotic, and, of course, the spooky moments in every episode. Along the way, they share stories from their own lives, reminisce about growing up together, and find surprising connections between Stars Hollow and the real world.
Whether you’re watching for the first time or returning for your hundredth trip to Stars Hollow, grab a coffee and join us!
New episodes every other Tuesday. ☕✨
Want to support our show? Keep us caffeinated at:
buymeacoffee.com/sistersinstarshollow
Episodes
31 episodes
Hello Jess! 🙍🏻♂️ | S2 E5: Nick & Nora/Sid & Nancy
Jess Mariano has officially arrived in Stars Hollow!This week, we're breaking down Gilmore Girls Season 2, Episode 5, "Nick & Nora/Sid & Nancy," as Luke's troubled nephew makes his first appearance, Alex shares her first predicti...
Where is Max!? 😠 | S2 E4: The Roadtrip to Harvard
Did Lorelai actually call Max to call off the wedding?! Does he know? Where is he? How did he find out? And why does no one ever address this?! Julia loses her mind over the complete lack of answers and shares exactly how she thinks th...
Red Flags are Waving 🚩 | S2 E3: Red Light on Wedding Night
Lorelai does not seem excited for this wedding… and the red flags are officially waving in the wind. This epsiode, we uncover not only spooky moments, but enough disturbing moments that we had to start keeping a full tally. Between ...
Something Feels Off… 😅 | S2 E2: Hammers and Veils
Rory's sudden flurry of extracurricular activity strains her relationship with Dean. Emily is cold when Lorelai finally reveals her big news. We’re breaking down Gilmore Girls Season 2, Episode 2, “Hammers and Veils,” where Lorelai ...
You Little You 😈 | S2 E1: Sadie, Sadie...
A proposal, some serious doubts, and Luke being just a little sneaky… Season 2 is already off to a chaotic start. This week, we’re breaking down Gilmore Girls Season 2, Episode 1, “Sadie, Sadie…”Lorelai has to decide if she’s really read...
Season 1 Recap: Friends, Coffee, & Cozy Feelings
In today’s episode, we are looking back at the absolute chaos of Season 1. We’re recapping everything that made us fall in love with Stars Hollow all over again.Subscribe so you never miss an episode as we head into Season 2!
1000 Yellow Daisies 🌼 | S1 E21: Love, Daisies and Troubadours
We made it to the Season 1 Finale of Gilmore Girls!! Alex has officially seen one full season! This episode truly has everything! Big moments, surprising turns, and an unexpected amount of spooky moments. We revisit Alex’s pr...
This is the "Uh Oh" Song 🫣 | S1 E20: P.S. I Lo…
We’ve officially reached the penultimate episode of Season 1, and things are starting to feel a little… dubious.Alex was surprised that this episode didn’t give too much away about how the finale is going to play out, but that hasn’t sto...
Coffee Break 3: Slides, Sips & Spicy Books
In this episode, we recap a recent adventure at a kids’ jungle gym, sip on a Lavazza K-Cup, and revisit an espresso martini from the other night. We also chat about a surprisingly intense puzzle competition, Julia’s new coloring hobby, and dive...
Strange Things are Happening 👟 | S1 E19: Emily in Wonderland
This week, Emily Gilmore steps into Stars Hollow where she surprisingly thrives and walks away with a surprising new appreciation for sneakers!Meanwhile, the Rachel–Lorelai–Luke situation continues to spin in circles. Will Rachel stay? W...
It's Her Mom's Closet 👚 (feat. Our Mom!) | S1 E18: The Third Lorelai
This week, we’re joined by a very special guest… our mom! Gran comes to town (or “Trix,” as Richard calls her… weird), and is surprisingly an unpleasant person, even when she’s given spiced nuts.We question whether Gran’s ver...
Dean is a STALKER 👻 | S1 E17: The Breakup, Part II
We’re officially in our feelings this week. Alex and Julia break down the aftermath of Rory and Dean’s breakup, and Lorelai finally says what we’ve all been thinking: Dean is a STALKER. Rory refuses to wallow, which sends us on a tangent about ...
Don't Forget the Meatball! 🍝 | S1 E16: Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers
This episode gave us so much to laugh about, and we break it all down. First of all… why is Rory bringing Lorelai a meatball from her date?? We have questions.We meet Chase Bradford and find him equal parts pretentious, hilarious, and cr...
Does Christopher Sell Drugs? 💊 | S1 E15: Christopher Returns
Christopher has officially arrived in Stars Hollow… and chaos immediately follows. Truly shocking. In this episode, we questions what Christopher actually does in California (because… what does it mean when you say you're in business??) a...
Stalker Dean Returns 👻 | S1 E14: That Damn Donna Reed
This episode gives us a lot to talk about. We dig into Rory’s "Donna Reed Night" and debate the big question: is she genuinely curious about being a trad-wife or is this one long, sarcastic bit? Either way, we cannot stop talking about what she...
Double, Double Toil and Trouble 🧙🏻♀️ (feat. Our Brother) | S1 E13: Concert Interruptus
This week, our brother joins us again, which means even more chaos and laughter.We dive into the town rummage sale, unpack the Chilton group project dynamics (we absolutely relate to this kind of assignment), and Nick has the hilarious r...
Coffee Break 2: Santa's White Christmas
Welcome back to our second Coffee Break! This week, we’re trying one of our listener’s coffee recommendations, Barnie’s Santa’s White Christmas, and honestly, it might be one of the best cups we’ve ever had!! 🎅🎄We chat about fun sweet tr...
Where Did Rune Come From? 🦢 (feat. Our Brother) | S1 E12: Double Date
This week, we’ve got a special guest, our brother Nick is back which can only mean one thing: extra laughs! we unpack the hilarity of both double dates, discuss whether we love or hate Rune, and question Lane’s maybe-soulmate (maybe not). We've...
Black Cats & Voodoo Dolls 🐈⬛ | S1 E11: Paris is Burning
Grab your coffee and get comfy! This week’s episode of Sisters in Stars Hollow is a wild one! We talk about Lorelai’s questionable decisions, Jackson’s new “zucchini" creation, and the moments that had us both laughing and cringing. So, grab yo...
Coffee Break 1: Pumpkin Spice Café
Grab your mug and get comfy, because it’s time for our very first Coffee Break! Julia and Alex shout out a TikTok comment (apparently Alex sounds like Lauren Graham?!), chat about current reads and book club dreams, and reminisce about the firs...
Are Dean & Lorelai Flirting? 😝 | S1 E10: Forgiveness and Stuff
Another episode that's an emotional rollercoaster! We laugh about Rory's questionable Christmas gift choices for Dean, and what is up with that spooky Lorelai/Dean interaction? Alex shares a similar spooky moment from her own life, Julia brings...
Oily Tacos in a Satin Dress!? 🌮 | S1 E9: Rory's Dance
We were not prepared for this emotional rollercoaster. It starts out cute and then spirals into chaos. Dean grabs another “spookiest moment” title, we have serious questions about eating tacos before a dance, and Emily’s horror at Lorelai’s mon...
I Smell Snow ❄️ | S1 E8: Love & War & Snow
Grab your mittens and a cup of coffee, because Stars Hollow is officially blanketed in snow! In this episode of Sisters in Stars Hollow, Julia and Alex gush over one of the dreamiest episodes yet, Love & War & Snow. Lorelai delivers her...
Kiss Kiss Kiss 🤭 | S1 E7: Kiss and Tell
Julia and Alex dive into their favorite episode yet, Kiss and Tell! From spooky surprises to quotes that had us laughing out loud, we cover it all. They share first-kiss stories, debate if Dean is snooping through Rory’s things, and uncover fun...
I Am An Autumn 🍂 | S1 E6: Rory's Birthday Parties
It’s birthday time in Stars Hollow! Julia and Alex dive into Rory’s two very different parties; one thrown by Emily, the other hosted by Lorelai. They share stories from their own sweet sixteens, celebrate heartwarming Rory-Richard and Rory-Par...
