And a Rewatch Podcast
"TV is comfort. It's a friend you've known so well and for so long, you just let it be with you..." So listen in each week as cohosts and special guests rewatch their favorite TV shows and discuss characters, ships, and pivotal moments. From reality competitions to sitcoms and everything in between, we love talking about TV almost as much as we love rewatching it!
Episodes
217 episodes
New Girl 2x17 Recap | "Parking Spot"
We're finally back at Apartment 4D... just in time for the roommates to squabble over a parking spot. That's right: We're talking about the hilarious, aptly titled episode, "Parking Spot" today!Jenn (
New Girl 2x16 Recap | "Table 34"
It's a new year but we're back talking about our favorite residents of Apartment 4D. Let's dive back into New Girl with "Table 34," shall we?Jenn (@notajenny) and Jaim...
New Girl 2x15 Recap | "Cooler" (The Final Part)
It's the end of 2025 and we've finally made it to our last episode about New Girl's "Cooler" — and this time we're talking solely about that iconic Nick/Jess first kiss.Jenn (
Selfie 1x04 Recap | "Nugget of Wisdom"
Who's ready to talk more about ABC's tragically cancelled series, Selfie?Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (@chels725...
New Girl 2x15 Recap | "Cooler" (Part 2)
Who's ready to talk all about the second half (and by that, we mean basically just 8 minutes) of New Girl's iconic "Cooler" episode?Jenn (@notajenny) and Jaime (
Reality TV & Soaps Rewatch | Chess & Rusicals
Join Chels (@Chels725), Jesse (@speakupjesse), Paige (@th...
Selfie 1x02 & 1x03 Recaps | "Un-tag My Heart" and "A Little Yelp From My Friends"
Welcome back to our Selfie summer/fall series where we're rewatching the tragically cancelled ABC series!Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (
Yellowjackets 3x03 & 3x04 Recaps | "Them's the Brakes" and "12 Angry Girls and 1 Drunk Travis"
Chels (@chels725), Sharai (@sharai), and Jesse (@speakupjesse)...
Reality TV & Soaps Rewatch | Mean Girls
Chels (@Chels725) and Jesse (@speakupjesse) are the only ones on the pod this week as they recap their favorite unscript...
Selfie 1x01 Recap | "Pilot"
It's time for a blast into the past: specifically back to 2014 when ABC debuted a tragically cancelled TV series called Selfie.Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (
New Girl 2x15 Recap | "Cooler" (Part 1)
We've finally reached the iconic and game-changing episode of New Girl, "Cooler"!And since this episode is jam-packed with things to discuss, Jenn (@notajenny) and Jai...
Mythic Quest Postmortem Recap | Saying Goodbye to Our Show!
Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (@chels725) are back one last time to talk about their beloved (and now tragically cancelled) s...
Reality TV & Soaps Rewatch | Messy Messy Messy
Though Paige (@thoughtsbypaige) is gone this week, the rest of the reality TV and soaps rewatch crew has returned. Join Chels (
Side Quest 1x01 Recap | "Song and Dance"
While Mythic Quest has unfortunately been cancelled, that won't stop us from talking about the show's universe! So we're back this summer to unpack the four episode anthology spin-off series, Side Quest.Jenn (
.png)
New Girl 2x14 Recap | "Pepperwood"
Welcome back to Apartment 4D where the Nick/Jess tension and flirtation is starting to build in this week's great New Girl episode, "Pepperwood."Jenn (@notajenny) and ...
Yellowjackets 3x01 & 3x02 Recaps | "It Girl" and "Dislocation"
If Yellowjackets is back, that means that your recap crew has officially returned too! Chels (@chels725), Sharai (@sharai...
Reality TV & Soaps Rewatch | Moisturize Me
Though Eoin (@EoinDaily) is gone this week, the rest of the reality TV and soaps rewatch crew has returned. Join Chels (@Chels7...
Mythic Quest 4x10 Recap | "Heaven and Hell"
It's our 200th episode! 🎉🎉🎉There's really no way that we'd rather celebrate than by talking about the Mythic Quest season finale, "Heaven and Hell."Jenn (@notajenny...
Mythic Quest 4x09 Recap | "Telephone"
It's the penultimate episode of Mythic Quest this season, and that means a lot of characters are coming to terms with their next steps. There's a lot of FaceTime involved. It's time to discuss "Telephone"!Jenn (
Mythic Quest 4x08 Recap | "Rebrand"
Every season, Mythic Quest delivers us an excellent standalone episode, and this year we get to know more about Brendan in "Rebrand"!Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (
Mythic Quest 4x07 Recap | "The Room Where It Happens"
On this week's Mythic Quest episode, Ian and Poppy's relationship finally fractures as David and Rachel appear before Congress. We're talking about "The Room Where It Happens"!Jenn (
Mythic Quest 4x06 Recap | "The Fish and the Whale"
This week on our Mythic Quest rewatch, it's time for a poker game that contains some pretty high stakes.Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (
Mythic Quest 4x05 Recap | "Second Skeleton"
This week, Poppy deals with some news: she's pregnant! We're back to talk all about "Second Skeleton."Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (
