Reproductively Speaking
Parenthood is messy, beautiful, exhausting, and transformative - sometimes all before breakfast.
Each episode, join Taryn Zweygardt, therapist and certified perinatal mental health specialist, for real and relatable conversations about the challenges and joys of parenthood. From identity shifts to mental health struggles, you’ll hear deep, honest talks, expert guidance, and inspiring stories that remind you - you're NOT alone.
Reproductively Speaking is here to help you nurture your mind, your relationships, and yourself, one episode at a time.
Connect with Taryn on Instagram @tztherapy
Learn more about working with Taryn: https://www.tztherapy.com
Reproductively Speaking
11. Mothers Without Joy: The Scrutiny That Hasn’t Gone Away
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Recently, I came across a 1963 magazine article titled “Mothers Without Joy.” As someone who LOVES thrifting and antiquing, I’ve always been drawn to old books and magazines. But…this one stopped me in my tracks.
The language was for sure dated, but the themes? Unsettlingly familiar. It felt like reading something written about today.
The article dove into "illegitimate babies”, and how pregnancy outside of marriage was viewed as a social and moral crisis. The burden of shame? It fell almost entirely on women.
Motherhood itself wasn’t the issue - unapproved motherhood was. While our language has changed today, the scrutiny is still very present.
History reveals what changing language can often conceal: women have long been evaluated on "mothering". What mothers needed in 1963, and what mothers need now, is NOT moral evaluation. We need support, autonomy, and compassion!
I mean…how different would motherhood look like in our world today, if it was met with care, instead of judgment?
Episode Recap:
- What a 1963 article titled “Mothers Without Joy” truly reveals
- How the term “illegitimate” highlights how deeply motherhood was regulated by marriage, age, class & race
- How the burden of shame & consequence historically fell almost ENTIRELY on women
- Why modern motherhood is still categorized into “acceptable” and “unacceptable” paths
- Why women continue to internalize cultural messages about motherhood & blame themselves
- The unfortunate common thread of motherhood today (regardless of your path there)
- Why the scrutiny of motherhood looks different now, but still carries so much
- What mothers have needed decades ago (and need now, more than ever)
**Disclaimer: The content shared in this podcast is for educational and informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for therapy or mental health care. If you’re struggling or need support, please reach out to a licensed mental health professional in your area, because you don’t have to go through it alone.
Links/Resources:
- Follow on Instagram @tztherapy
- Check out my website