The 5-Letter System That Closes at 7x the Rate of a Cold Call

Your clients will give you a referral reluctantly. They'll give you an introduction enthusiastically — but only if you give them the right story to tell. 

Most producers are sitting on their single greatest pipeline asset and never touching it: their existing book of business. 

In this episode, Randy Schwantz breaks down SODAR — a five-letter system that transforms your best client from "sure, I'll mention your name" into a champion who pre-sells you before you walk in the door. Introductions built this way close at seven times the rate of a cold call. If your pipeline still depends on strangers saying yes, this episode changes that. 

If this episode was helpful, share it with a producer or agency leader who needs it. 

 Get more insights like this every week:
 👉 Subscribe to the podcast & blog: https://thewedge.net

Transcript

[00:00:00] Hey, I wanna tell you about a flight I took a few years back. Um, I'm in the window seat, my head is down. I'm avoiding eye contact at all costs. I, I don't [00:00:10] talk to strangers on airplanes very much, but the lady who sits down next to me, man, she catches me off guard. Completely. Smart. Funny, I mean, one of [00:00:20] the most interesting conversations that I'd had in months, and we were only about 10 minutes into the flight.

Now, here's my question. For every insurance producer listening to this. [00:00:30] At the end of the flight, would you refer her to your brother? Hand her a business card and say, Hey, call him. He's a great guy. [00:00:40] Of course not. You had introduced them. You'd call your brother that night. You'd tell 'em the whole story.

You'd set up dinner, you'd make sure they actually [00:00:50] met. See, there's a world of difference between a referral and an introduction. A referral is handing someone a card and [00:01:00] wishing them luck. An introduction is a personal endorsement, a compelling story, and a really warm handoff all in one. [00:01:10] See your, your clients will do referrals reluctantly.

They'll do introductions enthusiastically if [00:01:20] you give them the right story to tell and show them exactly how to do it. And that is what Red Hot Introductions is and is the reason the best producers [00:01:30] who want to grow their book of business in the commercial insurance world have not made a cold call in years.

Before this episode is over, I'm going to give [00:01:40] you a five letter system that takes your best client from, sure. I'll mention you to, you need to sit down with this person, [00:01:50] and it closes at seven times the rate of a cold call, so stay with me.

So welcome to the Agency Growth Machine podcast. I'm Randy Schwarz. Six episodes in and [00:02:00] we built the complete selling system. You find the prospect, you prepare to them win. You run the wedge, you lock the deal in place. And protect what you've won. [00:02:10] But none of that matters if your pipeline runs dry. And today we talk about where the best accounts actually come from, [00:02:20] and it's not where most producers are looking.

So let's go. Here's a truth that will frustrate you and also liberate you at the [00:02:30] same time. See your single greatest asset as a commercial insurance producer. The thing most likely to get you in front of your next great [00:02:40] account. It's already in your possession. It's your existing client base. Every client you know, [00:02:50] knows other business owners, and some of them are exactly the kind of accounts that you want.

They go to the same industry [00:03:00] events. They sit on the same boards. They play golf together, they have lunch together. They trust each other. And not a single one of them [00:03:10] is to call you out of the blue sky and say, Hey, my buddy needs a new insurance agent. Here's his number. They have to be asked. [00:03:20] They have to be prepared.

And most producers never do either. And why not? Well, there's five reasons and I want to go through all of five of them [00:03:30] because until you recognize the mental barrier that is stopping you. You'll keep making cold calls and wondering why the results. Well, they're mediocre. [00:03:40] So, barrier number one, the fear of losing the annuity.

See you. You built a great relationship with your client, and the last thing you [00:03:50] wanna do is ask for something and have it feel awkward, so you protect the revenue stream by never pushing the relationship and the irony [00:04:00] not asking, leaves the relationship shallower than it could be. Barrier Number two, you don't feel like you've earned [00:04:10] it.

See, deep down, you know you haven't done anything particularly remarkable for this client. You show up at renewal, you check the coverage, you provide a [00:04:20] price. That's reactive service, and somewhere in the back of your mind, you know you haven't done enough to deserve an introduction to their best [00:04:30] relationships.

And the fix. Well go back to episode five, written service timeline. Give them a reason to brag about you. [00:04:40] Barrier number three, you don't want to look needy or greedy. Say you're driving a nice car, the [00:04:50] kids are in private school. You belong to a really nice country club, and the last thing you want is for your client to think you need to hustle for leads.[00:05:00] 

So you don't ask, you act like business just comes to you, and sometimes it does, but most of the time it doesn't. Barrier number [00:05:10] four, no compelling reason to ask. You don't have a growth goal. You don't have a vision for your book. Everything feels [00:05:20] stable enough. Yeah, you'd like more business, but you don't need it bad enough to do something about it.

And this is the slow death of a producer's [00:05:30] career. And then barrier number five, you simply don't know how. I mean, nobody ever taught you cold calling is uncomfortable, but at least you know [00:05:40] how to do it. Asking for introductions feels awkward and unpredictable, so you default to what you know, even though it produces worse results.[00:05:50] 

So read back through those five bearers and let me tell you which ones to apply to you, but be honest. Because here's what they all have in common. [00:06:00] Every single one of them is inside your own head. Not one of them is a limitation your client put on you. Your clients want to help you. Most of 'em do anyway.

[00:06:10] They just need a reason, a system, and a script. And that's what the rest of this episode gives you.

I'm gonna tell you about Jack Wilder, the number [00:06:20] one salesperson at IBM. When IBM was the most dominant company on earth, and the single practice had put him at the top. But first, the [00:06:30] system

The foundation of red hot introductions is a simple idea that sounds almost too basic to be powerful. You are right now. Only one or [00:06:40] two degrees of separation from almost any business owner in your market.

One of your clients knows them, or one of your clients knows someone who knows them. [00:06:50] The connection exists, you just haven't mapped it out. Six degrees of separation is the concept that you are only six connecting steps from [00:07:00] anyone on earth in your city or region. In the commercial insurance market you serve, the number is closer to one, maybe two.

So here's the [00:07:10] first step of the Red Hot Introduction system. Build your top 20 hit list, not a list of everyone you'd like to meet someday. A list of exactly 20 accounts [00:07:20] sized and profiled that you want to win in the next 12 to 24 months. Named specific with a projected commission [00:07:30] attached to each one.

And then print that list, put it somewhere visible, because the moment you have a specific target, you start seeing connections everywhere you weren't [00:07:40] seeing before. Which brings me to Jack Wilder. Jack was the number one salesperson at IBM in the [00:07:50] 1970s, twice. Put that in context. IBM in the seventies was as dominant as any company has ever been in any industry.

The [00:08:00] number one person on that Salesforce was the best of the best. And I asked him What, what was the secret? And he said it was simple. He made a poster of [00:08:10] his top 20 prospects and hung it on the outside of his cubicle. Listen to what I'm saying to you. Every day, more than 150 colleagues walked by that poster.

People would [00:08:20] stop, glance at and say, Hey, Jack, I know someone at that company. You want me to make a call? He didn't cold call his way to, number one, he made [00:08:30] his targets visible to his network and let his network work for him. And that's the whole concept. Make your targets known, [00:08:40] map the connections, and then give your introduction source exactly what they need to open the door.

And that's where SODAR comes in. [00:08:50] See, here's the problem with most referrals, even the well-intentioned ones. Your client calls their buddy and says, Hey, I've got a great insurance agent. You should talk to him. He's done a really good [00:09:00] job for me. Here's his number, and the buddy thinks Great, another insurance agent, and then he doesn't call.

Why? [00:09:10] Because your client didn't give him a reason to call. They basically gave 'em a card, not a story. And the story is what moves people to action. A [00:09:20] compelling story about a real result creates, well, desire. A desire to have the result for themselves. And so are is how you help your client [00:09:30] tell that story.

It's an acronym, five letters, walk your introduction source through all five, and they stop being a referral machine. They become a champion for you. [00:09:40] S stands for situation. What was the client's situation when you first started working together? High experience [00:09:50] mod, claims weren't being managed, only saw their agent renewal.

Get them to describe the problem in their own words and then O for opportunity. [00:10:00] How did you come into the picture? Were you introduced by someone else? Did they hear you speak? Had you stayed in touch over time? I mean, this stuff reminds your [00:10:10] client how the relationship started and it builds the narrative.

And then D, for decision, what pushed them over the [00:10:20] edge to hire you? Was it your proposal, your specific service timeline, a reference you provided? Help them pinpoint the moment they [00:10:30] decided to make a change, and then what were the prevailing reasons that led to that? Then A for action, what have [00:10:40] you done since they hired you?

Walk them through the specific proactive services you've delivered. The quarterly claims review, the experience mod analysis, the midyear coverage check. [00:10:50] Help them. Remember the ongoing proof

and then R for result, and this is the most important letter. [00:11:00] What is the quantified outcome? How much did their X mod drop? How many dollars did they save? [00:11:10] How much worry was eliminated? Make them name a number. And a story without a result is just a conversation. So when your client [00:11:20] has walked through sodar, when they can tell that story, start to finish, they're no longer referring you.

They are endorsing you. And there's a fundamental [00:11:30] difference. A referral says, here's someone you should call. An endorsement says, here's what happened to me. Here's what it meant to my business. [00:11:40] And here's why you need to sit down with this person. Now let me show you how the whole process comes together.

So step one, identify the target. Look at your client and [00:11:50] think who do they know that is on your top 20 list, or who could they connect or introduce you to? And then you, Hey John, I [00:12:00] know you and Bill over at Lakeside Manufacturing go way back. You know, he's someone I'd really like to meet. Would you be willing to set up a lunch or breakfast for the three of us?[00:12:10] 

And of course with a few exceptions, John will say, yeah. And now the challenge, what is John going to say to Bill? So if John calls Bill and says, Hey, [00:12:20] I've got an insurance agent. I want you to meet, he's a nice guy. Bill's not excited, he's polite. And there's a difference. So before John makes that call, you [00:12:30] walk him through sodar, you help him build that story.

You make sure that when Bill picks up the phone, he hears something like this. This is coming from John. [00:12:40] Hey Bill. I wanna set up lunch with you and my insurance guy. Three years ago, my workers' comp was a mess. I had no idea why it kept going up. [00:12:50] This guy came in, did claims review with us, identified really four reserves that were running way too high, and then when he got those things reduced and over the next two [00:13:00] renewals, my modifier dropped way over eight points.

Yeah, that's real money on my bottom line every year. I think you should meet 'em. Now, [00:13:10] that's not a referral, that's a prospect asking for a meeting before you ever introduce yourself. So Bill calls John back and says, well, when are we doing lunch? [00:13:20] Because Bill has a workers' comp problem too, every business owner does.

So that is a Red Hot introduction, the warmest possible entry into a sales meeting you will ever have. [00:13:30] And here's what makes it self enforcing. Walking your client through SODAR doesn't just prepare them to introduce you. It reminds them [00:13:40] out loud in their own words of every reason they made the right decision by hiring you.

It's the single most powerful retention tool and prospecting tool combined [00:13:50] into one conversation.

So here's a math that should bother every producer still building their pipeline through cold calls. [00:14:00] Cold call closing rates and commercial insurance average somewhere between say, one and 3% the best, maybe as high as five to 8% red [00:14:10] hot introduction, closing rates.

When the introduction is properly prepared through sodar. It's enormously high. So you save time invested [00:14:20] and a completely different outcome. Because a cold prospect is a stranger evaluating where to give you their time. A red hot introduction [00:14:30] is a warm prospect who has already heard your story and decided they want to meet you.

The best producers I've ever worked with, the ones writing seven figure [00:14:40] books figured this out early. They stopped spending their energy trying to convince strangers and started investing in deepening the relationships that they already had. [00:14:50] And their clients well became the sales force. The results became the pitch, and their time went from grinding cold calls to sitting [00:15:00] across from pre-sold prospects who already knew what they wanted.

So your five letter system, S-O-D-A-R, situation, opportunity, decision, action, result. [00:15:10] Pick your best client this week, walk them through all five. Ask them to set up launch with one person on your top 20 list. The one conversation could be worth more to your book than [00:15:20] six months of cold calling.

And next week is crisp. The sales meeting system that the best agencies in the country use to build producer confidence, sharpen [00:15:30] their weapons, and hold their teams accountable. Week in and week out. If your sales meetings feel like a waste of time, I call [00:15:40] 'em spreadsheet liars Club meetings. Then this episode is going to change that.

So subscribe, share this with your sales manager, but before you leave, think about this. [00:15:50] Commercial insurance selling is going through three eras, and right now, today, you and your agency are living in one of them. Era number one, I call [00:16:00] selling 1.0. And this is how your daddy did it or your granddaddy did it.

Three by five cards, yellow pages, a metal box on a wooden desk. The strategy, quote it, [00:16:10] price it. Hope you win it. No system, no processes, no differentiation. Just whoever had the lowest number on renewal day. Then era two is what I [00:16:20] call selling 2.0, and that's when Salesforce and HubSpot and Pipedrive all had big promises, big beautiful dashboards, enterprise grade, everything.[00:16:30] 

But do you know what it actually produced? Well, a pipeline report your manager could pull on Friday. That's it. The [00:16:40] training lived in a binder. The technology lived on a browser and they never talked to each other. Meanwhile, the incumbent already had their relationship, already knew the account, and [00:16:50] always got last look.

Selling 2.0 was about relationship building, consultative selling along with generic technology that slowed things down more [00:17:00] than it sped things up. And what it never gave producers was the system to win and grow a huge book of business. [00:17:10] And then era three, selling 3.0. And this is Bignition. It's one integrated sales operating system where the methodology is the technology.

And [00:17:20] the technology is the methodology. Seven steps, one platform goals tied to real life. Differentiation, you can prove. Appointment [00:17:30] setting that's systematic, not random pre-call strategy that's built to displace an incumbent, not just have a nice conversation. A selling process anchored on [00:17:40] one brutal truth, no one else will say.

The incumbent has to lose for you to win. And retention backed by documented [00:17:50] deliverables, not vague, abstract promises and results. Well measured at every level. Three eras, [00:18:00] three tools, three completely different games. 1.0. Beat the price 2.0, build the relationship 3.0 and listen to [00:18:10] this. Engineer the displacement.

Run the system. Win the account. An agency stuck in 1.0 or being commoditized. The [00:18:20] agency stuck in 2.0 are working harder and wondering why nothing sticks. An agency's running 3.0. Well, they're compounding every year, every [00:18:30] producer, every account that's selling 3.0, that's Bignition. So come find us, and if you like this, leave a review.

I'm [00:18:40] Randy Schwantz, go lock your deals in place and I'll see you next week.