Rewind Storytelling
I’m Justice Tilsher—bestselling novelist, story coach, and founder of JesusWriMo. I wrote my debut novel at 17 as a homeschool student, and now I help Christian writers like you silence the fears of comparison, self-doubt, and the lies of the enemy—so you can finally step into your God-given calling and write the book you were created to share. If you’re ready to write and publish the highest-quality book of your dreams—and change lives for Jesus—hit play below.
"As each have received a gift, use it to serve one another as good stewards of Gods varied grace."
— 1 Peter 4:10
Episodes
38 episodes
Ep. 38 - Writing the Mirror Scene: When Your Character Lives the Lie
It’s one thing when a character first believes a lie — it’s another when they start living like it’s true. This is the scene where your character makes their first conscious choice rooted in that false belief, and the world rewards them for it....
•
13:10
Ep. 37 - The Art of Weaving Hidden Depth Into Characters
The best characters don’t need long monologues to reveal their past, their quirks, traits, and little habits do it for them. In this episode, I break down how to create characters whose behavior hints at deeper layers, making them feel real and...
•
14:54
Ep. 36 - Raising the Standard in Christian Storytelling
This is a controversial episode. I rip the band-aid off and say what no one else wants to: the bar in Christian entertainment isn’t simply low...it was never there to begin with. From cringe movies to shallow storytelling, we’ve settled for les...
•
17:44
Ep. 35 - How to Write Chapter 2: Crafting the Impossible Choice (Hunchback of Notre Dame)
In this episode, I’m breaking down how to write Chapter 2 of your story — the moment where everything changes. We’re going to talk about crafting the impossible choice, the kind of decision that forces your character into motion and lo...
•
20:05
Ep. 34 - How to Get Anything Done in the Next 4 Months
Most people set New Year’s resolutions with big dreams… and most people fall off by February. Then the months fly by, and when September hits, the excuse creeps in: ‘Well, it’s only a few more months until January. I’ll just restart then.’ No. ...
•
14:30
Ep. 33 - Shalla-Bal and the Art of Moral Conflict: Writing Characters Torn Between Duty and Guilt
In this episode, I dive deep into one of Marvel’s most emotionally rich characters — Shalla-Bal, the herald of Galactus. She saved her planet by striking a bargain, only to spend the rest of her existence enabling the destruction of countless w...
•
17:48
Ep. 32 - The 3 Burnout Traps That Will Kill Your Writing Momentum
In this episode, I’m breaking down the 3 sneaky traps that lead writers straight into burnout, plus the simple shifts that will help you dodge them. You’ll learn how to set deadlines that actually work, take real breaks without guilt, and track...
•
14:59
Ep. 31 – The Art of the Tragic Redemptive Arc with Meg from Hercules
In this episode, we’re diving into one of Disney’s most complex and underrated heroines: Meg from Hercules.We’ll unpack how her tragic redemptive arc is shaped by one central truth: every character has a lesson to learn. And how...
•
16:13
Ep. 30 - Storytelling Lessons from the Jungle Cruise (and Other Disney Attractions)
In this episode, we're heading to the theme parks to break down how Disney rides can teach us everything we need to know about storytelling.From the spooky spectacle of Haunted Mansion... To the adventure and chaos of Pirates of...
•
17:17
Ep. 29 - Episode 29: Torn Between Two Worlds: What Tarzan Teaches Us About Character Transformation
In this episode, we’re swinging into one of Disney’s most underrated masterpieces — Tarzan.We’ll unpack how Tarzan’s transformation is driven by one central question: "Where do I belong?" And how that tug-of-war between truth an...
•
17:11
Episode 28 - The 5 Ways to Ruin the Opening of Your Book And Make Your Reader Hate You
Want to guarantee your reader never turns page two?In this episode, I’m breaking down five deadly sins of story openings — from worldbuilding overload to hiding your protagonist behind four pages of weather descriptions.We’ll cove...
•
18:53
Episode 27 - The Gollum Effect: How Side Characters Reveal the Truth Your Hero Wants to Avoid
In this episode, we’re heading to Mordor.But not to follow Frodo.We’re chasing Gollum.Because every great story has a mirror, a character who reflects your hero’s deepest fear, secret sin, or buried desire. And Gollum? He’s a ...
•
11:35
Ep. 26 - The Parable Every Writer Needs to Hear
In this episode, we’re digging into one of the most convicting parables Jesus ever told: the Parable of the Talents.We’ll unpack how God wired us for story, why creativity is a Kingdom assignment, and what Scripture really says about was...
•
15:58
Ep. 25 - Writing Tragic Character Arcs with Hamilton the Musical
In this episode, I’m diving into one of my favorite stories of all time — Hamilton. But we’re not talking history. We’re talking heartbreak.We’ll unpack how to write a broken hero like Hamilton — a man who climbs and climbs, onl...
•
24:01
Ep. 24 - Writing Characters With The Gap And The Gain
In this episode, I’m unpacking one of the most powerful truths in storytelling — the reason your character’s goal will never actually satisfy them. It’s called The Gap.Too many characters (and real people) live their lives thinking, “If...
•
20:24
Ep. 23 - The Anatomy of Betrayal: What Treasure Planet Gets So Right
In this episode, I’m diving into one of the most underrated heartbreaks in animation history: the betrayal in Treasure Planet.We’ll break down how Disney built one of the most gut-wrenching moments of backstabbing — and what it ...
•
10:36
Ep. 22 - Into the Writer-Verse: The Anatomy of the Perfect Protagonist
Miles Morales might be the most relatable Spider-Man ever written — and in this episode, I’m breaking down why.I’m diving deep into the psychology of what makes a character actually connect. Not just likable… but real. We’ll unp...
•
13:31
Ep. 21 - On Writing Characters Your Reader Falls In LOVE With
Be real — you've fallen head over heels for a fictional character before. For me? It was Elizabeth Bennet (don't judge). But here's the thing: there's a psychology behind crafting characters your readers actually fall in love with — and yes, it...
•
13:27
Ep. 20 - NaNoWriMo Is Dead. Now What?
NaNoWriMo? It’s dead.In this episode, I’m letting you in on what comes next — and it’s called Jesus Writing Month.It’s the biggest thing I’ve ever built. A writing revival for Christian storytellers who know their book is a...
•
14:10
Ep. 19 - Writing the Lost Man Storyline
In this episode, I’m breaking down my all-time favorite storytelling arc: the Lost Man. This powerful framework applies to nearly every unforgettable character—and we’re diving deep into how to write it well. Using The Greatest Showman...
•
20:34
Ep. 18 - You MUST Write Your Story
God gave you the dream of writing for a reason. This episode is your wake-up call to stop letting fear and the enemy's lies hold you back. We’re diving into why it’s your moral obligation to share the stories God placed on your heart—a...
•
13:37
Ep. 17 - Pixar's Big Mistake - Knowing When to Get Off the Train
They were on the verge of greatness… and nearly blew it. This is the wild story from Pixar’s early days—and the wake-up call you need if you’re chasing the wrong dream. One decision. One turning point. Don’t miss this.
•
10:42
Ep. 16 - Writing Every Day Is Murdering Your Creativity
You’re burned out and creatively drained. In this episode, I’ll show you how stepping away will reignite your inspiration and why rest isn’t lazy, but a nonnegotiable.
•
11:13
Ep. 15 - Overcoming The Fear Of Publishing and Stepping Into Your God-Given Calling
For a long time, I was afraid to share my writing with the world. What if they weren’t good enough? What if people judged me? But God didn’t call me to hide my voice—He called me to use it. In this episode, I’m sharing how Jesus helped me overc...
•
21:18