Secondhand Confessions
Other people's problems. Our favorite pastime.
Secondhand Confessions is where best friends Pugly and Mickey dive headfirst into Reddit's messiest relationship disasters, family feuds, bad decisions, and absolutely unhinged confessions. We read the drama, dissect the chaos, and deliver the unsolicited opinions nobody asked for.
New episodes every other Wednesday.
Episodes
35 episodes
Episode 36: My Boyfriend Put Benadryl in My Drink
In this episode, we explore what happens when the people closest to you start treating your autonomy like something they get a vote on.
Episode 35: He Wants to Propose. His Girlfriend Wants to Leave.
In this episode, doing the "right thing" gets complicated when every available option comes with collateral damage.
Episode 34: My Fiancé Left Me for "The One That Got Away"
In this episode, we explore the seductive pull of “the one that got away” and what happens when nostalgia collides with the life you’ve already built.
Episode 33: My Wife Catfished My Ex-Girlfriends
In this episode, deception isn’t loud—it’s strategic.
Episode 32: My Husband's Former Fiancée Wore the Dress She Almost Married Him In
In this episode, we dive into confessions shaped by grief, boundaries, and the aftermath of unspoken truths. First,
Episode 31: My Stepsister Mocked My Fiancé’s Facial Scars
In this episode, boundaries and appearances collide in ways no one sees coming. First,
Episode 30: My Dad Told Me I Was a "Broken Condom" Baby
In this episode, honesty doesn’t just set people free; it cuts deep.
Episode 29: My Boyfriend Says I Need to Get Over My Childhood Trauma
In this episode, one closed closet door hides more than just clothes—it holds years of trauma, healing, and the fragile trust between two people.
Episode 28: My Husband Bought Me the Earrings I Already Wear
In this episode, the little things turn out to be anything but little—as one Redditor’s Valentine’s Day takes an unexpectedly painful turn. First,
Episode 27: My Coworkers Wanted My Homeless Friend Banned
In this episode, workplace politics get personal—and painfully real—as three Redditors learn what happens when professional boundaries blur and basic human decency is left off the meeting agenda. First,
Episode 26: My Family Got Mad Because I Took My Own Cake Home
In this episode, love and loyalty are measured not in words, but in slice of cake—served with a side of disappointment and dashed expectations. First,
Episode 25: My Boyfriend Hasn’t Been to the Dentist in Six Years
In this episode, love is tested not by grand betrayals or secrets, but by sinus infections and stubborn plaque. First, a woman g...
Episode 24: My Daughter Refuses to Tell Her Boyfriend Her Dark Secret
In this episode, boundaries get blurred and secrets run deep. First, a college student finds himself at the center of an apartment co...
Episode 23: My Ex Showed Up at My Door the Night Before His Wedding
In this episode, exclusion and regret take center stage. First,
Episode 22: I Paid $400 to See If My Sister's Boyfriend Would Cheat
In this episode, tough choices blur the lines between right and wrong.
Episode 21: My Friend "Lost" My Wedding Dress
Weddings should be about love, but sometimes, they bring drama. A missing wedding dress sparks a heated debate over trust, <...
Episode 20: I Destroyed My Wife's Late Husband's Wedding Ring
In this episode, we explore the weight of love, loss, and loyalty in relationships. First, a husband’s well-intentioned Val...
Episode 19: Grandma Deliberately Gave My Baby Chickenpox
In this episode, family and friendship take a dark turn. A mother-in-law secretly infects her granddaughter with chickenpox<...
Episode 18: My Family Ordered 20 Pizzas at My Vegan Wedding
In this episode, pizza becomes the unlikely catalyst for chaos and tough decisions. First, a parent confronts their son’s friend, who might onl...
Episode 17: My Boyfriend's Late-Night Hobby Is a Giant Red Flag
In this episode, we explore holiday tensions and fractured relationships. First, a woman feels sidelined as her boyfriend prior...
Episode 16: My Sister's Cooking Is Ruining Thanksgiving
In this episode, we dive into the chaos of Thanksgiving, where family traditions clash with unexpected dilemmas and tough decisions. First,
Episode 15: My Husband Gave Me a Hall Pass I Never Asked For
In this episode, we navigate the intricate dynamics of misunderstandings, assumptions, and unconventional compromises. First, we meet
Episode 14: My Girlfriend's Pokémon Obsession Embarrasses Me
In this episode, we delve into the blurred boundaries between passion, obsession, and control. First, we meet