06 - Why Your Story Sells More Than Your Strategy

Strategy explains what you do. Story makes people believe it matters. In this episode I explore why your story is the real hook for premium clients - and why credentials or frameworks alone rarely win trust.

You’ll learn:

 ✔️ How your origin story makes clients buy into your reason, not just your service
 ✔️ Why detailed transformation stories cut through more than vague testimonials
 ✔️ How micro stories - small, human details - stick and build connection faster than polished pitches

Clients want results, but in the premium space, they also want to feel trust, excitement, and safety. Story delivers those feelings long before they’ve experienced your service. 

This week, your challenge is simple: stop polishing your pitch and share one story. Watch how differently people respond.

Want more? Join the VIP feed.
Get instant access to my free VIP podcast at elevateyourbusinesspodcast.com

That’s where the good stuff lives - behind-the-scenes strategy calls with real clients, bonus episodes packed with tips, and insights I don’t share anywhere else.

Join today and start building a business that feels as good as it looks on paper.

💡 Loved this episode? I’d love to hear your thoughts.
👉 Share your feedback or leave me a voice note HERE.

And if you’re ready to take these strategies further, explore free resources and mentoring programmes at https://www.aster.academy/

Hit Follow so you never miss a new episode of Elevate Your Business.

Transcript

Welcome to Elevate Your Business, the show for ambitious entrepreneurs who want to raise their game, work with premium clients and build a business that feels as good as it looks on paper. I'm Sarah, business mentor, strategist and a firm believer that you don't have to hustle harder to earn more, you just need to think differently. Each week we'll dive into the mindset, marketing and strategies that will help you grow with intention so you can have the income, impact and freedom you started this business for.

So today I want to talk about story. I'm a keen storyteller and a story reader so I love doing anything to do with stories but I don't want to talk about the tidy paragraph that you might have tucked away on your about me page and definitely not the very carefully polished LinkedIn summary that makes you sound vaguely human but really just lists your credentials. I want to talk about the story that's running underneath everything you do. 

So a lot of entrepreneurs hide behind strategy and they think if I can just make my framework sound airtight, if I can just outline the steps clearly enough people will buy and sometimes they do but premium clients aren't choosing you because you've got a better five-step process than the person down the road. They're choosing you because your story resonates because something about the way you tell it makes them feel this is my person and I see this constantly in the tutoring world which has been my world for the last few years and you can have two tutors with identical qualifications and track records and both can be absolutely brilliant at their craft and both are great at getting students into top schools but one presents themselves like a CV in human form so that's grades, results, methodology and the other one says something like I know how daunting it feels to sit those exams because I remember exactly what it was like walking into a room full of strangers at 11 years old completely overwhelmed and that's why I teach the way I do to make students feel capable and not crushed. So guess which one gets remembered and who wins trust faster? It is not the strategy that hooks people in, it's the story and this isn't just education. 

If you look at some of the brands that dominate like Patagonia and there's been lots written about them, they don't just sell jackets, they sell a story about protecting the planet. Same with Apple, they don't just sell laptops and iPads, they sell a story about creativity and rebellion and thinking differently. So the product is part of it obviously but it's the story that makes people line up outside a shop at midnight for something they technically don't need and the same applies when you're trying to position yourself in a premium market. 

Strategy on its own is cold, it's story that warms it up. The strategy explains what you do and the story makes people believe that it matters. So how can you use story and practise? I want to give you three ways that actually work. 

The first one is your origin story. So why are you here? Why do you do this work? Premium clients in particular they're not just buying your service, they're buying into your reason for doing it. So maybe you started because you were frustrated with how things were done, maybe you wanted to create the thing you wished you'd had yourself. 

Whatever it is, tell it and the more human you can make it, the more powerful it's going to be. The second is crystal clear client transformation stories and I don't mean vague testimonials that say Sarah was lovely to work with, I mean that's nice but it's wallpaper. What cuts through is the arc. 

So where did that client begin? What was the struggle? What shifted? And what does life look like for them now? The more detail you can give, the more believable it feels. And the third one is micro stories. These are the tiny often throwaway details that actually stick, which could be, and I've mentioned this before in an episode, the postcard that you send to a student before their exam, the conversation you had with the parent that changed the way you framed your work, or the one time you ignored your own advice and learned the hard way.

These little stories don't take a huge amount of time to tell but they make you real and when you're real, people remember you. Okay, I just want to pause for a moment here because you might be thinking, well Sarah, my clients don't care about me, they just want results. And that is partly true, they do want results. 

But in the premium space, results aren't enough on their own. They also want to feel something, they want to feel safe, they want to feel that they can trust you, they also want to feel a sense of excitement in you and they want to feel confident in your abilities to support them. And your story is the fastest way to deliver that feeling before they've even experienced your service. 

Think about it this way, and I'm going to give a book analogy because I am a keen reader. So when you sit down to buy a book, or when you stand up even to buy a book, do you read every single sentence on the back cover or do you skim a few lines and make a snap decision based on whether the story feels like one you want to enter? Well, one thing to bear in mind is that your clients are doing the same thing with you and they're looking for a story that feels like theirs. So here's my challenge for you this week. 

I want you to stop obsessing over polishing the perfect strategy pitch and instead, just for this week, find one story that you can tell. It might be why you started, it might be a transformation that you have witnessed, it might be something small and ordinary that shows what you value. But I want you to tell that story and watch how differently people respond. 

Because strategy teaches absolutely, but story is what connects and connection is what sells at a premium level. Thanks for tuning in to Elevate Your Business. If you loved what you heard today, the conversation doesn't stop here. 

Head over to elevateyourbusinesspodcast.co.uk and sign up for my free VIP podcast feed. Don't worry, the link is also in the show notes. That's where the good stuff lives. 

Behind the scenes strategy calls with real clients, bonus episodes packed with tips and insights I don't share anywhere else. It's completely free and you'll get instant access to exclusive content that will help you work smarter, think bigger and build a business you truly love. I'll see you inside there.