You Two Scare Me Podcast | A Paranormal Podcast
What happens when two best friends who are working moms with a decade of friendship and a deep love of all things spooky — finally start the paranormal podcast they've been talking about forever? You get You Two Scare Me Podcast, a show that's equal parts chilling, hilarious, and genuinely thought-provoking.
Hosts Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews are self-described silly, spooky girls with a serious respect for the unknown. Each episode, they dive into haunted history, ghost stories, cryptids, UFO encounters, urban legends, and unexplained phenomena — researching deeply, surprising each other with what they find, and laughing their faces off along the way.
From the haunted streets of Key West, Florida to ancient mythology, cursed objects, and real listener encounters, Andi and Feliz bring you stories that make you question what you think you know — and maybe leave the light on at night.
Every episode features:
- Deep-dive research into paranormal history, folklore, and supernatural events
- Real listener ghost stories in the "Somebody Told Me" segment — because your experiences deserve to be heard
- Genuine curiosity, warmth, and a whole lot of laughter to keep it light through the dark stuff
Whether you're a lifelong paranormal enthusiast or just starting to get curious about what lurks beyond the light, You Two Scare Me meets you where you are. No gatekeeping. No pretense. Just two friends who love this stuff and want to share it with you.
New episodes drop every Tuesday. Subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts.
Episodes
68 episodes
Route 66 Ghost Stories: Haunted Hotels, Cryptids, and Unexplained Lights Along America's Mother Road
This episode takes you on a haunted Route 66 road trip through six states, covering the most documented paranormal hotspots on America's most legendary highway. From the suicide-plagued Lemp Mansion in St. Louis to the cryptid sightings of Momo...
La Isla de las Muñecas: The Haunted Island of Dolls, a Drowned Girl & 50 Years of Obsession
This week. we are taking you somewhere you won't soon forget — deep into the ancient canals of Xochimilco, just south of Mexico City, to uncover the chilling story of La Isla de las Muñecas: The Island of the Dolls.Thousands of de...
Haunted Amusement Parks: Cedar Point, Chernobyl, and the Ghost Children Who Never Got to Ride
Haunted amusement parks, abandoned theme parks, and paranormal activity at some of the most famous and terrifying amusement parks in the world — this episode of You Two Scare Me Podcast covers ghost sightings, unexplained phenomena, and dark hi...
Don't Go Back in the Woods: Real Bigfoot Encounters
Summer should mean s'mores, stargazing, and sleeping under the stars. Unless you're one of the unlucky people in today's episode — because for them, the woods had very different plans.In this episode of You Two Scare Me, your favorite pa...
Haunted Summer Camps | The Ghost of Big Moose Lake, Johnny Sweetheart, and the Girl at Moon Lake
A third of summer camps in America have banned ghost stories. But the ghosts were already there — in the lake, on the shore, in the mist over the water — long before anyone invented a story to tell in the dark.In this episode, we're divi...
The Most Haunted Seaside Town in America: Cape May, New Jersey's Ghost Stories
What if almost every building in your favorite beach town had a ghost? Welcome to Cape May, New Jersey, one of America's oldest seaside resorts and, according to paranormal researchers, its most haunted.Hosts Andi and Feliz trade Key Wes...
Duendes, Lost Children, and the Spirit of the Amazon | You Two Scare Me Podcast
Four children survived 40 days alone in the Colombian Amazon after a deadly plane crash — and the indigenous searchers who found them believe a forest spirit called the duende had been hiding them all along. In this episode, Feliz and Andi dig ...
The Green Children of Woolpit: Medieval Mystery or Alien Encounter?
Dive into the shadows with Andi and Feliz on the You Two Scare Me Podcast as they unravel the baffling tale of the Green Children of Woolpit. This medieval mystery from 12th-century Suffolk, England, recounts the sudden appearance of two childr...
Mother's Day Ghost Stories: The Ubume, Crybaby Bridges, and the Paranormal Power of a Mother's Love
Mother's Day ghost stories, maternal grief folklore, and paranormal legends about mothers who refused to stop loving their children even after death — that's what we're diving into in this special Mother's Day episode of the You Two Scare Me Po...
Dead Children's Playground: The True Haunting Inside Alabama's Most Terrifying Cemetery Park
What could be more innocent than a playground? Tucked against the edge of one of Alabama's oldest and largest cemeteries sits a park so notoriously haunted that locals have given it a name that sends chills down your spine: the Dead Children's ...
The Uncanny Connection Between Twins | Telepathy, Shared Dreams & the Mystery of the Eller Twins
Do twins share a psychic bond? Can identical twins sense each other’s pain, finish each other’s thoughts, or even know when something is wrong from miles away? In this eerie and thought-provoking episode, we explore the uncanny connection be...
Tahoe Tessie: America's Most Mysterious Lake Monster
What's hiding more than 1,600 feet beneath the surface of Lake Tahoe? In this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz dive deep into the legend of Tahoe Tessie — one of America's most compelling and least-talked-about lake monst...
Witchcraft Then vs Now: Salem Trials, Dark History, and the Rise of Modern Manifestation
Witchcraft history, Salem witch trials, and modern manifestation practices collide in this deep dive into one of the most controversial and misunderstood topics in paranormal history. From medieval witch hunts and mass hysteria to TikTok witchc...
Goddess of the Dawn: The Pagan Roots of Spring, Easter, and the Rituals You Still Practice Today
Did you know Easter is named after a pagan goddess? That the Easter Bunny has a mythological origin involving a wounded bird, a divine transformation, and a punishment written in the stars? That the world's most powerful ancient religious rite ...
Seasonal Paranormal Phenomena Explained | Evil Eye, Cryptids & Global Folklore
Seasonal paranormal activity, spring folklore, and global spiritual rituals take center stage as we explore springtime supernatural traditions, evil eye cleansing (limpias), cryptids, shapeshifters, and increased spirit activity across cultu...
The Devil at the Door: The Terrifying Haunting of Loftus Hall
In this bone-chilling episode, Andi and Feliz travel to the windswept Hook Peninsula in County Wexford, Ireland, to explore the dark legacy of Loftus Hall—widely considered the most haunted house in Ireland.We dive deep into the 1766 leg...
Irish Creatures: Leprechauns, Irish Werewolves, Vampire Legends, Selkies & the Púca
What if the creatures of Irish folklore were never meant to be cute at all?In this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, we dig into the darker side of Irish creatures, Irish mythology, and Celtic folklore. Forget the cartoon v...
From the Archives: The Irish Banshee | Celtic Death Omen and Haunted Folklore
In honor of St. Patrick's Day, we’re bringing back one of our favorite episodes from the archives. This chilling dive into the legend of the Irish Banshee explores the eerie Celtic folklore behind the spirit whose scream was said to fore...
The Aos Sí- Ireland's Ancient & Dangerous Fairies
Join Andi and Feliz on this episode as they journey into the mystical and often terrifying world of Irish fairies, or the Aos Sí. Forget the glittery sprites of modern tales; this episode unearths the ancient, darker folklore surrounding these ...
Irish Folklore: The Fetch, Death Omens, and Piseoga
Join Feliz and Andi on the You Two Scare Me Podcast as they explore the mysterious and often unsettling world of Irish folklore. Discover the chilling phenomenon of "the fetch," a spectral double of a living person seen shortly befo...
Spooky Savannah: The Haunted Sorrel-Weed House & The Mirror Ghost
In this haunting episode, Andi and Feliz dive into the dark history of one of America’s most infamous sites: the Sorrel-Weed House in Savannah, Georgia. Built on a Revolutionary War battlefield, this Greek Revival masterpiece hides a legacy ...
Love Spells: The Dark History of Love Magic and Unnatural Compliance
In this special February episode of the You Two Scare Me podcast, hosts Feliz and Andi dive deep into the unsettling world of love spells and love magic. As part of their month-long series on love and the paranormal, the duo explores why the de...
Real Vampires: Historical Panic, Modern Encounters, and the Legend of Jacques St. Germain
Dive into the shadows with Andi and Feliz as they explore the chilling world of vampires. Moving beyond the capes and castles of pop culture, this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast investigates the historical hysteria that once consumed e...
Cursed Love & Paranormal Romance | The Ghosts Who Never Let Go
In this special Valentine's season episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, hosts Feliz and Andi dive deep into the shadows of cursed love stories. From the chilling hallways of the Banff Springs Hotel to the infamous Stull Cemetery, we explore...
Glitches in the Matrix, Simulation Theory, Time Slips, and the Mandela Effect
Show Notes for BuzzsproutIs our reality a simulation? Have you ever seen a car repeat the exact same movement twice? Or checked your phone only to find the time has jumped backward? In this mind-bending episode, Andi and Feliz explor...