The Scotchy Bourbon Boys

We Battle Blind For Our 2025: Bourbon Of The Year

Jeff Mueller / Martin Nash / Karl Henley / Chris thompson / Rachel Mueller Season 7 Episode 35

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:14:10

Send us Fan Mail

Five heavy hitters enter a blind tasting; a tie forces a live tiebreak and the crown goes to Old Man Winter With a prestige French oak finish. We trade hype for flavor, argue proof vs. balance, and learn how availability shapes a worthy Scotchy Bourbon Boys “Bourbon of the year.”

• sponsors thanked and distillery updates shared
• lineup set for the blind: five bourbons, one wild card on the side
• simple scoring rules agreed, color coding to prevent bias
• first-pass notes on cola, peanut, vanilla, and fruit-forward profiles
• proof chat and how it affects palate, not just heat
• debate on noses vs palates, dryness vs sweetness
• tally confusion resolved, two-way tie identified
• audience tiebreak selects Old Man Winter as winner
• value and availability weighed against rarity and price
• honorable mentions and how oxidation changes bottles over time

Make sure that you leave us good feedback on Apple and iHeart and Spotify five-star rating and everything. Leave a review and then become members.

What happens when you strip away labels, lock in a scoring system, and let the glass do the talking? We gathered the full crew, poured five of the year’s most talked-about bourbons completely blind, and chased the truth through cola notes, peanut vibes, dessert-like vanilla, and bright, fruit-forward finishes. The lineup was stacked: Knob Creek 21, Russell’s Reserve 13 (2025), A Midwinter Night’s Dram, Cathedral French Oak, and Old Man Winter from Preservation. Expectations were sky high for the heavy hitters—but the scoreboard had other plans.

We walk you through the tasting rules, the early favorites, and the turning point when pour number three changed the room’s mood. Proof chasers met balance seekers as a silky 90s-proof contender outperformed its label, while a 110-proof nose bomb turned out more polarizing on the palate than predicted. Cathedral French Oak cast a spell on the nose. Knob 21 delivered oak-driven structure. Russell’s 13 flashed that rich sweetness many love. Midwinter offered juicy fruit and charm. But the question we kept asking was simple: which glass makes you want another pour?

By the end, scores tied between two colors and we pulled in a live audience to break it. The winner? Old Man Winter—an underdog that paired layered fruit, spice control, and a welcoming finish with the practical upside of being findable at retail. We dig into why availability matters for a “Bourbon of the Year,” what blind tasting reveals about our biases, and how time in the bottle can flip your rankings weeks later. Stick around for honorable mentions, lessons learned from oxidation, and a reminder that great whiskey doesn’t always wear the most expensive label.

If you enjoyed this blind battle, follow the show, share it with a bourbon friend, and drop your own top pick of the year in a review. Your palate belongs in this conversation.

Add for SOFL

If You Have Gohsts

Support the show

https://www.scotchybourbonboys.com

The Scotchy bourbon Boys are #3 in Feedspots Top 60 whiskey podcasts in the world    https://podcast.feedspot.com/whiskey_podcasts/


Sponsors And Setup

SPEAKER_01

I used to have where the headphones go. Middle West Spirits was founded in 2008, focusing on elevating the distinct flavors of the Ohio River Valley. Their spirits honor their roots and reflect their originality as makers, their integrity as producers, and their passion for crafting spirits from grain to glass. Their Michelin reserve line reflects their story from the start to the bottle to your glass. With unique wheated it and rye bourbons and also rye and wheat whiskies, the Michelin brand is easy to sift. It might be a grain to glass experience, but I like to think of it as uncut and unfiltered from their family to yours.

SPEAKER_05

Let's get started.

Full House Introductions

SPEAKER_01

We are Full House. Yep, full house. We are all in the house as a group. We're five strong. Plus, our fans are here. Matt Lisen from Cleveland on the Rocks. We also have Walker. Everybody knows Walker from Arizona. We got John Ritt from suburbs of Chicago. We got Roxy. Hey Roxy. Good to join us. We got Whiskey. Thank you for coming down in your busy schedule. It's like, I mean, you it's even hard to talk to you these days. And then there's Super Nash in the house from South Carolina. And we got CT all the way from Dayton, the Springfield area.

SPEAKER_00

I had some people bring me up via Uber. But they're like from another country.

SPEAKER_03

From Uber Knight.

SPEAKER_00

So Springfield.

SPEAKER_03

Another country, meaning Columbus?

SPEAKER_00

No, no, no, no. No, another country south. They brought me up, you know, drop me off. It's heightened.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Well, he's going political. I totally got it. I mean, you know, Springfield was in the news for a while. It was there.

SPEAKER_00

Hey, I didn't bring any I didn't bring any dogs.

SPEAKER_01

Did they know how to drink? Did they know how to drive that giant GMC truck? They don't know. They flip them over. They're all cars. That's what we do in Springfield, man.

SPEAKER_00

Right. And then we have Jeff from Canton. Canton, China. I mean, I'm all the way to China. Yes, Canton.

SPEAKER_01

Canton.

SPEAKER_06

Things on the podcast.

SPEAKER_01

What are you talking about? I'm from Cantone, China. It's where that's a place.

SPEAKER_03

You know, that explains the thinness of the beard.

SPEAKER_06

Okay, move on. Move on.

Partner Shoutouts And Distillery News

SPEAKER_01

That explains the thinness of my nose hairs. I got no nose hairs after my wife just like gutted my nose right before this. It's like, I look good though. But damn. So, anyways, let's just get really quick to our sponsors. We want to thank for this year, because this is our bourbon of the year. But we got the spirit of French Lick. This William Dalton barrel series is fantastic. You know, you can check it out anytime you want. But they do William Dalton, they do Solomon Scott. They're in French Lick, Indiana. It's Alan Bishop's old stomping grounds. And if you want some damn good whiskey, stop by and tell them the Scotchy Bourbon boys sent you. Check out the Spirit of French Lick. Also, there is Whiskey Thief Distilling Company, two locations. Whiskey Thief in Frankfurt, where their main distillery is on Three Borns Boys Farm. And then also their tasting room in Louisville, which is in the New Lou area. Fantastic, both places. But no matter where you go for the price of missions, you're going to get to taste from five different barrels. It's a barrel pick all day, every day. There's no place like it. Yep.

SPEAKER_00

There's not a crew like it. I mean, think about the group that's down there working at that point.

SPEAKER_01

Everybody's Steven Star. Everybody Walter hires is just like it's just like exactly. Then he's got a distilling team. He's got Lisa Roper Wicker. She's got Ben Eve. Ben Eves, yeah. Yep. And he's got Kelly Tanneal. I mean, you're talking about a moonshiner, somebody coming up, and then you got somebody with that that's a seasoned bag. Yep.

SPEAKER_00

You got Hannah, that's the best freaking barrel paper.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, but Hannah's almost like a scotchy bourbon boy in her own, right? So, anyways, check out Whiskey Thief Distilling Company. It's like us, unfiltered. And then last uh the you've got the Middle West Spirits down in Columbus, Ohio, that's fantastic. And they just uh Ryan has put himself in the top of the level tier of all distilling with his 72,000 square foot new distillery. He's still got his craft distillery, he's got his service bar restaurant. I was just there the other day. Oh my god, it's a good thing.

SPEAKER_02

Doug Fat Fries.

SPEAKER_00

Doug Fat Fries at Ryan's place and the cocktails. That place is amazing.

SPEAKER_01

Plus, then he buys goes out and buys old Latinx. And then he's got Wendy.

SPEAKER_00

And Wendy's doing things. What is it? Archer. Archer Neiland.

SPEAKER_01

Nealand. And we that's a podcast. Look for that. We got their rise. I got the sweatshirt in the truck. Both of us. Ooh.

SPEAKER_02

Not yours, mine. You didn't get one.

The Bourbon Of The Year Lineup

SPEAKER_01

Of course I didn't. I had to buy it. No, you were right there. You were right there at Middle West Spirits when she launched it. Yeah, that but no kidding. So, anyways, Middle West Spirits, and then also we our good friend Alan Bishop from If You Have Ghosts, You Have Everything. He's working, and then also One Piece of the Time Distilling Industry. If you have Ghosts, You Have Everything is a combination of the Spirits world and the Spirits industry and all the stories that go behind it. Great podcast, along with the One Piece at a Time Distilling Institute, where he shares all his distilling knowledge, whether it's commercial distilling, whether it's home distilling, and whether it's you know, whatever the question is, he nerds out on you on One Piece at a Time Distilling Institute. So that's our sponsors. Take those away. This is our bourbon of the year podcast. We got everybody here. We're ready to go. We are blinding. This lineup right here. I think it's the beard. It's blinding. It's fine. That's good. That means this beard is spectacular. There you go. So we got old man winter. You just fall off the building. We've got Cathedral French Oak. We've got a Midwinter's Night's Dream. Dram. Dram. Yes. Yeah. It might be a dream to me because I have not had that. Russell's Reserve 13 2025. Yep. And Knob Creek 21. That's what we got this down for our five bourbon of the years. We we discussed it, we picked it, and we're going to get blind on this. And so some of us have not actually had some of these expressions. Like I have not had the Russell's 13, one of my favorite pours, but I have not had a chance to get that 2025. Oh, you suck. Who's it? God bless. Yeah. Is that um Bruce?

SPEAKER_00

No, I think I had no it's Bruce. No, I think I had uh no, it's Bruce.

SPEAKER_01

Yep. That is the grandson of Jimmy Russell. And that's it's gotta make it better. Put God bless bless on it. Fuck yeah. Yeah. I'm sorry.

SPEAKER_07

Wait a second.

SPEAKER_01

God bless. Fuck yeah. America! I mean, if you say God bless, I'm I'm supporting that stuff. And look at it, I got my old Carter Glenn waiting for some stuff, and I'm not gonna get anything in there because we're gonna get a bunch of them. All right, then we got the Knob Creek 21.

SPEAKER_02

Which came out at Saturday.

SPEAKER_01

No, I will have to say of these two, the Knob Creek and the Cathedral. If you were in the Crystal Glenn Karen Club, you've had a taste of these before. We do the tastings, and that's what happens at those tastings. You're gonna get some of the best bourbons that I taste throughout the year. So yes, yes, supernatural. Yeah, you didn't know. I'm sorry. You had an invitation. Everybody had an invitation. If you can't make it, it's like the bur you gotta come to the bourbon.

SPEAKER_03

Hey, yeah, let's not live in the past. Let's move on to the future. Well, but you're in growing then. All I gotta say is you're leaving me to drink. Yes. Him? Hold on, I'm with you, Rowan. I need to buy it.

SPEAKER_01

How is he with him? You're the one that's doing it.

unknown

That's the funny part.

SPEAKER_01

I didn't do shit. That's pretty funny. Is there butter pretzels on the table? What are you doing? Why are you turning? Why are you turning it? Yeah, Matt, Matt puts a hit my chair. Matt puts a little chair. Matt puts a what would you call peanut butter pretzel? I mean, he's favorite thing. We we did a tasting and pairing that night that that really kind of my favorite was. I thought for sure Matt would know what it was, but we did this. We did a Red Bull where you suck down some Red Bull and then you drank the bourbon. And I thought for sure Matt would know because this is this dude. Every time I see him, he's got a Red Bull. It was like in a little pink, it was like in a little pink cup. And I'm like, that should make it sound, that should make that bourbon taste familiar to you. And he's like, Nope, nope, he had no idea. All right, so we are on the first one. Okay, so so listen, right to left. You set each one down right to left.

SPEAKER_03

Right to the left. Why don't we just do one and then do the next one?

SPEAKER_01

Yes, we're gonna do one, but we set them down right to left, and then we're gonna rate each one right to left how we do, and then we're gonna add up the scores. And I'm gonna and we're gonna write them down. Everyone has a color, so you go off the color either. We're gonna write down the scores. The color doesn't.

SPEAKER_06

Yeah, we we put I sticker down the score.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, you got this color, but that tells us what they are when we do it. But this will be what we score that.

SPEAKER_00

You score on the colour.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, but if everybody okay, you do it on the phone. Okay, she's she's she has taken the next step over Super Nash. She's one of the floats.

SPEAKER_04

That's why we bring her in. She brings tech over, over, you know. Tech and beauty over us.

SPEAKER_01

Greetings from Missouri.

SPEAKER_02

All right. Bottle number one. We have no idea what it is.

First Pour Impressions

SPEAKER_01

Knob Creek 21 looks amazing. It is amazing. It looks like Knob Creek 9. Yeah, it's too large for Knob Creek 21.

SPEAKER_00

But it looks like 9. I mean it's the same bottle.

SPEAKER_01

I have no idea. To be honest, to be honest, it is what it is. There's a cola note on this. I just get cola right off the bat.

SPEAKER_04

Can I tell you what it is right off the bat?

unknown

No!

SPEAKER_04

Sweaty balls. Yeah, uh if anybody hasn't signed up yet. Bringing it back to shoot.

SPEAKER_01

No, that's right. W.nash's sweaty balls. No, no, no, no, no, no. I I got in trouble with uh status after.

SPEAKER_03

I know when it's not. But I'm not sure what it is.

SPEAKER_01

Don't try to tell what it is. Just tell what you like.

SPEAKER_03

Keep it to yourself, fool. So I just keep it to myself until after I've tasted it off.

SPEAKER_01

I like the cola smell, I have to admit. Yeah. You like the colon smell? Cherry cola is like. Alright.

SPEAKER_02

You got a little cherry in it.

SPEAKER_01

I got a little cherry. That's pretty good. That's a pretty good whiskey. It's good. I agree. I mean, it could, if I was to say something, it's like, it's like Nash is an old man. So it's old man winter sweaty balls. I thought we were not gonna say what it was. Middle. I was saying it's your sweaty balls.

SPEAKER_00

Are you trying to say high West tastes like sweaty balls?

SPEAKER_01

Oh no. Why is this not amusing whiskey? I mean, this is right up your right up your.

SPEAKER_03

This is actually really not funny. Wait till it's not. Huh?

SPEAKER_01

Are we ready to move on to let's go to number two? Let him get primed, yeah. He's not primed yet. He's only had one sip of whiskey.

SPEAKER_03

No, that's not true. I had several before.

SPEAKER_01

Oh, it only takes a few more.

SPEAKER_02

And a pair of swim trucks. Yeah, we are all we are all raids.

SPEAKER_01

That was a lot of belly that day. No, we get all five and then we start to so much belly. So Wappi gotta do the commercial in the middle. Grassies. Number two.

SPEAKER_03

We need your spool. Start your hand up. Do a little tipsy or something. You know. Hey, you're in first. This round brought to you by Chi Cheese. Why? Because they like to kill people.

SPEAKER_07

And they perfect. This round brought the Chi Chi's issue.

SPEAKER_00

Like you will be after the channel. They are. No, actually, Chi Chi's.

SPEAKER_01

Well, actually, Chi Chi's is coming back.

SPEAKER_03

Actually, I I use Chi Cheese because I figured they couldn't sue us.

SPEAKER_01

No, no, actually, Roxy was reading like a month ago that they're bringing back Chi Chi's. Yep.

SPEAKER_00

And you know there's still one in Massachusetts.

SPEAKER_01

They're actually making a thing to come back for Mexican lessons.

SPEAKER_00

And God nine million other Mexican restaurants on the world.

SPEAKER_01

Oh my god, if I had a chance to go to Chi Chi's again, I would go and you would be disappointed because the Mexican restaurants we have today are so much better than they are.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, absolutely. So much better. They're just so we just was so blind.

SPEAKER_00

It was good in them because we didn't have anything else. It was Taco Bell and Chi Chi's.

SPEAKER_03

It was the upgraded electricity. I will say there is an old there's still a normal road.

SPEAKER_01

There's three things in Chi Chi's that I kills anything that I've tasted in today's. They had like this tamale kind of thing with the little cilantro and whatever, and I would I love that with all the cheese on top.

SPEAKER_04

What happens is when you marry.

SPEAKER_01

I married an Italian.

SPEAKER_04

I married an Indian that lived in California that her mother taught her how to make oh my gosh, fresh homemade Mexican. I mean, on that, that's pretty good.

SPEAKER_02

I think I know what you go to restaurants, so you get disappointed.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah? All right. Are we ready, Roxy? Uh huh. For next two next round?

SPEAKER_05

Why?

Comparing Notes And Proof Talk

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Sure. Next round. Yeah, that's easy. It's light though.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah. This 21 killed 18. Yeah. Light.

SPEAKER_00

Oh, and the peanut is like you can't avoid the peanut. It's all peanut. Yeah, especially after our booker's taste.

SPEAKER_03

It's like no, it's all right. That's my job. It didn't suck, it didn't suck all the damn moisture out of your mouth. Like a leather glove or something. Man, what's up with you in leather and gloves and stuff? You're bringing up all the time there.

SPEAKER_01

So my favorite thing is I just got I just got a hey, listen, on Facebook. On Facebook, on Facebook just now. Somebody said the woman is because we are we are in India right now at their perfect time. The woman is piping off to us much. Ask her to leave.

SPEAKER_06

She hasn't said my comments to myself. And guess what? Now I'm gonna pipe up even more.

SPEAKER_01

You piper. Now it now it's like the messages are going off to the I got an artificial blend.

SPEAKER_00

Oh it's not even fair. Look at the oblong shape.

SPEAKER_06

It's all blue.

SPEAKER_00

Oh, you can look at it.

SPEAKER_03

It goes sideways, yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, that's the bus tour glends. I got one. That's the one I use on the side all the time. My nose is tight.

SPEAKER_02

Did I keep that artificial blend just for that purpose? Oh, I would. Don't worry.

SPEAKER_03

So outside of all the leather and baseball comments, I know you're competitive, CT. You needed a little bit more of a challenge. Great finish on three.

SPEAKER_07

Yeah.

SPEAKER_02

Oh, I know what that is. 100%. That finish is two of the three figured out.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, you do. It's like it's like blinds humble people.

SPEAKER_02

Alright, bring on the next one.

SPEAKER_01

Oh, we can't get the scope spent.

SPEAKER_02

Three just hits. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Three is pretty damn good. I know what it is.

SPEAKER_02

Oh. So we got a front runner right now. Oh there's a there's a difference in three. I mean, not saying that it's the best, but it's different.

SPEAKER_06

No, three is by far the best so far.

SPEAKER_01

It's no four just goes to level of insanity.

SPEAKER_06

Oh, four has a nice note.

SPEAKER_01

Four. You could say four or the F word.

Pour Three Changes The Pace

SPEAKER_02

Four. Four's got a light. Oh, it's so good. Yeah. That's like a super sweet vanilla, like dessert no. I still have a half a bottle and that.

SPEAKER_03

Can I ask the question? Oh, you probably don't know. No!

SPEAKER_06

Why are you yelling at everybody?

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, seriously. What's the proof on the middle?

SPEAKER_06

Wait, yell at me. That Indian guy would like to.

SPEAKER_00

They're telling the lady to put it down.

SPEAKER_04

What's the proof on the middle? What's the proof on the middle?

SPEAKER_01

Maybe they think I'm a lady. Maybe they're talking about it.

SPEAKER_04

This is an you know, it's irrelevant but irrelevant to tasting. I think this. I need to know the proof on the mid-winter's night drum. Well, I with mid- Okay, yeah, I'll give you that.

SPEAKER_00

Actually, just give them a hat. A couple of years ago, I could have told you that. Oh, yeah, yeah. That'll work. Now I need readers too. But 48 point. It's super fruity on the palette. It's like juicy fruit. 48 point. Look at what I'm saying.

SPEAKER_07

It's super fruity.

SPEAKER_03

Or 97. 97.

SPEAKER_02

Very fruity. Like what state it would act.

SPEAKER_01

Whatever came out this year, because it's a good thing. You know what proof that is? Quasimogam.

SPEAKER_02

Four doesn't match the palette.

SPEAKER_06

It tastes like um.

SPEAKER_01

Quasimogam.

SPEAKER_06

No, it's like Kiwis. It's totally fruit.

SPEAKER_01

It tastes like the hunchback of Notre Dame. It's earlier this year.

SPEAKER_03

It's earlier this year. Yeah, because I got it in the city.

SPEAKER_01

I tasted something that was phenomenal.

SPEAKER_05

It sweet, the finger sweetens up. It mellows out on the finisher right now.

SPEAKER_03

You just saw and they just got out there.

SPEAKER_01

Whatever's in this bottle, you get the definition. And there's like a little chocolate. Whatever's this bottle in four is I'll chug. I agree. The whole bottle. What proof is the ride kind of cathedral, yeah.

SPEAKER_02

102? 110. Oh, it's 110? Yeah, that's probably that bottle. I'm going with four. I'm going quasi-motified.

SPEAKER_05

Like a smoke. There's a smoke. It finishes with.

SPEAKER_01

That's what happens when you make a barrel that uses 300-year-old oak and then you char it and put it in as a finishing barrel.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, so we're are we just gonna go ahead and say four is cathedral?

SPEAKER_01

No, we're not. Let's we've got to taste five. I'm I'm I'm already in the barbicover. No, four is quasi-mobile.

SPEAKER_06

How would you know what's under there?

SPEAKER_02

Walter, do we have two more?

SPEAKER_01

Oh, he's mixing them up. Walker, you're wait, that's mine. One of the many from it right now. Sharing his hands.

SPEAKER_07

I have no idea.

SPEAKER_01

That's that's his.

SPEAKER_06

I've never tasted. Well, none of us did, right? Just remember.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, out of all of them.

SPEAKER_02

I had old man winner there, but what's old man winner proof?

SPEAKER_05

Ooh, that's nice.

SPEAKER_01

The nose on this that's the best nose. This nose hits. I uh I think it tastes a little better out of 100. Oh god, and nine point. Yeah, that I think I think I just switched.

SPEAKER_06

Wait, can we pump that through the furnace? Can we pump that through the furnace?

SPEAKER_01

Yes. Yes. Actually, I just want to dip my nuts in there so it gets a little case of hands. That's how you get you wanna basically dip your nuts in there so that uh Sheila smells on a warmer like spurbing instead of burning, burning the more.

SPEAKER_06

Holy shit, that's good. Oh, I know what that is.

SPEAKER_01

And you don't make her just take all of it in. I'm going with that's old man. I'm going with the last one. So the way this is gonna work. Now I gotta go back through them. No, no, no, no. So you gotta rate them, keep them right to left. It's two shitty glasses. What's that proof on old man one? I already said 109.8. Ooh, I gotta eliminate 110. What these are all like sitting right at the same place except for you didn't ask for the 13 to 87, the 97. How much is that on the 13? It's that's one twenty.

SPEAKER_04

That's 127. Just a rich eight, I believe.

SPEAKER_02

Rich. Alright, these are my two. Yeah, the back six is is.

SPEAKER_06

I gotta decide what's my number two. Don't switch them around.

SPEAKER_00

No, I'm not. I got them in. Why are you yelling at me?

SPEAKER_06

I put them in the order I think they are. I already switched them around.

SPEAKER_01

Put them in order. The color coding is not the number. I get it. What? Two nose. This one? It's like brown. Are you saying red is insane? Yes. The nose.

SPEAKER_02

That's how you do it. That is definitely brown sugar. I don't like the nose of red at all.

SPEAKER_01

You're you. Number two. So I love the blue nose.

Pour Five And Early Favorites

SPEAKER_06

No, blue nose is amazing.

SPEAKER_01

The green and the I like two a lot.

SPEAKER_02

Five is fucking with me though. And the nose on two is messing with me because I'm so.

SPEAKER_06

None of them are really black.

SPEAKER_01

I mean, I got my order. Three is Russell's reserve.

SPEAKER_04

And that's like a sponge from the from the room.

SPEAKER_01

Oh my god, three is blue. Russell reserve right there.

unknown

On number two.

SPEAKER_01

Hey, where's Walker?

SPEAKER_02

He just had an X Savage. There is no way. Hold on. There is no way three is Russell's the first time.

SPEAKER_01

TMI.

SPEAKER_00

What do you mean?

SPEAKER_01

I don't need to know. Yeah, but he's in the bathroom, so he's exiting the extra. Can he cook it upstairs on my stove? No, there came out of this bag right here.

SPEAKER_03

Oh my god, that nose the nose on one is starting to open up for me.

SPEAKER_01

Oh my god, it's also you should only get one time.

SPEAKER_06

Instead of like doing each one, every single element, what if we like.

SPEAKER_02

As you drink them, you should push the top one up and then load them.

SPEAKER_01

You gotta rate them. Tried and then all you have. And then as you go, so put them in your order. Okay, so so you put them in order, what you think is the best to worst. Yeah. Then you call out the blue, and if it if it's the lowest number, we'll win. There's five of us. The lowest it could get is five ones.

SPEAKER_06

Oh, I see.

SPEAKER_01

Then then we'll add. And then you get a seven eight. Or I could get it a three point five because it's tied between well, this would be if there's five. We saw how there's five. I could give it a one point five.

SPEAKER_06

Okay, so your number one gets five points, four points, no, number one gets one point. One point?

SPEAKER_01

Two gets two points, three, and then you're going for the lowest number.

SPEAKER_06

Oh, okay. We could do it the opposite way and go for the highest number, but sure.

SPEAKER_01

What are we doing? That would that would Why are you yelling?

SPEAKER_06

Always yells at me. Didn't mean I would like this.

SPEAKER_01

So are we gonna do we rank the number one five? Or do we number one is one? Thank you. So one is one, two is two, three is three.

SPEAKER_06

So I'm gonna what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna put the piece books. They got colors on the balls.

SPEAKER_01

So did the egg salad sandwich come out?

unknown

It comes in bowls.

SPEAKER_01

So I'm gonna put all the colors.

SPEAKER_02

You smell that raisin on one?

SPEAKER_06

It's got a weird nose.

Ranking Chaos And Palette Debates

SPEAKER_02

It's like it's one or you on the one.

SPEAKER_06

That's one.

SPEAKER_03

I love to eat a good muffin.

SPEAKER_06

One speed right. No, this is the first one we tasted. Okay, I say muffin as small as this one. Yeah, we're gonna be able to do that. Yeah, because that's just how my brain works. Okay.

SPEAKER_00

Are you left-handed?

SPEAKER_06

Jeff thinks I am, but I actually write right.

SPEAKER_00

No, she's I'm frightening left.

SPEAKER_07

I do everything left-handed like I'm gonna do it.

SPEAKER_06

I do all my things like this. See, I've seen this happen before it's a good thing.

SPEAKER_00

But yeah, there's a raisin nose too.

SPEAKER_01

I'm left-handed. Isn't that weird? Sure, I'm gonna be able to do it. Well, that breeds the right-hand free for himself.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Sometimes it's needed. He's fantastic.

unknown

But it is if I had a D.

SPEAKER_01

I just so those two are in a level. Okay.

SPEAKER_06

So since the colors on the bottom, then you can just Yeah, I'm doing I'm tallying up color. I'm gonna tally up colors right here.

SPEAKER_01

There's the stuff.

SPEAKER_00

No, there we go. Two is freaking Russell's, man. I'm telling you.

SPEAKER_03

I'm telling you, three is not. It's it's 21. Two is old man winner.

SPEAKER_06

Two smells to me. Two is like it's either old man winner or mid summer night's ground.

SPEAKER_07

It's because two cigar to me. It's not like a few.

SPEAKER_00

Three is knob. For me, three is knob because it dries out so fast. So what maybe your truth is one other.

SPEAKER_06

No, I know I'm just saying.

SPEAKER_01

This is way harder than the bookers. No, way harder.

SPEAKER_06

I agree.

SPEAKER_01

Bookers were like so paper thin of a difference. And it was like, okay, if that did that, if that this is like so much difference between that. There wasn't no can we all agree that there's not one bad one here? No, these are all fantastic.

SPEAKER_06

There's one that I think kind of is one that I think. Well, you tell us.

SPEAKER_04

I would just like to say that I think I should have had a Gusta 13 put in there too. Wild card.

SPEAKER_00

Wow, where is that?

SPEAKER_01

Okay, Walker. Now we're bringing in the wild card, bro.

SPEAKER_06

We have to do our own.

SPEAKER_01

Walker, Walker could bring in a wild wild card. Do you want to bring in a wild gusta 13?

SPEAKER_02

What? You know what I would add it? It's fun.

SPEAKER_01

It's fun. We're gonna do a wild card. Walker, that Augusta 13 open it and pour five more pores.

SPEAKER_02

It's good.

SPEAKER_01

And bring you, you know where the hey John, go get the glance out my back.

SPEAKER_02

13 was really good.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, in that back room, they're up against the wall by the self parking. I think four is a bunch of those those are the ones for this. Those are like displayed. Then I'd have to wash them all. I've never told you. I think that's because it's sweeter. Just a few. I think five is a really good one. That's a 13, right? You don't have to blind it. Is the 13 open? That's midnight winter drain. That's Russell's. That's 21.

SPEAKER_03

And that is the I did not know it was open.

SPEAKER_01

Cool. Midnight winter drain. Like midnight winter drain.

SPEAKER_06

I think one and two are either midnight's winter or Omega did it.

SPEAKER_01

It was up there. It didn't make it. And three is too spicy for me.

SPEAKER_00

Old man winters.

SPEAKER_01

I got too much oak for it to be in. I like it, but I'm just bourbon of the year. I I need not so much oak.

SPEAKER_07

These two are the things that we're doing. The last one we tasted.

SPEAKER_05

With the pee that's coming out of the bottle? No, we didn't do that one. And I know.

SPEAKER_02

It's good. But it it and that one, if that's what it is, or have some similarities.

SPEAKER_06

No, the last one we tasted.

SPEAKER_01

So number one. So number one, just if you taste number one again in your glass a little bit, it like changes. So here's the thing. There we go. Totally.

SPEAKER_05

Look at any of the stickers.

SPEAKER_01

So so this one, this one is based off of here. You can have the green river one. This one is based off of nothing on your bottom.

SPEAKER_07

Yes. No color. Neutral. That's the way I like it. Nothing on my bottom.

SPEAKER_01

You got old Carter.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, we heard Duchet. That's good.

SPEAKER_03

I got the Gillette Manscaped.

SPEAKER_02

I've heard.

Score Tally And Color Confusion

SPEAKER_00

You offered deaf it.

SPEAKER_06

And then what is it?

SPEAKER_01

Super. Another old card. What? Wild card.

SPEAKER_04

Because of wild card?

SPEAKER_01

It's the Augusta.

SPEAKER_04

Well Augusta.

SPEAKER_03

Why would you say it? Because we all saw it. So the wild card. It's supposed to be a wild card. Me and you might know. It's wild Augusta card. Not a blind wild card. You guys have said it numerous times.

SPEAKER_00

Alright, let's go. Let's go. I need number six here. Did I give you one? Number six is the one.

SPEAKER_01

Which we know it is a girl's book.

SPEAKER_02

Cheers.

SPEAKER_00

Cheers.

SPEAKER_02

It's just a matching burger. Matt, we may have or may have not drank eight of these barrels. Thanks, Matt. Hey, Kentucky Burberry Festival.

SPEAKER_04

Oh, that's so good.

SPEAKER_01

I have so many. Oh, these are now all of a sudden. A 13-year barrel strength bomb fuck.

SPEAKER_06

That's so good. That's really good.

SPEAKER_00

Oh. Okay, so it's good for a. We can't. Now we can't taste anything. Yeah. We can't put it in there because they did so many. Yeah. There's so many buckners. Why? It has nothing.

SPEAKER_04

We can't do like what's important in having a wild card if we can't put it in there.

SPEAKER_03

Well, because it's a wild card. Well, the other thing, too, isn't it? Isn't that really a single barrel product? It is.

SPEAKER_01

Because if anything else, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Whoa, wait a minute. Augusta is only Bucknards is only single barrels. They don't do anything but so if you put one in, yeah.

SPEAKER_06

It is very good.

SPEAKER_03

All right, so we get to drink it all and just toss it away. Toss the glass away.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, toss drink it away.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay. All right. So how do we get all right?

SPEAKER_06

Let's eliminate let's let's figure out what we got on the numbers. Oh, here it is. I'm gonna tally the numbers.

SPEAKER_00

So you got one to five, you rant them one to five. How did you rate? So we'll do we'll start with you, and then we'll rate number one, what your rating was, and then we'll move around.

SPEAKER_06

Make sure everyone's number one is the same color. Lowest to highest.

SPEAKER_04

We don't have to rate it. You put them in the order, and that order is your number.

SPEAKER_01

Right, but she's using so you use that, yeah. Yeah, but then you look at your numbers and you look at your number one, you look at the bottom, so tell her what your color is. This is our number one. What's your right? It'll be a reveal. Yeah. And that, yeah, tell her what the color is. What's my worst one or my best one? What's your worst? Start with the worst. Start with five. Are you serious?

SPEAKER_00

Blue is my five.

SPEAKER_06

Blue is your five? Okay.

SPEAKER_00

Yellow, if that's yellow. Is that yellow?

SPEAKER_06

Yeah, that's yellow.

SPEAKER_02

Five.

SPEAKER_06

Hold on.

unknown

Excuse me.

SPEAKER_06

Yeah?

SPEAKER_02

What? Green?

SPEAKER_06

Green?

SPEAKER_02

Oh, we're all. This is why we are what we are.

SPEAKER_06

And then yellow.

SPEAKER_03

My number five is that's what works, right? Yeah, yeah. So my number five is blue.

SPEAKER_00

Is blue? Touch blue, make it true.

SPEAKER_01

Number four?

SPEAKER_02

Matches.

SPEAKER_01

Four? My number four is yellow. What the hell color is that?

SPEAKER_02

Gold.

SPEAKER_01

No, wait a minute. You sure that's not green?

SPEAKER_06

That's gold.

SPEAKER_01

Are you colored blind? I can't tell you. Can you go four?

SPEAKER_06

Yours is green.

SPEAKER_01

Mine is mine number four is yellow. That's yellow.

SPEAKER_06

Your number four is yellow? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Look at. Is that gold or yellow? That's yellow.

SPEAKER_06

What was Chris's number four?

SPEAKER_03

Gold. Gold is four.

SPEAKER_06

Okay. And what's yours?

SPEAKER_03

My number four is yellow.

SPEAKER_06

Your number four is yellow.

SPEAKER_02

Wait a second. Well, what color is that? If that's yellow. Hold on a second, Reno. That's yellow. That's my yellow. So wait a minute. What is that? So this is the one I picked as four.

SPEAKER_06

That's gold.

SPEAKER_02

That's gold.

SPEAKER_06

So gold, I got a gold for.

SPEAKER_02

Oh, okay.

SPEAKER_06

My turn.

SPEAKER_01

Cheers, bro. With what? My learners.

SPEAKER_04

Your bug learners.

Wild Card Barrel Makes A Cameo

SPEAKER_03

Cheers. Cheers. What's next? We both have a few.

SPEAKER_06

My number four is red.

SPEAKER_04

Ooh, red.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, my number four is also red.

SPEAKER_06

Oh, wow.

SPEAKER_03

See? And Nom Creek 21 is not holding up.

SPEAKER_04

Alright. Jeff, we're down to number three. My number three is red.

SPEAKER_06

Hold on.

unknown

Okay.

SPEAKER_01

Is that blue or green?

SPEAKER_06

That's green. Your number three is green.

SPEAKER_01

I gotta do, I gotta get these. What was yours? You got any bowls of water over there?

SPEAKER_06

My number three is green.

SPEAKER_01

Blue, green, blue, green. Thanks for the bowl of water.

SPEAKER_03

Did you have me for green? Yes, yes. My number three is blue. You have green. Is that is that what color is that? Gold. That's gold.

SPEAKER_04

Alright.

SPEAKER_03

Next round. Next round. Number two. Number two. This is where it gets hard. Touch blue, make it true.

SPEAKER_06

Hold on, what is Jeff's number two?

SPEAKER_01

My number two is gold.

SPEAKER_06

Hold on.

SPEAKER_01

Gold. I feel like that was.

SPEAKER_06

Okay, what's your number two?

SPEAKER_01

Gold was way up the line.

SPEAKER_06

Yeah, you didn't like it.

unknown

I do. It doesn't matter.

SPEAKER_06

What's your number two?

SPEAKER_01

Blue.

SPEAKER_06

Blue?

unknown

Blue.

SPEAKER_01

His number two isn't my number five.

SPEAKER_06

Okay, what's your number two? Red? Wow, we're all over the map, folks.

SPEAKER_01

I love it. I love it. That's why this is awesome. This is how Bourbon of the Year.

SPEAKER_00

Because Rachel and I have the same palette. We don't like funky shit. We like good stuff.

SPEAKER_01

So you don't like that's Russell's.

SPEAKER_00

No, we don't like old fire. Wait, Rachel, we don't like old fire copper.

SPEAKER_03

No, it tastes like a country.

SPEAKER_06

What's your number two?

SPEAKER_03

My number two is that yellow. Is yellow? It was so bad.

SPEAKER_06

You know why you like it? Because it tastes like cigars. It's smoking. You know what? What'd you pick as two? Yellow. Yellow. That's awesome.

SPEAKER_00

I like it. What the hell was yellow?

SPEAKER_06

That was my five.

SPEAKER_02

That's my four.

SPEAKER_06

All right.

SPEAKER_02

Down to the here we go. Stop. Okay, okay. Okay. Stop. Oh, why are you yelling at everybody?

SPEAKER_01

Car, you just got here. Why are you yelling? Look at Car. Because I've got anger issues. Because Tiny has gotten to you.

SPEAKER_03

What did it for me for yellow is the nose. The one who eats that has just gotten amazing to me.

SPEAKER_02

I'm guessing that the fact that I haven't drank any of it is the nose on yellow.

SPEAKER_01

So two. This is the yellow. I'm going to tell you what yellow means. So yellow, and I like it, but yellow is it smells like a pot still, and the only pot still in this whole damn thing is old man winter. Alright, what's your number one? My number one. It's your green!

SPEAKER_06

Gold, gold, gold.

SPEAKER_01

Red.

SPEAKER_06

Alright, hold on. He's all over the place at that.

SPEAKER_04

Alright, Jeff, your number one. Your number one is?

SPEAKER_01

Green. Which would be green. I got red.

SPEAKER_06

And yours is red.

unknown

Hold on.

SPEAKER_01

He does knob creek 21.

SPEAKER_06

I've got gold. And I'm gold too.

SPEAKER_01

He goes to midnight summer dream drama. I think I picked that as well. And what's your dream? I'm green. That's that's that's this. You just cathedral. Alright.

SPEAKER_02

Are y'all making random guesses or not? No, it's our pick. No, it's our pick. I pick orange.

SPEAKER_01

Because it's sunshine. I already know the box. Walker's like Jeff spot on. He knows what he's talking about.

SPEAKER_02

Walker's over there, like you all are fucked up.

SPEAKER_01

Alright.

SPEAKER_06

Do you want me to tell you what they are first and then add them up? No, no, no. Start with number five.

SPEAKER_00

Who is number five and what it is? Number four, what it is.

SPEAKER_06

Okay, hold on, let me add it up. Jesus God. Hold on, seven.

SPEAKER_03

I'm uncomfortable if that is a title. I mean, you listen, I'm gonna guess you haven't been uncomfortable at most days of your life.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, Carl. Uncomfortable isn't something you're actually having. Your name is uncomfortable. His name No, Carl his whole thing is to make as many people each day uncomfortable. Really not.

SPEAKER_03

Okay. Which honestly you do just by using it. Oh, so oh my god. Make use of it.

SPEAKER_01

But I yeah, so I already accomplished your goal. You do. Yep.

SPEAKER_03

Wait, this is I'll be honest with you.

SPEAKER_02

Oh, I love buttons. It wouldn't look like a big thing.

SPEAKER_03

But you're gonna like there's three of these, I've got to go.

SPEAKER_01

So let's go the highest number for five.

SPEAKER_04

One, two, three, four, five. Oh, gold.

SPEAKER_01

I I see it.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, it's in the house.

SPEAKER_01

So what is the what out of the the five bourbons is the lowest? What was the lowest score?

SPEAKER_03

Because the two the two lowest.

SPEAKER_06

Let's go from the high. Let's go from the millers to the high. Number five. The worst. The most points. Walker. Now comes the reveal. I have the reveal.

SPEAKER_00

No, yes. We're yelling at her. We're going from the worst.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, no shit. We're going from the worst. Everybody shout so you can be on the microphones.

SPEAKER_00

This whole side of the review is a little bit more. Simad now. Simad.

SPEAKER_03

I just want to clarify. Simad she reads the scores. There are two of the worst scores. They're tied.

SPEAKER_04

And they're tied for number 13 each. And the colors are. Hold on, let's go. Wait, what's the scores?

SPEAKER_01

Quiet. If I would have given halves, that would have helped.

SPEAKER_06

Okay, listen. I'm just going to give you the most points. So number five. Yes.

SPEAKER_01

Number five. The fifth in all or five.

SPEAKER_06

Of all of that is yellow. And yellow is. Ding ding ding. Who what do you think it is?

SPEAKER_01

I pick that one.

SPEAKER_02

Yes, do this because we waited.

SPEAKER_01

It's gonna be lots of a lot of things. I'm gonna say midnight's dram.

SPEAKER_06

What do you think it is?

SPEAKER_01

Midnight winter's grammar. Or old man winter. I'm going midnight or old man winter. I'm going at mid midnight.

SPEAKER_06

It's old man winter.

SPEAKER_01

It has something to do with winter. So yellow is old man winter.

SPEAKER_00

No, you get the wrong one. This is old man winter. Yeah.

SPEAKER_06

Old man winter is yellow.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, and I had it at four, but it's spot.

SPEAKER_06

Midwinter is my dramatic. Yeah, that's what I was saying.

SPEAKER_00

So put it over there. So oh, okay.

SPEAKER_07

Sorry, sorry, sorry.

SPEAKER_00

He was a poet and didn't know it. We're sorry, the uh midwinter dram is number five.

SPEAKER_06

Number four is blue.

SPEAKER_01

Four is blue, and that is old man winter.

SPEAKER_06

And what do you think it is?

SPEAKER_01

Old man winter Sons of Bitches.

SPEAKER_00

Russell's.

SPEAKER_01

No, it's Russell. I think it's 100%. Oh, Russell's. My four, my number five was Russell's.

SPEAKER_00

My number two was Russell's.

SPEAKER_01

Blue? Blue is Russell's?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Oh I love Russell's. That's my number two.

SPEAKER_06

And I love Russell's. That's my number two. No wait.

SPEAKER_01

I want to switch my five to one.

SPEAKER_06

You don't get to switch.

SPEAKER_01

Oh my god. No switching because there's gonna be a tension.

SPEAKER_06

So our number three is a big thing.

SPEAKER_01

What's your number three?

SPEAKER_06

Is red.

SPEAKER_01

I agreed with that completely. Nobreak one. Nobreek 21. Yes, that the we knew that. I will drink that shit anyway.

SPEAKER_04

So now that was not a number two.

SPEAKER_01

So really? Old Man Winter and So Old Man Winter and you had red blue. We need to quit talking over each other. It's okay. We all have microphones.

SPEAKER_06

Okay. Wait, so now those red nuts tie.

SPEAKER_01

Number one? Yeah, 13 points.

SPEAKER_06

Yes. It's a tie.

Audience Tiebreak And Winner Reveal

SPEAKER_01

Old man winter and which wait, what now what's old man winter? Old man winter? And what's we need to do a blind. Yeah, yeah. Wait, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. No, no, no, no, no, no. We need to re pour the blinds. No, no, no. I drank all mine. I can't, I can't do it.

SPEAKER_04

That's not our problem. We need to use the color so we can grab our glasses.

SPEAKER_06

Okay. Cathedral is gold. That's where I had it in my number one.

SPEAKER_01

I had old man winner in front. I had it green, and I had cathedral as second. That was my number one in my and old man.

SPEAKER_06

Oh my god. We're Panther fans.

SPEAKER_01

My gold was green. It was my number three. Green was my number one.

SPEAKER_06

Green was mine.

SPEAKER_03

I'm gonna tell you straight up. Probably the tiebreaker to me is availability. That cathedral will never be released again. Old man winner, you can walk into the distillery.

SPEAKER_01

I walked in. No, not the distillery. I bought this bottle at top shelf, just sitting on the shelf. There you go.$159.99.

SPEAKER_00

That's exactly what he's saying. I've got a big thing.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, but the tiebreaker is available. Okay, but but we're gonna unless we're busted up church fuse, get 10 more glens, pour up small pores, and we gotta we gotta blind it.

unknown

The two.

SPEAKER_01

A lot of dishes.

SPEAKER_03

I don't need to.

SPEAKER_06

Well, we could figure out the thing.

SPEAKER_03

I love the nose on the ball. Green's the winner. Green's the winner for me.

SPEAKER_06

It's mine and Martin's number one. Green. You might not need to, but we have to. It's your number three and your number three. It was Jeff's number five.

SPEAKER_01

No, green. What?

SPEAKER_06

Green.

SPEAKER_01

So green was my number one. Jeff fucked up the whole thing.

SPEAKER_04

No, no, no.

SPEAKER_01

No, my number one was green.

SPEAKER_04

I did them in order.

SPEAKER_01

Blue was my number five. Your number one, your number one. No, no.

SPEAKER_06

Everybody was. This is what the scores for green were. Five.

SPEAKER_01

No.

SPEAKER_07

Three.

SPEAKER_01

No. Mine are sitting here right now. Green one. Gold two. Red three.

unknown

Why are you?

SPEAKER_01

Yellow four. And five. Five was blue.

SPEAKER_04

Right to left.

SPEAKER_03

You just said left to right. So green one. Yeah, because you just did left to right. Yeah, but what she was asking my number three.

SPEAKER_01

It's left.

SPEAKER_00

It was right to left.

SPEAKER_01

She asked us for the worst to last. What's your second four? The second one was yellow. Yellow. What's a yellow? Yellow, red, gold, green, blue was my number five. Switch it around. Oh god Jeff. Let's go back into it again. No. It's okay. No, yes. I'm going to fall back to the bottom.

SPEAKER_06

Do you want to blind the number one now?

SPEAKER_01

Okay, wait, stop. Green, green, green. Green just won by Green had one three green.

SPEAKER_06

Hold on. Green had one number five. So I'm just going to tell you. Change mine to one. Green had one number five, two threes, and two ones.

SPEAKER_01

Okay, mine was a one.

SPEAKER_06

Gold had a four, a three, a two, and two ones. So according to like the lowness of the numbers, technically gold had the least of the points that were.

SPEAKER_01

Are you still counting me by a five?

SPEAKER_06

Somebody gave green a five.

SPEAKER_01

I did not give green a five. It's over. I gave gold a five. It's written down.

SPEAKER_06

You gave gold a five.

SPEAKER_01

Yes.

SPEAKER_06

And you're no longer.

SPEAKER_01

I gave green a three. My gold was a one. Which is pick a one. My green's a one. Your gold was a one.

SPEAKER_06

My gold was a one, so you switched yours around. I didn't switch shit.

SPEAKER_01

This is still the same thing. I didn't switch a five with the one. Somebody get this one.

SPEAKER_06

Somebody gave green.

SPEAKER_01

Somebody get this man a quick with it. No. No, watch this. I'm gonna start snorting the green.

SPEAKER_06

Somebody gave green a five.

SPEAKER_01

No.

SPEAKER_06

And it's on the recorder. We can go back and watch it.

SPEAKER_01

Oh yeah.

SPEAKER_06

Somebody!

SPEAKER_04

Let's go back to the tape.

SPEAKER_01

Somebody's gotta go on their phone and I'm gonna try the red flag.

SPEAKER_04

Perfect way.

SPEAKER_00

You and I both had three. Mine still had. Is this a green?

SPEAKER_06

Yeah, you did. That's a green. And is this a blue? I got blue. That's a blue.

SPEAKER_01

I put blue as five. And what was.

SPEAKER_06

Yeah, okay, so blue, five, and then there was a green five, a yellow five, and a red. This is the order of our first points. Gold four. Somebody gave gold a four.

SPEAKER_01

I did not.

SPEAKER_06

Somebody gave blue a five, green a five, yellow a five, and red a four. That's the that was the the you know.

SPEAKER_02

I gave blue a five. I think I picked red. There's my red. I think you did. How did we screw this? I like red. What was it? We did all 21.

SPEAKER_03

All right.

SPEAKER_04

She read them.

SPEAKER_03

Honestly, I almost put it in as my bourbon of the year. So they got an average rate.

SPEAKER_06

And then you have one that's a good one. So gold got a 13. Talk about multiple. And green got a 13.

SPEAKER_01

So gold is the so you're saying gold.

SPEAKER_06

Gold got a four, a three, a two, and two ones.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. And because it got two ones and green didn't get two ones, it only got one?

SPEAKER_06

Green got a five, a three, a three, and two ones.

SPEAKER_01

And I gave it two ones. I gave it a one. Who else gave the who else gave the green a one? Me and him gave it a green, the two ones.

SPEAKER_04

It doesn't matter kind of.

Honorable Mentions And Learnings

SPEAKER_02

Martin and I gave both a one. Pick the bottle of the year.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Yeah. It's got to be a few. You're gonna have to blind the two based off what you're saying.

SPEAKER_06

No, they're so different, you can easily tell which one is which.

SPEAKER_01

Uh no, I disagree.

SPEAKER_06

I guess what you want to make.

SPEAKER_02

Let's there's three of us already picking out a five. Three out of five. Pick the green. Yeah, three out of five or pick old man winners.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, that's that wins. That wins. Why did no? There's only two ones. And there's two greens.

SPEAKER_04

There's three of us. The two ones is the ones that ain't picking it.

SPEAKER_01

Actually, two ones, two greens.

SPEAKER_04

Carl's picking old man winners.

SPEAKER_01

No, Carl picked no part. Carl picks green.

SPEAKER_04

You did not pick green for one. I'm picking it. I'm picking the one.

SPEAKER_01

That is not old man winter. That's green, is John's trying to talk about Old Man Winter.

SPEAKER_03

John's trying to do a tiebreaker from the game.

SPEAKER_01

You want to do a tiebreaker from the uh gallery?

SPEAKER_06

Yeah, what if that's let's make you guys tie?

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, you can yell at you. Go blind them assholes. Love you guys. Can we can we so wait? I I I I take back the assholes. Not today. Go blind those bitches. Blind those bitches.

SPEAKER_03

That's what I like.

SPEAKER_01

Blind those bitches.

SPEAKER_03

You need more?

SPEAKER_02

Do you still have a red bull on your fridge?

SPEAKER_01

I do. I do. I hope so. Can you get me half of it? There is a red bull. Split it. CT, it might be film. Listen, they don't make it handy rod. John, the fridge is right there. Just see if there's a red bull in there. Yeah, there is one, I'm pretty sure.

SPEAKER_00

I don't like the sugar-free one. Be in the door. I don't think it's sugar. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02

Put five, four, three, and two together.

SPEAKER_03

And it tastes like amber. Which one? Five, four, three, and two. Well, goddammit, Nash, you're 5432 mics. I've poured everything I have left in the window glass.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, if you got some. You guys, we are still alive. I knew we had one in the last number. Folks, this is all about being passionate. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03

I'm passionate. Our blood pressure development over this. After this podcast, it's all about being fucking that. Carl. Carl.

unknown

Thank you, sir.

SPEAKER_01

Hey, taste that.

SPEAKER_00

That's that's uh no, I'm not. No, it's it's not almost good.

SPEAKER_02

Don't taste like an embarrassing castle in your buttons. Why? Because you guys can't. Well, you need to trade that for your niece canceling.

SPEAKER_01

Why would I mess with you? Because you guys are messing with that. That wasn't, that was just what I had left. Just try it. It's a little oaky.

SPEAKER_00

Because it has knob 21 in it. And I like it. Oh, Carl.

unknown

Thank you.

SPEAKER_00

He likes the knob.

SPEAKER_02

I like, I like that. Is that the rumor on the street?

SPEAKER_01

Carl, when he does that, imagines it's it's balls. Shut up.

SPEAKER_02

What the hell is that?

SPEAKER_01

That's right.

SPEAKER_02

Don't you worry about it, it's Red Bull.

SPEAKER_01

Which Matt would never have any idea what it is. No. Sherry said it doesn't matter. Yeah, I told you that. I'm not good. I don't drink Red Bull.

SPEAKER_04

I love it.

SPEAKER_01

Sherry told me it doesn't give him wings. Don't give it to him. Oh, Roxy just.

SPEAKER_06

Here's your first one.

unknown

First.

SPEAKER_00

What am I? Thank you. What am I drinking out of this? What did you add here?

SPEAKER_01

That was one, two, and the five, four, and three. Chris.

SPEAKER_03

Oh, the placenta batch.

SPEAKER_01

That old man winter is damn good though. It actually goes against the Quasimoto and the Notre Dame Cathedral.

SPEAKER_00

The fact that Old Man Winter went against this.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00

At half the price. That's pretty good. Because the after fit. Because you can't get that. You can buy it. Well, you can get that. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03

You can anybody on the podcast can walk into the states where that's being distributed.

SPEAKER_01

Well, or you could go down to Marcy, Marcy at preservation. Marcy's got it there too. She does it. Yeah. She knows what she's doing. Oh yeah. What's uh what's the price point on Old Man Winter in Ohio? 129? No, 160. It was 160, 59.69 right there. Okay. Um 199 was the mid, that was the midnight's dram. That one was the 200, but this was that 160. I went with this. So let's talk about the two most expensive bottles on the on the counter that ended up in two and three. Because the Russell's was$199. Yep, and this one right here, I have no idea, but this was what,$229?

SPEAKER_00

$299.

SPEAKER_01

$229. This was even more.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, so two months the dental bottles on the counter.

SPEAKER_01

Well, Cathedral's the most expensive.

SPEAKER_00

No, it is not.

SPEAKER_01

Oh, yeah, it was. It's a$750 and it was like it was like$279. For seven. Yeah, it's like$600 some dollars for yeah, it was expensive.

SPEAKER_03

Secondary.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

No.

SPEAKER_03

No, uh at the at the festival. At the festival. It was$279. I thought I thought retail was pretty high, but I didn't get a bottom.

Closing, Links, And Ratings CTA

SPEAKER_01

I'm telling you that this was worth it. We just vote these are what number we like the best.

SPEAKER_06

No, just tell me what you just tell me which ones you like best. Red or blue. Which one do you like? Red or blue?

SPEAKER_07

Red.

SPEAKER_06

Red walker. Fine. Anybody who can.

SPEAKER_03

Don't be asking for another poor walker. It's like this is awesome.

SPEAKER_01

We can't decide, so our our awesome support is deciding to take it to the we're we're we're putting in three more people.

SPEAKER_03

And you know what? That was a really nice inside voice, and I just want to recognize you for that. I finally didn't start yelling. What what changed you? Thank you, Carl, for recognizing him as having a love CT. What? Thank you. I don't want to have an answer.

SPEAKER_01

Oh, no, no, it's okay.

SPEAKER_00

If I didn't tell her what I gave my numbers, I don't see it.

SPEAKER_01

I don't know what flavors red. Okay, so what? What are we talking about?

SPEAKER_06

So Matt says red, Walker says.

SPEAKER_01

So the new is it red?

SPEAKER_06

Red Harbor game.

SPEAKER_02

And John says the winner edition, which is a ginger and John says red.

SPEAKER_01

Alright, so the Scotchy Bourbon boys, because they all went with red. Scotchy Bourbon of the Year, boys, bourbon of the year. The the okay. This is the old Louisville whiskey company's barrel bottle breakdown of our bourbon of the year. We broke them all down.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, but it's we broke it all down. It's our competition of our boss.

SPEAKER_06

The winner is competition. I'm not gonna say it until y'all shut up.

SPEAKER_01

Why do you have to yell? Oh man winter!

SPEAKER_06

Woo!

SPEAKER_03

Congrats, Mercy. That's uh that's a damn fine leaf. Yep, yep.

SPEAKER_01

You were right there with I mean, you're with 300 year cathedral barrel whiskey finish. From and and and it was close. I mean it's not like one we said that it's so close.

SPEAKER_03

Old Man Winter is readily available. You could walk into preservation down to Bardstown today and you could buy one.

SPEAKER_01

You can you can I think you can go walk into top shelf? I think you can go buy this at top shelf right on your way home. I might they have it all over the place because I'm tired of it. Yeah, it's everywhere.

SPEAKER_06

I saw it.

SPEAKER_01

It's not like we sell whiskey.

SPEAKER_06

And you know it was a legit. This is missing some of these things.

SPEAKER_01

These were good. The first one.

SPEAKER_06

I mean, cathedral is delicious too. But you can't buy it.

SPEAKER_03

So I'll tell you what, honestly, I was disappointed with Cathedral flavor from that. But the nose was so good.

SPEAKER_06

Yes, the nose is insane.

SPEAKER_01

There's no disappointment to me. I wasn't disappointed, but yeah, because it's not as good.

SPEAKER_03

Great nose.

SPEAKER_01

I mean, at 110 proof, everything, but this is sitting, this one's sitting at 101.

SPEAKER_06

Old Man Winter was my ten proof.

SPEAKER_01

And that and that, this is not a neck pour, and that was a neck pour. That's a fresh crack. That's only gonna get better.

unknown

Like they're blended yet.

SPEAKER_01

The old man winter is what it was. Alright, guys.

SPEAKER_03

So before we wrap this up, maybe we should give some honorable mentions to things that we didn't bring, because I know we've all drank a lot of really good whiskeys this year. Yeah, and we're in we're all in the world. Nashley's in fucking church because he's like, yes, yes!

SPEAKER_06

So what else tiny did you really like this show?

SPEAKER_01

A couple of honorable mentions. Well, the Bomburgers are what it was it, uh PRG. Use your words. R P F G P F it's not three letters. And that's uh that's that's I don't it's not hard, but at the same time, I don't I get them mixed up. I had the right letters, I just don't get them in the right order.

SPEAKER_00

If you don't know if you don't know at home, PFG. I mean RPGs are probably different.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, that's what the terrorists used to blow up Americans. That was that was a great bottle that we had out.

SPEAKER_03

And then so for those of you that don't know, Bomburgers is made by our friend Dan over at Victor's. Yep. So shout out to Dan. Great bottle this year. I agree. Andrea Wilson. That's right. Andrea Wilson. And I agree. I mean the Bomb Burgers line is just fantastic. Any other honorable mentions of that?

SPEAKER_02

What happened to the Bomburgers? What happened to the Bomb Burgers in this line?

SPEAKER_03

Well, CT brought to pared down.

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, we're that's a tough one. Like it would have made it in.

SPEAKER_01

It tried to make it in, but we got it. We had that on the pre ship.

SPEAKER_06

I know, I know STF.

SPEAKER_03

Yes, Mr. Nash.

SPEAKER_06

Nash has got his hand out. Yes, Jesus.

SPEAKER_03

You finally wrote your hand for the honorable mentions for bourbon. Yes. I'd like to.

SPEAKER_04

Big shout out to Matt and Augusta Bourbon and for the 13 year that they brought this year and put out. It's a single barrel. And also, like I say, Matt, they're doing great things at Augusta Bourbon.

SPEAKER_03

So that was one of my picks that wasn't able to make it to the table. That wasn't because it was anything short about it. It was just because we just had to eliminate the bigger bigger thing.

SPEAKER_01

What people don't realize also is once you open a bourbon, when you open it and you drink it, then you're then you go about and keep it keep the keep the notes in your head. But when you start to taste head to head to things, things change. Once the bottle's open. For instance, uh Jerry's batch, Booker's, was by far, when I tasted it, uh, it got the highest rating this year of the other two of the the three that we tasted. But when we did Bookers of the Year, uh on On the Pond or what is it? What's it called? By the Pond. By the Pond actually took between the three of us for Bookers of the Year the honors opposed to Jerry's batch, which I would have thought would have taken it. But after having them open and all three open for a while, the closeness was very they were all very close, but by the pond was able to take it. So once you open a bourbon and then you get to this point, if it's early on in the season when they all hit, sometimes how they m oxidize changes the flavor, and it and when you get to this point and when you're tasting them all blind, it it makes a difference.

SPEAKER_06

I have an honorable mention that.

SPEAKER_03

And I was gonna say, my my only I'm sorry, my only comment is what the hell does that have to do with honorable mentions?

SPEAKER_06

But so the Star Hill Farm.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, but uh honorable it was Booker's. I the honorable mention was Booker's.

SPEAKER_06

Star Hill Farm.

SPEAKER_01

So I was my honorable mention.

SPEAKER_03

And I'm gonna give you a because I I did a fresh crack of the Star Hill Farms and it was terrible. And then let it sit open.

SPEAKER_06

Just for like about yes.

SPEAKER_03

So I I had mine cracked. Let it sit open. And I and I did have it open a little bit here and there as I was drinking it. But man, after about a month, it just changed.

SPEAKER_01

If you guys if you go by Ed Boy, who does Old Stubborn, and you're he talks about wheat wheat whiskeys. Wheat whiskeys are very no no no, they're that's del they're delicate. So they gotta sit for a while. So what you're talking about is the Star Heel Find Farm is not a bourbon, it's a wheat whiskey. Or maker's mark or papy or weller, all those. You always want to let them sit for a while before they become competition because they get they they're a more delicate grain than a rye, than a wheat. The wheat grain is whatever, so you want to just let them sit for a while.

SPEAKER_03

So again, we're off the honorable mention path. TV, what's your honorable mention?

SPEAKER_02

Whew.

SPEAKER_00

That's tough because I probably would have put the Penelope. No. I probably would have put the Penelope Omega in.

SPEAKER_02

Oh, yeah. I like that bottle.

SPEAKER_01

It was so man's got a sucking on it.

SPEAKER_05

Penelope Omega?

SPEAKER_00

I mean, listen, there's so many bottles throughout the year. Oh yeah. It's so bad. It's so bad that when you go back through this, you're like, was that last year's or this year's?

SPEAKER_01

I got a I got a Penelope, what is Barcelona? Is that what's the among Barcelona? What was what Barbados? What was the what was the Penelope I got that started with the B? Balencien?

unknown

This?

SPEAKER_05

No. No, that's mine. No, I got I got a Penelope over there. Get it.

SPEAKER_01

Get it, man. So my I was underneath my shirt. I'm so glad. Come around. Come around, John. Take the shirt off. See all the Penelopes back there? There's one. It's the tiny tone. We're the lap track.

SPEAKER_00

Whiskey, what was your second one? So I I'm gonna tell you, I struggled with this a little bit.

SPEAKER_03

I really like nine or eleven. I I've had the knob 21 when it's been open for a little bit, and I really enjoyed that this year. I almost brought it.

SPEAKER_01

Havana, that's what I'm talking about. Was that rum?

SPEAKER_02

Yeah, yeah. Now I've got some barrels of maple. I love so I've got to.

SPEAKER_03

I've got like 24 bottles and ob twelve. Because the batch one was so good. I just went to the bottom. I'll trade you today. I'll trade you. No, it's six weeks. Let's talk about the podcast, yeah.

SPEAKER_04

I remember a couple years ago. You you were wrapped up.

SPEAKER_03

I'm trying to trade. I know, but we could do that at once. So but op 21 I thought was really good. I will be honest with you. I I I cracked my cellar age. And again, I did the shaker, shaker because I didn't want to get an eck core. And I I didn't love it at first, but I really did a couple weeks after you opened it.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. So when we did Cellarage this year, 25, 24, 23. Yeah, the 24. 24 ended up winning. It did. But 25 was what she loved. And 23 had kind of faded, 24 had come into its own, and 25 still, but she loved it because 25 is just got a little bit more of that Chardonnay oak.

SPEAKER_07

It does.

SPEAKER_03

But I will tell you now it might it's a dryness to me. I mean it's it does, it has a complexity.

SPEAKER_02

And that's a good and that's a good bring-in to a backup because really, like had we had a 25 sitting here ready, readily available. I do it dropped this morning. I have a cell A's 25.

SPEAKER_04

I do too.

SPEAKER_02

I have a couple of it.

SPEAKER_00

But just button, but random bottle?

SPEAKER_01

Like, I don't that's a freaking good bottle. It's a freight bottle, but I don't think it overrides this. I didn't pick that.

unknown

Yeah, well.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, this finished second.

SPEAKER_04

Yeah, but not in mine. Because Maker's Mart 25 wasn't in there, so Celery's 25.

SPEAKER_01

We judge we judge by what was here in front of us.

SPEAKER_00

It probably wouldn't.

SPEAKER_01

It would have been in fourth.

SPEAKER_00

So we don't have a Celeries 25 here?

SPEAKER_01

It's right there, right behind her. Did you crack it all? Do we have five glasses? Yeah, we do. Yeah. There's 20. No, there's eight glasses. Go get eight. We're not going to be able to do that. Wait, wait, wait. We're going to end the podcast before we start this. So all right, everybody, we got to end the podcast.

SPEAKER_03

Yeah, I mean, that's the thing. We're starting to get a little off into weird. We always go off on the side. We should try that. No, the one thing that I think the one thing that I think that is pretty interesting about this whole thing. I'm just gonna take the fucking microphones. The one thing that I think is pretty interesting as we talk about our honorable mentions and our our candidates for Burber in the Year is there's no one distillery that that dominated here.

SPEAKER_04

I think everybody's making everybody's making good juice.

SPEAKER_03

There's so many things to choose from. Yeah, we have five very different palettes between us, and and yet we can you can find something to enjoy from almost everything.

SPEAKER_01

That's why we're a group. Once again, it's like we're getting together. I thought that was so true. The bourbon is the glue. Everybody can have different opinions on the bourbon. We all talk about it, we all enjoy it, we all relax, or we just want uh fresh glasses. We get to yeah, yeah. So, so wait, what's happening?

SPEAKER_06

This is the CellRH, 2025. But everyone could agree.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, but Walker's already got eight more glasses. He's got them right over there with the flag. No, no, no.

SPEAKER_03

Water me one plastic cup with some water in it. And we'll just rinse the glasses we have.

SPEAKER_01

No, he's got eight sitting on top over there.

SPEAKER_03

It's an awful lot of glasses.

SPEAKER_04

I'm just gonna rinse mine.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Are you guys all of a sudden are worried about my how much I how many glasses I have to wash?

SPEAKER_03

But rinsing them is like makes sense. You know what? I'm gonna drink out of this real fancy crystal bottle. Oh god, I hate you.

SPEAKER_01

Just pass that around. All right, everybody. It's like that's it. That's it for for the audio. www.scotchybourbonboys.com. That's our bourbon of the year. Our bourbon of the year is old man winter. How that happens, who would have ever known, but it it it got up there. It was an underdog that that owned it. And remember, like I said, www.scotchyburbonboys.com, Glenn Caron's t-shirts. John's wearing a t-shirt tonight. And then also we are there's bourbon balls available. Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, TikTok.

SPEAKER_05

Tell everybody there.

SPEAKER_01

Plus shipping? Okay. And then also iHeart, Apple, and Spotify. Make sure that you leave us good feedback on Apple and iHeart and Spotify five-star rating and everything. Leave a review and then become members.

SPEAKER_03

We wish you a Merry Christmas.

SPEAKER_01

We wish you Christmas. Remember. Remember, good bourbon equals good times. To you and your friends. Drink responsibly. Don't drink and drive. Wish you and happy.

SPEAKER_03

Woo! Woohoo! Anything that gets Jeff to quit talking. Drink God blessed. Uncut and unfilter. Please, Governor. And here we go.

SPEAKER_00

Merry Christmas, y'all.

SPEAKER_07

Cheers.

SPEAKER_01

Where did that all go? Oh my god. So good.

SPEAKER_06

I just want to like covered it and like just covered it. Covered it.

SPEAKER_02

It cheers you a little bit. Come on. Cheers.

SPEAKER_03

Cheers, cheers. Cheers. Cheers. So I'm gonna tell you. I almost brought celeries, but I knew that the midwinters is something that most of you guys probably haven't had. It's good. So I decided to bring it up. I've got a green bomb. And that's that's an empty fee. That's not good. Well there's a crystal sample. That's a vanilla bomb on the finish.

unknown

Green, green, green.

SPEAKER_03

I'll log it. That's why we're gonna. Green grow the rush. Just grow what is your one? And the reason that it's one of the responsibility is a little bit more.

SPEAKER_01

It was uh thank you, bro. What's y'all drinking? Celery.

SPEAKER_00

We're in the cellar. We'll drink over my years with 23. Yeah, I don't care.

SPEAKER_01

You can no more.

SPEAKER_03

Is this your lyrics?

SPEAKER_01

It was my lyrics that chat GPT changed. Then it was put in Twitter. Yeah, they can't. That's how you go um like us on YouTube. Follow us on YouTube.

SPEAKER_03

Like on YouTube. Follow us. Today's bourbon. I can see Jeff writing a line like we can do bourbon boys, and we were born. We can save them. Like us and follow us.

SPEAKER_01

Like the podcast today.

SPEAKER_04

Like today's Bourbon of the Year podcast on YouTube and Home Indian.

SPEAKER_01

Okay. And then tomorrow we can follow us on YouTube from OmegaCon Laundry.

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.