If You Don’t Say It I Will Podcast

Describe Us… Big Mistake 😭 | If You Don’t Say It, I Will S2 Ep. 3”

Samantha Gooding Season 2 Episode 3

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:18:26

Welcome back to If You Don’t Say It, I Will — I’m Sam and I’m Amy, and today we did something that sounded fun… and then immediately became a problem.


We asked people from our past (middle school, high school, early adulthood) to send in how they remember us — stories, descriptions, chaos, and a few “oh… so THAT’S my reputation” moments. Some were sweet, some were savage, and some made us realize we probably shouldn’t have been allowed outside unsupervised.


Then we cap it off with the Whisper Challenge / Headphone Game… which turns into pure unhinged nonsense the second the music starts.


If you grew up with us and you’ve got a story: send it in. Voice note or text is fine — anonymous if you want — and we’ll read/react in a future episode.


Subscribe + leave a review (good, bad, whatever — we’ll take the attention).

New episodes every week.


🖤 Follow us

⚠️ Note: Names/identifying details may be changed or left out.


#IfYouDontSayItIWill #Podcast #Storytime #WhisperChallenge #SmallTownDrama