62 | You Know You Should Say Something… But You Don’t

• Why do hard conversations feel so scary, even when you know something needs to be said?
• Why do you stay quiet when someone crosses a line, hurts your feelings, or pushes a boundary?
• What if staying silent is not protecting your relationships, but slowly creating resentment and distance? 

In this episode, Jessica Davis breaks down why speaking up feels so hard when you struggle with anxiety, people-pleasing, or self-doubt. If you’ve ever rehearsed a conversation in your head, talked yourself out of saying what you feel, or stayed quiet to keep the peace, this episode will help you understand what is happening underneath the surface.

She explains how the fawn response shows up in hard conversations, why your nervous system reacts like conflict is danger, and why avoiding difficult conversations often creates more emotional pain over time. You’ll also learn why conflict is not the enemy of healthy relationships, avoidance is.

What You’ll Learn in this Episode:

• Why staying quiet feels safe in the moment
• How people-pleasing keeps you stuck in anxiety and resentment
• What the fawn response is and why it makes you shrink during conflict
• Why avoiding hard conversations creates distance and disconnection
• Why conflict is not the problem, but avoidance often is
• How to speak up before your emotions build and come out sideways
• Why “I feel” statements help you communicate without attacking
• How using your voice builds confidence and self-trust

RESOURCES:
Get your FREE Anxiety Survival Toolkit to help you when your anxiety is overwhelming!

JOIN our NEWSLETTER! Get weekly emails about upcoming podcasts, but also how to fight against anxiety!

📱 Follow Us:

Instagram | Facebook | Threads 

🎙️ Presented by Davis-Smith Mental Health

This podcast was created by Davis-Smith Mental Health, offering counseling for teens & young adults in Illinois (only). We accept BCBS PPO, Aetna PPO, and self-pay clients.

Links: 
Anxiety Survival Toolkit:
https://www.blockoutthenoisepodcast.com/anxiety-survival-toolkit/

Newsletter:
https://blockoutthenoisepodcast.substack.com/welcome

Davis-Smith Mental Health:
https://www.davis-smithmentalhealth.com/

1:1 Confidence Coaching:
https://tidycal.com/blockoutthenoise/confidence-coaching

⚠️ Disclaimer:  Block Out the Noise provides personal insights and practical stra...

Transcript

When You Swallow Your Words

Jessica N. Davis 0:07

You're sitting there, someone says something that doesn't sit right with you. Maybe they crossed a line, made a joke at exactly the wrong moment, maybe they've pushed a boundary you've asked them not to push, and you feel it, that frustration rising, the butterflies going absolutely crazy in your stomach. You have something to say, but then you think, why cause more of an issue? What you say won't come off right anyway. It's just going to make things worse. So you go along with it, you sit in the awkwardness, you smile through it, you tell yourself this is fine, this is better for them and for you. And the whole time something inside of you feels really, really small. That feeling has a name, and today we're going to talk about what it's actually costing you and how to change it.

Show Purpose And Free Toolkit

Jessica N. Davis 0:58

Hi, and welcome to Block Up the Noise, a space to quiet the noise of anxiety, self-doubt, and overthinking. I'm Jessica Davis, licensed therapist, mindset coach, and the creator of the Courage Method, a framework designed to help you work through the hard stuff with tools that actually stick. Before we get into today's topic, go grab the anxiety survival toolkit. It's in the show notes. It has coping skills, audio tools, a full breakdown of the Courage Method, and a meditation. All free. The link is below. And quick reminder: this podcast is here to support and guide you, but it is not a replacement for talking to someone in real life. If you're struggling with your mental health, please reach out to a therapist. And if you're in crisis, contact emergency services or a local helpline. You don't have to go through it alone. All right, so let's

The Real Cost Of Staying Quiet

Jessica N. Davis 1:47

jump in. This is what it looks like day in, day out. You rehearse the conversations in your head a hundred times. You know exactly what you want to say. You played it out every way it could go. And in your version, it never goes well. So by the time the moment comes, you've already decided it's not worth it. You go along with what they say. You laugh when it isn't funny. You say yes when every part of you wants to say no. Some people even let coworkers call them the wrong name for years just to avoid that one uncomfortable conversation. And the whole time you tell yourself it's easier this way, less problematic. But here's what that's actually costing you. And I don't mean in some abstract, one day this will catch up with you kind of way. I mean right now in your relationships and how you see yourself. Every time you swallow something that needed to be said, it doesn't disappear. It sits, it turns into resentment, not always toward the other person, sometimes toward yourself, because part of you knows that you didn't show up for you. And over time that builds up like water behind a dam. You can't see it from the outside. Everything looks fine. The surface is calm, but the pressure, the pressure is building every single time you choose silence over saying what you actually feel. And meanwhile, the relationship is already taking damage. Not later, now. Every unspoken thing creates a little more distance, a little more disconnect. Honestly, a little more of you that the other person never gets to know. And then one day, the damn breaks. Not calmly, not the way you rehearsed it. It comes out as tears you can't explain, as shutting down completely, as snapping at someone over something that has nothing to do with what's actually going on. And now instead of the conversation being about what you needed to say, it's about how you said it. That's what staying quiet actually does. It doesn't protect the relationship. The damage is happening the whole time. You just can't

A Client Story Of Speaking Up

Jessica N. Davis 3:53

see it yet. Now, I want to tell you about someone I worked with. She had been avoiding hard conversations her whole life, even through high school and into college. Years of going alone to get along, smiling through things that hurt, staying quiet in moments that deserved her voice. We worked on it for a while. And I want to be honest with you, the information wasn't the hard part. She knew what she needed to do. The hard part was deciding she was worth the discomfort of actually doing it. And the moment she made that decision, everything shifted. She had hard conversations with professors that improved her engagement in college. She set boundaries with friends and family she had never set before. She went after the job she wanted and got it. And what struck me most watching all of that unfold was that she had spent years thinking that speaking up would make things worse. She didn't realize that staying quiet was already doing that.

The Fawn Response Explained

Jessica N. Davis 4:48

So why is it hard to just stop? Why can't you just decide to speak up and actually do it? Because your brain is working against you. When you're about to say something hard, your nervous system fires, your heart rate goes up, your stomach drops, your thoughts race, your whole body says, get out of here. And that response, it has a name. We call it the fawn response. It happens when your brain decides the safest thing to do in an uncomfortable moment is to make everyone around you as comfortable as possible. So you smile, you agree, you apologize, you shrink. Not because you're weak, but because your brain learned at some point that keeping the peace kept you safe. And it's been running that same program on autopilot ever since. Now, maybe you've tried to push past it before. Maybe you've told yourself, I'm going to say something this time. And then the moment comes and you think, I'll wait for the right moment. But the problem is the right moment never comes because the right moment never feels right. Your nervous system is treating a hard conversation the same way it would treat danger. And the conversation you are playing in your head only gets worse every time until you've convinced yourself that staying quiet is actually the smarter choice. But the truth is staying quiet is actually costing you. It's costing you your sanity, the way you see yourself, how you connect and show up in every relationship in your life. You think you're helping by staying silent, but you are slowly sheltering and killing the best piece of you, your

Why Avoidance Breaks Connection

Jessica N. Davis 6:21

voice. So here's what I want you to consider. What if conflict isn't the problem? I know that probably sounds strange, maybe even a little bit uncomfortable, but stay with me. Most people believe that conflict is the opposite of a good relationship, that if things are tense, if someone is upset, if a hard conversation needs to happen, something must be wrong. But that's not what the research says. Dr. John Gottman, one of the most respected relationship researchers in the world, spent decades studying what actually makes relationships fall apart. And what he found might surprise you. It wasn't conflict that damaged relationships. It was avoidance. The couples, the friendships, the families that went quiet, that smiled through everything, that never said the hard thing. Those were the ones that slowly fell apart. Because conflict isn't the opposite of closeness. Avoidance is when someone cares enough to say the hard thing, that's not a threat to the relationship. That's two people trusting each other enough, to be honest. That's intimacy, that's real connection. And you can't have that if one person is always staying quiet to keep the peace. So the goal isn't to never have conflict. The goal is to learn how to move through it in a way that brings you closer, not further apart. So how do you actually do it?

How To Speak Up In The Moment

Jessica N. Davis 7:39

Because knowing conflict isn't the enemy doesn't automatically make it easier to speak up. I had a client once who wanted so badly to start having hard conversations. They knew they needed to. They knew what it was costing them. But every time they tried, they cried. And the moment the tears came, the conversation stopped being about what they needed to say. It became about calming them down and making sure they were okay. And what they were actually dying to express got completely lost. When we dug into it together, something became really clear. The reason it felt so overwhelming, the reason it came out with that much emotion was because they had been holding it for so long. By the time they finally said something, it wasn't just one thing anymore. It was everything all at once. So one of the most important things I can tell you is this say it in the moment, not when you've rehearsed it perfectly, not when the moment feels exactly right in the moment. Because the longer you hold it, the heavier it gets. And the heavier it gets, the harder it is to say exactly what you want. Rip off the band-aid. Don't sit with it, don't wait on it, just release it. And when you do, use I statements, not hey, you always do this or you never listen or you make me feel invisible, because that will create defensiveness in the other person. But it's saying, I feel unheard when you're on your phone during dinner, or I feel hurt when I'm trying to have a serious conversation with you, but you turn to jokes. It doesn't have to come out perfect. It just has to be honest and it has to be about how you feel, not about what they did. When someone doesn't feel attacked, they're a whole lot more likely to actually hear you. So what does it look like when you finally start confronting

What Changes When You Use Your Voice

Jessica N. Davis 9:22

hard conversations? Because I think when we're deep in the habit of staying quiet, it's hard to even picture what it would look like to say what's on your mind. So let me paint that picture. You share how you feel, even when you're not sure if it will be received well. You finally ask the questions that have been swirling around your head, the ones that never made it out. You show up authentically, vulnerably, true to yourself. Not the version of you that has been choosing peace over sanity, the one with opinions, boundaries, curiosity, the one who feels things deeply and isn't afraid to say so. And you stop carrying the weight of everyone's feelings at the cost of your own. Because that's what silence does when it goes on long enough. It pulls you under slowly, quietly, until you've forgotten what it felt like to just breathe. Speaking up is how you come up for air. Remember my client that I was talking about earlier, the one who spent years going along to get along? Once she started speaking up, she told me something I haven't forgotten. She said she didn't realize how exhausting it was to manage everyone else's comfort at the expense of her own. You deserve relationships where you don't have to go under to keep everyone else afloat, where your voice belongs in the room, where the people around you get to know the fullest version of who you are. That version exists and it starts with one honest conversation.

Core Takeaways And Listener Requests

Jessica N. Davis 10:45

So here's what I want you to walk away with. Staying quiet has never been the safe choice. It's felt safe and even looked safe, but underneath the surface, it's been pulling you away from the relationships you want, the life you want, the version of yourself that you actually want to be. Your voice isn't a burden. It's the most honest thing about you. And the people who deserve to be in your life won't leave it because you used it. If anything, they'll finally get to meet you. So the next time you feel those butterflies, the tightness in your chest, that pull to just let it go, remember what letting it go has actually been costing you and say it anyway. If this episode hit home, I would love it if you would take a second to leave a review. It helps more people find this show. And honestly, it means everything to know that people feel supported by this show. And if someone in your life needs to hear this, share this episode with them. Remember, go download the anxiety survival toolkit in the show notes. It's free and you definitely won't be disappointed. Until next time, keep moving forward. Trust yourself, and never forget you have what it takes to block out the noise.