
Baby You Can Rate My Song
Paul? John? George? RINGO?! Tony and Eleanor rate and review every Beatles song to settle the age-old debate: who is the greatest songwriter in the Beatles?
Podcasting since 2024 • 27 episodes
Baby You Can Rate My Song
Latest Episodes
Julia Will Want You, Heavy Lady
Tony and Eleanor return from their break with a celebrity guest and a truly stacked roster of late-era Beatles songs. It's the longest episode yet, featuring a McCartney impression showdown and a shocking revelation about Tony's past. Follow al...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 24
•
2:20:22

Halftime Special
In a very special episode, Tony and Eleanor reveal the lads’ halftime scores, respond to messages from BYCRMS listeners, and welcome back a fan favorite guest. The song journey will resume October 8th — keep an eye on your feeds!
•
1:10:46

Tell Your Face I Wanna Hold Your Man
Tony and Eleanor are joined by an old buddy to discuss a Ringo vocal, a George joint, and some 50-50's (including a big, big boy). Topics of discussion include Akira Kurosawa, Franz Liszt, and trail mix. Follow along with the song list from thi...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 23
•
1:40:38

Won’t Be Feeling Too Much Love
Tony and Eleanor explore a peculiar Harrison contribution, mid-60’s Lennon love songs, and Paul and John’s final 50-50 effort. Follow along with the song list from this episode, available on
•
Season 1
•
Episode 22
•
1:29:34

You Saw My Life Better
Eleanor takes a turn in the listening chair while Tony assumes his post as leader of the podcast. They explore George's second tune and a debate between Paul and John about primary songwriting credit for an iconic song. Plus: some unexpected sc...
•
Season 1
•
Episode 21
•
1:16:28
