How to Coach Your Customer Success Team to Be More Strategic

In this episode, I break down what being strategic actually means in a Customer Success context. And how you, as a CS leader, can help your team move from task execution to value leadership.

We’ll walk through:

• The 5 core behaviors that define strategic CSMs
• How to coach and enable your team to develop this skillset
• Tactical ways to embed strategic thinking into your culture and operating model

Plus, I’ll share real frameworks, coaching questions and enablement tips you can start using right away.

If you want to build a CS team that drives revenue, retention and long-term customer value, not just completes tasks, this episode is a must-listen.

Ways I Can Help You Level Up Customer Success:

1. Value Realization Framework Online Course:  Install a repeatable system your team can run: deliver value, prove outcomes, and drive retention and expansion. Self-paced with ready-to-use templates. Learn more.
2. Newsletter: Practical, revenue-driven CS strategies in your inbox. No fluff. Subscribe here.
3. 1:1 Coaching: Hands-on guidance to roll out value realization in your org. Book a free consult call.

For more information, visit my website: Explore more resources and insights. CS RevSpeak

Let's Connect on Linkedin:  Get weekly insights, templates and real talk on CS leadership. Follow Angeline on LinkedIn.

Until next time, keep driving success and speaking the language of revenue!

Transcript

Angeline Gavino 0:39

Today's topic is one I know every customer success leader has said at least once, maybe a hundred times. We need to be more strategic. It's one of the most common pieces of feedback I hear in one-on-ones, team meetings, skip levels, and even performance reviews. But here's the thing: as common as it is, it's actually rarely well defined. It's fake, it's overused, and more often than not, your CSMs are sitting there thinking, yeah, okay, but what does that actually mean in my day-to-day work? If you've ever told your team to be more strategic, but didn't quite know how to guide them through it, this episode is for you. I'm gonna break down what strategic actually means in a customer success context, why it's often misunderstood, and how you as a customer success leader can help your team not just understand strategy, but actually operate that way every day. Welcome to the CS RevSpeak podcast, where we talk about practical insights, strategies, and frameworks that will help customer success leaders who carry a revenue number, drive sustainable growth, maximize customer lifetime value, and crush their numbers. I want to start by addressing the elephant in the room. Be strategic isn't actionable feedback. Yes, it sounds important, it sounds ambitious, but without context, it leaves your CSMs guessing. And when people are guessing, they default to what looks strategic. And that could mean for them, fancy QBR slides or a lot of QBR slides, over using executive language, adding more meanings to show their thinking big. But underneath all of that, the core behaviors often stay the same because they've never been shown a better way. I've seen this play out so many times as CSM thinks they're being more strategic by talking about product roadmap or by including benchmarks in their QBR. But when you ask, what are these customers' actual business goals? What metrics are they trying to move? They don't know how to answer. They've polished the surface, but they haven't really shifted their thinking. And it's not because they don't care, it's because we haven't defined what good looks like. We say be more strategic, but we don't break it down into real behaviors. We don't coach them through it, we don't show them how to think beyond tasks and outcomes. So instead of stepping into strategic thinking, they stay stuck in tactical execution, just with fancier packaging. If we want our CS teams to level up, we've got to get sharper as CS leaders too. And that means shifting from vague aspiration to specific coaching. It means showing, not just telling. And it means helping your CSMs connect the dots between their work and the customer's bigger business picture. And that starts with getting clear ourselves on what strategic actually looks like in the customer success world. Now that we've called out the ambiguity of being more strategic, let's get clear on what it actually means in the context of CS. Because being strategic isn't just about being more senior or sounding smarter, and it's definitely not about doing more for the sake of looking impactful. Being strategic is about making intentional decisions that drive business outcomes, both for the customer and for your company. So let me say that again. Strategic CSMs make intentional decisions that drive business outcomes. That means stepping out of task execution mode and into value creation mode. You need to shift the mental model from what do I need to do this week to what will move this customer's business forward. Let's break that down further. Strategic thinking and customer success typically shows up in five ways. Number one, proactive planning versus reactive management. Tactical CSMs react to whatever comes their way, support issues, customer questions, internal asks. Meanwhile, strategic CSMs, and I'm not talking about the role strategic CSM, but we're talking about CSMs who are strategic. They anticipate needs before they arise. They build account plans, they run regular business reviews tied to outcomes, they structure the customer journey around long-term value and not just fixing today's fire. They don't wait for the risk to show up. They look ahead and prevent it. Okay, number two, customer-centric business thinking. Strategic CSMs don't just understand product, features, and functionality. They actually understand how it ties to the customer's business and the challenges that they're trying to solve. Or at the very least, they're trying to tie those two together. They're going to ask better questions. What's the outcome your leadership team cares about? That's one example. Another example. What would make this initiative a success for you internally? Or how will you measure ROI on this investment? They know how to position product as a lever to achieve business results and not just adoption metrics. Number three, connecting activities to impact. A tactical CSM might say, we've completed onboarding and had three training sessions. On the other hand, a strategic CSM says, you've reached X percent of product adoption and your team is already seeing a Y permanent in turnaround time, which aligns directly to the operational efficiency goal you shared in our kickoff. Can you see the difference here? Like with the examples, one reports the tasks, but the other communicates outcomes. And here's the key strategic CSMs narrate the value story continuously, not just at renewal time. Okay, number four, it's about thinking beyond the day-to-day champion. Most CSMs build strong relationships with their primary content. Strategic CSMs build a network inside the customer's organization. They think about who influences renewal decisions, who owns the budget, who will be the executive sponsor for expansion. They learn to speak the language of outcomes and not just product features and functionality because that's what will resonate at the C level. And they don't wait to be invited to those conversations. They ask for a seat at the table. Number five, they know how to balance risk mitigation with growth opportunity. Strategic thinking isn't just about protecting the renewal, it's also about growing the account. And I'm saying this because you know here at CS RevSpeak, we talk about revenue-driven CS. And I really believe that there should be a core CS responsibility, whether or not you own the revenue growth piece, the expansion piece. A strategic CSM constantly scans for usage gaps, for white space opportunity, for adjacent use cases, for cross-functional expansion potential. So they're not just maintaining the relationships, they're actually proactively looking out for how they can help their customers grow the business and the role that your organization or your product will play to help them achieve that. So here's the shift. Strategic thinking in CIAS isn't one thing, it's a collection of mindsets, behaviors, and habits that move your team from task execution to value leadership. And as a customer success leader, your role is to help your team recognize and build those muscles intentionally, consistently, and visibly. You need a way to translate strategy into observable behaviors, things you can coach on, reinforce in one-on-ones, and build into enablement programs. Over the years, I've found that strategic CSMs consistently operate across five key dimensions. So earlier we talked about the five characteristics of a strategic CSM or a CSM who is strategic. Now we're going to talk about the five different dimensions where strategic CSMs consistently operate across. And these dimensions can serve as a practical framework to help your team grow beyond tactical execution. So I'm going to walk you through them one by one. First dimension, customer value orientation. At the core of strategic customer success is the ability to connect every action to customer value. Strategic CSMs don't just check off onboarding milestones, they connect those milestones to outcomes. So for example, this training session will help your team reduce testing time by 20%. Or this feature rollout ties directly to your goal of shortening deployment cycles. They just don't talk about what your product does, they talk about why it matters to the business. As a CS leader, your job is to train your team to speak in outcomes, not features. Build success plans that start with customer business goals and not product checklists. And in team meetings, regularly ask how does this help the customer win? How does this help the customer achieve their goals? Second dimension, account planning and growth mapping. Strategic CSMs think like account owners, not just relationship managers or worse, a support function. A strategic CSM understands where the customer is today, where they could go, and what will it take to get them there. They know how to map out stakeholder influence. They look for white space opportunities. They proactively identify growth paths and build them into account planning conversations well before sales ever steps in, if that's how you manage your expansion. And as a CS leader, you need to build structured account planning rhythms. Don't wait for the AMs to drive this. CSM should own the value narrative and be the first to spot expansion potential. And coach your teams to ask what's next in every customer conversation. Obviously, only after they've seen value. You always need to be in a mode where you're constantly trying to figure out how you can help them generate more value from your product. Number three, executive engagement. This is one of the most underrated but high impact dimensions. Strategic CSMs don't just build great rapport with the end users. They know how to build relationships with decision makers and economic buyers. And they don't wait until renewal time to show up at the executive table. They learn how to summarize impact in business terms. They know how to align with executive priorities. They know how to position themselves as partners and not product guides. And as a CS leader, you need to help your team develop what I call executive fluency. You need to help them how to prepare for C-level conversations, how to position values succinctly and in the language of the C level or whoever it is that they're trying to reach out to, and how to tailor the language to business priorities. Try having your CSMs deliver mock executive briefings internally. It's one powerful way to build and coach the skill. Fourth dimension, data-driven storytelling. Your strategic CSMs don't just show usage, they actually know how to interpret it. They tell a story with data. They know how to say, I'm going to give you a few examples, here's where you're gaining value, or here's where we're leaving impact on the table. Or here's how we can drive even better outcomes with X. So the best CSMs use product insights, help scores, industry benchmarks, customer KPIs to paint a picture of progress and opportunity. And as a CS leader, it's your job to give them access to this data and teach them how to use it as a conversation tool, not just a dashboard. Here's a tip: practice reviewing accounts with your team by asking what story does this data tell? Help them build that muscle and fluency when it comes to storytelling. And the fifth dimension, proactive risk and opportunity identification. Strategic CSMs are always looking ahead. They don't wait for a customer to disengage or complain. They know how to anticipate risks and address them early. And on the flip side, they don't wait to be handed expansion leads. They're identifying them through customer conversations, data trends, and success milestones. Teach your team to recognize early signals of low adoption, change in stakeholders, shifting goals, usage plateauing, and create a culture of raising flags early, not waiting for escalation. And just as importantly, you need to train them to spot expansion moments when new teams are coming on board, when usage is nearing thresholds, when they orchestrate business wins, which can open the door to broader impact. Okay, so there you have it. Five core dimensions that define truly what a strategic CSM behavior is. Let's recap. Number one, customer value orientation, number two, account planning and growth mapping, number three, executive engagement, number four, data-driven storytelling. Number five, proactive risk and opportunity identification. And if you're wondering where to start, pick one or two of these and focus your team's development there first. You don't need to overhaul everything at once. You just need to start building the habit of operating at a higher level. So the thing is, strategy isn't just a skill, it's a muscle. I know I keep saying that over and over again. And like any muscle, it needs practice, feedback, and reinforcement. As CS leaders, we can't just set the expectation and walk away. We need to intentionally coach strategic thinking into the fabric of how our teams operate. I'm not just gonna stop at telling you what being strategic means and what are the different dimensions. I'm gonna tell you five practical ways on how you can coach your team effectively. You need to shift your coaching conversations from tasks to thinking. Let's start with the easiest trap to fall into tactical coaching. It happens all the time. A CSM walks into your 101 and the conversation is all about who did you meet? What's the status of onboarding? Did you send the QBR deck? Did you follow up with X and with so and so? Now, don't get me wrong, those things matter. But if that's all you ever coach on, your team stays in task mode. So instead, start layering in thought-provoking questions that train their strategic plans. Here's a few examples. What's the business outcome we're helping this customer achieve? What risks are we not seeing yet, but should be watching out for? If you were the CFO of this company, what would you care about? What's the value story you'll tell at renewal time? Even just asking these consistently begins to rewire how your team approaches customer engagement. One pro tip make these questions part of your one-on-one agenda templates. Repeat them often and let your team start to internalize the shift. All right, use role plays to practice strategic scenarios. If you want your CSM to sound more strategic in real meetings, they need a safe space to practice first. Now let's recognize the problem. Most enablement programs only roleplay product demos or objection handling. What we need more of are role plays like executive QBRs or EBR, executive business reviews, account growth discussion, risk management briefings, business goal discovery sessions. Here's my recommendation: run internal workshops where your team has to present a success plan to a C-suite or executive, or pitch the value of a new feature in terms of ROI, or walk through an account review with a peer acting as a skeptical stakeholder. As a CS leader, we need to normalize practice. Personally, I'm a big fan of role-playing. In fact, I do think that it's a very underutilized enablement tool for customer success. Here's another bonus tip for you: record a few great examples and build a strategic conversation library that your team can revisit. Because when you show your team how good it looks like, it makes them more confident to navigate all these different scenarios. Number three, redesign your success planning around outcomes and not activities. Again, let's talk about one of the most powerful coaching tools, the success plan. If your team is filling out templated forms about goals and milestones, but no one ever revisits them, guess what? That's not a success plan. That's just admin work. Redesign your success plan framework to reflect strategic behaviors. Need to start with business goals, not just product adoption objectives. You need to define what success looks like in the customer's terms. You need to tie milestones to impact and not just activities. There should be a section for customer KPIs that they're tracking internally and then add a timeline for measurable outcomes. Then use a success plan as a live coaching document. Review it regularly in one-to-one and team meetings. Ask your CSMs, how are we progressing against this value narrative? Another tip: encourage your team to use the success plan as a leave behind for executive alignment. Send it to the executive after a customer meeting where you review your success plan progress, whether or not that executive actually went into the meeting. That alone starts to build credibility at higher levels. Another way to coach this, give exposure to strategic thinking across the business. If you want your CSM to start thinking like business partners, you need to give them visibility into how business decisions are made. And here's what I've seen work really well. Let CSM shadow sales discovery calls. Invite them to join product roadmap planning sessions. Include them in internal revenue forecasting meetings, or bring them into internal post-mortems for churn or lost expansions. And this is not just about adding extra word. It's actually about giving them context. When they see how sales frames impact, how product prioritizes features, or how finance thinks about renewal cycles, it sharpens their own perspective and helps them become better partners to customers. Encourage cross-functional learning. The best strategic thinkers are not just experts in customer success, they understand how every part of the business works together. Number five, align your recognition and KPIs to strategic behavior. So here's the final piece, and it's a big one. Your team will model what you reward. If you only celebrate activity metrics like meetings completed, QBRs completed, escalations resolved, and so on, you'll get more of that. But if you start highlighting strategic behaviors, you'll see a shift. So make it visible when someone drives executive alignment early in the journey, when someone builds a success plan that clearly ties to business KPIs, when someone identifies a meaningful expansion opportunity before sales, when someone spotlights a risk and mitigates it proactively, share those stories and team meetings, build those behaviors into your competency models, and add strategic behaviors into your performance reviews. Because you can't say you want a more strategic team while measuring them only on tactical output. Let's recap. Ask better questions, practice smarter scenarios, redesign your success planning tools, create more exposure to cross-functional strategy, and align your recognition and KPIs to the behaviors that matter. That's how you build a team that doesn't just execute tasks, but thinks, plans, and delivers like true strategic partners. Let's end this conversation by zooming out a little. Because even if you coach the right behaviors, even if you train your team, even if you build the best frameworks and role-play every strategic scenario possible, it still won't stick if the culture around your team continues to reward reactivity over intentionality. Strategic behavior has to be reinforced, not just through coaching, but through your operating environment. And as a CS leader, you're the one who sets the tone. Let me give you a few examples of what I mean. If your team meetings are focused only on numbers and dashboards, your CSMs will optimize for reporting. But if you build in time to talk about value stories, customer outcomes, or cross-functional strategy, they start thinking that way naturally. If your weekly priorities are all about urgent escalations and fire drills, your team will learn to react faster, not to think further. If every KPI they're measured on is volume driven, then don't be surprised when strategy takes a back seat. The thing is, strategic behavior isn't just taught, it's modeled and reinforced through culture. And you don't need to overhaul everything to build the strategic culture. Sometimes small changes go a long way. A few things to think about. Start your team meetings with a strategic win of the week instead of just metrics. Debrief customer calls by asking, what was the business impact? Add strategic thinking as a peer feedback category in performance reviews. Make success stories just as visible internally as churn or escalations. And most importantly, you need to model it yourself. When your team sees you take the time to prepare intentionally, to focus on outcomes over noise, to frame decisions through a business lens, they're gonna follow your lead. That's how you build a culture where strategic thinking isn't just a buzzword. It's gonna be the norm. So what do you think? Which of these coaching levers can you start applying this week? Where does your team need the most support in shifting from task execution to strategic impact? Let's keep the conversation going. Tag me on LinkedIn, share your takeaways, and let's talk about what building a truly strategic CSM team looks like inside your organization. And don't forget to subscribe to the CS RevSpeak newsletter for more frameworks, coaching tools, and leadership strategies to help you build a revenue-driven CS team that scale with intention. I'll see you in the next episode. If you enjoyed today's episode and you want to learn more about CS RevSpeak's coaching and training services, head on over to www.csrevspeak.com. I specialize in working with customer success leaders who carry your revenue number, and I look forward to helping you confidently run a revenue generating customer success team. Don't forget to connect with us on LinkedIn and join our Customer Success Leaders Hub for more discussions, resources, and networking opportunities. You can access the links on the show notes. See you next episode.