Unwatched Mysteries
An episode by episode break down of the original Unsolved Mysteries, from two fans of all things paranormal watching the series for the first time. Watch along with us on Peacock! (Not sponsored, but different streaming platforms have different episode orders).
Reach us at unwatchedmysteries@gmail.com and follow us on instagram @unwatchedmysteries.
Theme song and all music created by Jordan Krinsky; Find his music on Spotify (How Strange It Is) and instagram @howstrange_it_is_
Episodes
22 episodes
Season 1 Episode 20: Brushy Is Billy!
This episode covers the horrifying crimes of Sergeant Charles Mule, the murder of Donald Smith and the disappearance of his mysterious companion, and a look back at the story of Billy the Kid, questioning if he really was killed in the way lege...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 20
•
1:10:38
Season 1 Episode 19: So How Do You Feel About Death?
This episode covers the Burrowing Burglars of Los Angeles, Near Death Experiences, specifically those experienced by Kristle Merzlock and Thomas Sawyer, and the murder of Ohio repairman Perman Gilbert, with motives ranging from drug cartels to ...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 19
•
1:27:01
Mini Episode: The Hauntings of Pike Place Market
Hi Everyone! It's just Julie today to bring you a mini episode while we wait for the return to our regular programming. Since it's peak tourist season in our beautiful city, I decided to dive into one of Seattle's most visited and most haunted ...
•
23:47
BRB! H.A.G.S!
We are unexpectedly off this week! We'll be back for episode 19 ASAP. We love you all and hope you are thriving this summer! Hydrate! Wear sunscreen! XOXO
•
0:39
Season 1 Episode 18: Your Classic Dense Forest Animals
This episode covers the murders of speed racing legend Mickey Thompson & his wife Trudy, the many escapes and crimes of wanted man Michael Wayde Mohon, new witness accounts and physical evidence of the elusive Sasquatch in Pikes Peak, Color...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 18
•
1:16:43
Season 1 Episode 17: It's Like a Photo of History
This episode covers the history of Alcatraz, the infamous prison in the San Francisco Bay. Coverage focuses on the escape of three convicts, John Anglin, his brother Clarence Anglin, and Frank Morris, and the show's attempt to recreate their es...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 17
•
1:33:19
Season 1 Episode 16: A New Leaf on Life
This episode covers the murder of undercover vice cop Lester Garnier, the abduction and murder of 16 year old Katherine Hobbs and the premonitions she had leading up to her death, the story of Bill Purinton and the decades long search for his s...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 16
•
1:26:31
Season 1 Episode 15: Schweder Weather
This episode covers the remarkable psychic abilities of Dorothy Allison and how she has used those abilities to help in hundreds of police cases, the murder of Micki Jo West, children of the turn of the century orphan trains and their search fo...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 15
•
1:14:34
Season 1 Episode 14: It's Short for Leopard
This episode covers the case of missing 14 year old Jeremy Bright, the murder of John Martin, the disappearance of the highly successful prospector Dan Willans and the unclaimed fortune left behind, the community oriented softball umpire turned...
•
1:14:13
Season 1 Episode 13: Did You Ask Everyone About The Magic, David?
This episode covers the murderous road rage that took the life of beloved Los Angeles DJ Lee Selwyn, the missing person case of Michael Rosenblum and a psychic’s help in finding answers, and a Don Juan going by Arthur Frankford stealing from wi...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 13
•
58:15
Season 1 Episode 12: We All Know About Automated Teller Machines
This episode covers the lost connection between WWII soldier Philip and the Dentai family, the disappearance of Matthew Chase after a quick trip to the local ATM, the highly suspicious murder of Marilu Geri (Serrato) and the search for the trut...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 12
•
1:02:41
Season 1 Episode 11: Criminals Be Crimin'
This episode covers the life changing injuries inflicted on teenager Jenny Pratt, the stolen fortune and disappearance of Jack Quinn, the local legend of the double death of Clarence Roberts and his wife Geneva, and "Fumbles" the robber succeed...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 11
•
1:07:58
Season 1 Episode 10: Finally, UFOs!
This episode covers the murder of Charlie Sigmin, the layered disappearance of Rogest Cain, and the unexplained phenomenon of missing time and its potential connection to extraterrestrials.Trigger warnings for this episode include murder...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 10
•
1:14:52
Season 1 Episode 9: You Should Find This Rock.
This episode covers the unexplainable death of Kurt Sova, the remarkable story of John Nellis and the search for his dad and son, the murder of two Catholic Priests, Father Reynaldo Rivera and Father John Kerrigan, and the seemingly magical, lu...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 9
•
1:00:08
Season 1 Episode 8: Everyone, Get Lawyers
This episode covers the disappearance of Christi Nichols, Mark Adams's escape from San Quentin Prison, Oregon fraudsters Steven Cox & Eugene Richmond, and the horrific case of the murder of 4 year old Barbara Jean. A few notes from Julie &a...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 8
•
1:07:39
Season 1 Episode 7: That's Not Good Evidence, Dude.
This episode covers the spooky occurrences at General Wayne Inn, the random, tragic murder of Gretchen Burford, the conclusion of the Son of Sam coverage, and the confusing abduction and ransom of Annie Laurie Hearin.Trigger warni...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 7
•
1:10:38
Season 1 Episode 6: Emphasis on Weird
This episode covers part 1 of the Son of Sam murders, the mysterious life & unclaimed fortune of Walter "Curly" Green, and the devastating murders of Harold & Thelma Swain at Rising Daughters Church, plus the decades long investigation ...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 6
•
1:10:26
Season 1 Episode 5: You're Thinking of The Dark Web
This episode covers the legendary case of skyjacker DB Cooper, the suspicious, upsetting murders of teenagers Don Henry & Kevin Ives, and the fraudster Dennis Walker & his missing sports memorabilia. Trigger warnings for th...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 5
•
1:15:15
Season 1 Episode 4: Case Closed Ghosts Are Real
This episode kicks off with some personal ghost stories from Julie & Katie, inspired by the show's coverage of the haunted Queen Mary in Long Beach, CA. Additionally, this episode covers the murders of Roxanne Woodson & Cathy Clowers fo...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 4
•
55:25
Season 1 Episode 3: The More I Look, The More Confused I Get
This episode covers the attacks of Doreen Picard & Susan Laferte, the serial "heart attacker" of New York City, the suspicious disappearances of housewife Diane Brodbeck & prisoner Jon Yount, and a treasure hunt centuries in the making....
•
Season 1
•
Episode 3
•
1:05:48
Season 1 Episode 2: This is a Good Show.
This episode covers the layered story of Missy Munday, the questionable conviction of Michael Scott Martin, the suspicious death of Kurt McFall, and the story of a bundle of lost WW2 love letters that found their way home. Trigger ...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 2
•
1:01:38
Season 1 Episode 1: We Think?
Welcome to Unwatched Mysteries! This is our inaugural episode, diving into the beloved series Unsolved Mysteries for the first time. This episode covers the death of newlywed Shannon Davis, the suspicious death of Aileen Conway, a questionable ...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 1
•
59:56