Heart at Work with Trina Sunday

59. The Moment HR Stops Being Safe. A Story We Need to Sit With

• Trina Sunday • Episode 59

Share episode

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 16:53

What happens when someone does exactly what the system tells them to do, and the system still fails them?

In this episode, I unpack Susan Fowler’s experience inside Uber and the leadership decisions that turned a report of sexual harassment into a full-scale culture and governance crisis. This is not just a conversation about one organisation. It’s a conversation about power, accountability, leadership and the moments where culture is shaped in real time.

I talk about what happens when HR processes prioritise high performers over psychological safety, how language like “choice” can disguise unfair systems, and why small moments of inaction eventually become enterprise risk. If you lead people, influence culture or work in HR, this episode will challenge you to think differently about courage, responsibility and what human-first leadership looks like under pressure.

What would you do if someone walked into your office with evidence and trusted you to act? Connect with me on LinkedIn and let me know your thoughts on this conversation

SHOW NOTES: https://trinasunday.com/get-inspired/ 

Trina Sunday is a human-first leadership strategist, HR advisor and creator of the HEART Work™ model, helping HR leaders and People & Culture professionals build workplaces where people and performance thrive side by side. With more than 25 years of experience across HR, organisational development and leadership advisory in Australia, Asia and global leadership communities, she works with HR leaders and executive teams to strengthen leadership capability, shape workplace culture and drive human-first organisational transformation. Through the Heart at Work with Trina Sunday podcast, leadership programs and advisory work, Trina is passionate about empowering HR professionals to move beyond compliance and lead the future of HR with courage, clarity and influence.

Get Inspired 

Susan Fowler and Uber: The Moment Organisations Choose What They Protect

Today, I am taking you inside a story you have likely heard, but maybe have not sat with like this. Not as a headline, not as a scandal, but as a series of moments where something could have gone differently.

This is what happened inside Uber through the lived experience of Susan Fowler. Because this is not just about one company. It is about leadership. It is about HR and the exact point where organisations stop being human first and start protecting something else.

So as you listen, hold this question. What would I have done in that moment?


Welcome to Heart at Work with me, Trina Sunday.

This space is for HR leaders who care deeply about performance and equally deeply about people.

For more than 25 years, I have been asking one persistent question. What are the real conditions for happiness at work? Because when humans come first, something deeper shifts. How people show up, how leaders decide and how work feels.

Here we explore what it really takes to lead with courage, compassion and clarity. And we pull up a chair to the conversations HR leaders do not always get to have.

There is heart here, but there is also depth. If you are ready to build workplaces where people and performance thrive side by side, you are in the right place.


The First Moment

Let us get to the heart of it.

You have just started a new job. It is the kind of role you have worked really hard for. A respected company, fast moving, high performing. The kind of place people talk about like it is shaping the future.

You have chosen your team carefully. You are excited about the work. You are ready to contribute.

And then, on what is effectively your first proper day with your manager, a message comes through. Not about work. Not about onboarding.

He starts talking about his personal life. About being in an open relationship and how his girlfriend finds partners easily but he does not. And how he is trying to stay out of trouble at work, but it is difficult.

It does not take long before you realise what is happening. This is not awkward small talk. It is a proposition.

And I want to pause here, because this is the moment most people rush past. This is the first signal. Before HR. Before process. Before escalation.

This is the moment your body registers that something is off.

If you have ever been in a situation like that, you will know exactly what I mean. That split second while you are recalibrating. Where your brain is trying to catch up with what just happened and you are asking yourself, did that really just happen?

That is how Susan Fowler’s experience began at Uber. Not gradually. Immediately. Day one.


The System Is Tested

She does not ignore it. She does not minimise it. She does not try to rationalise it away.

She does exactly what we tell people to do.

She documents it. Takes screenshots. Captures the evidence. And reports it to HR.

If you are listening to this as a HR leader, I want you to really sit in this moment. Because this is the moment your function exists for. This is the moment the system is meant to work.

This is the moment where trust is either built or broken.

She walks into that conversation with clear, documented, undeniable evidence. And HR agrees with her. They explicitly say yes, this is sexual harassment.

No ambiguity. No grey area. No misunderstanding.

The organisation knows exactly what this is.


The Shift

And then something happens that changes everything.

Instead of action, the conversation shifts away from her experience and towards him. His high performance. His value to the company. His future that might be compromised.

She is told something that sounds almost reasonable until you really hear it.

He is a high performer. This is his first offence. They do not want to damage his career.

And then she is given a choice.

She can stay on the team, continue working with him, knowing that he will likely retaliate through a poor performance review.

Or she can leave. Start again. Give up the work she was hired to do.


The Illusion of Choice

If we slow this right down, this is one of those moments where organisations tell you exactly who they are.

What would I have expected to happen?

Immediate action. Clear boundaries. Protection of the employee who reported it. A signal, loud and unmissable, that this behaviour is not acceptable.

Instead, what happens is far more subtle and far more damaging.

The responsibility shifts from the person who created the situation to the person who reported it.

She pushes back. She explains that she has specific expertise that the team and the company need. That moving teams is not neutral. It has real consequences.

But she is told again, these are your options.

One HR representative reframes it in a way that is incredibly telling.

If she receives a poor performance review later, it would not actually be retaliation, because she was given a choice.

And this is where language becomes powerful.

Choice sounds fair. Balanced. Reasonable.

But it is not. Because a real choice does not come with punishment attached to it.


When Patterns Emerge

She moves teams, not because she wants to, but because she has to.

For a moment, things stabilise. She finds another team. She is doing excellent work. She rebuilds some sense of normality.

Then something else starts happening.

Quiet conversations with other women in the organisation.

Slowly, a pattern emerges.

They have had similar experiences with the same manager. Not one. Not two. Multiple.

Some had reported him before she even joined.

This is where the story fundamentally shifts.

This is no longer a misunderstanding. This is a pattern. A known pattern. A documented pattern.


Denial

She goes back to HR, this time not alone.

Multiple voices. Multiple accounts. A clear, consistent story.

This is the moment you expect the system to correct itself.

Instead, HR tells her there are no other reports. No one else has complained. There is no record of this behaviour.

Even though the pattern is real.

This is the moment where something deeper breaks.

Because now it is not just inaction. It is denial.

When an organisation denies a known pattern, it is asking the individual to question their own reality.

When the system rewrites what is real, trust does not erode. It disappears.


When the Reporter Becomes the Problem

From here, things evolve, but not in a good way.

She continues to raise concerns.

Now she is told she is being unprofessional for documenting things. That escalating via email is inappropriate. That she should be more careful.

Notice what has changed.

The behaviour has not changed. But the problem has.

Now, the issue is her.

When documenting problems becomes the problem, you are no longer solving anything. You are protecting the system.


The Culture Reveals Itself


Competitive, Not Collaborative

While all of this is happening, the broader culture starts to reveal itself.

Leadership dynamics are competitive, not collaborative.

Managers undermine each other. People withhold information to gain advantage and even brag about it.

Projects are abandoned. Priorities shift constantly.

It is unstable. It is not predictable.

This is not one bad manager. This is a system where power is protected and accountability is optional.


The Leather Jackets

Then there is a moment that might look small, but says everything.

The leather jackets.

There is a team tradition where new hires receive leather jackets. They are symbolic. They signal belonging.

When Susan joins, she is asked for her size, just like everyone else.

An expectation is created. That she is included. That she is part of the team.

The jackets arrive.

The men receive them.

The women do not.

Not delayed. Not coming later. Just not included.

She remembers giving her size. She remembers being part of the process.

So this is not an oversight. This is a decision made after inclusion was implied.

She asks what happened.

The answer is casual.

There were not enough women to justify placing an order.

No one stopped. No one questioned it. No one adjusted.

They simply removed them from the outcome.

This is where the emotional contract breaks.

Inclusion was implied. Participation was invited. Then quietly withdrawn.

She pushes back. Calmly. Logically. Reasonably.

But the response is resistance, delay and a lack of urgency.

Eventually, the conversation turns.

She is asked whether she might be the problem.

Raise an issue. Become the issue.


Escalation and Exit

Shortly after, it escalates again.

Her manager tells her she is on thin ice. That raising concerns and documenting things could get her fired.

There is no ambiguity.

She reports it again.

This time, HR acknowledges that what happened is inappropriate, even illegal.

For a moment, you think this is where it changes.

It does not.

Nothing changes.

No accountability. No consequence. No shift.

Within a week, she leaves.

Not because she could not do the job. She was an exceptional engineer.

But the environment made it impossible for her to stay.


When It Becomes Visible

She writes about it.

And when she does, it does not just circulate. It explodes.

From an executive perspective, everything shifts.

What was internal becomes visible.

Uber launches an independent investigation led by Eric Holder.

Over 20 employees are terminated. Senior executives exit. The CEO, Travis Kalanick, resigns.

This is not just culture.

This is reputational risk. Talent risk. Governance failure. Legal exposure. Investor confidence.

And none of it started with a headline.

It started with a moment. A report. A decision not to act.

Then another. Then a pattern ignored.

Over time, those moments compound.

Risk is cumulative.


The Real Question

This story is not confronting because it is extreme.

It is confronting because it is familiar.

Versions of this play out every day.

Not always this overt. Not always this documented.

But in small moments.

Where something is seen and not acted on. Where something is reported and minimised. Where something is known and ignored.

That is how culture is built or broken.

Human first leadership is not about intention.

It is about what happens in the moment when pressure hits. When power is involved. When decisions have consequences.

That is when culture is written.

So the question is not what went wrong at Uber.

The question is, when that moment shows up in your organisation, what will you do?

Because human first workplaces do not happen by accident.

They are created in the moments where we choose courage over comfort.

And that is heart work.


Closing

If this story has sparked something for you, not just interest but recognition, you will find more about my strategic advisory work at trinasunday.com.

Because these conversations do not belong in a podcast. They belong in the rooms where decisions are made.

Thanks for spending time with me.

If this conversation challenged you, clarified something or simply reminded you that you are not the only one holding the tension between people and performance, then it has done exactly what it was meant to.

This work is not easy, but it is necessary.

HR has a new future, and it leads with heart.

If you found value here, subscribe so you do not miss what is next.

Share this episode with someone who also believes that work can be better.

And if you want to go deeper, explore the Heart Work model, the programmes and the growing community of HR leaders at trinasunday.com.

Because when HR leads with clarity, courage and compassion, it does not just change workplaces.

It changes lives.

Until next time, keep asking better questions, keep backing your voice and keep putting humanity at the centre of performance.

Let us keep heart at work.