You Two Scare Me Podcast | A Paranormal Podcast
What happens when two best friends who are working moms with a decade of friendship and a deep love of all things spooky — finally start the paranormal podcast they've been talking about forever? You get You Two Scare Me Podcast, a show that's equal parts chilling, hilarious, and genuinely thought-provoking.
Hosts Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews are self-described silly, spooky girls with a serious respect for the unknown. Each episode, they dive into haunted history, ghost stories, cryptids, UFO encounters, urban legends, and unexplained phenomena — researching deeply, surprising each other with what they find, and laughing their faces off along the way.
From the haunted streets of Key West, Florida to ancient mythology, cursed objects, and real listener encounters, Andi and Feliz bring you stories that make you question what you think you know — and maybe leave the light on at night.
Every episode features:
- Deep-dive research into paranormal history, folklore, and supernatural events
- Real listener ghost stories in the "Somebody Told Me" segment — because your experiences deserve to be heard
- Genuine curiosity, warmth, and a whole lot of laughter to keep it light through the dark stuff
Whether you're a lifelong paranormal enthusiast or just starting to get curious about what lurks beyond the light, You Two Scare Me meets you where you are. No gatekeeping. No pretense. Just two friends who love this stuff and want to share it with you.
New episodes drop every Tuesday. Subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts.
You Two Scare Me Podcast | A Paranormal Podcast
The Most Haunted Seaside Town in America: Cape May, New Jersey's Ghost Stories
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
What if almost every building in your favorite beach town had a ghost? Welcome to Cape May, New Jersey, one of America's oldest seaside resorts and, according to paranormal researchers, its most haunted.
Hosts Andi and Feliz trade Key West sunshine for the Victorian streets of Cape May, where two centuries of history, a catastrophic fire, and generations of devoted vacationers have left more than memories behind.
This episode covers:
- Hotel Macomber's Room 10 — A loyal guest named Irene Wright checked in every summer for decades. She still does. Staff and guests report moving furniture, slamming doors, a trunk dragging up the stairs at night — and a captured EVP of a woman's voice saying "I'm still here."
- Congress Hall — Burned twice, rebuilt twice. Today guests report phantom children, a mournful "Watery Spirit" who leaves puddles behind, and full-body apparitions in 18th-century dress.
- The Southern Mansion — Esther Allen ran a Prohibition-era speakeasy here and clearly never wanted to leave. Guests report gardenia perfume, rustling petticoats, and Esther spotted dancing in the gardens.
- The Emlen Physick Estate — The most haunted building in Cape May, home to three generations of spirits — and ghost dogs.
Cape May's hauntings aren't about tragedy. They're about love — and the places we love so much, we never want to leave.
📬 Send us your paranormal stories: youtwoscaremepodcast@gmail.com 🌐 youtwoscaremepodcast.com 📱 TikTok @youtwoscaremepodcast, Instagram @youtwoscareme_podcast & Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast
Join our Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/cw/YouTwoScareMePodcast
You Two Scare Me is a paranormal and folklore podcast hosted by Feliz and Andi, recording from Key West, Florida. For entertainment purposes only.
Visit our Socials!
Instagram: @youtwoscareme_podcast
Facebook: You Two Scare Me Podcast
TikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast