Essentials of Crafting Negative Character Arcs + Deep Dive into the Disillusionment Arc

Not every character’s journey leads to triumph—some lead to harsh truths and shattered illusions.

In this episode we do an overview the negative character arcs and then focus on the specifics of the Disillusionment Arc.

Unlike positive arcs where characters grow and overcome their flaws, disillusionment arcs are about painful realizations. These characters start believing in something—an ideal, a system, a person—only to have that belief stripped away, leaving them changed, but not necessarily better off.

Using powerful examples like The Great Gatsby and The Firm, we’ll break down:
✨ How false beliefs shape a character’s journey
✨ The key differences between negative and positive arcs
✨ Why disillusionment arcs resonate so deeply with readers
✨ How to craft a compelling downfall without losing your audience

If you want to explore the darker side of storytelling and create characters whose struggles feel real, this episode is for you.

What You’ll Learn:

✅ Benefits of understanding negative arcs, even if your main character doesn’t have one

✅The essential components of a Disillusionment Arc
✅ How to differentiate a disillusionment arc from a traditional fall or corruption arc
✅ Why false beliefs are the driving force behind negative arcs
✅ How to use this arc to add depth and emotional impact to your stories
✅ Examples of disillusionment arcs in literature and film (The Great Gatsby, The Firm)

Episode Breakdown:

00:00 Introduction to Negative Character Arcs

01:21 Overview of Negative Character Arcs

06:51 Understanding the Disillusionment Arc

12:45 Disillusionment Arc in Story Structure

16:24 Examples of Disillusionment Arcs

22:03 Wrap Up

Negative arcs don’t just make for compelling stories—they reflect the painful truths we all face at some point. So if you’re ready to explore the darker side of character growth, grab your notebook and let’s dive in.

Transcript

Copy Transcript Copied

SPEAKER_00 0:00

A negative character arc is a type of character change in which the character's story is going to end in failure, defeat, or a morally compromised state. So, yeah, there's no happy ending here. You are not going to have a warm, fuzzy feeling after you read a story with one of these arcs in it. Now, typically, these are your tragedies, your cautionary tales, so their tone's gonna be naturally more pessimistic. Welcome to the Write It Scared podcast. I'm your host, Stacey Fraser, a formerly repressed creative soul, turned fiction writer, story editor, and author accelerator certified fiction book coach. At Write It Scared, we tell the truth about why writing a novel is so hard by acknowledging that most writers grapple with two stories: the one they want to put on the page to the best of their ability, and the often subconscious internal story that prevents them from doing it. This show is designed to help you identify and rewrite the internal narrative holding you back while you discover and write the story you want to tell and learn all the tools to help you do that successfully. Join me each week for a new episode where we'll talk about writing to deepen our understanding of the craft and of ourselves as writers. Writing a novel is an inside job that we do not do alone. Welcome to Write It's Scared. I'm glad you're here. Let's dive in. Hi, writer. Welcome back to the Write It Scared podcast. I'm your host, Stacey. Today we're going to continue talking about constructing character arcs and focus on negative arcs of change. We'll do a bit of an overview, but we'll only look at one specifically because this is a really big topic, and I want to give it the time it deserves because I felt like doing them all in one episode would just be way too much, and we'd be here for too long, and nobody wants to hear me talk for that long. So, as I said, we'll do an overview of the negative arcs and then do a deep dive into the one which is a bit of an outlier, the disillusionment arc, like my personal favorite, and then cover the other two arcs in subsequent podcasts. But before we jump in, have you had a chance to download First Draft Confidence? It's a free workbook and introductory guide to the foundation work that all of my clients complete before they begin drafting, and using it helps prevent false starts and abandoned drafts. It covers seven simple exercises designed to help you overcome mindset wobbles, resistance, keep yourself organized, set up realistic writing expectations, test drive your story concept, develop your cast of characters and a high-level outline that will work whether you're a panther or a plotter or somewhere in between. It also has resources on how to format your novel to publishing industry standards, word count expectations for your genre, and recommendations on excellent craft books for drafting novelists. So if you want to take as much guesswork out of planning and drafting your novel as possible, download First Draft Competence. The link is in the show notes, and you can also go to writeitscared.co forward slash novel planning guide. So negative character arcs don't get a whole lot of attention in the writing world. They're not talked about all that often. And I think it's kind of a shame. I mean, I get it. I see the reason for it. Stories that have characters with a positive arc of change are genuinely more popular because they're about hope and inspiration. While stories about negative character arcs are cautionary and tragic, they're just less feel-good. But even if your protagonist has a positive arc of change, you can still benefit from learning about negative character arcs because your protagonist isn't the only character who can undergo a significant change in your story. And knowing what other changes are out there are beneficial. Understanding negative character arcs can help you craft your villains, your antagonistic forces, if that's another character or a sentient being. And if you have a morally gray protagonist, it can help you learn how they became who they are in the story. Because remember, when we meet a character in the book, they come to us with a whole life of lived experience behind them that led them to become the person that we meet in the pages. So understanding what makes your character stick is incredibly insightful and it makes them feel true to the reader. A negative character arc is a type of character change in which the character's story is going to end in failure, defeat, or a morally compromised state. So yeah, there's no happy ending here. You are not going to have a warm, fuzzy feeling after you read a story with one of these arcs in it. Now, typically, these are your tragedies, your cautionary tales, so their tone's gonna be naturally more pessimistic. Personally, I like a good negative character arc, and I really love writing my antagonist or the wicked side of a character almost as much as I like writing the heroes and the positive things. Sometimes more, actually. And I think the reason is because these types of arcs allow us, or at least they allow me, to explore the darker side of humanity and think about what lengths people will go to protect the things that they covet, the things that they love, even the things that aren't good for them. Now, it's hard to imagine how we as readers can grow to care about a character who shows us their unsavory side, but we do. And the reason is because of empathy, just like within a positive arc of change. Empathy is the ability to understand the feelings and perspectives of others. And sometimes that's hard to look at. It can be why these types of stories are so uncomfortable. Negative character arcs can make us feel uncomfortable on the inside because it connect can connect with the dark piece inside of us. And as adults, we're all capable of darkness, or at least I think so. So as I said, there are three subtypes of negative character arcs. There's the disillusionment, falling, and corruption. Now, no matter what type of negative arc you begin with, you still need all those same starting ingredients for a character arc that we talked about back in episode 42. So your protagonist is going to have a false belief. They're going to have a reason for having that false belief, typically from a wounding event earlier in their life, and they are going to have a conscious desire or an external want that's driven by that false belief. And this is something that they think that will make them happy, right? They're also going to have an internal need or longing or an unconscious desire, all that means the same thing. And this represents the truth that the character needs to embrace to become genuinely fulfilled, and it's linked directly to the thematic truth of the story, which represents the lesson that the character must learn in order to grow internally. So a distinct difference between a negative character arc and a positive character arc is that characters with a negative arc of change are going to reject the story's thematic truth, with one exception. And that's the disillusionment arc, which we're going to talk about today. So these characters are going to reject the thematic truth, and their internal need, which represents what they need to grow into a better version of themselves, is not going to be met. Hence the downer endings. So let's look at those three arcs in general. In a disillusionment arc, the protagonist believes in something that does not serve them, and it's usually something along the lines of whatever they do have isn't good in it. And if they could only attain something better, they would be more fulfilled. And actually the opposite is true. And the hard truth that they have to face is that the thing that they've fantasized about, maybe even gotten, usually have, is not great. And basically, what they get in the story is the ultimate wake-up call, and by that time it has cost them what they really do value. They just weren't paying attention to. Instead, they become further entrenched into their false belief, or they start to believe in something even worse. And usually we see them driven to the point of death or insanity. So think of this as they go from bad to maybe unhinged and then to evil. The last negative character arc is the corruption arc. And in this arc, the character truly begins as morally good, but they allow something to twist their soul, and slowly they become enraptured by the comforts of whatever the false belief that they're leaning into tells them. And they knowingly turn away from the goodness of their own character and embrace the darkness. And they often become the thing that they hated in the first place. And personally, I find these arcs really hard to read. So the general takeaways for crafting a negative character arc, just the high-level things you want to think about. You need to know all the same ingredients as you do in a positive arc of change. The character's wound, false belief, what they want, what they need to grow internally, what they have to overcome to be a better version of themselves. But in a negative arc, remember, it is going to result in a character becoming less fulfilled at the end of the story than they were at the beginning of the story. There is a caveat, one exception. If your character has a positive recovery in a disillusionment arc, they can find fulfillment. That situation's a bit of an outlier, and we're going to look at a specific example of that today. But in general, stories with a negative character arc are cautionary tales, they are tragedies, and the trajectory of the protagonist's internal journey is going to reflect that. Okay, now let's look at the disillusionment arc specifically. While this arc is often portrayed in a negative light, the disillusionment arc can serve as a powerful tool for delivering a message of caution and encouragement. By exploring the struggles and the challenges that this character faces, these stories can ultimately provide readers with a sense of hope and inspiration. So here's the short and the sweet. In a disillusionment arc, your character is going to be emotionally invested in the wrong things at the beginning of the story, just like we see in a positive arc of change. The character will be ruled by this false belief, which stems from a wound, and it's typically whatever they believe, it's kind of like it's actually something they don't fully appreciate. Maybe it's their sound mind or a loyal friend or a good family or having their basic needs met. And typically by the middle of the story, but sometimes later, they're gonna get a shocking wake-up call and discover that whatever they have been believing and have invested in was masking a terrible and painful truth. And guess who is the problem? Well, they are, or their belief system and the actions that they took to get them to where they are in the story. So to me, the disillusionment arc is one of the most interesting negative character arcs because once the character learns the truth, they're presented with a choice. They have another opportunity, and sometimes they do choose to better themselves. And now sometimes not. Sometimes it's too late, and they just don't have the chance. The disillusionment arc is very similar to a positive arc of change, but there is one significant distinction. Well, actually two. One is how painful it is for this character to open their eyes and see the truth. And in the beginning of a disillusionment arc, these characters are typically in a good place. They have a positive outlook on their life. Or they get a positive outlook quite quickly because they are in pursuit of this false belief, which they think represents everything that will make their world right, and they're going after it. Now at the end of the story, they're in a negative place because the rug has been pulled out from under them, the rose-colored glasses are off, and they now see the truth that everything they invested in was actually alive. So, what specifically happens in a disillusionment arc is that through the course of the story, the protagonist is going to experience a very gradual loss in faith in whatever particular ideology or belief system or way of life that they're invested in, hence the name disillusionment. At the beginning of the story, they're kind of under the spell. And there's lots of factors that can play into this. It can be from personal experiences, social or political upheaval, or realizing their beliefs don't really align with reality. So we're going to take it blow by blow through story structure and see how it changes as it as this arc is put through the paces of the plot. So remember, a story is something with a beginning, a middle, and an end. At the beginning, the character has a desire, and there is usually some sort of problem. The problem gets worse, and at the end, we figure out how to solve the problem. So in the beginning of the story, we will be introduced to the characters, the world and the situation. And your protagonist is going to be fully invested in this false belief. And they don't think it's false, they think it's the best things in sliced bread. And they are only going to see the good things that believing this false falsity will afford them. And they start to make choices to get what they want, which will take them further and further away from the lesson they need to learn to actually become internally fulfilled. Now, as the character enters the second act of the story, they will descend more deeply into the illusion of the external comforts that the false beliefs afford them. So this is them living the good life, getting what they want. It's all working out. They may start to struggle just a little bit because they're starting to pick up on some hints that the world might not be as perfect as it seems. But the truth is more like an annoyance or an irritation or a nuisance. They easily ignore it because they are fully committed to pursuing their external goal in service to that false belief, and that that will make them happy. Now, by the middle of the story, somewhere around the 50% mark, is where things start to fall apart, and their false belief will come become partially exposed. And what's underneath is not good. As a matter of fact, it could be a disaster. And the contradiction between what the character believes at this point and what they now know cannot be ignored. They have to figure out what to do about it. So they're on a pretty slippery slope here, and often they're doing some pretty serious backpedaling too. They become increasingly disillusioned with their circumstances, which initially they thought were was gonna be amazing. And this is a gradual process between the the falling apart and the seeing the holes poke through the story and the truth gradually coming to light. Now, in the last third of the novel, which is the last act where we've you know just experienced the lowest moment for our character, and like everything is bad. The rose-colored glasses are gone, they see the whole truth and everything that's truly going on, and it is gut-wrenching. And they get the entire scope of what living in service to this false belief has cost them. And it has cost them everything. Typically, they've got feelings of alienation, of despair, of hopelessness. And then at the very peak of the story, the climax, right, they have an opportunity to take action in service to this awful truth that they have discovered. And that action directly opposes their choice to embrace the false belief and all of its extravagance and adventure and cool stuff that it promised when they entered the second act of the story. And because of this, because of that final choice, they may or may not live to fight another day in service to the story's truth. That's the author's choice. So it's a really interesting character arc that is very much like a growth arc, but it's just really painful. So, some examples of the disillusionment arc in popular fiction. The first, and probably most well known and most referenced, is the character Nick Caraway from The Great Gatsby, written by F. Scotch Fitzgerald. Another character is the unnamed narrator from Chuck Polinek's novel Fight Club, which is also a movie. And really, if you want to see a disillusionment arc in action, I would say go watch Fight Club. It's just a brilliant example of, you know, this poor person living under this false feeling, and they think their life is improving, and then it just starts to fall apart. And when the truth is exposed to this character, it's shocking and devastating. This poor guy doesn't have his ch stand a chance, and it's too late for him at the end of the story. Sorry for the spoiler, but it's a really great example. But there's another spin on the disillusionment arc that puts the character in a better place at the end of the book. And this is what I want to show you today. And there is some fair debate about this. What I'm about to explain could be seen as an example as a of a positive arc of change. Or disillusionment. Honestly, sometimes these arcs do blend, not just these two, but many arcs. But I feel like this is a great example of a character being so disillusioned to the point where they devalue the life they have at the start of the story. And they do some terrible things in service to what they think is gonna make them happy, and then they learn this really ugly truth that just guts them. So it works well as a disillusionment example. Plus, it's got a happier ending, and I like that. So the example we're gonna talk about today is the character arc of Mitch McDear from John Gersham's novel The Firm. It's been out a long time. There's a movie. If you haven't seen it, sorry, this is a spoiler. But in the firm, we meet this young, ambitious law student, Mitch McDear, and he believes that success and money are going to answer all of his life's problems and that the law is just. And he puts all his face in. And he was raised kind of a poor, scrappy kid, and he's got a brother in jail, and he's worked really hard to overcome his past. And at the beginning of the book, he and his wife are living in Boston and they're barely making ends meet. They're living in this hovel of an apartment, and they're really hopeful that things are going to get better once Mitch passes his bar exam and gets a job. And he does. He gets an amazing offer from a small but powerful law firm in the South that pulls out all the stops to impress him, and it's almost too good to be true. So naturally, he jumps at the opportunity and takes the job, and this puts a story into the second act where the character is engaging with the new world and life seems rosy and the money's flowing in, and he's got it all, he's got the house, he's got the job, the sexy wife. But pretty soon he starts to get some hints that things may not be quite as wonderful as they seem. So it's like these tiny little pinpricks are being poked into his idyllic version of reality. And he begins to realize that there are some unsavory angles to his employer. And as the story goes forward, he learns that his employer is not what they seem to be at all. The firm works for an organized crime syndicate and will do whatever it takes to protect their interests, including blackmail and murder. So by the time he has this realization, his, you know, vision, idyllic vision of the firm is shattered, but also his faith in the legal profession itself is shaken. And at this point, he's in too deep, and I honestly can't remember if he's complicit in the firm's illegal activity or not. But he's approached by the FBI uh to be an informant and help take the crime syndicate and the firm down. And he's got to take some very big risks to find a way to protect himself and his family. So he goes to work for the FBI, works to take down the firm, and you know, he's risking his life and also the life of his family. Now, this story has a happy ending and a positive transformation for Mitch because in the end, he has learned that the pursuit of success and wealth come at a great cost that is often not worth paying. And honestly, there wasn't anything wrong with his life back in Boston. As a matter of fact, at some point in the story, his wife says to him that they were happier as a couple back in Boston. And he also learns that the law isn't infallible. It's not always just. In the film, I think he gets a large sum of money uh because of the help that he gave to the FBI, if I remember correctly, and he gives it away. He gives it to his brother, who somehow he manages to get out of jail. But the point is, he makes completely different choices at the end of the book than he did at the beginning. He is no longer in the pursuit of money in the same way he was at the start. So disillusioned monarchs are so cool, they're very fascinating, and they are about characters learning a truth and seeing that they had it all wrong. And even if they, you know, fight against that fact, they have it all wrong. Mitch McDear doesn't, but other characters do. Their illusion has been shattered. It's kind of like that saying, you can't ever unknow what you know. So I hope this episode helped you understand the generalities of negative character arcs and then specifically the disillusionment arc. And the next time we come back for a craft chat, we'll talk about the remaining two negative character arcs, the falling arc and the corruption arc. And I think we can accomplish both of those in one go. So if you have any questions, please reach out to me. My email is Stacy at writeitscared.co. I'd love to hear from you. And I will see you next week when I will be back with a new guest, and we're going to be talking about writing historical fiction. And before you go, don't forget to download your free copy of First Draft Confidence so that you can plan and draft your novel without the guesswork. Just go to writeitscared.co forward slash novel planning guide or check the link in the show notes. Thank you for listening to the Write It Scared podcast. If you enjoyed today's show, please make sure to hit the follow button so you never miss an episode. And please leave a review. Reviews help other writers like you find the voices and messages they need to hear to continue to write their stories. Let's lift each other up. Remember, you can be scared and still be unstoppable. I'll see you next week.