Push Pull Health

Trick R Treat: Fitness Myths That Refuse To Die

Ben Davis Season 1 Episode 32

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:20:56

What does your rotten health attitude struggle with most?

Start with the noise and jokes, stay for the clarity. We’re taking a scalpel to the health and fitness myths people keep running into —from GLP-1 panic to the 6 pm food curfew —and giving you the simple playbook that actually holds up. First up: GLP-1s like Wegovy and Ozempic don’t “melt muscle.” Rapid weight loss on a low-protein diet does. If your appetite goes down and you eat less of the same low-protein meals, you risk losing lean mass. 

The fix is straightforward: keep protein high, strength train 2 to 3 times per week, and add fibre so you can stick to the plan.

Next, we crack the late-night eating myth. Calories at 9 pm are still calories. The real problem is behaviour: TV, wine, snacks, and decision fatigue. Some people even adhere better to more evening carbs when total calories are matched. Use a time window if it helps curb the 9 pm spiral, but don’t let a clock bully you. Then we take on sugar “addiction.” Your brain lights up with sugar, but it also lights up with hugs. That’s not the clinical definition of addiction. Ultra-palatable foods are engineered to be easy to overeat. The practical move is less demonising and more structured: protein-forward meals, fibre for fullness, treats without moral drama, and fewer opportunities to mindlessly graze.

We also address fears of insulin and fructose. 

No, you can’t store fat in a chronic calorie deficit because insulin “traps” it there. Fructose in fruit is not a poison; context and total energy matter. 

Spot reduction? Still a myth. Crunches build ab endurance, not selective fat loss. You’ll get a slimmer waist with a steady calorie deficit, lifting to keep muscle, and movement you can repeat all week. Breakfast myths fade too: your metabolism never shuts off, and meal frequency doesn’t stoke anything special. 

Finally, we wind down with a tight review of Trick' R Treat, a cult Halloween favourite whose rules are actually memorable: wear a costume, respect the jack-o’-lantern, and check your sweets. If only diet advice were that tidy. Until then, here’s what is: energy balance, protein, fibre, strength training, steps, and sleep. 

Enjoyed this? Follow, rate, and share with a friend who loves a good myth takedown. 

With a temper as short as her legs, Fiona joins Ben every week to forcefully "Push Your Health From The Pulls Of Life."

Expect Foul-mouthed narcissistic ramblings on fitness, nutrition, film, and life's daily rot. 

This weekly audio & video expansion on the world-famous 'The Daily (ish) Rot' email and video ramblings also includes: 

Usefully Useless Fitness and Diet Advice.
Half-arsed film reviews.
The exploitation of children.
True Crime recommendations.
Nutritious leprechaun-inspired recipes (short and to the point)
Narcissistic wisdom. 

WHO THE FU*K ARE WE?

Howdy,

I'm Ben, the only 'health' coach (not a life coach) who allows you to embrace your Rotten attitude towards exercise and nutrition! 

Empowering You to give the middle finger to your yo-yo diet and half-arsed exercise routine in JUST 30 Days! 

Are you sick of yo-yo-ing from one restrictive diet and hideous exercise plan to the next, begging for it to end so you can slip back into old habits? 

Only to start the same rotten cycle again?

YOUR COMPLIMENTARY 30 DAY DIET KICK-UP-THE-ARSER 

Youtube
Instagram
Facebook
Twitter 

Casual Relaunch And Halloween Banter

SPEAKER_04

They're noisy. Next door. I'm assuming they're watching this, so if you don't mind. Keep it down.

SPEAKER_01

Right.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, that's all I can hear.

unknown

Shh.

SPEAKER_03

Oh, I can use my arrow. In session. Okay, that's better. I can use my arrows.

SPEAKER_04

How are we looking on the camera?

SPEAKER_03

Good? Yep.

SPEAKER_04

It looks better though, doesn't it? I think.

SPEAKER_02

Are we are we?

SPEAKER_04

In terms of having the background, it looks better. It looks a little bit more professional.

unknown

Right.

SPEAKER_04

We can worry less about the curtains and the light streaming in.

SPEAKER_03

I never really worried about any at all. Oh, I did. Oh right, okay.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, I worried. Oh, I lost sleep over it. This is quite intense. It is.

SPEAKER_03

It's a bit too intimate for my liking. I like there being space between.

SPEAKER_04

This is new.

SPEAKER_03

Hello.

SPEAKER_04

We're just trying something out. This is a very casual episode.

SPEAKER_03

Legs are touching.

SPEAKER_04

Happy Halloween.

SPEAKER_03

Halloween.

SPEAKER_04

No, it's Halloween.

SPEAKER_03

It's Halloween.

SPEAKER_04

Happy Halloween.

SPEAKER_03

Why?

SPEAKER_04

You tell me.

SPEAKER_02

No, it's Halloween.

SPEAKER_04

Halloween. That's how they were saying it in Trick-A-Treat, the film we were all reviewing today.

SPEAKER_03

Oh. Well, that's a spoiler already, isn't it?

SPEAKER_04

Stateside. Canadians, they all they all say Halloween. There's an O in there for some reason.

SPEAKER_03

Not all. The news reporter said Halloween Halloween. Yeah. But the other guy said Halloween.

SPEAKER_04

Are you sure?

SPEAKER_03

Yep.

SPEAKER_04

Right. Oh.

SPEAKER_03

He's wanting our Julie Norton.

SPEAKER_04

Sorry about that.

SPEAKER_03

You're wrong.

SPEAKER_04

So they don't all say it.

SPEAKER_03

No.

SPEAKER_04

A lot of them say it. Halloween.

SPEAKER_03

But not all.

SPEAKER_04

Anyway.

SPEAKER_01

Right, who are you?

SPEAKER_04

Pushable health. Pushable health. Oh god. Pushable health. I'm Ben. I'm Ben. No, sorry. She's Fiona.

SPEAKER_03

And I'm Ben. And he's Ben.

SPEAKER_04

It's not for effect. It's not, honestly, it's not for effect. It's not.

SPEAKER_03

Corgan.

SPEAKER_04

She's Fiona.

SPEAKER_03

And he's Ben.

SPEAKER_04

And this is pushable health.

SPEAKER_03

Pushing your health from the poses of life.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, nice. What do we go for? Is it the yo-yo diet and the half-assed excise routine? Or is it the finding the form of exercising the stomach? Which one do you prefer?

SPEAKER_02

Half-arse diet.

SPEAKER_04

Okay. So what we do here at Push Well Health is we help you. Empower you. To get rid of. Stop.

SPEAKER_02

Maybe just maybe I've preferred the other one.

SPEAKER_04

I should probably know this. Empowering you to stop yo-yo dieting. No, oh my god. I've genuinely forgot it. Where's my phone? It's out there.

SPEAKER_02

Just do the other one.

SPEAKER_04

We stop yo-yo dieters. And we stop the half-assed exercise in just 30 days. Something along those lines. Or helping you, empowering you, find a form of excise that you can stomach, ideally twice a week, and a diet that you can stick to for longer than 10 minutes. Could be five minutes, could be 15 minutes. 10 works, isn't it? 10 minutes.

SPEAKER_02

10's a good round number.

SPEAKER_04

That's what we do.

SPEAKER_02

Good. That's what you do.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. Yes. It's 99.9% me. And you just do these. This is long, isn't it? Very reducing. But this is fine. This is fine, isn't it? You're allowed to have these intros if you talk about what you do. Who you're trying to help.

SPEAKER_03

Well, yeah, it's it's making me feel a lot more closer to you now since your legs are touching. Makes me feel more involved.

SPEAKER_04

I'm not too sure I could sit here for two hours.

unknown

What?

SPEAKER_04

The last episode was just over two hours.

SPEAKER_02

I'm not sitting like this for two hours. You make all shite.

SPEAKER_04

Right. That's too big. Okay. Okay. I will have a random bald Canadian at some point before 2030 record an intro and an outro.

SPEAKER_03

Oh you said that before, yes.

SPEAKER_04

But until then, we'll just keep doing this.

SPEAKER_03

Yes. Er what we're doing today, Ben? What we're talking about.

SPEAKER_04

Myths.

SPEAKER_03

Oh. What myths?

SPEAKER_04

Trick or treat. Oh. I haven't thought of the episode title.

SPEAKER_02

Why trick or treat? Is this myth a trick or a treat?

SPEAKER_04

Halloween.

SPEAKER_02

Oh, what gave that away?

SPEAKER_04

I don't know. Sorry, I'm thirsty.

SPEAKER_02

What are you dressed up as?

unknown

Lovely.

SPEAKER_04

That's refreshing, isn't it?

SPEAKER_02

Yes, it's the cop, Ben. It's the cop that makes it refreshing. It's a pumpkin. What are you dressed up as today, Ben? Please. I'm confused. You've got ghouls on your head and a few bats.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah. I've got this spooky polo on.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, that is that is nightmarish, to be fair.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, I'm sorry. This was purchased by my nan.

SPEAKER_02

Well. And your pajamas, not trousers. So Batman goes, spooky top.

SPEAKER_04

Just okay, now it's dragging. Jack of all. Now it's dragging. Now we need to move on.

SPEAKER_02

Jack. Jack of all.

SPEAKER_04

We're trying something new, aren't we?

SPEAKER_02

More jobs?

SPEAKER_04

Excuse me. This is the the relaunch, the re-re-re-re-re-relaunch. Is it? Of yes, we I do this every few months, like every episode. And then we just relaunch.

SPEAKER_02

Oh gosh. I didn't realise that.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah.

SPEAKER_02

Okay.

SPEAKER_04

There's a lot of talking from you.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, lots of talking.

SPEAKER_03

We don't like that.

SPEAKER_04

I'm the talent, so I'm trying to conserve my energy. Aren't I? We've had this discussion. So I thought, because a lot of the episodes we've done recently have been based on MNU. So they're a bit more serious. We were trying to take them seriously.

SPEAKER_02

But now it's back.

SPEAKER_04

This is just this is regular push-ball health. This is not in association with MNU. Even though I am soon to be an MNU evidence-based practitioner.

SPEAKER_00

Ooh, extremely.

SPEAKER_04

We might touch upon a couple of controversial topics on this episode. So that's separate. This is just pushbull health. Push poor health.

SPEAKER_02

Pushing your health and pulse of life.

SPEAKER_04

Yes.

SPEAKER_02

Okay.

SPEAKER_04

You were talking a lot. I was getting you to read out a lot of information. Yep.

SPEAKER_03

And I was doing it very reluctantly.

SPEAKER_04

It was so boring. So boring.

SPEAKER_03

I hated it.

SPEAKER_04

The irony, as I said before, I started to press record. Is that a lot of those clips were you just droning on about vitamins and micronutrients? Dosages. Just so boring. Oh, the mouse is gone.

SPEAKER_01

That's just fair.

SPEAKER_04

So boring. But they got a lot of the time they got a lot of for for us anyway, we're still we're still trying to get the views. But they got a lot of views. Compared to me sitting on the sofa talking about really interesting topics, not just making them up on the spa. We're getting sometimes double triple your videos with you just droning on, we're getting sometimes double triple the views.

SPEAKER_03

Well, what can I say? I've got a lovely voice.

SPEAKER_04

But they were just boring, weren't they? They were really boring.

SPEAKER_03

Not really.

SPEAKER_04

We got stuck in this middle ground.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, where you did not.

SPEAKER_04

I was doing a lot.

SPEAKER_03

No, you weren't. I do everything.

SPEAKER_04

I do pretty much everything. But we we we're getting stuck in this middle ground. There's other people that will talk about certain subjects and topics a lot more in depth. And are experts. You're not.

SPEAKER_03

I am not. And I never said I was. And I don't want to be, ever.

SPEAKER_04

Hence why I get you to talk about some of this stuff. Because I I didn't want to sit there for an hour going, right, that's right, vitamin D. Okay, so the dosages of vitamin D. Oh God. Oh God. Sorry, is that are you okay?

SPEAKER_02

Yes, shall we start with the episode? Yes, I know. I'm just trying to preface what we're doing.

SPEAKER_04

I'm trying to preface it's not woes. No, you can't keep no, I'm not having it. This isn't woes. This isn't woes. This is, I'm describing I haven't been told I'm describing the new direction of the show. We're just trying to get the middle ground.

SPEAKER_00

He's not having it.

SPEAKER_04

We're trying to get the balance of giving some decent information, evidence-based information. But it not being too boring and structuring it and talking about certain things like we would on a random Tuesday evening. Evening, darling. How's your day been?

SPEAKER_01

Shit. How's yours?

SPEAKER_04

Swearing.

SPEAKER_01

Good night. That's not a bad word.

SPEAKER_04

Do you see what I'm trying to get at? Yes. So we need to get a bit more. We're not going to sit there. I'll be honest with you. We are not going to sit there around the table talking about vitamin D. And the dosages and how much you need and how much you need to be outside. It's just not going to happen.

SPEAKER_03

Been there, done that, trialled, tested, didn't like it.

SPEAKER_04

You seem to be mangy for you, but I do you must you must understand what I'm trying to say. You must agree.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, so if the camera was talking off from me.

SPEAKER_04

If the camera was off, these are the conversations we would have.

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah? Yeah. Does that make sense? Yes. So that's what we're going to do. A little less talking from you, and if you are talking, it will just be having a discussion. Excellent. Not just me going, right, Fiona, next block, read that out for 10 minutes.

SPEAKER_03

No problem.

SPEAKER_04

Have you finished? I don't even listen as well when you read out.

SPEAKER_03

I know you don't.

SPEAKER_04

I have read the information. I do know the information. Sorry, I've just come round. What was that? So if I'm bored, what about them? God, I'm uncomfortable.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

How are you feeling?

SPEAKER_03

Uncomfortable.

SPEAKER_04

Okay, right. So some ifs. So we did something similar last year. We did. So this is now an annual thing.

SPEAKER_03

Let me just get it.

SPEAKER_04

It's still early days, Fiona, but we are we're taking this to the next level. We're taking this to the next level. I'm slightly less distracted. Just slightly. Wow. Okay. Okay, no worries. We'll wait. Okay.

unknown

Okay, I'm ready.

SPEAKER_04

This is the awkward part, we have to face each other. It's not good, is it? This is what people do. I I just keep seeing people, unless you're really professional and you and you're around a table.

unknown

Which we have.

SPEAKER_04

We've done that before, and that was that was just as bad. A lot of people just sit on sofas like this for hours. Twist their whole body and just go, yeah, absolutely. That sounds fantastic. I just love having this conversation with you. Well, it's been 12 and a half minutes and this hurts. I'm uncomfortable. So I'm not getting it.

SPEAKER_03

So will we start with mint number one?

SPEAKER_04

We did something similar, didn't we, Fiona?

SPEAKER_03

Sorry?

SPEAKER_04

Last year.

SPEAKER_03

We did.

SPEAKER_04

So this is the next this is the next five myths? Yep. We're giving ourselves an hour. An hour off.

SPEAKER_01

Yep.

SPEAKER_04

Just because this is casual, as you can tell. Just casual. We're just having a good time. We're relaxing. We're just relaxing. We're comfortable. We're feeling good. This was it. This is where it started to really pick up the momentum. Do you agree?

SPEAKER_03

Right. Common myth, common fitness and nutrition myths that need binin. Very important one, actually, and very relevant to today, I think.

SPEAKER_04

Okay. Talk into the mic if you can.

SPEAKER_03

GLP1 drugs cause muscle loss. What is a GLP1 drug, Ben?

SPEAKER_04

It's a weight loss drug. Oh, such as? Uh Wagovi, Monjaro, Ozempic.

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

Yes?

SPEAKER_03

Wagavi.

SPEAKER_04

Wagovi.

SPEAKER_03

Oh, is that what you said? Yeah, that's what I said. Yeah. Oh, I missed that one.

SPEAKER_04

Or Wagovi.

Myth 1: Do GLP-1 Drugs Cause Muscle Loss?

SPEAKER_03

Right. So the claim is everyone's panicking that it's empic or wagavi is melting their muscle faster than their waistline.

SPEAKER_04

Wagovi.

SPEAKER_03

Tell me the reality of that.

SPEAKER_04

Maybe it is wagovi. Maybe you're right.

SPEAKER_03

Just tell me the bloody reality.

SPEAKER_04

So what do you think, Fiona? What do you think?

SPEAKER_03

Wagovi.

SPEAKER_04

No, no, about about that.

SPEAKER_03

No.

unknown

Yes.

SPEAKER_03

It's too much of a weight loss in a short space of time. Right.

SPEAKER_04

So it's the weight loss. So the drugs themselves don't just eat away at your muscle. They help you lose weight. They suppress your appetite. Yes. Which means that you'll lose weight. Some clients that I've trained over the last year or so who have been taking some form of GLP1, they have fallen into the trap of they've lost lots of weight. Great. So they're making progress. But they've fallen into the trap of just eating less of the same diet. So the diet they had before using one of the GLP1s may have not been the best. May have not been balanced. Lacking protein, lacking fiber.

SPEAKER_03

Right. So what have they done then?

SPEAKER_04

Well, nothing.

SPEAKER_03

Just reduced the protein more.

SPEAKER_04

Their appetite has dropped. They've lost weight, okay? Appetite's dropped. Calories have dropped. Good. So now they can exercise. Now they can consider exercising. Brilliant. The private Pushwell Health Studio or the Push Well Health app is ready. In you come. But they haven't made any nutritional changes or very limited ones. Protein's still quite low. Fibers low.

SPEAKER_03

And what's what's what's protein good for?

SPEAKER_04

Uh muscle mass. Retaining muscle mass. When you're in a calorie deficit, it's good for retaining muscle mass. And that's one of the muscle recovery?

SPEAKER_03

Yes. If somebody's new to a gym, did need good amounts of protein for muscle recovery?

SPEAKER_04

Absolutely. Absolutely. You're learning. This is nice.

SPEAKER_03

I am.

SPEAKER_04

What's funny?

SPEAKER_03

So what's serious? So what exactly is it then? What's the reality in a simple sentence?

SPEAKER_00

Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_04

Yes, we're discussing it, Fiona. Remember, the notes, we're not reading off the notes anymore. The notes are there just to go, oh hang on, sorry, two seconds. Let me have a just have a quick look. But we've moved on.

SPEAKER_00

Okay.

SPEAKER_04

We're now just having a discussion.

SPEAKER_00

Okay.

SPEAKER_04

Okay. Okay, I'm not used to this. I know. Look at me.

SPEAKER_03

I'm trying to make it.

SPEAKER_04

Look me in the eye.

SPEAKER_03

Oh.

SPEAKER_04

My cat's not around, are they?

SPEAKER_03

Silly hurt.

SPEAKER_04

Oh god, it's so comfortable.

SPEAKER_03

Okay, so.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, so did that make sense?

SPEAKER_03

Yes, it did, Ben.

SPEAKER_04

So the drugs themselves aren't eating away at your muscle.

SPEAKER_03

Like little gremlin are eating the muscle. No, they're not doing that. No. That's what you'd envisioned though, wouldn't it? That's what you'd envisioned, though, isn't it? Like a little bit.

SPEAKER_04

Yes, I I believe a lot of people think that these drugs. Oh, you take you take uh this is why people are getting what's it called? Ozempic face. Well, Govy butt, exempic, Ozempic bum, butthole.

SPEAKER_03

I never heard that.

SPEAKER_04

You know, people are getting quite sunken faces. They lose all the body fat off their faces. Yeah, yeah. And their and their bums are caving in.

SPEAKER_03

Now Sharon Osborne. She's kind of prime example.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, she wasn't looking good.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

She wasn't looking good. But she's older now, wasn't she? Wasn't she in her 70s? Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

But she went really.

SPEAKER_04

She was quite slim anyway, wasn't she?

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, yeah, but she went very, very gone.

SPEAKER_04

So yeah, people who are already reasonably slim who are then losing an extra 20 pounds. It's got to go, it's got to be lost from somewhere.

SPEAKER_03

Okay.

SPEAKER_04

So did that make sense?

SPEAKER_03

Yes, it did.

SPEAKER_04

Okay, explain in one sentence. You explain in one sentence because you're the lay person. You're the sort of person I'm trying to teach and educate.

SPEAKER_03

It's the rapid weight loss. It's the rapid weight loss, the lack of protein, and not implementing good habits.

SPEAKER_04

Better habits, yes. Lack of fibre, yeah. Yes. So it's it's the nutritional choices you're making.

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

Not the drug. The drug is not making you lose muscle mass.

SPEAKER_03

So what does the drug do then for me? It just suppresses my appetite.

SPEAKER_04

Lots we can get into the science, of course, but we're not going to do that today.

SPEAKER_03

Okay.

Hilarious Shallow Hal Ozempic Episode

SPEAKER_04

We've got an episode, haven't we? On Ozempic.

SPEAKER_03

We do. Right. Yes.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. What was Oh, that was the Shallow Howe one. I think that episode was okay. It was okay. It was fine.

unknown

Right.

SPEAKER_04

It was fine.

SPEAKER_03

I'm very uncomfortable.

SPEAKER_04

But yes, go listen to that one. What's it called? Um Shallow How Does Does taking Ozempic make you shallow? Or does taking a weight loss drug make you shallow? It's it's very clever. It's very witty.

SPEAKER_03

I came up with that.

SPEAKER_04

Shallow how. Bad. Bad feel. Bad feel.

SPEAKER_03

Oh wow.

SPEAKER_04

Oh really offensive. Okay, there you go. Okay, so we're moving on to myth number two. Well, there's there's more there, isn't there? But let's let's keep rolling. Because we've we've just we've just got an hour, so.

Myth 2: Does Eating After 6pm Make You Fat?

SPEAKER_03

Right, this is one that I actually believed quite significantly, actually. Okay. I was very much like, yep. Yep. And there's another one as well. So eating after six pm makes you fat or your willpower runs out.

SPEAKER_04

Some would say, Fiona, that I'm a myth buster.

SPEAKER_03

Don't eat after six, your metabolism shuts down, or worse, I've got no willpower at night time.

SPEAKER_04

You your watchhouse now.

SPEAKER_03

Willpower.

SPEAKER_04

Metabolism.

SPEAKER_03

Metabolism.

SPEAKER_04

Yes.

SPEAKER_03

What did I say? Metabolism.

SPEAKER_04

God knows.

SPEAKER_03

Your metabolism.

SPEAKER_04

Yes, that's that's lovely.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, thank you.

SPEAKER_04

That's very well said.

SPEAKER_03

Hit me, baby, with the reality.

SPEAKER_04

Well, you tell me, Fiona. So why did you think that this 6 pm number time? So you thought that eating on. Right.

SPEAKER_03

I'm not I'm not using up any energy. So after after 6 pm usually there's no exercise or whatever. I see. So if I get at 9 pm, I'm going to bed straight away. Whereas if I have breakfast at 9am, I've got the whole day to walk to use some of that energy that I've consumed. Yes.

SPEAKER_04

So you've if you've So eating 800 calories of something at midday compared to 9 pm.

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

That 800 calories would just be stored as fat. And it would it would what? Even if you are at say maintenance or if you were in a calorie deficit, if calories were matched, that would just be stored as fat.

SPEAKER_03

I I'm not sure what what would happen with it, to be fair. I would just happen that somebody something would come in and eat it.

SPEAKER_04

Look, it's it's fine. Yes, but no, but the the logic is. Oh, I wouldn't say sound, but it makes sense, doesn't it? Yes. Yes, because if you're eating a big meal and then going to bed, your body's not working. It's it's switching off.

SPEAKER_03

But it is.

SPEAKER_04

Right.

SPEAKER_03

We have since learned. Even by just sitting here, we're burning energy. You've told me. Not much.

SPEAKER_04

Just drop it. There we go. That should be nice. That should be nice. Yeah, yeah, we're sitting here right now. We're burning fat right now.

SPEAKER_03

Yep.

SPEAKER_04

We're in the fat burning zone right now.

SPEAKER_03

We are. And at night time, when you're sleeping and stuff, you're in your fat burning zone, or are you?

SPEAKER_04

You'll be burning fat, yes.

SPEAKER_03

But you're not in your fat burning zone because you're not awake.

SPEAKER_04

What's the fat burning zone, Fiona? What we're in now. It's a made-up term, isn't it? Oh. Really? It's a made-up term. Well, it's we've discussed this before. It's the the fat burning zone.

SPEAKER_03

But going off on tangent.

SPEAKER_04

Oh.

SPEAKER_03

So why do where why if I eat late at night like a big meal at just say eight, nine o'clock, I'm absolutely starving the next day. Why is that?

SPEAKER_04

Depends what the meal is, mate. What's in the meal?

SPEAKER_03

We last had dinner at what time? Half five yesterday.

SPEAKER_04

Yes.

SPEAKER_03

I'm grand.

SPEAKER_04

Okay. It was what do we have for dinner? It was reasonably uh potatoes, some veg, chicken. So high protein potatoes are very satiating.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Some fibre from the vegetables.

SPEAKER_03

I guarantee you, if I'd had the same thing at 9pm last night, I would be starving today.

SPEAKER_04

Well that that means it's psychological then, doesn't it? But it also depends what you're eating. If you're eating a a packet of Harry Bows at 9 pm and then going to bed, yeah. Go for it. Enjoy it. It's all about balance. But chances are, when you wake up in the morning, hungry.

SPEAKER_03

Right. Any studies on this, Ben?

SPEAKER_04

Have we answered the question there? We haven't answered the question.

SPEAKER_03

No, you haven't really told me the reality, actually. You did in a roundabout way.

SPEAKER_04

Right, yes. Oh, okay. No, that works. Yes, the study. So the study is is about we've discussed something called ego depletion. So the point is calories are the same at 5.59 compared to 6 pm. But behaviourally, a lot of people may have the tendency to overeat in the evening after a long day.

SPEAKER_03

With a glass of wine.

SPEAKER_04

If are you more likely to eat a tub of Ben and Jerry's at 9am or 9 p.m.?

SPEAKER_01

PM.

SPEAKER_04

Right. Of course. Wine. Are you likely to glug a bottle of wine at 9am or 9 p.m.? Some people do. That's a whole different topic in itself.

SPEAKER_03

Depends.

SPEAKER_04

But for the most for the most part. For the most part. Realistically, if someone said to you, Oh God, I just saw.

SPEAKER_03

It's PM because it's associated with relaxing.

SPEAKER_04

Right. So if someone said to you, Oh my god, I glugged a bottle of wine yesterday. What time was that? Oh 9am.

SPEAKER_03

I'm just like, yeah, but you've got the whole day to do. You have to cook for dinner.

SPEAKER_04

You went to work? Yes. Oh, okay. If they said 9 pm, you go, yeah, being there, eh? Yeah. Long day. You know what Tuesdays are like?

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah. You wouldn't question it. No. No.

SPEAKER_03

Probably not.

SPEAKER_04

So it's it's the decisions that people are making. It's not a physiological thing. Calories are calories.

SPEAKER_03

But then I suppose between nine to five, if you're working, your brain is more active. Not active, but your brain is more occupied because you're working, you're more distracted, you're not focused on food, you're not focusing on your cravings, all of that as well. Yes, that yeah, that helps, yeah. So at night time, you've got nothing really to entertain you other than what's on on the TV.

SPEAKER_04

Some people might just snack, they might just graze throughout the day, so they don't eat proper meals. Breakfast is a breakfast bar, lunch is a soup, maybe. They're not eating properly, they're not having they're not having a breakfast, they're not having a proper lunch. They're just snacking. So they get to the end of the day, they're they're starving.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

They're starving, they've had a long day. They have their meal, it's not enough. The meal is that was okay. But what else have we got?

unknown

Okay.

SPEAKER_04

The ego depletion was about people's willpower will deplete. Roy Bammaster, Bimaster, Bad Roy, Roy something. There was this thing about how your willpower will actually deplete. And that's the reason why people, as the day goes on, are more likely to overconsume. That's not really a thing. It makes sense, doesn't it? It does make sense. But it's not physiologically, it's not a thing. You don't you don't have a willpower meter that just that is just going down physiologically. You still have the decision, you still make the decision.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, but then if you're not as focused on something, then the likelihood is you'll make that bad decision. Oh, you're a little gremlins already?

SPEAKER_04

Yes. Yes. This is quite an easy one, isn't it? It's not really logically, once you've moved past the fact that calories don't change at 6 pm compared to 5.59, then you start thinking, oh, okay, so maybe it's my my habits, my lifestyle, my environment, the behaviours that I tend to engage with after 6 pm, after a long day at work, after a long week. Makes more sense. It's not really it's not a bombshell, is it?

SPEAKER_03

No. So to take home from this, it's not the clock that's making you fat. It's your 9 pm meltdown. That's what you said on that. I like that. Is that what it says? I quite like that.

SPEAKER_04

No, who do you think said that? Do you think I wrote that?

SPEAKER_03

Oh, I quite liked that. Okay. But I do like, I do like them to be fair.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, there is some studies here.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, there is. Right. So for et al. 2011 says uh did a study and they ate most carbs in the evenings. Uh no.

SPEAKER_04

Right, sorry. So yes, they they took two groups of people.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Both groups overweight. One ate the the majority of their carbs earlier in the day. The other group ate most of their carbs later in the day. Right. So maybe after 6 p.m. Yes? Yeah. The group that ate more of their carbs in the evening had better adherence, lower hunger, improved leptin and insulin sensitivity, despite calories being matched. Oh, and what's just one study, of course, but.

SPEAKER_03

Hmm. Interesting. Okay. Very interesting.

SPEAKER_04

Okay.

SPEAKER_03

Okay.

SPEAKER_04

There is another study there talking about circadian rhythm. Yeah. And how you should maybe.

SPEAKER_03

That's Roddick Collins at all.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, do you want to read that out quickly? Very quick, let's move on.

SPEAKER_03

I can't really see it.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, okay. Right. But in terms of your circadian rhythm, it may make sense for some people when it comes to time restrictive eating. To eat within certain windows. So for example, if you are eating, if you only eat all of your calories between 8 a.m. and 6pm, yes, that might be more in line with your circadian rhythm, but it might just make sense. Because if you if your cutoff is 6 pm, then you're okay, aren't you? You're good to go. You haven't got to worry about the 6 pm. You've eaten all your calories. So you haven't got to worry about overindulging, binging, over consuming.

SPEAKER_03

Right, okay, now I'm not sure.

SPEAKER_04

Eating the Ben and Jerry's. Because 6 pm is the cutoff.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, you've had all of your 2,000 calories, say, in that day.

SPEAKER_04

Yes, for example, yeah. You might have had a nice nutritious breakfast, had a good hearty lunch, had an earlier dinner, and you're good to go.

SPEAKER_03

So then the peop so are people who are more likely just having 500 calories, say, between 8 to 6.

SPEAKER_04

500 calories.

SPEAKER_03

Just say.

SPEAKER_04

Right.

SPEAKER_03

And then they overconsume the 1000 they have 1,500 calories in the evening, but then they're the ones more likely to overconsume that calorie intake because they're starved.

SPEAKER_04

Potentially, yes. Yes. The point is it shouldn't make a difference for your goals. Yes. Whatever they may be.

SPEAKER_01

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

For weight loss, for fat loss, that's what a lot of people's goals are, aren't they? Yes. If calories are matched, you can eat whenever the hell you want. If your goal is to lose weight. If you're in a calorie deficit, you can eat 2,000 calories at 8 a.m. And if you maintain that deficit for the rest of the day, you will lose body fat.

SPEAKER_03

Hmm. But not 2,000 calories at 8 a.m., 4 p.m. and then 8 p.m.

SPEAKER_04

Hey, if you're if you've got, yeah, if you're if you're a big person. If you can get into a calorie deficit and still eat 6,000 calories, lucky you. Well done.

SPEAKER_03

Alright. Next myth.

SPEAKER_04

Is that it, Fiona?

SPEAKER_03

Yes, that's it. That was fine. It was fine.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, this is a big one.

SPEAKER_03

This is a big one. And we have spoken about this before, haven't we?

SPEAKER_04

We have, so let's not go too crazy about it.

Myth 3: Is Sugar Additive?

SPEAKER_03

I think this is very this is um schools and whatnot are quite big on this. Well, not myth, but yeah. Schools? Schools, yeah. Okay. Sugar is addictive. Oh the claim sugar lights up your brain like cocaine.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, we've heard that before, haven't we?

SPEAKER_03

So just to give a little example, a little definition of what exact what addiction is. So this has come from the American Psychiatric Association. It involves compulsive use of a substance despite the harmful consequences, often with tolerance and withdrawal. Tolerance needing more to get the same effect, withdrawal, physical or psychological symptoms when stopping. Hit me, baby. That sounds good. Tell me, what's the reality? Well, as always, let's start with studies in there.

SPEAKER_04

Let's start with you, Fiona.

SPEAKER_03

I would never I would never said that sugar was addictive, no. But I do think it does have an impact on people's activity level, of course.

SPEAKER_04

So it's behaviour again.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, it's behavioural.

SPEAKER_04

So yes, sugar, physiologically, is not addictive. How often have you had the urge to go into the kitchen, grab the bag of sugar?

SPEAKER_03

No, no, no, no.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03

I have it right now.

SPEAKER_04

How often have we done that? Come into the lounge, grab some spoons, and just tucked in.

SPEAKER_01

Did a bag of sugar.

SPEAKER_04

If it was the same thing for heroin or for alcohol, it's not happening, is it? If you've got that in your house and you are an addict and you are addicted to that substance, and it's in the cupboard and you can see it. You know it's there. You're not just gonna take it or leave it.

SPEAKER_03

Hmm. Yes. But I think what people think is, is because they think it's addictive because they want that sweet treat, don't they? And they constantly want that sweet treat. So they want that.

SPEAKER_04

It's the dopamine, the old dopamine hit. Yes.

SPEAKER_03

That's yeah, you feel you feel better after it. But then I always think that it's associated with because we'd have we'd have we'd have a snack. We'd have treats, wouldn't we? Like dessert basically in the evenings. Oh, treats, a bit of chocolate or a bit of chocolate or a crisps or whatever.

SPEAKER_04

Lots of treats in Canada, wasn't it, Fiona?

SPEAKER_03

There was too many treats. Treaty. There was too many treaties.

SPEAKER_04

We went to Canada in a camper van with my mum. And it was as terrible as you'd expect.

SPEAKER_03

No, it wasn't.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, Canada. Beautiful country. Beautiful country. The experience in the camper van, tough.

SPEAKER_03

Ben's mum likes treats.

SPEAKER_04

Treaties.

SPEAKER_03

Treaties. Lots of treaties. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, she likes her 11s.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, Canada have got lots of treats.

SPEAKER_03

Yes. Yeah. So we're not used to it, are we? All these treaties.

SPEAKER_04

I like a treat.

SPEAKER_03

I like a treat too. But one per day is good.

SPEAKER_04

But it was, yeah. Yeah, treats.

SPEAKER_03

But it was treats when we were driving, it was treats when we pulled up, but it was treats at 11. It was treats after breakfast.

SPEAKER_04

Well, I suppose you've got to get through that experience, haven't you? You've got to find a way to get through the experience of being in the camper man.

SPEAKER_03

Would you say would you say your mum is addicted to sugar ben?

SPEAKER_04

No, I don't think so. No. No. Just likes a treaty.

SPEAKER_03

Can't take it seriously when you're talking about treaties. Okay, anyways, what were we talking about?

SPEAKER_04

Sugar is addictive.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, no, it's not really addictive. Okay.

SPEAKER_04

But the the first line there. What was the first line about how it lights up the same?

SPEAKER_03

Sugar lights up your brain like cocaine.

SPEAKER_04

Yes, right. Yes, so does so does hugging.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, I'm not sure.

SPEAKER_04

So does being happy. So does when you stroke Donald. Not for me. The opposite effect. But when you stroke Donald the cat, those pathways light up.

SPEAKER_03

Is hugging addictive? I don't think it is. But then again, sugar's not addicted to.

SPEAKER_04

Seeing a child, people like people like children. They hug a child. That could be a problem if you're addicted to children.

SPEAKER_03

Right. Anyways, moving on.

SPEAKER_04

But you're not though, are you, Fiona? You you love kitties. Oh, you love them. You love the children.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, I do. Are you addicted to them? No, it's lovely to give them back.

SPEAKER_04

Okay. Who's that? And also, and also, when it comes to treaties, sugary treaties, a lot of these sugary treaties also have a good amount of fat in them. Sometimes there's even more fat than sugar. For a lot of these pastries and these cookies, there's a lot of fat rammed into them. So how do you explain that? I don't know. If it's just the sugar that you're addicted to, there's more fat in them.

SPEAKER_03

That's a good point.

SPEAKER_04

Right.

SPEAKER_03

But then again, it's like so people always associate being addicted to sugar with being addicted to chocolate. That type of stuff, like candy.

SPEAKER_04

Right, yep, sugar, yeah, some sugar in there, yeah. But you might have some fat as well.

SPEAKER_03

But you wouldn't say that somebody's addicted to Leucosid or lemonade. You you would with Coke, because Coke has that taste, a nice kind of taste to it. But these but lemonade, full fat lemonade, who do you see sinking lemonade? They're full of sugar.

SPEAKER_04

Yes.

SPEAKER_03

Cornflakes full of sugar.

SPEAKER_04

That's a very blanket term, Lofiona, because I'm sure there is many people that just love Leucasade and they just love lemonade. Lemonade is what I'm saying. Yes, and they will drink litres of it a day.

SPEAKER_03

Oh no, I don't think it's a little bit more than a little bit.

SPEAKER_04

And then if you ask them in what setting, if they wanted to lose weight, right, so let's you know let's have a quick look. Quick snapshot of your your an average day in the life of you. Yeah, so I drink four litres of lemonade a day. Okay. That's that's a lot of calories. I just don't like lemonade. Yeah, I'm addicted to sugar. Right, okay, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, but you're not.

SPEAKER_04

So if you're if you're drinking and consuming a lot of foods that are high in sugar, and then you remove those foods, yeah, people will talk about having withdrawal from these foods. So it feels like you are withdrawing from drugs or alcohol. Get the shakes, you get, oh my god, this is all you can think about is eating sugar. It's a thing. I'm not saying that people don't have these symptoms and they don't have these struggles when they try and remove certain foods from their diet or they try and cut down on certain foods. I'm not saying that. I'm not just saying, oh, well, you're wrong, you're an idiot. Physiologically, no, not addictive. Moral. I believe these people. I've got many clients who have said, yeah, I'm addicted to sugar. I just can't stop eating this food.

SPEAKER_03

And what is your response when to say that?

SPEAKER_04

Well, you have to then you're a moron. You have to be polite and you have to then slowly start educating. Go, right, well, let's uh what can we do? What what small changes can we start making? Do you feel like you could cut down on that food? Not remove it completely, but if you if you feel like you're overconsuming on that food or you struggle to to cut down calories in certain aspects, or can we start adding some more food to your diet? Here's some more protein, here's some more fibre. They start adding some more calories first. And then what is the well more sorry, more foods. Adding start adding more foods whilst trying to reduce in certain other aspects. To then if your goal is to lose body fat, try and get you into a calorie deficit. Try it into maintenance. Because you might be in well, yeah, well, you might be in a in a a fifth a 1,500 surplus most of the time. So let's just try and bring that down. Not here's a day here's a thousand calorie deficit, get into that, enjoy. Let's just bring it down.

SPEAKER_03

So when you start introducing and reducing, so when you start introducing, say the protein, something that's going to keep you fuller for longer, all of that and reduce, what is the results immediately? Well not immediately, but are they fuller for do they feel fuller and that they don't need to have that sugary the sugary snack? Or are they still like, oh, I'm still craving it?

SPEAKER_04

Or it takes time. Hence why a lot of people don't do it. Hence why a lot of people will go, right, that that sounds that sounds long. That sounds like I've really got to start changing my habits for the long term. Potentially, yes, yeah, some of them. Ugh, like six weeks red. Okay, yeah. Yeah, you can do that, but you you'll be miserable and you'll be re reducing your calories dramatically. And I'm not sure you'll be able to sustain that for the long term. For some people, going into more of an aggressive diet for three weeks, four weeks, if you've got a lot of weight to lose, makes sense, and having bouts of that. Doing that, maintenance, go again, maintenance that works, but at the same time, you need to start putting in drip feeding in habits and behaviour change that they can then maintain for the long term at the same time. Anything else there, Fierina? There's a lot, isn't there?

SPEAKER_03

There's a lot when it comes to studies here, Ben, as well.

SPEAKER_04

Please, Benton, that's a good one, isn't it?

SPEAKER_03

So Benton from Benton in 2010 wrote there is no support from the human literature for the hypothesis that shocrus or sugar may be physically addictive or that addiction to sugar plays a role in eating disorders. This has been coming from the clinical nutrition.

SPEAKER_04

Okay. Okay. There's a few doctors there that we've got.

SPEAKER_03

Lustig.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. Uh yeah. Grund Grundy. For some reason I always say, look, you have to be careful. I don't know why, but this is this is the new stage Fiona. We're just calling out charlatans. Quackery.

unknown

Right.

SPEAKER_04

If these people are making these claims, these people are making these claims. But so that's okay. That for some reason I was like, oh my god, our podcast is seen by like five people. Dr. Grundy's gonna come after me. No, not yet. Not yet. I look forward to it when it happens.

SPEAKER_03

But is it evidence-based, Ben?

SPEAKER_04

What these guys are saying. Yes, but also if these people are saying this, it's when people aren't saying this. If you say, this person said this and they didn't say that, or you've misinterpreted what they've said, that's a problem, isn't it? Or you're lying. Yes. You're saying this person did this and they said this and it's a lie, then that's a problem. That's when you might be getting sued. But if you're just if you're just repeating, if you're just parroting what this person said and you've and then you have your opinion on it, what's wrong with that? So that's what we're doing.

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

Right. Oh god.

SPEAKER_03

Did you read any of that? Did I read any of it? I read it twice, Ben.

SPEAKER_04

No, I'm saying what some of these doctors will say. So you got someone like Dr. Hyman.

SPEAKER_03

I like Grundy.

SPEAKER_04

Okay, start with Grundy then.

SPEAKER_03

Dr. Grundy and his famous grapes are sugar bombs, should only eat fruits in seasons like apes do. He was 80 pounds overweight from sugar, I'm assuming.

SPEAKER_04

That's what I wrote, yes. Yeah, so yeah, he that he uh what was it, Dr. Mike. There's a podcast with Dr. Mike. And he yeah, it's it's it's done the rounds where he talks about how grapes are sugar bombs. Okay, and then he compares he he effectively said, I don't the doctor, Dr. Mike said, Right, okay, but when it comes to if you're advising parents on on what to feed their children, would you say that they are better off trying to get them to eat more grapes compared to a Hershey's chocolate bar? And he was like, Oh, well, it's yeah, pretty much the same phone because it's got the same amount of sugar in.

SPEAKER_01

Right.

SPEAKER_04

Per whatever the grammar was. Well, it's it's the same amount of sugar, so pretty much the same phone. And he was serious. Like he said it with like a really smug, grotesque tone. This guy's a doctor. But that's his opinion. Grapes are sugar bombs. Sugar bombs. Like it's rough, isn't it? It's rough.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. Well yeah, yeah, high in sugar, to be fair. But uh but it's fruit. It's good for you.

SPEAKER_04

It's got a lot of good stuff in it, yeah. Yes, exactly.

SPEAKER_03

And it doesn't have the fat associated with the chocolate bears.

SPEAKER_04

Potentially, yeah. Yeah. Nothing wrong with Hershey's. Nothing wrong if you like a Hershey's, go for it.

SPEAKER_03

And to be fair, all of these chocolates and stuff, they've got a whole host of additive uh what do you call them to additives. Additives.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, that's on top of it.

SPEAKER_03

So they make them moorish, don't they? They make you want more.

SPEAKER_04

You are more likely to overconsume on Hershey's chocolate bars than you are grapes, I imagine.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, no, no, grapes.

SPEAKER_04

You can get for you for per calorie, you can get quite a few grapes in. They may be sugar bombs, but you can get you can get your calories worth of grapes. Yes, he was overweight.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Sometimes this is by 70 pounds. Sometimes not just the pounds. That's absolutely fine. We're not we're not demonising that. But some of these people across the board, and this is this is human nature, if you get results by doing something, and then at the same time you have a platform that you can shout about to people. If I if I lost lots of weight and it was through the carnivore diet, I could do the same thing. And then I had more people going, oh my god, this guy, he talks a lot of sense. And I was just talking about the carnivore diet, and I was then saying this is the only way to lose weight, it's very black and white with these people for some reason.

SPEAKER_01

Right, isn't it?

SPEAKER_04

Sometimes they do still sort of say stuff like, yeah, you try and move a bit more. Try and have a overall, you know, a minimally processed diet. Stuff like that. Exercise if you can. So it's not it's not all complete quackery. What's are we are we okay?

SPEAKER_03

It's the mouse, it keeps because it doesn't work undertain.

SPEAKER_04

Jesus Christ. Okay, this is fine for you. This is we're just testing it. We're just testing it. But this setup is absurd. So we need to work on it.

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

But it's fine because it's casual.

SPEAKER_03

Anyways, that back to Mr. Grundy.

SPEAKER_04

Look at you. Right, you need to look at look at me when I'm talking to you. Right, so we need to get this sorted for the next one.

SPEAKER_03

This is better because I took my headphones out. Because you're sat right down. When was this? Just five minutes ago.

SPEAKER_04

Oh dear, okay.

SPEAKER_03

That's right here ideal.

SPEAKER_04

But you're right here.

SPEAKER_03

I can hear you.

SPEAKER_04

Shall I get back to it? Shall I get back to it?

SPEAKER_03

Yes, get back to it.

SPEAKER_04

But this needs to we need to work on it.

SPEAKER_03

Anyways, go on. Right, what was I saying?

SPEAKER_04

Talking to them, mate. You're putting me off my flight. Grundy. Grundy. Yes. What were we saying about Grundy?

SPEAKER_03

He was overweight.

SPEAKER_04

Right, yeah. So the carnivore diet.

SPEAKER_02

Carnival diet.

SPEAKER_04

If I was overweight, I did the carnivore diet.

SPEAKER_02

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

I had a following. People started to oh, this guy, it talks sense. Oh, should I write a book? I'm gonna write a book. Oh my god, life changing. I lost loads of weight. All my health markers improved. I was near death. You saved my life. And I'm making lots of money. And I've got lots of supporters and followers who are supporting me based on me saying the carnivore diet is the only diet for you. And if you follow any other diet, it will kill you. And if you're overweight, if you feel like crap, if you've got medical conditions, it's because you're eating, you're over consuming calories. Specifically, sugar. Too much sugar. Yeah, you're right. I got great results. I cut all the sugar out, I reduced my calories, I just ate meat and eggs, minimal vegetables, and I feel fantastic. Okay, fine. It's hard to argue with that, isn't it? Makes sense. Yes. Yes. But grapes, sugar bombs. Rough.

SPEAKER_03

You're not a sugar junkie, you're just stuck in a biscuit and boredom of.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, that's I like that. You know that's chat GBT.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, so anyways, tell me about Hyman. You did you talked about Well, yeah, we're running, we're running out of time then. Okay.

SPEAKER_04

Dr. Hyman, yeah, food is medicine.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah.

SPEAKER_03

Well, yeah, you need to be able to do it.

SPEAKER_04

Eating for energy, eating for fuel. There's there's lots of terms.

SPEAKER_03

Nutrients to feel better.

SPEAKER_04

But once again, the whole if he's once again the whole food is medicine is then that means you need to cut out all your sugar. I'm not quite sure about Hyman, I'm not quite sure what other claims he's got, but that's one of them. Some of the advice, as I've just said, is is useful. Yes, is it useful for some people? For for most people, if possible, to eat a mostly plant-based diet. Yeah, probably. Don't eat too much sugar. Yeah. Yeah. Ideally. But it's the demonizing of it, isn't it?

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

It's it's the demonizing, and then it's saying that sugar and these types of foods are having a a unique effect on your body. Which we'll get to in a second with Robert Lustig. Dr. Robert Lustig.

SPEAKER_02

Oh, where's he?

SPEAKER_04

Oh, is he not on the original notes? Did you update the did you download the Oh Lustig? Right. Yep. Okay. There you go, Fiona. Well, you know, you've you've not said a lot this episode, which is fine. This is nice, but the energy.

SPEAKER_03

Sugar is toxic, poisonous. This is lustic now, not.

SPEAKER_04

This is Dr. Robert Lustic.

SPEAKER_03

Sugar is toxic, poisonous. Similar effect on the liver as alcohol. Fruity.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, sorry, sorry, fructose. Yeah. This is this is specifically about fructose. Fructose. Not a fan, Robert. He does not like fructose.

SPEAKER_03

Similar effect on the liver as alcohol. Fruity with energy energy balance.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, sorry, sorry. Yeah, that's that's my that's my word. He's being fruity with energy balance.

SPEAKER_03

He's this is why this is easier for you.

Sugar Addiction Claims And Evidence

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, sorry, that this all makes sense. So he he is, I believe, I believe, he's one of these people that if calories are matched, if you eat sugar, if you eat 3,000 calories of broccoli, if you eat 3,000 calories of table sugar, you will still put on weight based on you eating sugar or a high sugar diet. Anyway, please continue.

SPEAKER_03

Insulin hypothesis?

SPEAKER_04

Yes, that's fine, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

Implying sugar causes fat gain independent of calories.

SPEAKER_04

Right, that's what I was just saying, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

In his view, the insulin surge traps fat in cells, meaning you can be in calorie deficit but still gain fat because insulin is keeping energy locked away. So insulin suppresses fat breakdown temporarily. That's its job.

SPEAKER_04

That's reasonable, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

That's yes. Fat storage only persists when total energy intake exceeds expenditure. The you store fat even in deficit line is physiologically improcessable.

SPEAKER_04

Yes, there's some A's in there, Fiona. You store fat in deficit.

SPEAKER_03

In a deficit. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, there's a couple of A's in there, but never mind. Alright.

SPEAKER_03

That's my little dyslexic brain, Ben.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah. Well, I've given you I've given you the episode off. You should be fresh.

SPEAKER_03

I'm not.

SPEAKER_04

Talk into them. Hi, go on.

SPEAKER_03

Reading is still an issue from me, Ben.

SPEAKER_04

Right, this. Okay. Okay. What do you think of that then?

SPEAKER_03

Sugar's not the enemy.

unknown

Dr.

SPEAKER_03

Grundi is.

SPEAKER_04

Oh.

SPEAKER_03

Wow.

SPEAKER_04

Oh dear. Oh dear. Sorry about that, Doctor.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, and I don't like them.

SPEAKER_04

What I need to do, now I've well, I say I've got now I've got more time. I don't have more time. But I mean, what I need to do, I need to start getting into the weeds again.

SPEAKER_03

Into the what?

SPEAKER_04

I need into the weeds. I need to read the I need the weeds. Oh right, okay.

SPEAKER_03

I thought it's in week. I know to turn. Oh, sorry, sorry. I thought it's in the week.

SPEAKER_04

I need to read their books. I've not read any of these guys' books. Well I've I've listened to them on podcasts. I've I've I've read summaries, I've read, I've listened to people that I respect in the industry talk about them.

SPEAKER_03

It'd be interesting to see what evidence to have and what studies to have.

SPEAKER_04

The evidence is is always potentially, allegedly, is always dubious. Always. It's done in rodents.

SPEAKER_03

Interesting. Interesting. Anyhow. Oh, I do. I do like Huberman.

SPEAKER_04

That's a good question. Why? I was thinking about this the other day. We've had this discussion, I think, before. Why though? Why is Huberman? Yes, very intelligent guy, lots of interesting stuff he talks about. Why is he so popular for the layperson? Because a lot of the stuff he talks about is quite advanced.

SPEAKER_03

I think it's just because it reminds me of New Zealand.

SPEAKER_04

Right, okay. But I mean, okay, so take away take away Huberman in the car whilst driving, which he's talking about subjects and topics that are quite science heavy.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, there was a lot of science heavy, but then he did go in and he explained it in he did simplify it a little bit, some of the stuff. Some of the episodes I didn't like.

SPEAKER_04

Right.

SPEAKER_03

The really sciencey ones. I really didn't like that.

SPEAKER_04

Take away from take away the car. So if I went to you, right, Fiona, let's put some Huberman on. He's got a new, he's got a new, he's got another episode talking about sunlight and how you have to go outside first thing and open your eyeballs and just stare at the sun. And it's really good for you.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, no, I probably wouldn't be down for that.

SPEAKER_04

It's four hours long. Let's put that on.

SPEAKER_03

I liked hello friends.

SPEAKER_04

Chris Williamson, yeah, that's fine.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, I liked him.

SPEAKER_04

Right, yeah, that's different though. Talk about human.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, well, I don't know.

SPEAKER_04

It's it's just it's just a little bit more.

SPEAKER_03

I think it just reminds me. It just reminds me of travel.

SPEAKER_04

Okay, so that's not that's not great though, is it?

SPEAKER_03

No, probably not.

SPEAKER_04

But that doesn't really help with my question.

SPEAKER_03

No. How has he become Well, sure, I'll listen to another podcast and I'll see.

SPEAKER_04

How has he become so popular?

SPEAKER_03

But then my attention spells.

SPEAKER_04

For the lay person, because a lot of it's quite heavy.

SPEAKER_03

It is very heavy, yeah. But then he is straight to the point.

SPEAKER_04

No, he's not.

SPEAKER_03

He is he is. He gets talks.

SPEAKER_04

He rambles for hours.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, he says his point, he gives the research, then he rambles. He points ra he points, gives the point, talks about it, rambles. Right. And when he's rambling, I don't listen to him.

SPEAKER_04

I've not listened to him for a while, actually.

SPEAKER_03

I haven't listened to him in too much.

SPEAKER_04

So maybe I should yeah, maybe I should check it out again.

unknown

Right.

SPEAKER_04

I mean the last thing I heard about Huberman was there was uh I think he was like dating several women at the same time. Lots of naughtiness from Andrew, I believe.

SPEAKER_03

Hi, darling.

SPEAKER_04

Oh dear.

SPEAKER_03

Okay.

Myth 4: What's The Best Exercise For Losing Belly Fat?

SPEAKER_04

The cats enter the room, so let's let's speed this along. But yeah, please reach out. Huberman, what do you like about him?

SPEAKER_03

This one's for Donald. What's the best what's the best exercise for losing belly fat? They're claim. The claim. There must be more this is Chat GBT. Okay. There must be one move that melts body belly fat, right? Reality. No, there's not.

SPEAKER_04

No, you can't spot reduce. No. That's pretty much it. We need to move on now, but you can't spot reduce.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. So if I go and do 100 crunches, isn't that gonna help then?

SPEAKER_04

It may help with endurance and you might strengthen your core a little bit, but it's not going to independently from a calorie deficit burn belly fat.

SPEAKER_03

Well, how do I get rid of my belly then?

SPEAKER_04

It's a calorie deficit. It's a calorie deficit, it's moving, it's having a well-balanced diet. It's genetics as well. A lot of people might just store fat around their stomach and it sucks, and that's just the way it is. Women in particular, unfortunately, you will store more fat around your stomach and hips on average. Genetics.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. But when I go online and say about belly fat, they're telling me to do abdominal exercises.

SPEAKER_04

Do they? Yep. Yeah. Well it makes sense, doesn't it? It does make sense. If you've got flabby arms, you've got bingo wings, do some tricep movements.

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah. That'd be nice, wouldn't it?

SPEAKER_03

It's not very nice. We do not provoke or condone violence.

SPEAKER_04

So it makes sense, doesn't it? It does make sense.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, I know that. But then essentially, you're kind of doing not doing more harm because that's the wrong word, but you are adding because you're the more exercise you do for your abdominal, if you're not in a calorie deficit, it's gonna make you wider because you're building that muscle, sure enough.

SPEAKER_04

That's what it says in the notes, isn't it, Fiona? You've taken that from the nose. Yes. You've said that like it's your thing.

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah.

SPEAKER_03

But I'm trying to say in my words.

SPEAKER_04

Right, yes. Yeah, sometimes, yes.

SPEAKER_03

If you're if I was if I was maintaining my calories as I am now, and wasn't just everything's the same, so I'm basically not in a calorie deficit. And I started doing 500 crunches per day. Well, wouldn't my stomach get wouldn't my stomach get bigger? It'd get more tawned.

SPEAKER_04

You're you're trying to You're treating your you have to treat your your core, your abs. Your abs.

SPEAKER_03

I don't have a core abs. They're muscles, aren't they? Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

So you would if you want to get them bigger, but I you train them the same. You have to put them under some sort of resistance. You have to have some form of progressive overload.

SPEAKER_03

But I don't, I want to get rid of my belly fat.

SPEAKER_04

Right, okay. But that that was what I put in the notes, is that sometimes if you start training your core a lot, still you have to train them hard because they're a muscle. But if you start training your core a lot and you're trying to get a a more felt look, you're trying to get a slimmer waist, well then you might end up you'd have to train quite hard, but you might end up having bigger abs. Yes. So you become your waist becomes blockier.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. But not fatter. Because it'll be torn to it. It'll be harder.

SPEAKER_04

To lose the fat around your stomach or to to give it a good go, you need to be in a calorie deficit. And you need to try and be moving a bit more.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, deep.

SPEAKER_04

Exercising a little bit.

SPEAKER_03

The clue is if you want to build muscle, that's when you do the crunches. But if you want to lose belly fat, that's calorie deficit.

SPEAKER_04

It depends. If you're doing 500 body weight crunches, that you that's gonna take a long time.

SPEAKER_00

Oh yeah.

SPEAKER_04

That's gonna take a long time to build muscle. Because if I did 500 of these on my biceps, that's probably not a good example because you are you're using your body weight to do a crunch, so you are putting a bit of resistance into it. There's not much resistance here, though, is there? No. So I'm not gonna build my biceps.

SPEAKER_03

You need to bring that weight.

SPEAKER_04

So yes, so if you're doing crunches, you are still using some resistance, your body weight. But it's it'd be better probably for endurance.

SPEAKER_03

It's like if you plank, the more you plank you're still good at that.

SPEAKER_04

Right. The more you plank, the better at planking you get.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Will you get a uh a slimmer waist? Will you lose belly fat just because you plank more? Will you get bigger abs? No. Not not if you're just planking.

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

No, you you just you'll just get better at planking.

SPEAKER_03

Right.

SPEAKER_04

If that's what your goal is. Great. Enjoy.

SPEAKER_03

Well, the best exercise for belly fat, the one that stops you quishing after two weeks. God is so lame, isn't it? Right, this is another one. Breakfast is the most important meal of the day. Why? Dang on because it kickstarts your metabolism. Oh, oh. So the myth is how to kickstart your metabolism in the morning by eating breakfast. That's what everyone used to say. So you've got to kick start your metabolism, try lemon water, ice plunges, six mini meals, ensure you eat breakfast.

SPEAKER_04

I need to make these notes better because you reading them, it sounds a bit it's out it sounds a lot more jarring because we're at we've had now more of a just uh just a chat.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

So yeah. It's much better approach. Listening to you read these my notes, but then Chat GBT putting a his spin on it. Or or or she or they. It sounds really jarring. Really jarring. And sometimes you just miss words out as well, so it sounds even worse. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. So yeah, you're not all mower. Ooh. Your metabolism is working all of the time. If it wasn't, you'd be dead. So you're not kick starting it. You don't you don't kick start your metabolism.

SPEAKER_03

That's so dramatic. Well, if it wasn't, you'd be dead.

SPEAKER_04

Well, it's not dramatic, Fiona, it's fact.

SPEAKER_03

Okay.

SPEAKER_04

If you if you if you were kickstart it in the morning, that'd be a problem. That'd be a serious problem. And you can't. Because you're not a lawmer. Lemon water and having a big breakfast doesn't kick start it. It's always ticking over. So where did that myth come from? Because it might be a good habit. It's habits, it's about behaviour change, it's about behavioural concepts, it's about habits, lifestyle. Is it a bad thing to eat breakfast in the morning? No.

SPEAKER_03

No, for some people it's great. Is it a bad thing not to eat breakfast in the morning?

SPEAKER_04

No. Oh, there's minimal room over there for him. Bless his heart.

SPEAKER_02

Ben.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, okay. Oh, that's a shame.

SPEAKER_03

Shall we continue anyways? Because we've only got five minutes left.

SPEAKER_04

I spent an hour doing the memory card.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. I don't know when that went. I've just checked it now. Have you looked at it?

SPEAKER_04

No.

SPEAKER_03

I don't know when it went.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, okay. Oh, we've gone back to the old days. This was meant to be a fresh start. This is meant to be a fresh start for pushable health. Well, and the memory on the camera has run out. Even though I I cleared it this morning. Silly me. That's a shame. We were coming towards the end, so that's fine, but that's that's a shame. That's a real shame. That's that's yeah. Or serious PTSD. Oh, wow. And I don't use the word PTSD lightly. Oh, that hurts. I'm getting all sorts of flashbacks of the misery of the camera not working.

SPEAKER_03

But Donald is here having a wash. You're missing out on that.

SPEAKER_04

Okay, God, that's really taking me off my flow. Right, let's let's finish off then. What a shame. Okay. What a shame.

SPEAKER_03

So as usual, mitz fly around claiming that frequent eating stalks metabolism or that skipping meals triggers starvation mode. Oh, yeah, we've talked about those.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, don't exist.

SPEAKER_03

We can't walk about that anyways. Right, give me some studies, Ben. Hit me with studies.

SPEAKER_04

Well, no, we'll continue, Fiona. Human metabolism doesn't change meal to meal or day to day. It responds to total energy balance, not breakfast routines.

SPEAKER_03

It's quite good.

SPEAKER_04

Studies. Yes. Here you are. No, you know, you're the study person.

SPEAKER_03

Oh, why am I the study person?

SPEAKER_04

That's fine. Learn.

SPEAKER_03

Te at al 1991 shows no meaningful difference in metabolic rate between eating one meal or six.

SPEAKER_04

That's Te at al.

SPEAKER_03

Te at al.

SPEAKER_04

Right. Okay, yeah, there we go.

SPEAKER_03

Bell Oil at al, 1997, even found no difference in 24-hour energy expenditure between nibbling or gorging.

SPEAKER_04

Right, okay. There you go. So that that goes a bit more into meal frequency, doesn't it, as well?

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_04

And and how how meal frequency might affect your weight loss goals or your goals or your metabolism goes into the whole, oh, you must eat frequently throughout the day to keep the metabolism, to keep your metabolism stoked, to make sure the lawnmower doesn't shut down again, you've got kickstarted by eating more. One meal a day, that's not gonna work, your metabolism will be will be dead, drained. As always. Depending what your goal is. It's the behaviors, it's the habits, it's the total calories. If that what do you do?

SPEAKER_03

Time, Ben. It's an hour.

SPEAKER_04

Right, I know. Yes, we've been distracted by that turning off, haven't we? No. Why is it turned off? Yes, it's the same thing. It's the same thing, isn't it?

SPEAKER_03

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

Some people enjoy eating one meal a day. Some people enjoy eating six.

SPEAKER_03

I enjoy eating two. And then treating it.

SPEAKER_04

Brilliant. But it doesn't make a difference on your metabolism. Don't feel obliged to have to kick start it in the morning, which you won't, because if you did have to kickstart it, you'd be in trouble.

SPEAKER_03

Dead.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. So don't worry about having a big breakfast. If you're not hungry in the morning, don't eat. No problem. Your metabolism will be absolutely fine.

SPEAKER_03

Be grand. Be grand, Frankie. Okay. Where do you want me to go now? Here.

SPEAKER_04

Anything else on that, Fiona?

SPEAKER_03

Uh do you want me to start about denetient crap like that?

SPEAKER_04

Well, yes, a metabolism is affected by there there's an adaption in your metabolism based on you losing weight. We've discussed this, haven't we?

SPEAKER_01

Yes, we have. So people who

SPEAKER_04

Talk about they've got a broken metabolism or they can't lose weight because of their metabolism. If you're losing weights, you become a smaller person, which means your BMR basal metabolic rate, which we've talked about, you require less calories to exist. Your metabolism slows down a little bit because you become a smaller person who requires less calories.

SPEAKER_01

Ah, yes, I remember that.

SPEAKER_04

So it's adapted.

SPEAKER_01

Clever little thing, isn't it?

SPEAKER_04

But also behaviors. Neat, non-exercise activity phonogenesis, which we've discussed, which we've touched upon many times. Yes. That reduces. You're hungry. Less energy. You may not want to move as much. Some people exercise too much. They go crazy with the exercise. Ironically, exercising too much means that you're reducing your neat. And your neat makes up 60 to 70% of the calories that you burn every day.

SPEAKER_03

What's neat again?

SPEAKER_04

Non-exercise activity thermogenesis.

SPEAKER_03

Thank you.

SPEAKER_04

Be careful. If you're exercising like crazy all of a sudden, if you go from zero to six times a week, it's too much. Chances are your neat will reduce. You'll stop moving in between sessions as much. And that will hamper your weight loss goals. It sounds crazy, doesn't it? But I've got to exercise as much as possible. Exercise and that loses weight, no, it doesn't. No. Exercise for health, for strength, for purpose.

SPEAKER_03

So like on to six spin sessions a week.

SPEAKER_04

If if you love spin and you can recover from it.

SPEAKER_03

But then you don't do anything else. Whereas if you did tree and then you went for a walk every day.

SPEAKER_04

Yes.

SPEAKER_03

That'd be better.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. We've discussed this before, haven't we? Yes, we've got to be. Bodybuilders, people that are that are deep in deep in prep. They they stop blinking as much.

SPEAKER_03

What do you mean blinking?

SPEAKER_04

They stop blinking as much. People have been observed when you get into an extreme deficit or you're prepping for a bodybuilding show or whatever. Whatever you whatever reason that you may be in a in a big deficit. That your body starts to conserve energy. So it has to find lots of ways to conserve energy.

unknown

Right.

SPEAKER_04

So it stops you moving as much. It stops you wanting to move. This, the arms. Oh, you can't see it now because the camera's off. The arms, the hands. If I got into a a deep deficit, chances are that I would just stop moving as much. That's right. I would slow right down. I won't I wouldn't have the energy to do this. I wouldn't want to. But that's your body's like, no, sorry, Ben, you can't be as handsy anymore.

SPEAKER_03

That's so interesting though, isn't it? Yes. But how your body responds to that. Like to the point where you're not blinking as much.

SPEAKER_04

Yes, because you're starving, you're slowly starving yourself to death. So your body's not your body can't tell, oh, he's in his prep for his bodybuilding show. Oh, he's he's doing his photo shoot in six weeks. Oh, that's why we've reduced our calories. Oh, no worries. I'll I'll keep the energy high up for you, Ben, so you can do your walks, no worries.

Dieting Leads To Blinking Less

SPEAKER_03

But then my question is, and I've I've asked this question before, and you've answered the question, I can't remember what the response is. But then surely it is not good for these bodybuilders to be in that huge of a definition.

SPEAKER_04

Well it's not good for anyone to be in a massive.

SPEAKER_03

With anybody, yeah, but I was just that was the example you give.

SPEAKER_04

For a sustained period of time.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. But then it's only a short period of time, isn't it? That to do it for.

SPEAKER_04

Well, 12 weeks.

SPEAKER_03

Freaking hell. That's a quarter of the year.

SPEAKER_04

Dropping it bit by bit though. So the first six weeks. It depends what you're doing, depends what your goals are, but yeah.

SPEAKER_03

It's just it must be so harmful.

SPEAKER_04

Bodybuilding, it's one of those things, it's one of those sports.

SPEAKER_03

You're depriving, but then you're depriving your body, and I know you said about the diet that like you'd have somebody to start introducing the food in and whatnot, but you're going from deprivation to basically overloading. Essentially.

SPEAKER_04

When it when you're overloading.

SPEAKER_03

When when you start eating normally again. Right. I know you have that phase where you where you where you have your start introducing the introduction, whatever whatever phase is.

SPEAKER_04

Well, for everyone, regardless of bodybuilding. Maintenance phase, reverse dieting.

SPEAKER_03

I don't know which phase it was, but yeah.

SPEAKER_04

If you're dieting for a big chunk of time, if you're in in a in a deficit, in a large deficit for a a large chunk of time, it will be very beneficial to creep back up to maintenance. Your new maintenance, because you're in you are a smaller person now. So not the maintenance you had before. That's not maintenance anymore. That that's a surplus.

SPEAKER_03

But then a lot of people will go to bulk phase, then wouldn't they?

SPEAKER_04

If you go from a massive deficit for 12, 16 weeks and then start bulking straight away, yes, you you will put on a lot of fat quick.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

A lot of weight, including fat.

SPEAKER_03

But then that's my that's my argument. Surely that's that's not good for your body when you do it that way, because when you start to think about the extra sugar that's in your body, the extra everything, the protein, which your body now has to work harder to get rid of. So you're using your car, your your heart, you're using your kidneys more, liver, all of that more, but it's just been deprived for the past 12 weeks, not being able to bloody blink. Surely it has it's so bad for the body.

SPEAKER_04

If you're going through regular bouts of it over the years, it's not great.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Just yeah, it's it's very fascinating.

SPEAKER_04

This is good, well, let's save it because unfortunately I have I have semi-switched off because the camera's switched off. Well, I think that was very, very, we've gone way over the hour mark, and we've not even talked about the film. So the film is gonna have to be another five-minute job again, and that's it. It's annoying, it's frustrating. More editing now is now involved. It's rubbish. Rubbish. I need to mess. So what a shame. What a shame. Because I think the first, well, however long we got before the camera turned off, no idea. I think it was okay. This new format, I'm not very comfortable, but not bad.

SPEAKER_03

Not bad then.

SPEAKER_04

Certain things to work on, but not bad. I love hearing the enthusiasm. Let's keep that going. Let's bottle that moment, Fiona. They can't see it because the camera's off, but they can hear it.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

So that let's bottle that enthusiasm and let's br let's take that forward into the new year. No, sorry, I mean I mean deadly serious.

SPEAKER_03

You're so annoying. No, because that's what you want, Fiona. Let's take it into the new year.

SPEAKER_04

That's what you want, because in the future, when I can find someone else to edit these as well. So if the camera was to turn off or there was a malfunction, it'd be like, oh, that's that's annoying. But I'm not dealing with it, so it doesn't matter. Steve's dealing with it. I'd go, Fiona, this is fantastic. Keep going. I love the enthusiasm. Are you listening?

SPEAKER_03

Yes, I know. I'm just trying to do this.

SPEAKER_04

So what I'm saying is good job. That's great. Thank you.

SPEAKER_03

Thank you, darling.

SPEAKER_04

So keep that up.

SPEAKER_03

Right. What film are we talking about?

SPEAKER_04

Trick or treat. Sorry, this is gonna be rubbish.

SPEAKER_03

It's not trick or treat.

SPEAKER_04

Trick or treat.

Trick R Treat Film Review

SPEAKER_03

Yep. So what year was it, Med? 2007. I was doing North for a 1987 one, just to let you know. Oh wow, that's yeah, did did that film look like it was made in 1987? It did not, and I was thinking, this is weird. You've only got I looked at the characters and I was just like, oh, this isn't right.

SPEAKER_04

You've now only got one job, Fiona, because you don't do a lot of the reading anymore. So you you need to really nail this film part. No pressure, you need to focus. Okay, I'm gonna be able to do it. You need to get your head.

SPEAKER_03

Just to let me get a word in, that'd be great.

SPEAKER_04

Trick R treat. Trick R treat. Trick R treat.

SPEAKER_03

2007, 6.7 under IMDB. What do you think of that?

SPEAKER_04

I think it's quite a good film, actually. I think we watched it, everyone was in a bit of a bad mood. It was like, oh, this is a bit ugh.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, there was some good bits on it.

SPEAKER_04

I think it I think it's I can see why it's a it's a beloved recent Halloween film. A lot of people enjoy Trick R treat. It's it's one of those films that ushers in the the season.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, but when I was reading when I was reading the notes and I was reading the synopsis, it kind of made sense to film because I did have a hump on watching it, didn't I? Okay, well, the synopsis is five Halloween stories.

SPEAKER_04

It's an anthology, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

I didn't know that. So a principal has a secret life, granted a serial killer, a virgin is looking for her first time, a group of kids pull a prank, a woman who loads Halloween does not respect the rules, and a mean old man meets a demonic trick or treater. So I didn't realise they were all stories because it's it's quite cleverly done because they are very intertwined though.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. Yeah, you you might you were watching the film, weren't you? Yeah. So the characters. I didn't realise.

SPEAKER_03

I didn't I didn't I didn't really realise.

SPEAKER_04

Right.

SPEAKER_03

So what are the rules, Ben? It says here does not respect the rules. Tell me the rules of Halloween.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, from Sam, is it the Pumpkin Man?

SPEAKER_03

The Pumpkin Man, yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Quite a good character.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, there is something about him.

SPEAKER_04

Quite icon quite iconic, that character. Oh no, that's nice. Memorable.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. Quite freaky.

SPEAKER_04

Yes.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. That scene. At the end when he's with the old man and he just goes across the room. No, that's yeah. That was a good scene.

SPEAKER_04

It was you were yeah.

SPEAKER_03

I like the way he came back together as well.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, pumpkin seeds came out of him as well. Yeah. It was very good. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

When I think it was. It's good. This film's got some good stuff. Yeah. Anyway, sorry, Dave.

SPEAKER_04

Rule one, always wear a costume. Yeah. So this is Sam, the demonic sack man.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Rule two, always always pass out treats to trick or treaters. Rule three, never blow out a jack-o'-lantern before midnight. Oh. You tell me.

SPEAKER_03

Bad luck.

SPEAKER_04

Bad luck.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, it keeps it keeps it even more.

SPEAKER_04

Rule four, always check your candy.

SPEAKER_03

Oh why?

SPEAKER_04

Rule five, always respect the dead. Rule six, never take down your decorations before November the first. Rule seven, never hurt the innocent.

SPEAKER_03

So just come back to rule number four there. Always check your candy. Why? So the candy bear bar that Sam uses to attack the old man is the same candy bar that he got from the principal earlier in the movie.

SPEAKER_00

Very good.

SPEAKER_03

The principal put razor blades in the chocolate bars before he handed them out. That's how he killed them. So that's a very important rule, isn't it?

SPEAKER_04

Absolutely, yes.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, yes.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, the principal, great. I can imagine there's lots of teachers out there that would watch us and go, Oh, good for you, buddy. If I could, if I could murder some of these fat little shits, I would. Oh well, the rules are gone now. There's no rules now because the camera's turned off.

SPEAKER_00

Oh, okay.

SPEAKER_04

If I could, yeah, if I could may maybe not murder, maybe just teach these kids a lesson. I'm sure we'd be nice. Scare them. There's some manners on them.

SPEAKER_03

There is another rule there as well. Never blow out a jack or lantern before midnight. So I quite like the way it did this because at the end, so it started at the film started with an opening scene, which was actually the end of the film. Does that make sense? Because you're one, she blows out the jack or lantern, doesn't she?

SPEAKER_04

And then it goes earlier in the day, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, and then it it then the film starts with how she was murdered or whatever. So I quite like the way it did that, but you didn't realise until the end that it did that. So you're kind of it's kind of showing the rules, isn't it? All the rules.

unknown

Yes.

SPEAKER_03

In Fernanda. Yes, it is Fiona. Yeah, you see it. That's all young kids going round to that In the bus? What's it called? That I went to quarry.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. It's got some pretty heavy stuff in that those uh those what do we call them the children in the bus? Mentally handicapped?

SPEAKER_03

I don't know.

SPEAKER_04

Special needs?

SPEAKER_03

I think there are special needs.

SPEAKER_04

Okay but that that's that's quite that's quite heavy. So you've got a bus driver and parents who have gone, sorry, these kids are insufferable. Can you go and drive them into a lake?

SPEAKER_03

That's terrible. But was he going to do that because he gave out treaties first?

SPEAKER_04

So what happened? Unfortunately, bless him. Timmy, or we just called him Timmy. He just ended up driving the bus into the quarry anyway.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. So But how did he oh because he wasn't strapped in.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. So it kind of happened anyway. But yeah, good effort for trying to save the children.

SPEAKER_03

Trivia on that, they actually recruited those who did have some sort of d some sort of disabilities for that scene or some sort of inner um injuries for that scene. Okay. And they apparently had a hoot and they really enjoyed themselves. Lovely.

SPEAKER_04

Well, that's lovely. No.

SPEAKER_03

But quite heavy. Very heavy. Really heavy for the parents to do that and the bus driver to actually carry it out as well.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah.

SPEAKER_03

And then to live with that.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, what a shame. Decent film. Lots to discuss. The Red Riding Hood. That's that's good.

SPEAKER_03

So Anna Pakwans.

SPEAKER_04

Nowhere near, but that's fine.

SPEAKER_03

Her character, Laurie, is named after Laurie Strohl from Halloween 1978.

SPEAKER_04

Makes sense.

SPEAKER_03

The first note that I have here, Michael Myers scenes in the open scene. Remember across the road?

SPEAKER_04

Yes. Someone just ended out.

SPEAKER_03

That's Michael Myers kind of homage.

SPEAKER_04

A homage, yes.

SPEAKER_03

So that was very that was that was quite a bit.

SPEAKER_04

That was good. The werewolves. The werewolves.

SPEAKER_03

As you know, the werewolf transformations are done practically with some CG CG enhancements. Fantastic. Because Michael Dor Doherty, who is the director, knows that full C CG transformations don't always look the best. What do you think of that?

SPEAKER_04

No, that yeah. Yeah. He's spot on. They look haggard most of the time. And this was 15, 16 years ago. So you can only imagine. Well, saying that, in my mind, CGI doesn't look like it's improved.

SPEAKER_03

No.

SPEAKER_04

That much? No. Since. So.

SPEAKER_03

He also did Krampus.

SPEAKER_04

He did? Yes.

SPEAKER_03

Not bad. Not bad. I actually don't mind Krampus. It's alright, Krampus. I don't like I don't like the second one. I think there's a second one. We've discussed Krampus, haven't we, on the old show?

SPEAKER_04

Oh, they were the days.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, and that's my notes. On that.

SPEAKER_04

Okay.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_03

I think we've kind of covered both.

SPEAKER_04

Well, I would happily spend if the video was still on, I'd spend an extra five minutes on it. But no.

SPEAKER_03

And your note there gets gets a lot done in a short amount of time. It was perfect. It was perfect.

SPEAKER_04

82 minutes, wasn't it? Yeah.

SPEAKER_03

Perfect amount of time. In and out. Told a story. There was no Oh, it had a disclaimer. Sorry, it just kept into my he came into my head there. It had a disclaimer because of the jack-o'-lanterns or the pumpkins that were all in your man's house. Do you know um at the the old man's house? There was hundreds.

SPEAKER_04

Yes, I saw them, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

They had a disclaimer, no pumpkins were harmed during the making of this film. It's yeah, it's it's silly. It's silly. I'm getting it. But you don't realise it until you're I didn't realise it when I was watching the film. It was when I did this, when I was just actually, it's actually a good film.

SPEAKER_04

I think this is it. I think it's one of those one of those films that does the opposite. Sometimes you remember films a lot more fondly, and then you re-watch them and go, oh dear.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, that was that actually wasn't very good.

SPEAKER_03

I think I'd sit and watch this again now.

SPEAKER_04

Right, there you go. Because this is it.

SPEAKER_03

I'm more educated on it. The yearly tradition.

SPEAKER_04

Halloween.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Halloween season hits, you put this on. And I'm getting that's what people do.

SPEAKER_03

All of my notes.

SPEAKER_04

By the sounds of it, it's it's very well regarded.

SPEAKER_03

All of my notes are just negative. Charlie Nick and Street's weird name. Oh, you had you had a stinky attribute watching that film. Stupid quarry story.

SPEAKER_04

We still smell it now. Hideous. I've got hit the memory of the movie lingers more in the initial watching experience. So you watch it and go, oh, like you did. Oh, that's oh stinks. Rubbish. And then now we'll talk about it. Oh, actually, yeah, no, actually, it was there was some good stuff. And then hopefully you rewatch it again and go, Oh, do you know what?

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

It's silly, but that's the whole point.

SPEAKER_03

It's got a huge cult following that following it. Yes, it does.

SPEAKER_04

Yes. And uh I I believe Michael has number two, the script, ready to go. I feel they're they're re-releasing it this year, or maybe last year. It's been released either last year or this year. In because it never got a a cinema release.

SPEAKER_00

Oh.

SPEAKER_04

Which didn't help. So it just got banded around film festivals and then started building its cult following.

SPEAKER_03

Oh. Yeah, no. I think I'd go see that. I think I would. Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

If anything, if anything oh, sorry.

SPEAKER_03

I like the link that I had as well with the vampire, um, the principal dress dressed up as a vampire, didn't I? And then the werewolves, because in all stories, werewolves and vampires are enemies, aren't they?

SPEAKER_04

Yes, there you go, very good. So it's quite a bit. Yeah, I wasn't quite getting the need to have him as as the serial killer. Yeah, it's like we get this guy, this guy's a shit, yeah. But geez. And this as well.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. Um and we didn't see any kills.

SPEAKER_04

From who?

SPEAKER_03

From anybody. When you think about it, we've seen that we seen it before, but we didn't see the drawing. We just seen it after. We've seen the little boy's head on the table. We've seen her turn into the werewolf but not kill him.

SPEAKER_04

Uh yeah, I suppose.

SPEAKER_03

We've seen her just hung up on the tang underneath the phone.

SPEAKER_04

Maybe that was to keep it to fifteen, potentially. But yeah, yeah, the principal, yeah. So he killed killed the kid, yeah. Good good on him. But then then he was teaching I don't know, Billy or whoever, his child, how to kill.

SPEAKER_03

What happened, Billy, in the end?

SPEAKER_04

W was he not dressed up in his dad's shirt with the blood on at the end? He was sitting on the step on the step. He's now in the next generation. He can now continue his dad's good work. Oh, he'll probably be in the next one. Oh, I hope so.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_04

I've got here, it's almost too Halloween-y. It is a bit there's a lot of films, it's probably similar to Christmas. There's a lot of films that are set round the season or the holiday, but aren't actually based on Halloween. Eve even Halloween itself, even Michael Myers, it's set at Halloween, but it's not very Halloween-y. No, it's a lot of people. There's some leaves on the floor, but it's like apart from that, it's like, oh my god, this is so Halloween y.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, but then this is this is this film's kind of playing into the culture, isn't it? The Halloween culture in America, because it's the reporter. Oh, it's Halloween. It's a big festival, everyone's dressed up. Yes, it was very Halloween. It's playing into it as well a little bit, which it which makes it even more like, oh, it's actually Halloween. Spooky shit's gonna happen.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, yes, yeah. So it it does a lot, it does a lot well for itself.

SPEAKER_03

It does, yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, it rams it down your throat, Halloween, which is nice if you like Halloween.

SPEAKER_03

Well, I have to say, Ben, I'm so sorry for having a stinking attitude.

SPEAKER_04

Talking to the mite, you must.

SPEAKER_03

I'm very sorry for having a stinking attitude.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, a rotten attitude, you'd say you had a rotten attitude.

SPEAKER_03

Yep, yeah, just like I do to exercise and nutrition.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah. Oh, that's brilliant. That's brilliant. What a shame about the camera. Because this episode has been okay. It's been okay.

SPEAKER_03

I think it's been up there, Ben. Yeah. I think it's been a very chilled.

SPEAKER_04

Okay. Well, this is the future, then. We've got to get that laptop sorted out. We've we've got to get we've got to work on certain things. But this is the future.

SPEAKER_03

And Donald has been in and very quiet and behaved.

SPEAKER_04

I got used to this position. I'm still very uncomfortable.

SPEAKER_03

And the lights, who did that this morning?

SPEAKER_04

Oh, yeah. Okay, the lights changed, hasn't it? Because the curtains have been left open again.

SPEAKER_03

So we didn't quite all with closed Ben. The blinds haven't been.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, we didn't quite get it. We didn't quite get it. So next time the curtains will shut so the light doesn't stream in.

SPEAKER_03

Well, it's a learning curve. Anyhow, say goodbye. Pushable health.

SPEAKER_04

Pushable health. Yes? Oh my god. What's the outro? Pushable health.

SPEAKER_03

Pushing your health from the puzzle. We're on all the socials. We're on them.

SPEAKER_04

I'm trying to build this YouTube channel. It doesn't help when you can't actually use the camera and it turns off. That's a bit of a bummer because YouTube's about video. So that sucks. That hurts.

SPEAKER_03

Well you can put half a video on.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, brilliant. Great. Excellent. Yep. So yeah, YouTube, all the socials. Podcast, podcast. Podcast platforms are all we're on there.

SPEAKER_03

Are we on Spotify?

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I just said all the platforms, Fiona. All the platforms are on there.

SPEAKER_03

Sometimes, Ben, it's good to be specific.

SPEAKER_04

We're on there. Push poor health. Type it in, you'll find us. And what yeah, the logo is there's no logo. Well, there is a logo, but and we need to we need to work on certain things. But we're getting there. This is the next stage. We're now going all in.

SPEAKER_01

Thank you.

SPEAKER_04

What was the number, Fiona? We're in on this. We had a brief discussion. Off mic, off camera. The camera's off. What's the number? What's the number that we need to get to? Financially, subscribers, downloads, before we can start doing this at least once a week, if not twice. What do we need to get to where you can justify it?

SPEAKER_03

500k per year.

SPEAKER_04

Downloads?

SPEAKER_03

Money.

SPEAKER_04

I need to earn half a million pounds from this podcast.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, because then I don't know.

SPEAKER_04

So you need I to quit your job, you need to be earning a half a million just from the podcast. Is that right?

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

Okay. That seems expensive. That's a lot.

SPEAKER_03

Per year.

SPEAKER_04

What about downloads? What about subscribers? I say to you, Fiona, we've got 10,000 subscribers.

SPEAKER_03

I don't know what that means though.

SPEAKER_04

10,000 subscribers.

SPEAKER_03

I'd say what's going on.

SPEAKER_04

We got we got 10,000 downloads this week.

SPEAKER_03

That'd be impressive.

SPEAKER_04

Okay. Right?

SPEAKER_03

Right.

SPEAKER_04

Are you open to a second episode based on those numbers?

SPEAKER_03

Maybe.

SPEAKER_04

Okay.

SPEAKER_03

Maybe not.

SPEAKER_04

Right, pushable health. Pushable health. There will be a ball Canadian man talking about pushable health. At some point.

SPEAKER_03

Charlotte. And happy Halloween. Happy Halloween. It's Halloween next week.

SPEAKER_04

Happy Halloween. Go and watch Trick or Treat. Trick or treat. It's it's fun.

SPEAKER_03

And don't have a hump like I did.

SPEAKER_04

82 minutes. It's a good stuff.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_04

It's it's a good stuff. It's good stuff.

SPEAKER_03

It's a good stuff. Bye.

SPEAKER_04

Cheers.

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.

Review It Yourself Artwork

Review It Yourself

Review It Yourself