How Surreal Made Expensive Cereal Feel Worth It

Premium pricing does not work just because a product is better. It works when the brand changes what the product feels like.

In this episode of Full Fat Marketing, Leonora breaks down how Surreal made cereal feel more current, more desirable, and much easier to justify paying more for.

If you’ve ever wondered why some everyday products feel worth the premium while others just feel overpriced, this episode will show you how perception shapes value far more than most founders realise.

⭐ If you enjoyed the episode, please leave a rating and review, it helps more founders discover the show.

And if you’re building a food, drink or hospitality brand and want help applying these strategies to your business, feel free to reach out at leonora@lrbcreative.com

Follow along: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/https://www.linkedin.com/in/leonora-brebner-90817413b/

Check out our website: https://www.lrbcreative.com/

Sign up to the email newsletter: https://fullfatmarketing.substack.com/?r=4cq8g1&utm_campaign=pub-share-checklist

Disclaimer: Insights shared are based on Leonora’s experience with food and hospitality brands and are for educational purposes only. Results may vary.

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Most cereal is not something people tend to overthink. You recognize it, you grab it, you maybe look at the sugar once and then you completely ignore it, and you definitely do not expect to be paying a premium for it. And yet, Sereal shows up, charging significantly more, and somehow it doesn't actually feel ridiculous, which is quite an achievement because expensive cereal should feel almost a bit offensive. But here we are. I'm Lenora and this is the Full Fat Marketing Podcast, where you'll hear the uncomfortable strategy truths for FB brands that most people won't tell you, but I will. Now let's be honest here, they are selling a version of cereal that feels easier to justify paying more for. And to be fair, the product itself does help. What Sereal is selling is basically nostalgic cereal energy without the usual sugar crash and with tons more protein in it, which is actually a very decent proposition for someone. I always think of it like this. What if your childhood cereal got a LinkedIn profile and started going to the gym? That is what it almost feels like it kind of is. And it's not just an expensive cereal for the sake of it. It's cereal trying to solve a very modern adult problem, which is I want something that feels super fun and easy, but I also like it to not be so nutritionally chaotic. Believe it or not, most people do not actually want to eat joyless healthy food, no matter what it is that you actually see online about this. They want something that feels super familiar, satisfying, easy, and slightly better for them without turning breakfast into a serious guilt trip. And surreal sits right in that gap. So it's so important to realize that if the product itself doesn't make sense, the branding alone will not be enough. So great branding can seriously increase desire, but it cannot rescue a fundamentally pointless offer and product. The problem with most premium products that I see in everyday categories is this people compare them to the cheapest version immediately. It's automatic, right? So your brain thinks, why would I pay$10 for this when I can get something else for$5? And that is the battle. Most brands actually lose to it because they try to justify the price with more information, more claims, more in-depth explanations, more, but it's better for you, chat, that we all genuinely hate. And that really works. Customers are asking one very simple question that they only want the attitude to, which is does this feel worth it? Surreal understood that the answer to that question is not just about what the product is, it's about how it feels to actually buy it. What Surreal did really well is shift that comparison. They didn't try to win against the cheapest cereal. They knew that wasn't them, but they changed what you actually compare them to. And they did this in four different ways. Number one, they moved the product out of basic cereal territory. And this is the first thing they nailed. If Surreal looked like a standard cereal brand, then the price would feel genuinely insane. But it doesn't. Nothing about the brand feels cheap or functional or interchangeable. It feels really distinct and intentional, really premium and slightly removed from the rest of the shelf. So now that comparison changes. So when you pick it off the shelf, you're no longer thinking, okay, what am I choosing here? Corner flakes versus cereal. You're thinking this or the cheapest cereal I can find. And once you change the comparison set, you change how the price then feels. Which leads me on to number two. They removed the healthy guilt energy. This is where, oh, I can't even tell you, so many brands go wrong. They tried to justify a higher price by making the product feel better for you, more serious, and it ends up feeling like, okay, you should buy this, which for most people is not really a fun buying experience. Surreal did the opposite here. They made it feel really sort of light, self-aware, and not like you're making a super moral decision in the middle of the cereal aisle. People are much more likely to part with their cash on something that feels genuinely enjoyable, even to something that might come as random as buying a box of cereal, then something that feels like solely self-improvement. Number three, they made the brand do the heavy lifting, not the claims. And a lot of premium products lean very heavily on protein numbers, health benefits, functional ingredients. It's genuinely so boring. And I don't care. Like, and very few people will care about that. They just want to know if there are some benefits that immediately coincide with the sort of thing they're looking for. And this is the thing with Surreal, they're not leading with them. Instead, the brand itself carries a lot of that value through tone, personality, distinctiveness, how it shows up. If you look at a box of surreal, it's so instant what it is that you're getting, and you just understand it straight away. You feel like it's speaking to you with a really playful tone and humor. So now the product feels less like a functional swap, more like a brand you actively chose. And that is a really different buying dynamic for the consumer as well. Strangely, people are far more willing to pay more for something they feel that they've chosen than something they feel they've been convinced into because they're guaranteed for it to be better for you. Consumer psychology is mad. And lastly, number four, they made the whole thing feel way more current. Surreal feels like it belongs now. Current brands often feel more worth paying for, even if the product is not necessarily wildly different because people associate newness and relevance with value. That's just how consumer perception works. And surreal does that really well. Essentially, they didn't just increase the price, they increased what the product feels like, which is like price plus perception. And that is where the value really is created. And you see this with brands like Magic Spoon in the US as well, which is a very similar product. So this is not necessarily a one-off. But what Surreal has done well is to make that same idea feel less niche and more like something you could actually slot into your normal routine, which makes it way more scalable in the long run. Now, if you're a cafe owner, operator, or marketing manager listening to this, here's a practical takeaway of this episode. If people are constantly comparing your brand, your product to cheaper alternatives, the problem is usually not just your price. It's what you're being compared against. Ask yourself this: what are we? Whether it be intentional or accidental, being compared to, and how do we actually move away from that? A lot of brands aren't overpriced, they're just positioned way too close to cheaper options. So I would look at three things in this case. First, what does our brand feel closest to right now? What does it actually feel like? Not what you want it to feel like. If it feels too similar to lower priced options, people will naturally compare you. Second question, what in our brand makes the price feel easier to accept? Not justify it, I mean accept. That's the key word because customers are not reading a case study. They're making a feeling-based decision. And the third, where are we over-explaining instead of upgrading this perception? More information does not necessarily increase value. The practical move after this episode is simple. Look at your product and ask, does this feel like something people should compare to cheaper options or something they shouldn't? That one difference alone can completely change how your pricing is actually perceived. And that's the full fat version. Thank you so much for listening. And remember, you can listen to the Full Fat Marketing Podcast wherever you get your podcasts with new bite size episodes released daily, Monday to Friday. You can like me later for that. Oh, and if you're enjoying the podcast, I'd love it if you left a review, as it really helps more people find it. See you next week and have a fab weekend ahead.